The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
September 6, 2023: Inequality and the collapse of civilization, Mormon's coopting the cross, Should Trump stand trial, New Covid shutdowns, What happened to the Republican Party?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Two interesting thoughts from the mailbag.
One listener writes, “In response to the #exmormon topic… personally if find exmo’s some of the most annoying people to listen to and I’m sorry if that sounds harsh but that’s because ultimately i don’t believe their intentions are genuine. I believe those people are more interested in convincing themselves that the choice they made to leave the church, for whatever reason, was the right one. I feel like it’s almost comical that no one talks about the church more than someone who identifies themselves online as an Ex-Mormon does and that even includes members themselves. My typical reply to anyone trying to convince me that I should leave the church is echoes in similarity to Jeffrey R. Holland’s talk in general conference “Safety for the Soul”. I am the only active member of my family in the church (the rest are either inactive or left the church). I have never been able to convince anyone that my beliefs are correct. And I’ve never tried to. I’ve simply asked them that they respect my decision to stay in the church the same way I respect their decision to leave it. And I leave it at that.” I think that is often the best approach. What do you two think?
Another listener would like us to think about Peter Turchin’s argument that as empires grow, the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. When this happens, conflict replaces cooperation and it leads to the downfall of civilization. He also points out an argument that Clayton Christensen made in a 2012 Deseret News article that “The New Church of Finance” is leading corporations to abandon empowering innovations focus on sustaining innovations and efficiency innovations. This is bad because sustaining and efficiency innovations do not help workers. Taken together, this suggests that not all innovation or wealth accumulation is good for society. Do we have a moral obligation to oppose innovation that is not good for everyone in society?
The Thought Provoker
First up, Shawn: Something super sneaky happened this week…the Church changed their icon on google maps from Moroni to a cross. Perhaps the idea behind changing the icon from Moroni to a cross is to more clearly communicate that the church is part of the Christian family. “ https://www.instagram.com/reel/Cwk41DnpRyd/?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA== The other suggested reason for the change is to “guide people to locate an LDS church on google maps when searching for a “Christian” church.” ( a pragmatic missionary move) Regarding the first reason given by the source; Matt has stated in the past that he has found that traditional, orthodox christianity (Evangelicalism) is further from true Christianity than many non-christian religions. Sam has suggested that we should engage with those not of our faith with the purpose of embracing and celebrating our differences. So far, my evangelical friends are saying this is appropriation in order for us to look more mainstream. Does the Lord want us to be part of the modern Orthodox Christian identity and “blend in” or is this an attempt to take back the true meaning of Christianity by appropriating a conventional symbol?
Next up, Matt: Members of the Oath Keepers and the Proud Boys were recently sentenced for their roles in
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt:
Hey everybody, welcome to another week of the Latter Day Lens with Sean, Sam and Matt. It's good to have you with us this week. Okay, so we've got some interesting things from the mailbag. One of them is not quite so heavy. The other one is like I really had to think a lot about the stuff as I was putting it together. Okay, so the first listener writes about the ex-Mormon topic. They say that they have a lot of friends. In fact, everyone in their family they said... is either less active in the church or has left the church. And he thinks that it's not worth time. He says, I find exmos some of the most annoying people to listen to. And I'm sorry if that sounds harsh, but that's because ultimately I don't believe their intentions are genuine. I believe those people are more interested in convincing themselves that the choice they made to leave the church for whatever reason was the right one. I feel like it's almost comical that no one talks about the church more than someone who identifies themselves online as an ex-Mormon does. And that even includes members themselves. So he says the best thing to do is to just sort of leave it alone. So what do you two think? Sean, maybe the reason that Exmo is so like popular on, um, what did you call it? Twitch?
shawn:
social media.
Sam:
Reddit, I think is what he said.
Matt:
Uh,
shawn:
No,
Matt:
TikTok!
shawn:
it was
Sam:
Tick tock,
shawn:
Instagram
Sam:
tick tock,
shawn:
and TikTok
Sam:
yeah.
shawn:
is where
Matt:
Maybe it's
shawn:
the
Matt:
because
shawn:
hashtags.
Matt:
those people just can't let it go, like they're the loud, annoying, obnoxious people. And it's not because... Well, I don't know, so do you agree with the listener that it's better to just leave them alone?
shawn:
Well, I think that was more of your
Matt:
Yeah, that's
shawn:
sentiment
Matt:
my take for sure.
shawn:
because you're like, there's no point.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
I understand where you came from, I think. You were saying, I have a relationship of trust with certain people and in that relationship of trust, I'm able to influence or befriend or build a relationship and that is how we help each other go one direction or the other, right? There's no point in someone who's already taken an enemy stance to debate and battle bash, right? That was your point.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
But, but yeah, and I got that point. And I also got Sam's point, which I thought was really kind and good, which is it doesn't matter. How about just build relationships with those people? Right Sam, that was your point.
Matt:
They don't want relationships. I agree with Sam that it's good to listen to people, but I disagree with you, Sean, that we should engage with them.
shawn:
Yeah, I have...
Matt:
Listen
shawn:
I have...
Matt:
like the way that I listen to my kids when they're
Sam:
Uh...
Matt:
complaining at me that their allowance isn't high enough or something like that Yeah,
Sam:
Yeah, but
Matt:
yeah,
Sam:
why,
Matt:
yeah
Sam:
so here's my problem with that approach is you say, hey, I'm not gonna engage with them, I'm gonna ignore them, I'm gonna, I mean, is it the silent treatment, is it the cold shoulder?
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Do you refuse to engage because you're above it, right? I think the type of arrogance that you hear from ex-Mormons that kind of ruffles your feathers, like it's not a disease that will spread. If you're firm in your faith and your belief and you have a strong connection, like they're not gonna convince you. But there's no harm in hearing, there's no harm in empathizing, there's no harm in understanding and sitting with them in the challenges that they have. And there certainly is only danger in the world in saying, hey, I'm gonna refuse to listen to you because I just think, I think there's a certain amount of arrogance in saying I'm not gonna entertain that line of thought because I'm better than it, or I don't have time for it, or I'm not interested in it. Sometimes there's some really helpful, beneficial thoughts and ideas there that could heal them and also could help us have better empathy in the world and better understand how to defend our own faith.
Matt:
So the academic response to cancel culture, right? The way I see cancel culture is you express an idea that's unpopular or maybe shouldn't be expressed. And then the mob comes at you and says, you should lose your job, you should be fired, you should never be allowed to express that thought again,
Sam:
Which
Matt:
we
Sam:
is
Matt:
should
Sam:
wrong.
Matt:
destroy. Yeah, so
Sam:
It's
Matt:
the
Sam:
not
Matt:
academic,
Sam:
helpful.
Matt:
no, I agree. I think cancel culture is a bad thing. But what we do in academia is, if you say something really stupid, what we do is we just ignore you and we pretend like you never said it.
Sam:
That's worse! That's
Matt:
So in
Sam:
just
Matt:
my world,
Sam:
as
shawn:
Indifference.
Sam:
bad!
Matt:
like, yeah, the currency in my world is citations, right?
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
You know how good you are as a scholar because people cite your work and pay attention to your work. And so that, my natural inclination is if somebody says something like just dumb, I just be indifferent to it. I just don't pay any
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
attention
Sam:
but here,
Matt:
to it.
Sam:
but here's the problem is you have labeled everyone who has this exmo label as saying something dumb or wrong
Matt:
Oh, yeah,
Sam:
or combative
Matt:
yeah.
Sam:
and you're approaching it with an ego and an arrogance that isn't really
Matt:
Hmm.
Sam:
befitting of their approach necessarily. You don't know what they're going to say. Now, we're not talking about specific
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
examples here, but how arrogant to say that just because they're coming from a certain approach, you're not going to listen to them because Their opinion is dumb or not worthy of your time or consideration. Like
shawn:
Sam coming
Sam:
what
shawn:
out
Sam:
a
shawn:
guns
Sam:
terrible,
shawn:
a blazing
Sam:
what
shawn:
to
Sam:
a,
shawn:
Matt.
Sam:
what a terrible way to live to say, I refuse to consider their perspective because they're dumb. How do you ever expect to learn anything?
Matt:
I
Sam:
I
Matt:
didn't
Sam:
go back
Matt:
say
Sam:
to what
Matt:
they're
Sam:
I.
Matt:
dumb.
Sam:
Oh,
Matt:
I just said they don't want to listen to me so I shouldn't listen to them.
Sam:
but, but I go back to what I said last week, which is what a terrible world we would live in if we all look the same talk, the same thought, the same believe
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
Sam:
the same, like there is.
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
There is beauty in variety and difference.
shawn:
So I have a question for you about this because I can only judge my answer to this. I can only judge based on the experiences that I've had with people who have left the
Matt:
Hashtag
shawn:
church or
Matt:
Exmo.
shawn:
X mouse hashtag X
Sam:
two
shawn:
my
Sam:
billion
shawn:
folks.
Sam:
of them or three billion? Are we at
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
four billion yet, Sean?
shawn:
I haven't talked. I haven't talked to all of them yet. No.
Matt:
They're
Sam:
Okay.
Matt:
like McDonald's hamburgers. They
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
just keep spreading.
shawn:
It's documented the amount we put in
Matt:
I
shawn:
our
Matt:
know,
shawn:
episode.
Matt:
I know, yeah.
shawn:
So I went to when I do so my only experience is that they've been incredibly positive because when I engage with people I don't yet to make an enemy instead the relationships get strengthened and so I can only it's anecdotal I know but maybe it does depend on personality. However even though every time I've engaged with an XMO hashtag XMO. It's turned out positive in our relationship. It's evidence of Sam's point. However, Sam, here's a question for you. Many people who have listened to that episode have come to me and said they're very annoyed because they think that if I'm reaching out to those people and engaging with those people, my motives are
Sam:
impure because
shawn:
impure.
Sam:
you're trying to pure that apply them away or put them in a box or trying to convince them of something and I think it's Manipulative if that's your intent Sean your intent should be to understand and connect
shawn:
Oh, so guns a blazin' at me too. So you're jumpin' on their side. Okay,
Sam:
I am.
shawn:
so
Matt:
Sean is
shawn:
just
Matt:
manipulative
shawn:
like. Ha.
Matt:
and I'm condescending.
Sam:
Well, we already knew that about you, Matt.
shawn:
Alright,
Sam:
You're
shawn:
so...
Sam:
an academic. You don't generate money for anybody, but you tell us our ideas suck. It's good. I love
Matt:
Ha ha
Sam:
it.
Matt:
ha!
shawn:
So then Sam's altruistic and pure motive is to what? To understand them. That's
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
your altruistic and pure motive?
Matt:
I think what Sam is saying is, if you come into the situation thinking that you already know what they're going to say, or thinking that you already know what their motives are, then you probably are wasting your time. And that it's okay to engage with people, but you shouldn't have an agenda, or you shouldn't have already predetermined what you think their intentions are.
shawn:
You don't think there's any health in having a healthy kind we do it here all the time Like that was the original question was shouldn't we you guys both believe that we should in political circles Contend for what you believe in a peaceful kind way. Why not
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
religion? Why not?
Sam:
No, no, I'm not saying you don't contend with it, but if you engage with anybody that wears this exmo hashtag, which I think we're going down a rabbit hole a little bit because it's become so abstract. We're talking about this hashtag as if it represents a specific, you know, like it'd be interesting to talk about a specific argument that someone bearing that hashtag might make and then how that's a challenge one way or another,
shawn:
We could,
Sam:
right?
shawn:
oh
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
boy,
Sam:
But.
Matt:
like there's
shawn:
I could
Matt:
a
shawn:
do
Matt:
video
shawn:
that
Matt:
that
shawn:
because
Matt:
just
shawn:
I've
Matt:
came
shawn:
got
Matt:
out
shawn:
examples.
Matt:
this week. It's got like a million views, and it's this return missionary talking all about how the LDS Church is lying to you or what the LDS Church really is doing. And I've seen on YouTube, so there's this video with over a million views, and then there's these reaction videos to that video. And I think whoever it was that made this like 45 minute video. with like pictures, like it's well thought out, well designed, all about how the church is wrong or not true or whatever. What good does it do for me to message him on YouTube?
shawn:
I don't think
Matt:
To
shawn:
that,
Matt:
make a
shawn:
but...
Matt:
reaction video
Sam:
Oh,
Matt:
to him?
Sam:
and listen, I think there's time and place. I'm not necessarily talking about messaging with people on social media because there's a degree of separation and anonymity that goes along with social. What I am talking about is when we're face to face talking to someone, maybe even
shawn:
Any
Sam:
through,
shawn:
opportunity with
Sam:
yeah,
shawn:
a real
Sam:
I mean, let's,
shawn:
person, right?
Matt:
Oh.
Sam:
yeah, I'd love to sit down with somebody and just understand what their advantage point is. I mean, you know, there are people who've made claims to me and I think I've referred to it here before, hey, you know. Did you know there were four versions of the first vision? Right? Well,
Matt:
What?
Sam:
no, there weren't. There's no way that was. And you know, the old me 20 years ago probably would have argued ad nauseum that
Matt:
Hahahaha
Sam:
couldn't possibly be the case until you find out, you know what? That is, but that's okay. That's fine. I mean, we have an understanding and an explanation probably of that, right? So you can learn. And I think in some cases you kind of you, if you connect the right way, it is going to D, it's gonna make somebody less angry, maybe I don't know. So
shawn:
And I love that, and that's
Sam:
but
shawn:
been my
Sam:
I think
shawn:
experience.
Sam:
for next week, here's the challenge. Here's the deal.
Matt:
Oh no.
Sam:
Listener listener bag. Instead of making this so abstract, give us a concrete example of someone and an and an exmo topic. that you would find super annoying or difficult to sit down with somebody and really talk about and let's take it from the abstract to the real, right? So should we take Matt's approach, which is I'm not even going to entertain your deal because I know what I know and I don't even want to hear your viewpoint, or do we take Sean's approach, which is I'll engage with you to bring you back into the church, right?
shawn:
No, no, that's
Sam:
Or,
shawn:
not...
Sam:
no, I know, I'm just marginalizing you guys, or
Matt:
Sean,
Sam:
do we take mine, which
Matt:
don't
Sam:
is...
Matt:
fight the caricature.
Sam:
Yeah, that's right. Or do you take mine, which is, hey, let's have a conversation and let's see where we end up, right?
shawn:
Hey, if you're gonna misrepresent my stance, then I'm gonna call you a wet noodle for it. Let's just go
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
talk
Sam:
but
shawn:
to people and not have any point in it.
Sam:
I
shawn:
Ha
Sam:
misrepresented
Matt:
Oh Sean,
shawn:
ha
Sam:
Matt's stance and he had no problem
Matt:
I'm
Sam:
with
Matt:
okay
Sam:
it.
Matt:
with that.
shawn:
ha. Oh, that's
Matt:
I have
shawn:
true.
Matt:
no problem with that. I look down on the world. I'm okay. Okay.
shawn:
But Matt lives in a cartoon world. Hang on, I just want to bring in one quick point.
Sam:
Oh, Sean
shawn:
So
Sam:
needs
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
one more thing. Go ahead, Sean.
shawn:
so Sam, how do you not, how do you answer Luke 15 for them? Where there's the parable
Sam:
You'd have to
shawn:
of
Sam:
read
shawn:
the sheep,
Sam:
it because I don't remember it. What?
shawn:
the sheep,
Matt:
I think it says Matt
shawn:
if you
Matt:
lives
shawn:
lose.
Matt:
in a cartoon world.
shawn:
Ha ha!
Matt:
Ha ha ha.
Sam:
That's a bad joke.
Matt:
Okay there's some sheep and
shawn:
There's,
Matt:
some goats.
shawn:
who has
Sam:
Donkeys.
shawn:
a hundred sheep and one gets
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
lost doesn't go after and find that sheep. When he cometh and calleth together his friends and neighbors saying, hey, rejoice with me for I found the one lost sheep. I say unto you that likewise, joy shall be in heaven over one sinner that repenteth more than over 99 just persons. How
Sam:
I
shawn:
do you
Sam:
stand
shawn:
answer
Sam:
corrected.
shawn:
that?
Matt:
Yeah, Sam. We all have
Sam:
I stand
Matt:
an agenda.
Sam:
corrected, yes.
Matt:
OK, well, another listener decided to be really specific. And I have to admit, a little bit of it is over my head, just a tad.
shawn:
Well, you have
Matt:
Um.
shawn:
to study the link that you provided is a very, yeah,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
I had to study that link to try and understand the whole question.
Matt:
Yeah, they gave me some good links and I put them in the show notes. So listener, you can, you can learn about this too. So there's somebody named Peter Turchin and they make an argument that as empires grow, the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. And when this happens, conflict replaces cooperation, and it leads to the downfall of civilization. That's one point. The other point is an argument that Clayton Christiansen made in a 2012 desert news article. He talks about something he calls the new church of finance. And he says that it's leading corporations to abandon empowering innovations and focus instead on sustaining and efficiency innovations. And he says this is bad because sustaining and efficiency innovations don't actually help society or workers. So taken together, this suggests that not all innovation or wealth accumulation is good for society. So do
Sam:
Oh
Matt:
we have
Sam:
my
Matt:
a
Sam:
goodness.
Matt:
moral obligation to oppose innovation? That's not... So efficiency innovation would be like, instead of producing Camrys, you produce a Prius because it's cheaper to produce and you can sell more of them. No, that's a sustaining innovation, right?
shawn:
That's sustaining.
Matt:
An efficiency innovation is when you just find a way to sort of change the way that you're spending money so that you're making more money but you're not actually becoming a stronger, better organization or you don't.
shawn:
But he's saying that it helps the people because what it does is it brings something like, like let's take something that is not accessible because of the cost, I don't know, a vehicle, right? And then Model T Ford gets created and it's affordable. So they've made it more efficient and therefore more people benefit from it.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Well, how about the intersection of government control and free markets? And we have an example of that this past week. So President Biden was super excited to announce drug price reductions on select drugs that are super expensive, drugs that people, because of lifestyle choices in many cases, have to take. I'm trying to think of a few of them. I don't have
Matt:
They're
Sam:
the list
Matt:
like diabetes
Sam:
of them.
Matt:
drugs that
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
they're gonna negotiate the price
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
on and
Sam:
So drug companies have taken big risks and gone through large product innovation cycles with the FDA to develop these, bring them to market and market them to consumers. The government in the list of these drugs has gone in and they have negotiated super cheap prices. Well, what people don't get, I think, if you think about this logically, if they negotiate cheap prices, drug companies will offset the cost of those drugs into other drugs, right? Because they still have all their innovation, uh, expense, their regulatory approval expense, and then they have the cost of all the trials that never come to market or fail. Right. So they still have to bear that expense and that burden. So I think drug companies then, um, as they're forced to offer a product to the market at a super low price, they're forced to do one of two things. They're going to innovate less, right? and they're going to distribute the price of the or the cost of that manufacturing out in other products. And that's a problem when government gets involved in the free market as they are right now. So I think when you talk about these two models that Clinton Christensen talks about this Peter Churchin, like I think that's bad for free markets when government comes in and uses regulation or artificial price, basically price fixing. and it tries to tell industry, hey, you need to produce a product at a certain cost. The
Matt:
But
Sam:
industry
Matt:
the listeners
Sam:
then
Matt:
are...
Sam:
is gonna stop innovating and stop bringing best products to market. And you...
Matt:
The
Sam:
Okay.
Matt:
listener's argument though is that sometimes markets and societies reward products and services that are not the best for society. So it's true, diabetes drugs, people need those and we want innovation in diabetes drugs. But it's also true that Viagra makes lots and lots and lots of money and that doesn't necessarily solve a problem for society. And that there's other innovations,
Sam:
That is
Matt:
one
Sam:
a
Matt:
of
Sam:
standout drug, Matt. That's a very important
Matt:
the...
Sam:
drug.
Matt:
Viagra?
Sam:
Ha ha ha.
shawn:
Oh,
Matt:
Or
shawn:
revealing Sam.
Matt:
if you think in medicine, right, there's a lot of innovation in plastic surgeries and elective surgeries and things that make a lot of money, but there's not necessarily innovation in the day-to-day care that doesn't make a lot of money. And so that sometimes market incentives, this is Clayton Christensen's point, that market incentives drive innovations that are not for the better of society, they're just better for the people trying to accumulate well.
Sam:
So I took his point wrong. I took his point when the market looks at how free the market is or how it's not, it could change to a defense mechanism rather than an offense. And drug companies shifting from being super innovative to having to offset the cost of innovation to other products because they're forced to offer for a lower price, that will not in the short term, or not in the, that will in the short and middle term, that's gonna in. that will impact the ability for us to have drugs and solutions and cures that humanity needs. Think about this, that one announcement by Biden this week and the pressure by the federal government to bring medicines to the market could impact whether or not you could have a cure for a certain type of cancer or a certain type of terrible disease that could be cured five
Matt:
Well, no, because
Sam:
10s down
Matt:
they're
Sam:
the road.
Matt:
financing cancer research. Biden's spending more on cancer research than anybody ever has before. Ha
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
ha
Sam:
that
shawn:
don't take his tangent.
Sam:
the
shawn:
Sam's
Sam:
no
shawn:
hijacking
Sam:
the
Matt:
ha.
Sam:
best.
shawn:
the topic
Sam:
Listen, listen,
shawn:
and you've
Sam:
the
shawn:
given
Sam:
best,
shawn:
into his tangent.
Sam:
the best path to innovation
Matt:
is
Sam:
and to
Matt:
money.
Sam:
curing those problems is money. And that is that is a solution pursued by large corporations that they can then market make money off of and it's a circle.
Matt:
Or the government can just decide to fund
Sam:
But
Matt:
the research.
Sam:
government is a lot less efficient
shawn:
Hang
Sam:
at doing
shawn:
on
Sam:
that.
shawn:
hang
Matt:
Like
shawn:
on you
Matt:
they
shawn:
guys
Matt:
did with
shawn:
are
Matt:
COVID
shawn:
hot
Matt:
vaccine.
shawn:
Sam
Matt:
I'm sorry,
shawn:
is
Matt:
Sean. Ha ha
shawn:
Sam has hijacked the
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
topic
Sam:
I
Matt:
ha.
Sam:
love that
shawn:
Matt gave
Sam:
we're gonna
shawn:
in
Sam:
come back to COVID vaccines
shawn:
Hang on
Sam:
today. So
shawn:
hang
Sam:
yeah.
shawn:
on Do we have a set the question he posed and we're not we will not ignore it Sam is do we have a more obligation to? Oppose innovation that is not for good for everyone in society
Matt:
Yes.
Sam:
Yeah, but
shawn:
Matt
Sam:
I reject the premise of the question. I reject the premise of the question
Matt:
Sam's not gonna answer that question, because it's a...
Sam:
because it's stupid, it's ridiculous. Yeah.
shawn:
Alright, Matt,
Matt:
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
shawn:
so Matt, but I'll talk with you about it. Matt. So,
Sam:
I'm turning off my mic in protest.
Matt:
Ha ha ha!
Sam:
Government
shawn:
so Matt.
Sam:
oversight stifles innovation, and that's
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
That's
Sam:
what you're
shawn:
so
Matt:
not
Sam:
talking
shawn:
here's
Matt:
the
Sam:
about.
Matt:
question.
shawn:
Matt. Yeah, that's not even the question, Sam. Jeez.
Sam:
D'UGH!
Matt:
Hahahaha
shawn:
So Matt, the moral obligation to oppose innovation that is not good for everyone in society. Here's my problem with that. How do we determine which innovation is not good for whom?
Matt:
Oh, that's why we have social scientists. We know the answers to all of these questions.
shawn:
Oh no,
Matt:
That's
shawn:
oh
Matt:
so
shawn:
no.
Matt:
easy. Ask me a question, I can tell you who it's good for and who it's bad for.
shawn:
Which is exactly why
Matt:
Come
shawn:
I oppose
Matt:
to the experts.
shawn:
it. No, it's exactly why I oppose it, because there's a group of people who think they can determine what is best for me.
Matt:
I can.
shawn:
No,
Matt:
Now
shawn:
I
Matt:
you
shawn:
determine
Matt:
have-
shawn:
what's best for me.
Matt:
Well, but you could be wrong about that, Sean. You might think that-
shawn:
And that piece of paper that says your group of people have the authority to do that is a huge problem.
Matt:
So your problem with the idea that we oppose things that aren't good for everyone is you say, we can't possibly know what's good for everyone. So we should never oppose these things because we don't know.
shawn:
The answer of I know what's good for everyone suggests that someone who disagrees with you is going to have their rights trampled upon.
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
Yes.
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
it's inevitable.
shawn:
and that's absolutely wrong.
Matt:
Oh...
shawn:
You can't determine for Sam what Sam values most. You cannot. That's free agency. I think that's
Matt:
But
shawn:
what's best for Sam.
Matt:
I do know what's best for Sam.
shawn:
Oh,
Matt:
And he
shawn:
well.
Matt:
might disagree with me. But I've...
Sam:
Free markets unencumbered by government. That's the key.
Matt:
I know that that's what Sam thinks is best for him. But what's really best for him is something that we could... Now it would take some time. I'd have to sit down, maybe do some MRIs of his entire body and like
Sam:
I've
Matt:
figure
Sam:
already
Matt:
out
Sam:
done
Matt:
all...
Sam:
that!
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
So
shawn:
he does.
Matt:
we could take that data, Sam. We could take that data that's been gathered and we could tell you what's best for you.
shawn:
And they can make the decision for you, Sam. And then you'll have to never make decisions. You can
Sam:
So
shawn:
sit in
Sam:
terrible.
shawn:
a room.
Matt:
But Sean,
Sam:
What's wrong with academia? And that's what's wrong with Sean.
Matt:
at some point,
shawn:
Yeah
Matt:
everybody does that, right? It's just, what you're saying to me, Sean, is it's just a question of where we draw the line because everything we do in society is based on an accepted idea of what's right and wrong or what's good and bad for society. So for example, if you say to me, hey, we should have slower speed limits in school zones. And I say to you, no, I can drive 100 miles an hour in a school zone when a bunch of kids are there. And you say, no, that's dangerous. Like you could make a mistake, there could be some accident, some kid could die, and I could say, no, I'm good enough. I know for myself, I like practice on the course or whatever, I will never kill a child by speeding through a school zone. Like I just have that much knowledge about myself. And you guys would say, no, as a society, it's not worth that risk. We've decided as a society that nobody should be able to do that. because the risk is too great. And it's the same kind of a question.
shawn:
You've, yeah, I don't know. You've taken it too broad. We're talking about innovation specifically. That's a very broad example.
Matt:
I can
shawn:
No
Matt:
say...
shawn:
one would disagree with you
Sam:
Good
shawn:
there,
Sam:
job,
shawn:
but.
Sam:
Sean.
shawn:
Ha ha
Sam:
Telling Matt he answered off topic.
shawn:
ha.
Matt:
I can say that when you decide
shawn:
I'm sorry.
Matt:
as a company that you're going to focus on efficiency to create wealth More than what Clayton Christensen calls empowering innovations Then you're not allowed to do that anymore because we risk widening the gap between rich and poor in America and that widening gap of rich and poor could lead to our the end of our Civilization like Peter Turchin has studied this and he knows it'll lead to
shawn:
So
Matt:
the
shawn:
what's
Matt:
end of our civilization
shawn:
your... Okay,
Matt:
And that's
shawn:
so...
Matt:
too great a risk to allow you to be rich
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
when it could risk.
shawn:
so if you the magical genius, godlike scientists who have decided that, what is the percentage? Like if you're looking at three separate innovations and one innovation only serves 10% of society and the other two serve 100% of the society, is it 10%, is it 15%, is it 20%, what number determines we are going to squash that innovation because it doesn't serve everybody?
Matt:
That's the beauty of our political system in America, is we can elect people and they get to decide that for us. They just
shawn:
Now
Matt:
choose
shawn:
you're...
Matt:
those.
shawn:
that's not the question. We're not bringing in government.
Matt:
Oh, I have to decide?
shawn:
What
Matt:
Uh...
shawn:
you're saying, we as a society should decide. So you're trying to...
Matt:
I would definitely study the topic a little bit more before I made those percentages, before I figured that out.
shawn:
Hehehehe
Matt:
But just broadly, we can agree that like, hey, this listener is right. We should worry about rich and poor and that gap because it will destroy society. And we should focus on good innovation and not just let people get rich
shawn:
The premise of
Matt:
doing
shawn:
the question
Matt:
stupid
shawn:
is,
Matt:
things.
shawn:
do different types of innovation destroy the middle class? That's what the
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
question is. And
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
that's not, I don't know. We're
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
not agreeing with that premise.
Sam:
best innovation happens at the foot scuttle of risk, right? Which companies
Matt:
No.
Sam:
are best able to take on
shawn:
Unencumbered.
Sam:
in an unencumbered and more unrestricted free market. And
Matt:
You
Sam:
when
Matt:
guys
Sam:
government
Matt:
are such capitalists.
Sam:
comes in and tries to make decisions, or when academia comes in and tries to make
Matt:
smart
Sam:
decisions,
Matt:
people
Sam:
or even religion
Matt:
experience.
Sam:
tries to tell people what's best for them, it's a problem. Like, free market, think about, there is no healthcare. Is there a healthcare industry in the world that's better than the one in the United States?
Matt:
Yes, there are many
Sam:
Where?
Matt:
of them. Great Britain,
Sam:
Better?
Matt:
sure.
Sam:
Because people from the US go to Great Britain to have, they can't even,
shawn:
Hang on,
Sam:
like,
shawn:
Matt, does...
Sam:
they don't
Matt:
Spain
Sam:
get braces
Matt:
is the envy of
Sam:
in
Matt:
the
Sam:
Great
Matt:
world.
Sam:
Britain. What?
shawn:
Matt.
Sam:
Spain?
Matt:
There are people that are tourists
Sam:
Switzerland.
Matt:
to go to hospitals in Spain.
shawn:
Matt, how many governments or countries are using the innovations from America in their health programs that become attractive to other people?
Sam:
Oh, there you go, thank you,
Matt:
Are
Sam:
Sean,
Matt:
you talking
Sam:
I appreciate
Matt:
specifically
Sam:
that.
Matt:
about Viagra here? Are we gonna talk about the COVID vaccine? COVID vaccine was developed in Great Britain as fast as it was developed here, and they have national healthcare over there.
Sam:
It was developed in Russia faster by the way. I
Matt:
No,
Sam:
do remember
Matt:
it was
Sam:
Russia
Matt:
not.
Sam:
actually first
Matt:
It was
Sam:
came
Matt:
brought
Sam:
out
Matt:
to
Sam:
with
Matt:
market
Sam:
it and
Matt:
faster in Russia.
Sam:
yeah
Matt:
It was not developed faster.
Sam:
Its efficacy was not as good though
shawn:
I don't, I'm going to go out on a limb and say that
Matt:
Hmm
shawn:
the latter day lens here would suggest that agency perhaps maybe is the principle behind
Sam:
Ooh,
shawn:
what
Sam:
I
shawn:
should
Sam:
like
shawn:
guide
Sam:
that,
shawn:
our
Sam:
Sean.
shawn:
society?
Sam:
Nice.
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
What's
Matt:
well...
Sam:
I'll take that.
shawn:
your latter day lens defense Matt?
Matt:
We have a moral obligation to oppose everything that's bad in society. And just like Captain Moroni opposed the wicked Lamanites, if I know that income inequality is going to destroy my country,
shawn:
Why are you...
Matt:
I need to build walls of defenses to destroy income
shawn:
But you've
Matt:
inequality.
shawn:
okay, but you why are you just defaulting to some academics article about income?
Matt:
Oh, I'm not sure if Peter Turchin is right. If he's right, if he's right that this gap between rich and poor will lead to the fall of American society, I think I do have a moral obligation to oppose that and to try to
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
fix that.
shawn:
Well, we can dive in deeper on that later, right? Cause then we can discuss
Matt:
Yeah, I just don't know
shawn:
if
Matt:
if he's
shawn:
his premise
Matt:
right.
shawn:
is correct.
Matt:
I
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
watched that
shawn:
good.
Matt:
YouTube video, Sean, but that stuff puts me to sleep. It's so hard for me
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
to...
shawn:
it's hard, yeah.
Matt:
These big questions of like, rise and fall of civilization, that's so uninteresting to me. But other people like it, and so... It's fine.
shawn:
Well then let's get into something a little more thought provoking.
Matt:
Okay, Sean, you're first. Let's see if you can win the Thought Provoker today.
shawn:
Oh man, I love this one. This is, this made me so happy when this came across. This combines all the stuff I love. It's religion, it's marketing and branding,
Matt:
Oh
shawn:
it's modern, okay. So something super sneaky happened this week. And I don't think a lot of us noticed it. Most of us probably did not. So the church changed the icon on Google Maps from Moroni to a cross. So
Matt:
You
shawn:
perhaps.
Matt:
know how you say I'm a geek because I like political science?
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
What kind of a person pays attention to the icons on Google Maps? Is that a geeky person? Okay.
shawn:
Yeah, probably. Yes. It's a logo dude. It's amazing. Okay.
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
So the question is why, right? So perhaps the idea behind changing the icon from Moroni to a cross is more clearly, uh, is to more clearly communicate that the church is part of the Christian family. So the other suggested reason for the change is to, is it kind of a sneaky way or a smart way. to guide people to locate an LDS church on Google Maps when they're searching for a so-called Christian church. It's a more of a pragmatic missionary move. But regarding the first question given by the source of this article, Matt, you've stated in the past that you've found that traditional Orthodox or evangelical
Matt:
Christians.
shawn:
religion Christians is, you find as much further from true Christianity than many non-Christian religions, right? That's what you've said.
Matt:
Uh, yeah.
shawn:
And
Matt:
I
shawn:
then
Matt:
think, yeah. Mm-hmm.
shawn:
something like that. And then, and then Sam, you've suggested that we should engage with those, not of our faith, but only with the purpose
Sam:
Yes.
shawn:
of embracing and celebrating
Matt:
We lost
shawn:
their
Matt:
Sean.
shawn:
differences.
Matt:
Oh, there he is.
shawn:
Sorry. Did I repeat that?
Matt:
No,
shawn:
Sorry.
Matt:
it's okay. We got it.
shawn:
Yeah. So Sam, is that, is that fair? You've said that we should engage with people, not of our religion, but only to embrace. the differences and form good relationships.
Sam:
Yes,
Matt:
That's
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
not
Sam:
I
Matt:
only
Sam:
think.
Matt:
to
Sam:
I don't know.
Matt:
only Sam doesn't only want to engage to build relationships
shawn:
Well, let him answer. That's what you said before just 10 minutes ago.
Sam:
You cut in and out, so I'm just going to say yes for simplicity's sake. Keep
shawn:
Oh
Sam:
going.
shawn:
no, oh no.
Matt:
What's
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
your question, Sean? What's your question?
shawn:
so for my evangelical friends, what they're telling me is that this is appropriation. In order for
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
us to look more mainstream, we're appropriating an accepted symbol, which is the cross. So
Sam:
So what?
shawn:
the question is this, the question is this, does the Lord want us to be part of the modern Orthodox Christian identity and blend in? Or is this more of an attempt to take back the true meaning of Christianity? by appropriating a conventional symbol.
Matt:
We're going to take your symbol the cross and we're going to make it represent our church because we're the true church and you're not
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
The,
Matt:
That's
shawn:
that's
Matt:
the
shawn:
what the
Sam:
the,
shawn:
question
Matt:
that's
shawn:
is.
Matt:
the second option
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
the only, the only problem was starting to use the cross a lot and we are starting to use it more is I had such a cool story for the reason why we wouldn't use the cross ever. And it makes
Matt:
Hahahaha
Sam:
me like walk that back, right?
shawn:
Oh
Sam:
Like
shawn:
yeah, yeah.
Sam:
the whole, the whole line item about, you know, it was symbolic of his death and it was a terrible place. And it's like,
shawn:
Which
Sam:
it's
shawn:
is
Sam:
like
shawn:
the
Sam:
putting
shawn:
rhetoric.
Sam:
a, it's like putting a gun in around your neck and
shawn:
Which is
Sam:
you
shawn:
the
Sam:
know,
shawn:
rhetoric that
Sam:
in,
shawn:
we've
Sam:
in
shawn:
heard over
Sam:
In
shawn:
the years,
Sam:
a continuing
shawn:
right?
Sam:
restoration where things evolve over time, it makes me mad that I have to walk back things I've said in the past.
Matt:
So
Sam:
But otherwise,
shawn:
the
Sam:
I'm fine with the appropriation.
Matt:
I was driving past the Oram temple, the brand new Oram temple,
Sam:
True,
Matt:
and I noticed
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
it doesn't have an angel moroni on top.
Sam:
and many
Matt:
And
Sam:
don't now.
Matt:
yeah, and I remember President Hinckley, he was all about putting the angel moroni on everything. He put
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
it on temples that didn't have them,
Sam:
Yup.
Matt:
and now we're like, oh, let's get rid of the angel moroni. We want, and again, President Nelson is a prophet of God, so I support what he's doing, but. His whole thing is like, let's make Christ our symbol, right? Not
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
Moroni our symbol. But to me, these decisions about marketing and branding, they're not inspired like, hey, heavenly father, how do you want us to brand your church? They're just marketing decisions, right?
shawn:
Pragmatic, yeah.
Matt:
I
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
understand the name of the church, but the
Sam:
but
Matt:
marketing.
Sam:
marketing decisions reflect the approach or the attitude towards the overall topic. So it is a pretty big change, I think, to all of a sudden move to a cross, because didn't you all hear the whole, we don't use a cross because mentality
Matt:
Oh sure,
Sam:
or language
Matt:
yeah.
Sam:
from, I mean, we talked about that over and over and over on our missions.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
And that's a pretty big contrast to what we've said in the past. But I'm okay with it. Like, why not use that as a symbol? And
shawn:
Well
Sam:
it
shawn:
yeah, cause
Sam:
is
shawn:
that's...
Sam:
commonly accepted in Christianity. It does bring us closer to others that similarly believe in Christ. Why would we want to separate ourselves
Matt:
Why not
Sam:
that way?
Matt:
use the Star of David and the crescent? And
Sam:
We should
Matt:
why don't...
Sam:
combine them that
Matt:
We
Sam:
would
Matt:
should
Sam:
take
Matt:
use all...
Sam:
people off.
Matt:
We should do like this
Sam:
Talk
Matt:
little
Sam:
about
Matt:
bumper sticker that says, Coexist,
shawn:
So
Matt:
and it
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
can have
shawn:
you...
Matt:
the symbols of every religion. And then
Sam:
And
Matt:
we
Sam:
a
Matt:
just
Sam:
fish.
Matt:
put... We can put that on our church. And they're like, wow, they're everything. That church is everything.
shawn:
So, but what do you think is the, so for so many years we purposefully differentiated ourselves from Orthodox Christianity, because our statement is good people, but those religions are coming from creeds that are not of God. And these are apostate versions
Sam:
Yeah, but we were Mormon
shawn:
of Christianity.
Sam:
back then, Sean. We were Mormon back then.
shawn:
Yeah, because we were trying to differentiate between the two, but now are we gonna try and move forward and go, let's, not differentiate so much, let's build. I don't know, that's the question is.
Matt:
I don't like the idea of us copying other religions. I really, really don't like that. And I think
shawn:
You
Matt:
for
shawn:
like
Matt:
two,
shawn:
differentiating.
Matt:
no, I'm in favor of co-opting. We can take it and make it ours. If we have the money to buy the cross as a logo and as a symbol and no
Sam:
Ooh.
Matt:
one else can use it but us,
shawn:
So
Matt:
I'm a-
shawn:
you mocked me for the question, and now your strong opinion is exactly what the question was suggesting.
Matt:
I don't want anyone to mistake our church for an evangelical church, for a Catholic church, for a Russian Orthodox church. We're not like them. They have good things that they can bring to us when they join our church. I think that's great. I'm not saying there's not goodness there, but there's goodness in Buddhism and there's goodness in Hinduism and there's goodness in Islam. And I don't want to try to... I don't want people to think we're like evangelicals anymore than I want them to think we're like Islam or Buddhism or Hinduism. So I'm okay with co-opting as long as it's uniquely ours.
shawn:
Interesting.
Sam:
So,
shawn:
So,
Sam:
oh,
shawn:
I'll go ahead Sam.
Sam:
so I'd just like to read something from Reddit that I read. It says,
Matt:
Oh good.
Sam:
all Google Map locations are assigned a primary category. This category determines which icon is used on the market. Marker that appears on the map. Google created these icons and there's no process by which a request can be made to change it. So many years ago, for whatever reason, Google assigned the Moroni themed marker. And this change. is made to make meeting houses more consistent with Christian denominations. So it's not,
Matt:
Oh, so
Sam:
it,
Matt:
Google did it, not
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
us. Oh.
Sam:
That's what this one Reddit says. Who
Matt:
Do
Sam:
knows if that's true.
Matt:
you think that there was church pressure though to Google saying, hey, don't give us a Moroni thing. We're not Moroni. We're
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
the Church of Jesus Christ.
Sam:
here's what it says. With the approval of the Church Communication Executive Committee, meeting houses are now assigned the primary category, Christian Church, to increase their findability with Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and religious organization as additional categories. As a result, Google assigned icon change from Moroni to the cross. This change is specific to meeting houses only. Other church-owned properties may continue to display the Moroni marker, including temples or admin offices. That's more confusing, not less.
shawn:
But if you've
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
got a person driving down the street in a new state, then they're looking for a Christian church, they're now going to land at the doorstep of an LDS church.
Matt:
as they should because we're a good Christian church.
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
We're the only Christian church.
shawn:
but
Sam:
The
shawn:
that's
Sam:
truest.
shawn:
the point of the opposing the question as I did, Matt. And I see that your opinion is, yes, let's appropriate a symbol that the world has come to recognize as Christian because we are the true Christian Church. So you
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
like the appropriation.
Matt:
Yes, I'll take appropriation. And they can accuse me of anything that they want because their church wasn't founded by Jesus Christ and ours was. So if they wanna get mad, they can get mad at him, not me.
shawn:
Okay, Sam,
Matt:
It's his
shawn:
do you
Matt:
church.
shawn:
agree with that? Do you
Sam:
Yes,
shawn:
agree with
Sam:
I
shawn:
that,
Sam:
do.
shawn:
Sam?
Sam:
100%.
shawn:
Oh, you both agree. Okay, appropriate it. All right, good. My evangelical buddy, they were upset that this is appropriation
Matt:
Well, you know what?
shawn:
and...
Matt:
They should be upset. Because it's a symbol that they've put a lot of time and effort into creating. But I just would like all of my evangelical friends to know that we are the Church of Jesus Christ, and they're an offshoot. And that's fine. We welcome offshoots. They're happy. Like, they know that they're an offshoot of the true Church of Christ. They chose to be Protestants. That's what they are. We're not Protestants.
shawn:
I
Matt:
We're
shawn:
love
Matt:
the Church
shawn:
it, preach
Matt:
of Jesus
shawn:
it,
Matt:
Christ.
shawn:
I love it, preach
Sam:
We'd
shawn:
it, man,
Sam:
also like
shawn:
I
Sam:
to
shawn:
love
Sam:
be known
shawn:
it.
Sam:
under the hashtag Xmo, just for
Matt:
Hahahaha
Sam:
the purpose of
shawn:
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
Sam:
building bridges and making friends, influencing people.
Matt:
I mean I would be mad right? I would be mad if I like built but by the way evangelicals and orthodox
Sam:
It's
Matt:
Christians didn't create the symbol of the
Sam:
no,
Matt:
cross it was the Catholic Church that did that.
Sam:
it's not a
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
narrow symbol. And so in the marketing world, Sean, you probably know this, right? It's the number one most recognized symbol on the face of planet earth, right? The second happens to be the Mercedes-Benz logo, which is near and dear to my heart, but yes.
Matt:
Ha ha!
shawn:
Yeah. So would you guys go as far if you're counseling the church leadership to say put it up on buildings, put it up on temples.
Matt:
Yes, if you're going to get rid of Moroni, I don't want just a steeple that makes me look like a 7th day Adventist. I want a cross. There should be something. There should
Sam:
Or
Matt:
be...if
Sam:
an
Matt:
you're going to...yeah.
Sam:
S, so it looks more like Scientology or something, I don't know, it's
Matt:
We should just create...we've
Sam:
your choice.
Matt:
got a logo, right? We've got that
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
little logo.
shawn:
It's the Christus.
Matt:
But that's really tough to put on a steeple.
Sam:
Yeah, you can't put that, it's too heavy.
shawn:
I'm fascinated that you both think that we should put the cross on temples. That's fascinating to me. And, and
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
yeah, that's.
Matt:
but you know, Sean, so many temples have visitor centers with a prominent display of the Christus statue in the visitor
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
center with the big
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
windows
shawn:
yeah.
Matt:
around it.
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
I really think that that's the symbol that the church has decided to go with, is the Christus symbol or the Christ statue itself. But I would much rather see a cross on a temple than just a spire with nothing up there.
shawn:
I agree, yeah. Wow, interesting. Cool.
Matt:
But we could make it our own cross. If evangelicals don't like the way that, if our cross is too similar to theirs, we could do like a different cross. Make it more like a plus sign maybe. I don't know. What about a tree? Does anybody
shawn:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Matt:
take the tree? Hey, can I win Thought Provoker for that thought provoking
Sam:
yes
Matt:
question? Ha ha ha.
shawn:
We'll see at the end. Yeah, we'll see.
Matt:
Hey,
Sam:
hashtag
Matt:
I thought we decided
Sam:
LDS
Matt:
it.
Sam:
cross
shawn:
Yeah
Matt:
Okay, I get to go second for thought provoker. Okay, so this week, members of the Proud Boys were sentenced, members of the Oath Keepers were sentenced for their roles in the January 6th attack on the US Capitol. Some of them were sentenced to more than 15 years in federal prison for what they did. Now, I know that some Republicans like to say that Trump is being targeted for political reasons and that there's a two-tier system of justice in America. And I hear other Republicans saying Trump shouldn't be indicted because he's running for office and that sets a bad precedent. But I do think we should keep in mind that each of the indictments was not made by the Justice Department. They took the evidence before a grand jury made up of average citizens who were randomly selected to be on those grand juries. They listened to the evidence and then the grand juries voted that there was evidence for an indictment. So it's not like the Justice Department is just doing this on their own. There are Americans that are looking at the evidence saying, yeah, there's enough evidence there for a crime. And it's also true that a majority of Americans and even registered voters think that Trump did something wrong in the documents case and on January 6th. And there's not polling on this specific question, but I do doubt if anyone actually believes that the Oath Keepers or the Proud Boys would have stormed the Capitol if not for President Trump and the things he was encouraging people to do. So here's the question. Given this reality, Wouldn't it be morally wrong to not indict Trump? How could it possibly be good for our country for some people to go to prison for January 6th, but for Trump to never have to face a jury himself? That would be morally wrong, would it not?
Sam:
So I have an opinion on this. I'm gonna take the opposite viewpoint. I think if Trump ends up needing to go in front of a jury, it should happen well after the election. And here's the reason, we live in such a divided country with people on both sides who are incredibly passionate about their viewpoints, that the more about this comes out and if he does stand in front of a jury, it just deepens the anger and the divide between people. As an event, as something that happened, it's just divisive. And it helps his polling numbers. It makes him more popular with a super kind of, you know, ultra conservative, ultra fanatical corner of the world, Americanism. I think it's better to either not do it or do it after the election and allow it to happen completely outside the political cycle.
shawn:
Quick question, is...
Matt:
But shouldn't politics not be a consideration in this
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
situation?
Sam:
and in a perfect world and in a vacuum, it absolutely should. But the reality is, is in our social media world and 24 hour news cycle, it is absolutely front and center. And it w and it already has impacted. Like there's not a Republican right now in the debate stage that can get traction around Trump. And the dude has more indictments and more political problems than anybody in the history of politics and people still love him for it, right? It, it, it will eat our American political system up. And it would be it would be wise to somehow decelerate some of this negative rhetoric around it. And I've listened to all the shows, you know, that the justice system is doing a smart thing, they're starting at the absolute lowest level. So they've got a ton of detail behind what happened with the most minor actors so that by the time they get to the very top, they've got a super solid case and they know exactly who told who to do what. I just think there's some wisdom behind waiting. to take on Trump until after the election. So it doesn't turn into a an item for this presidential cycle.
Matt:
What do you say, Sean?
shawn:
Sam, you'd suggested that it's divisive to go after them now. Would you say it was more divisive than what they're being accused of on January 6th? Was that not divisive?
Sam:
No, I think the whole thing's a mess. But you know what? We've already talked about it. There are people who are members of our church and other Christian churches and evangelical churches that are really good, really normal people that have lost their ever-loving mind over this topic.
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
Neighbors
shawn:
I f-
Sam:
who you would say, hey, these are nice people that would just, that like to plant things in their flower garden that would carry a torch somewhere in defense of this because they think it's wrong, right? Like... Don't give Trump that ammunition. Don't allow him to benefit
shawn:
You think
Sam:
off of it.
shawn:
from a strategy standpoint. I don't know, Matt, I kind of agree with you. I'm gonna quote one of our country's greatest poets, James Hetfield,
Sam:
Did you know it?
shawn:
of Metallica.
Matt:
Oh, okay.
shawn:
It's the ultimate in vanity exploiting their supremacy. Justice is lost, justice is raped, and justice is gone.
Matt:
Wow, that's good poetry.
Sam:
Wow, and
shawn:
Huh. Hehehehe.
Sam:
nothing else matters.
Matt:
Well, but Sam, put yourself in the position of one of these families whose dad's going to jail for what he did on January 6th, and then you hear someone like you saying, well, you know, but Trump is so divisive and it tears the country apart, and so Trump's justice should either be delayed or should never ever come.
Sam:
I'm not saying don't ever come, I'm just saying don't make it a part or an issue of the presidential election cycle. Don't
Matt:
But
Sam:
give
Matt:
Trump,
Sam:
him that oxygen on the debate stage.
Matt:
he's the one making it. He's the one
Sam:
He
Matt:
that
Sam:
is.
Matt:
ran for office because his calculation is if I run for office, then that makes it hard for them to prosecute me. He's not even mounting a legal defense to any of these charges.
Sam:
No.
Matt:
The things he says on social media makes it harder for him to win the legal case. So he's hoping for a political solution to these legal troubles. And I think that as a society, we should say, No, you can't use politics to save yourself from legal problems.
shawn:
Agree.
Sam:
So,
Matt:
That would
Sam:
but,
Matt:
be a two-tiered system of justice.
Sam:
so
shawn:
Totally
Sam:
I
shawn:
agree.
Sam:
agree, don't use politics to solve a legal problem, but there's no law in place right now that says if you're a presidential candidate and you're under felony investigation, you can't run for president. Maybe that should be something, right? People need to think long and hard about how to prevent this very thing from happening again,
Matt:
But
Sam:
but right now
Matt:
there
Sam:
the
Matt:
is
Sam:
impact
Matt:
the 14th
Sam:
is terrible,
Matt:
Amendment, Sam. The 14th
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
Amendment says that anybody who has conspired to overthrow the country cannot hold public office. It says the how, maybe it wouldn't apply to President Trump, but Oath Keepers and Proud Boys were convicted of seditious conspiracy. And if Trump were convicted of that, then possibly he would not be able to run for office.
shawn:
And
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
Sam,
Matt:
And so...
shawn:
do you, do you,
Sam:
but
shawn:
do
Sam:
possibly
shawn:
you agree with?
Sam:
it would so enrage his base, the thought that they wouldn't be allowed to make a decision about whether to vote him in or not. It could also start a civil war. You have to look at how absolutely out to lunch some people are on that vantage viewpoint and how fanatical they are in his defense, thinking that the government has somehow plotted to ruin their lives, that, you know, he's got a minority, but a very vocal minority that backs him and... And I think you take the oxygen away from that by delaying his day in court till after the election. He's not going to get elected.
Matt:
Okay, so then who wins the thought provoker on this? I really feel like... not Sean. Sean didn't provoke any thoughts.
shawn:
You gotta wait till the end where I thought...
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
Oh, go
shawn:
I haven't said
Sam:
big
shawn:
anything
Sam:
finish
shawn:
about it.
Sam:
on big finish.
Matt:
Okay,
Sam:
Matt doesn't
Matt:
okay
Sam:
want
Matt:
Sean.
Sam:
to give it to me because
Matt:
Okay
Sam:
he doesn't
Matt:
Sean.
Sam:
want to admit
Matt:
Hehehehehehe
Sam:
it's gonna be delayed. Go ahead, Sean. Amaze us.
shawn:
Matt's point, no, Matt's point
Sam:
Matt,
shawn:
that
Sam:
you're right. Oh, you win, Sean. Good job.
shawn:
no, Matt's point about the, the indictment has come from a grand jury, right? These are normal
Matt:
Yes,
shawn:
citizens. These aren't politically
Matt:
yeah,
shawn:
motivated people. These are
Matt:
that's
shawn:
randomly
Matt:
right.
shawn:
picked citizens. I think
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
isn't,
Sam:
just good,
shawn:
isn't
Sam:
honest,
shawn:
that
Sam:
hardworking people that
Matt:
I,
Sam:
random
shawn:
why would
Sam:
citizens
Matt:
Sean,
shawn:
you question
Sam:
are.
shawn:
that?
Matt:
you
shawn:
Why would
Matt:
are
shawn:
you
Matt:
provoking
shawn:
question that?
Matt:
thoughts in me right now. I love it.
shawn:
Sam, why would you question? Why would you,
Matt:
No-
shawn:
you don't think so? You don't
Sam:
I've been
shawn:
think
Sam:
in front
shawn:
that...
Sam:
of a jury before and sometimes
shawn:
Grand
Sam:
those
shawn:
jury.
Sam:
juries are scary,
Matt:
S-Sam's not
Sam:
right?
Matt:
saying
Sam:
And
Matt:
the-
Sam:
we already heard grand jury leaks from people looking to profit from that whole process, write books and do other things.
shawn:
So
Sam:
I just think
shawn:
you don't trust a jury is what you're saying.
Sam:
I have no opinion on the grand jury in this case. I just think the topic and the issue helps Trump and you stop helping him by taking it away and delaying it till after the election.
shawn:
So delay, just delay it, not stop justice, just delay it.
Sam:
delayed justice. And in our world, 12
shawn:
Whoa.
Sam:
months, 18 months is not a long time. It happens
Matt:
unless
Sam:
very
Matt:
the person
Sam:
quickly.
shawn:
It
Matt:
becomes
shawn:
unless
Matt:
President
shawn:
yeah,
Matt:
of the United
shawn:
that's a big
Matt:
States
shawn:
deal.
Matt:
and pardons themselves of all of the crimes and
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
fires everybody who worked
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
on the case.
Sam:
No.
Matt:
Which Trump would do, right?
Sam:
Do you think Trump stands a chance of winning?
Matt:
No. Well, anybody who's running for office has a chance to win. And
Sam:
Nice
Matt:
Trump
Sam:
reverse,
Matt:
has...
Sam:
by the way, because my next comment is if he has no chance to win, then there's no risk, right? The only real risk is allowing this process to continue and for his positive base to become so large that he wins. And then every concern you have, like what you're talking about could be a risk under either scenario. Either they delay
shawn:
You have a way,
Sam:
it till after
shawn:
but-
Sam:
and they take it away or they do it now and it makes him bigger and he wins. Either
shawn:
But
Sam:
way, it's a problem.
shawn:
if both of you believe he's going to lose, then why delay justice? Justice is way more important than
Sam:
I think he
shawn:
how
Sam:
could
shawn:
it appears.
Sam:
win if I think his current trajectory, I don't share Matt's opinion. I think Trump could win.
Matt:
So, I do believe that Democrats want Trump to be the nominee because they feel like he's easier to beat than any other Republican out there. I do believe that narrative. But that's not what motivates me to... I really believe that... I understand why they started with the Proud Boys, I understand why they started with average Americans, but now we're moving up the chain. And if the argument is that everybody down below a certain level of authority, you're going to get convicted and go to jail. But the people who are actually orchestrating it, they're never gonna face justice because, well, it would just cause too many other problems. I just have a real problem with
shawn:
You
Matt:
that.
shawn:
don't agree with that, Sam?
Sam:
Uh, I, you know, for the purpose of this show, taking
Matt:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Sam:
the other side, I'm going to say, I think I, listen, Trump is president or Trump was president first time around despite crazy statements he made because even though he did crazy things, he had a very fervent base that was sick and tired of ordinary politics who thought there was a conspiracy out in the world that was out to get them. And astonishingly, despite world. politics and everything that's happened over the last many years There is still a strong base of people that believe that way and it defies reason in a lot of ways But it's a little bit anti science. It's a little bit pro, you know conspiracy theory It's definitely a little bit anti-democratic, but it is a very strong base and it's not it's you know It's inside the LDS religion. It's in the side the evangelical religion it's a theme and an undercurrent in in a religious base that's a little bit paranoid about government getting too big.
Matt:
So I agree with Sam that there is a risk of Trump going to jail and not being allowed to run for president that could lead to violent actions among
Sam:
Trump's
Matt:
his base.
Sam:
never gonna go to jail. Trump will never go to jail. It will turn into a civil war before that happens.
Matt:
So that's what I'm saying, like that argument
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
that Sam's making, I can see that. I can understand why you say, hey, there's a really significant risk of something like that happening. But I can also see the
shawn:
But
Matt:
other side.
shawn:
that would happen
Sam:
What's
shawn:
before
Sam:
the cost
shawn:
or
Sam:
of waiting,
shawn:
after.
Sam:
Matt?
Matt:
The cost of waiting is that it's just not fair, right? It's just not fair to other people.
Sam:
Ah,
Matt:
And, and,
Sam:
spoken
Matt:
and... Uh.
Sam:
like a true professor, it's not
Matt:
Ha ha
Sam:
fair. It's not
Matt:
ha.
Sam:
fair.
Matt:
And, and if you
Sam:
Dog
Matt:
wait
Sam:
on
Matt:
until
Sam:
it.
Matt:
Trump loses the election and then you go after him, you just seem like you're being petty at that point, right? Cause it's like, he's already
Sam:
Who cares?
Matt:
lost. Yeah,
Sam:
Justice
Matt:
I don't know.
Sam:
is justice, right
Matt:
But.
Sam:
is right, wrong
Matt:
But
Sam:
is
Matt:
Sam,
Sam:
wrong.
Matt:
don't you think that there's also a danger that if you don't prosecute Trump for these crimes, and he does win presidency, and he does start to do the sorts of things he started to do at the end of his last term, or starts to kind of cover his tracks, or pardon people, or things like that, don't you risk a revolution on the other side? Don't you risk civil war on the other side? Because those people are pretty angry too. So I don't think that not prosecuting Trump prevents a civil war. I agree it could.
Sam:
I'm more afraid of Trump's base candidly than the hostile other side.
Matt:
Alright, that's why Sam wins the Thought Provoker on this
shawn:
That's
Matt:
one.
shawn:
why
Matt:
That's
shawn:
Sam was
Matt:
good.
shawn:
the last one. Yeah, that's
Matt:
That's
shawn:
a good one.
Matt:
the thing I was waiting for Sam to say.
shawn:
That's the thing I was waiting for Sam
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
to
Matt:
Sam,
shawn:
say. Hahaha! Sam!
Matt:
it's your d- Sam.
shawn:
You fell right into Matt's trap!
Sam:
But I will say I like his politics so I just don't I'm with I'm with Christie that you'll like this. I think one of Christie's greatest lines is I like his what does he say? I like I Like his politics,
Matt:
Read my
Sam:
but
Matt:
lips,
Sam:
I don't like
Matt:
no need
Sam:
his
Matt:
to... Oh. Ha
Sam:
character.
Matt:
ha ha.
Sam:
No, no, that was Bush. That was Bush. Yeah. Oh, no Forget his cry or it's about his character. It's not about his
Matt:
He's
Sam:
politics
Matt:
like, it doesn't matter whether it was criminal behavior, it was behavior
Sam:
There you go.
Matt:
unbecoming a president of the United States.
Sam:
It was his character. It wasn't his criminal,
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
it was his character.
Matt:
Okay, Sam, you get the next topic.
Sam:
All right, so this week I was riding in an Uber and may or may not have been sick, right? May or may not have been displaying signs of potential COVID illness,
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
but
Matt:
but truthfully, did you have COVID? It does kind of matter.
Sam:
I, I plead the fifth, and it doesn't matter actually, it doesn't
Matt:
Okay,
Sam:
matter, it's
Matt:
okay,
Sam:
the principle
Matt:
I don't know your
Sam:
of
Matt:
question.
Sam:
it, dog on it.
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
So
shawn:
the question has been
Sam:
riding
shawn:
revealed.
Sam:
along, I get a phone call from Uber to say that my cab driver had reported me as being sick and riding in the cab. So they asked me some questions, which I, you know,
Matt:
Dishonestly
Sam:
whatever.
Matt:
answered.
Sam:
Yeah, who knows? I don't know. So it made me really interested, interested as I traveled this week all over the, all over the country. I am seeing more and more people wearing masks. In fact, I would say there's probably 30 to 40%, 20 to 40% of people in the airports right now that are masked up on their own. And there are news stories all over the place, and it even came up in the debates that COVID is back on the rise again. And there
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
are calls for masking mandates and other requirements surrounding a resurgence. And it really made me think, particularly that call from Uber, which honestly was a little freaky, right? Like they obviously have a process in place to identify it, try to root it out and protect everybody involved. But I also thought as I was walking around, isn't it enough if I have a concern for my own health to mask up on my own, or if I think I'm sick and I wanna protect others to also mask up, but not require by mandate, by government, people to comply with behavior. And then obviously masking mandates then lead to other things that were a huge challenge like my kids while they were in high school. You know, they'd be at school one day and then they'd get a text message that night saying, you sat within two chairs of someone that tested positive and you can't come back for four days and you have to test positive before you come back from school. There is the true risk of us coming back into a time of mandates. As members of the church, how should we approach new mandates? Should we support them or should we challenge them? And is it enough? as a human being for me just to mask up if I'm uncomfortable or not if I choose not to.
Matt:
So there was a time when we didn't know what COVID would do to somebody and people got COVID and most of them died. And I don't think we're in that situation anymore. I've had COVID, I've tested positive for COVID only once, but I'm sure I've had COVID three or four times. In fact, I think I had it last week. My mom was hospitalized with COVID last week and then I was doing things to help her in the hospital. And then I had what I would call mild COVID symptoms. There's things that happen in my body when I have COVID that... don't happen with any of the other illnesses I might get. But it's not the same as the first time I got COVID, which by the way, I think every time I get COVID, I'm on a cruise somewhere.
shawn:
hahahaha
Sam:
You might think twice about the cruise, but
Matt:
But
Sam:
that's
Matt:
in
Sam:
okay.
Matt:
December
Sam:
Go ahead.
Matt:
of 2019, so before we even knew about COVID, I went on a cruise to Mexico and I came home and I had COVID symptoms big time, but we didn't even know what COVID was at the time. And it wasn't until later on I was like, wow, I might've brought COVID to the United States in my little area.
Sam:
Was it COVID or the tequila worm? That's the question, Matt.
Matt:
Well, so it's these symptoms that I only associate with COVID. But anyhow, so what the hospital was telling me is that COVID is back and it's really contagious, but that it's not life-threatening. So to me, the moral question is always about life-threatening. If I work as an Uber driver or if I work in a public-facing industry, I know that I'm taking risks every day with an illness of some kind. And I think the social contract is, as long as it's not a life threatening illness, as long as it's just something that's going to maybe cause discomfort, then I don't think that my customers or society as a whole has an obligation to try to protect me from like the sniffles or diarrhea or whatever. But if, if COVID is life threatening and if people are not able to get treatments for it, then we do have an obligation as a society to mandate lockdowns and all of that sort of stuff because we have a right to protect the innocent who can't protect themselves.
Sam:
Sean?
shawn:
Yeah, yeah, I guess interesting take. I probably would be with you all up until the last point where the government is jumping in and mandating.
Matt:
But Sean, saving lives, that's the government's first priority, is to save lives.
Sam:
But I think the true
shawn:
Is
Sam:
question
shawn:
it really?
Sam:
is, does double masks save lives? So I remember
Matt:
Well, no,
Sam:
traveling.
Matt:
you should stay home is what you should do.
Sam:
Right
Matt:
The masking was like, nobody's staying home like they ought to, so fine, put a mask on to make people feel better. But if you have COVID and it could kill
Sam:
home.
Matt:
somebody,
Sam:
Yes,
Matt:
you should stay
Sam:
I agree.
Matt:
home. Yeah.
Sam:
I agree. Yes.
Matt:
I
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
did
shawn:
but
Matt:
stay
shawn:
that's a...
Matt:
home for a while when I was sick.
shawn:
Yeah, but you chose to do that, right?
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
You would have a problem if FBI agents were out in front of your house with guns pointed at you and saying, you cannot leave. Yeah, but I don't have any food. You cannot leave. Yeah, but I need to
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
go
Matt:
there's
shawn:
pick up my
Matt:
Instacart.
shawn:
kid. Yeah, but you cannot leave.
Matt:
Right, you can arrange all those. I'm okay with the FBI saying somebody cannot leave their house if they have an illness that's contagious and is gonna kill their neighbor. Of course I'm okay with
Sam:
So
Matt:
that.
Sam:
I think what we learned from the prior waves and from the inception is there are things that make sense to do. So, you know, immunizations make sense, right? Masking makes sense if you're sick. If you feel unsafe, for heaven's sakes, mask up as well. What I don't think is great and what I would fight against is closing down businesses and requiring masks and requiring, you know, calls to schools if you're sitting within three or four people forcing people to stay home, because I'm not sure that actually works.
Matt:
Pará tis!
Sam:
I'm not, I'm not sure that it actually truly protects anybody. And what it does, I saw and remembered well from the traveling world is it shifts. Like, like I would always get people coming up to me at the airports, you're not wearing your mask, right, you have to put your mask on, right, you know, you'd have your nose coming over the top of the tip.
Matt:
Oh, how
Sam:
It
Matt:
dare you.
Sam:
It causes people to lose their minds and start focusing on things that just don't matter. And you get the infamous, and I think it's terrible because it's both sexist and just wrong, but you get the Karen memes on TikTok, right? About people yelling
Matt:
Ha ha!
Sam:
at other people on airplanes. And it just, I'm not sure it helps. I'm not sure that masking up in an airplane helps. Now, if
Matt:
It
Sam:
you're
Matt:
helps.
Sam:
sick and you have
Matt:
It
Sam:
to
Matt:
helps.
Sam:
cough, cough
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
in the corner of your arm, right? Or put a mask on if you're not feeling well, right?
shawn:
Matt, you
Sam:
But
shawn:
heard, you heard what
Sam:
don't
shawn:
Vivek
Sam:
require it.
shawn:
Ramasamy said. More people died from the,
Matt:
Hahahaha
shawn:
from the
Sam:
Loneliness.
shawn:
response to COVID than COVID itself. You
Matt:
Uh-huh.
shawn:
heard what he said.
Matt:
I don't really believe anything that he said is true.
shawn:
Yeah, I don't either.
Matt:
I think that society's lost some common decency, like some common courtesy. And so I'm not in favor
Sam:
But you can't
Matt:
of...
Sam:
legislate common courtesy. You can't
shawn:
That's
Sam:
legislate
shawn:
correct.
Sam:
decency.
shawn:
Correct.
Matt:
Okay, as long as we're willing to say, accept strong penalties, right? So if I know I have COVID and I go out and I infect somebody with COVID and it's a life-threatening thing to them, I should be held accountable for that. Just
Sam:
In the
Matt:
the
Sam:
same
Matt:
same
Sam:
way
Matt:
as...
Sam:
that work in the same way we're currently holding people accountable for flu. If I show up to work with the flu and another person ends up in the hospital with the flu, they should be held accountable. Wait, they're not. Sorry, go ahead.
Matt:
Yeah, and the same way that Sam wants to hold Donald Trump accountable.
Sam:
Yeah
Matt:
If
shawn:
Uh
Matt:
I know that
shawn:
oh,
Matt:
I have AIDS,
shawn:
uh
Matt:
and
shawn:
oh,
Matt:
I go
shawn:
hot
Matt:
out with
shawn:
topic.
Matt:
my AIDS, and I have unprotected sex, and
Sam:
Right?
Matt:
I infect somebody with AIDS,
shawn:
It's
Sam:
You
shawn:
not
Sam:
should
shawn:
against
Sam:
be
shawn:
the
Sam:
held
shawn:
law.
Sam:
accountable.
Matt:
I'm... No, you are held accountable for that.
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
It's against the law?
Matt:
Yeah. Yeah, that's against the law. And COVID
shawn:
For
Matt:
should
shawn:
a...
Matt:
be treated the same way.
Sam:
How do you
shawn:
Hang
Sam:
know
shawn:
on.
Sam:
that by the way? I don't even know
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
that.
Matt:
you guys can Google it on your own time. Stories of people that infect other people with AIDS. There's civil lawsuits that happen. I don't know that anyone's ever been held criminally liable,
shawn:
It's
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
not
Matt:
but
shawn:
against the law.
Matt:
there's
shawn:
It's, it's.
Matt:
like negligence or something. I don't know, there's something in the law where they hold you accountable for that. So,
Sam:
It's bad form at the very worst, yeah.
Matt:
yeah. So I think, what is the question? Should we, yeah, should
Sam:
Should
Matt:
we
Sam:
we
Matt:
support
Sam:
support mandates
Matt:
mask mandates?
Sam:
or show preference towards personal choice?
Matt:
I want to show preference towards mandates because I don't trust people. People make bad choices all the time.
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
Okay.
Sam:
very good.
Matt:
Alright, so who are we going to say wins this one, Sam?
Sam:
Matt, we're gonna say you because you took
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
my two statements. You said, I'm gonna show a preference towards personal taste. I gave you two very distinct choices and you came up with a hybrid. So, or.
Matt:
Hahaha
shawn:
I'm gonna give this win to Sam because he picked a topic that got Matt fired up.
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
Oh, you're
Sam:
very
Matt:
right,
Sam:
good.
Matt:
Sam, you win. Yeah, that one really got me fired up. If you've had COVID as many times as I have, you'll get fired up. Alright,
shawn:
Hahahaha
Sam:
Oh
Matt:
let's move to the big question. So I've been prepping for class this week, and I've been reviewing a lot of academic literature on political ideologies, which I know that doesn't sound fun to most listeners, but it's super fun to me. So, just briefly, there's these different ideologies that people on the right hold onto.
shawn:
Matt, first of all, this is not a brief question. No, it's not. And let
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
me just say this. Once you finish stating it, I'm gonna do my best to dumb it down and make it a little more palatable.
Matt:
Okay, so I have a lot of links
shawn:
for
Matt:
and
shawn:
myself.
Matt:
I'm going to try to not read it exactly as it is, right? But there's this, there's a libertarian ideology, there's a conservative ideology, there's a republican ideology. So the republican ideology holds on to things like they're anti-big government and they're in favor of the rule of law and they like constitutions and they like separation of powers. just laissez faire, let people do what they want to do, and economic freedom. Conservative stuff tends to focus on the minimal state, the Anne Rand stuff that you guys bring up all the time that I'm not an expert in, but Anne Rand's sort of like anti-regulation maybe, and like freedom of the individual, fear of the collective, that sort of stuff. And then values, values is like really important in conservative ideology. So. When I look at the Republican Party today, now I know that most people just say conservative Republican, liberal Democrat, progressive Democrat, but I don't actually see that that's what's happening. When I look at the Republican Party today and I say, okay, who are the presidential candidates that are the most popular in the Republican Party? You've got Donald Trump, who certainly, whatever you want to say about him, he is not in favor of small government. The budget deficit under Trump was bigger than any president before Trump. and Biden's deficits are even lower than what Trump's deficits were. You're muted or something, Sam. So he's definitely like, go ahead.
Sam:
that back. He's a national treasure. I had to mute myself because I had to cough. COVID. Go ahead.
Matt:
So, whatever else Trump might be, he's not a small government person. DeSantis and his attacks in Florida on what he calls the woke agenda is the anti-transgender stuff, the anti-LGBT stuff, the meddling in school curriculums and all that stuff. Whatever else DeSantis might be, you cannot say that he is a champion of individual liberty because he's clearly in favor of the government. like trampling some kinds of individual liberties. And then Vivek Ramaswamy, he's Hindu, but he hides that on the campaign trail because Republicans are happy to tell like pollsters and focus groups, well, as soon as they find out that he's a Hindu, they're like, well, I'm not voting for him because he's not Christian. So there's like in the Republican party right now, there's this clear like kind of anti-religious, at least maybe we'll just call it pro-Christian, but they're certainly not in favor of like, other religions. And so when I look at that in the Republican Party I say, this isn't a party that's in favor of individual liberties and religious freedom and small government, this is a party that's in favor of all of that other stuff. So am I wrong? Is it true? Like if I'm wrong about this then why don't the Republican presidential candidates sound like what I think a Republican should sound like? And why are they doing all this other crazy stuff? Or is it that the Republican Party has lost its way and they don't stand for what they used to stand for?
shawn:
So Matt, I'll say the one person that I have heard so far that does sound more like the traditional definitions is Nikki Haley. She
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
in
Matt:
but
shawn:
fact...
Matt:
she's 6% in the polls.
shawn:
Yeah, but you said no Republicans are talking like Republicans. I think she
Matt:
Oh,
shawn:
is
Matt:
I see.
shawn:
a Republican talking like a Republican.
Matt:
Yes, yes, you're right. That's right.
shawn:
And then I'm not saying, yeah, but she
Sam:
I
shawn:
said
Sam:
think it-
shawn:
she even her, her main statement was, um, she said, why is nobody talking about the fact that it is not the Democrats that are doing the, the things that we re we conservatives were against. It's the Republicans. It's Donald Trump. It's spending more money. It's going into debt. That was, yeah, she called him
Matt:
attacking
shawn:
out for that.
Matt:
individual liberties with
shawn:
Correct.
Matt:
transgender rights and LGBT rights and abortion
shawn:
Yep,
Matt:
rights.
shawn:
right, exactly.
Sam:
I think it's true. You know, you may like Trump's policies, you may not like Trump's policies. I think he did some great things for the economy and set us up for some economic success during the Trump era. However, I think Trump has represented a diversion from what are considered traditional Republican conservative ideologies, I mean, very clearly. And is it Paul Ryan who resigned when Trump was
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
elected, right? You see some very core conservative individuals that were big figures in the party when Trump came to become president that left. He presents a challenge right now. That's again going back to delaying
Matt:
But
Sam:
the
Matt:
it's
Sam:
deal.
Matt:
not just Trump though. DeSantis, Ramaswamy, like-
Sam:
DeSantis was created by Trump. He's in Trump's image. Like he's a Trump too.
Matt:
But they're the most popular Republicans, so doesn't
Sam:
They are
Matt:
that suggest that...
Sam:
because Trump's polling is,
shawn:
It's
Sam:
again,
shawn:
all.
Sam:
the problem right now is Trump has a very rabid base and it's a small base, but it's a rabid base. And
shawn:
And
Sam:
no
shawn:
it's.
Sam:
Republican can win the Republican primaries without that base. And so
shawn:
And
Sam:
he controls it.
shawn:
Sam, you've said it many times before. It's not because Trump is a good politician. Trump's a good marketer. He's a good brander. Like, Sam, you had mentioned earlier that, wait a minute, a lot of people are happy with Trump's policies and what he accomplished as a president. It was funny this weekend, Matt was teaching me. He says, you know what? It was Mitch McConnell who put all the good policies in play. It wasn't Donald Trump.
Matt:
Sure. Everything Trump takes credit for. Mitch McConnell did it.
shawn:
But Trump was, like you said, like I pointed out, well, what about the Supreme Court nominees? Like that's a huge win.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
What do you
Matt:
Trump
shawn:
say?
Matt:
didn't have... Trump doesn't have any idea about who these judges are that he's putting on the courts or the justices or anything. Hey, by the way, he isn't paying attention to tax policy and all of the other... It's all Mitch McConnell. Mitch McConnell had been laying the foundation for that for a very long time.
shawn:
But Mitch McConnell is a boring old man. He falls asleep in front of the camera and a lifelong politician and has no marketing or branding power so the American people don't give him any look, right? Instead, it's Trump who's a marketer and a brander and the people are just following the clicks and following the headlines.
Matt:
Yeah, but the problem is that the Republican Party, as we knew it, is going to go away. It's going to disappear. If the Republican Party of the future is DeSantis, Ramoswami, and Trump, what young person out there is going to embrace that view of the Republican Party and say, yeah, I want to be a part of that? That's, like, don't you guys see that as a problem for the
shawn:
Big
Matt:
Republican
shawn:
problem,
Matt:
Party?
shawn:
huge problem, absolutely.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
Yeah, Sam, do you see this as a problem?
Sam:
I, you know, I don't, I don't want to overreact because, you know, once Trump's, I don't want to sound terrible because I do agree with a lot of Trump's politics, but as the moment Trump has gone, I think we returned back to the center. Like history,
Matt:
No way.
Sam:
we we've talked about this history is all about the pendulum swing and, and the, the swing to one extreme and then the swing back to the middle. And I don't think. There's not enough of a stump behind what Trump represents and who he is and what he's done to build a party long term around it. He's been successful because he's a larger than life personality that had a TV show and people have been sort of enamored with this idea of conspiracy theory and us against government and he plays on people's worst fears to that extent. But that's not a viable long term political stump. It
Matt:
I think it's wishful
Sam:
just isn't.
Matt:
thinking, Sam. I think that under Trump, you had Jeff Flake in Arizona, you had Liz Cheney, you have Adam Kinzinger, you have these very conservative, committed to principle statesmen. And I don't agree with Liz Cheney on everything she does. But what Trump has done is he systematically replaced those kinds of people in the Republican Party with people like Marjorie Taylor Greene and Lauren Boebert.
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
And... and
Sam:
I know,
Matt:
Ron
Sam:
but
Matt:
DeSantis. And when
Sam:
so
Matt:
he's
Sam:
once
Matt:
gone,
Sam:
Trump's gone, don't you think
Matt:
they are
Sam:
it's
Matt:
the
Sam:
done?
Matt:
party. No,
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
those
shawn:
but Matt,
Matt:
guys are
shawn:
he's,
Matt:
the party.
shawn:
but Matt, Sam,
Sam:
No,
shawn:
I think Sam's
Sam:
I don't think
shawn:
point
Sam:
so.
shawn:
is, Sam's point is correct. It's a cult of personality. And
Matt:
No.
shawn:
once the personality is gone, those people can't run, they can't stand up on the and behave the way Trump does and still make it. They don't have that personality.
Matt:
Look how Kevin McCarthy behaves right now in the House of Representatives. He is not governing from the center. Kevin McCarthy is governing from Trump's base. Because that little Freedom Caucus group, they have so much power because they're willing to just... buck the system and go against the system. And even though the majority are moderate, perhaps Republicans, or maybe they're not like the Trump kind of Republicans, they don't hold the power right now because they're not willing to stand up to the Marjorie Taylor Greene's.
shawn:
I think Sam is absolutely correct, man. It's a cult of personality. And once the leader of the cult is gone, I think it shifts back to something else.
Matt:
If Trump
Sam:
Ding
Matt:
were not...
Sam:
dong, the witch is dead, the wicked
Matt:
Okay.
Sam:
witch, the witch is dead.
Matt:
Okay,
Sam:
Haven't
Matt:
so who...
Sam:
you seen Wizard of Oz?
Matt:
So in the GOP presidential debate, when Trump's not on the stage, who emerges as the two most popular people at the end of that GOP presidential
Sam:
doesn't
Matt:
debate?
Sam:
count because even though he's not on the stage, his numbers count and everybody on that stage except a couple were pandering to his base. Like as,
shawn:
And it takes time, it'll take time
Sam:
yeah.
shawn:
for that influence to leave the Republican Party. But I think, Sam's right, I think it will eventually, not immediately, but over time.
Sam:
Paul Ryan will come back. He's a pretty
Matt:
No
Sam:
good
Matt:
way.
Sam:
dude. Have you listened to him speak lately, by
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
the way?
Matt:
he's on the board of Fox News. I have no problem with Paul Ryan.
Sam:
He's very involved.
Matt:
He's
Sam:
He's...
Matt:
not coming back. Liz Cheney won't come back. Jeff Flake won't come back.
Sam:
I disagree by
Matt:
You
Sam:
the way.
Matt:
lose them and then they're gone.
Sam:
Is it
shawn:
Matt.
Sam:
Jeff Flake LDS by the way?
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
Matt,
Sam:
I
shawn:
don't
Sam:
think
shawn:
you
Sam:
they
shawn:
think,
Sam:
come back.
shawn:
don't you think that
Sam:
Mitt Romney
shawn:
so...
Sam:
will come back. Ha ha
Matt:
The
shawn:
I
Matt:
Speaker
shawn:
hope so.
Matt:
of the House in Arizona won't come back?
Sam:
ha.
Matt:
Yeah I think, I mean, yeah I guess no, it's a future we don't know the answer to. When we look at predictions, I think I've been right more often than I've been wrong.
shawn:
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
Sam:
No, that's not true. I'm three for three right now. I'm three for three.
Matt:
Hahaha. So Sam's prediction is, and Sean, they say don't worry, when Trump's gone the Republicans will look like a party you once recognized. And I say, nope, he won.
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
He
shawn:
Eventually.
Sam:
yeah,
Matt:
won.
Sam:
but I read your, I read your paper where you said, uh, the, uh, Trump becoming president and then the transition to Biden marked the end of Republicans ever having a shot at presidential office ever again. And I
shawn:
presentation.
Sam:
wholeheartedly disagree with that as well. So like
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
But
Matt:
we
shawn:
Matt's
Matt:
were just
shawn:
fine
Matt:
talking,
shawn:
with-
Matt:
that was just about
Sam:
his
Matt:
the presidency.
Sam:
history avoids, uh, never again, right? Like it always finds a balance and the pendulum always swings back to the middle and in short of as President Hinckley loved to say, some sort of all ensuing calamity, the middle will be found again. And the Republican Party will find its way back to the Reagan years, which
shawn:
M-Matt-
Sam:
were the best for it, by the way, Matt.
Matt:
In the last eight presidential elections, how many of them did the Republican candidate win the popular vote?
Sam:
So I'm not qualified to answer that because I'm not a
shawn:
It's none.
Sam:
credentialed professor.
Matt:
The answer
Sam:
I'm
Matt:
is...
Sam:
just a
shawn:
None.
Sam:
businessman that likes to make lots of money. Go
shawn:
It's
Sam:
ahead.
shawn:
math.
Matt:
The answer is 2004, George W. Bush. George W. Bush is the last, in 2004, the last Republican to win the majority of the popular vote in the presidential election. And I don't think that Trump's gonna make it any, like Trump's really good at mobilizing the base, right? But Trump lost twice to Joe Biden, or to Democrats in the popular vote. And maybe like the Electoral College will save the Republican Party as it has in the past. But that's where that idea came from, is like. The American public is moving away from the Republican Party, and there's nothing that Trump's doing that's bringing them back to the Republican Party. And once he's gone, I don't think that there's anything that a Republican's going to do to bring them back. But, I don't know, we'll see.
Sam:
Hey,
shawn:
Mother-
Sam:
evangelical Christians who are a core base of the Republican Party love the whole forgive and forget ideology. There will be a renewal, a rebirth, a renaissance around the Republican Party once Trump's gone. But first things first.
Matt:
Uh huh. What's
shawn:
Hey Matt.
Matt:
first things
shawn:
I don't
Matt:
first?
Sam:
I don't
shawn:
know.
Sam:
know.
Matt:
I was so ready to let Sam have the last word, but then he ended it with first things first.
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
Listen,
Matt:
So that's...
Sam:
again, I go back to I like Trump's politics. You compare him to everybody else on that stage. If he would stick to just running it as a business, he'd do so well. Where he gets in so much trouble is when he talks.
shawn:
Sam, but Sam,
Sam:
So
shawn:
they weren't,
Sam:
what they should
shawn:
I think.
Sam:
do is they should take Trump's business acumen and put
Matt:
Oh
Sam:
it behind
Matt:
come
Sam:
Biden's
Matt:
on.
Sam:
lips.
Matt:
Sam
Sam:
Because
Matt:
I cannot
Sam:
Biden's
Matt:
let that
Sam:
not...
Matt:
be the last word.
shawn:
No way.
Matt:
Trump's
Sam:
Biden's
Matt:
business
Sam:
not speaking,
Matt:
acumen. Trump,
Sam:
Biden's
Matt:
should
Sam:
not
Matt:
we?
Sam:
speaking anyway. Biden's got somebody behind him. And then, and then you put, uh, you know, Mitch McCaul, like
Matt:
Sam,
Sam:
you put
Matt:
if
Sam:
the
Matt:
you
Sam:
three
Matt:
had
Sam:
of them
Matt:
Trump's
Sam:
together
Matt:
business
Sam:
and it would create
Matt:
record,
Sam:
one person.
Matt:
if you had Trump's business record, you would be out of work right
shawn:
Hehehehehehe
Matt:
now. Trump does not have an enviable business. Oh, that's right, the Trump organization that has
Sam:
He's a
Matt:
now
Sam:
billionaire.
Matt:
been convicted of a felony tax evasion, right?
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
He
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
is
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
not.
Sam:
at least Hunter Biden's never worked there, so we're okay.
Matt:
By the way, Trump is not a billionaire, nor has he ever been a billionaire. The, uh, they figured out the inflation.
Sam:
Says
Matt:
Anyhow.
Sam:
the professor. Okay, go ahead. That's for the next,
Matt:
I know.
Sam:
next
Matt:
I know.
Sam:
show.
Matt:
Sean, you have the last word.
Sam:
Sean, you win. You win, Sean.
shawn:
No, no, this is really fun to see two guys nerding out about politics. And now I think that we should celebrate that, Matt, you got cited in a really huge podcast by a really famous guy named Sam.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
You got cited. Your
Matt:
There's
shawn:
paper got
Matt:
nothing
shawn:
cited.
Matt:
that makes me more happy than to have a self-citation in my own podcast.
shawn:
hahahaha
Sam:
Wait, I was just like, what, Joe Rogan had Matt on? What's going on?
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
Hey, listener, thanks for joining us. Let's do it again next week.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories