The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
April 12, 2023: NASA, Trump Indictment, Abortion, Unequal Justice in the United States
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
- NASA announced the crew that would be flying the Artemis II mission and landing on the moon. It’s kind of exciting to have ambitious space goals again, but at the same time, this stuff is expensive. Each Artemis launch costs around $4 billion. The Artemis program at NASA will cost $93 billion over the next four years. With all of the private companies developing better technologies to send payloads to outer space, shouldn’t we spend this money elsewhere? For the cost of this program, the US government could give 9,300 people $10 million each, isn’t that a far better way to spend the money?
- I want to spend some time explaining how grand juries work, and how DAs make decisions about who and what to prosecute. There is actually some variation in this state by state. But, after I explain this, I want to discuss the Trump indictment. Is this case an example of prosecutorial overreach?
- The State of Idaho just made it a felony for someone to transport a minor across state lines to access an abortion without parental consent. Again, we probably all agree that abortion is wrong, but how do you feel about this particular law? It seems like Republicans are not being intellectually consistent. When it comes to transgender issues, they do not want to allow parents to make the choice for their children; but when it comes to abortion, they want parents to have some say in what their children do. My biggest problem with this law is that it carries with it a mandatory minimum sentence of two years. If Republicans are really worried about prosecutors overreaching, why give them a tool like this? Someone who goes on a roadtrip with a minor who ends up having an abortion along the way could easily find themselves on the wrong side of the law facing a mandatory minimum sentence. Is Idaho going too far?
Big Question:
Let’s talk about the justice system in the United States of America. For a long time, racial minorities have argued that they get the short end of the stick when it comes to equal justice in the United States because when there is some kind of a question about whether or not to charge them, they often get treated more harshly than an otherwise similar white defendant. Yet right now people seem to be upset that former President Trump was charged with a crime because they feel like political motivations are the wrong reason to indict somebody. If we think about the summer of 2020 and all of the protests relating to African Americans who were unfairly treated by law enforcement. And also think about the way that Trump supporters are talking about the indictment in New York State. Doesn't it lead to the natural conclusion that the justice system in the United States does not treat people equally? When prosecutorial decisions and decisions about who to arrest and where to arrest and who to charge and when to charge are left up to individuals, doesn't that inevitably lead to an unequal system of justice? Do we have a moral obligation to find means to make sure that everyone is treated the same under the law? Does equal justice mean that everybody must be treated the same?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Matt:
Welcome everybody to the Latter Day Lens. We're excited to get back to talking about current events this week. I'm here with Sam and Sean and I'm Matt. Again, I'd like to remind you, if you wanna interact with the show, we'd love to talk about the things you have to say in the comments. Feel free to email us, feel free to reach out on social media. We're happy to interact with you. But since we haven't had any comments from listeners, we're gonna just start with the news that I think is important. big deal. NASA this week announced the crew that would be flying the Artemis 2 mission that's going to be landing on the moon. So we're going back to the moon and if you ask them why are we going back to the moon it's because if we can learn to live on the moon then we can learn how to like go to Mars. So we've got this ambitious plan to go to Mars. Each Artemis launch, so there's three of them, one, two, three, each of those launches is expensive. They're around four billion to cost 93 billion dollars over the next four years. So if you think about all the private companies that are out there, the guy who owns Virgin Airlines, his company just declared bankruptcy, but you still have the Elon Musk stuff and you have the Amazon stuff. You have private companies trying to go to outer space. There's other countries trying to go to outer space. So it's not that I hate the idea of going to Mars and I don't see the benefits of outer space. I think that there's probably some benefits there. It's just a lot of money. Like I'm awesome at math but 93 billion dollars is enough that the US government could give 9,300 people 10 million dollars each
Sam :
Matt,
Matt:
and imagine if you did that
Sam :
Matt,
Matt:
in like a show?
Sam :
why, why are
Matt:
Yeah
Sam :
you
Matt:
yeah!
Sam :
always wanting to give the government money to the few? Like that's crazy. You want to give $10 million
Matt:
Ha!
Sam :
to 9,300 people and then what do they do?
Matt:
They would like, they could retire probably. We could like send them off. But imagine,
Sam :
Great.
Matt:
you
Sam :
10,000
Matt:
guys are entrepreneurs.
Sam :
people out of
Matt:
Imagine
Sam :
the workplace.
Matt:
if you, imagine if you, if the government just gave you 10 million dollars and said, do what you want. Couldn't you find more productive things to do with that money than going
Sam :
So.
Matt:
to the moon and going to Mars? Like, couldn't we grow our economy in substantial ways with that kind of seed money to almost 10,000 people?
Sam :
So first of all, I'm pretty passionate about this. So A, this is exactly what government should be involved in or these big projects that outsize that
shawn:
What?
Sam :
are larger than the ability of an individual to be involved in, right? And if you don't think, so one of the most successful programs right now is SpaceX, that is a government program, Matt, Sean. Like the money that the Fed has put into SpaceX has allowed SpaceX to do what it's doing. Now, the private sector does it better than government does it,
Matt:
Wait!
Sam :
provides the ability because it's so big to do it. Giving that money back
Matt:
Isn't
Sam :
to people
Matt:
SpaceX
Sam :
is insane.
Matt:
private?
Sam :
It's private, but
Matt:
SpaceX is private!
Sam :
it's private. But if you go look at it, the money that it uses to do what it does, it gets a majority of it from, Elon Musk is the master of taking federal money and turning it into private enterprise. So Tesla is
Matt:
Well
Sam :
a
Matt:
then,
Sam :
great example
Matt:
you're...
Sam :
of that. And
Matt:
You're
Sam :
so
Matt:
proving
Sam :
is SpaceX.
Matt:
my point!
Sam :
Yeah, but you want to give it
Matt:
You're
Sam :
back
Matt:
proving
Sam :
to people.
Matt:
my point! Well,
Sam :
Wait.
Matt:
I'm just not gonna force him to build
Sam :
You're...
Matt:
cars
Sam :
You're...
Matt:
or something with it. I just wanna give him money and let him do something with it.
Sam :
Yeah.
shawn:
What I-
Sam :
So
Matt:
Elon...
Sam :
there
shawn:
What
Sam :
are...
shawn:
I-
Matt:
Wait, you're telling me Elon Musk, the richest man in the world, or somewhere close to that, gets
Sam :
Yeah.
Matt:
most of his money from the federal government, and that's a good thing, but it's bad if we share it with other people.
Sam :
He would be bankrupt right now if it weren't for federal dollars. And he's talked about that
shawn:
You know
Sam :
on
shawn:
what,
Sam :
60 Minutes.
shawn:
hey, Matt,
Sam :
Ha
shawn:
Matt
Sam :
ha. Ha ha.
shawn:
and Sam, you know what I love sometimes with this podcast is my conservative capitalist friend, Sam, sometimes comes across as a big government socialist. And my other friend, Matt, Sam, you just, were
Sam :
No,
Matt:
KNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
shawn:
you
Sam :
no,
shawn:
really?
Sam :
no, no. The difference is taking public money and handing it back out ad nauseum for votes. Versus,
shawn:
Matt's talking about tax.
Sam :
so.
shawn:
Matt's talking about is tax breaks, right? Matt. That's what
Matt:
A
shawn:
you're
Matt:
TV
shawn:
talking about
Sam :
No,
Matt:
show. I'm talking about
Sam :
no,
Matt:
a TV show
Sam :
no.
Matt:
where you
Sam :
He
Matt:
win
Sam :
said,
Matt:
the money.
Sam :
he said, he said, I'm going to give 9,300 people 10 million each, and I guess they'll retire.
Matt:
Yeah!
Sam :
So now we have 9,300 people that are no longer participating in the economy, no longer coming up with great
Matt:
Well,
Sam :
ideas.
Matt:
I'm-
Sam :
So the great
shawn:
Hold
Sam :
example,
shawn:
on, man.
Sam :
I, there are areas where I'm big into government leading the way. So defense is a big one, right? Government has got to protect our sovereignty and our national interests. The other one are things like exploration. a famous Democrat, he's a friend of yours, Matt, once said
Matt:
I'm gonna
Sam :
that
Matt:
go.
Sam :
we have got to go to the moon by the end of this decade. And he provided a reason why, right? It would test our ability. It would create ingenuity that had never existed. And the space program back then in the 50s, 60s, and leading into our lifetime, paved the way for industries that never before existed. And that happened because the U S led the way in, in, uh, in its efforts to explore space. And there's a great TV that explores what, what would have happened had the Russians beaten the U S into space, it could have changed the history of the world. Had that happened, you know, our, our current state of space exploration of technology and owning so much of the marketplace in the world might not be what it is today had the U S not done that back then and, and the U S never could have done that back then. So
Matt:
I'm just thinking about the future,
Sam :
Were
Matt:
Sam.
Sam :
it not for
Matt:
And
Sam :
the
Matt:
I'm
Sam :
dollars.
Matt:
thinking
Sam :
Yeah.
Matt:
someday in the future, there's going to be an Apple TV documentary about the world's wealthiest nation, the wealthiest nation, the world has ever known that gave $10 million to 9,300 randomly selected individuals and task them with doing what they thought was best with that money. And they discovered so many things that nobody even ever would have thought of because these people don't normally have that kind of money.
shawn:
Oh my gosh, this
Matt:
Like
shawn:
is so fu-
Matt:
in a,
Sam :
You know what the test of that is? It goes back to the minimum wage law where this guy in Seattle stood up and said, hey, you know what? I want to pay everybody in my company a minimum $75,000 wage. So he provided that cost of living, that guaranteed dollar amount to the secretary, to the person cleaning the restrooms, as well as the top salespeople, and his company imploded on it. who know how to organize the efforts of other and who are focused on a goal. I'm better giving them that money and allowing them to go out and make it happen than just handing it out ad nauseam like you would like you'd like to see happening. So anyway, space program is good. That's my take.
shawn:
So, it's so funny how you guys reverse roles sometimes.
Matt:
I love the idea of giving the rich more government money because they know what to do with it better than giving it to other people.
Sam :
Elon Musk was almost bankrupt. Elon Musk would not be rich today were it not for that.
Matt:
You're proving my point. It sounds like you want to go back to the feudal system where there's no middle class. There's just the few that have everything and then all the other slaves to those people.
Sam :
hahahaha
Matt:
And we can't trust the slaves because what would they do with $10 million? We don't know.
shawn:
I think that's a good point.
Sam :
Ha!
Matt:
over and over again. We'll keep giving
Sam :
Hey,
Matt:
them their money because we trust their their
Sam :
free
Matt:
intellect.
Sam :
free
shawn:
I'm so
Sam :
market.
shawn:
confused
Sam :
I'm
shawn:
about-
Sam :
I'm glad I'm glad the government dollars came to Elon instead of going to the average person who wouldn't have been able to handle it as well. Matt,
shawn:
I had
Sam :
you
shawn:
no
Sam :
would
shawn:
idea.
Sam :
you don't trust the average person, let alone.
Matt:
No,
Sam :
You've said that on the past
Matt:
I,
Sam :
show.
Matt:
I, I, I don't trust them in so many things, but I believe in
Sam :
10
Matt:
the law
Sam :
million
Matt:
of large
Sam :
bucks,
Matt:
numbers.
Sam :
give it to him. OK.
Matt:
I believe that if I give $10 million to 9,000 people,
Sam :
Oh gosh!
Matt:
the probability,
Sam :
That just hurts my head.
Matt:
the probability that a thousand of them are going to create things that we never could have thought of before is better than if I give 93 billion to an Elon Musk. That's all I'm saying. I believe in the law of large numbers.
Sam :
So you support the lottery system basically.
Matt:
Well, the lottery is you pay in money
shawn:
Hold on, hold
Matt:
and
shawn:
on, hold
Matt:
then you
shawn:
on, hold
Matt:
hope
shawn:
on,
Matt:
to win.
shawn:
hold on, Matt, Matt, Matt. So is your solution
Sam :
Uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh
shawn:
to the question, is it really, you're not saying specifically, let's give 10 million to 9,300 people. You're simply saying
Sam :
no that's actually what he said but
shawn:
in the form of, no, I know, but I'm trying to clarify that. I don't think that's what your argument is. You're trying to say, take that money instead of
Sam :
Don't
shawn:
putting
Sam :
reframe
shawn:
it into a space
Sam :
it.
shawn:
program, put it back into people, is what you're saying. That's really what you're saying. You're not
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
saying
Matt:
I
shawn:
specifically
Matt:
think that...
shawn:
10 million to 9,300 people. You're saying-
Matt:
Yeah, I think that given where we're at in the space program now, then we can take that wealth or whatever that, I mean, it's all going to be borrowed anyways, but we can take that borrowed billions of dollars and put it to better use. That's, I love the space program. I like watching.
shawn:
But are you saying, are you taking the Republican traditional stance of cut the taxes, take that money away, close down the program, cut people's
Matt:
No,
shawn:
taxes and put
Matt:
no,
shawn:
it back into the... You're not saying.
Matt:
no, I'm saying tax the people, take their money and give
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
it to other people
shawn:
What the
Matt:
because
Sam :
because
shawn:
crap?
Matt:
they'll
Sam :
you know
Matt:
do
Sam :
best.
Matt:
better with
Sam :
Ha
Matt:
it.
Sam :
ha ha.
Matt:
Well, yeah, and so like in taxes, like it's not all taxes, we could just print the $93 billion.
shawn:
him.
Matt:
You could just credit their accounts. You don't actually have to
shawn:
Hey,
Matt:
tax people.
shawn:
so Matt and Sam, I have a question for you. You guys know who Milton Friedman is, right? Of course.
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
Okay, so he had a famous anecdote for how to spend money. And obviously we're the latter day lens. So we have to tie this into principles and what informs our opinions here. Cause both of you just spewed off political ideas about
Matt:
No, no, mine's
shawn:
space
Matt:
informed
shawn:
and.
Matt:
by morality. Jesus said, take from the rich and give to the poor.
shawn:
He did
Matt:
I
shawn:
not.
Matt:
don't remember, I think
shawn:
He
Matt:
it's
shawn:
did
Matt:
in
shawn:
not
Matt:
Moroni
shawn:
say that.
Matt:
chapter 11. I think it was Moroni 11.
Sam :
Sean,
Matt:
No.
Sam :
let
shawn:
You
Sam :
Sean,
shawn:
can't quote.
Sam :
let Sean, let's
shawn:
Matt,
Sam :
stay
shawn:
that
Sam :
on
shawn:
is
Sam :
this.
shawn:
wrong.
Sam :
Let's, let's,
shawn:
No scripture says that.
Sam :
let's stay on this though. I looked this up. Elon Musk got a $2.6 billion contract from the federal government to build a rocket that could successfully take people up to the space station. And as a result, he did that. He, the free market allowed that to happen. Would you rather have Elon Musk get $2.6 billion to do that or, 9,600 people give them 10 million each and just see what happens. That's crazy.
shawn:
But Sam, but your assumption that Elon Musk making a rocket that can self-land is the best use of anyone's resources.
Sam :
No, no,
shawn:
You
Sam :
no.
shawn:
like
Sam :
By
shawn:
the
Sam :
the
shawn:
space
Sam :
way,
shawn:
program, but
Sam :
it
shawn:
I
Sam :
wasn't
shawn:
don't think
Sam :
self-land.
shawn:
everyone does.
Sam :
That happened as a result of the contract. The contract was, there was a contest and it was to win this $2.6 billion
shawn:
But I don't
Sam :
contest.
shawn:
care. What a waste of money.
Sam :
I care.
shawn:
What a stupid program,
Matt:
Yes!
shawn:
Sam. What
Matt:
Yes!
shawn:
a waste of money.
Sam :
Wait, are you serious Sean? Are you kidding?
shawn:
Who cares?
Sam :
Oh!
shawn:
Tell me what, tell me specific, well no I'm not kidding.
Sam :
Mmm.
shawn:
You tell me,
Sam :
Okay.
shawn:
tell me, you said you watched the documentary. What are the benefits of any space program?
Matt:
Velcro Velcro
Sam :
Yeah, Velcro.
Matt:
Powdered drinks, you
Sam :
I'm
Matt:
know,
Sam :
sorry.
Matt:
like those flavored powdered things that you put
shawn:
So
Matt:
in a whole
shawn:
Sam, if those are the things,
Sam :
Wait,
shawn:
I'm going to have to
Matt:
Tang
shawn:
go on
Sam :
seriously?
shawn:
Matt's side here because those things, you didn't need all those wasted resources to get to the moon to create those things. Private citizens would have created those things. You don't
Sam :
Actually,
shawn:
need
Sam :
that's, that
shawn:
$10
Sam :
is completely
shawn:
billion.
Sam :
untrue. It is a
Matt:
There
Sam :
well-known,
Matt:
was nobody thinking of Tang.
Sam :
it is a well-known fact. So listen, satellite technology came as a result of the space
Matt:
Yeah?
Sam :
program,
Matt:
Yeah?
Sam :
advanced materials,
shawn:
Did it.
Sam :
including lightweight alloys, heat resistant materials have been not only developed, but perfected medical advances, including those that study, uh, the body and weightless conditions, robotics and automate automation, environmental monitoring,
shawn:
Are you Matt
Sam :
which
shawn:
or
Sam :
Matt
shawn:
Sam?
Sam :
should love. Like there's a long,
shawn:
Sam?
Sam :
if you
shawn:
Sam?
Sam :
could.
shawn:
Do
Sam :
You
shawn:
you
Sam :
can't
shawn:
really think that
Sam :
argue
shawn:
satellites
Sam :
that
shawn:
wouldn't
Sam :
the
shawn:
have been
Sam :
space
shawn:
created?
Sam :
program's been a waste of money. That's insane.
Matt:
What I'm arguing is I believe
Sam :
Have you
Matt:
in
Sam :
seen
Matt:
human
Sam :
the movie?
Matt:
ingenuity.
Sam :
Have you seen the movie hidden figures? Have you seen how people that are disenfranchised
Matt:
I
Sam :
minorities have come together to help contribute to a cause and a goal greater than themselves?
Matt:
What I'm saying is this, when I was a kid and I watched Back to the Future, part two, and they had hoverboards where
Sam :
Oh,
Matt:
they were actually floating on those skateboards
Sam :
I got
Matt:
and
Sam :
to go
Matt:
they
Sam :
back
Matt:
were going
Sam :
to
Matt:
to
Sam :
work.
Matt:
be there in like 30, 40 years.
Sam :
Yeah.
Matt:
I said to myself, this is, this is what we can do. Like we can invent hoverboards, flying cars, but instead we focused on the space program and we get Velcro and we get Tang because when you have government directed
Sam :
satellites
Matt:
programs,
Sam :
and alloys
Matt:
the government, I get a phone that I hold in my hand. I want a
Sam :
osteoporosis
Matt:
hoverboard Sam
Sam :
and
Matt:
and what I'm
Sam :
muscle atrophy.
Matt:
if I could get like If I could get like these these kids that are so creative Sitting in their basements and I give them ten million dollars
Sam :
Oh
Matt:
and
Sam :
no!
Matt:
I say
Sam :
No!
Matt:
make
Sam :
No!
Matt:
the future bright I can I'm trusting them instead of the space
Sam :
Oh!
Matt:
program
Sam :
Oh!
Matt:
that makes me it gets all these weird inventions like powdered drinks And stuff who cares about that?
shawn:
So.
Matt:
thought about that before we chose this topic. He really loves his space shuttle, but
Sam :
Listen,
Matt:
I'm telling
Sam :
wait,
Matt:
you.
Sam :
there's more. Wait.
Matt:
If Sean had a hoverboard in his, like a real hoverboard, not the fake ones we have now, if he had a real hoverboard that he could like stand on and do skateboard tricks, he would be holding that instead of these models of space things.
shawn:
Okay, so I'm hearing some major bias. I'm seeing now some major
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
bias
Matt:
sorry.
shawn:
in these conversations. Sam, I didn't know Sam was a space nut
Matt:
Thanks for watching!
shawn:
and Matt is clearly a government nut. So now I see
Matt:
Ha ha!
shawn:
the content. So
Sam :
You're not
shawn:
can
Sam :
gonna
shawn:
I
Sam :
win
shawn:
ask
Sam :
this
shawn:
a question?
Sam :
debate with me. So anyway,
shawn:
Can
Sam :
yes.
shawn:
I ask a real question then, Matt?
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
Cause
Sam :
Yeah.
Matt:
yeah.
shawn:
there's, isn't the real question. Sam, I'm gonna ask a real question here instead of you guys talking about
Matt:
Hahaha
shawn:
your space, your model spaceship. Isn't the question here, of money. Isn't that
Sam :
No,
shawn:
the question?
Sam :
it's not.
shawn:
Yes it is because we're the Latter-day Lens. We're not talking about politics and space programs, Sam. We're
Matt:
Well
shawn:
talking
Matt:
I want to know
shawn:
about
Matt:
Shawn,
shawn:
gospel
Matt:
does
shawn:
principles.
Matt:
God care? Does God actually care?
shawn:
Well, so for example, we pay tithing, right? And obviously he
Matt:
Yeah?
shawn:
cares because he takes that sacred offering and he calls prophets and apostles and a group of inspired women and men to decide how that money gets collectively spent or invested by the way, right? So I think God does care. So...
Matt:
About government money though?
shawn:
No, I'm not asking about government money. I'm just saying collective money. Is there a are
Matt:
Mmm.
shawn:
there principles that govern the wise use of collective money? I mean, that's sacred money, right? My taxes, your taxes, that's sacred money. People work their butts off. They work hard. They sacrifice. And that money should be treated somewhat sacred. Well, that's that's that's the I mean, ask my friends who scrape a living. And those taxes mean life and death for them, not life and death. They mean
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
a lot to them. And so that's sacred money. And so these people,
Matt:
Wow. I've never,
shawn:
well...
Matt:
I've never thought of that before, Sean, that government money is something that should be treated like with care and we should be careful how we spend it and thoughtful about what we take. I've,
shawn:
Are you
Matt:
seriously,
shawn:
serious?
Matt:
I've never thought of that before,
shawn:
Why? Why not?
Matt:
uh, cause it's a collective choice. There's winners and losers at all. I was just so happy that I found a topic that Sam's willing to spend government money on. I was like, yes,
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
eventually
shawn:
yeah.
Matt:
you can bring someone to your government side if you find something
Sam :
Space,
Matt:
they're passionate about.
Sam :
space
Matt:
It's,
shawn:
That's fascinating.
Sam :
and defense.
shawn:
That's true.
Matt:
It's just collective action. It's just like, it's
shawn:
Wow.
Matt:
when you, when you agree to live in a society, you agree like, like to these collective goals that there's freedoms I'm going to give up and there's things I'm going to get in return and there's things I'm going to give up. And taxes is just the price you pay for living in a free society. So I've never thought at all about like, if there's a moral or appropriate way to spend tax dollars, that just always seems to me like a collective choice. Thanks for watching. Bye.
shawn:
I feel like it's a sacred thing, right? Because my friend who's paying their taxes religiously and works very, very hard, but doesn't make a ton of money, who, man, it's a huge sacrifice to give up that money, but they gladly do it because they're part of our society. To me,
Matt:
Em.
shawn:
a politician being out of touch and deciding how to spend that money on things that are, I don't know, I think it's sacred money. I think God wants us to treat that money really seriously. There's a lot of parables. they're meant to just teach principles, but God talks a lot in the scriptures about increase, about stewardship.
Matt:
Sure. I always think of that as gospel stuff, or individual life stuff. I've never thought about that in terms of politics.
shawn:
Yeah, but money, I mean, some of those, I mean, you know, the...
Matt:
Yeah, well, so I do think that we should use government money to help the poor. I guess
shawn:
Yes,
Matt:
that would
shawn:
you
Matt:
be
shawn:
do.
Matt:
the motivation behind that, but
shawn:
Yes, yes, you do believe that.
Matt:
well, let's move to another topic. This is, this has been fascinating. And I'm really glad we found out how much Sam loves the space program.
shawn:
Hahaha
Matt:
I didn't know it before.
Sam :
No question.
Matt:
I mean, it's right there, but it's right there behind him every single time we talk. I
Sam :
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Matt:
don't know how I didn't pick up on all of the cues, but Trump is in the news. heard about this, but Trump was recently indicted on 34 felony counts in the state of New York. Before we talk about it a little bit, I just want to explain a little bit how grand juries work because some listeners might not be familiar with the process.
shawn:
This will be
Matt:
So
shawn:
interesting.
Matt:
there are.
shawn:
I think most of us don't know. So this will be interesting.
Matt:
So there's some states like the state of Utah, for example, a person who is the prosecuting attorney or the district attorney in an area, they look at the evidence and then they make a decision if somebody should be charged with a crime or not be charged with a crime. And then that person...
shawn:
A single person makes that decision.
Matt:
Yeah, usually it's a process. I mean, it depends on the state, but yeah, it would typically be the district attorney.
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
And then in those states, you have what's called a preliminary hearing. So after you've been arrested within 24 hours or quickly, anyways, there's various like time, but it's usually like 24 hours, you have to go before a judge and the judge looks at that evidence and they say, yes, there's sufficient evidence here that this person should be charged with this and we can set a trial date and we'll have this thing go to trial. other states they say we don't like the idea of having one person have all that power. So if you're a district attorney and you want to charge someone with a crime you have to call a grand jury and a grand jury is individuals in the community get randomly selected and called to jury service and you're called for a period of time and the district attorney can present evidence to the grand jury and they say here's the evidence we have here's what we want to individuals without law degrees, they look at the evidence and then they decide, yes, there's sufficient evidence here for you to charge a person with a crime. So in the case of New York and Atlanta, because that's going to come up later on in the state of Georgia, charges are brought by grand juries. You can do it the other way in New York, but in Trump's case what happened was there's a district attorney, clearly an elected position, who I heard him campaign on the that Trump needed to be prosecuted. He found evidence that he thought constituted a crime, so he went before the grand jury and showed all of his evidence to these people, and then those people are the ones that decided that yes, there's enough evidence here to charge Trump with these 34 felony counts, but just because the grand jury says there's enough evidence doesn't mean that the district attorney has to charge. They could still say at that point, I don't want to charge him with the crime, but in this particular case after that all came back from the grand jury, the district attorney said, yeah, there's sufficient evidence here and I'm going to charge him with 34 counts of these felonies. And then, then he indicted Trump and so then Trump came and um, so that's where we are now.
shawn:
That's fascinating.
Matt:
So yeah, so based on kind of that background knowledge of what's going on, um, I kind of want to hear your reaction. So I've heard like all, you can almost predict exactly what a person is going to say if you know a But I do hear there's some Democrats that say that the district attorney overreached and he shouldn't have charged Trump with this crime There's some Democrats that say Trump is guilty and should be in jail right now There's Republicans that say that this is all a political process and never should have happened in the first place So like based on what you guys have heard in the news What is your perspective on what's going on with Trump and these 34 indictments? Is it appropriate? Is it political is it the kind of thing we should support in society or is that something we should say? wrong nation be doing that.
shawn:
Well I guess the question
Sam :
Ye-
shawn:
is... Oh go ahead Sam.
Sam :
Go ahead, you go ahead, I'll come up after.
shawn:
I mean, the question is, I guess, I like that our society has, you know, everyone gets their day in court if they're accused of something. Isn't that the process that it's never going to be 100% fair or equitable? Never just
Matt:
but.
shawn:
because humans are biased and it's hard for us to do that. But it's a pretty decent system, isn't it, in America?
Matt:
But Sean, we've never never before has a, a former president of the United States been indicted. Right? So this is the first time that you have to worry about like secret service protection for an individual who might be going to jail. So some people say maybe there should be a little bit higher bar for something like that.
shawn:
I feel like if I don't understand, I've never understood that if why there'd be special political protections for people who break the law. I don't understand that. So I think that if the court case will reveal if a law was actually broken, right, and then the justice system will determine whether it's whether he's guilty or not. I mean, why is why is the president any different than an individual?
Matt:
Well, so another side of it is there's a lot of crime going on in New York City. And as a district attorney, you have to decide what you're going to fight, who you're going to put in jail, who you're not going to put in jail. And if you choose to go after a former president, you know that that's going to be an expensive case, a high-profile case. Just think about all of the court staff that had to stand there and keep the media out for that hearing. So
shawn:
But
Matt:
as
shawn:
if
Matt:
a district
shawn:
it's...
Matt:
attorney, if you're choosing to do that, you're all at the I'm not going to spend those resources on these other crimes that are happening in my city.
shawn:
So if he's innocent and is not convicted, then maybe you can look at the district attorney and saying, wow, you were more politically motivated than you were justice, right? But if he's guilty, then you can look at the district attorney or whoever it is and say, or the grand jury and say, well done, you found someone who
Matt:
Oh,
shawn:
broke the law and you can, right?
Matt:
so you're just saying it's too early to tell.
shawn:
I think so. Yeah. Let's see if he's guilty. Let's see if there's evidence and if it's clear and if he's guilty. What do you think Sam?
Sam :
You know, uh, as Matt described the setup on this, I knew that he ran on the platform of bringing Trump to account for this, but I'd never put two and two together in this way. The, the grand jury system is supposed to be not politically motivated, right? Well, this guy ran
Matt:
Right.
Sam :
to bring him down and then he went and he's in the process of bringing him down that by its very nature is political. And listen, I I've said it before. Like I think he probably did some great things in office, but he has no filter. And you know, he, he, he, on the, on the global stage and also here in the U S is kind of defined down the level of rhetoric and in multiple areas. So I, you know, I'm a little bit frustrated by the action because I think it, you know, I almost feel like it ensures Dems a good run at the next election because it's going to split the Republicans. He's one of the most polarizing characters we have politically. know, is it
Matt:
So
Sam :
right
Matt:
you...
Sam :
that one person could turn this into a political circus that ends up handing an election to the Democrats? And, and, you know, I think that's unfortunate. I mean, it's, it's a sideshow.
shawn:
Sam, would you feel the same way if he's guilty, if the evidence is presented and
Sam :
You know,
shawn:
he's actually guilty?
Sam :
you know what, with what he's accused of, who cares? Like there's a process to handle it. And I've said this on the show before, too. If he did what he said he was supposed to have done, let the process take care of itself. And and he probably
shawn:
That's what I
Sam :
did
shawn:
mean. The
Sam :
it.
shawn:
process,
Sam :
He probably
shawn:
if,
Sam :
did it.
shawn:
but that's what I'm
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
saying. But Sam,
Sam :
And
Matt:
so...
shawn:
as
Sam :
people,
shawn:
I'm saying, the process
Sam :
people have.
shawn:
would be, if he broke
Sam :
Yeah.
shawn:
that law, he should be indicted and then given a fair day in court. And if he's guilty of it, doesn't that somewhat contradict, not contradict,
Sam :
Here,
shawn:
but doesn't that go in
Sam :
here,
shawn:
the face of your argument
Sam :
here.
shawn:
that this was all politically motivated?
Sam :
Here's the problem. Here's the problem. When you're the president of the United States of America, and there's so much more focus on you, the penalty for having done what he is said to have done is going to end up being much greater than the crime probably merits, right? Like I there's a whole conversation going on politically about, hey, somebody should have picked a better one to bring them up on first. And some of the things that are going on in Georgia with him trying to, you know, impact the election between he and Biden, trying to find electors and trying to get people to, you know, refuse to, to, to confirm him, him, you know, Biden into office. Those things are severe. And if those are true, those probably merit the type of penalties that are happening here. I just, I have a tough time seeing, this conversation about him and Stormy Daniels out of the press. I just don't see how
Matt:
Well,
Sam :
it's worth it.
Matt:
so yeah, so here's my problem with it is the falsifying business records. It's basically 34 counts of falsifying business records. And as I read each indictment, I'm like, we already know about all of these because Michael Cohen brought all the evidence to Congress. We've seen all of the evidence of
Sam :
Yep.
Matt:
falsifying business records. And Michael Cohen went to jail for falsifying those business records.
Sam :
Yep.
Matt:
business records that we already know about because that evidence is already public. What feels politically motivated is that he decided to make them felonies by saying, well, they were falsifying business records to cover up another crime. And then now it's what's the evidence of the other crime? And it's either Stormy Daniels or he says there's some other things, some new evidence that's been brought to light. So what feels politically motivated to me is to say two misdemeanors, right? A misdemeanor we're going to prove later on. I wish that if you're gonna go after somebody, go after the easy stuff. I hate it when prosecutors overreach, and it feels like in this case the prosecutor's trying to make more out of it than what he could easily have done, because he's like got some kind of a beef with Trump or something like that. So to me, that's the part that feels like something that shouldn't happen in our system. Get
Sam :
Is
shawn:
you
Matt:
him
Sam :
it,
Matt:
on the 34 misdemeanors.
Sam :
is it right that a DA can run for political office on a promise to bring down a president and that such
Matt:
Well...
Sam :
a small population, such a small population can vote him in to do just that and then have him do that. I mean, that does feel politically motivating,
Matt:
But,
Sam :
right?
Matt:
but if you hear his, his actual speech, and I'm not, I'm not going to say that it wasn't part of his campaign to bring, but he never said in his campaign, I'm going to bring down president Trump. He said, I have experienced prosecuting Trump in the past. I'm up to the task. I can do it. So I agree. Like, of course you don't want to have people running on, I'm going to bring down the president. And of course you don't want to set a precedent where people can be ambitious in certain regions and say, I'm going to go after former presidents because thing for our American system. But I'm not sure that that's exactly what's happening here. Although it is true that his supporters really, really like that he indicted Trump on 34 felonies.
shawn:
Okay, so Matt, you feel like it's politically motivated and therefore pretty kind of.
Matt:
I guess what I would say is
shawn:
Thank
Matt:
this,
shawn:
you.
Matt:
every single district attorney is politically motivated and this kind of thing happens all the time and it really bothers me because I feel like whenever somebody runs for office, district attorney as an office, these ambitious lawyers, how do you get elected to a higher office or how do you get to be a judge by showing you're tough on crime, by showing you don't let anybody get away with stuff. politically motivated. I do feel like they harm individuals. I would be happy if this stuff with Trump brought more attention to that process and how kind of innately unfair it can be at times. But I don't think that he that Alvin Bragg really thinks to himself that he's the guy that's going to actually
shawn:
Thank
Matt:
put Trump
shawn:
you.
Matt:
in jail. Even if Trump's convicted of all 34 of these counts, he's not spending time in jail.
Sam :
No,
shawn:
to Matt where
Sam :
but
shawn:
the...
Sam :
the damage, it doesn't matter. It doesn't matter if he goes to jail or not, the damage or the impact, he is gonna be probably one of the most, that decision will end up being one of the most impactful decisions for the next presidential election, no matter the outcome.
Matt:
Well, let's move to another topic because I just can't, I just can't get enough of these abortion cases. These laws that are getting passed in states, I just don't know what to make of it. And this one comes from my home state of Idaho. This is fresh off the books. They just passed a law that makes it a felony for somebody to transport a minor across state lines to access an abortion without parental consent. So again, and by the way, it carries with it a mandatory minimum sentence of two years in jail. I think again, we all agree that abortion is wrong and we should try to think of ways to prevent abortion. But this particular law just seems so misguided to me. It seems like, and also it seems like Republicans aren't intellectually consistent because the state of Idaho also passed a law that said parents cannot give their minor children gender-affirming drugs if they want to. So it's like, okay, if you want, as a parent, if you want to drive a kid across state lines to get an abortion, well, that's okay. But if you give your kid gender-affirming drugs, well that's not okay. So it seems like really weird to me. Like on the one hand they're like well we should just trust parents and on the other hand they're like but we can't trust parents. And I think the thing that bothers me most about this law is you know there you can get an abortion just by getting pills right. There's pills that you could take that would help you have an abortion. So imagine you live in Boise, you're like some teenagers and you're gonna go on a trip to Portland or something like that. And while you're in Portland one of your friends goes to the pharmacy and take some drug and has an abortion or maybe they get an abortion while they're there in Portland. You don't even know about it, but you're the one that's driving the car as they're traveling like you're having this weekend outing. Now suddenly you get back to the state of Idaho and they say, did you tell her parents that she was going to have an abortion? And now you're faced with a mandatory minimum sentence of two years in prison for helping some kid get an abortion. Like none of this stuff makes any sense to me at all. a good idea.
shawn:
Matt, can I ask, what do you think is the motivation? Like if I read in the scriptures about the constitution or whatever form of government God wants, he says the free exercise of conscience, the right and control of property, and the protection of life. Do you think that the motivation behind the law is a bunch of conservative people going, hey, let's make it even, like, okay, we've passed the, we've made abortion illegal in our state, let's even go further and stop people
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
from leaving our state. So it's there, do you think it's a righteous intent implication of or execution of how to do it.
Matt:
I think a hundred percent it's motivated by morality, right? In
shawn:
Okay.
Matt:
Idaho you're bordered by Nevada, Oregon, and Washington and Utah, not that that helps on the other side. You got some other conservative States, but yeah, it's like a lot of the population in Idaho lives within an hour's drive of Oregon. So they say, well, we made abortion illegal in Idaho, but that doesn't sufficiently protect life if somebody could just leave and go to another state and have an abortion. And I think there's this image of like a teenage girl who's pregnant and then goes and has an abortion. parents didn't ever know about it and the parents should have had some say or some opportunity. I think it's like I think it's guided by this like parental concern and concern about life.
shawn:
So isn't this the interesting, to me, the interesting thing when you study scripture about what government should be? And it says things like restrain crime, but never control conscience, like punish guilt, but never suppress the freedom of the soul. I think those are righteous principles that come from scripture. And I always go, yeah, it's a little gray, right? It sounds like it's giving humans, like some people are going to err on the side of restrain crime and punish guilt. Others are gonna err on the side of not controlling conscience and not suppressing freedom of the soul, right? And so to me, isn't the United States in a fascinating experiment on allowing those two things to coexist? In other words, let states decide certain things so that if I choose to live in a state that is more strict, I can be there. If I choose a state that's a little more lenient, I can be there. So to me, it's
Matt:
Hmph.
shawn:
a good system to say, hey, Idaho, if you've passed laws, stay in your lane. control not what people do if they want to go to another state.
Matt:
Uh huh. What do
shawn:
I
Matt:
you
shawn:
don't
Matt:
say
shawn:
know.
Matt:
Sam? You've lived in Boise.
Sam :
You know what, Idaho is a wonderful place to live. So it would be interesting to get in their head and understand a little bit more why I'm not a fan of legislating. You know, it's not even trying to put morality into it. It's trying to like, catch all the loopholes, right? That's one of the challenges. You know, we, we, we talked to Dr. them. It's like saying, hey, we want to ban an outlaw abortion, but then we also want to take away any ancillary way or right or ability to go seek that outside the state. And I don't know, I'm just
shawn:
It
Sam :
not
shawn:
feels
Sam :
a fan
shawn:
like
Sam :
of
shawn:
overreach.
Sam :
that. And you know what's interesting is the LDS position on abortion, I think is much more progressive than other Christian conservative churches. We believe in
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam :
where evangelical and some of the other Christian religions are very black and white. And I think it's, I think that's a challenge. I think, I think, you know, in the greater Christian world, politically speaking nationwide, you know, when you become so black and white and you want to, it reminds me of a line from Man's Search. Oh, there's a great book.
Matt:
for meaning, man
Sam :
No,
Matt:
search for
Sam :
no,
Matt:
happiness.
Sam :
no, no, no, no, no, no. I got to remember what the, there's a great movie
Matt:
A man for all seasons?
Sam :
Man for all seasons. Yeah. Yeah. How did you get that out of that?
Matt:
That's
Sam :
And
Matt:
your favorite show, Sam.
shawn:
Thanks for watching!
Sam :
so, oh, have I talked about that before?
shawn:
Lots.
Matt:
Yeah, yeah.
shawn:
Yes you have.
Sam :
Okay.
Matt:
Yes, you've mentioned it.
Sam :
All right, fine. All right. I'm not going to throw out the quote, but, but, but the main character in that movie talks about how laws can be created for initially good intent, and then they can be used against you later on. And I think that's a great example. If, if, if the conservative Christian right becomes so black and white, some of these things are going to come back to haunt them later, because it's an overreach
Matt:
So,
Sam :
on behavior
Matt:
yeah.
Sam :
that I think is not intended by the people that want to put it in place.
Matt:
So there was a survey that was just done by PRRI, Public Religion Research Institute, and they look at attitudes about abortion by religious affiliation. And it's interesting, most religious Americans approve of abortion in some situations. There's only three religious groups that are opposed to abortion in most situations. And that's members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, white evangelical Christians, evangelical Christians and then Jehovah's Witnesses. So there's another moral question here, which is if we live in a society with religious diversity and we believe that the federal government should not impose religion on society, right? Like there should not be a state religion and the religions in society don't even agree about policy. To me there's this question of religious freedom. We like to talk about the importance of And when certain, when people of certain religious perspectives impose their religious views as policy so that people of other religious persuasions can't even live their religion the way that they think that, like from their own perspective, that's
Sam :
Yes.
Matt:
a problem too because some of these laws you cannot follow our handbook on abortion. We can't, there are members of our church that could prayerfully decide that abortion is the thing Heavenly Father wants me to do in this situation based on the guidance they received from their bishop and they would not be able to have that abortion in their state or in the case of Idaho and another state.
shawn:
So Matt, I think that,
Matt:
That's a problem.
shawn:
yeah, but I think that's why maybe this, what's it called, Matt, a republic that has states that have self-governance
Matt:
Federalism?
shawn:
or not so, that's called federalism.
Matt:
I think that's what we call it.
shawn:
I don't know if that's inspired by God to set it up like that or if this
Matt:
Well,
shawn:
is just where we landed. I know we can discuss.
Matt:
President Oaks says that's one of the inspired things in the Constitution. In General Conference.
shawn:
Yeah, well, we have a debate on whether that's exactly what he was saying or not. But
Matt:
That's
shawn:
my
Matt:
right.
shawn:
point is this, my point is this, the DNC, so our scripture says that all governments have a right to enact such laws as in their own judgment are best calculated to secure the public interest, and at the same time, however, holding sacred the freedom of conscience. So some states lean on the side of, you know, certain dogmatic laws that are in the public interest and others on the side of, Isn't that perhaps a good idea as to, hey, we live in a country that ultimately is trying to provide good laws for our society, but also give us ultimate amount of freedom. But it's a little different state by state. Isn't that a good solution, Matt? That compromises and says, okay, if Idaho is too strict on the subject, go. Go to Oregon. If Oregon's too loose and too immoral on the subject, go to Idaho.
Matt:
I like it when you have the last word, Sean. We're gonna now move on to the big question. So it's back to the justice system in the United States of America. So for a long time, racial minorities have been arguing that they get the short end of the stick when it comes to equal justice in the United States, because it feels like there's, when there's this question about whether to charge or whether to not charge, that racial minorities get treated more harshly than white people do. will cite to me crime statistics and they'll say look at these crime statistics, black people are committing more crimes than white people and I say no no no, when you look at crime statistics those are the people that have been charged and arrested, those decisions are made by people with authority that don't have to charge an arrest. So you can't necessarily look at crime statistics as a reflection of true crime because there's more crimes that get committed than get prosecuted. And if you think back to the summer of 2020 and anger among racial minorities that they're not getting treated fairly in the justice system. Now with President Trump you seem to have it on this other side. These people saying the justice system is persecuting us because we're conservative and they're just going after Trump for political purposes and so I wonder doesn't this lead to the natural conclusion that the justice system in the United States does not treat people equally? When we think of justice there's the the woman holding the scales and she's got the blindfold because in the United States justice is blind and everybody is treated equally, but it seems like it's not actually true that everybody's treated equally. What I think though is true is that not everybody is treated the same. So my question is if we have a system of justice that doesn't treat everybody exactly the same, does that mean we have an unequal justice system? Like do you have to have everybody is treated the same in order for it to be just and fair? where everybody's not treated exactly the same because after all we're different people.
shawn:
question.
Sam :
I don't think, I think it's a little bit of a reach to try to compare Trump and his prosecution with, uh, you know, minorities and things that would happen in court with them. I think Trump's prosecution has everything to do with him being a former president in United States and again, going back to brag and his promise to hold him accountable and then all the political motivations that are behind that. And I disagree
shawn:
Thanks for watching!
Sam :
with it completely. Um, but, but I do think our, uh, system is challenged because the people that have less money and less resources have an inferior access to justice, not withstanding, you know, courts usually paying, you know, if you're indigent for defense, the level of defense is just different, right?
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam :
I do love who's, is it Murdaugh, the guy that was just found guilty?
Matt:
Yeah,
Sam :
I love
Matt:
Alex
Sam :
that he,
Matt:
Murnau in South Carolina.
Sam :
I love that he was found guilty. Can you imagine how terrible that would have been that because of his position and because money. He had somehow gotten off from a charge where it was just screaming that he was guilty.
Matt:
But you know Sam, like in the summer of 2020 when a lot of, when it was very publicized, these African Americans who were being killed while they were defenseless, I, a lot of my friends would say to me, listen, just obey the law and you're not going to have these problems. Listen, just comply with the police and you're not going to have these problems. Or if they weren't committing crimes, they wouldn't have to worry about all of this. But now when it's like one of their own that's having problems with the law, now all of the justice system's biased. So
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
it
shawn:
that's
Matt:
feels
shawn:
hypocrisy.
Matt:
like some people want, Yeah, seems like some people are trying to have it both ways.
shawn:
Hypocrisy,
Sam :
I get,
shawn:
absolutely.
Sam :
again, I don't think you can bring Trump into it, but I think there is something to what you're saying. If you go into YouTube and you start searching, you start watching YouTube videos about traffic stops and how people are treated, there is definitely a difference based on your, based on your, you know, whether you're a minority or the color of your skin. And I think the fact that a lot of those are on YouTube and those are in the public forum and people can watch, don't you think that's slowly changing it over time? I hope it's getting better. the case or not. I don't have any access to it. I don't have any expertise on it. But
shawn:
I mean, it does seem like
Sam :
I wouldn't
shawn:
20
Sam :
compare
shawn:
years
Sam :
it with
shawn:
ago.
Sam :
Trump. Go ahead. Sorry, Sean.
shawn:
But it does, to your point, Sam, it does seem, Matt, and you tell me, it seems like 20 years ago it was out of the question for a policeman to be convicted of a murder
Matt:
Mm-hmm.
shawn:
in the line of duty. Whereas now it's happening. It's happening all the time, which it is just, right? If
Matt:
if they
shawn:
a police,
Matt:
committed a crime.
shawn:
if they commit a crime, then they should be prosecuted and they are starting to be prosecuted. So it does seem like, I don't know, Sam, if it's what you said, the videos and the public ability to record
Matt:
Well
shawn:
this
Matt:
sure,
shawn:
stuff. is affectment.
Matt:
without that footage of George Floyd getting killed on camera, I don't think those police officers ever would have been convicted of that. So there is
shawn:
Right,
Sam :
That's right.
shawn:
yeah.
Matt:
increased footage. I think that has some role to play, but the reason I think Trump is important is because he shows why it's unequal. Because if I'm rich, forget that he's a former president of the United States, if I'm rich, if I'm
Sam :
It's.
Matt:
connected, if I have friends in high places, I will get treated differently by the justice system.
shawn:
Correct. Yep. That's
Sam :
I just
shawn:
wrong.
Sam :
disagree. I mean, I think a Trump wouldn't have been pro. You know, people are going to go after Trump, whether it was Obama or Trump.
Matt:
Well, like, but- I don't know, like, it's just, yeah, I have a hard time wrapping my head around that, Sam, that Trump is not treated differently because of his wealth. Or pick any of the other billionaires in the United States of America
Sam :
Well, wait,
Matt:
who have the access to attorneys and-
Sam :
are you saying wealth or color?
Matt:
I'm saying that wealth is definitely a part of it and then I think regionally color of your skin matters a lot because if you there are just some communities where if you're
shawn:
So,
Matt:
African-American there's
shawn:
to Matt.
Matt:
there's you're just treated
Sam :
So
Matt:
differently
Sam :
if you're saying wealth, I agree 100%.
shawn:
But Matt, isn't this the deeper question? The deeper question is this, how do you, your main question, does equal justice mean that everybody must be treated the same? Obviously
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
that does, right? It does, absolutely. How do you, is that an impossible, it's impossible to implement, isn't it, when it relies on human beings who in most cases or many cases think they're doing the right thing, but because of bias or because of ignorance or whatever it is, or poor judgment at the time, they're making the wrong decisions does impede on someone's liberty. So.
Matt:
Yeah, so I think this is the way, one way that wealth influences it. Who are the judges in the United States of America? They're pulled from a certain class of people that have a certain level of education and they live in certain neighborhoods and they're going to see the world from the perspective of where they live, who their friends are and all of that stuff. So if I'm rich and my neighbor's a judge and my kid does something wrong, I can go to my neighbor as a friend and say, Hey, what should I do? Like how do I handle this situation? I'm making arguments we have the same worldview, we kind of see things the same way. Whereas a person who maybe doesn't speak that same language or lives in a different neighborhood, they're just they're from a different side of the tracks, let's say. And so you get treated differently, not because of your money, but because of
shawn:
But
Matt:
your
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
money.
shawn:
are you trying to make this discussion about wealth? Because if you take it down to a lower level, take a policeman who has some racist bias maybe and pulls over a black person and abuses them for wrong reasons, that has nothing to do with wealth. That just has to do with ignorance or bias. So are you trying to make this discussion about wealth?
Matt:
It's just about the whole, like to me, there's just like Trump to me, what's happening with Trump and the way that some people are rallying around him saying he should not be charged.
shawn:
Hmm.
Matt:
And then I compare that with what happens in other communities in the United States. I say, this screams to me that people are not treated the same with our justice system. At the same
Sam :
Alright.
Matt:
time, I want to have faith in our justice system.
Sam :
Matt, are you trying to say
shawn:
Yeah.
Sam :
that a Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, when he took trips with a Republican mega donor and decided not to disclose those, that those could have been, you know, influence
Matt:
Possibly biased, possibly
Sam :
bias?
Matt:
biased. Yeah, right,
Sam :
Yeah. Money
Matt:
yeah.
Sam :
wields bias. I'm just, I'm not, I don't buy the whole Trump connection because I think that's a whole big exception. But there is no question that in politics and in justice, money helps. a little less this year than it has in the past. Murdaugh's a good example of that and some others. And I think all of social media and some of the transparency that comes as a result of what happens on social media and that the instances you bring up are good examples. Hopefully that helps as well. It'd be great to think that one day justice is more equal. You know, it would.
Matt:
I'm a bit of a court TV buff, so I spend way too much time watching trials on court TV, so I
Sam :
Gwyneth
Matt:
watch almost
Sam :
Paltrow?
Matt:
all of Alex Murdoch's
Sam :
Did you
Matt:
trial.
Sam :
watch
shawn:
Matt,
Sam :
Gwyneth
Matt:
I watched
shawn:
it's
Sam :
Paltrow?
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
that whole, I did. Yeah, I did.
shawn:
Matt, Matt, that is part of what makes you so. Hehehehe
Matt:
I just love to watch. I'll have all these plans of what I'm gonna do today and I'll be like oh no I looked what was on court TV and now I can't leave for a couple hours. So Drew's gonna have to have lunch at some point so I'll be able to get some things done during the lunch break and then there's the afternoon break but like the legal arguments I can't get enough of that stuff I love it all.
Sam :
So was Gwyneth Paltrow advantaged beyond
Matt:
No,
Sam :
what she should have been because of her wealth?
Matt:
so
Sam :
Ha
Matt:
it's
Sam :
ha
Matt:
really
Sam :
ha.
Matt:
weird. It's really
shawn:
Oh
Matt:
weird.
shawn:
no.
Matt:
So Gwyneth Paltrow is the one that kind of gives me faith in the justice system because
Sam :
Yeah.
Matt:
going in, I assumed that she was gonna be guilty, but then you listen to the testimony, you listen to the evidence presented, and you're like, of course she wasn't guilty. This guy ran into her and then sued her for him running into her. So Court TV and the Alex Murdoch thing, same thing. I was like, oh, I'm worried about this jury in the South. case in Georgia where this African-American man was shot. I was worried what would happen, but I watched the Kyle Rittenhouse trial and I think in the end I decided it really does depend on the specific judge you get in a case and the rules that they make in that specific case. And so that's actually I think Sean, a case where maybe this federal system isn't so good. Because when you put that kind of power in local authorities you get really unequal on who those judges happen to be. And you get maybe more equality in other places depending on who their judges happen to be. So.
shawn:
So, but it's, isn't it impossible to remove that bias?
Matt:
Yes, it is.
shawn:
Yeah,
Matt:
This
shawn:
so
Matt:
is...
shawn:
we try but
Matt:
Yeah, well
shawn:
and isn't that a call for, we need more righteous people and principled people in those powerful callings, which means we need to do more missionary work and preaching, I don't know, what is the
Matt:
Sean,
shawn:
answer,
Matt:
I'm
shawn:
Matt?
Matt:
really glad you came up with that because the only conclusion I ever come to is tell my kids to never talk to the cops. The police are not your friends. The police are writing everything down and looking to charge people with crimes. So please children, don't talk to them about anything.
Sam :
And, and,
Matt:
It can
Sam :
and,
Matt:
only cause you problems.
shawn:
Oh
Sam :
and
shawn:
my
Sam :
yet
shawn:
gosh.
Sam :
as someone who's benefited our, my business, the business I'm in has benefited from police protection. There's no more
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam :
important role and job in society than that of police. And there is no,
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam :
there's no job. I would tell my kids to run away from more than a cop because
Matt:
I'm out.
Sam :
that's, that would make it a
shawn:
Hard.
Sam :
whole separate conversation of, you know, how,
Matt:
Yeah.
Sam :
how do you grow up wanting to be a police officer in today's world where, you know, discriminated against in the way that you use your,
shawn:
Can we?
Sam :
your role in your job.
shawn:
Matt, is that a proper tangent to work on for two minutes before we end?
Matt:
Yeah,
shawn:
Because
Matt:
go ahead.
shawn:
you're all familiar with Victor Hugo. You know who Victor Hugo is? He wrote a
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
book called
Matt:
Lame
shawn:
Les
Matt:
is.
shawn:
Miserables. All right. And I'm not talking about the movies, the book. That's a fantastic
Matt:
The book is
shawn:
study.
Matt:
too long, Sean. It's like a thousand pages. Nobody's going to read that.
Sam :
And
shawn:
If Knucklehead Sean
Sam :
the movie's
shawn:
can read
Sam :
basically
shawn:
it, then
Sam :
the
shawn:
you
Sam :
same.
shawn:
can
Matt:
Ha ha
shawn:
read
Matt:
ha
shawn:
it,
Matt:
ha
shawn:
Matt.
Matt:
ha ha
Sam :
The
Matt:
ha
Sam :
movie's basically the same. I read it in French and I think it's the same. Anyway, go ahead.
shawn:
You read it in French?
Matt:
Go ahead, Sean, you can make your point.
shawn:
Sam, when did, was that
Sam :
or
shawn:
in 1922,
Sam :
Russian I can't know
shawn:
Sam?
Sam :
I'm lying.
Matt:
Hehehe
Sam :
It's a lie. It's a lie. Go ahead.
Matt:
I actually read War and Peace in French.
Sam :
Oh,
shawn:
So,
Sam :
hang
shawn:
if we're
Sam :
on. I'm
shawn:
talking
Sam :
gonna show
shawn:
about,
Sam :
you.
shawn:
if we're transitioning from the idea that the justice system is unjust because of wealth or because of bias, and we've transitioned the talk down to, well, take policemen, right? What an important discussion. And I like the story of Lim Zerabli because you've got, on the one side, you've got a character who is 100% justice. not 100% but mercy, right? And I wonder, do we do any sort of training with our policemen about the black and white of justice versus the bringing in of the Christ-like charity? Like I know
Sam :
So.
shawn:
cops, I know cops whose role in life is to not just bust people all the time, it's to influence people for good and have changed people's hearts because look,
Matt:
Yeah.
shawn:
the law says that I'm supposed to arrest you to improve your life. And this changes people's lives. And what a powerful moment that is to apply both justice but mercy within there. Whereas I know other cops who are just so javert, right? Black and white, hard-nosed, and in their minds, they're doing the right thing. They're applying justice. That's what you were just talking about, Matt. Let
Matt:
And
shawn:
justice
Matt:
do you warn
shawn:
be blind.
Matt:
them? Do you warn them how Javert's life ended and say this will be you unless you change? Take these silver candlesticks and change your life, sweet police officer.
Sam :
The,
Matt:
So...
shawn:
I sing them
Sam :
the,
shawn:
the song
Sam :
the,
shawn:
about it, yes.
Sam :
the, the prop, the problem today though, is that police owners such scrutiny that when they use force, even the righteous, the good ones, they're penalized both in public and private where I think the good people that, that go into policing for all the right reasons, they're pushed out of the profession. I know many people that used to be cops that say, you know what, for my 75 grand a year, it's not worth it. It's not worth it. I can go into the public private sector.
shawn:
Yeah, right.
Sam :
And I can do better. And the problem with that is, is who are you left with sometimes? You're left with people that are a little bit power hungry, that aren't as interested in finding a job in the private sector. And then adverse selection, which is an insurance business risk concept comes into play, which is, you're left with a challenging section of the public, right?
shawn:
Matt,
Matt:
С вами был Седа Озов.
shawn:
I just wish your idea of government being more involved in influence. Why not? That would be nice to have government in the police forces. Preach a little more, teach a little more about the charitable influences that policemen can have and the positive impact on life. Yes, you need to be just, but there's a place for mercy.
Matt:
I do also think, I think that some police forces do much better than others. And, um, I will like not to get too personal, but there have been times in my life when I was in crisis and my family was in crisis and I didn't, I was not able to solve things myself and I had to turn to the police and I was very, very grateful for the way that the police officers intervened in these situations and the way like they helped me in a way that I could not get help any other way. And they were there for me. And same thing with other parts of the judicial system. I've had unfortunately interactions with prosecuting attorneys and things like that. And I'm always grateful. In fact, one of the worst days of my life, I sat in on sentencing. This judge was just giving people sentences and it was about eight hours, again a court TV buff, of just sentencing one after another after another. And I watched this judge administer these sentences and the victims would come and testify would testify and the stories they told and the things that they had gone through, it just broke my heart. And I thought, this poor judge, this is her job. She does this on a regular basis, listening to these cases and then deciding the appropriate sentences. And I was so grateful that there was a good individual, faithful, like kind, merciful person who's trying to weigh the, the justice system. And so I think that's why Sean, I really appreciated your suggestion that maybe the solution really is like, it's not the system. in the system and we just need really good people in those positions and if we just let whoever take those jobs or we don't treat them with the appropriate respect then we're gonna lose the good people that otherwise would be in those spots because in my own life I've benefited greatly from having good people in all of those positions.
shawn:
Well said.
Matt:
Okay, well that's the end of the Latter-day Lens this week. Again, I encourage you to reach out and let us know what you think. Perhaps we said something about Trump that really upsets you and you'd like to let us know. Perhaps Sam was too hard on police officers or when he talked about insurance it was confusing and you wanna know a little bit more about that. Reach out to us on Twitter at Latter-day Lens, we're on Instagram at Latter-day Lens or you can email us at thelatterdaylens.gmail.com, all one word. Thanks listener, we love having you. Uh-huh, I see it.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories