The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
July 19, 2023: In which we discuss questions from listeners. Lots of fun stuff in this episode.
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
- It seems like Shawn and Sam have been exposed to a lot of anti-union propaganda. Sam mentioned some better non-union ways that worker interests should be represented. I’m curious to hear more about these
- Do you think most people you all taught as missionaries changed their actual beliefs and opinions, or did they just find the church that matched their existing core beliefs? I've been thinking that most people have their core beliefs and find their religion and political party based on what matches that.
- Universal Basic Income and the American Dream
- Hey I love how much emphasis you place on the revealed doctrine. Sometimes you reference that the doctrine is the canonized scripture. I’ve been researching to find a quote or passage that confirms the “the doctrine” is to be found in the canonized scripture. Most of the friends and family that I talk to believe that doctrine is basically anything that is said from general conference, the ensign or anything that comes out of the mouths of current leaders of the church.
- American/Utah Exceptionalism in the church
- Do we put ourselves in spiritual danger by interpreting what the prophet is saying, or do we make the decision to follow because he’s a prophet of God and God won’t lead us astray?
- Do you have advice for Latter Day Saints, when confronted with the question of homosexuality and the church? is there a place for the LGBTQ community?
- You guys glossed over porn and sounded a bit naïve and ignorant about the real struggle that so many faithful, humble, good people experience. Why?
- With declining Christianity, what is the best way we can unite with other people of different faiths? Not hypothetically but practical things.
- I’m the dummy that doesn’t understand anything. Then I listen to this podcast and realized I need to have an opinion. Do you think it’s important to “have an opinion”?
- For Matt: when have “the experts” or “academia” been wrong and steered the world wrong. And how is society to know when they are right or wrong. When have their findings led to horrific things? How do we know when to follow their expertise? What qualifies one to be an expert? A degree could be obtained with straight C’s. Can comprehensive experience without a degree qualify one as an expert?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt (00:01.807)
Hey welcome everyone to a special episode of the Latter Day Lens. This is the one in which we just answer questions from the mailbox. So I'm not going to do as much talking on the front end because there's just questions. And we haven't prepared in advance any answers to these questions. Some of them we're just looking at for the first time right now. So I'm going to start with this one because I think it sounds like a lot of fun. It seems like Sean and Sam have been exposed to a lot of anti-union propaganda.
Sam (00:31.136)
Oh no.
Matt (00:31.855)
If you were a CEO worried about work stoppages, how would you undermine unions by spreading the same rumors and aspersions that Sean and Sam are repeating perhaps? Would you preface them by saying, of course unions used to do really great things. Anyhow, the question is that Sam mentioned some better non-union ways that worker interests should be represented. I'm curious to hear more about these.
shawn (00:43.195)
Thank you.
Sam (00:43.938)
Ha ha!
Uhhh
Matt (00:59.807)
What are some good non-union options? Like right now, I'm serious. The world to me looks like a favorable place for unions. You got the Screen Actors Guild, you've got the Actors on Strike, UPS is gonna go on Strike soon. Like unions are representing workers well. So what are these other options for unions?
shawn (01:09.647)
Yeah.
Sam (01:17.906)
The unions have destroyed good industries. Basketball is a great example, and baseball is a great example. As the world watches super rich people go on strike and gets ticked off that uber wealthy people are complaining about their inability to make an income. Matt, the Screen Actors Guild, Sean, is the best example of them all. I heard a politician yesterday on Meet the Press say, look, I'll tell you what we do. You take the richest actor,
Matt (01:20.116)
Ha ha
Sam (01:46.25)
which makes a lot more than the richest studio executive. You cut their pay by 20% each, and then you just allow that to trickle down into the coffers of the union. They can go buy whatever they want. The free.
Matt (01:58.183)
But okay, so you're comparing an actor to a studio executive, but what about the people who own the motion picture studio? It's the owners that are the ones that are raking in all the money. Like when you say the billionaire owners.
Sam (02:01.954)
Right?
Sam (02:10.21)
The executives do too. The, the, the executives make a lot of money as do the actors. It's a free market system.
Matt (02:16.847)
Yeah. I think that people make a lot of money because they're unionized and they can force the owners to give up some more of their profits to the employees. Right.
Sam (02:28.054)
Yeah. So, when you talk about alternatives to the unions, I think we live in a digital age where transparency is increasing, where employees have more leverage in this marketplace, where there's frankly not enough employees to go around. And, you know, employees, you know, good employers will do things to attract great employees, and they'll do things to retain those great employees.
over a long period of time. And I think given technology, there's less of a need to become union. I mean, look, I'm familiar and I hesitate to bring too much in because they are powerful entities and I don't want to get myself into trouble. But I've heard it said that there are certain areas where maybe a construction job isn't gotten by the unions and then the unions will actually go and picket a business.
Matt (03:09.283)
Right, right, right. Yes.
Matt (03:14.811)
Ha!
Sam (03:27.83)
with those alleged wronged employees, you actually find out that they're not the employees that are picketing. They're paid people that are paid to be there to picket a business. In its worst form, unions can just turn into blackmail and sabotage and not benefit the individual worker. I mean, for heaven's sakes, look at Utah's biggest union, which is the Teacher Association.
shawn (03:28.033)
Uh oh.
Sam (03:54.338)
They've been talking and we've talked a lot about it for years about better pay, better benefits. And have they, have they solved the problem of underpay in the state of Utah? Absolutely not. Has the UEA has w wait, what does that matter?
Matt (03:54.62)
Yeah.
Matt (04:06.468)
Well, they're a public union.
It means that they have to persuade legislators, right? So legislators are not just interested in profits and things like that. So, yeah, so it makes it harder. It makes, like the NBA just has to persuade the owners that it's in their best interest to change the contract so that they can put a product out there and make money. Whereas a public employee union has to persuade the whole public that they deserve more money. So it's a little bit different kind of a situation.
Sam (04:14.26)
Okay.
Sam (04:18.01)
legislators who are representatives of the people. So by virtue of
Sam (04:27.479)
Yeah.
Sam (04:39.123)
So, you're saying public unions are a bad idea.
Matt (04:41.88)
No, I'm just saying that it's harder for them to get what they want. Without the public union, things would be worse off for teachers in Utah. I think. I don't know.
Sam (04:48.108)
Yeah.
shawn (04:49.883)
Well, Matt, last week we started this whole discussion off. Your question was there's a wage gap, huge wage gap, and your solution was unions. So my example, so the same listener, Matt, the same listener called me out for saying, I don't think that the salary of the American Federation of Teachers is a good argument against unions because Randi Weingartner, yes, makes $500,000, but she's an attorney in New York and represents 2 million teachers.
Matt (04:58.678)
Yes, unions, yes.
Sam (05:01.742)
No, that's a bad idea.
shawn (05:18.971)
But here, I was simply bringing her up as an example of the argument, Matt, I was trying to debunk your argument that unions are good for the wage gap because clearly, I mean, that's such a funny, like Sam said, teachers don't make any money. They still don't make any money. If Sam or if Randy Weingart, who makes a half a million dollars, if, and the average teacher makes $40,000 to $60,000, what's the point? What's the point? It's just, it's just not succeeding. It's, and it's corrupt.
Matt (05:35.027)
but there aren't racials.
Sam (05:47.152)
You unions, unions are a crutch in 2023. And Matt, I will take your words of public unions being less effective as an admission of that. And we'll just move to the next topic.
Matt (05:58.706)
Let's go to the... Okay, so this was...
shawn (05:59.987)
But Matt, I would say Sam started off the last one with actually unions are good. It's just that they have become such a tarnished and poor example of an ineffective.
Sam (06:10.442)
I know, but the reader took that away. The reader took that away by saying that's a bad explanation.
Matt (06:16.537)
He's saying that you two, the reader, the listener is very kind and saying that you two are uninformed, that you're tools for corporate America.
shawn (06:16.779)
Oh, OK. I.
shawn (06:21.947)
I know I Sam you don't agree Sam you don't agree that unions are good in color good in concept and if we could get corruption out just like we get we get corruption out of government sometimes in business they're not bad they're a good thing it's individuals having it's capitalism Sam isn't it it's individuals coming together
Sam (06:22.83)
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Sam (06:35.262)
Oh, oh, oh.
Matt (06:35.573)
Sam is not.
Sam (06:39.934)
A lot of liberal, a lot of liberal ideas seem awesome. It's like a good show of the West wing. It's like, it makes my heart feel good. Tell you realize you just can't pay for it all. Unions are the exact same thing. It feels really good until you see how corrupt many of them are. And then you have to change your, change your stance. But anyway.
Matt (06:59.315)
Well, speaking of liberal ideas that sound so good on paper, let's get back to the universal basic income. So this listener writes that right now, 58% of Americans are living paycheck to paycheck. And so that makes it hard for the average American to take risks. Sam was saying that the ability to take risk is kind of what drives innovation and makes the capitalistic engine thrive.
Sam (07:05.047)
Oh no, not again.
Matt (07:25.171)
but people don't have money, extra money to take risks. So the universal basic income, let's just say that it was gonna give everybody a thousand dollars a month for a married couple, that would be $2,000 a month. Now you've just given them some extra money with which they can take some risk. And wouldn't that be good for the capitalist dream if everybody had just a little bit more money each month.
Sam (07:47.066)
It reminds me in Russia when my former companion used to say in communism, everybody's equal. There's just some who are a little bit more equal than everybody else. And handing out to everybody just a little bit of money so that everybody's just okay. The problem with that is in our market, in our free market, that'll work for a certain period of time. But like we saw in COVID, you start handing out just a little bit of money, inflation.
shawn (07:56.827)
Hahaha!
Matt (07:57.708)
This isn't communism. This is giving everybody a little bit of money
Sam (08:16.63)
buying power, wage power. You know, some of the Democrats thought that they solved some of the income problems as they saw wages escalating. What they didn't realize is on the tail of that, inflation shot through the roof, right? And so now they're trying to take measures to calm inflation. That's going to suppress wages back down. It's tough in reality, in a business world, void of really good, warm ideas that
Matt (08:24.483)
Yes. Yeah.
Sam (08:45.07)
or some of the liberal ideas you hear, it's tough to actually execute on that without causing a problem in the marketplace. I don't know how you hand everybody a little bit of money and still have the free market that we enjoy today.
Matt (08:58.747)
So your fear, Sam, is that giving people money causes inflation. But it could also be that the war in Ukraine and the supply chain disruptions from COVID, that those are the cause of inflation. And if we hadn't had all of these policies that were giving money to people, our economy would have tanked because the prices, the inflation still would have happened. People just wouldn't have had the money, people wouldn't have had the money to purchase things, right? So then you could give people now just a little bit more money and they could invest that money.
Sam (09:04.057)
In.
Sam (09:19.542)
No, I agree with that. I agree with that. Yeah.
Sam (09:28.162)
we're going to have just a little bit more inflation.
Matt (09:28.411)
and they could start a... But seriously, with $1,000 a month or $2,000 a month for a couple, you could start a food truck, you could start a side business, you could start some kind of side hustle, you could put that money into Bitcoin, you could put that money, you could invest that money if you...
Sam (09:43.306)
Yeah, but Matt, what happens when that one to $2,000, the buying power of that goes down to $100. And then you've got to give four to $5,000 and that goes to $200. And then you got to give five to $6,000. That's inflation over time.
shawn (09:43.595)
Hey Matt.
Matt (09:50.579)
But that's...
shawn (09:54.159)
Yeah.
That's a good point, Matt.
Matt (09:58.151)
but it drives innovation in the economy because there are more people with capital.
shawn (10:00.407)
Matt, would you, Matt, would you still, Matt, let's say we try this experiment and let's say 90% plus of the people do what a lot of people I know here, my actually good friends have done, which is when they were given money in COVID and they learned that the government will provide assistance, they will provide assistance for their home, assistance for their, and they decided to quit. And I know these people, I could, I could, oh, really, Matt? Matt.
Sam (10:00.82)
It doesn't though.
doesn't drive innovation.
Matt (10:22.483)
What? Why would they quit working?
Sam (10:26.458)
was the great resignation that was the great resignation it's a fact it was proved people walked away from the economy
Matt (10:30.907)
Wait, wait, wait. Was the government giving away more money than I was aware of? Because I was not getting enough money that I could quit my job.
shawn (10:32.207)
Hang on. Hang on.
Sam (10:37.076)
Yes.
shawn (10:37.943)
No, but Matt, let me explain. When they learned, what the heck, I'm getting paychecks from the government, they went in deeper and realized, oh, unemployment? Oh, government assistant housing? Holy cow. And I know I could tell you very specific stories about people who decided, oh, wait a minute. I don't have to work. I don't even have to try. And they literally, the great resignation, and they literally, Matt, for years and years and years now.
Matt (10:48.397)
Oh... Hahaha
Sam (10:59.609)
The great resignation. Yeah.
shawn (11:04.963)
They sit at home and they do nothing. Now, Matt, if we tried my.
Matt (11:07.875)
Wait a minute. Wait a minute.
Sam (11:10.134)
Well, they're starting to come back because that money that drove the inflation kind of has left the economy and people are like, there's no universal income. I got to actually contribute back to the economy again. Right, Sean?
Matt (11:16.605)
is
shawn (11:22.432)
Yeah, that's right.
Matt (11:23.375)
Wait, I thought you were going to tell me that we suddenly had a whole bunch of new startups that happened during the COVID. That's-
Sam (11:24.514)
I'm sorry.
Sam (11:29.984)
Oh no.
shawn (11:30.831)
That's one side of the story that you were able to find some stats on that, Matt. But in general, in reality, being in business and having the feet on the ground, man, there was a year and a half where I literally would have clients. And I don't do this in my business. They would call me and say, Sean, I'm so desperate to get someone to hire someone. No one will come to work for me. Can I pay you to go find someone to work for me? I'm like, yeah, literally they were offering me to go find workers for them. And I couldn't do it.
Matt (11:53.307)
Whoa!
shawn (11:59.587)
People weren't willing to work. You're in the same bucket, right Sam? Matt, that's how reality.
Sam (11:59.795)
We were in the same bucket. Yeah, we were in the same bucket. You would walk into a Starbucks, Sean, you'd walk into a McDonald's, you'd walk into Best Buy. It's like, hey, where's somebody to help me? There were not enough people around to help.
Matt (12:13.715)
So I just found this story on Bloomberg. Over 5 million new US startups show COVID era boom has legs. New business applications in 2022 were up 44% from 2019. Largest increases are in the South where many migrated recently. So.
shawn (12:31.523)
Well, but there's value, Matt, though, in real boots on the ground experiences, for example, that Sam and I have. I mean, we lived through it for two years dealing with lots and lots of clients, customers, businesses, companies. That was an extreme example. It was true. It's really shocking. There was not only so many people not willing to work.
Matt (12:39.059)
Yeah.
Matt (12:50.303)
Maybe you guys just have lazy friends. Do you have lazy friends? Is that what it is?
shawn (12:56.047)
Maybe.
Matt (12:58.412)
Sean doesn't know if he should.
Sam (12:58.659)
I just worked, I just worked a 14 hour day around people that worked a similar day. How do you ins... Did you really? That's exciting. Actually it's a Monday.
shawn (13:03.483)
Ahaha
Matt (13:05.607)
Let's see, I'm your friend. I'm your friend, Sam. I mostly slept today. I had a really nice... Well, I got home from a drive early this morning and I do sleep sometimes. I'm not like Sam.
shawn (13:14.219)
Good for you.
Sam (13:18.006)
Yeah.
shawn (13:18.863)
You're not lazy, Matt. You work hard. You work very hard. That's-
Sam (13:21.066)
Yeah, you're not lazy. Matt, Sean, can I ask Matt a question though? Don't you truly think Matt, that if your needs were taken care of, and you didn't feel tomorrow like you had to go out and ensure your food, health, education, prosperity, wouldn't you make different life choices with the time you have left in your life, wouldn't you go out and pursue other interests than trying to return a benefit in the economy that would help?
Matt (13:22.539)
Okay, thank you. I feel much better.
Sam (13:50.658)
pay for all those things?
Matt (13:52.303)
Yeah, but I, but that's what I'm trying to say. That's the American dream, Sam. What you just described is the American dream. Right? Because you're still contributing. You're still contributing to the economy.
Sam (13:56.542)
It's not the American dream. Oh my goodness. The, the American dream, the American, the American dream is as an immigrant coming to this country with whatever language you have struggling as a parent and as a provider and allowing your kids to assimilate into, into this land and become free, uh, you know, citizens of this country and then to give back.
in meaningful ways, becoming doctors and lawyers and real estate agents and car salesmen and whatever else. That's the American dream is that you can become better than your parents were because the opportunity is here to better yourself through hard work. There's no part of that is, hey, I'm going to come over here. I'm going to get a subsistence income. I don't have to fight. I can just exist. That's crazy.
Matt (14:31.132)
Hahaha
shawn (14:50.575)
Sam, I think the real argument, I mean, this is a funny argument, but what you guys are saying, but I think there isn't there. But Matt, isn't the real, isn't the real argument based in this, Matt? There are the scriptures talk about there will always be poured among us. And the idea is this. Well, no, hang on though. I'm not saying we should shoot for it. I'm not saying that. No, no, what I'm saying is this, Matt, that suggests that some people are more capable than other people, maybe.
Sam (14:57.134)
That's not funny, it's true. I'm gonna go back to my.
Matt (15:06.779)
Yep, but there's not supposed to be!
Sam (15:10.11)
Yeah, that's not the right argument. You must be poor.
shawn (15:19.839)
Or some people are placed in situations that are giving them more opportunity than others, I guess.
Matt (15:26.947)
In heaven. In heaven, Sean. Or is there gonna be a hierarchy, like a social class hierarchy? Oh, okay. Ahem.
shawn (15:31.267)
No, that's not what I'm saying. That's not what I'm saying. Not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is this, if it is true, and I know many people, you guys know many people, who just aren't as capable, they're just not as capable to produce. Whether I give them a thousand bucks a month or not, I don't know that they have the ability to produce. And isn't the real argument, the discussion is, they will always be paycheck to paycheck whether they have a thousand dollars extra or not.
Matt (15:49.074)
Right.
Sam (15:49.186)
so.
Matt (15:55.423)
But that's the American Dream.
Sam (15:56.974)
So that argument is where you lose me, Sean. It's those people that society should probably help that don't have the capacity. The people I worry about are the people who have the capacity and who, because the system isn't set up for them to risk and work hard, be creative. I have seen on the crucible of stress and pressure and challenge, people take risks and make massive gains.
shawn (15:59.823)
Why?
shawn (16:03.375)
That's what I'm saying.
Matt (16:03.856)
Yeah.
shawn (16:19.735)
Yeah, productivity.
Yeah. That's Sam. Sam, you're.
Sam (16:24.354)
contribute in incredibly meaningful ways that had they not taken that risk, they never would have done it. What you're describing are people who are challenged, who can't, who don't have that capacity.
shawn (16:32.203)
You're receiving, yeah, you're receiving my point, right? My point is this. There are some, the discussion should be built around those who have ability and those who don't. How do we as society take care of the poor or those who don't have the ability? Matt's proposal is $1,000 a month. My response to that, Matt, seems like, I don't think that's right because my experience with close friends or family members who don't, I just aren't as capable.
They're not as capable to finance that money or use that money in wise ways either, perhaps sometimes. So why just give them money?
Matt (17:02.815)
Well, in fairness, a thousand dollars a month is a baby step towards what I think is a better society which would be from each according to his ability to each according to his wants. Well, the law of consecration sort of sounds like that. And then, well, that one would be more specifically Karl Marx. And I don't, there's some real value in this idea of
shawn (17:09.359)
There, now we're good.
shawn (17:15.439)
Where'd you get that from, Matt? Where'd you get that quote from?
No, that's not where that quote comes from.
Aha, exactly!
Matt (17:30.883)
Everybody contribute according to your ability and everybody get back from society according to your wants and we don't need other people Like having billions of dollars and some people millions of dollars and some people hundreds of dollars Everybody should just have everything that they want Because they're giving what they can and then okay, let's move on Hey, I read about it in the Doctrine and Covenants, okay
Sam (17:51.074)
That will never work.
shawn (17:51.205)
Okay.
shawn (17:56.867)
You interpreted it that way.
Matt (17:59.787)
Okay, so this question, because we had a discussion about partisanship and people changing parties, and I said something to the effect that changing a party is a lot like changing a religion. And this listener writes in and they say, you know, on my mission, I taught people and I saw them change their religion. And, and he says, I grew up in an area where I didn't really know that like, Republicans and Mormons fit together. I just as I grew up, I sort of said, okay.
right now being a Republican makes sense and this situation being a Democrat makes sense. And so their question is, is it really like people don't change that much and they just over time kind of find a religion or a party or whatever that fits their values and beliefs? Or is it the people as they get older they're actually changing these things? Like I think the question is a lot about like uh
Do people really have these core beliefs that don't change and they just find the groups in society that match those? Or are people actually changing as they, like do we know anyone who's actually changed political or religious beliefs in a meaningful way?
shawn (19:05.739)
Yeah, Matt, can I take it first then Sam, you jump in? So I have kind of a dogmatic religious view on this a little bit. I'll go back to James 1.5, right? So it starts with that common scripture we all know in our church, if any of you lack wisdom, let him ask of God to give it to all men liberally, upbraideth not, shall be given unto him. But then six, which we don't really focus on very much is this, but let him ask in faith, nothing wavering, for he that wavereth is like a wave of the sea driven with the wind and tossed. And there's lots of references in scriptures about how the doctrines and philosophies of men
when you're not built on the foundation of Christ, these philosophies and doctors blow and people will just go whatever way the doctrine shows. So I like this question because it is about, to me, about epistemology, about how do we discover and know, how we understand what is true, what is right, what is wrong. So to me, I know this is a little bit of a dogmatic religious response, but if we learn, if we as people learn about truths, religious truths, economic truths, any truths by the power of the Holy Ghost.
Matt (19:53.939)
That's okay.
shawn (20:02.927)
then we are built on a foundation and will not waver. If we use any other mortal means to discover these truths, I think we will waver. We will go back and forth. And I know that's a little dogmatic.
Matt (20:14.516)
So you say that if your beliefs and things are built on true doctrine, then they don't change with time.
shawn (20:20.683)
And true doctrine can only be received by the Holy Ghost, right? Because they're delivered from God to earth through people via the Holy Ghost. That's the revelation process. And we can only receive that doctrine truly in our hearts by the Holy Ghost. So if I'm learning things by the Holy Ghost, which is God's method of communication to us, then I'm going to have truth on a foundation. Now, if it's a political truth, if it's an economic truth, if it's a religious truth, it doesn't matter, I think. I think it all applies.
Matt (20:50.215)
So here's my take on it. There's a lot of studies about the genetic heritability of different things, like what we're genetically predisposed to. So there was a time when I got involved in behavioral genetics and I wrote a paper, it's called the genetic heritability of presidential approval. And I show in this paper that what you think about the president of the United States, 63% of that is determined by your genetic makeup.
shawn (21:10.203)
Wow.
shawn (21:20.237)
Gosh.
Matt (21:20.395)
And then like 40% of that is your environment. And like none of it is family socialization. And one of the reasons I wrote that paper and got involved in that is because people, I think, look at biology and genetic stuff as deterministic kinds of things. And I think that in life, we have this sort of this constant fight between who we are and who our biology sort of like predisposes us to be. And I think that
shawn (21:26.852)
Wow.
Matt (21:48.723)
there's a scriptures, right? The natural man is an enemy to God and has been from the fall of Adam. We're all born with these natural tendencies that come with the bodies that we inherit at birth. And I think that a lot of people just sort of go along in life with their genetic predispositions and don't put a lot of effort into overcoming the natural man. And so I think that one of the reasons why you find strong heritability for things like presidential approval is because it's like,
It's a reflection of these other sorts of things in life that you just sort of are born a certain way and you have these natural predispositions, then you add to that the culture and the community that you're raised in and all of those influences, and people don't push back against that very much. And unless you push back, then you have no reason to change from how you just naturally become.
shawn (22:32.955)
Wow, because do you...
shawn (22:37.787)
Because if you're applying that to the religious doctrines we believe in, the only way to change the natural man is to come to Christ with humility and brokenheartedness and have a changed heart. And you're saying people don't do that, therefore their natural mortal fallen genetics determine what they think and believe? Wow, interesting.
Matt (22:53.875)
For the most part, yeah, because unless you become born again, or unless you, and says, and that we'll be an enemy to God forever and ever, unless we put off the natural man and become a saint through the atonement of Christ and become humble, submissive, meek, patient, full of love. So yeah, I think the gospel of Jesus Christ gives us a path to overcome our natural tendencies, but most people don't do that.
shawn (23:17.379)
Wow. Way to bring in the religion, Matt. You're not just a political scientist.
Matt (23:21.917)
What do you think, Sam?
Sam (23:24.082)
I think it's fascinating trying to compare a religious group or belief with a political group or belief. The religious belief is how we relate to God. The political belief is how we relate to other people. I get that we socialize into a political belief as part of a community and a set of beliefs and they intersect a little bit. But it's fascinating as you describe that.
It's fascinating how you describe that. And it kind of makes sense that it would be tough to leave a political belief and transition into a different one because you're leaving behind that community or those people that you know. And you think about born again Christians. You think about members of our church that historically have been very conservative Republican in the past. That's a challenge to kind of go over that dividing line, but that's fascinating that there's actually a, there's science that backs that up.
Matt (24:03.72)
Right.
Matt (24:19.895)
And if you think about members of the church from the Utah area, when they leave the church, they talk about like how hard that is for them to leave the church because there's so much like tied into that. And we have a good friend, uh, from our mission. I was talking to him. He left the church and, uh, he also registered as a Democrat. And he said that when he moved to Washington DC, he's like, it only made sense to be a Democrat because all of the primary elections, it's only Democrats. He's like,
Sam (24:28.086)
Yeah.
Matt (24:47.807)
but registering to be a Democrat was as hard for me as leaving the LDS church. Because it's all tied up in who you are. Sean, you come from a, but that's how it is. It's so much a part of who you are.
Sam (24:53.771)
Isn't that interesting?
shawn (24:55.06)
What? I hate that.
I hate that. It shouldn't be that! That's ridiculous! Ugh.
Sam (25:03.074)
But so it's part of who you are for people who value their political affiliation, but I can tell you there's a lot of people that don't care. And actually ambivalence about that or indifference towards political affiliation is a growing trend, as is, I guess, religious affiliation in the United States, particularly with younger people. And that's a problem, right?
Matt (25:20.912)
Right, right.
Yeah, younger people are just opting out of both of them. But Sean, if you're raised in a family that you're talking politics at dinnertime and you're talking religion at dinnertime and it's a part of who you are, then leaving that is a really difficult thing. But there's plenty of people that are not that political, but for the people who are socialized into this sort of world, that's what's determining their political views. It's not like they say, oh, I have this really conservative idea, which party will best represent me.
Sam (25:28.236)
Yeah.
Matt (25:55.445)
They're Republicans by birth, they're Democrats by birth.
shawn (25:58.117)
Okay, but I talked to a friend this weekend and we were doing Marco Polo back and forth, the app where you just make videos to each other, right? And he was talking... No, that would be more fun. That would be more fun. So I opened a Marco Polo because he has a video and he has this sunken face. You could tell he's feeling guilty and he's unhappy. He's like, dude, it's...
Sam (25:58.43)
Isn't that interesting? Huh.
Matt (26:09.387)
Oh, I thought you were like in the swimming pool like Marco.
shawn (26:22.471)
Sunday and I decided instead of going to church today, I did this and I did this instead. And he's like, I just feel so guilty. And I went to the store and got my drink and explained to me later on that he's like, you know, he's like, Sean, you probably know this too, right? When we grow up in the church, your parents go to dinner on Sunday nights and all of your friends go to dinner on Sunday nights. I'm like, dude, what are you talking about? I never knew any LDS people who went to dinner on Sunday night. That was against the Sabbath.
Matt (26:52.018)
Yeah.
shawn (26:52.647)
And I'm like, and he's like, what? Right? So we're both talking as if these cultural things are our religion, and that has determined who we are. And we got into this deep discussion about that is not the way God intends us to decide that we're who what our identity is, what political party to be associated with and so on. It has to be, I like the idea of rejecting what my parents teach me a little bit so that I can for here's what
Matt (27:11.976)
Right.
Matt (27:17.808)
I'm lying, because you're a punk.
shawn (27:20.055)
Well, but also, then Nephi was a punk, right? Nephi got preached to by Lehi and said, you know what, I'm not gonna take his word for it. I believe him, but I'm gonna go find out for myself through the Holy Ghost. Punks, punks.
Matt (27:29.087)
Okay, all right, you're a Nephi punk. Well, so actually though, that does remind me that in general conference recently, they've started saying the most important identity we should embrace is child of God, disciple of Jesus Christ. They're encouraging us to adopt different identities because there are some challenges that come with these identities we sort of inherit culturally. But Sean, this question is all about
shawn (27:33.635)
Yeah
shawn (27:44.624)
BAM!
Matt (27:55.523)
And I have no idea where to even go with this. I think this is just a you question. I love how much emphasis you place on the revealed doctrine. You say that doctrine is canonized scripture, but many people say doctrine is anything in the ensign, anything the prophets say in general conference. So where do you get this idea that doctrine is canonized scripture?
shawn (28:14.767)
from scripture.
Matt (28:16.591)
Well, what scripture, Sean? What scripture? Because DNC 68, what is it? Three says, anything you say when moved upon by the Holy Spirit shall be scripture. The mind of the Lord, the will of the Lord, the power of God unto salvation. So where is it that says only canonized scripture is doctrine?
shawn (28:35.451)
But if you, I mean if we try and decipher that verse, then what we would suggest is that then the prophets and apostles have only felt the Holy Ghost, were moved upon by the Holy Ghost four times in the last 140 years? Because only four times has something become scripture. Right?
Matt (28:53.806)
No, no, that's if you define scripture as canonized scripture. But Doctrine and Covenants 68 says, anything that you say is scripture, it doesn't have to be in the scriptures to be scripture.
shawn (28:57.528)
as scripture.
shawn (29:04.603)
But isn't this how we have plenty of evidence that this is how it works? When a prophet during any age gets up on a podium and preaches the truth and is moved upon by the Holy Ghost, one of two things is reality. One, they're either teaching existing revealed doctrine that can be found in existing revealed scripture or canon, or they're going to reveal something new.
Show me in the last 140 years where some new doctrine has been revealed and didn't find its way into the Canaanite scripture. That's just the evidence. There's nothing new that's been preached that hasn't become current. Who preaches that?
Matt (29:46.366)
Um... Heavenly Mother. That's in the proclamation to the world on the family that we are the children of heavenly parents. And that's nowhere in scripture.
Sam (29:51.886)
true.
shawn (29:55.171)
But there's reference, that is as vague as some of the scriptures I can preach to you or show you right now. Okay, I'll give it to you then. There's three references when we are taught three different places in scripture about the creation of Adam and Eve. And in one of those, in the book of, in the Pearl of Great Price, it says, we created
Sam (30:02.242)
pretty good, Matt. That's pretty good.
Matt (30:07.162)
I don't know.
shawn (30:21.839)
Adam and Eve, we created men and women in our image and in our likeness. In our likeness did we create them.
Matt (30:25.651)
Does it say parents? Parents? Does it say parents? Does there any inclination, indication that there's a woman involved in that? Cause that could be.
shawn (30:34.891)
Yeah, Adam and Eve created we them in our likeness. Adam and Eve, man and woman, created we them in our likeness.
Matt (30:41.032)
CLEARS THROAT
Sam (30:43.714)
Good points for Sean. Listen, nice job, Sean. That is quick thinking. Hey, to my kids who are listening, Sean got points on this one. So yes. Score one for the conservative Republican. Go ahead, Matt. Next question. No, you're not. You're the crazy liberal.
Matt (30:44.255)
Alright.
shawn (30:51.451)
Ha ha!
Matt (30:55.359)
Ha ha!
Alright, let's move on to this next... Wait a minute, I'm the conservative Republican!
Matt (31:11.183)
I've never voted for a libertarian in my life. It says, this question is, you guys glossed over porn and sounded a bit naive and ignorant about the real struggle that so many faithful, humble, good people experience. Why? Well, can I tell you why I glossed over it? Because every single commandment, there are people that really struggle with it. There are faithful, good, humble people that struggle with it.
Sam (31:13.102)
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
shawn (31:30.425)
Yeah.
Matt (31:40.127)
And so I don't know how to talk about like Paul talks in the scriptures about the thorn in the flesh, about some weakness that he had that he struggled with every day for his entire life. And it was never taken away from him. And so I don't know how to talk about like, how do you handle these struggles? Uh, because everybody has their own and they're all so unique. And so pornography to me didn't seem like I'd like a struggle that we should spend a lot of time discussing.
any more than like maybe the Sabbath day is something we should spend a lot of time discussing.
shawn (32:11.439)
points back to math.
Matt (32:13.58)
Oh, okay.
shawn (32:15.165)
That was wonderful.
Sam (32:15.878)
Well, so as part of that, that you're not proposing or teaching or advocating any solution that's particularly unique or helpful to anybody. I think the challenge, when we were talking about the issue, is pornography is against the commandments. And in a state like Utah, where most of…
the residents in Utah are members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. It's ironic that it appears to be such a large problem in Utah, right? And so, I think part of our question was, why is that? And maybe one of the answers is everyone struggles with something in a place where, you know, in a world where it's not looked at as sin, but in Utah where it is, that's just something people struggle with. Is that part of it?
Matt (33:06.307)
Yeah, and I think if there was an answer, I would like happily share that answer. But I've, I know enough people that struggle with pornography. I've been to enough things. So I've been to the church's, uh, 12 step program that helps some people with pornography. There's people that doesn't help. I've been to counseling with professional counselors who have programs that they go through that help some people that doesn't help some people.
Sam (33:11.158)
Yeah.
Matt (33:30.707)
The church has this video out that says that there was this guy that struggled with pornography addiction for 30 years. And then he started doing indexing and within one week of doing indexing, every time he wanted to look at porn, he started doing indexing instead. Within one week, his pornography addiction was gone. It's like, yeah. So it's like, well, right. I know when you watch the video, right. So I've, right. So I.
shawn (33:49.292)
What? Wow.
Sam (33:50.058)
I shouldn't laugh at that, but I've, I've never done. Yeah. Sorry. I'm not laughing at that. That's serious. Yeah.
Matt (33:58.843)
So that's what I'm saying, like there's not a solution to that problem. The solution to any struggle with sin is you turn to the Lord and he will guide you to the solution to your problem. Now, sometimes it's, sometimes it'll make it so you never struggle with it again. Sometimes it'll make it so you still struggle with it and you never get to be rid of it. So I just don't have an answer to that question.
Sam (34:02.732)
Yeah.
shawn (34:19.979)
See, that's a fascinating point you make there, Matt, because the purpose of this world isn't to become perfect and overcome every temptation and sin that we have. That is impossible. But the point of this world is to come to Christ with a broken heart and a contrite spirit and learn how to repent. And sometimes you're right, Matt, sometimes repentance will give us access to the atonement.
and Christ will sweep away that temptation and we will overcome it. And sometimes he won't, yet both of those individuals are saved because of Jesus Christ, because of that covenant. So it's possible for someone who struggles with pornography to be saved in the celestial kingdom, not on their merits, but on the merits of Jesus Christ. Isn't that the doctrine?
Matt (35:05.539)
Yeah, well, and so there's that man that struggled for 30 years, and indexing was the solution to his problem, but he didn't find it for 30 years. And then there's people I know that indexing didn't help them, right?
shawn (35:14.031)
But indexing...
But to your point, indexing wasn't the solution, right? Indexing was some blessing perhaps that God led them to, but it was the atonement of Christ that forgave them of the 30 years and also helped heal them of the 30 years. But I loved your other point. Some people will find indexing and will find Christ and maybe not overcome that weakness or sin, yet still can be saved through the atonement of Jesus Christ because he suffered for those sins. And it doesn't say, my requirement for forgiveness is…
Matt (35:25.748)
For sure.
shawn (35:46.275)
perfection, my requirement for forgiveness is broken heart, contrite spirit, repentance.
Sam (35:52.598)
So as a segue, as a segue, I haven't seen the video, but indexing, try it, I guess, right?
Matt (35:52.895)
And yeah.
Matt (35:57.503)
There you go. So there's two questions along the lines of the LGBTQ community and how we should relate to them in the church. So one of them is like, is there a place for these people in the church? And what do you do when you talk to somebody? So it seems like from the listeners, it seems like people are having a challenge of saying, how do I talk to my gay friends or my transgender friends and be true to who I am?
shawn (35:58.007)
Yeah, right, right.
Sam (36:11.256)
Yes.
Matt (36:27.079)
without like offending them or something like that or how do they fit in the church?
shawn (36:31.712)
Go ahead Sam.
Sam (36:32.806)
Why does having a conversation with somebody with that belief set challenge your own belief set? I don't understand that. I talk to people that have different belief sets all the time, and it's not an infection. Why is there this implication somehow? Where did it come from, this idea that just because we believe one way, someone else believes another way, that we're going to change them or they're going to change us? I don't think that's backed by science, is it?
shawn (36:59.311)
Sam, here's maybe an answer to that. You tell me what you think of this. There is a dissonant, there's some dissonant scriptural commandments. For example, one says, the most important thing you can do on this earth is to declare repentance unto the people and bring one soul to Christ. Then there's another commandment that says, do not judge people, love them. So isn't maybe part of the dilemma is if I, that paradox, isn't that why maybe it's so hard?
Sam (37:25.486)
paradox.
shawn (37:29.231)
What do you think of that?
Matt (37:29.715)
Well, every single person on this earth is doing something that's causing spiritual death. Every single person you ever meet. So the question is, how do I best help somebody repent? Is it by trying to identify their weaknesses and pointing it out and letting them know that, hey, I noticed this weakness you have, by the way, that's a sin, or is it by trying to bring them closer to Christ? So the best way to preach the gospel of Jesus Christ is to love as Christ would love. So that's why I don't see the
shawn (37:54.959)
Bingo.
That's how you call to repentance. I love it.
Sam (38:00.322)
Wait, wait, do you believe that your job with your LGBTQ friends is to call them to repentance as a member of the church, Sean?
shawn (38:09.679)
Good question, Sam.
Sam (38:13.28)
Let's just throw that out there. No, wait, Matt, make him answer the question. Come on.
Matt (38:13.38)
Okay, so let's say that I had a friend that was going to transition. Oh yeah, go ahead.
shawn (38:18.155)
Now take them, oh Matt, gladly, take it Matt.
Matt (38:20.763)
No, no, I like this, son. No, no, I don't want to get son in trouble.
shawn (38:23.263)
I want, I can answer it, answer by saying, I read abundantly in scriptures that it says that I'm supposed to call, I'm supposed to go out and cry repentance. I also read even equally as abundantly, like Matt said, that I'm not to judge and that I am to love. I think what we learned in Ukraine on our missions is this, declaring repentance to people is of no value without a foundation of love. Trust and an absence of judgment,
Sam (38:25.538)
Ha ha ha.
Sam (38:41.879)
Yes.
shawn (38:50.743)
Like without, so a default to judge not first, then cry repentance. Build that relationship of trust. I think that's the only way.
Sam (38:55.411)
Amen.
Yes.
Matt (38:58.927)
Yeah, but I will say that it's very deeply offensive to my gay friends. If I say to them, you're struggling with same sex attraction. And it is deeply offensive to them that members of the church won't call them gay. Uh, when elder Bednar said things like there are no gay members of the church, that, uh, it's just an affliction people deal with. And our doctrine on that is, is deeply offensive. So I don't know. I think that it's okay to see people as they are and treat them as they see themselves and not.
shawn (39:27.335)
That's a fantastic point, right? Because again, if I go, look, I have evangelical friends, they cry repentance to me all day long, uninvited, it's fine, it's fine, but it's of zero effect. It's of zero effect because they haven't built on this foundation of trust and love. And so I like that point, Matt, because if my friend isn't looking to repent or doesn't, you know, they wanna just be happy within their lifestyle.
Matt (39:35.521)
Hahaha
Sam (39:36.746)
Yeah, I do too. I do too. Yeah.
shawn (39:55.503)
then I don't have a foundation of trust or love to bring in repentance. So we default, I think, to the commandment of love them. Don't judge them, anyone. Love everyone. I think that's the only way to treat anyone who, like you said, who is struggling from spiritual death. That's all of us. We all have a sin. Our job is not to first identify which sin you have and then judge you on it and cry to repentance. It's to love them and not judge them.
Matt (40:13.031)
Yeah.
Sam (40:19.086)
By the way, we love Christ because he loved us first.
shawn (40:22.859)
Yeah. Nice Sam. Points to Sam.
Matt (40:24.187)
Oh, see, that's a good scripture. Okay, so this is with declining Christianity, what's the best way we can unite with people of different faiths? Not hypothetically, but practical things. So I'm gonna just start this. In my view, the challenge in American society is not the decline of Christianity. It's just the decline in, like, it's the decline in,
Sam (40:27.094)
Mic drop.
Matt (40:54.535)
I don't look at other Christians as like helping to build our faith. I look at them as competitors of our faith in the same way as like atheists or agnostics or Muslims or Buddhists. Like when I encounter other Christians, sometimes they're further away from Christ, the Christ that I know, than anybody else because they're so caught up in this dogma that they have. Right? And so...
shawn (41:19.264)
Interesting. Okay, keep going. This is interesting.
Matt (41:22.131)
Building faith in society is not just uniting with other Christians and trying to build Christianity in society, it's bridging out to everybody in society and trying to build greater faith in Christ. And I'm just saying that a lot of Christians don't have a lot of faith in Christ. And they're no different than the agnostics that I meet that don't have a lot of faith in Christ. In fact, some agnostics have more faith in Christ than a lot of these Christians out there. Don't you guys think that's, don't you think that's true?
Sam (41:44.133)
Wow.
Sam (41:47.758)
Mike dropped Matt. That's strong.
shawn (41:47.963)
Wow.
shawn (41:51.835)
That is fascinating. I mean, I guess you're right that the good relationships that I have with Orthodox Christians, Protestants, Catholics, there is, yeah, there's, I'm not gonna go as far as what you just said in telling them that they're unfaithful people, but I'm just kidding, I'm just kidding, I'm just kidding, I'm just kidding, I'm just kidding. No, I'm kidding, I'm kidding. But you're right, they do have, I have less hope that I'm going to get through to them than I do with my...
Matt (42:08.507)
No, I didn't say they're unfaithful people. No, I'm just saying like... Like, oh, but be a-
shawn (42:21.767)
non-Christian friends or my secular friends.
Matt (42:23.121)
If you pay, if you.
Sam (42:23.722)
Yeah, but why, why do you, why do we feel like we have to get through to anybody? Like.
Matt (42:28.391)
Wait, wait, I just want to say this and... I just want to clarify.
shawn (42:29.315)
What did you say? Go ahead, Matt.
Sam (42:32.407)
I guess as I get, I guess as I get, no, go ahead, Matt, clarify and then a point, I'll make a point, go ahead.
shawn (42:36.411)
Clarify.
Matt (42:36.963)
Yeah, what I'm saying is those evangelicals, when you get down to the core and I say, I believe in Jesus Christ, they're like, you don't believe in the right Jesus. You don't believe in my, so yeah. So I'm like, look, they're not a whole lot closer to my Jesus than anybody else is to my, that's what I'm trying to say. I'm not saying they don't have faith. I'm saying they reject my Jesus of the very core. Like they're always suspicious of everything I say about Christianity. They're like, yeah, but you're not a real Christian.
shawn (42:46.171)
Correct.
Sam (42:46.402)
Right? Revelations and last book and yeah.
shawn (42:48.964)
Yeah, correct.
shawn (42:54.115)
That's true. Very good point.
shawn (43:05.243)
Good point, that's true, that is true.
Matt (43:05.479)
So I'm just saying like there's easier to build faith with the non-Christians.
shawn (43:09.295)
Very good point. What do you want to say, Sam?
Sam (43:12.45)
I just, you know, I know we're commanded to go out and, and share the gospel message, but I feel less. And this is just in my heart as I meet people and I get to know people and I love people everywhere across the United States of America, there are incredible people everywhere of different religious backgrounds. Do you feel less of a need? I know you don't Sean, but Matt, do you feel less of a need to like convert everybody to our way or my way of thinking? Like.
I love the variety and I love the, uh, you know, maybe one of the things that we miss in the church and evangelicals, maybe they miss is just a diversity of opinion and thought and background that contribute to the whole. I love what president Hinckley used to say about, you know, he talked about, bring your background, bring, bring the strength and
and bring it into the gospel and into the church and use it to kind of broaden our approach. And sometimes I feel like we didn't really do that. We said that, but we didn't do that. And I found rather than meeting someone and saying, hey, I need to convince you of the way I see Christ and I see the gospel and I need to bring you into the church, I just enjoy getting to know people and how they believe and what they see.
at face for who they are and what they are, rather than trying to, I guess, convince them that I'm right or my way of thinking is right. And you know what? That's changed maybe even over the last five or 10 years. Is that wrong?
Matt (44:47.771)
Well, I think that we're a nation founded by God, and I think that we believe that as long as the nation is righteous, God will help preserve us. And I think that mistakenly, some people take that to mean we have to be a Christian nation and we have to worship the Christian God. But my belief is that Allah, that the Muslims worship, is the same God that I worship. And that the God, the Hindus have 330,000 gods, but that their worship of a higher being and the Taoists and the...
Sam (44:56.587)
Yes.
Sam (45:10.915)
Mmm.
Matt (45:17.307)
So there are different ways in which a person worships, but I think that religion in all its forms is good for our society and because it brings out the best in people. And I don't have to make this a Christian nation in order for this to be a nation of good people who are united with a belief in God, however they might call him.
shawn (45:37.743)
So maybe we'll use some maybe.
Sam (45:37.954)
So you can celebrate the different backgrounds that way. You don't feel a moral obligation to convince everybody that our brand of Christianity is... Sean, go ahead, cue Sean, cue Sean, go ahead, Sean. Ha ha ha.
shawn (45:48.099)
Well Sam, maybe what you're... I'm going to try and be peaceful here. Maybe what you're saying is good, better, best. The best would be if we could convert everyone to Jesus Christ and His true atonement and the true church. That would be best, right? A step under that and a step under that.
Matt (45:51.249)
hahahaha
Matt (46:08.041)
Sam wants there to be a little bit of a hierarchy in the next life. There's a terrestrial, a celestial. And.
Sam (46:13.938)
I'm telling you as a mature adult male, not a liberal who thinks he's better than everybody else, but just as a worker bee, I love the diversity. Like I'm in a town right now that was founded by Dutch. I left my business Wednesday night and I drove past six churches. And guess what?
In this Dutch area, every single church Wednesday at 7 p.m. was packed. And every person I talked to this week, they want to talk about their version of Christianity. And it's awesome!
Matt (46:43.635)
But you, you...
Matt (46:51.583)
But you are supportive of the mission to bring the world the gospel of Jesus. I think that's what Sean was getting at.
Sam (46:54.972)
I am I am I am I am I am I am but
shawn (46:58.787)
I was getting at Sam that it's good that you've got these amazing Dutch churches. I agree. That's a beautiful thing. And I do love the diversity too. It's probably better that they would be open and humble and it's best maybe to grow the church.
Sam (47:06.034)
I know. Yeah.
Matt (47:12.734)
If the...
Sam (47:14.446)
Oh, we're not, by the way, we're not going to have any listeners after that. People are going to go like, Hey, that's Sam guy. He's anti. He's my stake presence. Going to call me and listen, I'm not anti anything. I just love these Dutch people. Like there's wooden shoes and they hand out candy. And then if I go a little farther south from here, there's Amish and I do not want to become Amish, but I do love the pies and the ice cream. Yes, Sean.
shawn (47:21.474)
Hahaha
Matt (47:25.421)
I'm sorry.
shawn (47:27.927)
Yeah
Matt (47:31.295)
They had this.
shawn (47:34.095)
Sam, but if you change your views and you converted all those Dutch people, they would still give out candy and wear wooden shoes. There's your diversity. Yes, they would. They would.
Matt (47:43.603)
Sam's... Sam's life.
Sam (47:44.995)
No, they wouldn't. First Sunday they'd go without food and it would change their whole world, yep.
shawn (47:48.688)
Hahaha
Matt (47:49.383)
He's like, it was really weird. They were having this great ceremony, this big party, and then they invited me to the front and they sprinkled water on me and now I'm a part of their community. Ha ha ha.
Sam (47:56.911)
Oh wait, that actually happened in Russia and Ukraine. I remember that. Paska. All right.
shawn (48:01.071)
Ha ha!
Matt (48:03.767)
All right, so with this talk about America and God being at the founding of America, I wanted to talk about this question. So they say many members of the church in America feel like the United States is superior to other countries because the restoration happened here. And this person resents that, being from another country. They don't like this American superiority you get in the church.
And they also in their home countries didn't celebrate the United States the way that we do in the month of July in the United States, where everybody's like, la la, we're the best in the world. Right? And they were wondering, does the same thing happen in Utah, the people in Utah feel like they're superior to everybody else, the way that people in America?
Sam (48:43.786)
Oh no, don't answer that question, Matt. Do not answer that question. We're gonna lose. We have a faithful contingent in New York City and Seattle and they'll all stop listening if you tell them the truth.
Matt (48:53.439)
Do you want me to tell you a really kind of a fun story? So Elder Bednar came to BYU-Idaho. This would be maybe like, I don't know, six or seven years ago. So he came and he had a special meeting with just faculty members and employees, and it was a Q&A kind of thing. And this person raised their hand and they're like, you know, I've been looking at the church, of all the things the church has adopted that seem to have originated here at BYU-Idaho. And I'm wondering Elder Bednar, would you say there's...
shawn (48:56.269)
Yeah.
Matt (49:21.511)
what would you say is like the most special place in the church or something like that, right? Clearly like trying to feed up this idea of, Elder Bednar, will you please tell us that we're the best? And he says, something like that. He said, do you want to know where is the, if I had to say the place in the church right now that is most like Nauvoo, where there's all kinds of spiritual growth and there's all, he did. He said, where the saints are just so faithful and so diligent. Do you know what I would say?
Sam (49:31.138)
Highland, Utah.
shawn (49:34.063)
Ha ha.
shawn (49:42.307)
He answered it? He answered? He answered the question?
Sam (49:48.739)
Highland, Utah.
Matt (49:50.983)
West Africa. And then, and you feel this like collective sigh in the room. They're like, oh, it's not us. It's West Africa. No, it's true. And he said, you can't say this. You can't say Elder Bednar says there's gonna be dozens of temples in Africa. But he's like, the truth is, with how faithful and active they are, they don't need a couple of temples in West Africa. They need hundreds of temples in West Africa because those saints are so faithful.
shawn (49:53.18)
Yay! Yeah! Nice!
shawn (49:59.991)
I love that, I love that. That's awesome.
Sam (50:01.75)
He's, he's messing with them.
shawn (50:18.435)
Wow, that's awesome. Yeah, I wanna go to South Africa.
Sam (50:18.626)
Wow.
Matt (50:20.647)
Yeah, I think that this happens a lot, right? Like there's scriptures that say things and people want to feel good about who they are and where they're from. And so they're always like looking for external validation. Like, will you please tell us we're better than everyone else? And if an apostle won't, then we just tell ourselves that we're better than everyone else.
shawn (50:39.575)
Can I work on one answer in a weird way too, a little bit? Okay, this is a little weird. I don't know if this will land well, but this I, yeah. So there's also a feeling or there has been in the past a feeling of inferiority amongst the sexes too, right? Like women have for a long time felt like, okay, it's a patriarchy basically. So.
Matt (50:58.863)
Yes, they still feel that way, Sean. That's not over.
Sam (51:01.102)
That they do.
shawn (51:02.541)
OK, so here's what's interesting. So.
Sam (51:06.63)
Uh, take, take the points back from Sean from the mother, uh, whatever. Yep. Go ahead. Yep.
Matt (51:10.343)
Ha ha!
shawn (51:10.771)
I didn't get my point yet. I didn't go, okay. So we're in the temple one day and a sister and I got talking afterwards and they started talking about, I hate this and this and this because this makes the woman inferior to the man. And we had this really amazing spiritual conversation about, okay, let's analyze all of the exalting ordinances or covenants that you and I entered into just now or proxy.
Matt (51:13.549)
Oh, sorry.
shawn (51:41.555)
in the temple. And as we went covenant by covenant, what we realized was me, a man, entered into a covenant with God, these six covenants, that leads me to exaltation. And then we hopped over to the woman and said, hey, these same exact covenants, same ones that exalts me, also you entered into directly with God, and there's no difference. So in the end, the only thing that matters is…
salvation and exaltation and it is an individual covenant between me and God. It doesn't matter if I'm American, British, man, woman, right? So in the end I was like, yeah, why does it matter? What do you have in that, Sam?
Matt (52:25.289)
Ha ha!
Sam (52:27.896)
I'm not going to mention that that's true as of the last 18 months. We'll just allow that comment to sit. Go ahead.
shawn (52:33.283)
That's not true. No, no, no. This was during the old version of the temple ceremony and it still applies if you truly look at it. That was not a covenant of, no, Sam, that was not a covenant of exaltation. Oh, oh, okay, we'll talk off script. But you're...
Sam (52:46.975)
We can't talk about that here. Sean, are you ready to lay that down? Come on, let's go.
Matt (52:54.228)
I love the question is do Utahns think they're the best? And Sean's like, let's talk temple covenants.
Sam (53:03.086)
Uhhhhhh...
shawn (53:03.736)
It was-
Matt (53:04.793)
That's cause he's from Southern California and they all think that they're the best. People from Orange County...
Sam (53:08.95)
Hey, you have Steve, you have Steve Young, Sean, you've got Steve Young down there. So come on. Oh no. So, I'm going to go ahead and get started.
shawn (53:13.115)
I thought he was in Utah.
Matt (53:14.471)
The most annoying members of the church are in Southern California. I don't want to alienate any of my good friends in Southern California, but you guys are so cocky. You think that we all want to be on the beach, we all want to hang out, just because we come to Disneyland.
shawn (53:17.863)
Oh, dang. Wow. Dang.
WHAT?!
Sam (53:29.315)
And by the way, we do, but we don't admit it. Yeah. When, when our largest, uh, teachers union decides to let everybody out of school, the entire state goes to Southern California. So yes, it is true.
shawn (53:31.697)
Haha, boo yah!
Matt (53:40.071)
Hey, so with that previous question, they said, are there practical things we could do to unite with people of different faiths? Are there any practical things we could do to unite with them? I'll tell you, I'll show you one example. This was when I lived in Kansas, there was something called the interfaith soup kitchen. And it was like the community said we're gonna buy like get together to feed the homeless. And so every faith would take a week or a day or something each month to do that.
shawn (53:40.155)
It's true.
Matt (54:08.475)
And so the church was part of that. Like there's a lot of, there's interfaith like clothing donation. Like I think anything good you wanna do in your community, you can make it an interfaith thing that would help you to bring other faiths together.
shawn (54:10.747)
We do that a lot here in California.
shawn (54:22.927)
That's a good one, Matt. I think another one is what Sam was alluding to. Be really involved in your neighbors and your business associates lives. Love them and really talk to them. Engage in conversations. I do that all the time.
Sam (54:30.986)
Yeah. Without judgment, pre-condition or conversion, right? Try, truly love people for who they are, where they are. It could lead to something, right? Yeah. Don't spreadsheet it.
shawn (54:38.639)
But it could also lead to... Because Sam, one of my best friends is a...
Matt (54:47.219)
Ha ha ha!
shawn (54:48.407)
Good point. No, one of my best friends is a Protestant. And for years and years and years, we go on two walks a week. And at first it was just finding out about each other, loving each other and the diversity and the differences. And now it's to the point where we get in so deep with religion and it's so fun. So it's it progresses, but we never would have gotten there if we hadn't talked and just become friends and become close. So I like your point.
Matt (55:12.691)
So this question is about discussions we've had where we say you need to pray and receive guidance and follow the Holy Ghost. Because there is this danger of not following the prophet and saying the prophet said this, I believe that I should do this, and then you end up not following the prophet. Like isn't there some safety or in choosing to follow the prophet and saying, he's a prophet of God and he will never lead us astray.
So I'm just gonna align my will with the things that the prophet says. Because otherwise, if you put everything, it becomes like the Bible, where everyone interprets it differently, and then they're all confused. Like the Lord gave us a prophet for a reason. So shouldn't we put our trust in the prophet and follow the prophet, and not worry so much about finding our own individual interpretation?
Sam (56:01.137)
Didn't we already do this conversation on the whole vaccine mandate and some of the other, the water bottle thing and all that? I mean.
shawn (56:07.036)
Well, that question came out of that after that podcast.
Matt (56:09.903)
Is there spiritual danger in doing that? In saying, I know better than the prophet.
shawn (56:15.299)
I don't, but no one here has said, I know better than the prophet, I don't think. We've all agreed that anyone who stands there and says, I know better than the prophet, is in a problematic situation. We're talking from the context of faithful Latter-day Saints like Nephi, who believe in the prophet and are faithful to the prophet, like Nephi was to his father, Father Lehi. Nephi continually questioned or at least wanted to seek out his own.
understanding and revelation about everything that His Father Prophet, Lehi, revealed. So if you come from a viewpoint of I'm looking for reasons to disagree with the prophet or justify my sin or justify my differences in the church, that's a whole different category. Yeah, that person is questioning the prophet. That's bad. I've never questioned the prophet.
Matt (57:06.364)
Yeah.
Sam (57:09.223)
See, you've sort of opened my mind up to this and I'm kind of, I think we've kind of gotten there with you, Sean, that yours is a rigorous exercise in personal revelation. I think the kind of the easier way, dare I say the lazier path is just to follow without question, right? And you've really given me something to think about. I mean, I had never really looked at it that way before. I always thought when the prophet speaks, you know, you act as a member of the church.
shawn (57:27.931)
Mm-hmm.
Sam (57:37.058)
And over the past couple months, since we had that conversation many episodes ago, I love the concept of hearing and then seeking your own kind of confirmation of what's being said. Because that takes a lot more work. That's a lot more deliberate and it's a lot more personal. And it does feel very much the direction that our current profit points us the direction of, right?
shawn (58:01.455)
Well, and along, thanks Sam, and along those lines, Matt said something a few episodes ago, it was that same episode when we were talking about the water bottle. I remember Matt, you said, you said, yeah, but guys, I really, Matt says, I really struggle though, with sometimes hearing things that I disagree with, and it's a lot of work. I struggle and I struggle and I work and I have to pray and I have to fast. And you're almost saying it at the time, like, that's hard, why do I have to do all that? And I was like, that's it.
Matt (58:13.074)
Hahaha
Sam (58:23.874)
Yeah.
Matt (58:27.375)
Yes.
shawn (58:29.963)
You're doing it! That's exactly what God wants you to do, wants us to do, because in that process, Matt, we become closer to our Father in heaven, right? Scripture's always talked about that struggle.
Matt (58:39.037)
Yes, so I-
Sam (58:39.222)
Well, and it's, it's by that same token, Sean, it's interesting. I know a lot of people in my own ward and an area who have left the church or become inactive because president, uh, Nelson said, you know, encourage people to get the vaccine or because he encouraged people to wear a mask, they become disaffected with the church because of something that said that doesn't jive with them personally. And that's an interesting concept that you can say, Hey, you know what? I'm going to seek my own confirmation that what is being taught is
right for me. And if it's not, I can still be an active member in the church and faithfully follow the prophet. I mean, it's just fascinating. It's more work.
shawn (59:19.387)
Because think about it, there's got to be some Latter-day Saint who's faithful somewhere who would have an adverse reaction to the COVID vaccine, right? Maybe their genetics would just be a very bad situation. So should they just blindly go, well, the prophet is urging me, I'm going to go get it despite my adverse reaction? Or do they take it to the Lord and the Lord says, hey, the prophet's right to counsel and urge the church as a church-wide organization to do it? Not you though. Of course that can happen.
Matt (59:28.979)
Yes.
Sam (59:29.867)
Yeah.
Matt (59:47.911)
Well, and I think this is why I'm going to try and tie this back into the LGBTQ question. I have a friend who's gay and he told me, he's like my whole life, all I ever wanted to do was get married to a woman in the temple and live, we'll call it the church dream. Like he's like, I dreamed of that my whole time growing up as a youth. He's like, but at some point I realized like I am just not attracted to women and that dream
doesn't quite fit. But more than anything else, he wants to be faithful, he wants to be active, he has faith in Christ, he's converted to the gospel. So how do you do it? How do you live the life when it all seems to be teaching one way and it doesn't fit you and everything that you're hoping for in your life? And that's why we say, get personal revelation, because the prophet's gonna teach the doctrine, the prophet's gonna lead us the way the Lord wants him to lead us, but...
Sometimes in our lives our individual circumstances, the general counsel, the general teachings don't fit our individual circumstances. And if my friend comes to me and says to me, what should I do? I don't have an answer for him what he should do. I don't know the answer to him what he should do. Heavenly Father has that answer to him. And so the answer to the question, how do I deal with someone like that? The same as I deal with anybody. I love him, he's my friend, I care about him. And I say,
shawn (01:01:03.804)
Amen. That's it.
Matt (01:01:12.195)
I know you'll find the answer to that problem at some point in your life. I don't know what it is, but we're gonna be friends and like, it's not the defining thing in our relationship.
shawn (01:01:19.939)
Yeah, yeah, like I don't care who you desire to have sex with. I don't care why you judge things in your mind. And I don't care, right? We don't care about these things. What we care is... Keepin' it real. I'm keeping it real, Sam.
Matt (01:01:31.123)
Right.
Hahaha
Sam (01:01:34.71)
Sean just took it there.
Matt (01:01:37.639)
Alright, we're gonna quick, we're gonna quick, we're gonna quickly change the subject.
Sam (01:01:40.862)
We've we've lost the other third of we've lost the other 30 40 percent of listeners we have Listen, if you're in Seattle or New York, please stay with us We'll be back after this break
shawn (01:01:47.087)
Sorry.
Matt (01:01:49.905)
I'm gonna go.
Matt (01:01:53.759)
So there's two more questions and this one's gonna kind of lead into the next one. We're gonna end with this discussion about expertise. But this question is, I'm the dummy that doesn't understand anything. Then I listened to this podcast and realized I need to have an opinion. I've lived my whole life as a member thinking, I just don't get into politics because I don't understand. Because of that viewpoint, I'm criticized whether I think I am or just actually I'm for not having an opinion.
I guess I just take the approach of loving everyone best I can and let people be crazy for having such strong political opinions. My question is, do you think it's important to have an opinion?
Sam (01:02:30.082)
Well, I think we've shown that anybody can have an opinion because who are we to have any kind of an opinion? And we three former missionary companions have a heck of a time sitting around talking about stuff. Like, who are we to have an opinion? But it's awesome. We've had a heck of a lot of fun together these past months.
shawn (01:02:33.435)
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
shawn (01:02:47.672)
Yeah.
Matt (01:02:47.775)
I think that American democracy works best when not everybody has a strong opinion. There are people that care a lot about certain things. For example, I have a friend that all she does is study human trafficking. She literally has dedicated her life to stopping human trafficking. I can kind of figure out where she's lived in her life by new human trafficking laws that have emerged. That's her thing and that's what she loves and that's what she cares about.
shawn (01:02:52.988)
Oh wow, what? Whoa.
Sam (01:02:53.218)
Mmm.
Sam (01:03:15.682)
That's awesome. She's called to that.
Matt (01:03:17.075)
And we need, yeah, we need people like that. And we need people who care a lot about these other issues. And then we also at the same time need a whole lot of people that don't care at all about that. Because the people who don't care about it are what make our country work. Like if everybody's fighting to win office all the time, it doesn't work because there's just too much competition, too much animosity, too many people just care too much. So.
Sam (01:03:20.049)
Yeah.
shawn (01:03:27.779)
Why?
Sam (01:03:33.911)
Yeah.
shawn (01:03:34.818)
Oh, oh, oh.
Matt (01:03:44.355)
What I'm trying to advocate for in this podcast is not to have more people with opinions. I'm trying to tell people you should get involved in politics without feeling like you need to have an opinion in order to get involved. The problem in politics now is that the only people involved are the people that care so much about it that it's like life and death for them. And what we need is we need more people involved who care way less about it, who can say, calm down everybody. It doesn't really matter that much.
Sam (01:03:58.542)
Mmm.
Matt (01:04:13.403)
This is just like stuff we're talking about. I don't have an opinion about all those issues, but I'm gonna run for office because I can do the job and like help society without having such strong opinions about things.
shawn (01:04:22.723)
Whoa, interesting. Yeah, me too. Can I, I'm gonna, Matt, I'm gonna counter it and challenge you just for real quick, okay? Dean C-13018 says, whatever principle of intelligence we attain unto in this life, it will rise with us in the resurrection. And if a person gains more knowledge and intelligence in this life through his diligence and obedience than another, he'll have so much more of the advantage in the world to come. Because
Sam (01:04:25.006)
That surprises me that you take that approach. Yeah.
Matt (01:04:28.479)
because I'm a political scientist.
shawn (01:04:52.527)
you two have made me more political. I have explored thoughts, dissonant thoughts, hard thoughts, hard discussions has made me more knowledgeable, has made me more intelligent. If you break it down then to the question that he's asking is or she's asking is, should I care? Should I have an opinion? Should I strive to understand these things when I don't really care that much? I think yes, because at an individual level, they attain to more knowledge, they become more benefited in their life hereafter. So
Matt (01:05:21.807)
Okay, I guess I... Go ahead, Sam.
shawn (01:05:21.967)
They should care.
Sam (01:05:24.89)
So I would say that political opinion doesn't equate with knowledge.
Matt (01:05:31.233)
Right. That's right. You don't right. So right. Is it good to learn more about things for sure? Like, because
shawn (01:05:32.5)
hahahaha
shawn (01:05:36.867)
What? How can you say that?
Sam (01:05:41.191)
Ronald Reagan once said that sometimes you know things that just aren't so.
shawn (01:05:46.767)
Yeah, but Sam, abortion, is it a right thing? Is it a wrong thing? Your answer is it's political, who cares? What, Matt, what? What do you mean who cares? It's a moral issue.
Matt (01:05:46.78)
Yeah, I have-
Matt (01:05:52.499)
Who cares? Yeah. Who cares? Seriously, who cares?
Sam (01:05:54.827)
It's.
Sam (01:06:00.53)
All right, there goes the final third of our audience. We've thrown everybody away. New York, Seattle, we love you.
Matt (01:06:01.503)
No, it's not a moral issue. Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
shawn (01:06:03.596)
A PORTION?
shawn (01:06:08.832)
Matt, abortion isn't a moral issue that requires knowledge and wisdom. Oh you are gonna get flayed. Sam you are gonna get flayed.
Matt (01:06:13.583)
No. Sean, how can you, that is unknowable. Sean, it is, it is unknowable. The answer to your question about abortion is unknowable. You cannot find the answer to that question.
shawn (01:06:24.012)
Okay, I think, okay, what, how's?
Sam (01:06:24.246)
Wait, wait, I take interesting. I'm watching. I've got the popcorn.
shawn (01:06:28.387)
Yeah, interesting. Go ahead.
Matt (01:06:31.273)
Everything in abortion boils down to one question. When does life begin? It is an unknowable question. Nobody knows the answer to when life begins. Do you know the answer to that? Can I study enough to figure that out? You can't find the answer to that question.
shawn (01:06:44.591)
Kay says the scientist says you're approaching it from a scientific approach, but what about the religious approach?
Matt (01:06:52.783)
I'm going to pray about it and God's going to tell me it's 13 weeks. Matt, it's 13 weeks. I'm going to look it up in the scripture and be like, you know, that scripture in Jeremiah, he was talking about 17 weeks.
Sam (01:06:57.395)
Ha ha!
shawn (01:06:57.563)
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Sam (01:07:02.283)
Oh
shawn (01:07:05.879)
No, but Matt, it does say, I put man and woman on the earth. I've equipped them with the tools to multiply and replenish the earth. That's the purpose of it. And so I guess it doesn't say specifically when the spirit enters the body.
Matt (01:07:15.971)
Okay. When does when does exactly it's unknowable.
Sam (01:07:25.97)
Matt is deconstructing his profession right now and he'll be unemployed here very shortly as a political scientist.
shawn (01:07:28.955)
Hehehehehehe
Matt (01:07:31.536)
Look, everybody, do you know why we don't debate death? Because we know the answer to when death happens. Death happens when the person's dead. We debate about abortion because it's unknowable and nobody knows the answer to that question. So having a strong opinion about abortion doesn't do anybody any good. And saying, well, there's a moral right and wrong here. Okay, but what is it? Because the prophet hasn't told us what it is.
shawn (01:07:32.396)
Oh boy.
Matt (01:07:55.695)
I can't look up in the handbook what it is. I don't know the answer to this question.
shawn (01:07:59.391)
That's a good point. There's no doc. There's no, there's, I mean, you're going to get people emailing in all of this profits of this or this profits of this, but there is no, there is no canonized doctrine on it. That's for sure.
Matt (01:08:06.224)
Oh, I know, I know. And somebody's going to be like.
Sam (01:08:09.398)
You know, the handbook of instructions has said different things over time.
Matt (01:08:13.367)
And people are going to say, there are single-celled organisms that are alive. So conception, but I'm just saying there's not an answer to that question. There's not an answer. So then why, like why I feel like I have to form an opinion on that. There are things about abortion that there are answers to like, like what's the nicest thing to do in society? What uplifts people in society? We could talk about equality. We could talk about fairness, but you can't figure out.
shawn (01:08:13.487)
That's changed.
shawn (01:08:21.883)
Wow.
shawn (01:08:40.32)
Matt, but how can you say it's not a moral? Yeah, Matt. Yeah, I was gonna say it.
Sam (01:08:42.01)
a very liberal view for you to take Matt. I appreciate it. To my kids, just who are listening, I don't necessarily endorse Matt's opinion on this, but I see his point because truly, yeah.
Matt (01:08:45.772)
We could talk about protecting life too. Protecting life of mothers. We could talk about... Hey, listener, please, all of you who know when life begins, will you just... I don't want to know your argument. I just need to know a number. Just message us. Two weeks. 16 weeks. 17... Six weeks.
shawn (01:08:59.77)
It's good to be open-minded.
Sam (01:09:05.242)
Oh no, don't say it. Oh no. Listen, I watched, I watched Saturday's warrior and I know that it was the glimmer in the eye of the other person before, but is when it all began predestination. Yeah.
Matt (01:09:12.595)
Just tell me, is it the heartbeat that's like the electrical thing that the ultrasound gives you or it is an actual heartbeat?
Hahahaha
I'm out.
Matt (01:09:28.239)
I am not denying that there's a pre-mortal life. I'm not saying that, I'm just saying nobody can tell me when life begins. When is that embryo a human life? And when does it start and when does it not start? Nobody knows. And if I wanna go to the scriptures, and he says, I put into them their spirit, that's it, that's what I get. Okay, well then that would, okay, if I say breath of life, doesn't that imply breathing? So when our embryos would-
shawn (01:09:49.531)
The breath of life. You get the breath of life. You get... Yeah.
Sam (01:09:56.35)
Adam, in most of the times I've seen that with Adam, he looks to be about 28. So it's,
shawn (01:10:04.118)
Hahahaha
Matt (01:10:05.795)
Right. So nobody knows one in a...
shawn (01:10:07.227)
How about this? How about this, Matt? Let's promise our listeners that we will revisit this topic at a later date so we can get a little more in depth. Yeah, because I'd like to... I...
Sam (01:10:15.758)
Oh no, oh no, please no, please no, no more, no more unions, no more pornography and no more abortion. I think we've covered those.
Matt (01:10:17.839)
on abortion?
Matt (01:10:23.359)
Hahaha
shawn (01:10:27.953)
Hehehehehehe
Matt (01:10:28.707)
I just knew, like, we will just say at the beginning, we'll go with whatever our audience tells us, whatever number, it has to be the exact number. Whatever number is the modal answer, whichever number gets the most answers, that will be the... It's easy, right?
Sam (01:10:40.502)
Who who's going to count the votes? Who's going to count the votes though? Matt, we don't trust the liberal to do that. No.
shawn (01:10:41.291)
You're you. Yeah, but you're the man you read. Matt, you reduce you're reducing it down to just you reduce. You're saying the moral question would be if we knew exactly when a life began, then it would become a moral issue because then killing after that date is evil and before that is not evil. Is that what you're saying? Instead of instead of instead of treating it as okay, the conceptual purpose of.
Matt (01:10:56.464)
Yeah.
Matt (01:11:01.487)
Every... correct. Every single person.
shawn (01:11:11.103)
intercourse is to create a life and therefore the intent of that process is life. And that see that's what I'm saying Sam shaking his head. Let's revisit this. We'll come back to it.
Sam (01:11:20.598)
Sean has said intercourse twice this, this episode. Can we go to the next question, please? I'm not afraid of it. I just.
Matt (01:11:26.579)
hahahaha
shawn (01:11:26.763)
Why are you and Utah so afraid of this? Why are you so afraid of intercourse? You are. OK.
Matt (01:11:33.642)
Sean, everybody agrees that murder is wrong. There's not a single person you're going to talk to that says murder is okay sometimes if it's convenient.
Sam (01:11:41.27)
Matt's going to have us all voting for Kamala Harris by the time this is done. Let's go to the next question, please, please. Okay.
shawn (01:11:46.245)
Sam's done. Okay, okay, okay.
Matt (01:11:48.007)
Good, okay, format, but I wanna hear what everybody else has to say. When have the experts or academia been wrong and steered the world wrong? And how is society to know when they are right or wrong? When have their findings led to horrific things? How do we know when to follow their expertise? What qualifies one to be an expert? A degree could be obtained with straight Cs. Can comprehensive experience without a degree qualify one as an expert? And...
Since they asked me this question. I want to say that because I have a PhD. I'm an expert in Sam's field I don't care. I don't care what he's done in his life. I have the degree No, so expertise, of course, there's lots of ways to get expertise, right? You can get expertise through life experience when I say we need to trust the experts we're in the context of education, I'm talking about experts who
shawn (01:12:24.398)
Ha ha.
Sam (01:12:25.535)
Oh
shawn (01:12:28.931)
Yeah
Matt (01:12:40.947)
have degrees in those fields because that's how you establish expertise in academia. But there's expertise in all kinds of fields and you don't get them through degrees, some things you get through experience. So yeah, experts are.
shawn (01:12:53.94)
So you would trust a person who has a degree, even though they were the worst in their class, they cheated their way through it, they got terrible grades, they attained to no knowledge, they got their piece of paper, you would trust that person over a person who came up, bootstrapped it, learned lots of stuff on the streets, never got their paper though, Matt.
Matt (01:13:14.591)
Well, it depends on the field we're talking about. If we're talking about medical school, like medical things, I'm gonna trust a person who cheated their way through medical school and got Cs in medical school over somebody who's like, I've been reading lots of things on the internet and I've been watching lots of YouTube videos and I feel like I've got some expertise on this topic. Yeah.
Sam (01:13:33.166)
conspiracy theorists. You're not going to trust them, right? Anti-establishment, yeah.
shawn (01:13:34.542)
Okay.
Matt (01:13:39.304)
Yeah, so experts are wrong all the time. Academics are wrong all the time. I've written papers that I don't think that I'm right about those things. I don't retract them because I like to get citations on my papers. But that's the whole point of like people are wrong, people learn from their mistakes and then you grow as a field. So when I say we need to trust people with expertise, I'm not saying we should trust them because they're never gonna make mistakes.
Sam (01:13:50.603)
Oh no.
Matt (01:14:05.511)
We should trust them because they know enough about a field to dedicate their life to studying it. And somebody with that kind of like dedication to a knowledge about something, we should trust them. If I want to know about...
shawn (01:14:18.051)
You're not gonna rat out your people and answer the question that they've asked? When has academia led the world wrong?
Matt (01:14:25.039)
Okay, we've got eugenics is pretty bad. We've got medicine before germ theory, which was pretty bad when they like put leeches on your body and you're gonna feel better. We've got all kinds of really bad psychology experiments that caused damage to people. There's so many things where science and academia have been wrong about things. But the important thing is that it's self corrects that the fields of science correct themselves.
shawn (01:14:27.402)
Oh, pretty bad.
shawn (01:14:33.005)
leeches.
Matt (01:14:53.775)
and they adjust, it might take a long time, but that's because they have a method of establishing empirical evidence and we trust the empirical evidence. And so sometimes it takes a while because you need a lot of empirical evidence. So for example, let's talk about the COVID-19 vaccine. Some people say, I don't trust it because it was rushed through and they approved it too quickly and there could be all kinds of problems with it. Well, guess what academia would agree with you about that? But they said, this is the best we have right now.
We've gone through enough clinical trials that we're confident that there's not going to be massive problems if everybody gets vaccinated. So our best advice to you is go get vaccinated. Now, my wife chose not to, she chose to do the Johnson and Johnson vaccine because she didn't trust the mRNA technology that, that Moderna was using. And we're just going to have to see is this mRNA vaccine, is there, are there negative things with it? Are there positive things with it? But the evidence at the time said,
it's safe for most people to do it. So we're gonna say most people should do it. Now they never said there's not gonna be any side effects or any problems down the road. And there might be, in which case, then they would change what they said and say, guess what, there are some problems. Or like with masking, when they said, hey, you don't need to wear a mask because it's not gonna do you any good because the coronavirus is so small and mask isn't gonna help. And we need to save the masks for the medical professionals. And then later on they...
shawn (01:16:18.139)
Who said that?
Matt (01:16:19.495)
That was like early on the CDC said, don't wear a mask, it's a waste of time. And then they changed. Then they said, hey, actually a mask can be helpful. Well, now we're gonna say that you should wear a mask. And then people are like, well, they're changing their mind all the time. They can't possibly be right about that. But that's a sign of like good evidence. The fact that you're willing to change your mind when the preponderance of evidence says that you were wrong and you switch, that should have you have more confidence in academia, not less confidence.
shawn (01:16:24.603)
I don't remember that.
shawn (01:16:48.507)
Do you have any reservations where these are human beings? And when there's a group of academics who control a certain field, attain to a lot of power, get a lot of money, get a lot of grants, they get political influence, you don't think that corrupts sometimes the honesty of a lot of the academia's findings or expert findings.
Matt (01:17:14.623)
So when we're talking about like million dollar grants, I don't wanna make it sound like the idea of corruption is laughable, but it kind of is laughable, that somebody would be corrupt in science because there's really not a lot of money in doing bad science just to get grants.
Sam (01:17:34.007)
Cold Fusion, University of Utah.
Matt (01:17:36.547)
and then you ruin your name forever, right? So it's like, it's like this, yeah, yeah. There was a guy in our field who falsified, like they got an article published in the top magazine, a journalist called Science. And this was a grad student that like had this foundational path-breaking research, got a job offer at Princeton University. Like everything was wonderful. Like this kid was a superstar. And then, you know, it took a couple of months and then somebody figured out
shawn (01:17:36.731)
What's that? Yeah, but it...
Sam (01:17:40.462)
That's a fair example though.
shawn (01:17:42.907)
Yeah, but...
Matt (01:18:05.511)
He fabricated all of his data. And then within seconds, his whole life is poof, it's all gone. I don't know what this guy's doing with his life now. His name...
shawn (01:18:11.171)
Yeah, what was her name? What's the lady's, no, no. What's the lady's name that created the device that would, with one drop of blood, identify every, what was her name? Theranos, right? She, the money and the power that came along with being the expert was too overwhelming for this bunch of people and they defrauded everybody.
Sam (01:18:21.062)
Oh yeah. Yep. Theranos. Yeah.
Matt (01:18:21.559)
Yeah, Theranos. Theranos, right? Yeah.
Matt (01:18:38.452)
Did you see what happened to them? Who wants that?
Sam (01:18:41.867)
The beauty of the free market is it always finds out.
Matt (01:18:45.267)
Right. And in academia, it's the same thing. Like the way that this guy got caught was somebody was really impressed with his research and they said, hey, I would love to work on this with you and replicate this. And then anyhow, it doesn't take long to figure it out. Like people admire what you're doing, then study it a little bit more, and then they expose you for being a fraud. So there's just not a lot of incentive to do that. It's not to say it doesn't happen. There's examples in every field where somebody does that and it ruins their life. So why...
shawn (01:18:45.551)
Yeah
Matt (01:19:14.727)
Why would you do that? Why would somebody say, oh, I'm gonna go into this field and then I'm gonna end up working at like McDonald's because I'm ruined.
shawn (01:19:20.968)
Cause they...
Sam (01:19:21.326)
There's nothing wrong with McDonald's.
Matt (01:19:23.835)
But right, but who wants to get a PhD, publish in science and have everybody like forevermore, they google your name and
shawn (01:19:29.004)
But Matt, every politician and every business, every entrepreneur doesn't go into corruption thinking they're going to get caught. They don't think they're going to get caught. So why wouldn't that apply to academia? It applies.
Matt (01:19:40.919)
I'm saying we have bad apples, but they get caught. And so, so my push for expertise is simply this.
shawn (01:19:48.709)
Along that logic, there's no corruption in business and there's no corruption in government because they get caught so they don't do it.
Matt (01:19:57.123)
Okay, I'm okay with that.
shawn (01:19:58.679)
What?
Sam (01:20:00.814)
I would dispute that, but yeah, that's all right.
Matt (01:20:03.795)
They get caught eventually though, right Sam?
Sam (01:20:07.378)
No, not really. No.
Matt (01:20:08.727)
Oh, okay. Well, I don't know. Well, like, so if we go back to my friend who's like dedicated to fighting human trafficking, when I say expertise, I say, we need to have people like this making decisions about human trafficking. I'm not saying that no one's ever gonna get it wrong. I'm saying that the probability that somebody who dedicates their life to fighting human trafficking has some personal agenda and some little, just trying to build herself up or something like that, it's very, very small.
shawn (01:20:35.851)
Yeah, I'm with you. Okay, well, until someone says, hey, we're gonna have to shut you down because we can't fund you unless you lay off the Cuban sex trafficking world. And then they go, okay, give me your money. I'll stop the fight.
Matt (01:20:39.185)
So we-
Matt (01:20:49.536)
Oh yeah.
Matt (01:20:53.431)
I'm saying that the alternative is we look to YouTube for expertise and there's no check on that. There's no check on telling me is that information that these people are putting out there and getting millions of views, are they trying to be accurate or are they just trying to get clicks? Like that alternative isn't any better.
shawn (01:21:10.723)
Yeah, I agree, but there's bias in academia because of money, I think. Okay, go ahead.
Sam (01:21:11.202)
So, so isn't kind of the, isn't, isn't kind of the purpose of your point is that as members of the church, as we seek out truth, wherever we find it, experts have value, people that study us a subject that become excellent in an area, whether it's academia, science, whether it's business, right? It's finding the best people in different fields.
and educating yourself. And Matt, Sean, I think it's okay to have an opinion. It's okay to debate. It's okay to have conversations. And even though those conversations may sound very different than they have in our past, we might be talking about Kamala Harris one day or Joe Biden another day, or Trump another day. It's okay. We need to be more embracing as members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints of those divergent opinions and viewpoints.
Matt (01:21:51.431)
Yes, yes.
Sam (01:22:03.166)
And all of those things make us richer and make our religious observance richer, but also our culture richer.
shawn (01:22:11.867)
Beautifully said, Sam. Yeah, Sam. Bam.
Matt (01:22:12.007)
Well said, Sam. Hey, listener. Sorry if we didn't cover your questions in as much depth as you would have liked, and sorry if we didn't get to your questions. We really tried to get to all the questions today. If we didn't, feel free to reach out. We do the mailbag every week. We're excited to hear from you again this upcoming week, and hope you'll listen again next week. Take care.
Sam (01:22:13.842)
Wow, mic drop.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories