The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
October 25, 2023: Is the US a meritocracy? Killers of the Flower Moon, The Two-Parent Privilege, The path to communism/authoritarianism
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Thought Provoker:
First up, Sam. “participation trophies vs meritocracy”
Next up, Matt.” Martin Scorsese’s newly released film “Killers of the Flower Moon” is based on actual events that happened in Oklahoma in the 1920s. You can follow the link to read the full history, but the short version is that US government policy toward native Americans (specifically the Osage Tribe) in Oklahoma required them to prove that they were competent enough to manage their wealth that came from oil discovered on their lands. If an Osage citizen were deemed incompetent (determined by being too Native American) a guardian would be appointed to manage their assets. Since guardians would inherit the wealth of the Native person should they die, lots of Osage citizens started being killed. What moral obligation does Congress have to the Osage people? They passed a law in 1921 that allowed white people to steal the assets of Osage Natives. What ought to be done?”
Finally, Shawn: “A new book out by University of Maryland economics professor Melissa S. Kearney, is getting lots of attention. She claims with clarifying bluntness, that marriage is “the most reliable institution for delivering a high level of resources and long-term stability to children.” She marshals the voluminous evidence in her new book, “The Two-Parent Privilege.” in the U.S.; American children are increasingly being born and raised by single mothers. The U.S. has the world's highest rate of children living in single-parent households, according to a 2019 Pew Research Center study. Almost a quarter, or 23% of U.S. children under age 18, live with one parent and no other adults. Kearney's argument that children who grow up in unmarried households are fighting the odds has progressives miffed and accusing Kearney of stigmatizing single mothers. Conservatives are celebrating her findings as validating their support of marriage. For decades, liberals have run away from the issue of marriage and single parenthood, afraid of stigmatizing unwed mothers and their children. Now some are wondering whether the conservative marriage movement, embraced by President Bush, is on to something. Can government help poor communities by promoting marriage? Have families disintegrated in the wake of the liberals’ expansion of the welfare state.
The Big Question (From a Listener):
“Your gun control discussion reminded me of something I think Republicans get wrong. I'd love to hear your responses. In the Republican mind, the origin story of totalitarian communism goes like this:
1. A free and democratic country decides to provide unemployment benefits.
2. They provide health care to everyone.
3. Their children read Marx at college.
4. They vote in a communist dictator.
But the history of communism is almost the exact opposite. It goes like this:
1. An oppressive and wealthy dictator runs a country for the benefit of the wealthy (the Romanovs, Fulgencio Batista, the Qing dynasty, etc.)
2. He ignores the suffering of his people.
3. He lets his wealthy friends plunder the country.
4. The workers rebel and kill the dictator/czar/emperor.
5. One of the rebel warlords becomes a communist dictator.
Historically, the path to communism is not to provide health care and education for the working class. That's the path to becoming Norway. The path to communism is ignoring
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:00.561)
Hey, listener, welcome to another exciting episode of the Latter-day Lens. Good to have you with us. I'm here with Sean and Sam and I'm Matt. So we'll start out with the mailbag. So one listener writes, "'I really can't wrap my head around why people "'have such beef with TikTok "'anymore than any other social media platform. "'Imagine the state of Utah suing PlayStation or Nintendo "'for the amount of time their kids were spending on gaming.'
Shouldn't parental involvement be a better solution on monitoring what kids are watching rather than government bans? There's no, oh, okay. And then they say, why isn't Utah like banning Facebook and other meta apps? Which by the way, did you guys see that there's a lawsuit that they filed today? 33 states are suing meta for, I don't know, this sort of thing. Guess who's not a part of the lawsuit? The state of Utah, yeah.
Sam (00:32.554)
Yes.
shawn (00:52.388)
Ha ha!
Sam (00:52.402)
Utah. Yeah.
Matt (00:54.061)
That's right. Idaho, Kansas, all these conservative, not Utah for some reason. We don't like to sue places. We like to ban them. So yeah, so I don't think I don't the question, Sam answer the question. Oh, wait.
shawn (00:57.265)
I'm not listening to you guys.
Sam (01:08.054)
Uh, we, we already decided last week that, uh, government has no place banning Tik TOK like it's silly. Sue them, take their money and whatever, but, uh, allow the market, the free market to restrict it. But the problem is China, isn't it? China. Everybody's afraid of, yeah, everybody's afraid of China right now. They don't want Tik TOK getting all of our personal data. And then when the, you know, invasion happens, they know where we live. I don't know.
Matt (01:24.989)
Well, that's why people care about TikTok, right? Because of China.
shawn (01:37.272)
So, yeah. So wouldn't.
Matt (01:40.093)
But we're not worried about Meta or Google. Google knows everywhere I've been for the last 15 years. Yeah, China could never hack into that if they needed to. Yeah, I think that's the bigger thing with TikTok is China. Okay, this is, I don't know, Sean. I think you're trying to make this podcast about religion, but that's okay. This is from a listener. And so we've got... I...
shawn (01:45.189)
It's.
Sam (01:45.622)
Yeah, but the Chinese don't have that. Oh, yes, they do. Sorry, they have everything. No.
shawn (02:04.862)
I'm not the one that said something that has then been hounded on by people for months for you to answer. You're the one that said it.
Matt (02:10.769)
I know, I know, I know. Another listener asks, as an evangelical, I appreciate the honesty from Matt in saying he thinks traditional orthodox or evangelical Christianity is much further from true Christianity than many non-Christians. However, he has not provided any examples or clarity about that claim and even tried changing the subject when asked for clarity. Please provide any example of a non-Christian religion.
Sam (02:32.682)
Good point.
Matt (02:39.453)
being closer to true Christianity than orthodox Christianity.
shawn (02:43.92)
That's a bold statement, Matt. It was a really, really bold.
Sam (02:45.602)
How about Scientology? Does that count? No.
Matt (02:48.753)
Okay, so since the listener is an evangelical, I'm going to go to two Bible verses, all right? And I'll even read them from the New Living Translation because I think they like that one better, right? So James, chapter 1, verse 27, pure and genuine religion in the sight of God the Father means caring for orphans and widows in their distress and refusing to let the world corrupt you. And then the other one is...
shawn (02:54.096)
Oh, okay.
Matt (03:16.857)
Matthew chapter 7 verse 21. So then
Matt (03:46.253)
I'm defining true Christianity as acting the way that Jesus would act, right? There's also that verse when they say, when did we see you naked and clothed with you and hungry and fed you? And he'll say, and he says, inasmuch as you've done it unto one of the least of these, my brethren, you've done it unto me. So in order to be a true Christian, Jesus is telling us, you don't have to say Jesus, Jesus all the time, you don't have to do everything in His name. You just have to be good.
And you have to live the way Christ would have you live, and you have to be kind and charitable and help the poor and help the needy. And I see atheists doing that. I see agnostics doing that. I see non-believers doing that. And so in my view, that's closer to Christianity than the people who get all caught up in the divisions that the evangelicals and other Christians want to make in the world. They want to be like, we're the true Christians. We're the right church. We're the right way. You don't call it
him by Jehovah, some religions do that. You don't say, I accept Jesus and profess his name, and so you're not really Christian. And I say, that's not what Christ was teaching. Christ taught, live the way he lived, follow his teachings, and it doesn't even matter that much if you say, do everything in his name. Yeah.
shawn (05:01.028)
Wow, I've never really heard that interpretation of those two scriptures, but that's interesting. That's got me thinking. And I certainly am gonna hear it from my friends who listen and who are really wanting your answer to that. I didn't expect that answer, and that's an interesting answer. Okay, all right.
Matt (05:15.341)
They're going to love it, right? Well, so what distinguishes us, I think, from other Christianity is, so we, there's two things. We believe that grace not only saves you when you die, but grace helps you do good works when you're here on earth. So grace helps us to do good things. And I take from that an eternal view, where I say Christ helps people come to Him even before they know who He is by helping them to change their lives and do good work. So they don't have to necessarily know Jesus.
Sam (05:15.426)
Good answer.
Matt (05:44.473)
in order to be partaking in the grace of Jesus. And that's because of this other thing that we believe, which is the light of Christ. We believe that everybody has the light of Christ when they're born that guides them into understanding good and bad. And so I believe that people who have no idea who Jesus is can be following Jesus, can be saved by His grace, can be doing good things through His power, even if they have no idea who He is.
shawn (06:09.252)
That's well done. I think you've answered it and we'll give him plenty of fodder to come back to me. Do you think that applies? But sometimes we as a church talk about a strict doctrine of, well, wait a minute, Christ clearly also taught that you have to come unto him for salvation, which means you have to have faith in him and his identity. You have to have repentance and you have to be baptized and entered into those covenants. So there are very specific things that one must do, but you would be saying, yeah, but.
Matt (06:14.505)
There you go.
shawn (06:38.428)
evangelical isn't doing those things necessarily either. Is that right?
Matt (06:43.013)
Right. Well, so what I'm saying is true Christianity, right? So when Christ says what pure religion is, it's taking care of other people. When He says the things that matter the most to Him, it's how you treat other people. And I believe that the people who exercise faith in Him will, you know, they'll accept His ordinances or they'll accept Him. But you don't actually have to know Him in order to accept Him and to follow Him. That's what I'm saying. A Buddhist who's never heard of Jesus, who doesn't know anything about Him, who's following
what he thinks is like the Buddhist teachings, we believe that that's the light of Christ guiding him to do those good things. So there's good people all over the world who are behaving better than Christians because of Christ's grace and Christ's power. That's what I don't know.
shawn (07:25.712)
So to you it has less to do with kind of the specifics of doctrines and it has more to do with not behaviors because it's not the works that people do that bring us close to Christ.
Matt (07:35.599)
Well, Jesus is pretty clear about works. You have to feed the, you have to clothe the naked and take care of the widows and take care of the poor and the hungry. There's all kinds of works you have to do.
shawn (07:42.744)
Okay, good.
shawn (07:46.956)
Okay, good, good one. Okay.
Matt (07:49.065)
Okay. Apparently talking about Muslims celebrating Jesus in Bethlehem wasn't enough, so we have a little bit more depth on that now. Okay. Well, that's all from the listener mailbag. Unless, Sam, did you want to say something about that? Okay. Sounds like... And I will be...
Sam (07:50.702)
Good job, Matt.
Sam (08:07.726)
I'm gonna leave it to you. I think it's great. I think, you know what? You now have two solid examples, so we'll go with that. All right, so do I get the first thought provoker, Matt, for the day? All right, so can I vent a little bit and share something that's massively frustrating? So y'all know, everybody knows that I'm in the business world. So I get to watch people as they develop their careers professionally. We know in religion, in the gospel, part of our purpose on being on earth
Matt (08:19.393)
Yep, you're up.
Matt (08:27.845)
Yes.
Sam (08:37.582)
to repent and prepare to meet our Heavenly Father, right? And it's, we know that this life is a becoming, right? We start in one place, through repentance, through faith, we become a completely other person. So why the heck does society put so much stock in participation trophies? So what I mean by that is, in today's world, in the business place, even I would say in many church settings,
people are more concerned about accolades for the sake of accolades and attaboys for the sake of attaboys and girls than they are about real progress. So I don't know. Congratulations. Yeah.
Matt (09:16.651)
What's an atta boy, Sam?
shawn (09:18.285)
like an ad, an ad, an adaboys when you have a podcast and you are giving topics to each other and you're vying for points.
Sam (09:25.742)
It's actually a sandwich. It's an ice cream sandwich too, isn't it, Attaboy? They're really good.
Matt (09:26.333)
Oh, oh. No, that's a fat boy. Okay.
Sam (09:31.834)
There's also an attaboy, it's chocolate covered, very similar, but. So why have we in our world today taken away adversity and challenge and struggle, and we wanna just give everybody participation trophies? In the workplace, you think about it, in the church, we used to have a pretty rigorous scout program. Girls and young men fought to get guys, the Eagle Scout, I don't even know what the Girl Scouts went after, what did they get?
Matt (09:59.633)
The Young Womanhood Medallion
Sam (10:02.11)
Young womanhood medallion, it was a struggle, it was a challenge to get it to achieve it, right? Not everybody got it, right? And it's interesting, we'll put this in the notes, but there's some great research that shows, and I'll read this, it harms a child that constantly prays a child for merely showing up. It artificially raises self-esteem, the trophy actually takes away from the motivation to improve. It keeps kids from feeling frustrated and experiencing failure. And then, Matt, you meet them in the college setting,
Matt (10:07.853)
Yeah.
Sam (10:32.15)
where they're fragile and they can't take a little bit of criticism and their parents have to jump in and save them, right? I meet them in the workplace where they struggle to perform at a basic level and they fail before they become adults to understand a simple truth, which I learned from an NCAA basketball coach, Tom Izzo, and he said, hey, one of the things that's killing collegiate basketball is the NIL transfer.
Matt (10:32.466)
Ugh.
Matt (10:38.906)
Yeah.
Sam (11:01.986)
the transfer portal, where these athletes, when they come up against adversity with a team, they can go transfer and play somewhere else if they're super talented, rather than stay in a place, go through the adversity and the struggle, and become a better player on the other side by learning to work with a team. So what should our take, this is the question, Sean, you first, what is our obligation as members of the church? Is it to allow adversity? And.
Avoid participation trophies and find a way to reward based on meritocracy or otherwise Sean
shawn (11:39.344)
Hmm. Good question, Sam. Well, I think there's certainly a place for some trophy style. Everyone gets a place, right? There are some people who are truly disadvantaged. You know, like I've got family members who either have mental disabilities or, and it does kind of mean a lot to them to be a part of a program or a game or something where they participate and can enjoy in the.
the wins, right? So I think there's a place for it, but I think the latter day lens would teach for most of us that being accountable is more important than having false rewards. So I think I'm gonna be on your side, that the meritocracy, I know there's many who don't like the, I don't think I agree, yeah, no, yeah, I think the meritocracy side, it wins out, Sam, I think I agree with you on that.
Sam (12:33.622)
What don't you agree with, Sean? You almost went down a path there. Come on, give it to us, Sean.
Matt (12:34.053)
We... Right, we almost got... We almost got Sean to be honest.
shawn (12:39.572)
Well, you brought in the word meritocracy, and doesn't that, Matt, doesn't that, that's referring to a political system, a very specific
Matt (12:46.525)
Well, no, it's just, it's just you, you get based on your merits, right? So it doesn't have to be political. It would be like in a job, you hire the person who's best qualified for the job. So yeah, meritocracy means based
Sam (12:57.794)
See, Sean, I'm trying to have you take us back to scripture and say that the atonement solves for all the meritocracy and it allows for participation trophies, but yeah. So Matt, what's your take?
Matt (13:05.373)
the inequality. Listen, do you know why? Do you know why businesses give away junkie awards that don't mean anything? Because then they can pay people less and they'll stick with their jobs because they'll be like, No, my job really values me. I got a gift card this Friday, all the time. And it happens to me in my work, I get like these engraved plaques of way to go. And I'm like, stop it. I didn't do anything. If I really did a good job, give me money like
shawn (13:09.181)
Oh.
shawn (13:19.838)
I've seen that Sam. I've seen that.
Matt (13:31.261)
Don't give me this stupid certificate and then a gift card to the university store. Like that doesn't mean anything. Like how about you compensate my effort and then that will motivate me to do more. So businesses do it because it's a cheap, simple way to keep employees happy and you don't actually have to give them money.
Sam (13:45.25)
Yeah, but the problem exists well before you come into the employment place. Like it exists before you arrive at college. It manifests itself in grade inflation in high school. I mean, kids that have 4.2 and can't spell good, right? Like that's a problem.
Matt (13:57.661)
So that's, that, that's, so, so that comes from, and this probably happens in the business world too. When you have customers evaluate the performance, right? Then you're going to, as a, as a business, you're going to try and cater to those customers. Well, what happens in schools is you're having students and teachers evaluate the performance. And guess what they care about? They care about grades. And so you get grade inflation.
shawn (14:02.164)
I'm going to go.
Matt (14:23.897)
If you're, if you're like a referee or you're some, some kind of a coach, right. They evaluate you based on not your team performance. They evaluate based on their kids performance on your team. So there's all these weird incentive structures in society that say, like, just give people what they want, just tell them what they want to hear. And then they're going to leave you alone, or they're going to give you good reviews or something like that. So I don't know. I don't think that that's all bad. If I'm being totally honest, I think that that's fine. Like.
We don't live in a meritocracy. We don't live in a world where if you work harder than the next person, you're gonna achieve more than the next person. We live in a world of like favorites. No, we don't, Sam. No, we live in a world where who you know is more important than what you know. And where you come from is-
Sam (15:01.058)
Yes we do!
Sam (15:09.712)
I believe that partially, but that's not an absolute truth.
Matt (15:13.965)
It's so rare to like, there are so many deserving people. Like if you say deserving, right? There's like, at least in my world, when we look at job candidates and I say who gets hired and who doesn't get hired, it is not a meritocracy. There's so many.
Sam (15:27.382)
Matt, it's the American dream. It's the American dream that you come here from another country and you work hard and as a result of your labors, you pick yourself up from wherever you came from and you teach your kids the English language and about the American economic system and they're provided opportunity on the backs of your labor and your merit and they go on to create a better life. That's the American dream. It absolutely is true that if you work harder, you can create a better result. Is it perfect? It's not, but it's better.
Matt (15:53.125)
Well, well, the truth of all dreams, Sam, is that they're not actually real, right? A dream is a word that we use for like a lie or a myth or something, right? If I say, like sometimes my wife, sometimes in the morning, my wife will be mad at me and I'll be like, what did I do? And she's like, I had a dream last night that you did this and this and this in your dream. And I'm like, that's not real. And it's the same thing with this American dream that you keep telling me about.
Sam (15:59.657)
Oh no.
Sam (16:05.71)
liberal, democrat, communist.
Sam (16:12.988)
I can understand.
Matt (16:21.849)
It's not real. It's like a myth that we tell ourselves and we tell kids.
Sam (16:24.11)
Wait, you don't think the American dream of coming to this country from another place that's disadvantaged and you have no opportunity to outperform your social class, your economic class, all the other castes and places other countries put you, you come to the United States and you're on more of an equal footing where if you work hard, you put in an honest day labor, you have a better chance of getting ahead. You don't think that exists?
shawn (16:24.24)
Hang on. Okay, hang on, hang on. Matt.
Matt (16:54.077)
Tell the Chinese about that, from the Chinese Exclusion Act in the 1890s, to all the laws, the TikTok we just talked about, banning today. It's not true for everybody. Not everybody has equal opportunities.
shawn (17:04.026)
Number Matt.
Sam (17:05.038)
It's not true for everybody, and I agree that it's not perfect, but don't you agree that the American dream is live and well? If it's not alive and well, you're the problem. It's not the myth. It's not a myth. You're teaching our kids in a university setting that it's dead and it's a myth? Oh my goodness.
Matt (17:12.149)
It's a myth.
Matt (17:22.145)
I think that it's better for them to be aware that there is not a meritocracy in the United States of America. That you can work hard and you're not necessarily going to achieve what you've earned through your merit.
shawn (17:28.268)
Matt.
Sam (17:31.566)
Sean, do you disagree with what Matt's saying? I give Sean all the points and some extra points. Can...
shawn (17:33.972)
I do full heartedly. Yeah. I mean two things. Okay. Two things though. Two things though. There's one, it can be true at the same time that there of course is nepotism. No, no, hang on it. No, no, I'm not. I'm not. I'm not. I'm not. I am. Give me the, I got two things to say. Believe me. Believe me, Sam. Believe me, Sam. I'm coming to your side. Just let me say the first part. So there's, there's of course nepotism.
Matt (17:36.681)
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Sam (17:45.798)
No, you're handing out participation trophies. You do not do that. Pick a side, dang it. I'm fired up.
Matt (17:49.036)
Hahaha
Matt (17:54.561)
Eventually he's gonna eventually he's gonna get on your side soon
shawn (18:02.692)
There's of course meritocracy. There's of course, like unfair advantages. Sure, there's all of that. Yes, there is. Right, so for you guys to kind of talk in the black and white is not quite accurate, Matt. When you shake your head, no, no. I don't think that's accurate. Because now if you go to Sam's side, man, we could talk here for hours and hours about people we know, people we know collectively in common that have absolutely based on merit.
Sam (18:03.148)
Yeah?
Matt (18:06.821)
racism, sexism, economic disadvantages.
Sam (18:11.166)
Religious inequality. Yeah.
shawn (18:31.672)
work their ways to achieve some amazing, wonderful happiness in this world, which is the American dream that Sam's talking about. Sam or Matt, we could talk for hours and talk about, come on, you can't reject that. We know, yes.
Matt (18:42.185)
people that have done that, based solely on their own merits.
Sam (18:46.678)
No, no, no. The American, you have to have help, but that help is more readily, historically it's been more readily available here in the United States of America. That is the American dream, is that you can throw off some of the chains that bound you in other countries, like organized crime in Ukraine, right? A caste system in India. Is it perfect? It's not perfect?
Matt (18:48.345)
Right, right, you have to have help.
Matt (19:02.653)
So.
Sam (19:16.726)
But I see it every day in my business where somebody who really wants to work, who's really interested in putting in their best, they raise their position. They have a better shot at it. It's not perfect, but they have a better shot at it.
Matt (19:29.709)
and you reward them by compensating them with money, not with the trophies. And so the reason that you have these trophies is because there's some people in society that no matter how hard they work, they aren't going to merit something better. And so we say, have a trophy. Like, this is what you've earned. Like, this is what you get. You get this nice little trophy, this nice little certificate, and we're gonna keep you where you're at. Because if you really, really value what they're doing, you don't give them a little, like a pat on the head or an attaboy. You give them something more.
Sam (19:38.87)
You cynical, cynical man.
Sam (19:52.763)
Not true.
I know I agree. So in our business, we recognize that people value both, that people want the economic piece. They need the income, and we provide that. But also, we recognize that you've got to acknowledge people. But you can't just hand out participation trophies when someone does their basic job, and that's it. You've got to recognize people for doing things above and beyond. I do believe in a meritocracy. Now let me ask you this.
Matt (20:25.747)
Mm-hmm.
Sam (20:25.862)
If, if we become better as we struggle to achieve, the church did away with the scouting program and the Eagle Scout, the Eagle, that was a tough thing to get. It caused young men to develop over time. Should they bring something rigorous like that back as an achievement that people could present to universities for acceptance? It was used in, right? It was a big deal. Ask me if I'm an Eagle Scout. I'm not.
Matt (20:51.356)
hahahaha
Sam (20:56.072)
I'm not.
Matt (20:59.209)
There has never been a single day in my life that I regretted stopping at Star Scout and not continuing on. Like there's nothing about the Eagle Scout. Like the Boy Scouts program in my opinion is the epitome of giving you awards for nothing, right? Hey, you sat in the woods for three hours, have this environment. No, no, no.
shawn (21:05.712)
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Sam (21:10.212)
Oh
Sam (21:15.658)
Yeah, actually, I agree with that. I agree 100%. I retract the question. All right, Sean, you get all the points. You get all the points, because I completely disagree with Matt. And I think Matt is ruining the people that he's teaching by saying that the American dream is dead. And I wish every listener that we have, how many of her? Five, six people, seven people, whatever. Will you write the pot? Matt, what's our email address?
Matt (21:28.765)
Hahaha!
Matt (21:34.009)
I'm gonna go.
Matt (21:40.121)
It is thelatterdaylens.gmail.com.
Sam (21:42.838)
Will you please tell Matt that the American dream is alive and well, and will you encourage him kindly, gently, more than Sean and I can do, to preserve that, to do his part as he's educating these young minds to continuing that dream, that vision.
Matt (21:57.213)
to help them remain in their blissful slumber, unaware of the realities going on around them. I'm giving the points to Sam for this because Sam clearly believes in the American dream. And that, I mean, you gotta, I mean, these aren't just like giving you points. You earn that, Sam. You earn the points for maintaining a belief in the American dream.
Sam (22:07.231)
I do!
shawn (22:14.undefined)
Oh my gosh.
shawn (22:17.752)
Well, I'm going to I'm going to I'll pipe in and give Sam the victory because I love his passion for it. And I think it's an optimistic, unlike Matt's pessimistic message. Now, I'm going to give Sam the victory because it's an important message. It's optimistic.
Matt (22:25.905)
That's true! Real- Sorry. Go ahead, Sean. Go ahead.
Matt (22:33.331)
Sam gets, he gets the points for talking about the American dream without including the space program. So that alone deserves points. Okay.
shawn (22:39.894)
I'm sorry.
Sam (22:42.74)
It is idealistic and usually it's the liberal Democrats that are idealistic. On this point, I'm idealistic and I'm right. Go ahead.
shawn (22:51.667)
Although you can't argue that it's a pure meritocracy, right? And that only applies. I think, yeah.
Sam (22:54.698)
No, I don't. I don't. I argue that we're better if we are more of a meritocracy because we encourage people to do tough things. We know that when people do tough things, they become better. We meet the better version of ourself on the other side of adversity. That's truth of human nature. Come on, Matt. Bring it. Come on.
Matt (23:11.625)
Okay, well that's not why I'm giving you the points, am I? It's inspiring, I like it, we'll just move on. Okay, so Martin Scorsese has this film that just came out called Killers of the Flower Moon. Have you guys seen it?
Sam (23:15.93)
Okay, all right, very good.
Sam (23:23.434)
No. I don't have a lot of time for television. I'm working really hard. Meritocracy, okay.
shawn (23:23.588)
Not seen it, but heard about it, yeah, read about it.
Matt (23:25.449)
His his budget. This this is a movie, Sam. This is a movie. So it's actually three and a half hour movie. So far, I think he's got a $200 million budget that he spent on this movie and opening weekend, I think global box office is $40 million. So Taylor Swift outperformed this movie. But according to the critics, you got to see this show if you haven't seen it before. Anyhow.
Sam (23:43.798)
Mmm.
Sam (23:50.53)
Hmm.
Matt (23:51.321)
My question is, so this is based on actual events that happened in Oklahoma in the 1920s. So not that long ago, the 1920s. So the Osage Indians were moved from place to place to place across the United States. Eventually they were settled in this area of Oklahoma and oil was discovered on their land. And in the late 1890s, they started becoming a very wealthy people. And Americans were racist. I know I, sometimes I say Americans are racist that makes people mad, but
Sam (23:59.744)
Okay.
Matt (24:20.485)
We can all agree a hundred years ago, Americans were racist and they were not happy that these native Americans, uh, they were sort of like, um, challenging their view of, of the, of society and the way things ought to be. So Congress passed a law in 1921 that allowed, um, that, that allowed states to like, do this sort of competency test. And if, if you were ruled to be insufficiently competent to manage your wealth,
then the state could appoint somebody who would manage your assets for you. And in the state of Oklahoma, competency was determined by less and less Native American blood in your system. So the more full-blooded Native American you were, the more likely you were to be ruled that you were incompetent to manage your money. And then they would appoint, yeah, I know. And then they would appoint a white person to manage the assets of the Native Americans. And what happened that,
Sam (25:07.862)
That's racist.
That's terrible!
Sam (25:16.907)
Really?
Matt (25:20.409)
is a lot of these white people, once that happened, started killing the Native Americans. And so these Native Americans just started ending up dead and the white people inherited their assets. So this is like all the backdrop for this big question, right? So Congress passed the law, Oklahoma State kind of enforced these laws that took wealth away from Native Americans and gave it to white people. So does the US government or the state of Oklahoma
Sam (25:34.99)
What a mess.
Matt (25:47.869)
Do they have some kind of a moral obligation now to look back and say, look, we allowed racist, uh, right. Theft of wealth from native Americans. Sam doesn't like this question. He, he agrees it's.
Sam (26:00.494)
shit. He keeps bringing this. Wait, you found 10 different ways to ask this question. Reparations, reparations.
shawn (26:06.032)
reparations question.
Matt (26:06.289)
No, no, this one's about Native Americans. No, this is, this is Native Americans, right? And this is like a very specific case. And I only brought it up because there's a movie about it right now. That's, you know, it's in the dialogue. Yeah, yeah, what should we do? Mm-hmm.
Sam (26:16.094)
Yeah, I have an idea. I have an idea. I have an idea. How about if Martin Scorsese took how much did it cost to make this movie? Why doesn't he take 200? That's a quarter billion dollars. He should have just take that taken that money and paid for a patron. What's it called reparations?
shawn (26:17.021)
So, so, so...
Matt (26:25.687)
$200 million.
Matt (26:30.642)
Mm-hmm.
shawn (26:35.271)
Reparations to the tribe, to the tribe.
Matt (26:36.561)
Who's he gonna give it to? The white people in Oklahoma?
Sam (26:40.036)
No, the Osage citizens.
shawn (26:41.04)
the descendants of the sage tribe.
Matt (26:43.39)
But Martin Scorsese didn't pass the law. Congress passed the law. Martin Scorsese didn't appoint white people to take the wealth of Native Americans.
Sam (26:52.682)
I think it's tragic and it's painful and I don't know much of the story, but yeah. But I'm gonna go back to the problem I have in the state of California where they're paying, you know, people that were done wrong $1.2 million per person, depending on how long you've been alive and how long you lived in California. I think it's challenging for a government to be responsible for every wrong done to every people.
Matt (26:56.633)
I just told you the story, Sam. You know everything you need to know about the story.
Sam (27:21.27)
I think it's better to provide opportunity. I'd love to see that quarter billion dollars go into some sort of a fund to give opportunity. Education, opportunity, economic impact. And, yep.
Matt (27:21.865)
But, but this is...
Matt (27:33.165)
Okay, so pause for a second. Ask yourself this question. I want you to picture in your mind a oil tycoon from Oklahoma. Now, is it a Native American? Okay, so we know where the oil tycoon from Oklahoma got the money from. So can't I just take it from them and give it back?
Sam (27:41.772)
Okay.
Sam (27:44.908)
No.
shawn (27:50.845)
So Matt, does the... Well, Matt, does the... Oh. Well, hang on, Matt. Does the movie show, does it show evidence that you could, in a civil lawsuit, you could point to this person or this family took from this person or this family? Couldn't a civil lawsuit maybe fix the situation as opposed to a sweeping reparation?
Sam (27:53.514)
Yeah, but where does it end? Where does the madness end Matt? I mean, what about
Matt (28:12.15)
So this was 1921 that the law was passed. And as recently as 1970, any book that talked about this history in the real way was taken out of the libraries in the state of Oklahoma. Like they've been trying to cover up the history, right? We do have FBI investigation into the deaths, but you could easily look at the wealth transfers, right? There's gonna be court records of this is the person and this is the person.
shawn (28:22.708)
Evil, evil, right, that's evil, yeah.
Sam (28:23.278)
That's crazy.
That's crazy.
shawn (28:35.144)
So why not civil lawsuits, man? Why wouldn't civil lawsuits solve this? You're saying it's too long ago?
Matt (28:39.649)
Okay. Hey, I mean, I suppose one way is to go to the courts and have a jury award money, but couldn't you also just say the government did this? Can't the government appoint?
shawn (28:46.704)
Yeah. No, because Sam, no, no. No, because Sam's point is right on. If the government's job was to take every single wrong that was ever committed by the people or by a law, then there's no end. Oh boy. Ha ha ha.
Sam (28:51.306)
Government, it's not their job. Thank you, Sean.
Sam (29:01.122)
then it would kill the American dream. Ha ha It would kill the American dream.
shawn (29:07.716)
The VinoSpace program. That cheesy movie that Samlers refers to never would have been made. Ha ha ha.
Matt (29:11.533)
Oh. Listen, if the government passes a law that allows people to do horrible things, can't they? Okay, what do the scriptures say?
shawn (29:19.28)
scriptures are clear on it.
D&C 134 talks all about it, right? That men will be accountable for their acts in relation to making laws and applying those laws. And if those laws take away from the liberties, I'm preaching, the liberties and the rights of God's children, then those are wicked evil laws. And that our job, it says, the solution is, our job is to fight hard to get righteous people in place who will make righteous laws that protect the liberty of people.
Sam (29:33.038)
Preach, Sean, that's awesome.
Matt (29:34.557)
the
shawn (29:50.432)
And so unfortunately, I think the approach, which you can see some progress in, right? Those systemic, racist, evil laws somehow got on the books. Those are evil and wrong. They've since been overturned. They've since been changed, right? Because we got better people in place to change those laws. And I think scripture teaches us that is the right way to do it. It is unfortunate and sad, but I mean, who doesn't go through and, nah, I won't say that. That's gonna be, I don't wanna minimize what they've gone through.
Matt (29:56.207)
Mm-hmm.
Matt (30:02.409)
Mm-hmm.
Matt (30:06.054)
Yeah.
Matt (30:17.349)
Listen, when the Mormons were kicked out of their homes in Missouri in the 1830s, they went to try to get redressed, right? Because they were kicked out of their homes by the state of Missouri, and they never got it back. But it didn't mean, but Joseph Smith tried, and all of the saints tried. And so I think that there's something righteous about trying to get your property back when the government unlawfully, well, in this case, passes a law that allows them to lawfully seize your land, don't you?
shawn (30:26.352)
Ain't got nothing, yeah. Right.
shawn (30:37.165)
Yeah.
shawn (30:42.924)
Wrong, evil, yeah. Redlining is evil. All those things are racist and evil, but I like Sam's point, which is every single wrong has been, like there's so much, Matt. It would be a never-ending, all of our resources would be put into just righting the wrongs that have been done to everybody. Yeah, some more than others, sure.
Matt (31:02.337)
Okay, well I wanna give the points to myself. Wait. I made a really, I feel like I was really thought provoking and I feel like I made some really, but I guess I didn't provoke any thought. You guys are, okay, who are you guys gonna give the points to? Yeah.
shawn (31:05.02)
Oh. For what? For what?
Sam (31:05.662)
I object. Reparations.
Sam (31:17.61)
You know what, I will go watch the movie at some point and I'll award points after I see the movie. I wanna see how empathetic this causes me to be in the whole deal, yeah.
Matt (31:26.896)
Oh, okay.
shawn (31:31.596)
You may change your, your.
Matt (31:32.733)
Do you know who the killer is in the movie? Robert De Niro, right? So you got Robert De Niro being the white guy killing all these Native Americans. Yeah. All right. Well, so then Sean, are you gonna give the points to me? No, it's not important to me at all. We just have to award points. And so you have to like say who.
Sam (31:35.722)
No. Oh, nice.
Sam (31:43.615)
That's terrible.
shawn (31:49.616)
How important is it to you to have these points matched?
Sam (31:49.89)
Sean say no.
Sam (31:54.23)
I'm winning so far. It's a merit talk. Thank you. All right.
shawn (31:54.616)
No, Sam gets it. Sam gets it. Sorry, Matt. I'm sure you'll get the points on this one, Matt, because I know you're gonna take the opposing view, which I love. I'm grateful for. Otherwise, we'd all agree on everything.
Matt (31:58.567)
Okay, Sean, you're up. Yeah.
Matt (32:07.089)
You present two views. Okay, what's this?
shawn (32:10.656)
Okay, we'll see. Let's see. Okay. So new book out by University of Maryland economics professor Melissa Kearney is getting it. It's good. Oh, man. Dang. She's getting the book is getting a lot of attention. It's everywhere. NPR like podcasts, videos, it's everywhere. So she claims what
Matt (32:16.713)
Stay in your lane. Stay in your lane, Melissa. Sorry, sorry. I might have jumped in too soon.
Sam (32:31.498)
Wait, is NPR everywhere? Sorry, go ahead. Okay, go ahead. Can you really? Nice, okay, go ahead, sorry.
shawn (32:35.288)
That was just one example. It is actually, yeah, NPRs, yeah.
Matt (32:35.982)
It is actually. You can ask your smart speaker to play NPR no matter where you are. Yeah.
shawn (32:43.342)
Hehehehehehe
New York Times, Sam, you want me to watch it? New York Times, I can go on and on. No, no Russell Brand yet. No Russell Brand yet. So, okay, so she claims, okay, so Melissa Kearney claims with clarifying bluntness that marriage is the most reliable institution for delivering a high level of resources and long-term stability to children. And she marshals the voluminous evidence in her new book, The Two-Parent Privilege, okay? Okay.
Matt (32:49.681)
Russell Brand, Candice, Candice. You know that Candice lady? Okay, go ahead.
Sam (32:52.007)
Oh, Russell Brand, okay.
Sam (33:10.594)
Voluminous. Mm. Voluminous. OK?
Matt (33:11.305)
Stay in your lane, stay in your lane.
shawn (33:14.752)
So here's part of some of the facts. In the US, American children are increasingly being born and raised by single moms. The US has the world's highest rate of children living in single parent households now, according to a 2019 Pew Research study. Almost a quarter of all US children under the age of 18 live with one parent and no other adults. So her argument that children who grew up in unmarried households are fighting the odds has progressives miffed. There's been a backlash of progressives.
Sam (33:27.788)
Mmm.
Sam (33:33.134)
Hmm.
shawn (33:42.264)
and they're accusing Kearney of stigmatizing single mothers, but conservatives are celebrating her findings as validating their support of marriage. So for decades, Matt, liberals, and you gotta defend this, have run away from, I'm not saying you are, but you represent them sometimes. So for decades, liberals have run away from this issue of marriage and single parenthood, afraid of stigmatizing unwed mothers and their children. So now some are wondering whether the conservative marriage movement, embraced by
Matt (33:53.195)
I don't I'm not a liberal. Okay. Oh, okay.
shawn (34:10.68)
President Bush, for example, is onto something. Can government help, Kelsey, here's the question. Can government help poor communities by promoting marriage and have families disintegrated in the wake of the liberals expansion of the welfare state?
Matt (34:19.729)
No.
Sam (34:20.685)
No.
Matt (34:26.057)
No. Well, that was easy, Sean. Those are easy questions. Wait, let me ask you this. Okay, so almost a quarter. So 23% of US children under age 18, live with one parent and no other adults. To me, that seems like a success. That means that means 75% of kids live in two parent households. That's amazing. Or did? Yeah. Yeah, yeah, 70. Right.
shawn (34:29.888)
Okay, next topic.
Sam (34:41.55)
It's low.
shawn (34:47.41)
Uh.
Sam (34:48.014)
Well, 77 technically by my math. Yeah, that's a lot.
shawn (34:53.056)
A quarter, so a quarter, you're celebrating that a quarter, one quarter of all the children don't have, maybe don't have dads in the home. That is terrible. That's terrible. How about this, Matt? The Asian community, I think it's like 90% of the kids have both parents in their home.
Matt (35:00.081)
Yeah, that's actually really, really good. Well, yeah. Those numbers seem good to me.
Matt (35:13.517)
Yeah. Well, so, so there is, there are real problems that come from, from people living in poverty, right? There's all kinds of bad outcomes in society that come from a child being raised in a low socioeconomic status home. Right. And so what she's arguing is marriage reduces the probability that a kid's going to be raised in a low socioeconomic status home. But
Sam (35:13.762)
So it's a cultural thing in that case.
Sam (35:19.118)
Ahem.
Matt (35:43.481)
Yeah. So my only problem with the argument is that, like this idea of people cohabiting people living together, but not being married to each other. That's a relatively new recent phenomenon right like the last maybe 20 years. And so I don't know how far back she goes with her statistical trends. But the challenge we don't have the challenge with the claims she's making is we don't have enough experience with this
shawn (36:09.176)
That's not true. She read the book, she covers that clearly. She says the trend of people who don't get married, the trend is that they don't marry and they do break up. That is the most common trend. And not only that, Matt, but it was in the 50s or something like that where it was something like 4% of children in the United States were with a single parent. 4%, now today, 25%. You can't tell me that that's not a terrible, scary statistic.
Matt (36:12.745)
Okay. Mm-hmm.
Right?
Matt (36:34.706)
Yeah.
shawn (36:37.596)
And the fact that there's so much causal evidence now that these kids who are living without, only in a single parent home, they're not thriving. They continue to be poor. They continue to not get educated. They continue to go into crime. How can you say this is not a big deal? Yeah.
Matt (36:50.669)
Yeah, single parents, right? Well, so what I'm saying is this statistic that 50% of marriages end in divorce, that's been happening for a long time, right? So I'm trying to wrap my head around this idea that half of the marriages end in divorce and you still have 77% of kids living in homes with both parents.
shawn (37:08.384)
I think that's easy. It doesn't say 50% of... So if you... I know a guy that's been divorced five times, yet most of the people I know have never been divorced. So divorces are a high statistic, but people who get divorces are not.
Matt (37:16.375)
Oh, I see.
Matt (37:24.165)
So the statement that I was taking umbrage with is this, okay, so marriage is the most reliable institution for delivering a high level of resources and then long-term stability to children. I don't think anybody would argue that marriage is good for children. I think that the argument is whether it's the best way to provide a high level of resources for children. That's all. Because there's...
shawn (37:49.368)
But this study is being embraced by both left and right. And the evidence is that the left just doesn't want to acknowledge it. Yet this author, Kearney, is liberal, is saying we cannot ignore this. This is clearly a way to help social mobility. This is clearly a way to do it. And all of our solutions she's shown out there are really good solutions, like housing vouchers, right? Because the statistics show that that's
Matt (38:01.617)
Yeah.
Matt (38:16.893)
That's gonna make people stay married.
shawn (38:18.764)
Well, the single mom who, when you elevate people out of the slums, they start making better decisions like getting married, like education, these types of things. There's lots of good.
Matt (38:28.825)
So then now I feel like you're arguing for universal basic income. If we give people money, then they, we take them out of the, well, what's a housing voucher? A housing voucher is like giving you money, right? To, to, to buy a house.
shawn (38:32.325)
No, not at all.
Sam (38:32.595)
Oh no. No.
shawn (38:39.088)
How housing voucher is if you this it's the same as a school voucher right there's a certain amount of money that's available and if you qualify for it's from the government yeah but the government pays for schools right so there's a certain amount of money available and if you apply then you're going to leave that hood where you never could get out of that poor neighborhood and go into a neighborhood of affluent people and the statistics in this study show those people get married more those people have kids who stay in high school stay go to college all those statistics
Matt (38:47.357)
from the government. Yeah.
Matt (39:09.253)
Yeah. So you think that there are people that are, I don't think that anybody wonders whether kids in a home with two parents do better than kids in a home with one parent. I think everybody agrees about that. The question is what kind of marriage or how are you defining marriage, right? Does it have to be a mother and a father? Then there's people that will be mad about that.
shawn (39:10.308)
So why are, yeah, go ahead.
shawn (39:25.6)
No, the, not every, so you, you can't say that everyone agrees to that because what happens is you have a whole school of, sorry Matt, academia, higher education and progressives. This is what the study shows. I'm not saying this for my own words, my own bias. What they say, no, what they say is it's a non-topic. We shouldn't talk about it because it stigmatizes.
Matt (39:40.409)
No, no, I want to know what academics are saying. Marriage is bad?
shawn (39:50.644)
certain racial groups and it stigmatizes single women and it puts blame on them and makes them feel bad. So let's make it a non-issue, let's not talk about it, let's not promote marriage. In fact, let's do the opposite. Let's implement policies in government that almost do the opposite of promoting marriage. Like there's a bunch of case studies she gives where a woman with children is deciding between if I marry my boyfriend who's...
Matt (39:59.058)
Oh, I see.
shawn (40:19.144)
Income is lower than the assistance that I will receive then we will suffer So I'm not going to marry this person and my kids don't have a male Person in the home, which means they have a lower chance of leaving poverty a lower chance of graduating high school and so on So even if they make more less money, it is better for that man to be in that household by far the statistics show yet. Yeah That's what the books the evidence is showing in her book overwhelmingly
Matt (40:40.922)
Wait, that's what she's saying in her book?
shawn (40:46.448)
overwhelmingly the presence of the father in the home is the biggest indicator for people getting out of poverty and graduating high school and going to college.
Sam (40:51.694)
Thanks for watching!
Matt (40:54.577)
So can I tell you why those sorts of arguments bother liberals and academics? Oh, okay. Cause I'm putting Sam to sleep. Okay. Reason number one, um, for a hundred years, the United States intentionally broke up African-American families and sold them off as slavery. So there were these strong African-American nuclear families, and then institutionally our government broke them up.
shawn (40:58.884)
Yes, that's what I want to know. Why? My brothers and sisters who are liberal, how could you possibly ignore this?
Matt (41:24.005)
And then even after the end of slavery, in that whole civil, then there was a, another whole period of time where they continue to break up African American families. So for us to now say, Hey, the solution to problems is marriage and then not acknowledge the role that the U S government played in breaking up nuclear families. So, so if you want to say marriage is a good thing and marriage has all these positive outcomes, then somebody else is going to say to you, then the United States government owes reparations.
Sam (41:26.499)
Thanks for watching!
Sam (41:45.762)
Thank you.
Matt (41:53.769)
to African American families, they're going to. Because if.
Sam (41:54.106)
Oh no.
shawn (41:56.876)
If you really, if that's truly the argument of liberals, then shame on them for not saying because the millions of kids who would benefit from marriage and they're going, yeah, we better not talk about it because then we're going to have to do something and talk about reparations. Yes, they are. That's what they're saying.
Matt (42:01.145)
Why? It's true!
Matt (42:08.881)
Well, they're not saying let's don't talk about it. They're saying that the United States had a policy of breaking up families. And now we want to attribute all kinds of positive outcomes to marriage without acknowledging the harm that we did in the past in breaking up those marriages.
shawn (42:23.533)
So ignore it, so bury that, hide it, and don't move forward and build strong families because then we'll have to talk about reparations? Nah, I don't buy it, Matt, I don't buy it.
Matt (42:32.889)
Well, I'm saying that's one side. Then the other side is marriage and having children, like statistically and historically, harms women in their careers. So if you, one of the reasons that if you take a man and a woman and they have the exact same job, but the man makes more and the woman makes less, is because a woman takes time off of work to go have a baby and she has to put her career on hold. And so we say, oh, this man has more experience. Another is because,
Sam (42:58.519)
Thank you.
shawn (43:01.2)
So it's a so liberals are selfish because what that saying is that we should strive for our own progression instead of caring about our children. We should go after our own careers instead of doing the right thing for our children. It's a very self-centered. Yeah, if two parents Sam, if two Sam, if two parents are deciding, okay, we're are two individuals are deciding we had a kid together. And the statistics show that if the wife is at home,
Sam (43:14.518)
Wait, what? Wait.
Matt (43:17.751)
I'm just telling you why these arguments bother academics and progressives.
Sam (43:23.733)
Yeah.
shawn (43:30.68)
This kid has a better chance of being out of poverty, going to high school, graduating college.
Sam (43:35.487)
So I'm going to debate that a little bit, because I know some people who have made a decision that the husband will stay home and be the primary caregiver. And the wife has the best earning economic potential. And so she goes out and provides the economic assistance, and the husband does a great job at home. And I don't think they suffer any, because they're working together at that. I also know other people that have
shawn (43:41.336)
Yep.
Sam (44:03.702)
They both work, right? And they navigate ways together, they negotiate ways together to still provide for their kids as they're going up through those formidable years and provide them the education and the sports and other opportunities. I mean, I...
shawn (44:21.57)
So, but you're arguing that married people are making these decisions and the statistics show that the married people stick around, commit to the kids and yeah, they live different. There's all kinds of different ways to be married and raise kids. But what Matt's saying is liberals won't get married.
Sam (44:26.279)
Well... I-
Sam (44:32.018)
I just thought I thought I heard you I thought I heard you say that the wife is the better one to stay home that okay I just
shawn (44:38.976)
No, I wasn't saying that.
Matt (44:40.977)
What I'm saying is feminists don't like that argument because the supposition in society is that the man's going to go to work and the wife should stay home. And in the 70s through the 90s, that was reflected in careers and advancement and all of that sort of stuff. So so what I'm saying is like this idea of traditional marriage has been used in the past to oppress women and to oppress racial minorities. And so if you want to now say, hey, this is the solution to our problems.
Sam (44:44.171)
now.
Matt (45:10.981)
without going back in the past and saying, and we were wrong back then. We were wrong when we used marriage to oppress women. We were wrong when we broke up families in slavery. If you want to acknowledge that, then by all means, though, I don't think the liberals would be mad at you, but it's by but it's
shawn (45:25.188)
I don't think anyone would disagree that there was, in the 1950s, there was a giant and wrong stigma against single moms. And yeah, there was. And everyone agrees, but then you get the 70s changing the tide and going the opposite direction and basically saying that there's no more stigma. In fact, let's go all the way. Let's de-normalize regular marriage, man and woman, two parent marriages, and they went the opposite direction.
Matt (45:35.045)
Yeah, and all the way through the 90s.
shawn (45:54.252)
and that is the direction our country is going now. And all studies show that even with that stigma, the children come out far worse when there's not two parents in the household, far worse.
Matt (46:06.649)
But what I'm saying is we don't have the same kind of historical evidence for the case that you're making as we do for the other side, right? We have 200 years of history in our country with marriage being a certain way. And we've only got like 20 years of marriage being kind of redefined and rethought. So to say outcomes with children, we don't have enough data points to really look at that. I mean,
shawn (46:24.501)
No, that's not true.
shawn (46:29.124)
That's that this book this book disagrees with that big time. The data shows that yeah, read it. Okay.
Matt (46:33.049)
Well, I have to I have to read the book, Sean. I tried to I tried to get the book, but I wasn't able to get the book that quickly. And it was like twenty five dollars and you know.
Sam (46:41.319)
So before our next episode, I have a movie to watch, Matt has a book to read, and then I'm gonna withhold my points until there's enough data to support one viewer or another, Sean. But until then, I'm willing to give Sean the points because it was an interesting conversation and it got us thinking.
Matt (46:45.981)
Hahaha
shawn (46:51.78)
Hahaha
Matt (46:52.237)
Okay.
Matt (46:58.637)
All right. And it was very thought provoking. Good job, Sean. Today I got, I only got points for myself. So that's okay because I was the one that took the side of let's give participation trophies to people and you guys didn't like that. So it's okay. All right. So the big question for this week comes from a listener. They said.
Sam (47:00.706)
Yep. Nice job.
Sam (47:11.266)
Dude, you killed the American dream. That's insane. You should be run out of the... Hmm.
shawn (47:13.584)
Yeah. And gave yourself participation points for it.
Matt (47:24.581)
Your gun control discussion reminded me of something I think Republicans get wrong. So already we know that this person is probably not a Republican. I'd love to hear your responses. In the Republican mind, the origin story of totalitarian communism goes like this. First, a free and democratic country decides to provide unemployment benefits. Two, they provide healthcare to everyone. Three, their children read marks at college. Four, they vote in a communist dictator.
Sam (47:43.558)
I didn't read this before. Go ahead, this is great. Oh.
shawn (47:53.432)
So stop there, Sam, you're a Republican, is that how you look at it or not? Do you, is that how you look at it? You don't?
Matt (47:53.861)
But the hit...
Sam (47:53.905)
Mm-hmm.
Matt (47:57.209)
Yes, yes, yes. Where does communism come from?
Sam (48:01.496)
No, you could replace universal basic income with unemployment benefits under one and I'd probably be okay with that, yeah. Yeah, go ahead.
Matt (48:05.585)
hahahahahahah
shawn (48:08.571)
then you'd be a great, okay, all right, that's fair.
Matt (48:10.565)
Okay, so number one is a free and democratic country decides to provide universal basic income and health care and send their kids to a Marxist college and then they vote in a communist dictator. But the history of communism is almost the exact opposite. It goes like this, an oppressive and wealthy dictator runs a country for the benefit of the wealthy like the Romanovs or Batista or the Qing dynasty. He ignores the suffering of his people.
Sam (48:18.386)
Yeah.
Matt (48:39.173)
He lets his wealthy friends plunder the country. The workers rebel and kill the dictators or emperor. One of the rebel warlords becomes a communist dictator. So historically the path to communism is not to provide healthcare and education for the working class. That's the path to becoming Norway, which for you guys who might not know, Norway is a great place to live.
Sam (48:48.066)
who makes things far worse.
Sam (49:02.798)
It's a great place and it's irrelevant on the global stage, but go ahead.
Matt (49:07.313)
There's no skin cancer in Norway, as far as I can tell. The beaches are very rocky and cold. The path to communism is ignoring the poor and giving handouts to the rich. So the big question is, let me think, what's the big question? So then why are you guys so afraid that we're gonna turn into a communist society if we do universal basic income and give people healthcare? Cause that's not really how that happens. According to this listener, but-
Sam (49:14.05)
But there's no American dream.
Sam (49:21.665)
Mmm
Sam (49:34.454)
So Levi, what I would say in this case is that universal basic income, this progression towards communism is basically participation trophies for everyone, right? That's not, we meet the best version of ourselves when we go through some adversity and some challenge and we grow and develop. And if there's not a good incentive to do that, then you end up Norway. And...
Matt (49:46.727)
Ha ha!
Matt (50:01.021)
So I'm going to have a little different take on this. So there's this new concept in political science called democratic backsliding. And so it's true that what this listener is talking about, this idea that you're going to vote your way into communism by providing universal basic income and unemployment benefits and all that stuff, that doesn't happen. But it's also not true that the only way that you get a communist, or let's just say an autocratic society,
Sam (50:04.071)
I know you will.
Matt (50:29.117)
is by overthrowing some dictator because we can look at Russia. I put links to these in the show notes if people want to look at it. But democratic backsliding is basically what you see happening in the world today. So you can go to like Venezuela, right? Chavez was a democratically elected person who went the path of communism and socialism, ran Venezuela into the ground. You can see this happening in Russia with Putin. You can see this happening in Hungary right now.
And there's a whole list of countries that they go from a democratic regime into an authoritarian regime. And yeah, it's not by it doesn't happen by giving benefits to people. It happens by people electing autocratic individuals, people who want to bring authoritarianism to themselves, right? Belarus is another example. So
To me, like that's how you get to communism in our modern world. It's not this like overthrowing a dictator or something like that. You get to communism by individuals voting for bad people. So
shawn (51:33.596)
But isn't the listener's real point that not so much here's the real path to communism, but more guys, Republicans, universal healthcare is not going to lead to communism. It's going to lead to different forms of examples in the country, or in the world.
Matt (51:50.733)
Yeah, I think the listener is saying if you pass universal health care, you're taking care of the poor, and that makes communism less likely or something like that. But I think the point that I would make is, and I know this is going to upset you guys, especially Sam, it triggers you a little bit. The Republican Party today, and who they're voting for, and the individuals that they're supporting, are doing more to lead us towards the path of an authoritarian regime.
shawn (51:57.88)
Yeah, you're not.
Yeah, so...
Matt (52:18.213)
than the Democrats are when they say, let's give people free things. Right. Because if you look at like elections and free, like, if you look at democratic processes in the United States, there are more Republicans just as elected officials who are willing to say, let's break the rules, let's change the rules. Let's tear everything down rather than go along with losing. Then there are Democrats on the other side. And you see that in the house of representatives, right?
Republicans can't elect a Speaker of the House right now because there's a faction of Republicans that just won't go along with the majority unless it's the person that they want in the majority. And those Republicans are a threat to democracy.
shawn (52:58.116)
So Sam.
So Sam, let me mansplain this to you from Matt's perspective. Donald Trump is more of an authoritarian and January 6th is the evidence of that. Okay, go ahead.
Matt (53:07.233)
No, no, no.
Matt (53:12.122)
Not Donald Trump. I can just say Matt Gaetz. I can say Marjorie Taylor Greene. I can say this group of 20 Republicans in the House right now. No, that's how they are. Like you see it happen just today.
shawn (53:17.488)
That's a leaf. That's.
Sam (53:23.711)
But I do, with Mike Jones.
Matt (53:28.441)
Who was emmer right emmer was the guy from minnesota he got the majority of the conference and then it's like okay everybody Like get behind this guy. He's gonna be our leader
shawn (53:29.891)
Emmer.
shawn (53:36.752)
They're following the rule. As much as I hate what's going on, they're still following rules. There's no like, let's break down the system and.
Matt (53:42.009)
No, no, of course there is. The Republicans have in their conference a rule
Sam (53:45.89)
So, so, Emmer, Emmer withdrew. Mike Johnson was, is the latest up, right? So.
Matt (53:52.625)
So why didn't Emmer withdraw?
Sam (53:56.045)
There's no path.
Matt (53:56.421)
Be right. Why is there no path? Because the 20 Republicans or whatever say we're not going to support him on the floor.
Sam (54:00.927)
So.
Sam (54:04.106)
So I think everybody here has heard me say many times, the Republican Party's in a bizarre moment, right? It's a fractured, splintered party. It's a party of extremes for the moment. I truly believe it'll end up coming back to center at some point and will find its heart, will find its purpose, will find its platform, because what you're describing is not the Republican platform, now or historically, so.
Matt (54:31.101)
But what I'm saying is that, but there's a greater threat to democratic backsliding when you have people like that in office, than there is with universal basic income or healthcare or something like that.
Sam (54:34.918)
I agree. I agree. I agree. Yeah.
Well, I disagree on that. Universal basic income leads into communism simply because it takes away the incentive for excellence. It inflates, it deflates the value. You end up pumping so much money into the economy that inflation runs rampant. That creates a whole set of problems on its own. And before you know it, it's chaos and anarchy and a banana republic. But that won't happen because nobody's going to vote. But nobody's going to vote. Nobody's going to vote.
shawn (54:43.108)
You do agree with that, Sam? Oh, oh.
Matt (55:06.361)
So... so... so there...
shawn (55:07.92)
I thought it was communism.
Sam (55:11.88)
universal basic income.
Matt (55:13.969)
So there was a time when we had a little bit of a breakthrough and we realized that Sam is anti-union and I'm pro-union. And I think like in this podcast episode, what I've discovered is Sam is afraid that giving people things they haven't earned will make them lazy and that will destroy society. And I'm in favor of giving people things that they haven't really earned and don't really deserve because it will make them happy.
Sam (55:37.306)
Yeah, because you don't believe in the American dream. Here's the thing, Matt, is I think what that position fails to understand is life isn't just about having stuff. It's not just about money. Life is about creating things that better the world. And the United States has done a phenomenal job of that.
Matt (55:59.345)
We both agree about that.
Sam (56:03.934)
And that doesn't happen because some pixie dust sprinkles down from the sky with $2 million in a grant or a gift, and all of a sudden, I'm inspired to go out and create and take risk. That happens because you work hard, you make contacts and connections, and you're in the right place at the right time, and you take a risk. And that risk ends up yielding results. And then, is it perfect? No, it's not perfect. There's some real jerks that have become business leaders.
Matt (56:08.283)
You
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Sam (56:33.418)
have created innovation that have paid off. But generally, that's the American dream. I will never give up on that. And you need to rethink your life. Ha ha ha.
Matt (56:43.409)
But that's up until the last statement, that was the perfect way to end the podcast. So I want to respond.
shawn (56:45.273)
Hahaha!
Sam (56:51.787)
Stop teaching students that the American Dream is dead, Matt. Dang it, Sean?
Matt (56:57.333)
Oh no, I'm going to have to rewrite my exams for tomorrow. That was all those like, name five ways that the American dream is a myth. Hey, it was really good. You had me super inspired and happy and then you told me I had to rethink my life. Because I was like, he's right, the pixie dust isn't working for me anymore.
Sam (57:01.693)
Ugh.
Sam (57:04.898)
Yeah.
Sam (57:08.962)
Till the last. Yeah.
Sam (57:16.787)
I don't even know what that is by the way. It may not even be maybe in an insensitive statement, but yeah anyway
Matt (57:23.077)
Hey, listener, thanks for your comments. We like it when you reach out to us on the mail bag and thanks for listening to us. If you have other comments you'd like to make, especially because Sam called you all out and told you that you need to tell me that I'm wrong. If you wanna give me points, like you could just email thelatterdaylens.gmail.com and say, Matt gets 50 points. Like that's good enough for me. That would make me super happy.
Sam (57:46.438)
Is the American dream dead? That's what Matt needs to see. And it is not dead.
Matt (57:49.093)
No, no, no. Don't let Sam mislead you.
shawn (57:53.501)
Sam, I know what your next week's topic is gonna be for you.
Matt (57:56.409)
Is the American dream dead? Yeah, is the American dream and yeah, hey, listener talk to you again next week.
shawn (57:59.588)
Do it, Sam, do it.
Sam (57:59.638)
I just need to...
Yeah.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories