The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
Episode 70: Trump v Biden in the polls, NCAA paying student athletes, #rawmilk, Will 2024 see the rise of global authoritarianism?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Mailbag: One listener writes, “Like a lot of Republicans, Sam is pretty tone deaf when he talks about risk. On average, rich people have taken much less risk in their lives than the rest of us. Trump is a great example. Trump was a millionaire by age 8. Through all of Trump’s adventures and misadventures he was never in danger even of living the life of an average dentist or investment banker. And certainly not a school teacher or truck driver. Link.
When upper-middle class people tell poor people they should stop complaining and take more risks, they deserve scorn. If they do it wearing a monocle and/or top hat, they deserve the guillotine. Now that would be risk-taking! So, I propose that every time Sam wants to talk about all the risks rich people take and how that entitles them to more wealth than working people, he must wear a Monopoly-man style monocle and top hat.”
The Thought Provoker: Matt is up first this week. Bird flu is back in the US. Meanwhile, right wing media personalities are attacking pasteurized milk. A Media Matters analysis found over 13,000 posts on TikTok that included the hashtag #rawmilk. The first 581 videos from the “top” tab shown under a search “#rawmilk” had accumulated over 231 million views as of May 3. Instagram Reels promoting raw milk have also been plentiful, with one of the top reels encouraging pregnant women to drink raw milk even though consuming unpasteurized milk is particularly risky for pregnant women. Why are messaged like this so appealing to people who consume right wing media?
Next up, Sam. Why is Trump leading Biden in the polls?
Finally, Shawn. The NCAA has agreed to a $2.8B class-action settlement, paving the way for universities to directly pay college athletes for the first time. The settlement is a revenue-sharing model in which schools would pay athletes a cut of the money received from sponsorships, broadcasting rights, and ticket sales. Division I schools would have the ability to distribute up to $20M per year to their athletes. All Division I athletes dating back to 2016 are eligible to receive a share as part of the settlement class. Is it moral to pay students for the entertainment and income they provide schools?
The Big Question: David Brooks argues that the world seems to be experiencing a populist moment. In a recent global survey, sixty-six percent of Americans said that the country “needs a strong leader to take the country back from the rich and powerful,” compared with 63 percent of respondents among the 28 nations overall. Forty percent of Americans said they believed we need a strong leader who will “break the rules,” which was only a bit below the 49 percent globally who believed that. There are certain big moments in the history of mankind in which there was a global movement toward greater freedom in the world. 1848 is called the spring of nations because of the number of revolutions throughout Europe that overthrew monarchies and created independent nation-states. 1989 saw the collapse of communism around Europe and other parts of the world. Brooks worries that 2024 will see a wave of
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:01.508)
Welcome back to the Real Mormonism podcast with Sean, Sam, and Matt. It's good to have you with us. We've got so many exciting things to talk about this week. We're going to start with the mailbag. Now I have to say this, Sam, I don't think that this listener actually wants to kill you, but the way that they phrased their email was a little bit inflammatory. So I'm going to just kind of give the listener the benefit of the doubt, but I'm going to just make clear at the beginning. We don't condone the use of violence in politics.
Sam (00:13.403)
Mmm.
Mmm!
Sam (00:30.139)
No violence, no. Politics, social media, religion, we believe in whatever, yes.
Matt (00:31.012)
In fact, we're trying to do the opposite of that.
shawn (00:32.878)
especially via guillotines.
Matt (00:37.476)
especially if you're friends and you shouldn't be mean to it anyhow. Okay. So this person says, like a lot of Republicans, Sam is pretty tone deaf when he talks about risk. On average, rich people have taken much less risk in their lives than the rest of us. Trump is a great example. Trump was a millionaire by age eight. Through all of Trump's adventures and misadventures, he was never in danger of even living the life of an average dentist or investment banker and certainly not a school teacher or truck driver.
Sam (00:40.315)
Yeah.
Matt (01:06.98)
And the listener even provided a link because Sam, some of our listeners, they like to cite the things that they say on the phone. When upper middle -class people tell poor people they should stop complaining and take more risks, they deserve scorn. If they do it wearing a monocle and or a top hat, they deserve the guillotine. See, that's the thing that suggests death. I don't think he really wants. Now that would be risk -taking. So I propose that every time Sam wants to talk about all the risks rich people take,
shawn (01:12.718)
hahahaha
Sam (01:12.987)
Mmm... Mmm...
Sam (01:28.539)
Mmm, yeah, no.
Matt (01:36.228)
and how that entitles them to more wealth than working people, he must wear a Monopoly Man style monocle and top hat.
shawn (01:41.486)
There's the sketchy part.
Sam (01:43.387)
So I have no idea who this is, but it doesn't surprise me because this person, whoever they are, is trying to segment everyone into little buckets and trying to keep people in those buckets. And that's what the Democrats try to do is they try to keep poor people poor. They try to keep, you know, those that are struggling, struggling, because it makes everybody feel more comfortable knowing where everybody's supposed to be and knowing that they have a place. I believe in free market.
Matt (01:52.9)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (02:10.235)
I believe in our democracy and the promise that is America. And that if you start as this school teacher, as this person says, and you have aspirations to do different or to even become entrepreneurial as a school teacher, and you're willing to take risk in the sphere of your job, the potential is unlimited in our world. And so anyone that's going to sit there and lecture me about, you know, taking risk, right, right. Get, get.
Matt (02:33.156)
taking risk and everybody can take risk and everyone has equal opportunity.
Sam (02:37.531)
get a life. I will not even threaten their life. I'll just say get a life because, because a school teacher, there are a ton of opportunities, a ton of examples of school teachers that have sacrificed in the moment. In fact, I can think of one that the gentleman that created word perfect back in the 1990s, he was a post office employee and he took massive risk as a poor post office employee and created a software company. And because of that software company, now we have Thanksgiving points.
Matt (02:54.244)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (03:06.779)
here in Utah County. We have a lot of other, a lot of other economic ventures that have been an incredible, incredible benefit to the community. So just because you start out as a post office and it actually angers me that someone's viewpoint would be so narrow that they're going to try to say that a school teacher can't take risks. They don't have the opportunity.
Matt (03:14.308)
For.
For listeners who...
Matt (03:22.18)
For listeners who don't know about...
Sam (03:30.939)
That's terrible. That's anti -Gospel 100 % top -down. So I don't know who this person is, but get a life.
Matt (03:37.252)
But for listeners who don't know what WordPerfect is, WordPerfect was an alternative to Microsoft Word that has
Sam (03:43.067)
It was, it was Microsoft Word before Microsoft Word existed. Yes.
Matt (03:46.596)
and then Microsoft Word kind of does Word Perfect exist anymore? And there's free versions of the software that are better than Word Perfect, right?
Sam (03:49.787)
No, no.
Wait, Matt, it's not the point. It's not the point. A post office employee created a product that generated hundreds of millions of dollars and has blessed an entire state. I mean, what they've done in terms of good, the Ashton family over the past decades has been monumental. And he was a post office employee with like a hundred kids and he took a huge risk. So listen, if you're a Democrat and you want to keep people in a box, do it on your own time.
Matt (04:06.756)
Buh -bye.
shawn (04:11.31)
He's right. He's right.
Matt (04:11.524)
I'm Shane.
Matt (04:15.748)
100 kids. Wait, is that the LDS?
Sam (04:22.971)
Don't do it on ours.
Matt (04:23.844)
I'm trying to think of the elementary teachers though that took a risk and became fabulously wealthy because it seems to me like the only people that are teachers that are becoming wealthy are doing it through OnlyFans. I haven't heard of like any stories because you started, I was excited that Sam.
Sam (04:36.283)
Matt, get off of social media. Get off of social media. OnlyFans is a waste of time. I don't even know what it is, but I'm sure it's not good.
shawn (04:38.926)
Yeah.
Matt (04:40.164)
No, I'm serious!
I'm serious that those at least once a week, if you open up Fox news, you're going to read a story of some school teacher somewhere in the United States that opened an OnlyFans account and got fired from her job as a school teacher. But don't worry, she's making so much more money now. I was hoping Sammy, we're going to share a story of a teacher who became fabulously wealthy from taking risks, but you pivoted to a post office worker.
Sam (04:57.659)
Yeah.
shawn (05:03.054)
my gosh. Shut up, Matt.
Sam (05:05.659)
so, so Deanna jump, a kindergarten teacher in Warner Robbins, Georgia recently became a multimillionaire. She didn't inherit a fortune or win the lottery. She earned the money by selling lesson plans to other teachers. So that's an example of someone who's entrepreneurial, who took risk with her own time, who said, Hey, I want to, I, in the sphere of my experience and life, I'm going to take a little bit of risk with my time. I'm going to try harder.
Matt (05:18.34)
There you go.
Sam (05:31.611)
And she's made a ton of money. Actually, if you Google school teacher and millions, there are a ton of examples. It is actually unfortunate. It is unfortunate that in our world, you have people that so badly want to keep people in a box. It makes them feel better that they don't allow them to see the possibility of taking risk in their own sphere of experience and, and, and, and bettering their own world as a result. It's all, it's all over the place. Google it.
Matt (05:33.412)
There you go.
shawn (05:59.022)
Not only that, Sam, not only that, but villainizing people who have money versus people who don't have money and those boxes get created. Yeah, I agree, it's a sad thing. It doesn't matter. Sure, if you're rich, no, no, no, no, no, no. They're saying if you're wealthy, you are so privileged that your risk taking doesn't count. Like Donald Trump, I mean, I'm not supporting Donald Trump at all, but.
Matt (06:07.716)
I don't think the listener was villainizing anybody. They're just saying to suggest.
Sam (06:11.771)
Yeah they were, yeah they were. They -
Matt (06:21.7)
No, he's not saying it doesn't count. He's saying it's not a risk when you know that there's no, that you're not going to fall very far if you fail. Right? It's like a person.
Sam (06:29.627)
That's not true. That, by the way, a hundred percent not true because in the sphere of everybody's experience and wealth, risk is different, but it's still risk. If you venture or risk a million dollars and all you have is a million dollars and you lose a million dollars, you're in the same place. Right? So I see what his point is. His point is, Hey, Trump was a millionaire as a kid. His dad was always going to give him millions, but the great story of
business in America is typically the first generation creates the wealth and then the second generation squanders it and loses it. So there are a lot of examples of wealthy people that have lost everything and, and, and, and they have to start completely over. But Matt, I love this 41 -year -old side hustle brings in $125 ,000 a year in the state of Portland. Costs zero to start, riches are found in niches. And so she started selling lesson plans to other teachers. Like,
shawn (07:04.75)
Yeah, Sam's message is right.
Matt (07:27.012)
Yeah.
Sam (07:27.579)
Everybody can do that except for people that say you can't do that because there's some sort of a weird, hey, I don't want to be wealthy because wealthy people are. And then we start telling ourselves lies about people that are successful. When, when in America did we start to villainize millionaires and billionaires? It used to be when we were kids, you'd look at people that had been successful, that had made millions and we would idolize them. We'd want to learn from them. We'd want to duplicate and replicate their success. Why is it today?
shawn (07:31.694)
Sam's right.
shawn (07:37.262)
That's correct, Matt. That's the philosophy. And it's wrong.
Sam (07:56.795)
that anybody that's had success has done it stealing from the lower class. That is not helpful.
shawn (08:03.182)
But Sam, just to clarify too, you have never talked down about poor people or lower middle class people. You have just as much respect for those people who pick themselves up by the bootstraps and innovate and take risks as you do for the wealthy people. You do. You talk about them all the time.
Sam (08:15.291)
100%. 100%. 100%. I do not. I do not. I do not. I don't.
Matt (08:17.956)
Sam has disdain for the lower class. Sam, Sam, hey, hey, hey, I listen to Sam.
shawn (08:19.918)
No, he doesn't. No, he doesn't. He doesn't. I got Sam's back and you got points, Sam.
Sam (08:26.267)
Actually, so, so by the way, Larry Miller, auto dealer in the state of Utah, guess where he started? He was a parts guy. I tell this to people all the time. He was a parts guy at a Toyota store in Utah. He went on to become a multi -billionaire, the legacy that he left for his family. He took massive risk as a parts manager. I go to every parts manager I work with across our auto group. And I say, do you know that a man who went on to own one of the top five largest auto groups in the entire country started where you sit today?
shawn (08:32.27)
Yeah.
shawn (08:37.71)
Sam is preaching.
shawn (08:45.87)
There you go.
Sam (08:56.731)
Take the risk, have the dream, see the vision and work towards it. And in America, if you work hard enough, long enough and take enough risk, that opportunity is available to almost everyone.
shawn (09:07.854)
So Matt, as we transition, I want you to listen to Sam's message and then sit down and be humble.
Matt (09:13.476)
Well, listen, I listened to Sam talk about Jen pop in the airport. And so I'm not going to agree with you, Sean, that Sam, I listened to Sam talk about Ozempic at Disneyland. So it's true. Sam is a good person, but I'm not going to agree with you that Sam has no disdain for the lower classes. Sometimes.
shawn (09:20.91)
Sit down, be humble.
shawn (09:31.342)
He doesn't! There's no evidence of that. That's ridiculous, Matt. Dis -ridiculous.
Sam (09:31.451)
You know, you, you, you know, so, so, so you know what I, you know, what I will say is I do get frustrated where people have opportunity and they don't try.
Matt (09:43.044)
Okay, listen.
shawn (09:43.278)
But that could be a wealthy person or a non -wealthy person. That's not lower class. Stop putting people in boxes. That's Sam's message.
Sam (09:45.179)
That could be.
Matt (09:47.396)
I'm just, I'm just feeling, I'm feeling uncomfortable because Sean usually defends me and makes me feel good inside and we usually gang up on Sam and this doesn't feel good to me right now. Where
Sam (09:56.475)
Yeah, who who wrote that comment in do we know who wrote this comment to the part of the show? Okay Well, we love our listeners and we hope they change their way. Yeah
shawn (10:01.838)
Okay, next topic. Next. Let's go to Matt's topic about the bird flu.
Matt (10:02.276)
We don't, we don't know who we don't. It's just one of our listeners. Okay, so we do. Well, we love them all no matter what they think. Okay, we're gonna move to the thought provoker. And speaking of disdain, I'm gonna express some disdain for people on the right who believe ridiculous things. Anyhow, okay, here's my story. The bird flu is back in the United States. Now listen, the bird flu does not transmit from human to human.
Sam (10:12.187)
Okay. Okay.
Sam (10:18.075)
Okay.
Sam (10:22.395)
Here we go.
Matt (10:29.988)
but we have these cases of the bird flu popping up because people are drinking milk that's not pasteurized from cows. And so there was a, an analysis. This is a media matter. Media matters did an analysis of over 13 ,000 posts on Tik TOK that included the hashtag raw milk and the first 581 videos from the top tab shown under a search hashtag raw milk had accumulated over 231 million views.
Sam (10:36.283)
Mmm.
Matt (10:59.044)
as of May 3rd of this year. Instagram reels promoting raw milk have also been plentiful with the top reels encouraging pregnant women to drink raw milk, even though consuming unpasteurized milk is particularly risky for pregnant women. And these posts are predominantly from right -wing media personalities.
Sam (11:20.283)
Hey, listen, I got one answer for you.
shawn (11:21.198)
Nah, hang on, hang on, let him finish the question. Hey, I'ma finish the question.
Matt (11:25.38)
My question is why is, why are messages like this so popular, so appealing to people who consume right wing media?
shawn (11:31.15)
So hang on, Sam. Sam, I'll let you finish it off and slam the door. But here's the thing, Matt. Here's where your bias is being completely, completely exposed. The message of raw milk has not... You're acting like by putting people in boxes, you're acting like, well, this is a right -wing conspiracy. The message, Matt, the message of raw milk and those 231 million posts or views, that has been going on for years and years and years. It has nothing to do with your dumb bird flu government preaching.
Matt (11:47.236)
It is. It is.
shawn (11:59.822)
That's a message that has been a popular trend for so many years. That's nothing, it has nothing to do with it.
Matt (12:00.068)
No, no, I'm s -
Matt (12:04.004)
No, I know, but I'm saying that it's the right wing. I'm saying that the reason it matters now is because people drinking raw milk are getting the bird flu, right? So.
shawn (12:12.078)
Matt, I took two minutes, literally two minutes, and hashtag raw milk, and it is a mix of liberals and conservatives. Stop putting people in boxes. I'll show you the references. It's a mix of people because it's a health movement. It has nothing to do with politics, you nut.
Matt (12:21.284)
I don't believe you, Sean. I don't believe you.
Matt (12:30.148)
But if you go to Infowars, is Infowars left wing or right wing? Infowars is, yes, so why is it the right wing news people are the ones that are promoting it on their news outlets? Of course, of course on social media, you're gonna get people that are non -political that are promoting that.
shawn (12:33.998)
That's you, so who cares? Just because they have an opinion.
Sam (12:46.459)
I have an answer. I have an answer.
shawn (12:47.726)
For years you've had that. That's been a popular trend, Matt.
Matt (12:51.14)
Okay, what's your answer, Sam?
Sam (12:52.859)
I don't know why, but during COVID, the rightist right wing got a little nuts. Everybody was locked indoors a little too long and the conspiracy theories grew a little too much, but never fear the survival of the fittest will end up playing in this. Like if you drink this ridiculous milk and you expect some sort of a miraculous result at the end, like there's reason why science and technology help create a better world. And...
Matt (13:00.836)
Yes!
Matt (13:13.348)
unpasteurized milk?
Sam (13:21.723)
You know, people that are unwilling to, you know, protect themselves. Yeah. Drink pasteurized milk. Like, listen, we drank unpasteurized milk in Ukraine. We're not going to die. I like, we all got sick, right? It's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's no, it's, it's.
Matt (13:26.02)
Drink pasteurized milk.
Matt (13:31.876)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
shawn (13:34.414)
We must have been far right then, huh Matt? If we were doing it in Ukraine, we must have been far right. Cause that's the only source of people drinking raw milk, right Matt? You were far right in Ukraine and that's the conspiracy.
Matt (13:34.964)
You
Sam (13:42.395)
It's not the, it's not, it's, yeah, it's.
Matt (13:43.14)
That's right, Sean.
Matt (13:47.588)
Well, no, when at the grocery store or whatever, where we bought milk, that's the only choice that you had. And the
shawn (13:51.918)
Yeah, but it's a right -wing conspiracy, so we must have been part of that in Ukraine 30 years ago.
Sam (13:54.299)
Wait, it was the babushka. It was the babushka selling it from the blue milk truck with the yellow drum at the back of it.
Matt (14:00.612)
Yeah, that's right. As a woman pulls a trailer around the apartment complex shouting milk, I didn't go with my little bucket and say, please take it from that metal bin and put it into my milk container. Cause that seemed gross to me.
shawn (14:01.582)
Malako!
Sam (14:07.291)
Yeah.
but listen, what, what.
shawn (14:14.35)
That Babushka, Matt, according to your theory, that Babushka was a right -wing conspiracy fool. Yeah, there you go. So there you go.
Matt (14:20.612)
She was. She was.
Sam (14:20.763)
What, what, whatever cons whatever conspiracy theory is driving that trend right now, or fad ultimately, if pasteurized milk is the better way to go, it's either going to wear itself out because people are going to get sick and die or it'll become more, more, more used.
shawn (14:37.902)
Matt, you're missing the context of the raw milk fad. You're just jumping on politics.
Sam (14:42.97)
I don't even think the Democrat -Republican part, does it even matter? I don't know. It does? All right.
Matt (14:47.556)
It does. It does. Republicans always promote some idea that's anti -government. Republicans are so afraid of government that any crazy idea, right? And I don't want to go into too many of these details because they're people that I know and love and I don't want to talk about like their specific crazy things that they do, but people go on YouTube, they see some product being promoted by some alleged doctor and why is this doctor right? And everyone else is wrong. Some government conspiracy.
shawn (14:48.974)
It doesn't matter. No, it doesn't.
Sam (14:54.923)
there's no doubt. Yeah. Conspiracy theory. Yeah.
Sam (15:12.731)
Yeah.
shawn (15:16.43)
Your bias is, your bias. Matt, here's why, here's why, here's why. There's been, well, but I don't, well, in theory, yeah, but not in this milk thing because I've known for years, I live in liberal California and for years and years and years, the biggest trend here is raw milk. It's way healthier. They've been preaching it to me for years and years and years. Now all of a sudden, if someone who's right wing says it, Matt decides to make it political. It's not a political thing.
Sam (15:16.603)
Yeah. Wait, Sean, Sean, you, you see that, don't you? You agree with that, don't you?
Matt (15:16.708)
Where the government's out to... No, it's not my bias! This is what they tell me!
Matt (15:27.716)
okay.
Matt (15:38.34)
Okay.
Matt (15:42.212)
No, it's not. I'm saying that what they should do if they're smart, Sean, and they actually care about your health is they should say, guess what? There's the bird flu going around. So please stop drinking raw milk. It's better for you to drink pasteurized milk than to drink milk full of viruses that are going to make you sick and die. That's what they should be saying.
shawn (15:58.414)
So your problem, your issue is that they're not questioning, that they should not question the government. That's your problem. Do not question our leaders. Don't question the government. Is that your issue?
Sam (15:58.747)
Serv -Serv -Serv -
Survival.
survival of the fittest, Sean, survival of the fittest. Those people are making bad decisions. They'll end up getting weeded out of the gene pool because they'll die.
shawn (16:13.006)
No, they're not. You're a sheep. Don't be a sheep. Don't be a sheep. And just listen to the FDA.
Matt (16:19.14)
yeah, right. People who drink pasteurized milk are sheep who just listen to the FDA. This, Sean.
shawn (16:20.814)
Hehehehehe
No, saying that a long trend of drinking raw milk. Now, of course, in the context of the current bird flu, it's wise to obviously listen to that counsel. But don't vilify people for preaching raw milk, Matt. Don't place them in a box and get political and vilify them.
Matt (16:33.188)
Thank you, Sean.
Sam (16:38.331)
Hey, I have, I have a question for Sean just on this. What, why do you think it is? Cause I agree with Matt. I it's fascinating to me that the religious right and the Republican right, there is this super strong streak of paranoia that somebody's out to get them. It's a conspiracy theory. And there's one thing that's going to save the world, right? Whether it's, you know, when my mom had cancer, I remember we paid,
an exorbitant amount of money for some guy to pack mule this little dish of cream across the border from Mexico to the United States because, you know, the American medical system just wouldn't have this really precious cream sold here because it would break down the American medical system, which, which, yeah, which, which is absolutely crazy. And today there's even some good examples of it. I was at a, I was at a medical, I was near a medical convention.
Matt (17:27.812)
Big farm as opposed to it.
Sam (17:37.819)
I overheard a conversation about red light, and we have a red light in our house and people use it. And I thought they were positive about the red light. So I was like, yeah, I've heard about that. It's fascinating. And the two ladies who were medical, in the medical field, they said, Yeah, we actually think that's ridiculous. There's absolutely no scientific proof that that actually works. But there's something about, we love this idea that there's a miracle cure and that somebody out there is trying to hide it from everybody. And I don't know where that came from, but
Matt (17:42.5)
huh.
Matt (18:04.516)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (18:06.011)
but it is more prevalent on the right than the left. I think, I think ultimately it's going to weed itself out. And that's the great thing about a democracy and free market, because bad ideas end up weeding themselves out because they kill people, right? And this bird flu example in milk is a great example of that.
Matt (18:08.644)
Yes.
shawn (18:20.494)
I don't understand the far right at all, but I'll just quote Thomas Paine, one of our founding fathers, right? Society in every state is a blessing, but government even in its best state is but a necessary evil. In its worst state, an intolerable one. What is government itself but the greatest of all reflections on human nature? If men were angels, no government would be necessary. I thought that was Thomas Paine.
Matt (18:33.124)
man.
Matt (18:38.532)
Wait, that's James Madison. No, that's James Madison. But he says, but because humans aren't angels, you have to have government. That's the way that that quote ends, Sean. Go. okay. Listen, I'm fascinated that Sam has a red light. That's changed my thinking about Sam because I recently learned about the giant red lights.
shawn (18:47.854)
I just said that.
You
Sam (18:56.443)
there's a, there's a, there's a red light in my house. I'm not, it's not mine. I didn't buy it, but people, you know, people listening to this podcast right now probably are excited about it. And you know, there's no, there's, there's yeah, it does. It's fantastic. but, but.
Matt (19:00.676)
Yeah. huh.
shawn (19:08.238)
That's the beautiful thing.
Matt (19:08.292)
Yeah, that adds depth to Sam.
shawn (19:13.07)
That's the beautiful being about freedom, Matt. Don't vilify people for having red lights or wanting to drink raw milk. It's okay.
Matt (19:16.996)
Let me wait, but this is my problem, Sean. This is my problem. The virus bird flu has not been transmitted from human to human yet, but as more people get infected with the virus, we know that they can mutate and change. And so my concern is when people do stupid things like drink unpasteurized milk and more and more of them get the bird flu, then the virus is going to mutate and change. And then we're going to have another pandemic.
shawn (19:36.27)
There you go, you just...
Sam (19:38.875)
But, but, but, but, but Matt?
shawn (19:39.566)
So you've given good counsel, the FDA gives good counsel, but then you cross a line when you say stupid people drinks pasteurized milk. Yeah, you did.
Sam (19:46.551)
guess what kills bird, guess what kills bird flu, Matt, the red light. So as long, as long as we have that. So we may not pasteurize our milk here, the paranoid part of our household, but we, but we run everything we consume through a red light. And then we sit with the red light on our stomach for a little while after. So,
Matt (19:46.788)
I didn't say stupid. I did.
What?
Matt (20:02.884)
Uhhhh
shawn (20:08.366)
So I'm gonna give Sam the points for red lighting it. And Matt went political and put people in boxes. So points to Sam.
Matt (20:08.388)
Okay, Sam gets all the points.
Okay, alright. Sam, you're up next.
Sam (20:18.267)
All right. So, here's my question for you, Matt. So it's fascinating. Our mailbox, our mailbag topic at the very beginning was couched that, Republicans versus Democrats. And there was almost an implication in that question that we are a Democrat leaning show. Fascinating to me why it is it's I'm not a free market conservative Republican. I am progressive. I am progressive.
shawn (20:36.302)
You too, R.
Sometimes, in some things you are, you're a Democrat capitalist, I think is what you are.
Sam (20:48.699)
no, not at all. I, I, I, I, I already, I came out as a, in favor of Trump long before either of you did. So here's what's interesting. Here's what's interesting. Trump right now is leading. Okay. All right. So as of May 24th, which is yesterday, according to multiple different polls, and I have them all open here.
Matt (20:48.804)
He's just a Republican. Sam's a conservative. What we call him is a Reagan Republican. He's a Reagan Repu -
shawn (20:52.174)
Who cares that you're registered? Who cares that you're registered?
shawn (20:59.15)
That's true. That's true.
Matt (21:01.668)
By the way, that will never happen. I will never, ever come out in favor of Trump. Because I'm a Reagan Republican.
shawn (21:06.158)
hahahaha
Sam (21:17.435)
Trump is kicking Biden's trash right now. Like, wait, not true. He's leading in national polls by 1 .5 points. 41 .4 to 39 .9.
Matt (21:20.452)
Not true.
Matt (21:28.58)
Okay, that we, okay. We do not call that kicking someone's trash. One and a half percentage points. So Trump's ahead and Sam alleges more than the margin of error, but okay. Trump's ahead in national polls.
Sam (21:35.035)
It's, it's more than the margin of error. And actually you can look at all the national polls and not only is he ahead in every single national poll, which is interesting. I'm not sure the last time that's happened, but he's also, the momentum is clearly in his favor for the, for the last two, three months, particularly on a lot would say the Israel conflict, particularly on inflation market. You, you pull on, Hey, who do you feel most comfortable running the U S economy? Trump.
Matt (21:45.348)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (22:10.747)
actually breaks away in a large margin against Biden. So Matt, my question for you and for Sean, but is why is this? You're so bullish on Biden and you're so afraid of Trump. How could this be that this far in advance of the election, Trump is so far ahead, Matt?
shawn (22:14.894)
So,
Matt (22:31.364)
Do you want me to answer or do you want Sean to answer first?
Sam (22:33.115)
Sean, you answer it first and then.
shawn (22:35.47)
Well, I wonder how much of it is the dumb, dumb Democrats have indicted Trump on so many things that he's now a martyr. And I wonder if that is fueling the support. I think it's that. I don't know for sure, but it feels like that. So I wonder if Trump gets past all of his legal woes and starts campaigning, if it'll flip the other way.
Matt (22:57.316)
So I'll just say this, I do survey research as a part of my job and have been for like 10 years. And I'll just say the reason it's like this is because it doesn't matter. It costs somebody nothing to say that they support Donald Trump right now. So, or to say that they support Joe Biden. So.
shawn (23:13.626)
So you're saying your research for 10 years doesn't matter?
Matt (23:18.596)
No, I'm saying that when what you I'm saying that sure, maybe people like Trump, right? Doesn't predict anything in the future is what I'm saying. Of course, there's a lot of reason for people to say they like Trump over Joe Biden because people are very upset right now about what's happening in Israel.
Sam (23:20.955)
You're saying polling this far in advance doesn't matter.
shawn (23:22.862)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
shawn (23:32.814)
So why do your people poll then? You said 10 years you've done polling, that's what you do. And then you said, polling doesn't matter.
Matt (23:38.244)
Why do I do polling? No, I didn't say it doesn't matter. I'm saying it doesn't predict what's going to happen in November. It gives you a really good snapshot in time, right? So let's go back to 1988. So May of 1988, you have George Bush, the vice president at the time running against Michael Dukakis, the Democrat, Michael Dukakis.
shawn (23:43.822)
Okay.
Sam (23:57.243)
going to do it. Not going to do it. Thousand points of light.
Matt (24:01.028)
Michael Dukakis, Michael Dukakis polling at 49%, George Bush polling at 39%. Then you go to June of 1988, Michael Dukakis at 46%, Bush at 41%, then you go all the way to July of 1988, Michael Dukakis 55%, and George Bush 38%.
shawn (24:01.23)
SNL 80s callback. Good job, Sam.
Sam (24:22.171)
Wait, so Matt, Michael Dukakis was president of the United States when? Again? No, no, I know that, but prior to the election, he was president of the United States when? Again? he wasn't. Okay, so it's not... Correct, correct. Yeah. Yes.
Matt (24:27.012)
He lost, that's my point.
Matt (24:31.94)
He was not. So, are you saying that because Trump was president, we can't compare that? Because there's some kind of a record there. Now, listen, it's because the, the polling this far out, the campaigns haven't even begun, right? After there's a debate in June, which they're doing earlier than ever this year, they're going to have a debate in June. After that debate, you're going to start seeing some shifting in the polls that might matter. Once you get it after the conventions into September, October,
shawn (24:39.054)
haha
Sam (24:46.011)
Hmm.
Matt (25:00.068)
me a poll in September and October and then I'll start to be really interested in the results of that for the election.
Sam (25:03.771)
So Matt, in your opinion, what impact does Trump's court case have on the election? Like so far, it's been positive for him, it seems.
Matt (25:13.54)
There are, right, but Trump hasn't been convicted of anything yet, right? So there's about 6 % of the electorate that's Republican that says in polls right now, they would not vote for Trump if he were convicted of a felony. So if those people are telling the truth, if he were to be convicted of a felony, he would lose 6 % of the votes in the national polls. But again, the campaigns don't even care about the national polls. All they care about is the state by state races.
Sam (25:28.219)
Mm.
Sam (25:43.003)
Mm -hmm.
Matt (25:43.044)
And all of those races, if you go to real clear politics and the Cook political report, Trump is ahead by one or two percentage points. But the Democrats have put abortion on the ballot in all of those states, right? Florida is the most important state of all because if Republicans lose Florida, they can't win enough other states to win the White House. 70 % of Floridians want abortion to be less restrictive.
shawn (25:55.822)
Mmm.
Matt (26:10.02)
than it currently is in the state of Florida. The state of Florida has passed abortion laws that are way more restrictive than what Floridians want. So it doesn't matter to me what the polls say in a head -to -head matchup of Trump and Biden, because we don't know who's voting. And if abortion is on the ballot in Florida and it happens there the way it's happened in other states, you're going to have an electorate that's far more Democrat than you normally get in a Floridian statewide race because people who normally don't vote,
are going to turn out to vote in support of abortion rights, and then they will also vote for Joe Biden. So, it's not to say polls don't matter, but polls aren't the only thing that matters.
Sam (26:46.523)
It'll be, it's going to be interesting to see how the court case impacts it. We talked about this last time. Abortion has been looked at for Republicans as a huge negative. I actually think that it's a positive because it's allowed the issue to come back to the individual States and in the States where there's ends up being less restriction that appears to be anti -Republican, but actually Trump paved the way for the state to make that decision. So if Trump's smart and how he spends it and how he takes credit for things.
shawn (26:47.214)
Interesting.
Sam (27:14.587)
He can actually take credit for states being able to craft their own solution to abortion rather than telling everybody what they should do.
Matt (27:21.956)
His problem is he's not that clever because he went on television in Pittsburgh and said that he was going to take away contraceptive rights. And the person who's interviewing him is like, are you serious? And he's like, I mean, we're going to have to look at it, but it's the only thing that makes sense. And he's very clear that he wants to end birth control in the United States. And so now he has to backpedal and say, wait a minute, I wasn't talking about birth control.
Sam (27:38.555)
Well, look, look, look, he doesn't Trump. Donald J. Trump does not have to backpedal from anything because he doesn't forward pedal in the first place. So he is, I've, I've, I've, you know, I'm fully supportive of him. I hope he ends up being the next president United States. I fully endorse him, but he's nuts, right? He's a complete loon. So it's going to be fascinating to see over the course of the election series, exactly what happens. All right. Next topic.
Matt (27:47.332)
okay. Okay.
shawn (27:59.694)
god.
Matt (28:05.508)
Mm -hmm. Sean, you're up.
shawn (28:05.55)
Interesting. All right. So the NCAA, Sam has agreed to almost 3 billion class action settlement. Did you know that? Paving the way for universities to directly pay college athletes for the first time. So the settlement is a revenue sharing model in which schools would pay athletes a cut of the money received from sponsorships, from the broadcasting rights and the ticket sales. So division one schools would have the ability to distribute up to $20 million per year to their athletes and all division one.
Sam (28:13.755)
Mmm.
shawn (28:35.214)
athletes dating back to 2016 are eligible to receive a share as part of the settlement class. So my question is, is it moral now to pay athletes or students, sorry, is it moral to pay students for the entertainment and income they provide schools?
Matt (28:50.276)
So is it going to be hard for me to connect all the dots? But I think I can do this for you. The answer Sean is that it's morally wrong because the Lord only has one university in the world and it's BYU that competes in division one sports. And this change is going to make it so that BYU is no longer competitive in sports. And so it's morally wrong because it hurts BYU, which is the only university the Lord truly cares about.
shawn (29:18.414)
That's funny.
Matt (29:19.972)
It's true. BYU is done in national sports. There's no way that BYU could afford to pay their student athletes $20 million a year. In addition to the NIL that places like Alabama, right, this is 20 million from the university to pay the students plus the NIL. BYU is done in national sports.
shawn (29:33.07)
Yeah, but this... And you're saying it's immoral because BOU is the only university attached to the True Church.
Matt (29:42.34)
think how many people have joined the church because of Brigham Young University athletics. And it hurts, I'm going to say 15 million people. And so...
shawn (29:46.638)
I don't even know that answer.
shawn (29:51.47)
hahahahah
Sam (29:51.931)
So, Matt, I have a question. Why do you think BYU couldn't afford revenue sharing to the tune of some of these other universities? I mean, the...
Matt (30:02.788)
Okay, who's gonna, is it gonna be boosters that'll pay that $20 million?
Sam (30:06.299)
Well, there, there's a, there's an awful, there's an awfully large bank account in a place called enzyme peak for hundreds of billions of dollars, right? Be a.
shawn (30:06.606)
No, it comes from ad revenue and ticket sales.
Matt (30:12.964)
Yeah, I'll tell you right now. I'll tell you right now that the church has no interest in taking that money and spending it on athletics. No way. Well, no, because it's a worldwide church, right? So when you're, when you're putting it in a mall, you can argue that it's an investment in some way that's going to yield revenue, right? You can't argue that about athletics. And so already, if you look at the church's budget, like the,
Sam (30:19.931)
Cause they're busy on a mall. Why?
shawn (30:22.062)
than that. Good point, Sam.
Sam (30:29.115)
Okay. Okay. Well, wait, wait, you just, you made a very valid argument that, that church sports increases membership at a time when membership is challenged. If they can connect, if they can connect those dots, why would they not take the billions out of enzyme peak?
Matt (30:41.764)
no, now I can't make my facetious argument. Now I have to make a real argument. The number one budget item for the church, if you look at all of their expenses, number one is going to be missionary work, number two is temples, and then number three is church education. And there's a strong argument people are trying to make that says,
shawn (30:45.966)
Ha ha ha ha!
Sam (30:53.307)
Yes you do.
Sam (31:07.578)
Yeah.
Matt (31:10.852)
If you're going to spend so much on church education, you should spread the wealth outside of Utah and Idaho and you should be building education, right? That's why there's the BYU pathway program that tries to help people in other countries. If you say we're going to dump more money into BYU sports, then that's a really hard argument to make, right? That we're going to take this money away from like educating the world and spend it on football. But maybe we just call it missionary money and then it would be okay with me.
Sam (31:20.603)
Mm -hmm.
Sam (31:33.883)
Yeah. But, yeah, but if you, if you directly tie it to new members at a time when it's, when membership, some would argue is challenged, you know, that that's a pretty direct and dotted line. I do agree going back to the bigger topic that this will change the landscape, but probably not as big and significantly as we think. So the nil money, the nil money, the nil money is more than this revenue sharing.
shawn (31:34.574)
Are you?
shawn (31:54.478)
Do you think it's moral? Do you think it's moral, Sam?
Sam (32:00.539)
Well, of course it's, of course it's morals. Universities make a ton of money off these student athletes. The, the, the, the basketball player from Iowa is a great example, right? Iowa, the, the, the women's final national championship game had more viewers than the men's college sports. That's an incredible boost to Iowa. That's an incredible boost to women's basketball. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So pair now what's interesting is more money ends up.
shawn (32:21.102)
Caitlin Clark deserves to get paid on that. She deserves to get paid on that.
Sam (32:28.411)
going there from nil money than will ever come through revenue sharing. But it seems ridiculous to have, you know, that's why Nick Saban a lot said, a lot of people said Nick Saban's done. Like, you know, there's a certain amount of nil money there. You know, Alabama as a university, the center of football is going to shift with all this nil money and some of these other revenue sharing resources that are available.
I would argue that's actually a strength for the church and for BYU because of the wealth of the church that backs Brigham Young University. If the church decides to truly get involved and say, Hey, sports is an important missionary tool, which it is. If you go to a BYU football game in any city, anywhere in the United States, and you see the number of members that show up for that game, it's church, state conference, and it's BYU basketball or football, right? And, and.
shawn (33:18.638)
It's huge, yeah, it's big.
shawn (33:23.054)
Well, Sam, the...
Sam (33:24.955)
And, and, and you're going to get more members, new members, you're going to get better visibility there. And so I would take money out of Enzyme Peak and spend all day there versus at a mall. We don't need more Amber, Combie and Fitch, Nululu, Lemon, or SpinCycle.
shawn (33:31.982)
Well, you both gave interesting takes, but one point the Bible agrees with you on in Leviticus 19, 13, it says, thou shalt not defraud thy neighbor, neither rob him. The wages of him that is hired shall not abide with thee all night until the morning. So I think the Bible's clear that you really, when you hire someone, and clearly these athletes are being hired,
You can't rob them of their wages. They're getting, they are a source of revenue and entertainment.
Matt (34:02.628)
Well...
Sam (34:04.379)
Sean, I give you all the points because that was a wonderful way to close that topic because you're right.
Matt (34:08.676)
I did wonder how Sean would find a scripture about the NCAA. Okay. Well, let's talk about the big question. So David Brooks is a conservative columnist. He writes for the New York times and I put a link to his article. It's ungated because I have a subscription. I can give away free articles, 10 of them, I think per month. But anyhow, if you want to read the article, the, were you able to read it, Sean, the whole thing? Okay. Okay. So I actually really like what he wrote.
shawn (34:12.814)
hahahaha
shawn (34:33.326)
Yeah, I read the whole thing. Why didn't you ask Sam that question?
Matt (34:38.756)
Cool. We know the answer. If we're lucky, he's reading it right now, but I'm just pointing, I'm saying this to the listener cause they might, I think it's a really interesting read, but he argues that the world seems to be experiencing a populist moment right now in a recent global survey, 66 % of Americans said that the country needs a strong leader to take the country back from the rich and powerful. And, and that number is compared to 63 % of respondents.
Sam (34:39.803)
Yeah, that's true story.
Sam (35:03.867)
no. no.
Matt (35:08.516)
among the other 28 nations surveyed. And then he says, 40 % of Americans said they believe that we need a strong leader who will break the rules, which compares to about 49 % of the people in the other countries. So he goes back in history and he says, look, 1848 is the year we call the spring of nations. It's where European nations rose up and overthrew monarchies and a lot of European countries. We have 1989 is another kind of important time in history.
with the fall of communism as people rose up and overthrew communist dictatorships around the globe.
shawn (35:41.934)
Now here's the important part of your question, right? So listen to this sound.
Matt (35:45.22)
Yeah, so Brooks worries that 2024 is going to see a wave of moves away from democracy toward autocracy in nations around the globe. Because you already see this. There's a lot of people up for reelection around the world. And with these kinds of like authoritarian populist attitudes among the people, he fears that maybe we're going to see people voting for authoritarian populist leaders that will erode democracy.
shawn (36:07.918)
So that's, so Matt, before he asked the question, I need that clarity. Is this trying to say, is his article trying to say, and are you saying that this move away from democracy towards autocracy is because of current populism? Is that correct? So the populace, so the notion out there, is it the leaders who are saying, hey, you average people, it's your powerful leaders and capitalists and democracies that are pushing you down. That's the message.
Matt (36:23.812)
Yes. Yeah. Yes.
shawn (36:36.398)
That's the populist message, is that correct?
Matt (36:38.244)
That's right. So populism is a distrust in the existing regime and populism is a populist leader goes to ordinary people and they sort of like stir up this sort of anti -system like sentiment and use that to gain power.
shawn (36:56.878)
And currently the sentiment is the world is run by democracy and look how it's squashing the average person. We need to overthrow democracy.
Sam (36:56.987)
It isn't it.
Matt (37:04.9)
Well, the idea would be globally that democracy favors the rich and hurts the poor. And so we need to get rid of all of these democratic leaders and select somebody who's more authoritarian because they're the ones that are going to actually make the changes we want to see.
shawn (37:18.126)
Yeah.
So his polling or his findings show that that's what many people, the majority of the people are feeling and thinking in this world, right?
Matt (37:28.644)
Well, when you, when there's 63 % of the people in the world that say we need a strong leader to take the country back from the rich, and then about half of them are saying we need a strong leader who will break the rules and 40 % in America, then he says there's a chance that this could happen, right? So the question is, would that be a morally bad thing if that were to happen? And if so, then could we prevent that?
shawn (37:31.182)
Yeah. Yeah.
shawn (37:38.702)
Yeah.
Sam (37:48.555)
It isn't it great in this article that Trump has pulled the rabbit out of his hat. He is the populist leader and he has made himself the working classes solution to the rich. Yeah, it is interesting.
shawn (38:00.494)
It's so strange. It is so, so strange. Matt, so I mean, shut up. Shut up. So Matt, I mean, to answer your question directly, we'll go directly to DNC 121 .39. We have learned by sad experience that it is the nature and disposition of almost all men. As soon as they get a little authority, as they suppose, they'll immediately begin to exercise unrighteous dominion. Certainly that's true in political realms, right? Certainly. Very few, like George Washington will,
Matt (38:05.636)
Well, because he understands what it's like for these poor people. He understands what it's like to be taken advantage of by the system.
Matt (38:27.076)
Yeah, but... Yeah... Okay, I agree with that.
Sam (38:29.915)
What, what is so, so, so in the whole idea of history repeats itself, right. And we go through these cycles and, and I, I kind of believe in that concept or that idea. What does history say about, about this? Cause we are in a weird time. I mean, nationalism is on the rise, right? Nationalism globally is a big deal. Inflation globally, inflation is a big deal in Europe. It's a big deal in Canada everywhere. People are frustrated, you know, that the whole rich versus poor.
Matt (38:42.144)
What?
Sam (38:57.019)
thing is made worse by inflation and some of the challenges on income. You know, if people are looking.
Matt (39:03.204)
So the Marxist interpretation of history is that things go through stages and that the next stage is communism, which is like kumbaya, everybody lives together.
shawn (39:13.102)
And the capitalism is a necessary, an evil necessary, and it's a part of that that leads to this higher society. Yeah.
Matt (39:16.196)
part of that.
Matt (39:20.292)
I so I don't think Marxism ever envisioned this particular stage in history, right? I don't know how a Marxist would think about this, but we are at a time of unprecedented.
shawn (39:29.39)
Tell us, Matt, tell us how Mark, we've got a Marxist here. Tell us how Marxist thinks about that.
Matt (39:33.604)
I've read everything that Karl Marx ever wrote. And I'm just saying, I don't think they ever anticipated it to be like, this is something that unprecedented in their theory, right? Cause it's a hundred. No, no, I'm fine with, I don't mind being called a Marxist. I'm not a Marxist, but I am familiar with what he said. But no, what I'm saying is we've never had a time in the history of the world where democracy is as widespread as it is today.
shawn (39:37.998)
Yeah, I know.
Did you miss that I called you a Marxist? You're not going to respond to that?
Matt (39:57.828)
There are only two nations on the planet that don't call themselves a democracy, the Vatican and Saudi Arabia. Even China calls itself a democracy because around the world there's a lot of faith in the idea of democracy. But like we do know from scripture that democracies fail, the people turn away from democracy and move towards autocracy. But I just don't know that it's so where I'm weird is I just don't know that it's a bad thing. Like.
shawn (40:23.31)
So yeah, that's the thing, man. So I went through the history of major populists. So really early on, Mary Ellen Lees, her message was the government of Wall Street, by Wall Street and for Wall Street. She was a populist that was preaching against the power that the big capitalism had. Then you have Huey Long. He was assassinated because his message was redistribution of wealth. He was literally assassinated because he was saying, let's take the money away from the rich. Another one is Joseph McCarthy.
Matt (40:33.06)
She's from Kansas, right? Yeah.
Matt (40:41.924)
William Jennings Bryan.
Matt (40:51.652)
Mm -hmm.
shawn (40:53.23)
anti -communism and liberal intelligentsia. Average people, you've got to, we got to rise up against this evil communist, right? He was a populist. George Wallace and segregation, he was a populist. Was Thomas Jefferson one? So Bernie Sanders is a populist, Biden was a populist, Trump is a populist. It's a fascinating concept because it doesn't go along party lines. And sometimes it's...
Matt (41:04.804)
Thomas Jefferson? Yes. Yes.
Matt (41:16.516)
But the authoritarianism, right? The willingness, so populism doesn't always lead to authoritarianism, but it is at the moment, populist leaders are saying, hey, let's take away democracy, take away freedoms. But I'm just saying, if you look at the history of the Book of Mormon, and you say, when is the most peaceful and righteous time, those most peaceful and most righteous times in the Book of Mormon happened when there were kings, not democracies. And ones that went...
time that we read about in the Book of Mormon with the most contention is when there's that system of judges. Democracy creates conflict in society.
shawn (41:44.174)
Now that's, hang on, so let's, well hold on though. The most successful times in the scriptures were when there were righteous kings or righteous judges. It wasn't just kings or judges. It was righteous kings. When there were wicked kings, it was terrible. And when there were wicked judges, it was terrible. So it had to do more with righteousness than it did with the style of leadership. I don't think you're quite correct.
Matt (42:12.708)
So if 2024 ends up being historically the end of democracy around the world as we know it, it's not a bad thing as long as the leaders are righteous.
shawn (42:21.518)
No, I think there's probably more. I mean, the DNC talks about the constitution of the United States and specifically calls out the elements that support freedom, freedom of property. Okay, that's a democratic, that's a principle of democracy. The freedom of, talks about the freedom of press, right? Speech. So I think the DNC gives us clarity on what principles of democracy need to be supported. And that's why it's immoral, yeah.
Matt (42:48.196)
Well, the first thing authoritarians do is get rid of freedom of speech. And then sometimes freedom of property too. Hugo Chavez in Venezuela was really quick to get rid of oil rights, property rights over oil.
shawn (42:51.534)
There you go.
shawn (42:59.79)
Matt, how about I'll trigger you in this just to make it interesting to end on. So I'm going to quote the great Ayn Rand. The great Ayn Rand. The choice is clear cut. Yes, I know that's why I decided to trigger you. The choice is clear. Either a new morality of rational self -interest with its consequences of freedom, justice, progress, and man's happiness on earth, or the primordial morality of altruism with its consequences of slavery, brute force, stagment, terror.
Matt (43:05.188)
I mean calling, calling her great kind of hurts me. Yeah.
shawn (43:28.878)
and sacrificial furnaces.
Matt (43:30.628)
What I heard is altruism leads to slavery.
shawn (43:33.422)
That's what she said.
Matt (43:35.108)
I don't think that's a very great idea. Hey, did you know when I was in Germany, I visited Trier? Most people don't know about it, but it's one of the oldest cities in Europe and it happens to be the birthplace of Karl Marx. And while I was there, I bought a little bust of Karl Marx to add to my list of philosophers.
shawn (43:49.614)
What the, Matt, you are, you're, you gotta, gotta qualify this stuff. Our audience doesn't sometimes get your humor or your, yeah.
Matt (43:57.412)
Karl Marx, Karl Marx was a great philosopher, just like Anne Rand. If we're gonna say she's a great philosopher, so is Karl Marx. They have their good points, they have their bad points. And visit the birthplace of Karl Marx in Germany if you can, because it's a beautiful city.
shawn (44:06.766)
Okay.
Good, good, say that kind of thing.
shawn (44:15.662)
Why didn't you stop over in Russia and visit Ayn Rand's birthplace? Yep, true.
Matt (44:20.996)
I might not have come home again. They might have stopped me at the airport and gone through my phone. Sam, is it a good thing? Democracy? Or is it a bad thing?
Sam (44:29.275)
Well, it's interesting. Democracy is a great thing. And, this is, this is a cool topic. And you've made some interesting points. It is interesting in our world today, how less democracy is more efficient in the world. So you think about the ability for a government to make fast decisions and enact those decisions. You could argue China is more efficient in the world than the United States is right now. And so the, the, you know,
shawn (44:56.686)
But at what cost?
Sam (44:57.115)
having to have an election and get people on, you know, supporting an idea. Like China is more nimble. Russia is probably more nimble, right? Russia is doing a terrible thing in Ukraine. A lot of its people probably don't agree with it, but Putin doesn't care. He's, he's, he's saddled an entire economy around creating a war machine and they're doubling down right now on it. And so, and so, you know, in, in, in, you know, in, in the ballot of history,
shawn (45:02.478)
what cost.
Sam (45:27.547)
You know, people may look back and say, this probably is a turning point, right? Some of these more efficient, government methods may win in the end. And that's tragic. It, you know, people talk about how Trump and this, that, whatever's going to ruin our democracy. you know, the point you make today is probably more relevant, right? People will end up asking that the democracy be changed on this whole idea of dividing rich and poor, or those who have and don't have.
And it's a philosophy that I think is incredibly harmful, this idea that there's only so much and only some people get it and not everybody can have it. And so people who are citizens of an economy need to rush to get it instead of looking at our market and our system as everyone has an opportunity. And if everybody engages, works hard, everybody can have it. And there's more than enough to go around.
There's, there's this, the idea has changed in the world today versus when we were kids. People used to believe in that and they don't believe it anymore. And I hope it's, I hope it's not the death of the democracy, Sean, do you?
shawn (46:33.005)
What was well said.
Well said Sam. I'd love Matt. I'd love to hear your your little sermon on democracy. What do you think about democracy? You're the political scientist
Matt (46:44.26)
I think that democracy is under threat. And every time I talk about it in my classes, my students look at me like I'm a moron or an alarmist or something like that. And I say, listen, I study politics around the globe. And if the United States were any other country in the world, and I look at what's happening in the United States, I would say we're on the verge of the end of democracy in the United States. Apparently, so are a lot of other countries. It happened in Russia, it happened in Hungary. Like it's a very common thing.
shawn (47:09.646)
So give a positive end to this. How do we fix it? How do we save it?
Matt (47:16.516)
I don't know how to - I don't know how to - I'm not sure -
shawn (47:18.222)
What good are you political scientists if you don't have solutions?
Matt (47:21.476)
How am I supposed to solve the fact that 63 % of Americans want a strong leader to take the country back? How do you fix that?
shawn (47:26.414)
Yeah, yeah, that's what we, that's why we pay you. That's why we pay you political scientists to have that answer.
Matt (47:32.324)
to change people's minds. I can't even convince Sean to stop drinking raw milk. I'm supposed to somehow persuade people that they shouldn't want a strong, like I get it, right? People voted for Obama cause they wanted hope and change. People voted for Trump because they wanted change. People voted for Biden because they want to change and they don't ever see the change from the people they vote for. So they say, why don't we pick someone that can give us the change that we want?
shawn (47:37.774)
Hahaha
shawn (47:53.23)
All right, fine, if the political scientist isn't gonna give the solution, I am. Sam, it's time to run for office. You will lead democracy. No, you, Sam!
Matt (47:57.156)
Okay, thanks, Sean.
Sam could do.
Sam (48:01.723)
Sean's Sean's Sean's gonna run for. yeah. No, it's not me. It's not me.
Matt (48:05.828)
Yeah, we'll vote for Sam. Listen, I will vote for any good person because as we discussed before, good people make good decisions.
Sam (48:12.987)
Yeah, it does make don't you agree as we end that it is a little sad what you bring up like that. It is truly sad to think of our democracy diminishing and even more so that less people believe in it and what it stands for and what it stood for. Right. It's sad. No.
shawn (48:13.23)
What? That's a nice part to end on.
shawn (48:20.27)
scary.
shawn (48:32.014)
Sam for President.
Matt (48:33.444)
great way to end the show. Hey listener, thanks for joining us. We'd love to hear your thoughts about this stuff. I'm gonna be totally honest, I love it when listeners write in and attack Sam, but I also love it when listeners write in with thoughtful comments. So if you have some thoughtful comments you'd like to share, write in, we'll share them on the show.
Sam (48:44.187)
Hahaha!
Sam (48:51.611)
Hey, and Matt next week we're starting with Carly's comments because we have a great editorial comment that we need to include from Carly for next week's episode. We start there Carly. So all right.
shawn (48:57.326)
Yeah, good.
Matt (49:00.9)
Okay, sounds great. Have a good week everybody.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories