The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
Episode 72: Social Media and Free Will, YouTube Religion Conference, Hunter Biden v. Donald Trump, Equality of Economic Outcomes
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Thought Provoker:
Matt is up first this week. There is nothing members of our church value more than free will. Yet, Twitter founder Jack Dorsey warned this week that social media algorithms are robbing individuals of their free will. Specifically he said, “This is going to sound a little bit crazy, but I think the free speech debate is a complete distraction right now. I think the real debate should be about free will” “We are being programmed. We are being programmed based on what we say we’re interested in, and we’re told through these discovery mechanisms what is interesting—and as we engage and interact with this content, the algorithm continues to build more and more of this bias.” First of all, is he right? Second question, if he is right, what can be done to protect our free will?
Next up, Shawn. This week in Utah a bunch of religious YouTubers are putting on a virtual summit. “10 DAYS of talks, interviews and presentations by Latter-day Saints and Evangelicals on topics ranging from Jesus, marriage, politics, and heaven. The objective of this summit is to bring more voices to this conversation as we remain curious and committed to understanding respective beliefs, traditions and practices. “ Many of these social media content creators create sincere content and at the same time earn money via ads, pattern, contributions etc. Is this a conflict of interest? Is it wrong to create spiritual content for money?
Finally, Sam. Who deserves a longer prison sentence Hunter Biden or Donald Trump?
The Big Question: The Wall Street Journal this week has a story about the two different economies in the United States. Aaron Beck argues that the economic data show that rich people are doing especially well in the current economy while poor people are not. He shows that most of the economic growth in the US is in sectors dominated by areas where wealthy people spend money. The leisure and hospitality sector are booming. Food services, drinking places, amusement, gambling, cruise lines, air travel, and recreation are doing really well, but places like Campbell Soup and Pepperidge Farms are lowering their sales forecast because people are economizing on their snack purchases. While the overall unemployment rate is historically low at 4%, unemployment among 20-24 year olds is twice as high. Do governments have an obligation to try to make sure that all sectors of an economy or every demographic in an economy benefit equally from economic booms?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:03.984)
Welcome back to Real Mormonism. I'm Matt. I'm here with Sean and Sam. We're so excited to talk about the news of the week. But first, we have to talk about some things from the listener mailbag. Carly didn't send in any audio this week to kind of bail Sam out. So he's stuck with things that people emailed in the mailbag. So one listener writes, did Sam just say that people can't get ahead in China? Was he in a coma for the last decade?
Sam (00:22.028)
No audio.
Matt (00:33.648)
Question mark.
Sean, was Sam in a coma for the last decade?
Sam (00:36.812)
Alright.
shawn (00:39.77)
Let him finish eating his Giordale chocolates, okay.
Sam (00:43.372)
Yes. All right. So I got, so I have the chocolate dam. No, there has been economic growth in China, but in China there are classes and there are places where people start and where they end. And culturally China doesn't have the same view of free markets and opportunity. The American dream is not alive and well in China. If you end, if you start as a farmer's daughter,
Matt (00:43.696)
Hahaha!
Matt (00:47.696)
haha
Sam (01:08.652)
You are going to be relegated to that role or whatever position they put you at. They test you when you go through college and they decide what role you'll be in. And ultimately you're not going to rise higher than that position. I'm told by someone I met.
Matt (01:22.928)
Well, you can, you can join the Communist Party and work your way up the ranks of the Communist Party. And you can go from like nothing to something really big through the Chinese Communist Party. Well, it's just a different, I mean, I mean, if we're being completely honest about it, there are more people that are succeeding through the Chinese dream of the Chinese Communist Party than there are Americans succeeding through the American dream.
Sam (01:31.468)
That's fun. The Chinese, like, like.
shawn (01:37.306)
Is that the Chinese dream? Sam talks about the American dream. Is that your Chinese dream?
Sam (01:48.324)
no. no. Do you teach this in your, do you teach this at school?
shawn (01:51.418)
Why would you say something dumb like that? What are you talking about? if you're defining Chinese dream by getting into the Communist Party then more people are succeeding? man.
Matt (01:53.2)
What was the?
Right. Right. Right. Is that not true? Don't you think there are more more millionaires and billionaires in China than in the United States?
Sam (02:01.804)
Wow.
shawn (02:09.162)
that's who knows come with reference. Don't pull a Sam that you got to bring references for statements like that. now you sound like Sam. Good answer, Sam.
Matt (02:11.024)
okay. Well, I didn't, I didn't come prepared. This was just a question from the mail. I was expecting. okay. All right. Hey, listener, why don't you, why don't you fact check that for me and then let us know that I was right. There's more millionaires and billionaires in China than there are in the United States. And maybe we have a different way of becoming a millionaire in the U S but it doesn't mean that our way is better just because it's different than China.
Sam (02:37.068)
I actually, I disagree wholeheartedly. I think, I think the American dream is better because it's a place where you come regardless of where you come from, you can become an American. You can't become a Chinese person coming from France to China. And you can't participate in the society in the same way in China as a foreigner, as you can as a foreigner participate in the society here. So.
shawn (02:39.354)
Matt! I have to say shut up, Matt!
Matt.
Matt (02:58.928)
Mmm.
Sam (03:05.964)
Regardless how you look at it, the ability to pursue the American dream is a lot. It is there. Like I can raise my station as a person coming from China, living in the United States. I can participate in the free markets and better my world. And you can't do that as a Frenchman coming to China. You'll be discriminated against. You'll be held down and back. So anyway, that was, that's my point.
Matt (03:07.44)
Yeah.
Matt (03:26.896)
That's true. That's true.
That's true. I can't argue with that. That's true.
shawn (03:32.314)
Hey, just, I mean, Sam, you're absolutely right in all of this. And I just want to say one thing about Matt. When we were in the MTC, day one and day two, I thought this guy was the coolest guy ever. And then Matt started to let himself be his true self. And within two or three days, I did not like you at all, man. I did not like you at all because you were feeling more and more yourself. I prayed to get rid of you as my companion. The prayer was answered. I got with it. It was great, great, great. Matt was a snapper head.
Matt (03:47.824)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (03:51.404)
What? What? What? What? What? What?
Sam (04:02.06)
Where does this come from, Sean?
shawn (04:02.266)
He was a jokester and I know he understood his Sam. There was a day, there was a day. Remember this day, Sam, we were all being taught and Matt as usual was goofing around and saying weird things. And our teacher grabbed a chalk eraser and threw it as hard as he could, about two inches above Matt's head and said, get out. Do you remember that, Matt? I, I, I,
Sam (04:10.156)
Hmm.
Mmm.
Sam (04:17.644)
Hmm. Hmm.
Matt (04:21.488)
Mm hmm. I do remember that. Yeah. I was so I was surprised. I was like, why would you do this in the MTC?
Sam (04:27.276)
Wait, can I ask a question? What does this have to do with the American dream, China, and the ability to better yourself?
shawn (04:28.154)
Your face had such surprise and you stood up like, okay.
shawn (04:35.418)
I'll tell you, I'll tell you, I'll tell you. I've noticed Sam, I've noticed lately that Matt is loosening up on our podcast more and more. He's feeling like he can be his true self and say things like, I feel like the Chinese dream is more successful than the American dream and a better place to live.
Matt (04:36.848)
We're getting there.
Matt (04:42.608)
Hmm.
Matt (04:52.688)
For Chinese people. For Chinese people.
Sam (04:56.588)
So in the words of Cyndi Lauper, Matt is allowing his true colors to shine. They got you two colors shining through. You got your true colors and that's why I love you. So don't be afraid to let it go. True colors.
shawn (04:56.666)
See, stuff like that, Sam. He's being more true to his, his self.
Matt (05:06.864)
At least he didn't go girls just want to have fun. So I felt okay. Another listener writes, we're going to start a new podcast called real Mormon karaoke night. He actually sounds a lot like Cindy Lauper. Okay. The next listener writes,
shawn (05:07.29)
Yeah, yeah, he's feeling more free.
shawn (05:17.562)
boy.
Sam (05:24.364)
so beautiful like a rainbow. I do.
shawn (05:25.306)
Wow, he's still going.
He's still going.
Matt (05:34.64)
I'm glad Sam continues to highlight the high crime rates in blue states. Doesn't that prove that democratic policies lead to the breakdown of society just as the prophets predicted? Is this a question for me?
Sam (05:36.524)
no.
Mm -hmm.
shawn (05:47.578)
Wait, I think they're agreeing with Sam here and they're somehow saying that profits predicted that democratic policies would break down society. Is that what, what reference, no references.
Matt (05:51.184)
Yeah, I think they are.
Matt (05:56.368)
Yeah, so what it looks sounds like. Well, yeah, I think that the prophets never predicted the democratic policies would lead to the breakdown of society.
Sam (06:01.26)
That one got by the editor Matt because otherwise he wouldn't have allowed a pro My Viewpoint to pop in. Thank you to that listener for that comment. We appreciate it. The American Dream is live and well.
Matt (06:08.784)
hahahaha
shawn (06:08.89)
Heheheheh
Matt (06:13.616)
Well, so Sam, do you think, do you think Sam that the, the, that democratic policies lead to the breakdown of society?
shawn (06:15.45)
Yeah, by the -
Sam (06:23.852)
I think that part of what makes the American system great is that we have both views represented. And in the public square, we get to debate and we get to go back and forth. And the most dangerous thing that could happen in our democratic society would be one view prevailing over the other and extinguishing the other. So the free market of ideas ends up producing the best ideas. And this will come up later today in one of the topics. But...
Trying to restrain an idea or say, hey, that idea is less, that's not what made our society great. So democratic ideas need to happen so that people can see that they're bad.
Matt (06:53.968)
Okay. Am I?
shawn (06:55.29)
Nice.
shawn (07:04.57)
Good answer, Sam. Good answer.
Matt (07:10.8)
Okay, that's fine with me. Let's move on to the thought provoker. I think it's time we provoke some thoughts today.
Sam (07:11.884)
Okay, all right. Here we go.
shawn (07:12.09)
Good answer.
I gotta get it. I got a this is Matt's topic, right? So I got a I got a big answer response to this man.
Matt (07:20.688)
Okay, good. Do you know why you have an answer ready, Sean? Because I sent you guys this question yesterday. So you guys, I can't wait to hear what Sam's question is today. And Sean's going to get mad at me and say, hey, you don't have any evidence to back that up. And I'm going to say, well, I just barely heard of it. Okay. Anyhow. Okay. So there is nothing that members of our church value more than free will. And I've heard you.
shawn (07:44.986)
That's an overstatement, but okay.
Matt (07:47.6)
But, but almost every conversation I have with a member of our church about politics or society, they say, listen, the war in heaven was fought over free will and we need to preserve.
shawn (07:55.45)
Yeah, but.
shawn (07:58.842)
No doubt, no doubt free will is an important doctrine in our church, but to say no, nothing members of our church value more. That's not true. We value the atonement more and, and yeah, it's a bold statement, but no, it's true. We value, we believe it's a true doctrine. Very, very much so against the Calvinist theories. Yeah. Okay. Go ahead.
Matt (08:03.76)
Okay.
Matt (08:07.568)
okay.
Matt (08:14.992)
Okay. I'll change my statement. I'll change my statement to say members of our church value free will. Okay. Yet Twitter founder Jack Dorsey warned this week that social media algorithms are robbing individuals of their free will. Specifically, he said, this is going to sound a little crazy, but I think the free speech debate is a complete distraction right now. I think the real debate should be about free will. We are
shawn (08:22.746)
Thank you.
Matt (08:44.72)
being programmed. We were being programmed based on what we say we're interested in and we're told through these discovery mechanisms what is interesting. And as we engage and interact with this content, the algorithm continues to build more and more of this bias. So my question is, is he right that these algorithms are robbing us of our free will? And if he is right, is there anything we can do to protect ourselves from these AI algorithms that are going to rob us of our agency?
shawn (09:12.698)
Okay. So I might get a lot of pushback on this, but he is absolutely dead wrong in this a hundred percent dead wrong. Freedom of speech is absolutely something that is at risk. Governments can control speech. Societies can cancel speech and that's dangerous for our society. But free will. No, he's wrong. Free will cannot be. You can't steal someone's free will. So you guys know who Victor Frankel is, right? He wrote the book, man's search for happiness. He was a.
Matt (09:18.242)
Matt (09:37.488)
Yes.
Sam (09:40.108)
Man search for meaning, right?
shawn (09:40.954)
psychiatrist in a concentration camp, man search for, yes, meaning you're right. Happiness is a, Russell Bowen, huh? Sandsburg, there, man's search for meaning. So in that book, if you recall, he argued exactly against this. He basically argued that free will, according to Vicar Frankel, is the only thing in this world that no one can take from you. Nazis took his clothes, his family, his business, his money, his dignity. They took everything from him. But in the end, the reason he survived,
Matt (09:44.304)
Yeah man, search for meaning.
shawn (10:10.586)
and built his whole philosophy around was that they could not take his will or his ability to respond, to choose a response to what they were doing to him. He could choose in.
Matt (10:22.192)
But that's because that's because the Nazis never gave him access to social media and the algorithms that would control the way he thought. Right. So I don't know. Is the matrix, is that an appropriate like comparison for the, the man?
shawn (10:27.546)
okay.
shawn (10:36.506)
It's wrong, Matt. That's, I mean, I agree. I see where you're going, but there's if look, you're saying you're, you're saying that Matt, you're saying that tick tocks algorithms is more powerful at taking away your free will than the Nazis who strip you from your clothing, your food, your family, everything you have, put you in chains, beat you to death. And they can't make take his free will, but a tick tock algorithm can cause it serves you a dancing girl that isn't dressed very modestly.
Sam (10:39.852)
Set rate at R, that's curious.
Matt (10:42.736)
Hahaha
Matt (10:55.952)
Well, well, I'm -
Matt (11:02.192)
I'm going to be hesitant to compare anything to the Holocaust because I don't have any experience that I think could compare to that. But when somebody overtly tries to control you, you're aware that they're trying to control you and you'll put up defense mechanisms to fight back. And so if you're aware that the
shawn (11:17.338)
So do you think through deception, you think through deception our will can be destroyed?
Sam (11:17.964)
Okay, can I share my take on this? Can I share my take on this? Here's the fascinating thing about algorithms. So algorithms give us more of what we say we individually want, right? And it takes us down the rabbit hole. So our desires ultimately end up training the algorithm. So if you think about it in a gospel sense, we're sent to this earth to have experiences.
Matt (11:22.704)
Yeah.
Matt (11:26.16)
Okay, go ahead Sam.
Sam (11:43.404)
to better educate our desires and then our desires ultimately create what we end up becoming. We learn that algorithms speed that process up to an insane level. So isn't it more accurate to say that an algorithm actually helps us get to our end result faster and algorithms need to help us be less stupid as we go and live life. Like we need to be smart about the choices we make and the things we decide to consume.
And algorithms will help us see if that path is taking us down the wrong path faster than maybe some of these more subtle things. Like people back in the day with cigarettes, right? You start to smoke cigarettes, you become addicted to nicotine over time that develops into cancer, right? You become addicted to drugs over time that has intense and significant physical impact to your health. Well,
Algorithms take you down a hole that give you everything you want and more. It feeds, it feeds every appetite that you have. It's not creating something that's not there. It's just intensifying what is already there. And so people, it seems to me, people, it seems to me needs to need to be smarter about what we consume and digest. Be aware of it. There probably needs to be better education.
Matt (12:58.32)
Yeah.
shawn (12:58.426)
That's interesting, Tec. That's interesting.
Sam (13:08.172)
And then if we start to see ourselves seeing certain things over and over again, you got to find a way to step outside of that and, and get, get a broader mix or you declined to print Matt, you, you, you say often, I I'm not on Facebook. You say I am, I'm not on this social media platform. I'm not on the other one. That's the other thing you can do. You can choose to abstain from it and, and, and go back to, you can't go to print media necessarily anymore, but you can go to,
Matt (13:25.776)
Yeah, I'm not.
Sam (13:37.356)
platforms and you can electronically discover things. Yeah. So I'm not, I'm not a huge fan of going, I'm not a huge fan of controlling algorithms or other than the free market or saying that the government needs to come in and stop it because it's going to happen in one form, fashion, or another, whether it's the algorithm is being controlled by a social media platform as part of a free market or the government comes in and controls it through regulation.
Matt (13:39.024)
online versions of printlib. That's right. Yeah.
shawn (13:42.426)
Matt, what do you think? Matt, are you for it or against it?
Sam (14:05.74)
I think that's probably equally as harmful.
Matt (14:09.648)
I think that, I think, well, I think the three of us have experience in a context before social media, before all of this stuff. So we, we can kind of like regulate it a little bit, or at least we can sense what it's doing to our lives. When I think about young people today who were raised on this stuff, I don't know that they have the, like, I read an article today in print news, but it was online print news about
shawn (14:09.818)
Yeah, Matt, what do you, what's your take? Do you agree with him?
Matt (14:36.816)
how hard it is to be a teenager today if you don't have access to social media. As if it's like, it's great tragedy and a great trial. And to some extent, there's some truth to that, like since everybody's on it. And I do worry because I see what my kids consume, the algorithm is feeding them the same stuff over and over and over again. And it shapes the way they think about everything.
shawn (14:43.29)
Yeah.
shawn (14:57.722)
And like Sam's, but, but like Sam says, they're, the algorithm is feeding them based on their will, their desires, what they want to see, what they linger on, what they see.
Matt (15:05.808)
but they're too young to know how to control it, right? So if I get a bunch of stuff I don't like, I intentionally start searching for other things so that the algorithm will have to adapt and say, wait a minute, he wants a broader array of things, but young people who've never experienced anything like that don't know how to change the algorithm, so it's not showing them the same stuff.
shawn (15:10.682)
Well, let's.
Sam (15:23.66)
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But isn't it just life? Isn't it just life sped up? Isn't it just experience intensified? It's a version of what we got as kids. It's just faster. It's more immediate and it's more intense. Like part of it has got to be education from parents and from people in the social sphere, not controlling it by the government.
shawn (15:27.482)
But his thing wasn't, he wasn't specific to younger people or children.
shawn (15:44.57)
Yeah, I agree with you, Sam.
Sam (15:50.7)
Because as, as, as, as potent as it is for a social media company, which is free market social media to have control over that, how much worse? That's the terrifying thing about somewhere like China. I've said this already on this show China's control of Tik TOK and that algorithm is terrifying because now you've got a government trying to espouse a certain ideology and now they have control over it and they get a put pictures in front of Americans.
Matt (16:11.888)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (16:19.692)
When Palestine or Hamas attacks Israel and it's in defense of Israel and it's manipulating us in that way. These algorithms today, at least in theory, are intensifying our own interests and our own, you know, what we individually want to see. What's terrifying is the idea of an algorithm being in control of a government or of some sort of an ideology that could change the world politics.
And maybe it's the same thing. Is it the same thing? I don't know.
shawn (16:52.378)
real quick, Sam, I did get it. I did. It's a great point, Sam, just before I forget, I did get a listener asked me to ask you a question. Please spell the word Israel the way that you pronounce Israel. Cause they think it would, it would be spelled I Z I Z R O L L.
Sam (17:02.252)
Ooh.
Sam (17:06.284)
I -Z -R -E -A -L.
Matt (17:12.656)
Israel? Israel? Hey, so -
shawn (17:13.882)
Israel. No, but so, so, so I've, I've got, is it? It's awesome. I love it. So I've got it. I've got a couple of scriptures, Matt, to, to back up. I think what I'm saying. So.
Sam (17:13.9)
Israel, Israel, Israel. It's my Michigan accent for you.
Matt (17:21.808)
Ha ha ha.
Sam (17:21.996)
Sure, yeah.
It's also hummus. It's hummus. It's not hummus. It's hummus and chips. Yeah. Hummus.
shawn (17:31.706)
hahahaha
Matt (17:32.208)
is roll is combating hummus they want
shawn (17:35.802)
Thomas. So Matt, in Moses 6 .56, it says this, it is given unto them to know good from evil, wherefore they are agents unto themselves, for the power is in them, wherein they are agents unto themselves. And as much as man do good, they shall in no way lose their rewards. But there's a lot of, the whole Adam and Eve story is all focused on the fact that we are born into this world with the power to identify between right, wrong, blue, red,
Sam (17:37.932)
Uhhh...
Sam (18:01.26)
Mmm.
shawn (18:04.826)
and we have the power to do it. Like it says in Ephesians 4 .14, we henceforth be no more children tossed to and fro and carried about with every wind of doctrine by the sleight of men and cunning craftiness. And then it gives the answer on how to best avoid that. It says by speaking the truth in love. So it's really clear if we lead people, what's aspirational?
Matt (18:16.144)
Yeah, but that's a -
Matt (18:23.856)
It's aspirational, Sean. It's what you're, it's that's like, if you follow the gospel path, then you can be led into truth. But if you don't follow, like, so the thing that concerns me, like a couple of weeks ago, I had some students in class that they're like, explain to me what's happening with Trump. And I'm like, what, what are you talking? Like there's so many things. And they, they said, we're trying to figure out like these 34 indictments, like what happened.
And they're like, we cannot find any unbiased news that will just tell us the facts of what happened in that. Cause everything, when we Google search it, when we're looking for information, it's all one side or the other. It's all angry. It's all like hyperbole. And there's no like just information that's not biased to tell me what happened. And so they're like, so will you please tell me what happened?
shawn (19:11.642)
That's a, that's a pretty weak, that's a pretty weak stance in my opinion. It took me five minutes to find the actual text of the lawsuit. I read the actual lawsuit and the legal and the legal findings.
Sam (19:15.436)
Ooh.
Matt (19:19.28)
I know but Sean, yeah but Sean you're more sophisticated. You're more sophisticated.
Sam (19:22.38)
I think it's healthy that they recognize. I think it's healthy they recognize.
shawn (19:27.418)
I'm not more sophisticated, Matt. I didn't graduate college.
Matt (19:31.472)
But you're older, Sean, you have life experience.
Sam (19:32.268)
I think it's pretty.
I think it's pretty smart that they recognize that things are biased. That's step one, isn't it?
Matt (19:37.264)
Go ahead, Sam.
Matt (19:42.064)
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So.
shawn (19:44.826)
That is good. But Matt, here's, look, remember when Elijah came to the children of Israel, God commanded him, and he goes down and they're worshiping Baal, or at least they're toying with Baal, the god, false god Baal. And Elijah said, how long halt ye between two opinions? If the Lord be God, follow him, but if Baal, then follow him. In other words, your sin is your indifference, your sheep mindset of not, it's like he said also in Revelation, I know your works that they're neither hot nor cold.
but they're lukewarm and when they're lukewarm, I spit you out of my mouth. I would that you're hot or cold. I think the problem is people become like sheep. They turn off their brains and they just let the scrolling or let the, they're looking for the answer in someone, some news article to tell them what to think. So.
Matt (20:28.176)
Well, it's hard to find accurate information. If there's nobody there to tell you this is an unbiased source or there's nothing coming in your algorithm that tells you the opposing side, then all you get is one side and all you can see is one side. And then you say, how do I?
shawn (20:41.85)
How do they not recognize though that that is a biased size? It's all biased. It's all algorithm.
Matt (20:44.664)
because in their entire lives they've never seen the unbiased information. They've always gotten information from social media and those algorithms feeding them information. So I'm...
shawn (20:58.682)
So do you not think it's true when scripture says the power is given to each of you to decide to discern between these things. That's the whole point of the, of the garden, right? The tree of knowledge of good and evil is so that we had it in us to know, to be able to choose between a pole, right? Or a pole left.
Matt (21:06.32)
The only one.
Matt (21:15.312)
They had to leave the garden to see the, they have to have opposition. And so in some ways, the only way to get that is to like, like unplug and tune out and just sort of see life without those algorithms for a while. But what I'm saying is there are a lot of Americans that cannot do that. So that social media fast that President Nelson encouraged people to do, they could not do it, right? A week without social media was just too much for them.
shawn (21:19.546)
Which we have.
shawn (21:42.202)
They could do it, they chose not to do it.
Matt (21:44.912)
Well, this is where Jack Dorsey disagrees with you, Sean. They couldn't do it. I'm giving points to Sam on this. Sam had a take I'd never heard of before.
Sam (21:51.084)
You know, it.
shawn (21:54.298)
It was a good take, Sam.
Sam (21:55.244)
It is interesting to your point though. Do you remember when Facebook first came out and they said, Hey, part of our, an aspiration of Facebook, and we maybe heard this 10 years ago was to be the platform for delivering news. And I remember in our sensibility, we think of news as like watching the news at night. It's like Walter Crunk. It's not Walter, Dan Rather, right? And it's 60 minutes and it's
Matt (22:19.408)
David Muir.
Sam (22:20.62)
Yeah, it's like these PBS, right? Some of the different shows on PBS and whatnot. And I remember thinking, that's insane. Like you can't, MySpace, you can't put news on MySpace. It's too short. You're not gonna be able to understand a topic. I think it's fascinating the point you make that there's, when they first came out with that and said, this is what we wanna do, I thought that will fail because,
Matt (22:25.36)
Yeah.
shawn (22:42.202)
Back then you thought that Sam?
Sam (22:49.74)
How could anybody get all their news through, through, through.
shawn (22:51.706)
Good for you. No, you were wrong that it would fail, but you were right that it would be a problem. So that's really good wisdom of you, Sam.
Sam (22:57.196)
Yeah. How could everybody get all their news through Facebook? And what a challenge it is for kids today to recognize the need for more in -depth information. But then, like, I think people are good at sensing that news is biased. I watch Fox News and you're like, that's biased. I watch MSNBC. It's like, that's biased. It's more entertainment than it is true news. And I think that's pretty healthy for kids to recognize that.
But without having that background, that's fascinating to think about. How do you overcome the fact you've never had that before in life? That's going to be a challenge for those kids, right? So, and it's terrifying to think, Matt, that their best place for learning that is at school, where they have a lot of the ideas you're sharing with them about the American dream being dead and whatnot. But we'll have to get past that and give it to you. So, thank goodness. Okay. All right. Thank you.
Matt (23:37.744)
Yeah. Yep.
Matt (23:44.4)
Hahaha!
Matt (23:48.624)
Well that's not what I share with them. Alright, Sam gets the points on this one. Alright, Sean you're up next.
shawn (23:51.37)
Points to Sam, points to Sam.
Sam (23:55.34)
Thank you.
shawn (23:57.914)
All right, I can't wait to hear your responses to this. So this week in Utah, your homes, a bunch of religious YouTubers, yeah, you don't live there anymore, sorry, man. A bunch of content creator YouTubers are putting on a virtual summit. It's a 10 day virtual summit of talks, interviews, and presentations. Half of them are Latter Day Saints and the other half are content creator evangelicals.
Matt (24:07.408)
Yeah, I'm in Idaho.
Matt (24:22.672)
Wait, wait, what's a Latter -day Saint, Sean? I'm not familiar with that term. Do you mean they're members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter -day Saints? We are faithful members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter -day Saints and we like to use the Church's name whenever possible.
shawn (24:30.682)
yes, thank you. Thank you, Matt.
Sam (24:41.164)
Anything else is Satan, basically. Just so you know.
shawn (24:41.242)
Wow, people are gonna get mad at you for sounding like you're facetious, like making fun of that. He's not though. Listeners, he really is not. I know those of you who don't know Matt, he's not making fun of it. That is his way of being sincere. I promise you, he's not making fun of it. Okay, I'm translating for you, Matt. Okay, so half of them are evangelicals, half of them are members of our church. And the topics will range from Jesus to marriage to politics to heaven.
Matt (24:46.864)
I am not making fun of that! Ryan, I'm serious!
now? Yes, that's right. Okay, sorry, go. I'm sorry for interrupting Sean.
shawn (25:08.57)
The objective of the summit, they say, is to bring more voices to this conversation as we remain curious and committed to understanding respective beliefs and practices. So many of these social media content creators, they do, I think I've looked at most of them, they do create sincere content and at the same time they earn money via ads, via Patreon, via contributions, and they ask for the money. So is this, this one, well that's,
Matt (25:27.056)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (25:31.6)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (25:31.756)
How could that be bad? Why would that be bad?
shawn (25:34.842)
Well, that's my question. Is it a conflict of interest? Is it wrong to create spiritual content for money?
Matt (25:40.112)
Yes, that's pre -scraft, Sean. That's pre -scraft. No, no. So to me, to me, what you're describing is the same as there was like the back in the day, they'd have the preparing a people conference and they have these like prepper conferences. To me, this is the same as a conference only instead of paying an admission fee to get into the conference and then listen to speakers for free, you like watch their channel and maybe donate via Patreon. I don't
shawn (25:43.866)
So Sam disagrees, Matt agrees.
Sam (25:46.348)
Let's free.
Matt (26:07.44)
I don't think that this is an area where there's a right and a wrong. It's all about the individual. So Tim Ballard used to present at these preparing a people conferences. Ruby Frankie used to present at them. Chad Daybell used to present at them. Yeah. So it's not, yeah. So there's nothing wrong with those forums. What can be wrong is your intent as an individual, right? So some people who presented those kinds of things,
shawn (26:16.73)
my... What?! Seriously?!
Matt (26:33.264)
Maybe have bad intents or maybe there, maybe it lifts them up in pride or something like that. Like as an individual, you could use that forum for ill purposes, but that doesn't mean that the forum itself is a bad thing. So I don't think it's fair to say like, you're
shawn (26:46.842)
But what about, okay, I agree with you. I don't have as much problem with a forum. YouTube's fine, Instagram's fine, but what about I'm making money to, like for a long time, who comes to your minds when it comes to professional Mormons who do good and make money at it? Come on, you know some names, give me a break. John, by the way, right?
Matt (27:04.784)
Hmm.
John, by the way.
Sam (27:09.292)
Well, well, by, by the way, Russell Nelson, Boy K. Packard, Neil A. Maxwell, they all have books that are bestsellers at Deseret Book, right? So Deseret Book, Deseret Book is an arm of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter -day Saints, and it sells content that's created by church leaders and officials. And that is all for profit. Now we've, Sherry Dew has said that the apostle stuff is a loser. So they.
shawn (27:19.77)
Not anymore, Sam, not anymore. Not anymore they don't.
Matt (27:24.048)
Why? Why don't?
shawn (27:31.834)
So.
So check this out though, Sam.
Sam (27:38.828)
They prop it up a little bit with other things, but it's a free market exercise, Sean, right?
shawn (27:46.49)
But that culture has changed. So we were talking to my in -laws and they one time were out at their grandparents cleaning out all their old stuff. And they said, the culture back then was like this. They said they must've had 5 ,000 books because back then you would buy books and active members of the church would go to Desert Book or go online and buy every book that ever existed. I mean, thousands and thousands of books. And they all agreed. Those books said absolutely nothing because there was this culture of print a book,
Matt (28:09.2)
Yeah.
Matt (28:13.904)
What?
shawn (28:16.314)
so that the apostles or someone can make money, print the books they can make money. And I mean, it's true. I've looked through all these books. It's just like...
Matt (28:22.992)
I have them all on my bookshelf. I love those books. There's one by Henry B. Eyring called To Draw Closer to God. And all it is is a whole bunch of talks that he gave. There's one from Elder Holland about Jesus Christ. There's two or three I have from Elder Russell Nelson when he was Elder Nelson. Richard G. Scott. I have like all these books.
shawn (28:25.914)
What books do you have? What books do you have?
shawn (28:31.162)
What so?
Sam (28:42.184)
Personally, there's a great book about how Abraham Lincoln was visited by Moroni. And I really liked that book that I bought from Deseret Book. So, I think this relates to the previous conversation we had about social media. People need to be smart. People need to be not dumb. Part of our freedom is we get to make choices about content we digest. To your point, Matt, I think it is dangerous when you look at some of these fringe.
shawn (28:45.818)
Okay.
Ha ha ha ha.
Matt (28:49.2)
That would be Tim Ballard. That would be the Tim Ballard.
Sam (29:12.396)
content creators that are espousing crazy wacko ideas. We've all seen them. They're all on the fringe of the church, right? But I think there's also some helpful content and people just need to make decisions about what to consume, support the good stuff. There are plenty of, you know, the cool thing about social media and YouTube and all the different content that's out there is now more than ever. If I'm a whatever I am, there's probably a chance that I can
follow someone on social media that's sort of like me, that in their content, I find a version of myself. I connect with them in a way that's different or unusual, right? Maybe in the church, maybe it's a, maybe it's a, a, a female leader that is teaching really good ideas and interesting perspectives. And, and as long as it doesn't go off the rails, as long as it doesn't end up becoming harmful. And I get to make that choice about what I consume. That's awesome. And.
shawn (30:07.258)
So Sam, I'm not at all.
Sam (30:10.956)
and let her make money out of it. Why would you prohibit that? Okay. Okay. What was the question? Sorry.
shawn (30:12.986)
No, I agree, but that's not the question. Yeah, the question is about money. So for example, Sally DeFord, have you heard of Sally DeFord? She is a really talented, she makes music and for years she's made music and there is so much about Sally DeFord music within the church. And her message in the beginning was, look, you get this for free. No, no, no, different from the piano guys. Sally DeFord came out and said, I've been blessed in my life, I'm gonna give music for free. It is free to publish.
Matt (30:21.68)
Yeah, she makes music. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Matt (30:30.16)
Yeah.
Sam (30:30.476)
piano guys.
Matt (30:33.584)
Yeah?
Sam (30:36.876)
Okay.
shawn (30:42.682)
free to reproduce, license free, use it, we're preaching the gospel with this. And for 20 years, 15 years, she's given away her testimony and her talents in a way that has grown spiritually and she's given it away for free and it has reached so many people. That's really the essence of the question.
Matt (31:01.68)
Well, there's painters, right? Del Parsons? Right.
Sam (31:02.028)
Not everybody can do that and you shouldn't expect everybody to do that.
Matt (31:07.888)
Greg Olson, right? There are painters. Yeah, of course. Sure, why not? So again, every painting I have of Jesus, somebody got money for making that painting. There's sculptures that people make. Like everybody expresses their faith in Jesus in different ways. And there's nothing wrong with selling that for people who want to purchase it.
shawn (31:09.53)
Should you, if you could? Should you, if you could, Sam?
Sam (31:27.82)
There needs to be a rule though. This church related content, once it's created, the money should only be traded on Temple grounds. Like that should be the one rule. Like any of the social media content, any of the books, anything else, as long as the funds are traded on Temple grounds, on or about Saturday or Sunday, it's all good. But no, why would anybody object to it? I've never heard anyone object.
Matt (31:38.992)
hahahaha
shawn (31:39.066)
Hehehehehe hehehe he
shawn (31:50.426)
Yeah, no, it's, no, I'm not, my opinion is not, I'm not objecting to it. I think it's a good question to discuss. I was interested in your opinions on it. Look, you guys are talented guys, right? And you know, I've got a few things to say about stuff. And so it's always tempting after you have a podcast like this to go and say more stuff and to choose to do good in the world. It's just weird to think that if you can do something valuable,
Matt (31:50.968)
You
Sam (32:00.236)
Yeah.
shawn (32:18.906)
in a religious or spiritual sense and get it out there, it's weird to want to take money for that, isn't it? I don't know.
Sam (32:24.652)
Why on this show does everybody have a problem with making money? I mean, Matt and the Democrats, there's one person that Matt kind of ends up talking to on these shows. What is the problem with money? We live in a free market. We exchange our time for money. Money ends up getting us ahead and farther along. Like, the biggest problem in the world today is that people...
Matt (32:24.784)
Why? Why? It's not weird for Del Parsons to charge for his paintings.
Matt (32:34.544)
Well, well, Sam does not.
shawn (32:34.97)
I don't have a problem with making money Sam.
shawn (32:45.466)
I have no problem.
shawn (32:51.066)
I have no problem with money, Sam.
Sam (32:53.516)
People feel guilty about bettering themselves. People feel guilty about making money as if they have some sort of a social obligation as a result of it. They need to go repent for being rich. It's ridiculous. Yeah. Okay. okay. Okay.
shawn (32:58.809)
No, no, no, no, Sam, Sam, Sam.
Matt (32:59.504)
You
shawn (33:05.018)
Sam, Sam, Sam, it's a category error. Sam, it's a category error. I have no problem making money. I make fine money. I work hard. I have no problem. I'm a very strong capitalist. It's a category error. We're talking about why would you serve in the bishopric, Sam, and not make money? What are you, not a capitalist? What's wrong with you, you freaking liberal? Why would you serve? Yeah. no one would do it. No one offered it. You didn't create value? then you didn't create value, Sam, because that's the rules of capital.
Sam (33:16.396)
Yeah.
Matt (33:23.504)
Nobody would pay him money for his nobody's gonna give him. That's right. Right.
Sam (33:24.044)
Yeah, nobody would pay me money. No, I didn't. That's right.
Matt (33:31.152)
That's right, that's right.
shawn (33:32.89)
That's all my point is, is that it's a category error. We're talking about a religion. We're talking about spiritual matters, the salvation of souls. You didn't take money on your mission and you served your heart out, man. So I think it's a category difference.
Matt (33:43.152)
Nobody would pay me money for what I I'm going to give Sean the points on this because he expressed guilt about making money for creating a value in society. And Sam chastised him for it. And I loved that. That was that was really good content. Sean gets the points. Sam, Sam, who are you giving the points to?
Sam (33:50.668)
Good job, Sean.
shawn (33:51.77)
Sam you took it in the wrong direction. Sam you fed Matt. I reject the points.
Sam (34:01.9)
I give it to Sean. Sean was a good sport. He took it. He took it. He took he took it well. Everybody should always know that I'm okay with free market capitalism, even though Matt thinks it's a myth. Yeah.
shawn (34:06.938)
hahaha
Matt (34:07.344)
Yeah.
Matt (34:14.)
making money. Okay, Sam, it's your topic.
Sam (34:20.396)
All right. So interestingly enough, this past week, there was a famous court trial. I feel like we've spent a lot of time in court these past months, right? Between Chad Daybell, President Trump, and now Hunter Biden finally had his day in court on gun charges and shocker, he was found guilty on all counts. He's now a felon and he's facing, I think up to 50 all counts. Yeah. Well, all counts is all three counts, whatever the counts.
Matt (34:40.112)
All three counts. Okay. No, no, no.
shawn (34:46.586)
Man, are you defending them? Sounds like you're defending them.
Sam (34:49.292)
Of course he's defending him. No, he thinks.
Matt (34:51.088)
No, no, I just want us to be specific, that's all.
Sam (34:54.38)
Matt thinks it's political. So, so anyhow, he faces up to I think 50 some odd years in prison. Who, here's my question. Here's my question. Thinking about president or president Trump and Hunter Biden, who deserves the most prison time? And we'll start Sean with you. President Trump or Hunter Biden? No, absolutely not.
shawn (34:54.49)
Bye, yes, bye.
Matt (34:58.48)
Hahaha
Matt (35:04.656)
Matt (35:11.408)
former.
shawn (35:19.098)
I
Matt (35:19.632)
Can I reframe the question? Can I reframe the question to who do we think wants the most prison time?
shawn (35:25.754)
No, it's his question, Matt, who deserves.
Sam (35:25.868)
Now, who deserves the most prison time? We have two felons.
shawn (35:32.698)
I mean, I've only read the felony, the guilty, I've only read a little bit of the Biden one. I did read all through the Trump ones. I think the Trump one was pretty, I mean, he did break the law, so it's true, he should be punished, but probably not jail time. And it was very much politically motivated to elevate that to a felony. That was clear to me. With the Hunter Biden thing, I mean, I think it was pretty clear those were felonies, but I would say, Matt, if,
If many people for the same crimes have been they've gone to jail then he ought to for the same thing
Matt (36:07.536)
Sean did not answer the question of who should have more jail time.
Sam (36:10.06)
So how many years, Sean, who should get the most? Okay. So, okay.
shawn (36:12.314)
I don't think Trump should have jail time, but it may be possible that Biden should have jail time.
Matt (36:16.912)
alright, this is really, really easy.
shawn (36:20.314)
Six months. How about that?
Matt (36:22.256)
Well, I will say, I think neither of them deserve any jail time, but I will say that, okay, so Hunter Biden was found guilty of lying on a form used to purchase a gun and therefore, -huh, and therefore, and therefore purchasing a gun illegally when he's a felon, you're not allowed to purchase a gun. So he lied on the form and purchased a gun illegally. So that's, I have no problem by the way, with the fact that.
Sam (36:33.644)
federal form a federal form.
Matt (36:48.4)
They put him on trial and found him guilty of that. I do think it was politically motivated, but I don't care about that. He committed a crime, find him guilty, whatever. And I have actually no problem with the judge wants to throw the book at Hunter Biden and give him the maximum 50 years. But the bigger crime is Donald Trump because Donald Trump falsified business records. Okay. But with, but what makes it a felony, what makes it a felony is it's to enable an additional crime.
Sam (37:05.9)
Lied on a federal form, lied on a form, federal form.
shawn (37:11.354)
Hahaha!
Matt (37:17.808)
And in this case, the jury found that the additional crime that Donald Trump committed, which is why he lied on his business records, was to influence the outcome of a presidential election. In my opinion, trying to influence the outcome of a presidential election by illegal means is a larger crime than purchasing a gun. Yes, that's it. That's what he was found guilty of.
shawn (37:38.618)
You're misrepresenting what the federal crime was. That was not it, Matt. No, it's not. We'll come back next episode and give all the details with references. That's not what it was.
Matt (37:49.168)
I'll put the link in the show notes. That's exactly what he was found guilty of falsifying business records in furtherance of additional crime. The judge didn't say what the underlying crime was, but the pro. But the.
shawn (37:52.474)
Good, put the link in.
shawn (38:00.314)
See and then you inserted what you wanted it to be and what the liberal bias says it is and that is why it is it is it is politically motivated
Matt (38:07.471)
That's what the jury, the jury found him guilty of that. So.
shawn (38:14.234)
Not of that, no, of, of, not of what, not.
Matt (38:17.008)
falsifying business records in furtherance of an additional crime. They didn't, yes, that's what it is. Yeah, yeah, we'll put it in the show notes. Yeah, so that's why it's, and by the way, that's 34 counts of that. So 34 versus one count. And by the way, I'm a strong believer in the Second Amendment. I believe that people have the right to bear arms and they have the right to own guns. So I do think it's bad for...
shawn (38:22.106)
No, that's not what it said. All right, we'll look it up. We'll look it up to verify. If I'm wrong, then I'll say sorry, but.
Matt (38:44.176)
us to prosecute an individual for purchasing a gun. I think that's a worse crime, like to prosecute someone for. That's worse than falsifying business records in order to illegally influence the outcome of an election. So to me, this is easy. Trump deserves more jail time.
shawn (39:00.57)
Go ahead, Sam.
Sam (39:01.964)
So here's my take. Here's my take. I think neither of them deserve jail time. I think had this issue with Trump come up a year after the crime was not so close to an election where it could impact this election, he probably should have been disqualified from running, which this will shock everyone. I preferred probably they prosecute him for after this election so it was a non -issue through an election cycle.
But at the end of it, neither one of them deserve prison time. And ultimately the biggest harm to our system is exactly what Matt pointed out last time, which is at the end of the day, this impacts, this takes credibility away from our judicial system. And it makes our judicial system appear to be politically motivated because in both cases, you could make arguments that they may or may not have been brought up on these charges anyway, were we not in a hyper political environment. Hunter Biden had a
plea deal, which seemed reasonable by all accounts. And they probably should have proceeded with it and let him take his plea deal, learn his lesson and move on. Right. But we're in a hyper political environment and the judicial system has been politicized and ultimately our system loses as a result. So those are my thoughts. And I split the points evenly between Sean and Matt. Go ahead, Matt. Yeah.
Matt (40:17.616)
But in terms of the timing, Sam, the only reason the timing of the criminal case against Trump happens now is because when he's president of the United States, the policy of the Justice Department is you don't indict a sitting president of the United States. You have to wait until they're out of office. And so they had to wait until he was out of office to indict him and his attorneys.
Sam (40:43.5)
Yeah, also, yeah. Yeah.
Matt (40:45.04)
His attorneys made it take so long, just like they're doing in the other cases. He's the reason that it's delayed so long. He's been trying to delay it.
Sam (40:50.7)
So what we'll do is we'll sentence him on the eve of the Republican National Convention when he is appointed as the candidate for the Republican Party and four months before the national election. Like that's far worse. The impact that these charges end up having to a presidential election, everybody thinks it would be negative. It ends up being positive. It almost guarantees that he will be elected the next president of the United States because of all the paranoia out there.
Matt (40:56.207)
Hahaha
Matt (41:04.432)
Okay. But.
Matt (41:17.104)
But you guys both -
Do you guys both agree with, it's actually Jim Comey that said this, that Trump wants to get sentenced to jail time, that he's trying to get a jail sentence? Yeah, yeah.
Sam (41:26.156)
He does. Of course he does. Yes. I don't think, I don't think in his heart of hearts, he, he, he, he doesn't, he doesn't want to be convicted, but if he is convicted and if he is, well, he was convicted and sentenced to jail, he will become more popular. It's like the emperor on, on star Wars where he, where, where he says, give into the dark side because I will become more powerful or whatever he says.
shawn (41:28.698)
does he? I don't know. I don't see why he would you just think why because that gives him a better chance at being a martyr and getting elected.
Matt (41:45.712)
Right.
shawn (41:46.17)
Weird. So.
Sam (41:53.356)
as he's being thrown down the shaft with his electricity. That's the deal here. He gets power off this.
Matt (41:54.224)
Mm -hmm.
shawn (41:59.642)
So Matt, as a fact check myself, you were right. You're right. What I was remembering wrong was that the jurors did not need to agree on what the underlying unlawful means were. So there's no official finding that he was trying to falsify elections. But the prosecutors tried to put that in there so that that would be a message that our society would hear.
Matt (41:59.888)
Okay. Yeah, yeah.
Matt (42:24.656)
Right.
shawn (42:29.082)
But that's not what he was convicted of. So you can't say that.
Matt (42:32.624)
Okay, yeah. So in their closing arguments, that's what the prosecutor said. But the jury...
shawn (42:36.506)
Which, which actually is pretty slimy and dishonest because he was not convicted of that. They're just putting it out to the public that.
Matt (42:43.152)
Well, well they do agree that his falsifying business records was to further an additional crime. The jury just, but the jury, right, right, so.
shawn (42:50.746)
Yeah, period, but that's it. But that's it period. There's no you can't you can't insert whatever crime you want it to be so that that can affect future elections. You can't do that.
Matt (42:56.112)
Okay, but what do you... Okay, why else was Donald Trump? What was the other crime he was doing and what was he trying to cover up in falsifying those business records? Like what other crime?
shawn (43:08.634)
Look, go look at the evidence. There's a lot of crimes that they were talking about. Lots. There's tons.
Matt (43:12.88)
Okay, all right. I didn't hear any other like evidence presented in court of some other crime he had committed. So that's just why I assumed it was that. But you're right, Sean, the jury doesn't say what they think that the other crime was. Okay, I'm going to give points on that one to Sam, because Sam said that Hunter Biden's trial was political. And I didn't expect that from someone like Sam. Like that's
Sam (43:39.18)
as was Trump's.
shawn (43:40.058)
I'm going to give the points to Matt for saying that Biden committed the worst crime out of the two. Guns, you said guns and were worse than, you said that, didn't you?
Matt (43:49.328)
Wait a minute. I said that... whatever. It's just...
then no I said that no I said that trying to influence an election is worse than purchasing a gun because I support the second amendment and I think people should have the right to buy a gun even if they're a felon.
shawn (44:01.754)
okay, my bad.
All right, you talked yourself out of your points then.
Matt (44:08.976)
which by the way, did you see in the news that Trump no longer has the right to own gun in the state of New York because he's a felon now? Lucky for him, taxpayers are providing plenty of guns to protect him with the Secret Service. Okay, let's go to the big question. So the Wall Street Journal has a story out this week. I put a link to it that's ungated. So if you guys want to read the story, you can read the whole story. The author of this article argues that the economic data right now,
shawn (44:14.262)
Yes.
Matt (44:38.544)
show that rich people are doing especially well in the current economy, while poor people are not. So if you look at the economic growth numbers, most of the economic growth that's happening, most of the job creation that's happening is in the leisure and hospitality sector. So food services, places to get drinks, amusement, gambling, cruise lines, air travel. I don't know if you saw this, but Memorial Day air travel was the busiest it's been since before the pandemic. It's all back.
Right? All of the leisure spending is back. At the same time, Campbell Soup that owns Pepperidge Farms is saying, hey, people are cutting back on their grocery spending. They're not spending money on expensive snacks like Pepperidge Farms snacks. And so this author argues that this suggests that some people in the economy are doing better than other people in the economy. Unemployment overall is really low, but unemployment among 20 to 24 year olds,
is twice as high as it is for the rest of the economy. So the question I have is this, do governments have an obligation to try to make sure that all sectors of an economy or that every demographic in an economy benefit equally from economic booms?
shawn (45:53.658)
So before, before Sam just pounces, Matt, I'm going to say no. No, well, good. Well, okay. Before he answers, I'll finish. Cause I know Sam will go off on this, but the answer, Matt is no. In fact, you're the way you phrase the answer has convinced me of a couple of things. So you're saying that under a Democrat president, the rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer and younger generations have learned to depend on parents and government for their income instead of working. That's what you're saying to me.
Matt (45:57.424)
Wait, wait Sam's saying yes, Sam's saying yes.
Matt (46:11.824)
Mm -hmm. Yes.
Matt (46:22.288)
I didn't say that. No, I'm not saying that.
shawn (46:23.482)
So it sounds like, so it sounds like, well, that's what you asked. You said under Biden's presidency, that's exactly what you said. And this is by the way, exactly what Milton Friedman warned against that if you would apply the kinds of Bidenomics that he has or the, or the welfare state, exactly what would happen is the rich would get richer, the poor would get poorer and the younger generations would not work. They would be living off of the welfare state. So I think.
Matt (46:31.184)
No, the -
Matt (46:49.648)
Well, they're not working because they can't work. There's no jobs for them.
shawn (46:53.306)
That is absolutely not true. That is... What are you talking about? That's ridiculous.
Matt (46:58.64)
I mean, that's what I would assume. Like, unemployment rate is people who want to have a job and are able to find a job. So if you're not trying to find a job, you don't get included in the unemployment rate. So if the unemployment rate is twice as high for 20 to 24 year olds, it means they want jobs. There's just not jobs that they can do.
shawn (47:17.178)
I mean, in the real world, that's not what I've seen. I mean, I'm with businesses all the time. And what I see is people are trying desperately to hire as many people as they can, and they cannot find workers. They cannot find people to work.
Matt (47:29.328)
they should offer them more money. And then they could find, it's like the Los Angeles Lakers. They couldn't get Danny Hurley because they didn't offer him enough money.
Sam (47:33.702)
So.
shawn (47:37.818)
Go ahead, Sam.
Sam (47:39.942)
So Matt, can I just go back to your question? Your question is this, do governments have an obligation to make sure all sectors of an economy or every demographic in an economy benefit equally? Is that your question, seriously? So let's play this idea out, right? Are all sectors and all demographics equally beneficial to an economy? Like in an economy where the best ideas win, like,
Matt (47:53.36)
Yes. Yeah, that's the question. Yeah. Yeah.
Matt (48:06.8)
No. Well, by all demographics are.
Sam (48:10.118)
So do you know what Pepperidge Farm sells?
Matt (48:14.512)
Yeah, they sell my favorite thing in the world. Those, pirouette crackers, those cookies, like.
Sam (48:17.286)
They sell cookies and crackers and goldfish. Is it possible that in our current economy, people are like, hey, you know what? I value health and wellness and fitness and good health decisions more than I value eating things that aren't good for you. And maybe Pepperidge Farms and its parent company, Campbell's Soup, is suffering not from...
Matt (48:23.472)
Yes, they're so good.
Matt (48:30.416)
Matt (48:39.408)
No, Sam, come on.
Sam (48:45.414)
Not from like some sort of economic disadvantage because that's unfair, but they're suffering because people are making better choices. Like in a free market.
Matt (48:54.224)
Aren't you the one that told me that you want to sell Ozempic outside of Disney World? I don't think you believe that most Americans are trying to make healthy choices. Do you know what else would do well? Pepperidge Farms cookies.
Sam (48:57.894)
I do, and it would, it would do really well. No, but no, but, but, but what I am saying is, is, is the government can't look at all demographics, as you say, and all sectors of business and say every sector of business is, is equally of value. And so we're going to prop up the ones we do it. There's great examples of it. The corn subsidies, that's actually a huge political issue. You go to Iowa, you can't not talk about.
shawn (49:02.266)
Matt (49:22.48)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Sam (49:27.878)
subsidizing the production of corn. It's probably a bad idea. It probably never ever should have happened. And in government, the more it stays out with some exception of, of trying to prop up things that don't have economic benefit, the better because the best ideas in theory survive and the best segments of an economy survive and, and, and things evolve and develop and ultimately become better as a result.
Matt (49:29.712)
corn, oil subsidies.
Sam (49:56.038)
Like in a customer service industry, if Starbucks provides better customer service, then, you know, gateway coffee or whatever. I can't believe I use that as an example here on this show, but, Starbucks is probably going to do better if they provide a better service and they provide a better product. McDonald's, right? It's not healthy to eat at McDonald's. That's why McDonald's has evolved some of their food choices to make them more healthy and more appealing.
to a broader cross -section. Like I, I, I flatly, flatly reject this idea that, that some sectors are failing because of some sort of an inequity in the distribution of wealth. I think that is a tired claim. I think it's super harmful to our economy and our world today to say that rich people are doing something that's unfair and they have an advantage over people that are.
not rich. I think what we should do is we should learn from everybody across our economy. We shouldn't put the burden on every single person that everyone should be the same. We should celebrate differences and we should allow people to get a benefit by taking risk with their time and their money and bettering their own situation to the extent they want to. So not everybody wants to. And you know what? It's possible. Pepperidge Farms,
shawn (51:15.002)
So, so.
Sam (51:17.478)
Maybe it shouldn't be making cookies anymore. Maybe they should go do something else, right? So.
Matt (51:21.52)
Hahaha!
shawn (51:21.818)
So Matt, I'm going to hear your take and then I've got a really like a kind of serious follow -up question for you about this. So give us your take and then I'll ask you a quick question.
Matt (51:31.12)
Well, so what I do want to say is the reason that you have corn subsidies and the reason you have oil subsidies is because those individuals are politically mobilized and there's political benefit for a politician to talk about giving corn subsidies and oil subsidies. So it is true that the government does it. I wanted to make an argument for a centrally planned economy, but I just can't do it because historically it never ever works. So, so, so I, I,
Sam (51:53.574)
no, no. I may have a heart attack. Like the corn sub, the corn.
shawn (51:54.138)
Yeah. Yay! Good job, Matt. No, no, he didn't, no. Praise him, Sam. Sam, praise him.
Matt (52:01.616)
What?
Sam (52:06.406)
Okay, good job.
Matt (52:06.736)
No. So all I'm saying is like, if you're in one of these groups and you feel like you're being left behind, the solution is follow the example of the oil producers or the meat producers, the cattle producers, the milk producers, the corn producers, follow their example and get organized. Yeah. And when you get organized and lobby, then you're going to get the benefits that they get. That's my, cause I can't argue for central.
Sam (52:20.07)
Lobby lobby
Sam (52:26.182)
Do you agree with, do you agree with, do you agree with corn subsidies? Do you agree with corn subsidies?
shawn (52:26.49)
Well, that's practical advice. It may not be moral advice, but it's practical advice, right?
Matt (52:34.064)
If I am running for president and I need votes in Iowa, yes I do. As an... No. No, no, no. It's not good for America. It's not good for the economy. We should get out of it, but it's not gonna happen.
shawn (52:37.402)
hahahaha
Sam (52:38.982)
But as a business practice in principle, do you think it's a good idea? I don't either.
Less control by government is better in that case. So oil is a good example and corn is a good example. The reason the oil is there is because of the ebb and flow of oil prices. We want the infrastructure there so that when oil prices go back up or down, we can still afford to produce oil. It's national defense and it's so important to our economy. There's a reason behind it, but it's not a good idea generally. Go ahead.
shawn (52:54.938)
Wow!
shawn (53:08.954)
Sam just Sam just just
Matt (53:13.392)
But, but everyone will admit -
shawn (53:13.882)
Sam praise Matt right now. Cause he is, he is talking like a capitalist, a small government, rational thinker. Praise him, Sam.
Matt (53:21.04)
Right now, the government is artificially lowering oil prices by releasing money from the strategic oil reserves. That's irresponsible and that's not appropriate. So like it's clear that the government gets involved in these markets from time to time. And I just say like, if you feel like you're being left behind, organize and then get the government in your industry and they can help you out sometimes.
Sam (53:26.31)
Right.
shawn (53:42.522)
points to Matt. Way to go Matt. No, in this organizing fine Sam. That's free market Sam. Don't stop people from organizing.
Sam (53:43.11)
Yeah, but you're asking people to manipulate a system that doesn't work. Anyway, cool.
Matt (53:52.688)
Hey listen, Sam, if I sell auto insurance, I'm the happiest person in the world that every state mandates liability auto insurance coverage, because otherwise I would never sell an auto insurance policy.
Sam (53:56.518)
Yeah.
shawn (54:00.41)
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Sam (54:07.27)
And, and, and you know what, in auto insurance, it's interesting because the more people you get into it, the less expensive it is. So yeah, it's, I don't know.
Matt (54:15.856)
But if it wasn't mandated, nobody would have it.
shawn (54:15.994)
So Matt, Matt, just real quick, can I ask you a side tangent? So last week you argued that you believe that the scriptures teach about the immorality of personal property. So did you remember in Alma 32, when Alma was teaching on the hill, Oneido or something like that? And all these poor people came up and when they started to say to Alma stuff like, hey, behold, what should we do? We're despised of all men because of our poverty.
Matt (54:35.532)
yeah, I remember that. Yeah.
shawn (54:45.562)
poverty, they kick us out of our synagogues and we're just poor. And Alma turned to them with this super happy immediately towards them with this great joy and face because he says, you're now truly humbled. So why wouldn't you use scriptures like that? Wouldn't you who thinks religion first, kingdom of God first, think the more poverty, the better because it humbles people to be open to open the doors to missionaries you knock on their door. That's an honest question.
Matt (55:09.392)
Because I don't believe that getting rid of private property makes people poor. I believe that...
shawn (55:14.362)
No, no, no. All I was using that was an example of how you like to think Kingdom of God first and look for scriptures to inform, but in this situation, no, I know you did. I know you did. No, no, no. I know you did. I'm saying apply it to this. Why wouldn't you also say if the scriptural principle is when we are poor in heart, when we are poor, we sometimes kneel down in humility and are brokenhearted and will look for truths. So why wouldn't you be for a,
Matt (55:20.272)
Yeah, I did. I did. It was law of the law of consecration.
Matt (55:39.152)
Huh.
shawn (55:42.81)
poverty majority country so that people will open the doors to missionaries.
Matt (55:46.064)
What? Wait, wait, you're saying I should be happy about income inequality in America because the young poor people are going to be more likely to be humble and repent.
shawn (55:51.962)
Yeah
shawn (55:56.474)
You like to look at the scriptures to guide your ideas. Look at Amma 32.
Matt (55:59.376)
Yeah. Well, I would like to take from the rich and give to the poor so that the rich people can be humble because they have too much pride in their hearts and if they had fewer boats.
shawn (56:09.818)
But it wasn't, but that's not what happened in Alma 32 and Alma 32, they were poor and they didn't know where to turn. So they knelt down and turned to Alma and Alma preached to them the word and they all accepted it.
Matt (56:21.328)
Okay. All right. I like that. Listen, listener, when you say that Sean's the spiritual one, I feel a little bit offended. I don't feel like Sean's more spiritual than Sam or I. He just brings in scriptures more often than we do. But Sam and I have, what's the word, wisdom? We have like, the scriptures are a part of who we are. And it's just like, everything we say, you can find a scripture to support it.
And Sean's just doing that for us. He's finding the scriptures that support the things that we say because we know that it's true and Sean just helps us figure out exactly how it's true.
shawn (56:57.85)
That was really weak. That was a weak, weak sermon.
Sam (56:58.982)
Thank you, Sean.
Matt (57:02.128)
hahahaha
shawn (57:03.546)
I don't need to quote scriptures because I am scripture is what you said.
Matt (57:06.824)
No, because the scriptures are part of who I am. Okay, on the big question, we don't give points to anybody, but I do think that Sam made a really good argument about, because I was really ready to come in strong with central government and central planning. And as Sam spoke, I thought, I can't do this. It would just sound disingenuous. Like Sam made a really good point there. Yeah. So I say nice work, Sam.
shawn (57:10.714)
sorry.
Sam (57:28.23)
shawn (57:28.474)
Well done, Sam! Good job, man! That's a first.
Sam (57:35.782)
Fantastic.
Matt (57:38.128)
Hey, we won this week, Sean, because normally Sam is kind of happy, but he's also depressed. This week, Sam's a little bit like lower energy, but he's happy. I see a smile on his face. He feels like joy, he feels joy about America. And, and listener, you should like reach out and let us know. You should be like, Sam, way to go. Like you helped me, you made him end on a high note. You made him talk about like how capitalism is good. And we'd love to hear those kinds of things.
Sam (57:47.654)
Not completely depressed. Yeah.
Uggghhhh
shawn (58:06.97)
Matt, just don't tell Sam that you gave him the points just out of charity. Just so he would be happy. Just don't let him know that.
Matt (58:13.648)
I've done that before. He doesn't like those kind of points. I only do that if I want to like be mean to him, but I'm trying to like praise Sam this week.
Sam (58:17.738)
no meritocracy I believe in meritocracy meritocracy yes
shawn (58:23.226)
Aha, nice, nice.
Matt (58:26.032)
We're gonna end on that. Hey, listener, talk to you again next week.
Sam (58:27.43)
Alright.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories