The Latter Day Lens
Life's Biggest Questions. Real People's Stories.
Why do we suffer? How can we find happiness? What gives life meaning? Where can we find peace? What happens when we die?
These are questions people have wrestled with throughout history, across cultures, religions, and generations.
The Latter Day Lens explores life's greatest questions through the personal experiences of ordinary people from around the world.
Hosted by Matt Miles and Shawn Record, each episode features a guest sharing their unique journey of faith, the challenges they've faced, the lessons they've learned, and the experiences that have shaped their understanding of God and life.
We believe everyone has a story worth telling. Sometimes the most powerful lessons come not from religious leaders or experts, but from ordinary people who have experienced extraordinary moments of faith, love, forgiveness, and hope.
Our conversations are honest, thoughtful, and uplifting. We don't expect our guests to have all the answers. Instead, we invite them to share how they've wrestled with life's difficult questions and what they've discovered along the way.
Rooted in the perspective of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Questions of the Soul welcomes listeners from every background and faith tradition.
Every day, we share a new short video featuring a meaningful personal story. Full-length interviews are also available for those who want to hear more.
Our hope is simple: that through the experiences of others, you'll discover greater faith, find comfort in your struggles, and recognize that you're not alone in asking life's biggest questions.
The Latter Day Lens
March 15, 2023: Proper Role of Government, Government Regulation of Tech, Mexican Drug Cartels, Government Assistance to the Poor
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
On 60 minutes recently, the President of Microsoft (Brad Smith) suggested that it would be a good idea to have a government regulatory body—like the FAA for airlines or the FDA for drugs—created that would regulate big tech. Something like a digital regulatory commission. We have it for virtually every other segment of the US economy, is it time to create something to regulate tech?
Recently, a woman who was in Mexico for cosmetic surgery was kidnapped and her friends were killed in a case of mistaken identity. The cartel apologized and actually turned over the people responsible to the authorities, but many question the authenticity of the apology letter. The FBI is working with Mexico to bring the perpetrators of the crime to justice, but some people want the US to go further. Some have even called for the US to “unleash the fury and might of the United States” to combat drug cartels. What is the appropriate moral response to this situation? Jesus said to turn the other cheek, does that apply in matters of foreign policy?
Budget negotiations are in full swing in Washington D.C. Republicans would like to reduce the size of the federal budget. Biden is proposing cuts to the federal budget as well, but he would like to increase federal support for Medicaid, increase the child tax credit by $1,600 per child and pay for it with a minimum 25% tax on the richest Americans. The restored gospel clearly teaches us to take care of the poor. Alma 34:28 says that if we do not help the poor we are as the hypocrites that deny the faith. Should Latter-day Saints support government proposals designed to help the poor?
Big Question for debate:
Mosiah 29: 16 says that “because all men are not just it is not expedient that ye should have a king or kings to rule over you.” But, in verse 13 he says, “if it were possible that you could have just men to be your kings, who would establish the laws of God, and judge this people according to his commandments, yea, if ye could have men for your kings who would do even as my father Benjamin did for this people—I say unto you, if this could always be the case then it would be expedient that ye should always have kings to rule over you.”
If you look at the history of Nephite civilization as we know it, they do really well when they have a king (500 years until Mosiah and ~400 years after Christ) the only time we have lots of wars recorded is when they have the system of judges in place.
Furthermore, when Jesus comes again, He will rule as king.
The question: Is one form of government morally superior to another? Can’t we just choose any form of government and as long as the people are righteous, the society will prosper?
Visit our website to join the conversation: Latter-day Lens
Transcript
I don't think. That's for the last two years I've heard. I've heard from so many business owners. I can't hire. People like I'm desperate to hire people. Every single one of them said for about. A year straight I am. I have put job. Applications out there. I'm giving huge salary offers to people no one wants to work and you know there is government. Feeding them money, it backfired.
And I'll.
Thank you for joining us once again for another exciting episode of Latter Day Lens. Your home for authentic faith, promoting discussion of current political events. Welcome listeners to another exciting episode of the Latter Day Lens with Sean, Sam and Matt. We'll recently. I don't know if you guys watch 60 minutes, it's the the go to show for old people like me. So they had an episode recently where they were discussing open AI ChatGPT, the the new Microsoft search engine. And they had the President of Microsoft on there. They were discussing this, the challenges with AI technology challenges with search engine. And somebody that was on the program proposed that there should be some kind of a Regulatory agency that overseas digital content, they made the argument that we have the FAA that oversees airlines and keeps airplanes safe. We have the FDA that regulates. Drugs and food and we. Have regulatory agencies of for virtually everything. Except for digital content. And she asked the President of Microsoft if he thought that it was a good idea for us to have some kind of a Regulatory agency that overseas digital content or the digital sector of the US economy. And he actually said that he thought it was a good idea as long as it was done. So my question for you guys is, is it time to create something to regulate digital content?
Before they regulate digital content, I'd like to see if they could double down on the banking regulations, in particular in the digital area with with the failure of SVP over this past weekend. And you know, all the, the drama and the financial sector, you know you, Shawn, don't you think? Matt's hallmark is more regulation. Mine is sort of less and I would argue that in those areas where there's regulation, there is sometimes greater challenges. The bank is a great example, right? Everybody thought everything was just fine until interest rates go up and. It creates a challenge SVS VB as as of today. On the 11th. It'll be interesting to see Monday. What happens is that begins at that as that finishes working. Its way out. Adding to that though. Matt, to your point, Elon Musk has talked. About how AI. Scares him more than anything else right now. AI Elon Musk, who's a sub. For intelligent Guy who isn't much for government, regulation and oversight has talked about, somebody needs to to, to kind of have their pulse on it. So I'm not sure if it's the government or if it's some other type of a board that just watches how that happens. But it's interesting to me that Elon Musk has such a strong opinion.
So, Sam, the way you talked about banking made me think that you feel like perhaps government regulation, one of its roles is to make sure that banks don't fail or companies don't fail. I think the fact that a bank fails is not a sign that government regulation is. Failing governments regulations are there to protect the consumers, the people that have assets invested with the bank, and I'm sure the FDIC is going to protect their investments up to 100,000. Dollars like they do.
250 per depositor, yeah.
So then that means it's working, even though the bank goes out of business, your money is protected by FDIC.
So if if currents so I do believe a government's role has to do with regulating currency, right? So it's the the faith of the the United States. And so we do need regulation on government. I'm not sure that the 16th largest bank going belly up. And losing a ton of money is evidence of good regulation. Why can't we catch it before it goes to that point? Right, that's that's a threat to our national sovereignty, to the health of our economic system. Like how does. We'll find out more in the coming days, but how does something like that go go belly up in our current economy without? A little bit of advance notice. I don't think there's enough transparency behind that. If they want to focus on regulating some, regulate that.
OK. Sean, what are you saying?
We kind of went on three different tangents there. Which one you want to talk about?
I want to talk about digital regulating digital, the digital or the yeah, the yeah, digital content. Yeah, social media, AI.
Yeah, I I mean, I think just like the the our children who are the is the poor Guinea pig generation where we as parents have kind of failed them when it comes to. They were the first one introduced to the iPhone into this great massive leap in technology. We I don't know that there's any avoiding us ruining our kids in these generations because we don't know how to regulate that. We have no idea. We didn't know for the last 10 years how to how to regulate phones and iPhones and all the apps and stuff. So I wonder if if you tried to establish some regulations right now for AI digital. I think it's so new and so developing next two years, three years is all going to be different. So I don't think you can regulate it right now. Even if we wanted to, I think you're going to have to let the thing develop before you could even consider.
So the political science perspective on this is kind of interesting. There's a guy named Schattschneider and and he argues that when there's a like, like an emerging marketplace, you have kind of the wild Wild West for a. While and everybody's just competing. And it's like like, let's just see who emerges to the top and then what happens is the winners in the marketplace, they. They decide that they want to start getting rid of the competition down below them, and so it actually ends up being the the larger institutions or the winners who say let's have more regulation because they actually have the ability to adapt to those regulations. They often create those regulations. And the regulations are designed to keep their competitors out of the marketplace.
Yeah, yeah.
So in that sense, I'm not surprised that it's Microsoft saying. Yeah, you know what we. See need some regulation here because. They had an AI bot that they dropped in 2016 and it didn't work. And now I think they. Feel like they've got a little. Bit closer to something that they could regulate and so then they say how do we? Create regulations that's going to benefit us in the marketplace and then kind of get rid of that competition that we have to deal with down below.
So Matt, if you as a political scientist have just cited your own finding. Of doesn't that say that regulatory governments get tainted by the power of the free market? The you know, the market, the companies that are going to be influencing those regulations, how can you trust that regulations are without bias and favoritism and all that?
No, I wasn't saying there without bias and. Favoritism, I said.
Now, but how? Can you support the regulations when they do have bias and favoritism?
Because they protect us from the wild Wild West. So it's I, the wild, Wild West is a place where people don't want to live. And so the bad guys come in in the wild, Wild West and they create their own little rules and regulations. And then after a while, then they become legitimate. And then these are the organizations that are the legitimate organizations that are following all the rules because they created the. But in the end I. Think it's better for people? Because there's some expectation of, like, what's going to happen and what what can be done, what can't be done. I like that television can't put false advertising out there. I like. That there's laws. Regulating advertising on television. I like that you can't have cigarette ads on television. And I think there's some regulation of like the tech industry would be helpful for society as a whole, even that even though it means that governments going to be picking winners and losers.
Yeah, that's a big yeah, I mean. That's a tough one. I back to my original point. I I I just regulate what at this point, when it comes to these AI content creation, right? ChatGPT. Regulate what?
We'll make it so that I can't ask the question. Hey, Bing, how do I make a bomb at home? And then that's like, wrong to. And so, like, they can't give me that information, right?
Yeah, I think that's a bad idea to regulate, right? Like you want. You want less of that. The, the, the. The danger is somebody could learn how to make a bomb the the. Uh, the the chilling effect is, is to again that free speech and that that marketplace, I mean. You look at. What's going on in Ukraine and the crazy propaganda Russia is trying to put out there in that free market space about their efforts in Ukraine, right, like anybody right now could say anything and everybody's got to try to figure out what is real and what is truth, but.
So we should regulate, right, so that the government should help us.
I mean, Matt, don't, don't you want?
Find out. I don't think so. I think it's better than I think it's better to not know the fascinating part about digital. Again, going back to what Elon Musk talks about, he was an original investor in GPT, he said. You know, it's going to be tougher to know who's saying what and what is real communication like, you know, you're going to see a speech. From President Biden, and it's going to sound like Biden, but a little more lucid, like he's going to know what he's talking about a little bit better. And it's not going to stutter as much and and you're not going to be able to tell, it's not him. That's one of the challenges, right?
Right. But if we as a society are just in the habit of let me go to my favorite YouTube video and let's go back to a couple episodes back where Matt is sitting for hours, watching for some star to go supernova. When it's not, it was just clickbait. It was just a YouTube channel going. Hey, come watch. One channel, but Matt, you learned a valuable lesson there. You learn my life is not going to be controlled by some YouTuber who's giving me clickbait. Now I scrutinize things and now I'm not going to accept those things. I'm going to work extra hard to try and discover what is right, what is wrong, what is truth, and what is not I. I mean that accountability, I think is better for our citizens to have rather than let's just trust the YouTube guy or the government to tell me what is right and what is wrong. I like that we have to think about it. If you take the script look like this is a question and the mission prep class that I teach always. We look at the Scriptures and. I go. Hey, why is is this? Do you guys think when you read scriptures is it plain? Or is it a little complicated? Is there a lot of there's a lot of. There's a lot of there's a lot of dissonance, right? There's a lot of things that are hard to and. I so I. Ask him the question why does God make it so not so simple. And I think the answer was come up with this because he requires of us hard work to go and discover truth, to study and study and study. It says feast upon the words of Christ. Open it up and be told what to do. It's not a manual. I'm I'm kind. Of against manuals but.
So I think I think, yeah, I think I'm figuring out that the difference between you guys and me is you have faith in people and. I have no. Faith in people like people are. I don't, Sean. I don't think people. Have that kind of. Cognitive capacity to do that in their lives.
I you're wrong. You're wrong. God put us the the the value of a soul is very high in God's sight. He wouldn't put people on the earth without that capacity. He's given us the ability to choose between right and wrong. It's when we don't allow ourselves or teach each other. You have to grow that cognitive. Right by saying, oh, the my my YouTube channel guy, I trust him. I can just not think turn my brain off.
Teach correct principles and let them govern themselves. Matt, let's not.
Yeah, that is that is, that does not sound.
Let's not a laugh.
Like who said that?
It's not allowed the government.
Who said that?
No, it's not. It's not scripture. So I don't think we. Could quote it, so I don't know.
Yeah, that's right.
OK. Well, the next topic that's been in the news and and I think it's important to talk about, but I don't know exactly the, I don't know the answer to this question, but so there was a woman and some friends that went to Mexico for cosmetic surgery. And I actually read. Today that there was another there are three women from the United States that went to Mexico to sell things at the flea market that are still missing. And and most people probably know that that that, this group that went to Mexico, two of them the men were shot and killed. One of them was shot and received like significant injuries. And eventually they found the two surviving. People and brought them. Film and there's, like, mixed ideas about what what should be done. The FBI's working with Mexico to try to bring these drug cartel people to justice because they say it was a case of missing identity. Although the president in Mexico seemed to suggest that maybe these people had a criminal background, the the Americans did. Some Americans, Lindsey Graham from South Carolina, who's the senator of the state from where these people came. He says that we should unleash the fury and might of the United States to combat drug cartels. We should treat them like terrorist organizations. So this is my question that I always have in these situations when the question when we're filled with rage and anger about something that happened, that the natural inclination is to say, let's show them how tough we are. And like, let's just unleash our our might. On them. But Jesus said turn the other cheek. And oftentimes if I say no, no, no, Jesus said turn the other cheek, then people kind of like, scoff at me. So how do? We like reconcile this idea of, like, what's the appropriate response should should nations turn the other cheek? We as citizens, turn the other cheek like. What's the right thing to do in a situation like this?
To to what specifically in this in this to to the to a group?
Should should the United States seek vengeance on the drug cartels and just destroy them for what they did to these Americans?
So I read Graham's kind of reasoning for wanting to designate them as. As as terrorist organizations and one of the reasons that he's pushing is because the cartels are pushing fentanyl across our borders and 100,000 people, U.S. citizens have died from fentanyl. So that doesn't seem logical to me for him to say. Let's attack, attack, attack, because U.S. citizens are choosing. To take fentanyl and over. I I mean I think that's more of a US issue, right? If why are our people thinking fentanyl so much and overdosing? Why is it? Why are the drug issues here what they are? I don't think you can blame necessarily the supplier for that, right. Humans are choosing to take drugs.
But but the drug cartels in Mexico cause a lot of problems to U.S. It makes it hard for Americans, yeah.
OK. But that's, but that's not. But that wasn't his argument. His argument was fentanyl is killing 100,000 Americans each year, and it's now let's go attack the cartels. That just didn't seem logical. I agree that it makes probably make sense to designate them as a terrorist organization because they cause so much.
Then we then that gives us the right to go in and attack them according to the Bush. Doctrine that would say. We're going to go in and we're going to neutralize this threat before it becomes a greater threat against the United States.
Oh, then that doesn't sound I guess that that doesn't sound right. Sam, what do you think?
You know, you know, it's interesting. As soon as it happened, they apologized. The cartel did.
Which which which which.
We're not sure if it was sincere.
I think it's great. Well, it was sincere enough that they delivered up people they claimed responsible for it and said, hey, you have it and it makes me think of Breaking Bad if you saw. That right there. There is an interesting balance in the world. I mean. Evil, right? Secret combinations, organized crime, and legitimate society and our counter. We definitely have a counter against that evil that is drug demand, that is tourism, right? And money that we spend over the border and I already know there's been a massive chilling effect to tourism. And probably money spent there as a result of this going on, we probably need to do better at stopping it by stopping the demand. You know, I think. Those the the people from Arizona a year or two ago that were gunned down in just a terrible deal. People are afraid of Mexico. I have a lot of friends that used to go without question. My wife and I would go to Cancun all the time we'd go to. All the the vacation spots and I think people from the US are less likely and less willing to go. And I think it's going to be even even less likely now. So does does do the economic constraints deter the cartel? And then if we can somehow stop the demand, does it make? Even better, it invade Mexico to stop the cartel. That's a terrible idea, Matt. Is that your idea is. That the government regulation you want.
That's Lindsey Graham's. Well, I have noticed that Mexico, when you go to tourist areas, Mexico does a really good job of making you feel safe. Mazatlán is in the middle of like a territory controlled by drug cartels. And when you get off a cruise ship in Mazatlán, there's blue lines on the street and it says follow the blue lines to downtown and basically as long as you stay on the blue lines streets, you're gonna be just fine. And there's locals that like, come and show you the. Way they're like, don't. Go over there, let's. Stay on the. Blue lines until you're in downtown and then you can find your way. From there and it's the same with with like Cancun and yeah, Israel.
'S the same way, right?
You but Matt, do you? What is? What's your take on the proposal that to to make the cartels terrorist organization. So we can go to battle.
Yeah, I always. I always, I'm always. Torn on this Sean, like there's this part of me that says if we have the most powerful military in the world, we have an obligation to protect our own citizens. The way that a father would protect his children, but then there's this other side that says Jesus said violence isn't the answer. And so in these situations. I always try to look for the more peaceful solutions. But sometimes that makes us look weak and sometimes, like we've talked about, other situations where we're being where, where a perception of weakness leads to more harm than good.
So so do you. Do you agree with what I suggested that look if if we as Americans didn't? Weren't taking fentanyl in such great doses. There'd be less of a demand for it. And then the cartel would have no power. And as the issue lie in in us as parents and as citizens of the US to. Somehow go to the. Somehow get rid of or affect the morality of drugs in our country.
I think there's a long history in Mexico of now they're not. They haven't always been drug cartels, but there's these groups, the the the function outside the control of the government. And so. So right now, these groups we're going, we're going to call them drug cartels. Now these groups are making most of their money off of drugs for sure. But fentanyl is only the drug of choice right now. It used to be cocaine. There was a time when it was marijuana. So I think that whatever it is that people in the United before that during prohibition, it was alcohol, it was like come to Mexico and. Get your alcohol. So I think that it's not necessarily fentanyl, it's just kind of the way things are done in Mexico where there's these regional powers. That have their own military forces their own like. Their own like guns and stuff like that, that are enforcing their own rules and their own laws. So I just don't know that fentanyl getting like solving that solves this.
Well, I I don't mean fentanyl specifically, I mean drugs or alcohol in general, like, right, we we're from the latter day from the the church perspective. If we had, like, take Ukraine right, we went on our mission and we it was post communism. It was a fresh field and. There were such good missionaries in our mission and they and the the generation before us, they they did such good work with the people out there that these people have built this huge church community obviously been disrupted. More but the missionary work had a more powerful effect on the people than any other thing.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
So I'm just saying. Why don't we focus on? I mean, we're so limited in our abilities, but shouldn't the focus be on let's teach a secular United States? True principles.
Again, your faith is in the people, right? If we help the people change, then society changes for the better.
You come on.
We start at the ground up.
You, you you believe that you come on.
I I do believe.
That on some level, but then there's like the practicality of like it's so hard. So I look at my neighborhood and I say, what percentage of these people are going to be receptive to the gospel message. So since they're not, I'm going to. Control them makes them.
We'll, we'll we'll remove. We'll remove choice and we'll force them to do what is ultimately best for them. We'll ensure the result at the end, yes.
I guess in the end, maybe it all comes down to the same struggle we've been having since before. We were born. Choice versus, yeah, the agency. Well, I don't, but I feel like. Agency, though an eternal principle, I don't know that. Yeah, that's a topic for another day, OK. Let's move on to our next topic. It's the budget. Negotiations are in full swing. So you've probably heard talk about the debt ceiling, the debt ceiling as we mentioned before, is an opportunity for Republicans to kind of force their way into into negotiations about. Budget because the Republicans have the ability to stop the United States from paying all of its debt obligations. And so what's happening in Washington, DC right now is everybody's laying out their proposals and their plans, and Republicans are are proposing to cut a variety of things as Democrats probably have some things. That they want to cut. But Biden's uh budget that he just released his proposal is increase the child tax credit to make sure that working families have lots of money coming to them from the government. It's increased Medicare, make it so that more people have access to government sponsored health insurance. And and there's a lot of other things we have the links to all of these proposals in the description to the podcast. If you'd like to know more. About it, there's a lot of things where. Biden saying let's give to. The poor. And then we're going to pay for it with a minimum. 25% tax on the richest Americans. And so the question I have is that it's really clear in the gospel. That if we don't take care of the poor, if we don't do our part to help the poor and the needy, Alma says. We're as the hypocrites that deny the faith. Oh, shouldn't we as Latter Day Saints support government efforts to take from the rich and give to the poor as a way to fulfill our gospel duty of looking out for the poor?
Because Matt, those actions are to help the poor, they're not to create votes right when other politicians have come out and. Said, hey, let's let's. Give out a free cell phone or let's erase debt for your student education. It's to help people who are truly impoverished that need the help.
Those are all there.
It's not. The it's that and and and and also. How does that square with the whole self-reliance principle of the gospel right? It's not hey, handout handout give you stuff, it's give you skills and ability so you can stand on your own and support yourself and I think. A lot of governments.
Like a cell phone.
Exactly, exactly. I think a lot of government. Efforts to try to help lower income people or people in general. Will end up being pandering for votes rather than than really, truly thoughtful and effective ways to help raise people up. I think raising people up is, you know, giving them the skills and the abilities to go out and get it on their own, or allowing people that can create that wealth to create it and then go on and create other ways to create additional. Well, you know, money, you know, good business creates other good business which creates employees and and and and helps everybody it. Trickles down, right?
OK. Do you want me to go? Next, Sean, go for. It my take on this is that. I think we. Should no longer ask people to work for a living.
OK.
We should just ask the government. We should take from the rich, give everybody a livable wage. Like if we were to tax these billionaires, we could give everybody a living wage. Age and then people could they could like reach self actualization. I think that people are inherently good, inherently want to work, they want to do family history work.
They want to do.
They want a garden they want. To do something good and. And forcing them to go to. A job hinders that. And we need to like the government has a real opportunity to help. Humans reach their full potential by no longer requiring them to go to some job that takes them away from. The real labor of life.
Now listen, you better than anyone I know. You have the ability to look at both. What I've always loved about you is you have the ability to. Look at both sides of. Sometimes I can't tell how sincere you are with what you're if you're stuck in this trap of, oh, I can see both sides and I'm just spewing out of my. Mouth both sides. 3 minutes ago you said I don't have trust in people. I don't think people are good now you just. Say people are good.
Self actualized.
They want to work, so if you give them a yeah. If they want to self actually so. If you give them a bunch of money. They're going, they're. Not going to just sit back and become lazy. But which one? Do you believe in Matt? Do they have the ability to be good and? Be accountable for that money, or do they not?
I believe that government has the ability to steer people into becoming who they want them to become, so that if the government was to say, here's this money, stop thinking about where you're going to work and what job you're going to do.
Oh, there we go.
Stop thinking about like all these things, these mundane things of life, and focus on the thing that matters most. Maybe you do it as like some kind of a grant or some kind of a thing. You write a little report on all the things you learned in the last 20 years as you took our money and became. A better person.
Matt I.
Will still see that in reality the the, the, the friends and people that I know. Who have received the most help from charity or government? No, I I know this sounds cynical, but I just don't see that it creates the ambition to go out and. Become self reliant and to become productive the.
A long long.
Opposite happens when it's just given.
A long, long time ago there was a Council in heaven and there were two plans that were proposed.
OK, I I have evidence for my my idea when when the government shut down at COVID and they just gave everybody money. We have more new businesses started in the United States in that period of time where everything was shut down than. We did before. That like shutting everything down and giving people money and saying now, what do you want to do? It created like. This opportunity for people to say now I'm going to go do what I want to do.
How many?
Instances of mental health are through the roof.
How many businesses were shut down because of the same policy?
Mental health problems are through the roof. People ended up having all sorts of social issues. They can't talk to each other. They can't relate among each other like I don't know what evidence you have for what you're saying. It doesn't even make sense based on what?
All of the all of the new.
I know about food.
Business all of the new businesses that. Got started during those like right after the shutdown for like.
Name 1 Matt.
I'm Googling something.
Name name 1 Matt.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah, you guys Google this.
What new businesses?
I have the evidence on my side.
What about the companies that that were shut down and destroyed because of those government policies during COVID? Matt, what about all those people?
Right, so so I'm. Not arguing for the shutdown, obviously. I'm not saying the shutdown was good. I'm saying that what happened in the shutdown when the government flooded the marketplace with money and people couldn't. Go to their jobs. And they had suddenly money from government. What I'm saying is, people took that money that the government gave them and they were entrepreneurial. And they started their own business.
I don't think that's true. I don't think that's true, Matt.
And and uh.
For the last two years, I've heard. I've heard from so many business. Owners, I can't hire people like I am desperate to hire people. Every single one of them said for about. A year straight. I am I have put job applications out there. I'm giving huge salary offers to people no one wants to.
Work because they have their business, their own business, no.
And you know. No, it's that's not at. All what it. Was not they heard government feeding them money.
They don't want to work.
It backfired.
And and and on the backside. Now we have out of control inflation. We have demand that exceeds you know we we have supply that's way less than demand. We have tech problems and and you know chip shortages I mean there's nothing. You should almost. Be kicked out. Do we? Do we throw him off the island? There should be like. Some sort of a penalty for proposing such ludicrousness. I'm on the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, and it does talk about there was a a surge of startups, but it even talks about it talks.
Thank you. Thank you.
But it talks about here, how it was uneven and and relative to the resources. Provided it was a poor return. Let's see notice of these new business. Will drive job creation remains to be seen with the increase in new employer business merging within 4 to. 8 core like. Net, net inflation, uh social or mental health issues?
Look, look.
It's not even it's it's it's not worth it.
Look, Matt, I like that Matt, you. You you gave this solution which is the opposite of conservatism, right, which is fine. We can show that we can show that. Look, being a a disciple of Christ doesn't mean Republican. That's absolutely not a not at all.
That that's right.
So I like that you have out-of-the-box ideas. You are a political scientist, so I know. You believe in government? But you took you initially asked the. Question in the context of. Christ commanded us to take care of the poor, so it in that principle you're just saying?
Helping the poor.
Yeah, we should use the the money from the rich to take care of the poor by giving in the form of giving them money. Can you find any scriptural evidence that, that, that has ever been a successful model?
So that's scriptural evidence, but if you. Look at poverty in the world. As governments become more generous and and take. This role of the social. Safety net we're improving living conditions. For the poor across the world. So what it means to be poor in the United States today versus what it meant to be poor 100 years ago, vastly different things right now. There's still a. Gap in life expectancy between the rich. And the poor. But a poor person in the United States today has an amazing quality. Of life and I think that a large part, that's because the government is there providing resources. They are like Social Security, Medicare, so many.
Things you're not gonna be homeless.
It's not sustainable. That's the problem.
But Sam, but Sam would argue.
You should not give away stuff without there being a social cost, right?
Well, and Sam would. I'm sure, Sam, you would argue that the reason that that, that, that the conditions in the world today for the poor are so much higher is because of free market, not because of government, right, Sam?
Well, I think that this leads really well into our. Our big question that I wanted to debate today because it's all about control and and free will and all of that sort of stuff. So I I regularly hear people quote from Mosiah chapter 29, verse 16, that says that because all men are not just. It does not expedient that you should have a king or kings to rule over you. But they forget about verse 13 where he says if it were possible that you could have just men to be your kings who would establish the laws of God and judge this people according to His commandments. Yeah, if you could have men for your kings who would do even as my father Benjamin did for his people. I say to you, if this could always be the case, then it would be expedient that you should always have a king. To rule over you and so.
Ohh no. Matt's going for a king now.
I have two liking.
I if you have, if you say what's the? Ideal form of government. What will be the form of government when Jesus comes in the Millennium, the 1000 years of peace?
The accuracy.
We're going to have a. Yeah, yeah. Well and. If you look at the history of the Nephite civilization in the Book of Mormon, you have all these kings under the Nephites up until Mosiah. Changes and creates judges. You have. You don't have the judges system. After Christ comes you have some other form of government and the and the war is and all of the fighting and all the bickering happens in that period of time when they get rid of kings in the Book of Mormon. So I'm just saying, like, isn't it possible? That I don't want to advocate for kings. I just want to say, isn't it possible that there's no moral right and wrong in the form of government? You choose that if a people choose to say. We want to have a righteous king. That's not a morally wrong choice. And if someone says we want to choose to have all of the chaos and sadness that comes with democracy. That's not a morally wrong choice either.
Yeah, Matt, I think it's an awesome question. I really do. I think it's we're so used in our bubble to thinking. One way, but I think it's a great question and you do. I like that you cite. You know you have some proof text and scripture to kind of. This is there any other scriptural proof text that perhaps points to our modern way of of the US? For example the US Constitution. There's three or four references to the US Constitution and the way it was formed. In the doctrine and covenants, that's canonized Scripture for us. So this isn't just prophets said something and had a comment in General conference, this is canonized scripture, right? The C134. There's 15 scriptures there verses that talk specifically about modern government and how it should be and how it has been influenced by God, right? And one of those principles is don't rely on men, rely on righteous laws, right? And this was this was these were taught by George Washington and John Adams and. All these guys right that that we need a government of law, not citizens. Aristotle even taught that right all law should govern rather than any citizen, because then we have the ability to fight for laws that protect our our liberties and and our rights and our. Freedom to religion. As opposed to them to to every other man who is going to have a different opinion, right? I wouldn't trust Donald Trump to protect my I don't know any. Or other guys, what do you think?
So you're saying that you're saying there's a moral it could be morally justified to like like that? You could say, hey, there's a religious backing that says laws instead of people as kings. Except for that Jesus and the Millennium is going to be a king.
No, I'm suggesting that you're suggesting is correct that if we had a king versus a a Congress and a. President, as long as the righteous laws are in place, it seems like that's the most important thing. So I'm defending your idea. Perhaps that we could be a little more fluid.
It doesn't matter though.
But but.
I mean, what matters? What matters in the DNC is that that there the set of laws that exist in the government and perhaps some of. The structure of the government. Is a righteous way to have a a God created government?
So are there examples?
I can tell.
Are there examples across the world or anywhere else in history besides this where there's not? It's not a theocracy, right? It's not a religious government, but a government backed this way has led to the result you're talking about, because I think, you know Christ during the Millennium is one thing. That's that's a theocracy, right? And that's people bound together by a common. Belief a common life view. I don't think there's enough in common anywhere in our country, let alone across the world, that would allow people to agree to settle laws or a governance a religious governance that would enable this. I I think we're so far.
Well, but but Sam, the DS doesn't the DNC.
From it, I don't.
Know how it's possible?
Doesn't talk about a religious governance. The DNC just talks about preserving the freedom, freedoms and liberties, right? I mean it, verse seven of the DNC 134 says. Governments have a right and are bound to enact laws for the protection of all citizens and the free exercise of. Their religious belief. So if a king in Saudi Arabia doesn't provide that, it's an evil government. If a president in Congress and a government doesn't provide that, it's a evil government, right?
Well, so I would say, Sam, the examples I would use as king bed. Human is an example of a righteous king. There is in the Old Testament there's a number of righteous kings. King Josiah, you can look in the book of Esther and you see there's Wicked kings, and then there's righteous kings. But when they have righteous kings in the book of Esther, Society prospers. The people are righteous like like a righteous king can lead the people to righteousness. In a way that you don't necessarily get in a democratic society. But Matt, are you?
Giving the credit to the individual king or in the in isn't it same as I do? Doesn't it say that it's the laws that were established by that righteous? They says that doesn't.
And and yeah, that's what Mosiah says about his dad, Benjamin. But when you read the Old Testament, it says King Josiah did this. And when you read in the Book of Esther, it talks about this was a righteous king who did this. So they. Don't give the credit to the laws in those situations.
Yeah, but I think the principle is that there is that these righteous kings establish righteous laws like in DC 134, two we believe. And this is a we believe statement. We believe that. No government can exist in peace, except such laws are framed and held inviolate as well, secure to each individual. The free exercise of conscience. The right and control of property and the protection of life. Those are specific things that, for example, the United States government has codified. That's in. Law and that's a righteous thing. Whether a king or a president or a Congress is involved, I don't think it matters as much. I don't think. Are you saying that it's better to have a king? What you're saying?
What I'm saying is any society where the people are trying to be righteous, then that society will prosper and there is no right and wrong about form of government as long as you have a people that are trying to be righteous, then they're going to be blessed.
The problem is, what's the definition of righteous?
Well, God chooses that, right? God decides if we're righteous. Enough to prosper in the land.
I I.
I agree with that, but in our world today, in in our country, there's not a common understanding or belief in that. So doesn't that by its very nature say it's. It's a theocracy, right? It's a religious based government as opposed to, you know, we were close to that one. We're we're a predominantly Christian nation, right. Arguably a lot of the laws. Pushed people kind of towards that understanding, but it probably wasn't totally. Freedom of expression for all religions but but but it was very Christian, right. I think in our society today religion is expanded to take in things that you and I would even consider to be religion. There are there are there are special interest groups that are asking for religious protections that. That that would probably be tough to say. Hey, that's right or wrong. I I I I think I think a king, a Kingdom or a a a government ruled by a king by one person is tougher in our world today. Because of the that there are so many voices, there are so many different. Voices. I think it'd be.
Well, let me quote. Let me ask this question because this is what I'm really curious about from the latter day lens. Could a righteous latter day St. Advocate for a system like communism or socialism? And still say I'm a righteous good latter day St. my values point me in that direction.
So Matt, I have to, I have to pipe in here.
President Benson.
No, not even that saying we don't even need to go to a conference talk. We need to go to the to scripture. There's a canonized scripture. I just read it. We believe the governments are. Want to protect the right of exercise of free conscience, the right of control of property and the protection of life. Communism, so the so I've read. I've read the manifestos Marks and communist freedom of property is absolutely against that as well.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. So you're saying? Have you read the law of consecration, Sean?
For you.
Where's the where's text?
Dark darker, The covenants, doctrine and Covenants Section 42. Or you could think about language and the temple covenants about the law of consecration, but that's.
But that's not.
The law of.
But that's not to government. That's not saying to government, we're not concentrating our, our, we're not contributing anything to any government now.
It's a very thin line, Matt and Sean.
It's no, I don't think it is. We're not consecrating anything to government. We're consecrating it to God and his Kingdom.
I think for a society to do that there.
There's no law.
Has to be.
That says we got to do it to government.
There has to be a universal understanding of right and wrong. And we're so far from that that I think what you're proposing would be very difficult because there's.
Well, hold on.
Not enough of an understanding.
I'm not proposing anything. Let's just be clear. I I I just think that it's as I study the scriptures.
Mount Mount, Mount king.
Oftentimes I say people are taking like. Like forms of government and using that as a guide for their spirits, I think they're taking politics and mixing it with religion, using politics to guide their religion rather than the other way around. And I think that somebody could reasonably say if my religion is the most important thing in my life, I can choose any kind of government, and that's not morally wrong. As long as I hold to the principles and. The scriptures but.
That's the point, Matt is some forms of government don't hold to to scriptural principle, another one in in that DC134 says the laws in equity and justice should be sought for and upheld by the voice of the people in a Republic. That's a pretty specific form of. Government right there that the DNC is advocating for, isn't it?
But I'm saying that in other scriptures they advocate for other forms of government. And the and I just shared the one in Mosiah where he says you should have a king if you could always have a righteous king, then you should have a king.
No they don't. No, I didn't say. That I'll read it.
To you again. I say it to.
It doesn't say you should have a king. It said it would be desirable if. They could be righteous to have a king.
I say unto you, if this could always be the case, then it would be expedient that ye should always have kings to rule over you.
Yeah, OK. But I don't think that's saying the best form of government is kings. That's just saying when righteousness is upheld.
That's experience depends the definition of the word. Should but yes.
Well, there's a big there's a if in. There as well if and should, yeah.
But my favorite thing about this podcast is that we share of the same faith, and we oftentimes disagree. As this episode has clearly demonstrated. But we all love each other, and that's the important thing. And I don't think that we need to come to conclusions in order for us to. Still successful in this discussion. We might still just disagree about these things.
OK, well, that's the end.
Of our this week's episode of the Latter Day Lens, thank you for joining us and we hope that you'll TuneIn again next week for another exciting episode of. The latter day lens.
See you.
That is all the time we have. This week, but that doesn't mean the discussion is. Over in fact. We include links to the stories we discuss each week in the podcast description to encourage our listeners participation. Each of you have an important perspective. That builds the latter day lens. And we want to hear from you. Let's continue the discussion on social media. You can find us on Instagram at latter Day lens on Twitter. At latter Day, lens on Facebook. At latter day lens. Or you can e-mail us at the latter day lens at Gmail. Dot com all one word finally. Please make sure you subscribe to get updated content. Each week, thanks for making US1. Of the most listened to podcasts. We love our listeners.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Mission Stories: Latter-day Saint Missionary Stories & Mission Prep
Shawn Record | LDS Mission Prep & Missionary Stories