The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
September 13, 2023: Healthcare a right or a privilege, College rankings, Joseph Smith papers, Cheating in high school athletics.
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Thought Provoker:
The previous discussion leads into Sam’s topic for the week. Is healthcare a right or a privilege? I found an interesting link in this story that shows that US healthcare system is not the envy of the world. In 2007, the US spent $7,290 per capita on health care but ranks last among seven countries. The Netherlands, which spent $3,837 per capita on health care that year, ranks first. US News ranks the US healthcare system as 23 in the world.
Next up, Matt. The WSJ just came out with college rankings. They give high scores to colleges that prepare students for careers. BYU is ranked 20th, and BYU-Idaho ranks higher than many state colleges and universities. This is quite different from how others like US News rank universities. This is because places like BYU-Idaho have low tuition and are specifically trying to train students for careers. In the past, that has been a role filled by vocational schools and community colleges. What is the proper role of a University education? Do places like BYU have an obligation to prepare students for a career, or should they be focused on teaching higher educational skills?
Finally, Shawn: On the 179th anniversary of the martyrdom of Joseph Smith the final print volume of the “The Joseph Smith Papers,” was published. The project took 20 years and 10s of millions of dollars. It contains Principal documents produced by, under the direction , or written to Joseph Smith directly and features 27 volumes including 1,306 journal entries, 643 letters and 155 revelations. “Every document that we know of that was produced by or under the direction of Joseph Smith, or written to him directly, has been published with annotations,” “When you read these documents, … it’s not novel style. It’s not a narration. It’s document after document after document. And you kind of put the narration together. “The Church didn’t want to hide anything about Joseph Smith,” said Laurel Thatcher Ulrich, a Pulitzer Prize winner in history and the 300th Anniversary University Professor, Emerita, at Harvard University. “They felt confident that if the actual records, the primary sources, were available, responsible scholars would consult them.” Additionally, the scholarly approach in these volumes was endorsed by the National Archives as meeting the most rigorous criteria for documentary editing. Why is this a big deal? What is the intended outcome of the project?
Big Question:
I was watching a high school football game last week. At one point, one of the kids running with the ball fumbled, but the referees didn't have a good angle to see when the ball came out. TV cameras showed that the ball clearly came out well before the kid hit the ground. The refs ruled that there was no fumble on the play. Do players have a moral obligation to inform the refs that they got the call wrong? If not, what impact does this have on society? Wouldn't we have far fewer laws/rules if people were honest in every aspect of their lives?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt:
Hey welcome to another episode of the Latter Day Lens with Sean, Sam and Matt. It's good to have you with us today. We've got some fun stuff in the mailbag. So Sam, I think this comment is targeted to you. This listener wrote,
Sam:
I bring
Matt:
I think...
Sam:
it.
Matt:
I think Trump has done irreparable damage to the Republican Party, and I don't see myself ever voting for a Republican again until there has been a renaissance of the party, but I don't see that happening. I see both parties going further into the extreme and leaving myself caught in the middle, feeling abandoned by both sides and not wanted by either. I don't see Republicans shifting back to center when I was a campaign advisor for the Washington State Senate race. I remember giving the recommendation to the Republican Party district chair that they need to shift their political views toward the middle if they hope to win any elections in the future. And I was told by the Republican Party district chair to not come to any more Republican Party meetings
Sam:
That's
Matt:
because
Sam:
a solution.
Matt:
they thought their winning strategy was to become more like Trump. They did and the Republican lost in a landslide. And it was an incumbent.
Sam:
So
shawn:
Wow.
Sam:
this feedback, this feedback map proves my point. There is no way the pendulum will swing back towards the middle until people become so frustrated, sick and tired and disgusted with the current state of things that it forces people to shift. And if you listen to the talking heads this past week, there's already talk of Republicans pushing, pushing back to the middle and a little bit of surprise that it hasn't happened yet. So that to me, When you think about economic cycles and you think about political cycles and historical cycles, it has to go into the frustrated beyond belief. And it sounds like one of our listeners is, but there's clearly not enough Republicans that are frustrated with the current state of things to start the push back to the middle, but
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
it
Matt:
so
Sam:
will happen. It has to happen. Right.
Matt:
there was another listener that said that if you look at like historically where the parties have been on various issues, what we consider far right today would have been considered liberal in like the 1970s.
Sam:
Yes.
Matt:
And what's considered moderate today would have been liberal, right? And so this listener argues that things gradually make a leftward shift over time.
Sam:
Mmm
Matt:
And so that would kind of go contrary to your idea of this pendulum swinging back and forth. Right? Because
Sam:
or,
Matt:
they're not going to move to the middle.
Sam:
yeah, I, I cannot help but believe Trump pushed everything to the left a little bit because he was formerly a Democrat and he speaks outrageously, right? He's drugged the Republican party into a place that it's not used to being. It will swing back. I think I
Matt:
But
Sam:
could be wrong though.
Matt:
then you would say people like Vivek Ramaswamy and Ron DeSantis, they're not the future of the Republican Party.
Sam:
Oh, no way.
shawn:
Hehehehehehe
Sam:
They're, they're, uh, they're, they're basically Trump too. Right. They're
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Trump too. There will be, there will be calmer heads that will prevail. Ultimately that will bring it back to the middle. Paul Ryan. I mean, really, you know, I don't know as an adult, I look back at what Reagan did. You know, Reagan was what
Matt:
A communist.
Sam:
it meant to be.
Matt:
Ha
Sam:
And he was not a communist.
Matt:
ha!
Sam:
He was what it meant to be a Republican, uh, back in the eighties and nineties. And he set a standard that everyone has sought to emulate even from in his early campaign, and
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
I've got
Matt:
I
Sam:
to
Matt:
don't
Sam:
believe
Matt:
know that
Sam:
it
Matt:
Obama,
Sam:
goes back to that at some
Matt:
Obama's
Sam:
point.
Matt:
not trying to emulate Reagan. You're
Sam:
No,
Matt:
meaning
Sam:
no, no. I mean, Republicans.
Matt:
Republicans.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
All
Matt:
Sean,
Sam:
Republicans.
Matt:
what do you think?
shawn:
I think well done for this listener for being involved in politics. That's what's
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
needed. Because you two
Sam:
I
shawn:
won't do it,
Sam:
nice
Matt:
What
shawn:
and
Sam:
job
Matt:
are you
shawn:
I
Sam:
getting
Matt:
talking
shawn:
won't
Matt:
about?
shawn:
do it.
Sam:
nice job getting
Matt:
Oh.
Sam:
picked out of the Republican Party meetings, by the way. I mean, there has to be
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
more to that story. What did this person say about the current state that caused them to get the boot? Like, you know, they'll
Matt:
That
Sam:
take
Matt:
happens.
Sam:
money.
shawn:
But that's the message that we've given many times in the past, you guys, is the best thing that we can do is to have everyone get involved a bit in politics at any level. That's
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
what the church promotes. So this guy who's doing the right thing and talking to some idiot, lifelong political,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
to be able to get in his face and be like, you're doing the wrong thing. Well, if we had enough of those voices, then that's the solution, isn't it? I mean, you can't just wait for the leadership to switch. You can't, right Sam? You can't just wait and go, okay, well hopefully it swings. We have to be the ones that make it swing, aren't we?
Matt:
I don't know, I started watching that Netflix series, Narcos. Have you guys seen Narcos?
shawn:
or no.
Matt:
It's about the drug trade in Colombia. You have to watch it with VidAngel, or it's pretty naughty stuff. But anyhow, in that show all the good guys die and get tortured and killed
Sam:
Uhhh...
Matt:
and stuff. And so there's sometimes I say, I don't know, maybe we shouldn't get involved in politics.
shawn:
What the heck?
Matt:
Maybe sometimes you just let the bad guys win,
shawn:
Wait
Matt:
and not...
shawn:
a minute, wait a minute. Your train of thought was, we should do the right thing and get involved, and then you watched a TV show
Matt:
Ha
shawn:
where
Matt:
ha!
shawn:
good guys died, and you said, oh, I better not do that.
Matt:
It
shawn:
Oh,
Matt:
sometimes
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
feels like the good guys get killed. And I was reading in Helaman, you know, those like five guys who, like Nephi says, Hey, your chief judge has been murdered. And there's those five guys that say, let's go find out if he's really been murdered. And then they run and then he has been murdered. And then they like fall down and then they get arrested and put in jail for something they didn't do. And I think maybe it would have been better if they'd just hung out at the wall of Nephi and not done anything at all. And it just sort of said, Hmm, I wonder if he's right.
shawn:
I mean, Matt, the DNC does say that we should be anxiously engaged in good causes, right? Do things of
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
our own free will,
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
right? The powers in us to be agents and choose. Like,
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
shouldn't
Matt:
alright.
shawn:
we, hasn't the church pushed us to be involved in politics?
Matt:
It's just a mood I'm in probably today. Yeah, I think you're right. I think that people
shawn:
Hehehehe.
Matt:
should get
shawn:
Hahaha.
Matt:
involved. Okay, this other listener. So Sam last time talked about Biden negotiating drug prices and interference in the market and things like that. And they said, it seems unfair for big pharma to enjoy government protection of their patents when it's convenient and then complain about government meddling from the other side of their mouth. Medicine is a hard place for capitalism to operate. Unregulated markets have so many problems here. Demand is almost completely inelastic. He defines this for us, meaning a higher price does not reduce the amount demanded. If it saves your life, you're not gonna do without when the price gets too high. Meanwhile, patents mess up the supply curve. When you add patent protection, you create a monopoly, again, defining this for us, meaning that one supplier controls the whole market. And the price signals on the supply side stop working as well. But if you don't enforce patents, you ruin the incentives for medical research, kind of. When the price signals on both the supply side and the demand side are broken, how should the price be set? Question. I know that's not for me.
Sam:
Why didn't this person define a patent? I would have appreciated that. No,
Matt:
Hahahaha
Sam:
I'm kidding. That's such a... So listen, think about this. There is massive cost of bringing medicine to market in the United States. The FTC has a high bar. It requires, for every medication that makes it to market, and by the way, I have no experience in this, so I don't know what I'm talking about, but I think this is true. For
Matt:
But this
Sam:
every...
Matt:
could be like a fun experiment for us as a podcast. We could try
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
to bring a drug to market and see what it costs
Sam:
Like,
Matt:
us.
Sam:
well, but here's the thing for every drug that successfully comes to market and creates revenue and profit for the farm company. There are thousands. There are a lot. I'm not going to make up a number. There are many, many that fail. And so
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
all the expense associated with those failed tests and medications end up going into the cost that ends up being borne by the US consumer. for that successful medication.
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
And listen,
shawn:
not only that.
Sam:
there is no other country on the face of planet Earth that has been successful, like the United States has, not a single one, at
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
bringing innovation and successful medications to the marketplace. And so if you say, we're not gonna have a patent, the patent ultimately protects the pharmaceutical company which takes the risk. We're not gonna have a patent, and everybody, as soon as that medication hits the market, it's free game, like that won't work.
Matt:
But Sam, a patent is government interference in a market.
shawn:
it is.
Sam:
A patent is protection against stealing of intellectual property
Matt:
enforced by...
Sam:
in a market. Pardon
Matt:
enforced
Sam:
me?
Matt:
by a government.
Sam:
It is enforced by the government. Yeah, that's correct.
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
So you're happy.
Matt:
So the listener is saying, hey, we've got government interference in that market anyways. It's not a free market because you have government interference on the one side.
shawn:
It's two-faced.
Sam:
the dumbest thing ever. That's ridiculous.
Matt:
Hahahaha
shawn:
It's- no,
Sam:
It's
shawn:
that's true, Sam.
Sam:
not two-faced. It prevents intellectual theft.
shawn:
That's the point of the question, Sam,
Matt:
So
shawn:
is that it's...
Matt:
the government is artificially reducing supply on the one side, and then you're saying they can't artificially manipulate demand on the other side.
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
So.
Sam:
listen, the patent holder could say, hey, look, I'm going to bring a medication to market and I'm going to give no transparency behind what's in the market, what's in the medication. I'm not going to give any transparency behind the testing that went to bring it to market and consumers need to just have faith that this medicine will work. That would be the flip side of no patent. Instead, The government is involved vis-a-vis the FTC in an approval process where the farm company has to be fully transparent about what goes into that medication, the trials and the testing that happen. So yes, it is government regulation and interference, but it has to happen to offset the transparency the farm companies have to have to bring that medication to market. If there
Matt:
Good
Sam:
wasn't
shawn:
Not.
Matt:
feeling.
Sam:
any transparency and if they could be secret about it, they'd
shawn:
That's
Sam:
probably
shawn:
it.
Sam:
prefer that and then it'd be a free for all. But ultimately the consumer would be harmed.
shawn:
You sound like a confused capitalist is what you're saying.
Sam:
No, I'm
Matt:
No,
Sam:
not.
Matt:
he doesn't.
Sam:
I'm actually not.
Matt:
So the flip side of the FDA approval process for drugs is the vitamin industry. That's an unregulated market where you don't have to disclose what's in your vitamin or your supplement or whatever. That's
Sam:
Did I
Matt:
all
Sam:
say FTC?
Matt:
re...
Sam:
I meant FDA. That's right. Thank
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
you.
Matt:
yeah, that's fine. But so we do have that, right? We know exactly what it would look like if pharmaceutical companies did not have patents on their drugs. But what happened is it would be regulated just like the GNC stuff that you see and you don't know what's in it. They put the little nutrition label there, but there's no quality controls. If you go to the hospital and you say, hey, I want some vitamin D, they can't just go buy it from GNC because they don't know that the vitamin D at GNC is actually the right dose, the right amount. So they actually have to get like an FDA approved vitamin D as an example, right? So that's why drugs in hospitals cost so much more. You say, Why am I paying so much for a multivitamin when I can buy it at Walmart for cheap because hospitals are trying to regulate the dosage? So we do know what that market would look like.
shawn:
We've it we
Matt:
I just wonder if maybe that's better. Why don't we just have all drugs be like GNC vitamins and supplements
shawn:
Oh,
Sam:
What?
shawn:
now
Matt:
and
shawn:
Matt's
Matt:
say,
shawn:
arguing. But
Matt:
take.
shawn:
we know, but hang on, Matt, we know before 62,
Sam:
Sane.
shawn:
we know the other, that it's even worse than that, right? Because before 62, there were some major, major cases. There's a drug called thalidomide
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
that killed a lot of people.
Matt:
Yeah, it happens
shawn:
And
Matt:
in the supplements.
shawn:
well, but that was,
Sam:
Arsenic killed
shawn:
but
Sam:
a lot
shawn:
those are
Sam:
back
shawn:
the,
Sam:
in the 60s
shawn:
it doesn't kill, I don't think it kills as many people as thalidomide and all these other drugs. But those are the things that sparked more regulation, more regulation, more regulation. And. Here's an interesting idea though, Matt. Well, two things. I have two questions for you. The government and the market, didn't they kind of compromise? Because patents are only, what? For pharmaceuticals that are approved by the FDA, they're only monopolies
Matt:
Six years,
shawn:
for 12
Matt:
seven
shawn:
years.
Matt:
years,
shawn:
I think it's
Matt:
I was
shawn:
12
Matt:
at 12,
shawn:
years.
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
And then after that, they're forced to go public. So
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
isn't that a decent compromise? You've got a patent, right? To directly answer the question. Why not?
Matt:
Um...
shawn:
Because if they owned a lifetime patent, yeah, they could price fix and do really
Matt:
So
shawn:
some pretty nasty things,
Matt:
the problem
shawn:
but.
Matt:
with the American, so Sam's right. We develop a lot of drugs that other countries don't develop and guess what they do? They put price fixes on those drugs in the European Union and in other countries. They say, thank you for this AIDS drug. You can only charge this much for it. And so what happens is the American consumer is not just only, they're not only subsidizing the cost to bring that drug to market, they're also subsidizing the price reductions enforced in other countries around the world. So. So when it comes to this question of how long should they have a patent and how much should they be able to charge? I think we have to come up with like this really does I think need to be a global solution It seems really bad to me that someone in Mexico In fact, I can go to Mexico and buy the exact same drug at a lower price than I can buy it in the United States Because Mexico has laws that you can only charge so much for it So the United States we just pay so much more for our medicine than we otherwise would and so then I say What benefit is it to me to be in the United States health system when Mexico gets all of the drugs that we develop
Sam:
Really?
Matt:
at a better price than what I get in the United States?
shawn:
But how are you going to have a global fix on
Matt:
You
shawn:
prices?
Matt:
just need to have, it's a, almost every commodity these days is in a global economy, right? You can buy and sell it anywhere in the world. So it doesn't make sense to me for all these countries to have these various different rules and like, you know, you guys see how many people go to Mexico just for drugs, right? And just for healthcare because it's so much less expensive there. And they're using the same stuff we're using. And sometimes you get kidnapped and killed and stuff like that, but.
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
Sam, I have a second question for you, since you sound like you're the pro regulation guy. Which is surprising to me.
Matt:
No, he's only...
Sam:
No, I'm not pro-regulation.
shawn:
You preached
Matt:
He's...
shawn:
it.
Sam:
I'm actually pro-regulation when the regulation begins. So again, if government is gonna require transparency to approve medication, it needs to give a patent in exchange for that transparency. Otherwise,
shawn:
They do.
Sam:
no, I know they do. So that's.
Matt:
Or you
shawn:
Oh,
Matt:
can
shawn:
you're
Matt:
do
shawn:
saying
Matt:
it like
shawn:
it's
Matt:
vitamins.
shawn:
a good system, yeah.
Matt:
I'm saying
shawn:
The
Matt:
do
shawn:
Sam,
Matt:
it like vitamins.
shawn:
here's, yeah, but Sam, here's the question since you've seen pro-regulation.
Sam:
Interfere on
shawn:
Since,
Sam:
it would be just
shawn:
since.
Matt:
Hahahaha
Sam:
whatever you get at GNC. We can all go to GNC. That'd be great CVS
Matt:
Hey you guys,
Sam:
and Walgreens would be out of business
Matt:
you should Google this. It's called Craze. It was in 2013. It was this like supplement that everybody was taking. I think it was called Craze. And they're like, I have so much energy. But people were like, but it's like addictive. I can't stop taking it. And so then
Sam:
Math.
Matt:
there was this, yeah it was meth. A food science
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
professor was like, let's see what's in Craze. Meth. They're just taking meth and putting it in a
shawn:
When
Matt:
vitamin
shawn:
was that?
Matt:
supplement.
shawn:
When was that?
Matt:
When did they get caught? 2013. How much did they make before they were caught? A whole lot of money.
shawn:
Are you
Sam:
That's
shawn:
kidding
Sam:
more money
shawn:
me dude?
Sam:
than the people that smuggled all those aluminum cans into California, probably. I
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
bet they did better than that way back
shawn:
that's
Sam:
when.
shawn:
hilarious.
Sam:
Listen,
shawn:
Okay, Sam, I got a question for you.
Sam:
I would accept. Wouldn't, well, you go ahead, John, and then I'll ask this last question.
shawn:
Since 1962, when these big cases dropped down and regulation really started to ramp up for pharmaceuticals, the innovation has dropped by more than 50% since 1962.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
In other words, the innovation that regulation has squashed is now preventing people from being helped and saved from diseases because... Now the process is like before it was like a 12 month on average process
Sam:
Yeah, but,
shawn:
and about a million
Sam:
but.
shawn:
dollars. Now it's an eight year process, $52 million.
Sam:
But Sean, you're tying the decrease in innovation, which I'm not even sure is correct, you're tying that to regulation. I would argue that maybe it's less that and more the complexity of innovation. Now the cost to innovate and bring it to market.
shawn:
because
Sam:
And
shawn:
of
Sam:
then
shawn:
regulation.
Sam:
also, and then, and then
shawn:
That's
Sam:
also,
shawn:
the cost.
Matt:
Ha ha ha.
Sam:
and then also the ultimate cost in lawsuits against these companies for medication
shawn:
That's
Sam:
that
shawn:
the proper.
Sam:
is not good. Right. So you think about
shawn:
So Milton Friedman argued that that's the proper fix against, it's not regulation, regulation. The cost increases come from regulation. So I did work in the farm industry for about five years. And I
Matt:
What?
shawn:
was fascinated,
Matt:
Don't
shawn:
I
Matt:
you
shawn:
did.
Matt:
feel dirty inside? How do you ever wash that from your soul,
Sam:
Ish. Gosh.
Matt:
Sean?
shawn:
Whoa, dang.
Matt:
I'm just playing. How dare you heal people for a living.
Sam:
Ha ha.
shawn:
So the regulatory departments within this company were giant, huge staffs.
Sam:
How much
shawn:
And they...
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
did they pay you?
Matt:
of...
Sam:
How much did they pay you at GNC? By the way,
Matt:
Hahaha! Were you guys
Sam:
was
Matt:
selling
Sam:
it a lot?
Matt:
meth? Hahaha!
shawn:
That's not pharma.
Matt:
Of course they have huge staff.
shawn:
huge staff and they're very dedicated. Their only job is to go, okay, what is the regulatory laws? We
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
need to comply. And so they would bottleneck the whole process, rightfully so, because these drugs won't pass
Sam:
So,
shawn:
unless you are compliant.
Sam:
so you're saying eliminate the entire FDA approval process, allow
shawn:
no i'm not,
Sam:
companies
shawn:
i'm not-
Sam:
to bring whatever drug to market
shawn:
well,
Sam:
and claim
shawn:
i'm just-
Sam:
whatever
Matt:
Yes.
Sam:
they
shawn:
i'm just
Sam:
want.
shawn:
suggest-
Matt:
Yes,
shawn:
i'm just
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
suggest-
Matt:
saying that.
shawn:
oh matt's
Sam:
Interesting.
shawn:
saying that matt- it's-
Matt:
Listen, that
shawn:
it's
Matt:
COVID
shawn:
so funny-
Matt:
vaccine, the COVID vaccine we knew by May, like we knew in May that COVID vaccine was going to be just fine. And we should have taken the Russia approach and we should have said anyone who wants to come get it for free now and you can be our guinea pigs. And we should have bypassed all of that, like regulation stuff that they made Moderna go through.
Sam:
Can
Matt:
Like
Sam:
you imagine,
Matt:
you-
shawn:
I love how unpredictable
Sam:
can
shawn:
you
Sam:
you
shawn:
guys
Sam:
imagine
shawn:
are.
Sam:
the conspiracy
Matt:
Ha ha
Sam:
theories that would have landed on that? You thought you think the conspiracy theories are bad today, right? Like
Matt:
But
Sam:
Bill
Matt:
that's
Sam:
Gates
Matt:
exactly...
Sam:
is trying to infect everyone. Like it'd be three times as bad if GNC was distributing the COVID vaccine.
Matt:
But it's exactly what Israel did and they're fine. Things turned out okay there. And
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
we would
Sam:
but...
Matt:
have had fewer, the shutdowns wouldn't have been as long. It wouldn't have been as tough on the economy.
Sam:
But,
Matt:
Wouldn't
Sam:
but
Matt:
have been
Sam:
it's
Matt:
masking
Sam:
an asterisk.
Matt:
for as long.
Sam:
It's an asterisk, right? Israel doesn't take that approach to other medications, right? You can't, you
Matt:
We
Sam:
know,
Matt:
should though. I say, I
Sam:
interesting.
Matt:
say, why not? Right?
shawn:
liberal.
Sam:
I don't
Matt:
Let
Sam:
know
Matt:
people
Sam:
enough
Matt:
make...
Sam:
about the topic to say yes or no, but, but we should have our listeners write in what they think because I'm fascinated by this.
shawn:
liberal Matt is arguing for
Matt:
I'm...
shawn:
no government regulation. Supposedly capitalist Sam is saying regulate,
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
regulate.
Sam:
no,
shawn:
You guys are awesome.
Sam:
listen, this is consistent for Matt because Matt, you're
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
in academia and academia sees no, like it's science and
Matt:
Yes.
Sam:
it's quantifiable. And if it's just quickly following the science. So you're advocating
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
for more rapidly following the rabbit hole of science down to the solution. And then as soon as you've got it, pop that pop that baby out. Right. And
Matt:
That's what
Sam:
like,
Matt:
I say.
Sam:
yeah,
Matt:
Well, and I
Sam:
interesting.
Matt:
say people should have choice. Like,
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
the information's all out there. So, as if...
shawn:
Matt, you've argued so much in the past about the government's role is to protect consumers. So if there's no regulatory process, people are putting out drugs. Now it's true that a pharmaceutical company, his intention is to do the right thing, but then when they make a mistake and
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
2,000 people die, how is that not protecting the...
Matt:
You protect consumers by allowing them to sue companies for
shawn:
Wow,
Matt:
misdeeds.
shawn:
Milton
Matt:
That's
shawn:
Friedman!
Matt:
how you protect consumers.
shawn:
Matt, you are
Matt:
So
shawn:
Milton Friedman
Matt:
it's just
shawn:
right
Matt:
like
shawn:
now. That's
Matt:
the GNC
shawn:
awesome!
Matt:
stuff, right? I can go take whatever supplements I want to take, and if it causes me harm or does damage to me, there was a man that he was taking some supplement and he started growing female breasts, and he was like, what in the world is happening? This isn't supposed to be in my multivitamin. And then they found out that the place making his vitamins, they were doing estrogen. pills and the multivitamin in the same room and there was cross contamination and so he's getting
Sam:
are bad,
Matt:
he's
Sam:
are
Matt:
getting
Sam:
bad.
Matt:
a lot of estrogen in his daily multivitamin
Sam:
So.
shawn:
And he
Matt:
so
shawn:
sued.
Matt:
he sues the company
shawn:
Yeah, right.
Matt:
and then the company has to like make changes like why
shawn:
Sam,
Matt:
would we not do that with everything
shawn:
Matt truly is a conservative. This is straight out of Milton Friedman's books.
Sam:
So, so does, does the cost of those medications end up being where they are today because of the lawsuits, because successful
Matt:
notes
Sam:
lawsuits ended up driving costs north substantially, right?
shawn:
Milton
Sam:
You think
shawn:
Friedman
Sam:
about
shawn:
argued that it's way less because the incentive for
Sam:
Who's
shawn:
a pharmaceutical
Sam:
this Milton
shawn:
company
Sam:
Friedman? I don't know who that is. Getting it. If,
Matt:
He invented the game Monopoly.
Sam:
if, oh,
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
all right. I thought it was shoots and ladders. So my bad.
shawn:
We'll put it in the notes. I've got all of his studies that show that the regulations have caused way more higher price hikes
Matt:
For sure.
shawn:
than the lawsuits have.
Matt:
My problem with the FDA approval process is that it gives people a sense of confidence that everything's fine when maybe it isn't fine. And so then you get people prescribing Oxycontin, for example, right? And they say, you're feeling pain? Take this drug. And nobody thinks, let me do some research on this drug because the doctor told me it's okay and the FDA told me it's okay. And so people put blind trust in that system. Whereas if I go into GNC and say I'm feeling pain and they say take this little powder most people are going to research that a little bit because they'll say
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
that person behind the counter doesn't necessarily know what's best for me. So I
shawn:
I'm
Matt:
don't
shawn:
so
Matt:
know.
shawn:
happy to hear you talk like this, Matt. The anti-government guy. I love it.
Matt:
Okay, well this is actually a decent segue into Sam's question on the Thought Provoker. So
shawn:
It's a good question,
Matt:
last
shawn:
Sam.
Matt:
week I think I won every Thought Provoker segment.
Sam:
Interesting.
Matt:
Let's see
Sam:
Very good.
Matt:
if we can continue that this week. Sam, what's your Thought Provoker question?
Sam:
So the thought provoker question is simple. Is healthcare in the United States of America a right or is it a privilege? Matt.
Matt:
Wait, we just have to answer that? You're not gonna give
Sam:
Yes,
Matt:
like any kind of a background
Sam:
I'm not.
Matt:
or anything like that?
Sam:
You know what? You backfilled this with a lot of data that I
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
dispute. So you can bring your
Matt:
Oh,
Sam:
data
Matt:
okay.
Sam:
in if you want, and then
Matt:
No, no,
Sam:
we can
Matt:
I only,
Sam:
bring it there.
Matt:
I only put those links in for listeners if they want to look into
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
that. Okay, so the oath of office that the president takes when they're
Sam:
That's
Matt:
sworn
Sam:
where we're
Matt:
in as,
Sam:
starting?
Matt:
well, we've got to discuss rights in the United States.
Sam:
Okay, very good.
Matt:
So
Sam:
All
Matt:
the
Sam:
right,
Matt:
constitution,
Sam:
go ahead.
Matt:
the oath of office the president takes is to defend, I think it's America, but we'll just say American people,
Sam:
Mm-hmm.
Matt:
against all enemies. foreign and domestic.
Sam:
Mm-hmm.
Matt:
And a virus and a bacteria is an enemy, and
Sam:
Mm-hmm.
Matt:
the president therefore has a right or an obligation to defend our bodies from all potential enemies.
shawn:
Wow.
Sam:
What?
Matt:
And so we have a right to be protected from bacteria and viruses.
Sam:
What, what about McDonald's and the impact that McDonald's has on your body when you eat it every day?
Matt:
Yeah, well, it has two effects. There's the taste bud effect, and
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
then there's the there's
Sam:
Ha.
Matt:
the what it does to your body effect I think absolute I think if we thought of health care as a right the way that we think So in the declaration of independence, we say we have the right to life liberty and the pursuit of happiness If we thought of health as a right the way that we think of life and liberty as rights We would do things fundamentally different in society But I think it's a right. I think Individuals have the right to have, let's say, just basic health care.
Sam:
John?
shawn:
So to me, it boils down to this. The providers of healthcare are individual humans who become expert at healthcare. So in order to, if you were to argue that it's a right,
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
how are you going to force, because you'd have to force quality experts to provide healthcare. I don't see how you can make it a right.
Matt:
We do that right now, right?
shawn:
How do
Sam:
That's
shawn:
we force?
Sam:
the Hippocratic Oath.
Matt:
Like
Sam:
Hippocratic Oath, yeah.
Matt:
if I go into the emergency room, they have to treat me whether or not I can afford to pay for it.
shawn:
If you need a surgery, they don't have to treat you. They can give you... No, no, no. So when people go into the ER with a heart attack, the doctors check their vitals. If they get a real lot of heart attack, they give them a bunch of pills and say, you just have an anxiety, get out of here, go home. That's treatment.
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
That's
Matt:
No,
shawn:
government.
Matt:
no, that's not treatment
shawn:
No, that is treatment. That's government forced treatment is what that is.
Matt:
Okay, let me say it in a broader way
shawn:
They had a right to that treatment and they got their right fulfilled.
Matt:
I say that, okay, so I think that individuals have a right to be educated. Like, education, I would say, is a right that people have. And because education is a right, we require things of citizens that places that don't think of education as a right would require them, right? So we require that people get basic proficiency in reading and math and science because we say society is going to be better. if we teach people to like forego their natural instincts and like discipline their minds to learn these certain things. I think we...
shawn:
And as a forest right, as a government solution, what percentage of the people don't actually leave the school system with that knowledge?
Matt:
I think literacy in the United States is over 80%. Which is
shawn:
what
Matt:
pretty good.
shawn:
and that's the goal. You're saying it's a right for people to be literate. And so the government
Matt:
I think that
shawn:
comes in with a solution.
Matt:
you can't have a properly functioning society without basic levels of literacy and understanding of math and science. So when I say healthcare is a right, I think of it in a similar way. Healthcare is a right because whether we like it or not, the government pays most of the costs of healthcare in the United States. Because poor people and old people are the ones using most of the healthcare, at least they're the most expensive, and those things are covered by the government. So I think that, I say healthcare is a right because I think that citizens have certain obligations associated with healthcare, and the government should expect things of citizens related to healthcare, and then in exchange, the government promises certain outcomes. So that's why I think of it as like a right.
shawn:
What do you say, son?
Matt:
A right has benefits and obligations that are expected of you.
shawn:
What do you
Sam:
So
shawn:
think, Sam?
Sam:
my take is healthcare is mostly a privilege, but there's also a portion that's a right. So at the end of the day, the way insurance works is very similar to the way the government is funding healthcare anyway. It's through taxes. So people pay into entities, right? Insurance companies or Medicare, Medicaid, through taxes, and then claims or medical care gets paid out through that. I think where the... So when it comes to like death... situations, nobody's going to sit around. And if someone needs a heart, you know, heart transplant might even be a tough
Matt:
A pacemaker.
Sam:
one, but yeah, if they've got like just a terrible thing, that's a life or death, the Hippocratic oath to Matt's point, ER care, they're going to find a way to provide that, that life or death care for the person. I think where our system is broken is healthcare goes a little bit beyond that, um, emergency medical care in a hospital and it goes to help. As blessed a nation as we are, as much money as we have, as much opportunity as we have, we are broken people health-wise. We
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
make continually really bad decisions about work exercising and about what we eat and about how we live and little we sleep. And that part has a massive burden on the health care system. If in the United States, people could somehow wrap their minds around health care being a privilege. and would embrace the idea of, all right, how do I make myself healthier so that I don't burden this system as much? Basic medical care would cost less and there would be less pressure on it. The problem is, in a free market world, you know, medicine companies want you to consume medicines. And so, you know, they tout the best path to dealing with your cholesterol problem is to take this medication. It's not to get healthy. Right. But
shawn:
So.
Sam:
We people, Sean, Matt, me, we shouldn't pay for somebody that continually eats at McDonald's and needs to go on cholesterol medication, which is expensive. And what the government has done recently, which I think is infringing on the free market is they're driving down artificially the cost of cholesterol medication, eliminating the social cost to making bad health decisions. And it's a vicious cycle that'll just continue to repeat and repeat and repeat. There's got to be a way to fix that element. So that's one component. The second component that I think is super interesting about this whole debate is why healthcare is so deeply tied to employment. And
Matt:
This
Sam:
it's
Matt:
is
Sam:
something,
Matt:
all, these have
Sam:
it's,
Matt:
the same answer, Sam.
Sam:
it's something.
Matt:
It's called the American Medical Association. And it's the reason that drugs cost so much.
Sam:
Oh
Matt:
And it's the reason that everything...
Sam:
no, I smell a conspiracy theory coming, lay it
Matt:
Sam,
Sam:
on us Matt.
Matt:
it's not a conspiracy theory. I forgot to send you this book. We used to have healthcare in the United
Sam:
I might have
Matt:
States
Sam:
forgot
Matt:
that
Sam:
to read it if you send it. No,
Matt:
it
Sam:
go
Matt:
was
Sam:
ahead.
Matt:
not tied to employment. That was a decision that was made
Sam:
World
Matt:
in the
Sam:
War
Matt:
1930s.
Sam:
II. Yep.
Matt:
So the United Kingdom is gonna have nationalized medicine. and the United States says, we don't want that, what can we do? So the American Medical Association gets together with the insurance providers of America and they start working out a plan of like, how can we do this? And the insurance providers of America go to Congress and they say, we would like you to provide a tax incentive to any businesses that use health insurance to provide healthcare. Because before that, there were all these different kinds of systems, many of which were more cost effective. So they get. Congress passed that law, and then the insurance companies collude together to price everybody else out of the market. And they lost
shawn:
Mm.
Matt:
money for 10 years,
Sam:
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Matt:
and once everybody was out of the market, then in the 1960s, when there begins this push from Medicaid and Medicare, then the insurance companies say, we're on board with that, and then they start raising the prices.
shawn:
Mmm!
Matt:
And you can see advertisements from the time where the insurance companies say, are you going on vacation? Don't hire a babysitter. send your kids to the hospital. It's way cheaper than
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
having a babysitter. Go
Sam:
That's
Matt:
on
Sam:
awesome.
Matt:
a two, yeah. And look at the price to have a baby in 1960. Somebody like posted a receipt of the bill for giving birth at LDS Hospital in 1960. It was 160 bucks a birth
shawn:
Mm-mm, mm.
Matt:
because they're artificially lowering the prices to get everybody else out of the market.
shawn:
Wow.
Sam:
So I thought the employer sponsored healthcare was more about attracting and retaining employees post-World War II and creating that competitive marketplace. Obviously the cost of healthcare today outstrips that need and it
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
would be interesting to find a way to remove healthcare as a component of employment, make that more of a free market decision attached to buying not to where you work,
Matt:
I think it's
Sam:
and,
Matt:
a great idea. Do you know what
Sam:
and
Matt:
we call that idea, Sam? We
Sam:
Obamacare.
Matt:
call that Medicare for all. That's
Sam:
Right,
Matt:
exactly
Sam:
right.
Matt:
what Medicare for all is. It says
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
anyone who wants insurance, you can purchase Medicare, and you don't
Sam:
Mm-hmm.
Matt:
have to have an employer help you get your insurance.
Sam:
Mm hmm.
Matt:
That's a beautiful idea. I'm on
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
board.
Sam:
and with that you flip back. So that's great.
Matt:
Sam, you win the thought provoker. You used a conservative
shawn:
Oh man...
Matt:
argument
shawn:
Too
Matt:
to
shawn:
agree
Matt:
persuade
shawn:
with Matt. Ha
Matt:
me
shawn:
ha
Matt:
to support Medicare for All.
shawn:
ha!
Sam:
Yeah, but so how do you in Medicare for all because I'm not supporting it because I think
Matt:
Oh
Sam:
when you when you when you take away free markets, it becomes less competitive, less innovative, less
Matt:
It
Sam:
innovative and it and it delivers ultimately a less awesome product for the end user and end consumer.
Matt:
But Medicare
Sam:
So
Matt:
for All, that is the free market.
Sam:
how do you keep competition and allow Medicare, Medicaid to become the sole
Matt:
No, it's
Sam:
provider?
Matt:
Medicare. It's not Medicaid. So just, Sam, if tomorrow you could go purchase yourself a Medicare plan and get off of your employer sponsored plan, would you do that?
Sam:
I don't know, I might not.
Matt:
Think you would not right most people would not because most people like their employer sponsored plan But there are a lot of self-employed people who don't have access to an employer sponsored plan that would say I would love to Have the benefit of something like Medicare where there's a whole lot of people in the system And so my particular costs don't raise our premiums so much right or
Sam:
And, and, and by the way, even in the workplace, people that have severe, significant illnesses with major medical needs, that's a better solution for them than employer sponsored plans anyway. Right.
Matt:
Yeah. So Medicare for all doesn't get rid of any of the, the insurance system that we have. It just allows small business owners the opportunity to purchase into a health insurance plan that will cover them without being tied to their employment. I, it really is a conservative solution to this healthcare problem.
shawn:
Matt,
Sam:
Alright,
shawn:
how do you, how do
Sam:
we've
shawn:
you,
Sam:
solved
shawn:
how do you,
Sam:
it.
shawn:
but how do you in that, in that world, how do you prevent the problems I see as big problems? You used education as an example. Well, if, if I go through a, I look, I lived in multiple states and went to high school in multiple states and grade school, pretty mediocre education. And yeah, I have
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
to take responsibility for my own, but
Matt:
Well.
shawn:
the free right,
Sam:
explains a lot though.
shawn:
right? Education
Sam:
Interesting.
shawn:
is a free right is what you're saying.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
It's government provided, it's very mediocre. And if
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
I want higher education, I have to pay big bucks. Are you suggesting, isn't that what would happen in the healthcare system?
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
Mediocre healthcare
Matt:
yeah, for
shawn:
for
Matt:
most
shawn:
all.
Matt:
people. Well,
shawn:
But you think that works.
Matt:
we're not gonna promise that you can get your cholesterol medication, right? We're not gonna, but Medicare for all wouldn't even have anything to do with that, right? So if you look at the federal government budget, where does most of our money get spent? Number one is defense, then number two is social security and Medicare. We spend billions of dollars, maybe even close to a trillion of dollars every year. just on Medicare expenses. If you open it up so young healthy people who own small businesses can purchase Medicare, you're actually gonna reduce the cost of medicine to the federal government. Because now you have young healthy people paying into the system and not using the system. Whereas
Sam:
Right,
Matt:
right
Sam:
that's
Matt:
now the young
Sam:
it's called
Matt:
healthy people.
Sam:
its adverse selection. So adverse
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
selection means people with the biggest Issues end up overburdening the system and to your to your point 12% of the federal government spending last year 982 billion went to Medicare
Matt:
Yeah, almost a trillion dollars. Now, think about this. Who's making the money on the young, healthy people that never go to the hospital? the insurance companies, right? So they're making their money off of the young, healthy people. Medicare for all says, hey, you can buy into our system. It's gonna be not as good. It's not gonna be as awesome as what you would get in the private marketplace, but it'll be cheaper and you can buy into it. And I think that it's a conservative solution because then I don't have as many people saying, I have to go work for this company to get health insurance. I can go innovate and start my own business on my own. So it might be inferior, Sean, but. I don't know that anybody says government solutions have to be superior to the private market. The private market
shawn:
Now,
Matt:
can still exist, right?
shawn:
Sam,
Matt:
But
shawn:
oh, you're
Matt:
the
shawn:
saying
Matt:
government
shawn:
it was still—
Matt:
solution just makes sure everybody has an opportunity to partake.
shawn:
But then it's
Sam:
Which-
shawn:
more expensive overall because now I'm paying into one and if I need more than the basic mediocre services, I need to pay into the other as well.
Matt:
I don't think you have to do both. Medicare will cover the big expenses. Medicare covers cancer and diabetes and all that stuff. They don't
Sam:
So
Matt:
cover-
Sam:
Obamacare is the current attempt to do what you're describing, Matt, and it is atrociously expensive.
Matt:
No, Obamacare was backwards. Obamacare said we're gonna make everybody buy health insurance. That's not the right solution, right? That's creating a fault, that's creating false demand for a product without having good supply. And that does make, when you increase demand and the supply doesn't change, then the prices go up. So Medicare for All is the opposite approach. Medicare for All is saying let's increase the supply and don't force people to buy insurance, they can buy it or not, but anyone who wants it can afford it by buying Medicare for All.
shawn:
Okay, Sam, you get Thought Provoker winner for the first topic.
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
Matt, Matt rounded off for the second. I think you both win.
Matt:
Okay, Sean's not giving himself any points.
shawn:
Not at all.
Matt:
Sam,
Sam:
Uh,
Matt:
who do you say won, Sam?
Sam:
you know what I say? We withhold a winner until somebody figures this whole problem out. Cause it is a problem.
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
And, and
Matt:
Okay.
Sam:
it, and it is interesting. You know, we talk about unions and I talk about how destructive they are in the marketplace. If you freed up a employee, it's interesting because if you freed up employment plans connected to, uh, employment places, that would actually give the employee a lot more power in the marketplace and it would it would even it would make unions even more irrelevant than they are today. And
Matt:
That
Sam:
today
Matt:
is,
Sam:
they're dangerous.
Matt:
I think, back in the day unions used to be the health care provider. Unions would pay doctors and all of that stuff, yeah.
Sam:
And it was rampant with fraud.
Matt:
I'm not sure
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
after all of this time discussing unions where you're at for sure Sam, but I kind
shawn:
You're...
Matt:
of think you don't like them very much
Sam:
That could be.
Matt:
Okay, I get to go second the Wall Street Journal just came out with some college rankings They give high scores to colleges that prepare students for careers So in this one BYU was ranked 20th in the nation which
shawn:
for you.
Matt:
deep down we always knew that BYU was like a top 20 program
shawn:
Yes.
Matt:
This is way different than what US News uses to rank universities. So like BYU-Idaho in these new rankings ranks higher than Utah State and higher than like all kinds of state schools and that's not what you would find, right? But because BYU-Idaho keeps tuition low, BYU keeps tuition low, because BYU-Idaho is specifically trying to train students for careers, then rankings like this that are like, how much Does going to this college improve your earning potential over the course of your life? Places like BYU-Idaho, BYU are gonna score well on that. But in my view as an academic, that's always been the role of technical schools and community colleges. Those have always been the places to prepare kids for careers and prepare kids for vocations. College is about, in my view, like helping people train their mind and teaching critical thinking skills and teaching these higher level like skills that aren't necessarily career for a job preparation, but they train your mind to think as like a holistic, like well rounded adult. And so college in this, in my view, wouldn't be for everybody. It would only be for the people that are interested in this sort of like cognitive intellectual training. But It seems like that's not the way the world sees things anymore. So my big question is like, do places like BYU have an obligation to prepare students for a career or should they be focused on these other higher educational goals that I see as the purpose of a college degree?
shawn:
So Matt, did you say that your opinion is that colleges, higher education is not to prepare people for careers? It is more of the cognitive improvement of our society?
Matt:
Yeah, so I'm going to put there's this link that I'm going to read. So these are the things that we think of as like what a college education should do. So teach people about human cultures and the physical and natural world. Teach intellectual skills. Teach civic engagement kind of skills. And there should be some kind of like applied aspect of that, where you like learn how to apply that stuff to the practical world. In that sense, maybe it prepares you for a career. but
shawn:
But
Matt:
it
shawn:
you're
Matt:
shouldn't
shawn:
saying that
Matt:
really be about the
shawn:
yeah, you're
Matt:
job.
shawn:
saying it improves everyone's value and abilities overall generally source society is much better, but it shouldn't be focused on a vocation and ignore all that other stuff is what you're saying. Is that what you're saying?
Matt:
Yeah, that's right. Like, BYU-Idaho announced this week that they're going to have a three-year degree. You
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
can get
shawn:
I saw
Matt:
an online
shawn:
that.
Matt:
degree in business. And the way that they get that is they leave out all of that other stuff that I just mentioned, right?
shawn:
See, that's
Matt:
You just
shawn:
crazy.
Matt:
learn business, business.
shawn:
Yeah, that's pretty crazy to me. So the...
Matt:
But some people would say that's the... Some people say I go to college to get a job.
shawn:
So Matt, should there be more disclosure in that? I'd like to have choices in front of me and go, okay, we're gonna train you to get a job, we're gonna train you to have general knowledge and be a better citizen. Shouldn't there be some disclosures and advertising for that? So I can choose.
Matt:
I think that there are, it's just that most people don't know what they are, right? So if there's a college that says we're a liberal arts college, they're screaming to you, we are not going to prepare your kids for a career, we're going to prepare them to think. And
shawn:
Well, so.
Matt:
a uni- and a
Sam:
And
Matt:
uni-
Sam:
maybe not even that.
Matt:
well
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
no, like
shawn:
to me.
Matt:
liberal arts is those things I just described, right? Like civic responsibility and
shawn:
So Matt,
Matt:
knowledge of the world.
shawn:
I think there's utility in both, right? Having products out there that provide a way for someone to get a job and products that are out there that provide a way for someone to, yeah, just overall grow cognitively. That's, both are very valuable and beneficial for society. To me, the element that needs to be included in this discussion is we need to, as a society, make sure that people understand those aren't just your two options. College and higher education
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
isn't the only way
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
you can. I know many, many people who not only didn't go to college and thrive and are great citizens and have great careers, but many who decry their higher education waste of time. Many! Like,
Matt:
Because
shawn:
I didn't
Matt:
they didn't
shawn:
learn
Matt:
know
shawn:
anything.
Matt:
what they were doing, right? They didn't know... Like, I have... I tell my kids all the...
shawn:
Not only that, but also because the quality of a lot of that, a lot of it was a business and the quality of the education
Matt:
uh
shawn:
and the vocational training was not very good.
Matt:
I meet a lot of students that will say, why am I wasting my time in this class that has nothing to do with the job that I want to have someday? And I say, because you're in college.
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
If you want to train for a career, go to the technical school, go to the community college. They're never gonna make you take all those classes that don't help you with your career. They're gonna train you for a career. But I think people don't know that.
shawn:
There needs to be more disclosure and communication. The universities have done a poor job at, they've become very, a business. It's a business, it's for money. So, because
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
you would turn people off if you said, look, if you come to our university, you're gonna learn a lot, it's not gonna prepare you for the world or for an income. They wouldn't
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
ever disclose that. And so they're earning a lot of money purposely being quiet about it. And I think that's a problem.
Matt:
What I would tell all of those people doing the three-year business degree is I would say, forget about college. First of all, fourteen credits of that is going to be religion credit. So you're going to get a three-year degree a whole semester which is just going to be religion classes. I would say, do you want to go into business? Then go work in a business. Go, I don't
shawn:
Wow!
Matt:
know, sell cars, go
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
do welding, go do anything. The people that are most successful in business, now there's two different kinds but... By and large, the most successful people went into an industry, learned the industry, worked their way up. Like, that's how you... You don't go get a business degree in business administration and then you're like, okay, which industry gets to have my skills
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
as an administrator?
shawn:
you nailed
Matt:
Like,
shawn:
it, Matt.
Matt:
you
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
gotta
shawn:
that's,
Matt:
have something to offer the
shawn:
I think
Matt:
business that you...
shawn:
the three year degree is a problem. It's not a good move because what it teaches people is, oh, that's all I gotta do is fast track through it for three years and I've got my paper. And my paper is gonna be my solution for my career. And that's not the case, like you just said.
Sam:
I remember in my own experience at BYU, I remember at one point, um, getting invited to like a recruiting thing for, uh, for, for a medical pharmaceutical sales. And that was the big thing in the nineties, right? It was
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
to go work for a medical company and
Matt:
Sell
Sam:
you
Matt:
Oxycontin.
Sam:
know, you, yeah, you're selling whatever you'd have a drug, you know, you'd get a company car and you'd start
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
Sam:
out at like 60 grand a year or something like that. And to your point about sometimes practical experience is more valuable than the college education. Like I was making so much more than that at that point. Like
Matt:
Pfft
Sam:
that job that everyone looked at in college, the farm rep as being the ultimate opportunity post-college, was massively less than where I was.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
So I think you are right. Like I think a lot of really good companies, large companies have realized we have within my company. that we can actually provide an education forum based on experience and then also some additional online training through an LMS learning
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
management system.
Matt:
like canvas
Sam:
And we,
Matt:
or something.
Sam:
yep, we can actually, we can actually develop people internally as part of the company, give them opportunities to expand their own understanding and to be promoted within the company that really rivals that college education without an enormous debt load as you come out on the other side. I have a tough time though, because looking at it from my own kids, it's not a path you would sit and say, hey, don't go to college.
Matt:
Yeah, yeah.
Sam:
College
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
is
shawn:
exactly.
Sam:
so ingrained culturally in what it means. You graduate high school, you get a four-year degree, then you decide whether you want to pursue education further or you want to go into the workplace. That's just the way it is. I've heard so many times as a kid, you get that four-year degree to learn discipline, to... socialize to understand what you want to do and how you want to be in the world. I don't know if it was COVID, was it COVID that broke the mold where people said, hey, maybe we don't need to take that path. But in our own company, I'm seeing more and more people that were in college saying, hey, you know what, I'm going to set that aside and get practical work experience. It's the old adage of Cs working for As or As working for Cs. I'm going to get
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
the practical experience. And there are no less in the business workplace or business environment without that degree. Although I will tell you, as you get higher up, higher executive level in corporations, the degrees are critical, right? So
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
maybe it's different
Matt:
it can
Sam:
for
Matt:
be.
shawn:
Not
Sam:
everybody.
shawn:
always, not always,
Matt:
I
shawn:
but...
Matt:
think that's changing. Like, Governor Cox in Utah just changed a lot of these degree requirements for state jobs because he's like, these don't make sense. If somebody has the thing we're looking for, why should we care about the degree?
shawn:
Good
Matt:
So
shawn:
for
Matt:
I think
shawn:
him.
Matt:
some of that might change. Well, so President Nelson says that education is a religious obligation, but that doesn't mean college, right? You don't have to go to college to be educated. I have some kids in college and some kids that aren't, and one that wanted to come back to college, and I was like, listen, think about who you are and the way you spend your time and what you wanna do with your life. College doesn't fit you, but that doesn't mean you should stop learning. You still can educate yourself.
Sam:
But as a parent where the rubber meets the road on this argument is, would you start with that conversation with your kid as a graduating high school senior? Would you say, Hey,
shawn:
Alright Sam.
Sam:
I want you to take a year and think about life and decide you want to pursue a four year education or do you want to jump into the workplace?
shawn:
Great points.
Sam:
You know, I would
Matt:
Um...
Sam:
never do that. I would never ever
shawn:
Me
Sam:
prejudice them that
shawn:
neither.
Sam:
way. Like,
shawn:
But Sam, don't we have an obligation to say, hey, look, I'm not requiring you to finish college. I think you should get out on your own. You should start experiencing life, be in that
Sam:
never said
shawn:
social situation.
Sam:
that.
Matt:
Ah
Sam:
That's a terrifying prospect because it so goes against the mold. If my kids want to take that approach, they've got to go fight to make it that way on their own and it
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
makes
shawn:
no,
Sam:
you
shawn:
but
Sam:
nervous.
shawn:
I mean, sorry, I misspoke. I meant, Sam, go to college. Like, for example, if your kids left Provo and went to college somewhere else, they're on their own, right, they're living in a dorm. They're making decisions about when to eat and what to eat, right? That experience is valuable, but the message of, but you've got to get your
Sam:
I
shawn:
degree
Sam:
think
shawn:
in order
Sam:
to
shawn:
to have
Sam:
get
shawn:
a career.
Sam:
that on a mission. Yeah.
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
That's true,
Matt:
So,
shawn:
that's true,
Matt:
so
shawn:
good point.
Matt:
that, that transition period when a kid leaves home and then starts adulting on their own, it's tremendously difficult. Um,
Sam:
Mission.
Matt:
mission, I think
shawn:
Missing.
Matt:
mission is a great option. So I think, I think, um, I think it's close to 50% depending on like what you're looking at. Right. But there are, there's about half kid, half the kids that go to these major colleges and universities that like flunk out and fail their first year of school. It's, it's a very, very common thing. And most of that is like they struggle with mental illness challenges. I think that kids when they're young have their ways of coping with mental illness problems, then they go out on their own and they don't know how to handle them. And I think that that's not just a higher education thing. So what I'm trying to say is higher education actually has developed resources to help kids in that kinds of crisis that I don't know that businesses are equipped to do, right? Like you go out in the industry and you stop coming to work, they just fire you and let you go. So I do think as parents we have to think about like, how do we help our children successfully transition into adulthood? But I'm with Sam, a mission does as much as anything else to help a kid transition.
shawn:
Absolutely.
Matt:
My son that went into the army, boy that made him grow up real fast
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
when he went through bootcamping in the army. And college can do it for some people. But I just think this idea where people say, I need to go to college so that I can get a job, I think we need to get that out of people's heads because that's not gonna lead to success.
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
Man,
Sam:
But it
shawn:
I'm...
Sam:
starts with, it starts with us and I'm telling
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
you, I would never tell my kids don't do that. Right? Like that's,
shawn:
I'm gonna
Sam:
that's
shawn:
give,
Sam:
the challenge
shawn:
so I'm gonna give President
Sam:
as,
shawn:
Nelson
Sam:
as a
shawn:
the
Sam:
start.
shawn:
thought provoker and then Matt's asterisk that you get it for the asterisk and then Sam's, Sam
Matt:
Hahaha
shawn:
Wynn's thought provoker for talking about the practical realities of talking to your kids.
Matt:
I've
shawn:
You
Matt:
told
shawn:
all get it.
Matt:
every single one of my kids to not go to college. Yeah.
shawn:
Haha, wow.
Matt:
It's reverse psychology.
shawn:
OK.
Matt:
I tell
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
them, you'll
Sam:
but you
Matt:
never
Sam:
didn't
Matt:
succeed.
Sam:
mean it.
Matt:
Ha
Sam:
Yeah, you didn't mean it. You were just trying to mess them up. Ha ha ha.
Matt:
ha ha. Okay, Sean, you're up.
Sam:
Oh.
shawn:
Okay, can we bring some religion into this? We've done a lot of economy and
Matt:
I
shawn:
politics.
Matt:
feel like this, I've brought in scriptures.
shawn:
You did, you did,
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
sorry.
Matt:
okay.
shawn:
You did, sorry.
Sam:
I brought in a lot too, but we won't go back to that.
shawn:
Okay, so we haven't talked very much about the Joseph Smith papers. This is a big thing that it was announced that the project, the 20-year project that cost over, it cost tens of millions of dollars, was
Sam:
Why
shawn:
finished
Sam:
does it cost
shawn:
and launched.
Sam:
tens of millions of dollars to put together papers? I don't understand that.
shawn:
Well, let's talk about it. So basically.
Matt:
Do you know who paid for it, by the way?
Sam:
the turk.
Matt:
Larry
shawn:
No,
Matt:
H. Miller.
shawn:
not the church. The church didn't
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
pay
Sam:
Oh,
shawn:
for any of it.
Sam:
the car guy. Free
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
he
shawn:
the car guy.
Matt:
spearheaded
Sam:
market.
Matt:
the whole thing and funded the whole thing.
Sam:
Was that
shawn:
Here's
Sam:
before or after he made the really awful movie about, uh, what was the movie that, that plunked about Joseph Smith? That
Matt:
It was this
Sam:
played
Matt:
was all part
Sam:
in the
Matt:
of
Sam:
theaters.
Matt:
it
Sam:
Okay. This was part of,
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
all right, nevermind.
Matt:
that's it.
Sam:
Go
Matt:
Yeah
Sam:
ahead, Sean. I'll, I'll be quiet.
shawn:
So the reason it cost so much and took so long is because there's two reasons. One, it's 27 volumes, including 1,300 journal entries, 643 letters, and 155 revelations. Basically, every ounce of evidence that was sourced from Joseph Smith exists now in this collection. And the other reason is because it's gotten very high praise from the historians and academics for being, for example, Laurel Thatcher, Pulitzer Prize winner, professor at Harvard. They
Matt:
member
shawn:
felt confident.
Matt:
of the church who
shawn:
Is it a member of the Church?
Matt:
yeah she's a member of the church who grew up in Rigby Idaho or something like that sugar
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
city
shawn:
then I'll take away her. Okay, I won't say.
Matt:
no cuz she's a celebrated scholar
shawn:
They
Matt:
of
shawn:
felt
Matt:
mormon
shawn:
called.
Matt:
history
shawn:
She says they felt confident that the actual if the actual records, the primary sources were available responsible scholars would consult them. Additionally, the scholarly approach in these volumes was endorsed by the National Archives as meeting the most rigorous criteria for documentary editing. So academia gave gives high praises to the process. Right,
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
because it's primary sources.
Matt:
Yes!
shawn:
Right. That's the reason. So the question is, the real question is this to me. Why is this a big deal, the Joseph Smith papers, and what is the intended outcome of the product?
Matt:
Do you want to go first Sam? As an academic I'll say why I think it's a big deal.
Sam:
That you go first and then I'll fill in the holes
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
Thank you.
Matt:
it's a big deal because we want primary sources on Joseph Smith. There's so much innuendo. There's so many like mistruths and this person said this and this person said this. It's amazing to be able to just go to the primary source. It's all available online and you can just look and see what it was and then you can make your own decision. I think I wish there was like a Joseph Smith papers for everything in history that I could just go online click and read the original source and then decide for myself is it true or is it not true.
shawn:
Sam, do you really have an opinion on this? Because if you don't, I have a direct question for you that I'm super interested in. I've been interested all week
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
about this. But if you have an opinion,
Matt:
Ha ha
shawn:
go ahead.
Sam:
all right. I'm going to make a one sentence opinion, then you can ask the question, OK?
shawn:
Okay.
Sam:
So I think any time, to Matt's point, you can get everything out there. To the extent this represents everything, how can that be a bad thing? So I mean, why would I object to that? That's fantastic.
shawn:
Good, good,
Sam:
Sean,
shawn:
good.
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
question.
Matt:
you kinda like things hidden in the dark. You
shawn:
Do
Matt:
don't like
shawn:
you?
Matt:
transparency.
shawn:
Sam does?
Matt:
He
Sam:
the
Matt:
doesn't want pharmaceutical companies to have to tell us what's in their medicine.
shawn:
That's
Sam:
No, they do. That's
Matt:
Oh,
Sam:
the
Matt:
that's
Sam:
whole
Matt:
right,
Sam:
point
Matt:
I
Sam:
of
Matt:
got,
Sam:
regulation.
shawn:
what he wants.
Matt:
that's
Sam:
FDA.
Matt:
right, I was on
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
the other side of that one. Okay,
shawn:
That's
Matt:
sorry.
shawn:
right. That was you. So Sam, yeah, I've been thinking you all week. So I'm like, I really want Sam's take on kind of so I agree that this is an amazing good thing. But here's the only
Matt:
Can
shawn:
my only
Matt:
I ask you a question, Sean?
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
You were thinking of Sam all week? Ha
shawn:
Yes sir.
Sam:
Ha ha
Matt:
ha
Sam:
ha!
Matt:
ha!
shawn:
Yeah, what's wrong with that? Sam is my man.
Matt:
Um, yeah,
Sam:
Fantastic.
Matt:
okay.
shawn:
I only thought of you once, Matt. You're
Sam:
Good.
Matt:
Man!
shawn:
just
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
jealous. Okay, so the only, I think, not danger, but the risk with something like this is, it becomes like this. Like, Matt, you claim as an academic that because this is primary sourced, then all of this information should be trusted.
Matt:
No, no,
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
no.
shawn:
I know, but that's-
Matt:
The source should be trusted. So if Joseph Smith writes a letter to some girl who's his polygamist wife, I can trust that Joseph Smith said that to that girl.
shawn:
Yes, good.
Matt:
But
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
other than that, it doesn't establish anything.
shawn:
Okay,
Sam:
He wasn't a polygamist, you take that back.
shawn:
but Matt, but if, for example, when I was on my mission and started reading the King Follett discourse, right? And I read it in an Inzyne magazine,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
and I read it and I fell in love with it. I really love it. Okay, now as I have the Joseph Smith papers and I have the handwritten manuscript, what I'm realizing as I compare the two is, well, someone made a lot of interpretations on what those words were, because as
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
Wilford Woodruff was fast, quick, trying to write down what Joseph Smith was saying, there's some unclarity in a lot of those words.
Matt:
Sometimes he got it a little wrong.
shawn:
So, yes, what you said is true. As an academic, you can go, well, it's primary source. So Joseph Smith said it, so I can have it. However, the meaning or the interpretation or the intent or the context doesn't exist. So my fear is that many people will just go, oh, well, Joseph Smith said, for example,
Matt:
Mm.
shawn:
Moses did not have the Melchizedek Priesthood. Sorry, didn't say that, sorry, scratch that.
Matt:
Hahahaha!
shawn:
Moses after Moses died, the Melchizedek priesthood did not exist among the he said something to that effect and then he goes into great context and explaining this really fascinating idea about what the priesthood is but a lot of people will just go well Joseph Smith said that and so that is doctrine and that is fact.
Matt:
And what's your question for Sam? This was
shawn:
So
Matt:
you
shawn:
here's
Matt:
thinking
shawn:
the question.
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
about
Sam:
that is
Matt:
Sam?
Sam:
curious.
Matt:
Ha ha
Sam:
Where's
shawn:
Yes,
Sam:
me?
Matt:
ha.
Sam:
Where am
shawn:
absolutely.
Sam:
I in this shot?
shawn:
So Sam, you've mentioned a lot in the past about, and I admire your faith because you living in Utah your whole life, oftentimes
Sam:
Uh...
shawn:
you'll come back to, look, if the church said it, if I read it somewhere and a prophet said it, whether he was a prophet at the time or not, I love your faith because you go, that's what I believe in, right?
Sam:
do. Yeah.
shawn:
Yes, you do. Things like, don't
Matt:
This
shawn:
you?
Matt:
is what you were thinking about with Sam all week?
Sam:
Is he
shawn:
No,
Sam:
listening
shawn:
the-
Sam:
to the podcast regularly?
shawn:
Yeah, Sam, things
Matt:
Isn't
shawn:
like
Matt:
Sam the one
shawn:
things,
Matt:
last week?
shawn:
things like when you when someone says, hey, why don't you talk to your kids on your missions other than twice
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
a year? Oh, because
Sam:
yeah.
shawn:
it's doctrine because it
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
is absolute
Sam:
Got it,
shawn:
because that's what
Sam:
got
shawn:
you
Sam:
it.
shawn:
do. Right.
Matt:
And how he changes. When the church changes, he changes.
shawn:
Yes. Yeah.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
Is that not a fair characterization? It's not a bad thing.
Matt:
That's not the same as saying I found this random quote from Joseph Smith papers, therefore I'm going to say this is the truth forevermore.
shawn:
That is the same thing because Sam,
Matt:
Oh,
shawn:
if
Matt:
okay,
shawn:
I came
Matt:
there's
shawn:
to you and
Matt:
the question.
shawn:
said, hey, Sam, here is a documented primary source, a message that says,
Matt:
The Melchizedek
shawn:
Joseph
Matt:
Priesthood
shawn:
Smith said,
Matt:
wasn't
shawn:
look.
Matt:
on the earth after Moses lalala.
shawn:
Blah blah blah.
Matt:
And Sam will be like, it's in the Joseph Smith papers, now I believe it.
shawn:
It's just an example, Sam, and I'm
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
saying, is there a risk in people going, huh, it says it here in the Joseph Smith papers, this is truth.
Sam:
Your average human being isn't going to read the whole Joseph Smith papers.
Matt:
Let's go further. 1% of the
shawn:
Hahahaha
Matt:
Joseph Smith papers.
Sam:
Yeah. And so
Matt:
In fact,
Sam:
it's,
Matt:
your
Sam:
it's
Matt:
average seminary teacher is only gonna get
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
to 3% of
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
the Joseph Smith papers.
shawn:
Okay,
Sam:
What, what,
shawn:
fine,
Sam:
what these,
shawn:
but for those who are...
Sam:
what, what these are and why they're so good is because information about the church and the church's history has been tightly controlled up until the discovery of the internet
Matt:
Yes.
Sam:
and when the internet became available and all of a sudden all these alternate truths or facts, although you can't say that cause that doesn't even make sense. It
Matt:
Yeah, that makes you sound like a Trump supporter.
Sam:
that's right. That's right.
shawn:
Good luck.
Sam:
What, what's all this other stuff came out? It caused people's shelves to break for whatever reason. Right. Like it became confusing and the church is smart to run after putting all of this out there because you know, at the end of the day, I love the ending of Hamilton, right? Who lives, who dies, who tells the story. Right.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
It's whoever ends up telling the story that ends up controlling the narrative. And when you put everything out there, that actually puts the power in the reader to be critical and to think critically and to understand for their own reasons. So
shawn:
Well, that's
Sam:
it makes it tougher
shawn:
it. And
Sam:
for anybody to refute, I think.
shawn:
that is a good point. One of the descriptions of the Joseph Smith papers is it's not a novel. It's not a descriptive story. It is document after document, and people
Sam:
Probably
shawn:
are
Sam:
not
shawn:
left
Sam:
even
shawn:
on their
Sam:
that interesting
shawn:
own.
Sam:
to read.
shawn:
It's hard to
Sam:
Poem
shawn:
read
Sam:
after
shawn:
for sure.
Sam:
poem, yeah.
Matt:
Volume 2, I got volume 2 as a hardcover and I was like I'm gonna collect them all and then I saw how much they cost To have all of them and I'm like but it's online for free and I
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
would need like a special room in my house for the Joseph
shawn:
Thank
Matt:
Smith
shawn:
you.
Matt:
papers and who cares?
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
It's like a photocopy of a picture of a page
Sam:
You know,
Matt:
or something
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
we should go into business and you remember like the old Britannica encyclopedias
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
that people would go to door to door. We should do, we should call it living Joseph Smith instead of living scripters and we could go door to door. We could sell laundry detergent and we could sell, uh, the
Matt:
vitamins
Sam:
Joseph Smith papers.
Matt:
we
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
put meth
Sam:
That'd
Matt:
in
Sam:
be
Matt:
our vitamins
Sam:
fantastic.
shawn:
Look, I know it's a remote thing, but I guarantee you many people over the next years and years and years are going to start preaching certain doctrines because
Sam:
Okay.
shawn:
they found it in the Joseph Smith papers
Matt:
That's
Sam:
Free
Matt:
okay.
shawn:
that
Sam:
markets,
shawn:
aren't true.
Sam:
free market,
Matt:
I think it's
Sam:
free
Matt:
a...
Sam:
market ideas. That's awesome.
shawn:
Yeah, but I think it's important for us to share that Scripture has been very clear on methods of how we're supposed to discover truth. And the Joseph Smith paper is as valuable as it is, that is using man's methods
Matt:
But,
shawn:
to establish truth.
Matt:
but Sean,
shawn:
Yes, sir.
Matt:
as I mentioned to you when we talked about this off air, the Joseph Smith papers have led to alterations in the standard works.
shawn:
Go ahead.
Matt:
Because if you have the digital copy of the scriptures on the LDS whatever, you're gonna get automatic updates to the text and the content, that if you have the hardbound paper copies, you're not getting those. So when we do family scripture time, and my wife, the Luddite, opens up her paper scriptures
shawn:
Thank
Matt:
and
shawn:
you.
Matt:
starts reading something, we can say, that's not what the scriptures say. And she's like, Yes it is and then we like look and compare, right? So.
shawn:
Yeah, and it's words like thrash versus thrash, right?
Matt:
Right, it used to say thrash and now it says thrash. But there's some other things in there too. There's like a place in the Doctrine and Covenants where it uses this name or this word that means something and they just go back and replace it with the meaning of the word instead of this actual word.
shawn:
Okay, which
Matt:
So it's.
shawn:
is actually you're making my point, right? I know you're not saying, yes, man has discovered the method to discover truth outside of God, right? The historical primary source process is the way to discover truth. I know you're not saying that. It's a little
Sam:
Do you
shawn:
bit what
Sam:
not
shawn:
it sounds
Sam:
like
shawn:
like.
Sam:
the Joseph Smith paper, Sean?
shawn:
I love them, but I'm saying we
Matt:
What
shawn:
need
Matt:
I'm-
shawn:
to be clear that the purpose of them is to provide used man's method to provide primary source documents for Joseph Smith. But the
Matt:
I sit.
shawn:
process that we're supposed to use to discover truth, is study scripture and get revelation and compare all other things against that standard.
Matt:
I see it the opposite of what you're saying. I see it as what we had before the Joseph Smith papers were things that were just handed down. Either somebody said this or somebody put this in a manual or somebody said somebody said this
shawn:
secondary
Matt:
and we all
shawn:
source
Matt:
just believed
shawn:
or heroes
Matt:
it.
shawn:
thing,
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
right?
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
it was a, it was a sanitized correlation, correlated version of the church history.
Matt:
like the white horse prophecy, right? Everybody talks about the white horse and
Sam:
Or in Hatch, yes,
Matt:
the Constitution will hang by a thread.
Sam:
yes.
Matt:
And now you've got everything Joseph Smith ever said
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
and you
shawn:
beautiful.
Matt:
can just search the Joseph Smith papers and say, where is that? And you'll find out that it's nowhere because it didn't come from Joseph Smith. It came from somebody who said Joseph Smith said that on down the
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
line.
shawn:
yeah, great, great.
Matt:
So I think that we're doing the opposite. We're saying, let's get rid of all of this what I would call oral tradition that people believe is true because it was passed down orally. and let's go to the actual source of things. So I see it the opposite.
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
I think
shawn:
that's
Matt:
it's good.
shawn:
good. No, I do think it's good. I'm not saying it's bad. I'm just saying it needs to come with a continued message of don't rely just because some man says that this is the primary source, that this is actual truth and doctrine. Use
Matt:
So.
Sam:
That's
shawn:
the same
Sam:
life.
shawn:
process that God has always come, no, but life is also, you need to pray about things and you need to get revelation about things in order to really know the truth of them. Like the King Follett discourse, that preaches a doctrine that has not been canonized.
Matt:
I know.
shawn:
Therefore, but it's in there, but Matt, you're saying it's in there. Look, primary sources that
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
Joseph Smith
Matt:
I have
shawn:
said
Matt:
no
shawn:
these
Matt:
doubt
shawn:
words.
Matt:
that Joseph Smith said all that stuff,
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
but...
shawn:
so that's my point. So a lot of people, now that they have this primary source document, are going to go everything preached by Joseph Smith in the King Fault Discourse, doctrine and true. My point is careful, careful. That is not the method that God has established through scripture. He says feast upon the words of Christ, then pray to get the Holy Ghost. And that is the process and the method. Right. Do
Sam:
Props.
shawn:
you not agree that people will preach the Looking for discourse now more.
Matt:
I don't think anybody's reading that in the Joseph Smith papers.
shawn:
I am.
Matt:
What I want to do Sean is I want to give you points Because this is the thought provoking in this particular way. You are so skeptical of intellectuals and higher education and
shawn:
That's not
Matt:
institutions
shawn:
it.
Matt:
and You found a way to like take something beautiful like the Joseph Smith
Sam:
Hahaha!
Matt:
papers
shawn:
I know.
Matt:
and turn
Sam:
Ugh...
Matt:
it into an anti-intellectualism rant
shawn:
That's not it.
Matt:
That's what you're getting points for so you want to Wanna just give up your points, Sean? Hahaha!
shawn:
I don't care about the points like you do, Matt.
Sam:
Hey, props to car dealer Larry Miller for using his free market result to pay for this tens of millions
Matt:
Here's
Sam:
of dollars
Matt:
the true test
Sam:
project.
Matt:
of your idea, Sean. If we have a Brigham Young papers next where they give us everything Brigham Young ever said,
shawn:
Yes.
Matt:
then we'll find out,
Sam:
That
Matt:
that's
Sam:
won't
Matt:
right,
Sam:
happen.
Matt:
then we'll find out how
Sam:
That'd
Matt:
much people
Sam:
be.
Matt:
really believe all these
Sam:
That
Matt:
documents.
Sam:
that'd be a little too much transparency.
shawn:
I would love that man. I would absolutely love to have that because it's the same thing, right? There's some like you said, there's so much word of mouth. Like here's what he said. Here's what he didn't say.
Matt:
So there's a biography of Heber J. Grant that Truman Manson did because he was one of Heber J. Grant's grandkids. But Bob Bennett, this former Senator from Utah, was also a grandkid of Heber J. Grant. He was working on his own biography of his grandpa, and we'll never see that because he died before it was done. But I heard from that, now if you get called to be a general authority,
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
all
Sam:
they
Matt:
your
Sam:
take
Matt:
journals,
Sam:
your papers. Yeah.
Matt:
yeah, you
Sam:
They
Matt:
don't
Sam:
take
Matt:
own
Sam:
it
Matt:
it
Sam:
all.
Matt:
anymore.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
So how about if I ever see the Dieter F. Uchtdorf papers, then I'll know the church is being really transparent because they have it all and they could publish it all.
Sam:
That would
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
be interesting. And,
Matt:
Right,
Sam:
and
Matt:
give
Sam:
what,
Matt:
it.
Sam:
and what did his diary look like the night he got
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
released from the first presidency? Wait, what?
Matt:
Ha ha ha!
Sam:
Oh no, we've lost the other third of our audience. Sorry.
Matt:
No, but I honestly like in terms of transparency, I want the diaries like just 10 years ago Let's start 10 years and then work our way back. Let's have all of the president Monson papers out and all the president Hinckley papers Okay, the big question since nobody wants points anymore. I don't know why we even talk about points Nobody even cares Sean told me he doesn't even care about pay points We're gonna go into the big question. The big question is not so complicated and sophisticated this week. It's really simple There was a high school football game I was watching on TV, and this kid's running and he fumbles the football, but the refs don't see that he fumbles it. They think that the ground caused the fumble, and so they rule that it's not a fumble because the ground caused him to fumble. But you can see on the cameras very clearly that this kid fumbled the ball before he hit the ground, and he knew that he fumbled it before he hit the ground, because you would
Sam:
By the
Matt:
have
Sam:
way,
Matt:
to.
Sam:
this happened in college football last week. This wasn't even high school, but go ahead.
Matt:
Right, but I want to do it in high school because that's
Sam:
Okay.
Matt:
where I think it matters. So my question is, you're the high school kid running the ball and they knock it out of your hands and it caused a fumble and then the referee says, not a fumble because the ground caused it. Do you have a moral obligation to raise your hand and say, excuse me, I fumbled that football?
Sam:
You
shawn:
I think
Sam:
do
shawn:
if
Sam:
not.
shawn:
we, oh, Sammy, I think if we as a society teach that, then we are teaching a moral evil. So we disagree,
Matt:
Oh,
shawn:
Sam.
Matt:
well, I mean, with that backdrop, Sam, why don't
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
you tell us what you think? It could
Sam:
because
Matt:
be a moral evil.
Sam:
a game is a game with a set of rules and there are rules around what constitutes a penalty and a foul. There's a rule around the referee's job in that game and the player's job in that game. The ref's job in that game is to make a call to the best of their ability based on the information they have in front of them. The player's job in a lot of cases is to deceive. It, you know, you look like you're running one way and you begin to run the other way, you know, it's full accountability and transparency in the game of football to tell the other player, which way you're going to run
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
and just say, Hey, I'm going this way and keep it like every element of that game has to do with scoring points and the refs, their job is to create order and to call what's a penalty and what's not. And it's inconsistent with that. Uh, you see, you see receivers all the time. Uh, trying to make it look like, you know, somebody to get a past interference penalty, there's deception there and, and one side wins and the other side loses. You watch soccer, right? The flops that happen in soccer. Good. Do soccer
Matt:
Alright,
Sam:
players
Matt:
uh-
Sam:
have a moral responsibility to not flop to NBA back? Can you
Matt:
Yes!
Sam:
imagine the NBA? If there wasn't any flopping, like what fun would that be to watch, right?
shawn:
Matt
Sam:
Or
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
the fights in the NHL. I think in, in the If you're a game of sports, part of it is a little bit of deception and putting on a show and then it's up to the rest to
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
make a call.
shawn:
can I stop you because you started so strong and then you started to kind of get loose there. But I want to stop you because
Matt:
You said flopping.
shawn:
I need to, I need to,
Sam:
I said
shawn:
I need
Sam:
flopping.
shawn:
to repent for my
Sam:
Mm hmm.
shawn:
evil. Yeah, you
Sam:
Oh
shawn:
made a
Sam:
interesting.
shawn:
great point. And I can, I can go back on that with one caveat. So
Sam:
Okay.
shawn:
well said, really
Matt:
No!
shawn:
well explained. No, no, hang on,
Matt:
Hehehehe
shawn:
hang
Sam:
Well said sir, well said!
shawn:
on. One caveat, one caveat. The, so, so in the scenario, like I love what you said. There are
Matt:
What?
shawn:
rules to the game. Hang on, hang on, hang on,
Sam:
What
shawn:
Matt.
Sam:
part do you like? I wonder.
shawn:
There are rules
Sam:
Interesting.
shawn:
to the game and the rules
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
don't, if the rules don't specifically say, hey, in a controversial call, the ref is going to ask the player to make the final decision and has to be honest.
Sam:
But
shawn:
If that
Sam:
yeah,
shawn:
doesn't
Sam:
by the way,
shawn:
exist,
Sam:
yeah.
shawn:
it's a good point. But it's not my son's obligation to interrupt the ref and go, hey, I really did. That's a great point, I do agree with that. However, on Matt's side, I think, what do we teach in our kids in this situation? My
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
kid's never gonna play in the NBA. As good and as talented as he is, What are we teaching our kids in the situation?
Matt:
Yes, you gotta teach him honesty. So listen, it could be the referee's call in the end, but you be honest and at least you tell the referee, hey, I fumbled the ball and the referee can say, hey, stay out of this kid, that's not your role, that's not your job. This is my job to make this call and I don't care what you said.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
But
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
you teach
Sam:
and
Matt:
the kid
Sam:
I,
Matt:
to be honest.
Sam:
and in a high school football game, if the kid did that in front of parents,
Matt:
I know!
Sam:
the parents would eat that kid alive.
shawn:
Peer pressure,
Matt:
But
shawn:
Sam,
Matt:
don't you-
Sam:
So
shawn:
peer
Sam:
I've,
shawn:
pressure,
Sam:
I've
shawn:
huh?
Sam:
seen that happen. I don't, you see it as a question of integrity
Matt:
Yes.
Sam:
and, and moral, uh, you see it as a moral question. And I absolutely don't see it as a moral question. I mean, this happened in college sports last week and the rules say that the refs couldn't look up at the jumbotron. In this case, it was a BYU football game. They could not look up at the Jumbotron to see clearly that the ball hit the ground before
shawn:
They're not allowed
Sam:
the
shawn:
to?
Sam:
receiver. They're not allowed to.
shawn:
Wow.
Matt:
In
Sam:
So
Matt:
college there's different rules of like
Sam:
the coach,
Matt:
when you can
Sam:
the
Matt:
overturn.
Sam:
coach for the other side was pointing up and he was incredulous. He's like, look, just look up at the Jumbotron and the ref would not look up.
shawn:
Matt,
Sam:
He refused to look up.
shawn:
how about a compromise, Matt?
Matt:
Wait, wait,
Sam:
It's against the rules. It was
Matt:
let
Sam:
a
Matt:
me
Sam:
lack
Matt:
make
Sam:
of.
Matt:
my point.
Sam:
Hmm.
Matt:
My point is this.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
Everybody tells me that we need to have sports in school because
Sam:
Mm-hmm.
Matt:
sports teach kids things that they can't learn in the classroom. And we learn about camaraderie and teamwork
Sam:
Socialization.
Matt:
and competition all that.
Sam:
Yep.
Matt:
And honesty and integrity is not going to be on that list.
Sam:
Well, by the
Matt:
And
Sam:
way,
Matt:
sportsmanship isn't going to be on that list.
Sam:
let's talk about what honesty and integrity is because we actually hire people that come from sports for that exact reason. Honesty and integrity is learning that you're a member of a team and it's disciplining your body and your mind and yourself to show up, to give your full effort, to be accountable to your team members for a result. And as a team to hold each other accountable to that result, you absolutely 100% learn integrity.
Matt:
telling the truth isn't part of that.
Sam:
That's
shawn:
HAHAHAHAHAHA
Sam:
it's, listen, I think it's hypocritical as an audience member, as a fan watching from the sidelines, making a judgment call about whether somebody's being honest or not, whether they were in or out of bounds, because that
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
Oh, good point.
Matt:
I don't know whether he told anybody.
shawn:
Good point.
Sam:
everybody, the fans need to get over themselves in, in particular, a lot of times parents need to get over themselves because they have no place in that game. The game has a set of rules
shawn:
Peace.
Sam:
and everybody has a job and a role. And integrity is executing your individual role to the best of your ability and playing to the best for your team. It's not,
shawn:
But Sam,
Sam:
you know.
shawn:
in a scenario where Matt is saying that the student truly knows that they fumbled the ball. Now, Matt, if the ref doesn't
Sam:
Did the ref
shawn:
ask the
Sam:
ask?
shawn:
kid,
Sam:
Did the
shawn:
if
Sam:
ref
shawn:
the ref
Sam:
ask,
shawn:
doesn't,
Sam:
John?
shawn:
yeah, exactly, if the ref doesn't ask, then I don't think he has an obligation to do it.
Sam:
If the
Matt:
I...
Sam:
ref
Matt:
no way.
Sam:
comes up to him and asks, he absolutely should say it.
shawn:
Oh, there we go! There's the
Matt:
It
shawn:
compromise,
Matt:
spills over
shawn:
man.
Matt:
to all these other aspects of life, right? Like, my insurance company
Sam:
It
Matt:
tells
Sam:
doesn't.
Matt:
me, if you hit a car, do not admit
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
fault, right? We like teach people,
Sam:
Wait,
Matt:
you need to behave
Sam:
wait,
Matt:
one,
Sam:
stop.
Matt:
we need to behave
Sam:
Stop
Matt:
one way
Sam:
on
Matt:
in
Sam:
that
Matt:
a, uh-huh.
Sam:
one. Stop on that one. Okay, say what you said again,
Matt:
Insurance
Sam:
because
Matt:
companies
Sam:
I
Matt:
say you shouldn't admit fault if you
Sam:
That's
Matt:
hit
Sam:
right.
Matt:
somebody
Sam:
And, and you know why they tell you that
Matt:
Because
Sam:
it's not
Matt:
they want
Sam:
a
Matt:
to have
Sam:
deception.
Matt:
a legal fine about whether or not because there's a different arena in which we just Determine fault and we determine who's liable and things like that and you're not qualified to make that decision as a driver
Sam:
Well, does the professor who says that nobody's qualified to say anything. But listen, when
Matt:
hahahaha
Sam:
you're involved
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
in a car, have you been in a car accident?
Matt:
No, I have a perfect driving record.
Sam:
Okay. Sean, have you
shawn:
done
Sam:
been
shawn:
or not?
Sam:
involved in a car accident?
shawn:
Yeah, someone hit me.
Sam:
The moment that leads up to a car accident is confusing. It like things happen so fast and your perception of reality and truth can be malleable and it may not even be accurate.
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
So
shawn:
yeah.
Sam:
they say, don't run over to the other person and say, hey,
shawn:
great point.
Sam:
I apologize, that was 100% my fault. I never should have done that. Because your perception is informed on your life experience and it may be your first inclination to accept responsibility for everything and try to make everything right. People don't enter that legal situation usually fully informed about what was right, what wasn't. Your responsibility in that case is to truthfully fill out a police report and then the policeman... takes all the reports, reads them together, and then makes a decision. That actually removes emotion and deception, and
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
a
Matt:
that's right.
Sam:
lot of bad
Matt:
That's the
Sam:
stuff
Matt:
least
Sam:
happens.
Matt:
deceptive process.
shawn:
No!
Sam:
It is! Ha ha ha.
Matt:
Well, and then what happens is kids
Sam:
Oh.
Matt:
in school, they say, my job isn't to do my homework. Their job is to catch me if I'm cheating. And so I'm going to try and cheat and they're going to try and catch me. Like we create all these different scenarios in our minds.
Sam:
Not the same thing because in school they say, here's what constitutes feeding. You're not to feed.
Matt:
And
Sam:
If
Matt:
then...
Sam:
you're not to use cat GPP and you use it, that's clearly
Matt:
And
Sam:
a deception.
Matt:
in football they say, here's what a fumble is.
Sam:
Right, but who's responsible to say it's the ref's job to make that call? It's not the individual player's job.
Matt:
And whose job is it to decide if a student cheated in class?
shawn:
I'm out.
Sam:
It's the students. They're
Matt:
Oh,
Sam:
asked continually, did you cheat? Yes
Matt:
okay. No,
Sam:
or no?
Matt:
I wish we asked them continually.
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
I just feel like in some ways, I'm not saying that, like, I understand why we do all of these things in society, but I think that there's a cumulative effect where adults send kids a message, which is You don't have to be completely honest about everything that happens all the time because there's these other things going on that you can't quite comprehend, that you don't quite understand, and it's better for everyone if you just stay quiet. And I don't know that that's the lesson we want to teach kids. We want to teach kids to be forthcoming and honest.
shawn:
Sam who sold their
Sam:
Listen,
shawn:
birthright for a,
Sam:
listen.
shawn:
what they sell it for Matt?
Matt:
a mess-a-pottage.
shawn:
A mess of potage Sam.
Sam:
but for the world.
Matt:
Well, so, I see there's no harm in the student telling the ref, I fumbled the ball. If the ref decides, if the ref's hands are tied because of the rules, and they say, well, I can't do anything about that anyways because it's not a reviewable play, great! The kid was honest and the ref did their job and everybody's happy. There's nothing wrong with this world of like, everybody's so honest that we have complete information.
Sam:
I know, but Matt, where's the line in that? So a receiver running out trying to make, he's being deceptive in the field of play by trying to make it look like there's pass interference.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Should he not be deceptive in trying to show pass interference when it's not pass interference?
Matt:
I mean, I don't want to be hypocritical because when we play card games, I cheat all the time. I always
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
cheat in games.
Sam:
yeah,
Matt:
But...
Sam:
think about
Matt:
Hahahaha.
Sam:
I've played I've played risk with you.
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
You are the master of deception. So where is integrity in that?
Matt:
Do
Sam:
It's part of the game.
Matt:
you guys ever watch that show Survivor? In Survivor...
Sam:
Wait, are you changing the topic?
Matt:
No, no, it's a similar thing. In Survivor,
Sam:
Okay.
Matt:
they vote people out, right? And so a lot of Survivor is people lying
Sam:
Yeah. Right,
Matt:
to each
Sam:
gamesmanship.
Matt:
other about who they're
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
going to vote for and all that stuff. And I watch that show and I tell my family, If I ever play Survivor, I will be the only honest person.
shawn:
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe hehehe hehehe
Matt:
I will never lie to anybody in the game. And then they're like, but you cheat at
Sam:
You're
Matt:
UNO.
Sam:
lying to them. Yeah. So, Matt, before we go off this sports deal, I want you to answer the question about PI with the receiver. Should receivers not show PI if it's not there?
Matt:
They should not. I disagree with... I understand... I watched a football game today where some kid got like touched on the sideline and then did all this flopping stuff and then there was a 15 yard unnecessary roughness penalty and stuff like that. I understand why they do it
Sam:
Okay,
Matt:
but
Sam:
so
Matt:
it's
Sam:
no,
Matt:
bad.
Sam:
no. I want one more question. A quarterback who decides to run and he, he gives the fake impression he's going to run one way. He ends up going another way. Did he not do that?
Matt:
That's
Sam:
That's
Matt:
different!
Sam:
a deception. How is that different?
Matt:
That's deceiving the other team, not deceiving the officiators. The referees, right?
Sam:
So the line is deception with the refs.
Matt:
If you're trying to deceive the people who enforce the rules to get an unfair advantage in how the rules are applied, we call that cheating. Right?
Sam:
Ha ha
Matt:
That's the
Sam:
ha,
Matt:
same
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
with performance enhancing drugs. Why can't I take performance
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
enhancing drugs?
Sam:
So.
Matt:
Because it gives me an unfair advantage
Sam:
Stop.
Matt:
that everyone else is playing by one set of rules that I'm playing by another.
Sam:
So your line is pass interference and flopping. That's clearly out,
Matt:
My line
Sam:
but
Matt:
is
Sam:
you can
Matt:
the
Sam:
deceive,
Matt:
rules of the game.
Sam:
you can, right.
Matt:
You can't break the rules of the game.
Sam:
Yeah, yeah.
Matt:
And you
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
shouldn't
Sam:
so.
Matt:
try to make it look like the other team did break the rules if they didn't actually break the rules.
Sam:
So. So in your example, it walks out as he's going up the field, he knows he walked out, the ref didn't catch it, so he didn't call it, even though he's not specifically being asked, hey, did you step out? He has a moral obligation to self-report that.
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
Hello?
Sam:
What if he self-reports after the game?
Matt:
It could be that this is why I never played sports at a very high level. They're like, not only is he pretty bad, he's way too honest. He's hurting our team.
Sam:
Well, no, see,
Matt:
Why are
Sam:
here's
Matt:
you out
Sam:
the
Matt:
there
Sam:
thing.
Matt:
telling the ref, I held him,
shawn:
Here's
Matt:
I
shawn:
the,
Matt:
held him?
shawn:
but Sam,
Sam:
Here,
shawn:
but Matt,
Sam:
here's
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
the thing is I think you're, I think you're changing the definition of integrity and you're actually making it tough for honest kids that are actually trying to do their job in sports to show integrity. You're conflating integrity with
Matt:
with honesty.
Sam:
a, with a, no, with a parent and with a, with a fan's view of it versus the player and the refs. Hey, what would be interesting if we have a referee? listening to the show, it would be really
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
interesting
Matt:
let us
Sam:
to
Matt:
know.
Sam:
hear from the ref's perspective, does a player have an obligation to self-report infractions? Or should they... And by the way, Matt,
Matt:
If you know you
Sam:
let's...
Matt:
break the rules,
Sam:
Yes.
Matt:
you should tell somebody. That would be honest and integrity.
Sam:
So, I-15 southbound later
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
Sam:
on today, speed limit 75 miles an hour. If you're going 78, you have an obligation to call up
Matt:
Uh...
Sam:
the Utah Highway Patrol and say, and three miles over.
Matt:
Sam, the speed limit is 70. So
Sam:
Whatever.
Matt:
now we know how much you regard the speed limits. Listen, if I go 71 in the speed zone, if I break the speed limit, I make sure my bishop knows about that in my temple recommended interview.
shawn:
Hahaha!
Matt:
When he says, are you honest in your dealings?
Sam:
But
Matt:
I'm like, well,
Sam:
wait, I'm
Matt:
not
Sam:
curious
Matt:
really.
Sam:
about this though. I'm curious about this. Do you ever speed in front of your kids or anybody else?
Matt:
No, I go
Sam:
You
Matt:
five
Sam:
don't?
Matt:
over. I go five over. Is that speeding?
Sam:
That is speeding. That's five over.
Matt:
Oh
Sam:
You've made a calculation about what you can get away with, how far outside the line, the field of play you can go without getting caught. And you know that if you stay within that five over, you're not gonna get caught, but it's still a moral, it's still a deception.
Matt:
About two years ago I decided I was tired of following traffic laws, that they're just a waste of my time. So I started running red lights. I would like go stop at a red light and if no one was there I would just go.
Sam:
Uh...
Matt:
This one
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
time I was driving my daughter home from the her mission actually. And I'm going to turn left and the people in the left turn lane aren't going and I think they should. So I went into the other lane of traffic to turn left. Yeah, and then my kids started telling me, Dad we're afraid of riding in a vehicle when you're driving.
Sam:
Oh,
Matt:
And
Sam:
I,
Matt:
so I was like,
Sam:
I get,
Matt:
oh.
Sam:
I get that a lot. I get that
Matt:
I gotta
Sam:
a lot
Matt:
go back
Sam:
now.
Matt:
to following
Sam:
Now for the
Matt:
the
Sam:
same
Matt:
law.
Sam:
reasons, I just don't drive good.
Matt:
Ha ha
Sam:
Just kidding. Matt, that was a great topic. Thank you. You in points for the big question on thought provoker. And we
Matt:
Hey,
Sam:
do need to hear from a ref. So any
Matt:
yeah,
Sam:
refs out there, give us your take.
Matt:
let us know. Hey, listener, thanks for joining us. We'll talk to you again next week.
Matt:
Hey welcome to another episode of the Latter Day Lens with Sean, Sam and Matt. It's good to have you with us today. We've got some fun stuff in the mailbag. So Sam, I think this comment is targeted to you. This listener wrote,
Sam:
I bring
Matt:
I think...
Sam:
it.
Matt:
I think Trump has done irreparable damage to the Republican Party, and I don't see myself ever voting for a Republican again until there has been a renaissance of the party, but I don't see that happening. I see both parties going further into the extreme and leaving myself caught in the middle, feeling abandoned by both sides and not wanted by either. I don't see Republicans shifting back to center when I was a campaign advisor for the Washington State Senate race. I remember giving the recommendation to the Republican Party district chair that they need to shift their political views toward the middle if they hope to win any elections in the future. And I was told by the Republican Party district chair to not come to any more Republican Party meetings
Sam:
That's
Matt:
because
Sam:
a solution.
Matt:
they thought their winning strategy was to become more like Trump. They did and the Republican lost in a landslide. And it was an incumbent.
Sam:
So
shawn:
Wow.
Sam:
this feedback, this feedback map proves my point. There is no way the pendulum will swing back towards the middle until people become so frustrated, sick and tired and disgusted with the current state of things that it forces people to shift. And if you listen to the talking heads this past week, there's already talk of Republicans pushing, pushing back to the middle and a little bit of surprise that it hasn't happened yet. So that to me, When you think about economic cycles and you think about political cycles and historical cycles, it has to go into the frustrated beyond belief. And it sounds like one of our listeners is, but there's clearly not enough Republicans that are frustrated with the current state of things to start the push back to the middle, but
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
it
Matt:
so
Sam:
will happen. It has to happen. Right.
Matt:
there was another listener that said that if you look at like historically where the parties have been on various issues, what we consider far right today would have been considered liberal in like the 1970s.
Sam:
Yes.
Matt:
And what's considered moderate today would have been liberal, right? And so this listener argues that things gradually make a leftward shift over time.
Sam:
Mmm
Matt:
And so that would kind of go contrary to your idea of this pendulum swinging back and forth. Right? Because
Sam:
or,
Matt:
they're not going to move to the middle.
Sam:
yeah, I, I cannot help but believe Trump pushed everything to the left a little bit because he was formerly a Democrat and he speaks outrageously, right? He's drugged the Republican party into a place that it's not used to being. It will swing back. I think I
Matt:
But
Sam:
could be wrong though.
Matt:
then you would say people like Vivek Ramaswamy and Ron DeSantis, they're not the future of the Republican Party.
Sam:
Oh, no way.
shawn:
Hehehehehehe
Sam:
They're, they're, uh, they're, they're basically Trump too. Right. They're
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Trump too. There will be, there will be calmer heads that will prevail. Ultimately that will bring it back to the middle. Paul Ryan. I mean, really, you know, I don't know as an adult, I look back at what Reagan did. You know, Reagan was what
Matt:
A communist.
Sam:
it meant to be.
Matt:
Ha
Sam:
And he was not a communist.
Matt:
ha!
Sam:
He was what it meant to be a Republican, uh, back in the eighties and nineties. And he set a standard that everyone has sought to emulate even from in his early campaign, and
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
I've got
Matt:
I
Sam:
to
Matt:
don't
Sam:
believe
Matt:
know that
Sam:
it
Matt:
Obama,
Sam:
goes back to that at some
Matt:
Obama's
Sam:
point.
Matt:
not trying to emulate Reagan. You're
Sam:
No,
Matt:
meaning
Sam:
no, no. I mean, Republicans.
Matt:
Republicans.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
All
Matt:
Sean,
Sam:
Republicans.
Matt:
what do you think?
shawn:
I think well done for this listener for being involved in politics. That's what's
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
needed. Because you two
Sam:
I
shawn:
won't do it,
Sam:
nice
Matt:
What
shawn:
and
Sam:
job
Matt:
are you
shawn:
I
Sam:
getting
Matt:
talking
shawn:
won't
Matt:
about?
shawn:
do it.
Sam:
nice job getting
Matt:
Oh.
Sam:
picked out of the Republican Party meetings, by the way. I mean, there has to be
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
more to that story. What did this person say about the current state that caused them to get the boot? Like, you know, they'll
Matt:
That
Sam:
take
Matt:
happens.
Sam:
money.
shawn:
But that's the message that we've given many times in the past, you guys, is the best thing that we can do is to have everyone get involved a bit in politics at any level. That's
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
what the church promotes. So this guy who's doing the right thing and talking to some idiot, lifelong political,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
to be able to get in his face and be like, you're doing the wrong thing. Well, if we had enough of those voices, then that's the solution, isn't it? I mean, you can't just wait for the leadership to switch. You can't, right Sam? You can't just wait and go, okay, well hopefully it swings. We have to be the ones that make it swing, aren't we?
Matt:
I don't know, I started watching that Netflix series, Narcos. Have you guys seen Narcos?
shawn:
or no.
Matt:
It's about the drug trade in Colombia. You have to watch it with VidAngel, or it's pretty naughty stuff. But anyhow, in that show all the good guys die and get tortured and killed
Sam:
Uhhh...
Matt:
and stuff. And so there's sometimes I say, I don't know, maybe we shouldn't get involved in politics.
shawn:
What the heck?
Matt:
Maybe sometimes you just let the bad guys win,
shawn:
Wait
Matt:
and not...
shawn:
a minute, wait a minute. Your train of thought was, we should do the right thing and get involved, and then you watched a TV show
Matt:
Ha
shawn:
where
Matt:
ha!
shawn:
good guys died, and you said, oh, I better not do that.
Matt:
It
shawn:
Oh,
Matt:
sometimes
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
feels like the good guys get killed. And I was reading in Helaman, you know, those like five guys who, like Nephi says, Hey, your chief judge has been murdered. And there's those five guys that say, let's go find out if he's really been murdered. And then they run and then he has been murdered. And then they like fall down and then they get arrested and put in jail for something they didn't do. And I think maybe it would have been better if they'd just hung out at the wall of Nephi and not done anything at all. And it just sort of said, Hmm, I wonder if he's right.
shawn:
I mean, Matt, the DNC does say that we should be anxiously engaged in good causes, right? Do things of
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
our own free will,
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
right? The powers in us to be agents and choose. Like,
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
shouldn't
Matt:
alright.
shawn:
we, hasn't the church pushed us to be involved in politics?
Matt:
It's just a mood I'm in probably today. Yeah, I think you're right. I think that people
shawn:
Hehehehe.
Matt:
should get
shawn:
Hahaha.
Matt:
involved. Okay, this other listener. So Sam last time talked about Biden negotiating drug prices and interference in the market and things like that. And they said, it seems unfair for big pharma to enjoy government protection of their patents when it's convenient and then complain about government meddling from the other side of their mouth. Medicine is a hard place for capitalism to operate. Unregulated markets have so many problems here. Demand is almost completely inelastic. He defines this for us, meaning a higher price does not reduce the amount demanded. If it saves your life, you're not gonna do without when the price gets too high. Meanwhile, patents mess up the supply curve. When you add patent protection, you create a monopoly, again, defining this for us, meaning that one supplier controls the whole market. And the price signals on the supply side stop working as well. But if you don't enforce patents, you ruin the incentives for medical research, kind of. When the price signals on both the supply side and the demand side are broken, how should the price be set? Question. I know that's not for me.
Sam:
Why didn't this person define a patent? I would have appreciated that. No,
Matt:
Hahahaha
Sam:
I'm kidding. That's such a... So listen, think about this. There is massive cost of bringing medicine to market in the United States. The FTC has a high bar. It requires, for every medication that makes it to market, and by the way, I have no experience in this, so I don't know what I'm talking about, but I think this is true. For
Matt:
But this
Sam:
every...
Matt:
could be like a fun experiment for us as a podcast. We could try
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
to bring a drug to market and see what it costs
Sam:
Like,
Matt:
us.
Sam:
well, but here's the thing for every drug that successfully comes to market and creates revenue and profit for the farm company. There are thousands. There are a lot. I'm not going to make up a number. There are many, many that fail. And so
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
all the expense associated with those failed tests and medications end up going into the cost that ends up being borne by the US consumer. for that successful medication.
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
And listen,
shawn:
not only that.
Sam:
there is no other country on the face of planet Earth that has been successful, like the United States has, not a single one, at
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
bringing innovation and successful medications to the marketplace. And so if you say, we're not gonna have a patent, the patent ultimately protects the pharmaceutical company which takes the risk. We're not gonna have a patent, and everybody, as soon as that medication hits the market, it's free game, like that won't work.
Matt:
But Sam, a patent is government interference in a market.
shawn:
it is.
Sam:
A patent is protection against stealing of intellectual property
Matt:
enforced by...
Sam:
in a market. Pardon
Matt:
enforced
Sam:
me?
Matt:
by a government.
Sam:
It is enforced by the government. Yeah, that's correct.
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
So you're happy.
Matt:
So the listener is saying, hey, we've got government interference in that market anyways. It's not a free market because you have government interference on the one side.
shawn:
It's two-faced.
Sam:
the dumbest thing ever. That's ridiculous.
Matt:
Hahahaha
shawn:
It's- no,
Sam:
It's
shawn:
that's true, Sam.
Sam:
not two-faced. It prevents intellectual theft.
shawn:
That's the point of the question, Sam,
Matt:
So
shawn:
is that it's...
Matt:
the government is artificially reducing supply on the one side, and then you're saying they can't artificially manipulate demand on the other side.
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
So.
Sam:
listen, the patent holder could say, hey, look, I'm going to bring a medication to market and I'm going to give no transparency behind what's in the market, what's in the medication. I'm not going to give any transparency behind the testing that went to bring it to market and consumers need to just have faith that this medicine will work. That would be the flip side of no patent. Instead, The government is involved vis-a-vis the FTC in an approval process where the farm company has to be fully transparent about what goes into that medication, the trials and the testing that happen. So yes, it is government regulation and interference, but it has to happen to offset the transparency the farm companies have to have to bring that medication to market. If there
Matt:
Good
Sam:
wasn't
shawn:
Not.
Matt:
feeling.
Sam:
any transparency and if they could be secret about it, they'd
shawn:
That's
Sam:
probably
shawn:
it.
Sam:
prefer that and then it'd be a free for all. But ultimately the consumer would be harmed.
shawn:
You sound like a confused capitalist is what you're saying.
Sam:
No, I'm
Matt:
No,
Sam:
not.
Matt:
he doesn't.
Sam:
I'm actually not.
Matt:
So the flip side of the FDA approval process for drugs is the vitamin industry. That's an unregulated market where you don't have to disclose what's in your vitamin or your supplement or whatever. That's
Sam:
Did I
Matt:
all
Sam:
say FTC?
Matt:
re...
Sam:
I meant FDA. That's right. Thank
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
you.
Matt:
yeah, that's fine. But so we do have that, right? We know exactly what it would look like if pharmaceutical companies did not have patents on their drugs. But what happened is it would be regulated just like the GNC stuff that you see and you don't know what's in it. They put the little nutrition label there, but there's no quality controls. If you go to the hospital and you say, hey, I want some vitamin D, they can't just go buy it from GNC because they don't know that the vitamin D at GNC is actually the right dose, the right amount. So they actually have to get like an FDA approved vitamin D as an example, right? So that's why drugs in hospitals cost so much more. You say, Why am I paying so much for a multivitamin when I can buy it at Walmart for cheap because hospitals are trying to regulate the dosage? So we do know what that market would look like.
shawn:
We've it we
Matt:
I just wonder if maybe that's better. Why don't we just have all drugs be like GNC vitamins and supplements
shawn:
Oh,
Sam:
What?
shawn:
now
Matt:
and
shawn:
Matt's
Matt:
say,
shawn:
arguing. But
Matt:
take.
shawn:
we know, but hang on, Matt, we know before 62,
Sam:
Sane.
shawn:
we know the other, that it's even worse than that, right? Because before 62, there were some major, major cases. There's a drug called thalidomide
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
that killed a lot of people.
Matt:
Yeah, it happens
shawn:
And
Matt:
in the supplements.
shawn:
well, but that was,
Sam:
Arsenic killed
shawn:
but
Sam:
a lot
shawn:
those are
Sam:
back
shawn:
the,
Sam:
in the 60s
shawn:
it doesn't kill, I don't think it kills as many people as thalidomide and all these other drugs. But those are the things that sparked more regulation, more regulation, more regulation. And. Here's an interesting idea though, Matt. Well, two things. I have two questions for you. The government and the market, didn't they kind of compromise? Because patents are only, what? For pharmaceuticals that are approved by the FDA, they're only monopolies
Matt:
Six years,
shawn:
for 12
Matt:
seven
shawn:
years.
Matt:
years,
shawn:
I think it's
Matt:
I was
shawn:
12
Matt:
at 12,
shawn:
years.
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
And then after that, they're forced to go public. So
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
isn't that a decent compromise? You've got a patent, right? To directly answer the question. Why not?
Matt:
Um...
shawn:
Because if they owned a lifetime patent, yeah, they could price fix and do really
Matt:
So
shawn:
some pretty nasty things,
Matt:
the problem
shawn:
but.
Matt:
with the American, so Sam's right. We develop a lot of drugs that other countries don't develop and guess what they do? They put price fixes on those drugs in the European Union and in other countries. They say, thank you for this AIDS drug. You can only charge this much for it. And so what happens is the American consumer is not just only, they're not only subsidizing the cost to bring that drug to market, they're also subsidizing the price reductions enforced in other countries around the world. So. So when it comes to this question of how long should they have a patent and how much should they be able to charge? I think we have to come up with like this really does I think need to be a global solution It seems really bad to me that someone in Mexico In fact, I can go to Mexico and buy the exact same drug at a lower price than I can buy it in the United States Because Mexico has laws that you can only charge so much for it So the United States we just pay so much more for our medicine than we otherwise would and so then I say What benefit is it to me to be in the United States health system when Mexico gets all of the drugs that we develop
Sam:
Really?
Matt:
at a better price than what I get in the United States?
shawn:
But how are you going to have a global fix on
Matt:
You
shawn:
prices?
Matt:
just need to have, it's a, almost every commodity these days is in a global economy, right? You can buy and sell it anywhere in the world. So it doesn't make sense to me for all these countries to have these various different rules and like, you know, you guys see how many people go to Mexico just for drugs, right? And just for healthcare because it's so much less expensive there. And they're using the same stuff we're using. And sometimes you get kidnapped and killed and stuff like that, but.
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
Sam, I have a second question for you, since you sound like you're the pro regulation guy. Which is surprising to me.
Matt:
No, he's only...
Sam:
No, I'm not pro-regulation.
shawn:
You preached
Matt:
He's...
shawn:
it.
Sam:
I'm actually pro-regulation when the regulation begins. So again, if government is gonna require transparency to approve medication, it needs to give a patent in exchange for that transparency. Otherwise,
shawn:
They do.
Sam:
no, I know they do. So that's.
Matt:
Or you
shawn:
Oh,
Matt:
can
shawn:
you're
Matt:
do
shawn:
saying
Matt:
it like
shawn:
it's
Matt:
vitamins.
shawn:
a good system, yeah.
Matt:
I'm saying
shawn:
The
Matt:
do
shawn:
Sam,
Matt:
it like vitamins.
shawn:
here's, yeah, but Sam, here's the question since you've seen pro-regulation.
Sam:
Interfere on
shawn:
Since,
Sam:
it would be just
shawn:
since.
Matt:
Hahahaha
Sam:
whatever you get at GNC. We can all go to GNC. That'd be great CVS
Matt:
Hey you guys,
Sam:
and Walgreens would be out of business
Matt:
you should Google this. It's called Craze. It was in 2013. It was this like supplement that everybody was taking. I think it was called Craze. And they're like, I have so much energy. But people were like, but it's like addictive. I can't stop taking it. And so then
Sam:
Math.
Matt:
there was this, yeah it was meth. A food science
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
professor was like, let's see what's in Craze. Meth. They're just taking meth and putting it in a
shawn:
When
Matt:
vitamin
shawn:
was that?
Matt:
supplement.
shawn:
When was that?
Matt:
When did they get caught? 2013. How much did they make before they were caught? A whole lot of money.
shawn:
Are you
Sam:
That's
shawn:
kidding
Sam:
more money
shawn:
me dude?
Sam:
than the people that smuggled all those aluminum cans into California, probably. I
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
bet they did better than that way back
shawn:
that's
Sam:
when.
shawn:
hilarious.
Sam:
Listen,
shawn:
Okay, Sam, I got a question for you.
Sam:
I would accept. Wouldn't, well, you go ahead, John, and then I'll ask this last question.
shawn:
Since 1962, when these big cases dropped down and regulation really started to ramp up for pharmaceuticals, the innovation has dropped by more than 50% since 1962.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
In other words, the innovation that regulation has squashed is now preventing people from being helped and saved from diseases because... Now the process is like before it was like a 12 month on average process
Sam:
Yeah, but,
shawn:
and about a million
Sam:
but.
shawn:
dollars. Now it's an eight year process, $52 million.
Sam:
But Sean, you're tying the decrease in innovation, which I'm not even sure is correct, you're tying that to regulation. I would argue that maybe it's less that and more the complexity of innovation. Now the cost to innovate and bring it to market.
shawn:
because
Sam:
And
shawn:
of
Sam:
then
shawn:
regulation.
Sam:
also, and then, and then
shawn:
That's
Sam:
also,
shawn:
the cost.
Matt:
Ha ha ha.
Sam:
and then also the ultimate cost in lawsuits against these companies for medication
shawn:
That's
Sam:
that
shawn:
the proper.
Sam:
is not good. Right. So you think about
shawn:
So Milton Friedman argued that that's the proper fix against, it's not regulation, regulation. The cost increases come from regulation. So I did work in the farm industry for about five years. And I
Matt:
What?
shawn:
was fascinated,
Matt:
Don't
shawn:
I
Matt:
you
shawn:
did.
Matt:
feel dirty inside? How do you ever wash that from your soul,
Sam:
Ish. Gosh.
Matt:
Sean?
shawn:
Whoa, dang.
Matt:
I'm just playing. How dare you heal people for a living.
Sam:
Ha ha.
shawn:
So the regulatory departments within this company were giant, huge staffs.
Sam:
How much
shawn:
And they...
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
did they pay you?
Matt:
of...
Sam:
How much did they pay you at GNC? By the way,
Matt:
Hahaha! Were you guys
Sam:
was
Matt:
selling
Sam:
it a lot?
Matt:
meth? Hahaha!
shawn:
That's not pharma.
Matt:
Of course they have huge staff.
shawn:
huge staff and they're very dedicated. Their only job is to go, okay, what is the regulatory laws? We
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
need to comply. And so they would bottleneck the whole process, rightfully so, because these drugs won't pass
Sam:
So,
shawn:
unless you are compliant.
Sam:
so you're saying eliminate the entire FDA approval process, allow
shawn:
no i'm not,
Sam:
companies
shawn:
i'm not-
Sam:
to bring whatever drug to market
shawn:
well,
Sam:
and claim
shawn:
i'm just-
Sam:
whatever
Matt:
Yes.
Sam:
they
shawn:
i'm just
Sam:
want.
shawn:
suggest-
Matt:
Yes,
shawn:
i'm just
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
suggest-
Matt:
saying that.
shawn:
oh matt's
Sam:
Interesting.
shawn:
saying that matt- it's-
Matt:
Listen, that
shawn:
it's
Matt:
COVID
shawn:
so funny-
Matt:
vaccine, the COVID vaccine we knew by May, like we knew in May that COVID vaccine was going to be just fine. And we should have taken the Russia approach and we should have said anyone who wants to come get it for free now and you can be our guinea pigs. And we should have bypassed all of that, like regulation stuff that they made Moderna go through.
Sam:
Can
Matt:
Like
Sam:
you imagine,
Matt:
you-
shawn:
I love how unpredictable
Sam:
can
shawn:
you
Sam:
you
shawn:
guys
Sam:
imagine
shawn:
are.
Sam:
the conspiracy
Matt:
Ha ha
Sam:
theories that would have landed on that? You thought you think the conspiracy theories are bad today, right? Like
Matt:
But
Sam:
Bill
Matt:
that's
Sam:
Gates
Matt:
exactly...
Sam:
is trying to infect everyone. Like it'd be three times as bad if GNC was distributing the COVID vaccine.
Matt:
But it's exactly what Israel did and they're fine. Things turned out okay there. And
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
we would
Sam:
but...
Matt:
have had fewer, the shutdowns wouldn't have been as long. It wouldn't have been as tough on the economy.
Sam:
But,
Matt:
Wouldn't
Sam:
but
Matt:
have been
Sam:
it's
Matt:
masking
Sam:
an asterisk.
Matt:
for as long.
Sam:
It's an asterisk, right? Israel doesn't take that approach to other medications, right? You can't, you
Matt:
We
Sam:
know,
Matt:
should though. I say, I
Sam:
interesting.
Matt:
say, why not? Right?
shawn:
liberal.
Sam:
I don't
Matt:
Let
Sam:
know
Matt:
people
Sam:
enough
Matt:
make...
Sam:
about the topic to say yes or no, but, but we should have our listeners write in what they think because I'm fascinated by this.
shawn:
liberal Matt is arguing for
Matt:
I'm...
shawn:
no government regulation. Supposedly capitalist Sam is saying regulate,
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
regulate.
Sam:
no,
shawn:
You guys are awesome.
Sam:
listen, this is consistent for Matt because Matt, you're
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
in academia and academia sees no, like it's science and
Matt:
Yes.
Sam:
it's quantifiable. And if it's just quickly following the science. So you're advocating
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
for more rapidly following the rabbit hole of science down to the solution. And then as soon as you've got it, pop that pop that baby out. Right. And
Matt:
That's what
Sam:
like,
Matt:
I say.
Sam:
yeah,
Matt:
Well, and I
Sam:
interesting.
Matt:
say people should have choice. Like,
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
the information's all out there. So, as if...
shawn:
Matt, you've argued so much in the past about the government's role is to protect consumers. So if there's no regulatory process, people are putting out drugs. Now it's true that a pharmaceutical company, his intention is to do the right thing, but then when they make a mistake and
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
2,000 people die, how is that not protecting the...
Matt:
You protect consumers by allowing them to sue companies for
shawn:
Wow,
Matt:
misdeeds.
shawn:
Milton
Matt:
That's
shawn:
Friedman!
Matt:
how you protect consumers.
shawn:
Matt, you are
Matt:
So
shawn:
Milton Friedman
Matt:
it's just
shawn:
right
Matt:
like
shawn:
now. That's
Matt:
the GNC
shawn:
awesome!
Matt:
stuff, right? I can go take whatever supplements I want to take, and if it causes me harm or does damage to me, there was a man that he was taking some supplement and he started growing female breasts, and he was like, what in the world is happening? This isn't supposed to be in my multivitamin. And then they found out that the place making his vitamins, they were doing estrogen. pills and the multivitamin in the same room and there was cross contamination and so he's getting
Sam:
are bad,
Matt:
he's
Sam:
are
Matt:
getting
Sam:
bad.
Matt:
a lot of estrogen in his daily multivitamin
Sam:
So.
shawn:
And he
Matt:
so
shawn:
sued.
Matt:
he sues the company
shawn:
Yeah, right.
Matt:
and then the company has to like make changes like why
shawn:
Sam,
Matt:
would we not do that with everything
shawn:
Matt truly is a conservative. This is straight out of Milton Friedman's books.
Sam:
So, so does, does the cost of those medications end up being where they are today because of the lawsuits, because successful
Matt:
notes
Sam:
lawsuits ended up driving costs north substantially, right?
shawn:
Milton
Sam:
You think
shawn:
Friedman
Sam:
about
shawn:
argued that it's way less because the incentive for
Sam:
Who's
shawn:
a pharmaceutical
Sam:
this Milton
shawn:
company
Sam:
Friedman? I don't know who that is. Getting it. If,
Matt:
He invented the game Monopoly.
Sam:
if, oh,
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
all right. I thought it was shoots and ladders. So my bad.
shawn:
We'll put it in the notes. I've got all of his studies that show that the regulations have caused way more higher price hikes
Matt:
For sure.
shawn:
than the lawsuits have.
Matt:
My problem with the FDA approval process is that it gives people a sense of confidence that everything's fine when maybe it isn't fine. And so then you get people prescribing Oxycontin, for example, right? And they say, you're feeling pain? Take this drug. And nobody thinks, let me do some research on this drug because the doctor told me it's okay and the FDA told me it's okay. And so people put blind trust in that system. Whereas if I go into GNC and say I'm feeling pain and they say take this little powder most people are going to research that a little bit because they'll say
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
that person behind the counter doesn't necessarily know what's best for me. So I
shawn:
I'm
Matt:
don't
shawn:
so
Matt:
know.
shawn:
happy to hear you talk like this, Matt. The anti-government guy. I love it.
Matt:
Okay, well this is actually a decent segue into Sam's question on the Thought Provoker. So
shawn:
It's a good question,
Matt:
last
shawn:
Sam.
Matt:
week I think I won every Thought Provoker segment.
Sam:
Interesting.
Matt:
Let's see
Sam:
Very good.
Matt:
if we can continue that this week. Sam, what's your Thought Provoker question?
Sam:
So the thought provoker question is simple. Is healthcare in the United States of America a right or is it a privilege? Matt.
Matt:
Wait, we just have to answer that? You're not gonna give
Sam:
Yes,
Matt:
like any kind of a background
Sam:
I'm not.
Matt:
or anything like that?
Sam:
You know what? You backfilled this with a lot of data that I
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
dispute. So you can bring your
Matt:
Oh,
Sam:
data
Matt:
okay.
Sam:
in if you want, and then
Matt:
No, no,
Sam:
we can
Matt:
I only,
Sam:
bring it there.
Matt:
I only put those links in for listeners if they want to look into
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
that. Okay, so the oath of office that the president takes when they're
Sam:
That's
Matt:
sworn
Sam:
where we're
Matt:
in as,
Sam:
starting?
Matt:
well, we've got to discuss rights in the United States.
Sam:
Okay, very good.
Matt:
So
Sam:
All
Matt:
the
Sam:
right,
Matt:
constitution,
Sam:
go ahead.
Matt:
the oath of office the president takes is to defend, I think it's America, but we'll just say American people,
Sam:
Mm-hmm.
Matt:
against all enemies. foreign and domestic.
Sam:
Mm-hmm.
Matt:
And a virus and a bacteria is an enemy, and
Sam:
Mm-hmm.
Matt:
the president therefore has a right or an obligation to defend our bodies from all potential enemies.
shawn:
Wow.
Sam:
What?
Matt:
And so we have a right to be protected from bacteria and viruses.
Sam:
What, what about McDonald's and the impact that McDonald's has on your body when you eat it every day?
Matt:
Yeah, well, it has two effects. There's the taste bud effect, and
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
then there's the there's
Sam:
Ha.
Matt:
the what it does to your body effect I think absolute I think if we thought of health care as a right the way that we think So in the declaration of independence, we say we have the right to life liberty and the pursuit of happiness If we thought of health as a right the way that we think of life and liberty as rights We would do things fundamentally different in society But I think it's a right. I think Individuals have the right to have, let's say, just basic health care.
Sam:
John?
shawn:
So to me, it boils down to this. The providers of healthcare are individual humans who become expert at healthcare. So in order to, if you were to argue that it's a right,
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
how are you going to force, because you'd have to force quality experts to provide healthcare. I don't see how you can make it a right.
Matt:
We do that right now, right?
shawn:
How do
Sam:
That's
shawn:
we force?
Sam:
the Hippocratic Oath.
Matt:
Like
Sam:
Hippocratic Oath, yeah.
Matt:
if I go into the emergency room, they have to treat me whether or not I can afford to pay for it.
shawn:
If you need a surgery, they don't have to treat you. They can give you... No, no, no. So when people go into the ER with a heart attack, the doctors check their vitals. If they get a real lot of heart attack, they give them a bunch of pills and say, you just have an anxiety, get out of here, go home. That's treatment.
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
That's
Matt:
No,
shawn:
government.
Matt:
no, that's not treatment
shawn:
No, that is treatment. That's government forced treatment is what that is.
Matt:
Okay, let me say it in a broader way
shawn:
They had a right to that treatment and they got their right fulfilled.
Matt:
I say that, okay, so I think that individuals have a right to be educated. Like, education, I would say, is a right that people have. And because education is a right, we require things of citizens that places that don't think of education as a right would require them, right? So we require that people get basic proficiency in reading and math and science because we say society is going to be better. if we teach people to like forego their natural instincts and like discipline their minds to learn these certain things. I think we...
shawn:
And as a forest right, as a government solution, what percentage of the people don't actually leave the school system with that knowledge?
Matt:
I think literacy in the United States is over 80%. Which is
shawn:
what
Matt:
pretty good.
shawn:
and that's the goal. You're saying it's a right for people to be literate. And so the government
Matt:
I think that
shawn:
comes in with a solution.
Matt:
you can't have a properly functioning society without basic levels of literacy and understanding of math and science. So when I say healthcare is a right, I think of it in a similar way. Healthcare is a right because whether we like it or not, the government pays most of the costs of healthcare in the United States. Because poor people and old people are the ones using most of the healthcare, at least they're the most expensive, and those things are covered by the government. So I think that, I say healthcare is a right because I think that citizens have certain obligations associated with healthcare, and the government should expect things of citizens related to healthcare, and then in exchange, the government promises certain outcomes. So that's why I think of it as like a right.
shawn:
What do you say, son?
Matt:
A right has benefits and obligations that are expected of you.
shawn:
What do you
Sam:
So
shawn:
think, Sam?
Sam:
my take is healthcare is mostly a privilege, but there's also a portion that's a right. So at the end of the day, the way insurance works is very similar to the way the government is funding healthcare anyway. It's through taxes. So people pay into entities, right? Insurance companies or Medicare, Medicaid, through taxes, and then claims or medical care gets paid out through that. I think where the... So when it comes to like death... situations, nobody's going to sit around. And if someone needs a heart, you know, heart transplant might even be a tough
Matt:
A pacemaker.
Sam:
one, but yeah, if they've got like just a terrible thing, that's a life or death, the Hippocratic oath to Matt's point, ER care, they're going to find a way to provide that, that life or death care for the person. I think where our system is broken is healthcare goes a little bit beyond that, um, emergency medical care in a hospital and it goes to help. As blessed a nation as we are, as much money as we have, as much opportunity as we have, we are broken people health-wise. We
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
make continually really bad decisions about work exercising and about what we eat and about how we live and little we sleep. And that part has a massive burden on the health care system. If in the United States, people could somehow wrap their minds around health care being a privilege. and would embrace the idea of, all right, how do I make myself healthier so that I don't burden this system as much? Basic medical care would cost less and there would be less pressure on it. The problem is, in a free market world, you know, medicine companies want you to consume medicines. And so, you know, they tout the best path to dealing with your cholesterol problem is to take this medication. It's not to get healthy. Right. But
shawn:
So.
Sam:
We people, Sean, Matt, me, we shouldn't pay for somebody that continually eats at McDonald's and needs to go on cholesterol medication, which is expensive. And what the government has done recently, which I think is infringing on the free market is they're driving down artificially the cost of cholesterol medication, eliminating the social cost to making bad health decisions. And it's a vicious cycle that'll just continue to repeat and repeat and repeat. There's got to be a way to fix that element. So that's one component. The second component that I think is super interesting about this whole debate is why healthcare is so deeply tied to employment. And
Matt:
This
Sam:
it's
Matt:
is
Sam:
something,
Matt:
all, these have
Sam:
it's,
Matt:
the same answer, Sam.
Sam:
it's something.
Matt:
It's called the American Medical Association. And it's the reason that drugs cost so much.
Sam:
Oh
Matt:
And it's the reason that everything...
Sam:
no, I smell a conspiracy theory coming, lay it
Matt:
Sam,
Sam:
on us Matt.
Matt:
it's not a conspiracy theory. I forgot to send you this book. We used to have healthcare in the United
Sam:
I might have
Matt:
States
Sam:
forgot
Matt:
that
Sam:
to read it if you send it. No,
Matt:
it
Sam:
go
Matt:
was
Sam:
ahead.
Matt:
not tied to employment. That was a decision that was made
Sam:
World
Matt:
in the
Sam:
War
Matt:
1930s.
Sam:
II. Yep.
Matt:
So the United Kingdom is gonna have nationalized medicine. and the United States says, we don't want that, what can we do? So the American Medical Association gets together with the insurance providers of America and they start working out a plan of like, how can we do this? And the insurance providers of America go to Congress and they say, we would like you to provide a tax incentive to any businesses that use health insurance to provide healthcare. Because before that, there were all these different kinds of systems, many of which were more cost effective. So they get. Congress passed that law, and then the insurance companies collude together to price everybody else out of the market. And they lost
shawn:
Mm.
Matt:
money for 10 years,
Sam:
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Matt:
and once everybody was out of the market, then in the 1960s, when there begins this push from Medicaid and Medicare, then the insurance companies say, we're on board with that, and then they start raising the prices.
shawn:
Mmm!
Matt:
And you can see advertisements from the time where the insurance companies say, are you going on vacation? Don't hire a babysitter. send your kids to the hospital. It's way cheaper than
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
having a babysitter. Go
Sam:
That's
Matt:
on
Sam:
awesome.
Matt:
a two, yeah. And look at the price to have a baby in 1960. Somebody like posted a receipt of the bill for giving birth at LDS Hospital in 1960. It was 160 bucks a birth
shawn:
Mm-mm, mm.
Matt:
because they're artificially lowering the prices to get everybody else out of the market.
shawn:
Wow.
Sam:
So I thought the employer sponsored healthcare was more about attracting and retaining employees post-World War II and creating that competitive marketplace. Obviously the cost of healthcare today outstrips that need and it
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
would be interesting to find a way to remove healthcare as a component of employment, make that more of a free market decision attached to buying not to where you work,
Matt:
I think it's
Sam:
and,
Matt:
a great idea. Do you know what
Sam:
and
Matt:
we call that idea, Sam? We
Sam:
Obamacare.
Matt:
call that Medicare for all. That's
Sam:
Right,
Matt:
exactly
Sam:
right.
Matt:
what Medicare for all is. It says
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
anyone who wants insurance, you can purchase Medicare, and you don't
Sam:
Mm-hmm.
Matt:
have to have an employer help you get your insurance.
Sam:
Mm hmm.
Matt:
That's a beautiful idea. I'm on
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
board.
Sam:
and with that you flip back. So that's great.
Matt:
Sam, you win the thought provoker. You used a conservative
shawn:
Oh man...
Matt:
argument
shawn:
Too
Matt:
to
shawn:
agree
Matt:
persuade
shawn:
with Matt. Ha
Matt:
me
shawn:
ha
Matt:
to support Medicare for All.
shawn:
ha!
Sam:
Yeah, but so how do you in Medicare for all because I'm not supporting it because I think
Matt:
Oh
Sam:
when you when you when you take away free markets, it becomes less competitive, less innovative, less
Matt:
It
Sam:
innovative and it and it delivers ultimately a less awesome product for the end user and end consumer.
Matt:
But Medicare
Sam:
So
Matt:
for All, that is the free market.
Sam:
how do you keep competition and allow Medicare, Medicaid to become the sole
Matt:
No, it's
Sam:
provider?
Matt:
Medicare. It's not Medicaid. So just, Sam, if tomorrow you could go purchase yourself a Medicare plan and get off of your employer sponsored plan, would you do that?
Sam:
I don't know, I might not.
Matt:
Think you would not right most people would not because most people like their employer sponsored plan But there are a lot of self-employed people who don't have access to an employer sponsored plan that would say I would love to Have the benefit of something like Medicare where there's a whole lot of people in the system And so my particular costs don't raise our premiums so much right or
Sam:
And, and, and by the way, even in the workplace, people that have severe, significant illnesses with major medical needs, that's a better solution for them than employer sponsored plans anyway. Right.
Matt:
Yeah. So Medicare for all doesn't get rid of any of the, the insurance system that we have. It just allows small business owners the opportunity to purchase into a health insurance plan that will cover them without being tied to their employment. I, it really is a conservative solution to this healthcare problem.
shawn:
Matt,
Sam:
Alright,
shawn:
how do you, how do
Sam:
we've
shawn:
you,
Sam:
solved
shawn:
how do you,
Sam:
it.
shawn:
but how do you in that, in that world, how do you prevent the problems I see as big problems? You used education as an example. Well, if, if I go through a, I look, I lived in multiple states and went to high school in multiple states and grade school, pretty mediocre education. And yeah, I have
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
to take responsibility for my own, but
Matt:
Well.
shawn:
the free right,
Sam:
explains a lot though.
shawn:
right? Education
Sam:
Interesting.
shawn:
is a free right is what you're saying.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
It's government provided, it's very mediocre. And if
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
I want higher education, I have to pay big bucks. Are you suggesting, isn't that what would happen in the healthcare system?
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
Mediocre healthcare
Matt:
yeah, for
shawn:
for
Matt:
most
shawn:
all.
Matt:
people. Well,
shawn:
But you think that works.
Matt:
we're not gonna promise that you can get your cholesterol medication, right? We're not gonna, but Medicare for all wouldn't even have anything to do with that, right? So if you look at the federal government budget, where does most of our money get spent? Number one is defense, then number two is social security and Medicare. We spend billions of dollars, maybe even close to a trillion of dollars every year. just on Medicare expenses. If you open it up so young healthy people who own small businesses can purchase Medicare, you're actually gonna reduce the cost of medicine to the federal government. Because now you have young healthy people paying into the system and not using the system. Whereas
Sam:
Right,
Matt:
right
Sam:
that's
Matt:
now the young
Sam:
it's called
Matt:
healthy people.
Sam:
its adverse selection. So adverse
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
selection means people with the biggest Issues end up overburdening the system and to your to your point 12% of the federal government spending last year 982 billion went to Medicare
Matt:
Yeah, almost a trillion dollars. Now, think about this. Who's making the money on the young, healthy people that never go to the hospital? the insurance companies, right? So they're making their money off of the young, healthy people. Medicare for all says, hey, you can buy into our system. It's gonna be not as good. It's not gonna be as awesome as what you would get in the private marketplace, but it'll be cheaper and you can buy into it. And I think that it's a conservative solution because then I don't have as many people saying, I have to go work for this company to get health insurance. I can go innovate and start my own business on my own. So it might be inferior, Sean, but. I don't know that anybody says government solutions have to be superior to the private market. The private market
shawn:
Now,
Matt:
can still exist, right?
shawn:
Sam,
Matt:
But
shawn:
oh, you're
Matt:
the
shawn:
saying
Matt:
government
shawn:
it was still—
Matt:
solution just makes sure everybody has an opportunity to partake.
shawn:
But then it's
Sam:
Which-
shawn:
more expensive overall because now I'm paying into one and if I need more than the basic mediocre services, I need to pay into the other as well.
Matt:
I don't think you have to do both. Medicare will cover the big expenses. Medicare covers cancer and diabetes and all that stuff. They don't
Sam:
So
Matt:
cover-
Sam:
Obamacare is the current attempt to do what you're describing, Matt, and it is atrociously expensive.
Matt:
No, Obamacare was backwards. Obamacare said we're gonna make everybody buy health insurance. That's not the right solution, right? That's creating a fault, that's creating false demand for a product without having good supply. And that does make, when you increase demand and the supply doesn't change, then the prices go up. So Medicare for All is the opposite approach. Medicare for All is saying let's increase the supply and don't force people to buy insurance, they can buy it or not, but anyone who wants it can afford it by buying Medicare for All.
shawn:
Okay, Sam, you get Thought Provoker winner for the first topic.
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
Matt, Matt rounded off for the second. I think you both win.
Matt:
Okay, Sean's not giving himself any points.
shawn:
Not at all.
Matt:
Sam,
Sam:
Uh,
Matt:
who do you say won, Sam?
Sam:
you know what I say? We withhold a winner until somebody figures this whole problem out. Cause it is a problem.
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
And, and
Matt:
Okay.
Sam:
it, and it is interesting. You know, we talk about unions and I talk about how destructive they are in the marketplace. If you freed up a employee, it's interesting because if you freed up employment plans connected to, uh, employment places, that would actually give the employee a lot more power in the marketplace and it would it would even it would make unions even more irrelevant than they are today. And
Matt:
That
Sam:
today
Matt:
is,
Sam:
they're dangerous.
Matt:
I think, back in the day unions used to be the health care provider. Unions would pay doctors and all of that stuff, yeah.
Sam:
And it was rampant with fraud.
Matt:
I'm not sure
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
after all of this time discussing unions where you're at for sure Sam, but I kind
shawn:
You're...
Matt:
of think you don't like them very much
Sam:
That could be.
Matt:
Okay, I get to go second the Wall Street Journal just came out with some college rankings They give high scores to colleges that prepare students for careers So in this one BYU was ranked 20th in the nation which
shawn:
for you.
Matt:
deep down we always knew that BYU was like a top 20 program
shawn:
Yes.
Matt:
This is way different than what US News uses to rank universities. So like BYU-Idaho in these new rankings ranks higher than Utah State and higher than like all kinds of state schools and that's not what you would find, right? But because BYU-Idaho keeps tuition low, BYU keeps tuition low, because BYU-Idaho is specifically trying to train students for careers, then rankings like this that are like, how much Does going to this college improve your earning potential over the course of your life? Places like BYU-Idaho, BYU are gonna score well on that. But in my view as an academic, that's always been the role of technical schools and community colleges. Those have always been the places to prepare kids for careers and prepare kids for vocations. College is about, in my view, like helping people train their mind and teaching critical thinking skills and teaching these higher level like skills that aren't necessarily career for a job preparation, but they train your mind to think as like a holistic, like well rounded adult. And so college in this, in my view, wouldn't be for everybody. It would only be for the people that are interested in this sort of like cognitive intellectual training. But It seems like that's not the way the world sees things anymore. So my big question is like, do places like BYU have an obligation to prepare students for a career or should they be focused on these other higher educational goals that I see as the purpose of a college degree?
shawn:
So Matt, did you say that your opinion is that colleges, higher education is not to prepare people for careers? It is more of the cognitive improvement of our society?
Matt:
Yeah, so I'm going to put there's this link that I'm going to read. So these are the things that we think of as like what a college education should do. So teach people about human cultures and the physical and natural world. Teach intellectual skills. Teach civic engagement kind of skills. And there should be some kind of like applied aspect of that, where you like learn how to apply that stuff to the practical world. In that sense, maybe it prepares you for a career. but
shawn:
But
Matt:
it
shawn:
you're
Matt:
shouldn't
shawn:
saying that
Matt:
really be about the
shawn:
yeah, you're
Matt:
job.
shawn:
saying it improves everyone's value and abilities overall generally source society is much better, but it shouldn't be focused on a vocation and ignore all that other stuff is what you're saying. Is that what you're saying?
Matt:
Yeah, that's right. Like, BYU-Idaho announced this week that they're going to have a three-year degree. You
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
can get
shawn:
I saw
Matt:
an online
shawn:
that.
Matt:
degree in business. And the way that they get that is they leave out all of that other stuff that I just mentioned, right?
shawn:
See, that's
Matt:
You just
shawn:
crazy.
Matt:
learn business, business.
shawn:
Yeah, that's pretty crazy to me. So the...
Matt:
But some people would say that's the... Some people say I go to college to get a job.
shawn:
So Matt, should there be more disclosure in that? I'd like to have choices in front of me and go, okay, we're gonna train you to get a job, we're gonna train you to have general knowledge and be a better citizen. Shouldn't there be some disclosures and advertising for that? So I can choose.
Matt:
I think that there are, it's just that most people don't know what they are, right? So if there's a college that says we're a liberal arts college, they're screaming to you, we are not going to prepare your kids for a career, we're going to prepare them to think. And
shawn:
Well, so.
Matt:
a uni- and a
Sam:
And
Matt:
uni-
Sam:
maybe not even that.
Matt:
well
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
no, like
shawn:
to me.
Matt:
liberal arts is those things I just described, right? Like civic responsibility and
shawn:
So Matt,
Matt:
knowledge of the world.
shawn:
I think there's utility in both, right? Having products out there that provide a way for someone to get a job and products that are out there that provide a way for someone to, yeah, just overall grow cognitively. That's, both are very valuable and beneficial for society. To me, the element that needs to be included in this discussion is we need to, as a society, make sure that people understand those aren't just your two options. College and higher education
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
isn't the only way
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
you can. I know many, many people who not only didn't go to college and thrive and are great citizens and have great careers, but many who decry their higher education waste of time. Many! Like,
Matt:
Because
shawn:
I didn't
Matt:
they didn't
shawn:
learn
Matt:
know
shawn:
anything.
Matt:
what they were doing, right? They didn't know... Like, I have... I tell my kids all the...
shawn:
Not only that, but also because the quality of a lot of that, a lot of it was a business and the quality of the education
Matt:
uh
shawn:
and the vocational training was not very good.
Matt:
I meet a lot of students that will say, why am I wasting my time in this class that has nothing to do with the job that I want to have someday? And I say, because you're in college.
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
If you want to train for a career, go to the technical school, go to the community college. They're never gonna make you take all those classes that don't help you with your career. They're gonna train you for a career. But I think people don't know that.
shawn:
There needs to be more disclosure and communication. The universities have done a poor job at, they've become very, a business. It's a business, it's for money. So, because
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
you would turn people off if you said, look, if you come to our university, you're gonna learn a lot, it's not gonna prepare you for the world or for an income. They wouldn't
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
ever disclose that. And so they're earning a lot of money purposely being quiet about it. And I think that's a problem.
Matt:
What I would tell all of those people doing the three-year business degree is I would say, forget about college. First of all, fourteen credits of that is going to be religion credit. So you're going to get a three-year degree a whole semester which is just going to be religion classes. I would say, do you want to go into business? Then go work in a business. Go, I don't
shawn:
Wow!
Matt:
know, sell cars, go
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
do welding, go do anything. The people that are most successful in business, now there's two different kinds but... By and large, the most successful people went into an industry, learned the industry, worked their way up. Like, that's how you... You don't go get a business degree in business administration and then you're like, okay, which industry gets to have my skills
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
as an administrator?
shawn:
you nailed
Matt:
Like,
shawn:
it, Matt.
Matt:
you
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
gotta
shawn:
that's,
Matt:
have something to offer the
shawn:
I think
Matt:
business that you...
shawn:
the three year degree is a problem. It's not a good move because what it teaches people is, oh, that's all I gotta do is fast track through it for three years and I've got my paper. And my paper is gonna be my solution for my career. And that's not the case, like you just said.
Sam:
I remember in my own experience at BYU, I remember at one point, um, getting invited to like a recruiting thing for, uh, for, for a medical pharmaceutical sales. And that was the big thing in the nineties, right? It was
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
to go work for a medical company and
Matt:
Sell
Sam:
you
Matt:
Oxycontin.
Sam:
know, you, yeah, you're selling whatever you'd have a drug, you know, you'd get a company car and you'd start
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
Sam:
out at like 60 grand a year or something like that. And to your point about sometimes practical experience is more valuable than the college education. Like I was making so much more than that at that point. Like
Matt:
Pfft
Sam:
that job that everyone looked at in college, the farm rep as being the ultimate opportunity post-college, was massively less than where I was.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
So I think you are right. Like I think a lot of really good companies, large companies have realized we have within my company. that we can actually provide an education forum based on experience and then also some additional online training through an LMS learning
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
management system.
Matt:
like canvas
Sam:
And we,
Matt:
or something.
Sam:
yep, we can actually, we can actually develop people internally as part of the company, give them opportunities to expand their own understanding and to be promoted within the company that really rivals that college education without an enormous debt load as you come out on the other side. I have a tough time though, because looking at it from my own kids, it's not a path you would sit and say, hey, don't go to college.
Matt:
Yeah, yeah.
Sam:
College
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
is
shawn:
exactly.
Sam:
so ingrained culturally in what it means. You graduate high school, you get a four-year degree, then you decide whether you want to pursue education further or you want to go into the workplace. That's just the way it is. I've heard so many times as a kid, you get that four-year degree to learn discipline, to... socialize to understand what you want to do and how you want to be in the world. I don't know if it was COVID, was it COVID that broke the mold where people said, hey, maybe we don't need to take that path. But in our own company, I'm seeing more and more people that were in college saying, hey, you know what, I'm going to set that aside and get practical work experience. It's the old adage of Cs working for As or As working for Cs. I'm going to get
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
the practical experience. And there are no less in the business workplace or business environment without that degree. Although I will tell you, as you get higher up, higher executive level in corporations, the degrees are critical, right? So
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
maybe it's different
Matt:
it can
Sam:
for
Matt:
be.
shawn:
Not
Sam:
everybody.
shawn:
always, not always,
Matt:
I
shawn:
but...
Matt:
think that's changing. Like, Governor Cox in Utah just changed a lot of these degree requirements for state jobs because he's like, these don't make sense. If somebody has the thing we're looking for, why should we care about the degree?
shawn:
Good
Matt:
So
shawn:
for
Matt:
I think
shawn:
him.
Matt:
some of that might change. Well, so President Nelson says that education is a religious obligation, but that doesn't mean college, right? You don't have to go to college to be educated. I have some kids in college and some kids that aren't, and one that wanted to come back to college, and I was like, listen, think about who you are and the way you spend your time and what you wanna do with your life. College doesn't fit you, but that doesn't mean you should stop learning. You still can educate yourself.
Sam:
But as a parent where the rubber meets the road on this argument is, would you start with that conversation with your kid as a graduating high school senior? Would you say, Hey,
shawn:
Alright Sam.
Sam:
I want you to take a year and think about life and decide you want to pursue a four year education or do you want to jump into the workplace?
shawn:
Great points.
Sam:
You know, I would
Matt:
Um...
Sam:
never do that. I would never ever
shawn:
Me
Sam:
prejudice them that
shawn:
neither.
Sam:
way. Like,
shawn:
But Sam, don't we have an obligation to say, hey, look, I'm not requiring you to finish college. I think you should get out on your own. You should start experiencing life, be in that
Sam:
never said
shawn:
social situation.
Sam:
that.
Matt:
Ah
Sam:
That's a terrifying prospect because it so goes against the mold. If my kids want to take that approach, they've got to go fight to make it that way on their own and it
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
makes
shawn:
no,
Sam:
you
shawn:
but
Sam:
nervous.
shawn:
I mean, sorry, I misspoke. I meant, Sam, go to college. Like, for example, if your kids left Provo and went to college somewhere else, they're on their own, right, they're living in a dorm. They're making decisions about when to eat and what to eat, right? That experience is valuable, but the message of, but you've got to get your
Sam:
I
shawn:
degree
Sam:
think
shawn:
in order
Sam:
to
shawn:
to have
Sam:
get
shawn:
a career.
Sam:
that on a mission. Yeah.
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
That's true,
Matt:
So,
shawn:
that's true,
Matt:
so
shawn:
good point.
Matt:
that, that transition period when a kid leaves home and then starts adulting on their own, it's tremendously difficult. Um,
Sam:
Mission.
Matt:
mission, I think
shawn:
Missing.
Matt:
mission is a great option. So I think, I think, um, I think it's close to 50% depending on like what you're looking at. Right. But there are, there's about half kid, half the kids that go to these major colleges and universities that like flunk out and fail their first year of school. It's, it's a very, very common thing. And most of that is like they struggle with mental illness challenges. I think that kids when they're young have their ways of coping with mental illness problems, then they go out on their own and they don't know how to handle them. And I think that that's not just a higher education thing. So what I'm trying to say is higher education actually has developed resources to help kids in that kinds of crisis that I don't know that businesses are equipped to do, right? Like you go out in the industry and you stop coming to work, they just fire you and let you go. So I do think as parents we have to think about like, how do we help our children successfully transition into adulthood? But I'm with Sam, a mission does as much as anything else to help a kid transition.
shawn:
Absolutely.
Matt:
My son that went into the army, boy that made him grow up real fast
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
when he went through bootcamping in the army. And college can do it for some people. But I just think this idea where people say, I need to go to college so that I can get a job, I think we need to get that out of people's heads because that's not gonna lead to success.
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
Man,
Sam:
But it
shawn:
I'm...
Sam:
starts with, it starts with us and I'm telling
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
you, I would never tell my kids don't do that. Right? Like that's,
shawn:
I'm gonna
Sam:
that's
shawn:
give,
Sam:
the challenge
shawn:
so I'm gonna give President
Sam:
as,
shawn:
Nelson
Sam:
as a
shawn:
the
Sam:
start.
shawn:
thought provoker and then Matt's asterisk that you get it for the asterisk and then Sam's, Sam
Matt:
Hahaha
shawn:
Wynn's thought provoker for talking about the practical realities of talking to your kids.
Matt:
I've
shawn:
You
Matt:
told
shawn:
all get it.
Matt:
every single one of my kids to not go to college. Yeah.
shawn:
Haha, wow.
Matt:
It's reverse psychology.
shawn:
OK.
Matt:
I tell
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
them, you'll
Sam:
but you
Matt:
never
Sam:
didn't
Matt:
succeed.
Sam:
mean it.
Matt:
Ha
Sam:
Yeah, you didn't mean it. You were just trying to mess them up. Ha ha ha.
Matt:
ha ha. Okay, Sean, you're up.
Sam:
Oh.
shawn:
Okay, can we bring some religion into this? We've done a lot of economy and
Matt:
I
shawn:
politics.
Matt:
feel like this, I've brought in scriptures.
shawn:
You did, you did,
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
sorry.
Matt:
okay.
shawn:
You did, sorry.
Sam:
I brought in a lot too, but we won't go back to that.
shawn:
Okay, so we haven't talked very much about the Joseph Smith papers. This is a big thing that it was announced that the project, the 20-year project that cost over, it cost tens of millions of dollars, was
Sam:
Why
shawn:
finished
Sam:
does it cost
shawn:
and launched.
Sam:
tens of millions of dollars to put together papers? I don't understand that.
shawn:
Well, let's talk about it. So basically.
Matt:
Do you know who paid for it, by the way?
Sam:
the turk.
Matt:
Larry
shawn:
No,
Matt:
H. Miller.
shawn:
not the church. The church didn't
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
pay
Sam:
Oh,
shawn:
for any of it.
Sam:
the car guy. Free
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
he
shawn:
the car guy.
Matt:
spearheaded
Sam:
market.
Matt:
the whole thing and funded the whole thing.
Sam:
Was that
shawn:
Here's
Sam:
before or after he made the really awful movie about, uh, what was the movie that, that plunked about Joseph Smith? That
Matt:
It was this
Sam:
played
Matt:
was all part
Sam:
in the
Matt:
of
Sam:
theaters.
Matt:
it
Sam:
Okay. This was part of,
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
all right, nevermind.
Matt:
that's it.
Sam:
Go
Matt:
Yeah
Sam:
ahead, Sean. I'll, I'll be quiet.
shawn:
So the reason it cost so much and took so long is because there's two reasons. One, it's 27 volumes, including 1,300 journal entries, 643 letters, and 155 revelations. Basically, every ounce of evidence that was sourced from Joseph Smith exists now in this collection. And the other reason is because it's gotten very high praise from the historians and academics for being, for example, Laurel Thatcher, Pulitzer Prize winner, professor at Harvard. They
Matt:
member
shawn:
felt confident.
Matt:
of the church who
shawn:
Is it a member of the Church?
Matt:
yeah she's a member of the church who grew up in Rigby Idaho or something like that sugar
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
city
shawn:
then I'll take away her. Okay, I won't say.
Matt:
no cuz she's a celebrated scholar
shawn:
They
Matt:
of
shawn:
felt
Matt:
mormon
shawn:
called.
Matt:
history
shawn:
She says they felt confident that the actual if the actual records, the primary sources were available responsible scholars would consult them. Additionally, the scholarly approach in these volumes was endorsed by the National Archives as meeting the most rigorous criteria for documentary editing. So academia gave gives high praises to the process. Right,
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
because it's primary sources.
Matt:
Yes!
shawn:
Right. That's the reason. So the question is, the real question is this to me. Why is this a big deal, the Joseph Smith papers, and what is the intended outcome of the product?
Matt:
Do you want to go first Sam? As an academic I'll say why I think it's a big deal.
Sam:
That you go first and then I'll fill in the holes
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
Thank you.
Matt:
it's a big deal because we want primary sources on Joseph Smith. There's so much innuendo. There's so many like mistruths and this person said this and this person said this. It's amazing to be able to just go to the primary source. It's all available online and you can just look and see what it was and then you can make your own decision. I think I wish there was like a Joseph Smith papers for everything in history that I could just go online click and read the original source and then decide for myself is it true or is it not true.
shawn:
Sam, do you really have an opinion on this? Because if you don't, I have a direct question for you that I'm super interested in. I've been interested all week
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
about this. But if you have an opinion,
Matt:
Ha ha
shawn:
go ahead.
Sam:
all right. I'm going to make a one sentence opinion, then you can ask the question, OK?
shawn:
Okay.
Sam:
So I think any time, to Matt's point, you can get everything out there. To the extent this represents everything, how can that be a bad thing? So I mean, why would I object to that? That's fantastic.
shawn:
Good, good,
Sam:
Sean,
shawn:
good.
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
question.
Matt:
you kinda like things hidden in the dark. You
shawn:
Do
Matt:
don't like
shawn:
you?
Matt:
transparency.
shawn:
Sam does?
Matt:
He
Sam:
the
Matt:
doesn't want pharmaceutical companies to have to tell us what's in their medicine.
shawn:
That's
Sam:
No, they do. That's
Matt:
Oh,
Sam:
the
Matt:
that's
Sam:
whole
Matt:
right,
Sam:
point
Matt:
I
Sam:
of
Matt:
got,
Sam:
regulation.
shawn:
what he wants.
Matt:
that's
Sam:
FDA.
Matt:
right, I was on
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
the other side of that one. Okay,
shawn:
That's
Matt:
sorry.
shawn:
right. That was you. So Sam, yeah, I've been thinking you all week. So I'm like, I really want Sam's take on kind of so I agree that this is an amazing good thing. But here's the only
Matt:
Can
shawn:
my only
Matt:
I ask you a question, Sean?
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
You were thinking of Sam all week? Ha
shawn:
Yes sir.
Sam:
Ha ha
Matt:
ha
Sam:
ha!
Matt:
ha!
shawn:
Yeah, what's wrong with that? Sam is my man.
Matt:
Um, yeah,
Sam:
Fantastic.
Matt:
okay.
shawn:
I only thought of you once, Matt. You're
Sam:
Good.
Matt:
Man!
shawn:
just
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
jealous. Okay, so the only, I think, not danger, but the risk with something like this is, it becomes like this. Like, Matt, you claim as an academic that because this is primary sourced, then all of this information should be trusted.
Matt:
No, no,
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
no.
shawn:
I know, but that's-
Matt:
The source should be trusted. So if Joseph Smith writes a letter to some girl who's his polygamist wife, I can trust that Joseph Smith said that to that girl.
shawn:
Yes, good.
Matt:
But
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
other than that, it doesn't establish anything.
shawn:
Okay,
Sam:
He wasn't a polygamist, you take that back.
shawn:
but Matt, but if, for example, when I was on my mission and started reading the King Follett discourse, right? And I read it in an Inzyne magazine,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
and I read it and I fell in love with it. I really love it. Okay, now as I have the Joseph Smith papers and I have the handwritten manuscript, what I'm realizing as I compare the two is, well, someone made a lot of interpretations on what those words were, because as
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
Wilford Woodruff was fast, quick, trying to write down what Joseph Smith was saying, there's some unclarity in a lot of those words.
Matt:
Sometimes he got it a little wrong.
shawn:
So, yes, what you said is true. As an academic, you can go, well, it's primary source. So Joseph Smith said it, so I can have it. However, the meaning or the interpretation or the intent or the context doesn't exist. So my fear is that many people will just go, oh, well, Joseph Smith said, for example,
Matt:
Mm.
shawn:
Moses did not have the Melchizedek Priesthood. Sorry, didn't say that, sorry, scratch that.
Matt:
Hahahaha!
shawn:
Moses after Moses died, the Melchizedek priesthood did not exist among the he said something to that effect and then he goes into great context and explaining this really fascinating idea about what the priesthood is but a lot of people will just go well Joseph Smith said that and so that is doctrine and that is fact.
Matt:
And what's your question for Sam? This was
shawn:
So
Matt:
you
shawn:
here's
Matt:
thinking
shawn:
the question.
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
about
Sam:
that is
Matt:
Sam?
Sam:
curious.
Matt:
Ha ha
Sam:
Where's
shawn:
Yes,
Sam:
me?
Matt:
ha.
Sam:
Where am
shawn:
absolutely.
Sam:
I in this shot?
shawn:
So Sam, you've mentioned a lot in the past about, and I admire your faith because you living in Utah your whole life, oftentimes
Sam:
Uh...
shawn:
you'll come back to, look, if the church said it, if I read it somewhere and a prophet said it, whether he was a prophet at the time or not, I love your faith because you go, that's what I believe in, right?
Sam:
do. Yeah.
shawn:
Yes, you do. Things like, don't
Matt:
This
shawn:
you?
Matt:
is what you were thinking about with Sam all week?
Sam:
Is he
shawn:
No,
Sam:
listening
shawn:
the-
Sam:
to the podcast regularly?
shawn:
Yeah, Sam, things
Matt:
Isn't
shawn:
like
Matt:
Sam the one
shawn:
things,
Matt:
last week?
shawn:
things like when you when someone says, hey, why don't you talk to your kids on your missions other than twice
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
a year? Oh, because
Sam:
yeah.
shawn:
it's doctrine because it
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
is absolute
Sam:
Got it,
shawn:
because that's what
Sam:
got
shawn:
you
Sam:
it.
shawn:
do. Right.
Matt:
And how he changes. When the church changes, he changes.
shawn:
Yes. Yeah.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
Is that not a fair characterization? It's not a bad thing.
Matt:
That's not the same as saying I found this random quote from Joseph Smith papers, therefore I'm going to say this is the truth forevermore.
shawn:
That is the same thing because Sam,
Matt:
Oh,
shawn:
if
Matt:
okay,
shawn:
I came
Matt:
there's
shawn:
to you and
Matt:
the question.
shawn:
said, hey, Sam, here is a documented primary source, a message that says,
Matt:
The Melchizedek
shawn:
Joseph
Matt:
Priesthood
shawn:
Smith said,
Matt:
wasn't
shawn:
look.
Matt:
on the earth after Moses lalala.
shawn:
Blah blah blah.
Matt:
And Sam will be like, it's in the Joseph Smith papers, now I believe it.
shawn:
It's just an example, Sam, and I'm
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
saying, is there a risk in people going, huh, it says it here in the Joseph Smith papers, this is truth.
Sam:
Your average human being isn't going to read the whole Joseph Smith papers.
Matt:
Let's go further. 1% of the
shawn:
Hahahaha
Matt:
Joseph Smith papers.
Sam:
Yeah. And so
Matt:
In fact,
Sam:
it's,
Matt:
your
Sam:
it's
Matt:
average seminary teacher is only gonna get
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
to 3% of
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
the Joseph Smith papers.
shawn:
Okay,
Sam:
What, what,
shawn:
fine,
Sam:
what these,
shawn:
but for those who are...
Sam:
what, what these are and why they're so good is because information about the church and the church's history has been tightly controlled up until the discovery of the internet
Matt:
Yes.
Sam:
and when the internet became available and all of a sudden all these alternate truths or facts, although you can't say that cause that doesn't even make sense. It
Matt:
Yeah, that makes you sound like a Trump supporter.
Sam:
that's right. That's right.
shawn:
Good luck.
Sam:
What, what's all this other stuff came out? It caused people's shelves to break for whatever reason. Right. Like it became confusing and the church is smart to run after putting all of this out there because you know, at the end of the day, I love the ending of Hamilton, right? Who lives, who dies, who tells the story. Right.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
It's whoever ends up telling the story that ends up controlling the narrative. And when you put everything out there, that actually puts the power in the reader to be critical and to think critically and to understand for their own reasons. So
shawn:
Well, that's
Sam:
it makes it tougher
shawn:
it. And
Sam:
for anybody to refute, I think.
shawn:
that is a good point. One of the descriptions of the Joseph Smith papers is it's not a novel. It's not a descriptive story. It is document after document, and people
Sam:
Probably
shawn:
are
Sam:
not
shawn:
left
Sam:
even
shawn:
on their
Sam:
that interesting
shawn:
own.
Sam:
to read.
shawn:
It's hard to
Sam:
Poem
shawn:
read
Sam:
after
shawn:
for sure.
Sam:
poem, yeah.
Matt:
Volume 2, I got volume 2 as a hardcover and I was like I'm gonna collect them all and then I saw how much they cost To have all of them and I'm like but it's online for free and I
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
would need like a special room in my house for the Joseph
shawn:
Thank
Matt:
Smith
shawn:
you.
Matt:
papers and who cares?
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
It's like a photocopy of a picture of a page
Sam:
You know,
Matt:
or something
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
we should go into business and you remember like the old Britannica encyclopedias
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
that people would go to door to door. We should do, we should call it living Joseph Smith instead of living scripters and we could go door to door. We could sell laundry detergent and we could sell, uh, the
Matt:
vitamins
Sam:
Joseph Smith papers.
Matt:
we
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
put meth
Sam:
That'd
Matt:
in
Sam:
be
Matt:
our vitamins
Sam:
fantastic.
shawn:
Look, I know it's a remote thing, but I guarantee you many people over the next years and years and years are going to start preaching certain doctrines because
Sam:
Okay.
shawn:
they found it in the Joseph Smith papers
Matt:
That's
Sam:
Free
Matt:
okay.
shawn:
that
Sam:
markets,
shawn:
aren't true.
Sam:
free market,
Matt:
I think it's
Sam:
free
Matt:
a...
Sam:
market ideas. That's awesome.
shawn:
Yeah, but I think it's important for us to share that Scripture has been very clear on methods of how we're supposed to discover truth. And the Joseph Smith paper is as valuable as it is, that is using man's methods
Matt:
But,
shawn:
to establish truth.
Matt:
but Sean,
shawn:
Yes, sir.
Matt:
as I mentioned to you when we talked about this off air, the Joseph Smith papers have led to alterations in the standard works.
shawn:
Go ahead.
Matt:
Because if you have the digital copy of the scriptures on the LDS whatever, you're gonna get automatic updates to the text and the content, that if you have the hardbound paper copies, you're not getting those. So when we do family scripture time, and my wife, the Luddite, opens up her paper scriptures
shawn:
Thank
Matt:
and
shawn:
you.
Matt:
starts reading something, we can say, that's not what the scriptures say. And she's like, Yes it is and then we like look and compare, right? So.
shawn:
Yeah, and it's words like thrash versus thrash, right?
Matt:
Right, it used to say thrash and now it says thrash. But there's some other things in there too. There's like a place in the Doctrine and Covenants where it uses this name or this word that means something and they just go back and replace it with the meaning of the word instead of this actual word.
shawn:
Okay, which
Matt:
So it's.
shawn:
is actually you're making my point, right? I know you're not saying, yes, man has discovered the method to discover truth outside of God, right? The historical primary source process is the way to discover truth. I know you're not saying that. It's a little
Sam:
Do you
shawn:
bit what
Sam:
not
shawn:
it sounds
Sam:
like
shawn:
like.
Sam:
the Joseph Smith paper, Sean?
shawn:
I love them, but I'm saying we
Matt:
What
shawn:
need
Matt:
I'm-
shawn:
to be clear that the purpose of them is to provide used man's method to provide primary source documents for Joseph Smith. But the
Matt:
I sit.
shawn:
process that we're supposed to use to discover truth, is study scripture and get revelation and compare all other things against that standard.
Matt:
I see it the opposite of what you're saying. I see it as what we had before the Joseph Smith papers were things that were just handed down. Either somebody said this or somebody put this in a manual or somebody said somebody said this
shawn:
secondary
Matt:
and we all
shawn:
source
Matt:
just believed
shawn:
or heroes
Matt:
it.
shawn:
thing,
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
right?
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
it was a, it was a sanitized correlation, correlated version of the church history.
Matt:
like the white horse prophecy, right? Everybody talks about the white horse and
Sam:
Or in Hatch, yes,
Matt:
the Constitution will hang by a thread.
Sam:
yes.
Matt:
And now you've got everything Joseph Smith ever said
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
and you
shawn:
beautiful.
Matt:
can just search the Joseph Smith papers and say, where is that? And you'll find out that it's nowhere because it didn't come from Joseph Smith. It came from somebody who said Joseph Smith said that on down the
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
line.
shawn:
yeah, great, great.
Matt:
So I think that we're doing the opposite. We're saying, let's get rid of all of this what I would call oral tradition that people believe is true because it was passed down orally. and let's go to the actual source of things. So I see it the opposite.
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
I think
shawn:
that's
Matt:
it's good.
shawn:
good. No, I do think it's good. I'm not saying it's bad. I'm just saying it needs to come with a continued message of don't rely just because some man says that this is the primary source, that this is actual truth and doctrine. Use
Matt:
So.
Sam:
That's
shawn:
the same
Sam:
life.
shawn:
process that God has always come, no, but life is also, you need to pray about things and you need to get revelation about things in order to really know the truth of them. Like the King Follett discourse, that preaches a doctrine that has not been canonized.
Matt:
I know.
shawn:
Therefore, but it's in there, but Matt, you're saying it's in there. Look, primary sources that
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
Joseph Smith
Matt:
I have
shawn:
said
Matt:
no
shawn:
these
Matt:
doubt
shawn:
words.
Matt:
that Joseph Smith said all that stuff,
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
but...
shawn:
so that's my point. So a lot of people, now that they have this primary source document, are going to go everything preached by Joseph Smith in the King Fault Discourse, doctrine and true. My point is careful, careful. That is not the method that God has established through scripture. He says feast upon the words of Christ, then pray to get the Holy Ghost. And that is the process and the method. Right. Do
Sam:
Props.
shawn:
you not agree that people will preach the Looking for discourse now more.
Matt:
I don't think anybody's reading that in the Joseph Smith papers.
shawn:
I am.
Matt:
What I want to do Sean is I want to give you points Because this is the thought provoking in this particular way. You are so skeptical of intellectuals and higher education and
shawn:
That's not
Matt:
institutions
shawn:
it.
Matt:
and You found a way to like take something beautiful like the Joseph Smith
Sam:
Hahaha!
Matt:
papers
shawn:
I know.
Matt:
and turn
Sam:
Ugh...
Matt:
it into an anti-intellectualism rant
shawn:
That's not it.
Matt:
That's what you're getting points for so you want to Wanna just give up your points, Sean? Hahaha!
shawn:
I don't care about the points like you do, Matt.
Sam:
Hey, props to car dealer Larry Miller for using his free market result to pay for this tens of millions
Matt:
Here's
Sam:
of dollars
Matt:
the true test
Sam:
project.
Matt:
of your idea, Sean. If we have a Brigham Young papers next where they give us everything Brigham Young ever said,
shawn:
Yes.
Matt:
then we'll find out,
Sam:
That
Matt:
that's
Sam:
won't
Matt:
right,
Sam:
happen.
Matt:
then we'll find out how
Sam:
That'd
Matt:
much people
Sam:
be.
Matt:
really believe all these
Sam:
That
Matt:
documents.
Sam:
that'd be a little too much transparency.
shawn:
I would love that man. I would absolutely love to have that because it's the same thing, right? There's some like you said, there's so much word of mouth. Like here's what he said. Here's what he didn't say.
Matt:
So there's a biography of Heber J. Grant that Truman Manson did because he was one of Heber J. Grant's grandkids. But Bob Bennett, this former Senator from Utah, was also a grandkid of Heber J. Grant. He was working on his own biography of his grandpa, and we'll never see that because he died before it was done. But I heard from that, now if you get called to be a general authority,
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
all
Sam:
they
Matt:
your
Sam:
take
Matt:
journals,
Sam:
your papers. Yeah.
Matt:
yeah, you
Sam:
They
Matt:
don't
Sam:
take
Matt:
own
Sam:
it
Matt:
it
Sam:
all.
Matt:
anymore.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
So how about if I ever see the Dieter F. Uchtdorf papers, then I'll know the church is being really transparent because they have it all and they could publish it all.
Sam:
That would
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
be interesting. And,
Matt:
Right,
Sam:
and
Matt:
give
Sam:
what,
Matt:
it.
Sam:
and what did his diary look like the night he got
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
released from the first presidency? Wait, what?
Matt:
Ha ha ha!
Sam:
Oh no, we've lost the other third of our audience. Sorry.
Matt:
No, but I honestly like in terms of transparency, I want the diaries like just 10 years ago Let's start 10 years and then work our way back. Let's have all of the president Monson papers out and all the president Hinckley papers Okay, the big question since nobody wants points anymore. I don't know why we even talk about points Nobody even cares Sean told me he doesn't even care about pay points We're gonna go into the big question. The big question is not so complicated and sophisticated this week. It's really simple There was a high school football game I was watching on TV, and this kid's running and he fumbles the football, but the refs don't see that he fumbles it. They think that the ground caused the fumble, and so they rule that it's not a fumble because the ground caused him to fumble. But you can see on the cameras very clearly that this kid fumbled the ball before he hit the ground, and he knew that he fumbled it before he hit the ground, because you would
Sam:
By the
Matt:
have
Sam:
way,
Matt:
to.
Sam:
this happened in college football last week. This wasn't even high school, but go ahead.
Matt:
Right, but I want to do it in high school because that's
Sam:
Okay.
Matt:
where I think it matters. So my question is, you're the high school kid running the ball and they knock it out of your hands and it caused a fumble and then the referee says, not a fumble because the ground caused it. Do you have a moral obligation to raise your hand and say, excuse me, I fumbled that football?
Sam:
You
shawn:
I think
Sam:
do
shawn:
if
Sam:
not.
shawn:
we, oh, Sammy, I think if we as a society teach that, then we are teaching a moral evil. So we disagree,
Matt:
Oh,
shawn:
Sam.
Matt:
well, I mean, with that backdrop, Sam, why don't
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
you tell us what you think? It could
Sam:
because
Matt:
be a moral evil.
Sam:
a game is a game with a set of rules and there are rules around what constitutes a penalty and a foul. There's a rule around the referee's job in that game and the player's job in that game. The ref's job in that game is to make a call to the best of their ability based on the information they have in front of them. The player's job in a lot of cases is to deceive. It, you know, you look like you're running one way and you begin to run the other way, you know, it's full accountability and transparency in the game of football to tell the other player, which way you're going to run
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
and just say, Hey, I'm going this way and keep it like every element of that game has to do with scoring points and the refs, their job is to create order and to call what's a penalty and what's not. And it's inconsistent with that. Uh, you see, you see receivers all the time. Uh, trying to make it look like, you know, somebody to get a past interference penalty, there's deception there and, and one side wins and the other side loses. You watch soccer, right? The flops that happen in soccer. Good. Do soccer
Matt:
Alright,
Sam:
players
Matt:
uh-
Sam:
have a moral responsibility to not flop to NBA back? Can you
Matt:
Yes!
Sam:
imagine the NBA? If there wasn't any flopping, like what fun would that be to watch, right?
shawn:
Matt
Sam:
Or
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
the fights in the NHL. I think in, in the If you're a game of sports, part of it is a little bit of deception and putting on a show and then it's up to the rest to
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
make a call.
shawn:
can I stop you because you started so strong and then you started to kind of get loose there. But I want to stop you because
Matt:
You said flopping.
shawn:
I need to, I need to,
Sam:
I said
shawn:
I need
Sam:
flopping.
shawn:
to repent for my
Sam:
Mm hmm.
shawn:
evil. Yeah, you
Sam:
Oh
shawn:
made a
Sam:
interesting.
shawn:
great point. And I can, I can go back on that with one caveat. So
Sam:
Okay.
shawn:
well said, really
Matt:
No!
shawn:
well explained. No, no, hang on,
Matt:
Hehehehe
shawn:
hang
Sam:
Well said sir, well said!
shawn:
on. One caveat, one caveat. The, so, so in the scenario, like I love what you said. There are
Matt:
What?
shawn:
rules to the game. Hang on, hang on, hang on,
Sam:
What
shawn:
Matt.
Sam:
part do you like? I wonder.
shawn:
There are rules
Sam:
Interesting.
shawn:
to the game and the rules
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
don't, if the rules don't specifically say, hey, in a controversial call, the ref is going to ask the player to make the final decision and has to be honest.
Sam:
But
shawn:
If that
Sam:
yeah,
shawn:
doesn't
Sam:
by the way,
shawn:
exist,
Sam:
yeah.
shawn:
it's a good point. But it's not my son's obligation to interrupt the ref and go, hey, I really did. That's a great point, I do agree with that. However, on Matt's side, I think, what do we teach in our kids in this situation? My
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
kid's never gonna play in the NBA. As good and as talented as he is, What are we teaching our kids in the situation?
Matt:
Yes, you gotta teach him honesty. So listen, it could be the referee's call in the end, but you be honest and at least you tell the referee, hey, I fumbled the ball and the referee can say, hey, stay out of this kid, that's not your role, that's not your job. This is my job to make this call and I don't care what you said.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
But
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
you teach
Sam:
and
Matt:
the kid
Sam:
I,
Matt:
to be honest.
Sam:
and in a high school football game, if the kid did that in front of parents,
Matt:
I know!
Sam:
the parents would eat that kid alive.
shawn:
Peer pressure,
Matt:
But
shawn:
Sam,
Matt:
don't you-
Sam:
So
shawn:
peer
Sam:
I've,
shawn:
pressure,
Sam:
I've
shawn:
huh?
Sam:
seen that happen. I don't, you see it as a question of integrity
Matt:
Yes.
Sam:
and, and moral, uh, you see it as a moral question. And I absolutely don't see it as a moral question. I mean, this happened in college sports last week and the rules say that the refs couldn't look up at the jumbotron. In this case, it was a BYU football game. They could not look up at the Jumbotron to see clearly that the ball hit the ground before
shawn:
They're not allowed
Sam:
the
shawn:
to?
Sam:
receiver. They're not allowed to.
shawn:
Wow.
Matt:
In
Sam:
So
Matt:
college there's different rules of like
Sam:
the coach,
Matt:
when you can
Sam:
the
Matt:
overturn.
Sam:
coach for the other side was pointing up and he was incredulous. He's like, look, just look up at the Jumbotron and the ref would not look up.
shawn:
Matt,
Sam:
He refused to look up.
shawn:
how about a compromise, Matt?
Matt:
Wait, wait,
Sam:
It's against the rules. It was
Matt:
let
Sam:
a
Matt:
me
Sam:
lack
Matt:
make
Sam:
of.
Matt:
my point.
Sam:
Hmm.
Matt:
My point is this.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
Everybody tells me that we need to have sports in school because
Sam:
Mm-hmm.
Matt:
sports teach kids things that they can't learn in the classroom. And we learn about camaraderie and teamwork
Sam:
Socialization.
Matt:
and competition all that.
Sam:
Yep.
Matt:
And honesty and integrity is not going to be on that list.
Sam:
Well, by the
Matt:
And
Sam:
way,
Matt:
sportsmanship isn't going to be on that list.
Sam:
let's talk about what honesty and integrity is because we actually hire people that come from sports for that exact reason. Honesty and integrity is learning that you're a member of a team and it's disciplining your body and your mind and yourself to show up, to give your full effort, to be accountable to your team members for a result. And as a team to hold each other accountable to that result, you absolutely 100% learn integrity.
Matt:
telling the truth isn't part of that.
Sam:
That's
shawn:
HAHAHAHAHAHA
Sam:
it's, listen, I think it's hypocritical as an audience member, as a fan watching from the sidelines, making a judgment call about whether somebody's being honest or not, whether they were in or out of bounds, because that
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
Oh, good point.
Matt:
I don't know whether he told anybody.
shawn:
Good point.
Sam:
everybody, the fans need to get over themselves in, in particular, a lot of times parents need to get over themselves because they have no place in that game. The game has a set of rules
shawn:
Peace.
Sam:
and everybody has a job and a role. And integrity is executing your individual role to the best of your ability and playing to the best for your team. It's not,
shawn:
But Sam,
Sam:
you know.
shawn:
in a scenario where Matt is saying that the student truly knows that they fumbled the ball. Now, Matt, if the ref doesn't
Sam:
Did the ref
shawn:
ask the
Sam:
ask?
shawn:
kid,
Sam:
Did the
shawn:
if
Sam:
ref
shawn:
the ref
Sam:
ask,
shawn:
doesn't,
Sam:
John?
shawn:
yeah, exactly, if the ref doesn't ask, then I don't think he has an obligation to do it.
Sam:
If the
Matt:
I...
Sam:
ref
Matt:
no way.
Sam:
comes up to him and asks, he absolutely should say it.
shawn:
Oh, there we go! There's the
Matt:
It
shawn:
compromise,
Matt:
spills over
shawn:
man.
Matt:
to all these other aspects of life, right? Like, my insurance company
Sam:
It
Matt:
tells
Sam:
doesn't.
Matt:
me, if you hit a car, do not admit
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
fault, right? We like teach people,
Sam:
Wait,
Matt:
you need to behave
Sam:
wait,
Matt:
one,
Sam:
stop.
Matt:
we need to behave
Sam:
Stop
Matt:
one way
Sam:
on
Matt:
in
Sam:
that
Matt:
a, uh-huh.
Sam:
one. Stop on that one. Okay, say what you said again,
Matt:
Insurance
Sam:
because
Matt:
companies
Sam:
I
Matt:
say you shouldn't admit fault if you
Sam:
That's
Matt:
hit
Sam:
right.
Matt:
somebody
Sam:
And, and you know why they tell you that
Matt:
Because
Sam:
it's not
Matt:
they want
Sam:
a
Matt:
to have
Sam:
deception.
Matt:
a legal fine about whether or not because there's a different arena in which we just Determine fault and we determine who's liable and things like that and you're not qualified to make that decision as a driver
Sam:
Well, does the professor who says that nobody's qualified to say anything. But listen, when
Matt:
hahahaha
Sam:
you're involved
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
in a car, have you been in a car accident?
Matt:
No, I have a perfect driving record.
Sam:
Okay. Sean, have you
shawn:
done
Sam:
been
shawn:
or not?
Sam:
involved in a car accident?
shawn:
Yeah, someone hit me.
Sam:
The moment that leads up to a car accident is confusing. It like things happen so fast and your perception of reality and truth can be malleable and it may not even be accurate.
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
So
shawn:
yeah.
Sam:
they say, don't run over to the other person and say, hey,
shawn:
great point.
Sam:
I apologize, that was 100% my fault. I never should have done that. Because your perception is informed on your life experience and it may be your first inclination to accept responsibility for everything and try to make everything right. People don't enter that legal situation usually fully informed about what was right, what wasn't. Your responsibility in that case is to truthfully fill out a police report and then the policeman... takes all the reports, reads them together, and then makes a decision. That actually removes emotion and deception, and
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
a
Matt:
that's right.
Sam:
lot of bad
Matt:
That's the
Sam:
stuff
Matt:
least
Sam:
happens.
Matt:
deceptive process.
shawn:
No!
Sam:
It is! Ha ha ha.
Matt:
Well, and then what happens is kids
Sam:
Oh.
Matt:
in school, they say, my job isn't to do my homework. Their job is to catch me if I'm cheating. And so I'm going to try and cheat and they're going to try and catch me. Like we create all these different scenarios in our minds.
Sam:
Not the same thing because in school they say, here's what constitutes feeding. You're not to feed.
Matt:
And
Sam:
If
Matt:
then...
Sam:
you're not to use cat GPP and you use it, that's clearly
Matt:
And
Sam:
a deception.
Matt:
in football they say, here's what a fumble is.
Sam:
Right, but who's responsible to say it's the ref's job to make that call? It's not the individual player's job.
Matt:
And whose job is it to decide if a student cheated in class?
shawn:
I'm out.
Sam:
It's the students. They're
Matt:
Oh,
Sam:
asked continually, did you cheat? Yes
Matt:
okay. No,
Sam:
or no?
Matt:
I wish we asked them continually.
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
I just feel like in some ways, I'm not saying that, like, I understand why we do all of these things in society, but I think that there's a cumulative effect where adults send kids a message, which is You don't have to be completely honest about everything that happens all the time because there's these other things going on that you can't quite comprehend, that you don't quite understand, and it's better for everyone if you just stay quiet. And I don't know that that's the lesson we want to teach kids. We want to teach kids to be forthcoming and honest.
shawn:
Sam who sold their
Sam:
Listen,
shawn:
birthright for a,
Sam:
listen.
shawn:
what they sell it for Matt?
Matt:
a mess-a-pottage.
shawn:
A mess of potage Sam.
Sam:
but for the world.
Matt:
Well, so, I see there's no harm in the student telling the ref, I fumbled the ball. If the ref decides, if the ref's hands are tied because of the rules, and they say, well, I can't do anything about that anyways because it's not a reviewable play, great! The kid was honest and the ref did their job and everybody's happy. There's nothing wrong with this world of like, everybody's so honest that we have complete information.
Sam:
I know, but Matt, where's the line in that? So a receiver running out trying to make, he's being deceptive in the field of play by trying to make it look like there's pass interference.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Should he not be deceptive in trying to show pass interference when it's not pass interference?
Matt:
I mean, I don't want to be hypocritical because when we play card games, I cheat all the time. I always
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
cheat in games.
Sam:
yeah,
Matt:
But...
Sam:
think about
Matt:
Hahahaha.
Sam:
I've played I've played risk with you.
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
You are the master of deception. So where is integrity in that?
Matt:
Do
Sam:
It's part of the game.
Matt:
you guys ever watch that show Survivor? In Survivor...
Sam:
Wait, are you changing the topic?
Matt:
No, no, it's a similar thing. In Survivor,
Sam:
Okay.
Matt:
they vote people out, right? And so a lot of Survivor is people lying
Sam:
Yeah. Right,
Matt:
to each
Sam:
gamesmanship.
Matt:
other about who they're
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
going to vote for and all that stuff. And I watch that show and I tell my family, If I ever play Survivor, I will be the only honest person.
shawn:
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe hehehe hehehe
Matt:
I will never lie to anybody in the game. And then they're like, but you cheat at
Sam:
You're
Matt:
UNO.
Sam:
lying to them. Yeah. So, Matt, before we go off this sports deal, I want you to answer the question about PI with the receiver. Should receivers not show PI if it's not there?
Matt:
They should not. I disagree with... I understand... I watched a football game today where some kid got like touched on the sideline and then did all this flopping stuff and then there was a 15 yard unnecessary roughness penalty and stuff like that. I understand why they do it
Sam:
Okay,
Matt:
but
Sam:
so
Matt:
it's
Sam:
no,
Matt:
bad.
Sam:
no. I want one more question. A quarterback who decides to run and he, he gives the fake impression he's going to run one way. He ends up going another way. Did he not do that?
Matt:
That's
Sam:
That's
Matt:
different!
Sam:
a deception. How is that different?
Matt:
That's deceiving the other team, not deceiving the officiators. The referees, right?
Sam:
So the line is deception with the refs.
Matt:
If you're trying to deceive the people who enforce the rules to get an unfair advantage in how the rules are applied, we call that cheating. Right?
Sam:
Ha ha
Matt:
That's the
Sam:
ha,
Matt:
same
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
with performance enhancing drugs. Why can't I take performance
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
enhancing drugs?
Sam:
So.
Matt:
Because it gives me an unfair advantage
Sam:
Stop.
Matt:
that everyone else is playing by one set of rules that I'm playing by another.
Sam:
So your line is pass interference and flopping. That's clearly out,
Matt:
My line
Sam:
but
Matt:
is
Sam:
you can
Matt:
the
Sam:
deceive,
Matt:
rules of the game.
Sam:
you can, right.
Matt:
You can't break the rules of the game.
Sam:
Yeah, yeah.
Matt:
And you
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
shouldn't
Sam:
so.
Matt:
try to make it look like the other team did break the rules if they didn't actually break the rules.
Sam:
So. So in your example, it walks out as he's going up the field, he knows he walked out, the ref didn't catch it, so he didn't call it, even though he's not specifically being asked, hey, did you step out? He has a moral obligation to self-report that.
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
Hello?
Sam:
What if he self-reports after the game?
Matt:
It could be that this is why I never played sports at a very high level. They're like, not only is he pretty bad, he's way too honest. He's hurting our team.
Sam:
Well, no, see,
Matt:
Why are
Sam:
here's
Matt:
you out
Sam:
the
Matt:
there
Sam:
thing.
Matt:
telling the ref, I held him,
shawn:
Here's
Matt:
I
shawn:
the,
Matt:
held him?
shawn:
but Sam,
Sam:
Here,
shawn:
but Matt,
Sam:
here's
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
the thing is I think you're, I think you're changing the definition of integrity and you're actually making it tough for honest kids that are actually trying to do their job in sports to show integrity. You're conflating integrity with
Matt:
with honesty.
Sam:
a, with a, no, with a parent and with a, with a fan's view of it versus the player and the refs. Hey, what would be interesting if we have a referee? listening to the show, it would be really
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
interesting
Matt:
let us
Sam:
to
Matt:
know.
Sam:
hear from the ref's perspective, does a player have an obligation to self-report infractions? Or should they... And by the way, Matt,
Matt:
If you know you
Sam:
let's...
Matt:
break the rules,
Sam:
Yes.
Matt:
you should tell somebody. That would be honest and integrity.
Sam:
So, I-15 southbound later
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
Sam:
on today, speed limit 75 miles an hour. If you're going 78, you have an obligation to call up
Matt:
Uh...
Sam:
the Utah Highway Patrol and say, and three miles over.
Matt:
Sam, the speed limit is 70. So
Sam:
Whatever.
Matt:
now we know how much you regard the speed limits. Listen, if I go 71 in the speed zone, if I break the speed limit, I make sure my bishop knows about that in my temple recommended interview.
shawn:
Hahaha!
Matt:
When he says, are you honest in your dealings?
Sam:
But
Matt:
I'm like, well,
Sam:
wait, I'm
Matt:
not
Sam:
curious
Matt:
really.
Sam:
about this though. I'm curious about this. Do you ever speed in front of your kids or anybody else?
Matt:
No, I go
Sam:
You
Matt:
five
Sam:
don't?
Matt:
over. I go five over. Is that speeding?
Sam:
That is speeding. That's five over.
Matt:
Oh
Sam:
You've made a calculation about what you can get away with, how far outside the line, the field of play you can go without getting caught. And you know that if you stay within that five over, you're not gonna get caught, but it's still a moral, it's still a deception.
Matt:
About two years ago I decided I was tired of following traffic laws, that they're just a waste of my time. So I started running red lights. I would like go stop at a red light and if no one was there I would just go.
Sam:
Uh...
Matt:
This one
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
time I was driving my daughter home from the her mission actually. And I'm going to turn left and the people in the left turn lane aren't going and I think they should. So I went into the other lane of traffic to turn left. Yeah, and then my kids started telling me, Dad we're afraid of riding in a vehicle when you're driving.
Sam:
Oh,
Matt:
And
Sam:
I,
Matt:
so I was like,
Sam:
I get,
Matt:
oh.
Sam:
I get that a lot. I get that
Matt:
I gotta
Sam:
a lot
Matt:
go back
Sam:
now.
Matt:
to following
Sam:
Now for the
Matt:
the
Sam:
same
Matt:
law.
Sam:
reasons, I just don't drive good.
Matt:
Ha ha
Sam:
Just kidding. Matt, that was a great topic. Thank you. You in points for the big question on thought provoker. And we
Matt:
Hey,
Sam:
do need to hear from a ref. So any
Matt:
yeah,
Sam:
refs out there, give us your take.
Matt:
let us know. Hey, listener, thanks for joining us. We'll talk to you again next week.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories