The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
November 1 2023; Is marriage the solution to poverty? Young people want more platonic relationships and less sex on TV, The American Dream, Is the US more vulnerable to attacks from our enemies?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Thought Provoker:
Shawn is first. I hope that he will choose something about how underwhelming Boston was. How he had high hopes given all the history there, but it was just another dirty crime-ridden town run by liberals 😊
Next up, Matt: “UCLA’s Center for Scholars & Storytellers, or CSS, found that teens — plus the 18- to 24-year-old demographic that advertisers typically target — think sex and romance are too prominent in TV shows and movies, preferring to see more friendships and platonic relationships. Almost half of adolescents 13–24 felt that romance is overused in media (44.3%) and sex is unnecessary for the plot of most TV shows and movies (47.5%). A majority (51.5%) want to see more content focused on friendships and platonic relationships, with 39% seeking more aromantic and/or asexual characters (ace/aro) on screen.” Does this mean that Hollywood has gone too far? It seems like young people want more of the kinds of shows that were on TV in the 1950s. Is this a case of a swinging pendulum, or do younger people have a stronger moral code than out generation?
Last up Sam. Is the American Dream as cast by James Adams in 1931 still alive and well? What is the Latter Day Lens on that Dream?
American Dream | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Dream
The Thought Provoker. In the fall of 2021 President Zelensky’s approval rating was 28%. Ukraine was divided in factions about how to deal with Eastern Ukraine, and stories were circulating about his corrupt business dealings. Three months later, Russia launched a full scale invasion of Ukraine. Israel held five snap parliamentary elections in a span of less than four years: in April 2019, September 2019, March 2020, March 2021 and November 2022. Prime Minister Netanyahu had been charged with corruption, and in September of this year had just passed a law to help him consolidate power. A month later, Hamas attacked. I could create a similar timeline for what is happening in the United States right now. This suggests that the US is vulnerable to attacks from our enemies. Do we have a moral obligation to act to reduce the threat of attack? What could be done?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:00.48)
Welcome to another exciting episode of The Latter Day Lens with Sean, Sam, and Matt. Our last episode we sure filled up the mailbag. We can't get to all of the stuff in the mailbag, but there were two kind of lengthy essays that I'm going to try and condense and talk about first. So I think Sam, later on for your thought provoker, we're going to talk about the American Dream. So I'll just read this listener's point and we can just let it sort of soak in. So this listener...
shawn (00:28.904)
We're not going to react to it.
Matt (00:31.54)
I don't think there's any need to react to it because they say that I'm right and someone gave me fifty points last week and
shawn (00:33.764)
Oh, there is. Oh, I see what you're doing, Matt. You got points and you just want to shut us up.
Sam (00:34.486)
conversation.
Matt (00:43.7)
I know we're going to talk about it when Sam brings it up later on. So, I mean, we can react if you want, but okay, this listener says 50 points to Matt. I would love to believe in the American dream as I'm sure all of the podcast hosts would too. The reality is that it is naive to think the dream is one size fits all in a world that prioritizes business and economic growth. It's such a challenge to view life from any other perspective was such a wealth gap between the wealthy of society.
And even the upper middle class, it's no wonder we are losing faith in the American dream. So yes, the dream is a myth. It's one we would love to be a reality, but it would be wrong to continue to sell this dream on a silver platter when most immigrants won't achieve it. I'm not even sure that current American citizens can achieve it at this point, while housing prices continue to go up but wages are hardly moving. This isn't a lack of faith in the immigrants or the American people, but it's a lack of faith that people will truly...
give them a leg up in society without having the kind of connections that they need. So.
Sam (01:44.93)
So that's not what the American dream is, and that is what we'll talk about in a little bit.
Matt (01:50.276)
Yeah, we'll talk about it in a second, but listener, I mean...
shawn (01:52.036)
I mean, well done from the listener. It was articulate and very thoughtful, so really awesome. But I have a ton of responses to that, so I guess we'll refer to it later.
Sam (01:52.13)
Yeah.
Matt (01:57.503)
Yeah.
You're gonna have to wait, Sean. I'm really sorry. Last week, nobody gave me any points, and Sam encouraged the listeners to write in and tell me that I was wrong, and instead, this one wrote in to give me 50 points. So I appreciate that. I hope.
Sam (02:13.486)
Yeah, but to be, to be fair, you did put a filter block on our email. So like technically anything that had Sam, Sean, and points you blocked. So I'm not sure that counts. Yeah.
Matt (02:17.5)
Hahahaha
Matt (02:23.676)
It went to spam. It did go to the junk mail. And I just automatically deleted them. That's not true, Sam. Okay. Another listener writes, and we'll, we can react to this. Not me because again, they say that I'm right, but, um, okay. This listener writes, it's important to talk about marriage. I appreciated the ways Sean tried to steer the discussion toward the real policies that can strengthen families.
Sam (02:39.474)
Ha ha.
Matt (02:54.896)
The reason you'll raise the hackles of your liberal friends by talking about it is that we've seen some conservatives use these studies as an excuse to shut down discussions about other factors that limit kids' opportunities. Race and poverty and K-12 funding are still much, much bigger effects than marriage, even in Carney's research. Nevertheless, some conservatives will use marriage research to shut down these other important discussions, as in the problem is not systemic racism or underfunded schools,
It's fatherlessness. Poor people just need to get married and stay married. And the reason it's so attractive to focus on marriage is that it costs money to fix poverty and racism and failing schools. But for some conservatives, the solution to marriage, to the marriage problem is blaming poor people for their solution. And self-righteous lectures are 100% free. So, I have no reaction except for just joy that I feel inside my soul at that comment.
shawn (03:49.72)
Oh boy. So, Matt, so Matt, so Matt, yeah. So Matt, so the point of Kearney's, okay, so I agree, of course you have to consider all of it, right? Family, racism, poverty, the schools, like the inequality in the schools, absolutely. Here's the hip hop, so I initially asked this question wondering, hey, I wanna hear from some of our liberal brothers and sisters.
Sam (03:50.223)
self-righteous lectures. I like that. We got a chippy audience.
Matt (03:52.864)
shawn (04:20.088)
In the face of such clear and obvious evidence that if we all know and accept that fatherlessness is one of the leading and most evidential causes of poverty and the lack of social mobility, why is it, my main question is, why is it the liberals won't fight for it, discuss it? And everything that I researched and found, the answer is really, sorry, it's very pathetic.
And so the listener.
Matt (04:49.664)
The liberal answers are... wait, those answers are pathetic? Wait, you just heard from a liberal listener. Oh, okay.
shawn (04:54.454)
Here's the liberals answer. That's right, it's pathetic. And so was yours last week, sorry.
Matt (05:04.108)
No, I'm not offended, I just... it seemed kind of articulate, not so pathetic. Like what's...
shawn (05:09.24)
No, articulate, very articulate, but the reasoning, to me, I'm about to share, I'm about to share. So if the answer is basically this, okay, I'm gonna divide our two parties, and I'm gonna go, okay, the other side, if there's three causes that are in discussion, let's just take the family, let's take racism, let's take systemic racism, and let's take poverty, right? So first point, Kearney says,
Matt (05:12.496)
What's pathetic about, okay, oh okay, go ahead.
Matt (05:30.344)
Poverty? Okay.
Poverty. Okay.
shawn (05:38.864)
The reason for poverty, which leads to racism in certain aspects is the breakdown of family. So the whole study says the root of it isn't, like the study wasn't.
Matt (05:48.73)
Okay? And-
Matt (05:53.116)
Wait, wait. My question for you then, Sean, is this. Is, if I'm in a single father family, am I in poverty? Statistically. And the answer is no. No. No, this... A study just came out on like... So what do they call it? They don't call it hunger anymore. They call it like food insecurity. And in the United States right now, if you are in a single mother home...
shawn (06:02.744)
Yes. Yes it is. Absolutely. Read the study, Matt. It is absolutely that.
Matt (06:22.232)
or if you're in a home with racial minority parents, you're twice as likely to experience food insecurity as anyone else in America. So.
shawn (06:31.052)
You're, hey, you didn't cite that study in this. You didn't cite it. There's nothing to refer to, but I did. Kearney's study goes against what you just said. It has nothing to do with mother or father. It has to do with single parenthood.
Matt (06:34.321)
Well I know but I'm just-
Matt (06:44.664)
Yeah, but does she break it down and say, here's how single father families are doing, and here's how single mother families are doing? Because what I'm saying to you is, what she's calling breakdown of the family, you can't hear me? What she's calling breakdown of the family.
shawn (06:59.1)
Sam, did we lose him?
shawn (07:04.508)
Sam, can you hear him?
Matt (07:06.336)
What just happened? I'm here! Hold on, I'll come back.
shawn (07:07.653)
Matt, we lost you.
Sam (07:12.798)
see if he blips back.
shawn (07:16.757)
Sam, you're not gonna... Yeah, we may have to...
Sam (07:18.002)
We may have to try again tonight.
shawn (07:20.985)
Uh oh, do you have to go?
Sam (07:22.666)
No, no, I don't. I just, I mean, eventually I will. I'll have to. My, my, my stop time, my hard stops, probably two 30. I could do pro I could probably do. Um, today's Tuesday.
shawn (07:26.095)
Oh, if his...
Sam (07:44.354)
did lose him though. That's a hardcore loss.
shawn (07:51.273)
Does that messes up the whole recording?
Sam (07:52.576)
Note to Omar, you're going to have to edit this one.
shawn (08:01.916)
as it continues to record whether he's in or out.
Sam (08:06.978)
It'll just, in theory, it takes his, it may take his line and it may go out of sync.
Which, not the worst problem.
Matt (08:18.506)
Hey, there you go, that was great, huh? Okay, so should I just pick up where I left off?
Sam (08:20.854)
Mm-hmm.
Sam (08:24.662)
Yeah, just pick up Omar, I'll figure it out.
Matt (08:26.878)
Yeah, he'll figure it out. So, Shum, the reason why you have what she's calling marriage is because you have single mothers are at the highest risk of poverty. It's not the same for, so that's sexism, right? That's saying that sexism is built into her study.
shawn (08:39.608)
No, Matt, you've got to, of course that's a factor. Of course that's inner study. But the study is all about two parents not focusing on which sex is the single parent. It's two parents, two parent privilege is the whole book. And it's about both parents. It's not a... Yeah, it does, but that's not... Yeah, okay, so you're arguing, okay, gotcha. Ha ha ha.
Matt (08:54.262)
Right, but it matters. It matters if, well, again, I didn't read the book. But listen, the listener writes that, the question for you, Sean, is do you agree that marriage is only one of many problems and we should focus on all of them? Or should we just focus on marriage?
Sam (09:01.922)
Ha ha. Oh.
shawn (09:12.12)
Of course, of course. That's what the book even says, and I do agree with the book. Of course they're all there. But for a liberal person to say, play their violin and be whiny about, well, if conservatives aren't willing to acknowledge systemic racism, then we're not willing to acknowledge that two-parent families are the best. That's what he's saying. And that makes me kind of like, how selfish and wrong is that? You can't, it's hypocrisy. If you're saying, yes,
Matt (09:16.913)
Oh.
shawn (09:38.852)
We know that the other side, we know that systemic racism has a role to play in this. Yet, if they're not willing to recognize that, then we're not gonna talk about this other factor that has overwhelming evidence that will help people in social mobility. It puts party above principles, and it's absolutely wrong.
Sam (09:48.009)
You know.
Sam (09:53.366)
You know, Sean, that is a kindergarten argument. If you're unwilling to do this, then I'm unwilling to do that. So so could I get
shawn (09:58.728)
That's right.
shawn (10:02.232)
And so far, that's what Matt said last week, and that's what this listener is saying now.
Matt (10:05.834)
wait when did i say we shouldn't talk about marriage? i don't care i like a marriage i've been happily married for a long time i'm all in favor of marriage i want all my kids to get married i want everyone to get married i was you
shawn (10:09.069)
You said yes.
Sam (10:09.41)
Yeah.
shawn (10:13.132)
You, I know, I know. But you took the side of liberals and you tried to explain to me, well, they're not gonna talk about it. And it's okay that they don't talk about it because back in the day, the government was suppressing them so they're not allowed to talk about it. Oh, so, well, they just choose not to.
Matt (10:30.702)
No, it's not that you're not allowed to. It's that please acknowledge that. Please acknowledge the role of that when you talk about marriage. Wait, wait. What are the things we're supposed to be doing as a government? What are we supposed to like marry people off, like force them into marriages? We're supposed to make divorce harder. What are we supposed to do?
shawn (10:35.94)
And until you acknowledge it, we're not gonna do the things that help families come together to help poor people.
Sam (10:48.834)
Oh?
shawn (10:51.272)
Good, let's talk about policy. The good, that's good. I'm glad a liberal person's willing to talk about policy. Ha ha, you're fighting it pretty hard, Matt. You're fighting it pretty hard.
Matt (10:54.038)
I would love to- I am not liberal! I just don't see a strong role for government in making marriages strong.
Sam (11:01.152)
Oh
shawn (11:05.476)
Like the policies, like we talked about housing vouchers. That's one thing. We talked about, no, housing vouchers encourage marriage in the study. Because there are many factors that cause a single person to go, man, it's not worth marriage. It's a financial reason, right? For example, the case studies that she gave.
Matt (11:10.274)
That's not marriage, Sean.
Matt (11:15.118)
How?
Sam (11:25.654)
Wait, wait, that's, that's a horrible idea to have government incentivize marriage so that people are kind of ordered into, well, we better get married. Right. Like that's, that's.
Matt (11:29.668)
Hahaha
Matt (11:36.026)
Or we should not get divorced.
shawn (11:38.352)
So, okay, then we won't go over the policies that she proposed, but Sam, then you say, okay, if you're saying, Sam, right in front of you, black and white, the evidence shows that if you wanna take kids out of poverty, the best way to do that is to have two parents.
Matt (11:53.662)
Not the best, one of many.
shawn (11:57.432)
It's, but it is one of the best according to the study. You read the book, Matt.
Matt (12:01.551)
Okay. Okay, one of the best.
Sam (12:01.878)
So, so Sean, Sean is the capitalist as the capitalist. I do argue, I do see the argument that there needs to be better income equality because when there's better income equality than whether it's the man or the woman or whatever gender, race, religion, background, the worker is they have cool opportunity to generate income and income ultimately ends up providing.
better education, better housing, food situation, better access to opportunities. And whether there's one, two, three, or ten mothers, fathers, people involved, their economic situation is probably as big, if not a bigger predictor of their family situation.
shawn (12:33.58)
Upward mobility, social mobility.
shawn (12:45.668)
You nailed it, Sam. You nailed it. You just summarized the book.
Sam (12:48.994)
I'll drop my mic now. But that's less about marriage and more about free market.
Matt (12:51.518)
Okay, so what I heard was from Sam was, fix income inequality in the United States and you'll solve marriage problems.
shawn (12:51.757)
All point.
shawn (13:01.24)
No, he said marriage would be part of the solution of solving income. What'd you say, Sam?
Matt (13:05.394)
Okay. He made a-
Sam (13:05.598)
Oh, that's not what I said. I did. I did. I did actually side from a from a capitalist standpoint, I cited on the whole, if everyone has access to income, income will help solve for living situation, economic education, all that stuff. So well, we can go on to the next topic. Because I love I'm excited to talk about John's topic.
shawn (13:19.132)
Oh, you did?
Matt (13:20.138)
Yeah, yeah, that's right.
Matt (13:26.134)
Alright, Sean you're first.
shawn (13:30.48)
Well, this is my topic. I'm sticking with it. How about that? Ha ha.
Matt (13:30.611)
Yeah!
Sam (13:33.206)
Alright, let's do it.
Matt (13:33.81)
Okay, well then tell us, because listen, you're not going to get points unless you have a question that you ask us.
Sam (13:39.67)
Ha ha ha.
shawn (13:40.3)
Good, I'll ask that because I'm shocked. I really am. Like I'm really, really surprised at the answers that I've been getting that seems so political. So the question that I'll ask, yeah. Yeah, go ahead.
Sam (13:48.054)
Well, let, let me propose something. Let me propose something, Sean. We've all grown up culturally in a place where we value marriage super highly. Right. We all value marriage. Yeah. So we have a religious and a cultural expectation in marriage and it's right. But, but now you're faced with having to explain that and, and how that creates an outcome that's better.
shawn (14:00.688)
Because of the church. You're saying because of the church.
Sam (14:16.946)
And I'm going to challenge you. I don't think you've used the research to adequately explain it. Um, it, we, we can go to the doctor. We can go to the doctrine and covenants and we can explain married. It's an eternal principle. It's how we access the greatest blessings available to us on earth and after this life. But when you look at this life experience, we know
Matt (14:17.676)
Right.
Matt (14:23.082)
Yeah, that's right. Well, you're gonna get thought provoker points, Sam.
shawn (14:27.156)
Hahaha!
Sam (14:44.954)
Families are a strong social unit, but in an imperfect world, I'm not sure, I'm not, you know, I, you got to try harder, Sean. Let's hear it.
Matt (14:56.31)
Well, so let me just add to that, Sean. I'm gonna add to that. So it just in my own personal experience, right? So.
shawn (14:58.484)
See, see, okay, go ahead, go ahead.
Hang on, let me summarize here. So the two of you are arguing that marriage is an eternal thing, good for God, but in the eternities, but here on earth, not so much. You have to argue for that. Is that what the Stanchible taken?
Sam (15:15.33)
No, no, I'm not arguing that. I'm just saying you're not using the data to prove marriage out quite yet. Like, I don't think you've connected it well.
Matt (15:16.522)
You-
Matt (15:22.358)
Your argument... Right. Your argument...
shawn (15:25.366)
I got lists and lists of numbers that we went over last week, Sam. You want me to go over the numbers again?
Matt (15:27.99)
Your argument that marriage itself makes people better financially. That's right.
shawn (15:32.328)
Two parents, I'm saying two parents. No, I'm not arguing that. My argument is that the evidence is overwhelming both from the right and the left that when there are two parents in the household that allows children to leave poverty quicker and more often it ensures that they will graduate high school and that they will go to college. You read...
Matt (15:38.222)
So.
Matt (15:56.706)
What I'm saying Sean is, okay, so the first thing I want to say is, when you were reading the book, I was saying, stay in your lane, stay in your lane. Because economists are famous for doing this. They take some statistics that are out there and freely available, then they run some statistical models on it, and then they make arguments based on those models that don't make any sense at all. So... No, no, listen, I'm not in political science like telling like,
shawn (16:17.756)
That's all of you in academia. That's all of you. Ha ha ha.
Matt (16:26.618)
council marriage and things like that. I stay in my lane. I know what I do. So, wait, but wait, first I'm going to give you another example. Freakonomics, right in the book Freakonomics, they talk all about how making abortion legal made it so that there were fewer abortions because, no wait, no, that making abortion legal fixed crime in the big cities because
shawn (16:29.668)
What can I challenge that? Can I challenge that real quick?
Sam (16:38.862)
incentives.
Matt (16:53.234)
women weren't having unwanted pregnancies and the kids were wanted and then crime went down. And it's just like, that's the stupidest argument I've ever heard in my life. But economists do this because you'll see these patterns and trends and they ignore all of the other potential explanations and they just focus in on this one that they found a statistically significant relationship for.
shawn (17:10.968)
Okay, well I can't speak to that book, I haven't read it, so I won't even respond to that, but I will respond to your earlier one. If an economist says, I wanna understand, why is it existing in America that there are factions of people whose children continue the cycle of poverty? And that's an economic study, why not? But economics is sociology, isn't it?
Matt (17:16.282)
Mm-hmm.
Matt (17:29.566)
No, it's not. That's a sociology study. And they've been studying it in soci- No, they're different fields. And sociology has been studying this for like 50 years.
shawn (17:39.368)
Okay, but if just from an economic standpoint, if our society is in a loop of poverty, of course you can look at it from an economic standpoint. And sure, she's an economist. And she says, wow, look at this study. There's evidence that shows that these kids who have two parents are breaking the cycle of poverty.
Matt (17:50.126)
So.
Matt (17:59.03)
So, yeah, so this is again, the stay in your lane thing. Like, you can find statistical relationships for things. Like how you study it matters. I don't wanna go like way deep in the weeds of statistics and how this works, but let me make this point. The point is, I can find generalizable things in big data that suggest that something's going on. And based on these things I observe in big data, then I can go back and try and make an argument. But sometimes those arguments don't make sense.
shawn (18:03.643)
Ah, that's horrible.
shawn (18:10.706)
Sam.
Matt (18:28.042)
in the individual lives. So think about all the people you know in your life. And some are two parents. And then think about the people that you know, think about the people you know that are in two parent households, but they're abusive relationships. No, that's not an outlier, Sean.
shawn (18:32.84)
who have two parents who are thriving way more. Let me think, I'm thinking of all the people I know. The people with single parents struggle.
shawn (18:48.592)
That's an outlier. Those are gonna...
Sam (18:50.55)
Oh, it's, it's not an outlier. Actually. It's more often than not. Right. Or it's not more often than not, but it's, it's not, it's not a small percent.
Matt (18:56.259)
Thanks.
shawn (18:57.296)
That is not true. You guys need to read the book. Read the book. You're saying, you're saying that don't get married because the parents are gonna abuse the kids and you're better off with a single parent without abuse, even though you'll stay in poverty, won't graduate high school.
Matt (19:00.014)
There are so many abuse- I'm just looking at my life!
Oh.
Sam (19:11.455)
No.
Matt (19:15.19)
I'm saying that arguing that a two-parent household is better financially for a family sends a message to an individual that I'm in this abusive relationship and we have kids and now I have to decide what's in the best interest of my family and what's in the best interest of my kids and far too many people would conclude from this book, I need to stay with my spouse that's an abusive relationship because otherwise my kids are going to be less likely to graduate from high school.
shawn (19:42.788)
No one, no one, Matt, that's an outlier. No one disagrees with it. Everyone disagrees with it. No, no, no one disagrees with that. Of course no one would say, stay in an abusive relationship with the kids because it's not gonna be a better thing. That is an outlier and the study doesn't cover that. That has nothing to do with it. No, it's not. The argument is when people, when kids have two parents who aren't abusive, they are going to get out of poverty way quicker.
Matt (19:46.122)
No, the inverse of the argument is also true, Sean.
Matt (19:57.306)
That's exactly what that's exactly what your argument is.
Sam (20:05.337)
Is Sean, I-
shawn (20:11.528)
They're gonna go to high school, they're gonna go to college. And I'm shocked that you guys argue it. I'm shocked, I mean, I'm about to read the.
Sam (20:18.13)
How about if you say it this way, when two people are in a marriage and have kids and they have lots of money and they're educated and they're not abusive, and they're members of the church, I know I'm just putting, I can't believe that I'm with Matt on this. It seems to me, honestly, I can't believe I am with Matt.
shawn (20:28.124)
That's not the study.
Matt (20:29.02)
I'm sorry.
Matt (20:35.21)
Sean, Sean I'm telling you there's no way... Okay.
shawn (20:39.884)
I can't believe you're out with Matt on this. What is wrong with you? I'm gonna read the family, I'm gonna monologue right now and read the whole family, proclamation of the family, and...
Matt (20:50.186)
And Sean, you read it to me and you stop at the point where it says, we'll have better, like not be in poverty and we'll have higher high school graduation rates and we'll all of the things that this stupid book says, God doesn't promise us that if we have good marriages and two parent households, that we're going to prosper financially. That's not what's in the proclamation to the world on the family.
Sam (20:51.607)
Now you're going back to...
shawn (21:12.008)
It's not, but the study isn't just about finance. It is about, it is economics as it is getting, she's saying there's overwhelming evidence that the cycle of poverty gets broken because what happens in two parent households is kids will graduate high school and kids will go to college. They're way more likely to do those two things. So if they're getting an education, they're becoming better citizens, they're following your path, Matt. You believe that education is meant to broaden their minds.
Matt (21:37.774)
But you don't need us two parents to do that. That's what I'm saying.
shawn (21:40.604)
How can you spit in the face of the study? The study is so overwhelming. So Sam, you're not gonna get on my side and say, okay, there's overwhelming study that is recognized on both the right and the left. And Matt's argument is, well, it's not in my field. And so I'm not gonna believe them. Sam?
Matt (21:42.722)
Because I don't like the way that the study is conducted. She's...
Matt (21:55.498)
It's not in her field! She should stay out of her field!
Sam (21:57.8)
Ha ha.
So Sean, I'm the capitalist. So I see the impact of employment and economic situation on families. And I just see a better correlation between happy, healthy kids and graduation. More of a correlation to what you're doing, where you're doing it and how much you're making. Then, you know, I know it's terrible, huh? Yeah.
Matt (22:18.561)
Money.
shawn (22:21.98)
Oh, you guys, holy cow. Sam, liberal, very liberal, Sam.
Sam (22:25.334)
And you know, honestly, I would have made your argument up until Bill Cosby because that was basically Bill Cosby's argument. Honestly, it was, it was.
Matt (22:25.6)
Okay, alright.
Matt (22:32.274)
That was... right.
shawn (22:33.029)
All right, well, I'm gonna bring in one, I'm gonna bring in one semi scripture because it's not Canada.
Matt (22:38.126)
Sam's still getting the points, Sean. You can't change it. Sam's getting the points. No.
shawn (22:40.208)
Oh, that's okay. I agree, Sam should get the points. I don't care for the points. Okay, children, children are entitled to birth within the bonds of matrimony and to be reared by a father and mother who honor marital vows with complete fidelity, happiness and family is most likely to be achieved when founded upon those principles.
Sam (22:55.542)
Oh, wait, if we're going to scripture, you win, Sean, you win then. We're not talking about it now. So as a sociology experiment with data, we're talking about it from a religious perspective and none of us disagree with that.
Matt (22:59.85)
Right. Wait, Sean, we... Yeah.
Matt (23:09.034)
We all agree with you, Sean. We all agree that marriage is ordained of God. We all agree that people are most likely to find success and happiness in this life by finding a partner that they can spend eternity with and raise a family.
shawn (23:20.484)
No, it doesn't say that. It says, no, you're dodging it, Matt. Children, children are entitled to birth and are most likely to find happiness upon the principles of a mother and father. Happiness may be, it's prosperity, right? It's health, it's education. Maybe it's money, maybe it's not money. But your both argument is that money is the solution, not families.
Sam (23:22.798)
and everything else Oaks wrote.
Matt (23:25.258)
No, I also believe that children are entitled to that, but...
Matt (23:37.926)
No, not necessarily.
Matt (23:44.654)
No, we went to money because that's what your study did. We don't want to make it about... That's because that's... that's what your study shows.
Sam (23:44.658)
Uhhhhhh...
shawn (23:48.392)
You're the ones defending the money argument. Both of you are sitting there saying, kids will get out of poverty if they're rich.
Sam (23:55.314)
Okay, so as a good podcast host, I would recommend next topic because we keep going around in the same circle. And Sean, thanks for bringing up the topic. You did a great job. I'm gonna give Sean points for at the end, burying it in the gospel. We all agree with that, Matt. Do you agree as well?
Matt (24:16.638)
I want to move on. I think we should move on. My topic is so much more fun. So UCLA's Center for Scholars and Storytellers did a survey. They do this study every year and they're looking at teenagers because that's an important demographic for advertisers. And what they found was like their attitudes about tv shows and media. And what they found is that teens along with the 18 to 24 year old demographic that advertisers typically target
Sam (24:17.878)
Alright, move on. Next topic. Let's go. Okay.
shawn (24:17.928)
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
Matt (24:45.646)
think that sex and romance are too prominent in TV shows and movies, they prefer to see more friendships and platonic relationships. Almost half of adolescents ages 13 to 24 felt that romance is overused in media and sex is unnecessary for the plot of most TV shows and movies and a majority want to see more content focused on friendships and platonic relationships. So my question, does this mean that Hollywood has gone too far?
Sam (25:10.963)
Interesting.
Matt (25:15.05)
It seems like young people want more of the kinds of shows that were on TV in the 1950s. So is this a case of the swinging pendulum that Sam likes to talk about? Or, or, do younger people today just have a stronger moral code than our generation?
Sam (25:23.502)
Ah, the pendulum. I love it.
shawn (25:26.012)
hehe
shawn (25:34.696)
That is so hard. I do admit that I have a hard time understanding the youth of today. Like, in my deep discussions with my friends and kids, what are you laughing at? Why are you laughing?
Matt (25:47.2)
You have a hard time understanding why they want less sex in TV.
Sam (25:49.75)
What? Ha ha
shawn (25:51.395)
Hahaha
Matt (25:55.566)
They are so bizarre! I used to watch like these scrambled cable TV shows and try and look between the waves to see stuff I shouldn't see on TV, and kids today they just don't want any of that stuff!
Sam (26:07.062)
Eww.
shawn (26:09.045)
Well, it is saying that you did say that there's less of that. So at some point, that's what I'm saying. So I'm confused. Well, there's other things about the generation that I don't understand. For example, when I talk to a lot of them about, for example, the use of the N word and some racial, no, I'm not kidding. And the use of racial slurs.
Matt (26:12.81)
Yeah, it's definitely a shift. No, we're laughing because you don't understand.
Good.
Sam (26:21.059)
Can I share a theory?
Matt (26:32.511)
Were you in Boston recently?
shawn (26:35.452)
that I'm shocked that there is a different, like I always thought that the technology would bring enlightenment. I don't think it is. And so anyway, so I'm confused by this. Yeah, I wanna hear your theory, Sam.
Sam (26:45.354)
Okay, so I'm gonna give you a theory. And this is based on my capitalist leanings, right? So in the workplace, the youth of today, I think are more collaborative, and they refuse to fit into social groups and social circles that we often valued growing up. So the competition in a lot of ways isn't there. You see the race to marry younger isn't there. You also see,
Matt (26:58.487)
Oh.
Matt (27:14.379)
Right.
Sam (27:15.134)
less commitment to frankly, religion, right? And religious ideas. And so perhaps maybe one of the things that plays into this is greater collaboration, less competition, less wanting to fit into social boxes. That could play into what you're seeing, Matt. Hey, let's go back to the good old days.
Matt (27:38.423)
Well, don't you think there's something about them wanting to seek connections on a deeper level than what you get in the Hollywood sort of stuff, right? Like when I was a kid, I would watch the Donna Reed show and My Three Sons and leave it to Beaver. You don't think they want that stuff?
Sam (27:51.998)
No, no, nobody wants to. Nobody wants to see Donna Reed leave it to be. Have you watched that stuff at any quantity? It's racist. It's sexist. It's, uh.
Matt (28:00.65)
Not since I was a kid. Oh.
Matt (28:06.63)
But like, what do people do for fun in those shows? They hang out with their friends, they have a good time, they genuinely care about each other. Like sometimes I think like media, when it's too sexualized, becomes so fantastical that it's like they've lost all sight of the story. Like I sometimes watch a show on VidAngel, right? So one time I watched The Hangover on VidAngel. It takes like all of the swearing and naughty stuff out of The Hangover. And it was like,
Sam (28:10.474)
Yeah.
Sam (28:24.663)
Yeah.
Sam (28:35.378)
The three minute movie. Yeah.
Matt (28:36.118)
45 yeah, it was like a 40 minute movie and I didn't understand it and I was and people say I love the hangover And I'll be like I saw that I thought it was stupid and then they found out that I had all the bad stuff Taken out and they're like well that was all the good part of the movie So I sometimes I wonder if like we put all of the like plot with like we put so much of this bad stuff in Movies and in TV shows that if you take that out people are like well There's nothing there except for just this bad stuff
Sam (28:50.838)
Ha ha ha. Hmm.
Matt (29:03.702)
And maybe they don't like the bad stuff. Maybe they're more righteous than we are.
shawn (29:07.265)
So that, yeah, that would suggest that these kids are more sophisticated, right? They're viewing art and can separate that from the stimulus of.
Matt (29:19.886)
They want to, a majority of them want to see more platonic friendships, more platonic relationships in TV shows. Like what's that Sam? Who wants to see platonic relationships on their TV and their movies? It was different, right?
Sam (29:35.652)
Maybe the platonic relationships aren't modeled for them in single parent families that Sean was talking about, and so they need that. I don't know.
Matt (29:44.414)
Okay, well, we've hit a nice spot in this discussion where it turns out none of us know what we're talking about on this subject. But listener, you might know, and I think that I should get a lot of points for provoking thoughts on this because, well, I don't know. I provoke no thoughts, I guess, now that I think about it. All right, Sam, speaking of previous topics that we haven't talked about nearly enough, what's your thought provoker?
Sam (29:49.076)
Yeah, we have no idea. I have no idea.
Sam (30:04.227)
Oh, okay.
Sam (30:09.474)
So my thought, yes, my thought, it's recognized, but we're gonna fix that here. So ever since, so one of the political characters that I loved as a kid was Ronald Reagan. And one of the things Ronald Reagan did really well in the eighties is he painted this vision of America as a land of promise, a land of opportunity.
shawn (30:10.216)
How'd you like that set up, Sam? Hey Sam, wait a minute. Recognize his setup, please.
Sam (30:36.47)
He would always quote immigrants and people from the American Revolution, the founding of our country, not quotes that Matt would often use, but quotes nonetheless that reckoned and harkened back to, you know, a time where America was the land of opportunity. And so you go back on Wikipedia and you find out that this idea of an American dream was first coined in 1931.
Matt (30:46.812)
No.
Sam (31:05.466)
And this concept, yep, the concept that, you know, in the United States of America, if you're an immigrant, this is one of the very few countries where you can come work hard, learn a language, participate in an economic system, and you can not immediately, but eventually benefit not only your own personal circumstance, but also the circumstance of your family and those around you. And it's not perfect.
Matt (31:06.106)
100 years ago.
Ahem.
Sam (31:34.85)
There's a ton of flaws with it, but relative to every other country on the face of this planet and maybe others, the United States of America has opportunity that just doesn't exist anywhere else. So my question for you today, from a latter day lens and from a human lens, is do you believe that the American dream is still alive as well?
Matt (32:01.694)
And I'm not allowed to take the position that never was, alive and well. So I'm going to, I'm going to read this quote from the Wikipedia. So this is from the American dream. So this is in quotes that, uh huh.
Sam (32:02.19)
But no, you're not.
Sam (32:13.038)
But you don't need to say the there's no part you it's not the Wikipedia. It's just Wikipedia. Go ahead. Yes
Matt (32:18.83)
Oh, just, it's just, oh, I thought you were saying the American dream. Okay, got it. Life should be better and richer for everyone. Life should be better and richer and fuller for everyone with opportunity for each, according to ability or achievement, regardless of social class or circumstances of birth. So I can accept that idea of the American dream as the aspiration of America from its very founding.
But in the Declaration of Independence where it says, all men are created equal, we know that they at the time did not treat every person equally. It was a statement of aspiration. And so to the extent that the United States is aspiring to this, I'm all on board with the idea of an American dream as an aspiration. But as a reality, can I say that
that everybody has equal opportunity or they get their opportunities according to ability or achievement regardless of social class or birth? No. So I'll use an example. I have a friend who immigrated to the United States from Cambodia when he was a teenager. And so this would be more than 40 years ago. And so this individual today is very successful and is doing just fine. And when I talked to him, he says,
What an amazing thing that I could come to this country and become what I've become. And, and we both agree. It's like, wow, what an amazing opportunity for you because you probably didn't have, wouldn't have had that in Cambodia. At the same time, I worked with this person and I saw that he worked probably twice as hard as anybody else. There was a language barrier that prevented him from advancement. There was racial problems that would come along the way, right? And he would do his best to overcome those and ignore those and set those aside.
So is there opportunity for immigrants? 100%. But is it the same for everybody regardless of birth? No. He has to work harder.
Sam (34:18.252)
Wait.
Sam (34:22.286)
Thank you. Yes. Thank you. That is the American dream, Matt. That's what you don't understand. You are so averse, you fragile person. You're so averse to like anybody working hard or having like adversity or conflict or challenge. Like life is not fair, not for anyone. Like to your point, everything you're describing about this person.
Matt (34:27.326)
That's the-
Matt (34:35.514)
Yeah.
Matt (34:47.138)
Okay, so.
Sam (34:50.69)
They endured tremendous adversity, challenges and trial. And despite it all, there was the seeds of opportunity planted here that were allowed to grow. In another country, he would have been just flat out eliminated overall because of his religious background, because of his race, because of his cultural, because of the language he spoke. And regardless of his desire to succeed, yeah, regardless of his desire to succeed, he would have been refused the opportunity here.
Matt (35:09.77)
Yeah. His father was murdered.
Sam (35:20.586)
He thought he became a better person as a result of it and created something great. That is the American dream is imperfect as it is.
Matt (35:29.302)
Okay, if the American dream is that no matter where you're born, you get the same opportunity, then that's not alive and well. But if the American dream is, if you're born somewhere else, you can come here and work twice as hard and get more than you could there, okay, I'm all right. Sure, that American dream is alive and well, but it should be.
shawn (35:38.504)
That's not the record.
Sam (35:46.062)
Pete, would you, it should be universal basic income for every immigrant so that they can just see how they are. We'll play bingo and hope things get better. Go ahead.
shawn (35:53.94)
Are you guys Sam is Matt's?
shawn (35:59.196)
Sam, isn't the argument Matt's basically saying he wants equality in the outcome, whereas Sam, you're saying you want equality in the opportunity.
Sam (36:06.118)
No, he wants, Matt wants a quality on the, on the inside at the start, at the onset.
Matt (36:06.739)
No, no, no. No, no, no. I want equality. I want it to be that if you come here and there's a language barrier, or you're a racial minority, that we look past that as a society because we say all men are created equal. And if you work harder than the person next to you, you achieve more than the person next to you. But that's not how it is, right?
This friend of mine should be way further than where he is in life, if it were a true American dream.
Sam (36:35.906)
So you would have robbed him of the growth that he experienced if your version of the American dream were correct. So can I share a story with you? There's an individual that came and spoke in my company last week and I actually did an interview in another place with him. His name is Chris Nicketts. He has Down syndrome and his dad, his mom got sick, his dad ended up being at home with him.
Matt (36:41.651)
No! He still wouldn't work twice as hard.
Matt (36:47.821)
Yeah.
Sam (37:04.238)
And he's sitting there watching this Down syndrome boy become a teenager. He started to play video games. He was eating a lot and just wasn't doing much. And he's like, you know what? I don't understand why expectations for someone with Down syndrome are so low. And so he had a conversation with Chris. He's like, what would you like to do? What would you like to achieve? What would you like to accomplish? Now Chris is.
Background is different because he has down syndrome. He thinks different his possibility is potential different In the United States of America his dad Nick said, you know what? He likes physical activity. He's gonna combat gaining weight By first running a half marathon then a marathon and then they ended up Setting a goal of running a trial or a an Iron Man. And so this kid
Matt (37:57.387)
Wow.
Sam (37:58.114)
This kid is the first and the only kid with Down syndrome to be an Ironman. He completed an Ironman. And his dad talked to us about the adversity that it took to do that here in the United States. He wanted to do that. And people around him said, "'A,' it's not possible. "'You shouldn't be able to do it "'because he's got Down syndrome. "'You need to protect him.' "'He actually has to go to the Mayo Clinic once a year "'for a full physical top down.'"
Matt (38:07.012)
Wow.
Sam (38:26.734)
Just to prove that dad's not abusing the kid by pushing him so hard. Here in the United States, it's not perfect, but if you want to achieve and accomplish something and you're willing to work and it's not relative to the next guy, it's relative to you, you get the opportunity to become a better human being, to participate and give back more and improve our society. And there's nowhere else on the face of planet earth where you could do that. That's just be nuts. This conversation. All right.
Matt (38:56.586)
I really, I can't do that in Canada. I can't do that in Great Britain. I can't do that in France. I can't do that. I can't do that in Japan. I have to be in America. Okay.
Sam (38:56.694)
Go on.
Sam (39:06.735)
No, no, no. In Japan, there are social classes that prohibit you from having the same opportunity that we have here.
Matt (39:14.442)
Is there racism here that maybe functions the same as social class in Japan? Language barrier things?
Sam (39:18.314)
There's racism here that functions, but there's an awareness of those differences. And there's laws increasingly that help protect against it. And again, it's not perfect. To your point, I love that you're set up in the beginning. It is aspirational in the constitution and in our culture that happens. It's not perfect, but as an aspiration, I agree with you. It is alive and well. In reality, it's chained probably now more than it ever has been.
But it's our job as Americans to continue to protect this ideal and further it and pass it along to others. Sean, what do you think? We're going to cut that off now.
shawn (39:57.956)
I mean, I'm so, so on Sam's side with this. No, hang on.
Matt (40:03.162)
him and I agree. He ended his statement with saying he agreed with me.
Sam (40:04.302)
Uhhh...
Sam (40:08.17)
No, I did not. I said, if you mean it, it's aspirational. I agree with that. Yeah. Oh, but you said you're the soundbite from last week is there is no such thing as a American dream. You called the American dream of fraud last week on the show.
Matt (40:13.97)
Okay, thank you.
shawn (40:14.604)
Oh, that's the part of yours. So here, Matt, is it a Matt, Sam?
shawn (40:26.92)
So Sam, so is, so the, is it a matter of perspective? So for example, the, the reader that wrote in said the same thing, Matt, right? It's a myth because, and one of the examples they gave was I look at what it, I look at the very, very wealthy in this country and compare them to the middle class and go, well, that is unfair. But the reality is.
Matt (40:27.186)
I said it was a myth. It's an aspiration.
Matt (40:50.038)
No, no, it's that the wealthy people are taking away from the rest of society and making it harder for them to achieve.
shawn (40:55.78)
Right, right, right. So, hang on, hang on Sam. So comparing that to the middle class, for example, is what the reader said is really unfair. But isn't it a matter of perspective, because the studies that I found says this. For when it comes to living standards and income, nine out of 10 Americans will fall into the high and high middle class as compared to 13% of the rest of the world that would have even qualified for the middle class.
Sam (40:58.324)
Oh.
shawn (41:24.94)
13% versus 90%. The global standards have four categories, poor, low, middle, and high.
Matt (41:25.64)
of the middle class of the world or the middle class of the United States?
Matt (41:34.074)
Oh, so you're saying we should in the United States, we should be happy because we're way better off than people in Congo or like Haiti or
shawn (41:40.4)
That isn't Sam's American dream working because nine out of 10 people are living upper middle to higher in those higher categories, whereas only 13% live that in other countries.
Matt (41:44.449)
Now!
Matt (41:52.354)
But look at the change over the last 20 years, Sean. The middle class in the United States is dying. So
shawn (41:57.378)
But these statistics are 2019.
Matt (42:00.726)
If you look at the wealth, in the global wealth, there's like a handful of billionaires that own almost everything. And so are you saying should we? Right, well that's what you're saying, Sean.
shawn (42:07.768)
Okay, so, but Matt, it's relative. That's my point, is it's relative.
Sam (42:08.302)
That's relative though. That's relative. I'm in the car. I'm in the car business, Matt. You know how many people have. Cars that are $50,000 and more, and not just one in their driveway. They have multiples and homes worth hundreds of thousands of dollars and food.
Matt (42:24.589)
Uh...
shawn (42:27.325)
But but...
Matt (42:27.69)
I'm going to say in a percentage of the United States, less than 20%.
Sam (42:32.054)
Nope, absolutely not true. I'm going to Google this really quickly, see if I can find it out.
shawn (42:34.664)
The majority of the cars, like 70, I read it yesterday, 70% of the cars that are over 40, what, $5,000? 70% of the people.
Matt (42:40.918)
Wait a minute, now I gotta Google median car price in the United States?
Sam (42:45.642)
Yeah, you should do that actually, because it's gone up a lot, but average car payments.
shawn (42:45.805)
It's like 42,000 Sam, something like that.
shawn (42:51.064)
I think it's like 42,000 and 70% of the country owns that, man.
Sam (42:54.196)
I don't know. I didn't know it. I'm embarrassed. I don't know that. Yeah.
Matt (42:55.054)
The median car price was $31,000. $31,000 for a mid-sized car. I don't know like these different cars. A full-sized car was 47,000. So if that's the median, that means there's as many that cost less than that as there are that cost more than that.
Sam (43:12.703)
Thank you for explaining media to us. I appreciate that. Oh, okay.
shawn (43:12.764)
But Matt, you don't...
Matt (43:15.99)
Well no, it's for the listeners, right? Not every listener, like, loves statistics. Yeah.
shawn (43:17.542)
Ma-
But Matt, the global standards of nine out of 10 of Americans are in the higher or higher mid compared to 13? But that's the discussion. We're comparing America to the rest of the world.
Matt (43:27.39)
of the world, of the world. But I don't live, look, I can't look. Sure, I could take the same house that I have here and I could sell it and I could buy a beautiful beach house in Mexico. That doesn't make my standard of living better.
Sam (43:43.522)
So do you up?
shawn (43:43.56)
Sam's argument is that the American dream provides more prosperity. So if 9 out of 10 people in America have achieved prosperity compared to the rest of the world, doesn't that make his point?
Matt (43:54.694)
I think that would mean the American economic system leads to prosperity. I don't know that it's the American dream that lead. The American dream is an aspiration. I'm going to stay on this subject. The American dream is an aspiration. It's something we hope to achieve, but we haven't yet achieved it. So that
shawn (44:02.332)
How are they not tight?
shawn (44:11.414)
Is the economic system, is capitalism separate from the American dream? Or is it the same?
Matt (44:15.33)
Yes. Go to Wikipedia, Sean. The Wikipedia page is very clear. They're not.
Sam (44:19.638)
think they're the same. I mean, I think they're part and parcel. Like it's the American economic system that provides the opportunity ultimately that results in, in the realization of the dream or it not for the economic system, the dream would be less possible.
shawn (44:35.332)
I think Providence has shut off Matt's mic because I think that's proof that your argument wins. Matt's mic has disappeared.
Matt (44:35.966)
Uh, true. We could also say that about the educational system. Okay. So do I get the-
Sam (44:39.886)
Yep. I do love the debate though. I love the conversation because, um, it's awesome. Hey Omar, we got Matt. We need to have Matt back. That's funny. I'm going to have to go in about five minutes actually. Crazy enough. And my battery may die.
shawn (45:03.142)
Oh no.
Sam (45:06.014)
Oh yeah. 18 minutes. I have this beautiful laptop. It's an alien where man, it is touchy. Touchy. Oh, we lost.
shawn (45:07.415)
Your computer battery?
shawn (45:17.796)
It's a PC.
Yeah, you haven't gone over to Mac yet, huh?
Sam (45:24.042)
You know, I can't do it. I know. So, you know, you can see is just so like. Intuitive. Like I just know it, but for editing, um, all the social media and stuff, I've heard Apple is way better.
shawn (45:40.196)
It is way better. Speaking of antiquate, oh by far, yeah. Speaking of antiquated technology, on the plane I watched the movie Blackberry. Have you seen that? Okay, Matt's back. Oh, it's great. Go watch that movie, Sam.
Sam (45:41.142)
Have you found that?
Sam (45:46.296)
Yeah.
Sam (45:49.898)
No, but I've heard about it. I loved my Blackberry back in the day. Just so you know. Yeah. Hey, Matt, we've got about five minutes, unfortunately. So we'll start back up here. All right. Big question. Who won the points by the way on the American dream though, Matt, you can't finish that. Thank you. All right.
Matt (45:50.752)
Okay, I'm...
Matt (45:56.147)
Omar, this is where we're gonna start up again.
So you love the man. That's fine. Okay, let's go to the big question. Okay.
shawn (46:10.596)
S.A.M. Won the point.
Matt (46:12.591)
Okay, I'll give Sam the points because he ultimately agreed with me and I'll give him all the points for that. Okay, so in the fall, this is the big question. In the fall of 2021, President Zelensky of Ukraine's approval rating was 28 percent. Ukraine was divided into factions about how to deal with eastern Ukraine, and stories were circulating about Zelensky's corrupt business dealings. Three months later, Russia launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
shawn (46:17.52)
He greeted you on one little part.
Matt (46:39.291)
More recently, Israel has had political crises. This is before Hamas invaded. They held five snap parliamentary elections in the span of less than four years. And Prime Minister Netanyahu had been charged with corruption. He had been indicted on those charges. And then in September, he had just passed a law to help him consolidate power. A month later, Hamas attacks. I could create a similar timeline for what is happening in the United States right now that would sound eerily similar.
to Ukraine and Israel. And the United States does have a lot of enemies, so the question is, do we have a moral obligation to act to reduce the threat of attack from our enemies? If so, what could we do?
shawn (47:25.48)
I mean, having a strong military is something.
Sam (47:25.727)
would say no right now there go ahead Sean
shawn (47:30.66)
Obviously, continuing to build a strong military is a deterrent, right? And that is always proved. But then there's the other side of that argument. There's the other side of that.
Matt (47:38.457)
No. Israel has a strong military and Hamas attacked them anyways.
shawn (47:42.352)
You don't think US having a strong military is a deterrent to other countries?
Matt (47:45.747)
Well, other countries could use the kind of discord that exists in the United States right now to start a conflict from within, really similar to what they did with Hamas in Israel, and it wouldn't matter how strong our military is, because there could still be an attack from within.
shawn (48:00.528)
What kind of attack from within? What does that look like?
Matt (48:02.635)
Well, just like what Hamas did, right? You just have a group do some kind of terror attack, and then you put the country at war with itself.
shawn (48:10.416)
But you don't think when 9-11 happened, the strong military response was a deterrent to, I mean, it wiped out the people and the groups responsible for it. It may have created more, but it at least was a strong response.
Matt (48:23.547)
I want to prevent September 11th from happening again.
shawn (48:27.468)
Okay, so you don't think that a strong military does that? Well.
Matt (48:30.205)
I don't think so.
Sam (48:31.51)
Well, don't you think Palestine and Israel are two totally different situations to us? You say Palestine is internal. It's not internal. That's a, that's a, a small nation state ruled by terrorists neighboring Israel, a very strong country. And, and they found an opportunity to attack in a way that engaged both sides into a war. The terrorists wanted that war and they got it. Just like, just like the terrorists wanted a war with the U S.
when they attacked us and they got it. You can't, it would, it would be so nice for us to live in a world where all adversity, challenge and conflict is just completely erased and there's no risk of stepping outside your front door. You can't prevent, you can't prevent thing, terrible things from happening, especially by terrorists.
Matt (49:20.012)
Can we look at what's happening around the world and say, hey, this happened in Ukraine, this happened in Israel, the United States isn't some special place where this could never happen here, let's take steps to make sure that it doesn't happen here. Because, well, so for example,
Sam (49:33.955)
Such as what that things that we're not doing
Matt (49:38.963)
Well, there are people in the United States who would like to overthrow the government. There are people in the United States who obstruct justice. They obstruct... And then there's Americans that support those sorts of behaviors, right? That's one thing where we could say, hey, let's not support insurrectionists or people like that. But even more so, maybe we could be a little bit more kind to our elected leaders and give them more credit for the things that they do. So...
Zelensky's approval rating went from 28% to 90% once an invasion happened. The same thing would happen with Biden if somebody invaded us.
Sam (50:10.646)
Yeah, but that, yeah, that, that always happens. Bush's approval rating went from super terrible to huge. Once the attack happened, people loved Rudy Giuliani from the moment the attack happened, people rally around figures who speak strongly when those things happen. I just don't know that you can, you can't, you can't legislate that. What are you going to do? Tell people they've got to be nice to politicians?
Matt (50:38.859)
Yeah, I actually think that the church tells us these sorts of things all the time, right? They say, move beyond the two parties. They say, there's good in both parties. They say, look for good people to lead you. And I think that we, when we give into our natural tendencies to just sort of divide and fight and find fault with the other side, rather than looking like for the best in other people or looking for good candidates, we set ourselves up for these kinds of problems.
And so I just think it's like something to think about, like these things happen in other countries and they lead to big problems, and we shouldn't think that we're immune from that possibility.
shawn (51:13.864)
Thank you.
shawn (51:18.672)
So Matt, you're saying...
Sam (51:20.448)
I agree that the division in the US is our biggest threat. And I think there's a quote somewhere that, you know, it's not an attack from outside in. It'll be a disagreement and it'll be a conflict from within that will ultimately be our downfall.
shawn (51:38.172)
So if we all agree on that, which is well articulated, how do you accomplish that, right? Sam suggested you can't legislate that. And we're a small group of people that listen to the living prophet. So Matt, how do you accomplish that in a world that is so, in a country that is so divided by media and by political parties? How do you do that?
Matt (51:59.487)
I just think it's important for people to recognize that there's larger things at stake. So they think, I can go on social media and attack my political opponents and it doesn't cost me anything. Or I can watch TV programs that spend most of their time attacking the president or the speaker of the house or whoever and it doesn't cost me anything. And I just think that like, what we should do is we should say, hey, these people are elected officials. My wife suggested recently that we should pray for them.
when you pray for your leaders to make good decisions that helps you have better feelings towards them. Like there's a number of things we could do as individuals that would have a large effect if everybody started doing it. But sometimes I think we say, it's just a game, it's just fun, it's no big deal, and we don't recognize that it sends a message to other countries in the world, and it makes people who are your enemies feel like you're weak and a vulnerable target.
shawn (52:52.232)
Great message. That's a great message. Yeah, I would like to discover more pragmatic ways to do that, but that's a great message.
Matt (53:00.371)
Okay, well, we went all over the place on today's podcast. Thank you, listener, for hanging out with us. We hope you'll join us again next week. And if you'd like us to continue these discussions, you should send us gobs and gobs of emails because then we'll never be able to let it go. But if you want us to move on, feel free to just say, hey, Matt was right, and we'll just move on. All right. Talk to you again next week.
Sam (53:13.98)
Ha ha.
Sam (53:19.234)
Move on. Exactly.
shawn (53:19.58)
Hehehehe
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories