The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
Episode 73: Is it morally wrong to be rich? Is Matt a liberal, is Sam conservative? Trump's Tariff Proposal, Movie Pass, Movie Crash
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Mailbag: One listener writes, “You'll probably get several of these, but here are a few facts to clear up about two of the country's newest felons.1.The lies Hunter Biden told on his two gun license applications were that he does not use drugs. He was also convicted of possessing a gun while addicted to or using illegal drugs. 2. Where Trump is concerned, in New York, falsifying business records is only a felony if they were falsified in order to commit another crime or to cover up another crime. Trump's lawyer, Michael Cohen, paid Stormy Daniels to be quiet. Then Donald Trump reimbursed Cohen from his own account and called it a retainer for legal counsel. The jury unanimously found that the payments (34 of them) were not for legal counsel, that Trump intentionally falsified the records and that it was to cover up another crime (or commit another crime?)”
Another listener says, “according to this piece from CNBC: Over the past five years, the population of millionaires in the U.S. has grown 35%, nearly twice as fast as China’s. The U.S. is now home to 37% of the world’s millionaires, up from 35% in 2018.” Therefore, it appears that the US still creates more millionaires than China does. Love the podcast, even though you’re clearly being paid by the CCP to spread their Commie propaganda (HA!)
The Thought Provoker:
Sam is up first this week. Is it morally wrong to be rich?
Next up, Shawn. Is Sam conservative? Is Matt liberal?
Finally, Matt. This week, Donald Trump floated the idea of replacing income taxes with an “all tariff policy”. Simple math would suggest that the government may need to impose a 65% tax on all imported goods and services to raise the needed $2.5 trillion the federal government currently collects in income taxes. The last time we raised tariffs by 20% (in 1930) it led to the Great Depression. Is Trump an economic genius, or is this a bad idea?
The Big Question: The film, Movie Pass, Movie Crash documents the rise and fall of the company Movie Pass. In short, two entrepreneurs started a company with 30,000 subscribers who could see unlimited movies for $40/month. When a deal with AMC fell through, investors got nervous and urged these founders to bring on new leadership and new investors. The new team pushed the original founders out of the company, wasted millions of dollars, and ran the company into the ground. We often discuss the best-case scenario of free markets leading to wealth and innovation. We talk less about how corporate greed can destroy great products and ruin lives. Is the Movie Pass scenario an outlier, or is it the most likely scenario in a free market?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:03.341)
Hey everybody. Welcome back to the real Mormonism podcast with Sean, Sam and Matt. It is so good to have you with us this week. We're very excited that you decided to join us and we have all kinds of exciting things to talk about. So it wouldn't be a podcast if we didn't have a listener being upset at Sam, but, but this time we don't have any, we don't have any listeners upset at Sam. We have listeners upset at Sean and one of them's a little upset at me. So,
shawn (00:22.314)
Hahaha.
Sam (00:22.558)
It's tradition.
Matt (00:33.069)
Sam, you can just kind of sit back, maybe have a snack you like to enjoy. You could like chew on that a little bit.
Sam (00:36.858)
It's time for me to eat. All right, go for it. Thank you, listeners. We appreciate you.
shawn (00:42.25)
haha
Matt (00:42.861)
So one listener writes, you'll probably get several of these, but here are a few facts to clear up about two of the country's newest felons. One, the lies Hunter Biden told on his two gun license applications were the ones were that he does not use drugs. He was also convicted of possessing a gun while addicted to or using illegal drugs. Two, where Trump is concerned in New York,
Falsifying business records is only a felony if they were falsified in order to commit another crime or to cover up another crime. Trump's lawyer, Michael Cohen, paid Stormy Daniels to be quiet. Then Donald Trump reimbursed Cohen from his own account and called it a retainer for legal counsel. The jury unanimously found that the payments, 34 of them, were not for legal counsel. That Trump intentionally falsified the records,
and that it was to cover up another crime or commit another crime. So I think that's to you, Sean, because you were wrong about that. And...
shawn (01:50.122)
Well, no, I think we, I think we agreed on the facts. What, what, what I was kind of saying was really that's the felony that you're going to like bury Donald Trump instead empower Donald Trump. I think it was, I mean, sure. It's up to the jury, right? It's up to the jury and those testimonies to, to decide if that was a felony level crime. It just seems, it just seems weak and politically motivated is all I'm saying. I accept those facts, but it's just kind of weak.
Matt (02:00.845)
Mmm.
Matt (02:08.461)
Yeah.
Matt (02:13.037)
okay. Okay. Well, so then this is the listener that's mad at me. This listener says, according to this piece from CNBC, and I put the link in the show notes, over the past five years, the population of millionaires in the United States has grown 35%, which is nearly twice as fast as China. The US is now home to 37 % of the world's millionaires, up from 35 % in 2018.
Therefore, it appears that the United States still creates more millionaires than China does. Love the podcast, even though you're clearly being paid by the Chinese Communist Party to spread their commie propaganda. Ha!
Sam (02:53.406)
By the way to that listener, thank you so much for believing and knowing the American dream is still alive I was shocked Matt a couple weeks ago when you made that comment that people had more opportunity in China It blew me away and other people Who I know who listened to this my kids included they were shocked as well. Like how you could defend that Standpoint is tough. So Matt
shawn (02:59.05)
Hahaha.
Matt (02:59.661)
Hahaha.
shawn (03:07.642)
You
Sam (03:20.318)
Now that you have the facts, will you agree to share this in your college classroom? Go forward.
shawn (03:25.546)
haha
Matt (03:26.157)
Well, like we never talk about this sort of thing in my college classes. This is why I didn't have the facts accurate, right? We should talk about how many millionaires there are in the United States.
Sam (03:30.942)
maybe you should.
No, no, no, the American dream and how it's alive and well, because I know that you've said many times here it's not, but it truly is. And as.
shawn (03:43.754)
Matt, Matt, Matt, you would be such a good man if you just look Sam in the face right now and said, the American dream is live and well. Say it, just say it.
Sam (03:50.526)
Yeah. We at, and Matt and Sean and to our listeners, not only is it alive and well, thank you for saying that we are guardians of the American dream because that promise though it was made long ago and though it exists today is not guaranteed into the future. Like we have to be active at defending it. Right.
Matt (03:51.021)
I do believe that the American dream is live and well.
shawn (03:53.386)
Matt (04:10.541)
I like it better when listeners are mean to Sam than when they agree with Sam because then he kind of lectures me a little bit and it makes me feel dirty inside. I'm like...
Sam (04:13.566)
No, I do not. I do not.
shawn (04:17.834)
jeez.
Sam (04:18.846)
Yeah. So all you need to do is share this with your class so that you're not creating a train wreck of a next generation who doesn't believe in it. So that's okay.
Matt (04:28.109)
Okay. I like that. I'm going to write that down, Sam. I'm going to write that down. And if you could follow up on me, like in a couple of months or something, say, Hey, Matt, have you been doing a better job of spreading the American dream propaganda? And they'll say, yes, I have. Okay, Sam, you're up first with the thought provoker this week.
Sam (04:31.646)
Yeah, well.
Sam (04:41.886)
Yeah, fantastic. Thank you.
All right. So, you know, we traded texts about this earlier in this week, but all this conversation about free markets and, and how it's good to take risk and increase your lot in life in the American dream has, has led me to like, start to think a little bit about what is the church's take on, on free markets and on democracy and on, the opportunity we have to, to like,
Matt, you said at one time, a couple episodes ago, you didn't think it was right for people to have property ownership, that in the next world, proper, right, property ownership would be immoral. That really bothered me. And for two episodes straight, I left the show, our recording, depressed about what you were saying. Now, I don't believe what you're saying, but one idea did pop into my mind. So, Temple Going members of the church are probably used to a couple phrases.
Matt (05:18.541)
Immoral, immoral.
shawn (05:28.49)
Hahaha!
Sam (05:42.366)
You can buy anything with money and, in this world with money, and when asked if they need more money, a response of, we have sufficient for our needs, right? And, and I started to think about that. Like, is that an anti -free market, anti -property, anti -go -out -and -build -an -increase -and -ensure -it -with -the -world statement or sentiment? And is that contrary to what the church actually does? Because you look at it, the church,
Matt (05:45.197)
Anything in this world with money.
Matt (05:51.661)
We have sufficient for our needs. Yeah, yeah.
Sam (06:11.39)
has this enzyme peak famously, right, with hundreds of billions of dollars. The church is one of the largest property owners in the state of Florida and elsewhere across the country, in Nebraska and other places. The church maintains massive temples, a temple square, like it owns more real estate in many states than, it's the largest private property owner in multiple states. How do you reconcile your statement about
Matt (06:20.013)
Nebraska.
Matt (06:33.933)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (06:40.478)
don't own property, with what we hear in the temple, with what the church actually does. And it also seems in the same breath that a lot of the leadership in the church are chosen from ranks of successful business people, lawyers. You know, there's a billionaire apostle. There are more people with wealth and means that have created ownership and use that to kind of help the world in the apostleship than
then there are poppers, right? And this whole idea of poppership and, hey, I have enough money isn't really like taught aggressively. So Sean, usually I start with you, but I'm going to start with Matt on this one. Matt, what, what say you? How do you reconcile that view?
Matt (07:24.781)
I have lots of thoughts on because you had a multi, there were lots of parts of your question. So the first thing I'll say, Sam is you, you've mentioned before on the podcast, how during Nazi Germany, the church supported Hitler because we believe in obeying the laws of the land. Yeah. So, so just because the church participates in the system of capitalism and property ownership doesn't mean that that's the moral thing to do. It just means it's the system of government we live under. And so for the church in order,
Sam (07:29.758)
Yes.
Sam (07:36.99)
Correct. Give unto Caesar, right? Is that what you're saying? Yeah.
Sam (07:46.558)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (07:52.717)
for the church to prosper and do its job or fulfill its mission in this society, that's the way you have to function. It doesn't change the fact that property, now I'm not saying all property ownership is immoral. I'm saying that there are things that humans should not own. Land is something humans should not own. Individuals are something that people should not own. There are things that everybody on the planet has an equal right to. And as soon as you start to delineate property ownership,
Sam (08:08.158)
Such as.
Sam (08:14.046)
Correct.
shawn (08:14.186)
course.
Sam (08:18.27)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (08:20.909)
You create a system that's immoral because it leads people to placing value on things and to feeling like they own things. And so that sort of thing's immoral.
Sam (08:28.318)
So, so you're saying that in order to get along, the church is playing the immoral game to just progress in the world. And, and, and they're actually choosing at the highest ranks of leadership within the church, people that have played that game better than anyone else, almost to the point where it's set up as a standard or as something that, Hey, you know what, if you're, if you live church life, well, you live church doctrine and principles. Well,
Matt (08:35.853)
It's just the game. It's the, it's the rules of the game that we live under now. Right? Like,
Sam (08:58.334)
You're going to do a little bit better than the next guy because you'll be blessed with stuff, right?
Matt (09:00.973)
So then that's the second component of which I would call like the prosperity gospel, right? And I think that in that regard, people should follow the Holy Ghost and the guidance of like what they're supposed to do. So I'll just use an example. Like I try to not place too high a value on money in my life, but I try to earn money, right? But there was this time that like I got a job, I had a salary.
Sam (09:07.07)
Yes.
Matt (09:27.661)
The salary negotiation happened at a time that I wasn't aware that we were actually negotiating salary. And so once I took the job, I was like, I feel very underpaid. I feel like everyone else is getting treated better than I am. And it was a personal struggle for me because I felt like I should do the right capitalist thing and I should go fight for what I deserved. But every time I would pray about it, I would feel like, don't worry about it. It'll all get taken care of. It's no big deal. And so for at least six years.
I like made this choice to not fight for more salary and not. And then one day my boss came to me and said, you know, we decided we've been underpaying you for the last six years and we're going to make it up to you now. And then they gave me a raise and fixed it. That's like.
Sam (10:09.534)
What you're talking about is not a component of the free market. So part of you knowing your value is knowing the value, asking for it, or using your position against other jobs or opportunities to demonstrate your worth. Right. It was at a church institution that came back to you and said you were being underpaid shocker shocker shocker, in which case you were severely underpaid because you used to work for.
shawn (10:13.386)
Hahaha
Matt (10:29.389)
yeah, yes it was. No, but it's.
Sam (10:36.35)
You used to work for a state school in another state. You probably were paid twice there, right? So, but you came home to do the right thing and serve in the church, right?
Matt (10:39.597)
Yeah, yeah.
Matt (10:45.261)
Also, when I went to work at the MTC after my mission, that's not the thing that makes the most money, right? There's a component of like consecration. So I just think like people have to make choices about how they're going to use their time, talents and efforts to build the kingdom of God. And sometimes the Lord directs them to say, the thing you can do best to build the kingdom of God is go start a company that sells health equipment and become a billionaire. And some, no, it's not, it's not immoral to make money.
Sam (10:48.414)
Mm -hmm. No, no. Well.
shawn (11:10.506)
even though it's immoral. okay.
Matt (11:15.245)
I said it's immoral to own certain, to think of certain things as property. That's what I said was.
shawn (11:19.178)
Like money? Money's property.
Sam (11:20.574)
So, so we disagree on the property ownership thing. I think, I think a basic component of this life is being able to have those things and learn how to have a stewardship over those things to create more things that end up blessing other people's lives and make the world a better, greater place. Right. There's this.
Matt (11:23.821)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Matt (11:38.637)
But there are people, Sam, that feel like they should choose a career where they're gonna earn less money because they can be of greater service to society or to the church. So some people feel called to earn less.
Sam (11:49.022)
sucks.
So I want to actually point out that what you're describing is also part of the American dream because, because it's not just, and I think this is the element that I didn't express very well. It's not just the pursuit of economic benefit or gain or money. We don't just risk money. If it was just risking money to be able to get ahead as part of the American dream, it wouldn't really be the American dream. It would be just purely economic. You also can risk your time. You can risk.
the one thing that is the equalizer for all of us is time and life, right? We all have a certain number of minutes in a day. And we don't know how long we have in life, we get to spend that time in a certain way. So what you're describing is someone that says, Hey, if I invest my time in another place, I can actually have a bigger benefit to the economy and to the world than if I did it in in pursuit of money. I think that's also the American dream. Do you agree, Matt?
Matt (12:46.189)
Yeah, I think that's right. What do you say, Sean?
Sam (12:47.87)
Sean?
shawn (12:49.258)
So I think it's an interesting discussion. I don't think the Lord cares whatsoever that Elder Ciaran is a billionaire or that Gordon B. Hinckley was a lifelong employee of the church and didn't have a ton of money. I don't think it matters at all. Matthew 25 talks about the parable of the talents. And I think one of the points of that is to say the Lord gave, put on earth one person and chose to give them five talents.
and another person to another person one were all at different levels unequal and the lord doesn't care at all the amount of money or the amount of talents or the amount of productivity that doesn't matter what matters is what we each do with it that's all the matters and
Matt (13:30.317)
Wait, now I guessed wrong, Sean. Elder Kieran's the billionaire? How did he? I was going to say, he's a PR guy. Stevenson, right? Yeah. Nordic track and all the, the health. I'm sorry.
Sam (13:33.438)
No, he's not. He's not. He's not. It's elder. no, no, no. It's the guy that, Stevenson. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I'm sure keep Kieran is also a very successful businessman. I mean, he made a lot of money in his career. Yeah. Well, get your facts straight.
shawn (13:39.626)
Stevenson, Stevenson.
You missed the point.
Matt (13:47.949)
Yeah?
shawn (13:49.802)
Yeah, but you're missing the point. That's not the point.
Matt (13:53.097)
What's the, what's the, yeah, I just needed to know. Like when you were saying elder cure and I was like, wait a minute PR, you can become a billionaire in PR.
shawn (14:00.682)
Fine, but do you agree or disagree that the Lord doesn't care how wealthy they are? Perhaps it's a pragmatic thing and they can use that wealth to serve freely, but I don't think he, Gordon Hinkley wasn't a crazy wealthy person and he served for, that's right, but he wasn't crazy wealthy, so I don't think it matters. I don't think it matters to the Lord.
Sam (14:01.118)
Okay. Okay.
Matt (14:13.805)
because he worked for the church his whole life.
Right, he's a church employee.
Sam (14:19.006)
So, Sean and Matt, I have a follow up question to that then. So if it's okay to collect money, and even though it's immoral to have property, we still play that game and we still have a stewardship, right? And it can bless others. We can use our time to create an increase. Is it unjust to judge others for their different pursuits? Or should we look at, it's not, okay.
Matt (14:28.973)
You
shawn (14:42.058)
Absolutely, absolutely it is.
Matt (14:42.157)
No.
We should be judging other people.
shawn (14:46.154)
No, we shouldn't be judging them unrighteously. Yeah, see, this is Matt. This is audience. This is Matt's.
Sam (14:46.206)
Why? How should we be judging other people?
Matt (14:50.573)
No, I'm, I'm, I'm not saying this like facetiously, like it's, it, we should not judge others and say they're going to go to hell or they're going to go to heaven or whatever. Like that would be wrong, right? To do some kind of final judgment, but we should judge righteous. Like we should try to learn from other people. So in that sense,
Sam (15:07.902)
So Elder Stevenson, you judge him because he's a billionaire.
shawn (15:10.25)
You
Matt (15:11.853)
So judging, it all depends on how you use the word judge, right? Like I regularly make evaluations about other people and their decisions in life, not to say to myself they're a good person or a bad person, but to say to myself, what would I do if I were in a similar situation? So I...
shawn (15:16.01)
You said it!
Sam (15:19.646)
Right? Right?
shawn (15:26.602)
But you believe that Elder Stevenson has followed the wrong path, made the wrong decisions, immoral decisions, by becoming wealthy and owning property. You do think that.
Matt (15:34.253)
No, I don't think that. No, I don't think that. I don't think that, I'm not saying he did anything wrong, right? Like, first of all, I don't know enough to understand. Like based on what I can gather, he came home from his mission, he served in Japan and he had an opportunity to like build a business based on his knowledge of Japanese and like a gap he saw in the, yeah. So, and by the way, he created lots and lots of jobs. So I don't have any problem with anything.
Sam (15:54.974)
Exercise equipment. Yeah.
Matt (16:01.645)
It matter. I don't even care how much money he makes from that. Like to me, that's irrelevant.
Sam (16:05.406)
Should he feel guilty about having made that amount of money?
Matt (16:08.461)
I don't think so. Why would he feel guilty about that?
shawn (16:08.554)
No, of course not.
Sam (16:10.686)
So I just see in the world right now that there is so much judgment negatively against people who have been successful, almost as if their success is at the cost of everyone else who struggles. And I think it's a mistake that we make. I think it happens in the church. I think it happens socially in the United States as almost as if who are they to have become as successful and as wealthy as they are. And just because they were successful at building a business that delivered on the American dream.
Matt (16:23.245)
Well, it depends.
shawn (16:28.01)
It's...
shawn (16:33.482)
Not, not.
Sam (16:40.638)
I think people that feel bad or want to judge them need to look at their own lives and say, look, I have equal opportunity with my time to go create a similar increase in my own sphere. Right. And if I haven't done that, I probably should judge myself for not having done that. Matt fair or Sean fair.
shawn (16:55.018)
Not to beat a dead horse, but that is a symptom of metamarxism. Marxism teaches that relationships, no it is, relationships should be judged by balance of power and balance in power. So Sam, if you're wealthy and I'm not, then you are less moral than I am because there's a power balance there. It's all about who has the power. So Pete.
Matt (17:00.685)
jeez.
Sam (17:09.03)
But yeah.
Sam (17:14.326)
Right. Matt, what do you say? What do you argue?
Matt (17:17.485)
That's not what I would argue. Okay, so there's an individual and I don't remember his name, but he wrote this article, I'm gonna say about 10 years ago, and he and Mark Cuban were competitors in this space. Mark Cuban made his first billion dollars where he had this like internet channel that would broadcast sports games.
Sam (17:36.062)
Yeah, it, it, it, it streamed, it, it took a game with the audio for the game and it put it into packets so you could stream it on the internet. It was the first technology to do it worth billions.
shawn (17:42.698)
on the internet.
Matt (17:45.517)
And so there was this other guy that was doing the same thing at the same time. And in the end, Mark Cuban won that game and this other guy lost, right? It's not like his company failed and didn't become the, he didn't become the billionaire. And what he wrote about in this article was like, if I'm being completely honest, Mark Cuban wanted it more than I did. And he was willing to pay a price to make that happen that I wasn't willing to pay. And so, yeah. And so Mark Cuban became the billionaire and I didn't become the billionaire.
Sam (18:05.15)
Hmm.
Sam (18:08.958)
He took a risk. Yeah.
Matt (18:14.253)
So I think it's completely appropriate for people to look at situations like that and say, in this situation, this person became a billionaire through immoral, improper means that should not be rewarded. And this person did it the right way and they should be rewarded. And so I don't think Sean's right that it's about metamarcism and just jealousy. I think it's about who the person is and how they became wealthy. And there's some of them we would respect and there's some of them we would not respect.
Sam (18:43.806)
So one of the challenges with doing that though, is you may not totally understand how it came to be if you're not in that world, right? So Mark Cuban could make a judgment about how that happened or the person that competed against him, but Mark Cuban is ill advi - like he couldn't make a judgment about Matt, how well you use your time and how you're giving back to the world. I just think that's, that there is just this anti wealthy, anti successful.
shawn (18:50.346)
Yeah, how could you? How could you possibly?
Matt (19:02.957)
Sure, sure.
shawn (19:11.594)
There is, and it's wrong.
Sam (19:11.646)
sentiment in the world. And I think it is, it's anti -religious. Now, I also think there's a sentiment in the church that, hey, if you live a righteous life, you're going to be blessed with wealth. And that's evidence of your, of your righteousness. That's the prosperity gospel you're talking about. That is rampant. That is rampant. That is absolutely rampant. But, but, but, but I think it's equally as harmful. And I think people need to,
shawn (19:27.498)
No, that's not true.
Matt (19:31.469)
For sure, for sure people think that.
shawn (19:32.842)
But it's a lie and it's not founded in scripture.
Sam (19:41.918)
Well, probably chill out a little bit, but they also need to be open. Everybody gets to risk in different ways with their life.
Matt (19:44.717)
So you, I'm.
Matt (19:49.005)
So you guys are saying don't judge. And what I'm saying is judge righteous judgment. That's what I'm saying.
Sam (19:53.086)
But you can't, you don't have the platform or the background to righteously judge because you.
Matt (19:58.125)
Well, so then you recognize the limitations of that, right? You say, I can't judge, I don't know, finally, like, is this person a moral or an immoral person? But I can say, in this particular situation, maybe they shouldn't have done what they did.
Sam (20:08.77)
Larry Larry, wait, hang on. Larry Miller, Larry Miller.
shawn (20:10.25)
Well, your question later today is about that, right?
Matt (20:16.077)
did some very good things, right? Larry Miller used his wealth to fund the Joseph Smith Papers project. But I can also imagine that there are people who were competitors with Larry Miller in the auto industry that probably think he did some immoral things. But I don't know enough about it, right? So Bill Gates definitely did some things that, you know, there's the Apple -Microsoft fight that's been going on for a long time because of things that Bill Gates did, right?
Sam (20:23.23)
Mmm.
Sam (20:33.726)
Yeah, Bill Gates.
Matt (20:44.493)
They generated the code together and then Bill Gates copyrighted it and patented the code and made a lot of money off of it. But at the same time, Bill Gates does really good things in the world. So like in all of them, I think you don't have to, you don't pass final judgment, but you say, this is something I think is admirable. And this is something I don't think is admirable. You Sam, you do the same thing. You do it a hundred percent. Yeah.
Sam (21:03.39)
Cool. Well, this is a fun conversation. We all do it. We all do it. I'm just irritated by people that judge without knowing. Yeah, without knowing. All right, Matt, I give you the points for saying you believe in the American dream that it's alive and well and for agreeing to teach it in school. And Sean, I also give you the points for holding Matt to the, to the statement. That was beautiful. So,
Matt (21:11.053)
You. Judge you. Shut.
Matt (21:24.717)
Hahaha!
shawn (21:27.37)
Well, I'll give you the points, Sam. I was going to give them to Matt, but Matt continues with the unscriptural lie that personal property is immoral. So, Sam, you get the points.
Sam (21:35.262)
Yeah, by the way, that's, that's just bizarre. Yeah. There's, there's a big aster, yeah, but there's a big asterisk in, in, in the,
Matt (21:37.869)
Doctrine and Covenants, Section 42.
shawn (21:39.562)
It says that it's coveting his immoral, not owning property.
Matt (21:42.701)
No, it says give. By the way, there's a temple covenant to give everything you have to the Lord.
shawn (21:49.514)
That's a law of consecration. That's completely different.
Matt (21:52.973)
Yeah, what is that? In the law of consecration, what property do you retain? You retain nothing.
shawn (21:57.258)
Let's go over, okay, let's go, that'll be our topic next week. Let's do it. We don't live the law of consecration.
Sam (22:00.83)
Well, so, and by the way, which billionaire apostles, which billionaire apostles have given it all back?
Matt (22:08.429)
I'm just saying it with Sean's question is moral immoral in heaven. We won't own anything. So it's immoral to own things. I understand. We live in a telestial world. I understand.
shawn (22:13.918)
You're wrong. You're wrong. You're absolutely wrong.
Sam (22:18.462)
Will you own a healthy sense of pride though? That's my only question. In heaven, can you still have a little swagger? Because Matt, if you don't have a little swagger, I don't want to see you there. So.
Matt (22:23.181)
hahahahah
Matt (22:32.077)
I want to trademark some, if we all wear white robes all the time, I want to trademark some little stitch in the white robes that can like distinguish who are the better people in the white robes. All right, Sean, you're up.
shawn (22:37.386)
boy. boy.
Sam (22:39.934)
You want to put a stitch in a what? Yeah, exactly. Next question.
shawn (22:45.738)
All right, Sam, you didn't, this'll be a test if you actually read any of our pre -sent quotes. Okay, you don't, so good. So here we go. So I had a topic, but I had a great discussion with a good friend of mine who listens, is a loyal listener of our podcast. No, he's not, he's LDS. And I'm gonna give a shout out, shout out to Dave. And he gave a very poetic and beautiful description of the three of us. And I'm gonna read it to you now, and then I'm gonna have a, ask a question. He said this.
Sam (22:49.438)
I don't. No, go ahead.
Sam (22:59.806)
Evangelical. Okay. Okay.
Sam (23:06.558)
sup Dave
Sam (23:13.214)
Mmm.
shawn (23:14.41)
He says, no, it seems like as he's listened to us over time, he's seen kind of, I don't know if he means a progression. He'll have to give me clarity on that, but he here's the takeaway I got. He said, Matt and Sam are like balloons, one blowing to the left, one blowing and rising to the right. And he said, it's been interesting to watch these balloons go more to the left and more to the right, or at least establish themselves there.
And then he said, now you take, you bring now Sean in who is a moderate and brings in religion and that anchors those balloons down. Isn't that poetic and beautiful? That's great.
Matt (23:55.565)
No, you like it because it's your friend that said that. Yeah, that's right. Sean, there is nothing that you have ever said on this podcast that is moderate. You are definitely not moderate in any way. Of course you think you're moderate.
Sam (23:57.566)
It's self -serving. Yeah, it's self -serving.
shawn (23:59.05)
Whoa, I'm just saying what he said. I'm just a quote. It's just a quote.
shawn (24:09.258)
I think I'm way more. Okay, this is the essence of the question. So this is the essence of it. Hang on. So here's, here's the essence of the question.
Sam (24:13.822)
By the way, I have a question. Does he believe, because I think socially on a lot of, on some social relationship issues that I actually have begun to drift a little left. Does he see this? All right.
shawn (24:24.906)
So watch Sam, so watch this is, hang on, so this is the interesting question. So here it is. Is it true that Matt is politically very liberal and that Sam is politically very conservative and that Sean is moderate? Do you consider yourselves as such? Let's start with Sam, let's start with you. Do you consider yourself politically conservative or just conservative?
Sam (24:43.326)
I'm politically conservative, Sean, and you are not moderate. That is, that is a -
Matt (24:46.445)
That's right. That's right. That's all you need to know.
shawn (24:48.138)
No, I'm not. so you do consider yourself conservative, Sam.
Sam (24:51.838)
But on social issues, I am very progressive. And I think there are a lot of social issues where I say leave it up to the individual rather than a government, which should be conservative, but isn't today.
shawn (25:02.442)
Which, if we're being honest here, Sam, I feel like you not hide from those topics, but you don't publish them as much, don't you?
Matt (25:02.765)
Right.
Sam (25:09.79)
I don't hide from them. I don't hide from them.
Matt (25:11.469)
He doesn't hide from what he... Right. Right.
shawn (25:14.73)
I don't know that many people would know what your social stances are in a lot of that stuff, but.
Sam (25:19.966)
We've talked about it. We've...
Matt (25:20.173)
Well, we've talked about all of these issues. They could listen to our podcast, pick any social issue. And Sam is way further to the left than I am. You remember when I said that like that we should like enforce laws that are consistent with our moral beliefs, like make alcohol illegal, make coffee. Sam turns out isn't on the same side as me on that particular issue. Sam, Sam thinks people should have the right to drink alcohol.
shawn (25:22.922)
Okay, which issues are you talking about?
Sam (25:29.79)
abortion, women's rights, LGBTQIA.
shawn (25:46.09)
Yeah, but, but those, but that stance doesn't define liberal and conservative.
Matt (25:49.901)
Okay, well now, now's the essence of your question Sean, because now I have to put on my political scientist hat and say, when you're talking about, when you talk about liberal or conservative, you can talk about the way that people define it, which is in the popular conception, liberals are thought of as Democrats and conservatives are thought of as Republicans. So if you say something that the Republicans don't agree with, then most Americans would say that's not conservative.
Sam (25:53.182)
I'm a balloon.
shawn (25:55.658)
that's why we're here! We got a political scientist!
Matt (26:17.069)
Well, it turns out that Donald Trump is not a conservative person. So when Donald Trump becomes the Republican, the head of the Republican party, then popular ideas about what liberal and conservative are change. But if, but if you go back to philosophy, I'll just read from encyclopedia Britannica. Conservatives favor institutions and practices that have evolved gradually and are manifestations of continuity and stability.
Sam (26:24.734)
boy. Here we go.
shawn (26:29.546)
Yeah, right.
shawn (26:34.634)
wow!
Matt (26:45.325)
Government's responsibility is to be the servant, not the master of existing ways of life, and politicians must therefore resist the temptation to transform society and politics. And a suspicion of government activism.
Sam (26:57.758)
And the religious right has dragged the conservative party to be on social issues, not as conservative as you would imagine based on Matt's definition.
Matt (27:10.669)
And by the way, if you take the traditional definition of conservative, I know Republicans won't want to hear this, but Joe Biden is more conservative than Donald Trump because Joe, Joe, no, I'm well, okay. We can, we can set that aside, but yeah. No, but I'm serious. Like Joe Biden favors the way that the country has been for the last 50, 60 years. He's not talking about radical societal transformational change.
Sam (27:19.838)
Stop now it's becoming self serving. Matt Sean pop the balloon pop the balloon that is Matt.
shawn (27:20.65)
That is not true.
shawn (27:26.314)
Pop the balloons.
Matt (27:40.653)
Now you might say the Democrats are in favor of that, but you can't tell me anything Joe Biden has done that's like big and transformative and a big shift from the way society has been.
shawn (27:48.714)
That's just not true. Some fundamental topics like, for example, the definition of family. He is the example of deviating from that.
Sam (27:50.43)
Like, like the.
Matt (27:54.381)
What did Joe Biden do? Joe Biden who has a traditional family and hey, Joe Biden hasn't done anything policy wise to change that. What? he and Obama, I'm talking about the Biden presidency.
shawn (27:59.946)
Yeah!
Yes he has, he and Obama did everything policy wise to change that.
Sam (28:09.79)
Well wait, first of all, bye, bye, bye.
shawn (28:09.866)
Everything, all of his rhetoric and all of his teachings, all of his preachings, Biden himself is exactly the opposite of what you're talking about.
Matt (28:15.565)
Just the policies. He has... Well, so even if we set that aside, all I'm saying, Sean, is I am a conservative.
Sam (28:16.862)
Biden's not cognizant enough to make those determinations. He's, he's not there.
shawn (28:20.01)
boy.
I gotta say that one is, because hey, you're so, but watch this, watch. Sam, would you say Matt is liberal or conservative?
Sam (28:30.462)
I think Matt is conservative and he loves to play the liberal card because he's comes from academia. So he understands it really well. And I know, and you know, he spent a lot of time at a very liberal university. So he knows all the talk tracks. And I think at times it's very easy for him to pop in and just create a little, and I, I do truly believe that, you know, he supports Biden because of the hypocrisy of Trump. And on that we truly disagree, but, you know,
You put him anywhere in any large city and Matt looks conservative as compared to, yeah.
shawn (28:59.498)
Interesting.
Matt (29:05.933)
way conservative.
shawn (29:06.506)
So Matt, do you consider yourself liberal or conservative?
Matt (29:08.877)
No, I'm so conservative, Sean. I believe that religion has a strong role in society and that the government should support that role in society. And the only difference why people think I'm liberal is because my interpretation of scripture and my interpretation of religion doesn't always jive with the way that America practices capitalism. And so I look at the Book of Mormon and I look at the Doctrine and Covenants and I say,
There's a lot of stuff Joseph Smith says and teaches that's very similar to Karl Marx. And so.
Sam (29:41.022)
Which by the way, a lot of what he taught is very liberal, right? A lot of it. Zionism and yes.
Matt (29:44.525)
Yeah, yeah, right. So conservative to me is like these tried and true principles that have existed throughout the ages. We should not discard the gospel of Jesus Christ, the word of wisdom, families, all of this stuff, the things that hold society together.
shawn (29:54.09)
Like what? Like what? Like what?
Sam (30:02.014)
Matt wants to use government power to enforce those things, which in a world where everyone, no, that's not conservative though. I don't think.
Matt (30:06.349)
Yes, it's very conservative.
government's responsibility is to be the servant of existing ways of life. So the go...
Sam (30:14.782)
Right. Yeah, but not religious ways of life. People need to be able to have freedom. I think the true conservative approach should be to protect people's rights and minimize government's roles in, in enforcing that. So that.
Matt (30:30.285)
And I don't trust people. So that's the difference, Sean. It's not a lit. Yeah.
Sam (30:32.798)
Yeah, well that is, well that's a big difference between liberal and conservative as well, right? Is liberals don't trust people. They want to tell you what you have to do. Conservatives say, hey, government, we shouldn't trust government. Liberals don't trust people. Conservatives don't trust government.
Matt (30:49.389)
Yeah, okay. That's if you define it like that, then I would be liberal. Yeah. But if you define it in the traditional philosophical way, I'm very conservative, right? Like that's where Sam and I would be different, right? Because I want a strong role for religion in society. I want all the laws of society to be based on my moral values. And Sam wants individuals to be able to do that.
Sam (30:52.35)
You're liberal. Yeah.
shawn (30:53.226)
hahahahah
Sam (31:08.414)
You can't do that! It's not a theocracy, though. We don't live in a religious theocracy. We're not Iran!
shawn (31:11.914)
Yeah.
Matt (31:13.969)
And yet, if you look at what Joseph Smith was advocating for, that's what he wanted. Right, so that's what I'm saying. So Sean is...
Sam (31:18.398)
Yeah, but I...
shawn (31:21.77)
Matt, how do you balance that out with Alma 30? He says, there was no law against a man's belief, but it's strictly contrary to the commands of God that there should be a law which should bring man into an equal grounds. When it comes to agency, yeah, when it comes, for the sake of scripture, choose you this day, choose you this day whom you shall serve.
Sam (31:22.334)
Anyway.
Matt (31:33.069)
And then keep reading and then keep reading. If they lied, they were severe. If they lied, they were severely punished. If they stole, they were severely punished. So sure, there's no law against your belief, but if you don't act in accordance with our prescribed religious behavior, there's a strict punishment in that society. So that's fine. You can believe whatever you want to believe. You just better not drink coffee. You better not drink alcohol. You better not go too fast, drive too fast in a school zone.
because we have morals that we're going to uphold in society.
shawn (32:05.162)
Okay, so what I'm taking away from this is what I, what I.
Sam (32:05.79)
Wait, are you going to wear a burka going forward? Or are you going to like, is it sharp? What's the law? Sharia law. Are you going to put that in place? All right. Fair.
Matt (32:08.685)
Hahaha!
Sharia law I mean
shawn (32:12.138)
Sherela.
So what I'm taking away from this is just because we as listeners, just because we as a listeners can frame what political parties think today doesn't necessarily mean that that's what it's always been or that's the actual definition. So to say that Matt is liberal, it would be very easy, Matt, to pick five or six topics that are democratic topics. And that's why people would conclude, he's pretty liberal. And then same with Sam, capitalist topics.
Sam (32:16.542)
That's terrifying, by the way. I'm terrified.
Matt (32:18.605)
But it is conservative. That's conservative.
Sam (32:21.63)
No.
shawn (32:45.002)
pretty clear he's conservative as today's definitions allow. But you're suggesting, well, maybe we shouldn't label each other that way. Maybe we should look at the philosophies that make up those two sides of the spectrum and define it on that more. Is that what you're saying?
Matt (33:00.941)
I just think those labels are not at all useful, right? So like people label other people something because it makes them feel comfortable with the way that your friend called you a moderate because your friend thinks of themselves as a moderate and it makes you guys both feel good to say I'm moderate, but you're not moderate. And the reason people say that so -and -so is a conservative or so -and -so is a right -wing not or whatever, it's all because you're trying to make yourself feel better and not engage.
shawn (33:17.15)
my gosh, wow.
shawn (33:24.842)
So this is, Matt, so this is the kind of high -minded liberal attitude that maybe makes people question.
Matt (33:31.821)
What makes that a liberal attitude? That's not liberal. Like, people...
shawn (33:34.922)
your mistrust of people. You just said your mistrust of people and you're questioning people's motives and not trusting them. You agreed and you said, according to that, I'm a liberal. That's what you said.
Matt (33:40.813)
Well, wait, Sam's the one, Sam's the one that defined that as a liberal idea.
Sam (33:45.566)
That is true.
Matt (33:47.757)
I said, if we define it Sam's way, I'm a liberal. I didn't say I agree with his definition of that. listen, I'm just saying like basic psychology. You can see, right. It's, it's the same reason that I will never like Tom Brady because I'm a Miami dolphins fan. So I can label whatever I want to label. Cause it makes me feel better that my team loses all the time and his team wins all the time. And it means that they're like, I don't have to say all the nasty things that I feel about new England Patriots and their quarterback or their coach.
shawn (33:50.09)
Yeah, yeah. That's exactly what you said.
Sam (33:51.806)
Yeah, you do.
shawn (34:13.898)
Well, well Matt, but me and my friend couldn't, I don't think we could, like, I think he's a conservative guy. I don't consider myself any of these things. I don't think I'm that moderate. But I think when I'm comparing myself to a lot of things you say, Matt, we disagree on so many things. I would say, I would.
Matt (34:24.397)
You are definitely conservative.
Matt (34:30.573)
Right. So why do you call conservative? Why does it feel good to say conservative and not liberal? Because of where you're raised and where everybody around you like, it would be hard for you to go around and tell people, I'm a liberal Democrat. That wouldn't feel comfortable to you.
shawn (34:37.802)
It doesn't feel good.
shawn (34:45.162)
I've, well, Democrat maybe, but the word liberal I've used to describe myself, my life, other people all the time, because I agree with you, a traditional definition is more helpful than the current definitions.
Sam (34:47.07)
boy.
Matt (34:52.461)
But not -
Matt (34:57.229)
Yeah, so I think, I just think that these labels, people use them as a way to sort of like describe who, like what team they're on, what side they're on, who their friends are, where they grew up. So in some places people would be embarrassed to say, I'm conservative.
shawn (35:09.45)
Okay, so you're saying in the political scientist world you don't use these labels?
Matt (35:16.205)
We use them as tools to help describe things, but we don't attach any real meaning to them.
shawn (35:21.002)
What the crap dude? That's what he's doing!
Matt (35:25.357)
I don't think that it actually just like, yeah. So sure we talk about, but I don't like in our, there's a few people that write books about political ideology and right and left, but the correlation between where a person calls themselves on the right and left and where they place the political party that they belong to, it's like a correlation of 0 .98. It's almost like a hundred percent. So for most people, whatever they're using of right and left,
is just describing the party that they feel closest to. So I use the term party instead of right and left.
shawn (35:58.09)
Well, I'll go back.
Sam (36:01.47)
You know, it, it, it, it reminds me of the scripture and I'm going to try to quote it. Sean, you need to.
shawn (36:04.874)
Sam. All right, let's hear it.
Matt (36:05.389)
Yes!
Sam (36:09.95)
When they're talking about the time and how people would call good evil and evil good. And, and, and, it, it, there was an attempt to mislabel things, Matt, you're trying to mislabel things. Like our political system depends on conservative and, liberal on Republican and Democrat. We're a two party system. So beyond your sociological definition and your education background, like it is our political environment that there's two parties, those two parties.
shawn (36:15.37)
Very nice.
Matt (36:23.117)
hahahahah
Sam (36:39.87)
contest their ideas, and then someone comes out winner. I do think it's fascinating that at the end of the day, those that are elected as president end up being more moderate or in the middle. When you look back historically, like today, I would argue that a Clinton looks more moderate than some of the extreme views we see today, right? Or a George Bush looks more moderate, like,
you know, particularly when you think about, you know, conservative values of, you know, not spending a lot and, you know, it, things tend to become, things tend to become more extreme. And so your point, Matt, about using labels to create that animosity and kind of that divide, we're definitely seeing that. But I think it's time to move on. Is it time to move on? Please, please. I'm not giving Matt points for.
shawn (37:29.29)
Well, points to...
Matt (37:29.293)
I was just waiting for you to end with giving me points. Giving me points. I was just...
Sam (37:34.046)
admitting for trying to say he's a conservative Republican. Cause at the other day he's still, he still backs Biden. That makes him a liberal, liberal commie. I can't say the third word on this show. I got the points. Good. Thank you. Then yes, that's right. Yeah. Yeah.
shawn (37:40.906)
I'll give the points to Sam.
shawn (37:47.818)
boy.
Matt (37:49.169)
Better, better read than spiritually dead. That's the way. Okay. So my topic is this. So this week, speaking of liberal and conservative, Donald Trump floated an idea. He said we should replace income taxes with an all tariff policy, which is by the way, there could be nothing more true to the founding of the United States than an all tariff policy, because that's how they did it back in. Sure.
Sam (37:58.526)
Okay.
Mm -hmm. here we go.
Sam (38:08.862)
Mm -hmm.
shawn (38:15.946)
Is that right?
Sam (38:17.47)
Yeah, they threw the T end of the bay over that, didn't they? So, yeah.
Matt (38:17.933)
Yeah, that's what it was. However, fast forward to current times, simple math would suggest that the government would need to impose a 65 % tax on all imported goods and services to raise the needed $2 .5 trillion the federal government currently collects in income taxes. The last time we raised tariffs by 20 % in 1930, it led to the Great Depression. So Sam, mostly,
shawn (38:20.906)
shawn (38:29.898)
Hehehehehe
Matt (38:45.965)
Is Trump an economic genius or is this a bad idea?
Sam (38:48.158)
So first, so first of all, Sean, I take back my opinion from the last segment. Matt is definitely a raging liberal to even bring this up. It's crazy. Second, Donald Trump is an economic genius, but not for the reasons you might think. Donald Trump is an economic genius because he's running around saying ludicrous things to get people's attention so that we end up talking about these crazy ideas in places like this. There's somebody smoking something somewhere or drinking something somewhere that's like, Hey,
shawn (38:54.762)
hahahaha
shawn (39:01.322)
Hahaha
Matt (39:01.741)
Okay.
Matt (39:07.277)
Mm -hmm.
shawn (39:13.002)
Wow.
Sam (39:16.67)
I just paid a huge income tax bill to the IRS. I think the IRS is a waste of time and money. Let's, let's put a tariff on everything that comes into the U S let's let the Chinese fund our government. Right. It's, it's, it's social media fodder. It's a game. And the, the, the, the, the genius is there's a guy smoking something and drinking something at the same time. And he's angry at the IRS and he just.
shawn (39:27.722)
So it's rhetoric. You believe it's rhetoric for marketing.
Matt (39:28.141)
Mm -hmm. Mm -hmm.
Matt (39:32.269)
Where's the genius in this? I need to see the genius in this.
shawn (39:35.754)
Not the economic genius, he's saying it's marketing genius.
Sam (39:45.086)
became friends personally with Donald Trump, because although it will never happen, it's too big a change to the structure of the government and our economic system. It can never happen. Although it will never happen, Donald Trump made a friend of someone that really doesn't understand economic policy. And the friend is sitting there thinking, Hey, the Chinese can fund our government. I don't have to pay it anymore. Now it's ludicrous because we end up paying every tariff over and over and over and over. Right. It's just,
shawn (39:59.338)
shawn (40:06.826)
So Sam Hy...
Matt (40:11.533)
Yes. Yes.
Sam (40:13.918)
left hand to the right hand, but a lot of people that aren't savvy in the business background, don't see that necessarily. So...
shawn (40:20.874)
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Matt (40:21.901)
Yeah, I'm the one. I'm the one that doesn't see the harm in tariffs. Listen, the reason that it matters, Sam, is because Donald Trump did this. Donald Trump raised tariffs on China 20 % right before the pandemic. And people say, the economy crashed because of the pandemic. And then there was all of this like economic challenge that happened during the pandemic. And people say that was all the pandemic. And they forget that it was Donald Trump's tariffs that created the supply chain.
shawn (40:27.05)
So sit.
Sam (40:31.582)
Yeah.
Yes. Yeah.
Matt (40:50.445)
supply chain shortages in the first place. really, really? The tariff on steel, the tariff on aluminum, the tariff on pork. You're saying those things did not contribute to the supply chain problems that happened after the pandemic.
Sam (40:51.838)
It did not. It did not. It did not.
Sam (41:03.198)
So I need to go do my research and read but I don't believe so I think what created supply chain problems were the fact that the world shut down and people weren't showing up to work to produce those items like it.
shawn (41:07.562)
Hehehehe
shawn (41:13.642)
That's, yeah.
Matt (41:13.741)
Lucky, lucky timing for Trump. Both of them, both of them matter. You can't tell me that suddenly slapping a 20 % tariff. Look, Google it, right? It was December of 2019 that he slapped these tariffs on China and the price of goods started even before the pandemic started increasing because of those tariffs. So, so you say it's just rhetoric. I'm saying he does it.
Sam (41:19.582)
I don't believe that. I'm Googling it.
Sam (41:31.998)
now.
shawn (41:32.938)
So Matt, you're saying you're totally against tariffs, completely and totally.
Matt (41:39.053)
No, I'm not against tariffs. I'm against the idea of funding our entire federal government on tariffs and I'm against the idea.
shawn (41:43.05)
Yeah, but it sounds like you're against Trump raising tariffs on China for a little bit.
Matt (41:47.949)
I, what I'm saying is what Sam says is just rhetoric oftentimes finds its way into policy because I don't believe that Trump is an economic genius and I don't believe.
shawn (41:57.002)
So what's the right amount of tariff? Right percentage.
Sam (41:58.91)
He, he, he is, Trump is, Trump is nationalist. And in that nationalist vein, he loves anything that makes him look like he's trying to save America from everybody else over there. So it is, it, it, it does hurt America, but he loves that strain of, Hey, I'm going to protect the United States from China. Now, not at others have said it right. Mitt Romney said that about Russia. Hey, Russia is more dangerous than people know. And he ended up being right. Time will tell about China.
Matt (42:09.549)
Unfortunately, it hurts America.
Matt (42:22.701)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (42:27.838)
It's not a bad idea for us to isolate China a little bit to try to stop their rise. I mean, they're building floating nuclear islands in the South China Sea right now to try to take over control of that area and then ultimately take Taiwan. So we're not China's friend. We're economically reliant.
Matt (42:46.317)
But if we believe in free trade, the free trade is peaceful and helps prevent conflict, then the more wars we fight in the economic sphere with China, the more we escalate other kinds of tensions with China. So first Trump raises tariffs on China, then we ban TikTok, and now the Republicans want to ban drones of a certain type from China.
Sam (43:01.822)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (43:08.99)
So can I just go back to the fact that really bothered me? So the Washington Post, do you consider that to be a credible source of information? So the Washington Post says, contrary to expectation, the US inflation rate fell after the tariffs were imposed and remained lower for almost three years until the pandemic itself upended global supply chains.
Matt (43:18.573)
Yes, yes.
Matt (43:33.069)
Wait, that doesn't make sense. The pandemic, the tariffs happened simultaneously with the pandemic.
Sam (43:38.526)
Well, but the inflation that happened didn't happen at the beginning of COVID. It was a delayed reaction. So initially,
Matt (43:46.221)
Because of the pandemic, all the prices dropped because everybody stopped working. Yeah. Well.
Sam (43:50.621)
Right. It was not the tariff that I have. What you just quoted is not backed by any fact whatsoever. It's, it's a, it's a lovely way to make your point, but that's ridiculous.
shawn (43:57.258)
Hahaha
shawn (44:01.322)
I want to see if you two can tie this back to real Mormonism somehow. What's the real Mormonism take on all this?
Matt (44:08.493)
Wait, wait, first, first I gotta, first I have to appeal to listeners. Sam found a biased source.
Sam (44:09.342)
That's not our pie.
Sam (44:15.582)
It's a Washington Post. Actually, it's not completely biased because what it does is this article is talking about how similar Biden and Trump are. It says, Biden and Trump share a faith in import tariffs despite inflation risks. And then it talks about where we have seen inflation in the relationship with China, but Trump's increasing of the tariffs when he did it did not contribute to that.
shawn (44:16.714)
hahahahah
Matt (44:19.981)
Hahaha!
shawn (44:38.058)
Sam found an article that countermatched rhetoric and he's trying to dig deeper and say that it's a biased article.
Sam (44:41.374)
It's like, you know what, it's, it's.
No, it's, it's not, it is not connected. So, and what tariffs. Yeah.
Matt (44:49.069)
Okay, well...
shawn (44:49.898)
No, interesting. But still, Matt, still, still tied into real Mormonism somehow, because I'm not going to let you any longer get away with bringing up political topics and naming the podcast Real Mormonism without tying it in. Because I've got to tie in. I've got to tie in. Please do.
Sam (44:57.502)
I don't think we should try to tie it into it.
Matt (45:01.005)
Okay, all right, I'll give you the tie in. The tariff that caused the Great Depression was called the Smoot -Hawley Tariff, and the Smoot of that was a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter -day Saints. So oftentimes, well -intentioned members of our church make really bad policy that hurts our country.
Sam (45:07.71)
boy.
shawn (45:18.602)
Well done, I guess. Let me give you my little take on it. Yeah.
Sam (45:22.558)
Do not bring up Benson though. Do not bring up a prophet Matt you will this show will be
Matt (45:24.653)
hahahahah
shawn (45:29.098)
Sam took this on an interesting topic that I think was actually more interesting than Matt's topic, but I thought this was gonna be a discussion about tariffs versus taxes, so I came to the front of this. I would argue that it would be a small income tax, as we have it, is probably best because it's an investment into our society over these weird tariff ideas. When we pay tithing, we buy in. It's a faithful move, but we do as members of the church who pay tithing.
we buy in and it is a sacrifice we make or it's a commitment we make, I think income tax is a little bit like that. A little bit, a little bit, a little bit, a tried, a tried.
Sam (46:01.79)
Wait, are you comparing tithing to government taxes? Interesting.
Matt (46:05.549)
Sam, give him the points, give him the points, Sam. It's real Mormonism, like he gets points because he brought a scripture. And don't you feel more moderate now, Sam, now that Sean's brought in the scripture?
Sam (46:14.078)
You get points, Sean, you get points.
shawn (46:18.954)
Matt. my God.
Matt (46:22.605)
No, but it is, I appreciate that you tried to find the scripture about tariffs versus income taxes.
shawn (46:27.914)
I didn't actually, I just gave an opinion. It was a good one though. And I don't think I'm moderate, Matt. I don't think I'm moderate, so.
Sam (46:28.254)
I'm mad I couldn't cite the scripture quote I had earlier. We need a listener to cite that one.
Matt (46:35.277)
No, no, that was just me being funny. Sean, I'm sorry. Somehow, whenever I give you the points, it like hurts a little bit at the same time. And I don't mean to cause that sting as I give you the points.
Sam (46:36.67)
I'm moderate. Yeah.
shawn (46:45.258)
I wonder if one day you'll learn how to give an actual compliment without it being facetious.
Matt (46:52.173)
Well, Sean, you won my topic and so that's that's got to feel good, right?
shawn (46:56.298)
I don't know what I won it for, I don't think I did, but okay, alright. This is a fun one, this is a fun one. Sam didn't watch the movie, I promise Sam didn't watch the movie.
Matt (46:58.509)
okay. All right. Well, so the big question this week is this. Now,
That's okay. Like I've actually learned with the documentaries that get really popular after I watch a documentary, if I try and fact check the information in the documentary, oftentimes the documentary has some kind of a spin, some kind of a, they're not actually trying to, it's not like frontline or PBS or something. Just trying to give you all of the facts.
shawn (47:23.306)
Cut. Kind of like what just happened five minutes ago when Sam Fack checked your statement.
Matt (47:28.813)
Right. It's like that. So this movie is called the Movie Pass Movie Crash. It's a documentary that's on HBO Max right now, but it documents the rise and fall of the company Movie Pass. And to summarize for our listeners, because maybe you don't want to spend an hour watching this show, there are two entrepreneurs that started a company with 30 ,000 subscribers who could see unlimited movies in the movie theater for $40 a month. And then they had a deal set up with the movie
Sam (47:30.302)
Correct.
Matt (47:58.253)
chain AMC to make it grow much bigger. And the CEO of AMC was excited about it, but the CEO left and took another job and the new CEO was not as in favor of this plan. And so then when that happened, the investors of the company got nervous and the new team, they, they, they urge those original founders to bring on a new leadership team and new investors and the new team pushed out the original founders of the company.
and within a year wasted millions and millions of dollars and ran the company into the ground.
shawn (48:31.434)
Well, and what they did, these new people, was a bit dishonest. They were really, it was kind of defrauding. The things that they were doing were very, they weren't creating value for what they're offering. They were literally just cheating to earn more money.
Sam (48:33.054)
Wait, what? What? What?
Sam (48:41.63)
What? What year was this?
Matt (48:45.421)
2018.
shawn (48:46.954)
Yeah, 2018.
Sam (48:47.486)
Okay, I have a question.
What point does this make about anything? Somebody decided to give, like, who watches movies? Okay, go ahead. All right, go ahead.
shawn (48:53.226)
This is a good topic, Sam. This is a great topic. Why is that your question?
Matt (48:53.677)
Whoa.
Matt (48:58.797)
Wait, let me ask the question. Well, no. So Sam, the reason the AMC was excited is because they were afraid everybody was going to move to streaming services and they're like, okay, this could be Netflix for movie theaters and it could save movie theaters. Okay. So the question.
shawn (48:59.754)
Yeah, get to the question! Sam, sit down, wait a minute, wait a minute.
Sam (49:11.454)
Right.
shawn (49:14.506)
I'm taking the, ask your question then Sam. Sam, I'm taking it.
Sam (49:15.678)
Cue the national anthem. Did it say blockbuster? Was it blockbuster? Are we talking about blockbuster? Are we talking about AMC?
Matt (49:21.069)
Well, and one of the, one of the people that ran this company into the ground claims that he was one of the original founders of Netflix. So there was some, some optimism that this person could maybe do this. My question is we often discuss best case scenarios of free markets leading to wealth and innovation. And we talk less often about how corporate greed can destroy great products and ruin lives. So the question is, is the, is this movie past scenario an outlier?
shawn (49:43.85)
Good, I can't wait. Here we go. Nope.
Matt (49:49.229)
Or is it the most likely scenario in a free market?
shawn (49:51.946)
Let me answer this and then Sammy, you can pounce. Matt, this story is a perfect example of why capitalism is so great and works so well. In fact, it is exactly what Adam Smith wrote in The Wealth of Nations would happen when people try to, instead of create value and exchange value to people, but instead go after greed and money, the relationship would fall apart and it would destroy the company. This is exact response because those new people who came in, they decided,
Sam (50:03.998)
no.
shawn (50:20.522)
man, we didn't get the deal. We're not making as much money. Here's what we'll do. We will lower the price per month so low that it won't even cover our cost, but we'll sign up in the first month, 3 million people. And by doing that, we'll get this influx of cash pocket it. And then we'll go to another scheme or scam where we say, we've got data. We've got data that says that everyone who signs up for this, they're seeing less. They're seeing fewer movies. So we're profiting. So they would lie.
and they would pocket the cash because they'd get investments. And eventually, obviously it fell because they were just bleeding money. This is a perfect example of the invisible hand. These people were not creating value for anybody and in the end it crushed it.
Matt (51:00.205)
The original company had value. The original company had potential.
shawn (51:04.65)
That's right. That's right. That was good capitalism. They created value and people wanted that value in return and it was all working and profitable for everybody. The moment people came in and didn't create value for the people, it fell apart. That's the invisible hand.
Sam (51:08.03)
So.
Sam (51:13.406)
Well, let's.
Sam (51:17.886)
So, so let's look, let's, let's look at this in the context of history, right? You said what year was this started?
Matt (51:24.141)
2000 well it started in 2000. No, no, that's when like the new people came in and ended in 2018. So like 2016 is when they had 30 ,000 subscribers paying $40 a month 2016.
Sam (51:26.493)
18.
shawn (51:27.946)
It ended.
Sam (51:31.71)
Okay.
Sam (51:35.254)
Okay. Okay. So truly movie theaters are on the decline. The old, the old notion of standing up and waiting in line to go see Titanic. If you saw Titanic, like we did, if you saw it when we were kids, I remember we would wait hours in line and it was an experience and you're excited to be in a theater. You wouldn't catch me dead in the theater right now. Right. I want to watch a movie at home or in a place of my choosing. That's clean. I don't want to be around that. So.
The great thing about the free market is bad ideas fail and good ideas win. This is a stupid idea. And, and you know what? So no, no, no, no, just be, just be, listen, blockbuster was the owner of everything entertainment back when they were. And Netflix was pitched to blockbuster and blockbuster said Netflix will never survive. It'll never be anything. Right.
shawn (52:11.85)
No, it was a profitable idea, Sam. It worked. It was great. The beginning of this company was fantastic. Yeah, it was way profitable. They made money.
shawn (52:32.97)
Yeah, yeah.
Sam (52:33.566)
And it ultimately was the end of Blockbuster. These guys tried to duplicate what Netflix did with the same idea and it failed miserably, right? I haven't seen the documentary, but I, it didn't. Okay. Would you wait, I have a question. Would, would you pay $40 a month for an unlimited movie pass? You wouldn't catch me. I would never. Who's it's a dumb idea.
shawn (52:42.058)
No, it didn't fail. Yeah, you can even see it. You didn't see it. If no, it failed.
Matt (52:45.485)
You don't have to see it, Sam.
Matt (52:51.629)
No, I would not. But the reason it failed is because they lowered the price to $10 a month for unlimited movies. And...
shawn (53:00.01)
in order to get a bunch of cash upfront and enrich themselves. And it wasn't based on creating value.
Sam (53:00.222)
Would you?
Sam (53:04.83)
And, and, and companies, and companies do that actually companies will do that, out of self interest. You know, one of the big problems with large corporations right now, and in automotive, we see this, CEO can come in and their board can approve and authorize a large pay package. A CEO might say, Hey, you know what? We want to have Ford motor company go all in an electric. And if electric is super popular with the government and with, with.
shawn (53:18.346)
Mmm.
Sam (53:34.654)
Wall Street, that idea alone could create wealth and value in the stock. And it may not be backed by any new idea or any innovation or ingenuity. Now, the company to sustain that growth needs to deliver on it. And there are examples, Ford's a great example. Ford went all in on electric early on, they forced dealers to spend a ton of money to create infrastructure wasn't backed by demand. And they're suffering the consequences of that right now Chrysler.
shawn (54:01.322)
Yes, sir. That's right.
Sam (54:02.846)
Stellantis is another example. So that is a feature of it. There's an extent there was, but electric was super exciting on Wall Street. And so Wall Street paid to have companies get excited about it because it was a hot thing. That's free market. So when I see this, there's probably fraud in it.
shawn (54:06.218)
By the way, government was involved in all that, right? They meddled.
Matt (54:12.589)
I mean, that's just a little incentive they offered.
shawn (54:14.89)
yeah.
Sam (54:31.582)
and the market dealt with it, right? But it's a dumb idea. Like I'm not, I wouldn't pay 10, would you pay $10 a month for an unlimited movie pass?
Matt (54:32.493)
For sure.
Matt (54:36.525)
Okay but, like you also right now you have...
shawn (54:40.746)
Sam, three, like millions of people subscribe. You can't say it's a dumb idea if you're able to get millions and millions of people to subscribe. They wanted it, they liked it. Maybe you wouldn't and I wouldn't, but many people, I would not, I would not, but millions of people in 2008, but I wouldn't, Sam, but just because you wouldn't want it, millions of people did in 2018, not very long ago.
Matt (54:40.941)
No.
But now...
Sam (54:49.47)
Would you, Sean, would you pay $10 a month for an unlimited movie pass to go sit with smelly people and eat popcorn? I wouldn't.
Well, well, I just be curious anecdotally to find the people because I don't know, are they, I, I, I would guess what I'd pay probably four or five times that to go to a small, like if what they need to do is recreate or rethink the experience. Somebody tried to create cash on an idea that was exciting.
Matt (55:02.221)
I love.
shawn (55:05.802)
the millions of people.
Matt (55:06.093)
I love that Sam trusts people, he just doesn't want to be around them.
shawn (55:11.39)
They smell.
shawn (55:24.906)
Sam took this, Sam took your question to talk about his ideas of how movie theaters can be better.
Matt (55:29.485)
Well, I know that one of our listeners is going to right now, right out of business plan about how to make money on small theaters for billionaires. Well, but right now, Sam, you've got truth social, right? Truth social is not a company worth any money, but you've got lots of investors putting money into it. Right. But, but we know that the most likely outcome is that these small time investors are going to lose their shirts on their investments in truth social.
Sam (55:30.174)
They could be better.
shawn (55:34.858)
You
Sam (55:36.798)
Sam (55:43.006)
yeah, the stock market says it's worth money. Billions, right? It's enriched Trump.
Sam (55:56.094)
You don't know that. How do you know that?
Matt (55:58.061)
That's a very like, have you seen their financial reports? They had.
Sam (56:00.797)
This is why you can't now. I haven't seen it. I don't know anything about the company, but this is why certain like what basis do you have to make judgment about it? It's generating a ton of wealth. Hmm. Hmm. Hmm.
Matt (56:07.213)
They are what? No, it's not. There's nothing there. Right. They have no, they have like a fraction of the subscriber base that their competitors have. They have no average.
shawn (56:12.202)
That's not, there's no revenue, there's no income.
Sam (56:18.43)
So in the very, in the very beginning, in the very beginning, in the very beginning, it was fascinating because everybody said Tesla was a dumb idea. It'll never succeed. Like it, it used government.
shawn (56:18.57)
Which is why it will slowly die. Yes it will, they're not creating value.
shawn (56:29.226)
No, it did not. A valuable product. They created so much value that people want it and pay for it. Truth Social doesn't.
Matt (56:29.613)
Tesla had a product. What is the product of truth?
Sam (56:33.182)
It, it, it, it, it had a, it had a product that was losing billions of dollars. Like some of the best ideas out there have made money eventually, not in the beginning.
Matt (56:37.261)
Yeah.
So here's what I've learned from Sean. Capitalism is great because this thing where these people lost a good company, Adam Smith predicted it. And from Sam, it was a bad idea and that's why it failed. And if it's, yeah, I think you guys are reinforcing all of the kind of anti -capitalist attitudes people have.
Sam (56:55.71)
It is a bad idea.
Sam (57:01.342)
And, and, and by the way, if truth social is a bad idea, it will fail and the investors will pay the price, but that's the risk they decided to take. But.
Matt (57:06.573)
Yeah... Yeah...
shawn (57:07.882)
And the evidence that it's a bad idea is that there's no revenue. There's no value it's creating for people who are willing to pay any money. So it will fail.
Matt (57:16.397)
So the problem then that I have is when there are good honest people who don't understand the game that other people are playing, that they're the ones that lose out in the end. And the ones who understand this game, like Donald Trump, became a billionaire overnight with Truth Social and he's gonna cash in.
shawn (57:32.394)
But Matt, you can't force people to be honest. You have to let this market play out. You can't force them, Matt.
Sam (57:33.982)
You know, you know, mmm. Ooh, this, this is gonna lead. This is gonna lead. This is gonna lead to a fascinating conversation. So guess where affinity fraud is super rampant. Yeah, Matt to find affinity fraud for us.
Matt (57:39.885)
I'm...
shawn (57:49.066)
Utah. Utah.
Matt (57:51.725)
It's when you take advantage of people's trust in you to take their money from them.
Sam (57:58.078)
Right. Right. And so and it's somebody seeking to take advantage of a person who's open to being taken advantage of. But then it's also somebody thinking that they can get something for nothing. I don't know enough about true social to decide I'm going to invest in it. But if I'm looking to get a return, and I think, you know, Trump is the Savior incarnate, right, I might invest thinking that I'm guaranteed a return, guaranteed a return. That's on you.
Like if you're not smart enough to look at a company to research it to understand who's at the helm, I, I haven't put a penny in true social, right? Like, is the stock market a little bit of a, yeah, they have, but shame on them if they did, thinking they'd get a free return. They need to make, so much of what we talk about on this show is we need to be educated. We need to be wise about the decisions we make with our time, with our resources, with our, our economics. Like if I invested,
shawn (58:31.338)
see if they make no revenue.
Matt (58:37.773)
But some people have.
shawn (58:40.81)
He's right, Matt. Shame on them. That's on them. He's right.
Sam (58:56.99)
$100 million in true social, I deserve to lose every penny of it if it's a bad company. If somebody came to me and said, Hey, put a million bucks in this stupid idea about AMC and $40 up. Like I would have laughed them out of the room. Now here's what's interesting is for every person that gets laughed out of a room, Netflix is a good example. They got laughed out of the room at Blockbuster because there's no way you can mail a disc to someone.
shawn (59:02.25)
That's right.
Sam (59:23.198)
let them watch a movie, hope they'll return it, and then flip them another one. There was no, there was no path, there was no idea that made that realistic. But in a free market, those people, I've talked to the owner, the guy that founded Netflix, he took a huge risk. He was living on a beach in California in a band down by the river. And he, and he took, he took risk. And, and, and it was gut wrenching. And that one idea they wielded into
Matt (59:43.469)
I've seen him on Saturday Night Live.
shawn (59:47.466)
You
Sam (59:51.262)
into success. And he's tried to do a bunch of other companies since then, and he's had a tough time duplicating that. But, you know, could, could AMC figured out how to make $40 a month work? I mean, they had a bunch of subscribers. Maybe had someone stuck with it long enough, if someone had been more honest about it, had they been able to find that little magic switch, then the economy would have rewarded them. But if true social delivers no value, it'll go away, just like this did.
shawn (01:00:19.146)
The same way that the business model that your company here, the movie company, it turned into something that created no value for people. Matt, capitalism is great because what it does is it rewards companies who create value for valuable people. That's why it's great.
Sam (01:00:27.294)
What? What?
Sam (01:00:33.406)
And, and Matt, what you want, what you want is you want the federal government crowning the winners and the losers. You want them to equalize it all. You've you said that two episodes ago. You said, shouldn't you said, shouldn't you said, shouldn't the government figure out prop people up? No, the free market will end up, it'll create massive losers. Unfortunately. I mean, that's just the risk of it, but don't play the game, but.
Matt (01:00:40.429)
I don't think I said that. I mean, I asked that question.
shawn (01:00:43.433)
And that is a democratic liberal stance, you big balloon.
Matt (01:00:49.389)
It's a question. It's a question.
Sam (01:01:01.566)
But to someone who in 08 got burned by real estate and said, Hey, you know what? Real estate's a fraud. I'm going to go rent. Can you imagine the poor schmuck that in 2008 decided not to buy a house?
Matt (01:01:12.045)
I know.
I almost did that. I'm really glad that I didn't. I did decide to purchase Bayer and that was a really bad idea.
Sam (01:01:17.342)
Right?
shawn (01:01:19.818)
And no offense to any listeners who were renting in 2018.
Sam (01:01:21.63)
I bought Ford at $10 and guess where Ford is eight or 10 or whatever. Yeah.
Matt (01:01:28.749)
I should have just bought Bitcoin. Another thing that has no value and doesn't make any sense at all and yet keeps going up and up and up in price. Yeah. Hey listeners, this was a lot of fun. Thanks for joining us this week. Again, I think you've heard some misinformation that needs to be corrected and we're always open to feedback. If you could just kind of do some research and let us know, that would be great. Talk to you guys next week.
shawn (01:01:34.634)
There you go. No va - There you go. There you go.
Sam (01:01:37.758)
Fun Convo.
shawn (01:01:48.234)
Hahaha
Sam (01:01:49.374)
Uhhhh
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories