The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
Episode 81: The afterlife, bribes, tariffs, Romney 4 Prez, NASA & Boeing, Ranked choice voting
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Thought Provoker:
Sam is up first this week. Trump recently stated that tariffs are a tax on a foreign country. What do you think about tariffs?
Next up, Shawn. Before Joe Biden endorsed Kamala Harris, Aaron Sorkin wrote an op-ed in the New York Times saying Democrats should nominate Mitt Romney: "Nominating Mr. Romney would be putting our money where our mouth is: a clear and powerful demonstration that this election isn’t about what our elections are usually about it, but about stopping a deranged man from taking power." Is it impossible to think that a political party would ever do something altruistic like this?
Finally, Matt. NASA has given Boeing hundreds of millions of dollars to fund the development of a class of partially reusable spacecraft designed to transport crew to and from the International Space Station (ISS) and other low-Earth-orbit destinations. Now the crew of one of these vessels is stuck in outer space. What was supposed to be an 8 day mission may take 8 months because the spacecraft is flawed. Boeing is a private corporation that is poorly managed, yet receives billions of dollars in contracts from the federal government. Who should taxpayers hold accountable when private companies waste their hard-earned money?
The Big Question: A recent study was published that looks at what happens when a state adopts ranked choice voting. They find that in the elections after Alaska adopted rank choice voting, 1) the moderate candidate won the Senate race, who otherwise would have lost, 2) some Democrats and independents who favored the moderate Republican more than the Democrat were able to support her at all stages of the election, along with others who voted for her to stop the more conservative Republican candidate, and 3) Alaskan voters are largely favorable toward the new rules, but that certain kinds of populist voters are likely to both support Trump and oppose the rules. The big question is, based on this should more states adopt rank choice voting?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Sam DArc (00:00.846)
you
Matt (00:01.661)
Hello everybody and welcome to the real Mormonism podcast with Sean, Sam and Matt. We're excited to be recording together again. I hope you all enjoyed the president Meredith interview we posted last week, but I did hear from some people that you longed for the content we create each week. So we're back. We're not going to go into the details of why we were away, but it's mostly my fault and I blame myself and Matt.
Shawn (00:20.17)
Yeah.
Sam DArc (00:26.638)
the
Matt (00:40.021)
You
Matt (00:45.789)
So Sean regularly tells us that if we call ourselves the real Mormonism podcast, people are going to think that we should talk about religion. And every week I say, no, Sean, nobody thinks that that's what we do on this podcast. But it turns out somebody was watching us on YouTube and his name's James Isaacson, 6379. He asked this question. And so I, I feel like for our YouTube listeners, of which there's like 15 of you right now,
Sam DArc (00:53.454)
Mm -hmm.
Shawn (00:57.973)
Ha
Matt (01:15.07)
in hopes that maybe more will join. They'll be like, hey, this is a place I can get answers to my questions. We're going to answer this question from James Isaacson, 6379. He says, real Mormonism question, what is Mormon's beliefs happen after death? Because I heard you guys believe in like multiple different plans soul can go to and that people die can still be saved because they're put some hold cell and can be preach gospel.
And can I accept is these true? wondering question mark.
Shawn (01:46.155)
Okay, I get the gist of it, right? We get the gist of that. So it's like somewhat, okay, so to your comment before, Matt, the latter day lens was a perfect name for what we do. And you're right, if we're gonna call ourselves real Mormonism, we're gonna have to speak about religion a little bit. Give me a break, man. Anyway, this is a religious question. guys wanna take, Sam, what do you say to that?
Matt (01:48.102)
Yeah.
Sam DArc (02:06.048)
I, words, multi -level marketing. So yes, we believe depending, depending on how well you live this multi -level experience, can go to multi -levels after this. you and actually that's, that's right. That's, that's exactly right. So people wonder why multi -level marketing is such a big deal in Utah. That's why, because.
Matt (02:09.37)
Hahaha
Shawn (02:13.483)
I guess.
Matt (02:24.473)
And if you save more than one person, how much more joy you'll have in the next life.
Matt (02:35.217)
Yeah, it's part of our faith.
Shawn (02:35.435)
Okay, this is the reason why we were called the Latter -day Lens because when you guys try and do Mormonism stuff, it comes off like this.
Matt (02:42.801)
James Isaacson is going to learn that we are not theologians, nor do we pretend to be.
Sam DArc (02:46.338)
James, when you die, you have the opportunity to go to one of three worlds, the bigger or the good, the better and the best. It's like multilevel marketing. Anyway, Sean, will you correct all the false doctrine I've just taught? ahead. Okay.
Shawn (02:47.989)
Well, we could put, but.
Matt (02:56.945)
Yeah, that's right. So.
Shawn (03:00.907)
Yeah, I'm gonna bring in a scripture, how about that? It's an easy one. And this doesn't, no, it does, it does. This is Alma 4011.
Matt (03:03.802)
I don't think that's gonna help.
Sam DArc (03:05.863)
You
Sam DArc (03:10.36)
Okay.
Shawn (03:10.473)
Matt, know this one by heart. now concerning the state of the soul between death and the resurrection, which is like huge. That's a huge statement there. It has been made known unto me. Whoops, I lost it. It's been made known unto me. I lost it. the souls of all men, as soon as they're departed, as soon as they're departed from the natural body, immortal body, the spirits of all men, whether they be good or evil are taken home to that God, which gave them life.
Matt (03:11.665)
Yeah, yeah, talks about a holding cell.
Matt (03:24.775)
that the souls of every person after they depart this mortal life
Sam DArc (03:27.086)
Honestly, I think my explanation was better.
Shawn (03:39.781)
And then it talks about how those who did not turn to Christ will suffer and those who did turn to Christ will be in a state of paradise. And this all leads to an ultimate judgment or resurrection. At which time Sam's crude definition kind of goes into effect, right? The Bible says, the Bible says, you make fun of your Utah multi -level marketing more than anybody.
Matt (03:56.153)
Yeah, that was crude, Sam.
Sam DArc (03:57.388)
You can't call multi -level marketing crude, new skin would sue you. We officially apologize. What?
Matt (04:01.788)
Yeah.
Matt (04:05.233)
Yeah, to all of you that are selling multi -level marketing products right now, that's not crude.
Sam DArc (04:08.45)
Yeah, for a high value. Yes.
Shawn (04:08.779)
I think of all the three of us, Sam, who have mentioned multilevel marketing on this podcast, I'm at zero, Matt's at zero, you're at like 300, so you're the one mocking it. No, but it is like, but it is after that judgment, what's amazing, what I like about the doctrine is that like in the Bible says, the Lord says, in my house are many mansions. And I think we think what he's referring to obviously is this idea that a just God applies mercy and justice.
Matt (04:17.223)
You
Sam DArc (04:17.24)
Yes.
Shawn (04:35.795)
And it's not just black or white. It's not like you have to cross a line and there you're in heaven and there you're in hell. Nope. There's the celestial, the terrestrial and the telestial kingdom, all of which are different glories. So yeah, it's a nice doctrine. You can read about it all through the Book of Mormon.
Matt (04:51.911)
Hey, so listeners, let us know what you think about the idea of us talking about religion on this podcast. I think real Mormonism means we don't talk about religion. And if you disagree, keep asking us religious questions that we can answer, because we have a lot of fun talking about whatever you want to talk about.
Shawn (05:02.474)
You
Sam DArc (05:05.71)
you
Shawn (05:07.371)
And if you are, and listeners, you're from Utah and Idaho, then you might understand why Matt is so confused about these terms. Yeah? Yeah.
Matt (05:16.785)
Yeah, wait a minute. No, no Mormonism is Mormonism is the cultural, the life, the, the lived experience of members of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter -day Saints. It is emphatically not the doctrine. Hey, don't say you be in that's that's that's my company. Okay. Another listener texted, you guys seem to dance around the idea of property without really addressing it. Socialists and anarchists recognize different types of property, personal property,
Sam DArc (05:17.688)
Herbalife, new skin.
Sam DArc (05:27.136)
UBM.
That's correct.
Shawn (05:34.997)
Ha ha ha.
Sam DArc (05:40.989)
no.
Matt (05:46.343)
private property, absentee property, et cetera. Do you think all property is the same? Is your right to the business you built equal to my right to the business your daddy gave me? whoa,
Shawn (05:58.347)
Okay, watch this. The question...
Sam DArc (05:59.512)
Who's your, Hey, wait, I, I want to, I get to ask this question. Hey, Matt, Matt, Sean, who's your daddy?
Matt (06:04.093)
He gave me, he gave me, he gave someone else or is there some gray area there who determines which property is legitimate and by what criteria.
Shawn (06:06.985)
hahahaha
Shawn (06:15.221)
Okay, I've got that answer. It's a great question. Hang on.
Sam DArc (06:16.28)
But by the way, Sean would tell you that someone who has never built someone, someone who has never built a business is the only person that would ask a stupid question like that. Like to, to decline and to deny ownership of a business after the blood, sweat, tears it takes to build that business. Elon Musk said it's easier to, what does he say? Like stare into something and
Matt (06:27.611)
Hey, I built a business.
Shawn (06:27.829)
hahahaha
Matt (06:40.829)
to take a camel through the eye of a needle.
Sam DArc (06:44.162)
That's the exact quote, except not by Elon Musk. It's tough to build a business. And you know, it's amazing how once a business is successful and it's generating revenue and profits, how everyone wants to run in and, and partake in the success of that business. Nobody wants the risk, right? Nobody wants the financial catastrophe that happens when a business fails. And,
Shawn (06:44.715)
Shut up,
Shawn (07:02.816)
Ha
Matt (07:07.333)
You are not going to like the scripture I have for this, but Sean, you go first.
Shawn (07:10.099)
Well, yeah, before you bring it, Matt, hang on. Yeah, before you bring it, Matt. So the question of who determines
Sam DArc (07:10.252)
I, you know what? Yes, Sean, go ahead.
Matt (07:16.859)
Yeah, you go first, Sean. see, you, cause you're ready for this.
Matt (07:22.877)
Mm -hmm. Did we lose you, Sean? I think we lost him for a second. So then I'm going to share my verse. This is Doctrine and Covenants, section 78, verses five and six. Sam, you're not going to like this one either. That you may be equal in the bonds of heavenly things, yea, and earthly things also for the obtaining of heavenly things.
Sam DArc (07:31.617)
Okay.
Sam DArc (07:38.701)
Alright, I'm listening.
Sam DArc (07:44.11)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (07:49.501)
For if you are not equal in earthly things, you cannot be equal in obtaining heavenly things. So what they're saying in this verse, because this is the creation of the United Order in Independence, Missouri, is that if you're not equal, where everybody has the exact same stuff on earth, you can't be equal in heavenly things.
Sam DArc (08:08.45)
Yeah. And Matt, how did that work out for them back then with the United Order? How did that, how, how did that work out?
Matt (08:13.821)
Well, they had to work on it, right? mean, we ideally.
Sam DArc (08:19.266)
Wait, but just remind me because I forget how many years did it endure in our world today.
Shawn (08:23.319)
Matt did you?
Matt (08:25.617)
The United Order lasted for two years.
Sam DArc (08:27.96)
for two years, not even the length of a normal mission. So it failed and why did it fail, Matt?
Matt (08:30.999)
Ha ha ha!
Shawn (08:34.755)
Matt. Matt.
Matt (08:35.131)
because they didn't want to go to heaven. think it's because they didn't want to go to heaven because it says if you, if you can't be equal in earthly things, you can't be equal.
Sam DArc (08:37.674)
I... Many, many, many are called but few are chosen. And why are they not chosen, Matt?
Shawn (08:47.395)
Jeez.
Matt (08:47.771)
Because they don't want to go to heaven.
Sam DArc (08:49.644)
Right. Yeah. It doesn't work in our world. you, property is an important element of, of increasing what you have and taking risk and being able to give back to other people. If you don't have property, what's the incentive to work hard and to do better day by day, right? Other than
Matt (08:53.382)
Okay.
Matt (09:09.561)
I know that Sean came prepared with this one, so let...
Shawn (09:11.235)
Yeah, my back. Can you hear me?
Sam DArc (09:13.528)
Sean, you know what? If Sean's Internet connection will support his scriptural reading, Sean, go ahead.
Shawn (09:15.603)
Okay. All right, I'm back.
Matt (09:19.855)
Yeah, he's back. Let us have it, Sean. I know you're ready.
Shawn (09:20.163)
Well, the easy answer is this. Who should determine which property is legitimate and by what criteria? It's so simple. Whoever owns the property can decide where it goes. Right? He talks about
Okay, so God in the scriptures does say that there's a couple of things that are, he supports us defending, for example, our property. He says literally in D &C, he says, is justified to defend your property. So Matt.
Matt (09:33.181)
That would be God. God owns everything.
Matt (09:49.575)
But before that verse in the Doctrine and Covenants, he says to give it all away to the church, that everyone should be equal.
Shawn (09:50.859)
Only under, no that's only under a certain condition, right? And yes, it is under a certain, you don't make a covenant to consecrate in that way at this point, right? Tithing is that version. No, that's not the words of the covenant. To the Lord's church, right? So if the Lord's church requires you give all your property, then you would.
Matt (10:08.413)
I think we do. Pretty sure I made a covenant to do that, to give everything I have.
Yeah.
Sam DArc (10:17.56)
Yeah. But, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, by the way, by the way, for you to have everything, you have to own something. You can't give everything back. If you don't have anything this, why does this feel like a Seinfeld episode in order for you to give stuff, you have to have stuff. And you know, all these, all these self, all these self, all these self -righteous people that sit around feeling inordinate guilt because they have so much give it.
Shawn (10:20.003)
Yeah.
Matt (10:28.605)
Everything I get everything I get
Shawn (10:31.553)
Matt, you're a government guy. You like law.
Shawn (10:44.385)
Matt, the DNC says that one of the reasons that law exists is for the redress of all wrongs and grievances where personal abuse is inflicted or the right of property is infringed. And then it says where such laws exist as they will protect all men who are justified in defending themselves and their property.
Sam DArc (10:45.752)
That's their opportunity to give, but if you don't have, can't give.
Matt (11:07.323)
Yeah, but Sean.
Matt (11:11.197)
Sean, when they are writing that verse in the Doctrine and Covenants, there are Native Americans whose land they are taking away from them, whose property they are taking away from them. Yeah, so you can't say the person who decides how to distribute property is the person who owns property because property ownership laws are defined by the people who win the war, who win the fight, who become the next government. So property ownership is a very like loose idea.
Shawn (11:14.847)
unjustly right unjustly yeah unjustly no no no no no no
Shawn (11:23.885)
That's the rightful way, yeah.
Shawn (11:32.075)
No, it's easy, no, no, no, but Matt, it's easy to say that, it's easy to say that if you could argue that a Native American who lives on a certain land, they didn't even have the concept of we own this land. didn't even, they don't claim, many don't claim that they owned the land. They claim that they were there and they lived there and then no one could take it away from them, but they didn't claim ownership of it, right?
Matt (11:55.655)
So then they shouldn't.
Matt (11:59.911)
But when the Mormons in the Cache Valley slaughtered hundreds of Native Americans in the Bear River Valley,
Shawn (12:03.447)
Who justifies that? -nobody justifies that, man.
Sam DArc (12:08.11)
Take that back. Take that back, Matt. That never happened. Fake news, false history, that never happened.
Shawn (12:09.985)
Nobody supports that.
Matt (12:11.163)
I'm just saying you're, but, but they did support that Sean and the property that's there is only, only belongs to the native Americans because they organized and purchased the land back from the people that took it away from them. So I'm just saying like the idea that
Shawn (12:14.613)
No, nobody supports that.
Shawn (12:24.823)
There you go. So now so they introduced a law that allows them to own which the DNC says the laws should be created to protect personal property ownership.
Matt (12:34.329)
Okay, but if China comes in or Russia comes in and destroys that government that has that law, then who decides property ownership in that situation?
Shawn (12:39.351)
Well, yeah, if it's taken by force, yeah, there's no choice, of course.
Sam DArc (12:41.742)
China, Russia.
Matt (12:46.245)
all property is always taken by force at some point. It is. That's like, that's like the way government works.
Shawn (12:47.191)
That's the...
Shawn (12:53.923)
That's the way your Marx government works. Your Marxist government.
Sam DArc (12:54.914)
Now, but so, so if you think about this though, you think about what's when, when, when you think about what's best for personal growth development of the individual and of the society, our free market is awesome because truly think about Russia and Ukraine. When we lived there, people didn't have the same property ownership. And you're right. The government decided that because they were the ultimate force that was able to decide it.
Matt (12:59.908)
All governments work this way.
Sam DArc (13:22.604)
And the lack of that personal ownership took away an incentive to risk, be creative, to innovate, to contribute. And it stifled growth for generations, for decades. And Russia's seeing that right now again today. China has a, has a version of that same problem, right? The government ultimately owns everything. If they see something they want, they can come and take it and they can own it.
And that stifles the free market and creativity and innovation and Chinese people and Russian people and people from all over the country come to the United States to participate in our free market because of the property protections that are there. So the best governments will protect that property ownership.
Shawn (13:59.117)
Yeah, metal.
Shawn (14:02.849)
Yeah, and Matt, in fact, let me read from your favorite author. He says this, he says this, almost, almost one of the other favorite ones. No, he says this. He says, in fact, the abolition of private property is doubtless the shortest and most significant way to characterize the revolution in the whole social order. Yeah, that's right. Which has been made necessary by the development of industry and for reasons rightly advanced to communists, their main demand. And then he says, above all, it will have to take the control of industry and of all branches of production out of the hands
Matt (14:09.489)
Hmm, tostoy?
Sam DArc (14:12.108)
Lenin.
Matt (14:21.469)
That's Karl Marx.
Sam DArc (14:23.339)
Mmm.
Shawn (14:31.691)
of mutually competing individuals and instead instituted a system of which all these branches. Yeah. Yeah. They said the number one, right. The number one focus in a communist society is to take personal property away from everybody.
Matt (14:37.467)
Right, you want to take it away from the merchant class. He's saying take it away from the merchant class and give it to the people.
Matt (14:50.735)
Right, right. That's because communism, he believed that when you own the means of production, then you control everything else in society. So that's right. Well, I don't know. We haven't really had a Marxist government anywhere in the world. We wouldn't really know if it works. Socialism's not the... No, no, no. No, no.
Shawn (14:55.127)
Yeah, it doesn't work. It doesn't work.
Shawn (15:00.439)
Socialism, communism was, it was pretty closely providing those. Look, when the Marxist idea is that the first principle is to abolish private property and then communists and the Bolsheviks do that, you're applying the principles of Marxism.
Matt (15:18.919)
They didn't, they didn't, they did not abolish private property. They took private property and gave it to the government. That's not what Karl Marx said you do.
Shawn (15:20.173)
They did too.
Shawn (15:24.183)
Yes, he did. just read what he says. It's exactly what he says you do.
Matt (15:29.501)
Abolishing private property is not the same as giving it to the government. Those are different things.
Shawn (15:30.651)
my gosh, I've got so many, I've got so many, I don't wanna bore everyone. It goes into detail, it gives the steps. No, no, Sam's bored. It gives the steps. He literally in the Communist Manifesto gives the steps, how do you abolish private property? And it starts with high taxation and it goes down to the government taking by eminent domain private property.
Sam DArc (15:37.646)
I'm bored. I'm bored. I'm bored.
Sam DArc (15:46.83)
Mm -hmm.
Shawn (15:52.597)
I know it doesn't, but that's what it means. But that's what it means. Yes, it does. Sam.
Matt (15:53.903)
He never says eminent domain anywhere in the communist manifesto. No, it doesn't. Okay. We've got to move to the next question. My friends and I were recently telling mission stories. It seems clear that the payment of bribes by missionaries is an open secret. What do you think about the payment of bribes to advance the missionary effort? I have a story about this. This is okay. But before I tell the story, I'm just going to introduce this idea. It's called political culture and just like
Sam DArc (15:59.22)
Okay, next topic. I'm bored. Okay.
Shawn (16:09.955)
Wow. Yeah, tell us the story.
Shawn (16:18.883)
political culture.
Matt (16:23.461)
just like societies have different kinds of cultures about how to like make food and how to entertain and all those sorts of things. Societies develop their own political culture. And in the United States, our political culture says that briberies are bad, but that's not a universal truth. in, no, it's true.
Shawn (16:39.871)
Wow. Wow.
Sam DArc (16:43.252)
no, no, Matt is trying to re -educate the masses. That's interesting. That's what they do in communism, Matt, by the way. Wrong isn't wrong. Wrong is right.
Shawn (16:47.905)
Now finish your story, yeah.
Matt (16:49.679)
No, it's, I'm saying it's not, it's not a universe. There are places you, there are places you can go where, and by the way, somebody shared a story about this in general conference that they were trying to get a marriage license and they weren't able to until they gave a dog to the person who was giving out marriage licenses as a, as a gift, right? Like in other cultures, there's this like reciprocity, there's this gift giving, and then there's in the United States, we would call it a fee for expedited service.
where you just pay a little bit more money and then it happens faster. In other countries, bribes are kind of like that. Anyhow, here's my story.
Shawn (17:20.027)
So you're saying that it's not a universal truth because who's gonna decide what kind of exchange I wanna enter into, That's what you're saying. It's not a universal truth because it's almost capitalistic, right? It's barter, it's a barter system.
Matt (17:34.841)
Yeah, yeah, I'm saying it's yeah, and I'm saying in terms of
In terms of political culture, it's not appropriate for me to tell somebody else's government or their society how they ought to function based on the things that I'm used to and the way that things happen in my culture and my society. like nation, but so here's my funny, it's a funny story. I have a friend who was a mission president and as part of like to keep the mission functioning, they would give bribes to these like elected officials and he,
Shawn (17:51.648)
I like that. I'll buy that. Okay.
Matt (18:09.071)
as he gets his first year in mission service, he's like, I don't like this. And he starts complaining, trying to find a way around it. And the area president is like saying to him, calm down, man. You just have, this is just the way things are done in this country. And he's like, but this is morally wrong. And they would have a lot of discussions about it. Well, then year two comes around and there's still all of these problems. And he's like, not content. By the way, he told me this story himself. So I'm not like, this isn't my perception. This is what he told me. He's like,
It was morally wrong and I could not persuade the area president to stop paying these bribes to these elected officials in order to get things done. He said, and so then what happened was they told me as I was coming up on my second year of service, did you know that if you're called as a mission president to an area where it's a hardship mission, your mission presidency is only two years instead of three years. And recently we've decided that your mission is a hardship mission. And so you're only going to serve two years.
Shawn (18:59.432)
Wow. Wow.
Matt (19:06.127)
And then you're going to go. Yeah, yeah. Because I think that this happens, right? We put our own values on other societies and situations and we need to just be like, look, that's not that's not my place to decide what they should or shouldn't do.
Sam DArc (19:06.188)
kicked him out. Wow.
Shawn (19:12.685)
That's interesting, Matt.
That's an interesting take. You've swayed me.
Sam DArc (19:20.59)
I remember we paid bribes, we paid bribes to get medical equipment into Ukraine back in the day. So, I mean, yeah. Well, I didn't, but the church did. yeah. Yeah.
Shawn (19:23.639)
Did you? Did you really Sam? What I want to know. I thought you were gonna say I was with a missionary once like on a split and we had to go secure a meeting place. And for sure there was a bribe given there and it was it was an alcoholic bribe.
Matt (19:27.056)
Right.
Yeah!
Matt (19:43.751)
Mm -hmm.
Sam DArc (19:43.938)
But the better, more interesting question today, I think is, should the church or governments pay bribes to get missionaries back if they're taken hostage? So especially in light of the hostage exchange in Russia, right? So high value hostage exchanges. And the answer is yes, right? No, it's not. It's not my topic. Yes.
Matt (19:53.349)
Yes, for sure.
Shawn (19:57.965)
Is that your topic, Sam? Is that your topic today?
Matt (20:05.213)
But for sure they should, right? I saw a news program where Zelensky's like they're in Russia, right? And they're capturing these prisoners of war, these Russian soldiers. And Zelensky has said like in public speeches, these are the currency we're gathering for prisoner exchanges in the future. Like we need Russian soldiers as prisoners so we can exchange them for our prisoners in the future. Like in some places, that's just the way things are done.
Shawn (20:28.131)
I like it, man.
Matt (20:30.747)
Yeah, OK. Hey listeners, thanks for your emails and texting listeners. We enjoy it. Again, we would remind you if you want us to talk about religion, just keep asking us religion questions. Otherwise we're not going to do it because I there's zero chance that Sam's going to come up with a theological question. Maybe Sean will, but I. It's time for the thought provoker. Sam, do you have a religious question you want to ask this?
Shawn (20:38.061)
Ha ha ha.
Yes we are!
Sam DArc (20:48.622)
my goodness. This is abuse.
Shawn (20:48.993)
I will.
Shawn (20:54.263)
hahahaha
Sam DArc (20:57.77)
All right. Nope. Nope. I have a political, I was going to go with unions, but I'm actually going to change it up just a little bit. The political environment right now is too exciting between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump to not go into politics. So Trump over the, yeah, I've been practicing Trump over the past couple of weeks has gone off the rails a little bit and some of his word tracks and speeches. And one of the things he said among many, Matt,
Shawn (21:09.645)
Sam said her name right. Good job, good job.
Sam DArc (21:25.438)
before we started the show, you were talking about, compared his looks to Kamala Harris, which is fascinating. Yes. But, but, but the other clip that is fascinating because it, goes to a foreign policy is who pays tariffs. So Donald Trump swears this week that it's the foreign governments that pay the tariffs and news agencies, NPR, left -leaning news agencies have just grabbed onto that and they're playing it left and right.
Matt (21:29.735)
He is so beautiful, so beautiful.
Sam DArc (21:55.572)
And you hear the apologists on the conservative side arguing the one side and you hear liberals arguing the other or informed individuals. So ultimately who pays a tariff, Matt? Yeah. Yeah. This is my question. It's the best I could come up with short notice. Yeah.
Shawn (22:02.381)
You
Matt (22:03.483)
or just informed individuals.
Matt (22:12.517)
Really? Really? This is your question? Okay. I'm going to, I'm going to, I'm going to just sort of ask it in a different way, Sam. Who pays a sales tax? Yeah, but not directly, right? Directly a sales tax is like, let's say that I sell auto parts or I do some kind of a service. I have to collect the sales tax and then the government comes to me and collects that sales tax revenue from me. So indirectly,
Sam DArc (22:22.254)
the consumer.
Sam DArc (22:26.402)
Correct.
Sam DArc (22:36.418)
Mm
Matt (22:42.097)
business owners and private individuals who sell things have to collect sales tax on behalf of the federal and state governments. But the cost of that sales tax, they pass that on to consumers. This is exactly what happens with a tariff. When a tariff is levied, there's going to be, sometimes it's a government, if it's a state owned company or something like that, that actually gets levied the tax and has to pay that tariff. But they always pass that onto the consumer.
in the form of higher prices for the goods and services they produce? This is not a difficult question,
Sam DArc (23:16.014)
So are you in favor of tariffs? Yes or no?
Matt (23:19.133)
I am not in favor of tariffs because I'm in favor of free trade. I think that free trade is a good idea. think that if, because I think that if we want to tax people, we should tax their income. We should tax their wealth. People who have too much we should take from them, but goods and services should not be taxed for purchase. You should be able to purchase something without paying a tax on it.
Shawn (23:22.679)
Cause Matt's a capitalist.
Shawn (23:35.971)
You
Bye, what?
I'll take the opposite side that you can use tariffs as a political tool, right? Like we're not obligated, our government is not obligated to make sure that the consumers and the business owners in China are successful. They can use it as a tool, a political tool, why not?
Sam DArc (23:41.496)
Sean, you agreeing with Matt here on this?
Matt (23:50.769)
You're not a libertarian.
Matt (24:04.253)
But you understand comparative advantage, right? The international trade idea that like Ukraine can produce wheat for less expensive than Egypt can produce wheat. So Egypt should focus on the things that they can produce and Ukraine focuses on the things that they can produce. And then you have free exchange and it lowers the cost of goods for everybody because you have free exchange between countries.
Shawn (24:22.455)
Yeah, but again, politically, you can use it as a tool. And I see your point, of course.
Matt (24:30.585)
Why would I use that as a - why would I
Sam DArc (24:32.312)
So, so, so one of, here's my take, if you're curious, there's my take. One of the functions of the government is to protect the United States, right? And it's to ensure our ability to exist now and into the future. And a threat to national security is our inability to provide basic services and functions here in the United States. So an interesting thing happened. I forget what year it was, but it was several years ago, there was the huge,
Shawn (24:33.729)
Yes, very curious.
Matt (24:36.529)
Yeah, yeah.
Sam DArc (25:01.582)
there was a huge tsunami that hit Japan and it hit the Fukushima nuclear plant. And then it also hit a lesser known microchip plant where 95 % of all the microchips that are used in the production of automobiles were created. And not a lot of people realize this, but it quickly created a supply chain problem that immediately impacted automotive all around the world.
Matt (25:04.721)
Sam DArc (25:28.142)
So if you were looking to buy a car in the United States, if you're looking to buy a car in England, if you're looking to buy a car in Japan or China, because 98 % of those microchips were produced at that plant near Fukushima, they just weren't in existence. People lost their jobs. It crippled the auto industry short -term. One solution to that ended up becoming, the US saw that as a threat because all of the microchip production was in that one facility.
It was to levy a tariff against those. So as they came in, those microchips were more expensive and it incentivized a US based companies to produce similar microchips and an industry that had been decimated in the United States, i .e. it was much less expensive to make these microchips in Japan, China and Taiwan returned in some form function or another to the US.
It would never have been cost effective to do that were that tariff not there. And we've seen that similarly happen in oil and other industries where based on the cycle of the price, countries with much lower production costs can come in, they can dominate an entire segment that could threaten our national security, remove it completely from the United States, and then we become reliant on other countries.
The trick is identifying what are those industries? What are those services? Oil is certainly one, microchips are certainly another, and levying those tariffs as a disincentive from removing production capability here in the US.
Shawn (27:01.505)
That's interesting, Sam. don't know if I agree with you. don't know if using it as a... Well, I'm just saying is I don't... Using it as a...
Sam DArc (27:09.036)
Wait, you can't disagree with me. That's fact.
Matt (27:12.189)
Well, you're saying that you're saying a political tool the way you described before, Sean.
Shawn (27:13.783)
Yeah, no, no, no, I'm saying, Sam, if you're using it as an economic tool versus a political tool, then I'm not sure. I guess.
Sam DArc (27:17.262)
it's in defense of the United States.
Sam DArc (27:25.624)
It's a political tool and it's an economic tool.
Matt (27:26.555)
Listen, the problem with tariffs is, especially when you use them as a political tool, we put tariffs on Russia. They're experiencing a great deal of pain in trying to export Russian oil. We put tariffs on Iran to try to punish them for things that they're doing. And what happens is they find a way around our tariffs, they find a way around our economic system, and they sell oil to India on the cheap. And India profits and benefits from that because
Sam DArc (27:50.36)
Yeah.
Matt (27:53.573)
We're using tariffs as a tool to try to make other countries do what we want them to do.
Sam DArc (27:58.478)
That's another, that's a sanction, right? So that's, that's a tariff used as a disincentive to hurt economically the country. And you could argue that the tariff on oil exports to Russia has actually made it more money than it ever made before the tariff, right? Because it increased the cost of oil in the market because the amount of oil in the market was reduced by Russia's supply. And so they go sell it on the cheap and the cheap ends up being more expensive than the market.
Matt (28:06.183)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (28:14.566)
Right.
Sam DArc (28:28.302)
price of oil before, correct? But what I'm talking about is using tariffs as a way to protect production capabilities here in the U S so that in emergencies. Yes, you do. Why you can't it.
Matt (28:30.364)
Right.
Matt (28:37.853)
But you don't need to, but you don't need to. Well, I don't know. Listen, Trump put those tariffs on China and it didn't do anything to help our industries at home. And all it did is make things more expensive in the United States. So it seems weird for the person to be complaining about high prices and then at the same time say, I love tariffs. Listen, Sean, we debated and Sam found some story that we never found the link to. I'm telling you, Sean.
Shawn (28:47.125)
dear.
Sam DArc (28:51.086)
But when...
Shawn (28:53.283)
That's not what caused the inflation. We've debated this past, Matt. That's not what caused inflation.
Shawn (29:07.041)
No, they didn't. Okay.
Matt (29:07.517)
Those tariffs increased prices before the pandemic. They're a part of the increase of you can't put 25 % tariffs on aluminum and steel and expect it to have no effect on prices.
Sam DArc (29:10.956)
No, not sure the pandemic lack of supply. And so by, by, by the way, by the way, no, listen, listen, what I'm describing is exactly what happened during COVID supply chains were shut down and we were stuck with our ability to produce, products here in the U S largely. that, that impacted our supply chain all around the globe. So using tariffs.
Matt (29:27.866)
Yeah!
Matt (29:38.075)
and now things are more expensive because we're producing them at home at a higher cost.
Sam DArc (29:40.824)
They're more expensive, but at, but eventually it'll come back down, but tariffs in areas, tariffs in areas where it's key and crucial to our defense and our ability to continue as a U S. aren't a bad tool to help protect a production in the U S like
Matt (30:01.809)
I'm going to give Sean the points on this one because Sean said that tariffs are good for if you use them for political purposes.
Shawn (30:03.937)
And I'll give him to Matt because Matt is very pro capitalist in this. He's very free market in this, which he's usually not.
Sam DArc (30:08.888)
Ha ha ha ha.
Matt (30:13.149)
Free trade, I'm all about free trade. Free trade is great for everybody.
Shawn (30:13.216)
Ha ha.
Sam DArc (30:13.506)
That is true by the way. That is true by the way. And, and you're anti -Trump. So you're going to take that the flip side of Trump no matter what.
Shawn (30:16.087)
No matter what, no matter what.
Matt (30:20.783)
Listen, listen, To be anti -Trump does not require a deep discussion about tariffs, right? We could have picked so many things he said this week.
Sam DArc (30:27.69)
Hey, Matt, Matt, who's, who's better looking Trump or Kamala?
Shawn (30:31.841)
Matt, I think what Sam is saying, if Kamala would have said, I am for terrorists, you'd be arguing for terrorists. I think that's what Sam's saying.
Matt (30:33.629)
Kamala Harris is by far better looking than Donald Trump.
Matt (30:42.683)
No, I really don't follow the what I don't choose my positions based on what presidents say. Right? Like I can look at what President Trump did when he was president of the United States and say was his policy, his foreign policy good for trade, bad for trade. And it's clear that it was bad for trade. So when he says this is my idea, I'll say, I know it's his idea. He did it before. Okay. Well, some at some point at some point, then maybe I'll have a topic where I actually have the
Shawn (30:44.035)
We'll see. We'll see. We'll see.
Shawn (30:56.925)
Sam had some, Sam found an article that counters that. Sam found a good article.
Shawn (31:07.651)
Blink.
Matt (31:11.703)
citations that show what I'm arguing so that we can have because then I know Sean will do the homework and Sean might like jump on my side but on this one yeah I don't know it doesn't in the end who none of our listeners care about tariffs they don't want to hear us yeah
Shawn (31:15.893)
All right, let's do that. Okay.
Shawn (31:22.049)
All right. How about this one then? How about this one? Matt, you've told me once that your favorite show was West Wing and that got you into politics. Is that correct? West Wing? So Aaron Sorkin is the writer, creator of West Wing. So before Old Man Biden endorsed Kamala Harris, Aaron Sorkin came out with a really proactive and interesting, he wrote an op -ed in the New York Times. And here's what he said, which is surprising because he's very
Sam DArc (31:26.968)
now.
Matt (31:35.451)
I do love West Wing. I own every episode on DVD.
Both, yes. He wrote the first three seasons.
Shawn (31:51.329)
left -leaning, he says, yes he is.
Matt (31:58.043)
Aaron Sorkin is not left -leaning, He's what we would call a moderate Democrat. Okay.
Shawn (31:58.781)
okay. Fine. Fine. So he says Democrats should nominate Mitt Romney. And here's his reasoning. Nominating Mitt would be putting our money where our mouth is a clear and powerful demonstration that this election isn't about what our elections are usually about, but about stopping a deranged man from taking power. What an interesting thing, right? He's like, look, of course, if you Democrats put up Mitt Romney, Republicans will vote for him. What you shaking your head for?
Matt (32:29.223)
No they won't!
Sam DArc (32:29.794)
Wait, would not. Kamala Harris is more electable than Mitt Romney as a Democrat, Democratic candidate.
Shawn (32:32.041)
No, that's not...
Matt (32:34.877)
Right. Sean, this is like a Hollywood dream. Like this is Aaron Sorkin saying, wow, I wish I had thought of this when I was making a TV show.
Shawn (32:35.457)
No, no, no, no, no. No, no, no, Sam, I think, no, let me explain it. He's saying put up Mitt Romney because Kamala wouldn't even be in the picture. Put up Mitt Romney against Donald Trump and you're going to get people like Sean voting for Mitt Romney over Trump. It's going to be, if it's about beating, there would to be, if it's about beating Trump, then put up someone who can beat Trump.
Matt (32:50.567)
So what? He... Sean, you would vote for him. You're not enough Republicans. Sean, Sean...
Sam DArc (33:00.142)
There, he would, he would get, he would get no large percentage of the democratic vote. Like he would lose Democrats.
Shawn (33:04.611)
You think they'd vote for Trump over Romney? No way.
Matt (33:07.837)
Imagine
Imagine that the Republican primary election that happened about a year ago was Mitt Romney versus Donald Trump and nobody else is running. It's just Mitt Romney and Donald Trump. Who wins those Republican primaries?
Shawn (33:18.679)
Yeah.
Shawn (33:23.181)
Trump does, but that's, but in a case where Democrats aren't even taking part, then maybe Trump does. But when Democrats come in and go, all they go, what we need to do is do whatever it takes to stop Trump. Then it's a clear and easy win for Mitt Romney. Over Trump, they would want him over Trump. That's why, that's his point. You're not understanding his point. He's saying, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, his point.
Sam DArc (33:23.886)
That was the primary.
Matt (33:29.21)
Okay.
Matt (33:34.46)
Why would
Matt (33:39.931)
Why would they want Mitt Romney? They have, they
So, so you're saying I understand it. His point is that he wants good drama. Sean, I'm saying to you, why would a demo, why would Democrats choose somebody that they don't like? But Democrats will just stay home on election day. They're not going to come out and vote for someone they dislike.
Shawn (33:50.423)
Because they hate Trump worse.
Shawn (33:55.511)
Yeah, and Trump will win. No, they wouldn't. would go extra.
Sam DArc (34:00.472)
But but but, but Sean, they actually like Harris. They actually like Harris. This is the crazy thing. They actually think, they actually think Harris has a shot, which is baffling to me, but they, they actually think, got it.
Shawn (34:01.431)
Yeah, I know, but this was before Harris was an option. This was before she was an option.
Matt (34:05.031)
You
Shawn (34:08.491)
they did not Sam but they didn't until Biden endorsed her before that they didn't think everyone thought she was the biggest joke in the world. Everyone did.
Matt (34:13.597)
She has...
Shawn (34:19.191)
Yeah, no, but before that...
Sam DArc (34:20.76)
Got it.
Matt (34:20.797)
Have you seen the national polls where she's ahead by 4 % right now?
Sam DArc (34:23.702)
Yeah, but you talked about this. come, you come into the DNC. It's, it's, she's got a little bump. The bumps done. She's going to descend way back below Trump. still.
Matt (34:30.427)
Yeah, maybe. Guess what? Kamala Harris has a much better chance than Mitt Romney. A much better chance. Sean, the Kamala Harris ignites and excites Democratic voters in a way that Mitt Romney never could. And that's what matters. sorry. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Sorry. I didn't, I thought you asked your question.
Shawn (34:34.124)
Alright, see you guys later.
Sam DArc (34:36.235)
Yeah, that is true. I agree with you on that.
Shawn (34:37.677)
Well, let me, well you didn't even let me ask my question. So I'm gonna ask my question anyway, because you guys didn't even.
The altruistic move in Aaron Sorkin's idea would be if you really think that Trump is the worst person for our country, then you'll do the right thing, whatever it would take to get him out. And in this case, Mitt Romney clearly went over someone else. So it could work that way.
Sam DArc (35:04.974)
But, but, but that's, but that's not the way our political system works. Our political system doesn't work to con, it's not a game of risk where everybody conspires against the one player to absolutely take the one player. Everybody's trying to put forth their best option.
Shawn (35:14.509)
That's that's that's exactly but Matt Sam, that's exactly my question. Is it impossible to think that a political party would ever do something altruistic like that? You're saying no, they wouldn't because it's a game. It's because it's a game of power.
Matt (35:26.247)
That's not altruistic. Sean, what I'm saying is, I'm saying that what you're describing is not altruism. Choosing somebody from the other party is not an altruistic choice. If the other...
Shawn (35:28.45)
It is too.
Shawn (35:33.083)
Matt, hang on, on, hang on. Let me stop you right there. The number one message I hear every single day from every news source is if Trump becomes president, our democracy is lost. So it's altruistic because he's saying, no, you don't. the reason why it's altruistic is because if their claim is, if the Democrats claim is that he is Satan and if he wins, it's the end of America, then the altruistic move would
Sam DArc (35:37.773)
It's suicide.
Matt (35:48.4)
I agree with that.
Sam DArc (35:49.4)
You don't hear that on Fox News.
Matt (35:53.393)
That's it.
Shawn (35:59.735)
Be do something that ensures his win because Kamala Harris sure doesn't do that
Matt (36:05.149)
That would not, but what I'm saying, Sean, is that that doesn't ensure the win. Choosing a Republic. No, no, it doesn't, Sean. Mitt Romney can't even win the Republican primary. He's not going to win the general election.
Shawn (36:06.131)
More than Kamala Harris does. Yeah, it does. It does be.
Matt, know, I know, but I know that what Aaron Sorkin is saying that you're going to take all those Democratic votes and now they're all of a sudden going to be voting for a Republican.
Matt (36:23.973)
Aaron Sorkin
Sam DArc (36:25.208)
So, so I, I want to give Sean all the points because what he did in setting up this question, he started by trying to make a play for Matt on this, bringing Matt in and saying, Hey, you know what? love West wing. You love the show. You own the entire thing. Like you've never disagreed with a single thing. Aaron Sorkin has ever written said, done thought, whatever. And therefore you think this ludicrous idea of Mitt Romney, who, by the way, we all love Mitt Romney, but he tanked his own candidacy.
Shawn (36:37.507)
Shut up. was not. I was not. No I was
Matt (36:38.769)
You
Ha ha!
Hahahaha
Shawn (36:45.389)
You
Matt (36:49.425)
Hahaha
Yeah, right.
Sam DArc (36:54.936)
He's not president of the United States right now for his own. It's his own fault, right? Had he done certain things, he would be president. He didn't do them. He's, he's a terrible candidate. He would not win either the Democrat side or the Republican side. And you put the two babies together and you still don't have a president. it's Sean, you get all the points.
Matt (37:02.737)
Right.
Shawn (37:06.775)
All right, so Sam, Sam gets my points because he at least you get all the points Sam, because you at least tried to answer my question. Matt just wouldn't even consider it.
Matt (37:19.399)
Sean, I'm going to give you, I'm going to give you a football analogy to restate your question. The Kansas city chiefs and the San Francisco 49ers are playing in the super bowl and somebody says to the San Francisco 49ers, it's the worst thing in the world of Patrick Mahomes wins another super bowl MVP. So what you guys should do 49ers is you should leave the field and take the second team of the Kansas city chiefs and have the like B team Kansas city chiefs play.
Sam DArc (37:23.456)
no, please don't.
Sam DArc (37:31.982)
It's not the same thing. It's not the same thing.
Shawn (37:42.861)
That doesn't work. analogy doesn't work.
That does not work. Good try, good try.
Matt (37:47.389)
Because maybe they could beat the Kansas City Chiefs.
Sam DArc (37:48.748)
Matt, Matt, Matt, that that's a much worse comparison. That does not work. Yeah. No, it's try this Taylor Swift. nevermind. That's okay.
Matt (37:52.982)
Okay, I tried yeah, it doesn't make any sense
Shawn (37:53.239)
Hahaha!
Shawn (37:58.295)
That's why I'm disappointed in Democrats then because the altruistic move would be like, if Trump is the devil, then let me vote for someone who can definitely beat him. Let's join the Republicans.
Matt (37:58.909)
Sean, there's no world in which Democrats are going to vote for Mitt Romney. So it's a bad idea.
Sam DArc (38:04.534)
Okay, let's move on. Let's move on.
Matt (38:14.599)
How about if Trump is the devil the Republicans don't nominate him as their person? That's the solution. If the Republicans choose somebody like that, then you can pick anyone you want to beat him.
Shawn (38:14.979)
That's what I'm saying. That's what saying. They've already screwed up. They've already screwed up. The Democrats could do something altruistic and they don't.
Sam DArc (38:23.384)
So you know, the, the, the, the, fast, the fascinating next step, if the Republicans wanted to follow the Democrats lunacy would be Republicans putting Trump pressure on Trump and flipping Trump out for some other very electable candidate. It, it, it would never happen, but you've seen little shades of it here and there people questioning Trump's sanity, things he's saying like.
Matt (38:28.241)
They did!
Shawn (38:35.848)
Shut up, that's not gonna happen. Yeah, but that's not gonna
Matt (38:42.949)
No, it's true.
Shawn (38:45.184)
now you agree math that there's altruistic moves that people can make crazy things that people could do.
Sam DArc (38:54.08)
You have to do it within your own party. can't flip the party that way.
Matt (38:54.649)
No, Sean, Sean, what I'm saying is what the Democrats did was altruistic. What Joe Biden did was altruistic.
Shawn (38:56.929)
No, it wasn't. had no, he was forced out. He wasn't altruist. That's ridiculous. He was forced out. Yes, they did.
Matt (39:06.757)
Nobody forced him. Nobody had any power to force him out. He had to choose to do that, Sean. So the Democrats, look, I'm just saying you're underselling their altruism. Joe Biden did the altruistic thing because Joe Biden believes Trump's a threat. So he doesn't have to be more altruistic by endorsing Mitt Romney instead of Kamala Harris.
Shawn (39:08.235)
You think it was out of altruism? Okay.
Shawn (39:14.059)
Why did he wait so long?
Shawn (39:24.427)
Matt, what if, if Kamala loses, which I think she might, if she loses, yeah, I think she will then how altruistic was all of it. It was all out of self preservation and power.
Sam DArc (39:25.581)
no.
no.
Matt (39:34.055)
Mm -hmm.
Sam DArc (39:34.093)
too well.
Matt (39:36.699)
I mean, at least they put up a good fight, right?
Sam DArc (39:36.952)
You know, to quote Biden, and it's kind of a loser statement, at least he did his best. Mic drop. Yeah.
Shawn (39:40.424)
Alright, Matt's up.
Matt (39:46.011)
Right. Okay, so we're going to move to NASA because I know that this is a triggering topic for Sam, but I don't think that our listeners have been paying attention to this story. There's been so much excitement about presidential politics. People have forgotten that there are astronauts that are stuck in outer space.
Shawn (39:59.169)
This is an easy answer to Matt. You said Sam's disease. This is an easy answer.
Matt (40:09.471)
okay. Well, so NASA has given Boeing hundreds of millions of dollars to fund the development of a class of partially reusable spacecraft designed to transport crew to and from the International Space Station. But now the crew of one of these vessels is stuck in outer space. So what was supposed to only be an eight -day mission may take eight months because the spacecraft they took to the space station is flawed and cannot get them home again.
And so there's just waiting at the space station for another spaceship to arrive with enough space that can maybe take them home again. So the question I have is Boeing is a private corporation that is poorly managed. I don't think any of us would say I love what Boeing leadership is doing at the moment. At the same time, they receive billions of dollars in contracts from the federal government. So my question is who should taxpayers hold accountable when private companies
Shawn (41:02.339)
That's an easy answer, The contractor should, of course, unless they violated any part of the contract, this is, that's your question. You didn't ask that question. Your question, who should the taxpayers hold responsible?
Matt (41:05.915)
waste their hard -earned money.
Sam DArc (41:11.246)
Go ahead Sean.
Matt (41:18.087)
How is the taxpayer supposed to do that, Sean?
Matt (41:24.273)
Well, like if I say who should you hold accountable, there's some, well, if you're going to say Boeing should be held accountable by the taxpayer, there has to be some mechanism through which they can hold them accountable.
Shawn (41:26.647)
then you should have asked that question, because you didn't. You said, who should be held accountable? You made this government against private company.
Matt (41:37.073)
Well
Shawn (41:39.339)
Right, so the one's a customer and when the, yeah.
Matt (41:41.817)
No, it's not government against private. It's government is investing in private companies. when the government, when, the government puts billions of dollars of your money, cause I don't pay taxes, billions of dollars of your money into a program and then that company loses your money, what are you supposed to do about that? I'm just playing.
Shawn (41:44.225)
Yeah.
That's right. That's right.
Sam DArc (41:59.458)
Wait, wait, you don't pay taxes. Let's talk about that real quick. So, so you've been talking about universal basic income so you can self actualize it. You really don't pay taxes. Tell us more about that, Matt. Okay. Okay. Interesting. Interesting.
Shawn (42:04.162)
you
Hmm
Matt (42:10.749)
No, no, I pay taxes. I was just being funny. I don't pay taxes in the way that you guys pay taxes. I was looking at like the income tax rates the other day. I was like, my heavens, some people are paying a lot of money in taxes.
Sam DArc (42:22.712)
So, so I have an answer for you this number one, there's a few protections that go into these government bids. First protection is the individuals that go through the bidding process. So, so a project like building air force one building military jets, building rocket ships, these are years long and decades long projects and processes that take a long time to, to assign to award to.
hopefully as they're looking at new projects, they're not being granted those because it is a mismanaged company unless unless they fix it.
Matt (42:59.337)
But you know that they're going to be, you know they're going to get those projects because who is competing with Boeing for these contracts? Right, right. Because Boeing owns the space. And there have been times when the United States awarded contracts to Airbus, a competitor of Boeing. And then Boeing talks to the senators in all these various states and says, hey, if we don't get these federal contracts, we're shutting down our factories in your state and your state and your state.
Sam DArc (43:04.129)
Why?
Sam DArc (43:07.446)
I, you know what, I have no idea. I don't know.
Yeah.
Sam DArc (43:16.918)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (43:28.977)
You better put pressure on the federal government to give us those contracts. You better buy US and not buy Air France because we're American companies and you owe this. It's not a competitive process, Sam.
Shawn (43:35.949)
Yeah, what's your answer, Matt?
Sam DArc (43:40.536)
So who do you think should pay? How do they pay? I mean, do they got the company, the cost of, of a mistake like that would gut a company. They'd be done.
Shawn (43:46.039)
Because they made the mistake, that's just justice, Matt. You're saying they made this huge mistake.
Matt (43:49.061)
I think that that's what we should do. We should get rid of Boeing. No more Boeing. them, sell them by, sell them. What I'm saying is like, you guys are always telling me that corporations take tremendous risks and they deserve all of the profits that they earn because of the risks that they take. And I'm just pointing out that sometimes they take risks with not their money, but other people's money. And when those risks fail, then taxpayers are left holding the bag, not the corporation.
Sam DArc (44:02.456)
They do.
Shawn (44:05.399)
Yeah, but if the willing yeah, but Matt, can't you be. Yeah, but you can't just I mean, I mean, I agree they should be held accountable, but you can't look if a stupid government money by giving it to Boeing, then they have some responsibility there too. It's not just they're the good guys and the company's the bad guys. Stop meddling in an industry.
Sam DArc (44:06.616)
They do.
Matt (44:30.757)
I'm not saying they're the bad guys. I'm saying that Boeing should pay that money back. I'm saying that all of these, at some point Boeing is going to have a really nice payday and Boeing is going to make a whole bunch of money. And at that point, the federal government should say, by the way, you owe us these billions of dollars back that we invested in your company and you squandered. The government should put something in place that allows them to do that.
Shawn (44:43.267)
I mean, they should definitely pursue that. And through a legal battle, if it's judged that they should, then they definitely should. Yeah.
Shawn (44:54.093)
They should have, if they didn't, then shame on them.
Matt (44:58.737)
Why should it be legal? not write that in the contract in the first place? If you squander
Shawn (44:59.447)
Yep. I'm good with your solution,
Matt (45:05.371)
So you're in favor of that though, Sean, you'd like the government to do that?
Shawn (45:07.864)
You
Matt (45:10.693)
I like this. Well then you get the points, Sean, because you agreed with my solution. And Sam gets no points because he's not even triggered by a failure in the space program.
Shawn (45:13.438)
hahahaha
Sam DArc (45:20.334)
And you know what innovation costs billions and billions and billions of dollars of risk. So I'm okay with all the risk.
Shawn (45:20.845)
Sam says that every morning as he's drinking his Tang and putting up a Velcro picture.
Matt (45:26.845)
As long as we risk other people's money.
Sam DArc (45:30.893)
Yes.
That's right.
Matt (45:36.805)
Okay, so this podcast so far we've discussed property rights and delved into Marxism a little bit. We've talked kind of like heavy stuff about tariffs and our big question, if our listeners have not abandoned us yet, is sure to make the rest of them leave and never come back. Cause we're going to talk about ranked choice voting. Like what could be more exciting than that? I can see Sam already like, what are you kidding? We get to talk ranked choice voting? Yes we do. So,
Shawn (45:43.752)
Yeah, this is a tough one. boy.
Matt (46:05.295)
Alaska adopted ranked choice voting about two years ago. And so some political scientists studied what happens when a state adopts ranked choice voting. And what they found was that in the elections after Alaska adopted ranked choice voting, the moderate candidate won the Senate race who otherwise would have lost. And some Democrats and independents who favored the moderate Republican more than the Democrat were able to support her at all stages of the election.
And Alaskan voters like these new rules. So it seems that ranked choice voting allows people to vote for moderate candidates of the opposing party and probably leads to more moderate people winning office. So based on that, do we love ranked choice voting? Should we vote for it?
Shawn (46:46.059)
Matt, I'll answer first. I'm sure if you studied more case study, if there more case studies, I'm sure it would go all over the place. don't think ranked choice, I don't think there's enough data to prove that ranked choice voting, the outcome is always a moderate win. I don't think that's right.
Matt (47:03.653)
No it won't, Sean.
Shawn (47:10.925)
That was kind of how you led the question though, and I don't think that's the case, right?
Matt (47:13.133)
it's true. I don't want to get too technical. depends on the preferences of the voters. So in most states,
Matt (47:23.357)
So in most states, have what kind of looks like a normal distribution or a bell curve of preferences, where most people in a state are moderate and have preferences kind of in the middle. And then there's a few like 20 to 30 % of the voters that are on the extremes, one side or the other side. And so in a situation like that, ranked choice voting leads more towards the candidates in the middle because that's where most of the voters are.
and it takes away the advantages that people on the extremes have created for themselves in primary elections and making sure that more extreme candidates win.
Shawn (47:49.825)
Yeah, I wonder if more case studies would actually, I can't find, man, I'd be fine with this system. I don't see any scriptural principles or anything that would support doing this or not. I think it's a fine system. I don't think there's anything wrong with
Sam DArc (47:59.051)
So, so.
Sam DArc (48:09.486)
So, so Matt and Sean, just for our listeners, I have no idea what you're talking about. What is ranked choice, choice voting? A simple definition might be, going back to the days when you're in junior high school and you had to come up with your crush list and you had like number one, number two, number three, number four, number five. If you took your list from each year and you put them together, you would ultimately come up with a winner based on some sort of a metric showing first, second, third, fourth, fifth. Is that right, Matt?
Shawn (48:15.957)
Hahaha
Matt (48:17.008)
Yeah, so
Matt (48:24.221)
You
Matt (48:38.107)
Yeah. Yeah. It would be like in this election, Sean doesn't like Kamala Harris or Donald Trump. They're neither of them are his first choice. So he might put somebody like Robert Kennedy or Jill Stein as his first, as first choice. And then when they start counting up the votes in California, Robert F. Kennedy loses.
Shawn (48:39.691)
in first choice, right?
And then I, but hang on Matt, you have to give clarity. But I would also, Sam, be expected to give a second choice, a third choice, maybe a fourth choice, yeah.
Sam DArc (48:52.28)
So can.
can't
Sam DArc (49:01.996)
Yeah. Are, are, are the electorate and, listen, Matt, this is probably more your area because you hate people like in the U S you don't trust the electorate at all. Right. I trust them more, but do P are people educated enough to make a rank choice decision? Like, do they know enough to go past one?
Matt (49:11.931)
Yeah.
Matt (49:19.325)
Do you know what's crazy? In Australia, they have compulsory voting. And if you don't vote, you have to pay a fine for failure to vote. And they have ranked choice voting. And so, and sometimes there, have to rank them from one to 21. And if you leave any of those numbers out, it counts as not voting and you have to pay a fine. So, so in Australia, they're able to do, so I think if they could do it there, we could do it here, right?
Sam DArc (49:25.699)
Yeah.
Shawn (49:26.915)
That's crazy.
Shawn (49:33.217)
Yeah, Australia is a great example to follow.
Sam DArc (49:37.164)
Hmm.
Shawn (49:41.581)
Yeah, exactly. You're right.
Sam DArc (49:42.094)
Do they do they list the candidates in alphabetical order because it would favor a I would think yeah
Matt (49:44.689)
Well, I mean, if yeah, well, they, there's different ways that they do them. Oftentimes they'll just randomize the names, but there are legal fights in the United States state by state about how you put the names, but
Shawn (49:50.167)
Matt, after you asked the question, I did study this in depth, and I saw lots of content that was for and lots that was against, and I couldn't make up my mind that I think both were just biased. I don't see that this is gonna be any better than the current system we have or worse, so I'd be fine to do it or fine not to do it. I don't think it matters. Who?
yeah, yeah.
Matt (50:16.017)
I'll tell you who's against it every single time. The political parties are against it because the political parties right now in most states are controlled by people that have extreme views, people that are really like heavily activist and they see that this system would cause them to lose their power because when they nominate, when they nominate extreme people, those people tend to lose and then the other more moderate people tend to win.
Shawn (50:24.535)
Okay, then I'm for it.
Shawn (50:31.629)
then I'd be for it and you'd probably be against it, right?
Shawn (50:39.89)
sweet. two of us for it, Sammy, for or against it.
Matt (50:44.305)
Listen, as a political scientist, I love anything about changing the way we count votes. I'm always in favor of that.
Shawn (50:52.547)
Yeah, quite a few do it. You forward or against it, Sam?
Sam DArc (50:53.39)
You know, it's interesting. So Alaska, Maine, New York City, Massachusetts, Minnesota, California. It's interesting. I don't know.
Matt (51:03.525)
New York city, when they introduced rank choice voting, it made a huge difference in that mayoral race. Like there were a lot of candidates, a lot of money, a lot of money being dumped in that race. And the winner was a former police chief. was like, people were like, Hey, we want somebody that knows how to control the police department running our city, which you wouldn't have gotten otherwise. So I don't know. It's up. It's the reason I bring it up is because it's on the ballot in the state of Idaho this fall. We can vote to adopt a system like that.
Shawn (51:23.284)
do it, do it, man.
Go campaign for it, Matt. It sounds like a good deal.
Matt (51:33.083)
And I imagine it'll be on ballots in other states in the future.
Matt (51:39.953)
I decided a little while back that I'm never going to vote ever again, except for this particular ballot thing makes me want to vote. I I might vote in November. I'm supposed to be on a two week cruise over election day. So I, I'm not sure. I wasn't going to vote cause I wouldn't be around, but maybe, maybe I'll vote early and often.
Shawn (51:49.368)
Matt, I think you're the best political scientist I've ever known and sometimes I think you're the worst political scientist I've ever known. You're not gonna vote?
Shawn (52:01.665)
You're a political scientist, man. Shouldn't you be the voice for -
Matt (52:07.377)
Don't you guys, don't you think voting is the biggest waste of time in the whole world?
My vote, my vote, my vote in those student council elections in high school counted way more than my vote in anything that I do now. And I couldn't bring myself to vote in like student council elections, because it didn't seem like it mattered. So it seems even more like -
Shawn (52:20.877)
Sam, would you go and listen to Matt's lecture, his political science class talking about just don't vote, there's no point.
Sam DArc (52:29.55)
You
Shawn (52:35.639)
mean, you're looking at it in the abstract, man. It's of course my single vote. I mean, but what matters is when I discuss it with people and can influence someone else to vote or someone influences me to vote, the collective vote matters, of course.
Matt (52:37.607)
There is no point! There is no point! When is the last time your vote actually did anything, Sean?
Sam DArc (52:37.794)
No.
Shawn (52:55.589)
Celeste Malloy. I met with her chief of staff. Yeah, that was fun.
Matt (52:57.597)
Do you remember when you were in Washington DC, you went to visit that member of Congress who had a primary election. I forget her name. Celeste, Celeste Malloy. Yeah, so this, yeah, so this just came out in the news, that primary election that she was in, they had to do a recount because it was so close. They announced like two or three days ago that she won the primary election. It was so close. Guess how many votes she won by?
Shawn (53:05.378)
Did she lose?
Yeah.
Shawn (53:16.501)
my gosh, how many? See, your vote would have mattered.
Shawn (53:26.017)
Hahaha
Matt (53:26.589)
176, which is no, it wouldn't matter. 176 is not one, right? Like I can tell you an election within the last 15 years when somebody's vote mattered, but it's so rare that your vote matters.
Shawn (53:31.523)
Yeah, but no, hang on, hang on, hang on. All it would take, Matt, all it would take is 176 people to have your attitude and she would have lost. That's not very many people.
Sam DArc (53:44.642)
about one plus one plus one plus one plus one.
Shawn (53:45.699)
Matt, think you need to rethink. Matt, you either need to rethink this stance or rethink your career, I think.
Matt (53:53.501)
I don't have 176 friends that I'm persuading to not vote. Like that's a lot of people, Sean. 176 people at church is like a huge amount of people at church.
Sam DArc (54:06.865)
Hmm.
Matt (54:07.095)
I think that if you talk to most political scientists, they will tell you that voting is a horrible waste of time. organize if you want, go get involved if you want, knock on doors, work at phone banks or whatever, give money if you want, but voting.
Shawn (54:09.603)
What does that make you think of academia? Does that make you respect academia or think it's a joke? it does, Is it?
Sam DArc (54:25.794)
Yes, terribly. It's pragmatic. So yeah.
Matt (54:30.457)
Sean, you are so anti -establishment, it shocks me that you're in favor of voting. Like voting is a way to make people support outcomes that they otherwise wouldn't support, right?
Shawn (54:31.639)
Well, do okay? So let me ask a serious question then is that I've never even considered an alternative, right? We have democracy dumped down our throats from the day we're born as this righteous, sacred thing. Are you saying that voting and democracy, there is a better way to do it? Are you saying that?
Shawn (54:52.929)
Yeah, but you don't mean that.
Matt (54:57.405)
How many times have I said that righteous King righteous King is the way to go? Yes. Yes, I do mean that. Yes, of course. I mean that. Yeah.
Shawn (54:58.315)
You don't mean that. I can't even engage with you. You don't mean that.
Sam DArc (55:01.13)
no. no.
Matt (55:10.685)
Listen, I couldn't be more clear on this podcast. I don't trust people. I don't trust voters. I don't think that they make the very good decisions most of the time. And I think that when Jesus comes and kills all of the wicked people and he's the king of the world, we're going to be just fine. And none of us will have a vote. We'll have the same kind of vote when Jesus is king that we do in church when they say, so and so is going to be a primary teacher. All in favor? And you can say no, but nobody really cares that you said no in that situation. And I think it works just fine.
Shawn (55:32.262)
On that note...
Sam DArc (55:33.292)
Hehehehehe
Matt (55:40.71)
No big deal.
Shawn (55:41.356)
Hahaha!
Matt (55:43.805)
hey, I guess I get the last word this week. Thanks you guys. This was an enlightening discussion. I lost Sam about 15 minutes ago. He's like, I have nothing else I want to say about any of this stuff. Listener, I hope that you stayed with us longer than Sam did. Okay, we'll catch you again next week.
Sam DArc (55:51.81)
Ha ha ha.
Shawn (55:55.009)
That was one of the funniest endings we've
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories