The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
Episode 71: RESPECT for elementary education, capitalism v meta-Marxism, Right wing reaction to Trump conviction, MLB reconciles racial injustice
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Mailbag: Carly’s recording
The Thought Provoker:
Shawn is up first this week. An anonymous expert recently participated in a debate discussing Meta-Marxism and capitalism. They discussed how the theory of meta Marxism primarily looks at all relationships through the lens of power and power imbalance while capitalism looks at relationships through the lens of self-interested and trade. Is one theory moral and the other immoral or are they both just ways to govern and either is fine?
Next up, Matt. Right wing media figures are attacking the US system of justice following Trump’s conviction on 34 felonies this week. Charlie Kirk tweeted “indict the left or lose America”, Matt Walsh tweeted that the “The only thing I want to hear from [Republicans] is which Democrats they will have arrested.” Representative Mike Collins tweeted, “Time for Red State AGs and DAs to get busy.” I know Sam plans to vote for Trump, but are he and Shawn willing to defend this kind of rhetoric?
Finally, Sam. Nada, nada, nothing
The Big Question: Major League Baseball has officially incorporated Negro Leagues statistics into the Major League record. As result of Wednesday's integration, Negro Leagues legend Josh Gibson is now baseball's all-time leader in career batting average (.372, beating out Ty Cobb's .366), slugging percentage (.718, beating out Babe Ruth's .690), and OPS (1.177, beating out Ruth's 1.164). Gibson is also the new single-season leader in those categories. MLB has a historian who works for them who developed a team to do the research that allowed for these updates. Is this a model for how other groups in the US can deal with historical racial injustice?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:04.773)
Welcome to Real Mormonism. We're glad you're with us today. It's good to have you. I'm Matt, joined by Sam and Sean, and we're ready to talk about all kinds of fun stuff. First, we have to talk about... So last week we had a recording from Carly and we didn't play it. So we're going to start with the recording from Carly. She had some feedback for us about something we discussed a little while ago and we're going to react to that. So...
Sam (00:31.11)
All right, let's go to it. Here we go.
So I am here this week just to clarify some things that were said on last week's podcast that misrepresented my beliefs. It was said that I was frustrated being in the early childhood education program because I felt like I was surrounded by people who just wanted to get married. When in fact, I was frustrated with that stereotype because even though I struggled,
Matt (01:07.461)
That's it. She's mad that that Sam has represented her position. I feel like.
Sam (01:08.678)
Wait, one moment, one moment, one moment, one moment. Hang on just a second.
shawn (01:08.729)
No, this is tension building.
Sam (01:17.03)
to work their butt off to end up, you know, and they're paid.
it's because they believe in what they're doing and believe that their work is so important, which has been scientifically proven over and over again.
what we're taught and how we're taught and the relationships we have in those early years of life are so important and then.
Hang on, I don't know why this keeps stopping.
shawn (01:49.645)
Sam.
Matt (01:49.701)
Bravo Carly, bravo. That sounds like an indictment on capitalism to me. Scientifically proven that what she does is important, scientifically proven that we should be investing in that as a society and yet for some reason they're way underpaid. I so agree with you Carly.
Sam (01:54.246)
I don't know.
shawn (01:54.253)
Does not. That has nothing to do with capitalism.
shawn (02:07.181)
That has nothing to do with capitalism, you know? What are you talking about?
Sam (02:09.294)
So I think what she's saying is, is it's a super important job, super important role. And I think she wants it to be taken super serious at BYU and other places. And I think her initial concern was it wasn't. And I think as she gets further into it, she realizes, Hey, this is a super important job, super important role and something that probably needs to be a little bit better paid, a little bit better prominence, a little bit better respected.
Matt (02:11.013)
capitalism.
shawn (02:20.045)
Yeah.
Matt (02:34.021)
Hey Carly, I couldn't agree with you more. Your problem is that you're in Utah and you're surrounded by members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter -day Saints who don't value that and don't pay for that. You need to move to a liberal state. Go to New York City, go to Oregon, go to Washington. Places like that will pay you. Go to California, they'll pay you handsomely for this labor. The.
shawn (02:54.317)
Do you have references? Can you cite references for that, Matt?
Sam (02:57.766)
they will pay you handsomely to live in a place where crime is high and respect is low and the overall rating for those elementary education or any education is so low.
shawn (03:04.813)
Sam, don't bite.
shawn (03:10.957)
Sam, Matt is pulling that out of nowhere. There's no reference he provided.
Matt (03:12.933)
No, really Sean, you're gonna tell me that teachers salary, elementary school teachers salary is not higher in California, Washington, Oregon, New York, Massachusetts. It's higher Sean, we've had this conversation before. The teachers in Utah are the lowest paid.
shawn (03:20.206)
Show it. Show it. Show it.
Sam (03:21.766)
Well, it is, it is higher. There's no question it's higher. Yeah. Yeah. So Carly, Carly, thank you for the feedback. We stand corrected. Carly stands as one of the few guests we've had played an audio clip of. So nice job Carly. And we're excited that, that she was able to be on and she's recovering today from a little procedure on her foot. So she's a, you know, a homebound for a couple of few days or a week or so. So, hope you enjoy this episode.
shawn (03:27.053)
Show it.
Matt (03:36.773)
Yeah, that's true. That's true.
shawn (03:49.549)
I wish, I'd like to give Carly points and take them away like negative points from Matt for trying to hijack her topic and trying to pull it towards like liberalism and like bipartisanship. Carly was actually bringing up a really important topic, right? And that is respected. So good job, Carly.
Sam (03:54.95)
Yeah, I'd fully take him away from that. Definitely. Definitely take away from that.
Matt (03:58.021)
my goodness. my goodness. Hey!
Sam (04:06.598)
Good job, Carly.
Matt (04:07.685)
Wait, her point is respect? That's her really good point.
shawn (04:10.669)
No, I respect it. No, I respect it. She is respected.
Sam (04:10.758)
Respected. Respected.
Matt (04:13.477)
got it, got it. Hey, listener, if you're wondering why is it that Sam is so mean to so many listeners when they write in and he's so kind to Carly when she does a voice message, that's right. So don't take it personally, everybody else. Sam has a soft spot in his heart for Carly, as do we all. We all love Carly.
Sam (04:23.43)
Carly's my daughter. Yeah.
shawn (04:25.261)
Hahaha.
Sam (04:31.846)
Boy, that wasn't there a lot of animosity from last week's topic out there. I sure got a lot of feedback. I think, I think, I think, I think my friends were probably different than your friends, which is why I stick with my friends, but go ahead.
Matt (04:36.773)
Yes, yes, yes, yes. Sam was Sam. Sam told us he was angry and listeners could feel it.
Matt (04:47.461)
All right. Well, so that's the whole mailbag. Carly gets to be the whole mailbag this week because we see Sam being nice in response to listeners and we want to embrace that. And we want to just kind of revel in that a little bit and let and remember listener Sam can be nice if he really, really wants to. Okay. We'll move into the thought provoker and Sean is up first this week.
shawn (04:47.533)
hahahaha
Sam (04:51.814)
Okay. Good job, Carly.
Sam (04:57.894)
Points to Carly.
shawn (05:11.181)
Okay, we're going deep, Sam. So get ready, we're going deep. We're going theory, theory and principles. And I'd love to, Matt, I would love to name the persons, the people that were involved in this debate, but I don't know that you would respect them.
Sam (05:13.798)
boy. boy.
Matt (05:22.725)
Hey Sean, I've got scriptures. I don't respect anyone as much as the scriptures I'm going to share with you after you introduce your topic. So I'm excited to hear you repent on air.
shawn (05:29.517)
Excellent! That is excellent!
Sam (05:29.83)
Mmm.
shawn (05:33.389)
Okay, good. Whoa, dang. Okay, so these anonymous experts were having this really great debate. They participated in this debate and where they were, no, not at all. Nope, nope, none of those guys.
Matt (05:40.997)
Charlie Kirk, Ben Shapiro, Turning Point USA. Yeah, if you don't name them, Shama, I'm gonna name them for you. Megan Kelly. Elmo and the gang at Sesame Street.
shawn (05:52.205)
Gosh, dude. Matt, just because you accused Sam of being mean and then you say things with a smile and a happy voice doesn't mean you're not the same way, Matt.
Matt (06:03.205)
Okay, I take it back, Sean. I believe that you have legitimate sources for these things and you're just not sharing them because you don't want to make me mad. And so I'll be quiet now.
shawn (06:11.309)
Well, you have a very, how do we say, a hoity -toity version of who's an expert. So, okay, so they were discussing the new concept of metamarxism. And I know that might be triggering for Matt, but metamarxism, we won't go into the definition.
Matt (06:27.557)
I love Karl Marx. I love meta analysis. Meta and Marx. It's fine with me. I love it. I'm good. I'm good with that.
shawn (06:33.965)
Okay, good, good. So they're discussing metamarcism versus capitalism. And they discussed how the theory of metamarcism primarily looks at all, now listen here, Sam, I'm so curious about your comments here. So metamarcism looks primarily at all relationships through the lens of power and power imbalance, while capitalism looks at relationships primarily through the lens of self -interest and trade.
So I know that's abstract, but we'll get into the deep. So is one theory moral and the other immoral, or are they both just ways to govern? And either is fine.
Matt (07:07.237)
No, no, it makes sense.
Matt (07:15.365)
Well, I'm gonna take the position that capitalism is immoral and I'm gonna use scriptures to support that. So that's fine, if you want me to go first, I'll wait.
Sam (07:19.142)
no.
shawn (07:19.341)
I'm so shocked. I'm so shocked. Hey Matt, Matt, I'm also, yeah, but I'm also gonna have, I mean, if you're gonna go that way, you're also gonna have to defend that the Marxist view, that viewing relationships through power is moral too, because that's an easy one to do.
Sam (07:23.654)
Thank you.
Matt (07:35.877)
Well, that's not Marxism. That's what you called Meta -Marxism. That's not Karl Marx.
shawn (07:41.343)
It is two Karl Marx, it is absolutely 100 % Karl Marx.
Matt (07:44.613)
no, Karl Marx is about who owns the means of production, not about power. No, his no Marxism is about ownership, which is the same thing that I'm going to use to address capital capitalism.
shawn (07:49.421)
That's right. Same thing. Same thing. Same thing. Nope.
shawn (07:57.389)
And those who have ownership have power and those who don't have ownership have no power and therefore it must be taken from those who have the power. It's a relationship, it's commentary on relationships and who has power. We'll get into it. Go ahead, go ahead.
Matt (08:12.709)
Wait, I want to let Sam go first.
Sam (08:12.87)
So, so, so it's interesting cause this does relate a little bit to last week, right? So you think about free market, you think about our economy, you think of democracy, you think about what this country stands for. And I'll tell you, after we recorded last week, I was depressed for hours. Like your, your thoughts on, yeah, your thoughts on like democracy and like the American dream and the ability to get yourself further ahead. It depressed me.
shawn (08:18.189)
It does. It does.
shawn (08:28.493)
Matt (08:30.213)
So are our listeners.
shawn (08:32.237)
Wow.
Sam (08:40.55)
And then, and then I listened to it. I had other people listen to the podcast. They're like, the idea that this American dream, that this vision of America as a land of opportunity and a place to come to better yourself is dead or dying is sad. And I think it is sad. And, you know, you go back to the concept that we talked about last week, you know, people taking risk. And by the way, we don't, we don't only take, we don't only take risk with our money.
Matt (08:40.869)
Hmm.
Sam (09:10.054)
Because not everybody has the same amounts of money, but we all have the same amount of time. People take risk with time, which is life. And in America, you're better able to risk time and life to get yourself ahead than anywhere else. And, and Sean, when you think about this, you know, which of these two systems, I believe in the free market. I believe in, in our,
you know, in our version of the economy right now, you know, you're looking, wait, wait, hang on just a sec. You're looking at Marxism versus capitalism. I believe in capitalism. And, and, and, and I want to share just an example this past week. So we did an open house for one of our stores in the Chicagoland. And the person who was doing the catering was a lady from China. And she and I talked and she's like, Hey, I recently went back to Vietnam. I went back to China. I visited family and friends. I'm like,
Matt (09:42.757)
Well wait, hold on.
Sam (10:07.878)
How great for you. She said it was terrible. I said, why was it terrible? She said, because I realized I can't go back to China and be respected there. I said, why can't you? She said, because when I go back to China, she said, I'm seen as having a specific place in that world socially. And the government has put me in a place. I'm a daughter of a humble worker who's died, who can never ever get ahead. And she said,
I could never have the opportunities there in China that I have here. The government will ensure I never starve there, but they'll never let me get ahead. And she said, I go, she said, I go back to China and I visit and they want to put me right back in that box. Even though she said, I've taken a ton of risk with my time and my money here in the U S and it's paid off and I've gotten ahead. She said, I go back there and it all disappears. And that is the difference.
shawn (10:45.645)
Relationships of Power, Matt. That's Marxism.
Sam (11:06.374)
communist China, Russia, some of these, some of these other countries with dictators and others at the helm may give a vision that they're not going to allow people to die or go hungry or suffer, but they're never going to be given the opportunity to get ahead. And anybody that says by risking time, money, resources, a portion of your life, you can't get ahead here in the U S has a terrible view.
of what it means to be American. And, and every single, we talk often about what the, the church approach should be. Every single member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter -day Saints should defend that freedom of choice, should defend that free market, should defend capitalism, because it's in there we're able to self -realize. They do. Okay.
Matt (11:54.021)
They don't all go together, Sam. First of all, I want to say this. As Sam shared his story about the woman who went to China, it reminded me of the way that Sam likes to make fun of Sean's evangelical friends, that he thinks that they're imaginary friends. What Sam described to me sounded an awful lot like the plot to the movie, Crazy Rich Asians. And so I wonder if maybe, yeah, have you not seen Crazy Rich Asians?
Sam (12:14.822)
really? No, I could actually get you, I could get us a recording of this person. I thought her story was beautiful. Honestly, I was a little skeptical when she started sharing it with me because I'm like, hey, this fits a little too nice and neat into my own worldview. But here's, well, she's from China, Matt. And she went to Vietnam, was treated very well there, had a great story about what her experience was like.
Matt (12:21.957)
No, no, it's fine. I -
shawn (12:23.181)
Ha ha ha ha ha!
Matt (12:33.445)
Yeah, maybe she watched Crazy Rich Asians and shared it with you.
Matt (12:43.557)
I'm telling you.
Sam (12:44.422)
and then depressed going back to China because they will not allow her to get ahead. Matt, do you want to live in a country where your needs are taken care of and you can never fall through the social net, but you don't have the opportunity to rise above whatever station you're in?
Matt (12:46.821)
Okay.
shawn (12:48.397)
All right. Good story. Yeah, that's interesting, Sam.
Matt (12:50.565)
First of all...
Matt (12:57.029)
That's not capitalism, Sam. That's not capitalism. You have that in India. Listen.
shawn (12:58.477)
But hang on. So hang on, hang on, hang on. The topic though, taking Sam's story, is going a bit deeper into the fact that these philosophies, so Marxist philosophies, they talk about the nature of relationships, as does capitalism. And that's the part I'm fascinated by. I'm less fascinated by the politics.
Sam (13:01.126)
It's a free market.
Sam (13:05.254)
in the United States.
Matt (13:16.837)
I have a listen, I'm going to say this. The United States is not a capitalist system. You cannot name for me any market in the United States that is a truly free and unregulated market. So there is no capitalism in the United States. The United States is a socialist system with a little bit of, with a little bit of free market, aspects or components of it. So if you want to say capitalism, you can't say the United. Okay. So.
shawn (13:32.685)
That's not true.
shawn (13:39.853)
No, I think it's opposite. No, no, no, it's opposite. You can't do it. No, no, we're not just going to let you get away with that. It's a capitalist society with a lot of socialism involved. Yeah, it is.
Sam (13:44.134)
The fact that the fact that kids, the fact that kids go to school and learn that is terrible. It's terrible.
Matt (13:45.925)
No it's not, Sean. Tell me -
It's true. Okay, hey Sam, can I open up my own doctor's office tomorrow and start prescribing drugs to people? Why? Because it's not a free market in healthcare. Can I just start, can I open a business without a license from the government and just start selling goods and services? No, you need a business license to do that. Do I need a food handler's permit in order to sell food to the general public? Eventually.
shawn (13:52.045)
Hehehehe. Hehehehehe.
Sam (13:57.286)
No, because.
shawn (14:01.101)
But Matt, but Matt, hang on, but Matt, but Matt, but Matt, there's, Matt, yes you can. Yes you can. There are, no you do not, Matt. Matt, you do not.
shawn (14:15.085)
Eventually, yeah, eventually. Yeah, you do. Mm -hmm. Yeah, you can. No, you can. Matt.
Matt (14:17.733)
I can't just start selling stuff. Everything in the United States is regulated. And the fact that there's regulation means that you don't have a capitalist system. So if you want to talk.
shawn (14:26.445)
Okay, but that's irrelevant. Okay, now you're hijacking the topic. That's irrelevant.
Matt (14:29.733)
No, I'm not. You create this like this, this, this, this is what capitalism is and this is what metamarcism is. And you divorce the two ideas from each other.
shawn (14:35.597)
Not okay, but Matt, the nature of the question is this. When you view your relationships in your world, with your wife, with your family, with your friends, do you view them through a lens of I am an individual who through scripture is commanded to seek out my own righteousness, my own happiness, and then I'm going, and then I am to engage with my friends and my family in a way that can mutually lift.
Matt (14:55.109)
Wait a minute. What is that? Is that Marxism you're describing?
shawn (15:04.205)
We trade with each other, we mutually live. Or Marxism says, no, I'll describe Marxism now. Marxism says, I am gonna view my relationship with people based on power, based on whether I'm oppressed or I am the oppressor. That's exactly what, Mark, I've read the Communist Manifesto many, many times. I've studied it.
Matt (15:04.933)
That's Marxism. That's Marxism. Wait, no, what you just described is Marxism.
Matt (15:16.677)
No, that's not what... that's not what Marxism says. That's not what Marxism says.
Sam (15:20.938)
Hey, hey, could, could, could I make, can I make a quick comment? I don't think any of our, I don't think any of our listeners care. One or the other. Here's, here's what I think people care about. Okay.
shawn (15:27.821)
No! No!
Matt (15:31.205)
Okay, I'm gonna make my point.
shawn (15:31.669)
Yeah. No, no, no. Hang on. Sam made his point, Matt. Before you make your, hang on, hang on. Before you make your point, let me give you a couple of examples, okay? Here's one example of how metamarcism or Marxism has infiltrated people's minds and they view relationships through the balance of power. Here's one example. You look at the universities and the college students who have been protesting and protesting and protesting. You ask many of these kids, hey, where did Israel come from?
Matt (15:37.957)
Okay, let me. Okay, all right.
shawn (16:00.493)
Germany maybe? I think Germany is where I go. And then you ask, well, who do you support? And they, in their minds, you can see it turning. Well, I'm supposed to make the decision on who is the oppressed because they're the moral ones. And who is the oppressor because they're the immoral ones because Marxism is all about taking the assets, the production from the powerful and balancing that with them. So in the end, all these kids say,
Matt (16:13.957)
No.
Matt (16:25.029)
No.
shawn (16:27.149)
Israel is the evil one because they're the oppressor. America is the evil one because they're the oppressor. They have all the power. Palestine is the oppressed and so they are the moral ones. That's one example. Another example, another example, Matt, in higher education, if you ask anyone, what is the most patriarchal structured organization in the world? They're going to say what? Marriage. Marriage is a patriarchy. Yes, they are. Yes, they are. And it is oppressive.
Matt (16:31.301)
No. No.
Matt (16:36.645)
Okay, so here's why.
Matt (16:50.885)
No, they're not gonna say -
I was gonna say, Sean, do you have to really start citing these sources now? Because I don't know.
shawn (16:58.829)
Matt, you said that in this podcast like five episodes ago that marriage is viewed as an oppressive patriarchy. You said it yourself. I'll reference you.
Matt (17:07.365)
There are some forms of marriage are viewed that way. If you were to ask me, what's the most oppressive patriarchy? I never said marriage is the most oppressive patriarchy. No, no, no. I said that there is oppression in marriage and there is patriarchy in marriage and it reinforces patriarchy. But I didn't say it's the institution that's the most patriarchal. So this is what I'm going to say. This isn't my argument for why capitalism is evil. It's fine, Sean. If you want to say Marxism is evil, that's fine. That doesn't bother me.
shawn (17:14.221)
Yes, you did. You absolutely did. I'll pull it up.
shawn (17:20.045)
No, you didn't.
Okay, I'll bring up the reference.
You absolutely did. I will pull up the reference later. All right, you go ahead.
shawn (17:36.717)
I'm not, I'm not, I'm not asking even what's right or wrong. I'm asking about the nature of relationships.
Matt (17:42.693)
Okay, the problem with capitalism is capitalism puts a premium on not trade, not exchange, on property. And capitalism holds private property as something that's inviolate. And so what that tells people is you can own land, you can own resources, and that's an immoral thing because we all as citizens of the world, as human beings, we all have stewardship over natural resources.
shawn (17:45.549)
That's another question.
Matt (18:10.981)
We all have stewardship over the planet. And when you start, when you create a system that says people can own people, people can own property, people can own the land, then you take away from human beings their right to stewardship or their power to be stewards over that which they've been given. So capitalism is immoral because it places such a high premium on property, not competition, not self -interest, property.
shawn (18:35.245)
So here's, so Matt, here's, so I kind of disagree with that, but even if I stick with that, what about in the Doctrine of Covenants, where it talks about the sacred right of private property? You can't deny that.
Matt (18:46.181)
Well, let's go to Doctrine and Covenants 19, where it says, and again, I command thee that thou shalt not covet thine own property. Or where...
shawn (18:53.837)
The commandment is not, Matt, the commandment there, the law there is not that property is evil. It's that coveting property is evil.
Matt (19:01.029)
You can't covet it if you don't have it. How about this one from Doctrine and Covenants 117 verses 4, verse 4, Let them repent of all their sins and of all their covetous desires before me, saith the Lord. For what is property? What is property unto me, saith the Lord.
shawn (19:03.533)
That's not what it's saying. That's not what it's saying you nut.
shawn (19:15.085)
Matt, Matt, Matt, it has nothing to do, coveting has nothing to do with owning property.
Matt (19:21.477)
And if you want to go to ancient scripture, Old Testament, New Testament, you'll see nothing in there that justifies the idea that people can own land, that people can own other people, that people can own property. So you do have one section in the Doctrine and Covenants that suggests that we should, that governments should protect property rights. But that's far from saying that that's the righteous and moral thing to do is to let people own land. Okay, I'll be quiet because I'm making sandboard.
shawn (19:49.581)
No, I say I monologued for a long time. He had his say. That was good.
Matt (19:53.541)
When I see Sam's eyes glaze over, I say, we have to move on from this because if Sam is bored, everybody is bored and doesn't.
shawn (20:00.493)
He's a big boy. He's a big boy. He could, he could take a sip of a red bull and he'll be into it.
Sam (20:03.814)
I just, I, I, I, I'm honestly just shocked that you're saying that within the U S it's immoral to have property ownership rights and property rights. And like, like it, it is, I do, I do.
shawn (20:11.149)
Hahaha
Matt (20:12.613)
I'm saying that the United States is not a capitalist system and that it's immoral to say you can own land.
shawn (20:21.005)
Matt, how do you respond, Matt, to DNC? Here, I'm gonna find it and I'll read it.
Sam (20:24.326)
my goodness. I don't even care. Listen, listen, Sean, let's focus up for just, let's focus up for just one second. Can we focus up? it doesn't. Nobody cares. Nobody cares about the Marxist approach. Nobody cares about communism right now. What
shawn (20:29.037)
No, I like this. Sam, this represents the thinking, the thought process of many on the left and it's problematic.
Math, I mean Sam, in your little bubble maybe not, but the entire world is going in the direction of Marxism. Yes, everyone cares. We have to care.
Matt (20:46.341)
You have to save us, Sam.
Sam (20:48.102)
But but they don't call it Marxism. If you call it Marxism, people are gonna people are gonna think about communist Russia back in the 1960s, 70s, 80s, and it doesn't apply to them.
shawn (20:54.157)
Find the principles, Sam, the principles of Marxism is what we're talking about here. How Marxists view relationships.
Sam (21:02.566)
I agree. I agree with that. The view that Matt has about not owning property and not having a stewardship over that property. Like it depresses me to think that Matt is teaching students at a school like.
Matt (21:12.183)
We all.
shawn (21:13.421)
Hang on, so watch Sam. Sam, can I, can I, Sam, Sam, can I drop, can I drop, can I drop the mic on Matt right now? Hang on, Sam, Sam. Sam, Sam, Sam. No, Sam, listen, listen to this. Okay, listen to this, Doctrine and Covenants 134.
Matt (21:16.453)
We all have stewardship over the land, collective universal stewardship. Capitalism ruins it.
Sam (21:23.782)
Have you, have you not heard the parable about the virgins? Like, have you not the talents? Like, have you, do you not?
Sam (21:35.814)
I almost need to log off. I don't even care. Okay, go ahead, Sean. Sorry. No, I don't. I want to, cause listen, this is a big problem that Matt doesn't believe in the American dream and that he doesn't think that America with all of its property ownership and capitalist granted, there's a little bit of social leanings because there is regulation for help than some other things. But by and large, like,
shawn (21:39.693)
You don't care about the scripture? Why? What on earth, dude? No.
Sam (22:05.51)
Going back to the idea, you can risk in this country and get ahead. You can't do that in these other countries. And at the core of that, Sean, is this idea of ownership and stewardship and having property. And if you can't have that, we're toast. The fact that Matt is teaching kids, that is crazy, Sean.
shawn (22:11.597)
Okay
Matt (22:22.437)
Jesus teaches us.
shawn (22:22.669)
Hang on Matt, no, no. Matt, hang on Matt.
Matt (22:26.725)
Law of Consecration, Law of Consecration, give all your property back to the Lord. We don't need to own things. We don't need to have things. I'm just trying to live the higher law.
Sam (22:33.094)
Dude, dude. Yeah. Cause, cause, cause that worked so well in Navu and it worked well for Joseph Smith. And that's why they all decided to stay put where they were. Right.
shawn (22:34.477)
Alright Matt.
Matt.
shawn (22:43.853)
I'm taking back. Hey, I'm taking back the topic. It's my topic. Okay, you veered off and not answer the question. That's okay, but I am gonna end
Matt (22:50.021)
Are you crazy? I completely answered your question. Capitalism is, capitalism is, well, because I disagree with your premise, but capitalism is, listen, on the fundamental level, Marxism says no property, capitalism says property. Let's get down to everything else, and that's what it's about. Capitalism is immoral because it says own property.
shawn (22:52.845)
You said nothing about relationships.
shawn (22:58.861)
It's still the question, you can't change the question.
shawn (23:07.053)
All right, so Matt, so now, hang on. Well, you're wrong about that, but here, let me drop it on you. D &C, okay, listen up, Sam, Sam, listen up. D &C 134. Sam, listen up, listen up. We can bring in the doctrine, this is easy. Okay, Matt, I want your true honest response to this. Give me your true honest response to this, Matt. D &C 134. We believe, okay, this is a we believe verse. We believe, hang on, hang on.
Sam (23:13.826)
my goodness.
Sam (23:17.638)
Cause the church doesn't own property or anything stuff wise. Yeah, go ahead.
Okay. Let's, let's use doctor and the prop of our point. Okay.
Matt (23:34.597)
I know, we believe. It's like a group of people in Kirtland, Ohio, writing a statement about government. Go on, we believe, the government. I understand, but so are the ones that I shared with you, our canonized scripture. Yes, the Lord says to give all of your surplus property. The Lord says that, that's Doctrine and Covenants 43. I'll put the references in the show notes.
shawn (23:36.813)
Hang on. Matt, Matt, this, this is canonized scripture.
You didn't share any scriptures, not a single one!
shawn (23:53.869)
It never says that! Don't quote nothing! Give me a reference to that. Okay. No, bring it up now if you're gonna quote it.
Matt (24:01.477)
The law of consecration says to give all of your property away. The higher law of the Lord is get rid of your property. Okay. All right, let's.
shawn (24:04.941)
It doesn't say that.
No it's not. Okay here, let me read it. Okay, DNC 134. I want your response. We believe that no government can exist in peace except such laws are framed and held inviolate as will secure to each individual the free exercise of conscience, the right and control of property, and the protection of life.
Matt (24:27.557)
Okay, Sean, that sentence that you just read does not say that we believe that private property is a good thing or anything like it. It says that a government cannot exist in peace. Is that what this says?
shawn (24:28.909)
No, answer to it. Answer it. Yeah.
shawn (24:41.389)
We believe that no government can exist in peace except for these laws are protected.
Matt (24:44.421)
Yeah, okay. So that's talking about how to have a peaceful government, right? So that doesn't really tell us anything about whether or not private property is good or bad.
shawn (24:50.313)
Why would he put in there that the control of property is necessary, that we believe that it's necessary for our society? it's not scripture. you believe it's not scripture.
Matt (24:55.109)
Why would he? This is a group of guys in Kirtland. It is scripture, of course it's scripture. Who's the he?
Sam (25:02.886)
Hey, by the way, if you, if you don't, if, if you don't have property ownership, how are you able to consecrate anything? If you don't own it, how are you supposed to pay a tithing on anything? If you don't own it, how are you supposed to, because tithing is a 10 % of nothing. Like.
Matt (25:13.733)
You give it all away. You get whatever you get to give it back. Listen, it starts with tithing, but you covenant to give everything you have to the Lord, right? So you don't need to own anything. I'm just sharing with you scriptures.
shawn (25:16.365)
Ha ha ha ha ha.
shawn (25:22.029)
Matt, Matt, repent, Matt, repent, Matt. We believe that governments will be framed and held in violet as we'll secure to each other the free conscious, exercise of conscious, the right and control of property and the protection of life. That is doctrine, that is scripture. It's pretty clear.
Sam (25:27.462)
Yeah, but in.
Matt (25:41.669)
All right. That's not saying what you think it's saying, Sean. That's all I'm saying.
Sam (25:46.374)
I think the LDS churches view on property ownership. And I think the gospel view is a balance between capitalism and, it's a balance. It, I think it supports the principle of free enterprise and personal responsibility while emphasizing ethical behavior, stewardship, clarity, and community support. You can't have tithing unless you own something. You, you,
shawn (26:10.573)
And Matt, don't you think in the eternal perspective, the whole idea is that God created everything based on existing element, right? The first verse is right in the King Follett discourse. He talks about how God didn't create everything from nothing. He took existing element and organized it. Isn't that a model for how we are supposed to learn to become more like Him? Is to take property, yeah, take existing property.
Matt (26:29.605)
We're supposed to take other things? Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. Now you're gonna take the idea of the creation, that it's not ex nihilo, that there were already things there that somehow ownership, and that's private, that was God's property, and then this is his property? Stewardship is not property ownership. Stewardship is not ownership.
shawn (26:44.621)
It's stewardship over the existing materials, which we can say property. Well, no, but I think it is because remember in Moses when God said, okay, we created the world and then we put the laws in place and then we watched until these things obeyed. I think that's a reference to, I think that is a reference to ownership. No, I'm not saying God owns us. I'm saying,
Sam (26:52.998)
Here, here, here, here.
Matt (27:03.237)
That's not ownership. God does not own us.
Sam (27:05.638)
in Doctrine and Covenants 42, 32, that will remember the poor and consecrate of thy properties for their support. You can't consecrate something that you don't have, right?
Matt (27:16.613)
Right, give it to them. Give it to them.
shawn (27:16.781)
Whose properties? Whose properties? Whose properties, Sam?
Matt (27:23.205)
He wants you to give it away. You can accumulate things to give it away.
Sam (27:24.678)
Thou shall be diligent in preserving what thou hast, that thou mayest be a wise steward, for it is the free gift of the Lord thy God, and thou art his steward.
shawn (27:35.949)
Matt, do you own any property? Matt, do you own any? Do you own it? But you said owning property is evil. You said it's evil. Well, why do you do evil things?
Matt (27:36.133)
I'm just saying, I'm just saying we live in a capitalist system. Of course I own property. We live in a capitalist system. It is, it is. Because that's the law that we live under.
shawn (27:48.845)
There's no law that you have to own your house or car, Matt.
Matt (27:51.269)
Yes, of course there is. If I don't own my house or car, then how do I prosper in current society? Of course I have to live that way.
Sam (27:56.23)
The United Order didn't even work. That's what's funny. And in Ukraine, the church couldn't buy the land that the temple sits on because there was no property ownership. So you're looking at two, you're looking at two, you're defending that?
shawn (27:56.685)
So you're sacrificing.
Matt (28:05.989)
Exactly. Exactly.
Matt (28:11.461)
I'm saying that in heaven there will be no property ownership. There are systems of government where there's no, well, Sean asked me about right or wrong, moral good, bad. Like how am I supposed to look other than how heaven is? In heaven there's no property ownership. Of course she does. Okay, so we're going to give me the points on this one. I feel like you guys kind of moved my way. You're ready to, okay, Sean wants the points.
Sam (28:14.566)
Yeah, but we're not in heaven, Matt. We're not in heaven.
Sean.
shawn (28:23.757)
I hope your wife listens to this, Matt. And you guys have a...
shawn (28:31.917)
I'm taking the point. I'm taking the points myself.
Sam (28:35.558)
I'm, I'm on, I'm on track to be more depressed after this episode than last week, which actually is saying a lot seriously.
shawn (28:37.581)
I actually... Matt, you have to stop depressing Sam!
Matt (28:43.172)
You
It's hard for Sam the capitalist to think about the idea that some people think he shouldn't own anything. You shouldn't own anything, Sam.
Sam (28:53.894)
It, it makes me sad. It makes me sad to think that there are people that become angry thinking that they can't do better than where they are today.
shawn (28:54.381)
Yeah, that's wrong, Matt. That violates scripture.
Matt (29:03.045)
I'm not angry. I'm super happy. I can't wait for the day to give everything I have to the poor. Like that's super exciting.
shawn (29:10.285)
Do it now, you hypocrite. Do it now! I can't wait for the day that someone forces me to give stuff to the poor. If you're so excited about it, do it, you fool! Then do it!
Sam (29:11.078)
Yeah, but you wouldn't, you wouldn't, you would have nothing to give to the poor. Wait, Matt, Matt, wait, Sean, Matt, you would have nothing to give to the poor if you had no ownership over anything. You're excited to amass to be able to then pass it along. Like there's nothing more inherent in the gospel of Jesus Christ and the church of Jesus Christ of Latter -day Saints.
Matt (29:17.573)
No one's gonna force you. No one's forcing you.
Matt (29:26.949)
Yes, that's a really good point.
Sam (29:36.134)
a church with a multi hundreds of billions of dollars sitting in a bank account somewhere. Like we believe in property ownership. We believe in a free market. We believe in capitalism. It's a balanced capitalism, but my gosh, you can't honestly, truly believe what you say you're believing.
Matt (29:48.261)
Okay.
Okay, we have to move on. I'm going to give Sam the points for questioning whether I truly believe the things I say on this podcast. He gets lots of points for that. Okay. Yeah, yeah, I love you guys. No, but by the way, I do really believe this stuff, but it's still fun. I love talking about this with you guys. Okay, because honestly, I can see the pain in Sam's eyes.
shawn (29:57.933)
Yes, me too then. Okay. Yep. I agree. Matt, I love you so much, dude. Thanks for always being a country, being a contrarian.
Sam (30:00.742)
Ugh.
shawn (30:18.125)
You
Sam (30:18.854)
It just makes me so, makes me so sad.
Matt (30:18.949)
But I know that he still loves me even though he's like, okay. So right -wing media figures are attacking the U S system of justice following Trump's conviction on 34 felonies this week. Charlie Kirk. I think Charlie Kirk is the turning point USA guy. He tweeted indict the left or lose America. Matt Walsh. I think he's a one of those Ben Shapiro guys. He tweeted. The only thing I want to hear from Republicans is which Democrats they will have arrested.
And Representative Mike Collins, he's a House Republican, tweeted, time for red state attorney generals and DAs to get busy. So I know that Sam plans to vote for Trump, but I want to know, Sam and Sean, are you going to defend this kind of rhetoric?
shawn (31:02.701)
I know Sam's gonna come down on this, so let me get my opinion first and then I'll shut up. Is that okay, Sam?
Sam (31:07.366)
Awesome. It's all good. Yep. We're excited to hear your you should absolutely go first.
Matt (31:07.781)
Yeah, okay. You can go first, Sean.
shawn (31:09.133)
Okay, so since you both have thrown your hat in this race, I'm really, I think the only one who's qualified as a non -biased opinion on this matter. So I'm gonna give it first. Yeah, yeah. I've not thrown my hat. You both are like staunch supporters of Trump and Biden. I will not, absolutely will not.
Matt (31:19.781)
Really? You're non -biased, John?
Sean, you will not vote for Donald Trump. I know for a fact you will not vote for Donald Trump and you will not vote for Joe Biden. But that doesn't make you unbiased.
shawn (31:32.269)
That's why I am unbiased. So thank you, Sam. Thank you, Sam. So Matt, to your answer like directly, no, I'm not gonna defend the rhetoric, but two things can be true at once. One, it is right to prosecute a law breaker like Trump, right? If it's against the law, that's right. The second thing is right.
Sam (31:34.214)
Matt, are you gonna allow him to share his opinion on this? Matt. Okay.
Matt (31:37.441)
sorry.
shawn (31:55.917)
It is absolutely wrong to prosecute your political rival in order to affect the outcome of an election, especially when the accusations of a felony falsification of business records. Sorry, I studied the whole thing. It's kind of a weak prosecution. It's kind of a weak felony. To me, it is clearly politically motivated. And both those things can be true. Both of them can be true. Well, is it the state of New York, right? So the DA, whoops.
Matt (32:09.381)
Wait, wait, who prosecuted Trump?
Matt (32:18.469)
But who did it? What role did Joe Biden have in any of this?
shawn (32:25.645)
is New York and it's DA. Are they left -leaning or right -leaning?
Matt (32:31.397)
I know, but when you say prosecute political enemies, who's prosecuting their political enemies? Are you saying Joe Biden is prosecuting his political enemies?
shawn (32:37.357)
The, no, I'm saying that the Democrat party and those on the left who hate Trump are doing whatever they can to interfere now in, which is, it's hilarious too, because did you see that Donald Trump, his campaign announced on Friday evening that they've raised nearly $53 million within 24 hours of his felony conviction? That is more now than I think Biden has. So well done guys, good job.
Matt (33:02.821)
No, no, I was just trying to clarify. Okay, so I get it. Alright, Sam, what do you say?
Sam (33:07.054)
Well, I mean, I think it's a mess. We texted the night the verdict came down. Like, can you imagine like a bigger tension going on in the world right now? So, I mean, I, you know, Trump, Trump fans and Trump's camp think he's being persecuted, think he's being unfairly tried, you know, whatever the sentence is, like pro Trump right, are going to become more militant and more excited and more defensive of him.
And the pro Biden left is going to become more of the opposite. And, and so this also makes me sad about our country. Like we're, we're in a tough moment. Like if, if I was an adversary of our country and our capitalism and our, our, our promise of freedom here in the U S and abroad, now would be a great time for China to attack Taiwan. It'd be a great time for Russia to up the game or up the any in Ukraine for, you know,
Like it is a very destabilizing time because it's tearing apart the fabric of our country. Like never. I mean, you know, Trump should never have done what he did. You know, I, we've talked about this before. If, if I was looking to prosecute Trump, I would have waited till after the election, not because delayed justice, but just because I want to make sure I'm not impacting a, an election. And the more he gets hit.
And the harder he gets hit, the more his folks defend them. And, and if, and if, and if you took away the oxygen in the room by not giving him court time and TV time and, and talking points, you know, he, he would go away and he'd be an ex president. he'd be a noisy one, but, but, but he would exist in that space. And you know, it, it, it's, it's, it's sad. I don't know what ends up happening. It's just a mess. So.
shawn (34:36.429)
Which is pathetic.
Matt (34:59.749)
Here's what I'll tell you why I think that it's dangerous for anybody on either side to politicize the justice system. So in the United States, we have three separate branches of government and they kind of fight for power, right? This is the American idea is you have separation of powers and those branches fight with each other for power. But what you always have to have in the United States is you have to have a final voice. Somebody has to be the voice that ends the fight.
because democracy is contentious and it's messy. And there has to be a venue you go to that when that venue speaks. So the last hundred years it's been the Supreme Court because at first it was Congress, then it was the president. But as those two branches of government became politicized and the American public didn't trust them to interpret the constitution in an unbiased manner, then the last hundred years we've gone to the Supreme Court. So what happens when you attack the justice system?
Sam (35:32.678)
Supreme Court.
Matt (35:55.237)
and the justice system becomes, or that branch of government becomes viewed as a political branch of government. Americans lose trust in that institution and then we lose the final voice. So then when there's no final voice that everybody trusts, the only option left is violence. Like our institutions exist to prevent violence in society. So to me, yeah, go ahead.
Sam (36:01.286)
Which it is. Yeah.
Sam (36:15.846)
And that was the text message I sent you guys the night the verdict came down is it feels like there's so much frustration and anger and you know, we're probably as close to a time of violence as ever, right? And,
Matt (36:32.325)
because there's no final voice. There's no peaceful arbitrator.
Sam (36:34.666)
No.
shawn (36:34.765)
Matt, as the political scientist, have you really come to the place where you've lost all hope that there is no final voice?
Matt (36:40.645)
No, I mean, I still have hope in the American people, but it's hard to see. When 83 % of Democrats are expecting violence after the 2024 election, no matter who wins, and when you've got like two thirds of the country is expecting violence after the election, we know from market behavior that when people expect things to get good or people expect things to get bad, it becomes like prophecy and it starts to happen. We have that many people expecting something to happen.
That becomes prophecy. You have.
shawn (37:10.637)
But you're saying that the main problem is politicizing the justice system and you saying that has arrived in the example of prosecuting Trump at this time, in the example of the Supreme Court. Is there a way back? Is there a way back? Is there a way, do you think that it can, you do think so, okay.
Matt (37:23.557)
It's like a perfect storm, right?
Look, the Republicans could start talking about the justice system. So the Republicans dislike the FBI, right? And they dislike the justice system lower down. Democrats dislike the police and they dislike the Supreme Court. If everybody just dials back the rhetoric, it's really not that hard, right? You just say, you win some, you lose some, it's okay, let's move on. Right, so that's why I'm afraid.
Sam (37:45.958)
It won't happen.
shawn (37:50.061)
So what's the scriptural latter day LDS lens that informs us on this? Is it justice?
Matt (38:01.733)
It's really clear. President Nelson is so clear on this. Be peaceful, be peacemaker, seek peace. Nobody who shares our faith has any reason to stand outside of a courthouse and protest a decision that they're not even a part of. It's not even any of their business. It's the state of New York versus Donald Trump. If you're on the jury, do your job on the jury. If you're not on the jury, it's really none of your business. Same thing with the Supreme Court, right? Why would we go to a member of the Supreme Court's house and protest with their, that's their job. Let them do their job.
shawn (38:23.981)
Yeah, that makes sense. That's good, but...
Matt (38:30.821)
We can uphold the people who are in positions of power unless they're breaking the laws.
shawn (38:30.829)
well but you
But you brought up the politicizing of the justice system. I'm asking if you think there's any scriptural, spiritual guidance on that part. Like, is it just, is it?
Matt (38:41.157)
Matt (38:45.125)
Don't do it. Don't, I don't know. Why would you? Yeah, I don't think there's any scriptures about the justice system in the United States, but it just doesn't even make sense. The judges look.
shawn (38:48.493)
What verse? Is there a verse on that?
shawn (38:54.701)
Well, I've done the Book of Mormon.
I mean, the Book of Mormon talks about government and styles of government and judging all the time, no?
Matt (39:02.981)
It does also say that the best system of government is a king. So.
shawn (39:06.957)
It does not. It says that no, it says a righteous king or a righteous judge is the best system of government. It doesn't say that it's a king. No, it says it. Yeah, I do. Trust me, it says righteous king, doesn't it?
Matt (39:11.717)
You're gonna make me read that verse John
Matt (39:18.501)
Therefore, if it were possible that you could have just men to be your kings, who would establish the laws of God and judge people according to his commands, yea, if you could have men for your kings who would do even as my father Benjamin did for this people, I say unto you, if this could always be the case, then it would be expedient that ye should always have kings to rule over you.
shawn (39:22.221)
That's right. That's right. Just men.
shawn (39:29.933)
Right. Right.
shawn (39:38.125)
Right, but it's not saying that kings is the best leader from the government. It's saying that righteous, just people in that power. Right, but it could also say that righteous judges was just as successful as a righteous king in that scenario.
Matt (39:43.237)
Righteous kings. Righteous kings.
He didn't say that. He didn't say that.
Sam (39:49.382)
Right. Right. Righteous, righteous Kings that own everything. That's fascinating.
Matt (39:54.117)
Okay, so let's give me the points on this topic. All right. Well then Sam, you're up. It's your thought provoking question.
Sam (39:58.566)
No, no, no.
shawn (39:58.825)
Let's...
Sam (40:05.542)
You know, I'm going to pass on this week's question. We're going to go into the big question because I'm so, I, you know, this has been a fascinating conversation and, I've got nothing else to add. Yeah. Nope. Yeah.
Matt (40:08.229)
Okay, alright.
shawn (40:12.653)
He's triggered.
Matt (40:13.925)
I've broken Sam. I really didn't mean to break him. Okay. Here's the big question. Maybe I think this will make all of us feel good. Hey, listener, if you're like Sam and feeling down and feeling depressed and feeling like the world is coming to an end, here's a feel good thing for you.
Sam (40:21.894)
Okay.
Sam (40:28.582)
No, I actually, I don't feel like the world is coming to an end. I feel like your approach is dangerous. I think it's reflective of the entire country. You know, it is a fascinating social experiment on the state of members within the church. There are wide varying views on our world today. And it's probably those, the divide is probably only going to increase. And so this is probably a great example of how you have a conversation about it.
shawn (40:34.541)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Matt (40:36.261)
Wait a minute, wait a minute, which approach?
Sam (40:58.47)
and remain, you know, faithful, involved, engaged, not only members, but also good friends, right? Like, I don't, we don't, we see the world very differently. And the way, the way you might see it actually makes me depressed as I'll get out because I think it, it robs people of this potential to become better. And, I would love nothing more to our listeners, if there's a way to convince Matt.
shawn (41:14.157)
Hehehehe
Sam (41:24.71)
What is that way? How do we show him? If not the business owner from China that comes over and realizes the benefits of our version of democracy and capitalism and free market, what? There's gotta be something. And I'm not good enough to do it, but I've seen the benefits of this in my own life enough that it's amazing to me. And I hope the church doesn't turn the way you're talking, because that would be depressing too.
Matt (41:41.861)
We'll get there.
Matt (41:50.597)
I'm lobbying, Sam. I'm lobbying for them to give all of that money away.
shawn (41:55.725)
Sam, you need to go be a professor at a BOU so you can have that influence.
Sam (41:55.814)
Yeah. They have to have the, they have to have the money before they can give it away. Somebody has to own it before they give it. And the church has so many assets that there's no way that they agree with you yet. And until God himself comes down and says, it's all mine. which is what you're, he's already done that, right? But, but until I take it, you have to, you have to like take, it's the talents, right? You have to have that time, talent, stuff.
shawn (42:03.405)
It's a good point, Matt. It's a good point.
Matt (42:12.613)
He already, he's already done that. He's already said it's all his.
shawn (42:16.237)
Matt... yeah, that's true.
Sam (42:25.35)
And you've got to improve upon it and make it better. So anyway, let's go to the big question. We'll give me the points for Matt. Okay. Thank you.
Matt (42:28.197)
Okay, so it makes me feel better. I'll give you the points, Sam, for, we're gonna say that Sam's topic was to reiterate an argument he made earlier, and I'm gonna give him the points for that because I like the way that he did it. But it does make me feel better because when you said that you thought my approach was dangerous or harmful, I thought you were talking about what we were talking about with the justice system, and I was like, wait a minute, why would Sam be mad about my view about that? But I see, it's about private property.
Sam (42:40.166)
Thank you. Thank you.
Sam (42:52.55)
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
Matt (43:13.733)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (43:21.638)
This is going to tear the fabric of our country apart for all the reasons you listed, Matt, right? There's no judicial system that will have the final call. You know, Bush v. Gore took that away, right? That, that, that it'll, Trump will never allow that to happen. And, and, and the Dems probably won't either. There's, there's nowhere to go. So I'll call up everybody. Sean's got the scripture. Go ahead, Sean.
Matt (43:33.093)
score. Yeah.
shawn (43:42.573)
Hey Matt, I think I found a decent scripture on this justice thing. So this is Mosiah 3 .26.
Matt (43:47.845)
Okay. Okay.
Sam (43:49.318)
Is it an evangelical friend one or is this a LDS? Okay.
Matt (43:51.557)
Crazy rotations.
shawn (43:52.397)
He's from China. He's from China, yeah. All right, listen to this. So, therefore they have drunk out of the cup of the wrath of God, which justice could no more deny unto them that it could deny that Adam should fall because of his partaking of the fruit of the fruit. Therefore, mercy could have claim on them no more forever. So I like this because what it's basically saying is, if I view our manmade justice system, this scripture is saying you cannot in a.
Right? In God's world, you cannot deny justice. Justice is meant to be blind, not politically motivated. And then on the other side, it talks about mercy, right? So there's a place for mercy in it. But whether it's justice or mercy, it should be justice or mercy. It shouldn't be justice for political gain or for power gain.
Sam (44:23.686)
Yeah, but.
Sam (44:37.926)
The only reason that that justice or that judging works is because it's a social construct that everybody's agreed to abide by. And the moment that people think, say, I'm not going to abide by this because I've been robbed by the other side, it loses its power to do anything. And then the whole thing crumbles, right? Like if, if, if people are unwilling to take the sentence, whether God thinks we need to have justice or mercy probably doesn't matter in the world until he
shawn (44:55.917)
point good point.
shawn (45:02.061)
Yeah, good point.
Sam (45:06.854)
stands atop the mountain and says, it's done, right? Like we're, it, what a challenging time. Buckle up everybody, right?
Matt (45:15.397)
Okay, so the big question deals with racism. We've talked on this podcast before about what's the right way to deal with historical injustices that were caused by racism in the past. So this week, Major League Baseball, they announced something that they've done, and I wonder if this is a good model for dealing with historical injustice. So Major League Baseball has a historian who's paid. He's the Major League Baseball historian. He got a team of people together.
and they went through microfilm and microfiche, old historical newspapers, and they looked at the baseball games, every single baseball game that was played in the Negro leagues and in any other professional league where there was segregation back in the day. And so base.
shawn (46:00.525)
By the way, you're calling it that just for listeners because that's a title. It's not like Matt is okay with saying that word. It's a title of the league. He would never use that word outside of the title of what the league was called.
Matt (46:07.405)
the Negro League? Yeah, the name is... Yeah. Yeah, that's right.
Matt (46:15.749)
That's right. I'm sorry. I thought everybody knew that there's a museum to the to this baseball league in Kansas City and that's what they call their league. Yeah.
shawn (46:21.749)
Because it's a title. So the title is descriptive. It's not a word that just helping you out. Just helping you.
Matt (46:26.789)
okay. Yeah. Just thanks, Sean. Okay. So as they went through and did this, they said, we need to rethink. we need to, we're going to incorporate all of this information into the major league baseball statistics. And so as a result, Josh Gibson, who was a legend in that baseball league, he's now baseball's all time leader in career batting average. So his career batting average is above Ty Cobb. he's the career leader in slugging percentage.
So not Babe Ruth anymore, now Josh Gibson and OPS, which I don't know what OPS stands for, but yeah. So two of the records that belonged to Babe Ruth now belong to Josh Gibson. And he's also the single season leader in each of those categories. So my question is, is this a model for how other groups in the United States could deal with historical racial injustice? Like hire historians, have them go back in time.
shawn (47:05.421)
Babe Ruth currently had that, right? Now it's not him anymore. Yeah.
Matt (47:26.469)
have them look at what happened and then adjust everything today to reflect what was done in the past.
shawn (47:33.837)
So I've been all week when this came out, I've been studying Josh Gibson. What an amazing man. It's so sad because he died at a very young age. He had a brain tumor and he's like, look, if this is going to affect the way I hit a baseball, then leave it in there. I'll deal with the headaches. And it killed him eventually. So it's super sad. But obviously this guy was just a phenom, just at the most. So it's both exciting for me and sad for me. Like, okay.
Too little too late, right? He got no recognition. He got no praise. He got no back in the day when he deserved it. Yeah, yeah, he's dead. You know what I mean? Like he didn't get to, and it's.
Matt (48:09.221)
But now he does. But now he does. But now if I talk about Babe Ruth, I'm going to say, hey, by the way, Josh Gibson, who I didn't even know his name before. I mean,
shawn (48:20.204)
You know, I agree it's a good thing. It's still just heartbreaking because it's too little too late for Josh Gibson, but it is a good thing. Obviously this is a good thing. And your question is, is it a model for future? I think this is a good example for sure of how we can, we can do it. We obviously have to be careful on not creating revisionist history based on, what we want it to be. So I love that, that we can trust certain things. Experts say the word expert, say the word expert.
Matt (48:41.029)
Sure, just have a team of, yeah, have a team of historians do it. Yeah, yeah, experts, I like this, Sean, yeah. Listen, I'm surrounded by people who are trained historians that obviously people have biases, but if you have a team of people, then the team of people can look at things and if you can do it with baseball statistics, why couldn't you do it with anything else? No, I'm serious, this is a legitimate question. If you can...
shawn (48:49.165)
Tell me what degree they get.
no. no.
shawn (49:08.237)
Well, I would qualify.
Matt (49:08.773)
If you're willing to say Babe Ruth is not the slugging percentage leader in Major League Baseball, if you're willing to do that.
shawn (49:13.997)
Look, I think when it comes to history, there's always, for me, there's always gonna be an asterisk on it because history is not a science. Maybe it's a social science. Maybe it's a social, history is not a science. No one, yeah, but no one calls history a science.
Matt (49:22.245)
Of course it is!
Social science is a science as well.
Well, I understand because they don't use the scientific method, but it's scientifically rigorous is what I would say.
shawn (49:33.933)
So, yeah, but history, there's no method that proves history. It is in large part based on narratives that you take from the evidence. Yeah, yeah.
Matt (49:46.085)
No. Yeah, the evidence, the discovery of the evidence is history. So going through those old news...
shawn (49:52.205)
No, no, no, the interpretation of the incomplete evidence becomes history, but that doesn't mean it's factual. And I'm not downplaying Josh Gibson. I'm glad that there was enough data to come up with a statistic for his batting average to show that he had a better bat average than Taikob. I love that. I think that's really beautiful. But you said, do we apply this to everything in every situation? It's hard, Matt, because where I would start is redlining.
Matt (50:14.693)
Yeah, sure.
shawn (50:19.885)
I hate that this country applied redlining and affected people's property ownership because property ownership is sacred, Matt. Right?
Matt (50:19.973)
Okay.
Matt (50:24.837)
And your, your historians, historians can't document that. Historians can't go through and see who was redlined. Of course.
shawn (50:31.693)
I don't think they have not, they've not been able to do that so far successfully.
Matt (50:35.941)
That's because they weren't incentivized to do it, right? In Major League Baseball, it's this person's job. They gave this person the resources to hire a team of people to do it. So I'm just suggesting like, instead of saying, hey, let's set aside money for reparations and let's just give money to everybody who's the descendant of slaves. Maybe what we do instead is we set aside some money and say, let's hire some historians who are gonna investigate historical injustices and then we'll let them discover the evidence and then based on the evidence, we can adjudicate like,
shawn (50:57.293)
Hehehehe
Matt (51:05.093)
What's the right thing to do today?
Sam (51:05.702)
Well, here's what I think is so cool about this. First of all, OPS, by the way, is on base plus slugging. So it is cool to see the record corrected, but the, the, the national baseball league, is a private entity, right? Major league baseball, private entity, that private entity, private enterprise went back and identified an injustice. So they took records information they had available to them and they've implemented this as a solution. I think that's great.
Matt (51:12.677)
-huh.
Matt (51:21.413)
Yes.
Sam (51:35.27)
I think, I think where you get into trouble is that you're talking about, why don't we go back to historians and have them rewrite everything carte blanche across all history? Well, that's insane. Right? Like to me, it's, it's, it's, it's better. It's better when private entities and private enterprise comes up and says, Hey, look, we recognize something that should be corrected. Let's correct it. Right. I don't need.
Matt (51:49.125)
Well, we don't have to rewrite everything. We could just do it on certain. Yeah.
Sam (52:03.27)
the federal government to come back and rewrite Mormon history back to Joseph Smith, right? It's up to the church to advocate for its own position and figure out how it wants to be seen in the world. And, you know.
Matt (52:07.461)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (52:16.613)
But there are historians that dig up information that the church has maybe hidden over the years. And when they dig up that information, then it challenges an existing narrative. And then the church says, huh, we didn't know about that.
Sam (52:22.662)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (52:27.11)
Which is, which is, which is, which is helpful. But, but the only challenge I have with what you're talking about is there's an illusion to like some sort of a final truth or like one way, whether it's government, government's often the solution, right? And I don't believe, I don't believe that you pro you know, you nominate a bunch of historians is like the arbiter of truth on behalf of the government. And then they go out and they correct every all the rights, all the wrongs. Yes. Yeah. Yeah.
Matt (52:41.829)
Yes.
Matt (52:51.237)
you guys distrust, you guys distrust experts and governments. I see. It's that distrust.
shawn (52:53.421)
Points to Sam, points to Sam.
Sam (52:56.838)
So, so major league baseball, major, major league baseball, they did that. That's awesome. Like every private entity and enterprise should be incentivized somehow to go out and do it. And, and there's nothing wrong with that.
Matt (53:02.441)
You
Matt (53:07.973)
What if we had an agency of historical injustice and you say, hey listen, my...
shawn (53:12.748)
That's better, right, Sam?
Sam (53:12.95)
yeah, that'd be great. That'd be great. FB. Let's see. It's not the FBI, the CIA. It's it's what, what do you call it? Histor. Yeah. Yeah. And it's, and it's, and it's all the, it's, it's all the, university, it's all the university, historians such as yourselves that you can get into one room and you just, you just have them think about who, who they want to have self actualize over time and they can.
Matt (53:20.997)
ATF? Agency of Historical Injustice. H .J.
shawn (53:21.677)
H I
shawn (53:28.461)
The H -J!
Matt (53:33.285)
who were underpaid.
Matt (53:40.037)
No, no, but seriously, like if, if -
shawn (53:41.037)
Hey Sam, hey Sam, Matt said he wants to call this agency the HJ, which by the way has been used in the past called Hitler Youth. That's what HJ is. Jürgen, Jürgen, yeah, HJ was Hitler Youth, Matt. Okay.
Sam (53:45.51)
Yeah.
Matt (53:48.197)
J Hitler, H J is Hitler Youth. my. Okay, well, I'm not proposing that I'm proposing like, let's say, Hey, I've heard of my family history that I have an ancestor that was a slave that he invented a patent for something and his owner stole the patent and the white family who owned my father has made millions and millions of dollars off of my father's patent. And I think we should have that instead rather than saying,
shawn (54:16.589)
We all agree on that, Matt, right? We all agree on that.
Matt (54:17.733)
No, so if you had a Department of Historical Injustice where you go to them and they say, well, no, then all you're doing, you're empowering lawyers. I'm saying, why do we need to empower lawyers? Why don't we have a team of trained historians?
Sam (54:21.094)
my goodness. my goodness.
shawn (54:22.189)
No civil lawsuit there civil lawsuit. We have a system for that.
shawn (54:29.421)
I'd rather empower a private, I'd rather empower a private lawyer to go and do the work than a government agency called the HJ.
Matt (54:34.725)
And then, well, you know that the lawyer is an officer of the court, which is a government agency. Like you just want.
shawn (54:43.181)
and also a private citizen and private company.
Sam (54:45.894)
think we should, let's empower car salespeople to go out and find all the injustice, all the wrongs they can find. And then I'll take your car. I'll take my car salespeople. You take your historians and then Sean can advertise it and, and we'll be good. Matt, it's a, it's a, it's a terrible idea of having nationally appointed historians from liberal universities going like nobody would trust that again. That's the town. But.
Matt (54:49.029)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (54:55.009)
You
huh. It would be actually pretty good because I would trust car salespeople more than lawyers to handle this. Okay. All right.
shawn (55:13.325)
But the concept, Matt, but your concept, I think is correct, right? It is a good model. I don't think you've executed it very well, but it's a good model.
Sam (55:15.718)
But I, but I love, yeah, I love that Major League Baseball did this. Like this is a huge plus. So I'm not depressed anymore. I'm only mildly malaised.
Matt (55:27.013)
If I were to change it from Major League Baseball did this to Joe Biden did this, then it wouldn't feel so good inside.
Sam (55:30.854)
Yeah.
Sam (55:35.366)
shawn (55:35.565)
Well, many people don't trust government to do things correct. Either we don't trust them to do it honestly, or we don't think they're competent. So I'd much rather have.
Sam (55:42.374)
First of all, I'm sure Joe Biden probably took credit for it.
Matt (55:46.309)
I think he took credit for this.
shawn (55:46.445)
hahahahah
Sam (55:50.406)
You know what, we should let Joe Biden focus on controlling medicine costs and like equaling all the other ills in the world, which I disagree with. Yeah. Well, wait, is he, is, is Biden. So, so Al Gore created the internet. Are you saying that Joe Biden is, is, making it prolet. Okay. That's good. I thought that was Elon Musk. Isn't Elon Musk doing that? No. Okay.
Matt (55:55.973)
Mm -hmm. That's right. Getting internet to rural areas. Peace in the Middle East. Peace for Ukraine.
shawn (56:02.573)
Forg -forg -forg -forgiving the dead of some people, some people's schools.
Matt (56:06.693)
Yeah.
Matt (56:10.821)
He's giving the internet to rural areas. Yeah, we're going to get fiber.
No, we're getting fiber internet. Like lay the lines of fiber internet are being laid throughout the country in rural areas because these
shawn (56:18.253)
Hit you.
Sam (56:24.23)
So exciting, so exciting.
shawn (56:25.645)
That's a lot of people. That's a lot of people, Matt. That's almost as many people as the 80 million that he tried to use OSHA to force take a vaccination.
Matt (56:32.965)
Well, what we're trying to do is help these people find about the hashtag raw milk that they haven't been able to find in their rural areas because they don't have the internet. Hey guys, this was a super fun conversation today. I hope that nobody of our listeners or of our hosts is feeling sad, feel happy because one day sometime soon Jesus will come again. He will kill all the wicked and take away their property and give it.
shawn (56:38.349)
Hehehehehe
Sam (56:58.726)
but until then they will own the property free and clear if they're smart.
Matt (57:04.517)
Alright, have a good week everybody.
Sam (57:06.79)
See everybody, bye.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories