The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
June 28, 2023: The Bible is Back! Hunter Biden vs Donald Trump, Stem-Cell Chicken? How to find the truth
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Parents rights activists have been concerned about some of the materials available to children in public school libraries. Last year, they lobbied for a new law that would allow parents to challenge materials available in libraries and request that items be removed if they are not appropriate for children. Last month, parents in Davis County, Utah, successfully challenged to get the Bible removed from public school libraries in that school district. Recently other parents have challenged the Book of Mormon based on the same premise. After news of the Bible ban went viral officials in Davis School District reversed their decision this past week. The Bible is now allowed in elementary and middle school libraries in Davis School District. They said that, “The magnitude of the value of the Bible as a literary work outweighs any violence or profanity which may be contained in the book.” This looks to me like a judgment call. Who should decide whether a book is so important that a library should overlook the violence or profanity that might be contained in the book?
Hunter Biden is taking a plea deal for crimes related to tax-evasion. The deal will allow him to avoid prison time and he will only plead guilty to felonies. The House Ways and Means Committee alleges that the Department of Justice interfered in this case and gave preferential treatment to Hunter Biden. Meanwhile, Donald Trump has been indicted by a special prosecutor for mishandling classified documents and obstruction of justice. Some see this as evidence that the Department of Justice does not treat people equally. That the rich and powerful (and Democrats) get off easy, while Republicans are treated more harshly. What is happening here?
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration gave UPSIDE a greenlight, signaling its cultivated chicken is safe to eat. Last week, the U.S. Department of Agriculture approved UPSIDE's label, and today (Wednesday) the USDA issued a grant of inspection, which means the company has cleared the final regulatory hurdle and can begin sales. For people those who may not know, cultivated chicken is chicken raised from stem-cells in a factory. It tastes like chicken, because it is chicken, but it has never been alive. Is it ethical to eat? Is it Vegan? This probably won’t stop with chicken, Chinese companies exist that cultivate all kinds of things including human organs. Should we embrace this future?
The Book of Mormon promises that “by the power of the Holy Ghost [w]e may know the truth of all things.”, but there are some things that have not been revealed. How can we sort out the truth when it has not been revealed? For example, after
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Sam:
So this would be a classic Russia, Stalin move for Putin, which trump up some sort of a fake deal rift between him and Wagner.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Wagner, he wants to get out of Ukraine. That's a terrible position for him to be in. He has Wagner come mark on, uh, on Moscow. And as a result, everybody that's anti-Putin comes out of the closet and starts supporting Wagner. Wagner marches into Moscow, shakes hands with Putin, and they kill everybody that's against Putin, and they live happily ever after. And as a result, they're out of Ukraine. Putin has no adversaries or anybody against him in his court anymore, and he somewhat saves face with some little prick. I was wondering that this morning, and it's curious
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
that it's stopped now. Is that too much thinking?
shawn:
you're referencing to the news today that the Wagner group run by Prigozhin last night came marching on Moscow. Like they've rebelled and Putin's
Sam:
They did.
shawn:
right. And Putin's calling it a rebellion. He's calling it anarchy and he's calling it like, hey, we're not gonna have
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
this. So that's turmoil. That's good,
Sam:
They
Matt:
So
shawn:
right?
Sam:
turned
Matt:
what I
Sam:
around
Matt:
would say,
Sam:
sometimes.
Matt:
I think that Russia has a long history of this. History repeats itself. And this is exactly how the Soviet Union came to power. Russia was fighting in World War I. They needed more troops and armaments in World War I, so they instituted a draft. And the Russians all went to the front line in World War I and then felt like their government had abandoned them. And so then they just turned their rifles on the Tsar and overthrew the Tsar. And that's always, I've always thought that this was the big threat. of Putin's mobilization in Ukraine is that at some point the citizens will just decide to turn their weapons on Putin and overthrow him. And I don't know, I think it's possible that it's not over. I think it's possible that some Russians, now that you've given them arms and you've trained them, will say, why do we want Putin? Why don't we want Wagner instead? Because
shawn:
Oh.
Matt:
Wagner is like a war hero. He has all of the military successes behind him. Putin has all the military failures on his shoulders. And so it's easy for Wagner to say, I'm a war hero. I'm a military hero. Why are we having Putin instead of me?
shawn:
That
Sam:
The
shawn:
would
Sam:
problem
shawn:
be,
Sam:
is Wagner's every bit as bad a guy as Putin. Isn't he Sean? I mean, he is
Matt:
Pre-growshian?
Sam:
a thug.
shawn:
so yeah.
Sam:
Our
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
And
Sam:
pregosian. Yeah.
shawn:
his army is plucked from all the prisoners in Russia.
Matt:
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Look, I'm not hoping he becomes the leader. Well, all this does is make me fearful. In the age of nuclear weapons, we've never
Sam:
Right.
Matt:
had a country with nuclear weapons at civil war. So there's two things to be worried about. First, will the Russians use the nuclear weapons against their own people? That would be something I would be concerned about. But more than that, what if Wagner decides that he really does want to try and overthrow Putin and he needs resources? and he's able to capture a nuclear weapons facility and it's under his control, he's motivated to sell those weapons or to give those weapons to bad actors who are gonna give him the resources to overthrow Putin. So there's a lot of danger and risk to the world when there's a civil war in a country that's nuclear armed.
shawn:
Doesn't this also speak to how Russia's history of war, Matt and Sam, hasn't it been, you basically view your citizens as disposable, like, they don't seem to have the technology that a lot of countries have, because Putin's strategy and Russia's strategy has always been just throw bodies, we have bodies, that's what we've got, we've got tons of bodies, let's just throw bodies. And the devaluation of the human life seems to be their approach to war. And when you do that, you start making angry the people. I hope, it seems like what's happening.
Matt:
Yeah, I think generally that Russians are more comfortable with authoritarian rule than the Americans are. And I think that what we value freedom as kind of like this bedrock value of our country, like we're sort of founded on freedom and things like that. And I think that Russians value security and safety more than they value like individual freedom. So I think they're not as afraid. I think actually... I'm not saying you're wrong, Sean, about saying that they view that, that like the leaders might view the people as like just weapons or like tools or something like that. But I just think that the citizens are a little more comfortable with that. It's all it's like that's the price they pay.
shawn:
So a few weeks ago I sat at dinner with members of the church. One was a member of the church. They were Russians who had within 24 hours decided they needed to flee Russia because they felt
Sam:
Wow.
shawn:
like they were going to get conscripted because they were on lists because they were members of the church because for various
Matt:
Was this
shawn:
reasons,
Matt:
like a year ago?
shawn:
a couple of weeks ago.
Matt:
Oh, wow. Okay.
shawn:
Yeah. And they basically says, look, once we realized that we were on the lists, because we were members of the church, there was another 20, 10 years ago, he was kind of running campaigns or helping with the anti-Putin effort. He,
Matt:
Eesh.
shawn:
yeah, he realized within
Matt:
Does
shawn:
24
Matt:
he not
shawn:
hours.
Matt:
know where he lives?
shawn:
Yeah. But anyway,
Matt:
Wow.
shawn:
they escaped. They escaped. They got to Turkey and then they came to America and. They their main reason was they were saying they know that Putin doesn't value them their business their expertise their lives They knew that they would just put them on the front lines and he says a lot of people understand and fear that they know that they don't value our lives they see us as Assets they see us as which is funny because a couple weeks ago Matt we were talking about communism versus
Matt:
That's the way,
shawn:
capitalism
Matt:
that's right, capitalists see humans as assets.
shawn:
which we disagreed,
Sam:
They
shawn:
Sam
Sam:
do
shawn:
and
Sam:
not.
shawn:
I, we
Sam:
That
shawn:
disagreed
Sam:
is
shawn:
and brought
Sam:
a
shawn:
up
Sam:
complete
shawn:
the example.
Sam:
lie.
Matt:
Oh,
shawn:
We brought
Matt:
I'm sorry,
shawn:
up.
Matt:
I thought that was the point you were trying to make, Sean. I misunderstood.
shawn:
Not according to my Russian friends. They say that the communists view people as assets. Anyway,
Matt:
Come
shawn:
interesting.
Matt:
on, these people aren't communists. Russia's not a communist state. They abandoned communism long ago.
shawn:
The roots of Russian, current Russian, I mean the theories behind how it's run is
Matt:
no.
shawn:
based in communism.
Sam:
I'm not sure that's true.
shawn:
No,
Sam:
I think it's
shawn:
what
Sam:
more
shawn:
are you?
Sam:
of a dictatorship. Isn't it? Like
Matt:
I
Sam:
Putin
Matt:
think it's
Sam:
is.
Matt:
based in mafia ideology.
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
Hold on
Matt:
I
shawn:
though,
Matt:
think it's
shawn:
hold
Matt:
based
shawn:
on though.
Matt:
in like, what do they call it? plutocracy? it's like oligarchy or something?
Sam:
All agg-
Matt:
I don't
shawn:
Yeah, but
Matt:
know.
shawn:
one of.
Matt:
it's not about communism.
shawn:
But one of Marx's principles, Matt, you're a Marx fan is
Matt:
I've read everything he wrote, but it's not like out of a- as a fanboy.
shawn:
what's all right, then what's his principle about seizing?
Matt:
No, but Sean, what I'm saying
shawn:
No, no,
Matt:
is
shawn:
listen,
Matt:
that the
shawn:
see.
Matt:
Russians have abandoned Marxism. All of the stuff that they used to have to learn, Marxism, Leninism, and all their schools, they don't do that anymore.
shawn:
No, but the principles in the manifesto, many of them are still being applied, like
Matt:
now
shawn:
they are too. All right,
Matt:
okay sorry
shawn:
I'll find
Matt:
i didn't
shawn:
it. I'll
Matt:
mean to interrupt go ahead
shawn:
find
Matt:
yeah
shawn:
it. No,
Matt:
russia is not a communist state sean china
shawn:
no,
Matt:
is a
shawn:
that's
Matt:
communist
shawn:
okay. We can
Matt:
state
shawn:
move on. I'm not saying it's a communist state. I'm saying that the principles, the manifesto, the Marx principles,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
many of them are applied, which are kind of communist principles, which
Matt:
Proletariats
shawn:
have led to...
Matt:
of the world rise up, you have nothing to lose but your chains.
shawn:
Not those parts, no.
Matt:
Like the overthrow, like the workers owning the means of production.
shawn:
Correct, the state
Matt:
That sounds
shawn:
owning
Matt:
like...
shawn:
the means of production. Right, correct.
Matt:
Well, the state, that's not communism, that's socialism. Communism
shawn:
Oh, okay,
Matt:
is like Winko,
shawn:
okay.
Matt:
right? When Winko says employee-owned, that's communism.
shawn:
Was Russia
Sam:
which,
shawn:
ever communist then?
Sam:
which
Matt:
No,
Sam:
oddly enough,
Matt:
no.
Sam:
when
shawn:
No,
Sam:
code then,
shawn:
they
Sam:
yeah,
shawn:
never
Sam:
then,
shawn:
were then. Okay.
Matt:
Right, right.
Sam:
then it becomes free market and it becomes more about, uh, yeah.
Matt:
We've never had a true communist system in the world ever. And Lenin's hope was to skip, Marx says you have to go through these stages, right? That there's, it's like, there's no choice in it, right? Like it's the, you go through the agricultural stage, then you go to the capitalist stage, then you go to the social, no, socialism wasn't one of his stages. Capitalism, and then it goes from capitalism into communism. And Lenin said, Well, we've never had capitalism or we've never really. Yeah. At the time, uh, Russia wasn't a truly capitalist state. And so Lenin said, we want to skip from, uh, the stage we're in. We want to skip capitalism and go right to communism. And so he introduced this idea of maybe socialism that could be this soft capitalism that could lead to communism. But anyhow, no, there's never been a true communist state.
shawn:
But I'm saying these principles, for example, the abolition of private property, that's very much a modern Russian activity. Like my friend
Matt:
But
shawn:
was saying,
Matt:
they have private property in Russia.
shawn:
now my friend, so listen to this, my friend a couple of weeks ago, this Russian guy, he's a programmer and his wife's a lawyer. And he was explaining to us the conditions of the businesses that he was a part of. And I kept asking him like, hey, you know, why isn't... You're super smart and talented and your programming is such a needed skill. Why didn't you ever start a business? Like why didn't you guys get kind of entrepreneurial? Is that just not part of the culture there? He's like, oh no, it's part of the culture. Man, it is big time part of the culture. Here's the problem. Any business that gets started, that becomes successful at all, literally the mafia or the government comes and takes it over.
Matt:
Well, those
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
are
Sam:
well, that's
Matt:
not the
Sam:
corruption.
Matt:
same things. That's
Sam:
Is
Matt:
right.
Sam:
it the same thing?
Matt:
The mafia and the...
Sam:
That's what we had in Ukraine,
shawn:
It is the same
Sam:
by
shawn:
thing.
Sam:
the
shawn:
What
Sam:
way.
shawn:
do you mean, the mafia and the government are not the same thing. What
Matt:
They
shawn:
do
Matt:
are
shawn:
you mean?
Matt:
not the same thing, Sean.
shawn:
Really?
Matt:
You can't say the fact that the mafia takes over your private business is socialism or communism.
shawn:
No,
Matt:
That's
shawn:
no,
Matt:
corruption.
shawn:
what he was,
Matt:
That's
shawn:
no,
Matt:
criminal.
shawn:
he was saying that the,
Sam:
fighting two battles right one against the government the other
shawn:
no,
Sam:
against
shawn:
he was saying
Sam:
the
shawn:
that
Sam:
mafia
shawn:
the mafia is part of the government, that is
Matt:
They're
shawn:
a
Sam:
I'm
shawn:
tool
Sam:
just
Matt:
not
Sam:
trying
shawn:
that the
Matt:
part
Sam:
to
shawn:
government
Sam:
help
Matt:
of the government.
shawn:
uses. I believe him. Why wouldn't
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
you believe the Russian guy?
Matt:
no, I'm not saying I disbelieve what he's saying. I'm just saying that it's not an official part of the government. So this
shawn:
Not
Matt:
is
shawn:
official.
Matt:
what I've been, right, so this is how I led. Right, so if you, Russians would value safety and security. They would value protection against the mafia. They're gonna place a higher priority on that over the right to vote. Because they say, who cares if I can vote for my leaders? if I don't have protection and security and safety. And so the government in Russia, their bargain is like, we'll keep you safe from maybe the mafia types or things like that in
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
exchange
Sam:
In fact,
Matt:
for power.
Sam:
mafia, Matt, is what's kind of pushed people back towards, um, modern day Russian government because in the power vacuum, corruption became so big when we were there in Ukraine and, and in Russia, that it made people want the security and safety of this, the Soviet union. And I think that's partially what made Putin more powerful is people were longing for the good old days and, and he cleaned up. so to speak, some of the mafia and some of the corruption that was there
shawn:
But hold on, hold on.
Sam:
in the business.
shawn:
This is probably the most boring topic for our listeners, so maybe we transition away. But mafia
Matt:
or delete the whole thing.
shawn:
and oligarchs, oligarchs were mafia, are mafia. That's how oligarchs are created. And my buddy was saying that the mafia is used by government to gain control locally and
Sam:
Probably because it
shawn:
shifting
Sam:
pushes people
shawn:
that
Sam:
to
shawn:
power.
Sam:
government. Yeah.
Matt:
All I'm saying is that government in Russia is a complex thing. And I'm just saying I wouldn't conflate mafia and government. Maybe in practice that's what happens, but that's not like how the government is run. Oligarchs in Russia are created by Putin. That's why they don't back down from Putin, because they know
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
that everything depends on Putin. So
shawn:
but, okay, alright.
Matt:
do you think Putin's like the head of everything, including the mafia in Russia?
shawn:
You don't think that Putin is intertwined with mafia, like buddies, bosom buddies? You don't think that that's how much of business gets done? That is.
Matt:
I'm saying I don't know the answers to these questions, Sean.
shawn:
I've always felt that, I mean, think of the whole Ukraine revolution over the last, what, 15 years. Russia was played, I mean, it was mafia and Russia that ran things in Ukraine government for so long,
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
wasn't it?
Sam:
Russian government was sowing seeds of disruption and, and like, they were doing everything they could to create chaos in Ukraine. And they were probably doing that through the mafia and through organized crime in Ukraine.
shawn:
That's what I'm
Sam:
But
shawn:
saying.
Sam:
that doesn't mean that those same organized criminal entities are in charge in Russia.
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
I
Matt:
so.
Sam:
don't know. I can't imagine anything else competing with Putin.
shawn:
That's what
Sam:
To
Matt:
So
shawn:
I'm
Sam:
your
Matt:
yeah,
shawn:
saying.
Sam:
point,
Matt:
so.
shawn:
You think
Sam:
to
shawn:
that there's an
Sam:
your
shawn:
independent,
Sam:
point, I
shawn:
there's
Sam:
think.
shawn:
no way there's an independent group of mafia who competes against
Sam:
No,
shawn:
Putin. It's all
Sam:
no.
shawn:
intertwined.
Sam:
What, when,
Matt:
Well...
Sam:
when the Soviet Union fell, there was a power vacuum and organized crime and organized criminal elements came in and filled that vacuum and Putin, that was his opportunity to seize control. And so he was sort of, I guess, mafia and he was sort of organized crime in his origins, because he consolidated a ton of power by, by pulling a lot of the assets. But he turned that into government. It's different today, isn't it?
Matt:
What I'm saying is that Putin's official stance, his public statements, everything that he says that people
shawn:
So
Matt:
see
shawn:
trust, he's trustworthy.
Matt:
would be anti-mafia, right?
shawn:
Yeah, but that's, you're talking about Putin. He is a propaganda king. He's not gonna explain that his
Sam:
You think
shawn:
government
Sam:
he's a, do
shawn:
is.
Sam:
you think he's pro mafia?
shawn:
No, I think he
Matt:
Uh,
shawn:
is mafia.
Matt:
no.
shawn:
I
Matt:
No,
shawn:
think
Matt:
I...
shawn:
he is...
Matt:
Okay, I guess here's what I would say. The mafia
Sam:
We should talk
Matt:
in
Sam:
about
Matt:
Russia...
Sam:
book burning.
Matt:
I think the mafia
Sam:
Ha ha
Matt:
in Russia
Sam:
ha.
Matt:
is like the Wagner group, right? There's the official Russian military, and then there's a mercenary group that he uses called the Wagner group. I imagine there's a similar kind of relationship to which the mafia operates, where it's like Putin's not in control of it, but he allows them to operate because they do something for him that's valuable to him. But officially... He's not a part of it.
shawn:
I know it's not official, Matt, but
Matt:
Oh, okay.
shawn:
so my buddy was saying, he says,
Matt:
What
shawn:
I've
Matt:
you...
shawn:
got buddies who would grow businesses to be very successful, and then the mafia would come and hand that over, take it over and hand it over to government, that's
Matt:
But
shawn:
what
Matt:
you
shawn:
he was
Matt:
can't
shawn:
saying.
Matt:
call that communism.
shawn:
No, I'm not,
Matt:
That's
shawn:
you're
Matt:
called criminal behavior. That's
shawn:
right.
Matt:
outside the—
shawn:
I wasn't calling that communism, I was calling
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
the process of this open society, this open policy of taking people's property.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
That's a Marxist principle. That's in the manifesto.
Matt:
No,
shawn:
That's a main part of the
Matt:
I know,
shawn:
manifesto, isn't it?
Matt:
but what they're doing is not, they don't care. Marx can say that or not say that. What that is called is criminal behavior, right? Marx is when the government as an official policy takes away private property
shawn:
I'm just
Matt:
and
shawn:
saying
Matt:
gives
shawn:
the,
Matt:
it to the state.
shawn:
I know it's not official policy. I'm just saying the principles are the same there. If
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
the government
Matt:
one is theft.
shawn:
of Russia through mafia can control the assets, the private property of people, that gives them control. No?
Matt:
It's corruption. That's corruption.
shawn:
Oh
Matt:
If
shawn:
my
Matt:
the
shawn:
gosh.
Matt:
government passes a law that says all your assets are now state-owned assets, that's different than having the mafia come and steal them and give them to them as a present.
shawn:
Yeah, but how do you get there? One way you get there is you start to just implement the abolition of private property, which is happening in Russia.
Matt:
Sometimes I feel like you don't like communism, Sean. Ha ha ha.
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
Sometimes, sometimes I'll feel like you do Matt.
Matt:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
shawn:
Hehehe Matt, it's,
Sam:
Biden?
shawn:
you know, it's,
Sam:
Oh
shawn:
okay,
Sam:
wait, not Biden, Kamala. I can't remember what he said.
shawn:
can
Sam:
Never mind.
shawn:
I, can I
Sam:
Let's
shawn:
transit?
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
talk about work banning in the
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
state of Utah.
shawn:
before we start, I do have to ask you guys something because I got into a deep conversation with one of our listeners
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
and they had questions about Sam and Matt. I know them, so they know
Sam:
Oh.
shawn:
me. So they didn't have a question
Matt:
Was
shawn:
about me.
Matt:
it my, was it my sister saying that she's mad at me for the things I say on the podcast?
shawn:
Is that, did that happen as well, Matt?
Matt:
She was really mad at me about Kamala Harris.
Sam:
Was
shawn:
So.
Sam:
it someone in Oregon?
shawn:
No, no it was
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
not. This is
Matt:
alright,
shawn:
someone
Matt:
what
shawn:
else.
Matt:
did they say, Sean?
shawn:
Well, here's their question about Matt. They said, I can't tell when Matt is being serious or just trying to poke a bear. I
Matt:
What?
shawn:
can't tell if he really sincerely loves Kamala Harris and
Sam:
He
shawn:
communism,
Sam:
does
Matt:
Yes,
Sam:
love Kamala.
Matt:
I do.
shawn:
or
Sam:
He
shawn:
if
Sam:
does.
shawn:
he's just trying
Sam:
And Biden.
shawn:
to show people how to see, how to look at both sides of things and not just be a blind sheep following a political party.
Sam:
You should take that second option that that's
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
a higher. That's a higher virtue
Matt:
Rather
shawn:
Give
Matt:
than being honest, I'm just
shawn:
us,
Matt:
trying
shawn:
I think,
Matt:
to la-
shawn:
Matt, I think listeners,
Matt:
No-
shawn:
there's dissonance in how you talk. I'm a Republican, I love Kamala Harris. That's major
Matt:
Yes!
shawn:
dissonance. So people
Matt:
Well...
shawn:
go, what is he talking about? Sam is a true capitalist and you just beat him up, beat him up, talking about your communism and how much you are an expert on Marx. And people go, what? That's dissonant, right? Cause he's a Republican, he says. So anyway, explain.
Matt:
That's the whole point. Like you can be a Republican and you don't all have to agree about everything. You can be a member of our church and you don't have to agree about everything. I'm a Republican because there are principles that the Republican party at least used to stand for that mean something to me. And I don't think that those values are inconsistent with liking Kamala Harris. And they're not inconsistent with being at least well-versed in what Karl Marx says. You can know what Karl Marx says and still be a Republican. I'm not advocating for Karl Marx, but I think that if you honestly look at society, we do not have a true market economy in any sector of American society. There's no market that's not regulated by the government somewhere in the US society. So
Sam:
terrifying
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
then, what's that?
Sam:
and it's terrifying
Matt:
Well, so I say, given the fact that we're going to live in a state that's going to have government regulation over the economy, that's just a given, it's going to happen, then what are the regulations that I support? And if somebody says no regulations, I say that's not realistic because we're always
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
going to have regulations.
shawn:
You don't have to defend it. I actually did defend you, Matt, because I love
Matt:
Oh, okay.
shawn:
your approach. I absolutely love your approach and I do defend you all the time to people.
Sam:
Did you
shawn:
I
Sam:
defend
shawn:
say, look,
Sam:
me, Sean? Did you
shawn:
yeah,
Sam:
defend
shawn:
oh yeah, you're
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
me?
shawn:
next. Hang on, you're next, Sam. I definitely offended. Hang on, you're next. I'll tell you what they said about you and how I defended you.
Sam:
Wow.
shawn:
No, so Matt, I love your ability to see both sides of things and I love that you are making judgments not based on, well, this political party or this media company said this or that. You're looking at things from a lens that you strive. first and foremost to be founded on Christ and his gospel. I love that.
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
I do
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
love that. So I defend you and I think it's wonderful how you approach that. So yes there's dissonance in what you say sometimes because people aren't there most people are used to the narratives that are pushed on us through the common media.
Matt:
And don't you think, Sean, that it's possible that there is a faithful member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and a diehard socialist and a diehard communist. And the way that they practice their religion points them towards socialism and points them towards communism,
shawn:
I
Matt:
and
shawn:
haven't
Matt:
that it's
shawn:
met
Matt:
totally
shawn:
that,
Matt:
okay.
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
Whoa.
shawn:
I haven't met that. I want to, I want someone to defend certain principles of socialism and communism, because my personal experience in Ukraine was there were some very, very bad principles based in common, unprincipled. And so I would love to hear someone who really, really thinks or believes in it, and is also a faithful member of the church. Yeah, I'd love to have that discussion. I've never
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
met someone who's that
Matt:
so
shawn:
way.
Matt:
that's why I bring
shawn:
Most
Matt:
Carl.
shawn:
of the time, most of the time, Matt, that I meet hardcore either left, liberal or socialist, they leave the church.
Matt:
Well, that's why I bring up Karl Marx, because Karl Marx does a very good job of pointing out the dirty underbelly of capitalism. And so as I point out like the negative things that happen in capitalism, it becomes easier to see how a person could be a faithful member of the church and say, I don't think capitalism is great. I think there's a lot of flaws in capitalism. So just like you see flaws in socialism and communism that say that's incompatible with the gospel, there's people that see flaws in capitalism and say that's incompatible with the gospel.
shawn:
I see the flaws. I think many capitalists also see the flaws, but when you compare the two, one is much better than the other. It can benefit more people than the other. But anyway, I would love
Matt:
But
shawn:
to hear...
Matt:
I say it's a false choice that nobody is making anymore. China calls themselves a communist society and they don't look communist in any way at all. And we call ourselves a capitalist society and we have a lot of elements of socialism in our society. So I just take that as a false choice. I don't have to choose capitalism or communism. I can say, here's a problem and what's the best solution to this problem? And it's probably gonna be a mixture of some capitalism and some communism. I don't have to pick between those two.
shawn:
Yeah, I love that you take that approach and it's fun to discuss those principles and details. You say stuff like China has no resemblance of communism whatsoever and it makes me go, wait,
Matt:
as
shawn:
what?
Matt:
an economic system, right? Like,
shawn:
Oh, you say, okay, clarify that then because.
Matt:
well, because communism is an economic system.
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
So
shawn:
gotcha.
Matt:
sure, they are a non-democracy, although on paper they call themselves a democracy, right? And so they limit freedoms and they limit opportunity for individuals. And there's a select group of people that get to benefit, but that's not communism making that happen. That's their political system. That's them
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
choosing
shawn:
gotcha.
Matt:
to limit participation. And there's a whole lot of other aspects of that.
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
It's not
shawn:
gotcha.
Matt:
their economic system.
shawn:
Okay, no, this is the type of discussion that I love from you, Matt. You teach me stuff that goes against what, really, I think most of us are fed through mainstream sources. So I love that
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
you have, I've always loved that you have an independent thinking mind and that you're able to not view things from the mainstream narratives. Now, that's how I defend you. Now, Sam, here's the question
Matt:
Yeah, Sam.
shawn:
for you.
Matt:
Let's go after Sam.
Sam:
Let's go.
shawn:
Sam, it started off as a backhanded, question and it ended up
Sam:
F,
shawn:
very
Sam:
oh
shawn:
positive.
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
Oh, hey,
Sam:
F.
shawn:
So I've
Sam:
Oh,
Matt:
isn't
shawn:
had
Matt:
that
Sam:
very
Matt:
always
Sam:
good.
Matt:
the way it goes for you, Sam? Sean starts out with some kind of backhanded compliment.
shawn:
That is not.
Matt:
It feels
shawn:
I love
Matt:
like
shawn:
Sam.
Matt:
it has.
Sam:
It always
shawn:
I love
Sam:
ends up with money. So it's always
Matt:
Hahaha!
Sam:
a good thing in the end. It just starts sketchy.
shawn:
So Sam,
Sam:
That's
shawn:
the
Sam:
called
shawn:
question
Sam:
free
shawn:
was this.
Sam:
markets. Yes, go ahead.
shawn:
The question was this, and they were asking about what is Sam's approach to forming his opinions because Sam seems to be extremely
Sam:
Ha ha ha!
shawn:
confident in his opinions. That was
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
the first
Matt:
No.
shawn:
question. And I
Sam:
interesting.
shawn:
explored like, yeah, and I explored like, well, why do you ask the question? And this friend of mine I was talking to tends to go with their gut most of the time. And we've gotten into these deep debates about, well, Where in Scripture does it say we are to go with our guts when it comes to making decisions, right? There are processes in place. And so as we've had this debate, they kind of went back and said, well, Sam seems to go with his gut most of the time, his experience or his gut. And I thought, well, that's a great, let's ask Sam. What is Sam's, Sam, what is your kind of,
Matt:
They don't know you, Sam. They don't know you.
shawn:
well, that's, so what is your approach at when we talk about these topics? how do you inform your opinions on these things? Because you always have
Sam:
That's
shawn:
awesome
Sam:
interesting.
shawn:
opinions and it's always confident.
Sam:
That's interesting. You know, I always come back from my life experience, I would say most of all, I mean, part of the latter day lens is you apply your life experience, your personality or shared religious background and shared experiences to our opinions. It is interesting though. What we don't share a lot of on this show is coming back and addressing topics that we have covered in one form, fashion, or in another. There have been topics where we've started, started down a road. And, you know, I'm trying to think of one, there was one even recently where,
Matt:
The
Sam:
um,
Matt:
space program. It was the space program.
Sam:
Nope, nope, nope. I'm confident on that one.
Matt:
It's education,
Sam:
And
Matt:
Sam.
Sam:
it's, uh, you know, uh, I think education was one actually. And, uh, and then protesting, uh, what was the, uh, what was that topic? It was,
shawn:
Activism
Sam:
uh,
shawn:
in church.
Sam:
activism. Yeah. You know, activism to me is a fascinating idea. Like that's how our democracy was born in many ways. Activism was how the church was born. And an example of a little bit of a shift in my thought process is I looked at our own, my own business that I work in. Like if people see a better way in our business, they actually bring that up. I always say, don't have a, don't, don't point out a problem without bringing a solution and an open minded business looking to improve will adopt a better way. And we'll go down that road. And so it's interesting. I've started to think about this. Activism erodes. trust in institutions and act as activism is appropriate when best ideas aren't adopted. So business is either growing or dying and it's going to die if it stops adapting better practices. But I also see how you can't question or be activist in an organization because it'll crumble. So it's interesting. A lot of our institutions today, as I've thought about this, are crumbling under activism because they have refused to adopt. a better way when it's pointed out to them. People will say, Hey, here's a, here's a better, here's an idea or here's a better approach. And, and, or there are people who truly don't have the best interest of that organization at heart and they want to tear it down and then they do that in social media and other forums, but you know, in, in our business as an example, activism is inappropriate because it would crush our business, but Shame on us if we don't adopt a better way. So that's an example of a shift. But
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
and I think the important thing to know about Sam is, Sam is very well read, and Sam is also very direct in expressing his views, but he's open-minded and he thinks about things a lot. So the format of the podcast is such that we don't plan a lot in advance, we don't prepare things to
Sam:
all.
Matt:
talk about.
Sam:
But
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
yeah,
Matt:
we're just having
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
authentic conversations about things. And so I guess the listeners never hear this, but frequently we have some kind of a discussion on the podcast. And then the next day, Sam's texting is saying, wow, I've been thinking more about this and here's how my thoughts have been shifting about this. Like Sam does that way more than either you or I do, Sean. Like
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
that's how Sam is. And so he might come off as he's just speaking off the cuff and he's never thought about stuff, but that's because I choose,
Sam:
How do I come off?
Matt:
no, I'm just saying he might,
Sam:
Oh wow
Matt:
right? He might come off that way, but that's because I'm choosing the topics and Sean studies
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
a little bit in advance. But the format is just, let's just come and talk about the topics.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
So it just, like Sam might appear to be more aloof than he really is. That's what I'm saying.
Sam:
Now I'm a loop and I'm
Matt:
No, no, I'm just saying like it might appear that
Sam:
just,
Matt:
way,
Sam:
I love
Matt:
right, like
Sam:
it. Yeah.
Matt:
I don't know. I have no
Sam:
I
Matt:
idea
Sam:
don't know
Matt:
how people
Sam:
either.
Matt:
perceive
shawn:
No,
Matt:
you, Sam,
shawn:
no,
Matt:
because I...
Sam:
I don't know.
shawn:
that
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
was the good discussion was they're like, sometimes I love it when Sam is so dang confident about a topic and they're like, but other times he's really confident about a topic that I disagree with and I'm like, where's that coming from? But I do think, and so what I said to them was, no, listen, like Matt said, Sam's mobile read, Sam is very pragmatic and practical and he lives life with let me apply knowledge to action. And so I think experience, which I love about you, Sam, is this incredible. To me, at our age, you have more experience in life than many people that I know. And I love that you bring that
Matt:
He
shawn:
experience.
Matt:
did when he was six years old.
shawn:
He
Sam:
I
shawn:
did
Sam:
don't
shawn:
when he
Sam:
know.
shawn:
was six. When
Sam:
Oh
shawn:
I
Sam:
gosh.
shawn:
met you in the MTC
Sam:
What are we talking
shawn:
and heard your
Sam:
about?
shawn:
story, I was like, I'm a child. I'm
Matt:
LMAO
shawn:
a child compared to this
Sam:
Oh
shawn:
guy.
Sam:
gosh.
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
Okay.
Matt:
I think the thing that my family loves about Sam is that Sam pushes back against the things that I say. Because most of the things I say,
Sam:
Ha ha!
Matt:
people who know me are like, shut up! What are you saying? So maybe
Sam:
Ha
Matt:
that's
Sam:
ha
Matt:
where
Sam:
ha.
Matt:
it
Sam:
Uh...
Matt:
seems like, I don't know, I like that Sam pushes back.
Sam:
And there may be an element of theater in what we do in moments where,
Matt:
just
Sam:
uh,
Matt:
from
Sam:
you know,
Matt:
time to
Sam:
again,
Matt:
time.
Sam:
my favorite moment from the entire show, Sean is the, uh, imagery of Matt being confused at why people talk politics with him in church,
Matt:
Hahaha!
Sam:
countered by the fact that Matt walks into the temple, his temple assignments, a church place and says, Hey, you know, I really think Paul Harris should be president
shawn:
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe
Sam:
of the United States next up. And the, and the temple worker at that Rexburg temple. losses out in their frail and sensitive age at the thought of
shawn:
Hehehehe
Sam:
Ma Harris being president.
Matt:
I was having breakfast at a restaurant this morning. There's these older gentlemen in my ward that like to go out and to breakfast and talk politics with me. And one of these guys was just bashing Trump to like no end. And the guy at the booth next to us, I could just see him all uncomfortable and upset and angry. And one time he sort of like turns his head because I know he wants to jump in the conversation. And I'm just like pushing and pushing and pushing to see how upset I can make this guy at the other booth as we say bad things about Trump. And then when he would, turn around to try and jump in, then I would give my other friend a chance to bash on Biden a little bit and then he would calm down and kind of turn back around again. Anyhow, I do weird things for fun.
shawn:
Shit.
Sam:
I was on a, I was on a flight last night and there was a gentleman must've been in his eighties or nineties, uh, turned to me and I was watching the news and he said, you know, I don't care what anybody thinks. I don't care what that guy's done. Trump happened to be on the news screen. I don't care what he's done. His policies are phenomenal and
Matt:
Oh jeez.
Sam:
I hope he gets reelected.
Matt:
Oh my goodness. Oh
Sam:
And
Matt:
my
Sam:
I
Matt:
goodness.
Sam:
put my earbuds back. She's like, I'm just like, you know what? I don't have the energy.
shawn:
Hey,
Matt:
I can't listen to this.
shawn:
I have nothing against baby boomers, but you guys need to expand your social circles.
Matt:
Oh, I shouldn't hang out with baby boomers?
shawn:
No, I'm saying I have nothing against Baby Boomers. I'm just saying you've seen all your stories
Sam:
I'm a very wide social circle, I'll have you know. Ha
shawn:
are... I wanna
Matt:
Not
shawn:
hear
Matt:
me.
shawn:
more about the Gen Xers, Sam.
Matt:
I don't talk
Sam:
ha.
Matt:
to
Sam:
And
Matt:
anyone
Sam:
why
Matt:
who's
Sam:
GenX?
Matt:
still working. I only like retired people.
shawn:
Hehehehe
Sam:
Ha ha ha.
Matt:
Hey, let's talk about the news. We'll see what we decide to keep of all this stuff that we've been talking about
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
so far.
Sam:
no to Amar. We may take out all just kidding.
Matt:
Hey, welcome to the Latter Day Lens listener. We've got some exciting news this week. So first, we're finally gonna talk about this Davis School District banning the Bible. Like this made national news. We kind of avoided talking about it for a little while. The news this week is that they've changed their mind. They've decided to let the Bible back into the middle schools because the school district said, "'The magnitude of the value of the Bible "'as a literary work outweighs any violence or profanity.'" which may be contained in the book. Like seriously, like that means that we're gonna decide whether a book gets banned or not, not based on the violence or profanity or sexual content that might be in the book, but based on its value of a literary work. Like to me, this screams of, like we've talked about this before, I hate parents deciding what should happen in schools. This seems like a classic case of, you let the parents in control. They do really crazy things and you have to have like the adults step
shawn:
Oh,
Matt:
up,
shawn:
okay.
Matt:
the experts step in.
shawn:
Okay, but hold on, Matt. I did my research on what the law in 2022 was in Utah that
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
would allow this hilarious situation. This is the
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
funniest situation to me.
Matt:
it's ridiculous.
shawn:
Oh, it's
Matt:
And
shawn:
so
Matt:
you know,
shawn:
funny.
Matt:
they only changed their mind because somebody said, let's ban the Book of Mormon. And somebody probably got to Moroni chapter nine or whatever and they're like, wait a minute, they're eating women and children? I think we're gonna
Sam:
shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh shhh sh
Matt:
have to ban the Book of Mormon too. And they're like, we can't do that, that would be horrible. So we'll be the school district that bans the Bible, but we can't be the one that bans the Book of Mormon. And so then they're like, let's change our minds. Don't you
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
think that's...
shawn:
but hang on, the whole thing is hilarious. And the idea that little elementary kids are walking into their school libraries and going, wait a minute, wait a minute, where's the Bible?
Matt:
or that they're gonna check out the Bible from their
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
middle school library and read it and be like, oh my goodness, this is horrible for me. I'm a terrible person.
shawn:
But the other funny part is this law gets passed and one side of the aisle goes, oh, this is ridiculous. We've now given us the right to just ban any book. So let's go and throw it in their faces and show that we can
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
ban any book. Let's ban the Bible. And then the other side goes, uh-oh, what have we done? Anyway, so Matt, is this the process because I studied it? It all starts with a librarian or a board of librarians in its
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
school district. and they decide which books go into a library at a school.
Matt:
which by the way, they have to have at least eight years of training like college school to get that job. There are people that study in college how to choose books for a library. Like that's a real thing people do. So yes.
shawn:
I love that I've struck a chord with Matt already by attacking
Matt:
Those people
shawn:
the...
Matt:
make a decision. We'll
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
call
shawn:
so
Matt:
them
shawn:
you...
Matt:
experts.
shawn:
Okay, so again, I'm just going to review this process because
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
you've asked the question who should decide what books get put into a school library, a public school library. Okay, so
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
it starts with
Matt:
Experts.
shawn:
Matt's teammates. Matt's expert teammates,
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
right? Librarians.
Matt:
experts.
shawn:
who decide that a Bible gets in there, a Book of Mormon gets in there, a transgender guide gets in there. Those are
Matt:
Charlie
shawn:
the people that
Matt:
Bone,
shawn:
decide.
Matt:
mysteries
shawn:
Right.
Matt:
from A to Z, A to Z mysteries.
shawn:
Choose your
Matt:
Like,
shawn:
own adventures, yep.
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
Okay, so the board chooses, okay? Now this new law gets passed that says anyone, a parent, an expert, a politician, can red flag a book if they believe it contains sensitive, which in this case is pornographic or indecent materials. Okay? Now
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
the process is if someone red flags it, there is a separate committee, and by law the committee must include professionals, experts,
Matt:
Yes, yes,
shawn:
and parents.
Matt:
that's the
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
problem here. The parents. Because the parents can be a majority of that group.
shawn:
It just has to have the representation of those
Matt:
I know.
shawn:
that
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
the
Matt:
that's
shawn:
local
Matt:
what happened
shawn:
district can decide.
Matt:
in Davis County. It was mostly parents.
shawn:
I don't think, oh, you'll have to back that up. That's not what I saw.
Matt:
Well, it's in that news story.
shawn:
Yeah, but it's a combination of experts,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
politicians and parents. Okay, so then they decide, oh, yep, this is indecent or this isn't indecent, so this is taken out. Then if it's appealed, a separate committee, another
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
committee
Matt:
out.
shawn:
has to make a recommendation after they study it to the school board and then the school board votes on it publicly. and the
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
final decision is made. Is that the process?
Matt:
Yeah, I think that's pretty good, Sean. I think that sounds right.
shawn:
So I can't tell if that makes me just laugh at our political system or if it makes me proud. I can't tell if I love that process or hate that process.
Matt:
I can tell you right now, I hate that process.
shawn:
Okay, good. Okay,
Matt:
Why
shawn:
that's
Matt:
can't
shawn:
what
Matt:
the,
shawn:
I-
Matt:
a librarian has a job to do. Let the librarian do their job. You think that there are people that are like, I wanna be a middle school librarian because I'm hoping to turn all these children trans and gay and I'm gonna hide it from the parents. People are choosing to be
shawn:
I don't think
Sam:
So,
shawn:
that.
Matt:
like.
Sam:
so, so here's, here's the only way I'm going to weigh in on this one and it's
Matt:
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Sam:
going to be super fast. I'm going to be out.
shawn:
Use your gut, Sam.
Sam:
So I went. I went to a knowledge bowl with my son. He was in here in Utah County and it was held at a elementary school and it was not held at the library because there was no longer a library. It was held in a room called the media center
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
and
Matt:
yeah.
Sam:
in the media center or a bunch of computers and then there were probably 40 books, most of picture books and maybe some magazines and periodicals in our day and age. What the heck are people doing banning books? Anyway, it's all online. It's all on the computer. Isn't this
shawn:
Point.
Sam:
a ridiculous exercise?
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
I mean, this
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
whole look, look at the comments from this thing. Uh, look at the comments from this Utah parents, you know, I left off one of the most sex written books around the Bible. You'll no doubt find that the Bible has no serious value for minors because it's pornographic by our new definition. What an old notion to ban or approve books in a world where so much knowledge and information is available. It's ludicrous.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Like. Nobody, there
shawn:
So
Sam:
shouldn't
shawn:
you
Sam:
be
shawn:
say.
Sam:
a librarian deciding what to have in and what to have out. Um, parents should ultimately at home make that decision and then administrators to make the decision in the school about what they teach as part of curriculum. There
Matt:
What?
Sam:
isn't a library anymore. Who went to the library? Don, have you been to a library lately?
shawn:
No. Nope.
Matt:
Well, sometimes I get cold and I go inside the
shawn:
Hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe hehehe hehehe hehehe hehehe he
Matt:
library to warm up.
Sam:
Once a year I go to Barnes and Noble just to remember what it feels like to read in a place where I can smell coffee beans,
shawn:
So
Sam:
but
shawn:
let me
Sam:
that's
shawn:
understand.
Sam:
it.
shawn:
So Sam, you believe that an all book, no books should be banned. There should be no law that allows anyone, politicians, experts or parents to remove
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
books. It
Matt:
That's
shawn:
should
Matt:
right.
shawn:
be up to librarians
Sam:
There's no library,
shawn:
and schools.
Sam:
Sean, to ban it from. What's that media
Matt:
Well
Sam:
center with picture books?
Matt:
there are books in the media center.
Sam:
are not books. I have a picture of the media center. I was astounded.
Matt:
Well, they probably hid them because you were having a knowledge bowl and they didn't want people stealing their books. And so they probably just put them away for a little while.
Sam:
That's what people in our generation do. They steal books because they can easily Google them and get them and read them for free.
Matt:
Here's the irony of it all. These schools all have wifi in them and the kids
Sam:
Yeah!
Matt:
have phones. And I'm telling you, the wifi in the schools is not blocking porn on the phones. Ha ha
Sam:
It's
Matt:
ha.
Sam:
a stupid debate. It's an old notion. In 10 years from now, the ideas of banning or approving books will be like, the nation is making fun of Utah with this period because it's leading headlines because it's such a stupid conversation. It's an old notion.
shawn:
Well,
Matt:
I
shawn:
the...
Matt:
have, there's somebody I know, Sean, that was in middle school, junior high. They were watching porn all day long on the school laptop
shawn:
Oh
Matt:
during
shawn:
my
Matt:
class.
shawn:
gosh, dude. What the?
Matt:
And then, and then when I, when I had a conversation with the principal about like, um, how is this happening? The principal was like, what? I didn't know that they could do that.
Sam:
But were they at least,
shawn:
No.
Sam:
were they at least balancing that with spending time reading other books like the Bible and others? Do you know?
Matt:
They didn't want to check out the Bible because it had bad content.
shawn:
Matt,
Sam:
Well, they couldn't check it out. They couldn't check it out because it wasn't there.
shawn:
here in California had the same experience. When my kids entered middle school in a public meeting, I raised my hand and said, hey, what's the internet policy here and the data policy? Because what's gonna stop some kid coming up to my kid and showing something really inappropriate and fun? And their answer was nothing. That's
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
up to you as a parent to teach them.
Matt:
That's
shawn:
This is
Matt:
right.
shawn:
a, right, we have the internet. We're not gonna block
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
the internet. We, it's impossible. So, Okay, but Matt, your question though is someone has to decide what
Matt:
The
shawn:
books
Matt:
live-
shawn:
get taught, what curriculum, what books, not just libraries, not just libraries, Sam
Sam:
Why?
shawn:
says, but Sam,
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
it's
Matt:
out.
shawn:
not just about libraries. It's about, by the way, I'm looking at Sam and his backdrop is a library.
Matt:
Hahaha
shawn:
This book is personal library full of books. Yep.
Matt:
books and a space shuttle.
shawn:
So, but it's not just about books
Sam:
a library
shawn:
in a library.
Sam:
that smells of mahogany.
shawn:
Yeah. Right, Matt? You're talking about. school curriculum, this is a process,
Matt:
Well, in this
shawn:
there
Matt:
one,
shawn:
has to be a process.
Matt:
I just think this was a failure. Like, if we just leave it to the experts, we don't have stupid things like banning the Bible.
shawn:
This is your point
Sam:
It
shawn:
again,
Sam:
makes
shawn:
your
Sam:
no
shawn:
point
Sam:
sense
shawn:
again
Sam:
in
shawn:
is-
Sam:
the first place. You can't ban the Bible.
shawn:
Okay, but
Sam:
There's no library.
shawn:
Matt...
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
Oh.
Matt:
We're gonna move on. This was a good conversation. Wait,
Sam:
Did
Matt:
wait,
Sam:
I
Matt:
did
Sam:
win
Matt:
you?
Sam:
that? Did I win that round at least?
Matt:
Ding, ding,
Sam:
There is
Matt:
ding.
Sam:
no library.
Matt:
Wait,
Sam:
Okay. Thank you.
Matt:
did you wanna say something, Sean? Cause I don't wanna cut you off.
shawn:
Yeah, I don't think I'm gonna allow this to be left at, Matt feels like he won because he says that experts need to make all decisions and Sam just avoided the topic by just saying there's no library. Nope,
Matt:
But
shawn:
that's not
Sam:
There
shawn:
a
Sam:
is
shawn:
good
Sam:
no
shawn:
conclusion.
Sam:
library.
Matt:
Sam got the ding ding.
shawn:
Yeah, but I veto the ding ding.
Matt:
Okay, you tell us Sean. I promise whatever you say wins. You win with whatever you say next.
Sam:
As long as it is that there's no library anymore. It's a media
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
center.
shawn:
I am going to bring in a scripture then.
Matt:
Okay, good.
Sam:
Okay.
shawn:
All right, DNC 6825. And again,
Sam:
Can't be in the bible though.
shawn:
in as much as parents have children in Zion or any other of her stakes which are organized that teach them not to understand the doctrines and then so on and so on and so on, then basically there is scripture mandate that education is the responsibility of parents, right?
Matt:
Yeah, you're
shawn:
So to
Matt:
right.
shawn:
me, the process of choosing what book, what curriculum is a little bit arbitrary because it's gonna change from district to district and some state to state. And as long as there's a system in place that is fighting back and forth between the balance of freedom and not freedom, experts and parents, I'm fine with that. I think the system is probably just fine. Let everyone do it differently and fight and fight and fight. The problem is when we as parents default to schools and bureaucrats about our kids' education. Right? The scriptures teaches in D&C 6825 the responsibility is the parents to
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
educate our kids.
Matt:
I agree with that. Okay, you win, Sean. Wow, that was really good.
shawn:
I'm the
Matt:
You've
shawn:
winner.
Matt:
persuaded me.
shawn:
I should.
Matt:
Hey, so Hunter Biden is taking a plea deal. I don't know if you heard about this, but Hunter Biden did some naughty things. He like cheated on his taxes and fraud and all kinds of stuff. And he's taking a plea deal and that has upset a lot of Americans. And the House Ways and Means Committee did some investigating and they've made public some reports from whistleblowers in the IRS who say that Hunter Biden should have been charged with far worse crimes than what he's being charged with. And so the House committee says, hey, this is a sign that there's unfair justice in the United States, that people are being treated differently based on their connections. And last week Donald Trump was indicted for mishandling classified documents and for obstruction of justice. And people say, this also suggests that there's partisan bias, that maybe people are weaponizing the justice department and you don't get treated the same if you're a Republican as you do if you're a Democrat. So I'm gonna wait and say what I say later on this. I wonder what you guys say, because I don't
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
wanna hurt anyone's feelings.
shawn:
I need to know if the Ways and Means Committee, the House Ways and Means Committee is a partisan committee.
Matt:
So in the House of Representatives, it's controlled by Republicans right now. So the chair of that committee is a Republican. And on every committee, since it's controlled by Republicans, they have enough votes that just the Republicans on the committee could vote and have the votes to do whatever they wanna do.
shawn:
That's what I need.
Matt:
But they do say that Democrats on the committee agree with us in this statement. So they say that it's bipartisan. But the January 6th committee was bipartisan. There was a lot of Democrats and two Republicans, but a lot of Republicans didn't agree with Adam Kinzinger and Liz Cheney. So
shawn:
So the statements
Matt:
I would
shawn:
that
Matt:
say
shawn:
the...
Matt:
it's mostly Republican.
shawn:
That's what I'm asking, because the statement that came from the committee is pretty specific and damning, pretty poignant. But so your belief is that it's not really bipartisan. They say it is, but it's not really. It came from
Matt:
I don't
shawn:
Republicans,
Matt:
think that anything
shawn:
period.
Matt:
that happens in the House of Representatives right now is bipartisan.
shawn:
Okay, yeah, because statements like, the American people deserve to know that when it comes to criminal enforcement, they are not on the same playing field as the wealthy and politically connected class. The preferential treatment Hunter Biden received would never have been granted to ordinary Americans. Things like...
Matt:
Yeah, that's Republicans on that committee
shawn:
Biden's
Matt:
trying to
shawn:
ta-
Matt:
make an
shawn:
they said Biden's ta- that same report says Biden's tactics used by the Justice Department to delay the investigation long enough to reach the stat- statute of limitations for his son.
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
Is that true or not?
Matt:
that's what a whistleblower said who works in the IRS and we don't know their identity.
shawn:
But is it true or not?
Matt:
Maybe. I mean, I don't have any problem with taking that at face value and saying that maybe it is.
shawn:
So if that is, then isn't this a clear example of unrighteous dominion?
Matt:
It's a plea deal. So this happens all the time. Like if the police find out you did something wrong, they'll come to you or the prosecuting attorney or whatever and they'll come to you and they'll say, look, these are all the things we have evidence for that we could charge you with. But we don't have the inclination to take this to trial because we're not sure we could prove it in a court of law or that a jury would convict. So we'll plead bargain this down. And if you'll plead guilty to this and this and this, We'll agree not to charge you with all of these other things we could charge you with.
shawn:
So you're believing that there wasn't enough evidence and there wasn't a case,
Matt:
No, no.
shawn:
despite what the whistleblower said, so
Matt:
That's
shawn:
that the
Matt:
right.
shawn:
plea deal was the right way out. You don't believe what the whistleblower
Matt:
So
shawn:
said.
Matt:
I don't know if it's enough evidence or if it's more about a jury and convincing a jury, right? So if let's say that you're talking to the police and you confess to something, then the prosecutor is gonna say, wow, I've got a confession, that's strong evidence I can use against you. But if your confession looks kind of weak or something like that, then they'll say, I don't know. Right, it's all a prosecutorial decision about can I convict, can I not convict?
shawn:
Yeah, but isn't that the accusation is that the Justice Department isn't that the one that's who decides whether they're going to whether there's enough evidence and to convict or not.
Matt:
So then their claim is that President Biden is exerting
shawn:
influenced
Matt:
pressure
shawn:
it.
Matt:
on the Justice Department
shawn:
Right.
Matt:
and more specifically on a specific prosecutor in the Justice Department telling them to go easy on his kid.
shawn:
Right. And
Matt:
And
shawn:
they're
Matt:
there's
shawn:
basing
Matt:
no
shawn:
that,
Matt:
evidence
shawn:
they're
Matt:
of that.
shawn:
basing, well, no, there is too. I read that, you made me once again
Matt:
No!
shawn:
read a boring,
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
I read
Matt:
I'm-
shawn:
the whole, all the whistle blow. No, I'm just kidding, Matt. I
Matt:
No,
shawn:
appreciate
Matt:
no, you
shawn:
you.
Matt:
right, but you read that whole thing. There's nowhere in there where it says President Biden told somebody to do this.
shawn:
No, no, of course there's no evidence that connects it as well. That's what you're
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
saying. I
Matt:
that's
shawn:
see.
Matt:
what I'm saying.
shawn:
But there, but there is lots of evidence that those, uh, that the justice apartment was definitely pressured to delay it so that it, uh, reached the statute of limitations. Uh,
Matt:
Maybe.
shawn:
there were
Matt:
Pressured by Biden though? That's the whistleblower's claim. How does this whistleblower know that Biden put pressure on the Justice Department? That's
shawn:
Well,
Matt:
the
shawn:
what
Matt:
big
shawn:
if it
Matt:
question.
shawn:
OK, but what if even if it wasn't Biden, right? Joe Biden is not the one on trial here.
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
So
Matt:
so then
shawn:
you're
Matt:
the-
shawn:
just saying that there's you're just saying that there's not
Sam:
The
shawn:
sufficient evidence for it to be prosecuted. So the plea deal was better.
Matt:
That's what I think happened. Well, if I'm going to compare it to Trump, what happened with Trump is, I think that the prosecutors in the Trump case would have happily taken a plea deal. And they don't want to charge him with all of these felonies. Nobody wants to go through this trial. The only person who wants this trial is Donald Trump. The prosecutors would happily say, because we know this because of what they did in advance. They said to Donald Trump, for two years, you have these documents, please give them back to us. And then when they said, were coming tomorrow to get these documents, he
Sam:
Matt,
Matt:
hid them.
Sam:
he
Matt:
Ha
Sam:
was,
Matt:
ha
Sam:
he was busy. He
Matt:
ha!
Sam:
had a lot going on. He had a very
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
full social schedule and he
Matt:
And
Sam:
was unable
Matt:
then once
Sam:
to
Matt:
they've got all of
Sam:
accommodate
Matt:
these documents
Sam:
that.
Matt:
from him, once they find them and take the pictures of them all in his bathroom
shawn:
Oh, there's
Matt:
and
shawn:
evidence.
Matt:
all that stuff,
shawn:
There's evidence, yeah.
Matt:
okay, but they could,
shawn:
Yeah, no, I
Matt:
if
shawn:
agree
Matt:
he
shawn:
with you.
Matt:
today said I will plead this down to a misdemeanor, I think that the Justice Department would happily say Trump is pleading guilty to this misdemeanor and then they would move on.
shawn:
Oh, I don't know. I don't know if that's true or
Sam:
So,
shawn:
not.
Sam:
so the Hunter Biden thing though, isn't about the tax case or the weapons charge and the plea deal, this is just salt on the wound. The big deal is all the allegations surrounding bad acts with Burisma and Ukraine and, and
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
Biden's.
Matt:
but that stuff's craziness, right Sam? That comes
Sam:
Well,
Matt:
from
Sam:
I,
Matt:
Rudy Giuliani and his paid thugs from Russia
Sam:
it,
Matt:
that are all in jail.
Sam:
it might be, but here's the interesting thing. And we talked about this a little bit last time, and I thought we were going to go here a little bit to, there were two topics I thought we might cover today, one is porn in Utah, which we'll get to at some point, and then the other, the other was this, right? So I, I'm not a conspiracy theorist,
Matt:
Okay,
Sam:
but I
Matt:
I
Sam:
do
Matt:
believe you.
Sam:
think, but I do think in a world of drama, if it bleeds, it leads that I think certain narratives push people into certain directions. And there are narratives right now that are pushing two people into a presidential election that serves individual parties. Democrats want Trump to be the Republican presidential nominee to the terror of a lot of Republicans. And Republicans are just begging that Biden is the presidential nominee to the discouragement of many Democrats. And there's no better narrative right now. Then Trump's indictment, his popularity goes up with his base every single time he's indicted. He made a statement last week that he gets indictments when he flies over states now. It's not just, you know, when he's
Matt:
Unless he's
Sam:
formally...
Matt:
afraid to land because he'll get thrown in jail.
Sam:
Exactly.
Matt:
As he should be, by the way, because of all of his criminal activity.
Sam:
And there's a similar narrative that people are buying right now and Biden hasn't fully addressed. You know, you say, Hey, that whole narrative on Ukraine is crazy. Yeah. Somebody's got to end it. They've got to show it and end it if it is crazy, because there is a belief in the weaponization of, of the federal government right now. And the FBI is the one that's taken the brunt of that.
shawn:
Okay, but
Sam:
When you're
shawn:
when...
Sam:
going after, when you're going after a former president of the United States, as hard as they are, and you're going after the current, uh, son of a president of the United States, like they are that that's a challenge
Matt:
But Sam,
Sam:
that we
Matt:
they
Sam:
live in
Matt:
have
Sam:
the world.
Matt:
to follow the crimes. The Trump
Sam:
I get that.
Matt:
organization was convicted of tax fraud. I don't see any Republicans up in arms about Trump and the Trump organization being convicted, and by the way, the CFO convicted and going to jail. Trump's CFO of his business is in jail for tax fraud. And
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
yet
shawn:
I don't
Matt:
they're
shawn:
think-
Matt:
upset about Hunter Biden. It's like,
shawn:
But Sam, or
Matt:
why waste your
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
time
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
about Hunter Biden
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
and
Sam:
but.
Matt:
not be mad about the Trump organization?
Sam:
without a lot of information, education, and background and explanation, a Republican could see those as equal.
Matt:
Ugh. I don't understand.
Sam:
And, and, and in a world
shawn:
No,
Sam:
of social media,
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
those
shawn:
you're not
Sam:
could
shawn:
defending.
Sam:
get both sides charged up. I'm not defending
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
either
shawn:
you're
Sam:
side.
shawn:
not, he's not, he's not defending Trump. He's just saying.
Sam:
And whoever your friends are, they're critical of me, Sean. I'm not defending Trump and I'm not defending Biden
shawn:
That's why I'm
Sam:
by the
shawn:
clarifying.
Sam:
way either. But if I'm
Matt:
The
Sam:
the
Matt:
hunter
Sam:
president,
Matt:
by...
Sam:
if I'm the president of the United States of America and my son is found guilty or takes a plea deal over tax fraud and gun charges, I'm not going to have him at a political event that same week. not going to be in a public position
Matt:
You don't
Sam:
in the
Matt:
like
Sam:
White
Matt:
Hunter
Sam:
House.
Matt:
at the State Department dinner
Sam:
Now,
Matt:
or the
Sam:
that
Matt:
State dinner.
Sam:
was insane. What's behind that? How does that hurt?
Matt:
Well,
Sam:
That's
Matt:
he's
Sam:
the
Matt:
only been, he's pleading guilty to a misdemeanor, Sam. It's no different than being in the country illegally.
Sam:
It's, it's not about that misdemeanor. It's about the whole narrative that's going on right now. I'm
shawn:
Okay,
Sam:
putting.
shawn:
so Sam, you believe that none of this is about justice. This is all politics,
Sam:
It's all
shawn:
politically
Sam:
drama,
shawn:
motivated,
Sam:
it's all politics, and it
shawn:
drama.
Sam:
pushes Biden's
shawn:
Okay.
Sam:
ratings up with his base, and it pushes Trump's ratings up with his base.
shawn:
Okay, if, but Matt, you're saying...
Matt:
I think that Democrats would rather run against Ron DeSantis than Donald Trump. I don't think the
Sam:
No
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
Democrats...
Sam:
way.
shawn:
but Matt, back to the question because your question,
Matt:
Oh yeah, yeah.
shawn:
right? But you're saying, Matt, based on the question, you're saying, no, this is not a political move. This
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
is justice. You're
Matt:
This
shawn:
saying
Matt:
is the
shawn:
this
Matt:
way
shawn:
is
Matt:
things
shawn:
just.
Matt:
are done for everybody. I don't think Hunter Biden's getting any special treatment here.
shawn:
And that's based
Matt:
And
shawn:
on.
Matt:
I don't think,
Sam:
except when he got invited to the press dinner, but that's okay.
Matt:
well, yeah, because that's his dad, right? So,
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
okay. But in terms of the Justice Department, I think that Joe Biden as president is trying very hard to stay out of the decisions of the Justice Department. So when the Justice Department does something like chooses to indict Trump or chooses to take a plea deal with Hunter Biden, I don't think that... President Biden has anything to do with that, which is not true about Donald Trump. When he was president of the United States, he did use
Sam:
He
Matt:
the
Sam:
was
Matt:
Justice
Sam:
in everything.
Matt:
Department.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
There's, there's, there's audio tapes of him trying to create problems. Yeah.
shawn:
Yeah, no one here is defending
Matt:
So to me,
shawn:
Donald
Matt:
the politics
shawn:
Trump.
Matt:
of this is Republicans trying to make it seem like Biden is doing the same thing that Trump did. And I'm saying that Biden isn't doing that.
shawn:
So, and you're saying that the House Ways and Means Committee, who produced a report that is pretty convincing, it's a pretty good convincing
Matt:
Yeah, yeah.
shawn:
report that the
Matt:
That's
shawn:
Justice
Matt:
all politics.
shawn:
Department, Biden's Justice Department did get, have influence over the Hunter Biden plea deal instead of it being felonies.
Matt:
I think that they're just being partisan hacks and they're wrong.
shawn:
Okay, yeah, I have no evidence of knowing this. It seems like you've got your studies and opinion. I don't know, I don't know how to judge this. If it's
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
like.
Matt:
in reality, none of us do. That's why
Sam:
I'll
Matt:
it's such a divisive issue.
Sam:
hear, I'll
shawn:
Hahaha.
Sam:
be, I'll be, I'll be clear and I'll just lean into the narrative more. It's all crazy. And it's all just to bring two people to the election.
shawn:
That's interesting.
Sam:
And it's
shawn:
No,
Sam:
going
shawn:
it's
Sam:
to be
shawn:
interesting.
Sam:
an election that doesn't serve any party and just creates more chaos. Can you imagine?
Matt:
Sam, I will say if the Republicans are hoping for Joe Biden as the nominee, they're crazy because he's a very strong nominee. Like there are a lot of Democrats that could lose the next election. And I don't think Joe Biden's one of them. He's the incumbent president of the United States with a record that makes a lot of people happy. I don't think Republicans should hope to run against Joe Biden.
Sam:
Yeah, but yet in Vegas, I'm not sure you'd put money like.
Matt:
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Sam:
Anything could happen. You just don't know.
Matt:
Yes,
Sam:
Right.
Matt:
sure. I'm
Sam:
Like.
Matt:
not putting it on Robert Kennedy jr. I'm not thinking he's good
shawn:
Okay, but in short,
Sam:
No.
shawn:
Sam, your stance is that any headline with Biden or Trump in it is 100% about the upcoming election and is political and drama. Has
Sam:
I think a
shawn:
nothing
Sam:
lot of the
shawn:
to do
Sam:
prosecute
shawn:
with justice or law
Sam:
prosecutorial
shawn:
or anything.
Sam:
drama is pushing us as a country towards this election. And in an
shawn:
Okay,
Sam:
odd way, the
shawn:
interesting.
Sam:
more Trump gets prosecuted, he's his, uh, base ratings go up higher and the more, uh, Biden has troubles and problems.
shawn:
Interesting.
Sam:
I mean, and, and listen, I'm a conservative Republican. I'm not a huge Trump fan. I kind of lean with Matt on the whole Biden thing. He's done some good things,
Matt:
Yes,
Sam:
but,
Matt:
yes.
Sam:
but I'd rather not see him present for another term. I mean, I would rather not see him
shawn:
And
Sam:
president for
shawn:
that's
Sam:
another
shawn:
because
Sam:
term.
shawn:
you tend more traditional Republican, right? More capitalistic, less
Sam:
It's
shawn:
about
Sam:
like to see
shawn:
some
Sam:
better free markets and
shawn:
of the values that Biden pushes, right? That's why
Sam:
less
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
you stand
Sam:
constraint,
shawn:
there.
Matt:
I think the
Sam:
less
Matt:
only difference
Sam:
corruption.
Matt:
between Sam and I on Biden is where we place our values and policy. I value things that Sam doesn't value. I'll acknowledge that President Biden is not pro-business. And I'll acknowledge
Sam:
No,
Matt:
that
Sam:
he's not.
Matt:
the stock market class, the business class, I can see why they don't like Joe Biden. But I'm more
Sam:
Here comes
Matt:
of like...
Sam:
the backhanded. There
Matt:
no,
Sam:
we go.
Matt:
no. I'm just more of like a union worker kind of person. I'm... I'm more
shawn:
Sam
Matt:
in favor
shawn:
are you?
Matt:
of like the union sort of approach to things and I can see why Sam's not.
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
That's, that's the real difference.
shawn:
that's the main difference. Or Sam,
Sam:
Are you
shawn:
do you?
Sam:
pro Union, Matt?
Matt:
I'm strongly pro-union. Yeah, we
Sam:
Really?
Matt:
could talk about that another time,
shawn:
Sam,
Matt:
but
Sam:
Wow.
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
You let's do talk about that.
Matt:
Yeah, because
shawn:
Yeah, that would
Matt:
that's
shawn:
be a good
Matt:
really
shawn:
discussion.
Matt:
what it, for Sam and I, that's really what it boils down to, the differences of what we would like in candidates. Sam's a businessman. Of course he's gonna value the business candidate. I'm an academic. Of course I'm gonna value the candidate that's not so pro-business and is more
Sam:
The
Matt:
into
Sam:
union
Matt:
the, yeah,
Sam:
in
Matt:
I
Sam:
today's
Matt:
love unions.
Sam:
day and age.
Matt:
That's,
Sam:
Sean,
Matt:
well.
Sam:
will you write that down? We need to make sure Matt keeps writing things down and then he never brings them back up.
shawn:
Yeah
Sam:
We
Matt:
Hey,
Sam:
never
Matt:
speaking
Sam:
see him as
Matt:
of
Sam:
a topic.
Matt:
which,
Sam:
So
Matt:
this is something that nobody had on their radar at all. Yesterday, the food and drug administration gave the green light to a group, it's a company that produces cultivated chicken. They say it's safe to
shawn:
This is
Matt:
eat.
shawn:
so weird.
Matt:
So,
Sam:
That's wild.
Matt:
cultivated chicken, for those who don't know, you take stem cells from a chicken and in a factory, you raise those stem cells, not into chickens, but just into chicken breasts. So now you can eat boneless, skinless chicken breasts that never had the bone, never had the skin, and don't have all that nasty gristle inside of them. So,
shawn:
Never had eyeballs, never had a brain, never had
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
a heart.
Matt:
So, like some people say, hey vegans and vegetarians who are opposed to meat on moral grounds, now you have to change your mind because we're not treating animals inhumanely, we're not causing them pain, we're not hurting them, we're just raising them to never exist in the first place, and we're just growing the meat. And then there's other people that say, wait a minute, this feels like it's ethically wrong. Like, she'll be using stem cells to grow things. Like in China, because the United States is opposed to this, in China there are companies that take stem cells and then they will use them to grow human organs. They'll take like a monkey stem cell or a pig stem cell. And they've had this where they grow like a human heart that like, if you're on a wait list for a heart, you can get a genetic match to yourself of a heart that was grown in a pig. but it's your biological genetic match. And so I think that this could be the future where we use these stem cells and animals to grow food, to grow organs. And it seems like maybe this is the future that we should embrace, or maybe is it something morally wrong that we should avoid this like grown chicken.
shawn:
This is the weirdest and most complicated subject. It's so complicated. Because on the one hand, Matt, my gut reaction to hearing the chicken, I even watched a bunch of videos, people doing reports, going to this company, watching this piece of chicken get printed out
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
and then cooked up and then they ate it. And I was like, wow, this is so weird.
Matt:
And it tastes good.
shawn:
Tastes like chicken, they liked it, they enjoyed it, they talked about. Most of the push out there from the companies is...
Matt:
Climate change.
shawn:
climate change, which is fascinating, right? Because they say that 37% of methane comes from livestock and they're like, look,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
we can eliminate 37%. But that message also says we can eliminate livestock,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
right? We don't need bring in the animals, which to bring in a religious side, I mean, go to the, there's a lot of talk about beasts and animals in the scriptures, there is.
Matt:
Yeah. Well, we would keep the cute animals, Sean. We'd keep like the
shawn:
Nah,
Matt:
birds
shawn:
I
Matt:
and
shawn:
see
Matt:
the
shawn:
now
Matt:
chipmunks
shawn:
you're treating it.
Matt:
and the, we keep the ones we like.
shawn:
Well, then you're
Matt:
Fish?
shawn:
going against scripture. You're going
Matt:
I like...
shawn:
against scripture.
Matt:
wait...
shawn:
Cattle was commanded to multiply and replenish. They were. It says it. It says it specifically. Not only that, Matt, but in D&C 77, remember when Joseph Smith was asking the Lord about the revelations of John? And there was one, it's a bunch of weird stuff, and he was answering. And one of his talks about, we understand there are four beasts. What are these beasts?
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
You know what God's answer was?
Matt:
What?
shawn:
That, let's see.
Matt:
There are animals that live in heaven?
shawn:
Well, that's part of it for sure.
Matt:
hahahaha
shawn:
Because he asks, are the four beasts limited to individual beasts or they represent classes or orders? Flesh also of beasts and of the... I'll find it. Let me find it. I can't find
Matt:
You're
shawn:
it right
Matt:
confusing
shawn:
now, but let me find it.
Matt:
me, Sean.
shawn:
I'm sorry. I'm sorry.
Matt:
Wait, so this is morally wrong because of Revelations and the
shawn:
Well,
Matt:
Beast?
shawn:
we are the latter-day lens, Matt. So we're
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
trying
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
to inform our opinions
Matt:
Right.
shawn:
from Scripture. So there is definite command of God to say, look, if the drive to make this meat is we can eliminate cows, and
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
then there won't be methane, and then climate change won't exist. That seems to, why isn't that a moral decision, Matt? Because Adam himself was commanded to name
Matt:
Molten.
shawn:
every beast.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
Okay? The beasts themselves were commanded to multiply and replenish.
Matt:
Yeah?
shawn:
These are laws, these are commandments of God. So if the move
Matt:
Mmm.
shawn:
is, let's eliminate animals so that we don't have methane, so that we don't have climate change, that seems to be a moral, a bit of a moral conundrum, no?
Matt:
What do you say, Sam?
Sam:
You know for this I would actually go back to the cloning do you remember when they cloned the cow. And everybody was just outraged that you can't own this cow like it's just
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
wrong it's unnatural but science allowed it. And it was pretty cool and after that happened there were a ton of laws that came into place that restricted nations from doing stem cell and cloning and some other things which since then a lot of those technologies. have yielded incredible advancements in
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
human health and longevity. Like, uh, my daughter just went to Tijuana and she had it because she had to go there, I think, because he had to go outside of the U S laws. He had STEM cells injected to help with, uh, migraine headaches and some other things that she was having and it's helped
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
and it's interesting. I don't understand the moral objection. I understand the moral fear.
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
Sam:
And we're seeing a parallel to this with chat GPT and some of the other AI technologies. It's like, well, you can't replicate human intelligence. Like
Matt:
the
Sam:
we've got to control that too. Right.
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
And
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
yet, and yet what happens is out of each one of those, uh, evolutions and advancements comes technology, which ultimately makes life better and longer and help more vibrant. There has to be constraints
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
probably in it, but as it really relates to chicken. What's
Matt:
Hahahaha
Sam:
the downside?
shawn:
Okay, Sam,
Sam:
I want more chicken. Actually, I don't want more chicken. Pick-a-Lay should love it. Yes, Sean.
shawn:
you challenged, your challenges is at a moral limit. Let me ask you this question with that cloned cow, for example.
Sam:
Uncow, Betsy
shawn:
So
Sam:
or whatever his name was.
shawn:
you believe that the spirit that existed for that cow that was
Matt:
Oh
shawn:
cloned,
Matt:
boy.
shawn:
God
Matt:
Oh boy.
shawn:
placed that, this is a good question, why not? God
Matt:
I don't know
shawn:
placed,
Matt:
that cows have spirits.
shawn:
the scriptures
Sam:
Oh,
shawn:
say that all
Sam:
scriptures
shawn:
things
Sam:
say
shawn:
were
Sam:
they
shawn:
created,
Sam:
do.
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
yes,
Matt:
okay,
shawn:
they
Matt:
you've
shawn:
do,
Matt:
convinced
shawn:
man.
Matt:
me.
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
The scriptures say they do.
shawn:
Oh yeah, all animals,
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
all trees, every
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
living cell has
Sam:
yeah,
shawn:
a spirit,
Sam:
that
Matt:
Well
shawn:
was
Sam:
hasn't
shawn:
created
Matt:
wait,
Sam:
been changed
shawn:
spiritually
Sam:
yet.
shawn:
before.
Sam:
The
Matt:
so then
Sam:
temple
Matt:
how is
Sam:
thing.
Matt:
cloning a cow different than cloning a flower? Or cloning a rose? Like,
shawn:
Well, that's
Matt:
we clone
shawn:
what I'm
Matt:
plants
shawn:
asking.
Matt:
all the time.
shawn:
Yeah, but the scriptures also talk about there are different spheres and levels of intelligences and that animals
Matt:
Mm.
shawn:
are on a different level than humans that are
Sam:
What
shawn:
on
Sam:
level
shawn:
a different level
Sam:
are they?
shawn:
than flowers.
Sam:
Is
Matt:
Hehehe
Sam:
this a Scientology
shawn:
Yeah, I don't know.
Sam:
thing?
shawn:
So Sam, you believe that
Matt:
Cloned
shawn:
cow
Matt:
cow.
shawn:
was cloned and God placed the spirit of that cow into that cloned cow and
Matt:
No,
shawn:
you're like,
Matt:
no,
shawn:
that's what
Matt:
no.
shawn:
God intended it to be.
Matt:
No, no,
shawn:
What?
Matt:
no.
shawn:
No, what? No.
Matt:
A cloned
Sam:
No,
Matt:
cow's
Sam:
I...
Matt:
no different than an identical twin.
Sam:
I know, I think the clone cow lived its life with some sort of a demon, demonic dark personality. And it's one of the, I don't know, Sean, I
shawn:
I know, but you said it wasn't a moral issue.
Sam:
don't
shawn:
You said
Sam:
understand
shawn:
it wasn't moral.
Sam:
it, but fear drove that more than science did. And in that case, I'm actually okay allowing science to lead out a little bit
Matt:
Yes,
Sam:
because
Matt:
yes.
Sam:
in the shadow of that bad decision, they'll legislate a whole bunch of restrictions around that science. We were prevented from enhancements that better the human condition. And we were harmed by a lot of the rules and legislation. So you've got to have a little bit of faith in, you got to have a little bit of faith in God that he's not going to allow people to go do things that like are gonna, like, I don't know what the problem, what, okay, so there's a clone cow and they have a personality or they don't like. What's the harm?
Matt:
You sound
shawn:
No, no,
Matt:
just like
shawn:
I'm not
Matt:
Lucifer,
shawn:
asking.
Matt:
Sam. You're just like Lucifer. Hey listen, let me say this, Sean. Have you
Sam:
I am
Matt:
ever...
Sam:
eating chicken right now, so that's...
Matt:
Sean, sometimes when you drive to Utah, do you pass these like industrial cow farms along the freeway?
Sam:
Terrible.
Matt:
Yeah. So I think that the value of cloning or these stem cell things is it gets rid of that stuff. Like I don't think God intended for cows to be like herded along the freeway and kept in these tiny little containers just so that they could grow and produce meat and milk and then just stay in this little space their whole life. So if people really want to free the cow, great, take some of those cows that are like in, like on the side of the road waiting to be turned into steaks and free those cows and let them multiply and replenish the earth as they choose. Not as the farmer chooses who buys sperm online and then impregnates the cow
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
20
shawn:
well,
Matt:
times.
shawn:
all right,
Matt:
Right,
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
Southern?
shawn:
Matt. All right, well, Matt, how about DNC 8912? "'Flesh also of beasts in the fowls of the eye, Lord, have ordained for the use of man,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
for thanksgiving, nevertheless there to be use sparingly.' And it talks about,
Matt:
So then let's
shawn:
it is pleasing
Matt:
only grow the
shawn:
unto
Matt:
flesh.
shawn:
me.
Matt:
We don't need hoofs. It doesn't say hoofs for the use of man
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
or
Sam:
Well then.
Matt:
ears or snouts for the use of man.
shawn:
but I also read scripture to you that talks about how beasts, cows were commanded of God to multiply and replenish. You can't ignore those two.
Sam:
So, so is your take Sean that should not be allowed?
shawn:
Not at all, no.
Matt:
So what
shawn:
No?
Matt:
I'm saying is we're doing the, we're fulfilling the commands of God in a way that no one has ever conceived of before. That we allow the cows to multiply and replenish on their own and we grow the flesh and we only use the flesh that we grow from their stem cells
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
and we don't grow the fur and all that other nasty stuff.
shawn:
I listen to you guys, you know who Larry H Miller is, right? Do you know how
Sam:
Wagle-y,
shawn:
Larry H
Sam:
yes.
shawn:
Miller, he's the owner of the Utah Jazz, he's the one that built the jazz up and
Sam:
car
shawn:
made
Sam:
guy.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
them a success
Matt:
He's a car
shawn:
and owns
Matt:
guy, Sean. Don't try
shawn:
all
Matt:
and
shawn:
your
Matt:
change
shawn:
car dealerships.
Matt:
how we think of Larry H. Miller. Can't bring up K-Jazz. We know who Larry
shawn:
Matt, do you know
Matt:
H. Miller
shawn:
how he
Matt:
is.
shawn:
died?
Matt:
Uh.
Sam:
diabetes
shawn:
So,
Sam:
and he wouldn't take care of his diabetes.
Matt:
Are you
shawn:
so
Matt:
serious?
shawn:
here's,
Matt:
I thought
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
it
shawn:
so
Matt:
was gonna be
shawn:
here's,
Matt:
like steak inhalation.
Sam:
Nope. Chronic terrible
shawn:
so listen,
Sam:
diabetes.
shawn:
so he had diabetes and what happened was with diabetics sometimes neuropathy happens where blood flow doesn't travel for example
Sam:
Yep,
shawn:
to the legs and when
Sam:
cut his
shawn:
those
Sam:
feed
shawn:
extremities,
Sam:
off.
shawn:
when those legs get wounds because there's not enough blood flow from the neuropathy, those wounds won't heal and when those wounds won't heal they grow and when they won't heal you have to amputate. And through that process. he was losing limbs because of neuropathy and he died. So I worked for a company called Dermagraft. Dermagraft was literally regenerative skin cells
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
that would be placed on a matrix and they would put them on these wounds and because the body wasn't producing skin, these regenerative skin
Sam:
That's awesome.
shawn:
cells were
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
growing the skin and healing these people, Larry H. Miller probably could have survived.
Matt:
He didn't
shawn:
So.
Matt:
opt for the therapy?
shawn:
didn't exist when he died.
Matt:
Oh, okay.
shawn:
So when I worked for this company, it was fascinating because at first I was like, well, wait a minute. So we're growing human skin. That's crazy. And then I saw how many lives it blessed and I thought, okay, that's pretty fascinating. So on that side, yes, I can see it, but clearly there's going to be some lines that get crossed. And all I was trying to point out in the scriptures are there's lots of references to beasts. And Matt, this was the other comment that a couple of my friends made is that You
Sam:
still
shawn:
guys
Sam:
have
shawn:
don't
Sam:
beasts.
shawn:
care enough about what scripture says about these things. You just want your political views. So I'm trying to force you guys to listen to scripture a little bit. I'm preaching to you.
Matt:
No,
Sam:
So what does scripture
Matt:
I actually...
Sam:
say?
Matt:
I
Sam:
Is
shawn:
By
Matt:
really
Sam:
it
shawn:
the
Sam:
against
shawn:
way,
Matt:
value
Sam:
it?
Matt:
what scripture
shawn:
see
Matt:
say on this.
shawn:
Sam didn't even listen. He says, what did this guy, I've read the scriptures.
Sam:
That's it
shawn:
It says that beasts
Matt:
Ha ha
shawn:
are commanded to multiply and replenish for the benefit of man. And there's a,
Sam:
I
shawn:
now
Sam:
know, but,
shawn:
I like, Matt.
Sam:
but manufacturing chicken doesn't, doesn't fill that. I mean, you can still
shawn:
Okay.
Sam:
have beasts.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
I'd still love to have my little labradoodle poodle thing that's
Matt:
Gecko.
Sam:
running around. I mean,
Matt:
We choose the
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
beasts we like, Sean. It's like
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
a designer world.
shawn:
but the leading company who's making these chickens, this chicken, their whole point is we can eliminate 37% of all the beasts. We can not bring
Matt:
That's
shawn:
them into
Matt:
fine.
shawn:
the world.
Matt:
I think
Sam:
Probably
Matt:
that's
Sam:
a good
Matt:
okay.
Sam:
thing.
shawn:
Multiply replenishes the commandment.
Matt:
Well, let them, I'm saying we should let animals multiply on their terms, not having the rancher impregnate them.
shawn:
I like that. Okay,
Matt:
All right,
shawn:
I like
Matt:
let's
shawn:
that.
Matt:
talk about the big question this week. So the Book of Mormon promises, see Sean, people say I don't care what the scriptures say, the Book of Mormon says that by the power of the Holy Ghost, we can know the truth of all things. But there are some things that haven't been revealed. And so the question is, How do we sort out the truth when it has not been revealed? So as an example, something that's in the news this week, there's a medical doctor, Professor Pete Hotez. He criticized Joe Rogan and Robert Kennedy Jr.'s discussion of COVID-19 vaccines. And then these people are like, you know what you ought to do? You ought to debate each other, because you know, if we just debate, then we're gonna find the truth. And that professor's like, no, that's a waste of time. Why would I, I spend my life studying this topic. Why am I gonna debate somebody who's interested in misinformation or disinformation and give them a platform that makes us seem like we're equal on equal ground? And then other people say, wait a minute, that just suggests you're afraid of the truth. And so go ahead, Zam.
Sam:
No fish. Cause cause
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
you said it right in the word that you just said,
Matt:
Okay.
Sam:
it puts them on a platform like we're equal. And
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
I saw his responses to Rogan. Like he's all upset because people are protesting out in front of his house. Just to kind of continue the story. He feels very unsafe because this
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
social media world is like erupting against him. And his comment was, Hey, I'm a scientist. I'm not going to go out and debate science with people like
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
That's a terribly arrogant and elitist attitude. Go on Joe Rogan, go on some, you know, sit down with Oprah Winfrey and explain
shawn:
Get him
Sam:
your
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
story,
shawn:
get him
Sam:
right?
shawn:
Sam.
Matt:
Well...
Sam:
Explain your story. Like, what are you hiding? There's no reason to hide. It's science.
Matt:
I'll explain that, I can explain that part of it in a second.
Sam:
Okay, all right.
Matt:
So I think this happens all the time. This is just one example, right? But this happens all the time that you've got one group of people who are trying to either promote a product or a platform, they're trying to get attention, and what they do is they cherry pick information to present one side of a thing, and it's all about self-promotion. And then there's this other side that says, you know what, science is a valid source of information and these are honest people. just trying to find out the facts. And then those two sort of schools fight with each other because the ones that have a platform or an agenda are gonna say, they're trying to keep secret information away from you. And the other side is gonna say, we're not gonna engage with you people because we're not a part of that group. And so the big question is like, how do you find the truth when you're just inundated with information? How do you really find the truth about controversial topics when it seems like there's an imbalance of information? or it seems like there's some people you can trust or some people you can't trust. Like how do you figure out what's really going on? And just to address Sam's thing about science, I have this problem all the time. Like I'll be talking with my wife about something and she'll say, well, why don't you just explain that to people? And I'll say, because in order for a person to understand
Sam:
You wouldn't
Matt:
this,
Sam:
understand.
Matt:
it's true. In order for someone to understand this little point I wanna make, I have to have them take a whole semester's class worth of background information
Sam:
on.
Matt:
to get there. It's
Sam:
But
Matt:
true.
Sam:
do you, do you know how that sounds to
Matt:
I
Sam:
an
Matt:
know
Sam:
average
Matt:
that's
Sam:
human?
Matt:
why we don't
Sam:
Listen.
Matt:
talk to people, because it's like we only talk to each other because there's no way to like break it down. It's because, okay,
Sam:
There
Matt:
go ahead.
Sam:
has
shawn:
Nah,
Sam:
to be
shawn:
I
Sam:
a
shawn:
have
Sam:
better
shawn:
asked.
Sam:
way. There's got to be
shawn:
No,
Sam:
a connector.
shawn:
no, no.
Sam:
I want to know what the scriptures have to say, Sean,
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
but you got to understand when Matt comes back, when someone says, hey, Matt, give me an answer to this complex topic that you study in your academia. I can't explain it to you,
shawn:
Sam,
Sam:
you wouldn't understand it.
shawn:
I'm supporting
Sam:
Okay.
shawn:
your, no, no. Sam, I'm supporting you because I've multiple times asked Matt about complicated, and yeah, it takes him 20 minutes to explain
Matt:
Yeah?
shawn:
it to me, but 20 minutes, Matt, that's nothing, that's
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
easy.
Matt:
I can't do
shawn:
You
Matt:
20
shawn:
explained
Matt:
minutes.
shawn:
it,
Matt:
I can't
shawn:
okay.
Matt:
do 20 minute intro on the Joe Rogan podcast.
Sam:
Yes, you can.
shawn:
But yes
Sam:
You could
shawn:
you
Sam:
do
shawn:
can.
Sam:
a two hour interview
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
on the Joe Rogan podcast.
Matt:
Well, so let me tell you the problem with this particular situation is somebody's gonna cherry pick some stuff and throw some misinformation or disinformation. They're gonna throw some things at you that they haven't presented as honestly as I would think someone should present information. And then they're gonna ask you to respond to that. And then your response ends up being trying to debunk all of the mischaracterizations that they did. And your point, because you can't make it as articulately or you can't make it sound as like fascinating or like scintillating or something like that, then people just dismiss it. And then what they say is, okay, well, science has their side and then there's this other side and then those two ideas are equal, but they're
shawn:
But
Matt:
not
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
equal.
shawn:
hang on Matt, though, critical race theory is a polarizing topic that is just talked about by the extremes, right? So I went to college and I said, hey Matt, tell me about critical race theory. And within 20 minutes, you explained to me that in academia, there is a whole line of thinking called critical theory thinking, right? And critical theory thinking goes down this path that has different standards than just regular theory or these other things. And after you explained it, I went, okay, now I have a whole different view of critical theory, and in this specific case, critical race theory. Now I understand, and now I understand much better when people are fighting about it, should it be taught here, should it be taught there? Now I have a really much better understanding. So if you guys in academia shy away from explaining things, that's your failure,
Sam:
But,
shawn:
that is
Sam:
but,
shawn:
your failure.
Sam:
but Sean, what, what Matt is saying is that most people don't come with an honest desire
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
to know
Matt:
they're not
Sam:
they
Matt:
listening.
Sam:
come, they come with an honest desire to divide, but I think that's not a reason to let
shawn:
Amen.
Sam:
academia off
shawn:
Preach
Sam:
the hook
shawn:
it.
Sam:
for explaining
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
it. You got
shawn:
Amen.
Sam:
it. Put it out there. Like, listen,
Matt:
Okay, Ivermectin.
shawn:
That
Sam:
first
shawn:
is
Sam:
question.
shawn:
weak.
Sam:
This question is even more valuable in today's world where we do have AI and there, it's going to be very difficult to know. So I do another podcast and for that podcast, I have an AI voice that I've created using an AI generator and it is nearly indistinguishable from a real voice. You can't tell the difference between the fake and the real. And there will be value of information going on down the road. And what is real is gonna be an important question and decision and people have got to be able to take information and make their own decision. And that's a gospel principle, right? Uh,
Matt:
So,
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
it-
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
so let me use.
shawn:
if academia believes that you have found a truth or you've found wisdom and you don't go preach it, shame on you.
Matt:
Okay, so let me use an example,
Sam:
That's true, Sean.
Matt:
let me use an example that's not so political in nature. Have you guys heard about lectin and why lectin might be bad in foods? Okay, okay.
Sam:
The preservative, right?
Matt:
So I'm watching some, I'm just going through YouTube like I do from time to time. And it says something like, why should you not drink almond milk? And I'm like, oh, I have no idea. So I watched this video that's supposed to be telling me why I shouldn't drink almond milk. And the whole thing is this, this Tony Robbins style infomercial, 45 minutes long about how bad lectin is. And then I'm like, wow, I've never heard of lectin before. And wow, maybe I should never eat tomatoes again because it has lectin. It turns out everything that's good for you has lectin in it and you should avoid it. And so then I go down this for like 40 minutes to an hour, this rabbit hole of lectin. And when I go on YouTube and I try and find information about lectin, All I get is this same guy's other videos over and over and over again. And then if I scroll long enough, I can eventually get to this one woman who had this channel where she says, look, all this stuff about lectin, and then she kind of lays out the academic research on the topic. She has like
Sam:
Great!
Matt:
1,500 views. The lectin Tony Robbins video is like millions and millions of views. And in today's world,
Sam:
It's not Tony Robbins, by the way, but
Matt:
no,
Sam:
it's
Matt:
it's
Sam:
like
Matt:
a Tony
Sam:
him.
Matt:
Robbins
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
style. And he, by the way, drops Tony Robbins name in it and he says, I'm Tony Robbins personal physician or something like that. So that one has like 20 million views, I don't know, something like that. In today's world, people judge the value of information on the number of views your video has on YouTube. That's the way the
Sam:
I,
Matt:
algorithm teaches people to do it.
Sam:
I get that that's the math, but our personal responsibility is to seek for knowledge and it's to study that knowledge and it's to make a personal decision. So on a broad level, I agree with you, but at a personal level and as members of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, we have a responsibility to study it, to seek that knowledge and then to make a decision. And you can't make that decision if the guy refuses to put his academic research out in the world.
Matt:
But
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
what
shawn:
is
Sam:
you're
shawn:
your-
Sam:
not going to understand
Matt:
I,
Sam:
it
Matt:
but
Sam:
isn't a good solution.
Matt:
from my example, what you guys are saying to me is academia has a responsibility to create YouTube videos that are gonna have a couple hundred
Sam:
No,
Matt:
views to
Sam:
no,
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
try to
shawn:
so
Matt:
combat
shawn:
hang on.
Sam:
maybe,
Matt:
the people that
Sam:
maybe
Matt:
have
Sam:
not.
Matt:
millions of views
shawn:
So
Matt:
and
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
hope that somebody clicks their way through to get to that video.
shawn:
So Matt, let me clarify something. Your original question is, how can people really find out truth about controversial issues that are oversaturated with non-truths? But isn't your real question, how do we teach truths in a way that will reach most people? Because it sounds like what you're saying is, you're not saying, it sounds like you don't have trust that when I view, when I'm searching for something and I see all these contradicting YouTube videos that I don't have the ability to, or humans, most people won't have the ability to, Do what Sam says, study it, discern, pray to God, try and get revelation to decide what is true. So you're questioning, well, maybe the ability to teach these things should be a little clearer. And
Matt:
No,
shawn:
not...
Matt:
I really want to know how, because actually I think both of you are really good at finding the truth. And I think that this is a question that a lot of people have is, how do you find the truth? Like when I go to the, I've been trained as a PhD student how to find academic answers to things. And I know the reputable journals and I know the peer review process. So I trust in science a lot because I've been trained that way. And
shawn:
So
Matt:
so
shawn:
I have
Matt:
if
shawn:
to.
Matt:
I see something on YouTube, I say, let's go see what the science actually says about this. But I know that not everybody does that.
shawn:
So I have two responses for that, Matt, two questions for you. One, do you believe that all truth can be revealed, requires a revelation from God? Or do you believe that there's a set of truths and knowledge and wisdom that we on earth can discover and obtain by means of godless methods?
Matt:
I think that all truth is revealed by God, but I think that there are empirical regularities that we can discover that are related to like the natural world that we live in. So science
shawn:
that don't.
Matt:
can help us find answers to some things. Science can help us figure out how to grow chicken from stem cells. God's not gonna help us do that. So there's some things science is good for and there's some things that revelation's good for.
shawn:
Okay, so you do believe that there are truths that we are supposed to seek after, not including God.
Matt:
Yeah, but I just don't call them truths because I'm a scientist and I don't believe that I'm in a discovery of truth. I'm just in a discovery of like empirical regularities. I don't believe
shawn:
Isn't that
Matt:
the
shawn:
a
Matt:
stuff
shawn:
fact?
Matt:
that I,
shawn:
Define
Matt:
I don't
shawn:
empirical
Matt:
know.
shawn:
regularity.
Matt:
Well, it's like gravity, right? Since Newton discovered gravity, it's been the same rate since then, but I don't think that gravity is a truth. Gravity is just a fact of like our current existence,
shawn:
Isn't
Matt:
but it's
shawn:
fact
Matt:
not a truth.
shawn:
equal truth? Fact doesn't equal truth?
Matt:
I don't think so. But
shawn:
Really?
Matt:
anyhow, go on, I still want to know how you find truth, Sean. Without getting into this big philosophical discussion about
shawn:
Well, that's what
Matt:
what is
shawn:
I'm,
Matt:
truth.
shawn:
I can answer. I can, I got four scriptures
Sam:
He would explain
shawn:
queued
Sam:
it,
shawn:
up.
Sam:
but I don't think you'd understand
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
it that
shawn:
Yeah. I've got Matt, I've got four scriptures. Okay.
Sam:
Don't tell him. Keep that one secret at least for heaven's sake.
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
Do not tell him.
Matt:
Please tell me Sean, I'll donate $100,000 to charity if you'll just tell me.
Sam:
Okay, tell them, but only tell them half and tell them in code.
Matt:
How do you find truth, Sean?
shawn:
Well, I've got three or four scriptures queued up to the answers,
Matt:
Oh.
shawn:
but the reason I prefaced it by asking you the question is
Matt:
You're
shawn:
because,
Matt:
trying to set me up.
shawn:
no, I'm trying to find out if you think that this clear path of finding truth that scripture lays out would apply to gravity or not. Oh,
Matt:
I don't think so.
shawn:
so then your question isn't... Because you know the answer, the scriptural answer, right? Ask that you may know, Deuteronomy 8.11, ask that you may know the mysteries of God.
Matt:
But he doesn't tell us. There's things he doesn't tell us. And
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
you still
shawn:
hang
Matt:
need
shawn:
on.
Matt:
to
shawn:
Let's
Matt:
find
shawn:
keep reading
Matt:
answers.
shawn:
it. That ye may receive knowledge from all ancient records which have been hit up that are sacred, and according to your faith shall it be done unto you. Seek not for riches, but for wisdom, and the mysteries of God shall be unfolded unto you.
Matt:
Yeah, but there's some questions you're not gonna know the answer to right now.
shawn:
Like the mysteries of God, you mean? Like
Matt:
Like,
shawn:
mysteries, right?
Matt:
if somebody says to you, hey Sean, is there ever going to come a time when the church is going to allow same-sex marriage in the temple? You don't know the answer to that and you can't pray to find the answer. Will there ever be a time when women will be allowed to have the priesthood? We don't know the answer to that. There's
shawn:
So you're
Matt:
no way
shawn:
saying
Matt:
to find
shawn:
how
Matt:
the
shawn:
do
Matt:
answer
shawn:
you decide
Matt:
to that.
shawn:
those things? You're saying how do you decide those things if God is not revealing them? That's what you're asking.
Matt:
Yeah, there's things that God doesn't reveal, and there's things that He just lets us figure out on our own.
shawn:
How about 1 Kings 3, 9? Solomon praised to God and says, Therefore, give thy servant an understanding heart to judge, that I may discern between good and bad. And God praises him and says, thou hast asked this thing instead of riches or long-lasting life, thou hast asked for thy self-understanding to discern judgment, and for this I love you.
Matt:
So I think that God will help us find answers to questions like should I eat this, should I not eat this? Should I do this, should I not do this? Especially if it's something that's important to us. But there's a lot of questions people have that God's not gonna tell them the answer to that. And I think that there's a danger, they say that the Jews looked beyond the mark. And because the Jews were so interested in understanding things that they shouldn't or try to understand, that God sent a stumbling block. because he gave them things that they couldn't understand because they were looking
shawn:
You don't
Matt:
beyond the mark.
shawn:
do not think, well, my experience has been, and you tell me if I'm actually really curious if Sam and Matt, if you agree with this, or if this has been your experience. I've always received an answer. The answer is always yes, no, or it's up to you. You can choose this. Is that how
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
revelation
Matt:
for
shawn:
works
Matt:
everything
shawn:
for?
Matt:
you've, sure, when I'm praying about something for what I should do for myself or for my family, but maybe I have a question like, who's gonna win the Super Bowl? Or what's the best car to drive? Or like, people just have these like curiosity questions.
shawn:
But
Matt:
And
shawn:
that's,
Matt:
the vaccine
shawn:
but, but.
Matt:
really is that same kind of a thing, right? I can pray and say, should I get vaccinated? But this question of, is the vaccine safe for everybody? God's not gonna tell me that answer to that question because I don't get to receive revelation for everybody else. So if I want to know is the vaccine safe for everybody, I got to figure out some way to like find out the answer to that question.
shawn:
Okay, I see. Well, I don't, okay, so when there's not a universal and absolute truth, like is the vaccine the right thing for everybody,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
then likely it's a case by case baseness. And like you're saying, revelation can clearly come or decision and support for that decision can clearly come on a personal level. So you understand, obviously you apply
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
that in your life.
Matt:
so I think
shawn:
But
Matt:
Revelations...
shawn:
you're saying,
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
but you're saying, but I want to have the answer, is the vaccine safe for every human being on the planet? That's what
Matt:
Or
shawn:
you
Matt:
is
shawn:
want,
Matt:
communism
shawn:
you want that answer.
Matt:
the best way to do things?
shawn:
But these are abstracts that don't have a true black and white. These are
Matt:
That's
shawn:
they
Matt:
what
shawn:
don't
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
have
Matt:
trying
shawn:
a truth.
Matt:
to say. So how do you figure out the answer?
shawn:
Is not, is it not sometimes, I mean, we discuss this all the time in this podcast, right? Political policies, is there a right or a wrong? Or is it just what we as a community decide? I think God sometimes wants us to just use your brain and decide. You decide. You don't think that there's sometimes that?
Matt:
So how do you use your brain and decide though? That's what I'm saying.
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
Because there's lots of people shouting on both sides. So how do you figure out like who to trust, who not to trust? Like if you're a public policy person or you're voting for an elected official and you're trying to figure out like, are they gonna do what's in the best interest of society? You have to have some way of figuring out like, are they or aren't they?
shawn:
Yeah, and you're,
Sam:
So, so
shawn:
I'll
Sam:
isn't
shawn:
go ahead,
Sam:
it given
shawn:
Sam.
Sam:
it's given the man to choose, right.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
And in choosing we make mistakes and we learn from those mistakes. And the voices are only going to get louder and there's only going to be more of those like part of life is making those decisions, learning to make those decisions. What, what I think is dangerous and a lot of people try to do it is to offload that decision making to other people completely, right. To Joe Rogan or even a scientist or a political personality or even a religious personality, right? As, as, as members of the church children of God, we have the right to seek answers on our own behalf. And it's consistent with president Nelson saying, Hey, part of living through this next generation is learning that truth on your own and coming to know it. Maybe there's a little bit of a difference between truth and fact and. whatever, but the noise isn't going to get any less. There's going to be so much more noise. You think about AI and everything that's out there. How are you going to find truth? Like, um,
shawn:
Matt, could you Sam, could you apply the idea that principles govern? Maybe there isn't a black and white for very specific nuanced questions, but do you believe that you could always reduce it down to a true principle and that principle can govern what the decisions are?
Sam:
And
Matt:
I
Sam:
not
Matt:
don't
Sam:
my
Matt:
know.
Sam:
life. Yeah.
shawn:
No?
Matt:
Yeah, I don't know. I,
shawn:
You don't think so?
Matt:
I think that the vaccine is a
Sam:
Change
Matt:
really good
Sam:
my mind.
Matt:
example.
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
Like what is the principle behind a COVID-19 vaccine? Like should I do Johnson and Johnson or should I do the AstraZeneca
shawn:
Well,
Matt:
or should I do none of them at all?
shawn:
let's try
Sam:
I guess
shawn:
it.
Sam:
we're.
shawn:
What's the real question?
Matt:
The real question is should I get vaccinated? Should I wear a mask? What I'm saying, Sean, is what you're proposing here is going through a cognitive process that most people don't do for most decisions in their lives because that's too much work. So if my child is sick, I'm gonna go through this effortful process to say, what's the best medicine or the best treatment I can use to help my sick child? But if I'm in a grocery store trying to decide what to eat, I'm just gonna either... go with some kind of like cognitive shortcut. Maybe I go with the cheapest thing. Maybe I go with the brand that I trust, but I'm not going through this big, effortful process to figure it out. You
shawn:
Sometimes
Matt:
know what I'm saying?
shawn:
you do, sure you do, sometimes
Matt:
Yes,
shawn:
you
Matt:
sometimes
shawn:
do.
Matt:
you do.
shawn:
If I'm on a diet, then I do go back to what principles govern what food choices I should make,
Matt:
But
shawn:
right?
Matt:
everybody,
shawn:
Like.
Matt:
yeah, but everyone has limited cognitive, like potential, right? Limited cognitive capacity for a given time. And so if you're spending a lot of your energy because you're on a diet, thinking about what you're gonna eat, then maybe you're not spending as much time thinking about your financial health, or maybe you're not spending as much time thinking about, what's the best phone plan that I can have, or what's the best.
shawn:
But it sounds like you're trying to avoid, I think the scriptures are clear. We are to wrestle, we are to fight, we are to exercise our agency in that cognitive struggle in everything. I don't think we're,
Matt:
Man.
shawn:
you're looking for a shortcut, right? You're looking for, okay, I need to decide which serial to choose, I should pull out a device
Sam:
I'm going
shawn:
that tells me which
Sam:
to
shawn:
one is
Sam:
spend
shawn:
best.
Sam:
a day
shawn:
You're looking
Sam:
out
shawn:
for
Sam:
in
shawn:
a
Sam:
Portland
shawn:
shortcut.
Sam:
and see if I
Matt:
I'm
Sam:
can
Matt:
saying
Sam:
get a few
Matt:
that
Sam:
things
Matt:
I think that
Sam:
done.
Matt:
if everybody went through your process, then
Sam:
I'm going to spend
Matt:
there would
Sam:
a day
Matt:
be a lot
Sam:
east
Matt:
less
Sam:
out in Portland
Matt:
anger
Sam:
and
Matt:
and
Sam:
see
Matt:
contention
Sam:
if I can
Matt:
in society
Sam:
get
Matt:
today.
Sam:
a few things
Matt:
I think
Sam:
done.
Matt:
that the anger and contention that
Sam:
That's
Matt:
we
Sam:
interesting
Matt:
see
Sam:
to see. Alright,
Matt:
comes from the reality that most people aren't going through that process,
Sam:
I'm going to say thanks.
Matt:
that they're gonna rely on some kind of cognitive shortcut. And that typically is, let me just pick the brand that I trust, let me pick the person that I trust, let me just go with this thing that I always go with because they don't want to put the time into it.
shawn:
So the principle behind that is,
Matt:
I don't
shawn:
yeah,
Matt:
think
shawn:
you're
Matt:
sh-
shawn:
right, they go with majority rules. They go with a democratic process, right? They go
Matt:
So
shawn:
with.
Matt:
what you're saying, Sean, is we have a moral obligation to spend more time being intentional about our choices and thinking about the choices we make and less time just going with the flow.
shawn:
I'm suggesting the concept that principles govern everything is the most important thing. That we should definitely seek out the principles. Yeah, there may not be an answer in scripture or an answer in science that gives us the right answer in every situation, but I think we could seek out the principles that could back those up and base our decisions on the principles.
Sam:
So I love the idea that there would be a principle that would guide everything. I just struggle with that. Maybe I don't know enough gospel topics. Maybe I haven't studied enough in my life, but I was looking behind me for a book. There's a book called Grit. Have you ever read Grit?
Matt:
yes oh my goodness don't get me started
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
yeah tell me more about grit sam
Sam:
Oh no, I'm
Matt:
is
Sam:
not
Matt:
it
Sam:
gonna
Matt:
about
Sam:
go
Matt:
a woman
Sam:
there then.
Matt:
who went to the us military academy and developed an idea that's basically the same thing that everybody already knew but called it something cool like grit
Sam:
I don't remember that.
Matt:
Oh.
Sam:
Oh, no, maybe it's not great. It's it's the whole idea No, no, you're not stuck's worth grid is ducks worth. The other one
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
is uh, oh What's the other one?
Matt:
Please
Sam:
It's the
Matt:
tell
Sam:
guys?
Matt:
me it's Chu and it's about tribes? No,
Sam:
Oh,
Matt:
I don't know.
Sam:
it's about, it's about, uh, when you, sometimes when you make a quick decision based on your intuition and your experience.
Matt:
Oh, thinking fast thinking slow with Kahneman and Tversky?
Sam:
No, it's,
Matt:
Oh, okay.
Sam:
it was, I, I subscribed to the guy's podcast and I can't think of it now. My kids
shawn:
That's
Matt:
Malcolm
Sam:
have
shawn:
okay,
Sam:
it.
Matt:
Gladwell?
shawn:
disc,
Sam:
Gladwell,
shawn:
no, disc,
Sam:
it is Gladwell. It
Matt:
Okay,
Sam:
is Malcolm
Matt:
yeah,
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
Malcolm
Sam:
Gladwell.
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
Gladwell talks
Sam:
What's
Matt:
about
Sam:
the
Matt:
some
Sam:
book
Matt:
of this
Sam:
called?
Matt:
stuff.
Sam:
So,
Matt:
Well, he has
Sam:
so,
Matt:
a lot
shawn:
it Matt
Matt:
of them, but Blink
shawn:
or Sam.
Matt:
probably?
Sam:
the link. Yep, yep, yep.
Matt:
Okay.
Sam:
Thank you.
shawn:
Hey, both of you shut up about the authors in the book. Sam, just explain
Matt:
Hahaha!
shawn:
it. Ha ha ha.
Sam:
So the idea is, I can't even remember my idea, is
Matt:
Well, it actually comes from Kahneman, but okay.
Sam:
sometimes when you're presented with multiple decisions and multiple choices, the best path is your intuition, because your intuition, whatever that is, is a collection of your experience, your life, your values, your ethics, principles that you've learned.
Matt:
It's true.
Sam:
It's a latter day
shawn:
I,
Sam:
vision.
shawn:
hold, I
Sam:
Instead
shawn:
will.
Sam:
of sitting and struggling with things, in business in particular, sometimes it's moving fast.
shawn:
I love this, this is full circle. We began this
Matt:
Ha
shawn:
whole
Matt:
ha!
shawn:
thing, me saying that one of my friends came and says, hey, Sam seems to just go with his gut on all of his
Sam:
I
shawn:
opinions.
Sam:
do, and
shawn:
And
Sam:
I'm
shawn:
now
Sam:
wrong sometimes.
shawn:
you've just said, maybe
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
the best process is go with your intuition. Cause you're not talking revelation, you're
Sam:
But,
shawn:
talking intuition,
Sam:
but,
shawn:
you're talking gut.
Sam:
but guess what, Sean, I'm wrong quite a bit.
shawn:
So
Matt:
Intuition.
shawn:
don't go with
Sam:
And,
shawn:
intuition.
Sam:
and,
Matt:
Int,
Sam:
and sometimes
Matt:
no, int.
Sam:
I'm slow at making a decision, even though I know it's the right one, so those
Matt:
So
Sam:
are my two.
Matt:
the idea behind intuition that is, like as you more fully develop it, is that intuition is a combination of all of these factors of your life experience put together and you can't articulate why it is you're doing that, but you still have this sense that that's the right thing to do. And so that would be a combination of like your gospel views, your education.
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
There you
Sam:
it's the latter
Matt:
go.
Sam:
day lens.
Matt:
Intuition.
shawn:
Wow, but isn't spirit the gospel?
Matt:
But sometimes the spirit doesn't tell you.
shawn:
Yeah, but
Matt:
Sometimes
shawn:
intuition
Matt:
the spirit.
Sam:
No,
shawn:
sometimes is...
Sam:
Matt!
shawn:
But intuition can sometimes be a mortal experience. So not always is that inspiration from God. It's sometimes is mortal. It's a mortal
Matt:
It could
shawn:
process
Matt:
deceive you. You could
shawn:
and it
Matt:
be
shawn:
can
Matt:
deceived
shawn:
deceive.
Matt:
by your intuition.
shawn:
Right, which is why I suggest don't go with intuition, Sam. I think do not do that.
Sam:
Oh really?
shawn:
I disagree. Yeah, because I feel like my heart or my gut, which is mortal, will tell me lots of things and it feels right emotionally. But contrasting that to the wisdom that can come from spiritual knowledge, it's going to contradict sometimes because we're not meant to rely on our mortal gut. I don't
Matt:
Here's
shawn:
know.
Matt:
how I'm gonna sum up.
Sam:
This is going to be a fun conversation because it's interesting as we grow older and we get more experience and we grow in emotional intelligence, which is a big catchphrase right now. We learn how to educate ourselves to make good decisions based on information and a little bit less emotion. We focus, I think, in our culture heavily on emotion, and emotion can make the absolute wrong decision a lot of times.
shawn:
This is
Sam:
Because
shawn:
a great discussion.
Sam:
a motion can be fear-based. If you're a 14-year-old kid, it can be
Matt:
FSY?
Sam:
based on hormones. Your a motion isn't always the best indicator
shawn:
Okay,
Sam:
of
shawn:
so Sam,
Sam:
the right
shawn:
are
Sam:
choice.
shawn:
you saying that in the church, people conflate emotion with spiritual experience? Is
Sam:
Sometimes,
shawn:
that what you're saying?
Sam:
yeah.
Matt:
Sometimes.
shawn:
Okay, so I
Sam:
The
shawn:
will,
Sam:
hot,
shawn:
I.
Sam:
the burning in the bosom and the,
shawn:
Yeah, but
Sam:
I'm excited,
shawn:
so I'm going to...
Sam:
feel good about it.
shawn:
So Matt and Sam, what do you think of this statement? The spiritual experiences that we're meant to have from God are absolutely absent from any emotion. Emotion can sometimes follow it, but God will not communicate to us through emotions. Period.
Matt:
I disagree.
shawn:
Done.
Sam:
Yeah,
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
Strongly
Sam:
that's great
shawn:
let's
Matt:
disagree.
Sam:
that
shawn:
debate
Sam:
too.
shawn:
that.
Sam:
It could go to have the scriptures.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
Give me scriptural evidence
Matt:
I
shawn:
where
Matt:
will tell you
shawn:
the word...
Matt:
in your mind
shawn:
Hang
Matt:
and in
shawn:
on.
Matt:
your heart.
shawn:
Yeah, but that's talking
Sam:
Burning
shawn:
about...
Sam:
in the bosom? Burning in the
shawn:
That's...
Sam:
bosom?
shawn:
Guys, that's talking about spirit. That's not talking about emotion.
Matt:
Well, how do you distinguish? You have to have a lot of experience to know the difference between telling someone in their heart and then having them having an emotional experience.
shawn:
You think the scripture is when it says heart is literally talking, you don't think it's literally talking about our beating heart, you think it's talking about emotion?
Matt:
You feel a burning in the bosom.
shawn:
Yeah, but that's spiritually, that's a spiritual out, so Joseph Smith said it like this,
Matt:
Well, okay.
shawn:
when God gives us wisdom or communicates to us, it's as if his spirit was speaking directly to your spirit in the absence of your body and mind. So the emotions that your body and mind creates are not this...
Matt:
But Paul talks about godly sorrow. That's a sorrow that comes from God that motivates
shawn:
You saying that's
Matt:
you
shawn:
an
Matt:
to
shawn:
emotion?
Matt:
do. It is, yeah.
Sam:
savior
shawn:
You're not,
Sam:
in Gethsemane
shawn:
you're not.
Sam:
felt troubled, right? Like that's an emotion, right? Or sorrowful. That's an emotion.
Matt:
Okay, now we're way off topic. We're way, way. This is how I'm gonna summarize what I've learned from you all today. That
Sam:
I can't wait.
Matt:
we can make decisions through an effortful cognitive process guided by the Spirit, Sean's preference. We can make decisions through intuition and we can make decisions solely based on what the Spirit tells us. And I think that what we should do is have the most confidence when we've prayed about something and feel like that's what the Lord wants us to do. And we should have less confidence when we've made it based on some kind of a cognitive process or some kind of intuitive process.
Sam:
I thought I understood what Matt said.
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
It took me 40 minutes to get us there, but it was so
Sam:
We're almost two hours into this podcast,
Matt:
So,
Sam:
but I got you.
Matt:
so worth the time. Hey listener, thanks for joining us this week for the Latter-day Lens. Feel free to reach out to us and let us know what you think. What's always more fun when we have stuff in the mail bag to talk about. Have a
Sam:
nice
Matt:
good,
Sam:
to me.
Matt:
tweak.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories