The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
June 21, 2023: Lifestyles of the Super rich, Conservation leases on BLM Land, UNESCO, Legalize voting for non-citizens
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
A study was recently published that looked at 30 years of data from 1989 to 2019 from the Federal Reserve Survey of Consumer Finances. They examined how couples divide work, focusing on three different wealthy groups, the Super rich, the just plain rich, and the upper middle class. They found that in 2019, 53% of super rich heterosexual couples had arrangements in which the woman was not gainfully employed, compared with 27% of rich couples and 20% of upper middle class couples and 26% of less affluent couples. Only 28% of super rich couples had both the man and the woman working full time. Super rich couples had a median net worth of $17.6 million in 2019. Rich couples had a median net worth of $2.3 million and the rich or upper middle class had a median net worth of $796,000. You guys are always telling me that it would be bad for the government to just give people money. Because if they had money, they would spend their time lazing away their lives and doing nothing. Yet if we look at people who don't have to work in order to make ends meet, we still find that most of them are being productive with their time. Do you really think that these super rich people are different than poor people? Can't we just assume based on these data that if we were to give everybody enough money to survive that people would choose to do productive things with their time?
The BLM is proposing a new rule That would change the way in which public lands are managed. Here are some links about the specifics of the rule changes. In short, the BLM would like to add conservation as a key component in decisions it makes about public land use. Some people are upset because it will affect how much people pay to graze their animals on public lands and might make it difficult for them to find places to graze animals. Other people are pretty excited because they think that nature needs to be protected. If not for Teddy Roosevelt and his efforts to conserve natural spaces a 100 years ago, I think it's likely that we wouldn't have Yellowstone or Yosemite or most of the natural wonders in the United States today. Do we have a moral obligation to protect the lands we have from greedy capitalists or recreationalists who would otherwise destroy the public lands? Is conservation a moral imperative?
The Trump administration pulled out of UNESCO because they did not approve of that organization allowing Palestinians to be a part of it. They also felt like the organization had an anti-Israel stance. Under Secretary of State for Management, John Bass, said Rejoining UNESCO will “help us address a key opportunity cost that our absence is creating in our global competition with China,” “If we’re really serious about the digital-age competition with China, from my perspective, in a clear-eyed set of interests, we can’t afford to be absent any longer from one of the key fora in which standards around education for science and technology are set,”. This week. UNESCO announced that the United States plans to rejoin and pay more than $600 million in back dues. Is the Biden Administration making the right decision to rejoin this organization and pay hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars in back dues in order to be a part of the organization? Is it a mistake for the United States to use monies set aside for foreign aid or membership in international organizations as political props to try to force countries to behave the
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt:
Welcome listeners to another episode of the Latter Day Lens. So we've got some exciting things in the mailbag. I define exciting as things where they say nice things about me or where they say nice things about Sean. And then
Sam:
Not me.
Matt:
if they say mean things about Sam then it's exciting.
Sam:
Yes. That was all mean things about me, it's good.
Matt:
So one listener sent in some quotes to kind of support Sean's perspective on the big question from last week. This one's from Hubie Brown. He said, the only way I know of by which the teachings of any person or group may become binding upon the church is if the teachings have been reviewed by all the brethren, submitted to the highest councils of the church, and then approved by the whole body of the church. So that's kind of what you're saying is doctrine, right Sean?
shawn:
Yeah, yeah, I think
Matt:
Doctrine
shawn:
doctrine,
Matt:
is the
shawn:
doctrine.
Matt:
stuff that
shawn:
Yeah, I think
Matt:
so
shawn:
if the quote is referring to the teachings that become binding on the Church, I'm
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
assuming that means doctrine, yeah.
Matt:
So I don't have like in terms of like when we say follow the prophet or do what the prophet says Is that what the word binding means to you? Binding is if everybody agrees on it and it's sustained by the whole church then it becomes something that I should feel compelled to do and other
shawn:
I want,
Matt:
than that I
shawn:
well remember in the DNC there's a, Joseph Smith is talking to God about what is truth. How do you define truth? And remember what he said? He said something like, this is paraphrased, truth is the way things were, the way things
Matt:
Oh yeah.
shawn:
are and the way things will always be.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
I'm interested in those things. Like I like those things more than I like the temporal policy stuff. So I think that the binding doctrine or teachings would mean something like that.
Matt:
Truth.
shawn:
Truth.
Matt:
Thu-
shawn:
Absolute
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
and universal. But I had a really, really interesting discussion from one of our listeners. He was saying, because we use the example of the COVID vaccine, but he's like, hey, you guys should have talked about the masking. He says, because masking was a much more heated thing within his ward and stake and
Matt:
For
shawn:
friends.
Matt:
sure.
shawn:
And that...
Matt:
I knew people that would refuse to wear masks at church.
shawn:
And I knew people who would refuse to wear masks at church. And he says, let's see, he says, he thought, like it was hilarious to him, he says. He would go to church and he would put his hand out and he would touch the sacrament cups and
Matt:
What?
shawn:
the tray to
Matt:
That's
shawn:
take
Matt:
just
shawn:
the
Matt:
mean,
shawn:
sac.
Matt:
Sean. Oh, okay.
shawn:
What do you mean?
Matt:
I thought you meant like he's like up there where
shawn:
Rub,
Matt:
they're preparing
shawn:
oh no,
Matt:
the sacrament like touching
shawn:
no.
Matt:
everything.
shawn:
No,
Matt:
Got it,
shawn:
no, no.
Matt:
okay.
shawn:
When it was his turn to take the sacrament, someone was holding it with their bare hand. He was taking it with their bare hand. And he's like, yeah, we have these masks on. He's like, it just people were talking at the podium and touching the microphone with their hands. And he's like, it was just ridiculous to him. It was ridiculous to wear these masks. And so we had this discussion about, well, he he. So what was the reason that the prophet, like are we being obedient to the prophets to wear masks? When in fact, the reason that the prophet said wear masks wasn't it because legally, in order to meet as a church, we were required to wear masks. Wasn't that the law?
Sam:
Yes.
Matt:
Um, I don't know that that's why they said it though. Do you think that's why they said it?
shawn:
We couldn't meet as a congregation legally unless we had masks on.
Sam:
They asked congregations to obey the local laws wherever they met.
shawn:
Right. And
Sam:
So
shawn:
so
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
Matt, so,
Sam:
California
shawn:
so the
Sam:
was different than Hawaii was different than Utah was different than Idaho.
shawn:
So
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
in California here it was law. And so here's the fascinating component. If I'm being obedient to the prophet who says wear your masks at church, and some people took that as you gotta obey the prophet, the prophet's doctrine is wear masks at church. When in fact, more like the motive for wearing a mask at church was, well, we can't meet. And so I got it, we just gotta follow the law. Yet we have these people debating whether that's a Doctrine or a policy?
Sam:
I think
Matt:
Oh.
Sam:
the mask thing is more clear that it was policy as a result of law. The vaccination thing is less clear still, I think
shawn:
Why
Sam:
to a
shawn:
is
Sam:
lot of people.
shawn:
it less
Sam:
Well,
shawn:
clear
Sam:
because,
shawn:
though? Because
Sam:
because
shawn:
it becomes a matter of interpretation, just like all scripture, just like
Sam:
President
shawn:
all things
Sam:
Nelson
shawn:
that prophets say.
Sam:
deliberately set the example by getting his shot on television. Like it was a clear message, right? And I know the word, the wording was, it was an invitation and a privilege to get it. But, but, but it was very strong.
shawn:
So, Sam, you go back to the water bottle.
Matt:
No, because it wasn't because president, why does president Nelson choose to have his, his vaccination televised because he's trying to tell people this is what you should do. He's not having the smash the water bottle thing televised and he's not even asking anybody to notice that. Right. So
Sam:
I was somebody
Matt:
when the,
Sam:
else's.
shawn:
That's true.
Matt:
yeah. So, and, and then they made a special announcement about it, right? When they make an announcement from the first presidency that has a different weight than just recycling or something like that.
shawn:
But if we take vaccines or we take masks or we take Sabbath day or we take caffeine, all of these things that prophets talk about have a lot of kind of on purpose vague details and requires some interpretation. And that's why I always go back to first Nephi 10, 17. He says, Nephi says, having heard all the words of my father, who was the prophet? Nephi knowing that he was the prophet, believing he was a prophet. concerning the things which he saw, the prophet saw in a vision, and also the things which he spake by the power of the Holy Ghost, which power he received by faith. He said, Nephi says, I was desirous that I also might see and hear and know and understand of these things by the same power, by the power of the Holy Ghost. That's the gift of God to all those who diligently seek him. So you can still be obedient to the prophet and inquire of the Lord, should I be doing what the prophet is preaching?
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
It's still faithful.
Matt:
so my daughter who recently got home from a mission, we were talking about this and she reminded me of a talk that Elder Renlin gave where he was talking about receiving personal revelation and he talks about the Nephi example and he says, we should always be trying to follow the prophets and not asking for exceptions to it. So
shawn:
Agree.
Matt:
when Nephi is told, cut off Laban's head, Nephi wasn't praying and saying, heavenly father can I please cut off his head? didn't ask that question, right? He was doing something to just follow the commandments and then the Lord told him something and then it's like, okay, now maybe I should inquire of the Lord, right? So I think that there's like this intent with why you're asking matters a lot and
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
if you're asking because you're trying to get away with something or have a personal exception, that's different than I'm trying to do what's right and I'm asking for clarification.
shawn:
Well, that's, I can't think we all kind of assumed that motive in
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
the last discussion that yeah, amongst faithful people, how do you treat and handle dissonant things? Yeah. Anyway, I, it was a good
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
discussion with my friend because he was like, he was basically saying, was wearing masks doctrine from God, or was it a policy that enabled us to meet in church? And therefore it wasn't a teaching. It wasn't a teaching from a prophet, but it was something we obeyed in order to follow the local laws.
Sam:
Yeah. Again, I think that example is more clear cut than the vaccine or even the question, the proclamation of the family. Is that doctrine?
Matt:
No,
shawn:
It's not canonized.
Matt:
I don't know.
shawn:
No,
Matt:
I mean, it's
shawn:
but
Matt:
the teachings
shawn:
we touched it.
Matt:
of the prophet, right? That's,
shawn:
Well, hold on
Matt:
that
shawn:
a bit.
Matt:
is, if we go by this quote, that is the quorum of the 12 apostles and the first presidency. So it's
Sam:
Right?
Matt:
the two highest
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
councils of the church.
shawn:
but it's also, remember though, Sam, the pattern that I see at least is this, 99% of the time, the prophets aren't revealing new doctrine. What they're doing is they are clarifying, repeating the established doctrine of Christ as it's been established in scripture. I don't see any new doctrines in the proclamation of the family.
Matt:
I'll tell you the one
shawn:
It's
Matt:
that
shawn:
all
Matt:
I
shawn:
in the
Matt:
found.
shawn:
scriptures.
Matt:
I'll
shawn:
What?
Matt:
tell you the one that I found, Sean.
shawn:
Hmm.
Matt:
I've never seen this in the scriptures. It says, each of us in the premortal realm were like sons and daughters of heavenly parents. You won't find heavenly parents anywhere in the standard works.
shawn:
Hold on, hold on, but you do find there's three in the scriptures, there's Genesis, there's Moses, and there's Abraham that talk about the creation of man. And in Abraham, it talks clearly about we the gods created
Matt:
Uh-huh.
shawn:
man and women in our image. That's
Matt:
Uh-huh.
shawn:
not a reference perhaps?
Matt:
To a heavenly mother?
shawn:
man and woman,
Matt:
Okay, but
shawn:
Adam
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
and
Matt:
just
shawn:
Eve,
Matt:
saying
shawn:
created in
Matt:
heavenly
shawn:
our image.
Matt:
parents heavenly parents that phrase you won't find that anywhere in the standard works So that
shawn:
Oh, that's
Matt:
would
shawn:
true.
Matt:
be new doctrine, right?
shawn:
No, no, I think that they do definitely reword and clarify things, but is it new doctrine, the concept that there's a heavenly mother? No, there is scriptural reference.
Matt:
You ask your evangelical friend if that's how he reads the book of Genesis.
shawn:
I love my evangelical friend, but they're way off, Matt.
Matt:
I'm just saying, so if you were to show him the proclamation to the world on the family and say, you see, Heavenly Parents, that's just a clarification of what you read in Genesis, he might say, hmm, that's not exactly how I read the book of Genesis.
Sam:
What I love Sean about this approach and it's really got me thinking. And in fact, we had a discussion in our priesthood forum last Sunday about it. Was it emphasizes personal revelation and personal confirmation of things we hear, which I think that's
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
right. And in fact, someone in our meeting brought up a book. I think I texted it to you guys, a Harvard study or something created by somebody. The book's titled the sin of certainty. Right. And,
Matt:
Mmm.
Sam:
and, and in the church we do talk. About absolute certainty on certain things that you know what individuals may or may not know may or may not be certain may or may not be convinced of. And sometimes
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
that certainty robs others of the opportunity of finding out John what you're talking about yourself and that's a new construct right if you go back and you look at the I know language within the church. there's actually a couple of charts out there that show it in the eighties seventies. seventies, eighties and nineties that prior to that, it wasn't, I know, beyond a shadow of a doubt or with every
shawn:
Hehehehe
Sam:
fiber of my being, you know, there's hope that leads, uh, to, to faith and a knowledge, right. But, but, you know, the relationship with God is more of a, uh, a trust and a hope and, and a, and a seek and an understanding, right. And that's what
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
you're talking about.
shawn:
I think that is, yeah, I agree, I like that, Sam. And plus, look, there's only one doctrine in all of scripture that is more abundantly preached than this one, and that is faith, repentance, baptism, and the gift of the Holy Ghost. That is more abundantly preached in the scriptures and by the prophets that I have found. But the second to that is knock, seek, wrestle, feast, come and have that relationship with our Father in heaven through Christ. Like that's to me one of the most abundant messages through all of scripture. So instead of, it doesn't, I know you don't like the word blind, blind faith,
Matt:
No,
shawn:
Sam. I'm not,
Matt:
I don't like it, Sean.
shawn:
you want to fight about it, Matt? Ha
Matt:
No, I'm just saying that it's faith, right? Choosing
shawn:
ha ha.
Matt:
to follow without choosing to follow without praying about it is still an exercise of faith. It's actually saying, look, I trust this person so much I don't need to ask.
Sam:
Using the word blind before faith is marginalizing the person that is expressing that faith.
shawn:
You don't think, you guys are both suggesting that the concept of blind faith doesn't exist?
Matt:
No, no, no. I'm
Sam:
It
Matt:
just
shawn:
In our
Sam:
exists.
shawn:
church?
Matt:
saying that when
shawn:
It exists.
Matt:
members of the church... Yeah, but if a person chooses to follow the process... If a person says, hey, church leaders have asked me to wear a mask, so I'm going to wear a mask, that's not blind faith. That's them saying, I have faith in the leaders, I don't need to go seek out information on all this stuff, I can just follow them and trust them that it's okay.
shawn:
But that, but that.
Sam:
Or the prophet decided to get vaccinated on television, encouraged
Matt:
I
Sam:
everyone
Matt:
can just.
Sam:
else to do it, and then required missionaries, all of our
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
kids of whom were required during a period to get vaccinated, required missionaries to be vaccinated in order to serve mission.
shawn:
But that
Matt:
Like,
shawn:
habit,
Matt:
you, you...
shawn:
uh-huh, go
Matt:
Yeah, go ahead, Sean.
shawn:
ahead. But that habit of going, like I've heard this a lot, right? Well, if Joseph Smith was a prophet, and if I have a witness of that, then that means the Book of Mormon is true. And if the Book of Mormon is true, that means that the prophet is the prophet, this chain of faith.
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
If that is the habit that we have of discovering truth, it can be somewhat problematic in that you've got members of the church saying, if you don't wear a mask, you're going to hell. Because
Matt:
Well, so
shawn:
it's...
Matt:
the wrong part of that, Sean, is the judging of other people, right? The wrong part isn't the... Some things in life we gain a testimony of really quickly, and other things it's like over the course of our life we gain a testimony of them. It took me longer to develop a testimony of Joseph Smith than it did for me to develop a testimony in the Book of Mormon. But I can still behave as if Joseph Smith is a prophet before I've
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
received that
shawn:
yeah,
Matt:
confirmation. And that's
shawn:
I agree.
Matt:
an act of faith, not blindness.
shawn:
No, you're right,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
I agree with that. I just think that the abundance in the scriptures that says go get your own witnesses, go find the Holy, go let the Holy Ghost confirm to you that President Nelson's a prophet, that Monson's a prophet, that Hinkley's a prophet, that masks should be worn. That, I know, not to be commanded in all things, but that process is abundantly preached and it's only strengthening my relationship with my Heavenly Father. Right? Because I'm engaging with them.
Matt:
I love that about you, Sean. You're always encouraging people to pray more. And when I very
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
first met you in the MTC, and you'd be like, let's pray, I'd be like, again? I feel like we just prayed.
Sam:
Huh.
Matt:
So I do love, Sean, that you really want to encourage people to
Sam:
Oh,
Matt:
pray.
Sam:
oh, all I know is what I've learned is, is we transitioned to our first topic today. I can go undo my vaccination, which makes me feel happy. So I'll
Matt:
How do you undo a vaccination?
Sam:
find out. I don't know, but there's got to be a way I don't
shawn:
Oh my gosh.
Sam:
have to do it.
shawn:
Wow.
Matt:
Hey, well, so another listener said, I would love to hear Matt adopt a bit more of an expert voice on the topic of trust and political identification. He's done a lot of good research on how we align and identify ourselves politically. It's true,
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
I've done a lot of really good research
shawn:
Yeah, I wanna
Matt:
on
shawn:
hear
Matt:
some
shawn:
more
Matt:
of
shawn:
about
Matt:
these topics.
shawn:
that.
Matt:
Well, so I did wanna, go
Sam:
Should Sean
Matt:
ahead.
Sam:
and I congratulate you and affirm that you are an expert in the field?
Matt:
Words of affirmation is my love language.
Sam:
Perfect.
Matt:
So
shawn:
Yeah
Matt:
well
Sam:
We acknowledge
Matt:
so I did want
Sam:
you
Matt:
to.
Sam:
are an expert in the field as, uh, messed up as some of the opinions are. Go ahead.
Matt:
So listeners might have noticed that we don't use our last names in the podcast. And I think all of us have expertise in different areas that we don't actually really lean on that very heavily a lot of the time in the podcast. And I think that's because we made a decision about this podcast that we wanted the latter day lens is not something we own. And so I think what happens in conversations is if you lean too heavily on expertise or research or something like that, you silence other voices. And I have a strong conviction that my view is not the best view or the only view or the only important view. Even if I have expertise on the topic, I try to stay away from that and not talk about that because I think that these topics are things that everybody can discuss regardless of their level of expertise. And so I think that's why we try to like not lean too heavily on areas of expertise too often. What do you guys
shawn:
But
Matt:
say?
shawn:
I would echo the listener. I would love to continue to hear more. And I know that you're right. You're gathering data. You're studying this stuff. And ultimately, you're making a judgment or forming an opinion. And
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
I'm a little
Matt:
but the-
shawn:
more skeptical of academia. But
Matt:
Yes you are. You don't even send your kids to college.
shawn:
What do you mean? They go to college? What are you talking about?
Matt:
I'm just kidding. I just think, Sean, you're just generally skeptical. You're skeptical of academia and government. But do you know what you're not skeptical of? Prayer. You are not skeptical. But
shawn:
Why you mock me? Why you mock me in your voice, Matt?
Matt:
pretty much everything.
Sam:
Wait, why
Matt:
No, I'm
Sam:
are
Matt:
being
Sam:
you
Matt:
serious.
Sam:
mocking
shawn:
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Sam:
him? You're the one that's, you're the one that wants Kamala Harris. Maybe you should pray about that.
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
No, I'm being serious
shawn:
you
Matt:
like
shawn:
were...
Matt:
Sean you're Go ahead.
shawn:
God, you were in the MTC, you were a goof off. And so my initial
Matt:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
shawn:
response to
Sam:
Ha
shawn:
you
Sam:
ha!
shawn:
was like, oh man, this dude is not serious. And then when we got in the field, I learned that you were a goof off in the MTC because you were just bored and you were just ready to hit the ground working and going and going and going. And one day I was just in awe. And just you were my leader, dude, I loved it. I was learning so much from you. And one day we were talking and you said something like, Sean, you know what? It's more important to do the right thing for the right reasons than it is to do the right thing in general. He's like, in fact, it's sometimes bad to do the right thing for the wrong reasons. And I was
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
like, what are you talking about? But, but over the, and it almost immediately became a part of my thought process. So I, I think that prayer, the fascination of mine with prayer is because, and, and yes, and doing things intentionally has to come from that one true source, which is, which is God, the authority and the conviction.
Matt:
I didn't mean to make it sound like I was mocking you, Sean. I just know
shawn:
Hehehehe
Matt:
you well and I know that you're skeptical of power, authority, like all of that stuff. Like all of that stuff makes you nervous because you rely on God
shawn:
Not nervous.
Matt:
as your authoritative sword. Well, you don't love
shawn:
It doesn't
Matt:
it,
shawn:
make me
Matt:
right?
shawn:
nervous. I enjoy, look, I'm a punk rocker, I think. Like, I love
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
the punk rock movement because, yeah, because who gives the, man's authority has nothing. Paul said it. I don't come to you enticing words of man's wisdom or man's power or man's authority. I come with the power of God. That's what we should be seeking out. And Matt,
Matt:
You've
shawn:
you
Matt:
got
shawn:
have
Matt:
to
shawn:
man's
Matt:
be-
shawn:
authority. You have man's authority.
Matt:
You've got to be the only punk rocker who's a punk
Sam:
That thing's
Matt:
rocker.
Sam:
that way.
shawn:
The LDS punk scene, man. Follow
Matt:
I
shawn:
it.
Matt:
need to go to more of those Fugazi concerts.
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
Okay, let's get to the news. So the first story, and I'm just gonna frame the question first so that as I tell the story, it kind of makes sense. But so the question is, we've talked before about how I think we should just give people money. And you guys laugh at me and you mock me and say, no, people are lazy. So there was this study that recently was published. They look at 30 years of data. From 1989 to 2019, apparently the Federal Reserve does an annual survey of consumer finances and they looked at the upper middle class, the rich people and the super rich people and they looked at how these couples divide up the labor in their family. So just so listeners have perspective, a super rich couple, that group has a median net worth of 17.6 million, so that'd be people like Sam. And then
shawn:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Sam:
That's true.
Matt:
rich couples have a median net worth of 2.3 million. That's kind of the more the Sean range.
shawn:
Nope.
Matt:
And then the upper middle class is the median net worth of 796,000. I'm not even close to that. I need to like move to California. So my median net worth can be in that range. Anyhow. So those super rich people, they, they wanted to see of these heterosexual couples, how many of them have this situation where the man goes to work? and the woman stays at home and doesn't work. And so they find that of those super rich, 53% of them have that kind of an arrangement where the woman doesn't have a job. Those rich couples, only 27% of them have that arrangement. And of upper middle class couples, 20% have that arrangement. So that says to me, these couples, where they have so much wealth that they don't need to work, still most of them are choosing to work. Like, so I think that this supports my idea that like, if you just gave people money and they didn't have to worry about how they're going to survive, they're still going to choose to work.
Sam:
What I love about this question is I read this question four times in the email you sent across and I did not understand what you were trying to say with it.
Matt:
Ha ha!
Sam:
That's how you're going to come back to the conversation about we should give people a million dollars each instead of to the space program.
Matt:
Yes, yes, cause they'll still work Sam. Even though super rich
Sam:
We
Matt:
people
Sam:
should
Matt:
with
Sam:
object.
Matt:
seven.
Sam:
We should object and we should decline to answer the question. That's
Matt:
Hahaha!
Sam:
ludicrous.
shawn:
No, it's a good question. No, Sam, it's
Sam:
Wait.
shawn:
a good question.
Sam:
Okay. Go for it.
shawn:
Okay, Matt, really the essence of what you're getting to is you wanna have trust that if people are given an equal shot at things, production will happen, right?
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
You want equality of opportunity. That's what you're getting at, right?
Matt:
I want people to not have to do jobs that they hate. People will still
shawn:
Okay,
Matt:
choose
shawn:
well that's
Matt:
to
shawn:
a
Matt:
work.
shawn:
different story. Okay, that's a different story. Matt, I have a quote for you, and you need to tell me if this quote is Barack Obama or Adam Smith, okay? Ha
Matt:
Okay. All right.
shawn:
ha ha. Okay. It is a simple.
Matt:
I've read the complete works of both people, so I'm sure
shawn:
Have
Matt:
it'll
shawn:
you?
Matt:
be easy for me to know.
shawn:
Oh, well that's disappointing that my political science
Matt:
Like, who could
shawn:
friend
Matt:
read the
shawn:
has not read.
Matt:
complete works of Barack Obama? Ha ha ha!
shawn:
Hahaha Okay, here's the quote, you tell me, right? Equity, let's see, let's see. It is a matter of simple equity that they who feed, clothe, and lodge the whole body of the people should have such a share of the produce of their own labor as to themselves tolerably, well-fed clothe than lodged. So in
Matt:
That
shawn:
other
Matt:
would
shawn:
words,
Matt:
be Adam Smith.
shawn:
You think, why would it be Adam Smith, you think?
Sam:
Barack Obama doesn't speak that way.
Matt:
I... That's right, I was like,
Sam:
That
Matt:
Obama
Sam:
sounds like
Matt:
would
Sam:
somebody
Matt:
never...
shawn:
Oh, it's old
Sam:
in
shawn:
English
Sam:
the
shawn:
or whatever. What do you mean?
Sam:
17th
shawn:
Don't
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
judge Barack
Sam:
century.
shawn:
Obama. That's how he speaks.
Matt:
No, no, no.
Sam:
No,
Matt:
Barack Obama would never
Sam:
not
Matt:
say equity and labor
Sam:
from
Matt:
and
Sam:
Chicago.
Matt:
all of that sort of...
shawn:
Well guess what? That's a Barack Obama quote.
Matt:
Oh
Sam:
Oh,
Matt:
no!
Sam:
it's not either.
Matt:
Okay, read it
shawn:
He
Matt:
again,
shawn:
was quoting,
Matt:
now that we
shawn:
I
Matt:
know
shawn:
mean,
Matt:
it's Obama.
shawn:
it was him quoting Adam Smith though.
Sam:
Oh gosh.
Matt:
Hahaha
shawn:
I tricked ya.
Sam:
Full of conversation. Can I just make a point?
shawn:
No, then the point,
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
hang on, the point
Sam:
Don
shawn:
being though,
Sam:
you finish?
shawn:
the point being though,
Sam:
Yeah. Okay.
shawn:
both Barack Obama and Adam Smith agreed that, okay, our free market system is the best system to provide a reasonable living for the most people. That's kind of what they're saying. And he is saying that, okay, there are definitely those who will take a dollar, like Christ's parable, right, take a dollar and go invest it and go grow that dollar. And there are other people who won't be as good at that. And the scriptures do talk about, there will always be poor among us. That's what it says, right? But Barack Obama and Adam Smith here are saying.
Matt:
That's not aspirational, Sean. It's not Jesus saying, I hope there will always be the poor
Sam:
Hm.
Matt:
with you.
shawn:
No, I know it's not. No, no, no. But Barack Obama and Adam Smith, aren't they saying basically that this free market system is the best to provide the most wealth for most people in a situation where there is definitely going to be poorer? There's going to be. There's no way to make everyone equal when not everyone has the same abilities.
Sam:
Here.
Matt:
and the
Sam:
So.
Matt:
Lord called his people Zion because they were of one heart, one mind, dwelt together in righteousness, and
shawn:
Oh yeah,
Matt:
there
shawn:
okay.
Matt:
were no poor among them.
Sam:
But
shawn:
I sometimes
Sam:
we don't live
shawn:
forget,
Sam:
in that world. We're far
shawn:
no,
Sam:
from
shawn:
I
Sam:
it.
shawn:
sometimes forget that Matt's good and primary motives is to build the kingdom of God on earth.
Matt:
That's right. That's right.
shawn:
I forget that sometimes, okay, okay.
Sam:
So here's my take on it. If you take a workplace of 100 people
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
Sam:
and that workplace of 100 people, everyone has their own strengths and everyone has their own weakness. And to make that workplace as profitable as possible to produce as much of an output in innovative ideas and byproducts that benefit mankind, the best way to do that is to push your resources to the places where You get the best return and that's what free markets allow. Not everybody is sitting in their office at 10 o'clock at night working, right? Like
Matt:
Right?
Sam:
it just doesn't happen. And some will do that in exchange and pay the price to do that. And others simply won't. And the free market rewards that extra effort monetarily. And then it repeats over and over again. And to Sean's point in that example. those who have a responsibility to help those who don't. That's Christ's teachings, but not everyone is going to be equally yoked or equal in their ability to produce a benefit. And spreading money out equally in the hopes that you're going to run a jackpot is a less effective way than allowing resources to flow to people that produce the best byproduct or best return on those resources.
shawn:
Isn't it Matt?
Matt:
So Karl
Sam:
Oh no,
Matt:
Marx
Sam:
communism.
Matt:
in
shawn:
Oh
Matt:
the
shawn:
boy.
Matt:
book Capital,
Sam:
Going to
Matt:
his...
Sam:
communism tomorrow. Kamala Harris, Joe Biden. And now we're going to communism. Good.
Matt:
Karl Marx
Sam:
Uh,
Matt:
says
Sam:
you
Matt:
that. Hahahaha
Sam:
need or see me as public. Listeners. Go ahead.
Matt:
It's okay.
Sam:
Sorry, that
Matt:
Carl
shawn:
Let's
Sam:
you're
shawn:
hear
Matt:
Marx
shawn:
it,
Sam:
an
shawn:
Matt.
Sam:
expert.
Matt:
isn't the ant, he's not the
shawn:
Let's
Matt:
antichrist.
shawn:
hear it.
Matt:
Carl Marx,
Sam:
You're
Matt:
he
Sam:
an
Matt:
describes,
Sam:
expert.
Matt:
he describes exactly what you're saying, Sam. Carl Marx describes this in his book, Capital. And he says that what happens then is humans become reduced to an asset or something that you, or he calls them capital. And he talks about the negative things that does to humans and society. And he's living in this time where he's comparing them. to the agricultural society that preceded the Industrial Revolution. And so the concern is that by treating people like capital or something that you use to produce capital or treating them as an asset, you reduce humans to something that they're not.
shawn:
But that's a false way of looking at it. The working class bricklayer is not capital. Capitalists don't look at them as capital. Putin looks at people like capital, like things, right?
Sam:
By the way, guess what?
shawn:
The capitalist looks at the worker, not like a thing to be a disposable thing. It looks at them as a partner in a venture. And like Adam Smith, part of Matt, what you're suggesting... So Adam Smith actually had it, he says, look, our disposition to admire and almost worship the rich and powerful, which sounds like kind of not what you're preaching, but you're basically saying it's more important for there to be equality of riches. But he says, when we admire and almost worship the rich and powerful, and then we happen to despise or at least neglect persons of poor and of mean condition, this is the great and most universal cause of the corruption of our moral sentiments. When we say, like Marx does, oh, if you're poor, you're worth little. You're nothing. When in fact, that's not what Christ taught. He said, there will be poor among us and those people are just as valuable as is the rich person or this person or that person. Don't you think so, Matt? Why is the drive to make everyone equally rich? What does that have to do with the value of the people?
Matt:
No, I don't want to make them rich. I don't want to force them to work as labor. Because I don't want them to become an asset.
Sam:
Get
Matt:
What
shawn:
But
Matt:
were
shawn:
who's
Matt:
you saying,
shawn:
forced?
Matt:
Sam?
Sam:
get guess who? Guess who in this free market we live in sometimes makes the most money and gets the biggest return on it Landscapers
Matt:
Do I have to s-
Sam:
bricklayers to quote to quote dirty jobs Mike row I'm trying to find a good quote from him like it's those people that perform the most aggressive toughest manual labor that often are rewarded the most in our free market. And that's
Matt:
It's
Sam:
absolutely
Matt:
true.
Sam:
as it should be. Right. Like
Matt:
Yeah, no, it's
Sam:
contractors
Matt:
true.
Sam:
and bricklayers and people who make cement and big, you know, gravel pits and, uh,
Matt:
I once had a friend who was, well he was a client, but super wealthy and he owned an egg farm. And people would say to him like, how do you do this job that's so stinky? And he would say, you know, the chickens stink, but the money smells good.
shawn:
Hehehehehehe
Sam:
Yeah.
Matt:
And that's true, right? You can make a lot of money doing jobs that nobody else wants to do.
Sam:
Yeah.
shawn:
So then why, so if you're agreeing with that, Matt, why, what is your sentiment towards, well, I don't want people to do those jobs. That's kind of what you said before.
Matt:
No, no, no. My concern is this. As the economy shifts, I think we're at the precipice of a new economy emerging and all of these people that have been making lots of money as programmers are writing code for AI that's going to make their jobs obsolete. And smart vehicles, there's a lot of technological advances that are going to make a huge segment of the economy obsolete. But people, humans won't need to do those jobs anymore. And so I just think it's important that You don't shift the economy in such a way that you have like billionaires like Elon Musk that own the intellectual property created by all of these coders so that they get to make all of that money and then what happens to those coders? What happens to those jobs? And then they're left behind. So I just think you can create a society in such a way that says you don't have to work. Everyone will have a livable income and the billionaires aren't going to necessarily own all the property of everything that was created by all the... I just think, I just worry about the future. Like
Sam:
So
Matt:
it.
Sam:
I can't remember who said it or when they said it, but someone a hundred years ago said, Hey, as it relates to patents being filed by the, with the U S government, everything that can be invented in the history of the world has been invented and there will be no new innovation. And that statement was as ludicrous a hundred years ago as it was today. The great thing about free markets and capitalism is that it fights to find a way. And so as those jobs transition away from writing movie scripts and and writing code because AI replaces it, there will be all sorts of new industries that emerge where people will work
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
and they'll provide
shawn:
Matt.
Sam:
a value assisted by that AI. AI is never going to replace people completely
shawn:
Yeah,
Sam:
or entirely.
shawn:
Matt, if you have faith that if you give some random person a million dollars, that they will be productive with that, why don't you have faith that if they lose their coding job because of AI, that they won't be productive and
Sam:
Ooh,
shawn:
go
Sam:
that's
shawn:
and
Sam:
a good
shawn:
innovate
Sam:
question,
shawn:
somewhere
Sam:
Sean.
shawn:
else?
Matt:
No, it's not that I don't trust that they will, it just creates a lot of stress
Sam:
stress.
Matt:
and heartache and pressure on their lives that they don't need. Let's let them make that transition in a comfortable way
Sam:
We.
Matt:
with a couple of jet skis.
shawn:
But that stress drives me to innovation, doesn't it?
Sam:
Yeah,
Matt:
Well, what
Sam:
just
Matt:
I'm
Sam:
like
Matt:
saying
Sam:
bodybuilding.
Matt:
is this story
shawn:
It's like
Matt:
suggests
shawn:
bodybuilding.
Matt:
that it's...
shawn:
Let's go to Arnold Schwarzenegger, I like it.
Matt:
This story suggests that people with millions of dollars in assets still choose to work on a regular basis. So I don't think you need the stress of a job to count on people being productive. They're not doing it because they have to. They're doing it because they find satisfaction in labor. And I think
shawn:
I
Matt:
that's
shawn:
think maybe
Matt:
a fundamental human...
shawn:
you're concluding the wrong thing from that. Those people are wealthy because they continue to work when they don't need to. They have a love and a passion for whatever they're creating.
Matt:
Okay, let's talk about the environment then.
shawn:
Hahaha!
Sam:
Oh no.
Matt:
So the BLM Bureau of Land Management, they are proposing a rule change that would elevate conservation as one of their missions as an agency. And there's like technical things about the bureaucracy and rules and stuff like that we could discuss, but I think that's a little less interesting. So the question, like the problem is that people who recreate on public lands and people who use public lands for grazing cattle and sheep and stuff like that, they're concerned that if the BLM makes this change, then there will be a lot more land that will be designated as wilderness area. And wilderness area basically is land that humans can't really access. There's no roads in there. There aren't trails. You can't really mountain bike in those areas. And so there's this sort of fight going on, like should we focus more on conservation of public spaces or should we focus more on access so that people can go out in the woods and enjoy nature? And it's not a lot different than 100 years ago when Teddy Roosevelt came out and said, hey, we need to preserve Yellowstone and Yosemite from all of these businesses. And so he created agencies to protect those lands. So the question I have is, do we have a moral obligation to protect these lands? I phrase it as this, from greedy capitalists or recreationalists who would otherwise destroy them? Is
shawn:
greedy
Matt:
conservation
shawn:
recreationalists.
Matt:
a moral... Isn't that funny? I just thought it would be a really clever way to say it.
shawn:
That is
Matt:
because
shawn:
super
Matt:
it would
shawn:
funny.
Matt:
like kind of like poke at Sam a little bit. Sam's a greedy capitalist who
shawn:
No,
Matt:
wants
shawn:
Sam's
Matt:
to,
shawn:
a greedy recreationalist.
Matt:
who wants to
Sam:
True too.
Matt:
rape the natural land of its purity.
shawn:
Hahahaha
Matt:
But
Sam:
See you.
Matt:
do it, there are scriptures that say that we need to, we have a, we're stewards, right? So the stewardship imply conservation over recreation.
shawn:
I would be interested in Matt more of your opinion on this, but Sam, do you have anything?
Sam:
I'm curious, you know, Yellowstone and these protected lands are great. I live right next door to BLM land and as long as they protect it, it's awesome. We ride our mountain bikes in the hills around Draper, Utah. And, you know, it's frustrating to see encroachment of, of homes. So I think protecting some of those spaces, but, but absolutely allowing access. I mean, we teach the scriptures teach that. The earth was built for man, right? We have a responsibility to defend it and protect it. And, but to restrict access completely so that no one can have enjoyment from it doesn't seem to make a whole lot of sense, but you know, I'm not sure.
Matt:
So
Sam:
I'm not sure your
Matt:
here's
Sam:
point,
Matt:
my
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
example
Sam:
I guess.
Matt:
that'll maybe, maybe if this example will help elicit some responses. So we spent a summer in Payson, Utah, and we were renting a home right
Sam:
Sorry.
Matt:
at the mouth of Payson Canyon. Well, so early June, it was beautiful. Like we would go up the canyon, we would see deer wandering around because they've been down eating the vegetation. We could go up there, there were some lakes where we could go fishing. It was awesome. And then Father's Day morning, I thought there was a parade going on outside my house, but it was just a bunch of cows being led up the canyon because the cattle were gonna graze in the canyon for the summer. And from that moment on, we never saw any other form of wildlife. Just everywhere we went was cow, everywhere you looked. And then there were forest fires. And so then when we're out there fishing in these beautiful ponds, now helicopters are like grabbing water from those ponds to go fight the forest fires. And so within a couple weeks, the ponds are no longer there. There's no longer fishing. There's no longer wildlife because it's all being used, right, for like these other, I'm sure, admirable pursuits,
Sam:
I
Matt:
but
Sam:
tried to put out
Matt:
you
Sam:
a fire.
Matt:
lose... Ha ha
Sam:
What do you want them
Matt:
ha! Well...
Sam:
to
Matt:
Ha ha
Sam:
do? Stop fighting the fire.
Matt:
ha!
Sam:
Stop growing your cows. Just leave the
Matt:
Hey
Sam:
land
Matt:
listen, Sam.
Sam:
and let it sit there perfectly.
Matt:
Those those lakes are not the only source of water to fight a fire, right? We could stop growing alfalfa. I don't know something like
Sam:
little map,
Matt:
that
Sam:
the better example would be the great salt lake. And I think that's a pretty relevant example in our day, right? It was an, in a huge natural resource. It affects the climate in Utah and it has been resourced almost completely out of existence. Like it's, it's right now, people say threatening, you know, it's nearly extinct and then there's this whole concept of dust, which is toxic somehow. That'll be spread out on all of salt lake and like it.
Matt:
And
Sam:
It
Matt:
yeah.
Sam:
honestly is an environmental disaster. You could talk to people on both sides of that topic, right? That's a
Matt:
And
Sam:
problem.
Matt:
the church donated a whole bunch of their water rights just to preserving the Great Salt Lake, right? So that's an example. I
shawn:
So
Matt:
would suppose we could follow the church's example and say conservation and preservation perhaps is more important than the rights of these land, I don't know, cattle grazers, I don't know.
shawn:
Matt, you asked if it's a moral question, right? But is
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
it? Do you think it is? Is it a moral question? Or is this just one of those situations that scripture doesn't really inform us because you could be a good steward over that land by conserving it or by developing it, right? Either way, that's gonna bless someone. So is it a moral issue or is it one of those like, there is no black and white or there is no universal absolute? It's just how we as a society wanna decide to govern.
Matt:
Well, you could go you could go too far right Sean you could you could not conserve to the point that we're destroying The planet and then you could in no way define what we're doing as being good stewards of the land,
shawn:
So you
Matt:
right?
shawn:
feel like
Sam:
Inida
shawn:
it's of moral importance to balance it? Is that what you're saying?
Matt:
Go ahead, Sam.
Sam:
I think it does need to be balanced, right? You can't say, Hey, don't put out that forest fire. Cause I want to be able to look at the lake, right? Or, Hey, don't take your cattle
Matt:
Hahaha
Sam:
up there. Even though you've done it for 200 years, like cattle grazing to me seems like a fairly reasonable activity for someone that's in that industry and in that business. So reasonable steps to defend
Matt:
Capitalist.
Sam:
it. The great, the great salt lake is a puzzling deal, right? Let's, let's salt and whatever else comes out of the salt lake and help preserve it, make it come back. That's a possibility, isn't it?
shawn:
Matt, as the political expert, do you feel like the solution or the decision on this should be at an expert level? The politicians in charge, the experts in charge, or do you think it ought to be decided at a kind of democratic level? Let people vote and stuff.
Matt:
I think at the expert level on this, there's no consensus. There's just differences of opinion about what it means to conserve. So there are people that want to conserve waterways so that they can fish because they really love fishing. There's people that want to conserve waterways so that they can farm and they need the irrigation. So there's always these competing interests where there's two sides that want to conserve, but they want to do it for different reasons. And...
shawn:
So it's not a moral issue then. It's more of who's gonna yell loudest and how do we as a society wanna decide, period.
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
That's it, right?
Matt:
you've persuaded me.
shawn:
Is that it? We have, Matt, we have just a quick example. Here in Southern California, huge piece of land that was empty. All of a sudden some developers are like, we're gonna build this massive thing. The government pushes back so far because of, or so hard because of conservation that there happened to be this little loophole in the law. where the developers were able to go, fine, we're gonna skip you, government, we're gonna put this on the ballot. And so there was some loophole that allowed them and they're like, ha, look what you've done, you've shot yourself in the foot, we were ready to play ball and you didn't play ball so we're taking it to the people and we're gonna get our huge development. And then the people voted it down, which I thought
Matt:
Ha
shawn:
was
Matt:
ha!
shawn:
so hilarious.
Matt:
I thought the
shawn:
So.
Matt:
people wanted it more than what they did.
shawn:
Matt, was that a funny political joke? Would po-
Matt:
Yeah, that was really
shawn:
Was that
Matt:
good.
shawn:
a good
Matt:
I loved that song.
shawn:
one?
Matt:
Yeah, I like that.
shawn:
I was trying to make a political joke for you.
Matt:
Just for that, we're gonna change topics. We're gonna move to UNESCO. Are you guys familiar with what UNESCO is? I'm not really all that familiar. But
shawn:
just from what
Matt:
it's,
shawn:
we studied.
Matt:
yeah, there's links in the show notes if you wanna read about more what it is, but it's a United Nations organization that sets standards for science and research and things like that. And in the Trump administration, the United States pulled out of UNESCO. because they had allowed the state of Palestine into the organization, which the Trump administration didn't want to recognize as a state. And they did some things that the Trump administration thought were anti-Israel. So we're like, we're gonna punish you and we're gonna pull out. Well, then what happened is China stepped in. And this is from someone in the Biden administration. This is the undersecretary of state for management, John Bass. He says, rejoining UNESCO will help us address a key opportunity cost. that our absence is creating in our global competition with China. If we're really serious about the digital age competition with China, from my perspective, in a clear-eyed set of interests, we can't afford to be absent any longer from one of the key fora in which standards around education for science and technology are set. So this week, UNESCO announced that the United States is going to rejoin them and we're going to pay $600 million in back dues. So my question is... Is it a mistake for the United States to use monies that are set aside for foreign aid or membership in international organizations as political props to try to force countries to behave the way we want them to? Like what we did with UNESCO. Like
shawn:
Suggest
Matt:
we've
shawn:
for
Matt:
talked before. We've talked before that when the United States recedes, China steps in. And when we use our, we call it soft power, but when we use like our foreign aid and our influence with countries to try to punish activities that we think are bad, then China steps in and we give them greater influence. So is that a mistake for the United States to do that?
shawn:
Well, and to answer that, Matt, just for clarity for people listening, UNESCO stands for United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. So countries
Matt:
Yes.
shawn:
are getting involved to really influence worldwide policies in those areas, right?
Matt:
Yeah, they set standards for like human subjects research and standards for like technology. And we define like what's private, like protected intellectual property, things like that. There's all UNESCO kind of sets those.
shawn:
And so if China is heavily influencing, for example, AI, worldwide
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
AI regulations, that makes the United States nervous and Biden says,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
we gotta get back in there.
Matt:
Right. That's right.
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam:
If the United States has a big voice on UNESCO, how was it that Israel, in our opinion, was discriminated against and Palestine brought in without some sort of conversation?
Matt:
Well, because UNESCO is an organization with lots of members. So we have an influence in there and we pay dues and we give money to the organization. But in this particular case, we were outvoted. So we get outvoted, they do something we don't like and we say, fine, we're going to take our ball and go home. And China says,
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
good riddance, we'll come in.
Sam:
You know what's interesting is the UNESCO director, just in reading this, is Jewish. So
Matt:
Yeah, yeah, that's right.
Sam:
that's an irony. We get offended because we feel like they're being discriminatory against Israel, and yet the director is Jewish and supposedly helped broker the deal with the Palestinians. So
shawn:
Well,
Sam:
maybe we
shawn:
but...
Sam:
just need to have a little bit more of an open mind on it. Obviously I'm not in favor of withdrawing and giving kind of a chance to
shawn:
But
Sam:
fill
shawn:
there was,
Sam:
the vacuum.
shawn:
but before that, Sam, there was a 20 year period where the United States wasn't involved. I don't remember the years, but it seems like we go in and out of all these organizations depending on how much
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
influence we want to have. But Matt, doesn't this go back to our bigger discussion of should America's foreign policy come from we are the light on the hill? Is that the bigger discussion?
Matt:
Yeah, I think so.
shawn:
I think that should be a separate topic at some point. Let's talk about that foreign policy versus domestic policy. What are the benefits, pros and cons of being that light on the hill? Is it sound like, cause it
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
sounds like Matt, you are for this use of resources to,
Matt:
I definitely
shawn:
to become
Matt:
am.
shawn:
a part of it. You are.
Matt:
I
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
actually I'm nervous. I don't like the way that the United States I'm just not a fan of soft power Soft power has become this term that it's like we'll put sanctions on a country or we won't give you foreign aid and And we do all of that to kind of make you do what we want you to do Instead of using military might and I think that what's because there's now a new player on stage in the form of China We run a real risk as a nation. Every time we decide to use sanctions, every time we decide to punish people by not giving them money, China's there with lots of money, willing to give them money to support the Chinese interest. And I think that it's just something we need to be aware of, and I think something we need to be cautious about.
shawn:
Matt, I'm gonna default to your stance on this on one condition. You,
Matt:
Okay.
shawn:
we bring up at a later time, a bigger discussion on should we have, should our foreign policy, should we be strong on foreign policy which weakens our domestic focus or vice versa?
Matt:
Oh, okay.
shawn:
Yeah?
Matt:
Yeah, we can talk
shawn:
Could
Matt:
about
shawn:
we? Okay.
Matt:
that. Let's move on to the big question for this week, then. I love this question. This one, I think it's gonna get people super excited. So the question is, who should have the right to vote in America? I can't tell you how often I hear people say things like, only citizens should be allowed to vote in the United States. But this is the challenge, right? I'm concerned about this because voting is the mechanism through which we select our representatives. And if we want to go back to one of the founding fathers, Benjamin Franklin, who by the way, he's the only founding father that signed both the Declaration of Independence and the US Constitution. So then to me, Ben Franklin is the founding father, also maybe the most immoral man who was living at that time. But still, if we go to the OG founding father, he says, they who have no voice nor vote in the electing if representatives do not enjoy liberty but are absolutely enslaved to those who have votes." And so right now that's about 10% of our population in the United States is 33 million people. Benjamin
shawn:
Wow.
Matt:
Franklin would say that they don't have liberty and they're enslaved to the people that do vote. And I think that most people will be surprised to learn that for the first hundred years in the United States, non-citizens had the right to vote. So it's true we had restrictions on voting. You had to be a white male property owner.
shawn:
Ha
Matt:
But
shawn:
ha
Matt:
we didn't care if you were a citizen or not. All you had to do is be white man property holding. And we in fact encouraged non-citizens to vote because we thought it would bring them in and make them like feel more American, more a part of our country. And it wasn't until again, we talked about the racism of the early 1900s. That's when you start to see citizen based. restrictions on voting start to emerge in the United States. So citizenship associated with voting in the United States happens around the same time as these restrictions on immigration. And I think people would also be surprised to learn that there are lots of countries around the world that don't require citizenship in order to vote. For example, in the European Union, if I'm a citizen of, say, France and then I live in Germany, I have the right to vote in Germany. Even though I'm not a German citizen, I'm a French citizen. So for a lot of democracies, voting is about residency, not about citizenship. So my question for you, who should have the right to vote?
shawn:
Good question, Matt. So again, I don't think I can find any scriptures that help inform really the answer to that. This seems more like a, let's study what our laws are, what the Constitution says and does. But I don't even know about studying the laws because we can change laws, right? Current
Matt:
Yeah, but
shawn:
laws.
Matt:
President Oaks says we should advocate for constitutional principles. So...
shawn:
So what's the constitutional principle behind this?
Matt:
representation.
shawn:
Yes, yes.
Matt:
We have a representative form of government and so the question is who should be represented in that representative form of government. Should it just be
shawn:
So I actually have a list of questions for you, Matt, before I can form my opinion, you being the expert.
Matt:
Oh,
shawn:
Is
Matt:
okay. Sure.
shawn:
that
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
okay?
Matt:
gonna go ahead and do a little bit of a
shawn:
What would be, let's, I've always, I've been intrigued by your idea of IDs for non-citizens, right, in past episodes you've basically
Matt:
Oh yeah.
shawn:
said, let's take all of the efforts of our border security and focus on background checks and getting criminals out. and issuing a form of ID to non-citizens that allows them better to participate in the country. Yeah. Did I summarize
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
it? Okay. So based on that, let's say we do let them vote. What would be the effect of our two stupid, greedy political parties to earn those citizen votes?
Matt:
Fai.
shawn:
Would that be bad for our country or good for our country?
Matt:
Sam knows.
Sam:
Well, here's the problem in the game of voting. It all has to do with who ends up getting the most votes. So you have to follow the money. People spend money. They bring out the not all the votes. No party wants all the votes. Each party is incentivized to get the right votes. And a great example of a miscarriage of justice candidly is there was a great system that was put into place. I think a few years ago, I think it was called like Was it called ERIC? It's a voter registration system that actually the intent of this system, let me see if I can find the acronym on it. The intent of this system was to purify voter rolls all across the country. And it's called the Electronic
Matt:
Oh yeah.
Sam:
Registration Information Center. And it's technology that would purge voter rolls against driver's licenses and. passports and other easily available electronic databases. And it would sense when a person left residency in one state and went to another state, and it would make efforts to confirm their residency and then give them an opportunity to register. Republicans initially loved it. So when you talk about following the money and in fact, DeSantis Florida was one of the first States that came out hugely in favor of this. And DeSantis talked about it early on as being. a, uh, a victory in democracy, but Republicans very quickly turned on it. They went from, Hey,
Matt:
Hehehe
Sam:
this is great to, Hey, you know what? This is actually bringing out, uh, poor, uh, underprivileged voters because it's finding them. It's giving them an easy opportunity to register. And it started to start to bring out the wrong kind of vote. And very quickly, Republicans went from. Ron DeSantis saying this is the right thing to do for our state. It'll ensure our voter rolls are up to date to saying, Hey, there's a conspiracy behind this. It's allowing other people
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
to control
Matt:
that's right.
Sam:
voting. Right.
shawn:
Hehehe
Sam:
And they've,
Matt:
We're letting the poor people find
Sam:
they've
Matt:
out that they're not registered
Sam:
right.
Matt:
to vote. This is bad.
Sam:
Right. They've basically
shawn:
Hahaha
Sam:
shut it down. So what
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
should voting be voting should be. Everyone should have an opportunity. Everyone should. In fact, you can even argue right now we have the felon exclusion.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
Um, That excludes a lot of people that may still be worthy or having earned a vote, were it not for a crime that maybe was a minor crime. Everybody should be able to vote and then the cards land where they made. But that's going to be a tough problem to solve. Dairymandering is
shawn:
So
Sam:
equally a problem, right?
shawn:
Sam, your stance is that they should be allowed to vote.
Matt:
Every resident, right? Every
Sam:
Everybody.
Matt:
resident.
shawn:
Every resident.
Matt:
But not
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
kids. Not kids, Sam.
Sam:
I love, I love you turn 18. You learn a little bit about, uh, what it means to live in a democracy in school, and then you're qualified to vote. I remember the first time I voted, I was so excited to vote in the first presidential election that I was qualified to do it. I was excited to vote for state stuff. I mean, I saw it as a huge privilege and immigrants. You see the look
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
on their eyes when they're able to vote. That's it's important. And the, the politics that are involved by the two party system, roll and wheel power is really kind of
shawn:
But
Sam:
disappointing on both sides.
shawn:
that's my question to the two of you. Would the two greedy, stupid political parties that we have in our country, would they start pandering to just that group in such a way that it would be a fiasco
Matt:
They
shawn:
or no?
Matt:
would have
Sam:
What
Matt:
to change
Sam:
group?
Matt:
in some way. Right, so there's 33 million immigrants in the United States that aren't citizens.
shawn:
That group.
Matt:
That's enough to win. That's a presidential
shawn:
That's what I mean.
Matt:
election, right? So they become
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
swing voters initially, Sean, and then the candidates will have to learn, like, how do these people vote? Because right now nobody knows how they would vote. So sure, the parties are gonna have to shift and switch, but that's what we call
shawn:
Is that,
Matt:
representation, right? That's representation.
shawn:
okay. And so you think that's okay for a political party to be like, okay, we've got this huge block of people. Let's modify our message, not modify our platform on what is right and wrong for the country, but modify our platform based on what is gonna get these guys to vote for us. Is that what, that's
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
okay?
Matt:
so
Sam:
Politics.
Matt:
I think,
shawn:
That
Matt:
Sean,
shawn:
is
Matt:
that
shawn:
political,
Matt:
you think
shawn:
yeah.
Matt:
of it as way more strategic than what it is, like on a big picture, right? Elections are won state by state. And so the message to immigrants in Ohio is going to be different than the message to immigrants in Florida or in Arizona or in California.
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
There's going to be a different message state by state. But definitely the parties are going to adjust what they're trying to do to win those votes. And that's what we call representation. Now those people
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
will be represented.
Sam:
So
shawn:
Okay,
Sam:
I have
shawn:
so
Sam:
a
shawn:
it's
Sam:
tongue
shawn:
all good.
Sam:
in cheek
shawn:
Okay.
Sam:
question. I have a tongue in cheek question as a member of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, would we allow proxy voting and be able to go back to our records? And just like temple work, would we allow people
shawn:
What?
Sam:
who've, uh,
shawn:
Sam!
Sam:
you know,
Matt:
I
Sam:
there
Matt:
can
Sam:
are
Matt:
vote.
Sam:
political parties that believe in like harvesting the, uh, the, the dead boat. Why not go
Matt:
I can
Sam:
there?
Matt:
vote for and in
shawn:
Sam.
Matt:
behalf
shawn:
Ha ha ha.
Matt:
of Sam, who is dead.
Sam:
Yes. Well, opportunity
Matt:
Okay,
shawn:
Sam, what are you talking
Sam:
one
shawn:
about?
Sam:
vote.
Matt:
I'm opposed to voting for dead people, like letting dead people vote, but anyone who's alive, I would say any resident,
shawn:
Okay, so
Matt:
any
shawn:
you're both
Matt:
resident
shawn:
for
Matt:
should have the
shawn:
this.
Matt:
right to vote.
shawn:
You're
Matt:
I
shawn:
both
Matt:
think
shawn:
for
Matt:
so.
shawn:
this, but we're not a podcast of just listening to everyone agreeing on this. So I continue to have questions for both of you then to defend
Matt:
Sure.
shawn:
that. So would, okay, so you've answered the first question. You don't think that the pandering that would happen from both parties and them changing up their platforms and politicking would be a problem because eventually they would all just be citizens with the
Matt:
There.
shawn:
same interest as every other citizen.
Sam:
Why would it be a problem? Why could it possibly be a problem?
Matt:
It would just be representation, right? That's, so now I have to consider the interests of this immigrant community, that right now I'm ignoring
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
them because they can't even
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
vote.
shawn:
Gotcha. Okay. Good. Good answer. Okay. Second question. Would this if they could vote if would this attract more immigration? Two part question. Do you think it would attract more immigration?
Matt:
Do you think I don't think that anybody chooses to move to a country based on a will and excitement to vote in that country Right, like if I said
shawn:
No,
Matt:
to you
shawn:
but doesn't that lead to citizenship?
Matt:
No,
shawn:
And
Matt:
no, no
shawn:
there is a desire to be citizens here.
Matt:
No, what I'm saying, no, you don't have to be a citizen to vote that's
shawn:
No,
Matt:
what
shawn:
I
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
know.
Matt:
saying, right
shawn:
No, no, but wouldn't, but if it would progress to citizenship, right? If I'm a Chinese businessman and I go, oh, now I can vote if I have a residency in America, that will be easy for me then to become a citizen,
Matt:
So if I'm
shawn:
then
Matt:
being
shawn:
that would
Matt:
completely
shawn:
be encouraging.
Matt:
honest, so this is just anecdotally, I don't know any immigrants who are excited about becoming US citizens. Most immigrants I know are not concerned with citizenship. If they could have access to the same benefits that every other taxpayer gets, they're fine not being citizens of the United States. I think a lot of immigrants wanna come here for a time, but then go home again to their home country. I think very few of them want to stay here forevermore. And
shawn:
Oh.
Matt:
I know immigrants that have been here 10 years and have no interest in getting citizenship. They wish they could vote, but they don't want to be citizens of our country. They feel a kinship to their home country.
shawn:
Hmm. Okay, so you don't think it would encourage more immigration?
Matt:
I don't think that's what brings people here. Immigration is opportunity, maybe work, but I think that especially along the southern border, immigration could be just seasonal if we allowed it to be easier to be seasonal.
shawn:
But why then was for the last, I don't know, 10, 12, whatever long it's been, there's this American policy, I've got friends who've built whole careers on this, that if someone from China will invest a certain amount of millions of dollars into a commercial development here, they fast track to citizenship. And these guys are lining up. So
Matt:
Because
shawn:
what do you mean
Matt:
there's...
shawn:
people don't wanna be citizens here?
Matt:
So those people that you're talking about don't necessarily want to live here. Maybe they're trying to escape Chinese life, right? But there's benefits that only citizens get. What I'm saying is if you could have access to some of those benefits without citizenship, people wouldn't be trying to be a citizen. So for example, immigration is the easiest example, right? If you're a US citizen, you have a passport, you can come and go to the United States as often as you want, even if you're a Chinese resident or a Chinese citizen. So they're trying to get citizenship to make it easier for them to go back and forth from China. If we could fix that in another way, then they wouldn't care about citizenship.
shawn:
So the motive to invest millions of dollars in the economy is more capitalistic, it's less about, oh, I get to become a citizen. It's more about freedom to travel back and forth. Oh, interesting.
Matt:
That's what I think.
shawn:
I didn't,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
huh. Okay, well, okay, well, I guess that squashes my next question, because if you were to, because I would think, I would have thought, wrongfully so, I guess, that allowing citizens to vote would encourage them to say voting will allow me to become a citizen, non-citizens to vote. allow them to become citizens sometime in the future and that would attract more people.
Matt:
Sam, do you
shawn:
How
Matt:
think
shawn:
can
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
you
Matt:
wrong
shawn:
disagree?
Matt:
about that? Do you think the immigrants that are coming here want to be citizens?
Sam:
You know, I don't know. I probably don't, I probably don't have an opinion on that. I think if every immigrant had a vote, it would probably moderate some of the anti-immigration sentiment that's so hardcore in some of the parties maybe. But I don't think it would, uh, change the makeup of the country massively. I can't
Matt:
I don't
Sam:
think
Matt:
think
Sam:
of anything
Matt:
it would.
Sam:
that would,
shawn:
B-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b-b
Sam:
I do know a lot of the voting laws. If you go back to historically they're created in order to protect our version of what people see to be America, language, culture.
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam:
But in a world that's as homogenous as it is, that seems to me a little bit of an older notion.
shawn:
But then, Matt, why do we have these two idiot parties who have for many years fought back and forth, the one side saying open borders, let's let people immigrate, in fact, let's give them amnesty, let's
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
make them citizens, and the other side go, no, that's evil, that's bad, that's wrong. If that doesn't
Matt:
So
shawn:
mean that
Matt:
the
shawn:
there
Matt:
reason
shawn:
are a bunch
Matt:
they
shawn:
of people
Matt:
fight
shawn:
who
Matt:
about
shawn:
want...
Matt:
it, you notice, you notice Sean, they fight about it, but they never do anything about it. And there's
shawn:
Yes?
Matt:
broad consensus, right? There's people on both parties, they have enough votes that they could have fixed the immigration system 15 years ago. Like the votes
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
are there in the House and the votes are there in the Senate. So why
shawn:
Teach
Matt:
don't
shawn:
me?
Matt:
they fix it? Because
shawn:
Yeah.
Matt:
it's too easy to motivate voters based on that issue. So Trump gets indicted, just to go off the subject just a little bit. Trump gets indicted and goes and he's defiant and he raises $2 million in one day over his indictment. Immigration is the same kind of thing. You go out there and you say fiery, inflammatory things about immigration and it gets people excited to give you money. And it gets you excited to vote on election day. So neither party wants to solve this issue because this issue makes it really easy to mobilize voters on election day.
shawn:
That was the motive of my first question. What will the dumb parties do to pander to all these new potential votes? And they would do things like what you just described, which is empty, waste of time just to get votes.
Matt:
It's
shawn:
No?
Matt:
true they would have to find a new issue. Immigration would no longer be as inflammatory an issue as it is because all of the immigrants are gonna be in favor of like reasonable immigration policy and that'll be enough to sway elections. So then that's true, that issue would get solved.
Sam:
just find a different way to gerrymander or include
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam:
an exclude. I mean, that
Matt:
they'll
Sam:
really
Matt:
find
Sam:
is
Matt:
a
Sam:
the
Matt:
new
shawn:
Okay,
Sam:
game
Matt:
issue.
Sam:
right now. Yeah.
shawn:
okay, so these things are, these things, these topics that I'm asking really are irrelevant to you. You're basically saying, look, the principle, the constitutional principle is representation. People live here, they need representation.
Matt:
Yeah. So
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
for a long time we didn't allow black people to vote and we didn't allow them to be citizens. Then we allowed them to vote and it took like a while for the parties to figure out which black voters they wanted and which ones they didn't. But they figured it out eventually and so the issues that were divisive before black people could vote are no longer divisive because black people can vote. But now there's new issues that people fight about.
shawn:
Okay, you've definitely persuaded me, but I want listeners to give the opposite argument because we're not getting that argument represented here. I'm too neutral in wanting to learn.
Matt:
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
shawn:
You both have your strong opinions. I need someone on the other side to give me the counter argument.
Matt:
Hey, listener,
shawn:
So
Matt:
if you think
shawn:
a-
Matt:
that only citizens should vote, let us know. We'll open
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
up the mailbag.
shawn:
and a call to action.
Matt:
We'll be happy to hear your side. Like we said earlier, the latter day lens isn't just us. We're not the only people that have opinions on these issues. And maybe there's really good reasons to limit voting to citizens that we haven't discussed. So please let us know. Hey guys, thanks for another great episode. Listener, we'll talk to you again next week.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories