The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
October 11, 2023: Salvation vs Exaltation, Democrats and job growth, Parents behaving badly at youth sports, What are the appropriate limits on free speech?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Thought Provoker:
Shawn: President Nelson and President Oaks both preached clear and direct doctrine about what salvation is and what exaltation is. I am a little surprised at how new this concept was to many. The Scriptures teach it abundantly. Two questions: Question 1: Why do you think this was the primary message from General Conference from the Prophets? Question 2: Why would people choose single eternal life in a wonderful kingdom of glory versus familial exaltation and continuation of eternal lives?
Matt: September jobs numbers just came out and the US economy created over 300k new jobs in September. The unemployment rate is as low as it has been in 50 years. In fact, if you look at the unemployment numbers back to Obama, the only spike in unemployment is during the COVID-19 shutdown during the spring of 2020. The clear pattern beginning with Obama and continuing through Biden is a steady decline in unemployment. It appears that Democrats do a really good job of making sure that the private sector creates employment opportunities for everyone. Isn’t it time for us to acknowledge that Democrats are just as good at managing the economy as Republicans? Maybe the polling on this is actually wrong.
Sam: “Why is the intensity increasing in kids sports by parents today? “ Why are more parents living vicariously through their kids? Why is there more yelling, fighting and impatience at kids sporting events? Is it post Covid impacts? Is it people are not happy and living vicariously through their kids? Is it sports are more competitive? | | psychologytoday.com | |
| | Perspective | Overzealous parents are ruining youth sports. It’s past time to sit quiet and let the kids play. washingtonpost.com |
| | Why parents go nuts on the sidelines nbcnews.com
Big Question:
John Stuart Mill was a political philosopher whose thinking was very influential to the founders of our nation. He was known for having a very liberal position on the question of freedom of speech. In chapter 2 of his book On Liberty, Mill argues that “there ought to exist the fullest liberty of professing and discussing, as a matter of ethical conviction, any doctrine, however immoral it may be considered.” He really does mean that no topic should be off limits for public debate. However, he recognizes that some limits on free speech are necessary and states that “the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others.” Mill meant that speech leading to physical harm to others should be prohibited and that is what has guided legislative and judicial actions limiting free speech in the United States. However, it seems to me that Americans are now expanding the idea of harm to something that causes emotional or psychological harm. The net effect is that some ideas, and some opinions are being excluded from public discussion because they might “harm” others in non-physical ways. What is the morally correct way to define “harm”? Should society prohibit speech
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:00.762)
Hey listener, welcome to another exciting episode of the Latter Day Lens with Shawn, Sam, and Matt. So real quick listeners, I just wanted to point out that it happens almost every week when someone I know is listening to this podcast, they will start texting me in the middle of the podcast, reacting to things that we say. And I think that happens to Sam and Shawn as well, right? You get like reactions, yeah.
Sam (00:23.182)
Absolutely. Yes.
Matt (00:25.406)
So, listener, we've got a diverse audience. People all over the world are listening to this podcast. And if you don't know us, it might be hard for you to say, hey, I'm gonna text them and let them know what I think. But we understand that what we say is a little bit thought provoking. Maybe you're shouting at your radio from time to time, or your phone, or whatever. That's what we're trying to do. But we also want to hear from you. We like to hear your thoughts. So...
A lot of what we get is from people that are close to us, but that's not always the case. And so even if you don't know us, you don't have to worry about offending us. You can just, whatever you're shouting out, you can just email that to us at thelatterdaylens.gmail.com. But it's also fine if you just want to listen on your own and shout in your car. We're totally good with that. So
shawn (01:10.815)
You know, Matt, one listener told me this weekend said, hey, you guys should have a Discord chat for these topics because many people would want to jump on that and get the conversation going and continuing. But we'll have to discuss that together later.
Matt (01:23.858)
Yeah, Discord is like, I don't know what that is. Um... .. So...
Sam (01:26.194)
I was going to say you'd have to tell us what Discord is and then we have to download it. We'd have to learn it. How about if we just text?
shawn (01:30.791)
It's just a, it's just a, no, it's a, it's a forum. It's a forum. We would put our topics out there. People after the, during the podcast go on there and they start having a discussion with themselves about these topics. We can include, include ourselves in that. It's just a chat.
Matt (01:35.314)
this.
Sam (01:41.89)
Sounds very complicated.
Matt (01:43.83)
So I just stumbled upon this new technology. It's called email, and you can type on your computer or phone and send it for free. But, hey, listener, if you want to do a Discord thing, let us know. We'll contemplate that.
shawn (01:48.116)
Hehehehe
shawn (01:52.011)
Gen Xers, you Gen Xers.
shawn (01:58.575)
You guys are Gen Xers acting like baby boars.
Matt (02:02.29)
I'll take that as a compliment because isn't President Nelson a boomer or is he older than a boomer? Is he the greatest generation? Which by the way, what kind of hubris does it take to call yourselves the greatest generation? Alright, so the first thing in the mailbag is from a listener. One listener writes, it wasn't political at all, but Shawn's discussion of hymns might be my favorite segment of all time. Okay, I'm going to just pause right here.
shawn (02:13.899)
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
Matt (02:29.186)
I'm a little offended at that because I think all of our listeners know the effort that I put into choosing topics. And so the fact that Shawn's choosing a thing about hymns is your favorite of all time, like, maybe this is Shawn's mother or something like that, but I just had to pause there and say, major points to Shawn for a thought-provoking, passionate, inspiring discussion. And bonus points to Sam for the best misuse of the phrase, mucho gusto I've ever heard.
shawn (02:54.707)
Hahaha
Matt (02:57.43)
On a personal note, friends and bratia, I recently started taking piano lessons after a 30 year hiatus. I love having more music in my life. So, does this suggest that maybe this transition we've had to less political topics is a good thing? I'm just gonna start by saying I think no. I disagree with this listener.
shawn (03:12.612)
Oh, that's not their point. Although...
Sam (03:14.178)
No, no, no. I think there's a hidden motivation to that comment somewhere and we're all just left to guess what that is. But his use of the word bratia probably suggests who this might be and what their motivation may be. No, no, it's pure. Okay. Yeah.
shawn (03:23.987)
No way.
No way. No way. I disagree. I disagree.
Matt (03:28.498)
I- Isn't it interesting that somebody who speaks Russian is criticizing Sam's use of Spanish? Maybe this person doesn't know Spanish.
shawn (03:39.04)
No way man. I think I know who this is from and we kind of bonded on our mission over music. Music was a huge part of it. In fact, in the spirit of promoting good spiritual music to continue that discussion, I'm going to use this opportunity to promote three bands that I would like for our listeners to check out. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. The first one is a band called The Welcome.
Matt (03:53.27)
Oh no. Oh no. Oh no. Oh no. Wait, wait, wait. Okay. Shawn's going to say three, then Sam gets to say one and I get to say one because Shawn doesn't get to do the only promoting of cool bands. Okay. Go ahead, Shawn.
shawn (04:06.623)
Good, good, good. Okay, I'm nervous about what you guys are gonna say. The first one is Welcome Wagon. Go listen to the album called Welcome to the Welcome Wagon by the band Welcome Wagon.
Matt (04:09.454)
The first one is...
Sam (04:17.774)
Actually, Shawn, our primary sings that every Sunday.
shawn (04:21.979)
No, that's not, no, these are. No, what's, what's fascinating is this band is an, it's an evangelical preacher and his wife and it is the most artistic but beautifully spiritually inspiring stuff. It's amazing. The second one is Sufjan Stevens, S-U-F-J-A-N Stevens.
Matt (04:23.442)
Does it go like this? Hello, hello. I love that song and that is promoted, faith promoting.
Sam (04:25.622)
Hello. Yep, exactly. Yes. All right.
shawn (04:46.811)
And his album, start with the Transfiguration. That album is life change, talks about Christ and Abraham. And these are all pretty secular songs, but it's very, very spiritual. No, they're not ruckus, dude. They're chill, they're chill. Not emo at all, no, nope. Also.
Matt (04:54.774)
Is it a punk version of the Transfiguration? Is it... is it emo? Just listeners might not know, right? You can't just say Sufjan and the Transfiguration and then say, oh, that's good. And by the way, where are they supposed to check out this music? On some indie radio station?
shawn (05:11.155)
What do you mean? What are you talking about, Baby Boomer? Just go anywhere and find it. Where do you find music to listen to nowadays? Radio. Yeah, let's hear it. Go. Those are my two. I'll just do it too. Now, the third one would be this it's an old timey band from like the 40s and it's gospel music. You know, I forget the album, so I'll get that and I'll put it in later. You guys go.
Matt (05:16.689)
Like YouTube? I'll tell you when I tell you my band, I'll tell you. No, no, you gotta do year three. First year three. Do it.
Matt (05:39.19)
Okay. Alright, well my son was at a mountain bike race today, and so when they're in the starting line waiting to start the race, they'll play all kinds of music that's inspirational and gets them excited to start riding their bikes. And I heard the coolest song, it says, the lyrics are, I don't know about you, but I'm feeling 22. And I was like, this is so cool, upbeat and happy, and I looked into it, this person, this artist is Taylor Swift.
shawn (06:03.815)
Oh geez, don't, no, don't.
Matt (06:03.894)
I don't know if you guys have heard of Taylor Swift before or the song 22. Like it's really like happy and exciting and peppy and it was good.
shawn (06:12.537)
Matt, if I was near you right now, I would punch you in the face. So hard.
Matt (06:17.455)
Taylor Swift is the greatest songwriter of our generation. No, nobody is better than Taylor Swift.
shawn (06:20.667)
Wrong. Absolutely wrong. Yeah, I know you're not. I know you're not. I know you're being facetious. No, you're not.
Matt (06:26.383)
I'm being 100% serious. I am a big Taylor Swift. I am too! Like, how could you not love Taylor? Look at all of the albums that she has and all of the songs.
shawn (06:35.068)
Okay, Taylor Swift is musical fast food. She is the McDonald's of music. That's what she is.
Matt (06:40.202)
Oh stop it. Oh my. Look at you. You're always telling me like I'm so high and mighty about education and like that But I don't trust the common man. Listen to you about music so high and mighty. Taylor Swift is junk food
shawn (06:46.239)
Hahaha!
shawn (06:53.675)
Hehehe
Sam (06:53.846)
I think Taylor Swift is benefiting from her association to a well-known NBA football player right now. So, you know, the dude won a Super Bowl and now Taylor Swift's living in a little bit of a limelight, so her time will pass.
shawn (07:00.779)
Apparently, yeah.
Matt (07:01.455)
Oh yeah.
Matt (07:06.97)
She had like 900 million followers on social media, and now she's got what? 901 million followers? Okay, Sam, who's your band that we gotta check out?
Sam (07:10.618)
Yeah.
shawn (07:13.419)
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Sam (07:16.51)
Uh, you know, it's not a new one. It's an oldie, but it's just top of mind since this, this topic came out of absolutely nowhere, but I texted you guys both pictures from, I had some work friends that went to you to opening in Vegas this past weekend at the sphere, which for me, like it, it relates to what we all talked about, like talk about, like they spent $2.3 billion, $2.3 billion to create this facility. And.
Matt (07:32.333)
Yeah.
Sam (07:44.414)
The video and the audio, like it is just incredible. So it took old songs, which were written when we were all growing up and completely reinvented the way those were presented and in a way that, you know, probably appealed to every single sense. So I propose the church does that at the conference center. They need a sphere there for a tabernacle choir.
shawn (07:49.064)
Yeah, pretty cool.
Matt (08:01.955)
So.
shawn (08:05.599)
next time.
Matt (08:09.154)
So I think Bono wrote a biography or something recently, maybe an autobiography. This would be about a year ago. I was listening to him. He was doing an interview on NPR because he was promoting something and they were just talking about his life and I did not know this. Bono is one of the most religious people you will ever meet and he loves, loves singing hymns. That's one of his favorite things to do is sing hymns. So this brings us full circle to like, you too?
Sam (08:15.563)
Don't know.
Sam (08:27.078)
Oh, no question. Yeah. Oh, interesting. Interesting.
Matt (08:36.334)
Maybe not religious in the music they produce, but religious in their intention behind the music they produce.
Sam (08:40.982)
Yeah. And, and plus Matt and Shawn, it allows me to say, I like you too.
Matt (08:46.29)
Oh, that's so sweet. Okay, Shawn, tell us your special third band. Wait, first tell us how Sam's an elitist, because he only likes bands that spend two billion dollars on their concerts. But he's probably losing money. There's no way they made two billion dollars back from that tour, right?
shawn (08:46.487)
Oh man.
Sam (08:57.998)
Uhhh
Sam (09:01.47)
Well, no, by the way, you two did not spend $2 billion. That was their Broadway show, which was a miserable failure. It was Vegas that spent the money on this facility and this facility will pay out over time. They're getting. Yeah, yeah, yeah. They're they're getting benefit from tax break that the Joe Biden probably gave them. And and they'll make money over time after depreciation.
Matt (09:07.254)
Uhhh...
shawn (09:09.771)
Okay, so getting, yeah, getting.
Matt (09:12.15)
Oh, is that the dome thing? That black bald? Oh, I love that. That is so cool.
Matt (09:22.246)
Hey, nice, nice. We'll, we'll, we'll talk about that later on.
shawn (09:27.243)
Okay, the third band is Golden Gate Quartet. Old band in the 40s, these guys do. No, here, here.
Sam (09:31.626)
Also the primary things that.
Matt (09:33.848)
And Shawn calls us a boomer. Let's go back to the 19th word.
Sam (09:35.726)
the
Sam (09:40.578)
Oh no. Alright. Alright so.
shawn (09:42.503)
It is super spiritual. They're old historical kind of, they're spirituals from.
Matt (09:42.916)
You
Matt (09:49.495)
Listener you couldn't see the video, but they were all they're all dressed in blackface
Sam (09:51.125)
Old timey.
shawn (09:54.911)
Man, they're all black. Jeez. Cool.
Sam (09:55.875)
No, no, we are not even sure how we leave. We can't note to Omar. No, no to Omar. This whole part. Remove, remove. Okay.
Matt (10:00.05)
Play it again for us, Shawn.
Matt (10:05.844)
Hahahaha
Matt (10:10.946)
No, no, I'm okay with that. Those really are African-American people. It sounded like white people pretending to be black. It sounded like Eminem. All right, Omar, we might cut that out, Omar.
shawn (10:18.539)
How dare you, man. How dare you.
Sam (10:19.066)
Oh, no, this is not right. Okay. Can we, can we, can we transition into the end of the mailbag? I have a mailbag item that did not actually make it to the email inbox. So I have friends who listened to knowing that I was, knowing that I was engaged with conference this past weekend, friends from work decided to express some interest in curiosity and what happens at conference. So beyond the, what is it? 10 hours of television watching over two days.
Matt (10:30.36)
Yeah, let's do it, Sam.
Did I lose you? Oh, there you are.
Sam (10:48.854)
It was like, Hey, what goes on here? And the talk that was listened to was president Nelson's talk, the final talk of the conference, and one of my friends who we do have very interesting religious conversations latched onto one sentence from his talk. Um, and, and I'll read it here. It says, uh, never take counsel from those who do not believe, seek guidance from the voices you can trust from prophets, seers, revelators, and the whisperings of the Holy ghost.
who will show unto you all things that you should do. Please do the spiritual work to increase your capacity to receive personal revelation. So this friend, he said to me, he's like, so does this mean you and I can't have conversations? Does this mean you can't take some of the ideas that I have and adopt them or adapt them into your own life? And I of course said, no, it doesn't mean that because I still get to decide how to apply it. But it is an interesting question. What's your take?
shawn (11:46.303)
Well, he's in the context of his talk, his whole talk. He was talking about spiritual matters, right? So I think he probably was saying look in the pursuit of our own salvation or exaltation when we're dealing with spiritual issues or religion. I think he's probably his counsel was seek after wise faithful people in those spiritual aspects.
Matt (11:46.418)
Go for it, Shawn.
Sam (12:08.802)
So don't take counsel from nonmembers.
Matt (12:12.846)
Well, so...
shawn (12:13.111)
No, I think you're saying don't take counsel from people who are going to destroy your faith, perhaps
Sam (12:17.643)
Mm-hmm.
Matt (12:17.914)
I'm going to read the paragraph before it, Sam. So, I'm going to take from this
Matt (12:46.31)
that he's talking about a very specific situation. If somebody is attacking your faith, don't take counsel from those who don't believe. Does that sit better with you, Sam, if it's only in situations where they're attacking your faith?
Sam (13:01.43)
Yeah, I like that. I think that's a great answer.
Matt (13:03.958)
except for that before you've said that we should listen to people who are attacking our faith.
Sam (13:10.63)
I don't, you know, I, that's a great point. I'm not uncomfortable having conversations with people that don't believe the way that I do, because I also think that helps us to expand our own understanding of what we personally believe. But I also think then it gets into an argument about what is the meaning of the word take counsel, right? We could still have a conversation. We could still seek understanding, seek to see things from someone else's point of view without,
Matt (13:24.066)
Yeah. Well,
Matt (13:31.448)
Right.
shawn (13:32.436)
Right, right.
shawn (13:38.347)
That's not taking counsel. Yeah, that's a good point, Sam.
Sam (13:40.054)
without taking counsel. But you know what? That's a pretty thin line. I mean, like, you know, I don't know.
Matt (13:45.318)
So I'll share a personal experience. So when I was a kid growing up, my dad left the church and he was, I would just call him anti-Mormon. And I would have gospel conversations with him and he would tell me things that were 100% untrue. And he had no, and there was no internet at the time. There was no way to verify that. And I spent a good like maybe 15 years of my life trying to find answers to these things my dad had told me. And because of our relationship, I didn't believe him.
But I do think that this happens sometimes, that there are people that pretend to be honest seekers of truth, pretend to want to have a conversation, and then they're gonna fill you with lies. And if you're approaching this from, we're just having an honest conversation, you might start to question things and to doubt things because you think that these people are being honest. And I think that he's saying maybe be guarded about that.
Sam (14:18.389)
Mm-hmm.
Sam (14:34.358)
And, and, and I would argue that in the world, that's a super narrow subset of people that's a group of people who've probably been members of the church, who are probably bitter by the way they left the church or bitter by something that happened in the church that most people, if, especially as you get outside of the Utah footprint or the kind of the Mormon footprint, most people, uh, love to have religious conversations and love to compare, you know, I mean, aside from the whole, Hey, you added to revelation, stop doing that. Right. Which.
Matt (14:39.395)
Yeah.
Matt (15:03.704)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Sam (15:05.1)
That's not super tough. I think it's fascinating to talk to people just in general. So that's probably more about what I'm talking about. But I do think it hangs on the council.
Matt (15:14.982)
But I also think if I think back to my mission, there were times when I would engage when I would call the manipulation pattern. And I knew missionaries that liked to engage in a manipulation pattern of like manipulating people into doing things. And so, you know, if well-intentioned members of our church can be caught trying to manipulate people into like joining our church, it's not unreasonable to think that there's other people out there that have their own kind of manipulation pattern they're engaging in. But I agree, it's not a lot of people.
but they could be well intentioned in their efforts.
Sam (15:47.558)
That actually, this is a subject for next, a future episode, but I was in, I shared this with you guys. I was in elders forum several weeks ago and they handed us a word track that came from some guy somewhere at some point. He may have been a, a mission president at some point. And it was kind of this foolproof word track to share your belief with people that aren't of our religion. Right. And, and it was.
Matt (16:10.434)
Oh, that's right. That's right. It was so manipulative. Yes. I forgot about that, Sam. That's right. In your ward, it's well-intentioned, good people that are promoting this version of a manipulation pattern to get people to come to the church. Yeah.
Sam (16:15.668)
It was so manipulative. Oh, did I just lose my mic?
shawn (16:19.143)
Yeah, that was shocking. That was shocking.
Sam (16:31.062)
Yeah, yeah. Sorry, I lost the mic in my right ear, but it was so manipulative that if we tried, to your point, Matt, if we try to engage with others with that tactic instead of our own transparency, our own vulnerability, our own experience connecting with them on belief, that'll have the same effect as what President Nelson's counseling again. So thank you guys for answering that. That was fantastic.
Matt (16:37.1)
Yeah.
Matt (16:52.898)
Yeah. Good mailbag question. Okay, Shawn, you get to begin the Thought Provoker.
shawn (17:00.587)
Okay, good. So last week we I've got we've gotten quite a bit of feedback from the topic that we had at the end where we talked about our predictor responses to conference at that point. We would only listen to the first session. And so we focused in on elder Oaks or president Oaks discussion about salvation versus exaltation. Well lay the next day president Nelson then comes out and doubles down on that exact message really. So it's fascinating to me that both president Nelson and president Oaks both preached a clear and direct doctrine about
salvation versus well, what is salvation and what is exaltation? And actually I'm a little surprised at how new this concept was to many members of our church that I've discussed it with afterwards. Um, because the scripture is really teaching it abundantly, but anyway, so I have two questions. Why do you think this was the primary focus from general conference specifically taught from the prophets, the highest ranking, right?
And then the second question would be, why would people choose single eternal life in a wonderful kingdom of glory versus familial exaltation and continuation of eternal lives? But first question, why do you think this is the primary focus in general conference?
Matt (18:10.266)
Well, so I have to say that this being a primary topic is what sort of instigated what I wanted to talk about last week. Because, because to me, the question is, what does God want for all of his children? And, and the assumption is, well, if exaltation is the highest and the best, then anyone who ends up with something less than exaltation, somehow failed or chose something lesser or chose something not as good.
And that's the part that I just don't like about that message. So, to me the message of salvation and exaltation, that's not new. But it does sort of like, it creates this problem that I said last time, right? That we say, Jesus saves everybody through grace. Yeah, we love that. But what we do that no other Christian church does is we say, but he saves everybody differently. And not everybody gets the same salvation. And then that's where it starts to cause these problems. Because it's like,
shawn (19:07.263)
So would you rather have an orthodox heaven and hell? Like what's the problem you have? Would you rather have that? Heaven and hell, in or out?
Matt (19:14.781)
I love the doctrine that Jesus saves everyone. That's the truth. Jesus saves everyone.
shawn (19:19.307)
But that is the doctrine. But that is the doctrine that we preach. That's exactly what we preach. That was his message. That was their message.
Sam (19:23.39)
It, you know, the thought that came into my head is, is don't, don't we preach levels, Shawn, like a multi-level marketing deal? I mean, you could, you could, you could, yeah, you could follow, you can follow the rules, you can work super hard. You can do everything you're supposed to do. And, and, and you can not reach that top or highest level.
Matt (19:29.635)
Hahahaha
shawn (19:32.217)
Like a Utah County organization?
Matt (19:33.755)
Hahaha
Matt (19:43.866)
So here's what I'm saying, Shawn. Okay, so Abraham 3, 24 to 26. It's the only verses we get that are in the actual pre-mortal life. And it says, And there stood one among them who was like unto God, that would be Jesus, and he said unto them who were with him, We will go down, for there is space there, and we will take of these materials, and we will make an earth whereon these may dwell. And we will prove them herewith to see if they will do all things whatsoever the Lord their God shall command them.
and they who keep their first estate shall be added upon, and they who keep not their first estate shall not have glory in the same kingdom as those who keep their first estate, and they who keep their second estate shall have glory added upon their heads forever and ever." So the purpose of this life is for us to gain a body and prove the Lord, and show the Lord like what estate we're going to be in the eternities.
shawn (20:37.483)
Well...
Matt (20:38.154)
everybody who came to this, the purpose of this earth is so that we can get physical bodies and we can grow to become our best selves. And the fact that there is a celestial and a terrestrial and telestial, those are all kingdoms of glory and we get too caught up on like what heaven a person is going to go to. So if a person doesn't go to the celestial kingdom, they didn't fail, that was the whole purpose of their existence, is to become better than what they were before.
shawn (21:03.027)
So if.
So I've heard both of you say that phrase, our purpose is to become our best selves. And I don't see that in scripture anywhere, but I have a follow-up quote. Well, no, that scripture just talked about exaltation. It said, the result of those actions is glory upon glory. That, by definition, is exaltation, not salvation.
Matt (21:12.303)
Yes.
Matt (21:15.798)
I just read it to you.
Matt (21:27.574)
So wait, 26. They who keep their first estate shall be added upon. The first estate is the premortal life. So the purpose of this life is that the people who keep their first estate will be added upon. And then the second part, And those who keep not their first estate shall not have glory in the same kingdom with those who keep their first estate.
shawn (21:37.002)
Right?
shawn (21:40.659)
Yeah, because we get our bodies. Yeah.
Matt (21:49.326)
So, the purpose of this life is so that we can become like God created us so that we could become our best selves. That's all he wants for us.
shawn (21:54.336)
There's.
Okay, okay. So let me ask you a follow up to that question. When you say become our best selves, do you mean according to me? Or do you mean according to God? God wants us to become the best self that he has planned for us? Or is it to become the best self that I choose to be? Yeah, no. But what do you mean by that? You've both said that I don't understand quite what you mean. Is it? Is it I?
Matt (22:04.342)
No. I quit.
Matt (22:10.879)
Well, we have an agency.
Matt (22:17.97)
So grace, grace means that we can't do it on our own, right? We cannot become our best selves without Christ.
shawn (22:26.823)
Sorry, let me rephrase the question. You've said the purpose, God's intent for us, right? So the general conference talk said, God's intent for us is to become exalted. That's what the talk was. You're saying God's intent for us is not necessarily, it's to become our best selves. So.
Matt (22:43.959)
He did not say God's intent is for us to be exalted. He said God's plan is to exalt humankind. He has a plan.
shawn (22:47.699)
So he said that the goal.
shawn (22:52.199)
Right, and he said the goal of the church is exaltation, is what they both said.
Matt (22:58.906)
Well, I mean, maybe that's what the purpose of the Church is. I mean, I don't believe that that's the purpose of the Church either. I think the purpose of the Church is to help everybody, through the grace of Christ, to become their best selves.
shawn (23:10.767)
Okay, but so let me let me make sure I have clarity on that, right? Because if I asked you, Matt, give me the what is in your view, your best self. And then I look at God the Father and say, Hey, give me your view of Matt's best self. Those are going to be very, very different. So I don't when you say that phrase, who are you? Who's best self? Whose perspective of best self are you seeing?
Matt (23:33.846)
we get to decide for ourselves.
shawn (23:36.131)
Okay, so you don't think it's God's intention to make you Matt the best self that he has envisioned for you. It's the best self that you are willing to be.
Matt (23:47.258)
Yeah, God will not force anyone into salvation. So he has a plan that makes it possible for everyone to achieve exaltation. But he's not going to force anybody to do it. But he's all... But he won't be upset with us if we choose something different than exaltation.
shawn (23:50.631)
No, no, I'm not saying that. I'm saying...
shawn (24:00.167)
No, I agree with that. That's, I don't think that's even part of the question. I think.
shawn (24:08.359)
I guess where I come from in this is this. I have to believe that exaltation, which, okay, so here are the words in scripture that describe exaltation. It's glory added upon heads forever. It is becoming like God, becoming a God. It is being above all, and all things become subject unto you. That's not being above all people. That means things, subject to things, right? It's, well, let me finish. It's continuation of lives.
Matt (24:32.442)
You think everybody wants that, Shawn?
shawn (24:37.715)
The only way to truly know God and Christ, it is to be enlarged in all eternity. So this continuation of life's concept.
Matt (24:44.59)
Are you in Doctrine and Covenants 132? Mm-hmm. Okay. Just for listeners, if they want to know. Open that up. That'll make your head spin a little bit. Heheheheheheheheheheh.
shawn (24:47.291)
Most of that. Yeah, most of it. Yeah, that's where it's all best kind of shared. Yeah. Yeah, read D&C 132. That's a good one. I love that one. So what I'm saying is these words in scripture that teach us what exaltation is clearly are teaching us that in order to become like our Father in heaven, we family has to be part of that. I'm not saying that I'm just saying if God desires that of us and lays the path down.
Matt (25:09.046)
Not everybody wants that, Shawn.
shawn (25:15.815)
And God knows what is most is best for us. Why wouldn't our message be aspire to that? Fight for that, let's help each other to that.
Matt (25:23.258)
because people don't want it. Shawn, let's say I'm a billionaire and I say, here son, you can have a yacht, you can have a private jet, or you can have a motor home. And my kid's like, I want the motor home. And they're like, what's wrong with you? This yacht is worth a billion dollars. Why don't you want the yacht? And he's like, I'm afraid of the water. I don't think the water is very much fun. I'd rather cruise around in my motor home. Yeah, it's like, God offers us everything.
shawn (25:36.339)
What? Why? What?
Sam (25:46.21)
Starts.
shawn (25:48.875)
So does that, but does, yeah, that's true. No, I think it's a beautiful, wonderful, charitable, merciful plan that he saves us all in a degree of glory. And that's a beautiful plan, and I think it's very merciful. But we are here on earth, and we are helping each other get through this earth life, which is challenging. I don't think the message is a very good one that says, you guys are fine over there because you just don't want it bad enough. No, let's help each other get to.
Matt (25:52.078)
and we choose what we want. We get to...
shawn (26:18.579)
the thing that God envisions for us, the thing that is of most worth, which is being with Him, having His glory, living the life that He lives, in His love with our families, so we should encourage and not settle.
Matt (26:29.394)
Not... not everybody wants it. To me it's way better to say, you want the motorhome, I'll help you get the motorhome. Maybe all you want is to like make it through the next day of your life. I'll help you do that. I don't have to worry about what they want in the end or what their ultimate goal is or what path they're on. And so that's why I don't like the messages of like, you get saved and some get saved better than others. The yacht isn't necessarily better than the motorhome. The... First Sam!
shawn (26:45.971)
All right, Sam.
Sam (26:54.278)
Oh, it is. Been on a yacht or two and they're definitely, definitely better.
Matt (26:58.682)
Hahahaha
shawn (27:02.079)
Sam, Matt, but I have a hard time with it because, but I have a hard, but Matt, what it seems like you're saying is someone will be as happy living outside of God's presence, living outside of God the Father's presence, than they would be to live in His presence. No, you're not. That's not true. That can't be.
Matt (27:02.778)
But, but like some people are tent people, right? Like let them be-
Sam (27:05.719)
Yeah.
Matt (27:14.05)
Yes.
Matt (27:18.578)
Yes, they will be. Then what you're saying is not heaven. What you're telling me, Shawn, is that the Telestial Kingdom isn't heaven. Because if... ..
shawn (27:26.353)
It's a it's a
Sam (27:26.574)
because it removes the element of choice in free agency.
shawn (27:29.671)
No, no, no
Matt (27:35.332)
If you're...
Matt (27:42.34)
Bye.
Sam (27:44.814)
But Shawn, it is interesting if you define what the version of exaltation looks like and you help push everybody towards that, that does gently challenge free agency.
Matt (27:54.914)
Right. And if your definition of heaven in the telestial kingdom is eternal regret that you don't get to be in God's presence, that's not heaven, Shawn. Eternal regret is not heaven. So then what you're questioning, Shawn, is salvation. You're questioning, is salvation really good enough for most people or lots of people? And I'm saying, yeah, it is. It's totally good enough.
shawn (27:55.368)
Why?
Sam (28:05.495)
That's all.
shawn (28:07.563)
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
shawn (28:17.031)
Well, I am suggesting that there will definitely be an element. If I land in a kingdom that is lesser than the presence of God, less than the celestial kingdom, you don't think there's going to be an element of disappointment? That I didn't get what I could have had? I didn't get to be in the presence of the Father? That's impossible. That's impossible to me.
Matt (28:29.849)
I don't.
Matt (28:35.007)
I don't, and if I'm being 100% honest Shawn, I think anyone who ends up in the Telestial Kingdom heaven is going to pay a higher price to get there than you might pay to get into the Celestial Kingdom. Because the Telestial Kingdom, you have to suffer for your sins for a thousand years before you get to go to the Telestial Kingdom.
shawn (28:46.187)
I don't know what that means.
shawn (28:50.98)
Oh yeah, okay. Sure.
Matt (28:52.986)
Guess what, Celestial Kingdom people, they just repent on Earth, they accept Christ, they avoid all the suffering and go to the Celestial Kingdom. So I'm telling you, Telestial Kingdom people are going to go through way more pain than what you're going to go through.
shawn (28:57.439)
What the heck?
shawn (29:00.903)
Yeah, but guess what? But guess what? But guess they will. They will Matt, but guess what? I don't just strive, you know, you're not just going to strive into that celestial kingdom and go, yeah, all the suffering is gone. No, that suffering went somewhere. That suffering went to the Savior. And because of your covenant, no, yeah, no, but because of your relationship with the Savior and the gratitude and deep, deep love that you will have because he did that, that life together in the presence of God is a better life.
Matt (29:16.758)
Okay, but I didn't suffer it. I didn't suffer it.
shawn (29:30.739)
then I suffered for my sins and I went into a kingdom where I don't get to be in the presence of the Father. That is why it's the goal of the church to help us all become exalted.
Matt (29:40.226)
All I'm saying is that I can make the case that the celestial path is the easy path, and the celestial path is the hard path. And I don't think that we should like say to the people that endure a harder life and a hard... Like, if you choose the celestial kingdom, your life on earth is pretty much like hell, and then you suffer for it in hell, and then you get to go to heaven later on. Like that's a harder path.
Sam (30:04.675)
The problem with the whole debate though is you're making assumptions about how it all works in the end. We just don't know like who knows This isn't a game of shoots and ladders and ML a multi-level marketing like there's not I don't think it's that well Described anywhere how it all like it's all theory a little bit
shawn (30:09.671)
Good point. It's a good point.
Matt (30:09.766)
Hahaha! Sam!
shawn (30:13.963)
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
shawn (30:21.043)
But then, okay, then back, okay, Sam, then I'm gonna ask you back to the original question. Why was this topic the primary topic in general conference?
Matt (30:24.198)
Cough.
Matt (30:28.598)
Yeah, Sam. Tell us.
Sam (30:29.686)
I actually am curious. I don't, I don't know. I, you, you know what? Do you want me to give you the real reason? I think that there's a lot of people, particularly youth that are looking at what is offered by membership and they're, they're challenged by it. Like they're trying to figure out what does the church offer me? What does membership offer me? What is being part of this community offer me? How do I fit in? And right now.
shawn (30:29.947)
If it's all if it's all unanswerable. Your answer is I don't know.
Matt (30:33.93)
I'm- uh- I perf- how would we know?
Yeah.
Matt (30:56.462)
and the church decided to double down on the doctrine.
Sam (30:59.058)
Yeah, we've they first tried a concert. They had one Republic come to a stadium and they had a big concert and they had a testimony meeting and, and I'm being a little facetious, but not totally facetious, like, like that, that there is a challenge in the church. What do you do with these kids that are trying to figure the world and life out? And it's a compelling message. What you're saying, Shawn, if you're certain in that path.
shawn (31:00.487)
It's sweet, good doctrine, man.
shawn (31:17.791)
So you think Sam.
Sam (31:25.942)
But if you're trying to figure your life out, it is interesting that I have to follow all these rules, which are challenged by social norms today, only to hit the Telestial Kingdom. Like it's like, it's like, okay, I'm going to follow all of these rules. I had a great conversation about that this, this week. I have to follow all these rules and I get third prize. Like.
Matt (31:37.803)
Hahaha
shawn (31:50.299)
What do you mean by rules? You mean like, no, but what do you mean in the context of the kids? You mean I can't drink alcohol and I can't go party and I can't have premarital sex.
Matt (31:52.566)
commandments, Shawn.
Sam (31:53.442)
Commandment shot.
Matt (31:59.59)
Shawn, are you unaware of the commandments and what kids are doing these days?
Sam (32:01.922)
Ha ha ha!
shawn (32:04.715)
Hehehehehehe
Matt (32:07.461)
We've spent too long on this topic. But it's been.
Sam (32:09.77)
Yeah, let's go on. It's been fun.
shawn (32:10.066)
I woulda-
Matt (32:13.154)
I want to give thought provoker points to Sam because when I described my view of the afterlife he compared it to chutes and ladders and I thought that's fitting because that is sort of the way I view things.
Sam (32:15.374)
This is John. Oh, really? Okay.
Sam (32:25.695)
Uh...
shawn (32:27.044)
I'm gonna give it to Sam too because I still am super unclear what Matt's point is.
Matt (32:33.766)
This, the...
Sam (32:33.85)
I will, I will admit something. And I said it last week. I was a heck of a lot more clear on how that worked on my mission and leading up into it. And as a dad and as a parent and as someone that truly cares about the world, like I'm a little bit less certain now. Does that, what, what does that mean? Shawn, Shawn nearly fell off his chair. Sounds like I don't think I can be on a podcast with Sam anymore.
Matt (32:51.661)
Yeah.
That means that you...
shawn (32:57.011)
Yeah, I don't know what that means. No, no, I'm very curious at what that means. That's interesting.
Matt (33:00.226)
Well, no, I so I think to be honest, that's why they're talking about it, right? Let's reinforce some key doctrines. Let's reinforce some principles and let's get back to the basics because sometimes we get a little bit off topic on that stuff.
Sam (33:08.5)
Right.
Sam (33:12.618)
Yeah, which we've done. So next topic, Matt, you're going to take us into jobs. Yes.
Matt (33:14.866)
Okay, my topic is this. You guys are gonna love this. So the September job numbers just came out. The US economy created over 300,000 jobs in September. Unemployment rate is as low as it's been in 50 years. In fact, if you look at unemployment numbers back to President Obama, the only spike in unemployment is during the COVID-19 shutdown in the spring of 2020. We won't blame that on Trump even though that happened on his watch. So there's this clear pattern of un...
shawn (33:21.215)
So man.
Sam (33:25.888)
Wow.
Sam (33:42.37)
Kind of virus? Yeah.
Matt (33:43.858)
There's this clear pattern of declining unemployment rate from Obama through the Biden administration. And so my question is this, Republicans blame Democratic policies for inflation. And they primarily say taxes. But you know what else causes inflation? When everybody has a job and they have money to spend. And so maybe it's possible that Democratic policies are causing inflation because they're just making sure everybody has a job.
and so that's going to be inflationary in the economy. So, it appears to me that the Democrats do a really good job of making sure that the private sector creates employment opportunities for everyone. So shouldn't we just now acknowledge that Democrats are just as good at managing the economy as are Republicans? And all these people who think the Republicans are better are wrong.
Sam (34:30.994)
except Except the polling that you attached doesn't reflect that so that's interesting Statistical analysis polling. Okay, right? That's that that's a professor's view and a very liberal view But but I have one question
Matt (34:36.09)
Because, well... People are dumb, right? People don't know. People are unaware.
shawn (34:41.367)
Oh, hang on, hang on. Let this be, let this, let this, and let this be record, and let this be recorded that forevermore any poll that Matt cites, the ques- the rest of the people are dumb, you can't rely on this poll.
Matt (34:45.574)
Hahaha
Sam (34:50.746)
Yeah, yeah, yeah. So Matt, if the state of unemployment or the state of employment is so great, I have one question. You love unions? Why the heck are the unions running everybody out of work? So in Hollywood, they're just getting back to business. There was a huge health care strike this past week where health care workers who are critical by any measure walked off work for three days.
Matt (34:53.663)
That's true.
Matt (35:00.05)
Mm-hmm.
Yeah.
Sam (35:18.55)
The UAW is currently out and continues to be out. There's not a clear path to resolving that. If, yeah, United Auto Workers, if the state of employment is so good, as you say it is, why is everybody refusing to work?
shawn (35:24.523)
That's the auto, that's the auto workers, right Sam?
Matt (35:26.543)
Yeah.
shawn (35:36.075)
Okay, go Matt.
Matt (35:36.782)
because now they actually have power. Because the unemployment rate is so good, you can walk off your job and be confident that somebody else isn't gonna come in and take that job away from you. So the workers have power right now, and they're exercising that power to get the rights and benefits that they deserve. Auto workers should not be working more than four days a week, and they should not be working for less than $50 an hour, and they should have a pension that like, in...
Sam (36:03.79)
Please note the facetiousness. That's my problem though, is when I know that is what they're asking for. I don't work four days a week. Like I have a good job and I have to work pretty long hours. Right. Well, so
Matt (36:06.722)
No, that's what they're asking for!
Matt (36:13.262)
Well, you're compensated pretty well for that.
shawn (36:16.511)
Sam, you're a celestial worker, they're T-lateral workers. They just don't want it. They don't want that life.
Sam (36:21.799)
I just don't want to fall down the slide on this, but here's the challenge. I, I'm questioning the value of unions in a marketplace where, where unemployment is so low and workers are so highly valued. Why can't an employer and employee come to an agreement about their value, uh, by themselves without kind of the work of a union in between. And it's not totally your question, but I think.
Matt (36:45.426)
No. Jamie Dimon, by the way, Jamie Dimon this week, the CEO of JP Morgan Chase, said that in the future people will be working three and a half days per week. Jamie Dimon recognizes the inevitability of a three to four day work week, and unions are leading the charge for that. There's no reason in an economy and in a society as wealthy as we are that somebody should go to the factory for 40 hours a week. That's just insane. The people should be...
Sam (36:49.014)
Yeah. I know who that is.
Matt (37:13.146)
building their lives, building their families. There's enough wealth to go around. So instead of just letting the CEO who's working insane hours get all that money, share the wealth, let the people work a little bit less and let them achieve self-actualization in their lives through a steady employment of 30 hours a week, 32 hours a week.
Sam (37:29.054)
Oh no. Shawn, Matt wanted a way to be able to come back to universal basic income and dismantling the space program and giving everybody a hundred grand a year and just allowing them to rethink.
shawn (37:30.816)
Ha ha.
Matt (37:37.882)
Hahaha
shawn (37:38.409)
Yeah.
shawn (37:44.555)
Okay, but also Matt, but Matt, you're quite...
Matt (37:44.73)
But I just wanna, I just wanna, can we correct misperceptions about Republicans are so good with the economy?
shawn (37:50.523)
Okay, that's what I was gonna say. I was gonna say your whole premise of this question is to basically defend Democrats. And it's also Matt to falsely attribute the outcome of all of these questions to one or the other party, which is the opposite of what we're trying to accomplish with the latter day lens, Matt. We're not trying to say, we're not trying to say one party has all the answers and solutions. No, the other party has all the answers. We're trying to break that, Matt. What are you doing? We're trying, we're not.
Sam (37:53.883)
But the survey doesn't support that.
Matt (38:04.315)
Yeah.
Sam (38:07.646)
Yeah, shame on you.
Matt (38:08.891)
Hahaha
Matt (38:16.51)
I said Democrats are just as good as Republicans. I didn't say better than, I said just as good as. I'm not asking for Democrats to be superior, I'm just saying, look they're the same. Pick whichever one you want.
shawn (38:20.747)
Oh, okay. Okay.
shawn (38:26.735)
I don't think Matt, is that it? Can you is the same as saying I don't are you so you Sam disagrees with it? But matter you trying to say that political parties, their policies don't matter. The economic all the multiple economic elements have nothing to do with the policies of each party. It has to do with things like supply chain and has to do things like well, but then there's government plugging, pushing money into a into an economy that has a big effect on it.
Sam (38:27.438)
The, the polling, the, the polling doesn't support it.
Matt (38:39.963)
Yes.
Matt (38:46.768)
Right.
Matt (38:54.53)
That's why people... Well, guess what effect... Guess what effect it's had in the Biden administration? Creating jobs. So I'm just saying like... Well, but jobs create inflation. If you want to get rid of inflation, have a big recession where people all lose their jobs and the inflation is going to come right down because people won't have money to spend.
shawn (38:55.891)
But both parties do that.
shawn (39:02.307)
and inflation and inflation.
shawn (39:15.304)
But Matt, I've seen charts.
Sam (39:15.842)
Well, that's what they're trying to do with, with monetary policy with interest rates, right? You raise interest rates to the point it slows demand in the economy. The problem is there's so much pent up demand in the economy that it's not going to slow. And all of these strikes are actually making it worse because it's going to take new, you know, it's going to take new cars out of the market. That's going to continue to be pent up. And when it comes back, that's going to be higher price.
shawn (39:27.885)
Mmm, yeah.
shawn (39:36.952)
Sam, why is there still pent up demand in our economy? I don't understand that.
Matt (39:41.466)
Jobs. Cause everybody has a job and they want to spend their money.
Sam (39:44.702)
Yeah. Well, and by the way, I don't know if you guys notice this, but you go into a restaurant and there's not enough people. Like there's just not. That's why that's so I know unions is adding an element that you didn't intend, but that's why I'm so confused about the need for a union, right? Like good people are tough to find right now. And an employer should be able to come up with their own contract on that. But, but Matt, I disagree that the Democrats are better. I think it's okay to say, Hey, maybe they're the same, but
Matt (40:14.072)
Okay.
Sam (40:14.614)
Listen, that makes them worse because they say they're better. And the polling actually says Republicans are better. So take that. But here, here's the reality though, Matt, uh, unemployment spike during COVID was started by Trump, not by him in Wuhan, right? And so of course it's been a huge increase ever since an unemployment. That's not a tough trick to, uh, or lower.
shawn (40:15.327)
That's all he wanted. That's what Matt wanted.
Matt (40:20.942)
Well, people think that, but they need to understand the facts.
Matt (40:39.714)
No, no, no. No, I'm saying look at the chart. So if you look at the chart of unemployment rate, if you look at the chart of unemployment rate in the Obama administration, it starts to go down and then there's a big spike in the Trump administration and then it comes down, yeah, and then it comes down really rapidly, but then it just continues to go down, down in the Biden administration. So, so.
shawn (40:42.623)
You're saying the rate of increase.
Sam (40:43.798)
And by the way, mucho gusto, mucho gusto. It is nice to meet you. Yeah. Green Trump because of COVID. Yeah.
Sam (41:01.15)
Yeah. Nothing to do with Biden.
shawn (41:01.512)
I don't think it has such, not to do with political parties, it's the economy and the world stage that I think has this.
Matt (41:06.582)
Okay. So can I win that? Because listen, I went against the poll and I made you guys agree with me. So maybe I win the Thought Provoker.
shawn (41:18.259)
It's important to you to win. So yes, you win Matt. Pat him on the back, Sam.
Sam (41:20.287)
Uhhhhhh
Matt (41:21.494)
I mean if we're gonna do points shouldn't I try and get them? Okay alright alright.
shawn (41:24.203)
Pat him on the back, Sam.
Sam (41:24.63)
You've got them. Matt, Matt gets the points. Matt gets the points. All right. Here's my question. Why is the intensity increasing in kids sports by parents today? So I'm going to, I'm going to actually go to an experience I had just a couple of years ago, went to a, went to a basketball game. My youngest son was playing city basketball, right? And all of my kids, by the way, have been refs at some point. They've been paid by the city to go in and be refs. Um,
shawn (41:28.971)
Ha ha ha!
Matt (41:29.171)
Okay, Sam, your topic.
Sam (41:54.154)
At this game, some of the players start pushing each other. The coach doesn't do anything on the team that is responsible for the pushing. The pushing escalates. And actually the other team starts haunting our team in a really kind of disrespectful way. Finally, a couple of the parents jump in and one parent pushes one of the offending kids refs come in, say game is over by the way, kid refs, right? And.
And, and the, and the, and the coach on the opposite side jumps in and is frustrated and upset at these kids. Ref starts speaking to them in a very heated way. You shouldn't have stopped the game. These are just kids. Let them play, you know, but just let it happen. And a parent had pushed a kid and, and kids were pushing each other in a very disrespectful way. Uh, I went up to that coach after and just asking questions about how he was viewing this.
Matt (42:23.314)
Wow.
Matt (42:42.948)
Hahaha
Sam (42:53.266)
Not understanding kind of his approach and what he saw it. He thought, hey, kids are kids. Just let them play. Yes. Who the guess who the coach was? And I'll defend this publicly. No, last name last name was Povey, and I Googled the guy who wrote he wrote he wrote some book about better teams, right? He's the yes. He wrote, yeah, yes, I'm like, I'm like
Matt (43:02.406)
Who? Lavelle Edwards.
Matt (43:08.914)
Uh oh. Uh oh. He's-
He's the son of Stephen Covey, who wrote Seven Habits of Highly Effective Teens? Wow.
shawn (43:21.041)
Sam, ratting a guy out, Sam, you rat.
Sam (43:22.818)
Some of the parents came up to me afterwards and they're like, you know who that is, right? I'm like, I have no idea. Not a clue. And.
Matt (43:28.278)
You're like, I know that it's a person who can't control their emotions at a rec league basketball game. But by the- but in fairness, Sam, that's not one of the habits. He sharpened the saw, right? That might be part of it. But control your temper?
Sam (43:31.274)
Right. So the, so the. Yes. I, I messaged him after it. I said, Hey, I have a podcast, not this another and said, Hey, I'd love to have a conversation with you on it. And he completely ignored it. Shocker. Right. So what is it? Have you guys seen this type of bad behavior in kid sports, uh, in particular recently?
Matt (43:50.579)
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Doesn't wanna.
Matt (43:59.418)
We'll let Shawn go first because whenever I see him posting his kids stuff online, I think there's some bad parents in that crowd. So I think Shawn sees it more than I do.
Sam (44:05.602)
But but Shawn before you go though, I just want to share some stats. 87 according to a survey by the National Association of Sports officials, 87% of participants said that they had suffered verbal abuse in kids sports. 13% had been assaulted. 13% assaulted and 47% felt unsafe. So do we as members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints have a responsibility as parents
shawn (44:06.473)
Oh, okay.
Sam (44:35.375)
to not be so terrible, right? And kids sports and what causes this Shawn?
shawn (44:40.083)
Yeah, I think I'm going to brag about my kid a little bit in this because his whole... So he's a basketball player and has played forever. He's on a mission now, but he was a really talented kid and he had a really amazing high school experience playing basketball. He early on decided that his... They all had to pick nicknames and they would put them on the back of their shirts. So for four years in high school, the back of his shirt said Mormon Menace. So he picked...
Sam (44:42.891)
Do it!
Sam (45:06.236)
Oh wow.
Matt (45:08.523)
Does that mean what he thinks it means?
shawn (45:11.991)
Well, they picked him. He picked a moniker that helped him identify himself as, look, I'm not going to do all the bad things. I'm not going to get mad. I'm not going to fight. I'm not going to go and party afterwards. I'm not going to do all these things. So I think lots, lots and lots. Yeah. And and the adults were really bad examples to him. And he it emboldened him to he was more resolved to play the way he played without losing temper.
Sam (45:20.43)
showed his belief.
Sam (45:25.09)
Has he ever played elders core on basketball, Shawn, by the way? Okay. All right.
Matt (45:27.214)
Hahahaha
shawn (45:38.987)
keeping it cool. Anyway, so I think to answer your question about what's our moral obligations as members of the church, put morals and religion above the sports all the time. When he went to BYU, he got really competitive in the intramural thing and went all the way to the top with his little group of kids. And they're all freshmen. And all the older guys that they played against, at the end they always hugged and shook hands, but during the games, it was a swear fest, it was nasty. And that was pathetic, like really pathetic to him to watch.
Sam (45:40.7)
That's awesome.
shawn (46:08.767)
But your first question of why is it getting more heated? Here's what I think it is, Sam. I saw that somewhere along the lines, the institutions of sports started to get to, there's these professional sports that we all aspire to, and that's all I want. I wanna be an NBA player. And over time, those athletes didn't make it, and they faltered back into, well, I pursued it instead of my career, so now I'm gonna pursue sports, because that's all I know. And now these guys are the coaches, and they're sending the same message to all these kids.
Your kid is good enough to be in the NBA. Your kid is good enough to play Major League Soccer. And it's become an institutional kind of money grab a little bit because these guys have these clubs now and now the schools go year round and there's opportunity to make money. It's become a very big business. And so to me, I think it's.
Matt (46:51.858)
But you see it in places where that's not happening though either, right? You see it on tennis courts. You see it in people who have no aspirations to go pro. You'll see bad behavior and their parents behaving badly. I think it's more a function of the competitiveness, the competition, right? When you're in a competitive event, the natural inclination is to just act a fool trying to win. And people just don't turn that off, right?
shawn (47:04.915)
Do you?
shawn (47:20.42)
Like when you, like Matt, when you try and get points for our Thought Provoker competition, you do get a little obscene, it's true.
Matt (47:23.515)
Hahahaha
Matt (47:27.314)
That's yeah, but it's not like it's in every aspect of our lives and we like Sam already hinted at elders corn basketball Church basketball I would see church leaders behaving in a manner that I would have never guessed they would ever behave Fighting over a call in some leg basketball game. That's totally meaningless So sports have a really great potential for good in bringing people together But people who get caught up in the competition it has a lot of opportunity for evil
I don't know, Sam, that it's actually more prevalent now than it was in the past. I think what's different is it's more visible, because everybody's got a phone and a camera and so we see it more. But as I look back to my experiences growing up, there were foolish parents at every little game I ever was in. So I just don't think it's more now. I just think that it's...yeah.
shawn (48:12.779)
Yeah, I don't think it's new.
Sam (48:15.522)
So, so it feels like a little bit more. You, if you go into a couple of the articles I attached, there, there was a guy who made the comment, uh, it's, it's helicopter parents and lawnmower parents whose job is to mow down all the obstacles for their kids and give ownership to the, uh, ownership to the athletes. So it, I mean, they do feel that way. You see that in your role in your job, probably, right? You give a kid a grade and it's like, how can you
Matt (48:33.21)
Parents do feel that way. There are a lot of parents that are the, yeah.
Yeah, yeah. Oh a lot. Yeah. Oh jeez. Yeah. Oh jeez.
Sam (48:44.176)
How can you suppress the brilliance of this young mind by trying to give him an A-? Like, you've ruined him, right?
Matt (48:51.77)
Parents definitely feel like they have some kind of obligation to make life easy for their kids, right? To remove obstacles for all of their kids. And so I do think there's this element of... I'm going to share a story that's actually kind of embarrassing, but I had this... So there was a counselor at the school, and there was a discussion about my son taking the AP class. And I wanted my son to take the AP class, but not take the test. And then, so he was like kind of pressuring, like, in this situation.
And I tried to be really, really nice and I said, listen, I feel like I have a right to have my son be in this class and not take the test and I'm not pleased with what you said to my son. I sent it at like 10 p.m. I said, could you please call me tomorrow? He emailed me back like six minutes later and then he called me first thing in the morning and he spent like 10 minutes apologizing to me on the phone and I was like, this poor guy probably deals with...
like horrible parents. I was like, I'm not pleased. I know, I'm like, I'm not even all that upset. I just wanna have a little conversation and like make sure you understand my perspective. And he was so defensive, I thought, these poor high school counselors probably deal with angry parents on a regular basis who are threatening their jobs and all that kind of stuff. And so there is something like in society right now where people are way overreacting to stuff.
Sam (49:50.455)
Yeah. You gave him a heart attack. Yeah.
Sam (50:13.31)
So, so let me add an element to it, to what Shawn said, or one of you said, Hey, I don't think it's actually worse now has COVID played into this a little bit. And this kind of mentality and politics and society as a whole, that it's sort of us versus them, right? Like there's a conspiracy theory in every political corner and every social corner of the world. And I just wonder if part of that plays in, part of that gets infused somehow into kids' sports. I mean, the way some parents attack.
refs. I mean, it's an adult.
Matt (50:43.724)
I know, it's ridiculous.
shawn (50:44.323)
I think it's, I don't know, Sam, I don't know if it's COVID related. I think it's more what Matt was saying. A parent, parents nowadays, yeah, instead of when we grew up and them saying, get out the house and don't come home till late, now they are hovering. Parent, we hover, it's our fault, right? We're the hovering parents, we ruin these kids. Yeah, we have to get involved. We have to go defend our kid in that game. I think that's more of the issue.
Sam (50:48.802)
You don't think?
Matt (50:59.666)
Yeah.
Matt (51:05.754)
Hey speaking of conspiracy theories, Sam, you know how everyone got that notification on their phone this week about from the emergency? There are videos on YouTube about how that was the government activating the COVID-19 vaccine to turn us on. Isn't that insane? Yeah.
Sam (51:06.038)
But why? Yeah.
Yeah, yeah, I was in a meeting. Yeah.
I know, I know, I know. I saw it. I saw, I was, I was broadcasting a meeting to a few hundred employees that I, that I work with and everybody's phones went off all at once. So that, that is funny that that's, I mean, wait, why, why is that? Why do people have, why, why do we think there's a conspiracy in so much stuff? Why, why is that narrative even in society right now? Science is at an incredible place.
shawn (51:19.179)
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Matt (51:31.04)
Hahahaha
Matt (51:41.638)
Yeah.
shawn (51:43.659)
Because it gets, because it gets, because it gets headlines. Because it gets headlines and clicks.
Sam (51:46.006)
Progress is it? Yeah.
Matt (51:49.686)
But people have to believe it, Shawn, right? If people weren't believing it, they wouldn't be... Like, that is the most ludicrous thing, right? But people believe it, and so that's why that... It gets clicked because people believe that garbage, right? Sam wants to know why they believe that, but I believe that a 14-year-old boy found golden plates in New York, and so I can't fault people who believe outlandish things. But still, I'm gonna give Shawn the thought provoker on this one. I'm gonna give Shawn points on this one.
shawn (52:01.552)
Yeah, the question is why do they believe it?
Sam (52:09.634)
hahahaha uhhh
Sam (52:18.402)
Good job, John. I'm gonna give them to Shawn too.
Matt (52:19.726)
Because... because he blamed us. He pointed the finger straight. So we haven't done the big question in a while, but I'm really looking forward to this topic. So listener, bear with me a little bit. Political philosophy is super boring to read. I'm going to save you like the homework assignment of reading On Liberty from John Stuart Mill, because it'll put you to sleep real fast. But in Chapter 2, he makes this argument. So the question is freedom of speech.
shawn (52:24.683)
It is our fault. Gen X parents, we're the fault.
Sam (52:26.421)
It is our fault. Yeah.
shawn (52:32.479)
This is a good one. Yeah, this is a good one.
Matt (52:49.71)
When should we allow people to say things that are bad or that are crazy, right? And so John Stuart Mill, he's got a very liberal position in that he's saying, we need to allow as much freedom of speech as possible in a society because it's good for society. And then he says, so he says, there ought to exist the fullest liberty of professing and discussing as a matter of ethical conviction, any doctrine, however immoral it may be considered.
So he's like, really anything should be allowed, nothing should be off, should not be allowed. But then he says, but there do have to be some limits. And so then he says, the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community against his will is to prevent harm to others. And so Mill was a philosopher whose thinking influenced the founders of our nation. And so if you look through the judicial and legislative history of the United States,
That's kind of been the guide is speech is allowed as long as it doesn't cause physical harm to others. Which is why we'd say you don't have the right to shout fire in a movie theater if there's not actually a fire there. But it feels... Yeah.
shawn (54:01.807)
or incite or incitement to violence, for example, you cannot incite the violence, but go to the cause, go ahead to the to the capital on people and.
Matt (54:06.638)
because that would harm people.
Matt (54:12.962)
You're gonna trigger Sam stop it Shawn this is the big
shawn (54:14.427)
Sorry, Sam. Sorry, Sam.
Sam (54:14.946)
I am, I'm triggered. I'm, I've been physically harmed by this conversation.
Matt (54:20.77)
Well, so it does seem to me like as we think about cancel culture and all of these other things in society, now again, it's not governments that are doing this, this is individuals doing it, but it feels to me like what we're doing as a society is we're saying we're defining harm not as physical harm, but we're defining harm as maybe psychological or emotional harm. And if somebody says something that harms somebody else's emotions or has the potential to hurt someone's feelings, then we say,
shawn (54:20.865)
Emotionally.
Sam (54:40.974)
Emotional, yeah.
Matt (54:49.998)
that should not be allowed in society. And so this is the big question I want us to discuss is what is the morally correct way to define harm? Should we be prohibiting speech that causes emotional or psychological harm? And should we be pushing for limits to speech that cause potential to physical harm, even if it actually doesn't cause physical harm? Like what's the moral guideline here? How should we think about when is harm, what is harm, and when should we not allow speech that causes harm?
shawn (55:19.955)
Well, Matt, usually knowing you, you usually bring up a topic like this and kind of assuming or knowing what the answer is going to be on Sam and I's part, usually you taking the opposite answer. So first I'm curious, are you going to argue that we should prohibit language that would cause so-called emotional, psychological harm?
Matt (55:27.8)
No, I have no idea.
Matt (55:40.966)
really don't have a position on this. I just thought this would be something very interesting to discuss. Like, I don't know the answer. I can see the arguments for why it is morally wrong to cause emotional harm to other people. But I can also... yeah, morally wrong. Like, it's... it is morally... well, we're asking... we're asking the moral question. Should...
shawn (55:42.825)
Oh, okay. All right.
shawn (55:54.487)
morally wrong. Well, but that's not your question. It's legally, right?
Sam (56:00.47)
So, so, so.
shawn (56:03.771)
Is it wrong to be mean to people? Yeah, it's morally wrong to.
Matt (56:06.07)
Should, what, so should we be trying to prohibit that? Should we silence that? Should we cancel that? Like, should we say, you said something that hurt someone's feelings. The morally correct response is to silence you, so you never do that again. Okay, so that's the question. What's the morally correct thing?
Sam (56:10.338)
Here.
shawn (56:11.388)
No.
No.
shawn (56:17.892)
No, absolutely not. No way.
Sam (56:21.07)
It it's interesting because part of growth in life is going through adversity and challenge and like, I hate to use the word suffering, but like being stretched, being challenged, being given another point of view and kind of wrestling with that, that involves the potential for emotional harm. Like life involves the potential of physical harm, right? Like you can't wake up in the morning without risking. I mean, I think about these helicopter parents and the conversation there.
Matt (56:40.067)
Mm-hmm.
Sam (56:50.57)
Like maybe that's what you're seeing people trying to protect their kids from. Matt is, Hey, you can't give my kid a bad grade because that's going to do them emotional harm and that will stunt their ability to go get a good job later on. Right. Like
Matt (57:03.73)
Or you can't tell my kid he's bad at shooting the basketball and he should stop shooting in the game, because that's going to hurt his feelings and he's just a little kid, leave him alone.
Sam (57:08.478)
He's a, he's a prodigy. He's a prodigy. And one day he will make billions on that. Like, so it's, it, it's interesting. Part of life is being exposed to things that are potentially challenging to us physically, psychologically. I love Matt. You've talked in the past episodes about how you think some of the cancel culture that's gone on, that there will be a swing back to a normal. And when we look back 10 years from now,
That will be one of the things that we say, Hey, uh, that went too far, right? Society went too far with that. And I agree with that. Um, and, you know, this, this is kind of an extension of that. You, you can't, you can't legislate or prohibit the potential for someone to be challenged, uh, emotionally challenged. Now prove physical harm death. Like that it's a good idea to prevent that, right? Like that devastating.
Matt (57:40.256)
Mm-hmm.
shawn (57:59.467)
So.
Matt (58:03.132)
Yeah, that's right.
shawn (58:03.944)
So.
Sam (58:05.614)
moral, devastating emotional harm like PTSD. That's a challenge. It's malevolence that creates PTSD. Someone goes to war, someone's trying to kill them or they see terrible things. It would be great to legislate that, but I'm not even sure in a world where people go to war you can make that illegal. It'd be great to do it.
shawn (58:30.675)
So here's a real world example that happened yesterday in our neighborhood. So my son's high school of I think 4,000 kids, it's a huge high school. Yesterday midday, we all get alerts that, hey, we're on lockdown, there's been a bomb threat. And we all freak out. Hey, Tyler, we call our kid, hey buddy. Whoa, so we call our buddy Tyler, our buddy, our kid and their friends and everyone's like, whoa, we're out on the. So that.
Matt (58:44.822)
Yeah. That's illegal speech, right? Shouldn't that be illegal?
Sam (58:52.686)
Plus there's a bomb there, then that's not illegal. Go ahead.
Matt (58:55.406)
That's right.
shawn (58:56.315)
So then they're all hiding out, they're all scared. And later on, my son was telling me how some kids, when they make the announcement at school, they didn't explain what's going on. They just said we're in lockdown because there's been a threat. And there were certain kids and teachers who panicked so much that they locked the door, grabbed all the kids and says, guys, look out for a shooter. There's a shooter in the school. And all of a sudden, this, which they caught the person that did it. There was no threat. It was just empty talk. But, but.
Matt (59:14.865)
Wow.
Sam (59:22.658)
He was trying to get out of a test.
shawn (59:25.224)
And there was no physical damage. There was no physical, you know, no one got hurt physically, but lots of emotional, you know.
Matt (59:25.494)
Hahahaha
Sam (59:32.734)
But guess what? It's illegal to do what that person did.
shawn (59:35.463)
Yeah, I know. But that's the question here, right? What should be...
Matt (59:37.838)
Well, I could argue physical, right? Because you're in lockdown, you're in an uncomfortable situation. You're causing a little bit of physical harm there.
shawn (59:45.607)
But you're not saying that's why it should be illegal, because there's potential physical harm.
Matt (59:48.59)
Well, and I'm not even necessarily discussing laws, just more like what we should, like, like the Twitter people, the Twitter mobs that go after people, the corporations that do things that we dislike, and so let's go after them and try and shut them down. The retaliation that we get for speech, I wonder if we should just say, look, we should all agree to this moral code in society, like, this kind of speech is going to be okay, and it might make you unhappy and it might make you sad.
shawn (59:58.015)
Mmm.
shawn (01:00:01.951)
But that's... But how do you...
Matt (01:00:16.358)
but it's not causing physical harm, so you have to allow them to say it.
shawn (01:00:21.695)
You know who Jordan Peterson is, right?
Matt (01:00:24.31)
Uhhh... I don't dare to say no anymore. Yes.
Sam (01:00:25.538)
Yes.
shawn (01:00:28.851)
You don't know who Jordan Peterson is, Matt?
Matt (01:00:30.794)
I do, I do, yeah, yeah. I love him? Her. I love her. Him. I love him.
Sam (01:00:32.206)
Friends with Bill Cosby.
shawn (01:00:33.802)
So.
Sam (01:00:38.37)
Him, him, him. He looks, he looks like the guy in the, uh, in the commercials that says most interesting man in America. That's what he looks like. So.
shawn (01:00:38.858)
I am!
shawn (01:00:46.651)
Yeah, he does. So Matt, for the last eight years, he's a Canadian. And he's been in the forefront of this free speech debate in Canada and in the US a little bit, because basically the government passed a law that said, if you do not use certain types of speech to someone who wants to be labeled a certain way, that is a violation of law. And he said,
Matt (01:01:10.374)
Oh, is this the guy that refused to use pronouns?
shawn (01:01:14.427)
He didn't refuse to use them. He refused to be compelled to use them. He uses the pronouns, but okay. So he, his stance was it is morally wrong to compel me to use speech in a certain way, the same way that it's morally wrong to, to compel me to not, or to, to limit my free speech. Now we as a society have decided that certain things like incitement to violence is
Matt (01:01:17.759)
Oh, okay. Okay. Now I know who Jordan Peterson is. Okay.
shawn (01:01:43.087)
not only immoral, but also illegal. But I think we all agree here, right? We all agree that it's immoral to be unkind, mean, threatening, right? That's not your, what really is the substance of your question? Yeah.
Matt (01:01:43.158)
Wrong. Yeah.
Matt (01:01:53.642)
Yeah, I agree with that. That's wrong. Well, so I think, I think my take on this is that, um, I feel like there is a lot of pent up frustration that people feel like they can't say some things that they want to say. And it leads to other sorts of things, right? Like, like I do think like a lot of what happens at schools and what happens at maybe sporting it, like a lot of that really could be that people have
They feel like their thoughts and ideas and opinions are not allowed to be expressed in society. And so they're finding other avenues for that expression. And I think that the whole idea of freedom of speech is we allow people to say what they're gonna say. That means that my grandma's gonna say some like offensive things. And we can laugh at that. And we can maybe suggest to her, hey grandma, maybe you don't wanna ever say that again. But then she can say to us,
shawn (01:02:35.956)
Yeah.
shawn (01:02:39.902)
Yeah.
Matt (01:02:48.566)
I'm gonna say whatever I wanna say, and we just end it by saying, well, we love you, like, who cares, whatever, she's gonna say what she's gonna say. And I think that, like, it might be better as a society if we had that attitude. Rather than saying, I need to police you and tell you what to think and how to say, just to sort of say, let people be people, and if they're not hurting anybody, who cares what they're saying?
shawn (01:03:09.259)
Do you think that's a controversial stance to take in modern society? Because I feel like we all definitely agree with that.
Matt (01:03:13.334)
Yeah. I think that there are a lot of people in society that, like, there's just things in society you shouldn't say, right? And I have, I don't know if I've mentioned it before, but I know friends, at least in the world of science, that if they publish some things that are controversial, then it kind of ruins their careers. There's like a numb, there's just like, there's a lot of stuff.
And it's on the left and on the right, right? I don't know what in the world like Target did to like make everybody hate Target, but a whole lot of people started hating Target. And then people like hate on Taylor Swift or they'll hate on the right. There's people that they hate. I don't know, like they just start hating on people because of something they said or did or put in an ad and I just say our moral guide maybe should be if it harms somebody physically.
shawn (01:03:42.567)
It is, yeah.
shawn (01:03:53.544)
Amen.
Matt (01:04:08.854)
let's worry about that. But if it doesn't, let's don't worry about it so much.
shawn (01:04:12.54)
Which is reflected in current law. So you're just saying current law is correct, right?
Sam (01:04:18.318)
Well, it's not, it's not really reflected in law because it's not illegal to, it's not illegal to cancel someone. It's not illegal to have a strong reaction. I think it's a tough bet. I think it's a tough balance because cancel culture is a challenge, but, but cancel culture is where it is in as a reaction to people saying terrible things. Like you go back a generation and their attitudes on race and, you know, uh,
Matt (01:04:18.777)
Um... No.
shawn (01:04:26.303)
That's what I mean. So current law protects that.
Sam (01:04:46.422)
men marrying men, women marrying women. Like it was very different than what is considered acceptable today. And so you hear the comments of your grandmother saying what she says, and it's shocking to the sensibilities of kids today. And, and, and naturally, you know, I don't know how you outlaw that. Like I, I almost feel like over time, and you've said this in the past, it will, it will,
Matt (01:04:55.828)
Mm-hmm.
Matt (01:04:59.935)
Right. Yeah.
Sam (01:05:14.122)
kind of self-correct back to the middle. Cause we can't be as extreme forever as we're being today. Like we can't, can't cancel someone. I'm trying to think of the last person that's kind of been canceled as a result.
Matt (01:05:24.818)
So I've got a couple of ideas, a couple of examples sort of floating in my head and I didn't like think about them too much in advance of this but I recall that there was somebody who worked at Chick-fil-A or went through a Chick-fil-A during this whole like LGBT marriage stuff and they like went off in the drive-through at a Chick-fil-A employee and it went viral and then the person ended up losing their job and then this person like every time they apply for a job
Sam (01:05:49.25)
Mmm.
Matt (01:05:52.65)
somebody will find out and send that little Instagram video of that person going off on a Chick-fil-A employee and this person like cannot find a job. Or there was a, he's a professor at University of Toronto. He was offered a position at UCLA in psychology in the state of California. In order to get a job as a professor, you have to write a diversity statement, an inclusion and diversity statement. And he wrote one and they were gonna hire him. But then the students found like,
Sam (01:06:00.972)
Yeah.
Matt (01:06:21.174)
on a podcast years ago, he said something like, oh, I think these diversity and inclusion statements are silly. And so they like lodged a protest and said, you can't hire this guy because whatever he wrote isn't what he really thinks. And then they rescinded the offer to him. And they're like, sorry, we can't hire you because of this thing you said on a podcast. And I think things like this happen regularly where, you know, if you're just on the wrong side of some kind of viral video, like your life is ruined. And
Sam (01:06:51.006)
And truly you should not be judged by your worst moment. Like your worst moment just because it was captured on video. But how do you legislate that or how do you?
Matt (01:06:55.44)
Yeah.
Matt (01:07:02.126)
Well yeah, so I'm not talking legislation, I'm just saying can't we as a society just agree? Like, some people are gonna say bad things. In Idaho, there's some neo-Nazis up there saying some crazy racist things in private.
Sam (01:07:13.898)
Hey, but are you going to accept the neo-Nazis?
Matt (01:07:16.554)
No. So what you have is a normal reaction to them, right? Like, so if a neo-Nazi comes and says horrible neo-Nazi things, you hear them out and then you say, I respectfully disagree with you. I don't think you're informed about that. Like, that's what we do as a society. Right, right. Yeah, you just have a normal conversation and say, that's a very interesting perspective. Do you realize nobody really thinks that way anymore?
shawn (01:07:17.419)
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Sam (01:07:20.161)
Yeah.
Sam (01:07:31.063)
You're not going to try to get them fired is what you're trying to say. Yeah.
I don't know.
shawn (01:07:38.911)
What do you?
Sam (01:07:40.99)
I need to think about that a little bit because I don't necessarily want that neo-Nazi to get a bigger platform because they have a successful podcast somewhere. They make a lot of money and therefore they go buy themselves more TV time. Like the cancel element to that sort of makes sense. That's not their worst moment. That's the theme of their life, right? It is to hate a religious group.
shawn (01:07:52.173)
But Sam, you've...
shawn (01:07:57.803)
Because Sam, you've said it before, you're a capitalist, the market will work that out, right? If it becomes public that my local grocer is a neo-Nazi and is doing terrible or preaching terrible things, eventually we as a market are going to say, you're going out of business. But that's not cancel culture, is it? That's just accountability. That's accountability.
Sam (01:08:10.838)
That's what we're talking about.
Matt (01:08:17.338)
That's cancel culture.
Sam (01:08:17.951)
I think Matt's example was a bad one. Don't bring neo-Nazis into it. Let's pick one that I could have a challenge with.
Matt (01:08:24.446)
Sam, John Stuart Mill says everything ought to be allowed. Everything. Unless it's causing physical harm. And my fear is, you said this before, Sam, when we were talking about mental illness stuff is that if you force people to keep silent, it festers inside and becomes worse and metastasizes into something else. Speech is the same thing. Go ahead, John.
Sam (01:08:32.076)
Yeah.
shawn (01:08:42.505)
Hang on.
Sam (01:08:46.806)
So speech is the same thing, but there's a, there's by your fruits, you shall know them. And we have to judge by the fruits. Right? So if they're neo-Nazi and they're constantly preaching hate against Jewish people, how would you not make a judgment call about that person based on their behavior and their continued statements?
shawn (01:08:46.869)
Hang on, but if
shawn (01:08:53.427)
But it-
shawn (01:09:02.731)
But it's not but we're getting caught up. I think on the word cancel culture. If if a neo-Nazi grocer lives in a neighborhood with Jews and mostly Jews and all the Jews find out that he's a neo-Nazi. It's not cancel culture for them to not be a patron of his store. It's just common sense. And it's just accountability. That's not cancel culture. They're not canceling someone because of their speech. They're saying we don't align with this person's values. And so I'm not going to simply pay him money. That's all I'm going to go to the neighbor and pay him.
Matt (01:09:33.266)
Yeah, well so all I'm saying about neo-nazis is this. If you marginalize them as a society and you say you can't get a job, you can't be a part of society, your views are too radical, you're too crazy, you force them into... you force them into secret militant groups.
shawn (01:09:43.995)
let them know I'm saying no don't know and saying don't let them work just don't patronize there don't go to their grocery store. They'll feed each other they're gonna feed each other the neo Nazi store will feed each other. Yeah and they won't thrive and they won't thrive and the society response to them being dummies is gonna be all I don't I guess I got to question my morals.
Sam (01:09:44.255)
make them extreme. Yeah.
Sam (01:09:52.974)
Well, wait, how do they work if nobody will patronize? Well, that's Matt's point. That's Matt's point. They get pushed into the margins. Yeah.
Matt (01:09:55.593)
Hahahaha
Matt (01:09:59.75)
Heh.
Sam (01:10:09.718)
It's an, it's a, it's an interesting point. I actually give Matt all the points because I never thought we would. To my kids, I apologize. This is the point in the podcast. I apologize to my kids. We're talking about neo-Nazis and them being marginalized. And this is where I issue my deal. I apologize to them and I want them to know that that's not okay, but it is an interesting point in order to avoid the mental illness, the paranoia and the marginalization.
Matt (01:10:11.972)
Listen.
Matt (01:10:18.127)
Ha ha ha!
Matt (01:10:27.601)
Hahaha
shawn (01:10:29.343)
Hahaha
Sam (01:10:36.854)
Like some people truly, if they had a good job and they had something to look forward to, they would probably discard the crazy ideas that they have. If they're marginalized and they're forced into a closet, those paranoia, and COVID's a great example, people were forced into their house and paranoia and these crazy lunatic ideas just grew because they had no opposition to those ideas and they were constantly force-fed things.
Matt (01:10:44.442)
Yes.
Sam (01:11:05.23)
That's a fascinating point. I can't believe that we're talking about this in Neo-Nazis. I still give map points, especially John Stewart of all people. Yeah. Oh, I do Mormon stories. I actually listened to that. That's a good podcast. He does know him.
Matt (01:11:07.361)
So I'm the guy that... yeah.
shawn (01:11:07.385)
So Sam, use it. Okay, here's another example. You guys can run with this example, John Dillon.
Matt (01:11:13.738)
Hahaha
shawn (01:11:14.971)
Matt, go with the example of John DeLane.
Matt (01:11:18.263)
I don't know John DeLinn. Who's John DeLinn?
shawn (01:11:21.107)
Mormon Stories podcast. You know John DeLann, he was excommunicated five years ago together with.
Matt (01:11:25.678)
Wait, but, oh, is he expressing bad thoughts?
shawn (01:11:30.784)
He is the most anti Mormon person out there. He publishes it every couple of weeks. You're playing dumb, that's ridiculous.
Sam (01:11:32.878)
Why is Matt responding that he doesn't know this? That's interesting.
Matt (01:11:33.493)
Oh.
No, I know who he is, I don't know what he says. I only pick Neo-Nazi because I know what they do. I don't know what John Delin does that might be bad.
shawn (01:11:40.543)
Fine. Okay, fine. Every so every week he puts out a video and a podcast solely focused on tearing down the church anti LDS and his promotion of people to leave the church. Yeah.
Sam (01:11:44.974)
interesting.
Uh-huh.
Matt (01:11:54.75)
Oh, I didn't know that. The last thing I saw from him was all the Tim Ballard stuff. So like, whenever there's this like LDS thing...
shawn (01:11:59.547)
Yeah, he loves it. He loves it. Cause if someone potentially is getting ex-communicated or someone who's LDS who was once revered, he loves it. He just wants to.
Sam (01:12:05.376)
All right, Shawn, bring it home. What's your point?
shawn (01:12:08.391)
I'm asking Matt to use that as an example. What are you supposed to do in that situation?
Matt (01:12:10.418)
No, well, so all I want to say is my thought is that as a society, again, I'm the guy that watches the Cosby show, even though Bill Cosby did horrible things. As a society, I can say to somebody, I love you, you're a child of God, you're a person of worth, you happen to have some ideas that I think are terrible, but you're not doing any harm to anybody when you express those ideas. You're not doing any harm to anybody by thinking that.
shawn (01:12:37.643)
And there you go.
Matt (01:12:38.198)
So think that, express that, be you, and I'm still gonna include you in my community, and I'm still gonna include you in society, and hopefully over time, as you get to know more people, you'll say, maybe I was raised in a closet and didn't understand me.
Sam (01:12:53.698)
So, so, and I love Shawn that you brought up John Delin, cause he's someone that is in the margins of Mormonism, but he certainly has a huge voice. I have no problem listening to that, right. And not being offended by it, not being challenged by it, not feeling like it's doing worse. So Matt, if you'll, if you'll switch neo-Nazis for, for someone else, like, like the person that Shawn, I give you all the points in the world. And I think you made a great point today. So, uh, Matt wins.
Matt (01:13:15.494)
John Dillon? Yeah.
Matt (01:13:21.49)
Okay, awesome. And they don't even, we don't even do points on the big question. This is awesome. Okay, I love it. Hey, nice job you guys. Listen listener, I guarantee there's something we said that got you fired up. Let us know, we'd love to hear from you. Talk to you again next week.
Sam (01:13:22.87)
That wins. Don, what do you say? But we should. That was awesome. Great. Good job.
shawn (01:13:23.655)
Nice. Well done.
shawn (01:13:30.611)
It was a good one, yeah.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories