The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
May 3, 2023: Bank Regulations, GOP 2024 Presidential Candidates, Political News Media Landscape, What Obligations Do News Outlets Have?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Federal Reserve has completed its investigation into the collapse of Silicone Valley Bank. They have concluded that failure to properly regulate mid-size banks played a large role in the bank’s failure. “In the case of SVB, supervisors delayed action to gather more evidence even as weaknesses were clear and growing. This meant that supervisors did not force SVB to fix its problems, even as those problems worsened.” Their solution to the problem? More regulation. Do you agree that more government regulation will prevent failures like SVB in the future?
What has happened to the Republican Party? Here is the list of people who are running for the 2024 GOP nomination. If you look at the front-runners, I don’t see anything in them that remotely resembles the Republican Party I grew up with. I know that nobody wants to defend Trump—the likely nominee—but look at the rest of the field. Are any of these people better than Trump? Here is what President Oaks said in his April 2021 general conference talk on the constitution. “There are other duties that are part of upholding the inspired Constitution. We should learn and advocate the inspired principles of the Constitution. We should seek out and support wise and good persons who will support those principles in their public actions.” And “This process will not be easy. It may require changing party support or candidate choices, even from election to election. Such independent actions will sometimes require voters to support candidates or political parties or platforms whose other positions they cannot approve.” Are there any Republican candidates out there who are “good and wise” and who would support constitutional principles in their public actions?
Lots of news this week about the news media. CNN fired Don Lemon because of some sexist remarks he made on air, and because of allegations about how he treats women on his staff. Fox News fired Tucker Carlson because he alleged things on air that he clearly did not personally believe. Breitbart News recently told its reporters to stop covering stories that make Ron DeSantis more popular. We will talk more about the media in the big question, but I want to begin the discussion with these headlines. It seems like most political news outlets have a political agenda, and this influences not only what they cover, but also how they cover it. Are there any trustworthy news outlets, or is everyone pushing propaganda? If all political news is biased, how can a person find accurate information?
Big Question:
The First Amendment protects the freedom of the press. In part, this is because people need accurate information about what their government is doing to hold them accountable. Democracy simply cannot function properly if the people do not have access to basic information about what elected officials are doing. As such, news outlets have freedoms that other organizations do not. Several decisions allow reporters to refuse to identify their sources in court without facing contempt convictions. The court has ruled that newspapers can print
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
hawn
Here's the mistake I think most most of US members just make. We think that's talking about money and success. But if you really study those scripts, there's there's not a lot of. It's mostly about freedom of *******, freedom from *******.
Matt
Welcome to Latter Day lens. Unscripted faith, promoting discussion of current political events with Sean, Sam and Matt. Hey, welcome everybody to another exciting episode of the Latter Day lens with. New slate of current events to discuss. There's all kinds of really exciting stuff in the news, but we're going to begin with the. Least exciting thing. In the news, which would be the Federal Reserve and the banks? We discussed this a couple of weeks ago, so it turns out that the Federal Reserve they looked into the failure of Silicon Valley Bank ask themselves the question, why did it fail? And I think that they were very introspective. And the government blamed themselves and they said it's our fault that that bank failed and management there was some poor management on the part of SB. But if if the Federal Reserve had done a better job of regulating, then they say that the bank never would have failed and so their solution is more. So you know that I love government regulation. So my question for you is do you think that more government regulation will prevent failures like this bank in the future? It's just, it's just. A government failure of regulation and if they had just done their jobs, they could have stopped this unforeseen tragedy.
Sam
So Matt, you included a quote that says in the case of SVB, supervisors delayed action to gather more evidence as weaknesses were clear and growing. And that was the root cause according to what you wrote. If that's true, it's not the lack of regulation, it's just the lack of actionable oversight on existing regulation that caused. Cause the. And it's interesting in cycles of good economies and then challenging times and good economies and challenging times, whenever things are good, people want to continue to see good. And I think a weakness in human nature is a tendency to look the other way and overlook rules when things are so good, because you assume things. Will always. Be good. What should happen is whatever oversight was there should have been executed on like it should have been, and there wouldn't be a problem. I say less, you know, we don't. Need additional oversight. Wait, wait.
Speaker
What about? Wait, wait, wait.
Matt
Wait, I'm gonna jump in here, Sean. Real fast. OK, because I have a totally different take than that. Sam, I feel. Like Republicans don't.
Sam
You provided the quote OK.
Matt
No, no, no. That's right. And that's the quote from the Federal Reserve. What my take on this is that Republicans don't like government regulation. And so when government, when Republicans are in charge and Republicans are nominating people. To to be in charge of things like the Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell, for instance, was chosen by Donald Trump, a Republican. They choose people that are bad at regulating because Republicans are like Boo Boo regulations. We don't want oversight. So let's choose people who are bad at those jobs. And then those people do a bad job of what they're doing, and then the Republicans say, see government's no good. Because government can't do its job and. I say, well, if you picked good people for. Those jobs then we wouldn't have that.
Sam
Yeah, but that's a pretty general statement about the type of people that Republicans bring into those oversight roles. If you go and you look at other people like, who's in charge of the CFPB, I'm not a huge fan of her.
Matt
Nancy Pelosi, I think it's Nancy Pelosi.
Sam
Well, no, no, no, not Nancy Pelosi before her. She ran for a very early on in the the Democrat presidential way back when. Elizabeth Warren, right? So the Democrats have a tendency to bring people that have 0 background in business to try to do oversight in business in ways that are actually pretty detrimental and demonstrate a complete lack of understanding of business. The current head of the CFPB is a wonderful example of that right?
Speaker
I didn't.
Sam
Never spent a day in the business but but.
Matt
Is that Rohit Chopra?
Speaker
I did not think I.
Matt
OK.
Sam
Yes. And and.
Shawn
Did not think that this discussion would start off so early with one of you being anti Republican, the other being anti Democrat and being the two parties fighting against each other. I didn't know that this would be.
Matt
But I really think that's. The root of.
Sam
This, but what? No but see. Here's the thing. Though the quote right here simply states supervisors delayed taking action, they knew they needed to take action. They had actionable information. They should have taken action and arguably had they taken, they would have preserved confidence and there wouldn't be a there.
Speaker
Can I have?
Sam
Would have been a problem.
Shawn
So, Sam, you said something earlier that when times are good, we are prosperous. We tend to be a little more.
Speaker
It's the cycle.
Shawn
And you said you said we tend to be a little more the Book of Mormon reference, we tend to be a little more LAX and the people tend to. Act a little, we see. And and then we act less responsibly.
Sam
We want to see, yeah.
Shawn
And then there's problems. Well, isn't one of the accusations of the last. What is it, Matt? 5-10 years with all the bailouts? Isn't that also the heavy regulation and the government bailing bailing these banks out? Isn't that also a reason, maybe a lot of these banks are? Acting lax?
Matt
Because they know that there's no.
Shawn
They're not. They're not gonna fail.
Matt
Yeah, there's no consequence.
Shawn
No consequences. So more regulation makes people go well, it'll be fine. Let's take the risks. Let's behave badly.
Sam
OK, so let's add, you know, let let's take that one, two steps beyond. Let's add more. Regulation we ignore.
Matt
I'm saying right to not ignore.
Sam
The and then and then let's. Let's actually who's the person that that you wanted in charge of the? CFPB. I can't pronounce it. And I.
Matt
Right.
Sam
Apologize, I want to slaughter it, but.
Matt
Chopra, is that who it is.
Sam
So Rahid Chopra, let's put her in charge, even though she doesn't understand what she's supervising. And there's no there's no elected oversight for that organization. Some of the structure you have to admit, the way it's set up is lunacy. If we just obeyed the laws and we just did what we're required to do currently, this wouldn't have happened. Somebody fell asleep at the wheel, chose not to take action when they should have taken. And they should pay for that. There should be a consequence, Matt.
Shawn
Hey this is a very remote. You're a political scientist. Do you know who in 1963, Wright Pattman is the chairman of the House Banking and Currency Committee we have.
Matt
Now you're making it sound like because I know political science. Yeah, I should like Wikipedia is.
Speaker
Yeah, it's good to.
Matt
Part of my.
Sam
Members out of mouth.
Matt
See 1963. Let's see. No.
Shawn
No, no, no. Do you have his base like a baseball card you have like? A picture you. In your room nerding out with old politicians and and things. No, OK.
Matt
In 1963, I would have a Martin Luther King junior base. Of course.
Shawn
OK. OK, good.
Matt
But OK, go on Sean.
Shawn
So he he had a quote back in the day when things were failing and this was a big, scary thing. And he said, I think we should have more bank failures. The record the last several years of almost no bank failures. And finally, last year, with no bank failures at all is, to me, a danger signal that we have gone too far in the direction of bank. Safety now weird statement, but I think there's some wisdom in there's probably should be a good amount of bank failures. In fact, I believe don't quote me, but I think there's three to four bank failures per year in this. Country and they don't get bailed out.
Matt
Yeah, I'm not opposed. I'm not opposed to bank failures. I'm opposed to bank failures to the tune where the government has to bail out the banks, right?
Shawn
That's what your question was. Your question is do does government regulation prevent failures?
Matt
Failures like Silicon Valley bank. So the problem with Silicon Valley Bank is. They're being extraordinarily risky and they're not protecting. They don't have enough deposits on hand to protect, like they don't have enough cash on hand to protect their depositors. So, so then the federal government feels like they need to give money to people who are. Risky with their assets.
Sam
And and there were rules in place that had those rules been followed, and whoever the supervisors are, had they done what they were supposed to do, it never would. Have gotten as far as it did, but it did.
Shawn
So, Sam, you're saying you're saying let those people fail and let the bank fail and let the consequences follow?
Sam
Thing I absolutely would have let the big fail. And by the way, I want to take back what I said about Rohit Chopra from CFPB. He's a Harvard grad. And then he went to work for McKinsey. But I don't know that he's run business or had the business acumen. I have no way of knowing to be able to put the type of regulation in place that would be. Thoughtful and effective, right?
Shawn
So, so Matt and Sam, I feel like bringing in a little bit of scripture here because I think there is a principle here that's interesting. It takes it takes us on a tangent a little bit, but it's you.
Sam
Bring it.
Shawn
Tell me, Matt, if it takes us off.
Matt
Go ahead, Sean.
Shawn
'S idea of. This balance of banks failing and and protecting banks, I often hear members of our church refer to look if we're faithful or righteous, there's prosperity in the land. I agree that that this concept of keeping the commandments brings prosperity in the land, is abundant in the scriptures. There's lots of references to prosperity.
Matt
Well, mostly in the Book of Mormon.
Shawn
Yeah, there's four or five in the in the New Testament, but you're right mostly in. The Book of Mormon, but I.
Matt
Not doctrine and covenants really, right?
Shawn
There's a few in the B. And C yeah. There are, but here's the mistake I think most most of US members just make.
Matt
Oh, OK, all right.
Shawn
We think that's talking about money and success. But if you really study those scriptures, there's not a lot of. It's mostly about freedom of *******, freedom from *******, so prospering in the land without having *******. And it's talking about receiving God's glory. Basically, it's talking about spiritual prosperity. It's talking about the prosperity of the soul and of the spirit. It rarely. Now I would love for listeners to go and study these these principles. That I've studied a lot in the scriptures about this concept of prosperity. It's not necessarily talking about money and prosperity in that sense. So back to the topic. I don't know, man. I think there should be a good balance. I mean, if no banks are failing ever, and I know you're not arguing that. That suggests corruption to me, like clearly there are lots of businesses doing wrong things, and the natural consequence of those things should be failure, right? SVB Bank was doing risky, risky, risky things with no consequence. It seems like letting that fail. Seems like a a good thing, man, and I know the argument is. Yeah, but look at the people who suffer.
Matt
That's right.
Shawn
They'll be fine. They'll be fine.
Matt
Yeah, well, the problem is when the government puts FDIC on the bank, then it it's it's sending a message to the public that the government is going to help them out because they say this is Federal Deposit Insurance company, right. That corporation, that's.
Sam
That's different.
Matt
Well, so that's.
Sam
That's that's preserving depositors stakes in the bank that's not propping up the bank and allowing the bank to continue.
Matt
But what but but the?
Sam
So those are two separate things.
Matt
Big problem with SVB is that they are giving money to these depositors that have had assets in excess of what the FDIC would normally cover. And so I I do have a problem with that, right? It's like if you put $2,000,000 in the bank and it's not, it's just, I just think that the public isn't adequately aware of what's going on.
Shawn
Yes. Yep, that's it.
Matt
It's a complicated industry and so I think the government, if you're going to. Have something like the FDIC.
Sam
Very complicated.
Matt
Like giving confidence to a bank, then that the government has some obligation to the public to let them know. Some way of letting them know.
Shawn
I like that Matt. Matt, make make stronger laws that that put make banks more transparent with how much money and what kind of money and where it's going. Yeah, I want to know that I've invested this or I've put this money in. The bank and that they're living within the regulations, the FDIC regulations that keep my money safe and short. Yeah, make it make it very, very transparent. I think that's a good solution.
Matt
So let's move on to. The GOP presidential group like. I don't know. I don't know guys like. But I consider myself a conservative Republican, and I've always worn this this badge Republican Party with with pride. I've been a proud Republican most of my life. But as I look. At the field of presidential contender. I just find myself like wondering what happened to the Republican Party. Like, where did they go? And I have something I have a quote in here from President Oak. So this is in the April 2021 General Conference in his talk on the Constitution, he says there are other duties that are part of upholding the inspired constitution we should learn and advocate the inspired principles of the Constitution. We should seek out and support. Why is in good persons who will support those principles and public actions, and then he also says this process will not be easy. It may require changing party support or candidate choices, even from election to election. Such independent actions will sometimes require voters to support candidates or political parties or platform. Whose other positions they cannot approve, and so that says to me like that's kind of like a green light. Like, hey, if the Republicans aren't gonna uphold the constitutional principles, then maybe I need to send them a lesson and look for Democrat candidates. Well, so then I want to discuss this question. Like are there any Republican candidates out there who are good and wise and who would not support the constitutional principles in their public action?
Shawn
So Matt, do you want it? There's such good questions in that the first question is what the heck happened to the Republican Party? Why does it look so differently than it does now than it did in the Reagan era? And then the traditional conservative times in the? What 30s, Forties, Fifties, 60s? Is that the question, like what happened and why has it changed? Or is your question looking at the current Republican President saying?
Matt
Yeah, I I mean, I don't think we could really answer. I don't think we really know why it changed. But I do think we could look at where it is right now and and maybe I just misperceived things like maybe there's Republican candidates that are. Really are good candidates good and wise, and I just don't see them. And maybe the other Republicans aren't seeing them right now.
Shawn
So there's a there's a cool podcast called Conservative something Nice Plug. I don't remember they they these two guys. Basically, they just take books that are either the foundation of conservatism or the foundation of liberalism, and they just read the book, and then they summarize and talk about each book to kind of just point out. Look, here's what is traditional or foundational. Service ISM. Here's what is traditional, foundational liberalism. It's really fascinating. Now, if you look, they've kind of described that. Look, there's, there's traditional conservatism and then there's, like, the libertarian side of conservatism. Is that, would you summarize that populism?
Matt
And then there's populism. Yeah, protectionism xenophobe. Yeah, go ahead.
Shawn
So he goes, they go in to kind of explain that the the the major difference between like the Reagan era conservatism and then. Today, there's big differences. Isn't there? Like, like back in the day, let's see.
Matt
Reagan, with small government, fiscal responsibility.
Speaker
OK so.
Matt
National Defense, fight against communism in favor of immigration.
Shawn
Which is more which is more that mask, right? He brought in that anti communism kind of national security conservatism. That's kind of a conservative value, isn't it?
Matt
Yeah, I think it is, yeah.
Shawn
Which it doesn't like you had mentioned in the past, doesn't get talked about much and then the traditional conservatism is more about values, virtue and order, right?
Matt
Yeah, yeah. Moral principles.
Shawn
And then the the libertarian one is, isn't that more?
Matt
About individual freedom. Individual, yeah.
Shawn
Right. So if you, if you if you if you define conservatism based on those, I think you're right, you look at today's Republican Party and it looks very different, doesn't it?
Matt
But I do think so. I think that the allure from me to the Republican Party is that I've always sort of thought of the Republican Party as a party that's defending moral values, that I think are important in society. And and even in the in that regard, I feel like some of the candidates have lost their way and they're advocating things that don't look like moral values and moral principles, but it's it's also true that I'm not really embedded in this world. And I I imagine there are probably candidates out there. The fit, Sean, even the Reagan definition of conservatism, maybe they're just not popular. Right now, like Ace, like the guy from Arkansas Ace and ASA Hutchinson, I think he maybe is a Reagan Republican.
Sam
Yeah, I think I think they're out there. The, the, the challenges, they've just been drowned out and and there's probably some fear too because that approach right now doesn't sit well on a stage with Trump. I mean, Trump just beats the living daylights out of these people. He he calls them names, he marginalizes them and he runs them off stage. And, you know, a guy like Pence is a pretty good guy. Right. Like I I think he's a a very. Decent, good, good, good.
Shawn
Yeah, he seems like a.
Sam
Wet Noodle, though I I met, I met.
Speaker
What does that mean?
Matt
What noodle. What does that noodle?
Shawn
A guy that just follows around Trump for four years and just does whatever he says.
Sam
I I met. Well, but maybe that's a little bit of the Trump effect. I met Jeb Bush in in Iowa and and had breakfast with him and and his campaign ahead of his campaign with some people I work around and, you know, super nice guy, right? But not as not the rock star that our culture demands right now.
Shawn
So so isn't that?
Sam
And it's interesting. We're gonna. We're gonna talk about it in just a minute, but I think these cycles are real in history, and they're at work in our world. Today and as far One Direction as maybe Trump and others have taken the party, it'll swing. Back you would hope, right?
Shawn
I wonder, Matt, do you think it will swing back?
Matt
Well, I think that the Republican Party is at a bit of an inflection point. So if if I were to take a broad historical brush and sort of paint things, I'd say, yeah, history does repeat itself in some ways. I think that this group of Republicans that really likes Ron De Santis and likes Donald Trump geographically, a lot of them are, are concentrated in the deep. Mouth and you know, 50-60 years ago they were all Democrats and they were all fighting against the civil rights movement. And they were trying to stop the Democratic Party from civil rights and and they basically all decided, let's leave the Democratic Party and let's go to the Republican Party and the Republican Party embrace them. And it's really helped the Republican Party gain power. The ways that it couldn't before, but they've become.
Shawn
You're talking about working, you're talking about working class white people is. What you're talking about, right?
Matt
Oh, I don't, I. I just call them the racist Southerners. That's what I call.
Shawn
Oh, oh boy.
Matt
Them I mean, I mean. Like they're not a.
Sam
He's gonna find he's gonna find a way to give the current Republican Party a backhanded slap.
Speaker
No, no, no, no, like.
Sam
One way or another. Right backhanded copy. It's a party of right let's.
Matt
So I'm going to nobody. Nobody likes the the label racist, but I'm going to be quite honest like where I live in Utah and Idaho, we sometimes will have these like get togethers where we have these competitions and say hey let's tell jokes and let's see who's got the funniest jokes and then I will say by the way no racist jokes allowed and it's crickets. Nobody's got any jokes to tell. And then I say, OK.
Speaker
You can. I'm I'm.
Sam
Come on, come on, come on.
Speaker
I'm a.
Matt
100% serious, like they're people are racist, right? So not in like, not in, like and we hate black people kind of thing, but in a it's really fun to make jokes, racist jokes kind of thing.
Shawn
You think it's a? You think it's an ignorant racism, not a proactive.
Matt
I'm just saying, like young people who don't know better how to hide it. There's a lot of racism in Utah and Idaho.
Shawn
No, I do. I don't think it's.
Sam
A Utah well, it's like Romney's binders full of women. Comment, right?
Shawn
I don't think it's.
Sam
There's something deeply embedded that without knowledge is somehow brings you to that a little bit, actually, I think.
Shawn
Being being being the Southern California guy, I will defend Utah, Idaho. I don't think it's people in Utah and Idaho. They're racist.
Matt
No, no, no. So.
Shawn
I think it's I.
Matt
I didn't get to finish. My point, so I'm saying like. I see it in Utah and Idaho a little bit, but then go to the South, spend a little bit of time in Louisiana and Mississippi, Alabama, the Carolinas. There's there's, like a deep racism there. So we get it a little bit here in Utah and Idaho and you go to those other places and you want to tell racist jokes and you're not even gonna get anybody kind of like looking at you like you shouldn't be telling that racist joke. Like there's some deep racism, especially in the American South, and I'm so I don't wanna like paint the brush. And say the Republican Party is racist. But there is a a big segment of the Republican Party. That is overtly racist. There's a lot of them that are covertly racist, and then there's a lot of them that kind of like aren't opposed to racist people, right?
Shawn
So Matt, so Matt, so if that if.
Sam
I think that's an unfair generalization.
Shawn
But, but if that's true, we don't know if it's true or not, right? If that's true, that is certainly a a change from the Republican Party, right, Republican.
Speaker
No, no, no.
Shawn
What do you?
Matt
No, it's no, it's the. It's the Republican base. These are the people that got Ronald Reagan elected. He doesn't win with that. They're the ones that brought the Republicans in. In 1994.
Shawn
No, but what I'm saying is traditional conservatism or the Republican Party of Abraham Lincoln maybe isn't.
Matt
Ohh well come on.
Speaker
That you.
Matt
I mean, yeah, I.
Shawn
You asked what you asked.
Matt
Mean that's that's too far back.
Shawn
What happened? You asked what happened to the Republican Party? So I guess what standard over the Republican Party are you?
Matt
Well, yeah. I mean, there's a whole history there that we could talk. So all I'm saying is, if there's this group of the Republican Party that's racist, some of them, there's a group of them that really hates immigrants, some of them and.
Speaker
Alright, alright, alright. And then there's.
Matt
A large contingent of them that are, like, let's say, evangelical Christians, and they care about moral values. And all of that stuff sort of gets meshed together into one big. Sort of like goop that we. Call the Republican Party. And sometimes some of those candidates espousing those things have an outsized voice compared to the rest of the party. Right, so so I'm. Not saying Republicans are racist? I'm saying all parties are like coalitions of different groups of people. And this 30% of the Republican Party, that there's maybe like not not the kind of people I would hang out with that sometimes they get an outsized voice in the Republican Party and yeah.
Shawn
So, so, so maybe Sam, you mentioned earlier the celebrity element of Donald Trump that has really affected the Republican Party. Maybe that's there's something to that like to me, I think that the technology has. Enabled, for example big media to use its power to really divide. Like use philosophies to divide. And they do that because now that there's data like Matt, you've taught me this, that Donald Trump looked at Twitter would tweet something, look at the data results, the analytics and go, OK, this is what people. Care about and whether it's yeah.
Matt
100,000 likes. If he got 100,000 likes on a tweet, it became a a campaign promise.
Shawn
With so Donald. Trump would tweet something whether he believes it or not, whether it's moral or not, whether it's good or. Not whether it's conserve. Never. Not if it got up more than 100,000 retweets. That was a campaign that was what he'd campaign that he was simply marketing, right? Is what you're saying.
Matt
Yeah, yeah.
Shawn
So I think what I'm trying to get to is the technology has. Allowed big media. To to do that right to use the analytics to go OK, what are some what are groups of people that can sway votes? What are they into? All right, now let's make that our platform. And when it's money driven like that or power driven like that, what you get is you get Fox News and MSNBC, what you get is Republicans versus Democrat. You get division and. Divide, divide, divide. Divide and you get these extremes on both sides, which is what I think the the parties have. Become isn't it?
Sam
Well, but the great thing about the great thing about the history of America is anytime we swing to extremes, oftentimes it comes back and it you've gotta believe and and we're gonna talk about this in a second with our next question. But it's gonna swing back a little bit. And and I'm excited to go to question #3, but before we go there, can I just bring up one comment that I think we went by very quickly that is actually a. Big deal. So Matt, I had never read this comment from Elder Oaks. So, you know, an apostle in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints making a statement in a public forum, which then becomes policy sort of of the church, right. I've never heard of an apostle of the church talking about changing public party. And or aligning with public parties where we may not fully support or agree with the entire platform of that. So as I grew up as a kid in high school in our ward, we knew the one guy who was Democrat. He was crazy. And we all felt very safe because we had him in a in a in in such a a circle and a cocoon that he could have. No influence on.
Shawn
Wow, that's weird.
Sam
And now we're in a world now.
Shawn
Dude, that is weird. What you're saying.
Sam
We're in a world. The conversations we're having right now not only should be normal and they're not yet, but they should actually be encouraged. So instead of making fun of Matt for being pro Biden.
Matt
I am not.
Sam
Right. Like like there could be a time where the church looks at the two sides. I mean, and and and Trump is a fairy example of that. Like, you know, Utah voted Republican. You know, we've always been completely in the Republican camp. We gave Trump a tough time in the last presidential election. We were the one state that didn't go that way as as as much as as we had in the in the history of the.
Matt
So my yeah, my fear, Sam, is that?
Sam
Country right. So.
Matt
Republicans are going to just choose Trump the next Trump, and they're not going to, right. So Trump?
Sam
I don't think there is an extract though.
Matt
Ohh, come on.
Sam
There's still.
Matt
The Santas, the Santas, is so much like Trump.
Sam
Gonna be like him, no.
Shawn
No, he is not mad.
Sam
I I don't think DeSantis really has a chance.
Shawn
But he's not that much like Trump.
Sam
I really don't.
Shawn
Is he alright?
Matt
I ohh yeah.
Sam
He he's he doesn't have the personality. He doesn't have the character, you know?
Matt
Yeah, I just mean it.
Sam
He he's he's slow out the gates with his campaign and he is not taking the the hits. And here's another example. Just one last example about how things. Looking back, I was concerned when the Supreme Court overturned. Roe V Wade. From from a gospel standpoint, we're against abortion generally, but once something becomes ingrained as the law of the land, it concerns me to undo it. Republicans came back and they said, hey, we're not undoing this. We're just allowing states to have control over whether it happens or not. And it's interesting, this past week. There are two states that actually have it up, Nebraska and South Carolina. Where they were trying to ban abortion in those states, states where Republican Republicans had the majority and and and and banning abortion should have, should have taken off clearly and easily. And it didn't, right?
Matt
Yeah, but it did in Utah and Idaho.
Sam
So I I think. But it did in Utah and Idaho, and it could be undone. But we're pretty progressive.
Matt
So so kind.
Sam
In some right?
Matt
Of a funny story, Sam, about how this. Swing back in the day about 100 years ago, the Utah Peoples Party was the LDS party in. The state of. And the church decided that in order to get statehood, they needed to, like, either align with Republicans or Democrats. So David O McKay and his biography, the story, is that in church one Sunday, the Bishop said everybody sitting on this half is a Republican, and everybody sitting on this half is a Democrat, and David O McKay. She was just a child at the. And he says I was so disappointed because the only Republican in town was the town drunk. And I did not want to be affiliated with the Republican Party. So it is funny how things kind of change over time. The perceptions of parties and what they stand for. And I agree. I think that we should have an allegiance to something higher than a party and it there is not a party that I will agree with. Every single one of their positions and everybody in the party. And so if I'm going to just be a voter and choose based on positions, I have to be willing to say, hey, I can accept some things. I'm not a big fan of and then vote for the candidates I think are best.
Sam
And other oaks cleared the way for engine right and and I think that that's a pretty good reason for us as a podcast to have a goal to have a general authority in a public setting.
Matt
Yeah. Yeah. In general conference.
Sam
Talk about the podcast because this truly models that type of conversation, conversations that many of us may have been uncomfortable to. Have in any other.
Shawn
Yeah, I say pre I agree, guys preach it. It loud, right? Loyalty to a man made profit driven political party is falling. It's a wrong thing. It'll never lead us, right? Right. But if we take the principles of Christ through scripture or the apostles, yeah, we're going to seek for. Principles and laws, and we're going to, yeah, if that sways us, then so be it. No loyalty to these pardons.
Matt
And I would advocate to actually people should get involved in run for office themselves. If you don't like what a party, if you don't like what the Democrats stand for, go run for office and be a Democrat representative and then you get to decide what they stand for and all their voters have to sit around and say, well, I guess they hadn't. Well, I wish they hadn't taken that position, but Oh well, that's the person in charge.
Sam
And as evidence of that, isn't it crazy that this presidential election looks like it's going to end up being? Right, two people that have negatives that are so high, like the entire country is screaming. Don't do it yet.
Matt
That's what's going to.
Sam
It's gonna happen again. Good people need to truly get involved.
Speaker
So let's move on.
Matt
To a discussion of the news media. So there's a lot of news this week about what's happened, so CNN fired Don Lemon because of some sexist remarks he's made in public on air and stuff. He does how he treats women on his staff.
Sam
Many of them many.
Matt
A lot of people know about Tucker Carlson, that perhaps he was not the most. On this person in the world, I don't know if you guys are aware of this, but Tucker Carlson has the distinct honor of being fired from PBS, CNN, MSNBC and Fox News, so I can't think of a more fitting example.
Shawn
Hold on.
Matt
Of a person. You're just.
Shawn
He gets but.
Sam
What was he doing at PBS?
Shawn
But Matt, he gets but gets.
Sam
Was he like some people?
Shawn
Street map. But some people praise him for that, right? Because if if part of our argument is that a lot of these media giants have agendas, some people praise him to be like, oh, he's not willing to jump on their agenda. Obviously he has evidence that he is willing to jump on some agendas. But being fired from those places, some people say good for him because he wasn't willing to jump.
Matt
Right. But that's not true. Watch. Your shows on all of those. Networks, what he did is he was a chameleon and he adapted whatever the audience wanted the like. The extreme elements of that audience, he would just fan the flames of whatever those things are. And if you look at his Twitter post after he left Fox News, the same thing like who knows where he's going to go next. But he's certainly not gonna continue on the Fox News thing that he had at Fox News. He's gonna do some other thing. That he's already starting to fan the. Flames of whatever that. Is, yeah, but.
Shawn
One but one theory is that, like you said, he's a chameleon, right? On the one hand, he's he's just giving in to whatever the paycheck tells him to talk about and on and on the other hand, he's sometimes trying to go.
Sam
He's an entertainer.
Shawn
Yeah, but I don't agree with that. Is he good at it? No, definitely not. And do I support him? No, but. But but I mean, look at look at all the other voices in the media, look at, we watched Jimmy Kimmel every night. I don't know why that guy is so in love with Donald Trump. He talks about nothing but Donald Trump.
Matt
In love with making fun of Donald. Trump, right? He.
Shawn
Well, that's what I mean. He's obsessed with him. Yeah, but it helps Donald Trump because it makes him keeps him relevant. So it's such a backfire and Jimmy's end.
Matt
It's negative about Trump. But it helped. It helps. Jimmy Kimmel because it keeps his ratipt
00:00:02
Here's the mistake I think most most of US members just make.
00:00:05
We think that's talking about money and success.
00:00:08
But if you really study those scripts, there's there's not a lot of.
00:00:10
It's mostly about freedom of *******, freedom from *******.
00:00:16
Welcome to Latter Day lens.
00:00:17
Unscripted faith, promoting discussion of current political events with Sean, Sam and Matt.
00:00:26
Hey, welcome everybody to another exciting episode of the Latter Day lens with.
00:00:32
New slate of current events to discuss.
00:00:35
There's all kinds of really exciting stuff in the news, but we're going to begin with the.
00:00:38
Least exciting thing.
00:00:39
In the news, which would be the Federal Reserve and the banks?
00:00:42
We discussed this a couple of weeks ago, so it turns out that the Federal Reserve they looked into the failure of Silicon Valley Bank ask themselves the question, why did it fail?
00:00:51
And I think that they were very introspective.
00:00:53
And the government blamed themselves and they said it's our fault that that bank failed and management there was some poor management on the part of SB.
00:01:01
But if if the Federal Reserve had done a better job of regulating, then they say that the bank never would have failed and so their solution is more.
00:01:10
So you know that I love government regulation.
00:01:13
So my question for you is do you think that more government regulation will prevent failures like this bank in the future?
00:01:19
It's just, it's just.
00:01:20
A government failure of regulation and if they had just done their jobs, they could have stopped this unforeseen tragedy.
00:01:27
So Matt, you included a quote that says in the case of SVB, supervisors delayed action to gather more evidence as weaknesses were clear and growing.
00:01:35
And that was the root cause according to what you wrote.
00:01:39
If that's true, it's not the lack of regulation, it's just the lack of actionable oversight on existing regulation that caused.
00:01:47
Cause the.
00:01:48
And it's interesting in cycles of good economies and then challenging times and good economies and challenging times, whenever things are good, people want to continue to see good.
00:01:58
And I think a weakness in human nature is a tendency to look the other way and overlook rules when things are so good, because you assume things.
00:02:08
Will always.
00:02:08
Be good.
00:02:09
What should happen is whatever oversight was there should have been executed on like it should have been, and there wouldn't be a problem.
00:02:15
I say less, you know, we don't.
00:02:17
Need additional oversight. Wait, wait.
00:02:18
What about?
00:02:18
Wait, wait, wait.
00:02:19
Wait, I'm gonna jump in here, Sean.
00:02:21
Real fast.
00:02:21
OK, because I have a totally different take than that.
00:02:24
Sam, I feel.
00:02:25
Like Republicans don't.
00:02:27
You provided the quote OK.
00:02:27
No, no, no.
00:02:28
That's right.
00:02:28
And that's the quote from the Federal Reserve.
00:02:30
What my take on this is that Republicans don't like government regulation.
00:02:34
And so when government, when Republicans are in charge and Republicans are nominating people.
00:02:39
To to be in charge of things like the Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell, for instance, was chosen by Donald Trump, a Republican.
00:02:46
They choose people that are bad at regulating because Republicans are like Boo Boo regulations.
00:02:51
We don't want oversight.
00:02:52
So let's choose people who are bad at those jobs.
00:02:54
And then those people do a bad job of what they're doing, and then the Republicans say, see government's no good.
00:02:59
Because government can't do its job and.
00:03:01
I say, well, if you picked good people for.
00:03:02
Those jobs then we wouldn't have that.
00:03:05
Yeah, but that's a pretty general statement about the type of people that Republicans bring into those oversight roles.
00:03:10
If you go and you look at other people like, who's in charge of the CFPB, I'm not a huge fan of her.
00:03:16
Nancy Pelosi, I think it's Nancy Pelosi.
00:03:18
Well, no, no, no, not Nancy Pelosi before her.
00:03:21
She ran for a very early on in the the Democrat presidential way back when.
00:03:25
Elizabeth Warren, right?
00:03:27
So the Democrats have a tendency to bring people that have 0 background in business to try to do oversight in business in ways that are actually pretty detrimental and demonstrate a complete lack of understanding of business.
00:03:40
The current head of the CFPB is a wonderful example of that right?
00:03:42
I didn't.
00:03:43
Never spent a day in the business but but.
00:03:44
Is that Rohit Chopra?
00:03:46
I did not think I.
00:03:46
OK.
00:03:47
Yes. And and.
00:03:47
Did not think that this discussion would start off so early with one of you being anti Republican, the other being anti Democrat and being the two parties fighting against each other.
00:03:55
I didn't know that this would be.
00:03:56
But I really think that's.
00:03:57
The root of.
00:03:57
This, but what?
00:03:58
No but see.
00:03:59
Here's the thing.
00:03:59
Though the quote right here simply states supervisors delayed taking action, they knew they needed to take action.
00:04:06
They had actionable information.
00:04:08
They should have taken action and arguably had they taken, they would have preserved confidence and there wouldn't be a there.
00:04:11
Can I have?
00:04:14
Would have been a problem.
00:04:15
So, Sam, you said something earlier that when times are good, we are prosperous.
00:04:19
We tend to be a little more.
00:04:20
It's the cycle.
00:04:21
And you said you said we tend to be a little more the Book of Mormon reference, we tend to be a little more LAX and the people tend to.
00:04:28
Act a little, we see.
00:04:30
And and then we act less responsibly.
00:04:30
We want to see, yeah.
00:04:31
And then there's problems.
00:04:32
Well, isn't one of the accusations of the last. What is it, Matt? 5-10 years with all the bailouts?
00:04:39
Isn't that also the heavy regulation and the government bailing bailing these banks out?
00:04:43
Isn't that also a reason, maybe a lot of these banks are?
00:04:46
Acting lax?
00:04:47
Because they know that there's no.
00:04:47
They're not.
00:04:47
They're not gonna fail.
00:04:48
Yeah, there's no consequence.
00:04:50
No consequences.
00:04:51
So more regulation makes people go well, it'll be fine.
00:04:54
Let's take the risks.
00:04:55
Let's behave badly.
00:04:55
OK, so let's add, you know, let let's take that one, two steps beyond.
00:05:00
Let's add more.
00:05:00
Regulation we ignore.
00:05:02
I'm saying right to not ignore.
00:05:04
The and then and then let's.
00:05:05
Let's actually who's the person that that you wanted in charge of the?
00:05:08
CFPB. I can't pronounce it.
00:05:10
And I.
00:05:10
Right.
00:05:10
Apologize, I want to slaughter it, but.
00:05:10
Chopra, is that who it is.
00:05:12
So Rahid Chopra, let's put her in charge, even though she doesn't understand what she's supervising.
00:05:18
And there's no there's no elected oversight for that organization.
00:05:22
Some of the structure you have to admit, the way it's set up is lunacy.
00:05:26
If we just obeyed the laws and we just did what we're required to do currently, this wouldn't have happened.
00:05:32
Somebody fell asleep at the wheel, chose not to take action when they should have taken.
00:05:36
And they should pay for that.
00:05:37
There should be a consequence, Matt.
00:05:38
Hey this is a very remote. You're a political scientist. Do you know who in 1963, Wright Pattman is the chairman of the House Banking and Currency Committee we have.
00:05:47
Now you're making it sound like because I know political science.
00:05:49
Yeah, I should like Wikipedia is.
00:05:50
Yeah, it's good to.
00:05:51
Part of my.
00:05:52
Members out of mouth.
00:05:52
See 1963. Let's see. No.
00:05:53
No, no, no.
00:05:53
Do you have his base like a baseball card you have like?
00:05:56
A picture you.
00:05:58
In your room nerding out with old politicians and and things.
00:06:01
No, OK.
00:06:02
In 1963, I would have a Martin Luther King junior base.
00:06:04
Of course.
00:06:05
OK. OK, good.
00:06:07
But OK, go on Sean.
00:06:08
So he he had a quote back in the day when things were failing and this was a big, scary thing.
00:06:13
And he said, I think we should have more bank failures.
00:06:16
The record the last several years of almost no bank failures.
00:06:19
And finally, last year, with no bank failures at all is, to me, a danger signal that we have gone too far in the direction of bank.
00:06:25
Safety now weird statement, but I think there's some wisdom in there's probably should be a good amount of bank failures.
00:06:33
In fact, I believe don't quote me, but I think there's three to four bank failures per year in this.
00:06:37
Country and they don't get bailed out.
00:06:38
Yeah, I'm not opposed.
00:06:40
I'm not opposed to bank failures.
00:06:42
I'm opposed to bank failures to the tune where the government has to bail out the banks, right?
00:06:46
That's what your question was.
00:06:48
Your question is do does government regulation prevent failures?
00:06:52
Failures like Silicon Valley bank.
00:06:55
So the problem with Silicon Valley Bank is.
00:06:57
They're being extraordinarily risky and they're not protecting.
00:07:01
They don't have enough deposits on hand to protect, like they don't have enough cash on hand to protect their depositors.
00:07:07
So, so then the federal government feels like they need to give money to people who are.
00:07:11
Risky with their assets.
00:07:12
And and there were rules in place that had those rules been followed, and whoever the supervisors are, had they done what they were supposed to do, it never would.
00:07:21
Have gotten as far as it did, but it did.
00:07:21
So, Sam, you're saying you're saying let those people fail and let the bank fail and let the consequences follow?
00:07:27
Thing I absolutely would have let the big fail.
00:07:30
And by the way, I want to take back what I said about Rohit Chopra from CFPB.
00:07:33
He's a Harvard grad.
00:07:34
And then he went to work for McKinsey.
00:07:36
But I don't know that he's run business or had the business acumen.
00:07:39
I have no way of knowing to be able to put the type of regulation in place that would be.
00:07:43
Thoughtful and effective, right?
00:07:44
So, so Matt and Sam, I feel like bringing in a little bit of scripture here because I think there is a principle here that's interesting.
00:07:50
It takes it takes us on a tangent a little bit, but it's you.
00:07:50
Bring it.
00:07:53
Tell me, Matt, if it takes us off.
00:07:54
Go ahead, Sean.
00:07:55
'S idea of.
00:07:57
This balance of banks failing and and protecting banks, I often hear members of our church refer to look if we're faithful or righteous, there's prosperity in the land.
00:08:06
I agree that that this concept of keeping the commandments brings prosperity in the land, is abundant in the scriptures.
00:08:12
There's lots of references to prosperity.
00:08:15
Well, mostly in the Book of Mormon.
00:08:17
Yeah, there's four or five in the in the New Testament, but you're right mostly in.
00:08:20
The Book of Mormon, but I.
00:08:20
Not doctrine and covenants really, right?
00:08:22
There's a few in the B.
00:08:23
And C yeah.
00:08:24
There are, but here's the mistake I think most most of US members just make.
00:08:24
Oh, OK, all right.
00:08:29
We think that's talking about money and success.
00:08:31
But if you really study those scriptures, there's not a lot of.
00:08:34
It's mostly about freedom of *******, freedom from *******, so prospering in the land without having *******.
00:08:39
And it's talking about receiving God's glory.
00:08:43
Basically, it's talking about spiritual prosperity.
00:08:45
It's talking about the prosperity of the soul and of the spirit.
00:08:47
It rarely.
00:08:48
Now I would love for listeners to go and study these these principles.
00:08:51
That I've studied a lot in the scriptures about this concept of prosperity.
00:08:55
It's not necessarily talking about money and prosperity in that sense.
00:08:59
So back to the topic.
00:09:01
I don't know, man.
00:09:01
I think there should be a good balance.
00:09:03
I mean, if no banks are failing ever, and I know you're not arguing that.
00:09:07
That suggests corruption to me, like clearly there are lots of businesses doing wrong things, and the natural consequence of those things should be failure, right?
00:09:14
SVB Bank was doing risky, risky, risky things with no consequence.
00:09:19
It seems like letting that fail.
00:09:21
Seems like a a good thing, man, and I know the argument is.
00:09:24
Yeah, but look at the people who suffer.
00:09:25
That's right.
00:09:26
They'll be fine.
00:09:27
They'll be fine.
00:09:27
Yeah, well, the problem is when the government puts FDIC on the bank, then it it's it's sending a message to the public that the government is going to help them out because they say this is Federal Deposit Insurance company, right.
00:09:40
That corporation, that's.
00:09:42
That's different.
00:09:42
Well, so that's.
00:09:43
That's that's preserving depositors stakes in the bank that's not propping up the bank and allowing the bank to continue.
00:09:50
But what but but the?
00:09:51
So those are two separate things.
00:09:52
Big problem with SVB is that they are giving money to these depositors that have had assets in excess of what the FDIC would normally cover.
00:10:01
And so I I do have a problem with that, right? It's like if you put $2,000,000 in the bank and it's not, it's just, I just think that the public isn't adequately aware of what's going on.
00:10:10
Yes. Yep, that's it.
00:10:11
It's a complicated industry and so I think the government, if you're going to.
00:10:14
Have something like the FDIC.
00:10:14
Very complicated.
00:10:16
Like giving confidence to a bank, then that the government has some obligation to the public to let them know.
00:10:22
Some way of letting them know.
00:10:22
I like that Matt.
00:10:24
Matt, make make stronger laws that that put make banks more transparent with how much money and what kind of money and where it's going.
00:10:30
Yeah, I want to know that I've invested this or I've put this money in.
00:10:33
The bank and that they're living within the regulations, the FDIC regulations that keep my money safe and short.
00:10:38
Yeah, make it make it very, very transparent.
00:10:40
I think that's a good solution.
00:10:41
So let's move on to.
00:10:42
The GOP presidential group like.
00:10:46
I don't know.
00:10:46
I don't know guys like.
00:10:48
But I consider myself a conservative Republican, and I've always worn this this badge Republican Party with with pride.
00:10:57
I've been a proud Republican most of my life.
00:10:59
But as I look.
00:11:00
At the field of presidential contender.
00:11:02
I just find myself like wondering what happened to the Republican Party.
00:11:06
Like, where did they go?
00:11:07
And I have something I have a quote in here from President Oak.
00:11:11
So this is in the April 2021 General Conference in his talk on the Constitution, he says there are other duties that are part of upholding the inspired constitution we should learn and advocate the inspired principles of the Constitution. We should seek out and support.
00:11:23
Why is in good persons who will support those principles and public actions, and then he also says this process will not be easy.
00:11:30
It may require changing party support or candidate choices, even from election to election.
00:11:35
Such independent actions will sometimes require voters to support candidates or political parties or platform.
00:11:42
Whose other positions they cannot approve, and so that says to me like that's kind of like a green light.
00:11:47
Like, hey, if the Republicans aren't gonna uphold the constitutional principles, then maybe I need to send them a lesson and look for Democrat candidates.
00:11:55
Well, so then I want to discuss this question.
00:11:57
Like are there any Republican candidates out there who are good and wise and who would not support the constitutional principles in their public action?
00:12:04
So Matt, do you want it?
00:12:06
There's such good questions in that the first question is what the heck happened to the Republican Party?
00:12:10
Why does it look so differently than it does now than it did in the Reagan era?
00:12:14
And then the traditional conservative times in the?
00:12:17
What 30s, Forties, Fifties, 60s?
00:12:18
Is that the question, like what happened and why has it changed?
00:12:21
Or is your question looking at the current Republican President saying?
00:12:25
Yeah, I I mean, I don't think we could really answer.
00:12:27
I don't think we really know why it changed.
00:12:29
But I do think we could look at where it is right now and and maybe I just misperceived things like maybe there's Republican candidates that are.
00:12:38
Really are good candidates good and wise, and I just don't see them.
00:12:42
And maybe the other Republicans aren't seeing them right now.
00:12:44
So there's a there's a cool podcast called Conservative something Nice Plug.
00:12:49
I don't remember they they these two guys.
00:12:52
Basically, they just take books that are either the foundation of conservatism or the foundation of liberalism, and they just read the book, and then they summarize and talk about each book to kind of just point out.
00:13:02
Look, here's what is traditional or foundational.
00:13:04
Service ISM.
00:13:05
Here's what is traditional, foundational liberalism.
00:13:08
It's really fascinating.
00:13:09
Now, if you look, they've kind of described that.
00:13:11
Look, there's, there's traditional conservatism and then there's, like, the libertarian side of conservatism.
00:13:16
Is that, would you summarize that populism?
00:13:17
And then there's populism.
00:13:20
Yeah, protectionism xenophobe.
00:13:21
Yeah, go ahead.
00:13:22
So he goes, they go in to kind of explain that the the the major difference between like the Reagan era conservatism and then.
00:13:29
Today, there's big differences.
00:13:31
Isn't there?
00:13:31
Like, like back in the day, let's see.
00:13:34
Reagan, with small government, fiscal responsibility.
00:13:34
OK so.
00:13:37
National Defense, fight against communism in favor of immigration.
00:13:40
Which is more which is more that mask, right?
00:13:43
He brought in that anti communism kind of national security conservatism.
00:13:47
That's kind of a conservative value, isn't it?
00:13:48
Yeah, I think it is, yeah.
00:13:50
Which it doesn't like you had mentioned in the past, doesn't get talked about much and then the traditional conservatism is more about values, virtue and order, right?
00:13:57
Yeah, yeah.
00:13:59
Moral principles.
00:14:00
And then the the libertarian one is, isn't that more?
00:14:03
About individual freedom. Individual, yeah.
00:14:06
Right.
00:14:07
So if you, if you if you if you define conservatism based on those, I think you're right, you look at today's Republican Party and it looks very different, doesn't it?
00:14:15
But I do think so.
00:14:17
I think that the allure from me to the Republican Party is that I've always sort of thought of the Republican Party as a party that's defending moral values, that I think are important in society.
00:14:26
And and even in the in that regard, I feel like some of the candidates have lost their way and they're advocating things that don't look like moral values and moral principles, but it's it's also true that I'm not really embedded in this world.
00:14:39
And I I imagine there are probably candidates out there.
00:14:42
The fit, Sean, even the Reagan definition of conservatism, maybe they're just not popular.
00:14:46
Right now, like Ace, like the guy from Arkansas Ace and ASA Hutchinson, I think he maybe is a Reagan Republican.
00:14:54
Yeah, I think I think they're out there.
00:14:55
The, the, the challenges, they've just been drowned out and and there's probably some fear too because that approach right now doesn't sit well on a stage with Trump.
00:15:04
I mean, Trump just beats the living daylights out of these people.
00:15:07
He he calls them names, he marginalizes them and he runs them off stage.
00:15:11
And, you know, a guy like Pence is a pretty good guy.
00:15:14
Right.
00:15:14
Like I I think he's a a very.
00:15:16
Decent, good, good, good.
00:15:17
Yeah, he seems like a.
00:15:18
Wet Noodle, though I I met, I met.
00:15:20
What does that mean?
00:15:21
What noodle.
00:15:22
What does that noodle?
00:15:23
A guy that just follows around Trump for four years and just does whatever he says.
00:15:24
I I met.
00:15:27
Well, but maybe that's a little bit of the Trump effect.
00:15:30
I met Jeb Bush in in Iowa and and had breakfast with him and and his campaign ahead of his campaign with some people I work around and, you know, super nice guy, right?
00:15:41
But not as not the rock star that our culture demands right now.
00:15:46
So so isn't that?
00:15:47
And it's interesting.
00:15:48
We're gonna.
00:15:48
We're gonna talk about it in just a minute, but I think these cycles are real in history, and they're at work in our world.
00:15:56
Today and as far One Direction as maybe Trump and others have taken the party, it'll swing.
00:16:02
Back you would hope, right?
00:16:02
I wonder, Matt, do you think it will swing back?
00:16:04
Well, I think that the Republican Party is at a bit of an inflection point.
00:16:07
So if if I were to take a broad historical brush and sort of paint things, I'd say, yeah, history does repeat itself in some ways.
00:16:14
I think that this group of Republicans that really likes Ron De Santis and likes Donald Trump geographically, a lot of them are, are concentrated in the deep.
00:16:23
Mouth and you know, 50-60 years ago they were all Democrats and they were all fighting against the civil rights movement.
00:16:30
And they were trying to stop the Democratic Party from civil rights and and they basically all decided, let's leave the Democratic Party and let's go to the Republican Party and the Republican Party embrace them.
00:16:40
And it's really helped the Republican Party gain power.
00:16:43
The ways that it couldn't before, but they've become.
00:16:44
You're talking about working, you're talking about working class white people is.
00:16:47
What you're talking about, right?
00:16:48
Oh, I don't, I.
00:16:49
I just call them the racist Southerners.
00:16:50
That's what I call.
00:16:51
Oh, oh boy.
00:16:51
Them I mean, I mean.
00:16:54
Like they're not a.
00:16:55
He's gonna find he's gonna find a way to give the current Republican Party a backhanded slap.
00:16:59
No, no, no, no, like.
00:17:00
One way or another.
00:17:01
Right backhanded copy.
00:17:02
It's a party of right let's.
00:17:03
So I'm going to nobody.
00:17:06
Nobody likes the the label racist, but I'm going to be quite honest like where I live in Utah and Idaho, we sometimes will have these like get togethers where we have these competitions and say hey let's tell jokes and let's see who's got the funniest jokes and then I will say by the way no racist jokes allowed and it's crickets.
00:17:22
Nobody's got any jokes to tell.
00:17:24
And then I say, OK.
00:17:26
You can.
00:17:26
I'm I'm.
00:17:26
Come on, come on, come on.
00:17:27
I'm a.
00:17:27
100% serious, like they're people are racist, right?
00:17:33
So not in like, not in, like and we hate black people kind of thing, but in a it's really fun to make jokes, racist jokes kind of thing.
00:17:39
You think it's a?
00:17:40
You think it's an ignorant racism, not a proactive.
00:17:42
I'm just saying, like young people who don't know better how to hide it.
00:17:47
There's a lot of racism in Utah and Idaho.
00:17:49
No, I do.
00:17:50
I don't think it's.
00:17:50
A Utah well, it's like Romney's binders full of women. Comment, right?
00:17:53
I don't think it's.
00:17:54
There's something deeply embedded that without knowledge is somehow brings you to that a little bit, actually, I think.
00:18:01
Being being being the Southern California guy, I will defend Utah, Idaho.
00:18:04
I don't think it's people in Utah and Idaho.
00:18:06
They're racist.
00:18:07
No, no, no. So.
00:18:08
I think it's I.
00:18:09
I didn't get to finish.
00:18:10
My point, so I'm saying like.
00:18:12
I see it in Utah and Idaho a little bit, but then go to the South, spend a little bit of time in Louisiana and Mississippi, Alabama, the Carolinas.
00:18:21
There's there's, like a deep racism there.
00:18:25
So we get it a little bit here in Utah and Idaho and you go to those other places and you want to tell racist jokes and you're not even gonna get anybody kind of like looking at you like you shouldn't be telling that racist joke.
00:18:34
Like there's some deep racism, especially in the American South, and I'm so I don't wanna like paint the brush.
00:18:39
And say the Republican Party is racist.
00:18:41
But there is a a big segment of the Republican Party.
00:18:44
That is overtly racist.
00:18:46
There's a lot of them that are covertly racist, and then there's a lot of them that kind of like aren't opposed to racist people, right?
00:18:53
So Matt, so Matt, so if that if.
00:18:56
I think that's an unfair generalization.
00:18:57
But, but if that's true, we don't know if it's true or not, right?
00:19:00
If that's true, that is certainly a a change from the Republican Party, right, Republican.
00:19:05
No, no, no.
00:19:05
What do you?
00:19:05
No, it's no, it's the.
00:19:06
It's the Republican base.
00:19:07
These are the people that got Ronald Reagan elected.
00:19:09
He doesn't win with that.
00:19:10
They're the ones that brought the Republicans in.
00:19:12
In 1994.
00:19:12
No, but what I'm saying is traditional conservatism or the Republican Party of Abraham Lincoln maybe isn't.
00:19:19
Ohh well come on.
00:19:20
That you.
00:19:20
I mean, yeah, I.
00:19:21
You asked what you asked.
00:19:22
Mean that's that's too far back.
00:19:23
What happened?
00:19:24
You asked what happened to the Republican Party?
00:19:26
So I guess what standard over the Republican Party are you?
00:19:29
Well, yeah.
00:19:30
I mean, there's a whole history there that we could talk.
00:19:33
So all I'm saying is, if there's this group of the Republican Party that's racist, some of them, there's a group of them that really hates immigrants, some of them and.
00:19:42
Alright, alright, alright.
00:19:43
And then there's.
00:19:44
A large contingent of them that are, like, let's say, evangelical Christians, and they care about moral values.
00:19:49
And all of that stuff sort of gets meshed together into one big.
00:19:53
Sort of like goop that we.
00:19:54
Call the Republican Party.
00:19:55
And sometimes some of those candidates espousing those things have an outsized voice compared to the rest of the party.
00:20:02
Right, so so I'm.
00:20:03
Not saying Republicans are racist?
00:20:05
I'm saying all parties are like coalitions of different groups of people.
00:20:09
And this 30% of the Republican Party, that there's maybe like not not the kind of people I would hang out with that sometimes they get an outsized voice in the Republican Party and yeah.
00:20:17
So, so, so maybe Sam, you mentioned earlier the celebrity element of Donald Trump that has really affected the Republican Party.
00:20:25
Maybe that's there's something to that like to me, I think that the technology has.
00:20:29
Enabled, for example big media to use its power to really divide.
00:20:35
Like use philosophies to divide.
00:20:37
And they do that because now that there's data like Matt, you've taught me this, that Donald Trump looked at Twitter would tweet something, look at the data results, the analytics and go, OK, this is what people.
00:20:47
Care about and whether it's yeah.
00:20:47
100,000 likes. If he got 100,000 likes on a tweet, it became a a campaign promise.
00:20:53
With so Donald.
00:20:53
Trump would tweet something whether he believes it or not, whether it's moral or not, whether it's good or.
00:20:57
Not whether it's conserve.
00:20:59
Never. Not if it got up more than 100,000 retweets. That was a campaign that was what he'd campaign that he was simply marketing, right?
00:21:06
Is what you're saying.
00:21:07
Yeah, yeah.
00:21:07
So I think what I'm trying to get to is the technology has.
00:21:10
Allowed big media.
00:21:11
To to do that right to use the analytics to go OK, what are some what are groups of people that can sway votes?
00:21:17
What are they into?
00:21:18
All right, now let's make that our platform.
00:21:20
And when it's money driven like that or power driven like that, what you get is you get Fox News and MSNBC, what you get is Republicans versus Democrat.
00:21:27
You get division and.
00:21:28
Divide, divide, divide.
00:21:29
Divide and you get these extremes on both sides, which is what I think the the parties have.
00:21:34
Become isn't it?
00:21:35
Well, but the great thing about the great thing about the history of America is anytime we swing to extremes, oftentimes it comes back and it you've gotta believe and and we're gonna talk about this in a second with our next question.
00:21:48
But it's gonna swing back a little bit.
00:21:50
And and I'm excited to go to question #3, but before we go there, can I just bring up one comment that I think we went by very quickly that is actually a.
00:21:58
Big deal.
00:21:59
So Matt, I had never read this comment from Elder Oaks.
00:22:03
So, you know, an apostle in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints making a statement in a public forum, which then becomes policy sort of of the church, right.
00:22:13
I've never heard of an apostle of the church talking about changing public party.
00:22:18
And or aligning with public parties where we may not fully support or agree with the entire platform of that.
00:22:25
So as I grew up as a kid in high school in our ward, we knew the one guy who was Democrat.
00:22:30
He was crazy.
00:22:32
And we all felt very safe because we had him in a in a in in such a a circle and a cocoon that he could have.
00:22:38
No influence on.
00:22:39
Wow, that's weird.
00:22:40
And now we're in a world now.
00:22:40
Dude, that is weird.
00:22:42
What you're saying.
00:22:43
We're in a world.
00:22:46
The conversations we're having right now not only should be normal and they're not yet, but they should actually be encouraged.
00:22:52
So instead of making fun of Matt for being pro Biden.
00:22:55
I am not.
00:22:56
Right.
00:22:56
Like like there could be a time where the church looks at the two sides.
00:23:02
I mean, and and and Trump is a fairy example of that.
00:23:05
Like, you know, Utah voted Republican.
00:23:09
You know, we've always been completely in the Republican camp.
00:23:13
We gave Trump a tough time in the last presidential election.
00:23:16
We were the one state that didn't go that way as as as much as as we had in the in the history of the.
00:23:21
So my yeah, my fear, Sam, is that?
00:23:22
Country right. So.
00:23:24
Republicans are going to just choose Trump the next Trump, and they're not going to, right.
00:23:29
So Trump?
00:23:30
I don't think there is an extract though.
00:23:30
Ohh, come on.
00:23:32
There's still.
00:23:32
The Santas, the Santas, is so much like Trump.
00:23:32
Gonna be like him, no.
00:23:35
No, he is not mad.
00:23:36
I I don't think DeSantis really has a chance.
00:23:38
But he's not that much like Trump.
00:23:39
I really don't.
00:23:40
Is he alright?
00:23:40
I ohh yeah.
00:23:41
He he's he doesn't have the personality.
00:23:43
He doesn't have the character, you know?
00:23:44
Yeah, I just mean it.
00:23:45
He he's he's slow out the gates with his campaign and he is not taking the the hits.
00:23:51
And here's another example.
00:23:53
Just one last example about how things.
00:23:55
Looking back, I was concerned when the Supreme Court overturned.
00:23:58
Roe V Wade.
00:24:00
From from a gospel standpoint, we're against abortion generally, but once something becomes ingrained as the law of the land, it concerns me to undo it.
00:24:08
Republicans came back and they said, hey, we're not undoing this.
00:24:11
We're just allowing states to have control over whether it happens or not.
00:24:14
And it's interesting, this past week.
00:24:16
There are two states that actually have it up, Nebraska and South Carolina.
00:24:22
Where they were trying to ban abortion in those states, states where Republican Republicans had the majority and and and and banning abortion should have, should have taken off clearly and easily.
00:24:37
And it didn't, right?
00:24:37
Yeah, but it did in Utah and Idaho.
00:24:38
So I I think.
00:24:41
But it did in Utah and Idaho, and it could be undone.
00:24:43
But we're pretty progressive.
00:24:44
So so kind.
00:24:45
In some right?
00:24:45
Of a funny story, Sam, about how this.
00:24:47
Swing back in the day about 100 years ago, the Utah Peoples Party was the LDS party in.
00:24:52
The state of.
00:24:53
And the church decided that in order to get statehood, they needed to, like, either align with Republicans or Democrats.
00:25:01
So David O McKay and his biography, the story, is that in church one Sunday, the Bishop said everybody sitting on this half is a Republican, and everybody sitting on this half is a Democrat, and David O McKay.
00:25:13
She was just a child at the.
00:25:14
And he says I was so disappointed because the only Republican in town was the town drunk.
00:25:19
And I did not want to be affiliated with the Republican Party.
00:25:22
So it is funny how things kind of change over time.
00:25:25
The perceptions of parties and what they stand for.
00:25:27
And I agree.
00:25:27
I think that we should have an allegiance to something higher than a party and it there is not a party that I will agree with.
00:25:34
Every single one of their positions and everybody in the party.
00:25:37
And so if I'm going to just be a voter and choose based on positions, I have to be willing to say, hey, I can accept some things.
00:25:43
I'm not a big fan of and then vote for the candidates I think are best.
00:25:47
And other oaks cleared the way for engine right and and I think that that's a pretty good reason for us as a podcast to have a goal to have a general authority in a public setting.
00:25:48
Yeah. Yeah. In general conference.
00:25:56
Talk about the podcast because this truly models that type of conversation, conversations that many of us may have been uncomfortable to.
00:26:03
Have in any other.
00:26:03
Yeah, I say pre I agree, guys preach it.
00:26:06
It loud, right?
00:26:07
Loyalty to a man made profit driven political party is falling.
00:26:13
It's a wrong thing.
00:26:15
It'll never lead us, right?
00:26:16
Right.
00:26:16
But if we take the principles of Christ through scripture or the apostles, yeah, we're going to seek for.
00:26:21
Principles and laws, and we're going to, yeah, if that sways us, then so be it.
00:26:24
No loyalty to these pardons.
00:26:26
And I would advocate to actually people should get involved in run for office themselves.
00:26:30
If you don't like what a party, if you don't like what the Democrats stand for, go run for office and be a Democrat representative and then you get to decide what they stand for and all their voters have to sit around and say, well, I guess they hadn't.
00:26:41
Well, I wish they hadn't taken that position, but Oh well, that's the person in charge.
00:26:44
And as evidence of that, isn't it crazy that this presidential election looks like it's going to end up being?
00:26:49
Right, two people that have negatives that are so high, like the entire country is screaming.
00:26:55
Don't do it yet.
00:26:55
That's what's going to.
00:26:56
It's gonna happen again.
00:26:58
Good people need to truly get involved.
00:26:59
So let's move on.
00:27:00
To a discussion of the news media.
00:27:02
So there's a lot of news this week about what's happened, so CNN fired Don Lemon because of some sexist remarks he's made in public on air and stuff.
00:27:10
He does how he treats women on his staff.
00:27:13
Many of them many.
00:27:16
A lot of people know about Tucker Carlson, that perhaps he was not the most.
00:27:20
On this person in the world, I don't know if you guys are aware of this, but Tucker Carlson has the distinct honor of being fired from PBS, CNN, MSNBC and Fox News, so I can't think of a more fitting example.
00:27:36
Hold on.
00:27:36
Of a person.
00:27:36
You're just.
00:27:36
He gets but.
00:27:38
What was he doing at PBS?
00:27:39
But Matt, he gets but gets.
00:27:40
Was he like some people?
00:27:41
Street map.
00:27:42
But some people praise him for that, right?
00:27:44
Because if if part of our argument is that a lot of these media giants have agendas, some people praise him to be like, oh, he's not willing to jump on their agenda.
00:27:54
Obviously he has evidence that he is willing to jump on some agendas.
00:27:57
But being fired from those places, some people say good for him because he wasn't willing to jump.
00:27:57
Right.
00:28:01
But that's not true. Watch.
00:28:02
Your shows on all of those.
00:28:04
Networks, what he did is he was a chameleon and he adapted whatever the audience wanted the like.
00:28:09
The extreme elements of that audience, he would just fan the flames of whatever those things are.
00:28:14
And if you look at his Twitter post after he left Fox News, the same thing like who knows where he's going to go next.
00:28:19
But he's certainly not gonna continue on the Fox News thing that he had at Fox News.
00:28:22
He's gonna do some other thing.
00:28:24
That he's already starting to fan the.
00:28:26
Flames of whatever that.
00:28:27
Is, yeah, but.
00:28:27
One but one theory is that, like you said, he's a chameleon, right?
00:28:30
On the one hand, he's he's just giving in to whatever the paycheck tells him to talk about and on and on the other hand, he's sometimes trying to go.
00:28:35
He's an entertainer.
00:28:38
Yeah, but I don't agree with that.
00:28:40
Is he good at it?
00:28:40
No, definitely not.
00:28:41
And do I support him?
00:28:42
No, but.
00:28:43
But but I mean, look at look at all the other voices in the media, look at, we watched Jimmy Kimmel every night.
00:28:48
I don't know why that guy is so in love with Donald Trump.
00:28:52
He talks about nothing but Donald Trump.
00:28:53
In love with making fun of Donald.
00:28:54
Trump, right? He.
00:28:55
Well, that's what I mean. He's obsessed with him. Yeah, but it helps Donald Trump because it makes him keeps him relevant. So it's such a backfire and Jimmy's end.
00:28:55
It's negative about Trump.
00:29:01
But it helped. It helps.
00:29:02
Jimmy Kimmel because it keeps his ratings high because there's all the Trump haters in the world.
00:29:05
And that's.
00:29:07
And that's the point is, it's all about money, power, and ratings.
00:29:10
It's all about pandering.
00:29:11
Well, so then this is a question like I want to address this.
00:29:14
Question first like.
00:29:16
If all of the news, the popular news networks now, in fairness, we're talking about either cable news or Internet news.
00:29:24
If they're all just pandering to an audience and just saying whatever they need to say to get that audience to click or to watch, then like, how can you find?
00:29:36
Political news that doesn't have an agenda if they all seem to have an.
00:29:39
Agenda like if.
00:29:40
A person really wanted to find, really.
00:29:42
Good political news.
00:29:44
Where would they turn?
00:29:47
I so so Matt, it's interesting.
00:29:48
I'm not sure that's a new phenomenon.
00:29:50
So one of my favorite movies as a kid growing up, did you ever watch Jimmy Stewart in Mr.
00:29:55
Smith goes to Washington, right where he was.
00:29:55
Yeah, I thought you were gonna say a man for all seasons.
00:30:02
He was not in that one, but yes.
00:30:04
Jimmy Stewart, Mr. Smith.
00:30:06
Yeah, Mr.
00:30:07
Smith goes to Washington and he fights against the the the political machine that is run by the press and controls his hometown.
00:30:14
As a A skewed press is nothing new.
00:30:18
What is new?
00:30:19
And it really started as we were growing up.
00:30:21
I remember the first days Rush Limbaugh.
00:30:23
Came on the radio.
00:30:24
And I listened to it with my dad and it was exciting to hear because he said a lot of the things that represented, like, value, ethical values that that we held.
00:30:30
Conservative, yeah.
00:30:35
And it was interesting.
00:30:36
I I listened.
00:30:37
Him consistently for a good 3-4 years and and it turned somewhere it turned into pure entertainment and and you're kind.
00:30:47
Of like wait.
00:30:48
And then Fox News came on right, and you had the flashy graphics and you had the beautiful people with super.
00:30:53
Bill O'Reilly.
00:30:54
White team.
00:30:55
And at some point, yeah.
00:30:56
And Bill O'Reilly.
00:30:58
And Glenn Beck, right, and it and and at some point, you start to hear the people talk who watch that and you're like, wait.
00:30:58
Yeah, yeah.
00:31:07
That's not it.
00:31:08
That's not accurate.
00:31:10
And so that that pendulum swing back to normal, I think.
00:31:14
I think nobody knows.
00:31:16
First of all, why Tucker Carlson is fired, and that's fascinating.
00:31:19
Everybody knew instantly why Bill O'Reilly got fired.
00:31:22
Nobody truly knows why Tucker Carlson got fired.
00:31:22
And Don Lemon, right, CNN people know why Don Lemon was fired.
00:31:27
Why was that?
00:31:27
Yep, Yep. But sexism? Yeah.
00:31:27
Because of his sexism.
00:31:31
Sex, yeah.
00:31:31
Well, so and yeah.
00:31:33
But does the pendulum swing back right?
00:31:34
Well, and and it's true like the the press from the very beginning was a partisan press.
00:31:39
Candidates would pay for news outlets and their whole purpose was to, like, attack other candidates.
00:31:44
So it's true, there's nothing new about this but but but it is.
00:31:48
It's American.
00:31:49
It does make it hard to know who to trust because.
00:31:52
There's if somebody.
00:31:53
To use let's.
00:31:54
Use Rush Limbaugh as an example.
00:31:56
If somebody saying things that are consistent with my values, then it makes me trust them more because I say they're saying things that are consistent with my values and it makes.
00:32:06
Me a little bit.
00:32:06
Afraid to hear something from another side because they might not share my values and maybe they're trying to trick me.
00:32:13
So even if I know a little bit in my heart that maybe Rush Limbaugh's trying to deceive me.
00:32:18
Kind of like.
00:32:18
Trust him and maybe want that deception just a little bit because the other thing.
00:32:22
So, so.
00:32:22
Is a little scary.
00:32:24
So the challenge with today's media.
00:32:25
And podcast perpetrate it.
00:32:27
The guy from Comedy Central that took over Jon Stewart's role specifically talks about this. I forget his name.
00:32:30
Trevor Noah.
00:32:33
Trevor Noah talks about this.
00:32:34
He he says there's a familiarity that's created with podcasts and late night television that causes a person to feel like they know that person.
00:32:43
They know their heart, their soul, and they get to trust them.
00:32:46
Like you're talking about.
00:32:47
That that's never existed.
00:32:49
It started with Rush Limbaugh.
00:32:50
It went through Fox News and it exists today in.
00:32:54
But when we think about that pendulum coming back, I think people are starting to see that they have to make their own decisions.
00:33:01
They have to think for themselves as much as Glenn Beck talks about you've gotta research this.
00:33:06
You gotta research that.
00:33:07
If you listen to him for 10 minutes, he's trying to tell you in a very entertaining way exactly what you should think, right?
00:33:13
People do need to.
00:33:15
Come to their own conclusions and one of the best ways to do that, candidly, is to listen, in my opinion, to viewpoints that don't necessarily.
00:33:22
Your your own and and be able be able to explain why you believe different than someone.
00:33:27
But that's scary too, Sam.
00:33:28
Else does.
00:33:28
That, that that requires cognitive.
00:33:31
Hold me.
00:33:31
Why is that scary?
00:33:31
It it it requires cognitive sophistication, right?
00:33:35
If I'm listening to one person I can like, I can, like repeat what they're saying.
00:33:38
It's sophisticated, yeah.
00:33:40
But I don't really understand what they're saying and.
00:33:43
So if I.
00:33:43
Have a friend with a different perspective.
00:33:45
Like like let's.
00:33:46
Just take Jimmy Kimmel and Tucker Carlson, right.
00:33:49
If I watch Jimmy Kimmel.
00:33:51
All the time.
00:33:51
I'll leave with the impression that every Republican on Earth is a.
00:33:54
And like, they're just stupid.
00:33:56
And that's all I can really articulate at the end of.
00:33:58
This show I just, I don't know, they're just stupid.
00:34:01
And same with Tucker Carlson.
00:34:02
I would say every Democrat on Earth is just stupid and I can't articulate why.
00:34:06
I just know.
00:34:06
They're stupid, but.
00:34:07
Yeah, he nailed it.
00:34:08
But that's not the way you that's not the way you personally believe you're you're relaying how other people you believe other people act and react.
00:34:17
It's up to the individual person to interact with that media and the way they interact with it, and it's our own individual liberty and responsibility.
00:34:24
To digest that in a responsible way and then and then act on this in a responsible.
00:34:28
But Matt, you're saying that the that that I'm saying you're saying, no, Matt, you're saying that dissonance that cognitive dissonance is hard for many people to grasp, but I think.
00:34:29
Way you can't legend.
00:34:31
That, by the way.
00:34:37
But I think there's being the latter day lens.
00:34:39
I think there's there are, like, spiritual principles that drive this right, Dean.
00:34:43
So you 29 says. I mean, God, I gave them to men to be an agent unto himself.
00:34:49
Right.
00:34:49
The agency is a is a an eternal principle, a spiritual principle.
00:34:53
But he also says he also.
00:34:55
Says there it must needs be that there's an opposition in all things in order to have agency, we have to have that opposition.
00:35:02
So I think you're right, Matt.
00:35:03
I think there has to be.
00:35:05
On any given topic, it's healthy for us to have this dissonance.
00:35:09
I think it's a smart approach to for members of the church to listen to both sides, since we have these extremes.
00:35:15
Listen to Fox News.
00:35:15
Listen to MSNBC, listen to listen.
00:35:16
It's that's that's scary.
00:35:18
I'm just saying that's scary.
00:35:19
Like when I was young and and psychiatry was like of the devil.
00:35:24
Then I'd say I I think I might go to therapy and people would be like, why would you talk to a psychologist?
00:35:29
They're liberal. They're like.
00:35:31
Godless people and they're going to trick you into like, losing your faith in Christ and I think.
00:35:37
That for of course not.
00:35:38
Do you believe that today?
00:35:39
But I think that there's like for a lot of people, there's this, like this conviction of like I.
00:35:44
I know the church is true, but I really can't explain it to my friends and neighbors.
00:35:48
And my political views align with that, and I really can't explain those to my friends and neighbors.
00:35:54
And if I start deviating too far, then maybe I have to rethink all of these things.
00:36:00
I really believe and really think and it all kind of like falls apart like there's this fear like people have to be able to build up to these sorts of things.
00:36:08
And and it's hard to like and I don't know, Sean, that listening to both extremes is actually helpful for anybody.
00:36:14
That's just great.
00:36:15
Here's but, but here's the.
00:36:15
Craziness really don't think.
00:36:17
But you had said that you said you said that it's earlier that it maybe it's it's good for.
00:36:22
Us as people to look at the both sides to be able to consider maybe not the extremes I didn't mean.
00:36:26
Just go to the extremes.
00:36:27
I mean, look at both sides, which sometimes includes the extremes, but here's you said.
00:36:32
Yeah, I didn't say that.
00:36:32
That didn't you?
00:36:34
I said I think that I think that the extremes make you hate both sides the other side.
00:36:38
No, not the extremes you said.
00:36:39
Make sure and we you said 5 minutes ago we as people.
00:36:42
Good. Yeah. Sample.
00:36:43
I think I said that I I I said I I think it's not a bad idea to hear both viewpoints and then.
00:36:44
You did.
00:36:48
Do you disagree with?
00:36:48
Make a decision on your own.
00:36:48
That, Matt, I think people need to go to the boring stuff.
00:36:52
That's just so lame and makes you want to fall asleep, cause that's the only true stuff.
00:36:56
Without you're saying without bias, you're saying find a.
00:36:59
Find an NPR who isn't perfect, but you're saying find someone.
00:37:03
So is really making an effort to not be biased in their approach is.
00:37:06
Yeah, like PBS news hour.
00:37:06
What you're saying?
00:37:09
I can't watch that whole hour, but five.
00:37:10
BBC News.
00:37:11
Yeah, BBC.
00:37:13
But you watch an hour of PBS news Hour, you're gonna know both sides of everything, and you're gonna, and you're gonna.
00:37:18
Be asleep, by the way, after 30 minutes.
00:37:19
I mean it's.
00:37:20
Not it's not perfect, but you're saying that's the approach.
00:37:23
But let let me give you scriptures that back up maybe Sam's approach a little bit, right.
00:37:26
Secondly, fight two says 16 the Lord gave unto man that he should act for himself.
00:37:31
Wherefore man could not act for himself, save it should be that he was enticed by the one or the other.
00:37:37
And and I'm not sure we have a choice in today's world.
00:37:40
There are so many voices.
00:37:42
I think about all the things that the church recently has done to kind of put that choice back in the individual and the family between the the curriculum and the missionary age and and the the for the strength of youth.
00:37:56
Like and and Oaks's comment is just the capstone. Yeah, right. Like, as members of the church, you're gonna hear varying opinions.
00:38:05
And you're going to have to act, and the church is going to have to respect that and and and be OK with that.
00:38:13
And you're going to have to learn how to do that in a way and have a conversation like we are in a way that doesn't tear you apart.
00:38:19
We love each other, cause we've served together in in Ukraine. We know each other's heart and you can't.
00:38:26
There's nothing either one of you could say that would separate us from each other.
00:38:30
And and and every member of the church really needs to be that, you know, bound together with the, with the testimony of Christ.
00:38:37
Well, so let's go to the big question.
00:38:38
So the First Amendment protects the freedom of the press, and in part this is because in order for a democracy to function well, people need to have accurate information about what's going on in the government.
00:38:48
If the government is just dishing out.
00:38:50
Propaganda all the time and people don't really know what's happening.
00:38:53
Then you can easily have the the public be LED astray and you lose your democracy before you even know what happened.
00:39:00
So the Supreme Court has fought vigorously to protect the freedom of the press.
00:39:05
News organizations have rights that other organizations don't have.
00:39:08
It's harder to sue them for libel.
00:39:10
They can print classified information.
00:39:13
They don't have to reveal their sources in court.
00:39:15
There's all kinds of things at the same time.
00:39:18
Just because you're a news organization with constitutional protections doesn't guarantee that you're going to be viable newspapers.
00:39:25
Out of business all the time, people.
00:39:27
If they don't like your news aren't going.
00:39:29
To buy your product and then it doesn't matter what constitutional rights you.
00:39:35
So that's the crisis.
00:39:37
We're kind of dilemma, right, because on the one hand, the news organizations want to be accurate and hold the government accountable.
00:39:44
But on the other hand, they need clicks and viewers and advertisers, and they need to make money, and people tend to be more motivated by kind of antagonism.
00:39:53
And conflict and controversy sensationalized kinds of things.
00:39:58
So, and people also want to hear news that reinforces their own particular point of view.
00:40:02
So the question I have this is kind of the big question is like how do you deal with this paradox?
00:40:08
Like there's this one part of me that says.
00:40:11
If an organization is just a propaganda outlet, they don't get to have the word news behind their name.
00:40:16
We just say you're not a news organization and just to be like fair, like at the news stand.
00:40:21
I you know.
00:40:22
There are legitimate fake news about like the Bat boy or whatever.
00:40:26
Like you can see him in the grocery aisle if you ever go shopping anymore, you can see, like, legitimately.
00:40:31
Fake news and that stuff stuff maybe shouldn't be allowed to be called news.
00:40:35
Like that's one approach.
00:40:36
But maybe.
00:40:37
Inquire news.
00:40:38
Which one?
00:40:40
Yeah, except for the but it.
00:40:40
Inquiry meetings.
00:40:42
It's been around a long time, right?
00:40:43
It did break some.
00:40:44
Stories, right, like the Inquirer did actually have a true story one time about a presidential candidate.
00:40:49
I think it was John Edwards.
00:40:50
Was that anyhow?
00:40:52
And so you say, well, maybe we should just not let them be news anymore, but maybe there's something like.
00:40:58
We could do about.
00:40:58
It, like, maybe they're citizens, like as as consumers of media, maybe we have obligations as consumers of.
00:41:06
And we should say we're not going to go to propaganda organizations to get our information.
00:41:11
We're going to only go to legitimate government sources.
00:41:15
We're only going to read, like, official.
00:41:15
Government we should mint.
00:41:17
Actually, what what we should do is the government should buy TikTok.
00:41:21
And they could change.
00:41:22
The algorithm so that it just fed people real news instead of feeding them the stuff.
00:41:28
That is a really good idea.
00:41:29
Government solution to this problem.
00:41:30
Oh. Oh, wait, that's.
00:41:31
In China, never mind.
00:41:32
OK, go ahead.
00:41:33
I forgot.
00:41:35
Forgot China's already doing that.
00:41:36
Dog on it, they beat us.
00:41:37
Sam, you tricked me with your sarcasm, voice.
00:41:38
To it.
00:41:38
OK, never mind.
00:41:39
Next stop.
00:41:40
I just thought I thought.
00:41:40
You were really on to something there for a second.
00:41:45
What do you think, Sean there was?
00:41:46
A plan in.
00:41:47
The pre existence and everybody had a choice.
00:41:50
We need to respect that choice.
00:41:51
I don't I.
00:41:52
Don't think the answer is get government involved to police, police, media because you're you're.
00:41:56
Thank you, Sean.
00:42:00
I have a list.
00:42:01
I have a list of all the regulation that that's got in place and it's pages.
00:42:05
Government because government interference in.
00:42:06
I'm going to.
00:42:07
I'm going to.
00:42:07
Mark this one off.
00:42:10
And in the Second Amendment is the First Amendment.
00:42:12
1st amendment can't wait. Wait, wait. Sean, can I sue somebody and say all I want from you is you don't get to say news anymore like Dominion when they when they I don't want 700 million from Fox.
00:42:14
Sorry, the 1st amendment.
00:42:22
I want you to take news.
00:42:23
Off your.
00:42:23
Name so so.
00:42:24
No, that's free.
00:42:25
So can I make one?
00:42:26
Comment about that, though, so I think it's fascinating that Fox News decided to settle with Dominion.
00:42:31
Because I took in college a bunch of classes about libel and slander that those are some basic required classes in in media back then, and the development of of libel and slander laws as it relates to the media and press over the past many decades is fascinating from protecting ***********.
00:42:51
And other elements of free speech and are anything.
00:42:56
What? What would what?
00:42:57
Would have been terrifying is if Fox News had lost that and had gone all the way to the Supreme Court and it restrained a news organization from being able to share news and another.
00:43:06
Do you? Do you know?
00:43:07
What else?
00:43:07
Is for.
00:43:08
That's off the table.
00:43:08
Do you know what else is fascinating?
00:43:09
Sam, as if they had actually won that lawsuit.
00:43:12
Because then if they win that lawsuit, then a news organization can publish things that they know to be false and not be sued for libel, right?
00:43:18
Either way, either.
00:43:19
That's why I'm glad it was settled.
00:43:20
Way, right?
00:43:20
Right, because.
00:43:21
It's frightening.
00:43:22
Because because right now it it has to be an intentional act, you have to intentionally know that.
00:43:28
Right.
00:43:28
It's a fault.
00:43:29
Fact, which is a ludicrous statement, right?
00:43:32
And that's not a bad standard right now.
00:43:34
Alright, go ahead Sean.
00:43:36
So I don't think the government getting in and.
00:43:38
And I think.
00:43:38
It would be a negative effect if they start to really try and force words, and you can't use news.
00:43:43
You can't use news that seems pretty dangerous for a government to start telling me, like all my business.
00:43:47
But we do that we we do.
00:43:48
That with religions, right, we define what is and is not a religion, only certain.
00:43:52
All themselves are religion.
00:43:53
Only when it comes to tax benefits, right is it.
00:43:56
Ohh, we don't OK we don't.
00:43:59
Well, it can't.
00:44:00
It can't be a religion.
00:44:00
Well, we, we.
00:44:01
We live OG alright.
00:44:04
Are you serious, Sam?
00:44:04
You're just saying, saying saying he's saying he's.
00:44:05
Do you want to go down?
00:44:06
That road for tax, for tax.
00:44:07
Saying they're they're purposes.
00:44:09
Right.
00:44:09
For tax purposes, we have, we've outlined what is and is not a religion for these tax exempt purposes.
00:44:15
Yeah, but anyone can call, but there's freedom to call my my company or religion.
00:44:19
That's got a friend who's doing that.
00:44:19
Right, but if?
00:44:21
But you have.
00:44:22
To behave in a way your friends.
00:44:25
Fascinate me, Sean.
00:44:26
You have to behave in a way that is in line with what they define as a religion.
00:44:31
Right.
00:44:31
So I'm just saying you could do the same thing.
00:44:32
Ticket tax cuts.
00:44:32
With news organizations, right? So.
00:44:35
Just like what they do with taxes and religion, they could do with news and say if you're doing these sorts of things, you're not news.
00:44:41
But then the government would have a chilling effect on the way news is disseminated when free market at the end of the day is the best gauge for whether or not news is good and news is useful.
00:44:45
They would.
00:44:52
I would rather have a Fox News or an MSNBC out there have the market restrain it if it decides to then try to control it by government.
00:45:01
That's not a good look.
00:45:01
So what about Matt?
00:45:02
What about third party Rotten Tomatoes?
00:45:05
How about Rotten Tomatoes, right?
00:45:06
And Rotten Tomatoes becoming an aggregate for this movie is terrible.
00:45:09
Or this movie is good.
00:45:10
It's a good.
00:45:11
I like that.
00:45:11
I like going and saying, OK, here's what majority of people, not that majority rule is is always a.
00:45:16
Good thing, maybe sometimes it's really, really a good thing, but Rotten Tomatoes gives us an aggregate of what people's opinions are on certain things. Why don't we have the?
00:45:24
Rotten Tomatoes for outlets.
00:45:26
Oh, we have that all we have.
00:45:27
That sure, there's a whole.
00:45:27
Media outlets. What is that?
00:45:29
Lot of and ChatGPT is going to create.
00:45:31
What is it that there's a lot of organizations out there that are telling you, like, good news, bad news, biased news, accurate news?
00:45:32
More of.
00:45:39
Well, what about?
00:45:40
We need some we.
00:45:40
Need someone to make that mainstreamed and popular.
00:45:44
And that's you said there's a lot.
00:45:44
The point though?
00:45:45
That's the whole point is that people don't care enough to do that.
00:45:49
Well, let me ask you this, though.
00:45:50
So if you go back to our time in Ukraine, which was right at the end of the Soviet Union, so they're making this transition from a very controlled information environment to what Sam would call capitalism.
00:46:04
They they would regularly complain to.
00:46:06
Me about all of the bad stuff in.
00:46:09
Society, *********** negativity that they didn't have in the Soviet Union.
00:46:14
They're like we I never saw a drunk person on the street.
00:46:17
I never saw this and in addition to that they say and look at all the ****.
00:46:21
Being published like.
00:46:23
Naked ladies and papers and all that sort of stuff.
00:46:25
They never had that and democracy brought that to them.
00:46:29
And I sort of feel like.
00:46:30
I'm so glad this is coming up.
00:46:32
So glad.
00:46:32
I feel like Sam, Sam is saying.
00:46:33
This is coming up.
00:46:34
Like this is a.
00:46:35
Something we should tolerate as a society because it's better for us.
00:46:40
We have to tolerate it, Matt.
00:46:42
And and my son and I had a conversation, the one that served in Taiwan.
00:46:45
We talk often about the liberties in China, which is a communist country versus us.
00:46:50
They're very controlled.
00:46:51
In China, we have our freedoms, our society and culture reflects the values of the people who live in it, in one form, fashion or.
00:47:00
Or another.
00:47:01
And there's this thought that as long as there are is goodness and morality in this culture, it will represent and reflect that Russia, as it went over the precipice of communism to total free market, there was a vacuum and mafia and crime and every all the worst.
00:47:21
Prices came into full.
00:47:22
You and and that's what caused you, you know, the whole pendulum thing right, like and it swing all the way.
00:47:27
The One Direction to the point where it was so bad that people were asking for communism back, right, and Russia, they got a.
00:47:31
Right, that's Putin's.
00:47:34
Version of that.
00:47:34
Paul Mantra put put Putin now has the blue check next to whether or not the news agency or not right so.
00:47:41
They could only they could only listen.
00:47:43
To certain news news in.
00:47:45
Russia right now, I would rather have all the terrible things that come along with it, and if and if we're a nation of good people with, with a moral base.
00:47:55
You've got to believe that that's going to.
00:47:57
Reflect in what we hold and value.
00:48:00
So then.
00:48:00
As a.
00:48:01
And and Matt, you've been the one that has said it way back when you we asked the question, what will we look back on 20 years from now and say hey, we got it wrong in that day and I think you said there are some causes that have swung so far that we'll say, hey, that was that was too much even though it seemed.
00:48:20
We see politically correct that was.
00:48:21
Pretty much and and that's kind of.
00:48:22
Well, so.
00:48:23
We're seeing, right?
00:48:23
So then I think that this is naturally leading to the next question if if it's not going to be government controlled and not going to be government regulated and it's going to be market controlled, then that means citizens and as consumers have some obligations that go along with those freedoms.
00:48:37
So then what are the citizen slash consumer obligations?
00:48:41
Of of, of a society with a truly Free Press, where we're going to allow anything out there, but we're going to allow the market to decide.
00:48:49
Do I have some kind of a moral obligation to consume certain things and not consume other things?
00:48:56
Well, I I think I think that an important part of that is a limited but.
00:49:02
A legal system that protects against libel and right so it it kind of worked with the Fox News thing, right?
00:49:08
So that doesn't didn't work.
00:49:09
I don't know.
00:49:11
I don't know.
00:49:12
I I'm I mean I'm.
00:49:13
I'm not thrilled with that system.
00:49:15
I think it's ridiculous that politicians and news organizations can slander individuals and they don't have legal protections against them.
00:49:23
I would love to see that changed.
00:49:24
And I I just.
00:49:25
Think of the EI. Think of the E Jean Carroll lawsuit against Trump right now, where she's suing Trump for things he said about her while president of the United States.
00:49:26
How would you do it?
00:49:33
And the laws say, well, no, he's president of the United States, he cannot slander another.
00:49:38
Individual he was.
00:49:39
Just doing acting in his official capacity as President, and if he's acting in his official capacity as President, then.
00:49:45
You cannot sue him like I think that stuff is crazy and and and truth in that right like truth in advertising for businesses.
00:49:49
Oh yeah, that seems crazy.
00:49:50
That's not good and.
00:49:53
You can't just lie about your competitors, but candidates can lie about their.
00:49:57
So I I'm not sure that I love the unequal application of these laws in these in this particular realm.
00:50:03
But the laws are good, it seems, so it seems like if we can get better at at protecting against libel and slander, then that's a good element of the free market they have.
00:50:04
Well, well, and and.
00:50:12
That's a good function.
00:50:13
That's one good function of government.
00:50:15
Your, your, your.
00:50:16
Trump example is just spot on.
00:50:18
Like I hear some of the things he said.
00:50:20
You know the, the, the, the, the motions he made making fun of a a kid that was handicapped, you know, comments he's made in the press room.
00:50:28
That's someone who no matter what you think about his policy is not a moral person that occupied that office.
00:50:36
And and and and I think there are some members of the church that see that and and that's a great example.
00:50:43
And and someone in that spot long enough probably breaks the system because because you, you do have to protect.
00:50:51
I mean, how on Earth does the President of United States in a presidential debate make some of the comments?
00:50:56
He may.
00:50:56
Need to to to.
00:50:58
Laughter and applause.
00:50:59
It makes me think of Russell Crowe and Gladiator where you know where he says.
00:51:03
Are you not entertained?
00:51:04
Right and and?
00:51:05
And he says, hey, being in the arena, it is in power, right?
00:51:10
And and Trump understands that, and he knows that.
00:51:13
And we have, you know, we've we counted to to that that's.
00:51:17
So do I have a moral obligation to read accurate news that's really boring to prevent some of this craziness?
00:51:17
That's bigger.
00:51:27
No, I don't think so.
00:51:29
No, just like.
00:51:29
No, don't think so.
00:51:31
No, because.
00:51:31
I don't know.
00:51:31
How you do you know what, Matt, you know?
00:51:33
What would be cool is create a class in in school in high school called digesting Social Media News or News.
00:51:43
Like what if everybody went through?
00:51:44
I could get behind that what teach everybody to think.
00:51:45
What about?
00:51:47
Well, like just.
00:51:47
Quickly in high school.
00:51:47
Just as citizens, right listeners to our podcast, that might have say, what can I do as a citizen?
00:51:53
Do we have like is there some kind of like?
00:51:55
OK, so I would say.
00:51:57
I have a moral obligation to not consume *********** because by not consuming ***********, that's one in a billion that are watching it.
00:52:06
Now, that's not gonna watch it.
00:52:08
And then that hurts that business model in the future and and and entertainment that's like overtly opposed to my values for example.
00:52:17
The Book of Mormon, the musical I chose to never see that because I said they're just making fun of my faith.
00:52:22
Now other people can see it, and that's fine.
00:52:24
I don't have a problem.
00:52:25
I make moral decisions about the things I'm going to consume based on the society I want to live in and and are there moral principles that can guide our decisions and how we consume news that might like result in a better society?
00:52:42
You just it's just it's hard because your.
00:52:46
I yeah, it is, I.
00:52:47
It's a great conversation.
00:52:49
I don't know, Matt.
00:52:49
I I I I err on the side I think of let the opposition exist and let's teach let's I mean if we consume scriptures more we would learn how to differentiate how to discern between right and wrong and good and evil.
00:53:03
Let the spirit be our guide.
00:53:05
I think I know it's cliche, but we need to be better Christians and be very familiar with Scripture and with this the Holy Ghost because then we can discern.
00:53:14
But I think you need to let the opposition exist.
00:53:16
That's the nature of mortality, isn't it?
00:53:20
Watch this, Sean.
00:53:20
Watch this, Sean.
00:53:21
You're the one that's always dropping.
00:53:23
And I'm about to drop it.
00:53:23
I mean, that is right.
00:53:24
That's that's the whole purpose of our experience, is to learn good from evil and choose good and sustain and prop up good.
00:53:33
Not by force, but by choice and as appealing as it is to think about, you know, a communist.
00:53:40
That world where you can't get ***********, you can't get some of these other things.
00:53:45
I mean, Matt, you make the comment about ***********.
00:53:47
Most people in the United States, they don't agree with that comment.
00:53:50
Most people in the United States think it's OK and probably helpful, right?
00:53:53
Yes, I know.
00:53:54
I'm I'm well.
00:53:54
Aware it's a, it's a.
00:53:56
It's a.
00:53:57
It's a challenge, right?
00:53:58
But but I.
00:53:58
And that that's a social, societal problem.
00:54:01
But I can make the choice to not consume it even when I really, really want to, because I would.
00:54:06
Rather not see it as a sign.
00:54:08
And I can make the choice to never see another Nicholas.
00:54:10
Cage move. I'm just kidding.
00:54:13
But you can't, but you can't.
00:54:14
But you can't legislate.
00:54:16
Others not seem.
00:54:16
No, I agree.
00:54:17
I think I agree that we shouldn't legislate this, but I think that we as citizens, that we frequently like to talk about freedom and we rarely talk about responsibility.
00:54:26
And I think it's sometimes OK to focus on what responsibilities.
00:54:30
We have as citizens.
00:54:31
If we want.
00:54:31
To have freedom and we want to have, let's say we want to have a moral in a good society, we do have some responsibilities with how we exercise our freedoms that influence other peoples and don't just have an effect on ourselves.
00:54:45
So then what do you do, Matt?
00:54:47
How do you how do you ingrain or inject?
00:54:49
And heavens sakes, do not say Glenn Beck teaches a class to high school students.
00:54:53
Like someone should teach it, it would be a critical thinking class somehow.
00:54:58
Where it's.
00:54:58
Hey, here's the different ways you get news and information.
00:55:03
How do you digest it?
00:55:04
Right.
00:55:05
I don't know if that's a class.
00:55:06
I'm sorry to sound like a broken record, but the God put the scriptures on.
00:55:07
Is it?
00:55:10
Just let it be.
00:55:11
No, no.
00:55:11
Put the scriptures on the earth and there's such dissonance in the scriptures and you did that on purpose.
00:55:15
I think it is hard to understand all the things in the scriptures cause they.
00:55:16
Yeah, yeah.
00:55:20
Beat up against each other and it requires deep personal study and contemplation, and that that strengthens our cognitive abilities to see both sides of things and then discern so I I think it's feast upon the words of Christ.
00:55:30
It's great point.
00:55:32
That's the answer.
00:55:33
But I do also, I think I'll just say this, you get what you pay for and there are a lot of people out there that just want to consume free media and free news and get whatever shows up on TikTok.
00:55:43
And you have to assume that that's going to be garbage and and I pay money to subscribe to the Washington Post, the Wall Street Journal, New York Times, because.
00:55:43
Yeah, lazy.
00:55:52
Maybe I don't love what's in their opinions.
00:55:54
Sections, but if you, you gotta you gotta let reporters get paid for their jobs or they're not gonna be able to keep reporting on the news and that, like it is OK.
00:56:05
Hey Matt, can can I borrow?
00:56:07
Your volume for those.
00:56:10
It's so funny how we, like, just share Netflix passwords and all that stuff, right?
00:56:14
For some reason, we don't share all of those.
00:56:16
News and like like like.
00:56:18
There are legitimate newspaper newspaper organizations out there.
00:56:22
And they're dying, right? They're dying breed because everybody wants free news. And so I do think we have an obligation to say, look, if I'm going to spend $60.00 a month on.
00:56:32
Subscriptions of some kind?
00:56:34
Can I make one of them a newspaper?
00:56:36
Can I make one of them like something invested in giving me accurate information and I could just maybe wait on Netflix for?
00:56:44
I don't know, maybe not.
00:56:44
Subscribe to that one.
00:56:46
So So what if the three of us came up with a free market solution to that?
00:56:51
I think people could get behind that.
00:56:53
So to Shawn's point, and then to yours. Like what? What free market tool could there be that would allow people to have a choice and get access to some of these other news sources? Cause. Because to your point, the free stuff is garbage right now, right?
00:57:07
The stuff of value is behind a paywall because it costs money to create the stuff that's free is somebody that's just churning out stuff that you know isn't fit to read.
00:57:18
That that's a fascinating deal.
00:57:20
Like so.
00:57:20
So that being the case, how do you?
00:57:23
Remedy that, right?
00:57:24
Because us refusing to read something or or buying one more subscription isn't going to change the world.
00:57:30
But if we had a free market solution.
00:57:32
If you create an iTunes or a Spotify of News right where where you where the like, the news organizations are going to get paid for the stories that people read, but they can create like this like cultivated list.
00:57:45
It's like these are the kinds of things I want to know about, and you're going to get in your Spotify feed or your whatever feed the accurate.
00:57:52
I kind of disagree with you guys.
00:57:53
There's I think that.
00:57:56
It's you're never going to avoid the the opposite.
00:57:59
You're always going to have the extremes and the different sides in the opposition because money drives it all right.
00:58:03
The the moment, the moment you have two iTunes, you know for media competing against each other is the moment you start getting money.
00:58:03
You want that you want that, yeah.
00:58:11
Being the driving force behind the content, and it eventually just becomes a pandering source.
00:58:16
So I think you have to accept we have.
00:58:18
To accept the.
00:58:19
Fact that there is opposition, there are forces of good and evil, right and wrong, black and white, and many Grays in the area.
00:58:27
In in between.
00:58:28
I sort of.
00:58:29
I sort of see Sean know what Matt is saying, which is those last good sources are going away because there is no funding and and if there's no funding, they're just going to disappear into the night.
00:58:40
You know, you look at some of the great media sources here in Utah, like there used to be rich diversity and there used to be depth.
00:58:47
Now they're all owned by the same company and and they're a a shallow shell of their former self and and and.
00:58:51
Right.
00:58:53
And that is, if you go to Meet the Press and listen to some of their podcast.
00:58:56
Recently that that's a national problem and and that is.
00:58:58
So so so I.
00:59:00
So I started to abandon the big media and started to go online and go OK, let me listen to some of these guys.
00:59:00
A real problem.
00:59:05
So, for example, Ben Shapiro, he started going online and I loved it because all he's gonna give me.
00:59:09
The and then eventually I realized oh.
00:59:10
Wait, he's just pandering.
00:59:11
Yeah, he's just pandering.
00:59:13
OK, that's not a good source.
00:59:14
Let me look for another online version.
00:59:15
And right now I'm into Russell Brand and I.
00:59:17
Know he's a very he's very much so a conspiracy theorist, right?
00:59:19
But he's not a reporter, Sean.
00:59:20
His whole.
00:59:21
He's not.
00:59:21
A he's not giving.
00:59:22
You accurate news about what's going on.
00:59:24
I don't need he.
00:59:25
He doesn't need a credential.
00:59:26
But he looks good and he's got an English accent.
00:59:26
He doesn't need a credential.
00:59:28
No, he doesn't need a credential to be able to have a brain to analyze.
00:59:32
But I know, but I once.
00:59:34
We almost ended on a strong note.
00:59:37
Went I.
00:59:38
Want someone in?
00:59:39
The white.
00:59:39
House when when Biden does a press conference or I want someone in the White House that's going to challenge those questions to give me accurate information about what's happening there.
00:59:50
You know what I'm saying?
00:59:51
Like somebody who's there in the.
00:59:52
Room like look.
00:59:54
All of us could watch C-SPAN.
00:59:54
I sure miss you.
00:59:55
Like if ad nauseam, it's on all all the time and it's totally free, but nobody does it cause it's super boring.
01:00:01
So I need.
01:00:01
To pay somebody to sit through all that super boring stuff and tell me the little things that matter, that's the kind of that's what I.
01:00:07
Mean by news?
01:00:08
Well, I don't understand the rules.
01:00:10
What keeps Russell Brand out of The Newsroom in?
01:00:12
The White House.
01:00:13
But he's not there.
01:00:15
He's making a podcast, making you laugh.
01:00:16
He could go there if he wanted to, but he's not doing that because he's an entertainer, Sean.
01:00:21
He's a he's.
01:00:23
And he was married to Katy Perry.
01:00:25
Well, now I like it.
01:00:25
OK, now I got.
01:00:26
To follow him.
01:00:28
Yeah, but eventually he'll get there. He has 6.5 million followers on his YouTube channel.
01:00:33
Eventually doesn't.
01:00:34
If he believes in what he's doing, and so far it seems like he's he's very much so believing in his his messages, he could he could get there to the White House.
01:00:40
Why not?
01:00:42
Oh, come on shot.
01:00:43
I don't want to have to do.
01:00:44
This to you.
01:00:44
But I'm I gotta go.
01:00:46
That's the one problem with with like our digesting of news today is entertainers now become.
01:00:53
Purveyors and like it's kind of.
01:00:56
Yeah. Have you?
01:00:57
We need reporters that the people that are held up as deliverers of news.
01:00:57
They they become.
01:01:00
That's a good point.
01:01:01
What happened to the reporters that were critical thinkers?
01:01:03
That that like you know?
01:01:04
So name, name.
01:01:05
Name two of them.
01:01:06
Tamara Keith. Nina Totenberg.
01:01:07
All right, I'll go.
01:01:09
I will start looking at Tamara Keith.
01:01:11
Tamara Keith is the president of the White House Correspondents Association.
01:01:15
She covers the White House as well as anyone has.
01:01:19
Nina Totenberg covers the Supreme Court.
01:01:21
She she can tell you more about what's going on in the court Supreme Court.
01:01:25
Than anyone in the nation.
01:01:25
Just I I just want one.
01:01:27
I'll just focus on Tamara Keith and by the by our next podcast, I will have followed Tamara Keith.
01:01:31
That's awesome. You you, you.
01:01:33
Won't find them with an outsized YouTube or Facebook or LinkedIn presence.
01:01:36
That's OK, I don't need.
01:01:37
They're right.
01:01:38
She's a sweet.
01:01:39
She's a very kind.
01:01:39
But that's the point, right?
01:01:43
And a great reporter.
01:01:45
So there you go.
01:01:46
Part part of this mat part of our podcast should be let's promote voices that are actually doing the job, right.
01:01:48
And a liberal.
01:01:51
Yeah, that's what I think we should do.
01:01:51
Right.
01:01:52
So I'll go.
01:01:53
So I will go on and I promote to our listeners to do what I'm about to do, which is take a whole week.
01:01:57
Studying Tamara Keith.
01:01:58
I want to hear what she has to say.
01:01:59
I love it this this is good.
01:01:59
I wanna see if she really is.
01:02:02
Wow, this is fun.
01:02:02
Yeah, I like it.
01:02:04
Are you gonna?
01:02:04
Are you gonna are?
01:02:05
So you're turning off Russell Brand and you're going out of.
01:02:06
Oh sure, I'll take ohh sure.
01:02:07
The way alright, good.
01:02:07
I'll take a break from Russell Brand, I'll.
01:02:09
Love it.
01:02:09
Listen to Tamara Keith.
01:02:10
That's awesome.
01:02:10
OK, I like it.
01:02:11
Hey, guys.
01:02:12
Great conversation.
01:02:13
Today it was.
01:02:15
It was kind of like.
01:02:16
All over the place, sort of.
01:02:18
But I liked the topics I liked.
01:02:20
I liked Sam.
01:02:21
What you did to Sean here and there.
01:02:22
We say I hate to do this to you, Sean, but then you like kind.
01:02:25
Of beat him a little bit, spank him around.
01:02:28
And then gave me a hug.
01:02:29
That's right.
01:02:30
Push me in the face and.
01:02:31
Then give me a hug.
01:02:32
And if we haven't, if we haven't said it enough in our previous episodes, This is why we're doing this podcast.
01:02:33
That's the latter day lens.
01:02:38
We want to model for everybody what to do.
01:02:40
Have these conversations with people that you love, people that you know and feel free to join in on the conversations with us.
01:02:46
We'd love to hear from you guys in the future.
01:02:48
Have a great day.
01:02:52
That is all the time we have this week, but that doesn't mean the discussion is over.
01:02:56
In fact, we include links to the stories we discussed each week in the podcast description to encourage our listeners participation.
01:03:03
Each of you have an important perspective that builds the latter day lens and we want to hear from you.
01:03:07
Let's continue the discussion on social media.
01:03:10
You can find us on Instagram at latter Day lens on Twitter at Latter Day, lens on Facebook at Latter Day lens.
01:03:16
Or you can e-mail us at the latter day lens@gmail.com all one word. Finally, please make sure you subscribe to get updated content each week. Thanks for making us one of the most listened to podcasts. We love our listeners.
Audio file
Transcript
Speaker 1
Here's the mistake I think most most of US members just make. We think that's talking about money and success. But if you really study those scripts, there's there's not a lot of. It's mostly about freedom of *******, freedom from *******.
Speaker 2
Welcome to Latter Day lens. Unscripted faith, promoting discussion of current political events with Sean, Sam and Matt. Hey, welcome everybody to another exciting episode of the Latter Day lens with. New slate of current events to discuss. There's all kinds of really exciting stuff in the news, but we're going to begin with the. Least exciting thing. In the news, which would be the Federal Reserve and the banks? We discussed this a couple of weeks ago, so it turns out that the Federal Reserve they looked into the failure of Silicon Valley Bank ask themselves the question, why did it fail? And I think that they were very introspective. And the government blamed themselves and they said it's our fault that that bank failed and management there was some poor management on the part of SB. But if if the Federal Reserve had done a better job of regulating, then they say that the bank never would have failed and so their solution is more. So you know that I love government regulation. So my question for you is do you think that more government regulation will prevent failures like this bank in the future? It's just, it's just. A government failure of regulation and if they had just done their jobs, they could have stopped this unforeseen tragedy.
Speaker 3
So Matt, you included a quote that says in the case of SVB, supervisors delayed action to gather more evidence as weaknesses were clear and growing. And that was the root cause according to what you wrote. If that's true, it's not the lack of regulation, it's just the lack of actionable oversight on existing regulation that caused. Cause the. And it's interesting in cycles of good economies and then challenging times and good economies and challenging times, whenever things are good, people want to continue to see good. And I think a weakness in human nature is a tendency to look the other way and overlook rules when things are so good, because you assume things. Will always. Be good. What should happen is whatever oversight was there should have been executed on like it should have been, and there wouldn't be a problem. I say less, you know, we don't. Need additional oversight. Wait, wait.
Speaker
What about? Wait, wait, wait.
Speaker 2
Wait, I'm gonna jump in here, Sean. Real fast. OK, because I have a totally different take than that. Sam, I feel. Like Republicans don't.
Speaker 3
You provided the quote OK.
Speaker 2
No, no, no. That's right. And that's the quote from the Federal Reserve. What my take on this is that Republicans don't like government regulation. And so when government, when Republicans are in charge and Republicans are nominating people. To to be in charge of things like the Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell, for instance, was chosen by Donald Trump, a Republican. They choose people that are bad at regulating because Republicans are like Boo Boo regulations. We don't want oversight. So let's choose people who are bad at those jobs. And then those people do a bad job of what they're doing, and then the Republicans say, see government's no good. Because government can't do its job and. I say, well, if you picked good people for. Those jobs then we wouldn't have that.
Speaker 3
Yeah, but that's a pretty general statement about the type of people that Republicans bring into those oversight roles. If you go and you look at other people like, who's in charge of the CFPB, I'm not a huge fan of her.
Speaker 2
Nancy Pelosi, I think it's Nancy Pelosi.
Speaker 3
Well, no, no, no, not Nancy Pelosi before her. She ran for a very early on in the the Democrat presidential way back when. Elizabeth Warren, right? So the Democrats have a tendency to bring people that have 0 background in business to try to do oversight in business in ways that are actually pretty detrimental and demonstrate a complete lack of understanding of business. The current head of the CFPB is a wonderful example of that right?
Speaker
I didn't.
Speaker 3
Never spent a day in the business but but.
Speaker 2
Is that Rohit Chopra?
Speaker
I did not think I.
Speaker 2
OK.
Speaker 3
Yes. And and.
Speaker 1
Did not think that this discussion would start off so early with one of you being anti Republican, the other being anti Democrat and being the two parties fighting against each other. I didn't know that this would be.
Speaker 2
But I really think that's. The root of.
Speaker 3
This, but what? No but see. Here's the thing. Though the quote right here simply states supervisors delayed taking action, they knew they needed to take action. They had actionable information. They should have taken action and arguably had they taken, they would have preserved confidence and there wouldn't be a there.
Speaker
Can I have?
Speaker 3
Would have been a problem.
Speaker 1
So, Sam, you said something earlier that when times are good, we are prosperous. We tend to be a little more.
Speaker
It's the cycle.
Speaker 1
And you said you said we tend to be a little more the Book of Mormon reference, we tend to be a little more LAX and the people tend to. Act a little, we see. And and then we act less responsibly.
Speaker 3
We want to see, yeah.
Speaker 1
And then there's problems. Well, isn't one of the accusations of the last. What is it, Matt? 5-10 years with all the bailouts? Isn't that also the heavy regulation and the government bailing bailing these banks out? Isn't that also a reason, maybe a lot of these banks are? Acting lax?
Speaker 2
Because they know that there's no.
Speaker 1
They're not. They're not gonna fail.
Speaker 2
Yeah, there's no consequence.
Speaker 1
No consequences. So more regulation makes people go well, it'll be fine. Let's take the risks. Let's behave badly.
Speaker 3
OK, so let's add, you know, let let's take that one, two steps beyond. Let's add more. Regulation we ignore.
Speaker 2
I'm saying right to not ignore.
Speaker 3
The and then and then let's. Let's actually who's the person that that you wanted in charge of the? CFPB. I can't pronounce it. And I.
Speaker 2
Right.
Speaker 3
Apologize, I want to slaughter it, but.
Speaker 2
Chopra, is that who it is.
Speaker 3
So Rahid Chopra, let's put her in charge, even though she doesn't understand what she's supervising. And there's no there's no elected oversight for that organization. Some of the structure you have to admit, the way it's set up is lunacy. If we just obeyed the laws and we just did what we're required to do currently, this wouldn't have happened. Somebody fell asleep at the wheel, chose not to take action when they should have taken. And they should pay for that. There should be a consequence, Matt.
Speaker 1
Hey this is a very remote. You're a political scientist. Do you know who in 1963, Wright Pattman is the chairman of the House Banking and Currency Committee we have.
Speaker 2
Now you're making it sound like because I know political science. Yeah, I should like Wikipedia is.
Speaker
Yeah, it's good to.
Speaker 2
Part of my.
Speaker 3
Members out of mouth.
Speaker 2
See 1963. Let's see. No.
Speaker 1
No, no, no. Do you have his base like a baseball card you have like? A picture you. In your room nerding out with old politicians and and things. No, OK.
Speaker 2
In 1963, I would have a Martin Luther King junior base. Of course.
Speaker 1
OK. OK, good.
Speaker 2
But OK, go on Sean.
Speaker 1
So he he had a quote back in the day when things were failing and this was a big, scary thing. And he said, I think we should have more bank failures. The record the last several years of almost no bank failures. And finally, last year, with no bank failures at all is, to me, a danger signal that we have gone too far in the direction of bank. Safety now weird statement, but I think there's some wisdom in there's probably should be a good amount of bank failures. In fact, I believe don't quote me, but I think there's three to four bank failures per year in this. Country and they don't get bailed out.
Speaker 2
Yeah, I'm not opposed. I'm not opposed to bank failures. I'm opposed to bank failures to the tune where the government has to bail out the banks, right?
Speaker 1
That's what your question was. Your question is do does government regulation prevent failures?
Speaker 2
Failures like Silicon Valley bank. So the problem with Silicon Valley Bank is. They're being extraordinarily risky and they're not protecting. They don't have enough deposits on hand to protect, like they don't have enough cash on hand to protect their depositors. So, so then the federal government feels like they need to give money to people who are. Risky with their assets.
Speaker 3
And and there were rules in place that had those rules been followed, and whoever the supervisors are, had they done what they were supposed to do, it never would. Have gotten as far as it did, but it did.
Speaker 1
So, Sam, you're saying you're saying let those people fail and let the bank fail and let the consequences follow?
Speaker 3
Thing I absolutely would have let the big fail. And by the way, I want to take back what I said about Rohit Chopra from CFPB. He's a Harvard grad. And then he went to work for McKinsey. But I don't know that he's run business or had the business acumen. I have no way of knowing to be able to put the type of regulation in place that would be. Thoughtful and effective, right?
Speaker 1
So, so Matt and Sam, I feel like bringing in a little bit of scripture here because I think there is a principle here that's interesting. It takes it takes us on a tangent a little bit, but it's you.
Speaker 3
Bring it.
Speaker 1
Tell me, Matt, if it takes us off.
Speaker 2
Go ahead, Sean.
Speaker 1
'S idea of. This balance of banks failing and and protecting banks, I often hear members of our church refer to look if we're faithful or righteous, there's prosperity in the land. I agree that that this concept of keeping the commandments brings prosperity in the land, is abundant in the scriptures. There's lots of references to prosperity.
Speaker 2
Well, mostly in the Book of Mormon.
Speaker 1
Yeah, there's four or five in the in the New Testament, but you're right mostly in. The Book of Mormon, but I.
Speaker 2
Not doctrine and covenants really, right?
Speaker 1
There's a few in the B. And C yeah. There are, but here's the mistake I think most most of US members just make.
Speaker 2
Oh, OK, all right.
Speaker 1
We think that's talking about money and success. But if you really study those scriptures, there's not a lot of. It's mostly about freedom of *******, freedom from *******, so prospering in the land without having *******. And it's talking about receiving God's glory. Basically, it's talking about spiritual prosperity. It's talking about the prosperity of the soul and of the spirit. It rarely. Now I would love for listeners to go and study these these principles. That I've studied a lot in the scriptures about this concept of prosperity. It's not necessarily talking about money and prosperity in that sense. So back to the topic. I don't know, man. I think there should be a good balance. I mean, if no banks are failing ever, and I know you're not arguing that. That suggests corruption to me, like clearly there are lots of businesses doing wrong things, and the natural consequence of those things should be failure, right? SVB Bank was doing risky, risky, risky things with no consequence. It seems like letting that fail. Seems like a a good thing, man, and I know the argument is. Yeah, but look at the people who suffer.
Speaker 2
That's right.
Speaker 1
They'll be fine. They'll be fine.
Speaker 2
Yeah, well, the problem is when the government puts FDIC on the bank, then it it's it's sending a message to the public that the government is going to help them out because they say this is Federal Deposit Insurance company, right. That corporation, that's.
Speaker 3
That's different.
Speaker 2
Well, so that's.
Speaker 3
That's that's preserving depositors stakes in the bank that's not propping up the bank and allowing the bank to continue.
Speaker 2
But what but but the?
Speaker 3
So those are two separate things.
Speaker 2
Big problem with SVB is that they are giving money to these depositors that have had assets in excess of what the FDIC would normally cover. And so I I do have a problem with that, right? It's like if you put $2,000,000 in the bank and it's not, it's just, I just think that the public isn't adequately aware of what's going on.
Speaker 1
Yes. Yep, that's it.
Speaker 2
It's a complicated industry and so I think the government, if you're going to. Have something like the FDIC.
Speaker 3
Very complicated.
Speaker 2
Like giving confidence to a bank, then that the government has some obligation to the public to let them know. Some way of letting them know.
Speaker 1
I like that Matt. Matt, make make stronger laws that that put make banks more transparent with how much money and what kind of money and where it's going. Yeah, I want to know that I've invested this or I've put this money in. The bank and that they're living within the regulations, the FDIC regulations that keep my money safe and short. Yeah, make it make it very, very transparent. I think that's a good solution.
Speaker 2
So let's move on to. The GOP presidential group like. I don't know. I don't know guys like. But I consider myself a conservative Republican, and I've always worn this this badge Republican Party with with pride. I've been a proud Republican most of my life. But as I look. At the field of presidential contender. I just find myself like wondering what happened to the Republican Party. Like, where did they go? And I have something I have a quote in here from President Oak. So this is in the April 2021 General Conference in his talk on the Constitution, he says there are other duties that are part of upholding the inspired constitution we should learn and advocate the inspired principles of the Constitution. We should seek out and support. Why is in good persons who will support those principles and public actions, and then he also says this process will not be easy. It may require changing party support or candidate choices, even from election to election. Such independent actions will sometimes require voters to support candidates or political parties or platform. Whose other positions they cannot approve, and so that says to me like that's kind of like a green light. Like, hey, if the Republicans aren't gonna uphold the constitutional principles, then maybe I need to send them a lesson and look for Democrat candidates. Well, so then I want to discuss this question. Like are there any Republican candidates out there who are good and wise and who would not support the constitutional principles in their public action?
Speaker 1
So Matt, do you want it? There's such good questions in that the first question is what the heck happened to the Republican Party? Why does it look so differently than it does now than it did in the Reagan era? And then the traditional conservative times in the? What 30s, Forties, Fifties, 60s? Is that the question, like what happened and why has it changed? Or is your question looking at the current Republican President saying?
Speaker 2
Yeah, I I mean, I don't think we could really answer. I don't think we really know why it changed. But I do think we could look at where it is right now and and maybe I just misperceived things like maybe there's Republican candidates that are. Really are good candidates good and wise, and I just don't see them. And maybe the other Republicans aren't seeing them right now.
Speaker 1
So there's a there's a cool podcast called Conservative something Nice Plug. I don't remember they they these two guys. Basically, they just take books that are either the foundation of conservatism or the foundation of liberalism, and they just read the book, and then they summarize and talk about each book to kind of just point out. Look, here's what is traditional or foundational. Service ISM. Here's what is traditional, foundational liberalism. It's really fascinating. Now, if you look, they've kind of described that. Look, there's, there's traditional conservatism and then there's, like, the libertarian side of conservatism. Is that, would you summarize that populism?
Speaker 2
And then there's populism. Yeah, protectionism xenophobe. Yeah, go ahead.
Speaker 1
So he goes, they go in to kind of explain that the the the major difference between like the Reagan era conservatism and then. Today, there's big differences. Isn't there? Like, like back in the day, let's see.
Speaker 2
Reagan, with small government, fiscal responsibility.
Speaker
OK so.
Speaker 2
National Defense, fight against communism in favor of immigration.
Speaker 1
Which is more which is more that mask, right? He brought in that anti communism kind of national security conservatism. That's kind of a conservative value, isn't it?
Speaker 2
Yeah, I think it is, yeah.
Speaker 1
Which it doesn't like you had mentioned in the past, doesn't get talked about much and then the traditional conservatism is more about values, virtue and order, right?
Speaker 2
Yeah, yeah. Moral principles.
Speaker 1
And then the the libertarian one is, isn't that more?
Speaker 2
About individual freedom. Individual, yeah.
Speaker 1
Right. So if you, if you if you if you define conservatism based on those, I think you're right, you look at today's Republican Party and it looks very different, doesn't it?
Speaker 2
But I do think so. I think that the allure from me to the Republican Party is that I've always sort of thought of the Republican Party as a party that's defending moral values, that I think are important in society. And and even in the in that regard, I feel like some of the candidates have lost their way and they're advocating things that don't look like moral values and moral principles, but it's it's also true that I'm not really embedded in this world. And I I imagine there are probably candidates out there. The fit, Sean, even the Reagan definition of conservatism, maybe they're just not popular. Right now, like Ace, like the guy from Arkansas Ace and ASA Hutchinson, I think he maybe is a Reagan Republican.
Speaker 3
Yeah, I think I think they're out there. The, the, the challenges, they've just been drowned out and and there's probably some fear too because that approach right now doesn't sit well on a stage with Trump. I mean, Trump just beats the living daylights out of these people. He he calls them names, he marginalizes them and he runs them off stage. And, you know, a guy like Pence is a pretty good guy. Right. Like I I think he's a a very. Decent, good, good, good.
Speaker 1
Yeah, he seems like a.
Speaker 3
Wet Noodle, though I I met, I met.
Speaker
What does that mean?
Speaker 2
What noodle. What does that noodle?
Speaker 1
A guy that just follows around Trump for four years and just does whatever he says.
Speaker 3
I I met. Well, but maybe that's a little bit of the Trump effect. I met Jeb Bush in in Iowa and and had breakfast with him and and his campaign ahead of his campaign with some people I work around and, you know, super nice guy, right? But not as not the rock star that our culture demands right now.
Speaker 1
So so isn't that?
Speaker 3
And it's interesting. We're gonna. We're gonna talk about it in just a minute, but I think these cycles are real in history, and they're at work in our world. Today and as far One Direction as maybe Trump and others have taken the party, it'll swing. Back you would hope, right?
Speaker 1
I wonder, Matt, do you think it will swing back?
Speaker 2
Well, I think that the Republican Party is at a bit of an inflection point. So if if I were to take a broad historical brush and sort of paint things, I'd say, yeah, history does repeat itself in some ways. I think that this group of Republicans that really likes Ron De Santis and likes Donald Trump geographically, a lot of them are, are concentrated in the deep. Mouth and you know, 50-60 years ago they were all Democrats and they were all fighting against the civil rights movement. And they were trying to stop the Democratic Party from civil rights and and they basically all decided, let's leave the Democratic Party and let's go to the Republican Party and the Republican Party embrace them. And it's really helped the Republican Party gain power. The ways that it couldn't before, but they've become.
Speaker 1
You're talking about working, you're talking about working class white people is. What you're talking about, right?
Speaker 2
Oh, I don't, I. I just call them the racist Southerners. That's what I call.
Speaker 1
Oh, oh boy.
Speaker 2
Them I mean, I mean. Like they're not a.
Speaker 3
He's gonna find he's gonna find a way to give the current Republican Party a backhanded slap.
Speaker
No, no, no, no, like.
Speaker 3
One way or another. Right backhanded copy. It's a party of right let's.
Speaker 2
So I'm going to nobody. Nobody likes the the label racist, but I'm going to be quite honest like where I live in Utah and Idaho, we sometimes will have these like get togethers where we have these competitions and say hey let's tell jokes and let's see who's got the funniest jokes and then I will say by the way no racist jokes allowed and it's crickets. Nobody's got any jokes to tell. And then I say, OK.
Speaker
You can. I'm I'm.
Speaker 3
Come on, come on, come on.
Speaker
I'm a.
Speaker 2
100% serious, like they're people are racist, right? So not in like, not in, like and we hate black people kind of thing, but in a it's really fun to make jokes, racist jokes kind of thing.
Speaker 1
You think it's a? You think it's an ignorant racism, not a proactive.
Speaker 2
I'm just saying, like young people who don't know better how to hide it. There's a lot of racism in Utah and Idaho.
Speaker 1
No, I do. I don't think it's.
Speaker 3
A Utah well, it's like Romney's binders full of women. Comment, right?
Speaker 1
I don't think it's.
Speaker 3
There's something deeply embedded that without knowledge is somehow brings you to that a little bit, actually, I think.
Speaker 1
Being being being the Southern California guy, I will defend Utah, Idaho. I don't think it's people in Utah and Idaho. They're racist.
Speaker 2
No, no, no. So.
Speaker 1
I think it's I.
Speaker 2
I didn't get to finish. My point, so I'm saying like. I see it in Utah and Idaho a little bit, but then go to the South, spend a little bit of time in Louisiana and Mississippi, Alabama, the Carolinas. There's there's, like a deep racism there. So we get it a little bit here in Utah and Idaho and you go to those other places and you want to tell racist jokes and you're not even gonna get anybody kind of like looking at you like you shouldn't be telling that racist joke. Like there's some deep racism, especially in the American South, and I'm so I don't wanna like paint the brush. And say the Republican Party is racist. But there is a a big segment of the Republican Party. That is overtly racist. There's a lot of them that are covertly racist, and then there's a lot of them that kind of like aren't opposed to racist people, right?
Speaker 1
So Matt, so Matt, so if that if.
Speaker 3
I think that's an unfair generalization.
Speaker 1
But, but if that's true, we don't know if it's true or not, right? If that's true, that is certainly a a change from the Republican Party, right, Republican.
Speaker
No, no, no.
Speaker 1
What do you?
Speaker 2
No, it's no, it's the. It's the Republican base. These are the people that got Ronald Reagan elected. He doesn't win with that. They're the ones that brought the Republicans in. In 1994.
Speaker 1
No, but what I'm saying is traditional conservatism or the Republican Party of Abraham Lincoln maybe isn't.
Speaker 2
Ohh well come on.
Speaker
That you.
Speaker 2
I mean, yeah, I.
Speaker 1
You asked what you asked.
Speaker 2
Mean that's that's too far back.
Speaker 1
What happened? You asked what happened to the Republican Party? So I guess what standard over the Republican Party are you?
Speaker 2
Well, yeah. I mean, there's a whole history there that we could talk. So all I'm saying is, if there's this group of the Republican Party that's racist, some of them, there's a group of them that really hates immigrants, some of them and.
Speaker
Alright, alright, alright. And then there's.
Speaker 2
A large contingent of them that are, like, let's say, evangelical Christians, and they care about moral values. And all of that stuff sort of gets meshed together into one big. Sort of like goop that we. Call the Republican Party. And sometimes some of those candidates espousing those things have an outsized voice compared to the rest of the party. Right, so so I'm. Not saying Republicans are racist? I'm saying all parties are like coalitions of different groups of people. And this 30% of the Republican Party, that there's maybe like not not the kind of people I would hang out with that sometimes they get an outsized voice in the Republican Party and yeah.
Speaker 1
So, so, so maybe Sam, you mentioned earlier the celebrity element of Donald Trump that has really affected the Republican Party. Maybe that's there's something to that like to me, I think that the technology has. Enabled, for example big media to use its power to really divide. Like use philosophies to divide. And they do that because now that there's data like Matt, you've taught me this, that Donald Trump looked at Twitter would tweet something, look at the data results, the analytics and go, OK, this is what people. Care about and whether it's yeah.
Speaker 2
100,000 likes. If he got 100,000 likes on a tweet, it became a a campaign promise.
Speaker 1
With so Donald. Trump would tweet something whether he believes it or not, whether it's moral or not, whether it's good or. Not whether it's conserve. Never. Not if it got up more than 100,000 retweets. That was a campaign that was what he'd campaign that he was simply marketing, right? Is what you're saying.
Speaker 2
Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1
So I think what I'm trying to get to is the technology has. Allowed big media. To to do that right to use the analytics to go OK, what are some what are groups of people that can sway votes? What are they into? All right, now let's make that our platform. And when it's money driven like that or power driven like that, what you get is you get Fox News and MSNBC, what you get is Republicans versus Democrat. You get division and. Divide, divide, divide. Divide and you get these extremes on both sides, which is what I think the the parties have. Become isn't it?
Speaker 3
Well, but the great thing about the great thing about the history of America is anytime we swing to extremes, oftentimes it comes back and it you've gotta believe and and we're gonna talk about this in a second with our next question. But it's gonna swing back a little bit. And and I'm excited to go to question #3, but before we go there, can I just bring up one comment that I think we went by very quickly that is actually a. Big deal. So Matt, I had never read this comment from Elder Oaks. So, you know, an apostle in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints making a statement in a public forum, which then becomes policy sort of of the church, right. I've never heard of an apostle of the church talking about changing public party. And or aligning with public parties where we may not fully support or agree with the entire platform of that. So as I grew up as a kid in high school in our ward, we knew the one guy who was Democrat. He was crazy. And we all felt very safe because we had him in a in a in in such a a circle and a cocoon that he could have. No influence on.
Speaker 1
Wow, that's weird.
Speaker 3
And now we're in a world now.
Speaker 1
Dude, that is weird. What you're saying.
Speaker 3
We're in a world. The conversations we're having right now not only should be normal and they're not yet, but they should actually be encouraged. So instead of making fun of Matt for being pro Biden.
Speaker 2
I am not.
Speaker 3
Right. Like like there could be a time where the church looks at the two sides. I mean, and and and Trump is a fairy example of that. Like, you know, Utah voted Republican. You know, we've always been completely in the Republican camp. We gave Trump a tough time in the last presidential election. We were the one state that didn't go that way as as as much as as we had in the in the history of the.
Speaker 2
So my yeah, my fear, Sam, is that?
Speaker 3
Country right. So.
Speaker 2
Republicans are going to just choose Trump the next Trump, and they're not going to, right. So Trump?
Speaker 3
I don't think there is an extract though.
Speaker 2
Ohh, come on.
Speaker 3
There's still.
Speaker 2
The Santas, the Santas, is so much like Trump.
Speaker 3
Gonna be like him, no.
Speaker 1
No, he is not mad.
Speaker 3
I I don't think DeSantis really has a chance.
Speaker 1
But he's not that much like Trump.
Speaker 3
I really don't.
Speaker 1
Is he alright?
Speaker 2
I ohh yeah.
Speaker 3
He he's he doesn't have the personality. He doesn't have the character, you know?
Speaker 2
Yeah, I just mean it.
Speaker 3
He he's he's slow out the gates with his campaign and he is not taking the the hits. And here's another example. Just one last example about how things. Looking back, I was concerned when the Supreme Court overturned. Roe V Wade. From from a gospel standpoint, we're against abortion generally, but once something becomes ingrained as the law of the land, it concerns me to undo it. Republicans came back and they said, hey, we're not undoing this. We're just allowing states to have control over whether it happens or not. And it's interesting, this past week. There are two states that actually have it up, Nebraska and South Carolina. Where they were trying to ban abortion in those states, states where Republican Republicans had the majority and and and and banning abortion should have, should have taken off clearly and easily. And it didn't, right?
Speaker 2
Yeah, but it did in Utah and Idaho.
Speaker 3
So I I think. But it did in Utah and Idaho, and it could be undone. But we're pretty progressive.
Speaker 2
So so kind.
Speaker 3
In some right?
Speaker 2
Of a funny story, Sam, about how this. Swing back in the day about 100 years ago, the Utah Peoples Party was the LDS party in. The state of. And the church decided that in order to get statehood, they needed to, like, either align with Republicans or Democrats. So David O McKay and his biography, the story, is that in church one Sunday, the Bishop said everybody sitting on this half is a Republican, and everybody sitting on this half is a Democrat, and David O McKay. She was just a child at the. And he says I was so disappointed because the only Republican in town was the town drunk. And I did not want to be affiliated with the Republican Party. So it is funny how things kind of change over time. The perceptions of parties and what they stand for. And I agree. I think that we should have an allegiance to something higher than a party and it there is not a party that I will agree with. Every single one of their positions and everybody in the party. And so if I'm going to just be a voter and choose based on positions, I have to be willing to say, hey, I can accept some things. I'm not a big fan of and then vote for the candidates I think are best.
Speaker 3
And other oaks cleared the way for engine right and and I think that that's a pretty good reason for us as a podcast to have a goal to have a general authority in a public setting.
Speaker 2
Yeah. Yeah. In general conference.
Speaker 3
Talk about the podcast because this truly models that type of conversation, conversations that many of us may have been uncomfortable to. Have in any other.
Speaker 1
Yeah, I say pre I agree, guys preach it. It loud, right? Loyalty to a man made profit driven political party is falling. It's a wrong thing. It'll never lead us, right? Right. But if we take the principles of Christ through scripture or the apostles, yeah, we're going to seek for. Principles and laws, and we're going to, yeah, if that sways us, then so be it. No loyalty to these pardons.
Speaker 2
And I would advocate to actually people should get involved in run for office themselves. If you don't like what a party, if you don't like what the Democrats stand for, go run for office and be a Democrat representative and then you get to decide what they stand for and all their voters have to sit around and say, well, I guess they hadn't. Well, I wish they hadn't taken that position, but Oh well, that's the person in charge.
Speaker 3
And as evidence of that, isn't it crazy that this presidential election looks like it's going to end up being? Right, two people that have negatives that are so high, like the entire country is screaming. Don't do it yet.
Speaker 2
That's what's going to.
Speaker 3
It's gonna happen again. Good people need to truly get involved.
Speaker
So let's move on.
Speaker 2
To a discussion of the news media. So there's a lot of news this week about what's happened, so CNN fired Don Lemon because of some sexist remarks he's made in public on air and stuff. He does how he treats women on his staff.
Speaker 3
Many of them many.
Speaker 2
A lot of people know about Tucker Carlson, that perhaps he was not the most. On this person in the world, I don't know if you guys are aware of this, but Tucker Carlson has the distinct honor of being fired from PBS, CNN, MSNBC and Fox News, so I can't think of a more fitting example.
Speaker 1
Hold on.
Speaker 2
Of a person. You're just.
Speaker 1
He gets but.
Speaker 3
What was he doing at PBS?
Speaker 1
But Matt, he gets but gets.
Speaker 3
Was he like some people?
Speaker 1
Street map. But some people praise him for that, right? Because if if part of our argument is that a lot of these media giants have agendas, some people praise him to be like, oh, he's not willing to jump on their agenda. Obviously he has evidence that he is willing to jump on some agendas. But being fired from those places, some people say good for him because he wasn't willing to jump.
Speaker 2
Right. But that's not true. Watch. Your shows on all of those. Networks, what he did is he was a chameleon and he adapted whatever the audience wanted the like. The extreme elements of that audience, he would just fan the flames of whatever those things are. And if you look at his Twitter post after he left Fox News, the same thing like who knows where he's going to go next. But he's certainly not gonna continue on the Fox News thing that he had at Fox News. He's gonna do some other thing. That he's already starting to fan the. Flames of whatever that. Is, yeah, but.
Speaker 1
One but one theory is that, like you said, he's a chameleon, right? On the one hand, he's he's just giving in to whatever the paycheck tells him to talk about and on and on the other hand, he's sometimes trying to go.
Speaker 3
He's an entertainer.
Speaker 1
Yeah, but I don't agree with that. Is he good at it? No, definitely not. And do I support him? No, but. But but I mean, look at look at all the other voices in the media, look at, we watched Jimmy Kimmel every night. I don't know why that guy is so in love with Donald Trump. He talks about nothing but Donald Trump.
Speaker 2
In love with making fun of Donald. Trump, right? He.
Speaker 1
Well, that's what I mean. He's obsessed with him. Yeah, but it helps Donald Trump because it makes him keeps him relevant. So it's such a backfire and Jimmy's end.
Speaker 2
It's negative about Trump. But it helped. It helps. Jimmy Kimmel because it keeps his ratings high because there's all the Trump haters in the world.
Speaker 1
And that's. And that's the point is, it's all about money, power, and ratings. It's all about pandering.
Speaker 2
Well, so then this is a question like I want to address this. Question first like. If all of the news, the popular news networks now, in fairness, we're talking about either cable news or Internet news. If they're all just pandering to an audience and just saying whatever they need to say to get that audience to click or to watch, then like, how can you find? Political news that doesn't have an agenda if they all seem to have an. Agenda like if. A person really wanted to find, really. Good political news. Where would they turn?
Speaker 3
I so so Matt, it's interesting. I'm not sure that's a new phenomenon. So one of my favorite movies as a kid growing up, did you ever watch Jimmy Stewart in Mr. Smith goes to Washington, right where he was.
Speaker 2
Yeah, I thought you were gonna say a man for all seasons.
Speaker 3
He was not in that one, but yes.
Speaker 2
Jimmy Stewart, Mr. Smith.
Speaker 3
Yeah, Mr. Smith goes to Washington and he fights against the the the political machine that is run by the press and controls his hometown. As a A skewed press is nothing new. What is new? And it really started as we were growing up. I remember the first days Rush Limbaugh. Came on the radio. And I listened to it with my dad and it was exciting to hear because he said a lot of the things that represented, like, value, ethical values that that we held.
Speaker 2
Conservative, yeah.
Speaker 3
And it was interesting. I I listened. Him consistently for a good 3-4 years and and it turned somewhere it turned into pure entertainment and and you're kind. Of like wait. And then Fox News came on right, and you had the flashy graphics and you had the beautiful people with super.
Speaker 2
Bill O'Reilly.
Speaker 3
White team. And at some point, yeah. And Bill O'Reilly. And Glenn Beck, right, and it and and at some point, you start to hear the people talk who watch that and you're like, wait.
Speaker 2
Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 3
That's not it. That's not accurate. And so that that pendulum swing back to normal, I think. I think nobody knows. First of all, why Tucker Carlson is fired, and that's fascinating. Everybody knew instantly why Bill O'Reilly got fired. Nobody truly knows why Tucker Carlson got fired.
Speaker 2
And Don Lemon, right, CNN people know why Don Lemon was fired.
Speaker 1
Why was that?
Speaker 2
Yep, Yep. But sexism? Yeah.
Speaker 1
Because of his sexism.
Speaker 3
Sex, yeah.
Speaker 2
Well, so and yeah.
Speaker 3
But does the pendulum swing back right?
Speaker 2
Well, and and it's true like the the press from the very beginning was a partisan press. Candidates would pay for news outlets and their whole purpose was to, like, attack other candidates. So it's true, there's nothing new about this but but but it is.
Speaker 3
It's American.
Speaker 2
It does make it hard to know who to trust because. There's if somebody. To use let's. Use Rush Limbaugh as an example. If somebody saying things that are consistent with my values, then it makes me trust them more because I say they're saying things that are consistent with my values and it makes. Me a little bit. Afraid to hear something from another side because they might not share my values and maybe they're trying to trick me. So even if I know a little bit in my heart that maybe Rush Limbaugh's trying to deceive me. Kind of like. Trust him and maybe want that deception just a little bit because the other thing.
Speaker 3
So, so.
Speaker 2
Is a little scary.
Speaker 3
So the challenge with today's media. And podcast perpetrate it. The guy from Comedy Central that took over Jon Stewart's role specifically talks about this. I forget his name.
Speaker 2
Trevor Noah.
Speaker 3
Trevor Noah talks about this. He he says there's a familiarity that's created with podcasts and late night television that causes a person to feel like they know that person. They know their heart, their soul, and they get to trust them. Like you're talking about. That that's never existed. It started with Rush Limbaugh. It went through Fox News and it exists today in. But when we think about that pendulum coming back, I think people are starting to see that they have to make their own decisions. They have to think for themselves as much as Glenn Beck talks about you've gotta research this. You gotta research that. If you listen to him for 10 minutes, he's trying to tell you in a very entertaining way exactly what you should think, right? People do need to. Come to their own conclusions and one of the best ways to do that, candidly, is to listen, in my opinion, to viewpoints that don't necessarily. Your your own and and be able be able to explain why you believe different than someone.
Speaker 2
But that's scary too, Sam.
Speaker 3
Else does.
Speaker 2
That, that that requires cognitive.
Speaker 3
Hold me. Why is that scary?
Speaker 2
It it it requires cognitive sophistication, right? If I'm listening to one person I can like, I can, like repeat what they're saying.
Speaker
It's sophisticated, yeah.
Speaker 2
But I don't really understand what they're saying and. So if I. Have a friend with a different perspective. Like like let's. Just take Jimmy Kimmel and Tucker Carlson, right. If I watch Jimmy Kimmel. All the time. I'll leave with the impression that every Republican on Earth is a. And like, they're just stupid. And that's all I can really articulate at the end of. This show I just, I don't know, they're just stupid. And same with Tucker Carlson. I would say every Democrat on Earth is just stupid and I can't articulate why. I just know. They're stupid, but.
Speaker 1
Yeah, he nailed it.
Speaker 3
But that's not the way you that's not the way you personally believe you're you're relaying how other people you believe other people act and react. It's up to the individual person to interact with that media and the way they interact with it, and it's our own individual liberty and responsibility. To digest that in a responsible way and then and then act on this in a responsible.
Speaker 1
But Matt, you're saying that the that that I'm saying you're saying, no, Matt, you're saying that dissonance that cognitive dissonance is hard for many people to grasp, but I think.
Speaker 3
Way you can't legend. That, by the way.
Speaker 1
But I think there's being the latter day lens. I think there's there are, like, spiritual principles that drive this right, Dean. So you 29 says. I mean, God, I gave them to men to be an agent unto himself. Right. The agency is a is a an eternal principle, a spiritual principle. But he also says he also. Says there it must needs be that there's an opposition in all things in order to have agency, we have to have that opposition. So I think you're right, Matt. I think there has to be. On any given topic, it's healthy for us to have this dissonance. I think it's a smart approach to for members of the church to listen to both sides, since we have these extremes. Listen to Fox News. Listen to MSNBC, listen to listen.
Speaker 2
It's that's that's scary. I'm just saying that's scary. Like when I was young and and psychiatry was like of the devil. Then I'd say I I think I might go to therapy and people would be like, why would you talk to a psychologist? They're liberal. They're like. Godless people and they're going to trick you into like, losing your faith in Christ and I think. That for of course not.
Speaker 3
Do you believe that today?
Speaker 2
But I think that there's like for a lot of people, there's this, like this conviction of like I. I know the church is true, but I really can't explain it to my friends and neighbors. And my political views align with that, and I really can't explain those to my friends and neighbors. And if I start deviating too far, then maybe I have to rethink all of these things. I really believe and really think and it all kind of like falls apart like there's this fear like people have to be able to build up to these sorts of things. And and it's hard to like and I don't know, Sean, that listening to both extremes is actually helpful for anybody.
Speaker 1
That's just great. Here's but, but here's the.
Speaker 2
Craziness really don't think.
Speaker 1
But you had said that you said you said that it's earlier that it maybe it's it's good for. Us as people to look at the both sides to be able to consider maybe not the extremes I didn't mean. Just go to the extremes. I mean, look at both sides, which sometimes includes the extremes, but here's you said.
Speaker 2
Yeah, I didn't say that.
Speaker 1
That didn't you?
Speaker 2
I said I think that I think that the extremes make you hate both sides the other side.
Speaker 1
No, not the extremes you said. Make sure and we you said 5 minutes ago we as people.
Speaker 2
Good. Yeah. Sample.
Speaker 3
I think I said that I I I said I I think it's not a bad idea to hear both viewpoints and then.
Speaker
You did.
Speaker 1
Do you disagree with?
Speaker 3
Make a decision on your own.
Speaker 2
That, Matt, I think people need to go to the boring stuff. That's just so lame and makes you want to fall asleep, cause that's the only true stuff.
Speaker 1
Without you're saying without bias, you're saying find a. Find an NPR who isn't perfect, but you're saying find someone. So is really making an effort to not be biased in their approach is.
Speaker 2
Yeah, like PBS news hour.
Speaker 1
What you're saying?
Speaker 2
I can't watch that whole hour, but five.
Speaker 3
BBC News.
Speaker 2
Yeah, BBC. But you watch an hour of PBS news Hour, you're gonna know both sides of everything, and you're gonna, and you're gonna. Be asleep, by the way, after 30 minutes.
Speaker
I mean it's.
Speaker 1
Not it's not perfect, but you're saying that's the approach. But let let me give you scriptures that back up maybe Sam's approach a little bit, right. Secondly, fight two says 16 the Lord gave unto man that he should act for himself. Wherefore man could not act for himself, save it should be that he was enticed by the one or the other.
Speaker 3
And and I'm not sure we have a choice in today's world. There are so many voices. I think about all the things that the church recently has done to kind of put that choice back in the individual and the family between the the curriculum and the missionary age and and the the for the strength of youth. Like and and Oaks's comment is just the capstone. Yeah, right. Like, as members of the church, you're gonna hear varying opinions. And you're going to have to act, and the church is going to have to respect that and and and be OK with that. And you're going to have to learn how to do that in a way and have a conversation like we are in a way that doesn't tear you apart. We love each other, cause we've served together in in Ukraine. We know each other's heart and you can't. There's nothing either one of you could say that would separate us from each other. And and and every member of the church really needs to be that, you know, bound together with the, with the testimony of Christ.
Speaker 2
Well, so let's go to the big question. So the First Amendment protects the freedom of the press, and in part this is because in order for a democracy to function well, people need to have accurate information about what's going on in the government. If the government is just dishing out. Propaganda all the time and people don't really know what's happening. Then you can easily have the the public be LED astray and you lose your democracy before you even know what happened. So the Supreme Court has fought vigorously to protect the freedom of the press. News organizations have rights that other organizations don't have. It's harder to sue them for libel. They can print classified information. They don't have to reveal their sources in court. There's all kinds of things at the same time. Just because you're a news organization with constitutional protections doesn't guarantee that you're going to be viable newspapers. Out of business all the time, people. If they don't like your news aren't going. To buy your product and then it doesn't matter what constitutional rights you. So that's the crisis. We're kind of dilemma, right, because on the one hand, the news organizations want to be accurate and hold the government accountable. But on the other hand, they need clicks and viewers and advertisers, and they need to make money, and people tend to be more motivated by kind of antagonism. And conflict and controversy sensationalized kinds of things. So, and people also want to hear news that reinforces their own particular point of view. So the question I have this is kind of the big question is like how do you deal with this paradox? Like there's this one part of me that says. If an organization is just a propaganda outlet, they don't get to have the word news behind their name. We just say you're not a news organization and just to be like fair, like at the news stand. I you know. There are legitimate fake news about like the Bat boy or whatever. Like you can see him in the grocery aisle if you ever go shopping anymore, you can see, like, legitimately. Fake news and that stuff stuff maybe shouldn't be allowed to be called news. Like that's one approach. But maybe.
Speaker 3
Inquire news.
Speaker 2
Which one? Yeah, except for the but it.
Speaker 3
Inquiry meetings. It's been around a long time, right?
Speaker 2
It did break some. Stories, right, like the Inquirer did actually have a true story one time about a presidential candidate. I think it was John Edwards. Was that anyhow? And so you say, well, maybe we should just not let them be news anymore, but maybe there's something like. We could do about. It, like, maybe they're citizens, like as as consumers of media, maybe we have obligations as consumers of. And we should say we're not going to go to propaganda organizations to get our information. We're going to only go to legitimate government sources. We're only going to read, like, official.
Speaker 1
Government we should mint.
Speaker 3
Actually, what what we should do is the government should buy TikTok. And they could change. The algorithm so that it just fed people real news instead of feeding them the stuff. That is a really good idea.
Speaker 2
Government solution to this problem.
Speaker 3
Oh. Oh, wait, that's. In China, never mind. OK, go ahead. I forgot. Forgot China's already doing that. Dog on it, they beat us.
Speaker 2
Sam, you tricked me with your sarcasm, voice.
Speaker 3
To it. OK, never mind. Next stop.
Speaker
I just thought I thought.
Speaker 2
You were really on to something there for a second. What do you think, Sean there was?
Speaker 3
A plan in. The pre existence and everybody had a choice. We need to respect that choice.
Speaker
I don't I.
Speaker 1
Don't think the answer is get government involved to police, police, media because you're you're.
Speaker 3
Thank you, Sean. I have a list. I have a list of all the regulation that that's got in place and it's pages.
Speaker 1
Government because government interference in.
Speaker 3
I'm going to. I'm going to. Mark this one off.
Speaker 1
And in the Second Amendment is the First Amendment.
Speaker 2
1st amendment can't wait. Wait, wait. Sean, can I sue somebody and say all I want from you is you don't get to say news anymore like Dominion when they when they I don't want 700 million from Fox.
Speaker 1
Sorry, the 1st amendment.
Speaker 2
I want you to take news. Off your.
Speaker 3
Name so so.
Speaker 1
No, that's free.
Speaker 3
So can I make one? Comment about that, though, so I think it's fascinating that Fox News decided to settle with Dominion. Because I took in college a bunch of classes about libel and slander that those are some basic required classes in in media back then, and the development of of libel and slander laws as it relates to the media and press over the past many decades is fascinating from protecting ***********. And other elements of free speech and are anything. What? What would what? Would have been terrifying is if Fox News had lost that and had gone all the way to the Supreme Court and it restrained a news organization from being able to share news and another.
Speaker 2
Do you? Do you know? What else? Is for.
Speaker 3
That's off the table.
Speaker 2
Do you know what else is fascinating? Sam, as if they had actually won that lawsuit. Because then if they win that lawsuit, then a news organization can publish things that they know to be false and not be sued for libel, right?
Speaker 3
Either way, either.
Speaker 2
That's why I'm glad it was settled.
Speaker 3
Way, right?
Speaker 2
Right, because. It's frightening.
Speaker 3
Because because right now it it has to be an intentional act, you have to intentionally know that.
Speaker 2
Right.
Speaker 3
It's a fault. Fact, which is a ludicrous statement, right? And that's not a bad standard right now.
Speaker 2
Alright, go ahead Sean.
Speaker 1
So I don't think the government getting in and. And I think. It would be a negative effect if they start to really try and force words, and you can't use news. You can't use news that seems pretty dangerous for a government to start telling me, like all my business.
Speaker 2
But we do that we we do. That with religions, right, we define what is and is not a religion, only certain.
Speaker 1
All themselves are religion. Only when it comes to tax benefits, right is it.
Speaker 3
Ohh, we don't OK we don't. Well, it can't. It can't be a religion.
Speaker
Well, we, we. We live OG alright.
Speaker 2
Are you serious, Sam?
Speaker 1
You're just saying, saying saying he's saying he's.
Speaker
Do you want to go down?
Speaker 3
That road for tax, for tax.
Speaker 1
Saying they're they're purposes.
Speaker 2
Right. For tax purposes, we have, we've outlined what is and is not a religion for these tax exempt purposes.
Speaker 1
Yeah, but anyone can call, but there's freedom to call my my company or religion. That's got a friend who's doing that.
Speaker 2
Right, but if? But you have. To behave in a way your friends. Fascinate me, Sean. You have to behave in a way that is in line with what they define as a religion. Right. So I'm just saying you could do the same thing.
Speaker 1
Ticket tax cuts.
Speaker 2
With news organizations, right? So. Just like what they do with taxes and religion, they could do with news and say if you're doing these sorts of things, you're not news.
Speaker 3
But then the government would have a chilling effect on the way news is disseminated when free market at the end of the day is the best gauge for whether or not news is good and news is useful.
Speaker
They would.
Speaker 3
I would rather have a Fox News or an MSNBC out there have the market restrain it if it decides to then try to control it by government. That's not a good look.
Speaker 1
So what about Matt? What about third party Rotten Tomatoes? How about Rotten Tomatoes, right? And Rotten Tomatoes becoming an aggregate for this movie is terrible. Or this movie is good. It's a good. I like that. I like going and saying, OK, here's what majority of people, not that majority rule is is always a. Good thing, maybe sometimes it's really, really a good thing, but Rotten Tomatoes gives us an aggregate of what people's opinions are on certain things. Why don't we have the? Rotten Tomatoes for outlets.
Speaker 2
Oh, we have that all we have. That sure, there's a whole.
Speaker 1
Media outlets. What is that?
Speaker 3
Lot of and ChatGPT is going to create.
Speaker 2
What is it that there's a lot of organizations out there that are telling you, like, good news, bad news, biased news, accurate news?
Speaker 3
More of.
Speaker 2
Well, what about? We need some we.
Speaker 1
Need someone to make that mainstreamed and popular. And that's you said there's a lot.
Speaker 2
The point though? That's the whole point is that people don't care enough to do that. Well, let me ask you this, though. So if you go back to our time in Ukraine, which was right at the end of the Soviet Union, so they're making this transition from a very controlled information environment to what Sam would call capitalism. They they would regularly complain to. Me about all of the bad stuff in. Society, *********** negativity that they didn't have in the Soviet Union. They're like we I never saw a drunk person on the street. I never saw this and in addition to that they say and look at all the ****. Being published like. Naked ladies and papers and all that sort of stuff. They never had that and democracy brought that to them. And I sort of feel like.
Speaker 3
I'm so glad this is coming up. So glad.
Speaker 2
I feel like Sam, Sam is saying.
Speaker 3
This is coming up.
Speaker 2
Like this is a. Something we should tolerate as a society because it's better for us.
Speaker 3
We have to tolerate it, Matt. And and my son and I had a conversation, the one that served in Taiwan. We talk often about the liberties in China, which is a communist country versus us. They're very controlled. In China, we have our freedoms, our society and culture reflects the values of the people who live in it, in one form, fashion or. Or another. And there's this thought that as long as there are is goodness and morality in this culture, it will represent and reflect that Russia, as it went over the precipice of communism to total free market, there was a vacuum and mafia and crime and every all the worst. Prices came into full. You and and that's what caused you, you know, the whole pendulum thing right, like and it swing all the way. The One Direction to the point where it was so bad that people were asking for communism back, right, and Russia, they got a.
Speaker 2
Right, that's Putin's.
Speaker 3
Version of that. Paul Mantra put put Putin now has the blue check next to whether or not the news agency or not right so. They could only they could only listen. To certain news news in. Russia right now, I would rather have all the terrible things that come along with it, and if and if we're a nation of good people with, with a moral base. You've got to believe that that's going to. Reflect in what we hold and value.
Speaker 2
So then.
Speaker 3
As a. And and Matt, you've been the one that has said it way back when you we asked the question, what will we look back on 20 years from now and say hey, we got it wrong in that day and I think you said there are some causes that have swung so far that we'll say, hey, that was that was too much even though it seemed. We see politically correct that was. Pretty much and and that's kind of.
Speaker 2
Well, so.
Speaker 3
We're seeing, right?
Speaker 2
So then I think that this is naturally leading to the next question if if it's not going to be government controlled and not going to be government regulated and it's going to be market controlled, then that means citizens and as consumers have some obligations that go along with those freedoms. So then what are the citizen slash consumer obligations? Of of, of a society with a truly Free Press, where we're going to allow anything out there, but we're going to allow the market to decide. Do I have some kind of a moral obligation to consume certain things and not consume other things?
Speaker 1
Well, I I think I think that an important part of that is a limited but. A legal system that protects against libel and right so it it kind of worked with the Fox News thing, right? So that doesn't didn't work.
Speaker 2
I don't know. I don't know. I I'm I mean I'm. I'm not thrilled with that system. I think it's ridiculous that politicians and news organizations can slander individuals and they don't have legal protections against them. I would love to see that changed. And I I just. Think of the EI. Think of the E Jean Carroll lawsuit against Trump right now, where she's suing Trump for things he said about her while president of the United States.
Speaker 3
How would you do it?
Speaker 2
And the laws say, well, no, he's president of the United States, he cannot slander another. Individual he was. Just doing acting in his official capacity as President, and if he's acting in his official capacity as President, then. You cannot sue him like I think that stuff is crazy and and and truth in that right like truth in advertising for businesses.
Speaker 1
Oh yeah, that seems crazy. That's not good and.
Speaker 2
You can't just lie about your competitors, but candidates can lie about their. So I I'm not sure that I love the unequal application of these laws in these in this particular realm.
Speaker 1
But the laws are good, it seems, so it seems like if we can get better at at protecting against libel and slander, then that's a good element of the free market they have.
Speaker 3
Well, well, and and.
Speaker 1
That's a good function. That's one good function of government.
Speaker 3
Your, your, your. Trump example is just spot on. Like I hear some of the things he said. You know the, the, the, the, the motions he made making fun of a a kid that was handicapped, you know, comments he's made in the press room. That's someone who no matter what you think about his policy is not a moral person that occupied that office. And and and and I think there are some members of the church that see that and and that's a great example. And and someone in that spot long enough probably breaks the system because because you, you do have to protect. I mean, how on Earth does the President of United States in a presidential debate make some of the comments? He may. Need to to to. Laughter and applause. It makes me think of Russell Crowe and Gladiator where you know where he says. Are you not entertained? Right and and? And he says, hey, being in the arena, it is in power, right? And and Trump understands that, and he knows that. And we have, you know, we've we counted to to that that's.
Speaker 2
So do I have a moral obligation to read accurate news that's really boring to prevent some of this craziness?
Speaker 3
That's bigger.
Speaker 1
No, I don't think so.
Speaker
No, just like.
Speaker 1
No, don't think so. No, because.
Speaker 3
I don't know. How you do you know what, Matt, you know? What would be cool is create a class in in school in high school called digesting Social Media News or News. Like what if everybody went through? I could get behind that what teach everybody to think.
Speaker
What about?
Speaker 1
Well, like just.
Speaker 3
Quickly in high school.
Speaker 2
Just as citizens, right listeners to our podcast, that might have say, what can I do as a citizen? Do we have like is there some kind of like? OK, so I would say. I have a moral obligation to not consume *********** because by not consuming ***********, that's one in a billion that are watching it. Now, that's not gonna watch it. And then that hurts that business model in the future and and and entertainment that's like overtly opposed to my values for example. The Book of Mormon, the musical I chose to never see that because I said they're just making fun of my faith. Now other people can see it, and that's fine. I don't have a problem. I make moral decisions about the things I'm going to consume based on the society I want to live in and and are there moral principles that can guide our decisions and how we consume news that might like result in a better society?
Speaker 1
You just it's just it's hard because your. I yeah, it is, I.
Speaker 2
It's a great conversation.
Speaker 1
I don't know, Matt. I I I I err on the side I think of let the opposition exist and let's teach let's I mean if we consume scriptures more we would learn how to differentiate how to discern between right and wrong and good and evil. Let the spirit be our guide. I think I know it's cliche, but we need to be better Christians and be very familiar with Scripture and with this the Holy Ghost because then we can discern. But I think you need to let the opposition exist. That's the nature of mortality, isn't it?
Speaker 3
Watch this, Sean. Watch this, Sean. You're the one that's always dropping. And I'm about to drop it. I mean, that is right. That's that's the whole purpose of our experience, is to learn good from evil and choose good and sustain and prop up good. Not by force, but by choice and as appealing as it is to think about, you know, a communist. That world where you can't get ***********, you can't get some of these other things. I mean, Matt, you make the comment about ***********. Most people in the United States, they don't agree with that comment. Most people in the United States think it's OK and probably helpful, right?
Speaker 2
Yes, I know. I'm I'm well.
Speaker 3
Aware it's a, it's a. It's a. It's a challenge, right?
Speaker 2
But but I.
Speaker 3
And that that's a social, societal problem.
Speaker 2
But I can make the choice to not consume it even when I really, really want to, because I would. Rather not see it as a sign. And I can make the choice to never see another Nicholas. Cage move. I'm just kidding.
Speaker 3
But you can't, but you can't. But you can't legislate. Others not seem.
Speaker 2
No, I agree. I think I agree that we shouldn't legislate this, but I think that we as citizens, that we frequently like to talk about freedom and we rarely talk about responsibility. And I think it's sometimes OK to focus on what responsibilities. We have as citizens. If we want. To have freedom and we want to have, let's say we want to have a moral in a good society, we do have some responsibilities with how we exercise our freedoms that influence other peoples and don't just have an effect on ourselves.
Speaker 3
So then what do you do, Matt? How do you how do you ingrain or inject? And heavens sakes, do not say Glenn Beck teaches a class to high school students. Like someone should teach it, it would be a critical thinking class somehow. Where it's. Hey, here's the different ways you get news and information. How do you digest it? Right. I don't know if that's a class.
Speaker 1
I'm sorry to sound like a broken record, but the God put the scriptures on.
Speaker
Is it?
Speaker 3
Just let it be.
Speaker 1
No, no. Put the scriptures on the earth and there's such dissonance in the scriptures and you did that on purpose. I think it is hard to understand all the things in the scriptures cause they.
Speaker
Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1
Beat up against each other and it requires deep personal study and contemplation, and that that strengthens our cognitive abilities to see both sides of things and then discern so I I think it's feast upon the words of Christ.
Speaker 3
It's great point.
Speaker 1
That's the answer.
Speaker 2
But I do also, I think I'll just say this, you get what you pay for and there are a lot of people out there that just want to consume free media and free news and get whatever shows up on TikTok. And you have to assume that that's going to be garbage and and I pay money to subscribe to the Washington Post, the Wall Street Journal, New York Times, because.
Speaker
Yeah, lazy.
Speaker 2
Maybe I don't love what's in their opinions. Sections, but if you, you gotta you gotta let reporters get paid for their jobs or they're not gonna be able to keep reporting on the news and that, like it is OK.
Speaker 3
Hey Matt, can can I borrow?
Speaker
Your volume for those.
Speaker 2
It's so funny how we, like, just share Netflix passwords and all that stuff, right? For some reason, we don't share all of those. News and like like like. There are legitimate newspaper newspaper organizations out there. And they're dying, right? They're dying breed because everybody wants free news. And so I do think we have an obligation to say, look, if I'm going to spend $60.00 a month on. Subscriptions of some kind? Can I make one of them a newspaper? Can I make one of them like something invested in giving me accurate information and I could just maybe wait on Netflix for? I don't know, maybe not. Subscribe to that one.
Speaker 3
So So what if the three of us came up with a free market solution to that? I think people could get behind that. So to Shawn's point, and then to yours. Like what? What free market tool could there be that would allow people to have a choice and get access to some of these other news sources? Cause. Because to your point, the free stuff is garbage right now, right? The stuff of value is behind a paywall because it costs money to create the stuff that's free is somebody that's just churning out stuff that you know isn't fit to read. That that's a fascinating deal. Like so. So that being the case, how do you? Remedy that, right? Because us refusing to read something or or buying one more subscription isn't going to change the world. But if we had a free market solution.
Speaker 2
If you create an iTunes or a Spotify of News right where where you where the like, the news organizations are going to get paid for the stories that people read, but they can create like this like cultivated list. It's like these are the kinds of things I want to know about, and you're going to get in your Spotify feed or your whatever feed the accurate.
Speaker 1
I kind of disagree with you guys. There's I think that. It's you're never going to avoid the the opposite. You're always going to have the extremes and the different sides in the opposition because money drives it all right. The the moment, the moment you have two iTunes, you know for media competing against each other is the moment you start getting money.
Speaker 3
You want that you want that, yeah.
Speaker 1
Being the driving force behind the content, and it eventually just becomes a pandering source. So I think you have to accept we have. To accept the. Fact that there is opposition, there are forces of good and evil, right and wrong, black and white, and many Grays in the area. In in between.
Speaker 3
I sort of. I sort of see Sean know what Matt is saying, which is those last good sources are going away because there is no funding and and if there's no funding, they're just going to disappear into the night. You know, you look at some of the great media sources here in Utah, like there used to be rich diversity and there used to be depth. Now they're all owned by the same company and and they're a a shallow shell of their former self and and and.
Speaker 2
Right.
Speaker 3
And that is, if you go to Meet the Press and listen to some of their podcast. Recently that that's a national problem and and that is.
Speaker 1
So so so I. So I started to abandon the big media and started to go online and go OK, let me listen to some of these guys.
Speaker 3
A real problem.
Speaker 1
So, for example, Ben Shapiro, he started going online and I loved it because all he's gonna give me. The and then eventually I realized oh. Wait, he's just pandering. Yeah, he's just pandering. OK, that's not a good source. Let me look for another online version. And right now I'm into Russell Brand and I. Know he's a very he's very much so a conspiracy theorist, right?
Speaker 2
But he's not a reporter, Sean.
Speaker
His whole.
Speaker 2
He's not. A he's not giving. You accurate news about what's going on.
Speaker 1
I don't need he. He doesn't need a credential.
Speaker 3
But he looks good and he's got an English accent.
Speaker 1
He doesn't need a credential. No, he doesn't need a credential to be able to have a brain to analyze.
Speaker 2
But I know, but I once.
Speaker 3
We almost ended on a strong note. Went I.
Speaker 2
Want someone in?
Speaker
The white.
Speaker 2
House when when Biden does a press conference or I want someone in the White House that's going to challenge those questions to give me accurate information about what's happening there. You know what I'm saying? Like somebody who's there in the. Room like look. All of us could watch C-SPAN.
Speaker
I sure miss you.
Speaker 2
Like if ad nauseam, it's on all all the time and it's totally free, but nobody does it cause it's super boring. So I need. To pay somebody to sit through all that super boring stuff and tell me the little things that matter, that's the kind of that's what I.
Speaker 1
Mean by news? Well, I don't understand the rules. What keeps Russell Brand out of The Newsroom in?
Speaker 2
The White House. But he's not there. He's making a podcast, making you laugh. He could go there if he wanted to, but he's not doing that because he's an entertainer, Sean. He's a he's.
Speaker 3
And he was married to Katy Perry.
Speaker 2
Well, now I like it. OK, now I got. To follow him.
Speaker 1
Yeah, but eventually he'll get there. He has 6.5 million followers on his YouTube channel. Eventually doesn't. If he believes in what he's doing, and so far it seems like he's he's very much so believing in his his messages, he could he could get there to the White House. Why not?
Speaker 3
Oh, come on shot. I don't want to have to do. This to you. But I'm I gotta go. That's the one problem with with like our digesting of news today is entertainers now become. Purveyors and like it's kind of.
Speaker 1
Yeah. Have you?
Speaker 3
We need reporters that the people that are held up as deliverers of news.
Speaker
They they become.
Speaker 2
That's a good point.
Speaker 3
What happened to the reporters that were critical thinkers? That that like you know?
Speaker
So name, name.
Speaker 1
Name two of them.
Speaker 2
Tamara Keith. Nina Totenberg.
Speaker 1
All right, I'll go. I will start looking at Tamara Keith.
Speaker 2
Tamara Keith is the president of the White House Correspondents Association. She covers the White House as well as anyone has. Nina Totenberg covers the Supreme Court. She she can tell you more about what's going on in the court Supreme Court. Than anyone in the nation.
Speaker 1
Just I I just want one. I'll just focus on Tamara Keith and by the by our next podcast, I will have followed Tamara Keith. That's awesome. You you, you.
Speaker 3
Won't find them with an outsized YouTube or Facebook or LinkedIn presence.
Speaker 1
That's OK, I don't need.
Speaker 3
They're right.
Speaker 2
She's a sweet. She's a very kind. But that's the point, right? And a great reporter.
Speaker 1
So there you go. Part part of this mat part of our podcast should be let's promote voices that are actually doing the job, right.
Speaker 3
And a liberal.
Speaker 2
Yeah, that's what I think we should do.
Speaker
Right.
Speaker 1
So I'll go. So I will go on and I promote to our listeners to do what I'm about to do, which is take a whole week. Studying Tamara Keith. I want to hear what she has to say.
Speaker 2
I love it this this is good.
Speaker 1
I wanna see if she really is.
Speaker
Wow, this is fun.
Speaker 2
Yeah, I like it.
Speaker 3
Are you gonna? Are you gonna are? So you're turning off Russell Brand and you're going out of.
Speaker 1
Oh sure, I'll take ohh sure.
Speaker 3
The way alright, good.
Speaker 1
I'll take a break from Russell Brand, I'll.
Speaker 3
Love it.
Speaker 1
Listen to Tamara Keith. That's awesome.
Speaker 2
OK, I like it. Hey, guys. Great conversation. Today it was. It was kind of like. All over the place, sort of. But I liked the topics I liked. I liked Sam. What you did to Sean here and there. We say I hate to do this to you, Sean, but then you like kind. Of beat him a little bit, spank him around.
Speaker 1
And then gave me a hug.
Speaker 2
That's right.
Speaker 1
Push me in the face and. Then give me a hug.
Speaker 2
And if we haven't, if we haven't said it enough in our previous episodes, This is why we're doing this podcast.
Speaker 3
That's the latter day lens.
Speaker 2
We want to model for everybody what to do. Have these conversations with people that you love, people that you know and feel free to join in on the conversations with us. We'd love to hear from you guys in the future. Have a great day. That is all the time we have this week, but that doesn't mean the discussion is over. In fact, we include links to the stories we discussed each week in the podcast description to encourage our listeners participation. Each of you have an important perspective that builds the latter day lens and we want to hear from you. Let's continue the discussion on social media. You can find us on Instagram at latter Day lens on Twitter at Latter Day, lens on Facebook at Latter Day lens. Or you can e-mail us at the latter day lens@gmail.com all one word. Finally, please make sure you subscribe to get updated content each week. Thanks for making us one of the most listened to podcasts. We love our listeners.
00:00:02 Speaker 1
Here's the mistake I think most most of US members just make.
Audio file
Transcript
Shawn
Here's the mistake I think most most of US members just make. We think that's talking about money and success. But if you really study those scripts, there's there's not a lot of. It's mostly about freedom of *******, freedom from *******.
Matt
Welcome to Latter Day lens. Unscripted faith, promoting discussion of current political events with Sean, Sam and Matt. Hey, welcome everybody to another exciting episode of the Latter Day lens with. New slate of current events to discuss. There's all kinds of really exciting stuff in the news, but we're going to begin with the. Least exciting thing. In the news, which would be the Federal Reserve and the banks? We discussed this a couple of weeks ago, so it turns out that the Federal Reserve they looked into the failure of Silicon Valley Bank ask themselves the question, why did it fail? And I think that they were very introspective. And the government blamed themselves and they said it's our fault that that bank failed and management there was some poor management on the part of SB. But if if the Federal Reserve had done a better job of regulating, then they say that the bank never would have failed and so their solution is more. So you know that I love government regulation. So my question for you is do you think that more government regulation will prevent failures like this bank in the future? It's just, it's just. A government failure of regulation and if they had just done their jobs, they could have stopped this unforeseen tragedy.
Sam
So Matt, you included a quote that says in the case of SVB, supervisors delayed action to gather more evidence as weaknesses were clear and growing. And that was the root cause according to what you wrote. If that's true, it's not the lack of regulation, it's just the lack of actionable oversight on existing regulation that caused. Cause the. And it's interesting in cycles of good economies and then challenging times and good economies and challenging times, whenever things are good, people want to continue to see good. And I think a weakness in human nature is a tendency to look the other way and overlook rules when things are so good, because you assume things. Will always. Be good. What should happen is whatever oversight was there should have been executed on like it should have been, and there wouldn't be a problem. I say less, you know, we don't. Need additional oversight. Wait, wait.
Speaker
What about? Wait, wait, wait.
Matt
Wait, I'm gonna jump in here, Sean. Real fast. OK, because I have a totally different take than that. Sam, I feel. Like Republicans don't.
Sam
You provided the quote OK.
Matt
No, no, no. That's right. And that's the quote from the Federal Reserve. What my take on this is that Republicans don't like government regulation. And so when government, when Republicans are in charge and Republicans are nominating people. To to be in charge of things like the Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell, for instance, was chosen by Donald Trump, a Republican. They choose people that are bad at regulating because Republicans are like Boo Boo regulations. We don't want oversight. So let's choose people who are bad at those jobs. And then those people do a bad job of what they're doing, and then the Republicans say, see government's no good. Because government can't do its job and. I say, well, if you picked good people for. Those jobs then we wouldn't have that.
Sam
Yeah, but that's a pretty general statement about the type of people that Republicans bring into those oversight roles. If you go and you look at other people like, who's in charge of the CFPB, I'm not a huge fan of her.
Matt
Nancy Pelosi, I think it's Nancy Pelosi.
Sam
Well, no, no, no, not Nancy Pelosi before her. She ran for a very early on in the the Democrat presidential way back when. Elizabeth Warren, right? So the Democrats have a tendency to bring people that have 0 background in business to try to do oversight in business in ways that are actually pretty detrimental and demonstrate a complete lack of understanding of business. The current head of the CFPB is a wonderful example of that right?
Speaker
I didn't.
Sam
Never spent a day in the business but but.
Matt
Is that Rohit Chopra?
Speaker
I did not think I.
Matt
OK.
Sam
Yes. And and.
Shawn
Did not think that this discussion would start off so early with one of you being anti Republican, the other being anti Democrat and being the two parties fighting against each other. I didn't know that this would be.
Matt
But I really think that's. The root of.
Sam
This, but what? No but see. Here's the thing. Though the quote right here simply states supervisors delayed taking action, they knew they needed to take action. They had actionable information. They should have taken action and arguably had they taken, they would have preserved confidence and there wouldn't be a there.
Speaker
Can I have?
Sam
Would have been a problem.
Shawn
So, Sam, you said something earlier that when times are good, we are prosperous. We tend to be a little more.
Speaker
It's the cycle.
Shawn
And you said you said we tend to be a little more the Book of Mormon reference, we tend to be a little more LAX and the people tend to. Act a little, we see. And and then we act less responsibly.
Sam
We want to see, yeah.
Shawn
And then there's problems. Well, isn't one of the accusations of the last. What is it, Matt? 5-10 years with all the bailouts? Isn't that also the heavy regulation and the government bailing bailing these banks out? Isn't that also a reason, maybe a lot of these banks are? Acting lax?
Matt
Because they know that there's no.
Shawn
They're not. They're not gonna fail.
Matt
Yeah, there's no consequence.
Shawn
No consequences. So more regulation makes people go well, it'll be fine. Let's take the risks. Let's behave badly.
Sam
OK, so let's add, you know, let let's take that one, two steps beyond. Let's add more. Regulation we ignore.
Matt
I'm saying right to not ignore.
Sam
The and then and then let's. Let's actually who's the person that that you wanted in charge of the? CFPB. I can't pronounce it. And I.
Matt
Right.
Sam
Apologize, I want to slaughter it, but.
Matt
Chopra, is that who it is.
Sam
So Rahid Chopra, let's put her in charge, even though she doesn't understand what she's supervising. And there's no there's no elected oversight for that organization. Some of the structure you have to admit, the way it's set up is lunacy. If we just obeyed the laws and we just did what we're required to do currently, this wouldn't have happened. Somebody fell asleep at the wheel, chose not to take action when they should have taken. And they should pay for that. There should be a consequence, Matt.
Shawn
Hey this is a very remote. You're a political scientist. Do you know who in 1963, Wright Pattman is the chairman of the House Banking and Currency Committee we have.
Matt
Now you're making it sound like because I know political science. Yeah, I should like Wikipedia is.
Speaker
Yeah, it's good to.
Matt
Part of my.
Sam
Members out of mouth.
Matt
See 1963. Let's see. No.
Shawn
No, no, no. Do you have his base like a baseball card you have like? A picture you. In your room nerding out with old politicians and and things. No, OK.
Matt
In 1963, I would have a Martin Luther King junior base. Of course.
Shawn
OK. OK, good.
Matt
But OK, go on Sean.
Shawn
So he he had a quote back in the day when things were failing and this was a big, scary thing. And he said, I think we should have more bank failures. The record the last several years of almost no bank failures. And finally, last year, with no bank failures at all is, to me, a danger signal that we have gone too far in the direction of bank. Safety now weird statement, but I think there's some wisdom in there's probably should be a good amount of bank failures. In fact, I believe don't quote me, but I think there's three to four bank failures per year in this. Country and they don't get bailed out.
Matt
Yeah, I'm not opposed. I'm not opposed to bank failures. I'm opposed to bank failures to the tune where the government has to bail out the banks, right?
Shawn
That's what your question was. Your question is do does government regulation prevent failures?
Matt
Failures like Silicon Valley bank. So the problem with Silicon Valley Bank is. They're being extraordinarily risky and they're not protecting. They don't have enough deposits on hand to protect, like they don't have enough cash on hand to protect their depositors. So, so then the federal government feels like they need to give money to people who are. Risky with their assets.
Sam
And and there were rules in place that had those rules been followed, and whoever the supervisors are, had they done what they were supposed to do, it never would. Have gotten as far as it did, but it did.
Shawn
So, Sam, you're saying you're saying let those people fail and let the bank fail and let the consequences follow?
Sam
Thing I absolutely would have let the big fail. And by the way, I want to take back what I said about Rohit Chopra from CFPB. He's a Harvard grad. And then he went to work for McKinsey. But I don't know that he's run business or had the business acumen. I have no way of knowing to be able to put the type of regulation in place that would be. Thoughtful and effective, right?
Shawn
So, so Matt and Sam, I feel like bringing in a little bit of scripture here because I think there is a principle here that's interesting. It takes it takes us on a tangent a little bit, but it's you.
Sam
Bring it.
Shawn
Tell me, Matt, if it takes us off.
Matt
Go ahead, Sean.
Shawn
'S idea of. This balance of banks failing and and protecting banks, I often hear members of our church refer to look if we're faithful or righteous, there's prosperity in the land. I agree that that this concept of keeping the commandments brings prosperity in the land, is abundant in the scriptures. There's lots of references to prosperity.
Matt
Well, mostly in the Book of Mormon.
Shawn
Yeah, there's four or five in the in the New Testament, but you're right mostly in. The Book of Mormon, but I.
Matt
Not doctrine and covenants really, right?
Shawn
There's a few in the B. And C yeah. There are, but here's the mistake I think most most of US members just make.
Matt
Oh, OK, all right.
Shawn
We think that's talking about money and success. But if you really study those scriptures, there's not a lot of. It's mostly about freedom of *******, freedom from *******, so prospering in the land without having *******. And it's talking about receiving God's glory. Basically, it's talking about spiritual prosperity. It's talking about the prosperity of the soul and of the spirit. It rarely. Now I would love for listeners to go and study these these principles. That I've studied a lot in the scriptures about this concept of prosperity. It's not necessarily talking about money and prosperity in that sense. So back to the topic. I don't know, man. I think there should be a good balance. I mean, if no banks are failing ever, and I know you're not arguing that. That suggests corruption to me, like clearly there are lots of businesses doing wrong things, and the natural consequence of those things should be failure, right? SVB Bank was doing risky, risky, risky things with no consequence. It seems like letting that fail. Seems like a a good thing, man, and I know the argument is. Yeah, but look at the people who suffer.
Matt
That's right.
Shawn
They'll be fine. They'll be fine.
Matt
Yeah, well, the problem is when the government puts FDIC on the bank, then it it's it's sending a message to the public that the government is going to help them out because they say this is Federal Deposit Insurance company, right. That corporation, that's.
Sam
That's different.
Matt
Well, so that's.
Sam
That's that's preserving depositors stakes in the bank that's not propping up the bank and allowing the bank to continue.
Matt
But what but but the?
Sam
So those are two separate things.
Matt
Big problem with SVB is that they are giving money to these depositors that have had assets in excess of what the FDIC would normally cover. And so I I do have a problem with that, right? It's like if you put $2,000,000 in the bank and it's not, it's just, I just think that the public isn't adequately aware of what's going on.
Shawn
Yes. Yep, that's it.
Matt
It's a complicated industry and so I think the government, if you're going to. Have something like the FDIC.
Sam
Very complicated.
Matt
Like giving confidence to a bank, then that the government has some obligation to the public to let them know. Some way of letting them know.
Shawn
I like that Matt. Matt, make make stronger laws that that put make banks more transparent with how much money and what kind of money and where it's going. Yeah, I want to know that I've invested this or I've put this money in. The bank and that they're living within the regulations, the FDIC regulations that keep my money safe and short. Yeah, make it make it very, very transparent. I think that's a good solution.
Matt
So let's move on to. The GOP presidential group like. I don't know. I don't know guys like. But I consider myself a conservative Republican, and I've always worn this this badge Republican Party with with pride. I've been a proud Republican most of my life. But as I look. At the field of presidential contender. I just find myself like wondering what happened to the Republican Party. Like, where did they go? And I have something I have a quote in here from President Oak. So this is in the April 2021 General Conference in his talk on the Constitution, he says there are other duties that are part of upholding the inspired constitution we should learn and advocate the inspired principles of the Constitution. We should seek out and support. Why is in good persons who will support those principles and public actions, and then he also says this process will not be easy. It may require changing party support or candidate choices, even from election to election. Such independent actions will sometimes require voters to support candidates or political parties or platform. Whose other positions they cannot approve, and so that says to me like that's kind of like a green light. Like, hey, if the Republicans aren't gonna uphold the constitutional principles, then maybe I need to send them a lesson and look for Democrat candidates. Well, so then I want to discuss this question. Like are there any Republican candidates out there who are good and wise and who would not support the constitutional principles in their public action?
Shawn
So Matt, do you want it? There's such good questions in that the first question is what the heck happened to the Republican Party? Why does it look so differently than it does now than it did in the Reagan era? And then the traditional conservative times in the? What 30s, Forties, Fifties, 60s? Is that the question, like what happened and why has it changed? Or is your question looking at the current Republican President saying?
Matt
Yeah, I I mean, I don't think we could really answer. I don't think we really know why it changed. But I do think we could look at where it is right now and and maybe I just misperceived things like maybe there's Republican candidates that are. Really are good candidates good and wise, and I just don't see them. And maybe the other Republicans aren't seeing them right now.
Shawn
So there's a there's a cool podcast called Conservative something Nice Plug. I don't remember they they these two guys. Basically, they just take books that are either the foundation of conservatism or the foundation of liberalism, and they just read the book, and then they summarize and talk about each book to kind of just point out. Look, here's what is traditional or foundational. Service ISM. Here's what is traditional, foundational liberalism. It's really fascinating. Now, if you look, they've kind of described that. Look, there's, there's traditional conservatism and then there's, like, the libertarian side of conservatism. Is that, would you summarize that populism?
Matt
And then there's populism. Yeah, protectionism xenophobe. Yeah, go ahead.
Shawn
So he goes, they go in to kind of explain that the the the major difference between like the Reagan era conservatism and then. Today, there's big differences. Isn't there? Like, like back in the day, let's see.
Matt
Reagan, with small government, fiscal responsibility.
Speaker
OK so.
Matt
National Defense, fight against communism in favor of immigration.
Shawn
Which is more which is more that mask, right? He brought in that anti communism kind of national security conservatism. That's kind of a conservative value, isn't it?
Matt
Yeah, I think it is, yeah.
Shawn
Which it doesn't like you had mentioned in the past, doesn't get talked about much and then the traditional conservatism is more about values, virtue and order, right?
Matt
Yeah, yeah. Moral principles.
Shawn
And then the the libertarian one is, isn't that more?
Matt
About individual freedom. Individual, yeah.
Shawn
Right. So if you, if you if you if you define conservatism based on those, I think you're right, you look at today's Republican Party and it looks very different, doesn't it?
Matt
But I do think so. I think that the allure from me to the Republican Party is that I've always sort of thought of the Republican Party as a party that's defending moral values, that I think are important in society. And and even in the in that regard, I feel like some of the candidates have lost their way and they're advocating things that don't look like moral values and moral principles, but it's it's also true that I'm not really embedded in this world. And I I imagine there are probably candidates out there. The fit, Sean, even the Reagan definition of conservatism, maybe they're just not popular. Right now, like Ace, like the guy from Arkansas Ace and ASA Hutchinson, I think he maybe is a Reagan Republican.
Sam
Yeah, I think I think they're out there. The, the, the challenges, they've just been drowned out and and there's probably some fear too because that approach right now doesn't sit well on a stage with Trump. I mean, Trump just beats the living daylights out of these people. He he calls them names, he marginalizes them and he runs them off stage. And, you know, a guy like Pence is a pretty good guy. Right. Like I I think he's a a very. Decent, good, good, good.
Shawn
Yeah, he seems like a.
Sam
Wet Noodle, though I I met, I met.
Speaker
What does that mean?
Matt
What noodle. What does that noodle?
Shawn
A guy that just follows around Trump for four years and just does whatever he says.
Sam
I I met. Well, but maybe that's a little bit of the Trump effect. I met Jeb Bush in in Iowa and and had breakfast with him and and his campaign ahead of his campaign with some people I work around and, you know, super nice guy, right? But not as not the rock star that our culture demands right now.
Shawn
So so isn't that?
Sam
And it's interesting. We're gonna. We're gonna talk about it in just a minute, but I think these cycles are real in history, and they're at work in our world. Today and as far One Direction as maybe Trump and others have taken the party, it'll swing. Back you would hope, right?
Shawn
I wonder, Matt, do you think it will swing back?
Matt
Well, I think that the Republican Party is at a bit of an inflection point. So if if I were to take a broad historical brush and sort of paint things, I'd say, yeah, history does repeat itself in some ways. I think that this group of Republicans that really likes Ron De Santis and likes Donald Trump geographically, a lot of them are, are concentrated in the deep. Mouth and you know, 50-60 years ago they were all Democrats and they were all fighting against the civil rights movement. And they were trying to stop the Democratic Party from civil rights and and they basically all decided, let's leave the Democratic Party and let's go to the Republican Party and the Republican Party embrace them. And it's really helped the Republican Party gain power. The ways that it couldn't before, but they've become.
Shawn
You're talking about working, you're talking about working class white people is. What you're talking about, right?
Matt
Oh, I don't, I. I just call them the racist Southerners. That's what I call.
Shawn
Oh, oh boy.
Matt
Them I mean, I mean. Like they're not a.
Sam
He's gonna find he's gonna find a way to give the current Republican Party a backhanded slap.
Speaker
No, no, no, no, like.
Sam
One way or another. Right backhanded copy. It's a party of right let's.
Matt
So I'm going to nobody. Nobody likes the the label racist, but I'm going to be quite honest like where I live in Utah and Idaho, we sometimes will have these like get togethers where we have these competitions and say hey let's tell jokes and let's see who's got the funniest jokes and then I will say by the way no racist jokes allowed and it's crickets. Nobody's got any jokes to tell. And then I say, OK.
Speaker
You can. I'm I'm.
Sam
Come on, come on, come on.
Speaker
I'm a.
Matt
100% serious, like they're people are racist, right? So not in like, not in, like and we hate black people kind of thing, but in a it's really fun to make jokes, racist jokes kind of thing.
Shawn
You think it's a? You think it's an ignorant racism, not a proactive.
Matt
I'm just saying, like young people who don't know better how to hide it. There's a lot of racism in Utah and Idaho.
Shawn
No, I do. I don't think it's.
Sam
A Utah well, it's like Romney's binders full of women. Comment, right?
Shawn
I don't think it's.
Sam
There's something deeply embedded that without knowledge is somehow brings you to that a little bit, actually, I think.
Shawn
Being being being the Southern California guy, I will defend Utah, Idaho. I don't think it's people in Utah and Idaho. They're racist.
Matt
No, no, no. So.
Shawn
I think it's I.
Matt
I didn't get to finish. My point, so I'm saying like. I see it in Utah and Idaho a little bit, but then go to the South, spend a little bit of time in Louisiana and Mississippi, Alabama, the Carolinas. There's there's, like a deep racism there. So we get it a little bit here in Utah and Idaho and you go to those other places and you want to tell racist jokes and you're not even gonna get anybody kind of like looking at you like you shouldn't be telling that racist joke. Like there's some deep racism, especially in the American South, and I'm so I don't wanna like paint the brush. And say the Republican Party is racist. But there is a a big segment of the Republican Party. That is overtly racist. There's a lot of them that are covertly racist, and then there's a lot of them that kind of like aren't opposed to racist people, right?
Shawn
So Matt, so Matt, so if that if.
Sam
I think that's an unfair generalization.
Shawn
But, but if that's true, we don't know if it's true or not, right? If that's true, that is certainly a a change from the Republican Party, right, Republican.
Speaker
No, no, no.
Shawn
What do you?
Matt
No, it's no, it's the. It's the Republican base. These are the people that got Ronald Reagan elected. He doesn't win with that. They're the ones that brought the Republicans in. In 1994.
Shawn
No, but what I'm saying is traditional conservatism or the Republican Party of Abraham Lincoln maybe isn't.
Matt
Ohh well come on.
Speaker
That you.
Matt
I mean, yeah, I.
Shawn
You asked what you asked.
Matt
Mean that's that's too far back.
Shawn
What happened? You asked what happened to the Republican Party? So I guess what standard over the Republican Party are you?
Matt
Well, yeah. I mean, there's a whole history there that we could talk. So all I'm saying is, if there's this group of the Republican Party that's racist, some of them, there's a group of them that really hates immigrants, some of them and.
Speaker
Alright, alright, alright. And then there's.
Matt
A large contingent of them that are, like, let's say, evangelical Christians, and they care about moral values. And all of that stuff sort of gets meshed together into one big. Sort of like goop that we. Call the Republican Party. And sometimes some of those candidates espousing those things have an outsized voice compared to the rest of the party. Right, so so I'm. Not saying Republicans are racist? I'm saying all parties are like coalitions of different groups of people. And this 30% of the Republican Party, that there's maybe like not not the kind of people I would hang out with that sometimes they get an outsized voice in the Republican Party and yeah.
Shawn
So, so, so maybe Sam, you mentioned earlier the celebrity element of Donald Trump that has really affected the Republican Party. Maybe that's there's something to that like to me, I think that the technology has. Enabled, for example big media to use its power to really divide. Like use philosophies to divide. And they do that because now that there's data like Matt, you've taught me this, that Donald Trump looked at Twitter would tweet something, look at the data results, the analytics and go, OK, this is what people. Care about and whether it's yeah.
Matt
100,000 likes. If he got 100,000 likes on a tweet, it became a a campaign promise.
Shawn
With so Donald. Trump would tweet something whether he believes it or not, whether it's moral or not, whether it's good or. Not whether it's conserve. Never. Not if it got up more than 100,000 retweets. That was a campaign that was what he'd campaign that he was simply marketing, right? Is what you're saying.
Matt
Yeah, yeah.
Shawn
So I think what I'm trying to get to is the technology has. Allowed big media. To to do that right to use the analytics to go OK, what are some what are groups of people that can sway votes? What are they into? All right, now let's make that our platform. And when it's money driven like that or power driven like that, what you get is you get Fox News and MSNBC, what you get is Republicans versus Democrat. You get division and. Divide, divide, divide. Divide and you get these extremes on both sides, which is what I think the the parties have. Become isn't it?
Sam
Well, but the great thing about the great thing about the history of America is anytime we swing to extremes, oftentimes it comes back and it you've gotta believe and and we're gonna talk about this in a second with our next question. But it's gonna swing back a little bit. And and I'm excited to go to question #3, but before we go there, can I just bring up one comment that I think we went by very quickly that is actually a. Big deal. So Matt, I had never read this comment from Elder Oaks. So, you know, an apostle in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints making a statement in a public forum, which then becomes policy sort of of the church, right. I've never heard of an apostle of the church talking about changing public party. And or aligning with public parties where we may not fully support or agree with the entire platform of that. So as I grew up as a kid in high school in our ward, we knew the one guy who was Democrat. He was crazy. And we all felt very safe because we had him in a in a in in such a a circle and a cocoon that he could have. No influence on.
Shawn
Wow, that's weird.
Sam
And now we're in a world now.
Shawn
Dude, that is weird. What you're saying.
Sam
We're in a world. The conversations we're having right now not only should be normal and they're not yet, but they should actually be encouraged. So instead of making fun of Matt for being pro Biden.
Matt
I am not.
Sam
Right. Like like there could be a time where the church looks at the two sides. I mean, and and and Trump is a fairy example of that. Like, you know, Utah voted Republican. You know, we've always been completely in the Republican camp. We gave Trump a tough time in the last presidential election. We were the one state that didn't go that way as as as much as as we had in the in the history of the.
Matt
So my yeah, my fear, Sam, is that?
Sam
Country right. So.
Matt
Republicans are going to just choose Trump the next Trump, and they're not going to, right. So Trump?
Sam
I don't think there is an extract though.
Matt
Ohh, come on.
Sam
There's still.
Matt
The Santas, the Santas, is so much like Trump.
Sam
Gonna be like him, no.
Shawn
No, he is not mad.
Sam
I I don't think DeSantis really has a chance.
Shawn
But he's not that much like Trump.
Sam
I really don't.
Shawn
Is he alright?
Matt
I ohh yeah.
Sam
He he's he doesn't have the personality. He doesn't have the character, you know?
Matt
Yeah, I just mean it.
Sam
He he's he's slow out the gates with his campaign and he is not taking the the hits. And here's another example. Just one last example about how things. Looking back, I was concerned when the Supreme Court overturned. Roe V Wade. From from a gospel standpoint, we're against abortion generally, but once something becomes ingrained as the law of the land, it concerns me to undo it. Republicans came back and they said, hey, we're not undoing this. We're just allowing states to have control over whether it happens or not. And it's interesting, this past week. There are two states that actually have it up, Nebraska and South Carolina. Where they were trying to ban abortion in those states, states where Republican Republicans had the majority and and and and banning abortion should have, should have taken off clearly and easily. And it didn't, right?
Matt
Yeah, but it did in Utah and Idaho.
Sam
So I I think. But it did in Utah and Idaho, and it could be undone. But we're pretty progressive.
Matt
So so kind.
Sam
In some right?
Matt
Of a funny story, Sam, about how this. Swing back in the day about 100 years ago, the Utah Peoples Party was the LDS party in. The state of. And the church decided that in order to get statehood, they needed to, like, either align with Republicans or Democrats. So David O McKay and his biography, the story, is that in church one Sunday, the Bishop said everybody sitting on this half is a Republican, and everybody sitting on this half is a Democrat, and David O McKay. She was just a child at the. And he says I was so disappointed because the only Republican in town was the town drunk. And I did not want to be affiliated with the Republican Party. So it is funny how things kind of change over time. The perceptions of parties and what they stand for. And I agree. I think that we should have an allegiance to something higher than a party and it there is not a party that I will agree with. Every single one of their positions and everybody in the party. And so if I'm going to just be a voter and choose based on positions, I have to be willing to say, hey, I can accept some things. I'm not a big fan of and then vote for the candidates I think are best.
Sam
And other oaks cleared the way for engine right and and I think that that's a pretty good reason for us as a podcast to have a goal to have a general authority in a public setting.
Matt
Yeah. Yeah. In general conference.
Sam
Talk about the podcast because this truly models that type of conversation, conversations that many of us may have been uncomfortable to. Have in any other.
Shawn
Yeah, I say pre I agree, guys preach it. It loud, right? Loyalty to a man made profit driven political party is falling. It's a wrong thing. It'll never lead us, right? Right. But if we take the principles of Christ through scripture or the apostles, yeah, we're going to seek for. Principles and laws, and we're going to, yeah, if that sways us, then so be it. No loyalty to these pardons.
Matt
And I would advocate to actually people should get involved in run for office themselves. If you don't like what a party, if you don't like what the Democrats stand for, go run for office and be a Democrat representative and then you get to decide what they stand for and all their voters have to sit around and say, well, I guess they hadn't. Well, I wish they hadn't taken that position, but Oh well, that's the person in charge.
Sam
And as evidence of that, isn't it crazy that this presidential election looks like it's going to end up being? Right, two people that have negatives that are so high, like the entire country is screaming. Don't do it yet.
Matt
That's what's going to.
Sam
It's gonna happen again. Good people need to truly get involved.
Speaker
So let's move on.
Matt
To a discussion of the news media. So there's a lot of news this week about what's happened, so CNN fired Don Lemon because of some sexist remarks he's made in public on air and stuff. He does how he treats women on his staff.
Sam
Many of them many.
Matt
A lot of people know about Tucker Carlson, that perhaps he was not the most. On this person in the world, I don't know if you guys are aware of this, but Tucker Carlson has the distinct honor of being fired from PBS, CNN, MSNBC and Fox News, so I can't think of a more fitting example.
Shawn
Hold on.
Matt
Of a person. You're just.
Shawn
He gets but.
Sam
What was he doing at PBS?
Shawn
But Matt, he gets but gets.
Sam
Was he like some people?
Shawn
Street map. But some people praise him for that, right? Because if if part of our argument is that a lot of these media giants have agendas, some people praise him to be like, oh, he's not willing to jump on their agenda. Obviously he has evidence that he is willing to jump on some agendas. But being fired from those places, some people say good for him because he wasn't willing to jump.
Matt
Right. But that's not true. Watch. Your shows on all of those. Networks, what he did is he was a chameleon and he adapted whatever the audience wanted the like. The extreme elements of that audience, he would just fan the flames of whatever those things are. And if you look at his Twitter post after he left Fox News, the same thing like who knows where he's going to go next. But he's certainly not gonna continue on the Fox News thing that he had at Fox News. He's gonna do some other thing. That he's already starting to fan the. Flames of whatever that. Is, yeah, but.
Shawn
One but one theory is that, like you said, he's a chameleon, right? On the one hand, he's he's just giving in to whatever the paycheck tells him to talk about and on and on the other hand, he's sometimes trying to go.
Sam
He's an entertainer.
Shawn
Yeah, but I don't agree with that. Is he good at it? No, definitely not. And do I support him? No, but. But but I mean, look at look at all the other voices in the media, look at, we watched Jimmy Kimmel every night. I don't know why that guy is so in love with Donald Trump. He talks about nothing but Donald Trump.
Matt
In love with making fun of Donald. Trump, right? He.
Shawn
Well, that's what I mean. He's obsessed with him. Yeah, but it helps Donald Trump because it makes him keeps him relevant. So it's such a backfire and Jimmy's end.
Matt
It's negative about Trump. But it helped. It helps. Jimmy Kimmel because it keeps his ratings high because there's all the Trump haters in the world.
Shawn
And that's. And that's the point is, it's all about money, power, and ratings. It's all about pandering.
Matt
Well, so then this is a question like I want to address this. Question first like. If all of the news, the popular news networks now, in fairness, we're talking about either cable news or Internet news. If they're all just pandering to an audience and just saying whatever they need to say to get that audience to click or to watch, then like, how can you find? Political news that doesn't have an agenda if they all seem to have an. Agenda like if. A person really wanted to find, really. Good political news. Where would they turn?
Sam
I so so Matt, it's interesting. I'm not sure that's a new phenomenon. So one of my favorite movies as a kid growing up, did you ever watch Jimmy Stewart in Mr. Smith goes to Washington, right where he was.
Matt
Yeah, I thought you were gonna say a man for all seasons.
Sam
He was not in that one, but yes.
Matt
Jimmy Stewart, Mr. Smith.
Sam
Yeah, Mr. Smith goes to Washington and he fights against the the the political machine that is run by the press and controls his hometown. As a A skewed press is nothing new. What is new? And it really started as we were growing up. I remember the first days Rush Limbaugh. Came on the radio. And I listened to it with my dad and it was exciting to hear because he said a lot of the things that represented, like, value, ethical values that that we held.
Matt
Conservative, yeah.
Sam
And it was interesting. I I listened. Him consistently for a good 3-4 years and and it turned somewhere it turned into pure entertainment and and you're kind. Of like wait. And then Fox News came on right, and you had the flashy graphics and you had the beautiful people with super.
Matt
Bill O'Reilly.
Sam
White team. And at some point, yeah. And Bill O'Reilly. And Glenn Beck, right, and it and and at some point, you start to hear the people talk who watch that and you're like, wait.
Matt
Yeah, yeah.
Sam
That's not it. That's not accurate. And so that that pendulum swing back to normal, I think. I think nobody knows. First of all, why Tucker Carlson is fired, and that's fascinating. Everybody knew instantly why Bill O'Reilly got fired. Nobody truly knows why Tucker Carlson got fired.
Matt
And Don Lemon, right, CNN people know why Don Lemon was fired.
Shawn
Why was that?
Matt
Yep, Yep. But sexism? Yeah.
Shawn
Because of his sexism.
Sam
Sex, yeah.
Matt
Well, so and yeah.
Sam
But does the pendulum swing back right?
Matt
Well, and and it's true like the the press from the very beginning was a partisan press. Candidates would pay for news outlets and their whole purpose was to, like, attack other candidates. So it's true, there's nothing new about this but but but it is.
Sam
It's American.
Matt
It does make it hard to know who to trust because. There's if somebody. To use let's. Use Rush Limbaugh as an example. If somebody saying things that are consistent with my values, then it makes me trust them more because I say they're saying things that are consistent with my values and it makes. Me a little bit. Afraid to hear something from another side because they might not share my values and maybe they're trying to trick me. So even if I know a little bit in my heart that maybe Rush Limbaugh's trying to deceive me. Kind of like. Trust him and maybe want that deception just a little bit because the other thing.
Sam
So, so.
Matt
Is a little scary.
Sam
So the challenge with today's media. And podcast perpetrate it. The guy from Comedy Central that took over Jon Stewart's role specifically talks about this. I forget his name.
Matt
Trevor Noah.
Sam
Trevor Noah talks about this. He he says there's a familiarity that's created with podcasts and late night television that causes a person to feel like they know that person. They know their heart, their soul, and they get to trust them. Like you're talking about. That that's never existed. It started with Rush Limbaugh. It went through Fox News and it exists today in. But when we think about that pendulum coming back, I think people are starting to see that they have to make their own decisions. They have to think for themselves as much as Glenn Beck talks about you've gotta research this. You gotta research that. If you listen to him for 10 minutes, he's trying to tell you in a very entertaining way exactly what you should think, right? People do need to. Come to their own conclusions and one of the best ways to do that, candidly, is to listen, in my opinion, to viewpoints that don't necessarily. Your your own and and be able be able to explain why you believe different than someone.
Matt
But that's scary too, Sam.
Sam
Else does.
Matt
That, that that requires cognitive.
Sam
Hold me. Why is that scary?
Matt
It it it requires cognitive sophistication, right? If I'm listening to one person I can like, I can, like repeat what they're saying.
Speaker
It's sophisticated, yeah.
Matt
But I don't really understand what they're saying and. So if I. Have a friend with a different perspective. Like like let's. Just take Jimmy Kimmel and Tucker Carlson, right. If I watch Jimmy Kimmel. All the time. I'll leave with the impression that every Republican on Earth is a. And like, they're just stupid. And that's all I can really articulate at the end of. This show I just, I don't know, they're just stupid. And same with Tucker Carlson. I would say every Democrat on Earth is just stupid and I can't articulate why. I just know. They're stupid, but.
Shawn
Yeah, he nailed it.
Sam
But that's not the way you that's not the way you personally believe you're you're relaying how other people you believe other people act and react. It's up to the individual person to interact with that media and the way they interact with it, and it's our own individual liberty and responsibility. To digest that in a responsible way and then and then act on this in a responsible.
Shawn
But Matt, you're saying that the that that I'm saying you're saying, no, Matt, you're saying that dissonance that cognitive dissonance is hard for many people to grasp, but I think.
Sam
Way you can't legend. That, by the way.
Shawn
But I think there's being the latter day lens. I think there's there are, like, spiritual principles that drive this right, Dean. So you 29 says. I mean, God, I gave them to men to be an agent unto himself. Right. The agency is a is a an eternal principle, a spiritual principle. But he also says he also. Says there it must needs be that there's an opposition in all things in order to have agency, we have to have that opposition. So I think you're right, Matt. I think there has to be. On any given topic, it's healthy for us to have this dissonance. I think it's a smart approach to for members of the church to listen to both sides, since we have these extremes. Listen to Fox News. Listen to MSNBC, listen to listen.
Matt
It's that's that's scary. I'm just saying that's scary. Like when I was young and and psychiatry was like of the devil. Then I'd say I I think I might go to therapy and people would be like, why would you talk to a psychologist? They're liberal. They're like. Godless people and they're going to trick you into like, losing your faith in Christ and I think. That for of course not.
Sam
Do you believe that today?
Matt
But I think that there's like for a lot of people, there's this, like this conviction of like I. I know the church is true, but I really can't explain it to my friends and neighbors. And my political views align with that, and I really can't explain those to my friends and neighbors. And if I start deviating too far, then maybe I have to rethink all of these things. I really believe and really think and it all kind of like falls apart like there's this fear like people have to be able to build up to these sorts of things. And and it's hard to like and I don't know, Sean, that listening to both extremes is actually helpful for anybody.
Shawn
That's just great. Here's but, but here's the.
Matt
Craziness really don't think.
Shawn
But you had said that you said you said that it's earlier that it maybe it's it's good for. Us as people to look at the both sides to be able to consider maybe not the extremes I didn't mean. Just go to the extremes. I mean, look at both sides, which sometimes includes the extremes, but here's you said.
Matt
Yeah, I didn't say that.
Shawn
That didn't you?
Matt
I said I think that I think that the extremes make you hate both sides the other side.
Shawn
No, not the extremes you said. Make sure and we you said 5 minutes ago we as people.
Matt
Good. Yeah. Sample.
Sam
I think I said that I I I said I I think it's not a bad idea to hear both viewpoints and then.
Speaker
You did.
Shawn
Do you disagree with?
Sam
Make a decision on your own.
Matt
That, Matt, I think people need to go to the boring stuff. That's just so lame and makes you want to fall asleep, cause that's the only true stuff.
Shawn
Without you're saying without bias, you're saying find a. Find an NPR who isn't perfect, but you're saying find someone. So is really making an effort to not be biased in their approach is.
Matt
Yeah, like PBS news hour.
Shawn
What you're saying?
Matt
I can't watch that whole hour, but five.
Sam
BBC News.
Matt
Yeah, BBC. But you watch an hour of PBS news Hour, you're gonna know both sides of everything, and you're gonna, and you're gonna. Be asleep, by the way, after 30 minutes.
Speaker
I mean it's.
Shawn
Not it's not perfect, but you're saying that's the approach. But let let me give you scriptures that back up maybe Sam's approach a little bit, right. Secondly, fight two says 16 the Lord gave unto man that he should act for himself. Wherefore man could not act for himself, save it should be that he was enticed by the one or the other.
Sam
And and I'm not sure we have a choice in today's world. There are so many voices. I think about all the things that the church recently has done to kind of put that choice back in the individual and the family between the the curriculum and the missionary age and and the the for the strength of youth. Like and and Oaks's comment is just the capstone. Yeah, right. Like, as members of the church, you're gonna hear varying opinions. And you're going to have to act, and the church is going to have to respect that and and and be OK with that. And you're going to have to learn how to do that in a way and have a conversation like we are in a way that doesn't tear you apart. We love each other, cause we've served together in in Ukraine. We know each other's heart and you can't. There's nothing either one of you could say that would separate us from each other. And and and every member of the church really needs to be that, you know, bound together with the, with the testimony of Christ.
Matt
Well, so let's go to the big question. So the First Amendment protects the freedom of the press, and in part this is because in order for a democracy to function well, people need to have accurate information about what's going on in the government. If the government is just dishing out. Propaganda all the time and people don't really know what's happening. Then you can easily have the the public be LED astray and you lose your democracy before you even know what happened. So the Supreme Court has fought vigorously to protect the freedom of the press. News organizations have rights that other organizations don't have. It's harder to sue them for libel. They can print classified information. They don't have to reveal their sources in court. There's all kinds of things at the same time. Just because you're a news organization with constitutional protections doesn't guarantee that you're going to be viable newspapers. Out of business all the time, people. If they don't like your news aren't going. To buy your product and then it doesn't matter what constitutional rights you. So that's the crisis. We're kind of dilemma, right, because on the one hand, the news organizations want to be accurate and hold the government accountable. But on the other hand, they need clicks and viewers and advertisers, and they need to make money, and people tend to be more motivated by kind of antagonism. And conflict and controversy sensationalized kinds of things. So, and people also want to hear news that reinforces their own particular point of view. So the question I have this is kind of the big question is like how do you deal with this paradox? Like there's this one part of me that says. If an organization is just a propaganda outlet, they don't get to have the word news behind their name. We just say you're not a news organization and just to be like fair, like at the news stand. I you know. There are legitimate fake news about like the Bat boy or whatever. Like you can see him in the grocery aisle if you ever go shopping anymore, you can see, like, legitimately. Fake news and that stuff stuff maybe shouldn't be allowed to be called news. Like that's one approach. But maybe.
Sam
Inquire news.
Matt
Which one? Yeah, except for the but it.
Sam
Inquiry meetings. It's been around a long time, right?
Matt
It did break some. Stories, right, like the Inquirer did actually have a true story one time about a presidential candidate. I think it was John Edwards. Was that anyhow? And so you say, well, maybe we should just not let them be news anymore, but maybe there's something like. We could do about. It, like, maybe they're citizens, like as as consumers of media, maybe we have obligations as consumers of. And we should say we're not going to go to propaganda organizations to get our information. We're going to only go to legitimate government sources. We're only going to read, like, official.
Shawn
Government we should mint.
Sam
Actually, what what we should do is the government should buy TikTok. And they could change. The algorithm so that it just fed people real news instead of feeding them the stuff. That is a really good idea.
Matt
Government solution to this problem.
Sam
Oh. Oh, wait, that's. In China, never mind. OK, go ahead. I forgot. Forgot China's already doing that. Dog on it, they beat us.
Matt
Sam, you tricked me with your sarcasm, voice.
Sam
To it. OK, never mind. Next stop.
Speaker
I just thought I thought.
Matt
You were really on to something there for a second. What do you think, Sean there was?
Sam
A plan in. The pre existence and everybody had a choice. We need to respect that choice.
Speaker
I don't I.
Shawn
Don't think the answer is get government involved to police, police, media because you're you're.
Sam
Thank you, Sean. I have a list. I have a list of all the regulation that that's got in place and it's pages.
Shawn
Government because government interference in.
Sam
I'm going to. I'm going to. Mark this one off.
Shawn
And in the Second Amendment is the First Amendment.
Matt
1st amendment can't wait. Wait, wait. Sean, can I sue somebody and say all I want from you is you don't get to say news anymore like Dominion when they when they I don't want 700 million from Fox.
Shawn
Sorry, the 1st amendment.
Matt
I want you to take news. Off your.
Sam
Name so so.
Shawn
No, that's free.
Sam
So can I make one? Comment about that, though, so I think it's fascinating that Fox News decided to settle with Dominion. Because I took in college a bunch of classes about libel and slander that those are some basic required classes in in media back then, and the development of of libel and slander laws as it relates to the media and press over the past many decades is fascinating from protecting ***********. And other elements of free speech and are anything. What? What would what? Would have been terrifying is if Fox News had lost that and had gone all the way to the Supreme Court and it restrained a news organization from being able to share news and another.
Matt
Do you? Do you know? What else? Is for.
Sam
That's off the table.
Matt
Do you know what else is fascinating? Sam, as if they had actually won that lawsuit. Because then if they win that lawsuit, then a news organization can publish things that they know to be false and not be sued for libel, right?
Sam
Either way, either.
Matt
That's why I'm glad it was settled.
Sam
Way, right?
Matt
Right, because. It's frightening.
Sam
Because because right now it it has to be an intentional act, you have to intentionally know that.
Matt
Right.
Sam
It's a fault. Fact, which is a ludicrous statement, right? And that's not a bad standard right now.
Matt
Alright, go ahead Sean.
Shawn
So I don't think the government getting in and. And I think. It would be a negative effect if they start to really try and force words, and you can't use news. You can't use news that seems pretty dangerous for a government to start telling me, like all my business.
Matt
But we do that we we do. That with religions, right, we define what is and is not a religion, only certain.
Shawn
All themselves are religion. Only when it comes to tax benefits, right is it.
Sam
Ohh, we don't OK we don't. Well, it can't. It can't be a religion.
Speaker
Well, we, we. We live OG alright.
Matt
Are you serious, Sam?
Shawn
You're just saying, saying saying he's saying he's.
Speaker
Do you want to go down?
Sam
That road for tax, for tax.
Shawn
Saying they're they're purposes.
Matt
Right. For tax purposes, we have, we've outlined what is and is not a religion for these tax exempt purposes.
Shawn
Yeah, but anyone can call, but there's freedom to call my my company or religion. That's got a friend who's doing that.
Matt
Right, but if? But you have. To behave in a way your friends. Fascinate me, Sean. You have to behave in a way that is in line with what they define as a religion. Right. So I'm just saying you could do the same thing.
Shawn
Ticket tax cuts.
Matt
With news organizations, right? So. Just like what they do with taxes and religion, they could do with news and say if you're doing these sorts of things, you're not news.
Sam
But then the government would have a chilling effect on the way news is disseminated when free market at the end of the day is the best gauge for whether or not news is good and news is useful.
Speaker
They would.
Sam
I would rather have a Fox News or an MSNBC out there have the market restrain it if it decides to then try to control it by government. That's not a good look.
Shawn
So what about Matt? What about third party Rotten Tomatoes? How about Rotten Tomatoes, right? And Rotten Tomatoes becoming an aggregate for this movie is terrible. Or this movie is good. It's a good. I like that. I like going and saying, OK, here's what majority of people, not that majority rule is is always a. Good thing, maybe sometimes it's really, really a good thing, but Rotten Tomatoes gives us an aggregate of what people's opinions are on certain things. Why don't we have the? Rotten Tomatoes for outlets.
Matt
Oh, we have that all we have. That sure, there's a whole.
Shawn
Media outlets. What is that?
Sam
Lot of and ChatGPT is going to create.
Matt
What is it that there's a lot of organizations out there that are telling you, like, good news, bad news, biased news, accurate news?
Sam
More of.
Matt
Well, what about? We need some we.
Shawn
Need someone to make that mainstreamed and popular. And that's you said there's a lot.
Matt
The point though? That's the whole point is that people don't care enough to do that. Well, let me ask you this, though. So if you go back to our time in Ukraine, which was right at the end of the Soviet Union, so they're making this transition from a very controlled information environment to what Sam would call capitalism. They they would regularly complain to. Me about all of the bad stuff in. Society, *********** negativity that they didn't have in the Soviet Union. They're like we I never saw a drunk person on the street. I never saw this and in addition to that they say and look at all the ****. Being published like. Naked ladies and papers and all that sort of stuff. They never had that and democracy brought that to them. And I sort of feel like.
Sam
I'm so glad this is coming up. So glad.
Matt
I feel like Sam, Sam is saying.
Sam
This is coming up.
Matt
Like this is a. Something we should tolerate as a society because it's better for us.
Sam
We have to tolerate it, Matt. And and my son and I had a conversation, the one that served in Taiwan. We talk often about the liberties in China, which is a communist country versus us. They're very controlled. In China, we have our freedoms, our society and culture reflects the values of the people who live in it, in one form, fashion or. Or another. And there's this thought that as long as there are is goodness and morality in this culture, it will represent and reflect that Russia, as it went over the precipice of communism to total free market, there was a vacuum and mafia and crime and every all the worst. Prices came into full. You and and that's what caused you, you know, the whole pendulum thing right, like and it swing all the way. The One Direction to the point where it was so bad that people were asking for communism back, right, and Russia, they got a.
Matt
Right, that's Putin's.
Sam
Version of that. Paul Mantra put put Putin now has the blue check next to whether or not the news agency or not right so. They could only they could only listen. To certain news news in. Russia right now, I would rather have all the terrible things that come along with it, and if and if we're a nation of good people with, with a moral base. You've got to believe that that's going to. Reflect in what we hold and value.
Matt
So then.
Sam
As a. And and Matt, you've been the one that has said it way back when you we asked the question, what will we look back on 20 years from now and say hey, we got it wrong in that day and I think you said there are some causes that have swung so far that we'll say, hey, that was that was too much even though it seemed. We see politically correct that was. Pretty much and and that's kind of.
Matt
Well, so.
Sam
We're seeing, right?
Matt
So then I think that this is naturally leading to the next question if if it's not going to be government controlled and not going to be government regulated and it's going to be market controlled, then that means citizens and as consumers have some obligations that go along with those freedoms. So then what are the citizen slash consumer obligations? Of of, of a society with a truly Free Press, where we're going to allow anything out there, but we're going to allow the market to decide. Do I have some kind of a moral obligation to consume certain things and not consume other things?
Shawn
Well, I I think I think that an important part of that is a limited but. A legal system that protects against libel and right so it it kind of worked with the Fox News thing, right? So that doesn't didn't work.
Matt
I don't know. I don't know. I I'm I mean I'm. I'm not thrilled with that system. I think it's ridiculous that politicians and news organizations can slander individuals and they don't have legal protections against them. I would love to see that changed. And I I just. Think of the EI. Think of the E Jean Carroll lawsuit against Trump right now, where she's suing Trump for things he said about her while president of the United States.
Sam
How would you do it?
Matt
And the laws say, well, no, he's president of the United States, he cannot slander another. Individual he was. Just doing acting in his official capacity as President, and if he's acting in his official capacity as President, then. You cannot sue him like I think that stuff is crazy and and and truth in that right like truth in advertising for businesses.
Shawn
Oh yeah, that seems crazy. That's not good and.
Matt
You can't just lie about your competitors, but candidates can lie about their. So I I'm not sure that I love the unequal application of these laws in these in this particular realm.
Shawn
But the laws are good, it seems, so it seems like if we can get better at at protecting against libel and slander, then that's a good element of the free market they have.
Sam
Well, well, and and.
Shawn
That's a good function. That's one good function of government.
Sam
Your, your, your. Trump example is just spot on. Like I hear some of the things he said. You know the, the, the, the, the motions he made making fun of a a kid that was handicapped, you know, comments he's made in the press room. That's someone who no matter what you think about his policy is not a moral person that occupied that office. And and and and I think there are some members of the church that see that and and that's a great example. And and someone in that spot long enough probably breaks the system because because you, you do have to protect. I mean, how on Earth does the President of United States in a presidential debate make some of the comments? He may. Need to to to. Laughter and applause. It makes me think of Russell Crowe and Gladiator where you know where he says. Are you not entertained? Right and and? And he says, hey, being in the arena, it is in power, right? And and Trump understands that, and he knows that. And we have, you know, we've we counted to to that that's.
Matt
So do I have a moral obligation to read accurate news that's really boring to prevent some of this craziness?
Sam
That's bigger.
Shawn
No, I don't think so.
Speaker
No, just like.
Shawn
No, don't think so. No, because.
Sam
I don't know. How you do you know what, Matt, you know? What would be cool is create a class in in school in high school called digesting Social Media News or News. Like what if everybody went through? I could get behind that what teach everybody to think.
Speaker
What about?
Shawn
Well, like just.
Sam
Quickly in high school.
Matt
Just as citizens, right listeners to our podcast, that might have say, what can I do as a citizen? Do we have like is there some kind of like? OK, so I would say. I have a moral obligation to not consume *********** because by not consuming ***********, that's one in a billion that are watching it. Now, that's not gonna watch it. And then that hurts that business model in the future and and and entertainment that's like overtly opposed to my values for example. The Book of Mormon, the musical I chose to never see that because I said they're just making fun of my faith. Now other people can see it, and that's fine. I don't have a problem. I make moral decisions about the things I'm going to consume based on the society I want to live in and and are there moral principles that can guide our decisions and how we consume news that might like result in a better society?
Shawn
You just it's just it's hard because your. I yeah, it is, I.
Matt
It's a great conversation.
Shawn
I don't know, Matt. I I I I err on the side I think of let the opposition exist and let's teach let's I mean if we consume scriptures more we would learn how to differentiate how to discern between right and wrong and good and evil. Let the spirit be our guide. I think I know it's cliche, but we need to be better Christians and be very familiar with Scripture and with this the Holy Ghost because then we can discern. But I think you need to let the opposition exist. That's the nature of mortality, isn't it?
Sam
Watch this, Sean. Watch this, Sean. You're the one that's always dropping. And I'm about to drop it. I mean, that is right. That's that's the whole purpose of our experience, is to learn good from evil and choose good and sustain and prop up good. Not by force, but by choice and as appealing as it is to think about, you know, a communist. That world where you can't get ***********, you can't get some of these other things. I mean, Matt, you make the comment about ***********. Most people in the United States, they don't agree with that comment. Most people in the United States think it's OK and probably helpful, right?
Matt
Yes, I know. I'm I'm well.
Sam
Aware it's a, it's a. It's a. It's a challenge, right?
Matt
But but I.
Sam
And that that's a social, societal problem.
Matt
But I can make the choice to not consume it even when I really, really want to, because I would. Rather not see it as a sign. And I can make the choice to never see another Nicholas. Cage move. I'm just kidding.
Sam
But you can't, but you can't. But you can't legislate. Others not seem.
Matt
No, I agree. I think I agree that we shouldn't legislate this, but I think that we as citizens, that we frequently like to talk about freedom and we rarely talk about responsibility. And I think it's sometimes OK to focus on what responsibilities. We have as citizens. If we want. To have freedom and we want to have, let's say we want to have a moral in a good society, we do have some responsibilities with how we exercise our freedoms that influence other peoples and don't just have an effect on ourselves.
Sam
So then what do you do, Matt? How do you how do you ingrain or inject? And heavens sakes, do not say Glenn Beck teaches a class to high school students. Like someone should teach it, it would be a critical thinking class somehow. Where it's. Hey, here's the different ways you get news and information. How do you digest it? Right. I don't know if that's a class.
Shawn
I'm sorry to sound like a broken record, but the God put the scriptures on.
Speaker
Is it?
Sam
Just let it be.
Shawn
No, no. Put the scriptures on the earth and there's such dissonance in the scriptures and you did that on purpose. I think it is hard to understand all the things in the scriptures cause they.
Speaker
Yeah, yeah.
Shawn
Beat up against each other and it requires deep personal study and contemplation, and that that strengthens our cognitive abilities to see both sides of things and then discern so I I think it's feast upon the words of Christ.
Sam
It's great point.
Shawn
That's the answer.
Matt
But I do also, I think I'll just say this, you get what you pay for and there are a lot of people out there that just want to consume free media and free news and get whatever shows up on TikTok. And you have to assume that that's going to be garbage and and I pay money to subscribe to the Washington Post, the Wall Street Journal, New York Times, because.
Speaker
Yeah, lazy.
Matt
Maybe I don't love what's in their opinions. Sections, but if you, you gotta you gotta let reporters get paid for their jobs or they're not gonna be able to keep reporting on the news and that, like it is OK.
Sam
Hey Matt, can can I borrow?
Speaker
Your volume for those.
Matt
It's so funny how we, like, just share Netflix passwords and all that stuff, right? For some reason, we don't share all of those. News and like like like. There are legitimate newspaper newspaper organizations out there. And they're dying, right? They're dying breed because everybody wants free news. And so I do think we have an obligation to say, look, if I'm going to spend $60.00 a month on. Subscriptions of some kind? Can I make one of them a newspaper? Can I make one of them like something invested in giving me accurate information and I could just maybe wait on Netflix for? I don't know, maybe not. Subscribe to that one.
Sam
So So what if the three of us came up with a free market solution to that? I think people could get behind that. So to Shawn's point, and then to yours. Like what? What free market tool could there be that would allow people to have a choice and get access to some of these other news sources? Cause. Because to your point, the free stuff is garbage right now, right? The stuff of value is behind a paywall because it costs money to create the stuff that's free is somebody that's just churning out stuff that you know isn't fit to read. That that's a fascinating deal. Like so. So that being the case, how do you? Remedy that, right? Because us refusing to read something or or buying one more subscription isn't going to change the world. But if we had a free market solution.
Matt
If you create an iTunes or a Spotify of News right where where you where the like, the news organizations are going to get paid for the stories that people read, but they can create like this like cultivated list. It's like these are the kinds of things I want to know about, and you're going to get in your Spotify feed or your whatever feed the accurate.
Shawn
I kind of disagree with you guys. There's I think that. It's you're never going to avoid the the opposite. You're always going to have the extremes and the different sides in the opposition because money drives it all right. The the moment, the moment you have two iTunes, you know for media competing against each other is the moment you start getting money.
Sam
You want that you want that, yeah.
Shawn
Being the driving force behind the content, and it eventually just becomes a pandering source. So I think you have to accept we have. To accept the. Fact that there is opposition, there are forces of good and evil, right and wrong, black and white, and many Grays in the area. In in between.
Sam
I sort of. I sort of see Sean know what Matt is saying, which is those last good sources are going away because there is no funding and and if there's no funding, they're just going to disappear into the night. You know, you look at some of the great media sources here in Utah, like there used to be rich diversity and there used to be depth. Now they're all owned by the same company and and they're a a shallow shell of their former self and and and.
Matt
Right.
Sam
And that is, if you go to Meet the Press and listen to some of their podcast. Recently that that's a national problem and and that is.
Shawn
So so so I. So I started to abandon the big media and started to go online and go OK, let me listen to some of these guys.
Sam
A real problem.
Shawn
So, for example, Ben Shapiro, he started going online and I loved it because all he's gonna give me. The and then eventually I realized oh. Wait, he's just pandering. Yeah, he's just pandering. OK, that's not a good source. Let me look for another online version. And right now I'm into Russell Brand and I. Know he's a very he's very much so a conspiracy theorist, right?
Matt
But he's not a reporter, Sean.
Speaker
His whole.
Matt
He's not. A he's not giving. You accurate news about what's going on.
Shawn
I don't need he. He doesn't need a credential.
Sam
But he looks good and he's got an English accent.
Shawn
He doesn't need a credential. No, he doesn't need a credential to be able to have a brain to analyze.
Matt
But I know, but I once.
Sam
We almost ended on a strong note. Went I.
Matt
Want someone in?
Speaker
The white.
Matt
House when when Biden does a press conference or I want someone in the White House that's going to challenge those questions to give me accurate information about what's happening there. You know what I'm saying? Like somebody who's there in the. Room like look. All of us could watch C-SPAN.
Speaker
I sure miss you.
Matt
Like if ad nauseam, it's on all all the time and it's totally free, but nobody does it cause it's super boring. So I need. To pay somebody to sit through all that super boring stuff and tell me the little things that matter, that's the kind of that's what I.
Shawn
Mean by news? Well, I don't understand the rules. What keeps Russell Brand out of The Newsroom in?
Matt
The White House. But he's not there. He's making a podcast, making you laugh. He could go there if he wanted to, but he's not doing that because he's an entertainer, Sean. He's a he's.
Sam
And he was married to Katy Perry.
Matt
Well, now I like it. OK, now I got. To follow him.
Shawn
Yeah, but eventually he'll get there. He has 6.5 million followers on his YouTube channel. Eventually doesn't. If he believes in what he's doing, and so far it seems like he's he's very much so believing in his his messages, he could he could get there to the White House. Why not?
Sam
Oh, come on shot. I don't want to have to do. This to you. But I'm I gotta go. That's the one problem with with like our digesting of news today is entertainers now become. Purveyors and like it's kind of.
Shawn
Yeah. Have you?
Sam
We need reporters that the people that are held up as deliverers of news.
Speaker
They they become.
Matt
That's a good point.
Sam
What happened to the reporters that were critical thinkers? That that like you know?
Speaker
So name, name.
Shawn
Name two of them.
Matt
Tamara Keith. Nina Totenberg.
Shawn
All right, I'll go. I will start looking at Tamara Keith.
Matt
Tamara Keith is the president of the White House Correspondents Association. She covers the White House as well as anyone has. Nina Totenberg covers the Supreme Court. She she can tell you more about what's going on in the court Supreme Court. Than anyone in the nation.
Shawn
Just I I just want one. I'll just focus on Tamara Keith and by the by our next podcast, I will have followed Tamara Keith. That's awesome. You you, you.
Sam
Won't find them with an outsized YouTube or Facebook or LinkedIn presence.
Shawn
That's OK, I don't need.
Sam
They're right.
Matt
She's a sweet. She's a very kind. But that's the point, right? And a great reporter.
Shawn
So there you go. Part part of this mat part of our podcast should be let's promote voices that are actually doing the job, right.
Sam
And a liberal.
Matt
Yeah, that's what I think we should do.
Speaker
Right.
Shawn
So I'll go. So I will go on and I promote to our listeners to do what I'm about to do, which is take a whole week. Studying Tamara Keith. I want to hear what she has to say.
Matt
I love it this this is good.
Shawn
I wanna see if she really is.
Speaker
Wow, this is fun.
Matt
Yeah, I like it.
Sam
Are you gonna? Are you gonna are? So you're turning off Russell Brand and you're going out of.
Shawn
Oh sure, I'll take ohh sure.
Sam
The way alright, good.
Shawn
I'll take a break from Russell Brand, I'll.
Sam
Love it.
Shawn
Listen to Tamara Keith. That's awesome.
Matt
OK, I like it. Hey, guys. Great conversation. Today it was. It was kind of like. All over the place, sort of. But I liked the topics I liked. I liked Sam. What you did to Sean here and there. We say I hate to do this to you, Sean, but then you like kind. Of beat him a little bit, spank him around.
Shawn
And then gave me a hug.
Matt
That's right.
Shawn
Push me in the face and. Then give me a hug.
Matt
And if we haven't, if we haven't said it enough in our previous episodes, This is why we're doing this podcast.
Sam
That's the latter day lens.
Matt
We want to model for everybody what to do. Have these conversations with people that you love, people that you know and feel free to join in on the conversations with us. We'd love to hear from you guys in the future. Have a great day. That is all the time we have this week, but that doesn't mean the discussion is over. In fact, we include links to the stories we discussed each week in the podcast description to encourage our listeners participation. Each of you have an important perspective that builds the latter day lens and we want to hear from you. Let's continue the discussion on social media. You can find us on Instagram at latter Day lens on Twitter at Latter Day, lens on Facebook at Latter Day lens. Or you can e-mail us at the latter day lens@gmail.com all one word. Finally, please make sure you subscribe to get updated content each week. Thanks for making us one of the most listened to podcasts. We love our listeners.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories