The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
October 4 2023: Hollywood morality, 2nd Amendment, Who sings hymns?, Government Shutdowns, Liquor sales in Utah cities, President Oaks
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Mailbag:
One listener wrote: I come from Seattle but I finally moved out of the state after the crime became too much to ignore. Property crime ranks amongst the highest in the city and its suburbs in the US https://www.safehome.org/resources/crime-statistics-by-state/ If you live there you can almost expect your car to be at risk of burglary and/or theft. My car got broken into a three times a year. My house has been burglarized twice. I had homeless people living in the woods in my backyard.
Another listener asks, “Sam, you definitely listen to music, watch films and tv that is produced by and performed by all manner of sinful, degenerate people The music and Hollywood industries are ripe with sin and law breaking. Is it not hypocritical to judge Matt for watching the Cosby show? Do you abstain from all media unless it is produced by motab or the Deseret Management Corporation?
One last listener question is about the 2nd amendment. They ask, “Don’t we want the world’s largest armed militia in order to check the powers that government and politicians have? Someone mentioned that guns are irrelevant to a government who has tanks and fighter jets…sure, a gun loses to a tank one-on-one but 300 million guns wouldn’t! Our government and perhaps other countries are deterred by the fact that this country has a strong citizen militia of over 300 million guns. Don’t we want that?”
- Armed citizens aren’t very good at stopping active shooters. In the last decade armed citizens only helped out in 4-14% of active shooter scenarios.
- Infantry are notoriously inaccurate marksmen, so the military is developing rifles with computerized fire control for improved accuracy. The US military does not fear an armed citizenry and they haven’t since the Civil War.
The Thought Provoker:
Shawn is first. “The new Church Hymn book will be released between 2024 and 2030. The project started in 2018. Music participation in the church has been in decline for a long time! It has gotten quite bad. Is this a reflection of our general enthusiasm for public church worship or could it be a result of an outdated hymnal that no longer inspires in modern society?
Next up, Matt: Once again the Republicans in the House are going to shut down the federal government. Just after the last federal government shutdown ended in 2019, I did a little survey to see how people who work for the federal government were affected. 25% of federal employees were forced to work without pay. 56% of employees reported increased stress from the shutdown, and 26% said that they did not have enough money in savings to pay their bills during the shutdown. Although most of them get reimbursed after the shutdown ends, it seems immoral to me for our government to force people to work and to not give them the money to pay their bills right away. Is it morally wrong for the Republicans to keep shutting down the government?
Finally, Sam: “Do members of the Church of Jesus Chris of Latter-day Saints have a moral obligation to support or challenge laws that uphold the Word of Widsom and LDS Church standards? (Prohibition on Alcohol and Force Closure of Retail Businesses on Sunday) https://www.abc4.com/news/wasatch-front/highland-one-of-utahs-last-dry-cities-to-send-survey-to-residents-over-alcohol-sales/
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:02.666)
Thanks, Sean. Hey, listener, welcome to another exciting episode of The Latter-day Lens with Sean, Sam, and Matt. We are recording this just after the Saturday morning session of General Conference. So we're gonna have reactions to that at the end of our episode. In case you're wondering, Sean just barely woke up and he mostly slept through the... But...
shawn (00:22.871)
Hehehehe
Sam (00:25.262)
I missed that session.
shawn (00:27.378)
Hehehehehehe
Matt (00:28.01)
Don't worry, that won't stop him from interjecting thoughts and opinions about what happened in that session, because like Sean, we all do our homework on this episode, and even if we, on this podcast, even if we don't actually watch the session, we will educate ourselves, because we're that good. Hey, so listen, we have a lot of stuff in the mailbag this week to get to. We're going to start with...
shawn (00:33.527)
Ha ha ha.
Matt (00:54.074)
I don't know. I hate, I'm so tired of you people telling me about the crime in major cities in America. But that's okay. That's on people's minds. So we're going to talk about it. Um, this person has experience in Seattle and they did not like that I was using a survey of public opinion to talk about safety in American cities. They said that there's people that actually like look at crime rates and look at statistics in the cities to decide whether or not there's crime in major cities.
And so we put a link to this place. You can look at other data to see who's the safe cities in the United States. But anecdotally, this person says that if you live in Seattle, you can almost expect your car to be at risk of burglary and or theft. Their car got broken into three times a year. Their house had been burglarized twice. And they had homeless people living in the woods in their backyard. There's hyperdermic needles all over the streets and in children's parks.
when they still lived there, there were about 30,000 needles collected in a single year. So he says, is it safe to be a tourist? Yes, mostly, but it's not going to be in the next 10 years if something doesn't change with the city's leadership. So this person is suggesting that at least in Seattle, and then Sam has told us in Chicago, and then
Sam (02:13.734)
And I could actually add Sacramento to that. I have some very good friends that live in Sacramento and the whole, uh, unhoused encampment with needles and whatnot. Can you imagine having your house, your back fence, they're being unhoused folks doing drugs outside your back fence where your kids play. I mean, that is a challenge and that goes on in Sacramento as well.
shawn (02:16.599)
Mm.
shawn (02:30.347)
Don't, don't you, it's, it's not just Sacramento. It's every city in California. Oh yeah, it's in San Diego. It's in, especially in LA. Right, right.
Matt (02:35.314)
in California. When I drive down the hot.
Sam (02:36.787)
Guess what? It's not in Highland, Utah. We're going to talk about that later on today. But yeah.
Matt (02:41.194)
When I drive down the freeways in Southern California, there's tents like all over the freeways. And this would be about three years ago, we were gonna go on a cruise and I was like, and the cruise left early in the morning and I'm like, okay, we're gonna drive through the night and we're gonna stop at one of the beaches in California and we'll just spend the night at the beach and then we'll go get on the cruise the next day. And what I discovered is the beaches are owned by homeless people at nighttime.
I did not dare sleep anywhere in any of the parks or any of the beaches because
shawn (03:12.045)
Yeah, I think cities have a lot to say about that, so some of them don't allow that, but wherever you were, were you?
Matt (03:18.618)
Let's say I think I started in Long Beach area and then I didn't dare go to Santa Monica They all seemed too rich like they would have rules that they wouldn't let me sleep on the beach We actually had an exchange student with us at the time and she was like, what are we doing? I'm like, don't worry This is a very American thing to do You're gonna see the way
shawn (03:27.159)
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
shawn (03:37.31)
But Matt, so Matt is this topic, is this comment about polls or is it about crime? Is it about surveys or about crime?
Matt (03:45.159)
I think what they were saying is crime is a big problem in all the major cities. Seattle was on the list as one of the safest cities and this person was like, no way is Seattle a safe city.
shawn (03:54.603)
But you and Sam have debated for a long time whether that has, is that because these are Democrat cities or is that for other reasons? But I do like that this listener is calling you out on your love of polls and surveys. I love it, because I agree, I agree. Rarely have I seen a survey, like for example, the past five or six presidential elections, where it was even close to being correct.
Matt (04:07.49)
Hahahaha
Matt (04:18.982)
No, they're right. They're right, Sean. I am not going to let you take this topic and make it about surveys are no good. We'll have to have a whole episode just about surveys. You can talk about that next week. Um... Surveys are amazing. Um... I don't know. I still don't think that... I'm not persuaded that if Republicans were running these cities, they would be more safe. That's all I want to say about that. I don't...
shawn (04:20.36)
No they're not either.
shawn (04:26.647)
Hehehehe
Good, I'll make that note.
Sam (04:42.85)
I would disagree wholeheartedly. And I think there's, there's anecdotal evidence, maybe near silly surveys, don't back it up, but there's anecdotal evidence that Republicans would not allow unhoused to sit with hypodermic needles in somebody's backyard. 30,000, no less. It just wouldn't be tolerated. Right. There's a stronger sense of law and order and how law and order can rehabilitate as much as empathy and understanding and trying to, trying to better understand them.
shawn (04:44.983)
Hehehehe
Matt (04:50.33)
Hahaha
shawn (05:09.491)
Yeah, man, wasn't that your whole point last week in your thought provoker and bringing up the fact that Democrat governor has now become Republican because he wants to change his territory to be law and order.
Matt (05:13.058)
Um, um.
Matt (05:17.555)
Yeah.
Matt (05:23.39)
Yes, that's what I brought up last week, but I'm just going to say this. When I look at the Republicans in law and order, I think of January 6th and the law and order at the Capitol building, and I think about the—there was—this week there was a Democrat indicted for corruption, and you heard all of the calls of the Democrats to say to that person, resign, resign from office.
shawn (05:25.163)
Mm-hmm.
shawn (05:32.512)
Yeah?
Sam (05:42.546)
Wait, wait, you did not this guy. It's his second time for being indicted. The first time he would know the first time he was indicted, he was acquitted on bad evidence. They put him back in a senior leadership position. The Democrats did. The only reason they're up in arms this go around is because they know it takes away their leverage to be able to take pot shots at Trump during the presidential election. If he remains.
Matt (05:48.17)
But every Democrat... every Democrat... Yes? Right.
shawn (06:09.591)
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Sam (06:10.718)
If it weren't for Trump, they'd leave him alone. You're that is the most critical thing I've ever heard. And you say, I love you, ma'am. But that's the blue. That's. He was he was like, have you? Have you read the have you read what caused him to be acquitted? It wasn't due to it wasn't due to him not being guilty. It was it was a weird it was a weird. You know what? I need to go back and get the evidence because I'm going to be
Matt (06:14.11)
He was... Sam... He wa... He was acquitted last time. If you're found not guilty, you don't get to be punished forevermore for being found...
shawn (06:16.274)
I love it!
Matt (06:30.206)
No, no.
Matt (06:39.621)
Yeah, yeah
Sam (06:40.662)
I'll be judged in the next show as not having cited actual surveys. I'm going to get the background on that. I am astounded that Democrats are going after this guy this time around only because of Trump when they had a chance to get rid of him from the senior leadership position last time on very similar charges and they didn't do it. Same.
Matt (06:45.256)
Hahahaha
shawn (06:46.199)
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
Matt (06:58.984)
I'm just saying Sam, one party attacked the Capitol, one party supports crime in high places, and another party opposes that.
Sam (07:03.65)
Listen, listen, no, the Republican party did not attack the Capitol. It was a, it was a wacko extremist group. You know what? You never really know the conspiracy theorists would tell you that they were all Democrats. All right. Next topic. Yeah.
Matt (07:11.234)
Really? How many Democrats were there holding MAGA flags outside the Capitol? Storming... going... .. They were all Democrats defecating on Nancy Pelosi's desk. Alright, well the next one goes after Sam, so I love it even more. Another listener asks, Sam, you definitely listen to music, watch films and TV that is produced by and performed by all manner of sinful, degenerate people from abusers and rapists.
shawn (07:22.735)
Yeah.
shawn (07:30.079)
Hehehe
Sam (07:30.294)
Do it.
Matt (07:41.086)
rapists to pornographers and philanderers. What's a pornographer? The music and Hollywood industries are ripe with sin and law breaking. Secret combinations comes to mind. Is it not hypocritical for you to judge me for watching the Cosby show when you listen to all this other stuff? Do you really just only listen to things produced by the Deseret management group or the corporation of the president?
Sam (07:45.198)
My goodness, interesting.
Matt (08:10.526)
If you're gonna come after me for Cosby, why don't you boycott all the stuff that the people producing out...
Sam (08:16.934)
if the listener knew this the sorts of things that I watch in movies and read and whatnot like it's exactly it's a wide it's a wide range of stuff to see different people's viewpoints and experiences and take on the world here's the problem I have with the Cosby showing you all right so this is the deal Bill Cosby for years portrayed himself as America's dad
Matt (08:20.954)
Oh my goodness. I can't believe Sam's still in the church. Hahahaha
Matt (08:38.134)
Hahaha
shawn (08:39.193)
Oh, whoa.
Sam (08:45.866)
He portrayed himself better than 99% of African-American people. He told them, hey, the problems that go on in Black America are your fault, right? And he would list the things that contributed to what he saw as the deterioration in that culture. And he stood up strong, loud, and consistent over decades doing that. My issue with Bill Cosby in particular is he's an absolute hypocrite. So.
shawn (09:13.066)
Hehehehehehe
Sam (09:13.65)
If someone is going to stand up and make statements like he made, he's got to back it up with the way he personally lived. That's my problem with him. So I don't have a problem blocking. Like, um, people would just be actually, I won't even name it. Yeah. But, right. We, we talked about breaking bad, right? So breaking bad, there, there's, you don't know what that is. Like that's a great,
Matt (09:28.098)
Yeah, don't say it, Sam. You might have to give us your temple recommend at the end. Don't... Yeah. I don't... But for the listener, I don't know what that is. I've never heard of it. Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
shawn (09:38.059)
Hehehehehehe
Sam (09:41.618)
you into the descent in the madness of a person. But there's nobody that's making moral claims about we're great and we're showing you this. I do think there's a problem when someone in the public sphere presents themselves as one way and goes after an entire cross-section of society, telling them you need to be better, preaching to them, and then it turns out they're just as bad. And that makes it worse to quote a Simpsons line from a great episode.
Matt (10:07.538)
So, so it's the hypocrisy that bothers you. It's not the sin, it's the... And if, wait, so if Bill Cosby had, if Bill Cosby had been living an upstanding life the whole time he's saying these things, and then later on it comes out that he did something after he made the Cosby show, then that wouldn't bother you as much, right? Because you're like, during the period of the Cosby show, he was being consistent with the message he was preaching, and maybe he did something later on.
Sam (10:10.89)
Yeah, well, yeah, it's- yeah.
shawn (10:11.891)
No, hang on Sam. Sam, this is gonna...
Matt (10:34.246)
is that while he's creating this content that says one thing, he is behind the scenes doing something totally different.
Sam (10:40.566)
So the Cosby show aside just his own political take and how he preached to people and told them how they should live now Look people change their case of all of their take their own sense of more morality may evolve over time I'm a hundred percent okay with that But don't preach to somebody and tell them how they should be when you yourself are not doing that In any way shape or form the things that he was alleged to have done and was found guilty of having done, you know
Matt (10:44.781)
Yeah.
Matt (11:04.299)
Yeah.
Sam (11:10.474)
We're horrible and I think that yeah, that's what makes it well and in a terrible way Taking advantage of people from a power an unequal power standpoint and then trying to gaslight them to make them Feel like they were the crazy ones. I can't walk him for that reason John go ahead
Matt (11:10.558)
You're... raping women.
shawn (11:14.283)
Sam.
Matt (11:17.768)
Yeah.
Matt (11:23.988)
Yeah.
shawn (11:25.099)
Sam, you're gonna go viral with this one, Sam, because there's a famous meme out there by comedian Norm MacDonald, where he was talking to a guy and he says, you know, a lot of people are saying that the worst thing about what Bill Cosby done was the hypocrisy. And he says, you know, I disagree. I think it was the raping that was done, not the hypocrisy. So you're gonna go viral for that one, Sam. But I think the listener's reaction was how
Matt (11:29.642)
Hahahaha
Sam (11:29.811)
Oh, yeah.
Sam (11:33.762)
So.
Sam (11:44.556)
No?
Matt (11:46.495)
Hahaha
Sam (11:51.766)
No, I, but, but by the way, I don't agree with Norm MacDonald in that. I think what he did was horrible, but I think the hypocrisy is what disqualifies him from being watched and consumed in the public. I don't want a single dollar of my money to go to the, go to the guy.
shawn (11:56.867)
Oh!
shawn (12:04.446)
I see.
But I think the visceral reaction was how angry you got at Matt for watching Bill Cosby. So what did you have?
Matt (12:15.35)
But he still is. He still is mad at me. Sam's not gonna let me get away with that ever. And Michael Jackson, who molested kids, Sam doesn't want me listening to Michael Jackson music.
Sam (12:17.042)
I still am. Yeah. I don't like Bill Cosby.
shawn (12:22.017)
But, uh...
shawn (12:25.207)
Same thing, Matt.
Sam (12:26.37)
hit candidly. I will listen to Michael Jackson more. I'm more likely to listen to Michael Jackson than watch Bill Cosby. So, yeah. Yeah.
Matt (12:35.046)
Yeah, because of the hypocrisy. Michael Jackson never pretended that he didn't love little boys. He was open about that. Well, Sean, you're the one that's so, you're so into the media world, Sean. You're telling me it's okay to, you're telling me that we should just accept the horrible things that people are doing in their private lives and just listen to their art because we love their art.
shawn (12:35.551)
There's no hypocrisy.
Sam (12:41.282)
Oh no, that's terrible. Oh, my kids watch this show.
shawn (12:50.539)
What?
shawn (13:00.94)
That's your message Matt. Don't don't put me there. I'm just well
Matt (13:03.794)
Well, I want to know your message. Tell us, Sean. Sean, we're going to poke at you. You always want to like stand back and say, this is what Sam's doing. This is what do you say, Sean?
shawn (13:10.272)
Yeah.
Sam (13:13.546)
Hey, let, let me add one thought to it though. Most people in entertainment should be smart enough to just take their money and stay out of the public political sphere, right? Don't preach, don't preach to people politically. Yes.
shawn (13:13.647)
Hahaha
Matt (13:25.446)
No! I love that Taylor Swift is so involved in politics. She has 900 million followers and she's got a movement and she should use that power however, she wants to use it. I shouldn't say to her stay out of politics. If she wants to get involved she should. Sure, whatever. I don't care. Uh, is that the
Sam (13:34.911)
Yeah.
Sam (13:43.198)
Nicholas Cage. Sean Penn.
Sam (13:49.954)
Yeah, Sean Penn's the guy that went down and tried to put a deal together with the Mexican drug lord and felt like the US was, uh, yeah. Jane Fonda, Jane Fonda.
Matt (13:56.306)
Oh, oh yeah, yeah sure. Yeah, and the basketball player who went to North Korea sure whatever like yeah, I don't I think that so this to me is actually the real problem I have when with the hypocrisy argument is I feel like if An entertainer has to worry that they might be a hypocrite then it makes them less. It makes them more hesitant about
shawn (14:04.503)
Hehehehe
Sam (14:04.731)
Rodman? Dennis Rodman? Really?
Matt (14:22.906)
expressing their opinions on issues. Because in some ways we're all hypocrites, and so everyone should be able to express what they think.
Sam (14:27.794)
Okay. If I, if I don't need to worry about being a hypocrite, I'm going to be a lot more opinionated go forward. Just so y'all know. So.
shawn (14:35.639)
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
Matt (14:35.686)
Okay? You don't need to worry about being a- listen, every time I tell my kids to clean their bathroom, they tell me what a hypocrite I am because my bathroom's not as clean as I make them keep their bathroom. Like, everyone's a hypocrite in some way. It's okay to-
Sam (14:44.661)
Ah.
Yeah. Do you not think there's a problem with Bill Cosby telling people, uh, minorities that they need to live a different life when he himself personally was so far off that same track? You don't see a problem with that.
Matt (15:01.015)
I think what he did was absolutely wrong. I just happen to love the Cosby show. It's really, really good. And by the way, it's super, super cheap right now on Amazon.
Sam (15:04.159)
Yeah.
Sam (15:09.467)
Oh, okay. So, so, so back to the mail bag, I would love to hear our listeners just give Matt some feedback on that point. What do you all think? What's the vote, right? If this was a democracy and our listeners wrote in, what's our email address, Matt? Because I couldn't be hotter about this. Write in, give us your take on it. And then Matt, for the next episode, let's, let's count up the tally and see what people's take are.
shawn (15:09.472)
I mean, Sam.
shawn (15:19.211)
What you got?
shawn (15:23.749)
They did write in.
Matt (15:24.186)
It is TheLatterDayLens at gmail.com
shawn (15:33.663)
Matt, Sam, they did write in. They wrote in against you.
Matt (15:34.491)
Yeah, we'll take, we'll...
Sam (15:37.474)
No, one person wrote in this comment.
Matt (15:38.97)
What we should do is we should do a survey. We should do a public opinion survey and find out what people think. Okay, let's go to the next topic. Now the next topic, we didn't even bring that, well maybe we brought this up. Okay. Okay, so this person says, do we not want the world's largest armed militia? And in that I think they're talking about citizens, right?
Sam (15:45.46)
Oh gosh.
shawn (15:50.699)
We've talked about it a number of times in the past. Yes, we have.
Matt (16:01.802)
Do we not want the world's largest armed militia in order to check the powers that government and politicians have? For example, is it far-fetched to imagine that someone like Trump could abuse power in terrible ways against an unarmed America? Also, someone mentioned that guns are irrelevant to a government who has tanks and fighter jets. Sure, a gun loses to a tank one-on-one, but 300 million guns wouldn't. Our government and perhaps other countries are deterred by the fact that this country
has a strong citizen militia of over 300 million guns. Don't we want that? Sam wants that. He tells me that he feels safe that his neighbors all have guns.
shawn (16:38.775)
You've both said that if someone invades, please come to Utah because the citizens will take them down.
Sam (16:39.851)
I can't.
Sam (16:44.298)
I think it's hilarious that Matt keeps picking the questions that bring us back to Trump and January 6th. Come on, I get the point. I got it. Let's move on.
Matt (16:49.482)
I swear, I swear, these are listeners. This is not me. Actually, I want to say in response to this, like, there's a lot of misconceptions in this question. The first is that citizens as a militia would be at all effective against the US government. That is 100% just a fallacy. First of all, there's not 300 million guns out there. There's 320 million Americans, but only like...
30% of them even own a gun, so we're not a-
shawn (17:18.763)
Yeah, but Matt, but Matt, it's not a one to one. Many people own multiple guns. There's gotta be.
Matt (17:24.646)
Okay, you can only shoot one gun at a time, however, unless you're like Rambo out there. D-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-
shawn (17:32.445)
Bad point.
Sam (17:34.078)
Hey, Sean, you, you and I should exercise our veto, right? To say, this is a dumb point. Let's move on.
shawn (17:35.927)
Okay, there's 200 million.
shawn (17:41.875)
It's actually an interesting topic. It's an interesting topic, but that point is dumb.
Matt (17:42.118)
Okay, point number two. Point number two, people are not accurate when they shoot their guns. You can look at the studies of infantry, people that are trained military infantry, their accuracy rate is less than 30%. Most people, when you get in a high stress situation and you've got a gun out there, you're shooting bullets that miss people. You remember, is it, you remember that guy from the, from the Arizona Cardinals who like left the NFL to go join the military and then got killed?
shawn (17:48.843)
What?
shawn (18:01.815)
That's irrelevant, Matt. That's irrelevant. It is.
Matt (18:11.05)
You know how he got killed? Friendly fire. Yeah, on accident. Like the, like people, okay, so this, so this idea that you're gonna have a gun and the military is gonna show up at your door and you're gonna be like, you better stand back because I'm fully armed here. Did you have not, have you not seen the footage of Waco, Texas?
shawn (18:11.119)
Yeah. Friendly fire.
Yeah, but that's, but that's that.
Sam (18:28.202)
Wait, let's, let's back up. Let's back up. This is a ridiculous conversation, but I'll, I'll bite, right? Go, go, go to Waco, Texas, go to Ruby Ridge, go to any one of the crazy standoffs. It doesn't end well, but it is a terrible standoff that the guy in Oregon with a LDS, uh, with an LDS background, Ammon Bundy that took off, took over the John Day, whatever forest preserve or whatever.
Matt (18:34.555)
Okay good, bye Tim.
Matt (18:39.159)
Yeah.
Matt (18:48.314)
Amen Bundy.
Matt (18:53.973)
Yeah.
Sam (18:56.066)
Armed citizens are a veto against the military, whether it's because the military doesn't want to be seen as coming in and slaughtering its own citizens, which is truly not. I mean, why are we talking about this? Remind me what the point was again.
Matt (18:59.294)
No way.
Matt (19:07.43)
Well, somebody asked that question.
shawn (19:08.151)
The point was, the point, hang on, the point was, someone asked the question because in multiple times in our podcast we've talked about guns and should they be limited, should they be restricted? Right, one of the points, one of the points they made was, if you take, here's a list of countries who heavily, heavily restricts guns. North Korea, China, Saudi Arabia, Cuba, Belarus. Is that coincidental? No, I know, but is it coincidental that those countries don't do?
Sam (19:14.784)
Yeah.
No?
Sam (19:24.822)
Yeah.
Matt (19:28.45)
Great Britain, Great Britain, Germany, France.
Sam (19:28.738)
Yeah.
Sam (19:33.118)
In inner city Chicago, by the way, restricts guns by the Democrats, but there's still a lot of guns in Chicago. Go ahead.
Matt (19:37.246)
Australia.
Matt (19:41.758)
Sean, everybody restricts guns more than the United States. Canada? Of course they all restrict guns, because it's unsafe to have guns.
shawn (19:46.267)
Yeah, but... No, but... But are you to say, Matt, that there's no correlation between China and North Korea whose citizens don't have any guns and their authoritarian power? You don't think there's any relation? Oh... That's a...
Sam (19:48.462)
Brutal. Canadians aren't dangerous, though.
Sam (19:56.203)
in Canada.
Matt (19:58.194)
There's no relationship at all. No, there's no relationship at all. And then if you just think of it as a practical matter, pick any situation you want where it was our government versus somebody with guns, and the person with guns lost every single time.
And even if you want to go Ammon Bundy where it's like, oh, it looks like he won. Guess what? Ammon Bundy was sued by a hospital in Boise for like 50 million dollars and the dude's gonna end up in poverty the rest of his life because he felt so empowered by his militia, anti-government, you're not gonna take me down. Eventually you'll always lose.
shawn (20:13.879)
That's not.
shawn (20:30.783)
Yeah, but Matt, he was on the wrong side, right? But not only, yeah, but Matt, he was on the wrong side of law, he was on the wrong side of morals, right? Now take a citizenry who is on the right side of law and morals, and we all gather, this is the point I think the listener's trying to make. In a situation where you've got an authoritarian government, it could happen, why not? Look at Donald Trump.
Sam (20:34.262)
held off the military for a long time.
Matt (20:36.95)
But in the end, he loses.
Matt (20:51.465)
Oh.
shawn (20:58.667)
Why couldn't, is it really that crazy to think that something like that could happen under his regime? Huh, huh, Sam? Ha ha ha.
Matt (21:04.094)
Well, so I talked about accuracy of bullets, right? And I talked about how hard it is for people to shoot. The military is now developing computerized rifles so that they have 90% accuracy. So now you're going to... What you're describing, Sean, is Les Mis when the students go out and create a barricade and what happens to the kids? They all die. Like that's what happens. Take your guns...
shawn (21:09.739)
dumb.
So what?
shawn (21:17.643)
How many minutes?
shawn (21:27.359)
Wait, isn't that a story about the French Revolution? Didn't the French Revolution, didn't the revolutionaries win? Oh. Well, but Matt, I think I see where the listener's coming from. If the people, how many military members are there? How big is our military?
Matt (21:31.026)
No, no, it wasn't the French Rev- no, it was a different revolution. Prior to the French Revolution. And the students all die!
Matt (21:47.582)
We are the largest military in the world by 10 times. Like the individuals in it, it doesn't matter, Sean, because they have bombs that they can sit in the desert in Nevada and figure out where your house is and then radio control a bomb and blow you and your whole neighborhood up. There's no way you're gonna beat them.
shawn (21:50.007)
Do you know how many? Do you know how many though? Yeah.
shawn (22:05.771)
The po- it's a battle though, like Sam says, it's a battle. If there's 300 million people with guns against how many people in the military and all their tech, that's the point is that it's a deterrent. It's a veto. It's a check on ba- it's a, it's a, it's a check on power. I think it's a decent point.
Matt (22:21.162)
So my problem with it is this. So I turned on the BBC yesterday because that's where I get my international news. And there was a stabbing at a school in London and it was all over the BBC because it was this huge tragedy. How could somebody stab this 15 year old girl? I think she was 15. And I compared that to the United States. The United States, we have mass shootings in schools where multiple people die. And in the UK, they have a stabbing.
where one person dies. And that's the difference. And so I say, what's the... So if I get rid of guns, then I'm more like the UK, where people die in a stabbing, which isn't as violent as a mass shooting. And so then I say...
shawn (22:53.386)
No one argues against that.
shawn (23:04.915)
No, that's no one argues that at that point. Everyone agrees with that. That's common sense. But that's not the topic that he brought up, this argument.
Matt (23:12.386)
No, no, I know. So the only reason I argue about it, cause Sam says this is a stupid topic, I'm just saying the reason I take it on is... ..
Sam (23:19.042)
I apologize to the listener that wrote this in by the way, but I just, everything comes back to Trump January 6th and problems with the president, you know, it's just, come on, let's move on.
shawn (23:26.719)
Fine, Sam erased that part and argued the point. The point is not Trump, the point is that... Yeah, yeah, but it was just an example. You distract the same, you get distracted by it.
Matt (23:29.267)
I didn't-
Matt (23:33.359)
I didn't use the word Trump, Sam. That was the listener.
Sam (23:35.858)
No, you so, so an R an, an armed citizenry is a veto against the government. It just is. You can't walk into Idaho or Utah or any part of the Alaskan bush. And it, it's going to create a standoff at best or a slaughter at worst. And either one of those would impact. Why are we even talking about this? This is not, I want to talk about something else. Listen, if we end up, if, if.
Matt (23:44.431)
Now.
Matt (24:00.049)
fine we'll move on
Sam (24:04.342)
Trump to your point, if Trump to your point turns into a civil war, we have a lot of problems. There will be a lot of problems. Um, but we, I, I respect, I respect the listener. I've heard the question and I've used the next question. Yeah, let's move on.
shawn (24:05.936)
Sam, you gotta respect our listeners.
shawn (24:11.543)
Sam, you gotta respect our listeners. This was an important topic.
Matt (24:18.826)
I respectfully want to move on because Sean wants to talk about the hymn book. So why can't we move on to that? Sean, tell us about the hymn book. You have a thought for a long time. Now you're earning points with the things you say. So maybe you guys will be a little more cautious in what you say.
Sam (24:25.156)
Oh no.
shawn (24:28.342)
We're starting the thought provoker, right? All right. A kid.
shawn (24:37.415)
Now you guys need to be less indifferent. Okay, okay, less lukewarm. You guys heard conference this morning, right? Don't be lukewarm about topics.
Matt (24:40.266)
Hahaha
Ha ha.
Hey, I did actually listen to conference and nobody said that. That was maybe that you probably read my summary online or something. I create fake news conference summaries just to fool people like you, Sean.
shawn (24:48.83)
They did too.
shawn (24:52.279)
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
shawn (24:57.816)
Hehehehe
Sam (24:59.754)
Hey, they just announced they're building a temple in Donetsk. That's wild. Donetsk.
Matt (25:02.914)
Kirtland, Kirtland. Ha ha ha. All right, go Sean.
shawn (25:03.627)
Ah, shut up. Alrighty. Okay. So, the new church hymn book will be released between 2044 and 2030. That's a long time. The project actually started in 2018, which is a very, very long time. So here's, I do think this is a super interesting topic and I don't think this is just relevant for people who love music. Which Matt listens to you too. Sam listens to...
Matt (25:33.386)
Hey, I listen to Taylor Swift. I'm a Swiftie. Taylor Swift and um... NBA...
shawn (25:33.851)
What's your band, Sam? Sam's Band. Oh, jeez. Sam's Band. So you may be disqualified. Yeah, I was going to say Coldplay. So you both may be disqualified for this. I was just kidding. So music...
Sam (25:40.099)
Coldplay coldplay bring it
Alright.
Matt (25:47.474)
If I'm being totally honest, Motab. I listen to Motab and Paul Cardall 90% of the time.
shawn (25:52.211)
No you don't. Okay, so here's the question. Here's the question. Music participation in the church has been in decline for a long time. It has gotten quite bad. Is this a reflection of our general enthusiasm for public church worship? You understand? Like, this is a good question. Or, or, or could it be that it's a result of an outdated hymnal that no longer inspires in modern society?
Sam (25:54.518)
Bill Cosby.
Matt (26:09.754)
Yeah, I understand. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Matt (26:19.166)
You are such an evangelical. You wanna get rid of the organ and bring in the drums and the electric guitar, and we're gonna like sound like Christian rock when we're preparing for the sacrament. And I'm gonna sit there and say, I can't feel the spirit anymore because people like Sean wanted to change what worshipful music sounds like. Boyd K. Packer and I are rolling over in our graves.
shawn (26:25.611)
No, I don't.
shawn (26:30.206)
I do not.
shawn (26:33.812)
Oh.
shawn (26:37.899)
Oh, dang. That's a church medal. Oh, that was mean. That was really mean, man.
Matt (26:45.81)
Wait, is that not what you're saying? You're not saying rock, music, and drums? Oh, okay.
shawn (26:49.392)
No, not at all. I'm saying that for almost a 20 year period, the church is focusing on changing the hymnal. Now Matt, there are three really important scriptural references to the role of music in our worship. Like for example, for example, Christ takes his disciples into the room, performs the sacrament for the first time, the sacred, sacred ordinance. Then they sing a hymn together.
Matt (27:04.319)
Yeah.
shawn (27:14.503)
and that's what triggers him to go into the garden. Singing hymns is a really important part of our worship, and in our church, at one point, it was a powerful and important thing. We would sing with fervor. Well, hang on, though. Because most sacrament meetings that I go into is not very inspired. There's not a lot of singing with the heart. No, there's not. Okay, so you're saying in your sacrament meetings there are? I'll say this. Yep.
Matt (27:14.753)
Yeah.
Matt (27:23.922)
It still is! Why is the- why are you saying it's different?
Matt (27:33.867)
What?
Matt (27:38.086)
In my... I'll say this, Sean. Anywhere I go, someone's singing with the heart, because I am. I'm singing them loud and proud, and making the deacons around me sing them loud and proud too. I say, sing! Open up your handbook and start singing. I... yes, I really do. Yeah, I really do. Yeah. Yeah, because...
shawn (27:48.919)
How do you do that?
shawn (27:53.515)
Do you really, Matt, be serious here. Do you really sing loud and proud? I mean, you did on our mission. You did on our mission, yeah. But do you think, but do most other people?
Matt (28:03.134)
Well, so this is, if I'm being honest, this is the reason why I sit in the front of the chapel, always, because when you're in the front of the chapel, it feels like there's really good worshipful music. But anytime I sit in the cultural hall or like further in the back, I feel like I'm the only one singing. So that's why I always try to sit up front because then I feel like the music is really inspiring.
shawn (28:24.183)
So that's the question. Do you feel like the reason that you have to sit in a certain spot so that you can really fill that spirit in singing hymns with power, is that because we as a church have become lax on our general worship, our public worship? Or is it because people aren't just that, just aren't that into the old organ and the old traditional music? It hasn't kept up with our times.
Matt (28:45.662)
You are such... I'm gonna let Sam say because I've hurt your feelings. I called you names and so Sam gets to say what he thinks.
shawn (28:51.123)
What?
Sam (28:57.474)
You know, it's interesting. So we were, uh, my family and I, we were part of the Navu pageant for many years. So you go back to Navu, Illinois, right? We're historic, uh, a historically very important, uh, point in church history. And, and you're actually part of this pageant on a stage. And to Sean's point, you actually learn the importance of singing in church history, right? It connects people. It, it, uh, it invites the spirit in. And, uh, you know, that is interesting music. I think does that generally.
not just inside the church, but, but everywhere. And I think maybe that's a reason why evangelicals make music such a principal part of their worship and other religious organizations do as well. I would agree with you. Like there were some great foresters as part of the pageant that kind of connected you with the meaning behind the individual song and really kind of brought that out in a way that connected those that were performing. But you know what? Isn't that up to the individual to do not.
the book that's sitting in the pews. Like to me, that seems Sean, no offense, like an excuse saying, Hey, the hymnal hasn't been updated yet, or it's not current yet. Right. Each one of those hymns that's in there, many of those hymns in there have an important, uh, you know, connection back to church history. Um, you know, I even remember like when we were in, in Ukraine, right? There were, there were special hymns in Ukraine that had, you remember sister rencher from the MTC?
shawn (30:26.783)
Heck yes, she was awesome.
Sam (30:26.926)
Uh, yeah, he did a great job of teaching us some of those hymns in Russian, which they've all changed the words. Even to this day, you hear those hymns and you think of those words and what it felt, what it meant serving on a mission. So, Sean, I agree that music is important. I think it's more up to the individual to embed it with meaning and worship that way. Maybe not so much the hymnal. So, I don't know.
Matt (30:27.051)
Yeah.
shawn (30:51.415)
Would you apply that to teenagers? Would you apply that to youth? I mean, there's gotta be, there's gotta be a reason, Sam, there's gotta be a reason that a 12-year project that the church is taking 12 years to update the hymns. There's a reason.
Matt (30:54.522)
Yeah.
Sam (31:04.023)
COVID.
Matt (31:05.686)
Well, so I'll tell you, so when it comes to hymns, my family and I, every morning at scripture study, we share our verses, we sing a hymn, one verse of a hymn, and then we have a prayer. And even when, like, I have to be in Rexburg sometimes for my job, so they're all in Logan and I'm in Rexburg, I'll join in on our Facebook portal, and I sing the hymn all by myself where I'm at, and they're singing it where they're at, and we're all singing together.
shawn (31:32.107)
I love it, man.
Matt (31:33.774)
Music is a super important part of worship for our family, but I think Sam's right that it is an individual thing, and people just have to decide for themselves how important that's gonna be. My kids, when they start learning the piano, always have to learn the hymns. Whatever else they practice, they have to practice playing hymns. I think the reason for the 12-year project is different. I think that the 1983 hymnal was largely a Utah-based...
shawn (31:47.273)
I love that.
I love that.
Matt (31:59.394)
kind of a social network, who do you know kind of thing. And if you look at the names of the people who wrote the hymns, a lot of them are connected to leaders of the church. And I think that with this hymnal, they said, we want to be different. We want this to be a global hymn book that everybody has a part of because there's so many musically talented people in the church and it just takes that long. Because my mom submitted a hymn for the new hymn book. And I think she said they had over 30,000 submissions of songs for the new hymnal.
shawn (32:26.167)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Matt (32:28.114)
And it's just a process of going through all of that and figuring out like... And then they're going to translate it into different languages. And then they're going to have people record them.
shawn (32:37.259)
So I think everything you're saying is the root cause of that is that I think it's too common that we go into a church meeting and like you said, if I go in Ukraine, if I go to Africa, if I go to some place, these hymns don't, they just don't connect sometimes or they don't connect with the youth. So I think there's an importance in public worship, right? Gathering together as a body of Christ and being able to, and connecting and being able to
Matt (32:53.303)
Oh.
Sam (33:02.25)
and connecting.
shawn (33:05.087)
Can you, I mean, we've all been in situations where we are a mass group of people united. You ever been a part of a, when they dedicate a temple and we all get together and we do certain ordinances, right? What's that called? What is that called? That's the Hosanna Shau, right? Being a part of this, no, but being a part of this united chorus, right, towards God.
Matt (33:18.714)
Okay. The dedication of the temple?
Sam (33:19.862)
Hosanna shout, Hosanna shout part of them. Yeah. It's not an ordinance. I don't think.
Matt (33:26.619)
No.
Sam (33:31.054)
Everybody wants to be part of something, yes.
shawn (33:33.599)
Right, so I think it's an important part of our worship. I think the church has recognized, all right, these hymns, like you said, Matt, it's either colloquial to Utah, it's not really, and it also doesn't quite speak to some of the younger generations. It doesn't, it doesn't inspire.
Sam (33:46.806)
So, but, but isn't that the problem of a leader that won't take the time to explain it and help people see it or understand it like again, wrencher did when we were in the MTC and like some of those leaders did as part of the pageant, right? There is something at its core. Let's take, let's go outside of even the church and the hymnal is I think the hymnal is an, I don't think that's it. Look at the role of music in culture today. Have you ever been to a
shawn (33:57.535)
Yeah, good point.
Matt (33:57.587)
Mm-hmm.
shawn (34:01.515)
Great point.
Sam (34:15.618)
concert, like think of the best concert you've ever been to. Music has power, a unique power to bring an entire group of people together. And whether you're sitting at a YouTube concert or a Coldplay concert or a Taylor Swift concert, it does that. And to your point, Sean, it would be cool to see leaders in the church, be more thoughtful about it in teaching younger people about the meaning behind the songs and then inviting them to, you know, uh, sing and connect behind, behind those songs.
Matt (34:42.228)
soon.
So for the last two years, my wife goes to the Ward Choir, and I don't join the Ward Choir because I hate singing in Ward Choir. I hate people telling me what to do when I'm singing a song. But, um, two weeks ago! Like, uh... Well, yeah, but I'm just singing!
Sam (34:55.83)
What? But you're in the front row. Wait, you're in the front row because you want to sing with mucho gusto, but you don't want to be told how to sing. That is so interesting. That's a paradox. But go ahead. I interrupted you. Yeah.
Matt (35:04.414)
Yeah, and the Ward Choir, the Ward Choir, they pick a par and you have to, you like have to learn your part and you have to like come in and out of this. Anyhow, I hate Ward Choirs. But two weeks ago, a member of my bishopric calls me up on the phone and he says, Matt. Right, he said, you need to start going to Ward Choir. And I was like,
Sam (35:14.402)
Yeah.
Sam (35:18.878)
Ooh, you got called to be in the Ward Choir.
Matt (35:25.926)
I don't want to go to Ward Choir. No, first he thanked me for my work on flags in the ward. And I was like, thank you, I hope I never have to do that again. And he's like, well, speaking of that, I want you and your two boys to join the Ward Choir. It'll be very important for the whole ward to see you guys in the choir and enthusiastic and all of that. And I was just like, okay, well, I say I'll support my local leaders. So we joined the choir, we've gone one time, but we'll start from now on going to the choir. So that's a point to Sam's leadership, right?
shawn (35:52.42)
Wow, interesting.
Matt (35:55.562)
The leaders say, do this, and then the members will follow.
shawn (35:59.411)
Another point of Sam's leadership, I think you win the potpourri easily, Sam. When I was 16 years old in Denver, Colorado, they forced me to go to this fireside and there's this old dude up and his whole topic was singing, singing and hymns. And I was like, this is gonna be terrible. And at the end, my 16 year old punk self left there so inspired because this dude had so much enthusiasm and said what you said, Matt, when you sing, belt it out. He's like, just try it.
And he gave this whole inspiring talk about singing is worthless and pointless unless you do it with your heart and you do it with your voice. Get it out. And it was so inspiring that I just fell in love with the dang hymns. And so maybe, to your point Sam, that's a really good point. You win.
Matt (36:40.763)
Hey, there you go.
Sam you win, thought provoker. That was very thought provoking. Okay, so now it's my topic. So, actually I just barely checked the news. It turns out that the Democrats have saved the Republican skin once again. Yeah. The... well, and you watched. Now Matt Gaetz is going to try and get Kevin McCarthy out as speaker of the House. But anyhow...
Sam (36:50.078)
Alright, let's hear it!
Sam (36:57.166)
I saw that the budget impasse has been solved at least in thought for a bit.
shawn (36:59.455)
No way.
Sam (37:07.724)
Right?
Matt (37:08.198)
So, it just happened that the federal government shutdown isn't going to happen at least until November. But once again, right, they bring us to the brink here. You get bipartisanship in the Senate. The last shutdown we had was actually under the Trump administration and President Trump shut down the government. And so the last time that this happened, like, so to me it's always Republicans shutting down the government. It really isn't ever Democrats that are shutting down the government.
shawn (37:08.351)
Whoa.
Sam (37:15.766)
Right.
shawn (37:30.006)
Yeah
Sam (37:34.318)
Yeah.
Matt (37:36.894)
And so the last time in 2019, I did a little survey of federal government employees, and I found that 25% of federal employees were forced to work without pay. Now this matters to me because I have a son in the army and he lives paycheck to paycheck. And making him go to work and not paying him, that's like horrible in my opinion. So it's 25% have to do that. 56% of them said they have increased stress because of the shutdown. 26% they don't have enough money and savings to pay their bills.
Sam (37:55.372)
Yeah.
Sam (37:58.987)
Yeah.
Matt (38:06.878)
So, and in the end they always get reimbursed, but in the meantime you're creating all of this like angst on federal government employees who don't have the money to pay their bills. And so my question is, do Republicans have a moral obligation or is it morally wrong for them to keep shutting down the government?
Sam (38:17.644)
Right?
Sam (38:28.178)
It is morally wrong for the federal government not to figure out how to fund itself. And it's crazy that politicians would be able to say, we're not going to, we're, we're not going to pay soldiers. We're not going to pay air traffic controllers. We're not going to pay people that are crucial to the functioning of society. Yeah. But it is politics. Like what would the alternate be Matt? What would you propose as an alternate?
Matt (38:48.582)
the national parks. Yeah.
Matt (38:56.878)
here's an alternate, pass the bipartisan bill that everybody agrees to and don't say, right, you've got like a handful of Republicans that have these like principles or whatever they want to stand on and then I just feel like there are some Republicans whose approach is let's just tear everything down. If I don't get what I want, let's tear everything down. And so I don't know, it's just...
Sam (39:01.442)
Yeah.
Sam (39:08.095)
Yeah.
Sam (39:12.63)
Yeah.
shawn (39:17.184)
Does that come from the idea that Republicans are not for big central government and it's okay to cause wreak havoc? Does that come from there?
Matt (39:27.666)
I don't know why they feel like it's okay for them to do this. It's something that's always perplexed me. It's like your whole job is to just get along with people and pass legislation. So like it is interesting to me, Nancy Pelosi had the exact same number of a majority when she was Speaker of the House as Kevin McCarthy does now. And yet Nancy Pelosi kept those Democrats in line and she never shut down the government.
shawn (39:54.527)
That's a, you have a math that, but, but that's what I'm asking you is Nancy Pelosi's idea is that the government is the most important thing in the universe. Whereas Republicans go, no, no. We need to shrink and, and weaken government. Is that not, is that philosophy not central to your topic?
Matt (39:54.57)
They never had this same kind of problem, and the Republicans can't do it for some reason.
Matt (40:15.402)
Oh, so you're saying like Republicans have this anti-government idea in them anyways?
shawn (40:19.723)
So it's fine, it's fine. Shut it down, cause, yeah. Show how.
Matt (40:23.998)
Well, so I... people always tell me how Republicans are standing up for the moral good in society. I would just like to point out that it's not morally good to tear down the government you're elected to run.
Sam (40:31.096)
Oh no.
shawn (40:37.067)
Well, that's what you said, Sam, right? What, there's...
Matt (40:40.752)
Ron Swanson is not the morally good person in the parks and rec. The morally good person is the people trying to make the government work.
shawn (40:49.84)
Ron thinks he's moral though. Ron is... What is that? Hahaha!
Matt (40:51.722)
But he's not! But he's not!
Sam (40:55.042)
Wait, are you talking about a sitcom as a representation of a... Okay, that's fair. All right.
shawn (40:57.756)
Yeah, he is.
Matt (40:59.714)
Sure, but tell me Ron Swanson doesn't represent these people that Sean's talking about. You haven't seen Parks and Rec? You liar. Oh my goodness. I just gotta hold on. I gotta point out the things that Sam does watch and the things that Sam does not watch. That's my point. Yeah, go ahead. Okay.
Sam (41:04.842)
Never seen the show. Nope, nope, I haven't.
shawn (41:06.655)
He does. He does, Matt. He represents it. Matt, he does. He does, he represents it. It's a good character, yeah. Matt, here's, but I.
Sam (41:17.326)
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
shawn (41:23.052)
Hey, here's a good scripture waiting for the heckling. Oh, do you? Okay. Here's a good scripture that kind of it's fascinating because I found there's like four or five instances in multiple of our books, our scripture books that have this. It says, I would that you should remember that whosoever among you borroweth of his neighbor and should return the thing that he borroweth according as he doth agree.
Matt (41:29.193)
No, no, I want it.
shawn (41:47.451)
or else thou shalt commit sin, and perhaps thou shalt cause thy neighbor to commit sin also. There's a big, there's a lot of talk about borrowing from each other, having agreements with each other, and it does talk a lot about, that's a sin if you break those agreements. So if you look at it from that standpoint, right, it is a sin, it is bad, it is immoral.
Matt (41:58.103)
Mm-hmm.
Matt (42:02.123)
Yes!
I like it. And isn't there a scripture that says that it's a sin to like not give a fair day's work for your wage to like... yeah. Yeah. Right. So again, if you're elected to a position in government, you have an obligation to do your job. Even if you think that it's... even if you think the government's all bad, you should...
shawn (42:11.935)
Yes, there is. In DNC, yeah.
shawn (42:24.747)
I don't think that's no, no. That's not what I don't. The agreement that is broken is your son who commits to a job and is promised to get paid for that job. I think that's the, no, you're saying, okay.
Matt (42:34.314)
That's what I'm saying. I'm saying the Constitution says that every budget bill has to start in the House of Representatives. And the law says that the House of Representatives has to pass a budget every year. So if you're willing to say, I'm not getting what I want in this bill, even though there's agreement out there of what should be done, I'm not getting what I want, so we're not going to pass the bill, we're going to shut the government down. That's a morally wrong... but it's not a negotiation tactic.
shawn (42:58.84)
But that's just a negotiation tactic. Yes it is.
Sam (43:02.298)
It is actually. So if you, if you go back to West wing, one of the things I loved about West wing is West wing showed how awesome. Liberal progressive thoughts are in theory and how terrible they are in practical. So West wing had a ton of episodes where they talked about shutting down the government and they explored the morality of it. And from a super simplified standpoint, to Sean's point, Republicans conservative.
shawn (43:06.174)
I'm done.
Matt (43:16.874)
Hmm. Hahaha.
Matt (43:22.485)
Yeah.
Sam (43:30.082)
traditionally, not today, but traditionally, it's to minimize the size of government and act as a kind of a veto against liberal Democrats trying to create these out of control social programs. Now, it's not that case. Both sides right now want to spend a ton of money. They just want to spend money in the place where they want it to go. But shutting down the government, you go back to West Wing. That was a cool idea, right? Because it limited the growth of government over time. And today,
shawn (43:46.919)
Yeah. Good point, Sam.
Matt (43:47.151)
Hahaha
Matt (43:58.074)
It has always failed. It has always failed to get them what they want.
Sam (44:01.759)
Today, it makes very little sense, because what shutting down the government today does is it affects credit rating, it affects our place in the world marketplace, it actually increases our cost of debt, our credit rating as it goes down actually threatens the US currency as the gold standard in the global marketplace. So there's too much risk. I agree with you, Matt, if there was a way to get around the whole
uh, approving the budget and, and increasing the debt ceiling, ceiling automatically, that would be a good thing to do because both parties are trying to make government bigger and it, and it only, only a negative. What did Nikki Haley say?
shawn (44:38.815)
You heard Nikki Haley. Did you hear what Nikki Haley said about it? No, she said tie these budgets to the salaries of the politicians, right? Yeah.
Matt (44:43.114)
She said vote them all out.
Matt (44:51.302)
Right? That they don't get paid either. Well, so all I'm saying in response to this thing that it's a negotiation tactic. There are things that people use as negotiation tactics that we say are immoral. For instance, if I'm negotiating about the price of a new car and I pull out a gun and say, you're gonna give me my price, we call that theft. Even though I might say, no, I'm just negotiating. Or if there's a sales manager and we kidnap their daughter and say, give me the price I want on this new car.
shawn (45:12.503)
Bad example.
shawn (45:18.011)
Matt, you're Matt, you're backhanded. Matt, your backhanded compliments have piled up on me where I'm bold and bold and to say, Matt, that's dumb. What you just said. I'm just going to be direct.
Matt (45:18.93)
And I say, I was just negotiating. We say, we're.
Sam (45:20.706)
What are we even talking about now? I'm still sick.
Sam (45:27.605)
Uhhhhhh...
Sam (45:31.938)
Heh. Uh...
Matt (45:32.534)
Alright, so good, I'm hoping for, I've been trying to get you there, Sean. I'm like, why is Sean like just dancing around not telling us what he thinks, asking questions? If I go crazy enough, Sean will actually say, that is so stupid. So Sean, I'm gonna give you the thought provoker on that. I'm so happy you finally said that's so stupid. Okay, Sam, you're up.
shawn (45:41.261)
Oh, that's what you're doing, okay.
shawn (45:54.647)
Thank you.
Sam (45:57.159)
Okay, so here is my topic. I'm going to start with the question and then I'll give you some background on it. So the question is this, do members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints have a moral obligation to support or challenge laws that uphold Word of Wisdom and LDS Church standards? So in my community, I happen to live in a city called Highland, Utah, and it's one of the few cities left probably in the entire country, not the only one, but...
few where alcohol sales are prohibited in restaurants. So you cannot walk into a restaurant and get a drink. And retail establishments are closed on Sunday. And there's been an impact as a result of this, to property taxes. So property taxes here are more expensive than elsewhere, right? Property taxes have to offset money that would normally go to education.
But then also its impact our ability to collect sales tax. Osco considered coming in here for a period of time and didn't because of the Sunday prohibition. Other restaurants and retail businesses have refused to come in for that same reason. There is a, there is a something before the Highland City, before Highland City that would legalize alcohol sales in the city, and it has caused an enormous debate.
They're not dealing with the Sunday thing for now. They're just talking about, should it be legal to sell alcohol in Utah? Before I get into the fun stuff, which is in Highland, Utah, before I get into the fun stuff, which is the Facebook comments around Highland City, what's your opinion? Matt, is it the responsibility of a member of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints to defend this prohibition on the sale of alcohol in restaurants?
Matt (47:49.458)
Yeah, so my position on this is we know what's right and wrong, because it's been revealed to us from the Lord. And we should advocate for laws and policies that are consistent with our values and beliefs, as long as they don't hurt other people. And alcohol is one of those areas where I say there's actually more harm from legalizing alcohol cells than good that comes. If we got rid of alcohol in the United States, we would get rid of so many problems.
Sam (48:12.546)
Really?
shawn (48:16.791)
True.
Matt (48:17.018)
So many, there's so many things that are expenses that the community has to pay associated with alcohol that I say this is an easy one. Drunk driving. If you look at most rapes that happen, one or both of them were intoxicated at the time of the rape. If you look.
Sam (48:23.414)
such as, such as.
shawn (48:26.804)
Uh.
shawn (48:34.514)
40% of all convicted murders in America were alcohol related?
Sam (48:37.218)
Wait, is this true? Can you cite some surveys on this? You're saying that 40%? That's your stat?
Matt (48:39.56)
Yes!
shawn (48:41.736)
Yeah, we've done it.
Matt (48:43.455)
Yeah.
shawn (48:46.669)
40% of murder convicted murderers with the alcohol alcohol. Oh, sorry.
Sam (48:49.386)
Oh, he said rape, that both people were drunk at the time.
Matt (48:52.202)
Yeah, look at the statistics on rape. Yeah, it's like most people that are involved, if you look at rape, one or both of the people that's involved in a rape situation were drunk at the time, intoxicated at the time.
shawn (49:04.531)
The highest consumption, the state that has the highest alcohol consumption is Alaska. The state that has the highest aggressive crime rate, Alaska, violent crime, rapes and assaults.
Matt (49:13.546)
Violent crime. Yeah. There are so many negative things that come in society as a result of alcohol, but again, alcohol companies are huge money makers and they pay a lot in taxes. So, I don't know, I say, so cities will say, we should allow alcohol sales in our city because we want the sales tax revenue.
And I say, you know who's making more money than that? As the alcohol companies, first of all. But you're gonna bring in problems that exceed what you're bringing in sales tax revenue. So I would always come down. If I could make alcohol illegal, I would do it every time.
Sam (49:49.218)
So actually in the state of Utah, is it not true? Because if you want to buy hard liquor, you actually have to go to the state of Utah to purchase that. So the state of Utah benefits when a consumer has to buy alcohol at the state liquor store, right?
Matt (49:57.502)
Yeah, estate liquors.
Matt (50:03.85)
That's the reasoning for that, is they say, the state of Utah is gonna be in charge of shouldering the costs of enforcing all of these new crimes that will come as a result of the alcohol sales. We should be the only people profiting off of the alcohol sales.
For me, it's not even hard. And there's, right, like, there's not a lot of funding to go out there and research the bad ills of alcohol in society. I think the things that Sean and I have talked about are just the things that you can measure in terms of crime. But then move down to the family level. And a person who has a father who drinks all the time...
People who have like people in their family, like alcohol does nothing good for anybody in society. And I can't imagine why we would legalize it. Like, why don't you legalize fentanyl and cocaine and all the other, like why not? Like if you're gonna start, why would it just be alcohol, marijuana, tobacco? Well, if you're gonna let drugs be legal, let them all be legal because alcohol does as much harm as any of the other ones.
shawn (50:48.584)
Yeah, exactly.
Sam (51:00.994)
So do you think it's okay for a city inside a county and inside a state to have a law that's a higher standard or inconsistent with state law to have their own standard?
Matt (51:13.05)
I think so. Just like we allow states to have laws that are different than the federal government, unless the state specifically says you can't do that. But we allow that with all kinds of business regulations, right? Like Airbnbs, for example, you're going to find different codes in different cities. You're going to find different codes in terms of like how clean you have to keep your yards and zoning and all that stuff. So if a city says, we think that having alcohol in our city is going to make it so that we have more
drunk driving or our roads are less safe and we don't want that in our community. Especially if you know the geography of Highland, if you're buying alcohol outside of Highland, then it's kind of there's only like a couple of thoroughfares that get you into the city, right? But if you have alcohol inside the city, you're going to have more problems, alcohol-related problems in that city because they can just go to the local store and get it.
Sam (52:04.267)
So this is one of the comments that I think is just interesting. So when you go in and watch the debate on Facebook and in other places, I think there's some misunderstandings and there's some false understandings that don't help the debate, right? So you've got a population base that doesn't understand drinking very well. So one of the comments I heard is, is hey, there are limited roadways into the city of Highland. If there are multiple restaurants that offer drinking,
Matt (52:23.285)
Yeah.
Sam (52:31.374)
How are you going to deal with all these drunk drivers on the road? Right. And I, I don't have anything to back it up, but I feel like most people that would go in and eat a meal and consume some alcohol aren't going to drive drunk. Like just because you have one drink, you think just, just because just because Sal, this is an interesting departure. There's Sean in California where alcohol is readily available. There's no.
Matt (52:46.777)
Yes they are.
shawn (52:48.503)
Not most, not most Matt, no not most.
Matt (52:49.726)
Oh. Well, I-
Matt (52:57.16)
Yeah.
Sam (52:59.958)
limitation to day of the week, like there is in Utah relative to Sunday and other days. There's no, you don't have to buy a private club membership to come in and have a drink at a bar. Like the laws of the land have limited drinking and driving to much less than it used to be. So just walking into a bar and having a meal and having a drink. Actually, this is an interesting question. How many, how many, how many drinks do you think it makes? How many drinks before you become intoxicated or impracticed?
Matt (53:08.883)
Right.
Matt (53:28.854)
Well, okay, so it depends on your size and weight. It depends on how much alcohol is in the drink, right? So I would say I could probably drink six beers and not be intoxicated, but a teenager couldn't drink that many. A teenager would probably like one or two would be intoxicated.
Sam (53:29.611)
you think.
Sam (53:36.555)
Okay.
Sam (53:41.15)
Oh, wow. Okay. No. Yeah. Interesting. Sean, what do you think? Is it the responsibility of member of the church, Jesus Christ, the latter day saints to defend these laws or to be open to changing them?
shawn (53:50.097)
Just look at...
shawn (53:57.099)
Well, I can see both sides. I mean, I do, Matt has persuaded me over the years, you know, cause at first I was like, no, man, you need to separate church and state. You need laws that are protecting agency and freedom, give people choices. But over the years, I've been very, very persuaded by Matt that it's total hypocrisy, like, yeah, if you're going to allow, if you're going to make cocaine illegal, but not alcohol, absolutely hypocrisy. So I've been persuaded by Matt for sure on this topic and it
Matt (54:23.295)
Well...
Sam (54:23.569)
And so that means.
shawn (54:25.631)
So that means, yeah, you need to let the, plus I'm against, Matt, when it comes to central government versus local municipalities choosing, making laws. So if the local city or county wants to make laws that restrict alcohol, do it.
Matt (54:31.874)
Hahaha
Matt (54:43.654)
Well, and Sam, so there are only a few thoroughfares into Highland, right? And so, so if there's a teenager that goes out and gets a few beers, you know the roads they're going to be on, not necessarily to patrol them, but you know it like it keeps, it keeps little kids off of those roadways. It makes these accidents less likely if you have it outside of the city. But if you have it inside of the city and teenagers after the football game can go to a convenience store and get drunk,
You're just bringing that stuff inside of your community, whereas otherwise it would be outside and only come in certain places. What are you-
shawn (55:21.099)
Sam, here's some stats. District of Columbia, New Jersey and Utah are the, have the lowest rate of drunk driving in the country. Where...
Sam (55:21.102)
That's interesting.
Sam (55:31.686)
And that's interesting because drunk driving in Utah isn't 0.08, it's 0.05. So it's a much lower standard. So technically you would assume the instance all things being equal would be higher in Utah.
Matt (55:43.23)
And you've got to think what's going to happen to your property value, Sam. Highland, Utah is like one of the most expensive zip codes in the entire state. Start letting alcoholics come into that community and just see what happens.
shawn (55:55.147)
Hehehehe
Matt (55:56.482)
All of your general authorities will move out of your town, and your property values will plummet.
Sam (55:57.524)
So.
shawn (56:02.295)
But Sam, it'd be interesting to study so that the three states with the highest rates of drunk driving, Montana, Wyoming, and Texas. So it'd be interesting to study what are the motives of people drinking. But no, I think, what is your stance on it, Sam? I agree with Matt. Let Highland limit it.
Sam (56:02.356)
So here, so, oh, go ahead.
Matt (56:10.612)
Yeah.
Sam (56:22.594)
So Highland is a beautiful place to live. And in part it's beautiful because it is set, it's kind of set apart from everything else. So it is an enclave of sorts. And I suppose one of the things that does make it unique is there isn't a lot of retail businesses, right? If I want to go to a restaurant, I've got to drive 15 minutes away to get to a marginal restaurant and a half an hour away to get to a nice one. One of the things. Right.
shawn (56:26.793)
Eh.
Matt (56:46.218)
because you don't serve alcohol.
Sam (56:48.502)
So it's interesting, we lived in Idaho for a long time in Boise and we saw the explosion of growth in that area. And one of the things that really propelled it is they had one of these out or lifestyle malls. Uh, so the state of California, one of the investment, uh, retirement funds came in and spent billions on this mall, beautiful mall, a couple of the anchor restaurants were very nice, up brand restaurants sold alcohol. Right. And we had that debate back then. It's like.
Matt (57:14.294)
Sure.
Sam (57:17.046)
Part of what allows these restaurants to be there and for this place to be as nice as it is this outdoor mall is the liquor sales. You can't justify that the receipts, the income generated due to food sales in and of itself don't merit that. There was also a very, there's a great bowling alley with laser tag where, where they had alcohol on the one side, they didn't have it on the other, you know, ordinary bowling.
Matt (57:26.293)
Yeah.
Matt (57:34.39)
Right.
Sam (57:44.31)
does not justify as beautiful a facility as this big Al's was. So you could have night bowling and they'd have lights and dancing. Like there was all sorts of really cool stuff that the receipts that came from that helped to justify. And so, you know, if they're going to start to build some retail establishments in the city, I like the idea of having nicer stuff and nicer stuff comes on the tail of open on Sunday and alcohol receipts.
Matt (57:47.754)
Hahaha
Matt (58:08.936)
Yeah.
Sam (58:13.954)
So I'm okay with it to be honest with you. Yeah.
shawn (58:14.333)
Oh, wow.
Matt (58:16.318)
You sound just like Pinocchio and his friend when they got to Treasure Island and looked at all the nice things. Right before they turned into donkeys and went to the salt mines.
shawn (58:20.011)
Hehehe
Hahaha!
Sam (58:24.336)
Well, I hope I hope I hope I don't sound like Bill Cosby at least so but that's as long as I don't sound like him I'm good.
shawn (58:26.487)
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Matt (58:34.79)
I wonder Sam if Highland, Utah is the last city in America arguing about whether alcohol should be allowed to be sold. It feels like everybody's... Yeah.
shawn (58:39.935)
Yeah, right.
Sam (58:41.546)
It's gotta be one of the last. Now you go to the Midwest and there are still some of the, the kind of exclusion zones, but they've kind of gone away. Right. Um, and, uh, I disagree with you. I don't know. I don't think alcohol sales in and of itself brings a ton of negative into a community. I just don't think most people come to a nice high end restaurant, drink their minds out, and then they're posing a threat to.
Matt (58:48.959)
Yeah.
Sam (59:06.782)
all the citizenry as they drive away. But I could be wrong. I need to look at the stats on it. But if you go to, if you go to, there's a public Facebook group, it's public called Residents of Highland. If you go to the Residents of Highland Facebook page, the comments just will crack you up. I would sit and read them all, but it would take far too long. The lack of facts here and just kind of the concern based on things that I don't think are necessarily facts are entertaining, right?
Matt (59:12.031)
I am one of these.
shawn (59:20.267)
Ha ha ha!
Matt (59:36.554)
Well, this is why I think we have this podcast to encourage everybody to get involved. Because if you think you can't get involved because you don't know enough, you just haven't been involved. Because once you get involved, you realize most people have no idea what they're talking about. And so your ignorance is welcome. We welcome all ignorant people to get involved in politics. It will save our society.
shawn (59:52.075)
Hehehe
Sam (59:53.602)
Haha. Uh... Yup.
Matt (59:58.206)
Let's talk about General Conference real quick here at the end of the podcast. Any impressions or things you guys want to discuss from the Saturday morning session of conference?
shawn (01:00:08.231)
I did like Oakes, I did listen to Oakes talk and Oakes did talk about a topic, a doctrinal topic that I think is fascinating, right? Just to summarize, he basically talked about God has a glory for most of us. God has created a plan that gives a glorified result to most of us. Like just leave out the outer darkness people, very few. For everybody, yeah, basically to everybody. But then he points out really in a really important doctrine and I've had this debate with a lot of people a lot.
Sam (01:00:08.615)
No, I don't. Go ahead.
Matt (01:00:27.708)
He says basically to everybody. Yeah.
shawn (01:00:39.211)
there's only one spot which is the top level of the celestial kingdom that offered where God offers exaltation to us. Now if you look up the word salvation in the scripture it's abundant. If you look up the word exaltation in scripture it's abundant. Clearly God intends for us or at least has offered to us salvation and also exaltation. And so I like that he points out the distinction it's important that yes there's a glory for like it's a it's a loving just God it's
that there's a glory for everybody. However, anything under exaltation, to me is a form of hell. So.
Matt (01:01:19.422)
So that's to me the problem. So that's the real problem to me. We have a third of the members of our church that are adults, our single members of the church. And we tell everybody, it's by grace that you're saved, and Jesus Christ saves everybody. And then we say, but by the way, you're not getting really saved like I'm getting saved. You have to get married in an LDS temple to be exalted. And that's not, if you don't do that, right? And so...
shawn (01:01:47.287)
Oh boy.
Matt (01:01:48.286)
Like in the middle of President Oaks talks, one of my kids said to me, he's like, wait, I have to get married in order to go to the celestial kingdom? No. No, 100% you don't. You can go to the celestial kingdom without getting married in the temple, but you can't be exalted. Right, and so if you say, Sean, if you say anything less than exaltation is hell, then that... Yeah. That's hard.
shawn (01:01:57.271)
Correct. He didn't see the top level be exalted. Correct.
shawn (01:02:09.015)
I didn't say it was hell. I said it's a version, a version of hell. Here's why, here's why, here's why. Because scripture teaches that the definition of spiritual death is a separation from the presence of the Father.
Matt (01:02:21.562)
I can get that in the celestial kingdom. I don't have to be exalted to get that. So I can be in the celestial kingdom and not be married in the temple.
shawn (01:02:23.571)
Yes we can. That's, that's cur-
shawn (01:02:30.103)
That's correct, but to live the life that our Father lives, to fulfill the measure of our creation, to do everything that He has in store for us, we have to fulfill that portion of the new and everlasting covenant. Now, those people, but Matt, those people, there's no message, never once in our church have I said, or have I heard anyone preach, yeah, but if you're single, you're out. Never have I heard that. We know clearly that God will give every single one of us an opportunity to choose to live
that exalted life.
Matt (01:03:01.106)
What if you're gay, Sean? What if you're gay and single? What if you're gay and single and want to have a family? Because I talked to a guy this week. Gay, single, wants to have a family, and loves the church so much and says, how do I have that? And I said to him, you can go to the celestial kingdom. You can have a family. You can adopt kids. He's like, well, but what if I get married to somebody? I'm like, yeah.
shawn (01:03:11.127)
Okay, that's.
shawn (01:03:15.947)
So.
Sam (01:03:24.13)
So what are you proposing, Matt? What's your solution?
Matt (01:03:27.294)
Well, so all I'm doing is pointing out a bit of a paradox that we have in our doctrine. And I think about this question a lot because I talk with people who are in that situation. And every time I pray and ponder about it, I come to the conclusion that it's not my struggle. I can get answers from the Lord about my personal questions for my own life. And so when I'm trying to say, what should so and so do, that's not my sphere of influence. And so I'm not going to get those answers. And so...
I trust that those people can find their own answers to those questions, but I just want to point out that there is this paradox here that on the one hand we say everybody's saved, and on the other hand we say, but some of you aren't as awesome saved as other people are. And that can be hurtful.
shawn (01:04:07.339)
It's a, it's a, it's, that's a good point, Matt. So this weekend, there was this viral podcast, Dax Shepard interviewed one of the guys from Queer Eye. And they, they're two very liberal people who accidentally got into a very heated debate that made one of them cry because they talked about trans issues. And the one guy just got so emotional and it was pretty fascinating because
Matt (01:04:20.939)
Mm-hmm.
Matt (01:04:28.139)
Oh wow.
shawn (01:04:36.287)
Hearing this guy's preach so passionately and curse so much and start crying about this topic that many of us have no clue. I don't have any understanding of where he's coming from. To be in that homosexual or transgender community, I don't relate. I don't understand. Yet hearing him talk so passionately was very, very powerful. And to hear him bawl, cry in public. My point is...
Matt (01:04:57.344)
Yeah.
shawn (01:05:06.127)
Sometimes you're right. I like that Matt you're able to jump in other people's shoes and be like well if this is a doctrine It's and it suits me. Well lucky me, but if a doctrine doesn't suit well or sit well with someone who There's that those dissonance. There's that conflict. How do we look at it and You're right. I think the only answer we can possibly come up with it is what I have found in Scripture and in my own life is Christ loves me and knows my unique challenges
Matt (01:05:23.968)
Yeah.
shawn (01:05:34.395)
and my salvation and exaltation will be worked out together one on one. And so, yeah, I don't, I don't, I agree. We can't judge other people, but I do think that there's a message that should be strive for this was elder Oaks message, strive president Melk's message, strive for exaltation. That's what God has prepared for us. And that, that doesn't mean we should just focus on marriage map. Marriage wasn't, that wasn't, that's not the only requirement for the new number of lasting covenant.
Matt (01:05:53.845)
Yeah.
shawn (01:06:03.627)
There's way more.
Matt (01:06:04.406)
Sure, but if you listen to Elder Christofferson and he says the most important day in Pat Holland's life was the day she got married and he said the entire reason the earth was created Was so that people could get married in temples Then that's a really heavy marriage message And I don't I believe that the reason the earth was created is because Heavenly Father Wants all of us to become the best version of ourselves and for some people that is going to be exaltation
But for some people that's not going to be exaltation, and I think that the God created the earth for them every bit as much as he created it for me.
shawn (01:06:36.797)
Okay, that's...
shawn (01:06:40.491)
You sound like a Calvinist. You sound like a Calvinist to me right now. You sound like predestination. You sound like God has created, no, hang on. You sound like God has created someone who doesn't have the ability to fulfill what God has prepared for him.
Matt (01:06:45.846)
God... No, no, no!
Matt (01:06:54.79)
Everybody has the ability. I'm not saying anybody can't. I'm not saying people can't do it I'm saying that God created the earth and the plan of salvation so that all of us could become the best version of ourselves and some people were created as intelligences and spirit children and they rebelled in the pre-mortal council and they'll never get a physical body and some people were worthy in that pre-mortal life and they come to earth and they're gonna get a physical body and then they're gonna end up in the telestial kingdom and
and God knows that that's gonna happen with some of his kids. And I'm saying...
shawn (01:07:25.131)
But they didn't, but you're saying that was predestined. I don't think they had to. I think all of us have the ability to exercise faith unto repentance and intercovenance that will allow us to get to exaltation. That's God's desire. He wants me, you, every one of us to get there. My gay friend, my gay, you know, he wants that to happen and I believe him that he can get us there.
Matt (01:07:29.834)
I'm not saying...
Matt (01:07:49.014)
I totally agree with that. What I'm saying, Sean, is God is never going to be upset or feel regret or feel bad for all of the millions of people that don't make exaltation because he loves them for who they are and he's happy for wherever they end up is way better than where they started. And I think that God's happy with that. And so to suggest that...
Sam (01:08:09.782)
That's interesting. That's interesting, Matt, though, because that message doesn't resonate or translate in any doctrinal message that we hear at in sacrament meeting or any part of general conference. Why is that?
Matt (01:08:22.626)
But to me it does resonate with the idea that grace is what saves us and that Christ... So I feel like sometimes we have this dual message in the church which is Christ saves and by the way if you don't make it all... Right, Dalin H. Oaks said it in his talk, Christ saves everyone. But if you can't abide the law of a kingdom you're going to end up with something less. And then the implication is that somehow God's sad about that or you're going to be sad about that. And I just don't believe that because...
Because if I think of God as a father, and I think of all the parents I know, there are parents out there who have kids that do some pretty awful things, and I see those parents that love those kids so much. And when they think of their kids, they're not looking at them with eyes of regret and eyes of sadness and eyes of, I wish they were something different. Yeah, and so I can't imagine that that's how God is.
Sam (01:09:09.398)
Or judgment. Yeah.
shawn (01:09:13.367)
But Matt, there's another side to thinking of that. If I have five kids and these have strayed or these are middle of the road and these are extremely successful, I still always have hope that we can get them all to a success, we can get them all there eventually. We can help each other overcome. And in the eternal perspective of things and in what we learn in scripture, God's intention is for us to become like Him. Progression, eternal progression.
Matt (01:09:29.41)
Sure.
Sam (01:09:41.306)
You know, as-
Matt (01:09:41.715)
But that's not what President Oaks said.
Sam (01:09:44.063)
Yeah.
shawn (01:09:45.467)
Well, no, he was pointing out, yes, he was pointing out the reason for the divisions of glories in those kingdoms. And you're right, that there's some places that will be more people will be more comfortable that doesn't ultimately result in exaltation. But I've read, but I've also read scripture that talks about, well, I don't know, maybe Christ in the eternities can get us all there. Maybe that's the faith we ought to have, but that message won't resonate in a mortal earth because, oh, fine, I'll just wait till he gets me there then.
Matt (01:09:59.143)
Yes.
Sam (01:10:08.258)
That's that's.
Sam (01:10:14.35)
does that, how does free agency play into that though, Sean? If at the end of the day, Christ forces us, brings us to a place that we ourselves didn't choose to come.
shawn (01:10:14.478)
There's an urgency.
shawn (01:10:25.191)
Yeah, I don't think there's any forcing. And I think it's always choosing. I think agency is the key, but we live in a finite, you know, a mortal finite beginning and end, whereas eternity doesn't have that.
Sam (01:10:37.566)
Oh, I'm not going to quote shadow lands here, although you sound like the guy from that, but you know, it's interesting. You know, it's interesting. I think there is an element of having kids where at some point you watch your kids as much as you love them. And you realize that part of your job isn't to change them as human beings, you know, and love and respect them in a way you never understood you could. And there has to be a belief.
Matt (01:10:42.692)
Hahahaha
Matt (01:10:58.048)
Yeah.
Sam (01:11:07.966)
not that they're going to be fixed at some point, but that they will.
Matt used the word that they'll become their best selves, that they'll somehow become self-realized, that they will realize that they are enough and they're good where they are and who they are.
Matt (01:11:20.779)
Yeah.
shawn (01:11:28.459)
Sam just said self-actualization. He just said it.
Sam (01:11:30.61)
I know that's crazy, huh?
Matt (01:11:32.022)
Well, no, but that's the whole point. God, God doesn't, so everybody has... Yes! Everybody has the potential to be exalted. But not everybody is going to choose that. And Heavenly Father will not be disappointed in those who don't choose that. He's going to love them and be happy.
Sam (01:11:36.77)
I actually agree with you on this, Matt. Holy cow. Are Matt and I a green sun? Right.
shawn (01:11:41.15)
Hahaha
shawn (01:11:51.607)
So we have... so... I can...
Sam (01:11:51.646)
And you're saying, and, and you're saying by continuing to talk that word track, it's kind of condescending to ultimately the gift of his grace that takes us to whatever spot where we become our best selves, right? Because it pretends it's not good enough or somewhere along the way later. It'll be fixed when maybe that is good. Yeah. Interesting.
Matt (01:12:01.067)
Yeah.
shawn (01:12:02.171)
I can, but I, but I can.
Matt (01:12:12.018)
Mm-hmm.
shawn (01:12:13.175)
But I can agree with what you just said, you guys. I can agree with that, that God won't be disappointed with someone who lands in the deal, because that's part of His grace and that's part. I can agree with that, and also at the same time, believe that our Father in heaven does desire for us all to be exalted. And there is an element of shortfall if we don't choose to get there.
Like there's, we have a beloved mission companion whom I think we all served with, who listens to our podcast, Shout Out. He said at one point, he said, he says, Sean, I don't think God sees you right here in mortality. He's an eternal being. He only sees you in the eternal exalted, I'm paraphrasing him, maybe he can fix this. He only sees you in the, where you ultimately,
Matt (01:13:04.624)
Yeah, yeah.
shawn (01:13:10.867)
are which is exalted and that's right and that's the way God sees us because he doesn't see us in the finite he sees us in infinity he sees us in the eternal perspective and I wonder if that's how God sees every single one of us which means that salvation or exaltation can be worked out through the power of Christ's salvation and atonement not because of Matt I take issue with what you're saying because you're saying well our message is that it's by the grace of Christ but only
Sam (01:13:12.931)
us version of yourself. That's interesting.
shawn (01:13:40.511)
But then you have to do, your works will qualify you for certain things. That is not the message of exaltation. It is not. It was not. It absolutely was not.
Matt (01:13:46.23)
Well that was President Oak's message. If you can't abide the law of a kingdom, you should not be in that kingdom.
shawn (01:13:53.387)
But that's scripture, that's not President Oaks. But that doesn't mean that your work save you. That doesn't mean that at all. What that means is, what it means is Christ has all the power to save and exalt. And Christ offers, says, I give it to you freely, although I would like to require you to do X, Y, and Z. Now, X, Y, and Z doesn't in its own have any power to save you or exalt you. Just because I get married, that doesn't have any power in and of itself to save or exalt.
Matt (01:13:59.874)
It's just if you can live the law or can't live the law.
shawn (01:14:22.515)
It is still the power of Christ. Yeah, but if you don't, then you've broken Christ's requirement. It's not that you've not become, like marriage mat doesn't give you any sort of exalted celestial status.
Matt (01:14:22.698)
But if I don't, but if I don't.
Matt (01:14:36.327)
I just can't be exalted without it.
shawn (01:14:38.327)
But that's just because Christ requires it. It's not because there's anything powerful in it. It's because Christ has said to you, look, I'll give you my free mercy, my free salvation, but I want you to do X, Y, and Z. It's just one of those things.
Matt (01:14:51.702)
The last 20 minutes of this podcast has been Sean's dream come true. Sean wants a doctrinal religious podcast. It's true.
shawn (01:14:58.239)
How dare you. No, that's just...
Sam (01:15:00.546)
the way, it's, it's almost as if Sean woke up at six o'clock this morning to prepare. I mean, like it's such a cogent, cogent argument. I love it. So nobody would know it was just 10, 15 minutes ago. So, but great topic. I give the points to Sean if I get to give points. So, uh, however, I, I do go back. Like, I think it is an interesting point, Matt, you make. And, and as we progress down time, like I think in the church, we need to figure out how to talk.
Matt (01:15:04.803)
Hahaha
shawn (01:15:12.896)
Ha ha!
Matt (01:15:17.496)
Alright, I love it.
Sam (01:15:30.262)
better about it. Like there is this sense that you're settling. I don't know. There's got to be like a better connection. Yeah. That you failed. There's got to be a better connection between, um, you know, becoming your best self. And, uh, yeah, I don't know. That's interesting. And, and, you know, I didn't think of it until you talked about it, but having kids sort of helps you to see that maybe it helps you to understand God's love a little bit better that, uh, ultimately you really want
Matt (01:15:37.406)
Or that you failed.
Sam (01:15:59.238)
You want your kids to become their best self and to learn to love themselves wherever they are as their best self and not, you know, it's, it's not about failing. It's about, you know, it, uh, repenting and preparing to meet God, which isn't necessarily a pass fail test. I don't think, I don't know, Sean, John's shaking his head. He's like, he's like,
Matt (01:16:22.55)
Yeah. No, we're not, we're not, we're gonna, we're gonna end this.
shawn (01:16:23.424)
Well...
Sam (01:16:24.63)
He's like, Sam is talking scripture mingled with philosophies of men and, uh, okay. John's like, Sam didn't even quote a single scripture. This is a problem.
shawn (01:16:28.003)
No, that's not what I was thinking Sam. No, I like everything you say about it. It was good. That was... No!
Matt (01:16:29.686)
Who? We're good.
Matt (01:16:37.988)
Listener.
shawn (01:16:38.195)
Matt Mac gets a little uncomfortable when it bleeds over too much into religion and not as much about his field of expertise politics
Matt (01:16:42.425)
Hahaha
Sam (01:16:44.842)
Then it go back if I can start thinking like Matt did I may start watching Cosby I need to watch Cosby and Michael Jackson. Maybe I'm being swayed
shawn (01:16:54.107)
The end message here is that the Cosby show is a telestial TV show. That's the point, right?
Matt (01:16:58.408)
Hahaha!
Sam (01:16:59.254)
I'm not even sure it's that. I think there's outer, well, you can't see, yeah. Anyway.
Matt (01:17:02.77)
If loving the Cosby show is wrong, I don't want to be right. Hey guys, you guys are so cool. Thanks so much for doing this podcast. Listener, we're really interested in what you have to say about this stuff. These are things that I think these are questions everybody wrestles with and struggles with. We give you our word. If you write in a question about this topic and Sam starts to be mean to you,
shawn (01:17:05.559)
Sam (01:17:08.017)
And it is wrong.
Matt (01:17:26.634)
we will turn off his mic and not let him talk the mean talk and say, why are we talking about this?
Sam (01:17:29.277)
Ha ha!
Sam (01:17:32.631)
Oh, yeah, I'll try. I'll try to be more empathetic later on. So, yeah.
shawn (01:17:32.907)
Sam's not mean, Sam's passionate.
Matt (01:17:38.906)
And it will help, listener, if you don't put the word Trump in the question, because that's like a trigger word with Sam. He doesn't like that very much. All right. Thanks everybody. Talk to y'all next week.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories