The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
Episode 74: Life coaching, Corporate hijacking, Surgeon General social media warning label
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Mailbag: One listener writes, “I question your definition of liberal and conservative although I loved the discussion. You said conservatives mistrust government and liberals mistrust individuals. I would say that conservatives mistrust government and liberals mistrust businesses. What is it called if you think business and government are equally capable of oppression? Economic power is still power and deserves to be checked.”
The Thought Provoker:
Matt is up first this week. Utah is proposing new legislation to regulate life coaches. Shawn likes the free market, but this industry is a sweet spot for what Sam calls affinity fraud. Is it morally right to regulate life coaches?
Next up, Sam. Should a wealthy multi national corporation pay the ransom to resume business operations and prevent its demise? CDK is planning to make the payment, a source with knowledge of the situation told Bloomberg. The hacking group behind the attack is believed to be based in eastern Europe, the source said
Finally, Shawn. One of America's most senior health officials has called on the country to impose smoking-style warning labels on social media platforms. Writing in the New York Times, Surgeon General Vivek Murthy said social media increased the risk that children would experience symptoms of anxiety and depression. He wants people who visit these platforms to be shown a message warning that they are "associated with significant mental health harms for adolescents". He said such a label would "regularly remind parents and adolescents that social media has not been proved safe. Is this wisdom or a passive aggressive way to control people?
The Big Question: I’ve seen a couple of big stories about how an undocumented immigrant murdered a woman in Maryland. And other stories about a mass shooting in Michigan at a splash pad. Republicans seem to enjoy blaming Biden’s border policies for crimes committed by undocumented immigrants. Democrats blame lax gun control laws for mass shootings. Are they correct? Can government policies about the border and/or guns prevent this kind of stuff in the future?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:00.54)
Welcome back to the real Mormonism podcast. It's so good to have you with us. We hope that you'll enjoy listening to us as much as we enjoy listening to ourselves. Hey, you guys want to know what I did today? That was super fun. I burned weeds for at least an hour. I was standing out there burning weeds like flames as high as my head. You can't do that in California, can you Sean? Just burn things. Yeah.
Sam (00:15.668)
What'd you do?
shawn (00:23.88)
You're allowed to do that?
No, I didn't know you could do that in Idaho. Wow.
Matt (00:31.132)
There's like these people about climate change that say, hey, you're not supposed to just burn things and ruin the atmosphere. But as I watched all of the toxic smoke go up into the air, I thought, I don't care. I hope climate change is a real thing because it's freezing cold in Rexburg where I live and I can't wait for like the beaches to get closer to me. So that's how I did my part to furthering the climate change myth, whatever it is, furthering it along. Yeah.
shawn (00:48.84)
Good attitude, I like that.
shawn (00:56.552)
wow, you just said a whole bunch of words that later on will bring up a topic that does prove you're not very liberal. That's true, yeah. Okay.
Matt (01:03.772)
okay. Hey, well, we've got some stuff from the mailbag. One listener writes, I question your definition of liberal and conservative, although I loved the discussion. But I'm going to pause here for a second. A lot of people told me that they said that they didn't like the way that I defined liberal and conservative, but.
shawn (01:22.152)
Just you? They like the way that Sam did? Because he had a definition.
Matt (01:25.596)
Well, no, this person, this listener in particular, didn't like the way Sam did it. But I just thought I would point out some people didn't like my definition either, which I think just goes to the point that like these labels don't really mean anything. If people don't even agree on what they mean, why do we waste our time using them? Anyhow.
shawn (01:33.064)
Hehehe.
shawn (01:40.648)
That's a great point.
Sam (01:41.652)
Did they suggest how to better define it?
Matt (01:45.212)
Yeah, here's what they said. So you said conservatives mistrust government and liberals mistrust individuals. I would say that conservatives mistrust government and liberals mistrust businesses. What is it called if you think business and government are equally capable of oppression? Economic power is still power and deserves to be checked.
shawn (02:05.896)
He asked, what do you call it? I call it folly. I don't think that, where in scripture, show me in scripture where a business oppresses the people as opposed to governments. I mean, with governments, we have hundreds of examples, right? We have Pharaoh, starting with Pharaoh in Egypt, right? Pharaoh, you have King Noah in the Book of Mormon, you have King Nebuchadnezzar and Darius in the Old Testament, I mean, just government after government.
Matt (02:16.956)
Matt (02:21.756)
Well, we have -
Matt (02:27.804)
Do you have any?
Matt (02:32.06)
Do you have individuals, do you have individuals oppressing people in the scriptures?
shawn (02:36.84)
Sure, sure.
Matt (02:38.588)
without government power, just people oppressing other people.
shawn (02:43.08)
I mean, what examples do you have of that?
Matt (02:45.756)
I don't have any. That's why I'm thinking I don't know that the scriptures are going to help us on this one, Sean. If the question is, should we trust people or trust?
shawn (02:49.832)
They do help because no, no, no, no, they do help because if you have 30 examples of governments oppressing and you have zero examples of individuals or people or businesses oppressing, then that's insight. That's great insight.
Matt (02:58.492)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (03:05.724)
But we do know that the best form of government according to the scriptures is a king, a righteous king, right?
shawn (03:11.048)
No, that is your misreading of the scripture. No, he says, if you can have righteous kings, then a king would be better than judges. But if you can have righteous judges, then righteous judges. Yes, he does, because they go to that form of government. He says, I don't trust, he does too, he says, I don't trust that, the reason they stopped having a king was because I don't trust that you'll have righteous kings. It's not the best form of government. It doesn't say that at all. You're misinterpreting that.
Matt (03:13.852)
That's exactly what King Mosiah says.
Matt (03:19.004)
then that's the best.
Nana.
He doesn't say better than judges.
Matt (03:38.076)
Well, just because there are no businesses in scripture doesn't mean that we can't infer principles that say businesses can be corrupt and can misuse power.
shawn (03:46.792)
Yeah, okay. But we can also point out that there are hundreds, 30 examples of governments oppressing. And so if I'm looking for a scriptural insight, truth and knowledge, then what I'm going to find out is, okay, we better be wary of governments because they oppress all the time and never really all it's, Hey, all it says about business in scripture is free intercourse is the best method. It says that is the best method.
Matt (03:53.5)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (04:14.844)
Every time you say it, it makes me laugh, Sean.
shawn (04:17.96)
It's because you're a 12 year old child.
Matt (04:20.252)
No, no, no, it's because intercourse is so much more than business, right? You use it to mean business, but I think of it as so much more.
shawn (04:27.368)
Well, yeah, but it says free intercourse to trade freely one with another. That's business. That's business. They prospered. So I'm just saying there's no, I see zero evidence in scripture to suggest that there, I mean, of course businesses can oppress, but equal to governments, no way. And I think scripture supports that.
Matt (04:31.132)
Yeah, okay. That's
Matt (04:45.22)
Well, I disagree with this person's premise that conservatives mistrust government and liberals mistrust businesses. I don't think that's what it means to be liberal, that you mistrust business.
shawn (04:57.896)
I'm glad you clarified that.
Sam (05:00.084)
To me, I think there's got to be something like a business to me is an extension of an individual and I sort of stand by the idea that liberals just don't trust people to make correct decisions for themselves and that's a key core difference between the two -party approaches. Business is an individual or a collection of individuals deciding to have commerce or trade between individuals and I
Matt (05:00.124)
Sammy you're muted.
Sam (05:29.46)
Again, I think, I think that comment betrays a prejudice that a lot of people who are liberal have, which is individuals just can't be trusted to do things completely alone. Business can't be trusted. Yeah. Business can't be trusted to do things alone because at the end of the day, they're going to do things that will hurt other individuals and other people. And, that is the way, but, but.
shawn (05:43.208)
whether organized.
Matt (05:54.556)
But that's the way conservatives feel about government. Government also is just people.
Sam (05:58.452)
But government is different because government takes control over people. So whether, whether government is a king where through tyranny and through oppression and through, having an army, they take and seize control by force of other people, or whether it's a group of people that get together and decide on laws, judges and whatnot, and decide to be represented by that government can either be by consent or it can be by terror. And.
shawn (06:02.792)
Mm.
shawn (06:11.048)
by force.
Sam (06:27.86)
That's where conservatives have a lot of skepticism and mistrust is that something that is started by consent and agreement, a social contract can turn bad very quickly. I even saw, yeah, yeah, so.
shawn (06:28.072)
Yeah.
Matt (06:41.756)
Yeah. I just think that, that I, I don't think that it's helpful to like split it up as liberal and conservative. And I don't know to me, to me, conservatives want to preserve the past and liberals want to change.
Sam (06:50.612)
It, it, it, you know what? It's, it, it, it, it's, it's not helpful to divide up by labels, but necessarily we have to because that's where we are. You know, I saw Bill Barr this week talking about who he's voting for as president. He's endorsing Donald Trump and yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And.
Matt (07:09.5)
No way. Bill Barr? Who already... How many times did he come out and say he would never vote for Donald Trump because he's not fit for office?
shawn (07:12.072)
Who's Bill Barr?
Sam (07:16.404)
And, and CNN is challenging him on it. And he says, look in this, he says, I don't agree with the way this went down. He said, between these two choices, like we only have two choices. Americans have two ways you can go. And we're forced into this, this platform of you either have to go left or you have to go right, literally. And he said, I don't like it. I don't like president Trump, but he said, I like, you know, I like Biden and trust Biden a heck of a lot less.
Matt (07:35.868)
Yeah.
Sam (07:46.324)
And so he said, I choose Trump in that case. He says, I'm not endorsing him as a good person, but he said, that's, that's the way I, that's the way I have to go. And conservatives don't trust that government or liberals, liberals don't, or conservatives don't trust that government left to its own devices will end up doing the right thing. And I think, I think liberals in a lot of cases say, Hey, aspirationally government is great because it can.
Matt (07:58.332)
I'm conservative. Listen.
Sam (08:14.516)
make decisions for people who can't make decisions for themselves. And that is one of the most dangerous ideas of liberalism in the left that, that exists out there. And by the way, not to totally change the topic, but did you guys see any of the AI stuff online this past week about how, you know, the Democrats are putting up some AI version of Biden or some like fake, you know, actor for Biden for the debates that they're going to actually prop up someone that's not real?
Matt (08:17.66)
Yes.
shawn (08:19.336)
haha
Yeah, I agree.
Matt (08:42.168)
really?
Sam (08:43.86)
I love this stuff because this is, yeah, this is evidence of misinformation, I hope. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Matt (08:44.924)
More and more.
Yeah, of course. Of course that's true. Yeah. Sean, just, just to backtrack a little Sean, Bill Barr was the attorney general in the Trump administration who after January 6th or in the lead up to January 6th said that what Donald Trump did was so bad, he would never support him ever again. So Bill Barr was, yeah. And Mitch McConnell, Mitch McConnell did the same thing.
shawn (09:06.76)
fascinating. Hmm.
Sam (09:09.364)
And Trump, and Trump has a quote. It's awesome where he calls bill Barr all these names and Trump has said, Hey, in light of bill Barr, endorsing me, I'll take away this one word. And I think it was slothful or something like that. And CNN read bill Barr the quote, and this is the magic of Trump. CNN reading Trump's quote made bill Barr laugh. And he said, well, that's classic Trump.
Matt (09:26.478)
You
Sam (09:37.268)
That's the genius of that man is he can make his worst enemies laugh because what he says is so ludicrous, right?
Matt (09:37.34)
Yeah. That's not genius, Sam. That's just bullying. Yeah.
shawn (09:45.384)
He's a joke. He's a joke.
Matt (09:45.564)
Right, that's not... Okay, we're gonna move to the thought provoker, because I get to go first this weekend. And we don't want to talk about bill bar for too long, because it'll make us all feel slothful. Okay, so Utah is proposing new legislation to regulate life coaches. And Sean likes the free market, but this industry is a sweet spot for what Sam likes to call affinity fraud. So my question is, is it a morally right thing to regulate life coaches?
shawn (09:54.28)
Hehehe. Hehehe.
shawn (09:59.208)
boy.
shawn (10:14.42)
my gosh, let me, hey, so I'm gonna answer that real quick because also this week what happened was two of Matt's favorite people, Elon Musk and Javier Millet, who is Argentina's new president, who is just killing it. He's killing it, Matt. He's doing amazing things. He's destroying the government and making it small again.
Matt (10:17.404)
huh.
Matt (10:31.836)
making the art he's killing the peso in argentina killing the currency okay
shawn (10:34.696)
No, he's not. Anyway, so anyway, so they were at a big conference this week and here's what they said. And this answers your question. Here's what, yes, it is. Here's what Elon Musk said. It is. He says only nature makes real laws. Everything else is a recommendation. And he says, we should have a regulation removal department and we should change laws so that instead of getting permission in advance to do things, we should just be penalized for doing bad things.
Matt (10:42.396)
Wait, is this about life coaches? okay, good. Okay.
shawn (11:04.264)
So to answer your question, Elon Musk is right. He's absolutely right. And this man, I studied it out. After he set this question over, I studied up who is pushing for this law or to regulate life coaches. man, the cringiest dude I've ever seen, Mark Steinegel, who is the head of Doppel. That's Utah's department of professional licensing. And they've got all this marketing stuff out there and it is the cringiest grossest stuff. We have to.
Matt (11:06.172)
I'm shocked. I'm shocked that he thinks that.
Matt (11:16.22)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (11:31.516)
Wait, what makes it cringe?
shawn (11:33.328)
it is so cringe. So I guarantee that both of you have used, and I have many times used contractors who are not licensed. And what his, what his message is that you are a fool. You are an idiot and you will probably die. Like literally his marketing is when you use unlicensed contractors in any arena, you are going to get cheated. They're going to trick you. They're going to lie to you. They're going to, I mean, it's really an
Matt (11:35.228)
But what makes it cringe?
Matt (11:43.484)
course.
shawn (12:02.504)
unprofessional and anyway, so my point, my point is his, he's using this whole Jody Hillebrand spectacle to empower his agency. And the irony is Jody Hillebrand was a licensed therapist.
Matt (12:11.964)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (12:20.604)
but she was not a licensed life coach.
shawn (12:23.272)
So what, there's no such thing as a licensed life coach now. She was a licensed, yeah, but he's saying, you guys need to be licensed because we will protect you. And yet she was licensed. Well, they didn't do much protecting.
Matt (12:26.62)
Right, but there could be.
Matt (12:34.076)
Okay, so Sean, do you go to doctors that aren't licensed? Do you like to go to doctors that haven't been to medical school? Do you like to go to...
shawn (12:41.032)
Many Americans do. They'll go to Mexico. They'll go to other countries.
Matt (12:46.108)
And is it safer to do that or less safe?
shawn (12:49.512)
I'm sure it is for the people that go and do it.
Sam (12:52.436)
Well, I, so I have a question, Matt. What, what, obviously I did no reading on this. So I have no idea anything about the topic, but what, what's prompting legislation in the first place for life coaches.
Matt (12:52.572)
now.
shawn (12:57.608)
Hahaha!
shawn (13:03.528)
Government agencies and the stupid Jodi Hiller brand because they want it. So here's what Elon Musk said, when there's a lot of regulation, what it does is it empowers consultants and political agencies to make more regulations to ensure their work, their business.
Matt (13:03.534)
because... well, I -
Sam (13:05.396)
But why? But why?
Yeah, but she's a counselor.
Sam (13:22.548)
Well, I get that, but in the state of Utah, they decided to pursue this. They haven't done this anywhere else. Why, why now? Why here?
shawn (13:29.128)
Jodi Hillebrand, Jodi Hillebrand.
Matt (13:29.148)
because they're Jodie Hillebrand is one of them, but it wasn't just her. There was the, the eight families lady, right? What was her name? Anyhow, there, there are a number of life coaches in Utah. It's a, it's a growing industry. If you look at it, the, the, the most money that's made in life coaching is training people to be life coaches so that then they can go start their own business. But most people who are life coaches aren't making a lot of money.
shawn (13:45.512)
It is everywhere.
Matt (13:58.332)
And then there are some people that say it's hard for me to find who's a good life coach and who's not a good life coach. Like anybody right now in Utah can put up a sign and say, I'm a life coach and here's why you should hire me. And it makes it hard for consumers to know. Like it's hard. Yeah, but Sean, you maybe don't have this.
shawn (14:04.232)
I hate this.
shawn (14:08.232)
Good, good, should stay that way.
shawn (14:13.448)
Because consumers are idiots, Sam. Sam, consumers are idiots. You're an idiot and you don't know what's best for you.
Sam (14:16.244)
So, so, so can I share one thought and I wonder if this has anything to do with it. Right. So if you want to receive counseling services, so if you want to receive licensed counseling services, a, you have to be in the state where you receive it. And the licensed person who's giving those services has to be in the state. You receive it. If I understand right. Right. So now there's all these, now there's now. Correct. So now there's all this mental health,
Matt (14:37.916)
Yes.
shawn (14:38.056)
Not for coaching, not for coaching, right? For therapists, for.
Matt (14:41.34)
That's for therapy, for mental health counseling.
Sam (14:45.876)
you know, counseling online, and they either have to be licensed all state or they have to flip you to a life coach contract, which is less regulated, you can do that intrastate without having a license. And I wonder if in the state of Utah with online stuff, in addition to those two stories, if maybe that plays into it, I would love.
Matt (14:46.62)
Online stuff, you know.
Matt (15:09.244)
Well, let me tell you real fast. I'll tell you the other benefit of licensing. The reason that if you have to be licensed to do mental health is because if you want to get insurance to pay for things like mental health, they want to know that the care you're getting is from a licensed professional. So there are advantages to existing life coaches in creating regulations and a licensing system because the existing life coaches will then have opportunity to say to insurance companies, look, I'm licensed by the state of Utah. You should help pay for the...
the services I provide because maybe they don't treat a specific mental health concern, but they can help with overall wellness and it allows them, well, it just allows them to use a state credential to argue for coverage from an insurance company.
shawn (15:45.8)
It's overreach. It's out.
shawn (15:54.632)
It's overreach and it's self power that they're creating for themselves. It's terrible.
Sam (15:58.804)
So, so I think it's fascinating. I'm not a huge fan of creating regulation where there hasn't been any, but I have had counseling from an individual here in the state of Utah who, of one sort or another, who, who, who says, Hey, you know, I'm, I'm a therapist of sort, but he's more of a life coach. And I'll tell you what this guy's online YouTube stuff and the books and all the supporting collateral he gives. Like I'm sure he's a smart guy. he's a heck of a nice guy, church member, closely affiliated with the church, but it.
It feels like Tony Robbins a little bit, right? And, and, and, and, and it's like, it's like,
Matt (16:29.852)
Yeah, that's right. He's a life coach.
shawn (16:30.6)
But Sam, how are you able to decipher whether his content was good or not without the government helping you?
Sam (16:38.74)
Yeah, well, it's, you know.
Matt (16:40.892)
It's a lot easier when the government licenses people, Sean. It's a lot easier. I'm serious. Listen, right out of college, I got my undergraduate in psychology. Right out of college, my job was business development coach. I had no training in business. I had never run a business. I didn't know anything about business. And I would go sign people up for my training program. I would charge them like a thousand dollars. Yeah.
shawn (16:43.304)
Shut up, man.
shawn (17:02.472)
Yeah, I remember that. I remember that Matt. And you very quickly were like, wait a minute, I'm not pretty providing any value. So you quit and.
Matt (17:09.82)
I quit. Guess what? I didn't have to quit. I could have made a whole lot of money along with the other people that were making a whole lot of money selling absolutely nothing to people who are just suckers who thought, Hey, these people look good. They look like they know what they're talking about. Let's give them some money.
Sam (17:22.964)
Yeah, but here's the deal. The free market ends up deciding that. So the free market spit you out and chewed you up because you weren't delivering enough value, right? You...
shawn (17:27.463)
100%.
You
Matt (17:32.444)
No, it did not, I didn't, no, I left, I left, I could have made a lot of, I could have kept doing that. The free market did not push me out of that industry. My conscience pushed me out of that industry.
shawn (17:39.432)
Matt, you would not have been able to make a lot of money in the long run had you not created a tremendous value. The reward of the value you would have created would have made you a lot of money. You can't trick people and make a ton of money for a long period of time. You get exposed.
Sam (17:41.492)
You made, you made, you.
Matt (17:52.54)
Yes you can. Do you know who all of my customers were? No, do you know who my customers were? The everybody who purchases multi -level marketing that was like, I'm waiting for my residuals to kick in. When can I?
Sam (17:52.788)
So, so, but.
shawn (18:01.608)
then they value, Matt, then they value what you have to offer.
Sam (18:05.108)
By the way, those are the best, those are the best people to make a lot of money on because they've preyed on everybody else. So let me ask you this. So what you're saying is, is you were making tens of thousands of dollars each month and you said, Hey, I decide to intentionally walk away. Yeah. I'm not going to believe. I don't believe that. I don't. Yeah. Tens of thousands of dollars.
Matt (18:08.86)
That's what I'm saying. Right.
Matt (18:17.372)
Yes.
Feel guilty. Yes. Well, I, at first I thought what I was doing, really Sam, really, you don't believe I walked away from a lot of money because I felt like I, that I was easily bringing in that much a month for our company.
shawn (18:26.152)
hahahahah
Sam (18:34.64)
I, I, right, right. In revenue, but not in commissions. I'm telling you that like, I find it hard to believe that you are having so much success that you were super ec, because at the point you get economic. Okay. But, but at the point, but at the point you're having that much success and you don't feel like you're delivering fully on the promises you make to your clients. You have economic leverage to be able to turn back around and reshape what you're doing to make it.
Matt (18:40.604)
Matt (18:46.172)
My commission was 30%. I was getting 30 % of what I brought in.
Sam (19:02.9)
make it better. You have to like, like it sounds like you it sounds like you left.
Matt (19:04.444)
I realized that what we were doing was a sham. I realized we were just con - we were conning people, Sam. You're not gonna con - We were conning - We -
Sam (19:10.899)
You were conning people who were conning other people. Who, what, all right, let's play this out because I'm very suspicious of what you're saying. What was the company you worked for?
shawn (19:16.712)
Matt (19:18.3)
Okay, I won't get in trouble for saying it. Okay, it was called United Business Network.
Sam (19:26.42)
Okay, and what did they do?
Matt (19:29.02)
Okay, so what we did initially, man, my listener, our listeners are going to hate me when they hear what I did. Okay. What we did initially is we would hold these meetings in restaurants at lunchtime or breakfast time, where you would help people get sales leads for each other. So, so, so you'd pay for.
Sam (19:33.876)
Okay.
Sam (19:42.228)
Yeah, it was a lead generation thing. And people paid to join UBM. I actually know about that, yeah.
shawn (19:45.)
Huge value, huge value there. Many of us do.
Matt (19:49.308)
So that was our intro, right? You pay $400 to be a part of that club. And then what I would do is I would bring in new people into that networking group. And then I would sell them on our business coaching product, which was two weeks and $1 ,000 a person to do the business coaching. So in the lead generation, I had lots of what I would call respectable, smart business people that when I would approach them and say, hey, would you like to purchase?
shawn (19:53.672)
Networking Group.
Sam (20:07.22)
Okay.
Matt (20:18.044)
our business consulting package for a thousand dollars. They're like, what do you have to offer me that I don't already have? You don't really know anything about my business. And I was like, well, I think you should buy it anyways. And they politely say, no, thank you. Then we would have all these people that were in various multi -level marketing things, selling credit repair, selling vitamins, selling magnets. And they had already purchased it into some multi -level marketing scheme where they thought they were going to make a lot of money, but they're like, I don't know how to run my business. And so then I would say to them, Hey,
you want to spend $1 ,000 and we'll do this two week training for you. And those people would buy like, it was like giving candy to a child at Halloween. Like getting their $1 ,000 was the easiest thing.
Sam (20:57.108)
I know, I know, but what, what was the result of that? So you signed them up for this for a thousand dollars, which isn't a lot, which isn't a lot by the way. And, and. Okay. So it was a thousand dollars. And then what did they receive? Did they end up getting some sort of training or value for that dollars paid?
Matt (21:01.724)
Lots of money.
Well, this was 20 years ago. It was pretty good money back then.
Matt (21:14.492)
They sure did. Wish they got to do our two week coaching class. Have you ever heard of the E -Myth? You know, we'd go through the principles of E -Myth. We would go through seven habits of highly effective people.
Sam (21:18.004)
And what was that?
Yeah.
shawn (21:22.184)
Yes, great book. So what's wrong with that? Matt, you're providing a... Matt, your fear of money and success is causing you to look at this the wrong light. You're looking at it in the wrong light.
Sam (21:29.78)
So, so, wait, wait, let's stop. Let's stop. Let's stop. I'm, I'm, I'm going to suggest that it's your own insecurity that says that. So, so it's funny because back in the nineties, that was a big program. And back in the nineties, coaching of that sort was all the rage. Those business network lunches were very popular.
Matt (21:33.436)
No, I'm not afraid of success. Listen, I'm taking it... I had nothing to offer these people, right? I'm just conning them.
Matt (21:45.372)
okay. Alright.
Sam (21:57.492)
So you don't know this. I can't remember if it was after we all were in college or whatever, but the few years through college, I left the car business for a little bit. I actually went out to California and got trained by those guys, right. In Santa Rosa. No, no, no, no, no, no, no. It was by Michael Gerber, whoever it is, the guy, the guy that, yeah, the guy that actually wrote the book, right. So, so you guys were training people on the book, right.
Matt (21:57.5)
Yes.
Matt (22:11.9)
No, no, no, no, not us. I hope it wasn't us.
shawn (22:15.56)
The E -Myth people. The E -Myth people.
Matt (22:17.596)
the real people. the real people. I see.
Sam (22:26.516)
And we went out and got certified to train people on the book. What we did worked well for a period of time, but ultimately the market saw it. Like there were businesses that's out of, it's under a new owner now, but like the brick oven, the guy that owns brick oven, the guy that owns, there are multiple, multiple businesses in the Provo area that we had a relationship through those business lunches. And listen, you took principles in a book, like, seven habits or like that E -Myth.
Matt (22:26.812)
Sorta.
Matt (22:40.252)
Yeah, brick oven pizza.
shawn (22:41.96)
You failed that.
Matt (22:55.388)
EMEA
Sam (22:56.532)
And you help people think more clearly about their business and how to get, get better with their business. And if they didn't take time to stop and think about their business and get outside their business and think more strategically about it, you gave them the opportunity by reviewing that book on a regular basis to sit and think about it. Just like, by the way, you gave people during the two years you were on your mission, the time to stop and think about a book, right?
shawn (23:18.248)
Hehehehehe
Matt (23:20.06)
Hahaha.
Sam (23:22.868)
and make their life a little bit better by thinking strategically, not because you had all the answers to life, not because you were any better than anybody else, but because you had people slow down in life and be a little bit more intentional. So, so, so, so is it fraudulent? You know what? In both cases, who knows? It could be, wait, are you saying your mission was fraudulent? okay. Okay. Okay.
Matt (23:23.1)
Yeah.
shawn (23:23.208)
Ha ha.
shawn (23:33.096)
and you're sharing principles that other people have discovered and were teaching.
No!
Matt (23:39.356)
Yes, yes, I do know. no, no, my mission was not fraudulent. Business coaching, the business coaching I did, I offered nothing of value in exchange.
Sam (23:50.388)
And the biggest difference in those two, no, but that's fascinating. The biggest difference in those two are.
shawn (23:53.8)
Maybe you didn't believe in it. Maybe you didn't believe in those principles, but I'll just, as long as we're talking anecdotally, you both got trained and certified in this. I never did, but I love that book. And I'm telling you, I have helped dozens of businesses, right? Cause I helped startups.
Sam (24:00.34)
now he's...
Sam (24:05.62)
Yeah. So listen, listen, the federal government, it's okay if the federal government decides not to. Certify those like, I hate the life coaching industry. I make fun of it continually and every single day, but just because I don't like it and I want to make fun of it, doesn't mean it needs to necessarily be heavily regulated. I see the benefit of counselors being able to switch to life coaches to provide a multi -state counseling services. I will forever more.
Matt (24:06.78)
How much did you?
Sam (24:35.348)
make fun of this guy that has the Tony Robbins courses online and sells all of his stuff. Because at one point in one way or another, he's either delivering value, which other people pay for or not. the Jody Hildebrandt thing is proof that even with state licensing, the government can't prevent a lunatic from doing bad things. The government does not have that power. Matt, do you think the government through licensing would have power to stop Jody Hildebrandt?
shawn (24:57.896)
It's so dumb. And Matt...
Matt (25:04.348)
No, no, but it would get consumers more tools that they need to make good choices.
shawn (25:08.68)
You know what it leads to, Matt? You know what it leads to? Bam! Amen.
Sam (25:08.948)
You know what? People are smart enough to make good choices. Liberals like yourself don't think they can make smart choices, but they can.
shawn (25:15.312)
Matt, you know what it leads to? You know what it leads to? What it leads to is Mark Steinegel from the Department of Professional Licensing finding you money for giving any advice to a family member about how to run their life. Well, Matt, you're not a licen - Yes, they are. Because this dude, you watch his videos, he is so annoyingly aggressive with, we are saving the world. We are, we are, we are professional licensor police.
Matt (25:17.02)
Well, I - I'm gonna -
Matt (25:30.844)
Well they're not gonna find.
Matt (25:36.348)
But he's not playing, he's not.
But he's not finding people. He's not giving, he's not going to go around finding you for giving people advice. If somebody like me, he would come up.
shawn (25:46.184)
Yes, you do Matt. Matt, if you're a licensed, if you're an unlicensed contractor, like electrician, and you go and do work, their whole job is to go find you and put you on a blacklist so that people don't use you and watch his videos. The rhetoric is these people are thieves. If you're not licensed, you're wrong. You're evil. You're doing bad stuff. And so if you give advice, you're not licensed Matt as a coach.
Matt (25:52.668)
Yeah?
Matt (26:05.916)
Okay, sir.
Matt (26:09.724)
Okay, so who is it that said that I am insecure and that's why I want to reg you? Okay, I'm gonna give Sam the points, because I like that. Who are you giving the points to, Sean? You're gonna give them to Sam too? Sam, you're gonna just give them, you're gonna take them yourself or you're gonna give them to somebody else?
shawn (26:14.312)
Sam did.
shawn (26:18.472)
Nice. Points to Sam. Yeah, points to Sam. Yeah, points to Sam.
Sam (26:29.876)
I'm going to give my points to the unlicensed life coach that I think probably makes a lot of money. And, and a Michael Gerber who wrote the E -Myth who, by the way, his personal life, the dude is a train wreck. So he wrote a good book. He created, you know, it's fascinating the illusion between religion and between some of these people that, that, that sell these books. He created a religious following behind this idea that all you need to do is think strategically about your business. It's a truth.
Matt (26:33.148)
hahahaha
shawn (26:34.408)
Yay!
shawn (26:41.544)
Aaaaahhhh
Matt (26:41.756)
shawn (26:52.808)
It's awesome. It's awesome.
Matt (26:52.956)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (26:56.476)
jeez.
Sam (26:58.964)
That is true. And, and, and people, you know, people would go out into a desert and sit in a hot tent with the guy and you know, it's, it's the dumbest thing I've ever heard of. And I did it for years. So.
shawn (26:59.208)
You know what?
Matt (27:00.796)
Bye.
shawn (27:06.216)
So Sam, so Sam, so, Matt, since Sam monologued, I'm taking away his points and I'm gonna give them to Mark Steinegel, because that guy is so desperate for some attention. That guy is so desperate to be important in life, he gets the points.
Matt (27:17.5)
it could be that that's his job for the state of Utah. I don't know the guy. Hey, Mark. If you're one of our listeners or one of Mark's family members, we don't actually hate you. Sean's just use like Sean is thinking of you as a representative of the things in government he hates. So keep listening to us. Family members, if you need to write to us and let us know Mark's a kind person and we'll, we'll take all of the main things we said about him. We'll take them back. Okay, Sam, you're up next.
Sam (27:47.668)
All right. So, this week's story comes to my personal life and I'll share this here, knowing that it doesn't get out broadly. Cause I haven't talked this way about what happened this past week anywhere else. It's all been, it's everything's been on very much locked down. So every. Yeah. Well, it is, it is definitely breaking news. Yeah.
shawn (28:01.608)
So this is insider breaking news.
Matt (28:02.172)
Hey, so, so Mark, Mark Steineggel's family, Mark Steineggel's family, if you're mad at us, don't take this information to ruin Sam's life. We're just having fun.
shawn (28:05.576)
That's interesting.
Sam (28:11.156)
Yeah, that's right. That's right. So everybody out here, I think, or many of us know that I'm in the auto industry in the auto industry. We sell cars, we service cars. That's what the auto industry does. The place I work, we have multiple, multiple rooftops. We're a large automotive group. So it's interesting in automotive, we have various partners and vendors that provide different services. And one of the key partners or services that are provided to us that allows us to do our job.
is something called a dealer management software. So think about it this way. If you walk into a car dealership and you buy a car, you get service, everything that is done during your visit ends up getting logged into a computer in one form, fashion or another, right? So you make a payment, you make us, you schedule something, you take a ride in a car, you want to give somebody a driver's license, you want to print paperwork out to buy something, all of that.
Matt (29:07.58)
I want to extend my warranty.
Sam (29:09.428)
You want to extend your warranty. Anything and everything you want to do ends up being done through this dealer management software. One of the biggest providers of that is a company called CDK. So there are about 18 or 19 ,000 new car dealerships in the country. 14 ,000 of them are handled by CDK. It's a huge company. It's owned by a private equity firm. It used to be publicly traded. Now it's private. Well,
On Wednesday morning, I get woken up super early Eastern time zone by our emergency system that says, Hey, the system is down. I'm fascinated. So I call up a couple of the stores, I validate, I say, What's the message? They're like, There is no message. It's just completely gone. And when we call support, it's a busy line. Nobody's answering their phones. So I call our rep, no answer. I call our IT guys. They're like, Hey, there's no ping. There's nothing. It's shut down all across the network.
one of the executives calls me back and he's like, Hey, we've had a cyber incident overnight. We shut down our systems to be proactive. They'll be back shortly. So we think nothing of it. We're trying not to jump to conclusions. The whole marketplace says, Hey, there was a hack. There's a ransom. We don't know what it is or what it isn't. Midday, they start to bring back some of the services. And mid -afternoon, they have brought back all the services, but we still don't have access for some reason.
By 7 o 'clock Pacific time, I have a friend of mine in Sacramento that calls me up, and he's like, Hey, they took it back down. We were already closed by that point. And then the next day we got notification from them that said, Hey, we got hit a second time the afternoon of that first day. And they're like, we've turned off all of our systems. We're working to get back control. And then they went completely quiet. So Wednesday was day one, Thursday was day two, Friday was day three.
And today is Saturday, which is day four on day three. Everybody's thinking the worst. We're thinking, Hey, their systems are completely destroyed. There's some sort of ransom thing. They're not talking to anybody about anything. We finally get ahold of somebody at a very high level. I won't say who it is, but they said, Hey, here's the truth of it. We did get hacked. it was a cyber incident. There was a ransom. And they said in this game.
Sam (31:33.652)
what we're trying to do is we're trying to get control back of the system to limit the bad guys' access. And he's like, the more we limit their access, the lower the ransom. But he's like, We will be paying this ransom. We will pay the ransom. And I just got a note while we're on this call here. Late day yesterday, everybody's starting to think, Hey, they're going to pay it. It's Eastern Europeans that are doing this. And then while we're on this recording here, I just finally got a note saying that they've
It's a note that basically says, I'm still all in the middle of this. It says, it says, based on the information we have at this time, we anticipate the restoration process to take several days, not weeks, for major applications and ask for your continued support. But, but they're now, as of right now, what, midday, Saturday, they're saying, we have begun the restoration process. So they paid, Matt, I can't hear you. You might be muted.
They paid the ransom.
Matt (32:31.58)
So you should just fire them and move on, Sam. You should fire that company and just get another company. Because Sean tells me all the time, this is how it works in the free market. Somebody does bad service, you let them go. So why don't you just cut ties with them, Sam, and go to their competitor and just start new with them.
Sam (32:47.252)
Yeah. Well, it, you know what? It is an incredibly great solution and we probably, and anybody in our industry probably would have done that quickly where it possible. So if you think about it again for these past, well, it, no, it's possible. It's impractical financially and, and, and logistically. So, so, so, so think about it.
shawn (32:47.336)
Great solution. What a great solution.
Matt (32:58.876)
It's not possible, right?
Matt (33:04.956)
Mm -hmm. Mm -hmm.
shawn (33:05.288)
But the business has, it's a cost analysis at this point, right? The cost to hire someone new or to build your own compared to paying the dang ransom, they're doing a cost analysis, right?
Sam (33:13.14)
Mm -hmm. -huh.
Matt (33:17.564)
No, no, no, no, Sam's company has been paying for a service and they're not getting that service for the last several days and they can't move on because it's not practical for them to move on to a competitor.
shawn (33:30.76)
So here's what's fascinating about us taking opposite roles sometimes. My answer was gonna be, why is this not a national security issue? Why wouldn't the government get involved? Look at this, it's so weird. Matt's saying free market, I'm saying government. That's so odd.
Sam (33:43.348)
So, so, so get just a step back one step more. And it kind of helps answer this other question. So for the past four days, our stores have all turned to, we're still selling cars. We're still servicing cars, but we're now doing it with paper and pen, right? Which actually is good for a lot of the team members because they're learning how to do things that they've never done in a way they've never done it. The biggest challenge with paper and pen in today's world is banks can't fund contracts that way. We can't make payments to people that way.
Matt (33:57.724)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (34:11.092)
So we're actually having to go back to very rudimentary writing of checks and engaging, interacting with other people. The other problem we have is think about it. You go to a website, you request for more information about a car, that digital lead that comes across electronically, there's nowhere for it to go now. So our teams are having to go back and recreate all that historical sales data, that followup data, and they're having to make phone calls to people because of all the
all the government regulation and FTC, all personal data has been required to be in a single protected place. So salespeople don't have customers contact information. Nothing's written down anywhere. Nothing's stored locally anywhere. And that is due to government regulation to protect individual consumers. So it's been a fascinating exercise over the past four days is how do you still meet consumer demand for those services yet?
shawn (34:49.512)
So which.
Sam (35:04.916)
Because we were compliant with all the federal regulations about private information, how do we get private information so that we can still engage with consumers? And I'll tell you, here's the cool thing about humans and people. And this goes to free markets, Matt, and this goes to the power of our economy. We have been awesome at being super flexible and being super, we haven't had the resources of this system and of the information and of the ability to execute the way we normally do.
our teams have been outrageously resourceful at finding ways to meet the demands that are out there. And we've found ways, and when the systems come back up next week at some point or another, we'll go back, we'll reenter everything in that need to be re -entered that was missed over the past several days, and life will go on like normal. But here's the question for today. Here's the question for today. Should this company have paid the ransom? And before I say that, before I say that,
Matt (36:01.052)
No.
Sam (36:03.636)
There are multiple other companies that have gone through this exact same problem. MGM. There was a large auto group in Southern California this past week that was out for 10 days. There's, there's a healthcare. Hang on just a sec, Sean, you gotta let me set this up, man. I've paid, I've, I have fought way too, I have fought way too hard over the past four days for this. This is my, I own this baby. I own this. There's, there's a hospital system that was completely knocked out.
shawn (36:08.296)
points. One. So one so what 100 % so what
shawn (36:19.528)
It's been about 10 minutes, Sam. It's been about 10 minutes. This is a lot of detail, Sam. You haven't even asked a question yet.
Sam (36:31.7)
Not a lot of people know this, but there's a payment processing system in healthcare called Change Health, or I forget what it is, but it processes claims for prescription drugs and for healthcare that almost put doctors out of business because they couldn't get, they couldn't submit a claim. So as technology becomes better to take these things hostage, should businesses,
have the economic power to do it, pay ransoms that end up going to governments in this case, maybe the Russians, and enrich them.
shawn (37:08.04)
So 100 % points to Matt. Matt solved it right away about 10 minutes ago. Matt said the right thing. No, they shouldn't pay rent. I mean, it's up to them to do a business cost analysis. But in the end, Matt nailed it. This causes another company to step up and go, we are going to build a system that can't get hacked. Like this happens all the time in the website creation world. WordPress is hackable and full of malware. So another company called Squarespace comes along and says, we've solved it.
Matt (37:08.124)
No.
shawn (37:37.48)
So Matt, you solved it. 100 % of the points to you. Way to go. Free market.
Matt (37:41.788)
The reason you don't pay ransom, Sam, is because this stuff that happens to the big boys now was happening to small businesses like 10 years ago. So they start small with companies that really can't afford very much, and then they use that money to get better and better and better and more sophisticated. And the more people pay the ransom, the better they're gonna be. And they have the resources now to be better than the best tech companies. And why would they not keep doing it? Because we keep paying for it. The answer to this is,
Government regulation. It's really simple.
Sam (38:14.612)
So, so.
shawn (38:14.792)
You said free market was the answer, Matt.
Matt (38:17.084)
I was being facetious. Like I was pointing out for listeners that that the free market actually can't solve this problem because Sam's Sam's company, Sam's company can't just go to the next vendor right now. They have to. They've they've got so much of their inf. Yeah, but it's not practical. Sam told us it's not practical.
shawn (38:23.688)
Yes it can! You know that it does solve it!
shawn (38:31.272)
This, well it's painful, but they can.
shawn (38:37.704)
Is it practical to get hacked and pay a pay a ransom? That's not practical either.
Matt (38:40.796)
Sam's company didn't get hacked. So that's what I'm saying. The jargon that people use is too big to fail, but what it means is sometimes the relationships are so deeply embedded between companies and sometimes the information you share is so great that what happens to one company affects the other company in ways that you can't just go find the next competitor and switch all your business to those people.
shawn (38:57.832)
Matt, how would, how would.
shawn (39:05.128)
How would government regulation have stopped hackers from getting into the software? Go ahead.
Matt (39:13.82)
Well, there are laws in place, right? So what you do is you make the fine for getting hacked so much that a company is incentivized to not let it get hacked because they don't want to have to pay that fine.
shawn (39:22.472)
You would put, you would say government, you would say government should punish those who got hacked.
Matt (39:28.124)
Listen, I have a right for my information to be private. I can't tell you how many times I get emails that says my personal information is on the dark web because some company out there has been hacked. My local hospital was hacked. Almost every banking institution I've been with has been hacked. Email servers are hacked. Almost everything gets hacked. That's all against the law, Sean. So we should enforce the law that says protect consumer information.
shawn (39:45.352)
Yeah, yeah, we all deal with it. Yeah.
Matt (39:54.108)
And if you can't protect consumer information, then you don't get to do business anymore. It's really simple. Yeah, then.
shawn (39:55.176)
Who's?
shawn (39:58.6)
Okay, all right, that's your answer. That's your answer. Okay, all right.
Sam (40:03.444)
So, so it's interesting. I think back to something, a guy, my award said this guy that turned out to be a CIA dude. And he, he made the comment. He said, a lot of people don't realize it. He said, we're are, we're in world war three. And I was like, wow, that's, that's pretty dramatic. Right? Like of course, Ukraine, the whole thing over there. Right. That's a big deal. This is before Israel heated up. I'm like, that's not a world war. He said, no, you don't understand it. He said, world war three is not being fought by militaries.
Matt (40:16.604)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (40:31.7)
He said, World War III is being fought by governments electronically to destroy the framework of, of, of our democracy and, and, and our country. And so I actually take the path. Government regulation, it, in a, Matt, I think you're right with the answer, but in the wrong way, government regulation is not going to help protect data better than it currently does. Government regulation candidly is part of what causes a little bit the problem in the first place.
there is a ton of laws around personal information and disclosure when that stuff's breached. And I mean, consumers information is incredibly safe with most companies right now, because the government has massive penalties. If it's not, I mean, the penalties are massive. Every company I know, take safeguarding customer information incredibly, seriously the technology to fix these breaches or the technology to breach these companies.
is evolving fast, and it's super aggressive. And I think what this guy meant was, as he said, these attacks are part of this World War. And I think federal government should get involved in these situations, find out who the bad actors are. They know who they are. A lot of these guys say, Hey, it was me. And, and we should use our military capability to end it. We should go out and bomb these guys. We should go, we should attack.
Matt (41:56.7)
attack them. We could take down their infrastructure.
Sam (41:58.58)
We should attack them in every way. The only reason they're able to do what they do is because from a risk -benefit calculation, there's very little risk to them. The benefit is monetary, and the benefit to the company paying it is they get their business back. This company that was breached would lose their business. Multi -billion dollar company if they didn't get the data back. And so if the ransom is in the tens of millions, they have to pay it.
Matt (42:01.82)
Yeah.
Matt (42:27.836)
So the science technology building on campus, I used to be in a Bishopric where we met for church there and they have this room. The only reason I mentioned is that because you're like, why would you just sit there and stare at this? But there's this room where it shows the attacks on the infrastructure to the BYU Idaho, like their infrastructure. Anyhow, it looks like a missile attack, but it's like multiple times per second. There are hackers out there trying to hack into
Sam (42:54.548)
Yeah.
Matt (42:57.564)
the information at BYU -Idaho. And so I would just watch these like attacks occur and be like, what's happening here? So it is true. You have to be very sophisticated in order to prevent all of the attacks that are coming at you.
shawn (43:09.864)
So that's why I say it's like an, that's why I say it's.
Sam (43:10.036)
And it may be impossible. And because it's a, it's a, it's an attack from a foreign soil on an American company that should trigger the U S defense response because you know, the automotive industry is a key indicator of economic health in the U S healthcare is a key core service in the U S. these industries that are being attacked by these, by these folks are.
shawn (43:21.992)
Yeah, I agree.
Sam (43:38.228)
threatening our way of life. I mean, it's fascinating to me. We had never, we'd always considered we could be taken offline by some sort of digital issue or electronic issue, because we are so reliant on technology to, to, to conduct business. But I don't think we ever considered you could be thrown back to paper and pen, and that's all you've got, right? It, it, it is nuts. It is nuts. So.
Matt (43:58.972)
That's crazy.
shawn (44:03.88)
That's crazy.
Matt (44:03.964)
Okay, hey Sam, let's pause right here. Sean's here somewhere, but he can't hear us. So if we pause the recording here, then maybe if we, can you stop it and then restart it?
Sam (44:18.1)
Let's see you and one other. Can he hear us?
shawn (44:21.672)
Yes.
Matt (44:21.724)
Yeah, he can hear us, but we can't hear him.
Sam (44:24.692)
Okay, so I'm going to hit stop and should we just end the room and everybody come back in? So no tomorrow. We'll just put these two recordings together. It must be the hackers that did this to Sean.
Matt (44:31.836)
Yeah, yeah, let's do that. Yeah, so.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories