The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
Episode 76: Can you be LGBTQ and active LDS? God's hand in the presidential race, BofM witnesses, Border security and gun control
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Thought Provoker:
Matt is up first this week. One of the founders of WordPerfect, Bruce Bastian, died this week. The New York Times obituary described many facets of his life that are worthy of discussion. His company played a large role in making Utah what it is today. When he started WordPerfect, no tech company was headquartered in Utah, they showed the world the potential of the Utah workforce. Bastian was also a gay member of the church. For Mr. Bastian, coming out was both terrifying and hopeful. “I don’t think straight people can begin to imagine the inner turmoil and fear at this moment in a gay person’s life,” he told The Salt Lake Tribune. “All your dreams, plans, everything falls apart. The whole foundation of your life crumbles. You can stay the course or follow your heart and go to where every human being dreams of going — to happiness ever after.” Here is my question. Because of the time and place in which he lived, Bruce Bastian felt like it was impossible to be an active member of the church and openly gay, is that true today?
Next up, Sam. Since the recent Presidential debate, there have been calls for President Joe Biden to step aside and make room for a stronger competitor to Donald Trump. In an interview with George Stephanopoulos, Biden said the only way he would withdraw from the election is, “if the Lord Almighty comes out and tells me that I might do that.” So, will God tell Joe Biden to drop out? Does God care about this election? What is the role of personal revelation versus personal responsibility in this and similar situations?
Finally, Shawn. June 28 was the 195th Anniversary of the 3 witnesses of BOM. Why do you think God chose to keep the Golden plates hidden And only show 12 people. What role does a witness play in the conversion of a soul?
The Big Question: The Big Question: I’ve seen a couple of big stories about how an undocumented immigrant murdered a woman in Maryland. And other stories about a mass shooting in Michigan at a splash pad. Republicans seem to enjoy blaming Biden’s border policies for crimes committed by undocumented immigrants. Democrats blame lax gun control laws for mass shootings. Are they correct? Can government policies about the border and/or guns prevent this kind of stuff in the future?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:01.386)
Hello and welcome to another episode of Real Mormonism. Did you? I did this on purpose to see if I, cause Sean's about branding. And so I tried, I thought if I do something that's not on brand, will Sean react? And he did.
Sam (00:06.98)
That was very official, Matt. That was very official. That's almost terrifying. Wait, relax a little. Take, no, I'm just kidding.
Shawn (00:08.741)
Ha ha ha ha!
Sam (00:22.34)
And I'm, and I'm the one who got triggered, not Sean, Sam. That's crazy. Interesting. Sean, you're slouching. Catch up.
Matt (00:29.354)
Hey everybody, welcome back. You're here with Sean, Sam and Matt and we've got a really fun topic from the mailbag we're going to discuss this week. So this listener writes, this bleeding heart liberal strongly disagrees with Matt. Okay. I'm going to pause. I know that I shouldn't pause when I'm reading emails, but I'm going to pause. This is because I am not a liberal and so liberals strongly disagree with me. This person says,
Shawn (00:29.765)
Hahaha
Matt (00:55.722)
The US military should spend much more time on humanitarian projects. No one in the world is better than the US military at getting stuff into hard to reach places. Young soldiers could be so proud of the work they're doing. They could build skills and earn money and save lives. And the next generation of global young people would associate the American flag with food, shelter and safety instead of colonialism and aggression. The only plank in my presidential
Sam (01:23.396)
See this?
Matt (01:25.194)
Go ahead. That's all. No more.
Sam (01:26.084)
This is the problem, Matt, with bleeding liberal ideas. So to the young and the idealistic, it sounds awesome. It sounds wonderful. Think of the US military in every country, every corner of the world doing good things. But the reality is we live in a terrible world where every time an American with a US soldier, they're a potential target. And you don't want to pay these kids to go out with that military uniform and that target on and give them a mixed
a mission and ask them to do good acts and do great things with a gun in their hand and either create a scenario where there's an accidental shooting, which happens all the time, or they're a target while they're doing good, which happens all the time. And both are catastrophic. And I think Matt, you said you specifically cited having the ship off the coast of Israel. And you're right. It's a target, right? That's a tough neighborhood to do good in, right?
Matt (02:09.898)
Sound.
Matt (02:24.01)
Sam wants to save the US military to attack ransomware people who go after big corporations in the United States.
Sam (02:28.42)
Yes. Very specific goals. So corporate defense, corporate offense. Let's protect our economy. Let's protect our people. Let's protect our constitution. Yeah.
Shawn (02:29.093)
Yeah.
Matt (02:40.01)
Do you guys think that, do you really think that people associate the American flag with colonialism and aggression? People in other countries?
Sam (02:47.3)
think most people don't know what colonialism means. I think in a lot of places in the world, Americans are loud, Americans are wealthy, and our way of life represents a threat to a lot of different people out there who are angry with us because they think, like many liberals do, because we have, they can't have. The people that see the American dream as alive and well and want to be part of it,
Shawn (02:47.621)
I think Luke.
Sam (03:15.46)
and are willing to roll up their sleeves and come participate can and do, and they create a great life. But there's a lot of people for whom prosperity and the American dream is a threat, not an opportunity.
Matt (03:27.978)
But like when I go to other countries, and it's true, I've been to Europe and Mexico, Canada, I haven't been, well, not exclusively on a...
Sam (03:34.18)
on a cruise ship and a cruise ship is not a great way to experience the world. Sorry. Okay.
Matt (03:40.906)
I'm not talking about the cruises. I didn't mention, I didn't be like, I've been around the world. I've been to Cancun. I've been to Jamaica. No, but like when I go to other countries, there are people that dislike Americans. There was mostly that way. The strongest that way was in Russia, but generally almost everywhere I go, people like Americans. They don't think of us in a negative way. In my personal experience. Do you think that there are countries that hate us?
Shawn (03:48.517)
Ha ha.
Sam (04:08.548)
I went to, I went to France and I pretty much felt like they sort of hated us except when you got to Normandy and you saw what was done in World War II, people were very friendly, but it was also a tourism spot, right? But you get to Paris and there was indifference. And to your point, Matt, in Moscow, they were angry, bitter, and wanted nothing to do with us, even though I spoke Russian.
Matt (04:17.29)
And then they like us.
Matt (04:23.242)
See you soon.
Yeah.
Matt (04:30.602)
Yeah, you're right. They're still mean. Yeah. Well, Sam, as I remember, the only thing you could say in French was l 'encher la vache. And so it could be what you were saying to the French was like, launch the cow.
Sam (04:33.412)
They're still mean.
Sam (04:39.108)
Yes. Don't don't don't have a cow man. That's what I was saying. I kept asking for American fries that might have upset them too. When you ask for American fries near the Eiffel Tower, I had many a French fry thrown in my lap, so I don't know.
Shawn (04:47.237)
Ha ha.
Matt (04:49.29)
Hahaha
Matt (04:55.114)
Sean, what do you think?
Shawn (04:59.173)
I think that people just don't like YouTube and they associate with America, but they like Americans. No, I don't know. It's anecdotal. Yeah, yeah. We are.
Matt (05:01.77)
yeah.
Sam (05:04.356)
We are loud though, Sean, aren't we? As a country, yeah.
Matt (05:08.042)
Yeah. Okay. Well, hey, listener, thanks for writing to us listener. We always enjoy all of the stuff we get in the mail bag. We honestly can't get to all of it every week because we get to choose topics that we want to talk about, but we always appreciate that you guys write in and let us know. Hey, this, yeah.
Sam (05:11.236)
We need to chill out a little.
Sam (05:26.18)
Hey, Matt, on a scale of one to 10, how much did it hurt your feelings being called a bleeding liberal heart, but being criticized by a liberal, like one liberal to another? Okay. All right.
Matt (05:35.498)
That feels good to me. I don't mind that.
Shawn (05:39.397)
Does it maybe feel good, Matt, because you really want that title and you kind of are that title? Yeah, does it maybe feel good because you're like, yes, yes.
Matt (05:44.202)
a bleeding heart liberal. They think I'm part of their team. Hey, in other news, this is actually kind of exciting news to me because a lot of what we talk about in terms of politics is US politics. And oftentimes it's like Utah politics. I was looking the other day, we're actually a global podcast. There are only two continents where we don't have listeners and we have as many listeners in London.
Sam (05:50.884)
Yes.
Shawn (06:10.501)
Matt (06:13.93)
England as we do in Salt Lake City. So yeah. So our listeners in London probably don't think of me at all as a liberal. They're probably like, what is wrong with that guy? He sounds like a far right crazy compared to London.
Shawn (06:16.517)
Wow, that's fascinating.
Shawn (06:27.493)
Which makes Sam...
Matt (06:31.274)
A moderate like you, Sean. You and Sam.
Shawn (06:32.741)
Sam (06:33.732)
How did we get to London?
Matt (06:37.61)
Well, podcasts go everywhere, Sam. We have actually a listener in Saudi Arabia. You can be anywhere in the world and listen to our podcast.
Shawn (06:40.229)
You
Shawn (06:46.085)
Okay.
Sam (06:46.5)
Well, greetings to all of our London listeners. That's exciting. I didn't realize Al Gore had piped the internet that far. So my mistake. Yeah. It's good of them.
Shawn (06:53.381)
Hehehehehe
Matt (06:53.61)
Yeah. Yeah. Okay. I'm up first with the thought provoker this week. This is actually a very Utah centric story. So for those of our international audience, I'll try and give you a lot of like detail about why we care. But you know, this obituary, this person had an obituary in the New York times, which it's kind of a big deal. Like you have to be big to have them care about that you died. Okay. So Bruce Bastion, he was one of the founders of word perfect and he died this week.
So there's a lot of things they talk about in his life, but WordPerfect, I think is important in Utah because if you're familiar with Utah, there's the silicone slopes where there's a lot of tech companies that have moved to Utah and they use the talented workforce in that area. And there's a lot of kind of tech jobs. But at the time, this would be in the 1980s, WordPerfect was the only tech company that was headquartered in Utah.
And a lot of people sort of mocked him for it. But in time, the world kind of saw the potential of the US Utah workforce. And that was sort of, WordPerfect was like a word processor that eventually was purchased by Microsoft Word. And it was like, I think the guy made over a billion dollars selling WordPerfect to various companies. At the same time, Bastion was a game member of the church.
This is what he said for Mr. Bastion coming out was both terrifying and hopeful. This is what he says. I don't think straight people can begin to imagine the inner turmoil and fear at this moment in a gay person's life. He told the Salt Lake Tribune all your dreams, plans, everything falls apart. The whole foundation of your life crumbles. You can stay the course or follow your heart and go to where every human being dreams of going to happiness ever after. Eventually.
Bruce Bastion left the church because he felt it was impossible to be an active member of the church and openly gay. And so my question is, is that still true today? Is it impossible to be an active member of the church and be openly gay? That was a long setup for that question.
Sam (09:03.044)
That's, that's the first, that's, that's the first question of the podcast this week. Matt, you are going into heavy stuff right out the gate. That's a lot. That's awesome. Good for you. I say, I say yes, but I don't know anyone that qualifies as that.
Matt (09:12.074)
thank you, thank you.
Shawn (09:12.229)
You
Matt (09:19.402)
You don't know any openly gay active members of the church? I do. I know former members of the church that are openly gay. I know, no, I know. I know current members of the church that are openly gay and are planning to leave the church. And then I know people that are openly gay that are active in the church. Right, right, right. So choose anywhere in that spectrum. And I know somebody that fits in that spectrum somewhere.
Sam (09:22.052)
I do not. Do you?
Sam (09:30.34)
Wait, that's not the question though. Active current numbers. Yeah.
Shawn (09:32.197)
Yeah
Sam (09:39.236)
wait, that doesn't count either. Okay, so you do. Okay.
Sam (09:48.068)
So, so in bucket number three, which is the, which is the target of your question, are they more than three?
Matt (09:57.13)
It's a very hard thing to do to be an active member of the church and to be openly gay because there's cult. Now I'm saying that in Utah, right? But I would imagine in San Francisco or in other areas where people don't like frown so much on the LGBTQ community. I would imagine it's easier. I know like from news stories that there are members of Bishop Bricks who are openly gay in other places. So of course I think it's possible to be
Sam (10:02.276)
Yeah.
Matt (10:27.306)
active and openly gay, but it is hard, not impossible, but hard because of all that other baggage that comes along.
What do you say, Sean? You're from California. Do you know gay people that are active in the church?
Shawn (10:41.573)
I do. Yeah, I do. Not very many, not very many. I mean, looking at, I mean, looking at any one of us who has an inclination to one thing or another, that's not the point of the religion, right? The point is we all have one thing or another that we're challenged with or that is makes us different or right. And so
Matt (10:43.274)
So it's not impossible, right?
Matt (11:07.722)
Yeah.
Shawn (11:09.733)
Your question really is, can you be? Yeah, I think so. Absolutely. Because if your community is or your ward or your stake is embracing you and loving you and living a Christian world life, then yeah, absolutely it is. But I agree. I don't blame anyone for having a hard time with that, not being able to live that to its fullest. I definitely agree with that.
Matt (11:32.298)
So, would you guys agree with me that doctrinally you can be openly gay and go to the celestial kingdom? Right? Because there's nothing wrong with being gay. It's only wrong if you break the law of chastity. So you could be openly gay and not break the law of chastity and then still go to the celestial kingdom, right? So there shouldn't be any reason that a member of the church who's active and gay feels like they're not a part of the kingdom. Is that?
Shawn (12:00.005)
Absolutely, absolutely 100%. Yeah, that's doctrinal. That's scriptural. That's absolutely true. Yeah.
Matt (12:05.098)
Yeah. Yeah. So then I don't, it's weird to me, right? It's, I understand because I have friends in these situations, I understand why it's hard to do that. It's a lot easier to not be openly gay and just kind of keep it to yourself because really why is it anyone else's business anyways? But I think we shouldn't have a problem with openly gay people serving in various church positions.
Shawn (12:30.341)
Yeah, but that's not really the hard part of the question, right? The hard part of the question is, so there's a really cool guy. I follow this guy on Instagram and YouTube named Dennis Schleicher. his message is basically, look, I'm a full temple recommend holder and it's okay that I'm gay. And, but, but his message is, is a difficult one. He gets a lot of backlash from people because his whole message is, well, if you have an issue with me, the way that I'm being gay, then be more tolerant. Cause basically he's basically.
Matt (12:47.178)
Yeah.
Shawn (13:00.389)
saying I'm attracted that way, but I try not to act on it. But that's the same that all of us could say, right? I'm a certain way and I try not to act on it. Sometimes I win, sometimes I lose. the atonement of Christ, right? It's where our heart is, right? I love the sacrament prayer, because it doesn't say every week, we promise that we will keep every commandment and remember Him 100 % of the time always, and that we will take upon ourselves His name. It says we are willing to do those things.
We will it, we desire it, we want it. But you read things like Paul and Alma and Nephi who say, why is it that I don't do that which I want to do? And I do do that which I don't want to do. Why is it that my flesh, I fail so often? And yeah, so yeah.
Matt (13:29.93)
Yeah.
Matt (13:46.122)
Yeah.
I think members of any ward, if they were the bishop of their ward, would be in shock at how many members of the church that come to church every Sunday are committing adultery, breaking the law of chastity, defrauding their neighbors. Like, members of the church do some really bad things and we don't judge them for it because we don't know about it. And so it seems weird to me that we judge people who are openly gay because we act like we kind of know what they're up to.
Shawn (14:08.325)
That's a blo -
Matt (14:18.282)
when we really don't have any idea what they're doing. What are you?
Shawn (14:21.669)
That's an interesting...
Sam (14:22.052)
It does seem to me like there have been some pretty public members. For example, American Idol, who, what is his name? David Archuleta, an incredibly prominent, an incredibly faithful member, right? Served a mission, was a huge advocate, saying what the Mormon Tabernacle Choir are saying at a prophet's funeral, right? Was a
Matt (14:32.394)
David Archuleta
Matt (14:40.138)
Yeah. Sang with the Mormon Tabernacle Choir.
Shawn (14:44.965)
mean anything.
Matt (14:49.546)
That doesn't mean anything, Sam. I've never been...
Sam (14:51.076)
It, well, it, it, it means something because as George, because as George Bush said, when he shook Putin's hand and looked into his soul and deemed him good and right proximity to people who are in authority, you would think would pull that individual, right? And it does seem to me, so I'm just thinking about this question because I never read these questions in advance. So I'm, I'm allowing this to kind of soak it. It's just, yeah.
Matt (15:00.234)
I'm sorry.
Yeah.
Matt (15:15.082)
Sam's like...
Sam (15:18.308)
I'm thinking this through as you're asking it. It seems to me that there are really good members of the church that have struggled. And it seems to me like many of them have ended up leaving for one reason or another. David Archuleta is a good example. Imagine Dragons had singer, right? Who is not gay, but who's a huge advocate, right?
Matt (15:39.498)
He's sympathetic to the community. Yeah.
Sam (15:41.476)
Right. I, it would be a fascinating thing to find someone, you know, it seems to me too, the church every now and again will hold up people and say, Hey, look, you can do this. You can be gay and you can be a member as long as you, and then there are examples of those people ultimately leaving because they can't just, they just can't reconcile it. Right. And, and
Shawn (15:44.357)
Did I leave?
Shawn (16:02.341)
But those are ideologically religious reasons, right? I can't accept the fact that I'm not allowed to act on certain passions and feelings, right? Whereas Dennis Schleicher always says, as an openly gay man, I've found profound acceptance in the church. I know that's anecdotal, that's his experience, but he is basically saying the acceptance that he receives is not, it's not the ideological, you know what I mean? He's not saying I'm openly gay and I think it's not a sin. I find acceptance there. He's saying people are loving me and they don't care that I say I'm openly gay.
Sam (16:11.204)
Well, and - and -
Sam (16:25.412)
Well, so... Yeah.
Shawn (16:32.101)
I'm trying just like everyone else is to live the life that I feel is Christ's life.
Sam (16:34.052)
Yeah. Yeah.
Matt (16:35.722)
Does he live in Utah, Sean? Okay.
Shawn (16:37.669)
Yeah, he does.
Sam (16:40.26)
So I don't know him, I haven't listened, but the question that I would ask in my head as you're talking about what you're talking about is can you be authentic and can you really connect and have relationships with other people if it is so difficult for people you're attempting to connect with to understand your background, understand some of the struggles you deal with and understand ultimately kind of what drives you in that way, right? Like, I don't know, I don't know.
Shawn (17:06.277)
That's a good question, Sam. Yeah, that's a great question, Sam.
Matt (17:06.506)
Yeah. And I, the church gets a lot of criticism from the LGBTQ community for what they call homophobia or because they say we don't accept them. And, and my natural inclination is I want to defend the church. And I want to say, you guys are wrong. You don't understand us. But I think sometimes it's helpful to just sort of like take a step back and reflect and say, is there something that that community is telling us that we could listen to and learn from?
And then at the same time, as I read this obituary to Bruce Bastion, I thought in my head like, it's not like it was in the 90s. Like, okay, it's true. Maybe we're not as like welcoming or accepting as some communities would like us to be. But haven't we come a long way since the 90s in accepting people who are gay? Yeah. Yeah, I think so.
Shawn (17:53.413)
Yeah, yes, absolutely. Yeah.
Sam (17:57.412)
Well, I mean, in some ways, yes, in other ways, no. I mean, there have been policies that have come out even in the past several years that at first glance looked to be a challenge, right? I knew the Bashans growing up as a kid because I grew up in Orem. I actually grew up with kids of the other founder we've talked about at the Ashton's, right? He was a mailman. He worked in a mail office.
Matt (18:04.906)
Yeah.
Matt (18:18.538)
Yeah.
Sam (18:22.948)
and created this software and ultimately became a multimillionaire many times over, created Thanksgiving point, the golf course, done a ton of development and whatnot. The bastion thing when that broke in the nineties was a huge deal, right? His wife was upset, built this enormous mansion just to kind of show him and whatnot. And it was incredibly public and I'm sure it was very painful for him, him too. But as, and again, this is just maybe I'll change my mind later, but I would think.
It would be tough to feel like you could be connected and that you could have great deep relationships with other members when they can't, when it's so difficult for them to understand where you're coming from. And when so much of what's in the news challenges the, Hey, we love you. We accept you the way you are, you know, come bring all the good that you have and let's be better together. I, I think it'd be a challenge and it would be cool to see people that.
Matt (19:20.01)
Yeah.
Sam (19:23.044)
have overcome that. I think it was the Mormon Land podcast or there was another podcast that talked about gay women who were in the church and depending on what ward they were in, they're allowed to actually have callings, right? They may actually live together. And I'm not sure that's even true. That was just something I heard on a podcast. But then depending on the leader, they're either allowed to remain or not. But
Matt (19:46.346)
Well, the people that I know that are gay do a lot of ward hopping because your bishop has a huge influence on things, right? Your bishop decides if you get a temple recommend or not. And so depending on, no, no, no. Right, right. Yeah. So I agree with, I think there are definitely challenges. I think the solution is on an individual level. Like,
Sam (19:53.22)
Yeah. But is that the way you want to live is be on the run? I mean, you're on the run in that case, right?
Sam (20:04.228)
So what's the solution, Matt?
Matt (20:10.794)
Like there's nothing I can do about the institutional church, but there is something I can do about my behavior towards people around me who are gay, that lets them know that like legitimately I don't care, right? Be gay, don't be gay. You're my friend, I want you a part of my life, I want you a part of the church. We should all do that, right? Because everybody is a sinner, everybody's doing things that they should be repenting of. And we spend too much time judging other people for their sins and not enough time kind of focused on ourselves.
Sam (20:30.564)
Yes. Yes.
Sam (20:40.644)
And probably the first step in getting there is acknowledging, and this comes from my corporate world, the business understanding, the different, like you kind of have to acknowledge that we have bias in our backgrounds and our culture and our understanding. And we've got to learn to be accepting and loving of everyone, regardless of where they come from or how different they are from us individually and find ways to connect with them, even if we don't necessarily understand their background and what drives them.
That's not just a religious thing. That's just a social thing in the world, right? And, and then within the context of the religion and what we teach, find ways, find ways to connect and accept.
Matt (21:11.978)
Yeah, yeah.
Shawn (21:14.149)
Thank you.
Shawn (21:20.165)
Yeah.
Matt (21:20.234)
The other thing I would say is a lot of people think they don't know anyone who's gay, but the probability is that there are somebody you know, somebody in your ward who's gay. They might not be out, they might not be open, but they're gay and they're probably paying real close attention to what you say and what you do to decide what they think about the church based on the way the people around them are behaving. So, I think, yeah.
Sam (21:37.316)
Yeah.
Sam (21:42.596)
But think about what you're saying though. If that is true, do you really know them? And do they really feel accepted, right? If they're closeted, so to speak. Right. They feel judged. Yeah.
Matt (21:49.994)
Well, yeah, because they -
Well, especially young people, Sam. Like if you're young and in Utah, yeah, right, and their whole social world in Utah and Idaho tells them, don't be gay, don't be gay, don't be gay. So there are a lot of young people that are struggling with that, transgender stuff too, right? And they're formulating their ideas about the church based on the way the people around them talk about these sorts of things.
Sam (22:17.284)
Yeah. And it's people our age, Matt and Sean, I'm a terribly funny person. I am very funny, right? And I know that often I will make jokes or say things that potentially could be construed as very offensive, right? Or, or, or judgey or shame driving to all sorts of different people that, that, that, that category included. I have to be careful, right?
Shawn (22:17.669)
Yeah, that's true. That's true.
Matt (22:24.01)
Yeah you are.
Shawn (22:24.709)
Well done. Yes. Yes.
Shawn (22:37.349)
Ha ha.
Matt (22:43.626)
Yeah. Yeah. All right. Let's give points to.
Shawn (22:46.565)
That's the price of comedy Sam.
Sam (22:50.756)
Well, no, it's, it's, it's not though, because it's not, because truly to Matt's point, like, I would be devastated to think that there were somebody, a young man or young woman in the ward I'm in, who heard me make a statement that just seemed funny, because based on me growing up in the 70s and 80s, it was funny, who felt judged and felt like they couldn't be open. Like, that's terrible. I, you know, I've been called out in a business setting that you can't say that. You can't
Matt (22:50.89)
Yeah.
Shawn (23:10.597)
Yeah, that's right.
That's right, yeah.
Sam (23:19.524)
You can't be that way. And I can't even think of a specific example because I don't want to make it sound too terrible. But it's true, right? Some of the very casual things that sometimes we say that would be funny, 20 or 30, it's harmful and it could be hurtful and it could be divided, dividing right now. It could cause someone that has that background to go deeper underground and protect themselves even more and separate themselves.
Matt (23:26.89)
Yeah.
Shawn (23:34.149)
Well said. Yeah, well said. Well said.
Shawn (23:45.605)
and to turn away from Christ, which is the opposite message that we as disciples of Christ want to put. So well said. Both of you get points. All right, yeah, Mac gets the points. That's a good one.
Sam (23:49.124)
Right. Yeah. Good topic, Matt. You get all the points. Sean, should we give Matt the points?
Matt (23:55.466)
All right, thank you. Thank you, thank you. Okay, Sam, you're up next.
Sam (23:59.812)
no, I need to, you know what? That was such a good topic. I closed my notes. Hang on just one second here. I, I, no, stop, stop. If you give this away, what will I do with myself? My goodness. I finally have a great topic. So, you know what? Hang on a second. I'm pulling this up.
Matt (24:06.186)
It has to do with the presidential debate.
Shawn (24:08.357)
Yes it does.
Matt (24:11.402)
hahahaha
Shawn (24:12.645)
Ha ha ha ha
Shawn (24:16.805)
Hahaha!
Matt (24:22.09)
Now for the listener while Sam's pulling this up, Sean encouraged us all to be a little more religious because we're called the Real Mormonism Podcast. Even though I want to pull us in a more political direction, Sean wants it to be a little more religious. So this is Sam's attempt to be a little more religious.
Shawn (24:22.213)
I think, I think.
Sam (24:35.14)
Yes. Yes. Thank you. I appreciate that. I can't find it.
Shawn (24:38.885)
Ha ha ha!
I think you have an identity crisis going on, Matt.
Matt (24:43.562)
Sam, the subject of your email is podcast. So if you just search your email for the subject podcast, it was sent at one.
Sam (24:48.516)
the
Shawn (24:53.957)
I could read it for you if you want.
Matt (24:55.178)
I'll read it to you, Sam. I'll read it to you.
Shawn (24:57.157)
We can read it for you.
Go for it.
Matt (25:01.226)
Since the recent presidential debate, there have been calls for President Joe Biden to step aside and make room for a stronger competitor to Donald Trump. In an interview with George Stephanopoulos, Biden said the only way he would withdraw from the election is, if the Lord Almighty comes out and tells me that I might do that. Now, if that sounded choppy, that's a direct quote from Joe Biden. And it sounded even worse when Joe Biden said it.
Sam (25:24.388)
And it was choppy.
Shawn (25:24.581)
Ha ha.
Shawn (25:29.125)
You
Matt (25:29.77)
So the question is, so will God tell Joe Biden to drop out? Does God care about this election? What is the role of personal revelation versus personal responsibility in this and similar situations? I know Sean has the answer to this.
Sam (25:29.956)
Sam (25:42.276)
Yeah, so Sean, go for it. Go for it.
Shawn (25:45.125)
You want me to answer first? Well, we...
Sam (25:48.644)
Absolutely.
Matt (25:48.906)
Yeah, tell us Sean. I'm sure you have a scripture about personal revelation.
Shawn (25:53.541)
Well, we talked about this a little bit last week, right? My topic was annuacoptus, right? Is God continuing to bless our endeavor? And, and I mean, I, there's a number of questions in here, Sam. I'm not sure which one. I mean, yeah, I'll jump to the religious one, right? Well, obviously.
Matt (26:02.922)
yeah.
Matt (26:12.682)
Would, does God care? Sean, does God care who wins the presidential election?
Sam (26:12.932)
Well, Sean, yeah, here's the first up. Here's the first up. On television on Super Bowl Sunday, whoever wins, they drop to their knees and thank the Almighty for being given the opportunity to win. Does God care about this election cycle? Does he care about sports? Let's start with the election cycle. Does he care about Trump v. Biden? And we know Matt's answer is going to be yes. Does he care, Sean?
Shawn (26:16.773)
Is that the question you want to go? Yeah, what's the question?
Shawn (26:30.565)
Okay.
Shawn (26:39.237)
Okay.
Sam (26:42.212)
enough to inspire Biden to withdraw.
Matt (26:43.178)
I don't think, actually, I do not think God cares at all. I actually think that there's nothing less important than politics. I don't think God cares who wins elections. Yeah, I really don't.
Shawn (26:48.325)
Yeah
Sam (26:52.388)
Okay, Sean?
Shawn (26:54.629)
No, I think he does. I have to believe that God is involved in everything we do, that he has that ability and he has that will.
Sam (27:00.132)
And so predicting if Trump right now is going to win the election, which everyone projects he's going to win the election, and if God cares about Trump not winning the election, do you think that he will tell Biden to drop out? And will Biden listen?
Shawn (27:08.549)
You
Matt (27:20.202)
no no he won't tell biden that because agency
Shawn (27:20.933)
I don't think so. I don't think so. But I think that's the key. But that's the key, though, is you don't even in the statements, he's not listening to you know, he's not seeking. Look, the concept of revelation is really limited to our religion, right? Not many people believe in that concept. I certainly don't think Joe Biden will use that concept. So I don't think he's seeking out God's will in the situation. So no, of course, I don't think that would happen. No.
Sam (27:44.932)
So does, go ahead Matt.
Matt (27:45.482)
So the theme, this is gonna go a little deep and weird, but trust me, it's worth it. So the theme of the book, War and Peace, that Leo Tolstoy wrote, that four volume book, his whole message in the book, War and Peace, is God doesn't care who does whatever, that God has this plan for history and people just kind of step in and fill the role and there's very little agency that people have.
They're just filling this role that God has predestined or predetermined for them to do. And he kind of uses war and peace to kind of share that message. And I think that, what's that, what Sean?
Shawn (28:21.369)
That's the message of war and peace? Providence?
Matt (28:24.522)
Yeah, yeah, yeah. If you read the whole book, you get a lot of times of Pierre, one of the main characters, doing this whole wrestle with God about, yeah, anyhow, yeah, that's the message of war and peace. And I actually think the exact opposite of that is true. God cares about individuals. He cares about individual agency, and he cares about helping us to become the best version of ourself. And whatever else happens in the world just happens.
Shawn (28:37.189)
Okay.
Matt (28:52.746)
I don't think God actually cares about that.
Shawn (28:52.901)
You can't think that across the board though, Matt. You don't think that there are many instances in the history of the world where God played a role, God had a hand. I mean, obviously the Doctrine and Covenants talks about God inspiring, for example, the men, the founding fathers to establish the Constitution.
Matt (28:56.81)
I do.
Matt (29:03.594)
Uhhhh
Sam (29:06.724)
So, so.
Matt (29:11.434)
Well, that's because if you listen to President Oaks' view of that, it's because there's needed to be a country to restore the gospel. So the purpose of the Constitution is to create religious liberty enough that you could restore the gospel. But beyond that, but beyond that, he cares about the restoration of the gospel. But beyond that, he doesn't really care.
Shawn (29:18.405)
That's right.
Shawn (29:23.333)
So therefore God does care about politics.
Shawn (29:31.141)
Okay, so limited experience, limited situations God will get involved in if it establishes freedom to step.
Sam (29:37.412)
Okay. So, so, so then coming back to this question, is it Joe Biden's responsibility to seek that revelation and will he be told dropout or is it God's responsibility to reveal the Joe Biden that he needs to drop out and align history such that he drops out, Matt? Cause you're pro -Biden, right? You've already said it. I'm pro -Trump. I want Trump to win. This is perfect for my, my viewpoint, but what, what about yours, Matt? Should Biden
Shawn (29:47.909)
Hahaha
my gosh.
Matt (29:52.522)
I'm sorry.
Shawn (29:55.205)
What on earth?
Shawn (30:01.317)
my gosh.
Matt (30:01.546)
Yeah.
Sam (30:05.412)
appeal for an answer and will he get one to drop out or
Matt (30:08.458)
He already got his answer. Biden already knows that he's the man for this time and there's no reason for him to drop out. He wouldn't.
Sam (30:15.588)
But last week you advocated for him to drop out. You need him. You want him to drop out to quote a few good men.
Matt (30:21.258)
I think I said that if he was truly concerned about democracy in America, then he wouldn't drop out. He would resign and let Kamala Harris be the president. But I don't think he actually truly cares about the things he says he cares about, right? Where he's like, democracy is on the ballot and this is like the most important election of our lifetime. I don't think he actually believes that. So that's what I was saying last week.
Shawn (30:30.821)
Ha ha ha.
Sam (30:33.316)
goodness.
Sam (30:38.276)
-huh.
Sam (30:46.18)
Sean, what's your take? Should Biden seek for revelation and would God tell him to drop out or is it God's responsibility to construct history such that he drops out?
Shawn (30:58.949)
Sam, you're amazing, dude. I think in the absence, no, I think in the absence, no, in the absence, no, I'm not. I'll answer, in the absence of a willing son or daughter of God seeking out God's will, none of that's gonna happen. It's up to his free agency. None of it's gonna happen. He's not seeking God's will.
Sam (31:02.692)
What's your take? What's your take? Come on, Sean. You know, for the second week in a row, Sean won't answer my question. I love it. Okay. Go ahead. All right.
Matt (31:05.162)
Sean doesn't want to tell you, Sam. He's afraid.
Sam (31:20.452)
Yeah.
Matt (31:22.346)
Well, wait, do you think that Trump is seeking God's will? Yeah, so if none of them are seeking God's will, then how could God's will even happen?
Shawn (31:26.181)
Not at all. No way.
Shawn (31:32.997)
Well, yeah, that's yeah, I agree with that. Sam, do you think the opposite? Do you think that God is going to strike down Joe Biden so that Donald Trump becomes president?
Sam (31:39.748)
On a lighter note, when Joe Biden made that comment in the Stephanopoulos interview, I was on an airplane and I laughed out loud and I thought, I wonder if Biden will have a heart attack and then Trump shortly thereafter will as well. But the thought of Kamala Harris is terrifying. So no, I, no.
Matt (31:52.042)
Hahaha
Shawn (31:52.709)
Ha ha ha ha ha, jeez.
Matt (31:55.306)
you'll get used to it, Sam. She's amazing. She's amazing.
Shawn (31:56.709)
No, all right. Hey Sam, Sam, Sam, I have done for the last two weeks a deep dive into her history. I'm getting a good grasp into what her actual platform belief systems values are. And in the coming episode, I'm going to present to you guys the Kamala Harris, that's a teaser, yeah.
Sam (32:03.332)
Sam (32:09.028)
And...
Matt (32:13.994)
That's a teaser.
Sam (32:14.02)
Are what so as a further teaser, we are you pro Kamala now?
Matt (32:19.786)
Yes. Well, Sean's judging her harshly.
Shawn (32:20.037)
I am absolutely not. Nope. Nope. I will present to you the evidence and you can defend her however you want, Matt.
Sam (32:22.724)
Yeah.
Sam (32:28.196)
So, so I just want one follow up question. So in LDS church culture, there's the white horse therapy earth theory, right? The white horse. Is it false? Okay. I don't know this. Is it false? Okay.
Matt (32:37.29)
Yeah, but that's false prophecy, Sam. Number one, Joseph Smith never said it. The original source of that is 1910 and it's a person in Hawaii.
Sam (32:47.332)
Wait, for everybody listening, will you just explain what it is?
Matt (32:52.394)
The White Horse Prophecy is an alleged prophecy of Joseph Smith that the Constitution would hang by a thread and the elders of Israel would rise up to save the baby led by a person on a white horse who would save the Constitution.
Shawn (33:06.341)
Sam and Matt, I would just...
Sam (33:06.532)
And since I was a kid, everybody thought Orrin Hatch, and then they thought it was Mitt Romney. Like there are all these, or Harry Reid, that all these people would stand up and defend the Constitution. But you're saying it's a complete, it's false. It's not correct. It's not rooted.
Shawn (33:11.141)
Hehehe
Matt (33:19.306)
Not only is it right, not only did Joseph Smith never say it in 2010, the church had an official statement that said the white horse prophecy is not doctrine.
Sam (33:28.228)
interesting.
Shawn (33:28.325)
Sam and also, I'll soap box it a little bit. Do you find it in canonized scripture? Cause if you don't, there's no trusting it.
Sam (33:32.772)
Well, okay, so I would like to own the fact that now for two weeks in a row, I brought false doctrine into this episode. So thank you.
Shawn (33:39.877)
Hahaha
Matt (33:41.162)
Do you know what I'll tell you though that's interesting is Joseph Smith, if you go to history of the church, he actually prophesied the fall of the US Constitution and he called it an old granny. And Brigham Young in 1853 said that the Constitution is a work in progress and that we still have to work to kind of help the Constitution become what it should become.
Sam (34:00.804)
Well... H -H -
Shawn (34:01.861)
And if none of that became scripture, then it's just a bunch of human beings giving their opinion about stuff.
Sam (34:06.212)
Well, but historically, it kind of makes sense they would feel that way because aspirationally, the Constitution would have protected the early saints and their freedoms, and it didn't, right? It drove them west and outside the US. Like the early members of the church were not benefactors of the Constitution, right?
Matt (34:15.018)
And right.
Shawn (34:17.861)
Good point.
Matt (34:24.714)
Right. I have a, maybe I'll soapbox about this on another episode, but, I don't want listeners to get all worried and stuff. We love the constitution. We think it's great. And the doctrine and covenant says that it's, what does it say? Sean? It's, inspired.
Shawn (34:40.709)
not so much, yeah, the meaning of it.
Matt (34:42.954)
President Oaks says that it's an inspired document. President Benson said it was inspired and I have no problem with that.
Sam (34:48.9)
And to our listeners in London, we love the Constitution. So yes.
Shawn (34:50.021)
Good, okay. Poke the bear.
Matt (34:52.33)
And the Magna Carta, without the Magna Carta, you don't have. I'm gonna give points to, wait, what are we talking about? Is this Sam's topic? I can't give you points for this topic, Sam. Okay, I'll give Sean the points because he said that we don't have to listen to Joseph Smith unless it's in scripture.
Shawn (34:58.085)
Ha ha ha.
Sam (35:04.356)
I went so deep. I went so deep. I brought in correct doctrine, false doctrine. We went all around the world. So, yeah.
Shawn (35:08.037)
I don't
Shawn (35:13.029)
I'll give you points, Sam.
Shawn (35:18.789)
hahahaha
Sam (35:19.812)
hahahaha
Matt (35:22.314)
or Brigham Young. All right, Sean.
Shawn (35:23.461)
I'd say I'd say it man. I'd say the King Fall at discourse, which is not scripture is pretty accurate though Most of it not all of it. Okay, anyway
Sam (35:29.188)
Mmm.
Matt (35:30.154)
Sean, the prophecy I'm talking about, Joseph Smith leads with this, I prophesy in the name of Jesus Christ. And he does not say that in the King Follett discourse, so.
Shawn (35:39.525)
But that's the point in it now becoming doctrine. You don't know if that was primary sourced. It wasn't even primary sourced. Show me a primary source where he said that. That's not primary source. The history of the truth says it's not primary source.
Sam (35:39.844)
Hmm, interesting.
Matt (35:46.698)
Sure it is. It's in the history of the church.
Matt (35:53.002)
Okay. What's the Kingfala discourse? Is that primary source?
Sam (35:54.404)
Alright, points go to Sean.
Shawn (35:56.581)
It does. It has which which version because there's seven primary sources for that.
Matt (36:00.97)
Alright, Sean gets the points.
Sam (36:02.596)
Sean gets the points. Okay.
Shawn (36:02.949)
Hahaha, I don't know. All right my topic. Okay. Well you guys it came and went I was waiting all day for a text on June 28th a couple of days ago for you from you guys To celebrate the 195th anniversary of the three witnesses the Book of Mormon. I didn't get anything from you guys. I can't believe it
Sam (36:12.836)
Mmm.
Sam (36:19.14)
I sent the text, it did not come.
Matt (36:19.306)
It was - I was celebrating -
I was celebrating July 2nd, which is the eight witnesses of the book of Mormon, cause eight is more than three. And so I thought it was a better day than.
Shawn (36:30.309)
It's a numbers game for you. I get it, I get it, okay. So anyway, so yeah, June 28th was the 195th anniversary of the, what we think was the anniversary of the three witnesses of the Book of Mormon. So my question is pretty simple. I've always looked at the witnesses and their testimonies and on a very early age in a very, I don't know, I don't know, I wasn't very smart, but I'd look at that and go, okay, there you go, there's proof. Clearly that's not the purpose of that. Like, so I really, now you guys are old.
seasoned wise, why do you think God chose A, to keep the golden place hidden, and then only show to all people? Like, what's the point of these witnesses? What role do witnesses like that play in an individual's conversion? Like, what's the significance?
Matt (37:14.378)
But Sean, more than, more than 12 people, Sean, because there was that woman in the David Whitmer family who got to see the plates too.
Shawn (37:22.053)
Is that in the DNC?
Sam (37:22.436)
13.
Matt (37:24.554)
There's a church movie about it.
Shawn (37:27.045)
jeez. Okay. No.
Sam (37:29.412)
you
Matt (37:29.898)
Wait, you don't believe that? and then there was that family in the book, the work and the glory. There was some...
Shawn (37:35.333)
Knock it off!
Sam (37:39.172)
no.
Matt (37:40.874)
Wait, your question is why three witnesses? Three witnesses because the Book of Mormon says three witnesses.
Shawn (37:43.365)
No? you think it was just a fulfillment of prophecy?
Matt (37:49.098)
Well, God says that by the mouth of two or three witnesses will everything be established. So you don't need more than three witnesses. Why should there be more than three witnesses?
Shawn (37:57.989)
Well, that's not quite my question. The question is why witnesses? What role does this witness play, right? It's like, I believe I was in the Salt Lake temple and I was told a story where I believe, I think it was Wilfred Woodruff was in the hall, Lorenzo Snow saw Christ walking down that hallway and Lorenzo Snow, right? And that was a fascinating comment someone taught me. And I was like, well, is that real? I guess I could find out for myself. I do believe it was real, but only not because someone told me, not because I believe there's a witness.
Matt (38:04.426)
Mmm.
Matt (38:12.554)
Lorenzo Snow, yeah.
Matt (38:20.81)
It is.
Shawn (38:26.437)
I was able to go and spend the time to pray and to really find that out myself. And I can honestly say I received something very clear, powerful spiritual revelation about that. But does that, so is that the role of a witness then? It's to.
Matt (38:40.81)
I'll tell you this, Sean. I went to the Holy Land, to the Garden of Gethsemane and the alleged garden tomb, and I don't think Jesus was in either of those spots. I think that those places are made up to sell money to tourists from America. You can, it just doesn't feel like he was there. You go there and it's like, nah, this feels like Las Vegas or something. This feels fake. It doesn't. If you go to Jerusalem, there's the Garden of Gethsemane. Yeah, okay, so you go to the Garden of Gethsemane.
Shawn (38:52.993)
yeah, based on...
Shawn (39:01.945)
my gosh, wow.
Sam (39:02.02)
Wait, where's this, Matt? I missed where you were. Where is this? Yeah, I've been. you don't think that's, that doesn't feel different to you? Doesn't seem different. Interesting.
Matt (39:12.01)
No way.
No. Or did you go to the garden tomb, the thing that the inter -denominational church, there's no way that's the real garden tomb and that hill, there's no way that that's where he was crucified.
Sam (39:19.012)
Yes. Yes.
Shawn (39:22.309)
Okay, so Matt, you're sick. But Matt, what you're...
Sam (39:23.62)
so actually I have a, I have a really funny story about this if we have a minute, but, but I don't want to disrespect Sean. So you do yours and then I get to tell how the face washed off the, the Hill where Christ was crucified and it fell into a Palestinian bus stop. And the way, the way the tour guide at that spot described it, it was like, it's been here for 2000 years and he showed up to work one day and this thing slid down the hillside.
Shawn (39:37.221)
You
Matt (39:50.058)
Hahaha
Sam (39:52.036)
And my comment to him, I actually chuckled. I felt terrible, but I'm terribly sarcastic sometimes. And our, our group was mortified that I laughed at it, but I just thought, what an irony. Like it's been there for 2000 years and he wakes up one morning and erosion pushes it into a Palestinian bus station.
Matt (40:09.29)
There's no way that that's where Jesus was crucified. There's no way, right?
Sam (40:12.228)
It's the historically accepted place, right?
Shawn (40:13.957)
But Matt, you're saying when you enter that place and whatever witnesses are saying this is where it happened, you don't feel a spiritual confirmation based on that. That's what you're saying? And Matt, listen, I've always loved about you that you do have a way, you're sensitive to the Holy Ghost. I can see in your face when you
Matt (40:26.41)
That's right, that's what I'm saying, yes.
Sam (40:34.116)
curious mind. No. you're sensitive here.
Matt (40:40.778)
okay.
Shawn (40:43.333)
when you're feeling it. And I, you've always had this kind of closeness, I think to that. So I like that your answer is the witnesses over here are liars. I know that more than them based on their evidence, based on their history, because the Holy ghost, right? You're an intellectual, you're an academic, right? And you do base a lot of your decisions in your life on what is the manmade evidence that proves something. But I like that there's this other side of you that you've, you, you'll listen maybe to a witness, but you'll go, I'm gonna get my own answer on that.
Matt (40:56.65)
Yeah.
Matt (41:00.33)
Mm -hmm.
Shawn (41:13.157)
Because that's the way that we're supposed to do it, right?
Matt (41:14.794)
Yeah.
Sam (41:15.524)
That's the way it's supposed to be, right, Joe?
Matt (41:18.346)
So that's why we have witnesses, Sean. We have witnesses to tell us a story and we can go seek our own personal confirmation.
Shawn (41:25.989)
Okay, so you do believe that that's what the three and the eight witnesses were for, is to say, okay, now I've got something to ask God about. Did the books really appear in his hands or did they not? That's what you think it's for?
Matt (41:29.226)
Yeah.
Sam (41:31.812)
Matt (41:35.21)
Yeah. Well, and they all left the church. So there's something powerful in people saying, I know that this line, I saw these gold plates. I know that they were real. Or in the case of the three, when it says this angel came and told me this, I know that this happened. And then saying, but I don't want to have anything to do with the church. And then leaving the church, but never denying their testimony. There's a power in that.
Shawn (41:57.605)
Okay, but that's the opposite to your answer. Here what you're saying is, I trust a historical figure, I'll look at all the evidence, he even left the church, so he must have really believed what his eyes saw.
Matt (42:01.546)
Mm -mm.
Matt (42:09.45)
But there is power in that. Listen, Sean, I always say this, that God is always going to give you as much evidence to believe something as there is evidence to disbelieve something because in the end, belief is a choice. So there's never going to be overwhelming evidence one way or the other because otherwise there's no room for faith. And so,
Shawn (42:23.365)
Hmm, interesting.
Shawn (42:31.525)
Look at that. See, see what happens when we make this podcast about religion. Really interesting, deep wise things come out of your.
Matt (42:38.026)
thank you. Well, don't you think that's true though? Don't you think that makes sense that there's never going to be overwhelming evidence one way or the other?
Sam (42:38.148)
That is.
Shawn (42:44.485)
Well, look, I've always been fascinated with the definition of faith in the scriptures. It says, faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen. An evidence of something that isn't seen has to be based, there's a substance or something there. And in my life, I've always studied that as meaning, well, that substance and evidence is not seen because it's within the soul. It is the spirit. It is a power that is the spirit, right? Oftentimes described as a still small voice or a burning in the heart or whatever.
Matt (43:13.61)
But faith is also a commandment. King Benjamin commands the people to believe in God. So that means that faith is also a choice. And that's true.
Shawn (43:20.965)
Also a choice, but it's based on, it's gotta be based on something. It's gotta be based on some kind of evidence, right? I wanna, we're commanded, it can't be blind.
Matt (43:27.786)
Yeah, so that that verse in Hebrews 11 that you quoted Hebrews 11 one I always like the new living translation version of it where he says faith is the confidence that what we hope for will actually happen. It gives us assurance about things we cannot see. So I know you don't, but that's why I read it because I like that translation better. OK, alright.
Shawn (43:43.717)
Yeah, I don't like that. I don't like.
Shawn (43:49.701)
Well, I like the other one better, okay?
Sam (43:52.388)
you
Matt (43:52.938)
Well then I'll give you points for that Sean, because you're going to doggedly stick to the King James translation despite all of the flaws that we know about that translation from the Book of Mormon.
Shawn (44:02.725)
Hey, Joseph Smith made corrections, right? All the corrections that needed to be made perhaps to the Bible. He did not? You don't think he did? What do you think? Why not?
Matt (44:08.81)
What? No way. No, no, no. There's no way he did. No, no. Okay. We'll have to have that as a topic for a different day too. Yes. Yeah. I have a friend that's a biblical scholar that like studies all these ancient languages and stuff. And this is a good friend of mine. It's Sam. Okay. It's Sam.
Shawn (44:17.829)
Okay, alright.
Shawn (44:23.685)
I know who you're talking about.
Shawn (44:28.741)
hahahaha
Sam (44:30.692)
Wait, I'm very uncomfortable with the chuckles after that comment. Very uncomfortable. Okay.
Matt (44:34.538)
Okay, we're going to move to the big question. Okay, now this is something we've kind of waited on a little bit. It was scheduled for a couple of weeks ago, but I decided we're going to get to it this week. Okay. I have seen a couple of big stories about how an undocumented immigrant murdered a woman in Maryland. And I've seen other stories about a mass shooting in Michigan at a splash pad. So
Sam (44:48.452)
No.
Matt (45:03.498)
From these stories, what I've seen is that Republicans seem to blame Biden's border policies for the crimes committed by undocumented immigrants and Democrats blame lax gun control laws for the mass shootings that happen. My question is, are they correct? Can government policies about the border and or guns prevent this kind of stuff in the future?
Shawn (45:51.547)
So of course if a government, if our government completely shuts down the border, doesn't let a single person in, yeah of course there'll be an effect. There'll be less X, Y, and Z. Same as, hang on, same as if they ban guns completely and take them all away, of course there's gonna be massive effect, right? The question isn't, so yeah, of course government can affect it, but.
Matt (45:59.818)
No way. No way.
Matt (46:11.562)
Wait, so then that would mean the Democrats are right to blame gun laws for gun deaths and Republicans are right for blaming the border on violence by illegal immigrants.
Shawn (46:16.571)
Yeah, but, but.
Shawn (46:22.523)
But the reason that the Republicans and Democrats make those claims has nothing to do with facts or truth. It's completely political. They're trying to tell a story to get votes, right? They don't really believe those things. Absolutely not.
Matt (46:35.498)
When you were a kid, when I was a kid, I would see this bumper sticker that said, if guns are outlawed, only outlaws will have guns. And it seems to me like the same thing would apply to the border, right? If you shut down the border, people are still gonna get through. They're just gonna be more hardened criminals that get through. So I don't think.
Shawn (46:52.651)
so you're actually arguing for the Democrat case is correct, the Republican case is not correct. That's what you're going to argue for?
Matt (46:58.858)
what I now listen, I don't like to get like two on one side or the other side, but it does seem to me that the gun violence that we see in the United States, the people that are committing those crimes are breaking laws by having the guns that they have access to.
Shawn (47:16.731)
So what do you think of this then, Matt? I just read an article. Do you know which state in the US, one of the top three states that have the most strict gun laws? I live in that state, by the way. I live in the state. Yeah, and so California has some of the strictest gun laws and the rate of gun violence is not going down. Now it's a little, it is lower, but it's not reducing.
Matt (47:26.666)
I do? California? I would say California, New York, and Illinois probably have the strictest gun laws.
Matt (47:42.762)
Right. Well, that's because like bordering states can just bring guns into California. Like it's easy to get a gun and bring it into a state. Right.
Shawn (47:53.563)
I don't think so.
Sam (47:53.572)
Here's my take though. I think if both of those issues were not political, it would be solved overnight. And the solution, actually Democrats and Republicans are not that far apart on the border anymore. So Trump politicized it enormously in his first election. He saw it before a lot of the Democrats did. And now the Democrats, I think, are coming around to the same solution.
Shawn (48:01.659)
Yeah, nice Sam.
Sam (48:19.94)
The problem is, is everybody in a political season is playing the whole who gets to take credit for the answer. And so right now Democrats don't want to support the Republican answer. Republicans are preventing the Democrats from implementing their solution. And, and it is a political thing. If people came together and put politics aside, both the gun issue and the border issue would very quickly be solved and it would not be cut and dry. It would probably be something of.
Shawn (48:25.979)
Bam.
Sam (48:47.364)
more reasonable allowance of people to come across the border for the further the American dream. It would probably involve some sort of amnesty, which we've done over and over and over again. Multiple administrations have done it. And then there would be things that would be implemented to prevent, you know, cartels and criminals and drug runners and gun runners and all the other things from coming across the border. We have the ability as a country to fix that problem. The problem is,
There's the line in politics that you can't never waste a good disaster. You want this drama. The same goes for guns. The NRA is a huge pro -gun lobby. They're tightly affiliated with Republicans. Every time a Democrat gets an office, gun sales go through the roof. Every time there's the potential for some sort of a change in gun policy, gun sales go through the roof.
there is a path to reasonable control, right? And it would be, it would, it, it, it, yeah, it would be background checks. It would be registration. It would be limiting some of the certain types of weapons that are available. I mean, there are templates in other countries for things that work and the stuff that happens in California and Chicago and other States to restrict it, that in and of itself,
Shawn (49:44.135)
Matt, Matt, Sam is spitting facts and truth. Like this is very articulate wise stuff.
Matt (49:44.298)
Yeah.
Matt (49:50.25)
Listen.
Sam (50:10.308)
does not solve the problem. It has to be a nationwide. It's one of those unusual things where I think states' rights doesn't work as well. It's got to be a national solution and both parties have to get on board. But the reality, Sean, is it will never be implemented.
Shawn (50:21.371)
Sam, I don't think I've ever heard a more articulated, a more perfectly articulated way that I look at politics than what you just did. That was absolutely perfect.
Matt (50:21.706)
This is one.
Matt (50:29.322)
Well, let me, that's because the two of you are into big government regulation and I'm in favor of freedom of the people because I'm telling you on this, I'm the opposite of both of you. I say that when it comes to guns, the more laws and restrictions and regulations you put place on guns, the harder you make it for law abiding people who want to use guns responsibly to use guns. You really do.
Shawn (50:35.963)
Shut up.
Sam (50:36.772)
Ha ha
really?
Sam (50:48.804)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (50:53.668)
Of course you would. Of course you would. Do you?
Shawn (50:55.147)
my gosh, NRA.
Matt (50:56.586)
No, I really think that like I'm surrounded by people. I have neighbors that do not purchase meat at the store. They hunt for all of their meat. They grow all of their vegetables in their yards and they have to travel around various states at various seasons to be able to hunt and get meat at various times of the year. And I say, why would the government make it harder for these people like this? Not like there's a ton of people out there hoping to eat antelope someday. Let the people go out and shoot the antelope if they want to shoot the antelope. But because there's criminals.
Sam (51:02.532)
Yeah. Yeah.
Sam (51:21.636)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (51:26.378)
that want to do bad things with guns, then these law -abiding citizens have to deal with all of these restrictions on guns. So the more restrictions you place, the harder you make it for good people.
Sam (51:33.54)
Yeah. But, but, but, but the only, the, the, the only thing that I'll, and this is not a popular platform in my own party, but the only thing I disagree with you on is the type of super fast automatic weapons that are military, military plus grade. And a lot of your neighbors, cause I've seen them in your neighbors homes. A lot of your neighbors have those weapons and, and it, there is, yeah. Yeah.
Matt (51:48.17)
That's fine.
Matt (51:53.098)
At the 4th of July parade, at the 4th of July parade, they were handing out coupons for a free hour at the shooting range in the local armory where you could like, choo choo choo choo. So I'm fine with saying some kinds of guns are for military use. But okay, but now I'm going to say the same thing on the border. There are there are illegal actors who have a strong incentive to cross the US border because they want to sell drugs and they want to sell
Shawn (51:56.795)
Ha ha ha!
Sam (52:04.036)
yeah. yeah.
Sam (52:09.764)
That's all I'm talking about. That's all I'm talking about.
Matt (52:22.986)
various, maybe they want to do like sex trafficking, like there are bad people that want to do it. The tighter you make the restrictions on the border, the harder you make it for the good people to be able to come back and forth across the border and it hurts the economy and it makes their individual lives harder. So again, just like I say, we need fewer gun restrictions. We actually need fewer border restrictions because a tighter border incentivizes criminal activity at the border. And so if you want to have a safe border, you've got to loosen the restrictions there.
Shawn (52:35.963)
Yeah, I'll go with you on that.
Yeah, I'll go with you on that.
Matt (52:52.522)
so that good people are able to come and go freely.
Shawn (52:55.611)
But I'll go with all that, Matt. I think you said it really well. But to Sam's point, you can't have anarchy. If it was non -political, I think Sam's right. We would put some good standards for these things. But because it's so political, it's in chaos.
Matt (53:05.258)
If you want to open it...
Matt (53:11.05)
If you want to open a checking account, you go and you show your ID and they can look and see, do you have a criminal background? They can see even if you're from a foreign country. All of this stuff is in the database. You could within 30 seconds, anyone at the border, do a background check and see if they've got any kind of a criminal history. And if they have no criminal history, let them in.
Sam (53:27.78)
But, but, but, but by the way, that is a check and that is a, a benchmark by which you would allow people to come in the country and leave the country and then come back. I mean, whether it's a physical, what, what, whether it's a physical wall or a physical border, which if you go to Israel, one of the things that were so impressive to me in Israel, if you go and see the wall that Israel has, separating Israel from Palestine, it is massive.
Matt (53:41.386)
Okay, then I'll get rid of that one.
Sam (53:57.38)
And to your point, like a concrete wall does not separate. It does not solve that problem. But again, Democrats and Republicans coming together and not making it a political issue, whether it's doing a background check as people come across the border or whether it's having just multiple points of entry with clear guidelines to speedily decide, Hey, you can come in, you can't come in and here's the reason why you can't. And here's what you need to do to come back in. There's something about that.
Matt (53:57.834)
Yeah, but -
Sam (54:24.996)
border control, which makes us a country that shouldn't be a political issue. It should be something that everybody should be able to agree on. As a country, we have to have a border. We have to be able to define what it is to be inside the U S and what it is to be outside the U S. And, the, the, the problem today is it's not, you know, it, it, it's, it's, it's too, it's too open for corruption. Corruption is too easily,
Matt (54:48.426)
I wanna
Sam (54:54.116)
rewarded by crossing the border.
Matt (54:57.13)
we should just, every place where there's problems in Mexico, we should just bring it into the United States because we solve crime problems better than anyone in the world. So make it a, make it a Democrat state. Take, take, take any state in Mexico with problems and make it, let Democrats run that state and they'll clear the crime out in no time.
Shawn (55:06.075)
Hahahaha!
Sam (55:06.756)
What? We do not. What state do you live in? wait, you're in Idaho. That's right. I forgot. You, you live.
Shawn (55:11.995)
You don't!
Sam (55:18.628)
Matt, all the United... No, no, no. All the world is not Disneyland to your...
Shawn (55:24.091)
my gosh.
Matt (55:26.282)
Hey, you know what? Good conversation, you guys. I didn't bring any of this stuff up in the mail bag, but last week there were people really mad at me about my take on pets. I chose not to read any of that this week because I didn't want to, I don't want other people to hear their take on pets because I feel like I'm right. But I think it's cool that we can disagree about things and not like get upset with each other about it.
Sam (55:38.724)
Mmm.
Shawn (55:51.643)
Yeah.
Sam (55:51.652)
I do think it's interesting though that you censored all of those out of the public reading. So I don't know how, I don't know how sincere that is. You got a hate mail and you wouldn't read it just, just for your own, just for you. So I have several friends that listen to this podcast very quietly and they hate animals. So actually I had some comments that were like, Hey, we actually agree with Matt on one thing. First thing ever, by the way, because.
Matt (55:55.53)
You
Shawn (56:01.659)
Hey, it's.
Shawn (56:10.523)
wow.
Matt (56:13.994)
Yes, yes. Isn't that, we can always find common ground. If we try hard enough, we'll always find somewhere where we can agree.
Sam (56:20.9)
Yes. But in true democratic form, you will never read that on air. You will continue to perpetrate the myth and the lie that everyone. So that was big of you to come clean at the very end. Did you feel guilty at the very end? Is that what made you, was the guilt and the shame, what made you, made that, make that confession at the very end? Because you can't, you can't delay your repentance to the very end of the show. You've got to do it earlier.
Shawn (56:23.151)
my gosh.
Matt (56:26.506)
hahahaha
Shawn (56:38.587)
Ha ha.
Matt (56:40.778)
No, no, I'm...
I brought it up because I want to encourage listeners to tell Sean and Sam that they're wrong about their views on the border and gun control. Cause I'll read those. If you write in and say that I'm wrong, it's like not for sure that I'm going to read that email.
Shawn (56:53.147)
Yeah.
Sam (56:54.116)
you
Shawn (57:01.915)
Matt, we agreed with your stances. Sam just articulated a really hard fact that was really powerful. Yeah.
Matt (57:09.386)
we agree on that? okay. Yeah, I don't think, yeah, okay.
Sam (57:10.212)
Yeah, it was just better. Well, not totally, but almost.
Shawn (57:16.507)
Last point before we break, Sam, one more time, would you please spell for our listeners the word Israel?
Sam (57:24.836)
is roll isr o ll isr o ll is that what it is my goodness
Matt (57:24.906)
It's nu - nu - nuclear.
Shawn (57:27.003)
Spell it, just spell it.
Or maybe IZ RUL? I love it.
Matt (57:35.626)
And with that, we're gonna end this episode this week and listener will talk to you again next week. Thanks for joining us.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories