The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
July 5, 2023; Porn in Utah, Ecstasy, Mental Health, and the Word of Wisdom, Are Unions Good for Society?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Another listener pointed us to James Jones comments on ATC. He argues that Paul publicly corrected Peter for his behavior toward Gentiles (Galatians 2:11-14). He also notes that President Uchtdorf acknowledged that mistakes have been made in the past. Ultimately, we have an obligation to engage in activism toward the church if leaders are not following the commandments.
The News:
Pornography fans in Utah appear to be searching for ways to bypass internet IP restrictions after Pornhub blocked access to all Utahns ahead of a state bill that requires porn websites to verify the age of their visitors. The Google Trends chart shows that searches in Utah for the term VPN spiked the week of April 30-May 6, 2023, when the law went into effect. Does this mean people in Utah are consuming porn in violation of state law?
Scientists have been using MDMA (ecstasy) to treat a variety of mental disorders including PTSD, anxiety, depression, and racism. Interestingly, some of the early research on the benefits of MDMA came from studies of LDS young people in the early 2000s who were consuming the drug a rave parties. Some people think that this research will lead to the legalization of MDMA. There are lots of illegal drugs that are not specifically banned from the Word of Wisdom (by name) and many legal drugs which are. Paul H. Peterson wrote an MA thesis while at BYU that traces the history of the Word of Wisdom, but basically, in the 1930s President Grant led the charge urging faithful members to stop consuming tobacco and alcohol. He was also a strong proponent of prohibition. It seems that social conditions are often associated with revelation on the Word of Wisdom. Is it time to revisit which substances are banned in the Word of Wisdom?
Big Question:
There is a persistent pay gap in the United States between men and women as well as among whites and racial minorities. Government policies have done little to reverse this. Guess what has worked… Unions. Unions have a long history of helping workers obtain better working conditions. Unions have led the charge for better worker safety, paid leave, healthcare, retirement, and financial security. Every worker benefits from unions, even if they are not part of a union. Why would a worker ever support right to work laws?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt:
Hello, I've enjoyed listening to your podcast and have found most of the discussions enlightening. I have to take issue with the discussion on masks that you had in your most recent episode. First of all, we knew by the time the first presidency urged us to wear masks that COVID wasn't spread primarily by touching surfaces, but by respiratory droplets. So thinking that wearing a mask while touching a microphone that someone else touched is ridiculous, isn't really supported by the knowledge that we had and about how the virus is spread. Hey Sean, that's about you, Sean.
shawn:
So Matt, let's pause there so I can just answer that, because I'm super grateful that the listener would go and do the research and obviously is citing something, right? They either listened to health care professionals or government and came to this conclusion. Now, it's such an interesting discussion, right? Where we go back to, how do you know when the profit or how do you know that something is true or not true? And we do our best. Especially when there's not a black and white or an absolute truth to be to be discovered, right? For example masks I don't think there's a black and white on it. But it's interesting the dilemma it points out the right dilemma because Our listener in their diligent searching right they mentioned that We the first presidency where we knew by the time the first presidency spoke that Oh the respiratory droplets
Matt:
Yeah, so
shawn:
not
Matt:
touching
shawn:
by probably
Matt:
sir,
shawn:
touching surfaces, okay,
Matt:
right.
shawn:
but But I went to the CDC's website a long time ago, and it literally on the CDC's website says this, respiratory droplets can land on hands, objects or surfaces around the person when they cough or talk. And people can then become infected with COVID-19 from touching hands, objects or surfaces with droplets and then touching their eyes, nose or mouth.
Matt:
But didn't they
shawn:
And
Matt:
update that?
shawn:
that's, I checked it yesterday, it was still on there.
Matt:
Really?
shawn:
Yeah, yesterday it was on
Matt:
Wow.
shawn:
there. I copied and pasted and used it. And my only point in bringing that up is this, what authority are we to believe?
Matt:
on this.
shawn:
No, no, like your topic last week, Matt, like
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
on any item that is not exactly a black and white truth, like this,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
our listener did their due diligence and found evidence that it's not gonna pass other than respiratory droplets. It doesn't land on things. And then I find a source, which is a government source that says the opposite. To me, there's always gonna be these opposite pieces of information, which again is why it's so important for us to go back to study it out, do our research, and then go to God and find out what exactly we're supposed to do through the Spirit.
Matt:
Yeah. And I think in addition to that, there's people, individual differences in how they would behave, right? Some people are more cautious. Some people are more adventurous. And so you could take the same information. And even if both people believed that same data, and even if it was like true, they would still have a different reaction or a response to that information. So
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
yeah, I think that it's wise that we take whatever, when we want to find answers to something, I think it's wise to take it to the Lord. But you know, my daughter got mad at me when I said that the Lord doesn't reveal truth about scientific things. She got upset at me. And so I have to be careful
shawn:
Good,
Matt:
how I say that. Ha ha
shawn:
good,
Matt:
ha.
shawn:
she should have, good. You did say something like, God doesn't,
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
yeah, you did say something like that.
Matt:
right. And she pointed me to this idea that all of the scientific revelation, like discoveries of science are inspired by the Holy Ghost. And so for me to say like that the Holy Ghost doesn't reveal things about scientific things, minimizes scientific discoveries that have been inspired by the Holy Ghost.
shawn:
So I'm hearing an apology and a repentant
Matt:
Well, no,
shawn:
tone.
Matt:
I actually disagree with her on that, but...
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
No, no, I agree that the Holy Ghost inspires scientific research, but I don't necessarily agree that there's truth in that. It's all in a definition of what truth is.
shawn:
Okay, that's definitely a later topic, huh?
Matt:
Yeah, we could talk about that at a different time.
shawn:
That's interesting though.
Matt:
Hey, let's get to the second idea. So the second, the idea that the first presidency told everyone to wear masks at church only had to do with being able to meet legally is also wrong. The laws differed significantly depending on the state and locale, which is something that Sam said. But Sam also
shawn:
No,
Matt:
said
shawn:
I said
Matt:
that,
shawn:
it. I said
Matt:
oh, you
shawn:
it.
Matt:
said that? So stating it was clearly a policy as a result of law is wrong. It wasn't the law in Utah and many other states that you had to wear masks to meet in church.
shawn:
Yeah, they pursue it. The listener persuades me on that. I think, I think my suggestion that it was just law driving that. I think there are some instances where, I mean, the first presidency had to consider that in areas where it was law. And even when it wasn't law, there was a tremendous social pressure to do it. And I think it's a, it's a smart PR move to, to follow that law. Was that the primary motivation behind it? No, I'm probably more persuaded by the listener, especially because I went back and I read exactly what the first presidency said. And they used safe language. They said, we urge people to mask and we urge people to be vaccinated. That wasn't a command, but
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
it's a pretty strong, urging is a pretty strong word for the first presidency, right?
Matt:
So I went, I mentioned before that a student of mine are doing a research project on this topic. And so we went back and we were looking at the data again, just to make sure that we had everything right. And it turns out that the first presidency message had basically no effect on vaccination rates
shawn:
What?
Matt:
among members of the church.
shawn:
Is that conclusive? Like you believe that's
Matt:
It's,
shawn:
the
Matt:
yeah, I am very, very persuaded. We have multiple different kind of data points and different ways of looking at it. And what you do is you can look at vaccination rates by county before the first presidency message and after the first presidency message. And then you can say, okay, since most counties in the United States that happen to be majority LDS also voted for Trump, you can kind of look at the Trump vote as kind of this proxy. for the effect of political, like partisanship or political attitudes on vaccination rates. And so we estimate like how many people are gonna get vaccinated in a Republican County after the first presidency announcement. And then we say, okay, how many people got vaccinated in predominantly LDS counties after the vaccination? And what you're hoping to find is that these LDS counties, even though they're predominantly Republican, that they're going to have a higher vaccination rate compared to the other Republican counties in the United States. And what you see is it's exactly the same.
shawn:
Interesting.
Matt:
There's basically
shawn:
So,
Matt:
no difference between.
shawn:
so
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
do you chalk that up as somewhat soft language from a prophet? In other words, it's different when a prophet says, verily, and I, and, and the, and has, and almost is in a, I command you mode and the Lord speaketh mode versus we urge you to do something. Do you think it's because it was, I mean, I mean, it wasn't, it wasn't something to be ignored. It's good, always good, obviously, to follow the prophets. guidance, especially when they're even when they're just urging us. But do you think that had a play an effect on that?
Matt:
Yeah, so I about two or three years ago, I wrote this little paper that on the effect of Mormonism, like Mormonism's influence on politics or the church's influence on politics. And I went back all the way to the beginning and then kind of traced some big issues until the present time. And what I noticed is that the church's influence on politics is waning over time. And fewer and fewer people are just following the church when it comes to matters of politics. And I noticed like within the last couple months, the church even released a statement saying that like, elected officials, if their views disagree with those of the church, they don't have to do what the church tells them to do on matter like in voting as elected officials. So I just think it's part of a broader trend where when it used to be that the church leaders had a lot of sway in politics. and they're just not having as much anymore.
shawn:
Sam, what do you think? Because when we talked about this last time, your comment was kind of a few times, you mentioned in surprise, like, well, the prophet was clear, like, who in their life is an active member of the church who doesn't follow what the prophet's saying? And you were surprised that there would be people who didn't do that. Well, Matt's study is saying that almost nobody listened to it, right, Matt?
Matt:
Yeah, it didn't overcome partisanship.
sam:
Yeah, I think it is interesting. You know, I, I remember, uh, President Hinckley getting up in conference and telling people, Hey, don't shop on Sunday. In fact, I remember that, that talk, right? Uh, shops in Utah were starting to open on Sunday and people were shopping and they were eating and doing other things. And he gave that there's no reason why you need to do this on Sunday. There's no reason why you need to do that on Sunday. And I wonder, it'd be interesting to research the correlation between that talk and that moment, and then kind of the decline in the influence, uh, between, Hey, do this and whether that's done. Because, uh,
Matt:
Yeah, yeah,
sam:
you know, that, that is
Matt:
I think
sam:
not
Matt:
they
sam:
fault.
Matt:
don't follow.
sam:
No, no.
Matt:
Yeah.
sam:
And then what does that say more
shawn:
But
sam:
broadly
shawn:
I- but-
sam:
about, uh, you know, discipleship and, and the church in, in Utah in terms of, you know, it's, it's cultural impact, it's social impact.
shawn:
But you're suggesting, Matt, that it's just when they come out with somewhat political
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
direction.
sam:
Awesome.
Matt:
what I study is politics, but Sean,
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
my hunch is that it doesn't matter. Politics, not politics. People aren't following the church leaders on things. They're just kind of going with what they think, and whether
shawn:
Oh.
Matt:
it's church or not church, I think that you're gonna have the same effect, which is,
shawn:
Is that
Matt:
I
shawn:
your?
Matt:
think, kind of what Sam's hinting at.
sam:
Yeah, Sunday's not political. You know, I live, the city I live in is Highland and we actually have a rule in Highland that businesses have to be closed on Sunday. And,
Matt:
Whoa.
sam:
and I, I anticipate that will probably change over the next few years because it has caused some very big businesses not to move into Highland. And then we suffer the consequences of property taxes. And so people complain about the expense of maintaining that standard. And I think we're one of the last
shawn:
How
sam:
cities
shawn:
can you have?
sam:
that holds that.
shawn:
How can a city have a law to say I can't do business on Sunday?
sam:
Like,
Matt:
Well you can
sam:
it's...
Matt:
have all kinds of laws. We have
sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
alcohol laws, we have laws about drugs,
shawn:
That
Matt:
we
sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
do
shawn:
can't
Matt:
all...
shawn:
be constitutional.
Matt:
of course it is.
shawn:
It is?
sam:
Well, what
Matt:
Of
sam:
about
Matt:
course! Cities can pass ordinances about stuff.
sam:
get guess what else there is in the state of Utah? You cannot sell cars seven days a week. You have to be closed
shawn:
What?
sam:
on Sunday or actually, I think the law says you have to be closed one day a week. And most people shock or choose Sunday. But yeah, there are.
Matt:
Yeah.
sam:
And actually that's not
Matt:
There's
sam:
unusual across the country. There are many states, Michigan, Illinois, or not Illinois, Michigan, Indiana. A lot of the Midwest Bible Belt states do the same thing.
shawn:
Wow.
Matt:
There's a lot of municipalities that have laws about what you can and can't sell on Sunday, Sean.
shawn:
Oh my gosh, that's shocking
Matt:
I know.
shawn:
to me, it really is.
Matt:
Well, so the next topic, another listener writes, capitalism does a lot of things right. Marx had a lot of lovely things to say about capitalism. Over and over he described capitalism as the best economic system in the world, the world had ever seen so far. Capitalism is indeed very efficient at meeting human needs. My issue with capitalism is that it meets each person's needs. relative to that person's wealth. Capitalism listens twice as hard to the needs of a person with twice as much money. This is not efficient, healthy, or Christian. Let me be clear that this is a systemic problem. I do not mean to say that insurance agents, mortgage brokers, or salespeople do not work hard or are not talented or do not provide a valuable service to their employers, their customers, or to society. Capitalism, after all, is a worthy thing to work for. I only mean that capitalism does not naturally match people's consumption to their production because of the massive effort it requires just to keep it running. Matt's universal basic income proposals address capitalism's problems quite effectively. They are a democratization of the economy. Universal basic income carves out a fraction of the economy where a person's needs are as important as any other person, irrespective of wealth. Under a universal basic income, some people would quit selling their labor. But most would still labor, and most of us would keep our nine to five. Oh, and don't worry, capitalists, the vast majority of the economy will continue to attend enthusiastically to the needs of the trust fund babies. Good work, I love you all.
shawn:
So Matt, I wanna hear your reply to that.
Matt:
I think this is wonderful. Yeah, I think that's great.
shawn:
He agrees with you, so
Matt:
I
shawn:
you
Matt:
do
shawn:
think it's
Matt:
like
shawn:
great.
Matt:
the idea of a universal basic income. I think I've said this lots of times. And every time I listen to the news now, I can't help but think of another example where universal basic income could solve that problem. I sense that you're not in favor of a universal basic income.
shawn:
Um, is it proposed that a universal basic income would be on top of all of the other services that the government provides or would it be in
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
lieu of? It
Matt:
no, on top of
shawn:
just.
Matt:
the idea is the idea is that you tax, you know, like Facebook and Google and all these places that are making billions of dollars by selling your data to other people. You just tax them and you take all of that money and you say, we're going to write like Elon Musk doesn't need to be the richest person in the world. He can be much less wealthy and we can just give that to everybody. Just give them a paycheck. a paycheck for being alive.
shawn:
I just find no principle that says that it is a righteous thing to give everyone an equal amount of money. I don't see anything that says that.
Matt:
Well, okay, let's say Sean that you and your family owned an oil well. And every time somebody pumps oil out of your oil well, they give you a little piece of the profits because you own the oil well. And so in perpetuity, your family gets money from that oil well. It's the same kind of thing.
shawn:
That's no, that's completely different.
Matt:
No, no, it'll be like... it'll be
shawn:
No,
Matt:
like...
shawn:
here's the difference. Here's the difference. If I enter into a free contract with someone and I get in perpetuity a commission
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
from that free contract, then we have an agreement and it profits both of us. And we both strive to make it a more successful and profitable oil well because
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
we both have our interests with each other. The government taking your money by point of gun in order to pay someone else, it is because if
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
you
Matt:
no,
shawn:
for a few...
Matt:
it's an agreement. It doesn't have to be a gun.
shawn:
No, because so many if it's a law passed, you're saying the law gets passed. And
Matt:
Uh huh.
shawn:
now my money will be I will be taxed even more and that money will be paid to someone else right?
Matt:
Well, that's a social contract, Sean. That's a social contract that we enter into as part of living in a free society.
shawn:
Okay, I guess I've been...
sam:
Are there any examples? Are there any examples, Matt, elsewhere across the world where that works? Truly.
Matt:
I do know that there are European countries that are testing universal basic income. And I think maybe it's Finland, but I don't know. This isn't a thing I'm a huge proponent of, so I haven't studied this a lot. I'm sure our listener who advocates for it has, but sure, there's a lot of countries that are trying this now that say, look, we need to just do a universal basic income for people.
shawn:
Matt, I'd be open to the experiment if it was in lieu of providing so many government services. Because it would make sense that if we're saying, look, we trust people enough that they will be productive, and we're saying, okay, then we're gonna provide for their basic needs, then let's trust them to be productive with that money to provide for their basic needs. Why are we now, it just seems like it's going more and more and more to this state... It's just centralizing power and giving more power to the state when, you know,
Matt:
You need to learn to trust the state, Sean. The state loves
shawn:
What?
Matt:
you. The state
sam:
Ugh.
Matt:
is looking at, the state is
sam:
This
Matt:
looking out for
sam:
of
Matt:
you.
sam:
all the of all of all the topics and all the conversations. This is the dumbest and
shawn:
Ha ha
sam:
it
shawn:
ha!
sam:
is worthy. It is worth noting that the call that whoever sent this email and I love the line. Let me be clear. This is a systemic problem. I do not mean to say that insurance. Listen to me. Chooses insurance agents, mortgage brokers or salespeople do not work hard or are not talented. So the sarcasm is just seething from this person, right?
Matt:
No, no,
sam:
Go
Matt:
no.
sam:
ahead.
Matt:
The
sam:
Was
Matt:
reason
sam:
that yours?
Matt:
that this listener chooses that, I cut out part of the email, but
sam:
Okay.
Matt:
they were saying that there are sectors of the economy that exist not to be productive, but to just help capitalism keep track of assets and help decide like where these assets are gonna be moved. And that that's horribly unproductive in an economic system. So that's why they picked on those particular things because like it's something like a sixth of their time. Each week is spent just moving assets around or keeping track of how assets are being allocated in the economy.
sam:
Okay, so I would need to see the rest of the email. I mean, truly our economy in the United States is becoming one of a service related economy, right? So we're exchanging time, we're providing services in exchange for income. But the offensive part about a universal income is this whole implication that the government can best provide for the people and best the government is in the best position under that social contract to equalize resources in such a way that it benefits the economy and or best provides opportunity and abundance in the places where it should be. And I just, in my own experience, I haven't seen that. I think there's merit to having hard work and having creativity and more than anything, having risk rewarded, because risk is a fundamental and key part of capitalism. It's someone willing to say, I'm willing to take a... $100 risk I'm willing to take a million dollar risk. I'm really willing to risk 10 million dollars and I could lose everything on an idea on a product on a concept and I'm willing to give life blood and passion towards developing that and when you lose that incentive Then good people walk away. I remember the guy in Seattle. I don't know if you guys remember this or not He was heralded as a hero initially. He said hey, you know what for my company? I'm gonna pay everybody 70 grand everybody, the secretary, the
Matt:
Is
sam:
sales
Matt:
this Howard
sam:
people.
Matt:
Schultz, the Starbucks CEO?
sam:
No,
shawn:
No.
sam:
no, that's a
Matt:
Oh,
sam:
different
Matt:
okay.
sam:
deal. He did
Matt:
Okay.
sam:
not do that, by the way. He did not do that. But this was another businessman. Everybody heralded at him as a hero initially. And then years later, people went back to him and he had gone. His company was not as successful and it wasn't as successful because a lot of the good people in the company that wanted to see the fruits of their labors rewarded left and went somewhere else. Right. So now all of a sudden you've got a lot of people that are doing tasks that economically don't merit the type of pay
shawn:
Hmm.
sam:
trying to get in there. And so you're lopsided. And then the really good people that are excellent at doing their job are gonna go find a better place to be. America is great on the backs of ingenuity, creativity, and people who are willing to take risks. And are there
Matt:
Let me.
sam:
examples where that's unequal? Absolutely. But by and large, it's worked. very well from us for us since our inception and universal income would destroy that.
Matt:
Let me ask you this question, Sam. So where
sam:
Okay.
Matt:
I work, we kind of have equalized incomes. What we earn is not based on what we bring to the organization, and it's not based on what we could earn if we were to leave the organization. It's just the set salary that's based on how many years you have experience. And
sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
I noticed that there are people that I work with, in fact, we have a rule, you can't ask people how much they make. because I think for obvious reasons, but anyhow, it's not hard to find out what other people make. And I do notice that there's from time to time, there's this like, people will see, oh, this person is making more than me, or this person is making less than me, and I'm working harder than they are. And then they'll get
sam:
Right?
Matt:
kind of upset about that. And
sam:
Right?
Matt:
my approach to that has always been to say, I don't care, I feel like they're paying me enough. If I wanted something more, I could go somewhere else. and I'm comfortable with the amount of work that I do for the pay that I get. And I just sort of try to not worry about everybody else. So my question for you, Sam, is do you think that kind of part of human nature that makes you want to kind of compare what you're earning and how hard you're working compared to other people, do you think that that's the part of human nature that sort of forces us into this kind of capitalistic approach? Or
sam:
No.
Matt:
do you think it's the system itself that makes people be that way?
sam:
No comparison is the thief of joy. And I love that quote from Brene Brown. And I'm, I know whoever wrote this would appreciate that quote inserted in that moment. I don't think it's the comparison because I think there are people that generate great wealth, that have great wealth. There's people who are incredibly humble and everyone. I think, you know, happiness is, is wanting to expand your talents and abilities the best you can and give back the best you can, but also finding joy wherever you are. Capitalism works because people are willing to take risks. They're willing to work
Matt:
Yeah, but...
sam:
very hard to prove out ideas. And,
Matt:
But why take
sam:
you know.
Matt:
risks? Why would, why do we want people to take risks?
sam:
Because we don't grow without taking risks. You become sharper. We talked about this or alluded to it in the very beginning. Stress is bad over a long period of time. Pressure is good because it hones all of your physical systems. It makes you sharper. It makes you think clearer. When you take a risk and you put money up, and you put a part of your life up to prove out a concept or a product or a service, and that's not accepted in the marketplace and you lose everything, that's devastating. And the promise of America is that I can go back to work and I can work to get that back. And if my idea is good enough and I work hard enough, I have an opportunity to have the American dream. It's the entire America, what happens to the American dream under universal income? It's insanity. I
Matt:
But,
sam:
can't
Matt:
but...
sam:
believe
shawn:
Yeah
sam:
in the state of Utah we're even talking about this. This is not
Matt:
So
sam:
Portlandia
Matt:
Sam,
sam:
for heaven's sakes.
Matt:
another question I have though Sam is what you described sounds an awful lot like going to the casino, which we would not encourage people to go
sam:
Oh!
Matt:
to the casino, right? So I just wanna know like how is it different than saying how is capitalism and rewarding risk different than saying, just go to the casino?
sam:
Well, let's go to Nauvoo back in the founding of the church. So Nauvoo, or Joe, now I'm gonna go down a road. I haven't thought this out. So it'll probably break
Matt:
That's okay,
sam:
under the,
Matt:
that's okay, we're not scripted,
sam:
but
Matt:
Sam.
sam:
the church took a huge risk to build a city in Nauvoo. They went to a place where there was swamp and malaria and disease and pain and suffering. And they built one of the greatest cities at that point. Secondly, to Chicago, I think it was, in terms of population. in a place that was God forsaken and no one wanted. That was a massive risk. And they did it because they believed in their faith and they were willing to exchange their labor on their belief. And they were willing to sacrifice everything to build this place and to build a temple that they could then go worship from. And it took people that were able to generate income and stuff in excess of their need to be able to create that temple. And it meant a lot to them. You do
Matt:
So
sam:
a universal
Matt:
yeah.
sam:
basic income. How the heck does that even? I mean, it's, it's an affront to the American dream, Matt.
Matt:
So I think what I heard you say is that the difference of capitalism and a casino is a casino you're trying to get something for nothing. You're taking an insane risk with no effort, whereas
sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
capitalism
sam:
Oh.
Matt:
you're investing in your risk with your labor.
sam:
Although I would concede and I love your comparison that there's a very fine line between the two and it's probably no coincidence that you know among highly religious populations that crime prevails where people try to get something for nothing thinking they're deserving of it somehow.
shawn:
Hehehe.
sam:
Affinity crime right, financial crimes and
Matt:
Yeah,
sam:
other
Matt:
yeah,
sam:
such
Matt:
yeah.
sam:
things, people who prey on each other in religious settings. I think people trying to get something for nothing is wrong, but someone that truly believes in an idea, a service, a product. I mean, we all we have the space, we have space, we can go up to space and hang out on the moon. We can go
shawn:
Oh
sam:
explore
shawn:
boy,
sam:
Titanic.
shawn:
Sam.
sam:
Listen, those people that went down and gave their life exploring the Titanic. You know what? We're going to find out if they were absolute morons for what they did, but the technology
Matt:
We've we've
sam:
developed
Matt:
we already figured
sam:
to be able to
Matt:
that
sam:
do it.
Matt:
out.
sam:
Well,
Matt:
Yeah,
sam:
it
Matt:
they
sam:
blew up
Matt:
cut
sam:
on them.
Matt:
corners.
sam:
Yeah, they did
Matt:
Yeah.
sam:
cut corners and listen, they paid it. They paid an ultimate price. But that's another, you know, that that's a side effect. I would rather risk that than never risked before. And I think there was some great American literature that even says that. I can't remember what it is at the moment, but
Matt:
It's
sam:
I'm sure.
shawn:
Well,
Matt:
better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all.
sam:
There
Matt:
Is that what?
sam:
you go. I don't want to be one of the faint hearts that goes into the night quietly, but Matt, for heaven's sakes, come on.
shawn:
Sam,
sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
do you do you agree with the listener who said my issue with capitalism is that it meets each person's needs relative to that person's wealth? Capitalism listens twice as hard to the needs of a person with twice as much money. Do you agree with
Matt:
Of course,
shawn:
that statement?
Matt:
of course. Oh wait, you're not asking me. Ha
shawn:
No, I'm not asking you that.
sam:
Well,
Matt:
ha
sam:
of course it does. Yeah, money
Matt:
ha.
sam:
buys money buys. And in the perfect in the perfect example of capitalism, if you've attained greater wealth in theory and it doesn't always work this way, then that hopefully you're willing to reinvest that and create more opportunity around you. I listen. Capitalists right now in our world, billionaires, people with a lot of money, they are villainized and it is a shame. because I've been
Matt:
Whoa!
sam:
around people that have a lot of money who are very wealthy and they have very pure desires to help others. They have very pure desires to provide opportunities for others and they do that. They provide thousands of people with great jobs, great opportunities to improve their life and their individual situation and they're honest, good people striving to do the best. And in our culture today, that's not a popular thing.
Matt:
But
sam:
They're
shawn:
So
Matt:
would
sam:
cons...
Matt:
you
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
accept, Sam, that rich people are no different than other people, that some of them are really good and some of them are not really good, some of them worked hard to get wealthy, some of them just inherited their wealth?
sam:
Yeah, but it's not
Matt:
Would
sam:
as
Matt:
you,
sam:
random
Matt:
Gru?
sam:
as you're it's not as random as you're saying it. You're you're saying it as if, you know, 50 they got there by earning it. It's it's I think. I, you know, I think the market, I would hope the market returns better than that.
Matt:
Okay, well on another topic, another
sam:
Hey,
Matt:
listener
sam:
wait,
Matt:
pointed at...
sam:
before we go away from that though, under universal basic income map, what happens to the American dream? What then becomes the American dream? I am curious about that under that argument.
Matt:
I think that people define the American dream differently. I think that there are people that are motivated to earn and to try to accumulate wealth and try to accumulate things. But I think that there are other people that say that the American dream is just peace and prosperity and happiness. Not everybody wants to take risk and become uber wealthy. Some people are content to just have enough to meet their needs. For those people, you meet the American dream by having enough to live on that you don't have to worry about going to a job that you hate 40 hours a week or 60 hours a week. And you can serve in your community, you can participate in art classes if you want.
sam:
Oh
Matt:
You're still contributing to society, you're just doing
sam:
gosh.
Matt:
it
sam:
See,
Matt:
on your terms.
sam:
see, I disagree. The great story of immigration in the United States is doing that terrible job and sacrificing and working your way up without respect for your class or your cast or your religion or anything else and bettering your kids' situation so that they can then go to school and better their own situation. And listen,
Matt:
But
sam:
not
Matt:
the kids
sam:
everybody
Matt:
don't always
sam:
needs...
Matt:
do that, Sam.
sam:
Absolutely true. But that is the American
Matt:
Yeah.
sam:
dream though, immigrants coming to this country
Matt:
I say
sam:
for
Matt:
the,
sam:
that promise.
Matt:
I would take the American dream in the Warren Buffett sense, right? Where the Warren Buffett says I've got billions of dollars, but I'm living just an average life. I don't need those billions of dollars. And I'm not giving them to my kids. I'm going to give it away to charity and my kids can like fend for themselves. Like that's an equal kind of American dream where it's not about living this life of, I don't know, excess maybe.
sam:
Well, we're
Matt:
I don't know.
sam:
not talking about a life of excess, because I think Warren Buffett's approach is dead on. I mean, and I know many
Matt:
Yeah,
sam:
people
Matt:
but-
sam:
who have that agree with that.
Matt:
But that's not the Trump approach, right? That's not what the Trump kids are doing. That's
sam:
Wait,
Matt:
not what the Kennedy kids are doing.
sam:
Trump doesn't personify the anti-universal income crowd.
Matt:
Well, I
sam:
He
Matt:
don't
sam:
doesn't
Matt:
know.
sam:
represent that thinking. Okay, we can go to the next one. I was just curious, what of the American dream under universal income? So maybe a listener could let us know their thoughts on that.
Matt:
So we discussed previously activism towards the church and another listener pointed us to James Jones. He's a podcaster. He's an African American and a member of our church. He argues for activism towards the church. In fact, he says that sometimes it's necessary. So he uses this example in Galatians chapter 2 verses 11 through 14. Paul publicly corrects Peter for his behavior towards Gentiles. Paul says, hey Peter, when we were having dinner with me and you, and I think it's Barnabas or Barabbas, I can't remember the guy's name, you were just talking to us as you would any Gentile and it was no big deal. But then when the Jewish people were around you, you started treating us like second class citizens because we hadn't been circumcised. And he publicly calls Peter out and he says, Peter, this was wrong and you shouldn't behave that way. And... He also notes that President Uchtdorf, in a talk we put the link in the show notes, he acknowledges that people in the church have made mistakes in the past. And so he argues that if as a member of the church, I see another member of the church doing something that's not consistent with the commandments, I have an obligation to point that out and to correct them, even publicly. Even just like Paul corrects Peter, who at the time was the president of the church. we have an obligation to point out when people are doing things that are inconsistent with the commandments. So my question is, is that activism towards the church or is that something else that he's describing?
shawn:
That's it. It's a I would encourage everyone to go look at James Jones's Instagram post where he discusses it. It's super fascinating. He's very articulate.
Matt:
And we put a link to that in the show notes as well.
shawn:
Yeah, and he seems to be very faithfully, you know, approaching it with pure intent. I mean, it's a he does a fantastic job and it's controversial what he says. It is. It's some of it's hard to listen to, but it's
Matt:
But is
shawn:
yeah.
Matt:
it active, is what are you describing the same thing as activism towards the church? So, if I, let's say that I'm with President Nelson and we're like driving in a car and he's in the passenger seat and he doesn't have a seatbelt on and I say, hey, President Nelson, put your seatbelt on. That's different than saying this policy that you're doing is wrong and therefore you need to change the policy. And in order to persuade you to change the policy, I'm gonna use this activist approach and I'm gonna like do protests or I'm gonna do sit-ins or something like that.
sam:
So Matt, last week in the podcast, I kind of broached this a little bit by taking it out of the religious sphere and into the business world. And I said that I was anti-activism or I was very pro-activism before last week's conversation. But then I thought about activism in the business sense. And I'm like, there's really no need for activism. It reaps chaos in general. unless the business doesn't listen to people trying to innovate because business and social institutions they become better through input from those that work in those institutions and so as long as long as there's listening and there's collaboration and there's growth over time nothing can stay the same forever then it's a healthy organization where activism in business and social organizations is important is when it stops listening and it stops growing, adapting, or evolving as it probably should. Now, translating that or transferring that into the church is tough because we believe the church is led by a prophet called of God and that when he speaks that is as if God were speaking himself. So how do you make, how do you, how do you, you know, if someone says, hey, I need to speak with an activist voice, in this church, how dare you? I mean, how do you do that? But if you go back to business and social structures, that's probably a healthy way to respond to the need for change. And there's probably, Matt, some pretty good examples even inside the church where there's been some gentle pushing and in some cases, maybe not, that have led to clarification or evolution of policies, not maybe doctrine, that have benefited the church overall. So. I think it's a challenging thing, but it is still at heart, very American to be activist when needed.
shawn:
But Sam, we also have to be really aware and remember D&C 121, right? Reprove someone betimes with sharpness when moved upon by the Holy Ghost and then show forth afterwards an increase of love toward him so that you're not made enemies. To me, Matt, there's an important distinction. If I am going to make a decision to reprove a prophet, I better have some strong spiritual I better be moved upon by the Holy Ghost.
sam:
Yeah, but the-
shawn:
It seems like there's a lot of activism that doesn't seem to be that way, right? There was that period of time with the John DeLinn and the other gal that was pushing for
Matt:
ordained
shawn:
priest-ordained
Matt:
women movement.
shawn:
women movement. I was so open to hearing her argument. And I remember there was a time during that whole dilemma where she, or that whole... debacle that she was like, I'm going to go and make my case tomorrow. Everyone join me. I was like, great. I can't wait. And I was excited. And I said, let me hear her religion. Let me hear her spirit. Let me hear her proclaim that this activism, we should all follow because she has some spiritual guide to it. And she didn't, she talked for two hours and never once mentioned Jesus Christ or faith or the spirit. It was literally just a personal political activist approach. And I was immediately out because it didn't follow DNC 121. And I had no, there's no spirit in it. There's no truth in it.
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
So
Matt:
I also think that there's a different structure in the church, that
sam:
Yes.
Matt:
it is a large global organization, but it's also locally managed. And what you're supposed to do if you have a problem with something happening in the church is you go to your bishop and then you go to your stake president. And then if it needs to go above that, then your stake president can kind of point you to where to go. You don't need to write an email to President Oaks or to President Nelson, because we don't have all the information. We don't have like... We're not pervy to the discussions that happen when policy are made. So we're gonna go based on assumptions that may or may not be accurate. So we can have influence at the local level. And I think that works its way up like it would in any other organization. We just need to have faith in that and not try to like change major policies.
shawn:
I think that's so perfectly said, Matt. And the other thing is this, there's enough misunderstanding among all of us in our daily lives when it comes to religious principles and ideas, truths, that we're discussing it with each other all the time. Shouldn't our activism approach be more with each other,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
teaching each other and trying to inspire each other and having these good discussions with each other and move us all towards a more abundant, I guess... you know, pursuance of truth at a local level, at smaller.
Matt:
Focus on our own sphere of influence, the things
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
that we have obligations for.
shawn:
I think so.
Matt:
Okay, well let's get to the news. Some people have been waiting to discuss this for far too long, and I'm sorry for making anybody wait, but it turns out that Utah passed this law making it illegal to access pornography for minors. And so Pornhub and other online porn providers, have to like verify your age and things like that before they can allow you to access their porn sites. I'm not really like versed in these things, but I know that you can get around that because you can get a virtual private network that will make it so that your IP address from your computer, now I'm telling everybody things like how you can hack things if you need to, but it'll make
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
it so the IP address from your computer doesn't show that you are where you're currently residing or where you're like accessing the internet from. So. Once this law went into effect in Utah in May, Google Trends, and we have a link to this, shows that search in Utah searches for the term VPN. It spiked that week. It went as high as that Google records it. And then requests for virtual private networks in Utah also went up a lot during that time. So it appears that lots of people in Utah are trying to bypass porn in violation of state law. And my question is, wait, why should I care about that? Why should
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
I care if people in Utah are breaking the law to access porn?
sam:
So, so first of all, I think kudos to Utah for trying to legislate something that's very difficult and maybe even impossible to legislate, right? So they're trying to protect minors from something that's proved in this state to be incredibly addictive. I travel all over the country and I hear from time to time people who know where I'm from saying citing stats that are every now and again published that Utah's overall actually an outsized portion of pornography than any other state in the nation. And if that's true,
Matt:
Oh really?
sam:
if that's true, and maybe somebody could even validate that while we're while we're talking, if that's true, given our religious affiliation, why would that be right? And and if that's true, why then do kids with You know, I think kids obeying the law is, I'm not sure. Hey, just because, just because, uh, just because it's a law, you know, kids don't eat the higher law to the most of those kids is going to be a church authority and, and the command not to view pornography, but it, but it's fascinating to me that there's a paradox that, you know, uh, pornography is a sin and it's not something that anyone should be consuming and yet the state out, overly consumes it, right?
Matt:
I have friends from Germany that tell me regularly that in Germany you can drink alcohol at any age and that's why Germans are so responsible with their consumption of beer.
sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
Whereas in the United States, we don't let you consume alcohol until you're older and so people just go crazy drinking alcohol in an irresponsible way. So maybe Sam, other places that don't have this strong religious restriction against porn, maybe they're just responsible porn consumers.
shawn:
Ha ha.
sam:
That's your angle?
Matt:
I have no idea. Sam,
sam:
Oh my gosh!
Matt:
how would I know why anybody looks at porn? Why do I even know why people in Utah are looking at porn more than other places? Maybe in other places you can like look at porn when you're buying groceries and you can't in Utah. I don't know the answer to this question.
shawn:
Sam, you're just bringing it up because it confuses you where a state that should have such a higher, so much of a higher standard is
sam:
Well,
shawn:
doing
sam:
that's
shawn:
it.
sam:
exactly
shawn:
That's why you're
sam:
why
shawn:
confused by
sam:
I
shawn:
it.
sam:
want to know. So maybe we go to our listeners and the listeners share it with us. So it's a great paradox.
Matt:
Hey, any of you out there that are watching porn, could you tell us why?
shawn:
hahahaha
sam:
Well, so I will tell you outside of our religious community, even in other Christian religions, they don't view it the same, no pun intended, but they don't view it the same, right? They don't look at it as egregiously as we do. And so I don't know if it's stigmatized in such a way where some people are curious, but that stat, the overconsumption as a state. In fact, some of the surveys I've seen is Utah consumes top in the nation pornography overall. And then with this new law, Utah attempts to do something very noble. It's kind of proof that there's some things maybe you shouldn't legislate because it's just not going to work. And they try to do something right. And that restriction in and of itself is skirted in a very big way. It'll be interesting long term, too, to see if it. ends up sticking if they find ways around the VPN and they require companies to comply. I mean, they've got pretty hefty penalties for these porn companies if they don't comply with this law. So maybe it'll ultimately they'll have to validate VPN usage, Sean.
shawn:
Can I, Sam, can I have a word on this a little bit?
sam:
Do it.
shawn:
I remember Jacob, Jacob's talking about, he says, aggrieved with me that I must use so much boldness of speech concerning you before your wives and your children, many of whose feelings are exceedingly tender and chaste and delicate before God, which thing is so pleasing unto God? I think parents need to do a better job of protecting their kids against pornography. I think that
Matt:
Sean,
shawn:
we have
Matt:
it
shawn:
become,
Matt:
is so hard to do.
sam:
Yeah, it is so hard
shawn:
I
sam:
to
shawn:
know
sam:
do.
shawn:
it is, I know it is, but that's what I'm saying. That's why I prefaced it with Jacob, Jacob too,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
right? It's a harsh thing for us to point ourselves in the mirror and say we need to do a better job because this is a tender and chaste and delicate topic. But we do, Matt. We used, we were the guinea pigs, or at least we let our kids be the guinea pigs for this technology, the phones and such.
Matt:
Hey.
shawn:
And we need to do a better job at protecting our kids against pornography, period. It needs to consume us. We need to do better at it.
Matt:
It really would have to consume you because I'm a very controlling person as we've established in previous episodes and I've tried every single thing there is to control and you can't do it. The only way to get someone to not view pornography is for them to decide that they don't want to view it because if they want to they will find a way. There's no technology, there's no anything out there that'll stop it. You can take their phone away. You can block their wifi. They're going to find it. They just find it.
shawn:
You're saying that every human being today, because of the conditions that we live in, are going to view pornography.
sam:
No.
Matt:
I'm saying that anyone who wants it is gonna access it, no matter what you, I mentioned before that I know somebody that just sat in class all day watching it. I know other people that like, they
shawn:
Yeah, but...
Matt:
set up filters, your WiFi at some place, they set up a filter that says, hey, you can't go to certain websites. You can just create your own website with AI now, Sean,
shawn:
Sure, sure,
Matt:
and then
shawn:
but,
Matt:
you put
shawn:
okay,
Matt:
links on that to your other website and then you can, you
shawn:
it's
Matt:
can't
shawn:
true.
Matt:
stop it.
shawn:
But, but,
sam:
Matt, there's help
shawn:
no,
sam:
for
shawn:
we can.
sam:
you, man. There's
shawn:
Like,
sam:
help.
shawn:
think about it, Matt. Matt, think about it. When you, if you discovered that your school is unfiltered access to pornography through the library internet, we can go and march into that school and say, you gotta do something
Matt:
You
shawn:
about this.
Matt:
cannot.
shawn:
Like, this is ridiculous.
Matt:
You cannot.
sam:
Wait,
Matt:
They won't do anything.
sam:
Sean, how many kids do you have?
shawn:
I have two, two
Matt:
I am
shawn:
kids.
Matt:
telling you, Sean, from my own experience.
sam:
Hahaha
shawn:
No. Ha ha ha. Hi.
Matt:
Good luck. Good luck
sam:
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Matt:
in your conversation with the school library, the school technology specialist, the whoever you want to
shawn:
No,
Matt:
talk
shawn:
no,
sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
to.
shawn:
no.
sam:
because
shawn:
Let me finish
sam:
by
shawn:
my thought.
sam:
the way,
shawn:
No, no, no.
sam:
they
shawn:
Listen,
sam:
don't
shawn:
listen,
sam:
know because
shawn:
listen.
sam:
they're still trying
shawn:
Listen.
sam:
to ban the Bible. They still think it's a library.
shawn:
Yeah, that's true. That's true.
Matt:
Good luck
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
if you're the state of Utah
sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
and you want
shawn:
I'm
Matt:
to
shawn:
not,
Matt:
put it in.
sam:
Yes.
shawn:
Matt, what I'm saying is, I'm sure you then talk to your friends. I'm sure you then talk to your parents, the parents in your ward. You did some good through that experience by passing that information along. You made people aware
Matt:
Mm-mm.
shawn:
and they became better at protecting their kids.
sam:
Yeah, you don't know the
shawn:
I'm
sam:
difference
shawn:
just saying.
sam:
you made, Matt.
Matt:
I'm feeling so,
shawn:
Yeah, you don't.
Matt:
so empowered right now. I'm feeling so good about
sam:
Wait,
Matt:
my efforts
sam:
can
Matt:
in this regard.
sam:
because this was my I was so fascinated by this headline. Can we just throw this out? Let's get some listener feedback on this. What explains that paradox between the high consumption and our religious belief? And what's the solution as a state? Because I'm not sure that just putting a law in place as noble as that is. And and I. It will certainly probably help, but ultimately what is the solution?
Matt:
So I
shawn:
Well,
Matt:
used to have the... Go ahead, Sean.
shawn:
I would ask people who if they're gonna engage, consider the fact that we as parents, and I'm not saying we're failures if we fail. I agree with you, Matt, that
Matt:
Yeah
shawn:
every person has free agency. I'm not trying to judge or be, I'm just saying that we as parents can't just give up and write it off as, ah, they're gonna do what they're gonna
sam:
Sean,
shawn:
do.
sam:
I don't think
shawn:
There's
sam:
most
shawn:
more
sam:
parents
shawn:
we should
sam:
are
shawn:
do,
sam:
giving
shawn:
we should be more
sam:
up.
shawn:
active.
sam:
They're not giving up.
Matt:
I tried that approach, Sean, where it's like,
sam:
Just try harder.
Matt:
oh, I saw you watching porn. I'm going to lock you in the closet and make you watch hours of porn until you're sick of it. That didn't
shawn:
hahahaha
Matt:
work either.
sam:
You did? Did you really?
Matt:
No, no,
sam:
Oh,
Matt:
I never actually. No, no,
sam:
that's horrible.
Matt:
I didn't do that.
sam:
Okay.
Matt:
I don't have that much porn. So there was this guy, this activist, he used to come visit me and say, hey, I want, he was like, I want to get rid of porn in libraries. And what can I do? What laws can I pass to get rid of porn? And he had all these laws like, you know, IP addresses and all of that stuff. And I'm like, people are going to get around that. And so what I would say to him, I would say, do you really want to get rid of pornography? You tax pornography to death. And if pornography is not making money off of the people coming to their sites, then they're going to stop doing it as much. And so if you taxed like to death
sam:
Wait!
Matt:
pornography and then take that money and give it as a universal basic income.
sam:
Wait, wait before you said universal basic income just to appease just a you realize you just went down a very capitalist approach to a practical problem. Like I could
Matt:
Sure,
sam:
I could hug you right
Matt:
we can,
sam:
now. That's that's exactly what you
shawn:
Yeah
sam:
should
Matt:
I love
sam:
do.
Matt:
using capitalism to punish bad people. I'm not opposed to using
sam:
Holy
Matt:
the principle,
sam:
cow.
Matt:
but no, but Sam, don't you agree?
sam:
Yeah!
Matt:
If you just tax porn to death,
sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
you could just make it
sam:
As
Matt:
way less accessible to
sam:
yes,
Matt:
people.
sam:
as long as you don't give people enough
Matt:
Because
sam:
money to
Matt:
we
sam:
pay
Matt:
can
sam:
that
Matt:
track,
sam:
tax
Matt:
we
sam:
on the
Matt:
can
sam:
other
Matt:
track
sam:
side.
Matt:
everything that, you can track everything that somebody puts on their
sam:
Yes.
Matt:
phone. So every time someone visits your website, this much money is what you're going to pay to us. and then they'll find a way to block people from coming to their websites.
sam:
I, that would have to be thought
Matt:
Okay.
sam:
out a little bit, but that's not a bad idea. Nice job, man.
shawn:
Once again, Matt, you're solving gospel problems with government.
sam:
No,
Matt:
Hahaha
sam:
this is an economic solution, but yes.
Matt:
Okay, so it's kind of big in the news now that so scientists have figured out that MDMA, the street name of this drug is ecstasy. They can use this to treat a number of different mental disorders. So it's successful with PTSD, anxiety, depression, even racism. This is something I think is kind of an interesting take on this. So some of the early research on the benefits of MDMA came from studies of members of our church in the early 2000s. because scientists were like, okay, we want to figure out the effects of ecstasy, but we need to find a population that's not smoking tobacco and not drinking alcohol, that's just doing ecstasy. And they're like, wow, look at all these rave parties in Utah. There's all these Mormon teens that are like, well, no, tobacco is against the word
sam:
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Matt:
of wisdom and alcohol is against the word of wisdom, but ecstasy is not against the word of wisdom. And so that
shawn:
Yikes.
Matt:
was some of the first research on like potential benefits of this drug. was studies of LDS people back in the 2000s. So there are a lot of illegal drugs that are not specifically banned from the word of wisdom by name. You know, I think that we say illegal narcotics, but we're in an age now where it's like, okay, marijuana is being legal and it's being legalized in lots of places. And there are some church statements that say, hey, you shouldn't use marijuana recreationally, but I don't know that that's really sunk into people's heads. Paul H. Peterson wrote a master's thesis while he was at BYU for his history degree that traces the history of the word of wisdom. And we have a link to a lot of these things in our show notes. But basically what he shows is that until the 1930s, the word of wisdom wasn't widely practiced among members of the church. And alcohol and tobacco restrictions were not strongly enforced until President Grant who was a strong proponent of prohibition and spent a lot of time talking about like, we need to stop using alcohol and tobacco as members of the church. So he kind of goes through this history, how like the activism with prohibition also was happening at the same time as making the word of wisdom, a requirement to enter the temple and things like that. So it seems like social conditions. are often associated with revelation that people receive on the word of wisdom. So the question is, is it time to revisit which substances are banned in the word of wisdom?
shawn:
But
Matt:
Like.
shawn:
well, Matt, there never really has been a published list of what is and what isn't banned in the Word of Wisdom other than...
Matt:
Temple recommend interview questions,
shawn:
Well,
Matt:
right?
shawn:
specifically-
Matt:
If you wanna get baptized or if you wanna go to the temple, then it's coffee, tea, tobacco, alcohol, and illicit narcotics.
shawn:
point. Okay, so you're saying that needs to be you're suggesting
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
that
Matt:
some
shawn:
should be revised?
Matt:
marijuana is not in that list. And I guarantee there are people out there saying marijuana is fine, cause that's not an illicit drug. And clearly there were some kids in the 2000s that were like, ecstasy is not in that list, so it's fine. And I haven't heard any like general conference talks about the word of wisdom in a long time. I know that there was something in like the new era or the youth magazine, like maybe 10 years ago that was like. You know, you shouldn't be doing energy drinks either, but there's not anything like really clear about the word of wisdom right now. And I think that as MDMA and these other sorts of drugs become legal, then like there's this real chance that people will be like, what is the, really? I can't smoke a cigarette, but I can smoke marijuana.
shawn:
Matt, you said that part of the temple recommend questions is narcotics.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
So narcotics
Matt:
Well.
shawn:
are any substance that affects mood or behavior consumed
Matt:
anti-depressant
shawn:
for medical or non consumed for non medical or medical purposes. So it's
Matt:
That's a narcotic.
shawn:
that's
Matt:
So
shawn:
a narcotic.
Matt:
like an antidepressant.
shawn:
I mean, do you think
Matt:
or
shawn:
that's
Matt:
aspirin.
shawn:
what is being, do you think that's what's being asked
Matt:
That's what
shawn:
in
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
the
Matt:
saying,
shawn:
temple recommend question?
Matt:
it's not clear, right? So I guess
sam:
Does
Matt:
I could
sam:
it
Matt:
ask
sam:
need
Matt:
my
sam:
to be
Matt:
vision.
sam:
clear?
Matt:
I don't know, it just seems like, so it seems odd to me where people are like, I'm not drinking coffee, but I'm drinking like this monster energy drink, right? Or I know a lot of people that like, the tea beverages and all, like it just seems like there's this whole world of like, what is the word of wisdom talking about? And maybe we need to sort of revisit it to help clarify some things. Don't you think clarification would be helpful?
shawn:
Or, Matt, do you think that the Lord sometimes allows vague, for example, the Sabbath day, how to really treat the Sabbath day wholly? It's pretty vague. There's not a lot of instructions. There was during the Law of Moses,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
but there's not today. And I wonder if certain things, and the Word of Wisdom was very strict and specific during the Law of Moses, but we don't live that law. And
Matt:
How
shawn:
so
Matt:
am I
shawn:
perhaps—
Matt:
supposed to teach somebody that alcohol is naughty but ecstasy? Sure.
shawn:
Why would
sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
you
sam:
why
shawn:
come
sam:
would
shawn:
to
sam:
you?
shawn:
that conclusion? Ecstasy is clearly
sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
a narcotic.
Matt:
Okay, marijuana, like mar-
shawn:
Clearly a narcotic.
sam:
I don't, I would argue that there's no rational member of the church that would read the dark, the word of wisdom and conclude that recreational marijuana is acceptable.
shawn:
Yeah, I
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
think that's
Matt:
but
shawn:
someone.
Matt:
young people aren't always rational.
sam:
I know, but you, you fix that or you solve that by what Sean talks so passionately often about, and those are conversations around the dinner table, study of the scripture, engaging with them and teaching them the right things rather than. Um, I mean, I remember, do you, do you remember there was a, there was a conference talk. I don't remember when it was, but there was a, there was a conference talk where there was some comment made about a member of the church should never go into a Starbucks. And should never and should never be seen holding a Starbucks cup. And.
Matt:
they have delicious
sam:
All right,
Matt:
hot cocoa.
sam:
it's ludicrous,
shawn:
I'm sorry.
sam:
like
Matt:
Yeah,
sam:
you,
Matt:
it's
sam:
you count
Matt:
really
sam:
the number
Matt:
yummy.
sam:
of Starbucks in like, it's not, it's not about what you're holding and what it looks like and where you are as much as it is the impact on your body and the promised blessings of following the word of wisdom. And I don't know, I kind of side with Sean that that's a personal process where You, you learn that and, and you come to be convinced of it. Like, you know, I have a lot of friends outside,
Matt:
So
sam:
outside
Matt:
here.
sam:
the church that would love to not drink ever alcohol and who claimed to be a little bit jealous that I don't, and, uh, I, I think further clarifying it would take away some of the benefit, but you know what, as soon as I say that it's crazy. because things will change and they'll clarify it. We'll talk about how great it is and why it needed to be clarified. So I'm open. I'm open either way.
shawn:
Matt, but I think you're at risk there in Utah and Idaho at bankrupting the state if you make caffeinated sodas illegal. And part of that word of wisdom, I mean.
Matt:
I'm not advocating for like what should be, so here's where my issue comes in. So when Sean defines narcotic for us, then we say, well, it's okay to use narcotics under the direction of a physician if you have a prescription. And in my opinion, that empowers certain kinds of medical professionals relative to other kinds of medical professionals. And it says like, this person can give you a drug and you don't have to think for yourself. just take the drug that they're giving you. But if on your own you study ecstasy, for example, and you say, hey, ecstasy is gonna be helpful for my health, or like there's this herbal, whatever remedy, or marijuana, or whatever, like in some ways, the word of wisdom, the way that it's set up, where it's like these things you can't ever do, and these things you can do if a doctor tells you to do it, it's sort of like, it limits human freedom, and then it also like, yeah, I don't know, just. It creates this weird sort of two tier system that
sam:
You
Matt:
I'm not
sam:
always,
Matt:
a huge fan of.
sam:
you always want
shawn:
I feel
sam:
more,
shawn:
like Matt, I don't think
sam:
you always
shawn:
the word
sam:
want
shawn:
of wisdom...
sam:
more government oversight, Matt. You always want more. Stop it, would you?
Matt:
No,
shawn:
Matt, the...
Matt:
I'm saying that to say to somebody you can smoke marijuana if you have a prescription. I
sam:
By
Matt:
have a
sam:
the
Matt:
problem
sam:
way...
Matt:
with that.
shawn:
But Matt, the word of wisdom doesn't say that though, Matt. It doesn't offer...
Matt:
But that's the way the church is interpreting the word of wisdom with the marijuana legalization in state by state.
shawn:
How so are they doing that? You're saying
Matt:
They say
shawn:
that they've
Matt:
that you shouldn't use recreational marijuana, but if you're using it under the direction of a physician, then that's a different thing, that's okay. And you see it in the language that they create in laws in these states that, well, you can use medicinal marijuana, but not recreational
shawn:
Right.
Matt:
marijuana. Well, medicinal
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
marijuana means that I have to go to a doctor and get a prescription, and I can't just say, I'm using this the same way the doctor would tell me, but without a prescription. Do
sam:
I just
Matt:
you
sam:
think
Matt:
see what I'm saying?
sam:
if you're in a place where you're rationalizing your
shawn:
Yeah.
sam:
behavior like that, then it probably doesn't really help you much anyway, right? Like, I, but as soon as I say that, they'll probably come out
shawn:
That's
sam:
and clarify
shawn:
true,
sam:
it more.
shawn:
yeah.
sam:
But I do remember the statement about not going in Starbucks and I had to use Starbucks Wi-Fi every week for work and it scared me because I was like, well, do I sit in my car?
shawn:
No!
sam:
Do
Matt:
Oh,
shawn:
Hehehehehehe
sam:
I
Matt:
oh.
sam:
wear sunglasses
Matt:
Did you?
sam:
and put a fake beard on? Like how do I do this?
Matt:
That's why
shawn:
Hehehehe
Matt:
they have the barcode on your temple recommend now, Sam, so that they can track you
shawn:
If you
Matt:
and
shawn:
go
sam:
It's
shawn:
to
Matt:
deactivate
sam:
not a barcode
shawn:
Starbucks.
Matt:
it.
sam:
because of the word bar.
Matt:
Oh,
sam:
It's
Matt:
it's not.
sam:
a QR code. Yes.
Matt:
It's a Scantron.
sam:
Thank you.
Matt:
Hey, well, let's move to the big question because this is one I'm super excited about. So
shawn:
Oh boy.
Matt:
there is a persistent pay gap in the United States between men and women, and it's about women earn about 75% 75 cents on the dollar compared to men. And then if you compare whites to racial minorities, it's about the same. Racial minorities earn about 75 cents to every dollar that a white person earns. And you can look over the last 20 years, government policies have done little to reverse this. But do you know what has reversed this is unions. Unions have a long history of helping workers obtain better working conditions. They've led the charge for worker safety, paid leave, healthcare, retirement, financial security, and every worker benefits from unions, even if you're not part of a union. This is a non-governmental organization, a union, that's helping to make lives better for all workers. And I just think, why would any worker ever support a right to work law in their state? Because unions help everybody. So you're with me on this, right Sam? Unions help everybody.
shawn:
Matt,
sam:
I don't
shawn:
hold
sam:
accept
shawn:
on Sam,
sam:
the
shawn:
hang
sam:
premise
shawn:
on Sam,
sam:
of the question,
shawn:
before you
sam:
but
shawn:
go into,
sam:
Sean apparently wants to say something
shawn:
yeah, hold
sam:
before
shawn:
on
sam:
I
shawn:
Sam,
sam:
reveal truth. Yeah.
shawn:
before you go into attack mode, Matt, Sam, before you go into attack mode, because I know you're just raring to go. Matt, you know where there is also a huge pay gap?
Matt:
Where?
shawn:
Randy Weingarten, who is the president of the largest union in the country, makes $560,000 per year.
Matt:
Uh-huh.
shawn:
to be president of this union.
Matt:
Well, that's not
shawn:
Now the
Matt:
an
shawn:
teachers,
Matt:
easy job.
shawn:
now the teachers, Matt, the teachers in that union averaged what, 46,000 a year? That seems like a pretty big pay gap to me.
Matt:
Well, okay, you can have a pay gap in different professions, right? Like, I'm okay with that, but if you told me that a woman teacher is going to make 75 cents on the dollar of a man teacher who has the exact same education and the exact same amount of experience, then that would be wrong. And the
shawn:
That's
Matt:
reason
shawn:
true,
Matt:
you don't
shawn:
but...
Matt:
see that with teachers is because they're unionized and
sam:
Hey,
Matt:
the unions
sam:
can I ask
Matt:
equalize.
sam:
a question?
shawn:
It's true, but the stigma, but the stigma, Matt, of unions is that it is a corrupt, they're corrupt organizations
Matt:
They're not.
shawn:
that feed the pockets of the leadership. 560,000? We have talked five or six podcast episodes about teachers and how they don't get paid well enough.
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
How do you have the largest union in the country, the teachers union, and the leadership making millions and millions of dollars? And there's still this.
Matt:
You said $560,000.
shawn:
Oh, sorry.
Matt:
Hundreds and hundreds of thousands of dollars.
shawn:
Sorry, my bad.
Matt:
Go
shawn:
I'm
Matt:
ahead,
shawn:
just saying,
Matt:
Sam.
shawn:
there's
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
a stigma there,
sam:
You
shawn:
but
sam:
wanted
shawn:
yeah,
sam:
to
shawn:
go
sam:
talk
shawn:
ahead, Sam.
sam:
about unions last week and you're using gender pay gaps as the, as, as the justification for unions.
Matt:
That was one of them. I also talked about worker safety, healthcare benefits, paid work leave, retirement benefits. You show me, so back in the day, I worked at a bank in West Valley, Utah. And I would help people kind of manage their wealth, manage their retirement. And I would see workers that had worked their whole lives in some industry that were non-union. And they had really... Bad retirement plans, if anything at all, they had nothing saved, they were in really tight financial situations. But somebody from the Teamsters Union came in, or the Pipeworkers Union, those people were taken care of for the rest of their lives. With healthcare in their older years, with money that would kind of go up each year, that wasn't dependent on government. Like the unions figured out a way to take care of workers in a way that
sam:
They
Matt:
nobody
sam:
have
Matt:
else
sam:
in the
Matt:
has.
sam:
past. So back when unions came into existence, I think they served a very worthy and an important role. And it wasn't it was a little bit equalization of that, but it was also protecting workers against poor working conditions. To your point, safety and giving, you know, laborers, hard laborers a voice so that, you know, they weren't down in a mine just. subject to work in horrible conditions without fair pay. What's happened over the years though, unfortunately,
Matt:
Yeah.
sam:
with these unions as they've evolved is they're requiring members to pay a fee, which then goes into these large chests and then fewer people are making decisions about how to use that and there have been repeated instances of theft and corruption and misuse of those funds
shawn:
and political
sam:
So,
shawn:
activism, of course.
Matt:
Which is good, I mean
sam:
well,
Matt:
you need
sam:
it's
Matt:
to use politics to pass these
sam:
political
Matt:
laws.
sam:
activism is good unless it's corrupt activism, right? And it's and it's not it's not and it's not to the benefit of that union. So I've seen more instances where those unions threaten and harass their own members more than. And this is a tricky subject because they are very powerful organizations, not what they used to be, but they still are very powerful organizations.
Matt:
Yeah.
sam:
And and, you know, I think scripture tells us when you get a little bit of power, you know, you wield that and you know, they will act unfairly against their own members of those who decide to step outside a line with the way they're approaching business, whether they decide to strike and somebody wants to cross a picket line. I mean, in our day and age, there are better mechanisms for labor's voice to be heard. than those unions. I mean, I'm familiar with retail organizations that have said, hey, we're not going to use union labor to build something. And the unions will come in and they'll actually have union laborers pick up, picket the business for not using the labor, which again, the, the labor, the, the labor contract and the terms of that labor don't benefit the individual. I've actually seen many of those contracts in those negotiations. They benefit the the union. The labor in today's marketplace, it's such a competitive market, the labor can negotiate better with in a work environment than a union can third party. And so it ends up benefiting the union more than the individual.
shawn:
So Sam.
sam:
And then it's ironic as they come and picket supposedly
shawn:
Yeah.
sam:
these laborers, you actually come to find out that these people picketing aren't actually union workers, they're homeless people paid you know, five, 10 bucks an hour to go stand out in front of businesses with picket signs. So.
shawn:
So Matt, I'm with Sam here that the idea and the concept of unions is absolutely amazing, right? Individuals coming together through free exchange to become a powerful force to benefit their lives. I think it's amazing. And
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
just like in business and government, there's obviously going to be corruption throughout unions. I'm with Sam though. It does seem like I was looking at the largest, again, the teachers' unions are the largest in the country. I was looking at all their milestones that they've accomplished. And in the beginning, I was like, wow, look what they've done. For example, they were the ones that got equal pay for black teachers starting in
Matt:
See?
shawn:
1918,
Matt:
See
shawn:
right?
Matt:
that?
shawn:
School boards and equal education for kids. All good stuff. But
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
you know what their most recent in the last 20 years, their most recent milestone is they spent 10 million dollars for an online app called Share My Lesson.
Matt:
That's
shawn:
And.
Matt:
a big deal. Like that's something
shawn:
It's.
Matt:
that really helps all teachers, right? Being able to share ideas, especially for new teachers.
shawn:
It's technology that someone owns. It's an app that
Matt:
If
shawn:
someone
Matt:
you...
shawn:
owns. It's a network and a directory that is absolutely benefiting someone financially.
Matt:
Do you know the best success that I can think of recently with unions is the Delta Airlines pilots, right? They had to fly
shawn:
Oh
Matt:
all of this stuff through the pandemic and then their salaries weren't being raised. They weren't getting the working conditions they wanted. So they went on strike and then they got what they wanted from Delta Airlines.
shawn:
So Matt, if you listen to Milton Friedman talk about this, he says that the best example of unions working is the airline pilot union.
Matt:
Yeah, it's a good union.
shawn:
But he mocks it because he says, those airline pilots already are making good money. They were very smart and unionized and they make even more money and benefit themselves even more.
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
But he's trying to say that most unions who are trying to be the representatives fighting for the little man. aren't doing nearly as good. Teachers union is a great example. Teachers
Matt:
Do
shawn:
make no money.
Matt:
you know who else who has a great union is the Major League Baseball Players Association, the NBA Players Association?
shawn:
Oh boy.
Matt:
Those unions are representing multi-millionaires and
shawn:
So
Matt:
they
shawn:
isn't
Matt:
still
shawn:
that the...
Matt:
see the value in unionizing because if you guys are telling me that power corrupts and I say, okay, well then why doesn't that apply to CEOs and to the billionaire class? It's going to corrupt them too. So you need to fight and say, Look, as the TV revenue comes in and the NBA owners are making more money, we're going to force you to share that revenue with us. And what you guys are going to want to play salary caps on teams so that they don't have so that to limit the amount of money that they can pay players. And
shawn:
I
Matt:
we're
shawn:
agree
Matt:
going
shawn:
with
Matt:
to
shawn:
you,
Matt:
fight
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
to make you get rid of that so that players
shawn:
Totally
Matt:
can
shawn:
agree.
Matt:
share more.
shawn:
I totally agree with you. I think what Sam's saying, correct me if I'm wrong, Sam, is the concept of unions is a very good one. The application of unions, not so good. It really benefits the powerful and the rich. It doesn't so much, yes, of course it does. There are instances, obviously, where it helps the workers, but not nearly as much.
Matt:
If the workers in a union don't like the contract that was negotiated, they vote down the contract. If the
shawn:
Okay, but.
Matt:
workers in the union don't like what the union boss is doing, they vote for a new union boss. If they don't like the pay, they vote for a different pay for that person. It's all done democratically through elections. The workers are still in control of what happens.
shawn:
Have you seen that famous documentary?
Matt:
Hahaha! All I'm saying is the unions work for the really rich employees, they would work for the really poor employees too. And I will never...
shawn:
That's
Matt:
I will
shawn:
exactly right, Matt.
Matt:
never understand why the working class does not want to have unions in every single industry. It
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
would
shawn:
but
Matt:
benefit them so much.
shawn:
let's talk about that, Matt, real quick. Because your question about this topic is, why would anyone not want to be a part of a, what was your question, let's see.
Matt:
Right to work laws, right? So
shawn:
The right
Matt:
right to
shawn:
to
Matt:
work
shawn:
work law.
Matt:
laws are these laws that make it harder for unions to organize in your state.
shawn:
Well, that's, I don't know, man. I thought that wasn't how I researched it. That's not the right to work law. Basically. If it's a right to work state, that basically gives, um, that forces companies to require that their employees work within a union, right? So the dues are basically your dues are basically taken from you no matter what. If you want to be a part of the union or not, you're, you're getting forced to pay those dues, that's what
Matt:
That's
shawn:
right to
Matt:
the
shawn:
work
Matt:
way
shawn:
is.
Matt:
that conservatives market right to work laws. But that's not the real, it's already illegal to force someone, like without a right, you don't have to be a right to work state to make that illegal. Federal law makes it illegal for a union to compel somebody to be a part of their union. So they say that as their justification for creating these right to work laws, but the right to work laws that states are passing just make it hard for unions to organize in a state.
shawn:
That's
Matt:
And so,
shawn:
not what I studied. I studied that it literally gives... So if California is a right to work, I can go work for someone and they can't take my wages without my consent
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
in order to pay the union.
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
Not in a not in Sam, not in a in a state that isn't a right to work state.
Matt:
So there's a lot of details in what it means to be right to work. There's a whole set of policies in those laws. And that's, Sean, the one that you're talking about is the way that they sort of like sell it to the mass public to get them to support it. But broadly what it's about is how many votes are required in order to unionize, where you can hold those meetings, what the businesses can and can't do to retaliate against you if you decide you want to unionize. It's this whole package of things or billed as right to work. And they say it's just about not forcing people to pay union fees, but mostly it's about making it hard for unions to exist in those states. And I say, why wouldn't people, like setting aside that particular set of policies, every state, every worker should want to unionize and should want to be a part of a union. I'll never understand
shawn:
Well, so
Matt:
why they don't.
shawn:
I'll read, hang on Matt, I'll read the Wikipedia statement, I'll have to give you the references if we can post them.
Matt:
No, no,
shawn:
A
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
right to work law gives workers the freedom to choose whether or not to join a labor union in the workplace.
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
So in a non-right
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
to work state, you have no choice. The company can require that your money is taken from your paycheck to pay the union whether you choose to be in it or not.
Matt:
Yeah, but a company's never gonna try and organize a union in their organization. Yeah, they do.
shawn:
Right. So Sam, the right to work state, yeah, the right to work state prohibits that from happening. The right to work state eliminates the ability to basically take your wages if you don't want to be in a union.
Matt:
Well, so Sean, this is from the AFL-CIO, which is a very large union. So
shawn:
They're a union.
Matt:
it's possible that their information is biased.
shawn:
They're the largest union, by the way, the largest union.
Matt:
But they say, on average, workers in states with right to work laws make $8,000 less a year. The poverty rate in those states is 12% higher. The rate of workplace deaths is 50% higher. And they have 11.7%... of people younger than 65 uninsured in those states. hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah Well, of course the unions are gonna be opposed to right to work. Of course that. I understand that. Well, I'm just saying like, I'm saying that everybody should be pro-union, right?
shawn:
I'm Pro Union, I am Pro Union.
Matt:
Hey, that reminds me of another thing President Biden did. I'm trying to make this list because people will frequently say, what has Joe Biden done that's any good?
shawn:
Yeah
Matt:
And I remember now, we almost had a rail worker strike that would have shut down the whole economy and Joe Biden negotiated a good compromise there where the union chose not to strike. He kind of like forced the rail lines to work with the unions on this railway worker strike. That was a big deal. Most Republicans didn't talk to- hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
shawn:
Hehehehehehe Matt, hey Sam, you're a movie buff. Have you seen the documentary from 1976 called the Harlan County, USA?
Matt:
Uh...
shawn:
No?
Matt:
wait, is that something to do with King Henry VIII and chopping off wanting to marry?
shawn:
No, that's Sam's favorite movie. No. I'm
Matt:
Was
shawn:
saying
Matt:
this...
shawn:
this is Harlan County USA is heralded as one of the most, one of the best documentaries of all time. It was,
Matt:
What?
shawn:
yes, it was coverage of the 1973 Brookside strike, 180 coal miners and their wives fought against Duke Power Company and they caught it all on tape, the entire process. It's
Matt:
Wow.
shawn:
the greatest documentary almost ever made. It's so good.
Matt:
Wow.
shawn:
Yeah. Yeah, go watch it. And this is definitely, I think it's a pro-union. I mean, the outcome kind of makes you jump on the side of the union.
Matt:
I didn't know there was like a Roger Ebert of documentaries.
shawn:
Sam, Sam is.
Matt:
No, I wish I could unionize, but no, that will not happen.
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
Some universities do, and a lot of universities, the faculty have unionized.
shawn:
Hey, Matt, you started this whole discussion off by showing how unions have helped the pay gaps in certain areas. Did you know that governor Ron DeSantis, who you really like,
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
has
Matt:
Love.
shawn:
signed a law that has approved more than a billion dollars for teacher pay in
Matt:
Mmm.
shawn:
the next year's budget? $252 million increase over the current record.
Matt:
Wow.
shawn:
So Florida has invested $3.3 billion for teachers.
Matt:
I think that's a great idea. That's wonderful.
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
Wow, if only he could be president of the United States.
shawn:
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
Matt:
Hey, listener, thanks for joining us for another week of the Latter-day Lens. You might have noticed as we discussed some of these topics that we might lack expertise. For example, Sean didn't seem to know much about pornography.
shawn:
Hahahaha
Matt:
And I don't know, maybe there's stuff about right to work laws. You didn't like what we said. As you can see, we are always happy to open the mailbag and read your comments. So. Let us know what you think and join us again next week. Thanks everybody. recording
shawn:
Man, you guys are a riot.
Matt:
Hahaha Hahaha Really?
shawn:
Unions are, Sam, unions are... American.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
There's your teaser clip, Matt, there's your teaser clip for the podcast episode.
Matt:
I have to be careful what I say, but they are the scum of the earth.
shawn:
I'm out. But Sam, the concept of a union is very American and very good, right?
Matt:
Are you
shawn:
Individuals?
Matt:
going to tell me Jimmy Hoffa was corrupt? Not Jimmy Hoffa Jr. I think what happened was... I think that unions are good. I think that what happened was when the mafia decided to kind of try to legitimize what they were doing a little bit, they kind of jumped in bed with some of these unions, and some of these unions got themselves into some pretty deep problems. And now you've got organized crime involved in some of that stuff, which, you know, you don't want them
shawn:
Why didn't
Matt:
in your
shawn:
you
Matt:
leadership.
shawn:
say that? Why didn't you say that in the podcast?
Matt:
Because that's not about unions. That's just about a couple of unions, right? That's like saying, what do I think about? I don't know. What do I think about computers? And then I'm going to talk about some bad computer manufacturer in China. That doesn't tell us about computers. There's just some bad apples. Hahahaha Hahaha!
shawn:
Oh god.
Matt:
Oh man, somebody in my ward was like, Hey, I heard you have a podcast, I would love to listen to it. I'm like, Yeah, listen. And then he's like, What do you talk about? And then I sort of was telling him and he's like, wanting to talk about those issues with me. And I'm like, I don't
shawn:
Uh
Matt:
think
shawn:
oh.
Matt:
you're gonna want to have this conversation with me. You should just listen to the podcast. Because I'm not gonna say it to you.
shawn:
Good.
Matt:
In church. My son, he's excited because he turns 18 before the presidential election and he gets to vote. And he's like, if it's Kamala Harris, I'm voting for her. If it's Biden, I'm voting for him. I love the Democrats. And the other day he's like, I think maybe I'm a Democrat.
shawn:
Which son, which son, Matt?
Matt:
Jacob, he's
shawn:
Aw,
Matt:
like,
shawn:
Jacob.
Matt:
maybe
shawn:
Ha ha
Matt:
I'm a Democrat.
shawn:
ha.
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
said
Matt:
there's
Sam:
almost
Matt:
worse
Sam:
like
Matt:
things.
Sam:
that's akin to sexual orientation.
Matt:
find myself attracted to these democratic ideas and policies. I don't know what to do. Is there a pill I could take? Is there a therapist I could visit with? No, I don't want to out
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories