The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
August 30 2023: Prigozhin, CES Honor Code, Trauma in the church, GOP Presidential Debate, The value of leadership
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
We gotta start with Prigozhin. Sam, last week you suggested that he was the biggest threat to Putin, now he is no more. US officials say that a bomb is likely the cause of explosion that downed Wagner leader Prigozhin's plane, His death may help Ukraine in the short-term, but it removes Putin’s greatest internal threat. Besides the United States, who could stop Putin?
The Thought Provoker:
This week we will start with Sam: The Church Educational System announced changes to the honor code and dress and grooming standards at the BYUs. Since this is something Matt suggested, are church leaders listening to our podcast? Dallin H. Oaks in September 1971. His first talk as BYU President. Ff to the 32:00 mark.
Next up Shawn:
There are some people who've left the church because they suffered what can accurately be described as trauma. That doesn't mean it's not God's church, of course. Just that it's run by people. But before we can explain that to ex-Mormons it's important to listen to their personal pain. And sit with them in those dark, lonely places. And tell them they did not deserve that treatment.” What kind of obligation do we have as Saints to those who have chosen to leave the church? Is there something we should be doing to help those who experience trauma to heal?
Finally, Matt: GOP Presidential Primary debates are about one thing… branding. The first debate is when candidates define who they are and try to sell their brand to the Republican primary voters. The moderators obviously have a different goal, they want to generate highlights that will keep people talking about their network. The two goals don’t often align and it can make it hard for some candidates to define themselves. Based on what you’ve heard or seen from the first GOP debate, how are the GOP candidates branding themselves? Do any of them fit the Latter Day Lens standard of honest, good, or wise people?
Big Question (from a listener):
In a recent episode, Sam recently talked about "leadership" which gets a lot of emphasis in the church and in the country. But the kind of business leadership we discuss seems very different from the leadership Jesus demonstrated. Or Paul. Don't you think? When you take off your MBA goggles, do you see Jesus performing the behaviors we teach in leadership classes?
Is there evidence to suggest that better leaders increase productivity? By how much? Which leadership behaviors correlate with high productivity? When we run these stats it's important to watch out for survivorship bias. That is, companies that fail generally go broke and can fall out of our counts if we're not careful.
Or, is there a scriptural basis for the compensation of "leaders" compared with the rest of an organization?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt:
Hey welcome listener to another exciting episode of The Latter Day Lens with Sean, Sam and Matt. So before we get to anything else I think we have to start with Prigozhin. Like he died.
shawn:
I'm sorry.
Sam:
By the way, did we sort of predict that? I feel like I got two things right, Matt, last week, and I need a little acknowledgement for
Matt:
So
Sam:
that, so.
Matt:
I think you
shawn:
Hehehe
Matt:
are aren't
Sam:
Ha
Matt:
you
Sam:
ha.
Matt:
the one that said he was the big threat to Putin that he was the
Sam:
So, so I actually said that rather than the U S go in and take down Putin and, and Russia, I felt like we should allow them internally to tear themselves down. And pregosian was the best option when he was marching on Moscow.
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
I, I still maintain that. Hey, actually
Matt:
I'm
Sam:
I have two
Matt:
out.
Sam:
comments on there. Number one, truly, how do we know pregosian is dead? Because
Matt:
Come
Sam:
those guys
Matt:
on.
Sam:
are smart enough. They're smart enough. Um, he
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
had five body
Matt:
No.
Sam:
doubles that traveled under his name. Like
Matt:
No,
Sam:
those
Matt:
no, no.
Sam:
guys are smart enough
Matt:
No,
Sam:
to
Matt:
no,
Sam:
like
Matt:
no.
Sam:
do the spy stuff. Right. And then outside of that, who else is, who else has pergosian's profile that could, uh, that, that could pose and present a threat to a Putin. Right. There's
shawn:
It's a good
Sam:
somebody
shawn:
point.
Sam:
else there that could
shawn:
It's
Sam:
do
shawn:
a
Sam:
it.
shawn:
good
Sam:
Let
shawn:
point.
Sam:
them.
shawn:
It's a good point. Now, why would, why would we believe
Sam:
Let
shawn:
the
Sam:
them burn themselves down.
shawn:
propaganda news from Russia? I mean, that was a pretty quick release that, Oh, progression's dead. Why would they announce that? I mean, unless Putin is really trying to say, Hey, look, mess with me. This is what happens to you. Right?
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
Is that
Sam:
he was,
shawn:
what it was?
Sam:
he was saying that in advance of the elections, but we do know it's a high likelihood. It's him, Sean, because he was flying in an Embraer,
Matt:
Right,
Sam:
a French
Matt:
it was a
Sam:
private aircraft.
Matt:
private
Sam:
Right.
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
jet.
shawn:
okay.
Matt:
And
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
then it's not just Prigozhin, it's his number two in command, and it's all of their bodyguards. And then the news out today is that Russia is now making the Wagner Group swear allegiance to the Russian military. And then I just looked at this headline from CNN,
Sam:
It was
Matt:
the
Sam:
like
Matt:
Bell...
Sam:
in the gladiator movie. It's like
shawn:
This
Sam:
in
shawn:
is,
Sam:
the gladiator
shawn:
it's
Sam:
movie
shawn:
a joke.
Sam:
when the emperor has Marcus Aurelius's troops swear to him. This is going to be a showdown.
Matt:
Belarus's president Lukashenko says, I warned Vagner, I warned Prigozhin twice to watch out. They were after him.
Sam:
Ooh,
shawn:
Oh my...
Sam:
good for him. His hands are clean.
Matt:
Hahahaha
Sam:
That I feel like, I feel like if he warned him twice, that's fair. And what was
Matt:
Look.
Sam:
pregosian doing flying through Russian airspace? I'm baffled by that. He's not that stupid.
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
Matt.
Matt:
so there's, there's some stories out there, but like none of this stuff has been validated. So I don't think we know, but he was working in Africa. Then he got an urgent message that said you have to come home real quick. Right. And so he like
Sam:
Wait,
Matt:
hurries home.
Sam:
wait, I have a question. He got an urgent message from his friend Putin saying,
shawn:
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
Matt:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Sam:
Hey, come home quickly. We need you here. Can you make sure your plane is flying right over this city at that time? So that we can have the, uh, it was a surface there, a missile that shot it
Matt:
No,
Sam:
down,
Matt:
no,
Sam:
I understand, right?
Matt:
it was a bomb. It was a bomb planted inside the plane.
shawn:
What?
Matt:
So
Sam:
Oh. Hmm.
Matt:
yeah, and it blew the wing off. And have you seen the footage of the plane coming down?
shawn:
Yeah, yeah.
Matt:
There's no way this is like an accidental, like the wing is gone and it comes tumbling down. Like, of course the Kremlin denies that they had any involvement in the disappearance and the murder of Prigozhin.
Sam:
Can we at least agree it's suspicious? Like I know he's probably dead, but
Matt:
Yes, he's dead.
Sam:
in the Russian world, like how do you really, really know, right?
Matt:
Again, we can go back to the list of people who have opposed Putin and who are all now dead
Sam:
They're
Matt:
or
Sam:
dead.
Matt:
in jail. So then...
shawn:
So Matt, with state controlled media, why would they release it so quickly and easily if it's so obvious that they killed them?
Sam:
There's a flaming jet on the ground.
Matt:
Well, yeah, because Putin comes out the winner, right? This is, you deny, but the message is very clear to Russians. Oppose Putin, no matter how powerful you are, no matter how safe you think you can be. Oppose Putin, and I can get you. I can get you whenever I want to, however I want to.
Sam:
Which helps in advance of the elections that are up and coming, right? Like it takes his tenuous or challenged control and makes it more certain, does it not?
Matt:
Okay, so then the question I want to ask is, who can stop Putin? Sam said that Prigozhin was the best internal option. There are no more internal options, Sam.
Sam:
I think Putin is watching listening to our podcast and that's why he took for Goshen out this past
Matt:
Hahaha!
Sam:
week. So listen, I'm willing to, I'm willing to tell you who's our next best option, but I think we should do it off air for that
Matt:
Oh,
Sam:
person's
Matt:
okay.
Sam:
safety. Yeah.
Matt:
Oh,
shawn:
Ha
Matt:
okay,
shawn:
ha
Matt:
so that
shawn:
ha!
Matt:
they don't tie. Can't we just say the United States? Can't we say the
Sam:
No!
Matt:
United States has a moral obligation to help
Sam:
Ugh,
Matt:
the Russian
Sam:
please.
Matt:
people?
shawn:
Sam is this the reason you hate Mitt Romney, you guys in Utah? Because Mitt Romney, every other
Matt:
Hahaha
shawn:
post I see from him, he's saying, guys, the biggest threat to the US is China's biggest partner, which is Russia. We need to go in. That's
Sam:
No,
shawn:
what
Sam:
I
shawn:
Mitt
Sam:
agree
shawn:
Romney
Sam:
with,
shawn:
keeps saying.
Sam:
I agree. I agree with Mitt Romney when he said in the debate or when he was told, Hey, your politics from 1984 are calling, right? Like, like, uh, Mitt
Matt:
Obama.
Sam:
Romney took heat during the election campaign because Romney knew what a threat Russia was our
Matt:
And
Sam:
mistake as
Matt:
Obama
Sam:
a country.
Matt:
laughed at him.
Sam:
Right. Obama laughed at him. Our problem as a country is Obama right after the Sochi Olympics during the first minor incursion. did nothing. And then after the second, just in advance of it, minor incursion turned full scale war. We did nothing. Our moment to do something, to take action was before it began. And now we've got to be smarter. We've seen those movies about attempted assassinations on Adolf Hitler. And there were people in his inner circle that were well positioned to do it. And there were well documented attempts. People just need to find those attempts and maybe this ups the stakes and maybe it even creates a greater likelihood that happens. But I go back to last week, our best shot is Putin doing something terrible and tragic that so unites the world. It's a, it's a Pearl Harbor. It's a September 11th. It's a terrible, terrible
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
act that no one wants to see happen that, that drags everybody else into it. Otherwise
shawn:
but Matt,
Sam:
I want nothing to do with the war over there.
shawn:
but
Sam:
I don't
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
want to, I don't
shawn:
I'm
Sam:
want
shawn:
with,
Sam:
to attack a country with nuclear weapons.
shawn:
but Sam, I'm with Matt. He's already done that horrible tragic thing. They're
Matt:
I don't
shawn:
killing,
Matt:
know what we're waiting for.
shawn:
there's
Sam:
Ciao.
shawn:
like a half a million Ukrainians dead reported. A half a
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
million.
Sam:
well, I'm not going to send us troops and nuclear stuff into a nuclear country.
shawn:
What more would justify? You just said there's something more that would justify risking a nuclear war.
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
What
Sam:
well, tyrants,
shawn:
more?
Sam:
tyrants are ultimately brought down when their own acts exceed their
shawn:
like
Sam:
ability.
shawn:
invading a
Sam:
And,
shawn:
country and killing half a million
Sam:
and,
shawn:
people?
Sam:
and Pearl Harbor was a good example. September
Matt:
Do
Sam:
11th was a
Matt:
you
Sam:
good
Matt:
know
Sam:
example.
Matt:
what brought Hitler
Sam:
We
Matt:
down?
Sam:
will do that.
Matt:
Hitler
Sam:
But
Matt:
was taken down by the Soviet army and the United States army coming into Germany from both sides. So
Sam:
No.
Matt:
I
Sam:
Okay.
Matt:
feel
Sam:
Yeah. But, but Hitler kept going.
Matt:
like
Sam:
For
Matt:
until
Sam:
truly,
Matt:
the Soviets were at his bunker and then either
Sam:
truly
Matt:
flew away or he killed
Sam:
had,
Matt:
himself.
Sam:
had Hitler stopped at Poland. Had Hitler
Matt:
Uh huh.
Sam:
stopped at a collection of countries, there'd be a lot more German speaking people in Europe and there wouldn't be a lot of, uh, unfortunately, Jews people around. So
Matt:
So
Sam:
we
Matt:
whata?
Sam:
should
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
probably.
shawn:
what I don't understand is why you're willing to send Americans into war for certain events and you're willing at the beginning of the Crimea incident to send Americans in, yet now what are you waiting for? I don't understand.
Sam:
You know, listen, if there was oil in Russia, I'd be all over it. Let's
shawn:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Sam:
go take the oil.
Matt:
If only there were oil there.
Sam:
Cause I just filled up my Sequoia at a hundred dollars for the tank. And that's no, but listen,
Matt:
Do you know what?
Sam:
you listen, you listen to the debates, uh, this past week. And we'll go into the next thing I was right about from the last episode, but
Matt:
Pfft.
Sam:
like
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
Ukraine was a topic. There is no will. on the Democrat or on the Republican side to invoke a war on Russian soil. It's just not going to happen. You could find someone that could go over and plant that bomb, take him down, but it has to happen from within at this
Matt:
Do
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
you
Sam:
point.
shawn:
what do you say?
Matt:
know what got us into Vietnam? It was the Gulf of Tonkin speech
Sam:
Are you really
Matt:
by Lyndon
Sam:
going to bring
Matt:
Johnson.
Sam:
up Vietnam as a good example? You want Vietnam?
Matt:
And so allegedly, Vietnam attacked our troops in the Gulf of Tonkin, and so that rallied public support to go in and fight in Vietnam. And it turns out that the whole thing was made up. It was a false flag event. They never actually attacked us. So. That's what scares me about if we have to have an event. I feel like we're setting ourselves up for some kind of a false flag, where it's like, here's this event that's gonna rally people around and it may or may not be true. Whereas we could just go in for the right reason right now, which is Putin is the next Hitler, and we can stop him now while he's vulnerable, or we can wait until he gathers his forces.
Sam:
I am so grateful that neither one of you have a button in front of you and or are old enough to have problems ascending or descending Air Force One stairs. So
Matt:
And by the way,
Sam:
you're
Matt:
Sam,
Sam:
not in line.
Matt:
I'm always fascinated by your history of presidents in Russia, that you leave out Trump, who would not give Ukrainians missiles that Congress had authorized them to have, because Zelensky wouldn't create some false investigation in Ukraine that made Trump
Sam:
He,
Matt:
in the next presidential
Sam:
listen,
Matt:
election.
shawn:
Fair point,
Sam:
Trump's,
shawn:
fair point Sam.
Sam:
Trump's intentions were pure. He just didn't want to help Hunter Biden.
Matt:
Oh,
Sam:
He
Matt:
that's
Sam:
knew
Matt:
right.
Sam:
that any
Matt:
That's right.
Sam:
arms, any
Matt:
That's
Sam:
money that
Matt:
right.
Sam:
flew into Ukraine back then would just go straight to Biden and to a Hunter and.
Matt:
Ukraine's fighting their war, the United States says let's give them some missiles, some Javelin
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
missiles, to help them in their fight, and Trump says no. Well, maybe if you could just come out and make a statement and say that there's an investigation. So...
Sam:
Why didn't Obama after the Sochi Olympics, why didn't he do something? In all seriousness.
Matt:
Because Obama is a pacifist, and Biden is a pacifist, so they
Sam:
You
Matt:
don't
Sam:
agree
Matt:
want
Sam:
though
Matt:
war.
Sam:
that was a huge mistake and a key moment in the history of this
Matt:
I don't know, 2014
Sam:
conflict?
Matt:
was a different time. We had troops in Iraq and in Afghanistan, and I don't think that was a good time to start a third conflict. And so I think Obama's approach was always diplomacy first, and diplomacy failed.
Sam:
Are we in a better place right now? Are we
Matt:
Yes,
Sam:
ready for war?
Matt:
yes,
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
we have no troops in Afghanistan.
Sam:
China's
Matt:
We have no
Sam:
on its
Matt:
troops
Sam:
heels.
Matt:
in Iraq. We have
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
the world, the European nations united against Russia. Yes, and by the way, Russia's in a very weak position. We're in a much
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
better place now than we were in
Sam:
you,
Matt:
2014.
Sam:
you can't do something like that without public will. And it's going to be a tough thing to get. I don't know how you get it. Like, again, it's going to take an event.
Matt:
So Sam, what else were you right about last time?
Sam:
So I made the bold prediction that Trump would not show up for the, uh, the, uh, the debate
Matt:
Oh, that's
Sam:
and
Matt:
right!
Sam:
both of you, I think said, Hey, he will show up. And I said,
shawn:
We
Sam:
he
shawn:
did.
Sam:
will not show up. He will find a side show.
Matt:
Uh
Sam:
And he
Matt:
huh.
Sam:
did,
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
uh, yesterday his mug shot showed up online, which was fascinating. Seriously. So he skipped
Matt:
I
Sam:
the
Matt:
know.
Sam:
debate and then I think either Thursday or Friday, he was booked, which
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
is
Matt:
the
Sam:
crazy.
Matt:
next day, the day
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
after the debate. Well, okay, good job, Sam. You were right about two things.
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
Let's see
Sam:
Listen,
Matt:
if you can.
Sam:
I just want to protect the next person we talk about. I don't want to bring... We...
shawn:
Thank you.
Matt:
I think Trump could take out Putin. I really think Trump could
shawn:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Matt:
do it.
Sam:
the
Matt:
Hey, let's see if you can win the Thought
Sam:
Uh-uh.
Matt:
Provoker today, Sam. You get to go first.
Sam:
You know, so it's interesting that the CES or the church educational system came out with changes to the honor code and dress and grooming standards at the church school. So BYU Idaho, BYU Provo, BYU Hawaii. And we've
Matt:
N-sign,
Sam:
talked,
Matt:
College and BYU
Sam:
Ensign
Matt:
Pathway.
Sam:
College,
Matt:
Don't leave those out, Sam. Don't be.
Sam:
does it,
Matt:
Don't.
Sam:
by the way, does it apply to continuing education?
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Like, okay. All right. So all of those students are required to go through a list of questions, which closely resemble the temple recommend questions that are often asked, but there are a few departures from those that expand, um, things like the word of wisdom. And one of those refers to, uh, marijuana as strictly being out of bounds. And we haven't seen that before. Actually, I was moving my son into college housing and talking about this topic. And Braden told me, he's said, no, no. Birch has said in the past marijuana is out. and they've talked about other things that are out. I thought this was the first thing where this was an official part of the honor code.
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
My
Matt:
it,
Sam:
question
Matt:
yeah.
Sam:
is this, we've talked about it in the past, Matt, you've advocated for adding that. I've said, look, the word of wisdom is what it is and it's up to the individual to interpret it and decide how it works for them. Is the church listening? That's your question. to the podcast like
Matt:
Of course,
Sam:
Putin did.
Matt:
of course, yes.
Sam:
And does this mean additional things should be added? There's a long list, caffeinated drinks, five-hour energy I consume ad nauseum.
Matt:
Mmm.
Sam:
Will there be other things in addition to marijuana that are added to it, Matt?
Matt:
Well, five-hour energy wasn't added to the list, right? Marijuana
Sam:
It was
Matt:
was.
Sam:
not. No, marijuana
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
was.
Matt:
I don't know if you saw, but Elder Bednar recently had a little Instagram video where he talked about a day in the life of a member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles and he like showed
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
a video of all the things he does. I don't think this made it into it, but I do think that part of their daily routine, or at least weekly routine, is to sit down and listen to the latter-day lens. So
shawn:
Yeah, yeah.
Matt:
I'm
Sam:
Yes.
Matt:
pretty sure to that question, yeah,
Sam:
All right.
Matt:
they're listening to what we say. So be careful what you say in response to this Sean, because there's power in your words.
shawn:
Okay.
Sam:
Yeah. So
Matt:
So.
Sam:
Matt should, should additional items be added beyond marijuana?
Matt:
Well, I think that with the church educational system, they always try to have what they consider to be a higher standard than the rest of the church. And I put a link to this. There's a talk that President Oaks gave in 1971. It's his inaugural address as president of BYU. And he's talking about beards and long hair. And he says, and then it's actually got published in the New Era too. He's like... There is nothing scriptural or doctrinal about long hair and beards. It's totally a response to the social conditions of the day. And I imagine at some point in the future, this will change at BYU, but it hasn't changed for now. But he just says, you know, long hair, long hair and beards is associated with rebellion and protest and hippies
shawn:
60s and 70s,
Matt:
and
shawn:
yeah.
Matt:
yeah, yeah. And so it's clearly not that anymore, but the, but the dress and grooming standards haven't changed at the church educational system thing. So I don't know that they're gonna change the word of wisdom any more than what they already have, at least for Temple Recommend interviews, but it doesn't surprise me that they've added it to the specific language in the church educational system stuff.
Sam:
Could I share the second part of this change that was a little surprising to me?
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
So I'm going to read this quote. Let's get your take, Matt and Sean. LGBTQ students are welcomed and valued part of the campus community and share a common identity with every student as sons and daughters of God. Now this is the interesting part in the change. Same-sex romantic behavior has been and continues to be contrary to the principles included in the CES Honor Code. challenges with that will be dealt with a case by case basis with each student.
Matt:
that's how it's been applied for a long so it might not have been that specific
Sam:
So the standard is romantic behavior? Same fact.
Matt:
Right, and I would have this question because I used to do a lot of these What are ecclesiastical interviews? And so I asked the stake president. I'm like listen It's this question about the law of chastity We're not applying it the same way because we're saying you should not have sexual relations outside of marriage Which implies that if a gay kid wants to make out with another gay kid Then we would say that's okay because we allow heterosexuals to do that But that's not how we're applying it at the BYUs.
Sam:
Stricter Standard.
Matt:
Yeah, I was like, so like if a student says to me, hey, I'm holding hands with my gay lover or we're on a date or whatever, then I have to say, hey, that's not following the honor code. And then they would say, where is that in the honor code? And I would say, well, it's not in the honor code, but it's how we interpret the honor code. So they're just making that more specific so that it's very clear, like, that should we call this a double standard? Because we always say
Sam:
I
Matt:
heterosexuals,
Sam:
think you have to. Yeah.
Matt:
Yeah, it is a double standard, right? Because we say the law is chastity, but that's not how we actually apply it when it comes to individual circumstances.
Sam:
So why do you think the standard is so high as it relates to same sex attract him? Is it because of the public view, the public element of it? Is there, is it an old notion that behavior will catch or spread by just being seen or what,
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
why do you think, why do you think they, they took that approach? Cause it doesn't hurt anyone, does it? And then you can actually go down the road of like, what is, uh, same sex romantic behavior? Like what does that, mean, right? Like, I've seen, so I argued with somebody
Matt:
If you
Sam:
at
Matt:
watch
Sam:
work this
Matt:
Top Gun and
Sam:
right.
Matt:
they have the greased up, like,
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
they're playing volleyball,
Sam:
Right.
Matt:
you
Sam:
So
Matt:
cannot enjoy that too much, because that's a little bit romantic.
Sam:
can I, can I share something with you in that? I think this is fair for public discussion, but it may not fully fit our audience, but I'm gonna bring it up here anyway. President Obama in his college days actually wrote in a memoir that he really tried to see gender equality in a different way. And, uh, believe it or not, it's actually written and documented that in college, whenever he would Kiss someone, make out with someone. He tried to see, he tried to have empathy both for having a relationship with a woman, but then also for the man. Now, that has come out over the past few weeks. You can find it online and people have given him
Matt:
What
Sam:
a lot
Matt:
does
Sam:
of
Matt:
this
Sam:
criticism
Matt:
mean? Empathy?
Sam:
for it.
Matt:
Like he
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
made
Sam:
he's,
Matt:
out with guys?
Sam:
yeah,
Matt:
Mm-mm.
Sam:
he tried to imagine what it would be like being a guy, making out with guys, so he could understand that same-sex
Matt:
He tried to imagine
Sam:
approach.
Matt:
it or he actually did it.
Sam:
No, he did not do it. He quote
Matt:
He's
Sam:
unquote,
Matt:
kissing a woman imagining
Sam:
kissing
Matt:
that
Sam:
a woman,
Matt:
it's a man.
Sam:
yes. Yes.
Matt:
What?
shawn:
Hehehehehehe
Matt:
Now we have to get into the whole highlight reel thing of
Sam:
Ha
Matt:
like
Sam:
ha.
Matt:
what do you mean when you're kissing somebody? So you're saying... Ha
Sam:
John,
Matt:
ha ha.
Sam:
I just won this question because I blew Matt's mind a little bit here.
shawn:
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
Sam:
He wasn't expecting that.
Matt:
That's very thought provoking. I don't... Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Sam:
It is documented. Well,
Matt:
Ha ha.
Sam:
but let's be fair to people that have that attraction that we don't truly understand, right? As one reader challenged us to do, let's sit in that position, try to empathize with that viewpoint and understand how this policy would impact them. That
Matt:
What?
Sam:
standard, which is much higher than we do for heterosexual couples,
shawn:
So.
Sam:
Does that create a place where they feel welcome
shawn:
So
Sam:
and
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
not judged? Yes,
shawn:
So Sam,
Sam:
John.
shawn:
your original question was, do we feel like the church is
Sam:
Extra
shawn:
moving
Sam:
points
shawn:
towards?
Sam:
for
shawn:
Oh,
Sam:
getting the original question, by the way. Go ahead,
shawn:
thanks.
Sam:
sorry.
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
I answered
shawn:
we can't,
Matt:
that. Of course they listen to us. Oh wait, wait.
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
not that
Sam:
yeah.
shawn:
original, not the original fake question, the original
Sam:
Okay,
shawn:
real question.
Sam:
I'm going to
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
be dragged into my bishop's office and asked about this. So yes, go
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
ahead.
shawn:
The original question was, does the church see value, are they purposely making things more strict, and is that the direction things will go?
Sam:
That was not the question.
shawn:
What's the, re-ask it then.
Sam:
No.
shawn:
You had
Sam:
So
shawn:
said, you had said.
Sam:
a couple
shawn:
You.
Sam:
of things were added and clarified. Marijuana is an example to the
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
word of wisdom. Will
shawn:
right.
Sam:
there be additional ads or clarifications? One.
shawn:
That's what I said.
Sam:
Right,
shawn:
Do you
Sam:
okay.
shawn:
see that the church is trying to be more strict and more specific in their honor code policies? Isn't that the question?
Sam:
Yes.
shawn:
Will they continue to be more strict? For example, specifically
Sam:
Possibly.
shawn:
calling out marijuana, specifically calling out
Matt:
Energy drinks.
shawn:
those
Sam:
They
shawn:
types
Sam:
haven't
shawn:
of things.
Sam:
done that yet. No five hour energy.
shawn:
OK.
Sam:
I can do that in the light
shawn:
So
Sam:
of
shawn:
that's.
Sam:
day,
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
not in
Matt:
no,
Sam:
the closet.
Matt:
there's, if you read the new era, Sam, they went
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
after it with the young people.
shawn:
Okay,
Sam:
Fortunately,
shawn:
so this is.
Sam:
fortunately they no longer send the new era to my house. So I don't get that anymore.
shawn:
So, so this is, so this to me is a really fascinating discussion because you, the outside world, like, like Orthodox Christianity, for example, who, especially Calvinists who really believe that it's, we are saved by grace alone, they really have a problem with, hang on, they really have a problem with our idea of checklists and what an interviews, for example, temple recommend
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
interviews, right? They really
Sam:
Right.
shawn:
believe, well, you're going against the doctrine of Christ by saying that if you say yes to these 15, um, questions, basically what you're saying is my works are saving me. Yes, I'm doing this. Okay. Now you are worthy. If you are, if you are behaving in a certain way, you're basically worthy because of your actions. And I do believe that in our church, we do misunderstand that we do think, okay, if I behave a certain way, if I keep
Sam:
Or if we pay
shawn:
us.
Sam:
10%, I prefer the 10% because that allows me to pay my way out of problems.
shawn:
Exactly,
Matt:
Hahahaha
shawn:
right? Right? Well,
Sam:
Right.
shawn:
I pay my 10%.
Sam:
All right. That was Luther, Martin Luther. I apologize. No, to our audience. I do not actually believe that, but yeah,
Matt:
Sam believes in indulgences.
shawn:
He
Sam:
12%,
shawn:
had to clarify.
Sam:
12%. Don,
shawn:
He had to stop himself real quick and clarify.
Matt:
Well so, can I jump
Sam:
I,
Matt:
in here?
Sam:
I get your point. Yes. Go ahead, Matt, but,
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
but
shawn:
let
Sam:
now,
shawn:
me finish my
Sam:
now
shawn:
quick
Sam:
was
shawn:
point
Sam:
going
shawn:
though.
Sam:
down the road and he was about to answer whether or not.
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
This was consistent. Go ahead.
shawn:
let me finish my point and then hand it off to Matt,
Sam:
Okay.
shawn:
though. So it's strange to me to see that the church decides in this policy for education system to be even more strict and to be even more, it sends a message to kids that, oh, okay, I guess what makes me worthy to not only be the temple, but what makes me worthy to be at a BYU is that I have to live a certain level of righteousness and it is teaching a doctrine that is not quite accurate. It's not. It's not like, for example, very, very clearly scriptures teach yes, I am bringing in a scripture. Yes, you are both smirking. Oh, no, you're not.
Matt:
I'm not
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
smirking.
shawn:
You're
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
not. You're not.
Matt:
smiling. I'm so happy.
shawn:
Right. For example, Proverbs, my son, forget not my law. Right. The law is important. It is, but Let thine heart keep my commandments. Right? He wants us to be willing to do these things. And sometimes things like the CES being more strict in rules is saying, no, in order to be worthy, you have to keep that. You have to be perfect, which leaves
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
out Christ.
Sam:
I think
Matt:
Well, and I don't even...
Sam:
the
Matt:
Go
Sam:
intent
Matt:
ahead.
Sam:
of the honor code is to create a standard and then require people to live the standard.
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
And I
shawn:
I know, but
Sam:
think
shawn:
the...
Sam:
the idea of the honor code is awesome, but
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
I do think there's some challenges inherent in
shawn:
but
Sam:
it,
shawn:
it
Sam:
right?
shawn:
needs to be clarified because kids do believe, some people do believe, well, I'm only worthy for salvation if I've got a temple recommend, right? That's for example. Or I'm only worthy for salvation if I qualify to go to BYU. That's a crazy message. That's a non-doctrinal message. And I'm not
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
saying that's the intention of the message, but that sometimes is what comes out of us. We just have to be careful.
Matt:
So I would, in the past I interviewed lots of young people who wanted to go on missions, and then obviously I did the ecclesiastical interviews for church schools, and I did notice that there was this huge disconnect where I would say to somebody, you're not worthy to go on a mission, and then they would just want to give up, because they're like, well if I can't go on a mission then what's the point? And I would be like, the point is, like, serving a mission isn't the most important thing that you're going to do in your life. The most important thing you're going to do in your life is... qualify to live with Heavenly Father again someday. Like the gospel of Jesus Christ is not the same as all of these different rules, rules we create. And I think that the church, the CES standards have to be thought of the same way. They're specifically for students who want to go to the BYUs or the faculty members who want to teach at the BYUs. And I have lots of friends that are very active in the church, very stalwart, great, great people who choose to not go to the BYUs to teach. because they don't agree with the standards that are created for those CES institutions. They think that there's nothing wrong with having a beard for example. And so maybe they want to wear a beard, right? And I think there's maybe nothing wrong with dressing differently than the church schools might expect them to dress. And I think it's okay for students to do the same thing, to say, I'm not going to one of those BYUs because the way that they are interpreting the gospel is different than the way that I interpret the gospel. And by the way, they're not The church schools are not trying to tell you how to live the gospel. They're just creating a standard for the students and faculty of their institutions so that they can create the kind of culture that they wanna create.
shawn:
Right,
Matt:
And
shawn:
but
Matt:
that
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
culture doesn't always fit members of the church.
shawn:
but it does backfire sometimes. It does
Matt:
For sure.
shawn:
teach many kids that in order for me to have a faithful relationship with my father in heaven, to be saved in the celestial kingdom, I have to be righteous and I have to be obedient to a lot of little teeny, teeny rules. Sometimes that is a conflated understanding and
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
BYU policies do teach that, and
Matt:
So
shawn:
that's
Matt:
we should
shawn:
a problem.
Matt:
push back against that. And we should say, the doctrine on some of these things has not been revealed. We don't know the answers to some of these questions. These are just. The ideas that a group of people who have jobs as university presidents or Elder Clark as a general authority, but he's the commissioner of church education, like it's a calling and a job perhaps for him. They just got together and said, what should be our standard? And they came up with a list. That's not the same as saying Heavenly Father decided that this is the moral guide for society.
shawn:
That is an extremely important distinction, and I think that's not ever talked about, and it should be, because that is important. So kids don't go through life in the church thinking, oh, that kid's a sinner because he has a beard, and that guy's a sinner because his shorts are a certain length. And that happens a lot, a lot, a lot. And
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
it's wrong.
Matt:
I'll just tell you from personal experience. Every student I ever met with that, not every student, most of the students I met with that were having really big problems that disqualified them, we'll just say for even partaking of the sacrament, always looked perfect. They followed the dress and grooming standards to a T.
shawn:
Bingo!
Sam:
That's right.
Matt:
And the kids that did not follow the dress and grooming standards oftentimes were not having similar other problems in their lives. So you really can't tell much about a person by the way that they dress and the way that they look.
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
Well said.
Sam:
and the better they look, sometimes the less authentic or more inauthentic. There's a corollary there. So here's my prediction since I'm two for two in the last two episodes.
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
My prediction is that language on same-sex romantic behavior, and I've got no skin in the game on this, ends up getting changed or evolves
shawn:
Hehehe
Sam:
because I think it is an unequal standard that's tough to monitor. I mean... Matt, you and I would never hold hands on BYU campus, but there are probably guys from different cultures that might. And
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
how
Matt:
and-
Sam:
do you apply the standard of this to just human relationships? If you guys wanna hold hands, why would an honor code that I think the honor code is an outward manifestation of an inward commitment? We hear that a lot. And why should an honor code restrict that? And Take that into two girls that, you know, I mean, you're more likely to see, uh, you know, two girls holding hands or, or I just, I think that's
shawn:
I
Matt:
Or
Sam:
going
Matt:
there's
Sam:
to be such a
shawn:
love...
Sam:
tough
Matt:
a
shawn:
I
Matt:
brasso.
shawn:
love...
Sam:
thing.
Matt:
You gotta avoid the brasso. No hugging the men. Well, so, and I honestly,
Sam:
So
Matt:
my...
Sam:
that's my prediction and I'll be three for three after a little while. Thank you.
shawn:
I love it when in one second Sam is wearing a red MAGA hat and just conservative
Matt:
Hahaha
shawn:
concern and in the next moment he's as socially liberal as it gets. I like it. I like it Sam.
Matt:
I would like to see more of an emphasis on church attendance and Sabbath day behavior. I think that matters a lot more in the eternal scheme of things than holding hands and things like that. At the same time, I do have a lot of faith in local leaders and how this stuff gets applied person to person is by a bishop with priesthood keys. They're not perfect, like everyone makes mistakes, but I do have faith in the process of ecclesiastical leaders doing what's best for kids.
Sam:
And as a side note to my ecclesiastical leaders, I also have high faith in
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
that and
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
their process. And nothing that I've said right now could be construed as walking away from that. But I do make that prediction. We'll have to come back to it in a future
shawn:
Interesting,
Sam:
episode,
shawn:
that's
Sam:
Matt.
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
interesting.
Matt:
my prediction in that regard, Sam, is that changes about the same time as the beard and the sideburns and the long hair thing changes,
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
right?
shawn:
yeah.
Matt:
Which Elder Oaks in 1971 said it would probably change sometime in the future, and now I don't think he could be in a position of much more power than he is to change
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
that
Sam:
good
Matt:
if he
Sam:
point.
Matt:
wanted
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
to.
Sam:
Good point.
Matt:
But maybe he walks around and he sees all these hairy men and he's like, I got nothing on my head, I got nothing on my face.
shawn:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Matt:
And he just... wants to make sure that nobody else can either because
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
he's a little jealous. Hey
shawn:
But
Matt:
that
shawn:
a
Matt:
was
shawn:
good,
Matt:
pretty-
shawn:
hang on, hey Matt, real quick, a good example of that, I remember getting home from my mission and one day going to the temple, Provo temple, and I went in there and I had a little bit of a beard, and I remember the guy looks at me and he kind of gets angry faced, the temple worker, and he said, who let you in here with that beard? And that's a good example of what happens when we don't clarify the distinction between, hey, we got a private school over here, BYUs, the BYUs, who do have some standards? but they're not doctrines, so don't conflate the two.
Matt:
Yeah. Well, that reminds me of a time when I was working in the temple at the Provo temple and the guy walked in full on biker gear, leather jacket, leather pants,
shawn:
Yeah!
Matt:
uh, some chains on his arms, and then a big old beard. And I was like, isn't that awesome that we're not going to keep him out of the temple just because of how he's dressed and what he's looking like. I thought
shawn:
Amen.
Matt:
we had very different experiences, Sean, you and I.
shawn:
I love that.
Matt:
Alright, well so we're going to decide the winner at the very end of this because last time we awarded points I never won and then sometimes it was a tie and so that's not satisfactory
shawn:
Okay, we'll
Sam:
Of course, of
shawn:
wait
Sam:
course
shawn:
till the
Sam:
that's
shawn:
end.
Sam:
how we'll do it. Go ahead. So we'll
Matt:
Okay,
Sam:
just keep
Matt:
wait.
Sam:
this in our mind, yeah.
Matt:
My first one. We'll say that I won that last one. We can all agree that I won the last one. I mean, Sam had a good question, but it didn't provoke any thoughts in me. It provoked
Sam:
Are you out
Matt:
anger.
Sam:
of your mind? I just talked about same sex romantic behavior
Matt:
Cough
Sam:
on BYU campus.
Matt:
That provokes something other than a thought.
Sam:
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
The... Sean, who do you say won? I voted for me, Sam voted for him.
Sam:
I brought in Obama's journals just so you
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
know that
Matt:
that's
Sam:
too.
Matt:
true.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
Yeah, Obama fantasizing
shawn:
because...
Matt:
about gay men while kissing Michelle.
shawn:
Yeah. I think
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
there's topics coming up that Sam's gonna win, but I'm gonna give this one to Matt because you,
Matt:
Yes!
shawn:
your thought that was provoking was you proclaimed something that was so obvious, so pathetically obvious that...
Sam:
John's in the bag for Matt. I know it. I'm
shawn:
No,
Sam:
okay
shawn:
I'm
Matt:
Hahaha!
shawn:
not!
Sam:
with it.
shawn:
No,
Sam:
Well, you
shawn:
you're
Sam:
guys
shawn:
gonna
Sam:
just
shawn:
win!
Sam:
not just
shawn:
You're
Sam:
don't
shawn:
gonna
Sam:
hold
shawn:
win
Sam:
hands,
shawn:
these next
Sam:
please
shawn:
topics.
Sam:
do not hold hands.
shawn:
You're...
Sam:
All right. Next topic.
shawn:
All right. Well,
Sam:
I'm kidding.
shawn:
so I, I had my, I have lots of topics that I wanted to submit and a listener wrote in and I think it's a, I think it's, it's a good followup topic to last week's discussions about,
Matt:
Two weeks
shawn:
uh,
Matt:
ago. Last
shawn:
two weeks
Matt:
week
shawn:
ago.
Matt:
was Russia.
shawn:
Sorry.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
Sorry about, um, uh, contending for the faith
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
and the idea that there were two billion, there are two billion, uh, hashtags, exmo posts. So
Matt:
You keep increasing the number. You said 1 billion, now it's 2 billion.
shawn:
Are you sure?
Matt:
I don't know. Go ahead, Sean.
shawn:
No. So I'm gonna actually read what this listener wrote in because it's an important distinction. So he said this, it's kinda long, I'll go quick. He said, I'd like to mention one thing I thought was missing from the ex-Mormon discussion. There are some people who've left the church because they suffered what can accurately be described as trauma. There are lots of ways that we do Mormonism, in quotes, in ways that traumatize our fellow congregants. Certainly, gay members have suffered and continue to suffer a lot of ugly stigma and emotional abuse. Many people suffer physical or sexual abuse that was enabled or reinforced by church explicitly organized around a patriarchy. From making very normal teenagers feel like chewed gum to telling part member families that they won't be together in the afterlife or killing someone's dream because they were in the wrong gender. We as an organization have done real lasting damage. This doesn't of course mean that this is not God's church. It simply means that it's run by people. which is a great distinction. But before we can explain that to ex-Mormons, it's important to listen to their pain, their personal pain, and sit with them in these dark, lonely places, and tell them that they did not deserve that treatment. What kind of obligation do we have as saints to those who have chosen to leave the church? Is there something we should do to help those who experience trauma to heal?
Matt:
So I would agree that everyone experiences trauma, and some people experience it from things that happen as in the church organization. But I don't think that it's just people who've left the church, there's people that are in the church that experience that trauma. So I think we have the same obligation to ex-Mormons as we do to Mormons, potential Mormons to everyone, which is to try to help them heal from the trauma they face. But I don't feel any personal obligation. to like defend the church or stand up for the church or explain away why something happens at church. I just don't feel like that's my job.
shawn:
Hmm.
Matt:
And so I don't do a very good job of listening to people, I'm gonna call it complain about the church. Because I don't know, that's just not something I'm
shawn:
It's...
Matt:
good at. And I don't know that it does a lot of help. I don't know, I could be wrong, but I have friends that do that, and I have nothing wrong with my friends that do that, but. I'm personally, I don't feel obligation to engage in conversation about that sort of stuff.
shawn:
Sam, what do you think?
Sam:
You know, it's a, it's a tough topic. I mean, definitely there's a lot of people that have experienced trauma. A lot of people that have challenge. I think we don't, I think one of the reasons we're doing this show and the latter lens is such so important is it's an ability to have conversations about difficult topics in ways that is not. You know, destructive to individual people's faith and also to end individual people's journey. And I do, I think the world is a lot better. with varied and different points of view. And the more we all think the same and see the world the same and all look the same, it sucks, it's not that interesting. And
shawn:
Hahaha.
Sam:
so I actually don't have a problem with people that have alternative viewpoints. I don't have a problem talking and having conversations about alternative viewpoints. I don't, at my age, feel like I'm going to be convinced to go down a different path because I hear someone else's you. I understand, Matt, what you're saying, which is you don't want to sit around and listen to somebody angrily rant over and over again about the same thing. I do wonder, and I've seen instances and examples in my own life, if you care about someone enough to hear them and to understand them, sometimes the anger and the edge of that rant will die on the table of
Matt:
Yeah, that's
Sam:
friendship
Matt:
true.
Sam:
and relationship. I mean, people, people don't like, they just don't care. It goes to the old statement, people don't care how much you know until they know how much you care. And in, in the church, in a business organization, in any social group, there has to be an element of us versus them for a group to coalesce around an idea. And I do think one of our challenges is, when we see a different idea, we're so coalesced around the gospel and the standards. I love what you brought up earlier, Sean, right? which is not whether or not I have a beard, right? It's not whether I have a white shirt on Sunday, that's an outward manifestation of an inward commitment. I should be okay hearing and being around and loving and connecting with people with those diverging views. And then I guess maybe it's idealistic. I believe at the end of the day, they're either gonna respect me enough to not dump on me too much. or if they do, there's probably not much of a reason for us to have a continued relationship.
shawn:
And
Sam:
But
shawn:
bye.
Sam:
I don't have enough of those relationships with people who think differently from me. I work out of state in a place that's very different from where I live here in Utah, and I love the variety
shawn:
relationships.
Sam:
that exists out there. But
shawn:
But
Sam:
that's different than the anti,
shawn:
by the way,
Sam:
which
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
Matt's
shawn:
I'm,
Sam:
talking about.
shawn:
I can't be in Matt's bag because last week I gave you the points for making that point.
Sam:
Okay.
shawn:
I think I
Matt:
S-
shawn:
love that point that you made last week because
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
I kind of heard yes, the way that we contend for the faith is not going Bible bash with ex Mormons. Our way is to form relationships and love them and have relationships with them. What a
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
great,
Sam:
when it's
shawn:
what
Sam:
not
shawn:
a great
Sam:
even
shawn:
thing.
Sam:
to have a view, it's not even to have a, it's not even to have like an objective. Like
shawn:
No,
Sam:
when
shawn:
it's
Sam:
you
shawn:
have
Sam:
say,
shawn:
a relationship,
Sam:
Hey, I'm going
shawn:
you
Sam:
to
shawn:
said.
Sam:
be friends you so that I can convince you of what I know and have you see the world. Like I see it
shawn:
That was your
Sam:
that
shawn:
point. Yeah.
Sam:
right. Let, let some of my nearest closest friends are people who bitterly disagree with, I mean,
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
I'll
shawn:
yeah,
Sam:
sit at,
shawn:
that was
Sam:
I'll
shawn:
a great
Sam:
sit
shawn:
point.
Sam:
on, on patios, overlooking oceans with people at work and they will just beat into me about how we've added to revelations. Right.
shawn:
Yeah, it's a great
Sam:
But.
Matt:
hahahaha
shawn:
point, yeah.
Sam:
but I love them and I get their viewpoint and at the end of the day, we love and care about each other.
shawn:
That's a great point.
Matt:
So,
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
can I share a story? So there's one time in my life that I can remember that I wanted to quit the church and be done with it and just never go back. I was in my 20s, I was an elders quorum president, and we had at least 100 prospective elders who nobody knew who they were, they were just names on the list. And then we had 100 elders, of which maybe 15 came to church regularly. And I would go, I was like, I'm gonna bring these people back to church, and I would go and I would visit them and... And I would try to like get anyone to do any kind of home teaching or anything. My presidency, like three of the four people, well then that would be just me. So they were less active, right? When they called them to be in the elders' court of presidency, they're
Sam:
Were
Matt:
like,
Sam:
you
Matt:
wait
Sam:
less
Matt:
do
Sam:
active, Matt? Were you less active? Did you have to activate yourself? Ha ha.
Matt:
I... I was literally like the only active person. And anyhow, I would spend so much of my day like out... visiting people and trying to bring them back into the elders quorum and try and build something because I had faith that we could build something strong there. Helping people move. Oh my goodness. And then you show up to their house and there's like a pile of everything and then some garbage bags and they're like, hey, could you help me just throw the stuff in garbage bags and then move it? I was like, oh my goodness. Anyhow, one day I went to ward council. And I'm sure she was a well-meaning Relief Society president, was talking about something or other, and she was very clear in that meeting. She said something like, Well, the biggest problem in our ward right now is that we have an elders' corps president that's not doing anything.
shawn:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Matt:
Something to that effect. And I was...
Sam:
That's where you learn to quell dissent and prefer strong government.
shawn:
That's
Sam:
You
shawn:
hilarious.
Sam:
wanted that gone. Did you ever kick out?
Matt:
I was so upset. I could not go to church that day. I went to downtown Salt Lake and watched music and the spoken word and I just cried for hours.
shawn:
Aw, Matt!
Matt:
And it was hard.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
And like, eventually I got through that and I had bitter feelings towards the Relief Society president at first, but eventually I healed and got over that. And so from that I decided like trauma in the church is an experience that many, many people are gonna have to experience. And the way that you get through trauma is not by sharing your story with other people. This is a story I don't share with very many people because it's not, it doesn't matter. The way you get through trauma is by turning to Christ. But you do need people with
shawn:
Wow,
Matt:
you
shawn:
well
Matt:
to support
shawn:
said.
Matt:
you.
shawn:
Wow, man, that's
Sam:
I completely
shawn:
powerful.
Sam:
100% disagree with what you just said.
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
Oh, I thought it was a really powerful message.
Sam:
So,
Matt:
so
Sam:
so,
Matt:
people help you through trauma?
Sam:
so do you believe that you are stronger for that experience?
Matt:
For sure.
Sam:
That, that your faith in the gospel, in Christ, your commitment to the church is stronger because of that, right? It did
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
not divide or separate you. It made you stronger. He,
Matt:
But it almost pulled
Sam:
he,
Matt:
me away.
Sam:
it, it almost pulled you away, but it did. And that's
shawn:
But Sam
Sam:
a key
shawn:
is messi-
Sam:
element, right? But it
shawn:
But-
Sam:
could
shawn:
but-
Sam:
have,
shawn:
his-
Sam:
but it
shawn:
but
Sam:
could
shawn:
his-
Sam:
have. So
shawn:
But Sam
Sam:
wait,
shawn:
his
Sam:
hang
shawn:
messi-
Sam:
on just a
shawn:
Oh
Sam:
second.
shawn:
god.
Sam:
Just a second. You,
Matt:
I'm waiting. I'm waiting.
Sam:
you think. that there are other people that have had a similar experience to you that maybe make another choice
Matt:
Yes,
Sam:
that end up leaving
Matt:
for sure.
Sam:
or end up becoming embittered.
Matt:
For sure.
Sam:
Sharing that is an authentic and a vulnerable demonstration of something tough you went through that actually endures us more to you and makes you more relatable and more connectable than you were before we started today's podcast. That story is a strong an important story to share because if you don't think there's other people in the church that haven't gone through that experience, I mean, I've been in a bishopric before. People say that, you know, that show people say the darndest things,
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
like in ward councils and in other places, they're, they are volunteers who, and especially if they're an older age, will say the dumbest things, right? And so your experience isn't, isn't limited to your role. But it was incredibly painful because it happened after everything else that you did. It makes you more relatable, more connectable. And the fact we don't talk about that more, the fact people don't share that story, whether you stayed or whether you left, if you left over that and you shared that with you who stayed, there's a possibility that connection and that relationship that's created as a result of that story brings you back or heals that trauma. There's not a world. Trauma becomes worse when it's hidden in a dark closet and is
shawn:
that's
Sam:
allowed to fester
shawn:
but
Sam:
unhealed and unhelp. We
shawn:
Sam
Sam:
heal
shawn:
perhaps
Sam:
as
shawn:
you're
Sam:
human beings, we heal as human beings because we're able to relate and connect. I
shawn:
But...
Sam:
love this movie, I love the movie Man for All Seasons,
Matt:
Yes,
Sam:
but I
Matt:
yes.
Sam:
also
shawn:
Oh
Sam:
like,
shawn:
boy,
Sam:
I also
shawn:
oh
Sam:
like
shawn:
boy.
Sam:
a movie, I also like a movie,
Matt:
Hidden Figures
Sam:
no, well actually I do like that one too. I also like a movie called Saddleland and I recently watched it on an airplane ride. And at the very end,
Matt:
This
Sam:
The
Matt:
is
Sam:
main
Matt:
the C.S.
Sam:
character,
Matt:
Lewis
Sam:
yes,
Matt:
story.
Sam:
C.S. Lewis says, we love, one of his students says, we read to know we're not alone. And he was an antisocial kid and he still needed to learn. C.S. Lewis, after he lost his wife to pain and tragedy of it all, said, we love to know we're not alone. And to love another person from
Matt:
Lame is.
Sam:
Les Mis, to love another
shawn:
Wow,
Sam:
person is
shawn:
you're
Sam:
to see
shawn:
on a
Sam:
the
shawn:
roll.
Sam:
face of God. When you share that, Matt, you'll be... you increase the likelihood you will connect. And the fact that we don't feel free to do that for fear of judgment is a problem in the church.
shawn:
But Sam, I think you're missing one important piece that Matt
Sam:
I'm
shawn:
mentioned.
Sam:
missing a lot of important pieces, but go ahead, which one
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
do you want
shawn:
but,
Sam:
to cling
shawn:
but
Sam:
on
shawn:
you,
Sam:
to?
shawn:
but the, the beautiful monologue did include a lot of musicals and movies. So that's, that's including a lot of important pieces too. So that's good.
Sam:
Should have brought two more in, I missed two. Darn it.
shawn:
No. So Matt, Matt's point that his, his solution for trauma was to lean on the one and only person who you tell me if I'm wrong, Matt. the one and only person who understands that trauma and can comfort him and heal him and make him grow through that trauma. He turned to the redeemer, he turned to the savior for it to overcome his trauma. And
Sam:
We
shawn:
I'm assuming
Sam:
are all-
shawn:
Matt, I'm assuming that is what helped you to love, like my wife has a very powerful similar story. She's a POU, there's a girl she was, I don't remember, she has roommates with, but for some reason this girl just hated my wife and just was extremely cruel and mean. And it just was tearing my wife apart. She was in the board. And Kristin's solution in that situation was to turn to Christ. And the amazing result of that was the pain and the sorrow and the angst that she felt from that, magically through the atonement of Christ turned into pure love for this girl who was her enemy, who was being so cruel to her. And that was one of the most life-changing stories for me to learn that. Now, I hear what you're saying, Sam. I agree that there's really big value in, there's huge value in sharing experiences and building uncommon experiences to help other people go through their trauma. And ultimately, I know what you're saying, it leads people to then do what Matt did, which is turn to Christ, right?
Matt:
Well, it doesn't
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
have to, but it can.
Sam:
yeah, it can. Like the priesthood is the ability to act in the name of God. Right. So we are all Christ's. I mean, who, who is Christ, but us in
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
the church and so us connecting and relating and understanding each other, I think it's important
shawn:
I'm gonna make
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
an.
Sam:
pain and pain, pain and trauma only grows in dark
shawn:
I don't know if I agree with what
Sam:
closets.
shawn:
you just said
Sam:
I
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
know.
shawn:
I don't
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
know, I'll have to think about that.
Matt:
well, we, yeah, I guess we can experience Christ outside of other people, but other people, so it's true, if I didn't have individuals in my life who were saying, hey Matt, it's okay, it's all right, and we're still kinda like leading, it wasn't only Christ in that situation. Christ is the one that allowed me to heal, Christ is the one that allowed me to overcome the anger, but you do need other people along the way, it's true. I'm just so uncomfortable being that other person for other people. I just...
Sam:
Right. We all are right. It's vulnerable and
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
it sucks sometimes. Yeah.
shawn:
So, so the original question from the listener though, goes to something we haven't really addressed, which is people who have truly in the church had very serious traumas, right? Real true abuse, those things. He's asking, do we have an obligation to give reparations or to reach out to those people? And I think the answer to that is a clear yes. Yeah, I mean, just as much sympathy or empathy as I could possibly bring forth for anyone who's truly had abuse. Now I have a problem sometimes, and this is my own failure, my own weakness. in comparing true abuse, like sexual abuse to Matt's abuse, the abuse, the story you gave.
Matt:
not even close to the same thing.
shawn:
No, I
Matt:
That's
shawn:
know they're
Matt:
another
shawn:
not saying
Matt:
reason
shawn:
that.
Matt:
why.
shawn:
No,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
I know you're not saying that. And that's why sometimes I have a problem with, you know, the relationships that I have with, with people who have left the church who we're not fighting. We have great relationships, but I seek to understand their pain. Where they, you say pain, where does the pain come from? And one guy explained it like this. He's like, you know, Sean pain comes in all different manners. He says, one day I'm a musician and I needed to sell my guitar. And he says, I sold it. And I turned around and walked home and I started crying my eyes out because I love that guitar. And he's explaining how that's true trauma. That's real trauma.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
And it's a real pain. And I'm going, what? And I needed
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
to, it was a good for me to learn that lessons. I need to understand it, but that's not the same pain as someone who is sexually abused.
Matt:
Not at all. They're different. But, but I will say, and this is a story I won't share because it's not only my story to share, but I do have experience with sexual assault and sexual abuse. And you do need professional help for that. You cannot heal completely from that without turning to some kind of professional help.
Sam:
becomes worse in darkness,
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
in
shawn:
But
Sam:
isolation.
shawn:
I like your point, your first point Matt, that is not the Joseph Smith's fault, right? That that sexual
Matt:
No,
shawn:
abuse happened. That
Matt:
no.
shawn:
is some,
Sam:
Why? I
shawn:
you
Sam:
don't
shawn:
know, or God's fault, right? That is
Sam:
know. Nobody's
shawn:
some individual.
Sam:
saying it is.
shawn:
No, no, but no, that's not true, Sam. Many, many people blame the church, blame religion, blame God for leaving. That's a lot of the message.
Matt:
But that's
shawn:
And
Matt:
part of the grieving process, right? If you go through the like the stages of grief, it's like denial or anger or something like that. That's just people in a grieving process. But yeah, I understand. I know that people say that.
Sam:
I, I think we get concerned though, that anger will spread. And I just don't think it's true.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
2 billion posts.
Matt:
Okay, well so on the thought provoker, I'm not gonna give it to me, because you both provoked thoughts in me that, like on this subject, I felt like I already knew it all, but you both have said things that I hadn't thought of before. So...
Sam:
I vote Sean.
shawn:
I vote Sam.
Matt:
okay.
shawn:
No, I vote Sam.
Matt:
Wait, now I have to choose the... okay,
Sam:
Uh,
Matt:
Sam. Sam wins.
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
trophies for all.
shawn:
I really love your, I love your take on it, Sam. And the relationship part is the most important part is just as Christian as it gets. I love that part.
Matt:
So we're gonna get a little lighter and talk about something that matters way less than any of this. The GOP presidential debates. Like honestly, listener, if you care about who becomes the next president of the United States more than you care about these other topics, there's something wrong with you.
shawn:
Hehehehehehe
Matt:
The president doesn't matter all that much.
Sam:
Great. Matt just offended the other third of our audience.
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
They're like, no, it's gotta be Vivek Ramaswamy. If it's not him, my life is over. Well, so,
Sam:
Uh.
Matt:
so listener, just to like lay the background. So one of the main purposes of having primary debates is to give candidates a chance to introduce themselves to voters. Because they spend a lot of their time in Iowa or New Hampshire visiting one-on-one with individuals, but they don't get a chance to build a national brand. And so a Republican debate gives them a chance to build that brand. And on that note, I'm actually grateful that Trump didn't go to this debate because he would have sucked all the air out of the room and Republicans wouldn't have had a lot of chance to kind of see the other candidates. So in this particular debate, the first one, it's your, it's your first introduction to the voters. And so the question that I have, and the moderators, by the way, they have a different take, right? The moderators who work for Fox news are trying to get clicks. They're trying to get quotable moments. They want people talking about this debate for years to come. and if they can find some kind of question or situation that will like ignite anger or fighting, then that's what the moderators are looking for. The candidates aren't always looking for those same things. So the goals of the candidates and the network, they're not always the exact same thing. So that makes it hard for candidates to kind of stand out or to introduce themselves the way that they want to introduce themselves. But given that Sean last week really didn't know anything about any of the candidates,
shawn:
Hehehe
Matt:
and I didn't know a lot about many of them, What is the takeaway from this first debate? How are they branding themselves? And do any of them fit the latter day lens standard of an honest, good, or wise person that we could support for president of the United States?
shawn:
So how about I'm going to give to directly answer your question. I'm going to give my fly by for each one, what their brand presentation
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
was being a
Matt:
right,
shawn:
branding guy. And then I'm
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
going to shut up because, because both
Sam:
Very
shawn:
of you have
Sam:
nice.
shawn:
a have much more insight onto this.
Matt:
No, no, I'm really interested in what you have to say about this.
shawn:
Okay.
Sam:
Me too.
shawn:
V
Matt:
Wow, you got that from that debate. Uh-huh. Uh huh, okay. Hahaha Uh huh.
shawn:
I
Matt:
Hahaha
shawn:
don't know. I don't know what his message was other than I'm a good old boy. Nikki Haley, I'm a strong leader and an independent thinker. And the rest
Matt:
Uh huh.
shawn:
I didn't
Matt:
Sean.
shawn:
listen to.
Matt:
Well okay, so Tim Scott is one that you might not have picked. Like if I were to ask their campaigns, the ones that you mentioned, what it is they're trying to like project as their campaign, they got it right. That's exactly what they're doing. Tim Scott is the one that you maybe missed. So Tim Scott, any sense of what Tim Scott might be, Sean? He's a peacemaker. He's a lover,
shawn:
Perfect.
Matt:
not a fighter.
shawn:
I love that. Okay. Yeah, that made sense.
Matt:
Yeah, so this debate was hard for him because there was not a format conducive. Well, you don't shut off the mics of the other people and you let Vivek just go blah, then it's hard to raise your hand and be like, can't we all just get along? Why are we all being so mean to Vivek? That was good, Sean. What do you
shawn:
You
Matt:
think,
shawn:
think it
Matt:
Sam?
shawn:
was accurate, Matt? I think it was accurate. Oh, okay.
Matt:
I think that was totally accurate, yeah.
Sam:
So on the note of total transparency, I didn't watch the debate. So
shawn:
No!
Matt:
Oh, Sam.
Sam:
I had every intent of doing it. I was in the Eastern time zone. I was exhausted. I actually went to bed at eight o'clock that night and had a wonderful night's sleep. But
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
I have read a lot of the recaps, honestly. I think most Americans would probably have been more pulled into it had Trump been there. It would have been interesting to see how everyone else reacted with him.
Matt:
But what would Vivik have done if Trump was there? There would be no room for him to do his antics,
Sam:
Um, no,
Matt:
right?
Sam:
no.
Matt:
Makes you kind of wonder if maybe they coordinated that a little bit, right? Cause remember I said Trump's not gonna, Trump's gonna go because he doesn't wanna have a stage of people attacking him
Sam:
Matt's trying
Matt:
and
Sam:
to
Matt:
no
Sam:
explain
Matt:
one,
Sam:
why Trump didn't go.
Matt:
no,
Sam:
It was
Matt:
think
Sam:
planned.
Matt:
about it.
Sam:
I love it. Yeah.
Matt:
No, don't you think it was? Cause he doesn't wanna have just nobody defending him. And I said, who's gonna defend Trump? And I didn't know that Vivik Ramaswamy would be so anxious to defend Trump.
Sam:
He was Trump's surrogate. There.
Matt:
So-
shawn:
Do you think that's accurate, Matt? That his whole end game strategy is, Trump's gonna win anyway, I wanna kiss his butt and be his VP.
Matt:
Yeah, I
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
think 100%.
Sam:
some of the other candidates are doing that though, too. I mean, nobody wants to cross the MAGA base, right, except for Chris Christie. And that's why Christie is so appealing to Matt, right? But that's also what makes Christie such a challenge as he goes through the, uh, through the primer, through these elections.
Matt:
I think Nikki Haley did the best in the debate.
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
Because,
shawn:
she was awesome.
Matt:
so Cook Political Report says it like this. There's like 30% of the Republican elector that's always Trump. They'll support him no matter what. There's about 20% that are never Trump. And then there's another 30% that are sometimes Trump. They like Trump, but they're open to other options. Chris Christie's closing the door on the sometimes Trump crowd, right? Especially the way Vivek portrayed him as just so anti-Trump. And Christie didn't really have any kind of an answer for that. But Nikki Haley portrays herself as, I'm acceptable to the never Trump crowd. I'm also acceptable to the sometimes Trump crowd. So she played that hand really, really well.
Sam:
So, so Matt, I have a question for you after this debate. We've seen the, you've seen the first debate. I'll go back and watch it before we go into the next one. Who do you think ends up being the primary candidate when we go into the general election for the
shawn:
Too
Sam:
Republican
shawn:
early.
Sam:
party?
shawn:
Way too
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
early.
Sam:
It,
Matt:
it is
Sam:
it,
Matt:
too early.
Sam:
it is too early, but it's still interesting to ask. Who do you think
Matt:
So
Sam:
ends up
Matt:
I
Sam:
being
Matt:
think
Sam:
the?
Matt:
that, so when you hear pundits talk about it, they say there's never anybody that's been at 50% at this stage of the game that hasn't become the nominee. But. But they're not thinking about the fact that Trump is an incumbent president. Trump has four years of record behind him. The fact that he's only at 50% suggests that there are a lot of Republicans who are not happy with him and are looking for another option. So what ultimately ends up happening depends on who stays in the race and who gets out of the race. If it were a race head to head, Nikki Haley, Donald Trump, I think Nikki Haley could win the nomination. If it were a-
shawn:
That'd be awesome.
Matt:
If it were head to head DeSantis and Trump, I think Trump would win the nomination. But if you make it a three-way race, DeSantis, Trump, and Nikki Haley, then it's hard to predict who would win that. There's like too many options there and it's too hard to predict who's going to go where.
shawn:
There's so much to happen yet to happen, but based on the little bit that has happened, I think Nikki Haley comes out as a really strong candidate. I would vote for her at this point if I had to choose. But you asked the question, Matt, who fits the latter day lens most closely of being honest, good, and wise? I'm still going to stick with my guns. The only person that really projects that most is Mitt Romney. You weird
Matt:
Yes,
shawn:
Utahns. What's
Matt:
Mitt
shawn:
wrong
Matt:
Romney!
shawn:
with you? What is wrong with you Mormons?
Matt:
He's not running for president, Sean.
shawn:
I don't care. He's
Matt:
He
Sam:
So,
shawn:
the
Matt:
wasn't
shawn:
one that's
Matt:
on the
shawn:
qualified.
Matt:
debate stage.
Sam:
so let's assume it's Biden and Trump that make the, based on the current polling, it's Biden and Trump, fair?
Matt:
Okay.
Sam:
No names. What is, how does no names, how does the no names movement play into the general election a year from now?
Matt:
I can't see any Democrat leaving Joe Biden to vote for the no names candidate. Because the people, the Democrats who don't like Joe Biden are further left than Joe Biden. The moderate Democrats, the ones that are kind of in the middle, they like Joe Biden. So I don't think that the no names hurts Joe Biden among Democrats. It does, like, cause problems among independents. And so there's some independents out there that are never Trump that might go no names because they don't want Trump, but they also could just go Biden. So I don't think no names actually hurts Biden that much. I think that there's more like more and no names doesn't do anything to Trump. Trump voters are going to vote for Trump regardless of the no names thing out there.
Sam:
Okay. So we got to ask this question this early in the race, right? And we'll come
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
back and listen to these episodes based on what you know now, who ends up as the next president of the United States, Matt.
Matt:
Joe Biden. Joe Biden. Yeah.
Sam:
Yeah. You think he
Matt:
Right
Sam:
gets reelected?
Matt:
now, I don't even think it's close. I don't think that there's, for sure Trump doesn't beat Joe Biden. I don't think that that, like Biden already beat Trump when he wasn't an incumbent president. When Biden has a whole record that he can run on, he beats
Sam:
John,
Matt:
Trump easily.
Sam:
how do we end up on a show with a latter-day lens? Member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints advocating for the reelection of a Democratic incumbent. That's fascinating.
shawn:
He's...
Matt:
Uh,
Sam:
If that's
Matt:
uh,
Sam:
not
Matt:
if...
Sam:
proof of the latter-day lens, I don't know what is.
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
Okay,
Sam:
We
Matt:
so
Sam:
love you, Matt.
Matt:
who wins the thought provoker there? That was a provoking thing for Sam to say. Was it thought provoking?
shawn:
Hahaha!
Matt:
I'm actually giving thought provoker to Sean because
Sam:
Uh...
Matt:
he watched
Sam:
I agree.
Matt:
the debate and he
Sam:
Yup.
Matt:
like, he is not informed on politics at all. It's not his
Sam:
That's
Matt:
world.
Sam:
right.
Matt:
And he nailed, like, those campaigns have been spending months trying to like... Focus their branding message on this one moment and Sean picked it up
Sam:
Gone.
shawn:
Matt,
Sam:
Did you
shawn:
you,
Sam:
use chat GPT on that? Did you
shawn:
no,
Sam:
use chat
shawn:
he,
Sam:
GPT or was
shawn:
no,
Sam:
that your
shawn:
he,
Sam:
real? Okay. All
shawn:
he
Sam:
right.
shawn:
framed
Sam:
Good job.
shawn:
the question within my wheelhouse. That's what I do for a living
Sam:
I,
shawn:
is branding.
Sam:
I give it to Sean and I remove the points to me because I didn't watch the debate.
Matt:
Ha
Sam:
I think
Matt:
ha!
Sam:
it's terrible. What a hypocrite. Uh, my family actually watched the debates because of this show. They were fascinated to see what would happen. They
shawn:
Oh nice.
Sam:
said, Hey, you got it. You got it right. Trump didn't show up. I was like,
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
yes, I did. Thank you.
Matt:
And next week they're gonna be like, Sam, why didn't you watch the debate? We gathered
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
as a family, where were you? Hey.
Sam:
I was far away as usual. Go ahead.
Matt:
So the big question for this week comes from a listener. He writes, in a recent episode, Sam recently talked about leadership, which gets a lot of emphasis in the church and in the country. But the kind of business leadership we discuss seems very different from the leadership Jesus demonstrated, or Paul. Don't you think? When you take off your MBA goggles, which by the way, Sam hates MBA goggles, but when you take
Sam:
Oh.
Matt:
off those goggles, do you see Jesus performing the behaviors we teach in leadership classes? And then he gets a little bit meaner. When I put on my lefty hat, it seems like leadership culture is a scam to justify the theft of wages from workers, as in,
Sam:
Oh no.
Matt:
hey, why am I doing all the work and you're making all the money? Well, because my leadership is what enables your production. Do you think that's true? Partly true? Is there evidence to suggest that better leaders increase productivity, if so by how much? And which leadership behaviors correlate with high productivity? There's the question. Is there a scriptural basis for compensation of leaders compared with the rest of an organization?
shawn:
Well, before Sam jumps in, because I know Sam's ready to jump in, there are some scriptures that give a little bit of insight. Like
Matt:
Yes,
shawn:
for...
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
Oh, do you have some too?
Matt:
No, well I do, but I wanna hear yours.
shawn:
So Malachi 3.5 talks about a bunch of sins or problems. Like I will come near, like, and I will come near to you to judgment and I will be swift witness against, and he starts listing things like adulterers, sorcerers. And you know what's clustered together with adulterers and sorcerers? Um, those who oppress the higher link in his wages. That's
Sam:
Whoa,
Matt:
Ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
shawn:
combined. That's combined
Sam:
whoa.
shawn:
with, okay. So there's that
Sam:
So,
shawn:
there's general.
Sam:
so
shawn:
There's.
Sam:
an oppressor, a sorcerer. That's fascinating.
Matt:
And yeah.
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
In Jeremiah 22, 13, woe unto those who build a house of unrighteousness and his chambers by wrong, that useth his neighbor's service without wages. So that's kind of similar,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
right? And then in Matthew 25, it talks about the parable of the talents. And I don't know. I mean, that's, I know that has to do with spiritual things more than the literal talents, the money. But, well. We'll keep it at that. It's more spiritual, but that references the productivity of human beings. Yes, spiritually, but I don't know. Maybe it does bleed into a little bit secular or
Matt:
I like this one, maybe it's not about corporations, but I like it. It's in Mosiah 4.26. And then what he says, I would that ye should impart of your substance to the poor, every man according to that which he hath, such as feeding the hungry, clothing the naked, visiting the sick, and administering to their relief, both spiritually and temporally, according to their wants.
Sam:
Mmm.
Matt:
So we should give people.
Sam:
I want a big house and a boat
Matt:
Exactly,
Sam:
and
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
yes.
Sam:
I want
shawn:
so
Sam:
a
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
yacht
shawn:
so Sam,
Matt:
That's
Sam:
that
shawn:
I have a
Sam:
we're
shawn:
question.
Matt:
right
Sam:
back
Matt:
from
Sam:
to
Matt:
the...
Sam:
Universal Basic Income. This
Matt:
The-
Sam:
is fantastic.
Matt:
the-
Sam:
This
shawn:
No,
Sam:
is
shawn:
no,
Sam:
very
shawn:
no.
Sam:
full circle. I appreciate
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
this.
shawn:
I have
Matt:
The
shawn:
a question
Matt:
communist,
shawn:
for you, Sam.
Matt:
wait, wait. The communist manifesto says,
shawn:
Oh boy.
Matt:
from each according to their ability to each
Sam:
Ugh...
Matt:
according to their wants. And then
Sam:
Yeah?
Matt:
Lenin was like, well, we can't give everybody according to their wants because it's too much. So he says, from each according to their ability to each according to their needs. But the
shawn:
Huh?
Matt:
Book of Mormon is clearly saying, give temporally according to their wants.
shawn:
So define that, Matt. If you're touting that scripture, help me define that, because I don't understand what that means. Well, does it really mean that if I choose to have a leisurely lifestyle and not work as hard as Sam, are you really saying that I can ask for whatever I want? What do you think
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
that means? No, it doesn't.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
What do you think it means really?
Matt:
Well, so, so
Sam:
All right.
Matt:
again, all right, we'll let
Sam:
All
Matt:
Sam,
Sam:
right.
Matt:
we'll
Sam:
Here,
Matt:
let Sam
Sam:
here.
Matt:
help us out here.
Sam:
There we go. I have a question. So in a, in a, in a gospel perspective, what is the purpose of this life?
Matt:
to return to live with Heavenly Father,
Sam:
Right.
Matt:
to become our best selves,
shawn:
by coming
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
to Christ,
Matt:
to
shawn:
by
Matt:
prove
Sam:
It's
shawn:
coming
Sam:
a,
Matt:
them
shawn:
to
Sam:
it's,
shawn:
Christ.
Matt:
here with, yeah.
Sam:
it, it's a process of becoming, right. And Joseph Smith even talks about the level of intelligence we achieve here. We'll take with us, right. We're going to retain that. And there's
Matt:
Yes.
Sam:
something in this life about experience and work and struggle and challenge, growing us and developing us and, and polishing us, right? Like there is no celebration of lack of work. or lack of effort or lack of progress, right?
Matt:
That's true.
Sam:
Nauvoo, if you go back to the saints, they walked into a swamp, they cleared the swamp out, they built a beautiful building, a great personal expense. Not everybody was paid equally for that effort, but there is something beyond pay that as human beings we value. We value giving back, we value contributing to a cause bigger than ourselves. We do need to put food on the table, but here in the United States, I think the food on the table Sometimes, not always, there's people that truly have a challenge and need to be focused on. But here in the United States, you can't tell me we struggle to put food on the table for 60 or 70 or 80% of the people out there. So there's something about hustle and hard work and intensity that yields innovation, that yields a better product, that yields the ability to fly a rocket to the moon, right? And as a result, find Tang
shawn:
Oh
Sam:
and Belkow and
shawn:
no... You
Sam:
pens
shawn:
lost
Sam:
that
shawn:
me!
Sam:
write upside down. Listen, a good leader, a good leader that can paint a vision of the future and bring people along in achieving and accomplishing that vision to the point where people who are part of that feel bought off, they feel like they're part of what they're achieving and accomplishing, and they feel like their work, their labor made a difference and maybe even changed the world. What, what could there be better? And in exchange for that, I, I turn. I exchanged time in pursuit of that vision and I get back money in compensation. That is a rare thing. There's
Matt:
But
Sam:
not
Matt:
why?
Sam:
a lot of people that can do that. There's examples in the history of the world. JFK did it with the space race, right? The 50s,
shawn:
Ah.
Sam:
he said, in a decade, we're going to go to the moon. Nobody had ever been on the moon before. The United States had no idea how to do it, but we knew we had to do it to beat the Russians. That's a tough, challenging thing. And yet it brought people from all diverse backgrounds together. Some of them got paid crap to do it. Others got paid incredibly well. The market dictated that. But if you handed around universal basic income or if you just dispersed to everybody what they wanted, you're robbing the individual of the growth that comes with struggle. And that is contrary to the gospel, I would say.
Matt:
Well, so the United Auto Workers just announced that they want to strike, and their demands are they want a 46% increase in wages, and they want to move from a 40-hour work week to a 32-hour work week.
Sam:
Unions are insane.
shawn:
Wow, that's a big ask.
Matt:
And I imagine it's because the United Auto Workers feel like they're doing all the work. So why are the leaders of the big three auto companies, why are they making all of this money and not the people that are actually doing the job? So can't you set up a system where you say, okay, like here's how much money, instead of giving the wealth to the shareholders, give the wealth to the employees and the workers that are doing all of the hard work.
shawn:
That system
Sam:
So
shawn:
is set up, man.
Sam:
who puts together that rubric? Like here's
Matt:
Ahem.
Sam:
your value as a human being. So you work, listen, this will get me going. The American dream
Matt:
I'm sorry.
Sam:
is an immigrant coming over to the United States and working in tough conditions on an assembly line floor, making tremendous and enormous sacrifices so that their kids can learn English, participate in our educational system, and have opportunity affiliated and tied to the dollar. And there are stories, even those that were on the debate stage Wednesday night, of people that have arisen out of great struggle, a massive income who benefited the economy in ways that no one ever would have anticipated. It's absolute insanity to say that somehow the world should just hand out to everybody what they want. Take away that strife and struggle and rob them of the opportunity of growth. How else do they get that growth? What do you
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
say?
Matt:
so what I would say is the American dream should include individuals who were born in the United States into tough circumstances, having the opportunity to overcome their circumstances and have a decent life. Right? If you work hard, there should be a living wage. If you work hard, you should share in the wealth of the company. If you're producing the labor for an organization, you should share in the wealth of that organization just as much as the leaders do.
Sam:
That aspiring tiered system is as flawed as a free market system we have today. Like what makes Elon Musk worth billions of dollars? And the risk that he's taken in the market, some of it was on government, but he still took it, right? What makes him worth that much more than any other individual? It is unequal, but it is the way our system is. If you create a metric that says, hey, You know, that auto worker who's an assemblyman, he's on a tier three out of six. Right. And maybe the, this, the CEOs of the auto companies is on a tier four out of six because their ability to impact, you know, thousands of employees is like, it just descends into
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
chaos madness and who controls the rubric.
shawn:
So
Sam:
Like
shawn:
Sam
Sam:
that's
shawn:
and,
Matt:
I'll
Sam:
when
Matt:
do it.
Sam:
Atlas shrugged.
shawn:
I'll do
Sam:
I love
shawn:
it.
Sam:
that quote Atlas
Matt:
Ha
Sam:
shrugged
Matt:
ha ha.
Sam:
who held the globe up because it's like, if I'm not going to get a return on that, on the risk. What's the point of making the risk?
Matt:
I
shawn:
about.
Matt:
knew we could get you to quote Ayn Rand if we pushed this topic
Sam:
hahahaha
Matt:
long enough.
shawn:
I'm shocked that it's been 30 episodes before Sam has mentioned Ayn Rand.
Sam:
Mm-hmm. Just watch I'll
Matt:
Hey, so
Sam:
bring
Matt:
Sam
Sam:
Glenn back into it
Matt:
you
Sam:
Yeah
Matt:
brought up Elon Musk. Elon Musk comes into Twitter, a thriving company that's doing just fine, and
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
destroys it. And people who worked there and built it and created something, because
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
he has more money, he purchases the company, he overpays, and he destroys what they've built.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
So I don't think Elon Musk should be our example of the leader who's
Sam:
What should there
Matt:
like...
Sam:
be a rule against a really successful? He has said, he has said in an interview, I love his interview. Somebody said, Hey, what, why do you go buy a company and destroy it? He said, you know what? I didn't like what they were saying. I didn't like their approach. And guess what? I have so much money. I can do it. Right.
Matt:
That's
Sam:
Did
Matt:
a problem, Sam.
Sam:
that's not
Matt:
These people
Sam:
a problem.
Matt:
have been, they've dedicated
Sam:
Oh,
Matt:
their lives to an organization
Sam:
so
Matt:
and
Sam:
they
Matt:
some
Sam:
go.
Matt:
rich brat can come in and destroy the organization because they feel like it.
Sam:
So they go to another organization and they rebuild it. One of the
shawn:
So
Sam:
great
shawn:
Matt,
Sam:
things
shawn:
hang
Sam:
about
shawn:
on.
Sam:
our free market economy is that if it was all taken away from me today, you don't like country music, so you wouldn't listen to this. If it was all taken away from me today, Matt and Sean, how quickly could I rebuild it in this economy, in this free market society? If I have a knowledge of how to do it and I have a knowledge of how to lead with history, you can recreate things. Not everybody can recreate equally, truly, but not everybody
shawn:
Okay.
Sam:
wants to take the risk that I'm willing to take or others are willing to take and you can't penalize someone
shawn:
You're
Sam:
for it.
shawn:
both just monologuing secular statements and you're ignoring our listener's question.
Matt:
Uh-huh.
shawn:
The question
Sam:
Our listener's
shawn:
is.
Matt:
I used...
Sam:
question is worthy of ignoring, especially
Matt:
I used...
Sam:
when he says, uh,
shawn:
Oh,
Sam:
don't
shawn:
hang
Sam:
you think, don't you think.
shawn:
on.
Matt:
I...
shawn:
Is there a scriptural basis for compensation of leaders compared with the rest of an organization?
Sam:
There's not.
Matt:
I found
Sam:
The script
Matt:
a scriptural
Sam:
will be.
Matt:
basis for communism.
shawn:
Yeah, but you
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
didn't
Sam:
and
shawn:
define
Sam:
that's,
shawn:
Matt. You got
Sam:
that
shawn:
to define
Sam:
was a good
shawn:
what
Sam:
idea.
shawn:
it means. Define what it means. What does it mean
Matt:
I think that...
shawn:
to each according to their want? Go ahead.
Matt:
I think that if you have a righteous society, then the Holy Ghost helps people to temper their wants to things that are reasonable and make sense. So it's
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
not like everything-
shawn:
so you believe that scripture applies to
Matt:
Everybody.
shawn:
the... No, no, you believe that applies when Christ is on the earth during the millennium or in the celestial kingdom. But then you're
Matt:
or
shawn:
saying it doesn't apply now.
Matt:
we should strive for it now. We should strive for it
shawn:
But
Matt:
now.
shawn:
you
Matt:
And
shawn:
said
Matt:
so.
shawn:
in a perfect world, we're in a righteous society. That is not what we are at.
Matt:
So if I'm the CEO of an organization, then I say to the employees, hey, I'm no better than you are, and we're in this together, and when I benefit, you're gonna benefit the exact same amount that I'm
Sam:
But
Matt:
gonna benefit.
Sam:
by the way, some great companies have taken just that approach and they've done well with it. One way that hasn't worked is there was a CEO in Seattle that said, you know what? I think everybody should get 75 grand a year from the secretary to the janitors, to the top salespeople. And that company was destroyed within the year. Right. So
shawn:
What?
Sam:
I think
shawn:
So...
Sam:
it's up, it's, it's a CEO's creative prerogative to share in that way. And there's some great companies built on
shawn:
So,
Sam:
that REI is an example.
shawn:
so I have a question for both of you. So if we're looking for scriptural basis for how to pay wages, isn't an overwhelming scriptural principle the agency that God has given us? Freedom agency. So how are we not talking about, so Sam, I'm a huge fan of, I'm as big a fan of Adam Smith and the wealth of nations as Matt is of Marx and the communist manifesto. Ha ha
Matt:
Come on.
shawn:
ha.
Matt:
I like Adam Smith.
shawn:
Okay, good.
Matt:
They're not competing ideas. They're just different ideas.
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
You can have them both. Ask China.
shawn:
all right. Good point. Great point. But what he talks about is the free entering into a free contract, right? Like I can go, Sam, I can go work for you and advocate for myself and negotiate for a wage that I am willing to work for you. I'm willing to exchange my labor to you for a specific wage. And Sam, you have the ability to hire me for that wage? or not, right? And this free exchange is scriptural, right? So to try and find, to our listener, to try and find, hey, leaders should make this much, employees should make this much, that's impossible because free agency is the principle that governs this. Shouldn't it be? I should be taught or I should learn how to advocate for myself to enter into a free exchange and make what I choose to make.
Sam:
I would imagine that a lot of the people that object to our current system are currently benefiting from that system pretty well and in some cases over-empathize with the people who are adversely challenged by it without truly knowing their position. Right?
Matt:
Well, yeah, but what I'm trying to say is I'm not advocating for a new system. I'm saying that a component of leadership should be advocating for the fair compensation of the people that work in an organization.
Sam:
Oh, I, we don't disagree with that at all. I agree with that a hundred percent.
Matt:
Like right now there are a lot of workers on strike in various industries. It's disrupted lots of aspects of my life because people are on strike. They're on strike because the market says you need to be fairly compensated and the market's going to decide what your compensation is going to be. That leads to sometimes a very competitive, combative situation where you have to prove your worth to an organization. in order for them to say, you're worth this much, because we're disagreeing about how much value you bring to the table, and they say, fine, we'll leave, and then you're gonna see how much value we bring to the table, and then that's gonna kind of bring it to some kind of a market equilibrium. And I think that leaders should not behave that way. Leaders should say, I'm not just gonna compensate them the lowest that the market dictates, I'm gonna compensate them maybe better than the market dictates.
Sam:
Matt, that's free market and you're absolutely right. Good leaders will pay very well to get people bought off in their vision and help execute on the vision. I mean, that's, that's leadership 101. I
Matt:
But
Sam:
think
Matt:
that's not what they
Sam:
you're
Matt:
teach you in the business schools.
Sam:
that w I disagree with that. I think basic leadership is understanding the power that workers have because they can make choices. And then it's making sure we talk a lot in the business world about employee retention and the cost to onboard and the cost of turnover and creating an environment that is conducive to people participating in a vision bigger than themselves, giving back in unique and interesting ways and being well compensated for it. You're using evidence of strikes by unions as an example of saying there's inequity in it. I think in some of those cases, unions are set up by their very nature that they have to do these strikes. If you took fair votes in some of these cases, Not everybody would say, hey, let's strike the, the people who contribute to these unions in a lot of cases are forced to go along with things that don't necessarily make most sense for the individual. And actually, uh, in that, in that layer or that division between management and workers, I don't work around any unions, but management and workers, that actually makes that relationship more dysfunctional,
Matt:
Adversarial.
Sam:
probably results in, uh, in less pay. And it probably makes it tougher for leadership to say, hey, buy off in our vision because you've got a wall standing in between you and that, and that messaging. I
Matt:
So,
Sam:
mean, America
Matt:
yeah, so I...
Sam:
is great because of our free market system and good leaders that have driven great vision.
Matt:
Yeah, I'm not attacking the free market system. I think what I would say is, I've seen individuals that take a small business and grow it into something big and lasting, and oftentimes, those individuals are not doing it by themselves. They invest in people. And when I watch Shark Tank,
Sam:
Yes.
Matt:
I see the same kind of thing. You'll see Mark Cuban that'll be like, I hate your company, I hate your business, but I love you. and I'm investing in you, and I'm gonna
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
buy something as long as you promise me that I get first dibs on every other next thing that you start.
Sam:
That's leadership 101, yes.
Matt:
So then I think that that's the kind of leadership that you would see from Christ and from Paul. That's scriptural leadership. Scriptural leadership is finding individuals who are talented in ways that you're not, and taking advantage of those skills to work together with them to create something that benefits both of you together. more than the two of you separate could have accomplished on your own.
shawn:
But
Sam:
Yes.
shawn:
Matt, I think the question is rooted in, what about those individuals who aren't that talented, aren't that smart, aren't as aggressive? The ones that Mark Cuban doesn't want to hire or work with. The question is, how do you get those people who aren't maybe as attractive in a free market and get them some fair wages, even though they're just in the factory turning a wheel? That's the question.
Sam:
So a great company will provide opportunities for advancement and education and growth and desire to be contributing to something above and beyond themselves. The question, the big question, Sean, Matt, was more about the inequity, the perceived inequity between leadership and employees,
shawn:
Yeah, right.
Sam:
which pits the one against the other. And I don't think that's the right way to look at this, Matt. I give you all the points on this end, because I think you're looking at it the right way. And listen, it's not just the CEO, it's middle and it's lower management that has the ability to set goals and engage with employees and help reduce turnover and help people to feel like they truly have ownership over a part of the vision. They make the difference in a company, large and small.
Matt:
I would say that leadership is important. It's hard to, like, how do you rate how important some things are, but I know that I lack basic leadership skills because I'm great at coming up with a vision, I'm great at coming up with an idea, but then making it happen, I'll do it for a month or something and then I will get bored and it'll fall apart. This podcast works because you two make the podcast work. I had an idea and you guys said, yeah, we're gonna make that happen. And then we really quickly like figured out roles and who's gonna do what. Like that to me is the essence of leadership is providing the vision, but then also providing an infrastructure that enacts the vision. And so you don't have a company without that.
Sam:
Everybody has their individual role.
shawn:
That's
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
awesome. Matt, how does it feel
Sam:
Points
shawn:
to
Sam:
to
shawn:
have
Sam:
Matt.
shawn:
destroyed it and won it?
Sam:
He won it
shawn:
You
Sam:
in the
shawn:
leave
Sam:
end.
shawn:
this, you're
Matt:
I w-
shawn:
gonna have
Matt:
hehehehe
shawn:
a full week of just relishing in your victory and win here. This is awesome.
Matt:
It's good because my family's been a little salty with me and I need to let them know I'm a winner. Leave me alone.
shawn:
Ha ha
Matt:
Hey
Sam:
Uh...
Matt:
guys, thanks so much for another great episode. Listener, join with us again next week. Take care.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories