The Latter Day Lens

Is the Book of Mormon Socialist? (Episode 185)

• Shawn & Matt

Share episode

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:03:16

Send us Fan Mail

Is the Book of Mormon socialist?

That question launches Matt, Shawn, and Levi into a much bigger debate about capitalism, democratic socialism, wealth inequality, agency, public education, corruption, and how far government should go in encouraging people to make good choices.

But first: Is America's government becoming too corrupt?

A new Gallup survey finds that 89% of U.S. adults believe government corruption is widespread—the highest level Gallup has recorded in two decades.

Matt turns to King Mosiah.

Mosiah argued that government should operate according to the “voice of the people” and established a system of judges rather than continuing Nephite monarchy. Would greater direct accountability to voters reduce corruption today?

Should Americans directly elect more officials—including judges and presidents—or is one of the strengths of the Constitution precisely that different institutions respond to voters at different speeds?

Levi argues for what he calls a heterogeneous government: a House of Representatives that responds relatively quickly to changes in public opinion, a Senate designed to move more slowly, and courts insulated from immediate political pressure.

Matt sees a downside: the farther an official gets from direct voter accountability, the easier corruption may become.

That leaves an uncomfortable question: How much democracy is too much democracy?

Then the conversation turns to economics.

Matt begins with the recent experiences of the United States and Argentina and asks whether contemporary conservative economic policies have actually improved everyday life for ordinary people.

But the conversation quickly becomes theological.

Matt compares elements of the Democratic Socialists of America platform with teachings in the Book of Mormon and argues that scriptural teachings about poverty, inequality, work, and care for the poor can sound surprisingly compatible with some policies associated with the economic left.

Shawn strongly disagrees with equating those teachings with socialism.

The Book of Mormon certainly condemns pride, exploitation, neglect of the poor, and excessive attachment to wealth. But does that tell us anything about what government should do?

Then Matt brings up Fourth Nephi.

After Christ's ministry among the Nephites, the people had “all things common among them,” and the society was characterized by extraordinary unity.

Is that evidence for a more egalitarian economic system?

Shawn identifies what may be the crucial distinction: they chose it.

Can government create a Christlike society by compelling people to share? Or does using coercion to produce an outwardly righteous result undermine the agency that makes the action righteous in the first place?

Levi reframes the economic question another way. If two different sets of economic policies produce roughly similar levels of economic growth, but one provides more healthcare, education, environmental protection, or assistance to the poor, why wouldn't society choose those additional benefits?

That leads Matt to the economic outcome he would most like to recover: a society where a household can realistically choose to live on one income, allowing either parent to remain home if the family wants that arrangement.

And that leads directly to education.

International educational performance has continued to decline. OECD's new PISA 2025 results report historically low average mathematics and reading performance across OECD countries, with reading down 28 points since 2015 and mathematics down 22. The OECD also warns that excessive or poorly guided use of digital devices and AI can undermine learning.

Meanwhile, only 32% of Americans say they are satisfied with the quality of K-12 education in the United States, the lowest result in Gallup's 27-year trend.

Matt sees a connection to the previous episode's discussion of federalism.

Are American schools too locally controlled?

If individual communities determine educational priorities, a dominant local faction can place enormous pressure on schools. One community may emphasize academics. Another may care more about athletics, extracurricular activities, religion, ideology, or simply keeping parents happy.

Would national standards force competing factions to compromise until only the things Americans broadly agree children should learn survive?

Shawn sees the opposite danger. Centralization means that when government makes a bad decision, everyone is stuck with it. Local control gives families at least some opportunity to choose communities that better reflect their priorities.

Then comes the episode's biggest question:

Should government ever try to make us better people?

Prohibition becomes the case study.

Alcohol produces genuine external harms. But the Constitution of the Church's political theology, particularly Doctrine and Covenants 134, also emphasizes freedom of conscience and warns government against suppressing the freedom of the soul.

So where is the line?

Matt introduces the idea of a government nudge.

Rather than simply banning something, government can make desirable behavior easier and undesirable behavior harder.

Levi takes the idea further: What if buying alcohol required a license? Someone convicted of drunk driving or alcohol-related domestic abuse might temporarily lose the ability to legally purchase it.

Shawn sees the danger immediately.

A “nudge” seems attractive when government is nudging people toward your values.

What happens when the political majority changes?

The conversation turns to government incentives surrounding marriage and same-sex relationships as an example of how policies designed to encourage behavior one majority regards as desirable can burden people who do not share the majority's values.

That produces the central tension of the episode:

Government inevitably influences behavior. But when does influence become coercion?

Can government discourage harmful choices while still respecting agency?

Or should government remain neutral and leave persuasion about morality to families, churches, communities, and individuals?

And, naturally, the conversation ends with the policy question America has somehow failed to confront:

Should Broncos fans have to pay an extra tax?

In this episode:

• Why 89% of Americans perceive widespread government corruption
• King Mosiah and the “voice of the people”
• Direct democracy vs. representative institutions
• Why different branches of government move at different speeds
• Accountability and political corruption
• Capitalism, socialism, and the Book of Mormon
• The Democratic Socialists of America platform
• Poverty and wealth inequality in scripture
• Fourth Nephi and “all things common”
• Can government force righteousness?
• Property rights and agency
• The one-income family
• Why educational performance is declining internationally
• AI and digital distraction in schools
• Local control of American education
• Federalism and national education standards
• Prohibition
• Alcohol, agency, and public harm
• Government “nudges”
• When incentives become coercion
• Doctrine and Covenants 134
• And an entirely reasonable tax on Broncos fans

00:00 — Welcome Back, Levi
05:28 — Is American Government Too Corrupt?
07:17 — Would King Mosiah Elect Everyone?
11:59 — Majority Rule vs. Minority Rule
13:02 — Why Government Should Move at Different Speeds
15:03 — Does Accountability Reduce Corruption?
19:33 — Has Conservative Economics Failed?
25:37 — Is the Book of Mormon Socialist?
29:07 — Fourth Nephi: “All Things Common”
30:24 — Can Government Force Righteousness?
33:02 — Why Not Provide More If We Can?
35:27 — Can One Income Support a Family?
36:59 — Are American Schools Failing?
40:51 — Is Local Control Hurting Education?
43:50 — Would National Standards Work Better?
48:19 — Prohibition, Alcohol & Agency
51:34 — Does Agency Include Bad Choices?
52:03 — Can Government Nudge Us Toward Good?
53:05 — Should You Need a License to Buy Alcohol?
54:16 — Can Government Make People Righteous?
57:55 — When Does a Nudge Become Coercion?
1:02:13 — Tax the Broncos Fans?

Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens


People on this episode

Head Shot

Matthew Miles

Co-host
Head Shot

Shawn Record

Co-host

Podcasts we love

Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.

Mission Stories Artwork

Mission Stories

Shawn Record
This Week in Latter-days Artwork

This Week in Latter-days

This Week in Mormons