The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
Episode 86: The Role of Prophecy in Our Lives
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Summary
In this episode of the RM Podcast, hosts Matt, Shawn, and Sam engage in a lively discussion covering a range of topics from political dynamics within the Democratic Party to the importance of sports in American culture. They delve into the implications of recent events, including the case of Kirk Gibson and the moral obligations of sports teams like BYU. The conversation also touches on the fragility of democracy, the role of prophecy in the church, and the ongoing debate between the letter of the law and the spirit of the law. The episode concludes with predictions for the future and reflections on civic engagement.
Takeaways
Democratic Party can replace candidates without a primary election.
Voting for president is actually voting for electors, not individuals.
Kamala Harris's educational background is often misunderstood.
BYU's success raises questions about moral obligations in sports.
Kirk Gibson's story highlights resilience in the face of illness.
Sports serve as a powerful connection point in American culture.
The need for accountability in online communities is pressing.
Civic engagement is crucial to maintaining democracy.
Prophecy assures the church's stability, but agency is essential.
The balance between the letter and spirit of the law is complex.
Chapters
00:00 Introduction and Identity Crisis
01:57 Democratic Party Dynamics and Electoral College Explained
06:03 Kamala Harris and Ivy League Misconceptions
07:57 BYU's Winning Streak and Moral Obligations
10:01 Kirk Gibson's Charity Gala and Personal Reflections
12:59 The Power of Sports in American Culture
16:59 Discussion on a Disturbing Case of Abuse
20:02 Secret Combinations and Societal Responsibility
24:59 The Fragility of Democracy and Civic Engagement
30:03 The Role of Prophecy in Church and Government
34:00 Letter of the Law vs. Spirit of the Law in Sports
40:02 Final Thoughts and Predictions for the Future
Keywords: politics, democracy, sports, Kirk Gibson, BYU, Kamala Harris, electoral college, charity, civic engagement, law
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:01.31)
Welcome everybody to the RM Podcast with Sean, Sam and Matt. It's good to have you with us here today. Sean, do you like the way I did that, the RM Podcast?
Shawn (00:11.178)
Yeah, it's gonna take some getting used to, but okay, that's a good start.
Matt (00:15.286)
I actually like Realm. Well, we'll talk about the name some other time. But yeah, I
Shawn (00:19.18)
Yeah.
Sam (00:20.511)
I do, I hate to be the guy to point this out, but I feel like it's an old schtick now. Like you have brought this up at the beginning of every single show. should put it to bed. Put it to bed. Put it to bed.
Matt (00:25.898)
Yeah.
Shawn (00:29.014)
It's called an identity crisis.
Matt (00:32.374)
Sam is already bored in the podcast and we've just barely started. Hey, so one of, there was a listener that texted in three hot dog GIFs, GIFs, whatever those things are called. And I think that it happened because I specifically said to not text us about dogs. And they're like, I could text about hot dogs. That would be super fun. But I'm just gonna interpret that as they were saying.
Sam (00:36.802)
I'm already bored.
Sam (00:43.361)
Mmm.
Sam (00:47.452)
Mmm, huh.
Sam (00:55.968)
that's fun. Okay.
Matt (01:00.064)
Hot dog, like they really like our podcast. Hot dog three times. All right, so one of the listeners wrote in and said, can you say something more about why it is fair for the Democrats to replace Joe Biden at the top of the ticket without having a primary election? I've read that other candidates like the guy in North Carolina cannot be replaced. Do you guys know about this guy in North Carolina?
Sam (01:03.246)
Hot dog, hot dog, hot biggity dog. Yes, I love it.
Sam (01:20.962)
Mmm.
Shawn (01:25.749)
Matt's gonna go off.
I don't know anything about him now.
Matt (01:29.057)
Well, do you know about the guy in North Carolina? He's the candidate for governor. He's a Republican candidate and news broke that somebody found his username on porn websites and he's been saying some pretty nasty things. And so the Republicans in North Carolina have all but abandoned him. He only has three staffers left on his staff because everyone else has quit and said, we're not gonna support you anymore. And so people are wondering like,
If the Republicans can't replace that guy in North Carolina, why could the Democrats replace Joe Biden? And it's an easy answer. Because when you vote for governor of your state, you're voting for a person whose name is on the ballot. And once the ballots are printed, you can't change the names on the ballots. Like North Carolina voting starts soon. But when you vote for president of the United States, you're not actually voting for a person. like when Sam says he's voting for Donald Trump,
Shawn (02:05.992)
Sam (02:06.071)
All right, give it to us.
Matt (02:27.018)
He's not actually voting for Donald Trump. He's voting for the Republican electors to the electoral college in the state of Utah, rather than like the Democrat electors for the electoral college. because president, yeah, so because president is the electoral college, you've only ever been able to vote for electors to the electoral college and those names never appear on the ballot. And so it doesn't matter.
Sam (02:41.182)
Interesting.
Matt (02:54.186)
The Republicans could change away from Trump if they wanted to. Democrats could still change away from Kamala Harris if they want to. The names that they can't change are the slate of electors that they sent to the state of Utah or the state of Idaho or the state of California for the electoral college. Those names can't change. See?
Shawn (03:11.68)
Which is why, isn't that why people get confused about we're not actually a democracy, like a pure democracy. We're a democratic republic, right? And the republic means we're really voting for representatives who then make final decisions on things, right? We're not a democracy.
Matt (03:20.722)
Republic, yeah.
Matt (03:29.044)
Yeah, that's true. Yeah. So that's why in every other race there comes a time after which you can't change the person's name on the ballot, but in a presidential race, you can, you could the day before the presidential election, change the nominee for the party if you wanted to.
Shawn (03:45.26)
It doesn't look good. I think most of us want to feel like we're in a democracy and therefore we have a say. So doesn't look good that the Democratic Party did basically place Kamala Harris in there against any, she received zero votes from any people. So I think there's a big issue with that, but you're saying there's nothing wrong with that. That's legal and that's the way that's been set up.
Matt (04:09.494)
Right. And in the end, she only needs 270. Yeah.
Shawn (04:11.5)
Is that right Matt?
Matt (04:18.134)
Wait, am I, do you hear me now? Okay, yeah. So in the end, she only needs 270 votes to be president anyways, and it's those 270 electoral college votes. So it doesn't really matter, like primary elections and all that stuff for president of the United States. It just doesn't, right? And if you're the party, like all you care, like the president is so important, all you care about is the president. You don't care as much about like, I don't know, these other little races.
Shawn (04:18.156)
Yeah.
Sam (04:20.13)
We hear you now. Yeah, you're out for a minute.
Shawn (04:30.442)
Right.
Shawn (04:36.182)
Yeah.
Matt (04:48.914)
Anyhow, okay, so another listener wrote in and said, one quick correction. Sean said Kamala's parents went to Ivy League schools. Her parents both got their undergraduate degree outside the United States, her mom in India and her dad in Jamaica. They both went to UC Berkeley for their doctoral degrees, a great school but not Ivy League. Kamala went to Howard University, a historically black college and UC San Francisco for law school. So there you go, Sean, she's not.
Shawn (04:49.58)
Okay, all right, all right.
Shawn (05:17.718)
Look, I'll take the correction. I'll take the correction. I think too many of us, I mean, what is even the definition of Ivy league? Would you know that Matt?
Matt (05:18.834)
Ivy League.
Matt (05:28.054)
Yeah, yeah. Ivy league is like the SEC or the big 10. Ivy league is a league of schools that compete in sports against each other and they're all in New England.
Shawn (05:37.164)
So, so come on, man. Like the listener, like we're, come on. We're talking higher education. We're talking of, come on. We're talking. So the correction, okay. I received the correction that Kamala Harris and her parents went to schools that don't play in a certain athletic section.
Matt (05:43.904)
You
Matt (05:49.258)
You
Sam (05:55.202)
Wait, that's not what Ivy League means?
Matt (05:55.442)
league yeah it is Ivy League is like Princeton Yale who are the other Cornell I think is in that league
Sam (06:03.202)
Wait, I believe the Ivy league literally refers to Ivy, which is Roman numeral for four. Hang on a second. I have to check this and that there's yeah. Ivy, the Ivy league is an American collegiate athletic conference of eight private research universities in the Northeastern United States. What are the Ivy league? are. I learned something. This is awesome.
Matt (06:13.364)
Yeah, now we're now we'll Google it Sam. What is wait, go on Roman numeral four. This is getting interesting.
Matt (06:24.57)
Mm hmm. Yeah, that's right. Brown Columbia, Cornell, Dartmouth, Harvard, Princeton, University of Pennsylvania and Yale. Yeah, those are the Ivy League.
Shawn (06:26.476)
That's right.
Sam (06:36.6)
Yup. are eight private institutions in the Northeastern United States. The Ivy league is known for his, blah, blah, blah, Very cool. Nice. Doesn't matter. I'm bored.
Shawn (06:38.838)
So...
Shawn (06:42.836)
Okay, so that's interesting. It's kind of missing the whole point of the podcast of the episode we did.
Matt (06:46.198)
Well, there you go. But some of our listeners care about being accurate. Okay, Sam, you're up first for the Thought Provoker.
Shawn (06:54.388)
Yeah, that's a good correction. Okay.
Sam (06:54.978)
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, so, hey, on a prior episode, we talked about whether BYU has a moral obligation to win. And it's fascinating because I think the players, the coaches, all the staff and fans probably listened to our podcast because BYU now sits at an improbable, is it three and O Matt?
Shawn (07:14.54)
Four? Four and O?
Matt (07:14.858)
Four, four and four and
Sam (07:16.974)
For now, after having beat K -State, Kansas State, which was ranked, right, at home. Right now BYU is ranked top 25. I don't know the exact rank. My son Nate will die when he hears this because I should know this. I should know, but I don't. So does this, so this isn't my question. I'm going to transition into another sports related, but.
Matt (07:21.846)
Yeah. 13, they were ranked 13. Yeah.
Sam (07:41.727)
Does this kind of prove that BYU is listening to our podcast because they are winning as is their moral mandate?
Matt (07:47.978)
They did it just for us. heard that we predict. I think I predicted they would win six games and Sam predicted they would win five games. And they're already at four. Yeah.
Sam (07:49.666)
They did it just for us, so.
Sam (07:57.858)
Yeah. So I mean, we're, we're yeah. So, so here's the deal. BYU will just, improbably at four and O they will collapse. Now, now I predict they, they lose the next three games. That's, that's the, that's the prediction, but moving on. Yeah. Mo - moving on. So. Yep.
Shawn (08:07.776)
hahahaha
Matt (08:12.086)
He's doing that.
Shawn (08:13.59)
That's over, that's over running confidence Sam.
Matt (08:17.236)
He's doing that just to motivate, just to motivate the listeners of our show who play for BYU.
Shawn (08:22.348)
Yeah.
Sam (08:23.682)
Yeah, yeah. So, so here's my little tidbit from life. Sometimes I like to bring in moments from my work and things that I do at work. So last night, we did a big charity gala in the place where my business is domiciled. So our headquarters are in Kalamazoo, Michigan. And we had something we called Drive for Life. It was awesome. Last night, our keynote was a guy by the name of Kirk Gibson. Now,
fascinating little trivia. Matt or Sean, I don't think Sean is probably going to know this, but Matt or Sean, do you know who Kirk Gibson is by chance?
Shawn (08:56.3)
What do mean? I know who this is. We talked about this two episodes ago. I'm the only one that knew who Kirk Gibson is. He's the one that with an injury, an ankle or a leg injury or something hits the game winning a home run against, I think it was Boston. And right in the 86 maybe 87 world series, 88 and he hits that home run walk off. I think it was, and he runs the corners limping, pumping his arm. And it was an epic, epic major league baseball moment in the 80s or in the nineties is great eighties. Yeah.
Matt (08:59.712)
Sean knows.
Sam (08:59.712)
Okay. Okay.
Yes.
Sam (09:08.846)
LA Dodgers. Yeah. 88, 88. Yeah.
Sam (09:18.082)
Yep. Yep.
Sam (09:24.524)
Yeah. Yeah. So he has Parkinson's disease. And in fact, it's interesting. Do you know who else today announced they have Parkinson's Brett Favre? No, no. Michael J Fox is far along. Brett Favre actually announced he has Parkinson's, which is fascinating. It's a debilitating disease. And as we, so a little behind the scenes to this event, I spent some time, I went to his office in Detroit. I interviewed with them.
Shawn (09:29.27)
No.
Matt (09:34.142)
Michael J. Fox.
Sam (09:51.956)
super incredible guy. wants to create these centers where people can go and, and experience Parkinson's together and rehab together and kind of create a community. And he's doing it. Right. That does not sound hard. This is not, this is not a topic for you to take the opposite side on. That is not, what do mean? That sounds awful.
Matt (10:01.354)
That sounds horrible. That sounds awful. I can't imagine anything worse than...
Shawn (10:05.344)
Why?
Matt (10:12.374)
Hey kids, we're going to experience Parkinson's together. Ready?
Sam (10:17.74)
No, if, if, if you have, if you and four friends have Parkinson's and you experience it together, like you can have empathy for each other. can suffer through it together. can understand, you can receive support. can receive a rehab. Yeah.
Matt (10:23.222)
okay.
Matt (10:29.014)
Got it. Got it, got it. I misunderstood Sam, I'm sorry.
Shawn (10:29.708)
Yeah, Matt, it's not an amusement park for...
Sam (10:34.126)
Yeah. Yeah. There's, this is not, this is not an ozempic moment sold at Disney world. This is not that. So I was, I was super impressed by him. after having spent time with him doing an interview a few weeks ago, he actually at the event, he got up, came up on stage. could feel the rush of adrenaline as he was getting ready to speak. And as a 60 some year old person, let's see, how old is he? I'm going to look at this up.
Matt (10:40.352)
Got it.
Sam (11:02.694)
67, think he is 67 years old, seven 67, I think according to Wikipedia, this is wrong. This could be wrong. I don't know. As this, as I know, as, a, as a 67 year old guy, and as an incredible athlete, like the people that were in that room from Michigan, cause he played for Detroit for many years, and that was his first world series win had nothing but a ton of respect for him.
Matt (11:02.902)
71.
Shawn (11:09.932)
That's okay, Sam.
Matt (11:10.39)
I don't know, Sam, it's your question.
Shawn (11:13.076)
We don't need to know his age. It's okay.
Shawn (11:26.901)
Yeah.
Sam (11:30.508)
He stood up there in front of that group and he took probably three literal minutes, which is forever in front of a group to compose himself, to put his glasses on, to get his notes out. And I'm sitting next to him at a chair sitting there. So if he needed to sit down, he could, he never did. And I was also sitting there with a mic so I could ask questions as the MC. And I'm telling you what, I got goosebumps watching this man, this powerful guy responsible for two iconic moments in sports.
gather himself and speak and connect with this audience. And I'll tell you what, it gave me goosebumps. Like I'm not a huge baseball fan. I didn't know about him before I went and met him. I don't know a lot about Parkinson's. I don't know anybody that has that. But in that moment yesterday, I had a tremendous amount of respect for a person who has accomplished so much, who's been so powerful in his life and who now is suffering something debilitating, who he knows
Shawn (12:04.14)
That's cool.
Sam (12:30.082)
He knows the end, right? It's not going to end well, right? It's a debilitating, it's a chronic illness. And yet he chose to show up and stand in front of this group. And he said, look, our, coach at, at Detroit said, when we win the world series, it'll only count for something if we're willing to give back. And he said, it would be much easier for me to go quietly into the night. That's a quote from Reagan, Matt, if you got that. when he had what?
Matt (12:56.536)
I didn't know that.
Sam (12:57.868)
What did he have? Reagan had Alzheimer's, right? He stood up in front of this group, super vulnerable, gave a speech. And as a result of what he did, we raised him over a million dollars to charities, which is absolutely cool. And listen, Sean and Matt, I have absolutely no question. You can't challenge this. You can't question this. It was an experience that was incredible. So here's the question. I will ask a question because I always ask a question.
Matt (12:59.976)
Alzheimer's.
Shawn (13:14.646)
That's cool.
Matt (13:20.202)
Ha ha ha ha.
Shawn (13:20.629)
Okay.
Huh.
Sam (13:26.582)
What is it about sports that connects with people so well? Is it the conquest? Is it that people pick a side on sports? He represented two iconic moments in sports history. There were tears in people's eyes. He really connected and then raised a million dollars, which was awesome. Why is sports so powerful to us in American culture? Matt or Sean?
Matt (13:51.286)
I think it's only meaningful for people that don't have other purpose in their life. Like if you don't go to church very often, if you don't do anything meaningful in your life, then you can watch a football game and can feel a part of something. But it really is so meaningless. Like, it's so dumb. It's like, why don't I sit down and watch some old ladies play canasta or something like that.
Sam (14:01.422)
What? Really? Wait, BYU is 4 -0. BYU is winning.
Shawn (14:04.118)
Ha ha! Ha ha!
HAHAHAHA
Sam (14:18.316)
Hmm. my goodness. All right. I'm out of this podcast now. I'm completely out.
Matt (14:20.79)
You
Shawn (14:25.004)
Hey, you asked a question. He gave his answer.
Matt (14:27.126)
I'm just being honest Sam. I didn't know there was a wrong answer. Listen!
Sam (14:28.364)
Yeah, but it's, it's, it's the wrong answer, Sean. It's not the answer that he's supposed to have. Wrong answer.
Shawn (14:31.275)
I re
Shawn (14:35.116)
I like Matt's answer. I have a very different answer, but I really like Matt's answer.
Sam (14:38.67)
All right. Let's hear your answer, Sean. I think I might like yours better.
Shawn (14:42.38)
Well, my answer is different than I think you'd expect growing up with two brothers in the eighties and nineties, major league baseball, football, all the sports were just coming alive. All the pro sports. So this is the Michael Jordan era. This was the Walter Payton era in baseball, Eric Davis and Darrell strawberry, all the like, it was just awesome. And we actually liked them so much. Yes, it was fun to play. It's fun to play. That's one reason, but we love the characters, man.
Sam (14:47.168)
Okay. huh. huh.
Sam (14:54.123)
-huh.
Shawn (15:11.436)
We loved Jose Kinseko with his huge arms and getting up the bat. Like, I don't know if you guys watch and the steroids. Yeah. But right now there's a Japanese major league baseball player called Shohei Otani. And he is, he's, he's gone for like 16 for 20 in the last three games. He's, he's, and it is so, and so to me, Sam, watching this guy play is less about yay. The Dodgers won and less about who's going to win again this year that no one will remember. It's about that guy.
Matt (15:16.63)
steroids.
Shohei Otani. Yeah, he's the best.
Sam (15:23.914)
mmm
Matt (15:28.63)
He's 50 -50 for the year. Any...
Sam (15:28.696)
Hmm
Shawn (15:41.138)
I like these big, strong, know, Moroni looking guys who are just heroes. I don't know. Not heroes. I retract that. They're not heroes, but they're just cool macho guys. That's what I think. I like it.
Sam (15:42.046)
yeah.
Sam (15:46.306)
Hmm.
Matt (15:53.258)
This is why Sean likes WWE and the Macho Man Randy Savage and Rowdy Roddy Piper and Junkyard Dog.
Sam (15:57.454)
So, so, so, so Sean, Sean, you know, Phil Heath. you ever heard that name? So Thursday I'm meeting him and he's, he's speaking to us. I'm yeah, he's in a, he's a professional bodybuilder and I'm not going to say that he's doing anything to chemically to get there seven time. Mr. Olympia, right.
Shawn (16:00.768)
Same reason, yeah.
Sure. Yeah.
Shawn (16:07.951)
that's fun.
Matt (16:08.03)
he's that canasta champion, right? He's really good at mahjong.
Shawn (16:10.826)
Hahaha!
Matt (16:16.67)
Untoward.
Shawn (16:20.574)
He won. He, he won. think he's second all time for most Mr. Olympia wins. Yeah.
Sam (16:25.666)
Yeah. All right. So what's a question I should ask him besides giving a Matt's opinion about sports?
Shawn (16:28.832)
man.
Matt (16:28.935)
You should ask him.
Shawn (16:32.076)
Ask him what's better, the classic physique or the dudes that weigh 10 ,000 pounds. Yeah. Yeah, that's a good
Sam (16:36.886)
Okay. Okay. Okay. All right. Well, listen, Sean, I give you all the points because you have respect and you're a little bit in awe of people who have disciplined themselves to the point they can do something no one else can do. Matt, you get zero points because you have, know, obviously, obviously you've got issues. So anyway, next up is Matt. So, yeah. Thank you.
Matt (16:44.191)
Okay.
Shawn (16:48.513)
you
Shawn (16:57.942)
Good question.
Matt (16:59.766)
Speaking of issues, wait till you hear my topic. There's a French man, Dominique Pellicott. He's a 71 year old man accused of drugging his wife to sleep and recruiting dozens of men to sexually abuse her for over 10 years. I'm telling you, we'll get there. This guy was mad at his wife because she cheated on him. And so in retaliation, he would drug her.
Shawn (17:02.314)
Yeah, this is heavy. This is heavy.
Sam (17:02.67)
All right.
Sam (17:07.736)
Mmm.
Sam (17:15.554)
What? Wait, wait, what are we doing? What is this? okay.
Shawn (17:17.772)
This is a question, it's a good question.
Matt (17:28.214)
For 10 years he did this, drug her. And then he would go into these internet chat rooms or these internet, like these, these places. Okay. Okay. And so he pled guilty to all charges, but he's like, I'm guilty, but so are all of the other men in this room of 15 of the 50 men that helped abuse his wife pled guilty. The other 35 didn't. And cause they say we didn't know.
Sam (17:34.05)
Matt, my kids are listening. All right, get to the question. Get to the question.
Okay. All right.
Sam (17:47.281)
Mmm.
Sam (17:50.563)
Really?
Matt (17:52.82)
we were doing anything wrong. thought this was all just legit stuff that he was asking us to do and it was consensual and all that stuff.
Shawn (17:55.954)
Jeez.
Sam (17:57.166)
Where did you Sean? Where did Matt find this question? This is crazy. Was it really? I don't watch that news. Go ahead. Sorry.
Shawn (18:01.002)
This was big in the news. Yeah, it was.
Matt (18:03.786)
Yeah. So this is one of many such cases like this. You could turn on the news. As we know, I like to watch true crime stuff. You could turn on the news any day and you're going to see some trial going on of people who were involved in these like online communities that, recruited people to participate in sexual acts. And then it went too far and they're accused of rape and all of that stuff. And what I, my question is, is, isn't it time for us to shut this stuff down? Isn't it time for the police?
Sam (18:12.397)
Mmm.
Matt (18:33.408)
to like come into these chat rooms and these internet communities and say, no more. Like there was a time in society when we didn't allow this stuff to happen, even among consenting adults. And I think it's time we just end it all. They've all gone too far.
Sam (18:38.606)
So this is.
Sam (18:46.926)
So this is Matt's entry into censoring social media and putting an end to the social media public space, which by the way, in this case, absolutely 100%. How do you not? Like that's crazy. But I would also say that these other defendants that say they're innocent, absolutely not. That's crazy. Like I cannot imagine a world where you would
Matt (18:55.272)
I say sensor, yeah, sensor it all.
Shawn (19:00.93)
wow.
Sam (19:12.514)
perpetrate that sort of a thing and not understand that you have some liability or you have some responsibility for what happens there. So I'm not a fan of censoring social media overall, but that you found, you found the, you found the one little tiny crack, the one case that's so insane. It's so fringe that happens so rarely that, yeah, that you got me. anyway, Sean, what's your take?
Matt (19:27.05)
Yes! Yes!
Shawn (19:27.116)
So? Alright.
Shawn (19:33.324)
You got Sam to be a socialist. I'll counter it because Matt, your question got me thinking about, I had the question in my mind, how many times in the scriptures does the phrase secret combinations exist? And I searched it out. It's about 12, 13 times. Clearly the Lord is warning us in scripture against these secret combinations. And you you could discuss what do they actually mean, but
Matt (19:36.8)
Shut it down.
Shawn (20:02.144)
The reason I bring it up is because when you look at these depraved, very evil, sinful men and what they're doing to this victim, this poor, poor daughter of God, the way they were doing it was in secret. And thank goodness, at least at some point later on in life, they got caught and there will be some form of justice. But it's interesting in the scriptures, whenever it's talked about secret combinations, the Lord clearly despises them. And he says that his wrath will be poured out against those in secret combinations.
But Matt, think you're focusing on the wrong thing, right? The issue is not chat rooms. The issue is evil men applying secret combinations to get gain and to do wicked and evil things, which has existed by the way, from the beginning, the problem is not chat rooms.
Matt (20:46.294)
Okay. But what did the Lamanites do to the secret combinations? They kicked them out of their land. And I knew you were going to say something like this, Sean. So I found a verse in the Book of Mormon. It's Jerim chapter one, verse five. It says, now behold, 200 years had passed away. The people of Nephi had walked, whacked strong in the land. They observed to keep the law of Moses and the Sabbath day holy unto the Lord. And they profaned not.
Shawn (20:59.489)
All good.
Matt (21:15.742)
neither did they blaspheme, and the laws of the land were exceedingly strict.
Shawn (21:21.324)
No, I like that. No, listen, I'm to back you up here and then I'll explain. Ether 822 even goes further and says, nation shall uphold secret combinations to get power and gain until they shall spread over the nation. Behold, they shall be destroyed for the Lord will not suffer that the blood of his saints, which shall be shed by them, shall always cry unto them from the ground for vengeance. yeah, no, I agree that I, no, listen, Matt, I agree a hundred percent that the
Matt (21:42.464)
See? Kick him out.
Shawn (21:47.926)
that we should fight against these secret combinations and these wicked evil people. But the way to do that is to not, you're, you're crossing a line when you say, okay, we're just going to start censoring every group that is private. You can't do that. So are you willing to let them, the same police go into your bedroom and censor what you're doing now? You're getting, now you know what you're getting into. You're getting into sodomy laws, Matt. So now remember the sodomy laws.
Matt (22:05.332)
Yes. Sure.
Sam (22:10.357)
no. no. Could we not talk about the sodomy laws?
Matt (22:11.286)
All I'm saying Sean is it's okay for it to have really strict laws and to not allow people to just do anything they want to do under the guise of we're consenting adults.
Shawn (22:15.841)
Hahaha
Sam (22:25.166)
Sean, Sean, Sean, Sean.
Shawn (22:25.798)
But who decides that man? Like you can only police things that are illegal and you need evidence for things that are illegal.
Sam (22:31.224)
Just, just, just tell Matt that what he shared is so shocking to the conscience and to the regular person that we just, we just say, Hey, it's, it's unacceptable. cause it it's unacceptable, but that's about it.
Matt (22:38.752)
Yeah, see?
Yes!
Sam gets the points, Sam gets the points. That's awesome, Sam, that was right. That's the right answer.
Shawn (22:49.9)
Hey, just cause Sam's being a little lazy in his feedback.
Matt (22:54.026)
He is not! Right!
Sam (22:54.316)
I'm not, it's not lazy. It's shocking. I don't even want to hear about it. Like I want, I want, I want some like SS type guys to jump in and just put everybody in jail and you know, there are other things that I can't even describe.
Matt (23:02.454)
Yeah
Shawn (23:05.804)
Here's the map. Here's listen, listen, but here's the warning. Okay. Listen, in 2003, there was a big landmark case, Lawrence versus Texas. And what it did and what it did is it took sodomy laws and made them unconstitutional because what you had was a bunch of overzealous government officials literally knocking down doors because someone rumored that, they think there's two men in there, you know, committing sodomy.
Matt (23:15.328)
We're not going into sodomy laws, Sean.
Sam (23:18.552)
Please don't. Please don't. Please don't. Please don't. no.
Matt (23:20.894)
You
Matt (23:31.631)
I'm sorry.
Shawn (23:33.354)
That's that's horrible. That is absolutely horrible, but that's what you're advocating for here, Matt. Okay. Now the government is going to place every chat room that every person is in. It's not good.
Matt (23:36.342)
Hmm.
Sam (23:37.794)
We used to have such a good show. People used to, people used to watch this. They'd let their kids watch it. Math found the one thing. It's like, it's like debating the Trump thing. Like everybody wants to go to the extreme and you're like, well, of course that's crazy. Well, of course it's crazy.
Matt (23:45.302)
Sam gets the points. Sean, Sam had the right answer on this one. It was super, super easy.
Shawn (23:50.09)
Yeah
Shawn (23:53.608)
Nah, you guys are wrong. You guys are wrong.
Shawn (24:00.492)
Okay, Sam, okay, Sam, what are your favorite? Sam, I know you're a big chat room guy. So your favorite chat rooms are things like the Lego chat rooms or the Minecraft chat rooms. So what if now you've got government officials over your shoulder looking at all your chat rooms and all of a sudden you say some joke about some dude and now they're gonna shut down your social media and they're gonna come knock on your door.
Matt (24:02.965)
Yes!
Sam (24:07.598)
I'm not a chat room guy.
Matt (24:11.092)
You
Sam (24:17.688)
Hmm.
Sam (24:22.85)
No, listen, I'm against censoring social media and it almost, it's almost without qualification. But when you describe what Matt just described this, honestly, this is how, gun laws become more stringent. Like you see something as terrible and awful as these shootings, these mass shootings in schools. And it shocks the conscience so much that the reasonable average person says no more. that's where oversight.
Shawn (24:26.846)
Not here you're not.
Matt (24:32.736)
Yes!
Shawn (24:49.44)
Guys, guys, the secret combination that this evil dude used had nothing to do with chat rooms. Sure, that was one tool he used to get more people, but if the chat room didn't exist, he'd go elsewhere. He'd go.
Matt (24:50.154)
Yes.
Sam (24:56.372)
I, I don't, I don't, I don't, I don't think, I don't think that guy was thinking, gosh. I don't think that guy was thinking secret combinations. Anyway, we will now, the trigger warning that we had, whatever started way back when we're going to remove it now. Cause Matt's topic is over. Matt, we were asking you not to bring up anything like this or even talk about Trump next episode. That's all we ask. So just sports take.
Matt (24:59.762)
No, it would be too hard to f what is he gonna knock on people's doors? Hey, you wanna rape my wife?
Yeah. Alright.
Shawn (25:11.734)
Heh. Heh heh.
Okay. Okay.
Shawn (25:22.678)
Just sports, Matt. Just baseball.
Sam (25:26.2)
Kirk Gibbons everybody, ladies and gentlemen. you. Yes. Yes.
Shawn (25:27.532)
Gibson, Gibson.
Matt (25:29.226)
I worked very hard to make sure we wouldn't talk about Trump this episode and I'll make sure we don't talk about rape and stuff the next time.
Shawn (25:36.646)
man. Okay. My turn, right? All right. This is the big question because this question is better than your big question, All right. Here we go. So in our church, so many of us find a lot of comfort and peace in the idea that the restored church is on a super solid foundation that will never fall into apostasy again, right? It's been prophesied that
Sam (25:36.819)
Okay, please, please.
Matt (25:39.38)
Yeah, Sean, you're up.
Sam (25:44.654)
Interesting.
Matt (25:45.95)
okay, alright.
Shawn (26:00.426)
that Christ will come before apostasy comes again. So this restoration is final. So we know and have confidence that the church is established, the priesthood is here. And on top of that, living prophets and infallible scripture exists and it gives us members something to just trust completely and to put a lot of faith in. So yeah, some members, so some members tend to
Sam (26:17.526)
this is fun. This is fun. I know this is fun.
Matt (26:23.392)
Trigger warning, trigger warning.
Shawn (26:28.534)
put the same kind of trust and faith in our American constitution and our American government. In other words, they like the comfort that comes from, but the constitution is spoken of in the DNC and it came inspired of God and God inspired those founding fathers, right? But lately in the news, I'm hearing more and more that our democracy is fragile, that civil war is imminent, that we are losing our ability to, or our rights to vote. And so the question is this.
Sam (26:34.251)
this isn't where I thought you were going.
Sam (26:44.664)
Mm -hmm. Mm -hmm.
Sam (26:51.256)
Mmm. Mmm.
Shawn (26:57.76)
Do we need to worry about our country or should we trust, have trust that it's all gonna be fine? We're on a solid foundation. This government that God had influence in inspiring, it's fine. What do you think?
Matt (27:10.102)
Sean, can you think of any other thing in like the history of the church or the history of nations where God has ever said, do whatever you want to do, it doesn't matter, you're going to be fine because I've set this up and it can't fail. He doesn't even say that about the restoration of the gospel.
Shawn (27:22.696)
I don't But but I'm not suggesting I'm not suggesting I'm not suggesting at all that that's what God's saying
Sam (27:24.814)
Ooh, good response, Matt. So Sean, Matt is going to the first part of your question, not the second. That's fascinating. That's fun. Go ahead, Matt.
Shawn (27:34.368)
Yeah. Yeah, but I'm not, I'm not, but Matt, I'm not suggesting the reason that it's on a firm foundation is because a God wills it and B he's placing his children on the earth at this time who will follow him. In other words, I
Sam (27:48.846)
So can I tell you what I don't like about that? The first part of your question. So I think it takes away personal responsibility to stay engaged, to ask questions and to push in the right direction. There's nothing manmade that can't go astray, right?
Shawn (27:51.606)
Yeah. Yeah.
Shawn (28:00.982)
Mm -hmm.
Shawn (28:05.292)
Remember how the book of Mormon talks about carnal security? You feel like if you have that attitude, it's like a carnal security.
Sam (28:12.142)
I feel like sometimes people are like either, something is perfect. So it'll never go astray. Or in the case of government, they say, Hey, you know what? know it's all going to go to hell in a hand basket anyway. So we might as well stand back and watch. Right. And, and in both cases, it absolves you of the personal responsibility to act, to help guide it in the right direction, both as it relates to the church and as it relates to, government. If, if, if what you said was true about the church.
Shawn (28:25.804)
interesting. So when you look.
Shawn (28:31.948)
Okay, so let me.
Shawn (28:38.038)
That's interesting.
Sam (28:42.446)
You could argue that blacks still wouldn't have the priesthood today because it took some pressure to receive the revelation that changed that when President Kimball announced it. You could argue that if people didn't care about the constitution and weren't working to preserve it, that it would be anarchy today, and it's not.
Shawn (28:53.014)
Well, let me ask you a follow up then.
Shawn (29:03.564)
Okay. So, so follow up question to you then Sam, based on that in your personal life and in the macro church life, restored gospel life. So you feel like the carnal security is, we're still a danger that you feel like, no, no, no, no, no. I've got to be vigilant because my testimony and the church's foundation is fragile. have to like be really, really, really vigilant in and almost like out of
Sam (29:13.24)
Mm
Shawn (29:30.07)
fear and jealousy be like, no, we've got to stay on top of this or else it could fall. And do you also apply that to the constitution and the United States government? Yeah.
Sam (29:38.594)
watch this. Yes. Yes, of course.
Matt (29:40.566)
Yeah, of course. Listen, Sean, even Joseph Smith didn't believe that the constitution would never fall. You can go to, if you look up the council of 50, which was established in Nauvoo, this is what Wikipedia says, you can, it's, it's well, only cause it makes it easier in a podcast, but yeah, it's in the, it's all in the Joseph Smith papers. I'll put a link to it in the show notes, but
Shawn (29:41.718)
Is that right?
Shawn (29:53.772)
You bet. You bet. You told me you would bring a primary source reference for this and instead you're quoting Wikipedia?
Sam (30:03.534)
Primary source, primary source. Yeah.
Matt (30:09.878)
Joseph Smith and other early Latter -day Saint leaders believed that Jesus would establish a political kingdom of God in the turbulent times leading up to his second coming. God's political kingdom was to be centered around the Council of 50, a group of 50 men organized in Nauvoo shortly before Joseph Smith died in 1840. It was organized in 1842. So even Joseph Smith, as he's campaigning as president of the United States, believes that the US Constitution is going to fail.
and that there will be a new system of government. So there's nothing in scripture that says that the constitution can't fail. So Sam's right about this. think.
Shawn (30:41.9)
Okay.
Shawn (30:45.398)
Yeah, it does say it's inspired. It does say that God has inspired certain parts of it, but you're right. It doesn't say that mankind can't walk away from it. That's true.
Matt (30:54.878)
It says it was created by inspired people. It doesn't say the document is inspired. It says he inspired people to write the document or to create the document. People like who he raised up to that purpose.
Shawn (30:59.903)
It's...
Sam (31:06.478)
It does make you, it does make you crazy when you hear an evangelicals do it. think members of our church do it where they say, Hey, you know what? It's it's, you know, we're getting towards the end of days. Like it's the second coming is coming. We all know things are going to go crazy. Build a bunker, hunker down and just watch it all happen. And that's not how you engage civilly, civically in the political process or even
Shawn (31:08.491)
Yeah.
Sam (31:33.154)
You in our own homes, you've got to be vigilant. You've got to defend. You've got to ask questions. You've got to understand, and you've got to work towards the better world, not watch it happen worse.
Shawn (31:41.484)
Okay, but how do you reconcile then when you read, for example, in D &C 101 -77? God said, this is God's words, according to the laws and the constitution of this people, which I have suffered to be established and should be maintained for the rights of the protection of all flesh according to the just and holy principles. So we know God suffered for it to be established. He established the constitution.
Sam (31:48.077)
Mm
Matt (31:55.38)
Yeah, to be established.
Matt (32:01.77)
established it. Yeah, established it, sure. It doesn't mean that everything in the Constitution was destined to remain forever. If so, then why did we get rid of the three fifths clause that said African Americans were only three fifths of a person if it was intended to never change?
Shawn (32:15.244)
Sure. Sure. But wasn't it the principles of the constitution that led to the overcoming of that three fifths clause, right? It's the principles that talk about, well, wait a minute of the principles of life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness, the, the, okay. Okay. All right. All right.
Matt (32:25.087)
What principle?
Matt (32:29.13)
That's in the Declaration of Independence.
Yeah. So again, my perspective on that stuff, Sean, is that it's all aspirational. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter -day Saints is the restored church. We're aspiring to someday become the kingdom of God that God wants us to be, but the restoration continues. The founding of the Constitution, the Declaration of Independence, they were aspirational. They didn't even do the things they said that they wanted to do when they created the Constitution. So it's up to us to make sure that if those founding principles are inspired,
It's up to us to make sure that they endure. And I think to Sam's point, we look backwards in history and just assume that this stuff was inevitable and that it was somehow gonna happen. And then if we take that, like that thought looking forward and say, this stuff's inevitable, it's just gonna happen. Then we forget that things happen because people make them happen. If to the extent that things move forward, it happens because somebody stands up and says, now is the time to make the change. And they don't just sit back passively and do nothing.
Sam (33:24.654)
Wow! Matt! You believe in the American dream! my goodness! This is beautiful!
Shawn (33:32.581)
Yeah.
Matt (33:32.894)
Of course. Well, so, if I'm being honest, this is the reason why I don't vote anymore because voting doesn't do anything. And I decided, I'm like, I'm either going to do something to make a difference in society or I'm not. And if I'm not going to actually go get involved and make something happen, voting just gives you this sense that you're doing something. But when, come on, Sean, you're... Look, voting doesn't do anything. Sean...
Sam (33:44.462)
Ugh.
Yeah.
Sam (33:54.965)
false sense of security.
Shawn (33:55.52)
So you just give up on all of it, Matt. You just don't do anything.
Yeah, I understand. Yeah, it doesn't matter. No, I agree. Yeah.
Matt (34:00.532)
Vote for whoever you want to vote for in California for president. It matters not at all. Yeah. So, I'm either going to do something that matters, in which case I would maybe start voting again too, or I'm going to have to do anything at all. Like why pretend?
Shawn (34:11.827)
Okay. That's a good, it's a great point. Matt, it's a great, it's a great point, Matt. It's a great point, but, back to the original is just quick, quick questions and we'll end on this one, but you all agree that it's been prophesied that there will not be an apostasy. So whether you apostatize Sam or Matt or Sean or not, the church is going to be on the earth until Christ comes, which is kind of comforting, right? I have a lot of like comfort and faith in that.
Sam (34:13.058)
You should move to Michigan, Matt, because Michigan, matters. Wisconsin, it matters.
Matt (34:15.99)
It does matter in Michigan.
Sam (34:37.294)
But, Sean, yeah, it could fall.
Matt (34:38.262)
But it could fall, Sean, it could. If there's nobody left to serve in the church, it ends. If everybody leaves the church, it doesn't matter what the prophecy says, it's over.
Shawn (34:40.63)
What do you mean? Not if the prophecies...
Sam (34:49.976)
Correct.
Shawn (34:50.06)
Wait a minute if God told a prophet that the great apostasy will happen and I will restore he told many prophets Isaiah he showed Moses he showed that in the latter day before Christ comes I will once more establish the fullness of the everlasting gospel and it won't leave the church again
Sam (34:53.239)
You
Sam (35:06.414)
So, so Sean, Sean, that's the difference between prophecy and agency though. If, if everyone, the probability of this happening is very low, but if everyone walked away, exercised their agency and said, we're out, it's done. Right.
Shawn (35:23.318)
Yeah, but you don't think, but I think what I agree is a great point, but I think that God is sovereign and if he declares it, he can send people to the earth who are going to choose to maintain obedience and repentance.
Matt (35:32.726)
People still have to do it.
Sam (35:33.646)
I can't ask you this question because this will just, you know what? I'm not going to ask it. ahead. People have personal agency.
Matt (35:39.702)
Sean, people still have to do it. If President Nelson tomorrow decides he quits, then he's gone. And if Oakes and all of them all quit, then they're gone. And then there's chaos when we say, who's the new leader? And then if that process leads to a bunch of people leaving the church, then they're gone.
Shawn (35:46.241)
No, I agree.
Right, but...
Yeah, but, but okay. I, yeah, I know, but, but he, but the same could be said. Yeah. But, the same could be said for, well, Adam and Eve, maybe they would have decided never to partake of the fruit and they still be there. Of course we have agency. Of course we do. But God shows Adam and Eve knowing their faithfulness, knowing their humility, like God is sovereign. And that doesn't mean it takes away from any of our agency. God, it does not.
Sam (35:55.744)
If Joseph Smith is martyred and they don't know the succession.
Matt (36:00.245)
Yeah.
Matt (36:09.343)
Okay.
Matt (36:17.748)
It does. If you say, if you say, don't have to do this because it's never going to fail, then you are giving up your agency.
Shawn (36:23.412)
No, I would never say we don't have to do this because it won't fail. would never say that.
Matt (36:27.73)
You say we don't have to worry about this because it could never fail.
Shawn (36:30.464)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Sam (36:31.276)
Or if you follow unquestioningly, right? Like you still have to think critically, have to act critically.
Matt (36:33.877)
Yeah.
Shawn (36:34.156)
No, I'm not saying that either. No, no, no. I'm saying there's a great deal of comfort and peace that comes and it inspires me to actually work harder with it because I'm like, wow, what a strong foundation. I want to be a part of that. I'm not saying it justifies us to be lazy, but I tend to have that attitude towards the government, the constitution, but I hear more that you like, do you guys honestly think 10 years from now there could literally be civil war and the U S government falls apart?
Sam (36:47.318)
Yeah. Yeah.
Sam (37:01.39)
Yeah. Yes. yeah. think civil work had happened this year. mean, there's no question that the country is 50 50 split. It's angry. It's super divided. Like everybody feels like they have almost a religious fervor for their viewpoint. And nobody is into this whole idea of, you know, settling in between. Like people just don't believe that they have extreme.
Matt (37:02.295)
I think two months from now that could happen. Two months from now. Right, right. It could, yeah.
Shawn (37:03.808)
Do you really, Sam?
Shawn (37:16.043)
Yeah.
Shawn (37:20.652)
Yeah.
Shawn (37:29.056)
But Sam, don't you think that the checks and balances and the principles of our government will protect against any sort of huge failure just because we have people disagreeing with each other?
Sam (37:33.004)
No, no, the, the, the checks and balances slowly erode by votes to change the laws with the Supreme court, with the legislature. Like our, our government is not guaranteed now and into the future. And that's why it's so important for us as members of the church, us as individuals to engage because we could lose it in our generation. all it takes is bad decisions in one generation.
Shawn (37:46.024)
Okay, all right, interesting.
Shawn (37:59.37)
Okay, all right.
Sam (38:02.766)
And there've, you look back at 2000, you look back at the terrorist attacks of 2001, and there have been some really bad decisions that have eroded agency, have eroded personal liberty and freedom, and have eroded the balance of power. And it's not guaranteed.
Shawn (38:19.116)
Okay.
Matt (38:19.286)
You know what, Sam? I heard Pete, I heard Pete Buttigieg talking about that today and he agreed with you. He was saying like, they said, Hey, what are the failures of the democratic party since like in our generation? And he pointed specifically to some of the things that happened since 2001. He's like, Democrats let people down in these situations.
Shawn (38:24.928)
Ha ha ha!
Sam (38:25.984)
you
Sam (38:37.71)
And, and, and you know, what's interesting is Matt, you brought up an extreme case and it caused me to say, my goodness, we have to censor. It was the extremity of 2001 seriously that caused people to give up their personal freedoms and liberties. And then changed in a lot of cases, the balance of power as we've gone since one up to our day today, where it's not as secure as it's been in the past. Now.
Shawn (39:02.421)
Interesting.
Sam (39:03.116)
It doesn't always have to be that way. I think, I think there is an element of history that swings back to the middle, but that's not guaranteed if people don't fight for it. If people, hear more and more, Hey, you know what? We're living in the last days. You know, we know this is going to happen and you know, it's just kind of fun to eat popcorn and watch it happen. That is a terrible, sentiment for members of the church to have just because that's our belief. Like it's not our job to bring it here.
It's our job to be stewards of what we've been given. And we've been given, we've been given a stewardship over the constitution and over the government. Now, Matt would take, Matt would take issue with me on that because I support Trump and we could go into that whole debate. But, but it's, but, but, but it's important for us to debate those things, right? And to think critically about those things and then act to the best of our conscience. So.
Shawn (39:34.024)
Yeah, interesting. OK.
Shawn (39:38.668)
Cool, I like it, that's cool.
Shawn (39:46.668)
We won't. We all got there.
Matt (39:46.932)
No, no, no, we don't have to go there.
Shawn (39:55.766)
Well, I tell you what, I'm going to give both of you, well, I'm going to, both of you, might give the points because you are so united on this and very, very passionate about this, but I'm going to not give you the points. I'm going to take the points myself because I took a uninterested, indifferent kind of bored Sam and I engaged you, man. You went in. I got you.
Sam (40:02.818)
No.
Matt (40:15.634)
Yeah, that's true. Hey, I'm just going to plug this book. There's a political scientist, his name's Nathan Kalmo. He wrote a book called With Ballots and Bullets. And he looks at American history, like he looks at the period before the Civil War, and he points out a lot of the similarities between what was happening with partisanship and like right now, partisans are willing to endorse violence against the other side. And he shows that like
Sam (40:25.784)
Mmm.
Shawn (40:37.759)
my gosh.
Matt (40:42.708)
What's happening now is very similar to what happened right before the Civil War.
Shawn (40:45.878)
Well, Matt, I'll look into it more. I'm not totally persuaded by you too, but I do love your United passion. So that causes me to want to go look into it. I just tend to be a little more optimistic, but, but maybe I'm wrong. Maybe I'm just naive. Yeah.
Matt (40:58.666)
Maybe, maybe you're naive, Sean, but I'll give you the points because you said maybe you're naive and I like that. Okay. So for the big question, we're going to go to the Olympics, the women's gymnastics in the Paris Olympics. So Jordan Childs is an American gymnast. She won the bronze medal on the floor routine in Paris and there was this historic all black podium, but the medal was revoked over a technicality. So apparently,
Sam (41:02.478)
You
Shawn (41:03.444)
Okay. Okay. Good.
Sam (41:08.173)
No, no, no.
Matt (41:28.22)
you can challenge in your score as a gymnast, you can't challenge the score that they give you for how well you did the routine, but you can challenge the difficulty score. And Jordan Childs, after she finished her routine and saw the score, she said, hey, you guys didn't give me an appropriate difficulty score for this one little thing that I did. It should have been a higher difficulty score. And the judges looked at it and they said, you're right. And they awarded her a 10th of a point.
which was enough to move her into bronze medal status. But the Romanian who moved from third to fourth, she said, wait a minute, the rules say that you have one minute to challenge that. And she took longer than a minute. She took one minute and four seconds. And so then the body overseeing the Olympics said, you're right. And they stripped the bronze medal away from Jordan Childs and they gave it to this Romanian gymnast.
Sam (41:56.206)
Mmm.
Sam (42:20.77)
Mmm.
I love it.
Matt (42:23.518)
And now there's video footage and it's getting appealed and all of this sort of stuff. But this leads me to a big question, right? Because the big question is how important is that four seconds? And so to me, this is a really classical question of the letter of the law versus the spirit of the law. And my question is, which is more important? And should we let our evaluation of specific situations decide whether we choose to follow the letter of the law or the spirit of the law? Or is there some...
guiding principle that can let us know, no, you should always follow the spirit of the law or no, you should always follow the letter of the law.
Shawn (42:59.116)
Do you think Matt that it will, that answer will be different depending on like if it's a spiritual matter versus if it's a, an Olympic sports, you know, judgment, like, you think the answer? well that's what I was asking. Do you think it matters or do you feel like, no, there's gotta be a principle that governs here. It's either spirit of the law or letter or both.
Matt (43:09.856)
Does it matter for you? I don't think it matters.
Sam (43:20.126)
So, in, in sports here would be my take. So in sports, it's gotta be a little bit towards letter of the law because without it, you can't find a winner and a loser, right? It drives me nuts to see is an NFL. think they can actually end in a tie if, certain things are like, that's insane. There's no, like in sports, yeah, in sports, you, you play a game, you enter a competition.
Matt (43:36.116)
Mm -hmm. Yeah. Baseball can end in a tie.
Sam (43:46.23)
And the rules have to govern how that competition is executed so that you can figure out who won, who lost, who's doing better, who's doing worse. And that's how you progress over time. if, if, if, if you say, spirit of the law, it'll turn to anarchy in sports. So sports probably more than life needs to be letter of the law because it's about discipline and it's about winning and losing.
Matt (44:10.454)
So the fact that she got her appeal in four seconds too late, sorry, too bad. Even though the judges were wrong, you didn't get it in in time.
Sam (44:14.51)
Yeah. There, there. Well, because, yeah, because, because then we'll, know, where, where does, where does it begin and where does it end? Right now, all of sudden everybody's coming back five minutes later saying, Hey, I need like, what's the penalty for appealing and not winning your appeal? Do you lose points? Like, why wouldn't everybody just appeal at 30 seconds?
Shawn (44:18.796)
I mean that's justice, right? That's just.
Matt (44:36.822)
You have to pay money. It's like over $1 ,000 to appeal. I think it was a total of $3 ,000 she had to pay to appeal that decision.
Sam (44:40.952)
Okay.
Sam (44:44.472)
So she had to go find the money. took a minute five and
Matt (44:46.846)
I mean, if you're, yeah, if you're in a, if you're in a, no, she didn't need the money before she appealed. The reason it took her maybe too long was because she was the last one to compete. And so she didn't have as long to like make the decision as other people might've had. A bronze medal, Sam, a bronze medal in the Olympics? Of course that matters.
Sam (44:55.084)
Mm
Sam (44:59.138)
does the story matter? Like at the end of the day, there are rules.
No, I get that. But but think about this. She was in fourth place before she began the appeal. She tried the appeal. She won it. But as it turns out, like, she was too late. So she ended up basically back where she was, like, it's embarrassing. It's frustrating. It's got to be not great. But if if if you say, Hey, you know what, what, what, what, what would you propose, Matt, you award both of them so bronze?
Matt (45:26.068)
You're heartless. You are heartless.
Shawn (45:27.392)
hahahaha
Matt (45:31.764)
No, the spirit of the law. It's like, look, the judges were wrong and they should have, they made the mistake. So you don't say to her, well, your appeal was four seconds too late. So it doesn't matter that we acknowledge that we made a mistake in your score. We know what your score is. So there you go, the spirit of the law.
Sam (45:41.463)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (45:46.636)
I know, but, but, but if they, if, if they don't have a time for that appeal to happen, then it will always, the results will always be open. Like somebody a day later or a week later or a month later could come back and say, well, Hey, know, looking at the tape, you know, I'm sort of thinking, and then what do you do? You just give everybody metals. Matt, you Democrats want, you Democrats, you Democrats want to give everybody participation trophies. And we're talking about the Olympics. This.
Shawn (46:00.3)
Ha
Matt (46:06.644)
No, you just deny it. You just deny that appeal.
Shawn (46:14.198)
Ha ha ha ha!
Sam (46:16.076)
Listen, Kirk Gibson would say it's the letter of the law that Mr. Olympia, the bodybuilder. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. If, if, if by that canasta, whatever that is, if you mean to, world series championships. Yes. Yes.
Matt (46:16.8)
I
Matt (46:21.322)
Wait, is Kirk Gibson the guy that plays Canasta? I'm forgetting.
Shawn (46:25.194)
hahahahah
Matt (46:34.954)
Okay, Sean, what do you say?
Shawn (46:36.618)
I man, kind of tend tend towards Sam here. I think, well, let me, let me explain. I think when it comes to manmade institutions, then the rule of law really is important. And I think that it's important to like, and now you extend it to just, it's not even a manmade institution. It's a game. We're talking about games here, right? Throwing balls, doing flips. Then I think when it comes to, yeah, but when it,
Matt (46:39.188)
You guys are so mean!
Matt (46:59.988)
Yeah, yeah.
Sam (47:02.634)
of money involved, lot of money, millions of dollars on the bronze. No, no, no, no, I'm not. You're trying to minimize it. You're trying to minimize it by saying, it's just a sport. And I don't think that's necessarily the right approach. I think the right approach is it is sports. Sports is about discipline and development and competing. And the only way you can ever compete is you've got to have rules. Otherwise, if you don't have rules, there's no competition. So if BYU takes the field and they
Matt (47:05.022)
Yeah.
Shawn (47:05.805)
now you're back on your...
Matt (47:22.891)
Yeah.
Sam (47:31.054)
you go back and say, hey, we're, you know, we're BYU or the Lord's university. should, we should have won this game. Well, Kansas state's like, well, my gosh, you know, we'll give you another 48 points on, the game and therefore you win. Like, yes, yes.
Shawn (47:43.244)
Okay, Sam, Sam, do you apply that same standard to remember when we were in Ukraine on the mission and you'd hail a cab and you'd get in the car and because the yeah, but luckily, and because the car, the, the, law was you had to wear a seatbelt. Do you remember what they would do? The driver, he would take his seatbelt and cross his shoulder and just set it on his lap. So it appeared that that seatbelt was on, but they'd never click it. I don't know if you guys
Sam (47:49.524)
Mm -hmm. Yes. Pyechali. Pyechali. Mm -hmm.
Sam (48:07.232)
I will tell you not to go down a rabbit hole, but if you talk about politics in Yugoslavia, you will get taken to the Padyelam or Ligi and you will be questioned about whether you were trying to incite a riot in Ukraine on behalf of Yugoslavia. I may have had a personal experience with that, but the letter of the law is super important.
Shawn (48:21.502)
Why do you think that would happen, Sam? Why do you think that happened?
Matt (48:22.208)
You
Shawn (48:26.26)
Yeah. Hell yeah. That's what I'm saying. So do you agree with like, for example, was that an immoral move? Like if you don't put your seatbelt on, you just cross it over and you don't.
Sam (48:36.14)
I'm not, you know what, I'm not comparing sports to, driving cars in Ukraine. No, if you don't have sports, then you have chaos. what would Vegas do? How would Vegas determine a winner and a loser and pay out their bets? Okay.
Matt (48:40.54)
Laws of the land. Sports is so much more important than laws of the land, Sean. Don't get confused.
Shawn (48:50.782)
No, hang on Sam, hang on. You got to answer my question. If your son gets in the car and goes down the road to Kmart and doesn't click the seatbelt in, but just puts it across his lap so the cop won't give him a ticket, that's the spirit of the law and the letter of the law. Would you say, no, man, need, just same way you would answer the sports question, would you say, no, you need to apply the letter of the law there. The law is the law.
Sam (48:57.836)
Yes. Yeah.
Sam (49:15.136)
If, if, if the police officer came to me and said, should I give him a ticket? Because he doesn't, he hasn't clicked it. This is the most insane question. I'd say, of course. Yeah. Like the, the less, yeah. If, if he didn't click it and he got away with not getting a ticket, I'd high five him and say, that's pretty cool. But where are your seat belts the next time? no. no. Okay.
Shawn (49:19.712)
Yeah, you say yes. You would. Okay. Okay.
Shawn (49:29.79)
What, what if he went two houses down? What if he drives from your house, two houses down? No, this is important. This is the letter of the law versus the spirit.
Matt (49:35.786)
Listen, I don't want to offend you guys.
Sam (49:38.99)
Actually, do you Matt, do you want a real letter of the law as it relates to driving? Nate will die when I tell this story. So my son Nate, my son Nate went on a date homecoming after he rode a big bike ride over this past weekend, he asked a girl out super late. And he texts me I'm on an airplane and he says, Hey, dad, I am 16. I've had my license, I think for like four months. And the rule is, you can't drive by yourself if you've only had your license less than six months.
Matt (49:42.358)
good. Then I definitely want this.
Shawn (50:08.524)
That's right.
Sam (50:09.068)
You have to have another, yeah, you have to have another family member in the car. said, are you okay if I pick this girl up and drive to the dance by myself? I searched all over the internet, trying to find any loophole that would allow him to do that. And guess what? I couldn't find a loophole. So guess what? I said, no. And, and then guess what he did? And I actually, I had some people that were like, Hey, you know, you should have maybe said, yes, he went and had, and this is
Matt (50:09.266)
In Utah, that's the law.
Matt (50:17.051)
Mmm. Mmm.
Matt (50:23.808)
There's no loophole. Right. Sam. He broke the law.
Sam (50:37.676)
Nate, I apologize. If the girl is listening, we apologize. He, he concocted a plan with his brother, Braden. Braden sat in the back of the car with maybe a blanket over him and this SUV he hid, while, while Nate drove, he and the girl at the dance. But, but, but, but Braden, Braden, Braden fulfilled the letter of the law by sitting in the back of the car, unknown to anybody.
Matt (50:38.292)
Nate, we're sorry to out you.
Matt (50:46.152)
Shawn (50:53.33)
Nate, you are my hero, dude. You are my hero, man. That is awesome.
Matt (50:56.374)
Brayden, Brayden is the one that did it.
Matt (51:05.942)
Braden and his wife sat in the back making out.
Sam (51:08.566)
That's right. But, but, you know, it's interesting, I'm told there was an accident right in front of the school, a big accident involving some students. And the comment may have gotten back to me that Nate said, Hey, you know what, maybe that was good that we didn't because you think about it, the end of the day, if he takes that risk and decides he can't go back and say, Hey, you know what, I got in this terrible accident, this girl got hurt, you know, spirit of the law, I had nothing but my best intentions at heart.
Matt (51:22.486)
Hmm
Sam (51:34.755)
The law is going to say you're personally liable for it. Now as parents, you're culpable for it. There has to be order in that. if you want to, if you want to take it into there. All right. Let's hear your answer. All right.
Matt (51:41.16)
Okay, you guys aren't gonna like, you're not gonna like my answer to this, but it's true. People want to follow the letter of the law when they're not able to feel the spirit in their lives. Because the spirit will always tell you. The spirit, this is not my phone, the spirit will always tell you, hey, stop that ringing. The spirit will always tell you when there should be exceptions to the letter of the law.
Sam (51:53.73)
What? What? Stop. Will you answer the phone and just stop? Taco Bell, Taco Bell in and out.
Shawn (51:54.71)
Keep going, I like it. I like it.
Shawn (51:59.862)
Yeah, sorry. That's my fault.
Sam (52:08.822)
No, the spirit doesn't need to have to tell you that it just tells you to just follow the law for heaven's sake. my goodness.
Matt (52:14.874)
Man, I was doing so good. I'm sorry that I laughed. Yes! Yes, that's right.
Shawn (52:16.3)
No, no, no, I'm with you, Matt. I'm with you. I like that. I like that very much. I think he's serious. He is serious.
Sam (52:20.77)
John thinks you're serious.
Matt (52:22.294)
I almost made it all the way through that statement without laughing. Listen, Sam, you can tell I'm serious if I start laughing in the middle of this statement.
Sam (52:26.702)
He's not serious, Sean. No, he's not. He's not serious. He's totally making fun. He's 100 % joking.
Shawn (52:27.459)
you're not serious?
Shawn (52:33.12)
Wait, you're joking Matt, you don't believe that? I think knowing you over all these years, you absolutely believe that.
Matt (52:38.998)
I don't think I believe that everyone should... No, 100 %!
Sam (52:39.158)
Sean, Ashton Kutcher, Ashton Kutcher is sitting with Matt right now and you've been punked. So.
Shawn (52:43.082)
I can give some stories. I can tell you some stories.
Shawn (52:50.284)
Shut up, dude. Shut up, dude.
Matt (52:50.614)
100 % I believe that we should pray about things in our lives, but I didn't, I don't actually believe that. You only follow the letter of the law if you can't follow the find the spirit.
Sam (52:56.428)
Mm -hmm.
Shawn (52:57.578)
Okay, let's let's have a okay. Let's end up. Let's have a this. Let's end on this story. At the beginning of the Russian war invading Ukraine, they invaded a city a certain city. What was that certain city called guys? my people. Do you guys know anything about Mariupol? what happened in Mariupol? How did the gospel of Jesus Christ enter the land or the city of Mariupol?
Sam (53:00.632)
That's a big burden to the spirit. no.
no, no, no, no.
Matt (53:10.494)
Marupil. Yeah, Sam lived there for a while.
Sam (53:18.998)
Right, spirit of law. Yeah, yeah.
Matt (53:19.678)
We broke the letter of the law.
Shawn (53:21.4)
All you did cause you got on a bus and you're like, look, I know we're not supposed to go in here, but did you feel the spirit maybe? Or what was the reason?
Matt (53:27.094)
Sean, this is not a story that I tell my children. I want them to be good missionaries. I don't tell them.
Shawn (53:31.38)
And what did the mission, what, hang on, what did our mission president say to you two when you had confessed that you broke the law? What did he say to you?
Matt (53:38.816)
We didn't break the law, we just broke a mission rule. He said,
Shawn (53:40.778)
Yeah, the letter of the law. You broke the letter of the law.
Matt (53:46.984)
No, no, Elder White, remember Elder White? Yeah. He said, no, no, he said, I don't think you meant to break the rules, did you? And I say, no, I didn't, I didn't mean to break the rule.
Shawn (53:50.696)
And he said, well done guys.
Shawn (53:56.575)
Hahaha
Sam (53:57.39)
He was blinking a lot when he said that, by the way, had teary -eyed.
Shawn (54:01.162)
And then you guys brought the gospel into a city that was.
Sam (54:04.46)
And then we paid massive amounts of bribes to bring in medical equipment. listen, life, life Sean is full of irony, but it doesn't mean you need to like run towards the irony, the difference between the way things are and should be. yeah.
Matt (54:06.89)
You
Shawn (54:07.794)
Amen. See? See? See?
Matt (54:12.053)
Yeah.
Shawn (54:16.884)
Okay, alright, I'll consider that.
Matt (54:17.342)
I love it. I'm going to let, I'm going to let Sam have the last word. That was super good. Hey, listener, thanks for joining us this week. We will, do you know, next episode we're going to do just predictions. It's going to be all predict. So far I've been keeping a tally. None of the things I predict come true. And so I think it'd be fun to have a whole episode of predictions because if we do enough of them, maybe something I say will actually come true. Sam, your predictions aren't so hot either, as I recall.
Shawn (54:20.566)
Yeah, that was good. That was good.
Sam (54:21.784)
Mmm.
Sam (54:44.354)
Really? No, actually I think I've, I've, I've landed them. I need to go back to my log. Well, no, that, that the season is not done yet. BYU could actually regress and wins between now and the end of the year.
Matt (54:47.734)
How many wins for BYU did you say?
Matt (54:57.406)
We're gonna look at general conference predictions and Sean actually has never made a prediction. So I'm actually kind of excited to put him on the spot and make him predict things about like, will a woman ever talk at general conference again? Things like that. It'll be super fun. All right, join us again next time. Thanks everybody.
Sam (55:00.462)
Mm
Shawn (55:10.912)
What? my god.
Sam (55:12.022)
Hmm, interesting.
Sam (55:19.298)
That was super fun. Good episode.
Matt (55:20.83)
Yeah, good job you guys. Hopefully the audio was fine.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories